Species differences in the expression of major histocompatibility complex class II antigens on coronary artery endothelium: implications for cell-mediated xenoreactivity

Indirect recognition of allopeptides promotes the development of cardiac allograft vasculopathy

Graft loss from chronic rejection has become the major obstacle to the long-term success of whole organ transplantation. In cardiac allografts, chronic rejection is manifested as a diffuse and accelerated form of arteriosclerosis, termed cardiac allograft vasculopathy. It has been suggested that T-cell recognition of processed alloantigens (allopeptides) presented by recipient antigen-presenting cells through the indirect pathway of allorecognition plays a critical role in the development and progression of chronic rejection. However, definitive preclinical evidence to support this hypothesis is lacking. To examine the role of indirect allorecognition in a clinically relevant large animal model of cardiac allograft vasculopathy, we immunized MHC inbred miniature swine with synthetic polymorphic peptides spanning the alpha(1) domain of an allogeneic donor-derived swine leukocyte antigen class I gene. Pigs immunized with swine leukocyte antigen class I allopeptides showed in vitro proliferative responses and in vivo delayed-type hypersensitivity responses to the allogeneic peptides. Donor MHC class I disparate hearts transplanted into peptide-immunized cyclosporine-treated pigs not only rejected faster than unimmunized cyclosporine-treated controls (mean survival time = 5.5 +/-1.7 vs. 54.7 +/-3.8 days, P < 0.001), but they also developed obstructive fibroproliferative coronary artery lesions much earlier than unimmunized controls (<9 vs. >30 days). These results definitively link indirect allorecognition and cardiac allograft vasculopathy.

Immortalized bone-marrow derived pig endothelial cells

Primary cultures of porcine endothelial cells (EC) can only be maintained for a limited number of passages. To facilitate studies of xenogeneic human anti-pig immune responses in vitro, pig microvascular bone-marrow (BM) and macrovascular aortic EC were obtained from our herd of partially inbred miniature swine, homozygous for the major histocompatibility locus, and immortalized with a modified SV40 large T vector. The resulting BM-derived (2A2) and aortic (PEDSV.15) immortalized EC lines showed unlimited growth and EC phenotype as indicated by expression of von Willebrand Factor (vWF) and low density lipoprotein (LDL) receptors as well as by formation of typical cobblestone monolayers. Ultrastructural studies revealed morphological similarities in primary and immortalized EC. Flow cytometry analysis demonstrated constitutive SLA class I expression by all lines whereas SLA class II was only expressed after stimulation with porcine IFNgamma. Furthermore, pig CD34 mRNA was detected by Northern blot analysis in primary and immortalized aortic EC but not in 2A2. Both EC lines expressed a number of myeloid markers, adhesion molecules and xenoantigens, the latter being determined by binding of human natural antibodies. Gene transfer into the porcine EC lines was successfully performed by electroporation or calcium-phosphate transfection, as well as by adenoviral infection. Finally, the functional similarity between primary and immortalized EC was demonstrated in adhesion and cytotoxicity assays. Together, these results suggest that 2A2 and PEDSV. 15 represent valuable tools to study both human cellular and humoral immune responses in vitro against pig EC derived from microvascular and large vessels.

T-Cell suicide gene therapy for organ transplantation: induction of long-lasting tolerance to allogeneic heart without generalized immunosuppression

Standard immunosuppressive drugs used for allogeneic organ transplantation do not specifically target alloreactive T cells and must be given for the lifetime of the patient, resulting in significant morbidity and mortality. We aimed to induce experimental immune tolerance to vascularized heart allograft using a suicide gene allowing selective elimination of dividing T cells expressing Herpes simplex virus type 1 thymidine kinase upon ganciclovir administration. We show that without ganciclovir, transgenic mice selectively expressing thymidine kinase in T cells rejected a vascularized cardiac allograft in 7 days. In contrast, allograft was definitively accepted after a 7-day course of ganciclovir initiated at the time of allotransplantation. Interestingly, T cells from both rejecting and tolerant mice proliferated in response to donor or third-party allogeneic stimulation. This state of tolerance was challenged through a second vascularized cardiac allotransplantation. Third-party allografts were rejected while those syngeneic to the first allograft were accepted without any additional treatment. These results show that short-term pharmacogenetic immunosuppression can induce long-lasting, robust, and specific tolerance to solid vascularized allograft without generalized continuous immunosuppression.

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism induces long-term tolerance to cardiac allografts in miniature swine

BACKGROUND

Tolerance to cardiac allografts has not been achieved in large animals using methods that are readily applicable to human recipients. We investigated the effects of mixed hematopoietic chimerism on cardiac allograft survival and chronic rejection in miniature swine

METHODS

Recipients were T-cell depleted using a porcine CD3 immunotoxin, and each received either of two nonmyeloablative preparative regimens previously demonstrated to permit the establishment of stable mixed hematopoietic chimerism across MHC-matched, minor antigen-mismatched histocompatibility barriers. Five to 12 months after the chimerism was induced, hearts from the original cell donors were heterotopically transplanted into the stable mixed chimeras.

RESULTS

Cardiac allografts transplanted into untreated recipients across similar minor antigen barriers were rejected within 44 days (within 21, 28, 35, 39, 44 days among individual study subjects). In contrast, hearts transplanted into the mixed chimeras were all accepted long term ( > 153, > 225, > 286, > 362 days) without immunosuppressive drugs and developed minimal vasculopathy.

CONCLUSIONS

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism, established in miniature swine using clinically relevant, non-myeloablative conditioning regimens, permits long-term cardiac allograft survival without chronic immunosuppressive therapy, significant vasculopathy, or graft-versus-host disease.

A 12-day course of FK506 allows long-term acceptance of semi-identical liver allograft in inbred miniature swine

BACKGROUND

Spontaneous tolerance to liver allograft has been reported previously in outbred pig models, but the lack of genetic background did not allow to analyze the impact of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) on tolerance induction. A model of semi-identical liver allograft was therefore developed in inbred miniature swine in order to mimic the clinical situation of living related liver transplant (parent into infant) and to study a protocol for inducing tolerance to liver allograft.

METHODS

SLAdd (class Id/d, class IId/d) pigs received orthotopic liver allograft from heterozygous SLAcd (class Ic/d, class IIc/d) miniature swine. Eight animals did not receive immunosuppression. Fourteen SLAdd animals had a 12-day course of FK506 and were divided in two subgroups. In subgroup FK-1, six pigs received a daily intramuscular injection of FK506 at 0.1-0.4 mg/kg, in order to reach daily trough levels between 7 and 20 ng/ml; in subgroup FK-2, eight additional animals received two daily injections of FK506 at 0.05 mg/kg regardless of the daily trough levels. Graft survival, liver biological tests, histology, cellular and humoral immune responses, as well as detection of microchimerism were assessed in all groups.

RESULTS

All untreated animals rejected their allograft and died within 28.1 +/- 9.5 days. These rejector animals developed a significant anti-donor cellular and humoral immune response. No peripheral or lymphoid tissue microchimerism was detected in this group. In contrast, long-term survival was obtained in five FK-treated animals (112, 154, 406, 413, and 440 days), whereas several pigs died with a normal allograft function from either overimmunosuppression or intercurrent causes. All FK-treated pigs developed a specific anti-donor unresponsiveness in both cell mediated lymphocytotoxicity and mixed lymphocyte reaction and did not develop anti-donor alloantibodies. The study of the anti-donor immune response by mixed lymphocyte reaction, during the first postoperative week, demonstrated a specific anti-donor unresponsiveness in the peripheral blood from the first posttransplant day. Although microchimerism was detectable in the peripheral blood for several postoperative weeks (maximum 10 weeks) in FK-treated animals, donor cells or DNA were not detected during the long-term follow-up in peripheral blood or lymphoid tissues.

CONCLUSIONS

Spontaneous tolerance to semi-identical orthotopic liver allograft did not occur, whereas a 12-day course of FK506 allowed long-term graft acceptance. All FK-treated animals developed in vitro signs of specific immune unresponsiveness and transient peripheral microchimerism. The specific anti-donor cellular unresponsiveness occurred on the first postoperative day after surgery and was of long-term duration. The study of the early immunological events in this model could be of major importance regarding clinical living related liver transplantation.

Mechanisms of tolerance induction and prevention of cardiac allograft vasculopathy in miniature swine: the effect of augmentation of donor antigen load

OBJECTIVE

Cotransplantation of a donor kidney along with a heart allograft can induce tolerance to both organs and prevent cardiac allograft vasculopathy in miniature swine. To determine whether the tolerogenic effect of donor kidney cotransplantation was due to an effect specific to the kidney graft or to an increase in donor antigen load, we compared heart-kidney recipients with recipients receiving two class I disparate hearts or with recipients receiving donor peripheral mononuclear cells at the time of isolated heart transplantation.

METHODS

Recipients of major histocompatibility complex class I disparate allografts received 12 days of cyclosporine (INN: cyclosporin; 10-13 mg/kg administered intravenously on days 0-11). Group 1 animals received a heart alone (n = 5). Group 2 animals received heart and kidney allografts (n = 4). Group 3 animals received two major histocompatibility complex-matched heart allografts (n = 4). Two double-heart recipients were thymectomized 21 days before transplantation. Group 4 animals received a heart allograft and an infusion of high-dose donor peripheral blood leukocytes (2.5 x 10(9) cells/kg, n = 2).

RESULTS

Vasculopathy developed in group 1 recipients and the allografts were rejected within 55 days. Group 2 recipients accepted their heart and kidney allografts indefinitely without vasculopathy. Euthymic recipients from group 3 accepted their hearts long-term (>190 and >197 days), but vascular lesions developed. In thymectomized recipients from group 3, the hearts were rejected in 63 and 96 days with severe vasculopathy. Group 4 recipients demonstrated transient macrochimerism but their hearts were rejected within 47 and 63 days.

CONCLUSIONS

The beneficial effects of donor kidney cotransplantation on cardiac allograft survival and prevention of cardiac allograft vasculopathy are likely to involve both an increase in donor antigen load and an effect specific to the kidney allograft.

Evidence against a pivotal role of preformed antibodies in delayed rejection of a guinea pig-to-rat heart xenograft

INTRODUCTION

Whereas the involvement of elicited xenoantibodies in delayed xenograft rejection is currently being substantiated, this study focuses on the role of the preformed fraction of xenoantibodies.

METHODS

To check the influence of the latter, we combined pretransplant complement inactivation (cobra venom factor) and antibody reduction (plasmapheresis) in a guinea pig-to-rat heart transplant model.

RESULTS

Antibody reduction on plasmapheresis before xenografting did not prolong delayed xenorejection in decomplemented rats, although the immunohistologic pattern lacked the immunoglobulin deposits along endothelial walls found in xenografts of merely decomplemented recipients. Astonishingly, plasmapheresis, if carried out 2 days before transplantation, almost tripled xenograft survival, although preformed antibody levels were completely restored and even rebounding at the time of grafting. The pattern and number of infiltrating cells did not differ in dependence of the timing of plasmapheresis nor did the proliferative response of lymphocytes in the mixed lymphocyte reaction differ. However, plasmapheresis led to a retarded decrease of the mononuclear cell tumor necrosis factor alpha secretory potential, which correlated well with a diminished immunohistologic staining of tumor necrosis factor alpha secreted by graft-infiltrating mononuclear cells.

CONCLUSION

These findings argue against a pivotal role of preformed xenoantibodies in the pathomechanistic process of delayed xenograft rejection and challenge the therapeutic strategy to reduce preformed xenoantibody levels before xenotransplantation in complement-inactivated recipients.

Tolerance to vascularized organ allografts in large-animal models

Although studies of tolerance induction in large animals remain limited compared with murine studies, a number of encouraging observations have been recently reported - especially in nonhuman primate models. The development of antibodies or proteins binding to costimulatory molecules and of an immunotoxin that is active on T cells have been particularly important advances leading to expanded opportunities for extending strategies for tolerance induction to large animals.

Chronic allograft rejection. Do the Th2 cells preferentially induced by indirect alloantigen recognition play a dominant role?

Chronic rejection has been the major obstacle to the long-term allograft survival in the clinic. Although the etiology of this rejection reaction is multifactorial, alloantigen-specific immune activation plays the most critical role. We herein hypothesize that CD4+ Th2 cells that are preferentially induced by the indirect recognition of allogeneic histocompatibility antigens late in transplantation may play the most critical role in the initiation and/or maintenance of chronic allograft rejection. Immunosuppression used to prevent acute rejection and the nature of antigen-presenting cells and alloligands in the graft may all contribute to immune deviation to the Th2 response. This response may be further perpetuated by type 2 cytokines conceivably produced by activated macrophages, NK cells, and CD8+ T cells in the graft. Cytokines and growth factors induced by this type 2 response, in turn, allow for activation of B, endothelial, and smooth muscle cells that collectively contribute to the pathogenesis of chronic allograft rejection by producing alloantibodies and growth hormones required for interstitial fibrosis, extracellular matrix deposition, and vascular neointimal hyperplasia.

Specific Suppression of Human CD4+ Th Cell Responses to Pig MHC Antigens by CD8+CD28− Regulatory T Cells

Evidence that T cells can down-regulate the immune response by producing or consuming certain cytokines or by lysing APCs or Th cells has been provided in various systems. However, the generation and characterization of suppressor T cell lines have met with limited success. Here we show that xenospecific suppressor T cells can be generated by in vitro stimulation of human T cells with pig APCs. Similar to allospecific suppressors, these xenospecific suppressor T cells carry the CD8+CD28− phenotype and react to MHC class I Ags expressed by the APCs used for priming. TCR spectratyping of T suppressor cells showed oligoclonal usage of TCR-Vβ families, indicating that xenostimulation of CD8+CD28− T cells results in Ag-driven selection of a limited Vβ repertoire. Xenospecific T suppressor cells prevent the up-regulation of CD154 molecules on the membrane of Th cells, inhibiting their ability to react against the immunizing MHC class II xenoantigens. The mechanism of this suppression, therefore, appears to be blockade of CD154/CD40 interaction required for efficient costimulation of activated T cells.

T cell-mediated xenograft rejection: specific tolerance is probably required for long term xenograft survival

T cell-mediated mechanisms of xenograft rejection appear resistant to standard immunosuppression protocols used to prevent allograft rejection and, consequently, higher doses of immunosuppressive drugs are required to promote xenograft compared to allograft survival. Evidence from recent studies suggests that porcine xenografts may be especially immunogenic in humans because of a prominent and vigorous indirect xenoresponse and because of the ability of porcine endothelium to activate human T cells. This has led to an anxiety that systemic immunosuppressives, used as the mainstay of therapy for clinical xenotransplantation, may not allow the long-term survival of porcine organs transplanted into human recipients. This article will review the biology of T cell xenoresponses, present the case for the development of novel graft-specific immunosuppressive regimes in clinical xenotransplantation, and review recent experimental progress in this area.

Transplantation tolerance prevents cardiac allograft vasculopathy in major histocompatibility complex class I-disparate miniature swine

BACKGROUND

The mechanisms and treatment of cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV) remain elusive. We have used partially inbred miniature swine to determine the role of class I MHC antigens in the pathogenesis of CAV and to determine whether acquired tolerance to donor antigen can prevent the development of CAV in large animals.

METHODS

Previous studies demonstrated that miniature swine treated with 12 days of cyclosporine (CsA) after the transplantation of MHC class I-disparate kidney allografts all became tolerant to the donor kidneys and survived indefinitely. In the present study, heart allografts were transplanted across the same MHC class I disparity in CsA-treated swine.

RESULTS

Unlike kidney allografts, heart allografts were rejected in 33-55 days. By postoperative day 28, all cardiac allografts had developed the intimal proliferation characteristic of CAV. When hearts and kidneys from the same donors were transplanted simultaneously into class I-disparate, CsA-treated recipients, the hosts became tolerant to their cardiac allografts and survived long-term. Furthermore, none of the hearts from the combined heart/kidney recipients developed evidence of CAV. Thus, this report demonstrates that: (1) MHC class I antigens play an important role in the pathogenesis of CAV, (2) the specific unresponsiveness to donor class I antigen induced by a class I-disparate kidney protects a heart transplanted from the same organ donor, and (3) the induction of acquired tolerance prevents the development of CAV.

CONCLUSION

These findings in a preclinical system establish the significance of antigen-dependent mechanisms in the pathogenesis of CAV and underscore the importance of achieving tolerance in clinical transplantation.