Reversible polyglutamylation of alpha- and beta-tubulin and microtubule dynamics in mouse brain neurons

Identification of tubulin deglutamylase among Caenorhabditis elegans and mammalian cytosolic carboxypeptidases (CCPs)

Tubulin polyglutamylation is a reversible post-translational modification, serving important roles in microtubule (MT)-related processes. Polyglutamylases of the tubulin tyrosine ligase-like (TTLL) family add glutamate moieties to specific tubulin glutamate residues, whereas as yet unknown deglutamylases shorten polyglutamate chains. First we investigated regulatory machinery of tubulin glutamylation in MT-based sensory cilia of the roundworm Caenorhabditis elegans. We found that ciliary MTs were polyglutamylated by a process requiring ttll-4. Conversely, loss of ccpp-6 gene function, which encodes one of two cytosolic carboxypeptidases (CCPs), resulted in elevated levels of ciliary MT polyglutamylation. Consistent with a deglutamylase function for ccpp-6, overexpression of this gene in ciliated cells decreased polyglutamylation signals. Similarly, we confirmed that overexpression of murine CCP5, one of two sequence orthologs of nematode ccpp-6, caused a dramatic loss of MT polyglutamylation in cultured mammalian cells. Finally, using an in vitro assay for tubulin glutamylation, we found that recombinantly expressed Myc-tagged CCP5 exhibited deglutamylase biochemical activities. Together, these data from two evolutionarily divergent systems identify C. elegans CCPP-6 and its mammalian ortholog CCP5 as a tubulin deglutamylase.

Systems-wide proteomic characterization of combinatorial post-translational modification patterns

Protein post-translational modifications (PTMs) have been widely shown to influence protein-protein interactions, direct subcellular location and transduce a variety of both internal and externally generated signals into cellular/phenotypic outcomes. Mass spectrometry has been a key tool for the elucidation of several types of PTMs in both qualitative and quantitative manners. As large datasets on the proteome-wide level are now being generated on a daily basis, the identification of combinatorial PTM patterns has become feasible. A survey of the recent literature in this area shows that many proteins undergo multiple modifications and that sequential or hierarchal patterns exist on many proteins; the biology of these modification patterns is only starting to be unraveled. This review will outline combinatorial PTM examples in biology, and the mass spectrometry-based techniques and applications utilized in the investigations of these combinatorial PTMs.

Mass spectrometry analysis of C-terminal posttranslational modifications of tubulins

In mammalian brain and ciliary axonemes from ciliates, alpha- and beta-tubulins exhibit an extraordinary heterogeneity due to a combination of multigene family expression and numerous posttranslational modifications (PTMs). The combination of several PTMs located in the C-terminal tail of tubulins plays a major role in this important polymorphism of tubulin: polyglutamylation, polyglycylation, detyrosination, tyrosination, removal of the penultimate glutamate residue, and phosphorylation. In order to document the relationship and functions of these PTMs, we have developed a tubulin C-terminal Peptide Mass Fingerprinting (PMF) method. Using simplified microtubule proteins and tubulin C-terminal peptides purifications, direct matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry (MS) analysis can generate a complete picture of all tubulin isotype-specific C-terminal peptides together with their respective PTMs. This chapter will illustrate the capability of this approach to compare tubulin isoform compositions and document the changes in PTMs between samples with different tubulin assembly properties or consecutively to inactivation of modification sites or modification enzymes. Complementary MS-based approaches useful to document the structure of the highly heterogeneous posttranslational polymodifications will also be presented.

Hyperglutamylation of tubulin can either stabilize or destabilize microtubules in the same cell

In most eukaryotic cells, tubulin is subjected to posttranslational glutamylation, a conserved modification of unclear function. The glutamyl side chains form as branches of the primary sequence glutamic acids in two biochemically distinct steps: initiation and elongation. The length of the glutamyl side chain is spatially controlled and microtubule type specific. Here, we probe the significance of the glutamyl side chain length regulation in vivo by overexpressing a potent side chain elongase enzyme, Ttll6Ap, in Tetrahymena. Overexpression of Ttll6Ap caused hyperelongation of glutamyl side chains on the tubulin of axonemal, cortical, and cytoplasmic microtubules. Strikingly, in the same cell, hyperelongation of glutamyl side chains stabilized cytoplasmic microtubules and destabilized axonemal microtubules. Our observations suggest that the cellular outcomes of glutamylation are mediated by spatially restricted tubulin interactors of diverse nature.

TTLL3 Is a tubulin glycine ligase that regulates the assembly of cilia

In most ciliated cell types, tubulin is modified by glycylation, a posttranslational modification of unknown function. We show that the TTLL3 proteins act as tubulin glycine ligases with chain-initiating activity. In Tetrahymena, deletion of TTLL3 shortened axonemes and increased their resistance to paclitaxel-mediated microtubule stabilization. In zebrafish, depletion of TTLL3 led to either shortening or loss of cilia in several organs, including the Kupffer's vesicle and olfactory placode. We also show that, in vivo, glutamic acid and glycine ligases oppose each other, likely by competing for shared modification sites on tubulin. We propose that tubulin glycylation regulates the assembly and dynamics of axonemal microtubules and acts either directly or indirectly by inhibiting tubulin glutamylation.

Roles of beta-tubulin residues Ala428 and Thr429 in microtubule formation in vivo

The C termini of beta-tubulin isotypes are regions of high sequence variability that bind to microtubule-associated proteins and motors and undergo various post-translational modifications such as polyglutamylation and polyglycylation. Crystallographic analyses have been unsuccessful in resolving tubulin C termini. Here, we used a stepwise approach to study the role of this region in microtubule assembly. We generated a series of truncation mutants of human betaI and betaIII tubulin. Transient transfection of HeLa cells with the mutants shows that mutants with deletions of up to 22 residues from betaIII and 16 from betaI can assemble normally. Interestingly, removal of the next residue (Ala(428)) results in a complete loss of microtubule formation without affecting dimer formation. C-terminal tail switching of human betaI and betaIII tubulin suggests that C-terminal tails are functionally equivalent. In short, residues outside of 1-429 of human beta-tubulins make no contribution to microtubule assembly. Ala(428), in the C-terminal sequence motif N-QQYQDA(428), lies at the end of helix H12 of beta-tubulin. We hypothesize that this residue is important for maintaining helix H12 structure. Deletion of Ala(428) may lead to unwinding of helix H12, resulting in tubulin dimers incapable of assembly. Thr(429) plays a more complex role. In the betaI isotype of tubulin, Thr(429) is not at all necessary for assembly; however, in the betaIII isotype, its presence strongly favors assembly. This result is consistent with a likely more complex function of betaIII as well as with the observation that evolutionary conservation is total for Ala(428) and frequent for Thr(429).

Cell biology of embryonic migration

Cell migration is an evolutionarily conserved mechanism that underlies the development and functioning of uni- and multicellular organisms and takes place in normal and pathogenic processes, including various events of embryogenesis, wound healing, immune response, cancer metastases, and angiogenesis. Despite the differences in the cell types that take part in different migratory events, it is believed that all of these migrations occur by similar molecular mechanisms, whose major components have been functionally conserved in evolution and whose perturbation leads to severe developmental defects. These mechanisms involve intricate cytoskeleton-based molecular machines that can sense the environment, respond to signals, and modulate the entire cell behavior. A big question that has concerned the researchers for decades relates to the coordination of cell migration in situ and its relation to the intracellular aspects of the cell migratory mechanisms. Traditionally, this question has been addressed by researchers that considered the intra- and extracellular mechanisms driving migration in separate sets of studies. As more data accumulate researchers are now able to integrate all of the available information and consider the intracellular mechanisms of cell migration in the context of the developing organisms that contain additional levels of complexity provided by extracellular regulation. This review provides a broad summary of the existing and emerging data in the cell and developmental biology fields regarding cell migration during development.

Glutamylation on alpha-tubulin is not essential but affects the assembly and functions of a subset of microtubules in Tetrahymena thermophila

Tubulin undergoes glutamylation, a conserved posttranslational modification of poorly understood function. We show here that in the ciliate Tetrahymena, most of the microtubule arrays contain glutamylated tubulin. However, the length of the polyglutamyl side chain is spatially regulated, with the longest side chains present on ciliary and basal body microtubules. We focused our efforts on the function of glutamylation on the alpha-tubulin subunit. By site-directed mutagenesis, we show that all six glutamates of the C-terminal tail domain of alpha-tubulin that provide potential sites for glutamylation are not essential but are needed for normal rates of cell multiplication and cilium-based functions (phagocytosis and cell motility). By comparative phylogeny and biochemical assays, we identify two conserved tubulin tyrosine ligase (TTL) domain proteins, Ttll1p and Ttll9p, as alpha-tubulin-preferring glutamyl ligase enzymes. In an in vitro microtubule glutamylation assay, Ttll1p showed a chain-initiating activity while Ttll9p had primarily a chain-elongating activity. GFP-Ttll1p localized mainly to basal bodies, while GFP-Ttll9p localized to cilia. Disruption of the TTLL1 and TTLL9 genes decreased the rates of cell multiplication and phagocytosis. Cells lacking both genes had fewer cortical microtubules and showed defects in the maturation of basal bodies. We conclude that glutamylation on alpha-tubulin is not essential but is required for efficiency of assembly and function of a subset of microtubule-based organelles. Furthermore, the spatial restriction of modifying enzymes appears to be a major mechanism that drives differential glutamylation at the subcellular level.

Polyglutamylation: a fine-regulator of protein function? 'Protein Modifications: beyond the usual suspects' review series

Polyglutamylation is a post-translational modification in which glutamate side chains of variable lengths are formed on the modified protein. It is evolutionarily conserved from protists to mammals and its most prominent substrate is tubulin, the microtubule (MT) building block. Various polyglutamylation states of MTs can be distinguished within a single cell and they are also characteristic of specific cell types or organelles. Polyglutamylation has been proposed to be involved in the functional adaptation of MTs, as it occurs within the carboxy-terminal tubulin tails that participate directly in the binding of many structural and motor MT-associated proteins. The discovery of a new family of enzymes that catalyse this modification has brought new insight into the mechanism of polyglutamylation and now allows for direct functional studies of the role of tubulin polyglutamylation. Moreover, the recent identification of new substrates of polyglutamylation indicates that this post-translational modification could be a potential regulator of diverse cellular processes.

Gamma-glutamyl hydrolase: kinetic characterization of isopeptide hydrolysis using fluorogenic substrates

Gamma-glutamyl hydrolase, a cysteine peptidase, catalyzes the hydrolysis of poly-gamma-glutamate derivatives of folate cofactors and many antifolate drugs. We have used internally quenched fluorogenic derivatives of glutamyl-gamma-glutamate and (4,4-difluoro)glutamyl-gamma-glutamate to examine the effect of fluorine substitution adjacent to the scissile isopeptide bond. Using a newly developed continuous fluorescence assay, the hydrolysis of both substrates could be described by Michaelis-Menten kinetics. Fluorine substitution resulted in a significant decrease in observed rates of hydrolysis under steady-state conditions due primarily to a approximately 15-fold increase in Km. Using stopped-flow techniques, hydrolysis of the non-fluorinated isopeptide was characterized by a burst phase followed by a steady-state rate, indicating that formation of the acyl enzyme is not rate-limiting for hydrolysis of this isopeptide. This conclusion was confirmed by analysis of the progress curves over a wide range of substrate concentration, which demonstrated that the acylation rate (k2) is approximately 10-fold higher than the deacylation rate (k3). The increased value of Km associated with the difluoro derivative limited the ability to obtain comparable pre-steady-state kinetics data at saturating concentration of substrate due to inner filter effects. However, even under nonsaturating conditions, a modest burst was observed for the difluoro derivative. These data indicate that either deacylation or rearrangement of the enzyme-product complex is rate-limiting in this isopeptide hydrolysis reaction.

Ciliary tubulin and its post-translational modifications

Tubulin, the most abundant axonemal protein, is extensively modified by several highly conserved post-translational mechanisms including acetylation, detyrosination, glutamylation, and glycylation. We discuss the pathways that contribute to the assembly and maintenance of axonemal microtubules, with emphasis on the potential functions of post-translational modifications that affect tubulin. The recent identification of a number of tubulin modifying enzymes and mutational studies of modification sites on tubulin have allowed for significant functional insights. Polymeric modifications of tubulin (glutamylation and glycylation) have emerged as important determinants of the 9 + 2 axoneme assembly and motility.

A targeted multienzyme mechanism for selective microtubule polyglutamylation

Polyglutamylases are enzymes that form polyglutamate side chains of variable lengths on proteins. Polyglutamylation of tubulin is believed to regulate interactions of microtubules (MTs) with MT-associated proteins and molecular motors. Subpopulations of MTs are differentially polyglutamylated, yet only one modifying enzyme has been discovered in mammals. In an attempt to better understand the heterogeneous appearance of tubulin polyglutamylation, we searched for additional enzymes and report here the identification of six mammalian polyglutamylases. Each of them has a characteristic mode of catalysis and generates distinct patterns of modification on MTs, which can be further diversified by cooperation of multiple enzymes. Polyglutamylases are restricted to confined tissues and subtypes of MTs by differential expression and localization. In conclusion, we propose a multienzyme mechanism of polyglutamylation that can explain how the diversity of polyglutamylation on selected types of MTs is controlled at the molecular level.

Glutamylated and glycylated tubulin isoforms in the aberrant sperm axoneme of the gall-midge fly, Asphondylia ruebsaameni

The axonemal organization expressed in the sperm flagella of the cecidomyiid dipteran Asphondylia ruebsaameni is unconventional, being characterized by the presence of an exceedingly high number of microtubular doublets and by the absence of both the inner dynein arms and the central pair/radial spoke complex. Consequently, its motility, both in vivo and in vitro, is also peculiar. Using monoclonal antibodies directed against posttranslational modifications, we have analyzed the presence and distribution of glutamylated and glycylated tubulin isoforms in this aberrant axonemal structure, and compared them with those of a reference insect species (Apis mellifera), endowed with a conventional axoneme. Our results have shown that the unorthodox structure and motility of the Asphondylia axoneme are concomitant with: (1). a very low glutamylation extent in the alpha-tubulin subunit, (2). a high level of glutamylation in the beta-subunit, (3). an extremely low total extent of glycylation, with regard to both monoglycylated and polyglycylated sites, either in alpha- or in beta-tubulin, (4). the presence of a strong labeling of glutamylated tubulin isoforms at the proximal end of the axoneme, and (5). a uniform distribution of glutamylated as well as glycylated isoforms along the rest of the axoneme. Thus, our data indicate that tubulin molecular heterogeneity is much lower in the Asphondylia axoneme than in the conventional 9+2 axoneme with regard to both isoform content and isoform distribution along the axoneme.

Tubulin glycylation and glutamylation deficiencies in unconventional insect axonemes

Though the 9+2 axonemal organization has generally been conserved throughout metazoan evolution, insect spermatozoa possess a substantial variety in axoneme ultrastructure, displaying different axonemal patterns. Therefore, insects provide a wide range of models that may be useful for the study of the mechanisms of axoneme assembly. We have used antibodies specific for glutamylated, monoglycylated, and polyglycylated tubulin to investigate the tubulin isoform content expressed in the unorthodox sperm axonemes of four insect species belonging to both of the superorders Palaeoptera and Neoptera. Each one of these axonemal models exhibits distinctive structural features, either showing the typical radial organization endowed with a ninefold symmetry or consisting of an helical arrangement with up to 200 microtubular doublets, but in all cases these axonemes share the absence of a microtubule central pair. Our results showed that all these atypical patterns are characterized by a dramatic decrease in both tubulin glycylation and glutamylation levels or even lack of both polymodifications. These data provide the first examples of a simultaneous extreme reduction or even absence of both polymodifications in axonemal tubulin. Given the unrelated positions of the analyzed species in the insect phylogenetic tree, this common feature is probably not due to evolutionary relationships. Therefore, our findings support the hypothesis of the existence of a correlation between the low level of polymodifications and the lack of a microtubule central pair in these peculiar insect flagellar axonemes, similarly as was previously proposed for cilia of Tetrahymena glycylation site mutants.

Differential binding regulation of microtubule-associated proteins MAP1A, MAP1B, and MAP2 by tubulin polyglutamylation

The major neuronal post-translational modification of tubulin, polyglutamylation, can act as a molecular potentiometer to modulate microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) binding as a function of the polyglutamyl chain length. The relative affinity of Tau, MAP2, and kinesin has been shown to be optimal for tubulin modified by approximately 3 glutamyl units. Using blot overlay assays, we have tested the ability of polyglutamylation to modulate the interaction of two other structural MAPs, MAP1A and MAP1B, with tubulin. MAP1A and MAP2 display distinct behavior in terms of tubulin binding; they do not compete with each other, even when the polyglutamyl chains of tubulin are removed, indicating that they have distinct binding sites on tubulin. Binding of MAP1A and MAP1B to tubulin is also controlled by polyglutamylation and, although the modulation of MAP1B binding resembles that of MAP2, we found that polyglutamylation can exert a different mode of regulation toward MAP1A. Interestingly, although the affinity of the other MAPs tested so far decreases sharply for tubulins carrying long polyglutamyl chains, the affinity of MAP1A for these tubulins is maintained at a significant level. This differential regulation exerted by polyglutamylation toward different MAPs might facilitate their selective recruitment into distinct microtubule populations, hence modulating their functional properties.

Tubulin polyglycylation in Platyhelminthes: diversity among stable microtubule networks and very late occurrence during spermiogenesis

The distribution of glycylated tubulin has been analyzed in different populations of stable microtubules in a digenean flatworm, Echinostoma caproni (Platyhelminthes). Two cellular types, spermatozoa and ciliated excretory cells, have been analyzed by means of immunofluorescence, immunogold, and immunoblotting techniques using two monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), AXO 49, and TAP 952, specifically directed against differently glycylated isoforms of tubulin. The presence of glycylated tubulin in the two cell types was shown. However, the differential reactivities of TAP 952 and AXO 49 mAbs with the two axoneme types suggest a difference in their glycylation level. In addition, within a single cell, the spermatozoon, cortical microtubules underlying the flagellar membrane, and axonemal microtubules were shown to comprise different tubulin isoforms, the latter ones only being labelled with one of the antiglycylated tubulin mAbs, TAP 952. Similarly, the antiacetylated (6-11B-1) and polyglutamylated (GT335) tubulin mAbs decorated the two types of axonemal microtubules, but not the cortical ones. From these data, a subcellular sorting of posttranslationally modified tubulin isoforms within spermatozoa, on the one hand, and a cellular sorting of glycylated isoforms inside the whole organism, on the other hand, is demonstrated in the flatworm E. caproni. Last, a sequential occurrence of tubulin posttranslational modifications was observed in the course of spermiogenesis. Acetylation appears first, followed shortly by glutamylation; glycylation takes place at the extreme end of spermiogenesis and, specifically, in a proximo-distal process. Thus in agreement with, and extending other studies [Bré et al., 1996], glycylation appears to close the sequence of posttranslational events occurring in axonemal microtubules during spermiogenesis.

Glutamylation of centriole and cytoplasmic tubulin in proliferating non-neuronal cells

We have examined the distribution of glutamylated tubulin in non-neuronal cell lines. A major part of centriole tubulin is highly modified on both the alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits, whereas a minor part of the cytoplasmic tubulin is slightly modified, on the beta-tubulin only. Furthermore, we observed that tubulin glutamylation varies during the cell cycle: an increase occurs during mitosis on both centriole and spindle microtubules. In the spindle, this increase appears more obvious on the pole-to-pole and kinetochore microtubules than on the astral microtubules. The cellular pattern and the temporal variation of this post-translational modification contrast with other previously described tubulin modifications. The functional significance of this distribution is discussed.

Localization of microtubules containing posttranslationally modified tubulin in cochlear epithelial cells during development

In the adult gerbil inner ear, hair cell microtubules contain predominantly tyrosinated tubulin while supporting cell microtubules contain almost exclusively other isoforms. This cell-type specific segregation of tubulin isoforms is unusual, and in this respect the sensory and supporting cells in this sensory organ differ from other cells observed both in vivo and in vitro. Thus, we hypothesized there must be a shift in the presence and location of tubulin isoforms during development, directly associated with the onset of specialized functions of the cells. We describe the appearance and/or disappearance of tubulin isoforms in sensory hair cells and five different supporting cells (inner and outer pillar cells, Deiters cells, cells of Kölliker's organ, and cells of the tympanic covering layer) during development of the gerbil organ of Corti from birth to 14 days after birth. Tyrosinated tubulin was initially present in all cells and remained predominant in cells that decrease in number (Kölliker's organ and tympanic covering layer) and exhibit active processes such as secretion and motility (sensory cells). Posttranslational modifications occurred in the supporting cells in a time-dependent manner as the number and length of microtubules increased and development proceeded, but the establishment of elongated cell shape and polarity occurred prior to the appearance of acetylation, detyrosination, and polyglutamylation of tubulin. In the pillar and Deiters cells, posttranslational modifications progressed from cell apex to base in the same direction as microtubule elongation. In the pillar cells, posttranslational modifications occurred first at the apical surfaces. In the pillar cells, the appearance of acetylated tubulin was rapidly followed by the appearance of detyrosinated tubulin. In Deiters cells, the appearance of acetylated tubulin preceded the appearance of detyrosinated tubulin by one or more days. At onset of cochlear function, detyrosinated tubulin and acetylated tubulin had achieved their adult-like pattern, but polyglutamylated tubulin had not.

Polyglutamylation and polyglycylation of alpha- and beta-tubulins during in vitro ciliated cell differentiation of human respiratory epithelial cells

Tubulins are the major proteins within centriolar and axonemal structures. In all cell types studied so far, numerous alpha- and beta-tubulin isoforms are generated both by expression of a multigenic family and various post-translational modifications. We have developed a primary culture of human nasal epithelial cells where the ciliated cell differentiation process has been observed and quantified. We have used this system to study several properties concerning polyglutamylation and polyglycylation of tubulin. GT335, a monoclonal antibody directed against glutamylated tubulins, stained the centriole/basal bodies and the axonemes of ciliated cells, and the centrioles of non-ciliated cells. By contrast, axonemal but not centriolar tubulins were polyglycylated. Several polyglutamylated and polyglycylated tubulin isotypes were detected by two-dimensional electrophoresis, using GT335 and a specific monoclonal antibody (TAP952) directed against short polyglycyl chains. Immunoelectron microscopy experiments revealed that polyglycylation only affected axonemal tubulin. Using the same technical approach, polyglutamylation was shown to be an early event in the centriole assembly process, as gold particles were detected in fibrogranular material corresponding to the first cytoplasmic structures involved in centriologenesis. In a functional assay, GT335 and TAP952 had a dose-dependent inhibitory effect on ciliary beat frequency. TAP952 had only a weak effect while GT335 treatment led to a total arrest of beating. These results strongly suggest that in human ciliated epithelial cells, tubulin polyglycylation has only a structural role in cilia axonemes, while polyglutamylation may have a function both in centriole assembly and in cilia activity.

Tubulin polyglutamylase: isozymic variants and regulation during the cell cycle in HeLa cells

Polyglutamylation is a posttranslational modification of tubulin that is very common in neurons and ciliated or flagellated cells. It was proposed to regulate the binding of microtubule associated proteins (MAPs) and molecular motors as a function of the length of the polyglutamyl side-chain. Though much less common, this modification of tubulin also occurs in proliferating cells like HeLa cells where it is associated with centrioles and with the mitotic spindle. Recently, we partially purified tubulin polyglutamylase from mouse brain and described its enzymatic properties. In this work, we focused on tubulin polyglutamylase activity from HeLa cells. Our results support the existence of a tubulin polyglutamylase family composed of several isozymic variants specific for alpha- or beta-tubulin subunits. In the latter case, the specificity probably also concerns the different beta-tubulin isotypes. Interestingly, we found that tubulin polyglutamylase activity is regulated in a cell cycle dependent manner and peaks in G(2)-phase while the level of glutamylated tubulin peaks in mitosis. Consistent results were obtained by treating the cells with hydroxyurea, nocodazole or taxotere. In particular, in mitotic cells, tubulin polyglutamylase activity was always low while glutamylation level was high. Finally, tubulin polyglutamylase activity and the level of glutamylated tubulin appeared to be inversely related. This paradox suggests a complex regulation of both tubulin polyglutamylase and the reverse deglutamylase activity.

Synthetic peptides identify the minimal substrate requirements of tubulin polyglutamylase in side chain elongation

The minimal sequence requirement of Crithidia tubulin polyglutamylase is already fulfilled by tubulin-related peptides carrying a free alpha-carboxylate on a glutamic acid residue. Since the product of each glutamylation step fulfills the substrate requirements necessary for the next cycle, very long side chains are generated with brain tubulin as a substrate. Up to 70 mol of glutamic acid was incorporated per alphabeta-heterodimer. We speculate that the strict choice of a particular glutamate residue for the formation of the isopeptide bond initiating a novel side chain is made by a tubulin monoglutamylase which requires the entire tubulin as substrate.

Isolation of tubulin polyglutamylase from Crithidia; binding to microtubules and tubulin, and glutamylation of mammalian brain alpha- and beta-tubulins

Trypanosomatids have a striking cage-like arrangement of submembraneous microtubules. We previously showed that alpha- and beta- tubulins of these stable microtubules are extensively modified by polyglutamylation. Cytoskeletal microtubular preparations obtained by Triton extraction of Leishmania tarentolae and Crithidia fasciculata retain an enzymatic activity that incorporates radioactive glutamic acid in a Mg2+-ATP-dependent manner into alpha- and beta-tubulins. The tubulin polyglutamylase is extracted by 0.25 M salt. The Crithidia enzyme can be purified by ATP-affinity chromatography, glycerol-gradient centrifugation and ion-exchange chromatography. After extraction from the microtubular cytoskeleton the glutamylase forms a complex with alphabeta tubulin, but behaves after removal of tubulin as a globular protein with a molecular mass of 38x10(3). In highly enriched fractions a corresponding band is the major polypeptide visible in SDS-PAGE. The enzyme from Crithidia recognises mammalian brain tubulin, where it incorporates glutamic acid preferentially into the more acidic variants of both alpha- and beta-tubulins. Synthetic peptides with an oligoglutamyl side chain, corresponding to the carboxy-terminal end of brain alpha- and beta-tubulins, are accepted by the enzyme, albeit at low efficiency. The polyglutamylase elongates the side chain by up to 3 and 5 residues, respectively. Other properties of the tubulin polyglutamylase are also discussed.

Doublecortin is a developmentally regulated, microtubule-associated protein expressed in migrating and differentiating neurons

Recently, we and others reported that the doublecortin gene is responsible for X-linked lissencephaly and subcortical laminar heterotopia. Here, we show that Doublecortin is expressed in the brain throughout the period of corticogenesis in migrating and differentiating neurons. Immunohistochemical studies show its localization in the soma and leading processes of tangentially migrating neurons, and a strong axonal labeling is observed in differentiating neurons. In cultured neurons, Doublecortin expression is highest in the distal parts of developing processes. We demonstrate by sedimentation and microscopy studies that Doublecortin is associated with microtubules (MTs) and postulate that it is a novel MAP. Our data suggest that the cortical dysgeneses associated with the loss of Doublecortin function might result from abnormal cytoskeletal dynamics in neuronal cell development.

The carboxy-terminal sequence Asp427-Glu432 of beta-tubulin plays an important function in axonemal motility

Flagellar motility is the result of specific interactions between axonemal microtubular proteins and the dynein motors. Tubulin, the main component of microtubule, is a very polymorphic protein resulting from the expression of several isogenes and from the existence of various post-translational modifications. In order to characterize tubulin isoforms and tubulin domains that are important for flagellar movement, we prepared monoclonal antibodies against axonemal proteins from whole sea-urchin sperm tails. The monoclonal antibodies obtained were screened for their potency to inhibit demembranated-reactivated sperm models and for their monospecific immunoreactivity on immunoblot. Among the different antibodies we obtained, D66 reacted specifically with a subset of beta-tubulin isoforms. Limited proteolysis, HPLC, peptide sequencing, mass spectroscopy and immunoblotting experiments indicated that D66 recognized an epitope localized in the primary sequence Gln423-Glu435 of the C-terminal domain of Lytechinus pictus beta2-tubulin, and that this sequence belongs to class IVb. The use of synthetic peptides and immunoblotting analysis further narrowed the amino acids important for antibody recognition to Asp427-Glu432. Because the primary effect of this antibody on sperm motility is to decrease the flagellar beat frequency, we suggest that this sequence is involved in the tubulin-dynein head interaction.

Tubulin polyglycylation: differential posttranslational modification of dynamic cytoplasmic and stable axonemal microtubules in paramecium

Polyglycylation, a posttranslational modification of tubulin, was discovered in the highly stable axonemal microtubules of Paramecium cilia where it involves the lateral linkage of up to 34 glycine units per tubulin subunit. The observation of this type of posttranslational modification mainly in axonemes raises the question as to its relationship with axonemal organization and with microtubule stability. This led us to investigate the glycylation status of cytoplasmic microtubules that correspond to the dynamic microtubules in Paramecium. Two anti-glycylated tubulin monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), TAP 952 and AXO 49, are shown here to exhibit different affinities toward mono- and polyglycylated synthetic tubulin peptides. Using immunoblotting and mass spectrometry, we show that cytoplasmic tubulin is glycylated. In contrast to the highly glycylated axonemal tubulin, which is recognized by the two mAbs, cytoplasmic tubulin reacts exclusively with TAP 952, and the alpha- and beta- tubulin subunits are modified by only 1-5 and 2-9 glycine units, respectively. Our analyses suggest that most of the cytoplasmic tubulin contains side chain lengths of 1 or 2 glycine units distributed on several glycylation sites. The subcellular partition of distinct polyglycylated tubulin isoforms between cytoplasmic and axonemal compartments implies the existence of regulatory mechanisms for glycylation. By following axonemal tubulin immunoreactivity with anti-glycylated tubulin mAbs upon incubation with a Paramecium cellular extract, the presence of a deglycylation enzyme is revealed in the cytoplasm of this organism. These observations establish that polyglycylation is reversible and indicate that, in vivo, an equilibrium between glycylating and deglycylating enzymes might be responsible for the length of the oligoglycine side chains of tubulin.

Association of estramustine resistance in human prostatic carcinoma cells with modified patterns of tubulin expression

Estramustine (EM) is an antimicrotubule drug used in the treatment of hormone refractory advanced prostate cancer. To investigate the mechanism of resistance to EM, we compared its effects on human prostate cancer cells (DU145) and an estramustine-resistant derived cell line (E4). Immunofluorescence demonstrated that EM caused depolymerization of microtubules and blocked cells in mitosis in DU145 cells, with less effect in E4 cells. Using tubulin isotype-specific antibodies, a threefold increase in betaIII and approximately twofold increase in betaI + II isotype in E4 cells compared to DU145 cells were observed. A most interesting observation concerned an increase in the posttranslational modification of alpha-tubulin of both polyglutamylation and acetylation in the E4 cells. Significant to this observation, using direct EM photoaffinity labeling of tubulin, drug binding to the most acidic posttranslationally modified forms of alpha-tubulin was shown to be minimal. Taken together, these results indicate that the modification of the tubulin expression pattern may be responsible for estramustine resistance by both lowering the amount of drug bound to microtubules and inducing more stable microtubules.

Multiple forms of tubulin: different gene products and covalent modifications

Tubulin, the subunit protein of microtubules, is an alpha/beta heterodimer. In many organisms, both alpha and beta exist in numerous isotypic forms encoded by different genes. In addition, both alpha and beta undergo a variety of posttranslational covalent modifications, including acetylation, phosphorylation, detyrosylation, polyglutamylation, and polyglycylation. In this review the distribution and possible functional significance of the various forms of tubulin are discussed. In analyzing the differences among tubulin isotypes encoded by different genes, some appear to have no functional significance, some increase the overall adaptability of the organism to environmental challenges, and some appear to perform specific functions including formation of particular organelles and interactions with specific proteins. Purified isotypes also display different properties in vitro. Although the significance of all the covalent modification of tubulin is not fully understood, some of them may influence the stability of modified microtubules in vivo as well as interactions with certain proteins and may help to determine the functional role of microtubules in the cell. The review also discusses isotypes of gamma-tubulin and puts various forms of tubulin in an evolutionary context.

Profile of glutamylated tubulin expression during cerebellar granule cell development in vitro

The developmental regulation of tubulin and several of its posttranslational modifications was examined during the differentiation of rat cerebellar granule cells in vitro. In particular, we have noted that the glutamylation of alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits varies during development and becomes more prominent in differentiating neuronal processes. These results indicate that glutamylation of tubulin may be important in the stabilization of microtubules during the maturation of the neuronal cytoskeleton.

Tubulin tyrosine ligase: protein and mRNA expression in developing rat skeletal muscle

Alpha tubulin can be post-translationally tyrosinated at the carboxy-terminus by a specific enzyme: tubulin tyrosine ligase. The expression of tubulin tyrosine ligase mRNA and protein during the development of rat skeletal muscle was examined in the present study. A portion of the coding region of the rat ligase cDNA was isolated and sequenced. The nucleotide and amino acid sequences showed about 90% homology with previously reported porcine and bovine ligase sequences. In newborn rats, ligase mRNA and protein were highly expressed in skeletal muscle. During early postnatal development, however, both ligase mRNA and protein dropped down dramatically. Quantitative measurements revealed that ligase protein at postnatal day 20 represented only 10% or less of the level at postnatal day 1. Ligase mRNA expression was also examined during the myogenesis in vitro. A strong ligase mRNA signal was detected in both undifferentiated myoblasts and cross-striated, contractile myotubes. The present results suggest that, during muscle differentiation, ligase function may be regulated by the amount of available mRNA. The discrepancy in the ligase expression between the in vivo and in vitro myogenesis suggests that factors controlling the levels of mRNA in vivo are lost in vitro.

Structurally similar Drosophila alpha-tubulins are functionally distinct in vivo

We used transgenic analysis in Drosophila to compare the ability of two structurally similar alpha-tubulin isoforms to support microtubule assembly in vivo. Our data revealed that even closely related alpha-tubulin isoforms have different functional capacities. Thus, in multicellular organisms, even small changes in tubulin structure may have important consequences for regulation of the microtubule cytoskeleton. In spermatogenesis, all microtubule functions in the postmitotic male germ cells are carried out by a single tubulin heterodimer composed of the major Drosophila alpha-84B tubulin isoform and the testis-specific beta 2-tubulin isoform. We tested the ability of the developmentally regulated alpha 85E-tubulin isoform to replace alpha 84B in spermatogenesis. Even though it is 98% similar in sequence, alpha 85E is not functionally equivalent to alpha 84B. alpha 85E can support some functional microtubules in the male germ cells, but alpha 85E causes dominant male sterility if it makes up more than one-half of the total alpha-tubulin pool in the spermatids. alpha 85E does not disrupt meiotic spindle or cytoplasmic microtubules but causes defects in morphogenesis of the two classes of singlet microtubules in the sperm tail axoneme, the central pair and the accessory microtubules. Axonemal defects caused by alpha 85E are precisely reciprocal to dominant defects in doublet microtubules we observed in a previous study of ectopic germ-line expression of the developmentally regulated beta 3-tubulin isoform. These data demonstrate that the doublet and singlet axoneme microtubules have different requirements for alpha- and beta-tubulin structure. In their normal sites of expression, alpha 85E and beta 3 are coexpressed during differentiation of several somatic cell types, suggesting that alpha 85E and beta 3 might form a specialized heterodimer. Our tests of different alpha-beta pairs in spermatogenesis did not support this model. We conclude that if alpha 85E and beta 3 have specialized properties required for their normal functions, they act independently to modulate the properties of microtubules into which they are incorporated.

Tubulin post-translational modifications--enzymes and their mechanisms of action

This review describes the enzymes responsible for the post-translational modifications of tubulin, including detyrosination/tyrosination, acetylation/deacetylation, phosphorylation, polyglutamylation, polyglycylation and the generation of non-tyrosinatable alpha-tubulin. Tubulin tyrosine-ligase, which reattaches tyrosine to detyrosinated tubulin, has been extensively characterized and its gene sequenced. Enzymes such as tubulin-specific carboxypeptidase and alpha-tubulin acetyltransferase, required, respectively, for detyrosination and acetylation of tubulin, have yet to be purified to homogeneity and examined in defined systems. This has produced some conflicting results, especially for the carboxypeptidase. The phosphorylation of tubulin by several different types of kinases has been studied in detail but drawing conclusions is difficult because many of these enzymes modify proteins other than their actual substrates, an especially pertinent consideration for in vitro experiments. Tubulin phosphorylation in cultured neuronal cells has proven to be the best model for evaluation of kinase effects on tubulin/microtubule function. There is little information on the enzymes required for polyglutamylation, polyglycylation, and production of non-tyrosinatable tubulin, but the available data permit interesting speculation of a mechanistic nature. Clearly, to achieve a full appreciation of tubulin post-translational changes the responsible enzymes must be characterized. Knowing when the enzymes are active in cells, if soluble or polymerized tubulin is the preferred substrate and the amino acid residues modified by each enzyme are all important. Moreover, acquisition of purified enzymes will lead to cloning and sequencing of their genes. With this information, one can manipulate cell genomes in order to either modify key enzymes or change their relative amounts, and perhaps reveal the physiological significance of tubulin post-translational modifications.

Interaction of kinesin motor domains with alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits at a tau-independent binding site. Regulation by polyglutamylation

Interaction of rat kinesin and Drosophila nonclaret disjunctional motor domains with tubulin was studied by a blot overlay assay. Either plus-end or minus-end-directed motor domain binds at the same extent to both alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits, suggesting that kinesin binding is an intrinsic property of each tubulin subunit and that motor directionality cannot be related to a preferential interaction with a given tubulin subunit. Binding features of dimeric versus monomeric rat kinesin heads suggest that dimerization could drive conformational changes to enhance binding to tubulin. Competition experiments have indicated that kinesin interacts with tubulin at a Tau-independent binding site. Complementary experiments have shown that kinesin does not interact with the same efficiency with the different tubulin isoforms. Masking the polyglutamyl chains with a specific monoclonal antibody leads to a complete inhibition of kinesin binding. These results are consistent with a model in which polyglutamylation of tubulin regulates kinesin binding through progressive conformational changes of the whole carboxyl-terminal domain of tubulin as a function of the polyglutamyl chain length, thus modulating the affinity of tubulin for kinesin and Tau as well. These results indicate that microtubules, through tubulin polymorphism, do have the ability to control microtubule-associated protein binding.

Axonemal tubulin polyglycylation probed with two monoclonal antibodies: widespread evolutionary distribution, appearance during spermatozoan maturation and possible function in motility

Two monoclonal antibodies, AXO 49 and TAP 952, probed with carboxy-terminal peptides from Paramecium axonemal tubulin and with polyglycylated synthetic peptides, are found to recognize differently tubulin polyglycylation, the most recently identified posttranslational modification discovered in Paramecium axonemal tubulin. With these antibodies, we show that tubulin polyglycylation is widely distributed in organisms ranging from ciliated protozoa to mammals; it arose early in the course of evolution, but seems to be absent in primitive protozoa such as the Euglenozoa. Tubulin polyglycylation is the last posttranslational modification which takes place in the course of Drosophila spermatogenesis and its occurrence corresponds to the end of spermatozoan maturation. An involvement of polyglycylated tubulin in axoneme motility is suggested since AXO 49 and TAP 952 specifically inhibit the reactivated motility of sea urchin spermatozoa.

Expression and posttranslational modification of class III beta-tubulin during neuronal differentiation of P19 embryonal carcinoma cells

We have used a combination of immunofluorescence microscopy, northern blotting, ELISA, and isoelectric focusing to characterize the expression of neuronal Class III beta-tubulin in P19 embryonal carcinoma cells induced to differentiate along a neuronal pathway by retinoic acid. Following 48 h differentiation, beta-III tubulin mRNA is evident and beta-III tubulin appears in the mitotic spindle of neuroblasts. Neurite outgrowth is obvious by day 3, and beta-III tubulin protein and mRNA levels increase concurrently until approximately day 7, when beta-III mRNA levels begin to decrease while protein levels remain high. In addition, increasingly acidic beta-III tubulin isoforms appear during neuronal differentiation. The expression of these isoelectric variants occurs concomitant with a temporal increase in the levels of beta-III tubulin present in the colchicine-stable microtubules. These results implicate posttranslational modifications of beta-III tubulin in the increased microtubule stability noted in differentiating P19 neurons.

Cortical structure and function in euglenoids with reference to trypanosomes, ciliates, and dinoflagellates

The membrane skeletal complex (cortex) of euglenoids generates and maintains cell form. In this review we summarize structural, biochemical, physiological, and molecular studies on the euglenoid membrane skeleton, focusing specifically on four principal components: the plasma membrane, a submembrane layer (epiplasm), cisternae of the endoplasmic reticulum, and microtubules. The data from euglenoids are compared with findings from representative organisms of three other protist groups: the trypanosomes, ciliates, and dinoflagellates. Although there are significant differences in cell form and phylogenetic affinities among these groups, there are also many similarities in the organization and possibly the function of their cortical components. For example, an epiplasmic (membrane skeletal) layer is widely used for adding strength and rigidity to the cell surface. The ER/alveolus/amphiesmal vesicle may function in calcium storage and regulation, and in mediating assembly of surface plates. GPI-linked variable surface antigens are characteristic of both ciliates and the unrelated trypanosomatids. Microtubules are ubiquitous, and cortices in trypanosomes may relay exclusively on microtubules and microtubule-associated proteins for maintaining cell form. Also, in agreement with previous suggestions, there is an apparent preservation of many cortical structures during cell duplication. In three of the four groups there is convincing evidence that part or all of the parental cortex persists during cytokinesis, thereby producing mosaics or chimeras consisting of both inherited and newly synthesized cortical components.

Post-translational modifications of tubulin suggest that dynamic microtubules are present in sensory cells and stable microtubules are present in supporting cells of the mammalian cochlea

Post-translational modifications to tubulin in the sensory and supporting cells of the cochlea were studied using antibodies specific to the tyrosinated, detyrosinated, acetylated and polyglutamylated isoforms. In the sensory cells, microtubules which label intensely with antibodies to tyrosinated tubulin are found in networks within the cytoplasm. Microtubules which label with antibodies to detyrosinated tubulin and polyglutamylated tubulin, but not acetylated tubulin, form a small component of the microtubules found in the cytoplasm only in the region below the cuticular plate. Microtubules in the supporting cells (inner and outer pillar cells and Deiters cells) are arranged in bundles and contain little tyrosinated tubulin. They are composed instead of predominantly post-translationally modified isoforms which include detyrosinated, acetylated and polyglutamylated tubulin. The findings suggest that microtubules in the sensory cells form dynamic structures, since microtubules that undergo cyclic polymerization and depolymerization predominantly contain tubulin that has not yet had its carboxy-terminal tyrosine residue removed. The presence of microtubules in the supporting cells in which the tubulin has been polymerized into microtubules long enough to be post-translationally modified, provides evidence that these microtubules are stable, long-lived and could contribute to the structural support of the sensory organ of Corti.

Monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies detect a new type of post-translational modification of axonemal tubulin

Polyclonal (PAT) and monoclonal (AXO 49) antibodies against Paramecium axonemal tubulin were used as probes to reveal tubulin heterogeneity. The location, the nature and the subcellular distribution of the epitopes recognized by these antibodies were, respectively, determined by means of: (i) immunoblotting on peptide maps of Paramecium, sea urchin and quail axonemal tubulins; (ii) immunoblotting on ciliate tubulin fusion peptides generated in E. coli to discriminate antibodies directed against sequential epitopes (reactive) from post-translational ones (non reactive); and (iii) immunofluorescence on Paramecium cells, using throughout an array of antibodies directed against tubulin sequences and post-translational modifications as references. AXO 49 monoclonal antibody and PAT serum were both shown to recognize epitopes located near the carboxyl-terminal end of both subunits of Paramecium axonemal tubulin, whereas the latter recognized additional epitopes in alpha-tubulin; AXO 49 and a fraction of the PAT serum proved to be unreactive over fusion proteins; both PAT and AXO 49 labelled a restricted population of very stable microtubules in Paramecium, consisting of axonemal and cortical ones, and their reactivity was sequentially detected following microtubule assembly; finally, both antibodies stained two upward spread bands in Paramecium axonemal tubulin separated by SDS-PAGE, indicating the recognition of various alpha- and beta-tubulin isoforms displaying different apparent molecular masses. These data, taken as a whole, definitely establish that PAT and AXO 49 recognize a post-translational modification occurring in axonemal microtubules of protozoa as of metazoa. This modification appears to be distinct from the previously known ones, and all the presently available evidence indicates that it corresponds to the very recently discovered polyglycylation of Paramecium axonemal alpha- and beta-tubulin.

Effects of taxol on the polymerization and posttranslational modification of class III beta-tubulin in P19 embryonal carcinoma cells

Undifferentiated P19 embryonal carcinoma cells and P19 cells induced to differentiate along a neuronal pathway by 10(-6) M retinoic acid were treated with taxol to examine the effects of this microtubule-stabilizing drug on the subcellular sorting of class III beta-tubulin and on neurite outgrowth. P19 cells were grown on cover slips and then treated with taxol at concentrations of 10(-6) to 10(-9) M for 24 h. The microtubule cytoskeleton was examined after double-immunofluorescence labelling with a monoclonal antibody to alpha-tubulin (YOL 1/34) and a monoclonal neuron-specific class III beta-tubulin antibody (TuJ1). Treatment of undifferentiated P19 cells with concentrations of taxol greater than 4 x 10(-8) M caused microtubule bundling and multiple aster formation and promoted polymerization of the low levels of class III beta-tubulin found in these cells. In neurons, at 2 x 10(-8) M taxol, bundling of microtubules at the base of the neurite was apparent. At taxol concentrations greater than 1 x 10(-7) M, enhanced assembly of class III beta-tubulin was apparent, although long neurites were not observed. Using isoelectric focusing followed by western blotting, we detected an additional isoform of class III beta-tubulin after treatment with 10(-6) M taxol. The results indicate taxol treatment alters the normal subcellular sorting of tubulin isotypes, promotes the polymerization and posttranslational modification of class III beta-tubulin, and interferes with neurite outgrowth.

Monoclonal anti-dipeptide antibodies cross-react with detyrosinated and glutamylated forms of tubulins

Two monoclonal antibodies, GLU-1 and A1.6, raised against gamma-L-glutamyl-L-glutamic acid dipeptide (Glu-Glu) and Ca(2+)-dependent ATPase from Paramecium, respectively, recognized the dipeptide Glu-Glu sequence. Whereas the antibodies immunofluorescently stained very few, if any, cytoskeletal fibers in cultured mammalian cells, almost all interphase as well as mitotic spindle microtubules became visible after treatment of cells with carboxypeptidase A. Immunoblot analysis demonstrated intense cross-reaction of the antibodies to the alpha-tubulin subunit. alpha-Tubulin isotypes produced as fusion proteins in bacteria were labeled by both the antibodies only when the proteins did not contain a tyrosine residue at the C terminus, indicating that GLU-1 and A1.6 specifically recognize the detyrosinated form of alpha-tubulin. When microtubule protein purified from brain was probed, not only alpha-but also, to a lesser extent, beta-tubulin were revealed by the dipeptide antibodies. A synthetic tripeptide YED containing one glutamyl group linked to the second residue of the peptide via the gamma position was also recognized by the antibodies. Since this peptide sequence corresponds to the amino acid sequence of polyglutamyated class III beta isotype at amino acid position 437 to 439, it is suggested that GLU-1 and A1.6 are able to recognize the glutamylated form of beta-tubulin. These results indicate that the C-terminal Glu-Glu sequence displays strong antigenicity, and the antibodies recognize the sequence present in the C terminus of the detyrosinated form of alpha-tubulin and the glutamyl side chain of beta-tubulin. Particularly strong immunoreaction was detected with ciliary and flagellar microtubules; thus, stable axonemal microtubules appear to be rich in post-translationally modified tubulin subunits.

Differential distribution of glutamylated tubulin during spermatogenesis in mammalian testis

The distribution of glutamylated tubulin has been analyzed in mammalian testis using the specific mAb GT335 by immunoelectron microscopy and immunoblotting. In spermatozoa of various species, immunogold labeling showed the presence of glutamylated tubulin in all of the microtubules of axoneme and centrioles, whereas the microtubule network of the spermatid manchette was unlabeled. In earlier germ cells, centriole was the only microtubule structure to be labeled. A similar distribution was observed using the anti-acetylated tubulin antibody (6-11B-1), confirming previous results of Hermo et al. [Anat. Rec. 229:31-50, 1991]. However, among testicular somatic cells, microtubules of some Sertoli cell branches were not acetylated but glutamylated. 2-D PAGE of mouse and hamster sperm extracts showed a high level of alpha and beta-tubulin heterogeneity, comparable to that found in brain. Immunoblotting with GT335 revealed a large amount of glutamylated tubulin resolved into numerous alpha as well as beta-tubulin isoforms. This suggests that the major testis-specific tubulin isotypes (m alpha 3/7 and m beta 3) are also glutamylatable. These results show a subcellular sorting of posttranslationally modified tubulin isoforms in spermatids, glutamylation being associated with the most stable microtubule structures.