Pattern formation in the vertebrate neural plate

Roles of cell-autonomous mechanisms for differential expression of region-specific transcription factors in neuroepithelial cells

Although a number of genes have been found to have restricted expression domains in the embryonic forebrain and midbrain, it remains largely unknown how the expression of these genes is regulated at the cellular level. In this study, we explored the mechanisms for the differential expression of region-specific transcription factors in neuroepithelial cells by using both primary and immortalized neuroepithelial cells from the rat brain at embryonic day 11.5. We found that differential expression patterns of Pax-3, Pax-5, Pax-6, Dlx-1, Dlx-2, Emx2, Otx1 and Dbx observed in vivo were maintained even when the cells were isolated and cultured in vitro, free from environmental influences. Furthermore, in response to Sonic hedgehog, which is a major inductive signal from the environment for regional specification, neuroepithelial cells that maintain distinct regional identities expressed different sets of ventral-specific genes including Islet-1, Nkx-2.1 and Nkx-2.2. These results suggest that certain cell-autonomous mechanisms play important roles in regulating both environmental signal-dependent and -independent expression of region-specific genes. Thus, we propose that use of the in vitro culture systems we describe in this study facilitates the understanding of regulatory mechanisms of region-specific genes in neuroepithelial cells.

Xotx genes in the developing brain of Xenopus laevis

The vertebrate Otx gene family is related to otd, a gene contributing to head development in Drosophila. We previously reported on the expression of Xotx2 gene, homologous to the murine Otx2 gene, during early Xenopus development. In the present paper we report an extensive analysis of the expression pattern of Xotx2 during later stages of development and also the cloning and developmental expression of two additional Otx Xenopus genes, Xotx1 and Xotx4. These latter two genes bear a good degree of homology to murine Otx1, higher for Xotx1 than for Xotx4. Both these genes are expressed in the forebrain and midbrain regions and their developmental patterns of expression are very similar, although not perfectly superimposable. Spatial and temporal expression patterns of the three Xotx genes suggest that they may be involved in the early subdivision of the rostral brain, providing antero-posterior positional information within the most anterior districts of the neuraxis. The three Xotx genes are expressed in all the developing sense organs of the head, eyes, olfactory system and otic vesicles. By in situ hybridization the earliest detectable expression is found in anterior mesendoderm for Xotx2, and in presumptive anterior neuroectoderm for Xotx1 and Xotx4. In addition, we examined whether Xotx1 is expressed in exogastrulae, finding that Xotx1 expression can be activated in the apparent absence of vertical signals of neural induction.

Reprogramming Hox expression in the vertebrate hindbrain: influence of paraxial mesoderm and rhombomere transposition

The developing vertebrate hindbrain consists of segments known as rhombomeres, which express combinations of Hox genes implicated in specifying segmental identity. Using chick-chick and chick-transgenic mouse graftings, we show that anterior to posterior rhombomere transpositions result in a progressive posterior transformation and coordinate induction of new Hox expression. This shows that hindbrain plasticity is evolutionarily conserved and implies rhombomeres may be undergoing continual assessment of their identities. The nature of the changes is dependent on both the anteroposterior position of the graft and its origin. Transposed somites from specific axial levels and developmental stages have a graded ability to induce changes in Hox expression, indicating that paraxial mesoderm is a source of the environmental signal responsible for the plasticity.

Vertebrate neural progenitor cells: subtypes and regulation

Several advances have been made recently in characterizing neural progenitor cells. In vertebrates, multipotential stem cells have been demonstrated in the developing forebrain both in vitro and in vivo, and a class of stem cells has been identified in the adult CNS. Factors that regulate the proliferation and differentiation of subtypes of neural progenitor cells have also been described. In invertebrates, progress has been made in identifying genes involved in neural progenitor cell specification, cell-fate choices and regulation.

Regulation of vertebrate neural cell fate by transcription factors

Evidence that region- and cell-type-specific transcription factors regulate morphogenesis and differentiation of the vertebrate nervous system comes from numerous studies, including descriptions of discrete patterns of expression during neural development and analysis of mutant phenotypes. Recently published works provide insights into the roles of vertebrate transcription factors in regulating the generation of neural precursors, regionalization of the nervous system, and subsequent differentiation of specific cell types within these regions. For instance, misexpression studies in Xenopus embryos show that the newly isolated basic helix-loop-helix protein NeuroD is able to promote neurogenesis, whereas analysis of mouse embryos mutant for the homeobox gene En-1 demonstrates that this transcription factor is required for proper development of the midbrain-hindbrain region. A recent study in chick shows that the combinatorial expression of Islet-1, Lim-1, and two other LIM homeobox genes, Islet-2 and Lim-3, defines subclasses of motor neurons in the spinal cord, supporting a model where combinatorial repertoires of transcription factors may act to generate diverse cell types.

Differentiation processes in the amphibian brain with special emphasis on heterochronies

Amphibians and caecilians exhibit a great variety of adult morphologies, life histories, and developmental strategies (biphasic development, direct development, viviparity, and neoteny). While early brain development and the differentiation of neural tissues in the three amphibian orders follow a basic pattern, differences exist in the onset and offset as well as the rate of growth and differentiation processes. These differences are described within a phylogenetic framework, and special emphasis is laid on the relationship between altered ontogenies and phylogenetic diversity. We concentrate on ontogenetic differentiation processes in the motor, olfactory, and visual system. We discuss the morphological consequences of secondary simplification of the brain in the context of paedomorphosis, which has happened several times independently among amphibians and consists in the abbreviation or truncation of late developmental processes. We deal with the cellular and molecular basis of brain development and the consequences for the adult nervous system in representative species of the three amphibian orders. Our analysis reveals that differences in brain morphology are largely due to heterochrony (i.e., the desynchronization of ontogenetic processes), a phenomenon that in turn is related to changes in genome sizes and life histories.

Cooperative model of epithelial shaping and bending during avian neurulation: autonomous movements of the neural plate, autonomous movements of the epidermis, and interactions in the neural plate/epidermis transition zone

Morphogenetic movements during neurulation cause a tissue to change shape within the plane of the epithelium (e.g., conversion of the oval neural plate into the narrow spinal plate and the wide brain plate), cause bending out of the plane of the epithelium (e.g., raise the neural folds and curl the neural plate into a tube), or contribute to both phenomena. In this study, pieces that contain neural plate alone, epidermis alone, or both tissues (with or without underlying tissues) are cut from chick embryos and allowed to develop for up to 24 hr. Examination of histological sections through such isolates allows analysis of the formation of neural folds. When the neural plate/epidermis transition zone is disrupted, neural folds do not form. Conversely, when the transition zone remains intact, neural folds form. Neural folds form even when most of the medial neural plate and lateral epidermis has been removed, leaving only the isolated transition zone. These data indicate that the transition zone is both necessary and sufficient for the formation of neural folds. The transition zone may play a number of roles in epithelial bending including organizing, focussing, and redirecting movements that are autonomous to the neural plate or epidermis. Time-lapse video recording, and sequential photographs allowed the documentation of such movements. Neural plate isolates exhibit autonomous rostrocaudal lengthening and mediolateral narrowing. Isolated strips of epidermis exhibit autonomous movements which, unlike wound-healing movements, are unidirectional (medial), and region-specific (beginning and reaching their greatest extent in the cranial region). Isolated pieces of neural plate or epidermis remain flat instead of bending, providing further evidence that the transition zone is necessary for the formation of neural folds.

Induction of anteroposterior neural pattern in Xenopus: evidence for a quantitative mechanism

The developing vertebrate nervous system arises from ectoderm in response to inductive signals from the dorsal mesoderm, or Spemann organizer. It displays pronounced anteroposterior (AP) pattern, but the mechanism that generates this pattern is poorly understood. We demonstrate that the inducing ability of dorsal mesoderm is regionalized along the AP axis at the early gastrula stage, using the homeodomain-encoding genes Xanf-2 and en-2 as markers of anterior and mid-neural pattern, respectively. In addition, we show that changing the size ratio of posterior dorsal mesoderm to responding ectoderm affects the type of AP pattern induced. A low ratio leads to induction of anterior neural pattern, while a high ratio leads to expression of only mid-neural pattern. These and other results indicate that a quantitative mechanism specifies AP neural pattern.

Midline signalling is required for Pax gene regulation and patterning of the eyes

Pax6 and Pax2 are members of the Pax family of transcription factors that are both expressed in the developing visual system of zebrafish embryos. Pax6 protein is present in all cells that form the neural retina and pigment epithelium, whereas Pax2 is located primarily in cells that will give rise to the optic stalk. In this study, we have addressed the role of midline signalling in the regulation of Pax2 and Pax6 distributions and in the subsequent morphogenesis of the eyes. Midline signalling is severely perturbed in cyclops mutant embryos resulting in an absence of ventral midline CNS tissue and fusion of the eyes. Mutant embryos ectopically express Pax6 in a bridge of tissue around the anterior pole of the neural keel in the position normally occupied by cells that form the optic stalks. In contrast, Pax2 protein is almost completely absent from this region in mutant embryos. Concommitant with the changes in Pax protein distribution, cells in the position of the optic stalks differentiate as retina. These results suggest that a signal emanating from the midline, which is absent in cyclops mutant embryos, may be required to promote Pax2 and inhibit Pax6 expression in cells destined to form the optic stalks. Sonic hedgehog (Shh also known as Vhh-1 and Hhg-1) is a midline signalling molecule that is absent from the neuroepithelium of cyclops mutant embryos at early developmental stages. To test the possibility that Shh might be able to regulate the spatial expression of Pax6 and Pax2 in the optic primordia, it was overexpressed in the developing CNS. The number of cells containing Pax2 was increased following shh overexpression and embryos developed hypertrophied optic stalk-like structures. Complimentary to the changes in Pax2 distribution, there were fewer Pax6-containing cells and pigment epithelium and neural retina were reduced. Our results suggest that Shh or a closely related signalling molecule emanating from midline tissue in the ventral forebrain either directly or indirectly induces the expression of Pax2 and inhibits the expression of Pax6 and thus may regulate the partitioning of the optic primordia into optic stalks and retinal tissue.

Distribution of tissue progenitors within the shield region of the zebrafish gastrula

The zebrafish has emerged as an important model system for the experimental analysis of vertebrate development because it is amenable to genetic analysis and because its optical clarity allows the movements and the differentiation of individual cells to be followed in vivo. In this paper, we have sought to characterize the spatial distribution of tissue progenitors within the outer cell layers of the embryonic shield region of the early gastrula. Single cells were labeled by iontophoretic injection of fluorescent dextrans. Subsequently, we documented their position with respect to the embryonic shield and their eventual fates. Our data show that progenitor cells of the neural, notochordal, somitic and endodermal lineages were all present within the embryonic shield region, and that these progenitors were arranged as intermingled populations. Moreover, close to the midline, there was evidence for significant biases in the distribution of neural and notochord progenitors between the layers, suggesting some degree of radial organization within the zebrafish embryonic shield region. The distributions of tissue progenitors in the zebrafish gastrula differ significantly from those in amphibians; this bears not only on interpretations of mutant phenotypes and in situ staining patterns, but also on our understanding of morphogenetic movements during gastrulation and of neural induction in the zebrafish.

Determination events in the nervous system of the vertebrate embryo

Molecular and functional data suggest that the regionalization of the caudal portion of the vertebrate embryonic brain (hindbrain) is set up through a process of segmentation. In contrast, the more rostrally located met-mesencephalic domain (mid-hindbrain junction) appears to follow a mode of specification that relies on long-range inducing and organizing activities originating from the central region of the domain. Recent studies addressing this mode of anterior/posterior determination point to Wnt-1 as a key player in this process.

Patterning of the neural ectoderm of Xenopus laevis by the amino-terminal product of hedgehog autoproteolytic cleavage

The patterns of embryonic expression and the activities of Xenopus members of the hedgehog gene family are suggestive of role in neural induction and patterning. We report that these hedgehog polypeptides undergo autoproteolytic cleavage. Injection into embryos of mRNAs encoding Xenopus banded-hedgehog (X-bhh) or the amino-terminal domain (N) demonstrates that the direct inductive activities of X-bhh are encoded by N. In addition, both N and X-bhh pattern neural tissue by elevating expression of anterior neural genes. Unexpectedly, an internal deletion of X-bhh (delta N-C) was found to block the activity of X-bhh and N in explants and to reduce dorsoanterior structures in embryos. As elevated hedgehog activity increases the expression of anterior neural genes, and as delta N-C reduces dorsoanterior structures, these complementary data support a role for hedgehog in neural induction and anteroposterior patterning.

Xwnt-8b: a maternally expressed Xenopus Wnt gene with a potential role in establishing the dorsoventral axis

In amphibian embryos, establishment of dorsal-ventral asymmetry is believed to involve dorsal-ventral differences in vegetally derived mesoderm-inducing signals and/or differences in the competence of animal hemisphere (ectodermal) cells to respond to these signals. Previous studies have shown that certain Wnt proteins can generate an ectopic dorsal axis when misexpressed, and that they do so by modifying the response of ectodermal cells to inducers. None of these Wnt proteins are expressed at an appropriate time to do so in vivo. In this study, we describe the isolation and characterization of a full length cDNA for the Xenopus Wnt gene, Xwnt-8b, whose biological activity and expression pattern suggest that it may be involved in establishment of the dorsoventral axis. Both maternal and zygotic Xwnt-8b transcripts undergo alternative splicing to generate mRNAs which encode two different forms of Xwnt-8b protein. During early cleavage stages Xwnt-8b transcripts are confined primarily to animal hemisphere blastomeres, while zygotically derived Xwnt-8b transcripts are restricted almost exclusively to a band of cells in the prospective forebrain of neurula and tailbud stage embryos. Ectopically expressed Xwnt-8b can completely rescue dorsal development of embryos ventralized by exposure to ultraviolet light, and can induce a complete secondary axis in wild-type embryos. Axis induction is observed only if Xwnt-8b is supplied prior to the onset of zygotic gene transcription. This biological activity, together with the presence of maternal Xwnt-8b transcripts in cells that will be induced to form the dorsal mesoderm, is consistent with the possibility that Xwnt-8b may be the endogenous agent that establishes asymmetry in the response of ectodermal cells to mesoderm-inducing signals, thereby initiating dorsal development.

Tissue-specific and differential expression of alternatively spliced alpha 1(II) collagen mRNAs in early human embryos

Expression of the alpha 1(II) procollagen gene is not confined to chondrogenic tissues during vertebrate development. Transcripts of the human gene (COL2A1) are alternatively spliced to give mRNAs which either exclude (type IIB mRNA) or include (type IIA mRNA) an exon encoding a cysteine-rich domain in the amino-propeptide. The distribution of COL2A1 mRNAs in 27- to 44-day human embryos and 8- to 24-week fetuses was studied by in situ hybridization and RNase protection analyses. Type IIA mRNAs were expressed in prechondrogenic cells and were also preferentially expressed in chondrogenic tissues at regions of chondrocyte commitment and cartilage growth. During maturation of chondrocytes, there is a switch to expression of type IIB mRNAs. In non-chondrogenic tissues of early embryos, type IIA mRNA expression was associated with active tissue remodeling, epithelial organization, and sites of tissue interaction. Type IIA mRNAs were also expressed in some non-chondrogenic tissues where expression had previously been undetected, such as the tooth bud, liver, adrenal cortex, apical ectodermal ridge, and indifferent gonad. In older fetuses type IIA mRNAs were the sole or major transcript in most non-chondrogenic tissues except the choroid plexus and tendon. In the meninges there was a unique switch from type IIB to type IIA expression. The expression pattern of COL2A1 transcripts suggests that, in addition to contributing to the structural integrity of the cartilage extracellular matrix, type II procollagen may serve a morphogenetic role in embryonic development. Our findings clearly show that the pattern of expression of type II procollagen mRNAs is largely conserved between man and mouse. However, some differences exist, and these should be taken into consideration when animal models are used to study human diseases associated with COL2A1.

Expression of the novel murine homeobox gene Sax-1 in the developing nervous system

We have isolated the novel murine Sax-1 gene, a member of the NK-1 class of homeobox genes, and report its expression pattern in the developing central nervous system (CNS) in comparison to two other homeobox genes, Evx-1 and Pax-6. Sax-1 was found to be transiently expressed in the developing posterior CNS. First seen in the ectoderm lateral to the primitive streak, the signal later encompassed the neural plate. Posteriorly, the expression domain overlapped with the Evx-1 expression in the streak, while anteriorly it was delimited by the Pax-6 signal in the neural tube. This early phase starting at day 9.5 pc, Sax-1 was expressed in distinct areas of spinal cord, hindbrain and forebrain. Particularly strong signals were detected in rhombomere 1 and in the pretectum. In these areas, subsets of neurons may be marked and specified. In addition to the normal pattern of Sax-1 during development, the expression in different mouse mutants was analysed. In Brachyury curtailed homozygotes, the expression of Sax-1 was found to be reduced during neurulation and even lost at day 9.0 pc. Ventral shift and finally loss of the signal in the ventral spinal cord was observed in Danforth's short tail homozygotes.

Model of forebrain regionalization based on spatiotemporal patterns of POU-III homeobox gene expression, birthdates, and morphological features

In situ hybridization was used to map spatiotemporal expression patterns of the four known intronless POU-III transcription factor genes Brn-1, Brn-2, Brn-4, and Tst-1 in the developing rat forebrain vesicle, beginning on embryonic day 10. The results indicate that the proliferation layers (ventricular and subventricular) and mantle layer of the forebrain neural tube each display a strikingly unique pattern of regionalized POU-III expression. Within a particular region, or layer within a region, none to all four of the mRNAs may be detected, and during development a particular mRNA in a particular region displays one of five expression patterns, or a combination of these patterns, which may be described as conserved, lost, transient, acquired, or redeployed expression. In the developing brain as a whole, Brn-1 and Brn-2 early on display somewhat different spatial expression patterns that converge to essential identity in the adult, whereas Brn-4 expression is initially broad and becomes much more restricted in the adult, and Tst-1 expression expands greatly through development. Usually, though not always, expression patterns tend to correlate with major histological features in the forebrain (often internal or external sulci associated with proliferation zones), and little evidence for waves of expression moving through the whole forebrain over time was obtained. Thus, clear differences in hybridization intensity often are observed between the cerebral cortex, basal telencephalic nuclei, hypothalamus, ventral thalamus, dorsal thalamus, and pretectal region. In contrast, transverse bands of hybridization extending from the roof to the floor of the forebrain, corresponding to proposed neuromeres, were not observed with these probes. The results suggest that POU-III transcription factors help define specific regions in the early neuroepithelium as well as different cellular phenotypes in the ventricular, subventricular, and mantle layers of specific regions later in development. Thus, the functions of these regulatory proteins may be different in proliferating neuroepithelial cells, young neurons, and mature neurons and appear to be region-specific.

Evolutionary-conserved enhancers direct region-specific expression of the murine Hoxa-1 and Hoxa-2 loci in both mice and Drosophila

The HOM-C/Hox complexes are an evolutionary related family of genes that have been shown to direct region-specific development of the animal body plan. We examined in transgenic mice the DNA regulatory elements that determine the temporal and spatially restricted expression of two of the earliest and most anteriorly expressed murine genes, Hoxa-1 and Hoxa-2, which are homologues of the labial and proboscipedia genes of Drosophila. In both mouse and Drosophila, these genes have been shown to play a critical role in head development. We identified three independent enhancers which direct distinct portions of the Hoxa-1 and Hoxa-2 expression domains during early murine embryogenesis. Two enhancers mediate hindbrain-specific expression, being active in either rhombomere 2, the most anterior rhombomere expressing Hoxa-2, or in rhombomere 4, a region where Hoxa-1 and Hoxa-2 have been shown to exert critical developmental roles. The third enhancer is essential for the most extensive expression domain of Hoxa-1 and contains a retinoic acid response element. Point mutations within the retinoic acid response element abolish expression in neuroepithelium caudal to rhombomere 4, supporting a natural role for endogenous retinoids in patterning of the hindbrain and spinal cord. Analysis of the murine Hoxa-2 rhombomere 2-specific enhancer in Drosophila embryos revealed a distinct expression domain within the arthropod head segments, which parallels the expression domain of the Hoxa-2 homologue proboscipedia. These results suggest an evolutionary conservation between HOM-C/Hox family members, which includes a conservation of certain DNA regulatory elements and possible regulatory cascades.

XIPOU 2, a noggin-inducible gene, has direct neuralizing activity

XIPOU 2, a member of the class III POU domain family, is expressed initially in Spemann's organizer, and later, in discrete regions of the developing nervous system in Xenopus laevis. XIPOU 2 may act downstream from initial neural induction events, since it is activated by the neural inducer, noggin. To determine if XIPOU 2 participates in the early events of neurogenesis, synthetic mRNA was microinjected into specific blastomeres of the 32-cell stage embryo. Misexpression of XIPOU 2 in the epidermis causes a direct switch in cell fate from an epidermal to a neuronal phenotype. In the absence of mesoderm induction, XIPOU 2 has the ability to induce a neuronal phenotype in uncommitted ectoderm. These data demonstrate the potential of XIPOU 2 to act as a master regulator of neurogenesis.

Neuroectodermal fate of epiblast cells in the distal region of the mouse egg cylinder: implication for body plan organization during early embryogenesis

The developmental fate of cells in the distal region (distal cap) of the epiblast was analysed by fate mapping studies. The displacement and differentiation of cells labelled in situ with carbocyanine dyes and lacZ-expressing cells grafted to the distal cap were studied over a 48-hour period of in vitro development. The distal cap epiblast differentiates predominantly into neurectodermal cells. Cells at the anterior site of the distal cap colonise the fore-, mid- and hindbrain and contribute to non-neural ectoderm cells of the amnion and craniofacial surface ectoderm. Those cells in the most distal region of the epiblast contribute to all three brain compartments as well as the spinal cord and the posterior neuropore. Cells at the posterior site of the distal cap are mainly localised to the caudal parts of the neural tube. A minor contribution to the embryonic (paraxial and lateral) and extraembryonic (allantoic and yolk sac) mesoderm is also found. Epiblast cells located outside the distal cap give rise to surface ectoderm and other non-ectodermal derivatives, with only a minor contribution to the neuroectoderm. Results of this study provide compelling evidence that the precursor population of the neural tube is contained in the distal cap epiblast of the early-primitive-streak-stage embryo. Furthermore, the regionalisation of cell fate within this small population suggest that a preliminary craniocaudal patterning may have occurred in the neural primordium before neurulation.

Involvement of wnt1 and pax2 in the formation of the midbrain-hindbrain boundary in the zebrafish gastrula

The secreted signalling molecule encoded by the wnt1 gene and the paired box-containing pax2 gene are thought to play an integral role in patterning the zebrafish rostral nervous system. Using a double-label analysis, we compare the expression patterns of wnt1 RNA and pax2 protein during zebrafish embryogenesis to determine whether they were expressed in identical or overlapping patterns in individual embryos. During gastrulation, wnt1 RNA was detected in a pattern similar but not identical to the pax2 protein. Later, wnt1 and pax2 co-localize to the midbrain-hindbrain boundary. Exogenous retinoic acid, a teratogen that is known to affect the formation of the midbrain-hindbrain boundary, has a profound affect on both wnt1 and pax2 expression at gastrulation. Furthermore, when pax2 is overexpressed in zebrafish embryos, the wnt1 pattern of expression expands ventrally in the prospective rostral neuroepithelium. Despite the widespread and random distribution of exogenous pax2 RNA, it alone is unable to induce wnt1 expression in other ectopic sites. These results are consistent with the coordinate expression of wnt1 and pax2 being in a pathway responsible for establishing the midbrain-hindbrain boundary and support the earlier interpretation that pax2 may regulate wnt1 expression [Krauss et al., 1992], although only in a subset of embryonic cells. These data suggest that a predisposition for the regionalization of the central nervous system exists at gastrulation.

Expression of two zebrafish orthodenticle-related genes in the embryonic brain

To analyze the molecular mechanism of pattern formation in the anteriormost regions of the zebrafish embryo, we isolated two zebrafish sequences, zOtx1 and zOtx2, related to the Drosophila orthodenticle (otd) and two murine Otx genes. zOtx1 and zOtx2 encode predicted gene products which are 82% and 94% identical to the corresponding mouse proteins. Transcripts of both zebrafish genes appear abruptly at high levels in a triangular patch at the animal pole of the mid-gastrula, a region which contains cells fated to become midbrain and forebrain. Between 9 and 14 h of development, zOtx transcripts disappear from forebrain regions in a manner characteristic for each gene, and from 14 to 24 h, particular regions of the forebrain and midbrain express one or both genes. The posterior limit of expression of both genes in 10-30-h embryos forms a sharp boundary at the posterior border of the midbrain. As in the mouse, the early expression patterns of the zOtx genes are consistent with a role in defining midbrain and forebrain territories. However, there are a number of interesting differences between the forebrain and midbrain regions which express the genes in the two species.