Influence of different tripeptides on the stability of the collagen triple helix. II. An experimental approach with appropriate variations of a trimer model oligotripeptide

Recent Advances in Collagen Mimetic Peptide Structure and Design

Collagen mimetic peptides (CMPs) fold into a polyproline type II triple helix, allowing the study of the structure and function (or misfunction) of the collagen family of proteins. This Perspective will focus on recent developments in the use of CMPs toward understanding the structure and controlling the stability of the triple helix. Triple helix assembly is influenced by various factors, including the single amino acid propensity for the triple helix fold, pairwise interactions between these amino acids, and long-range effects observed across the helix, such as bend, twist, and fraying. Important progress in creating a comprehensive and predictive understanding of these factors for peptides with exclusively natural amino acids has been made. In contrast, several groups have successfully developed unnatural amino acids that are engineered to stabilize the triple helical structure. A third approach to controlling the triple helical structure includes covalent cross-linking of the triple helix to stabilize the assembly, which eliminates the problematic equilibrium of unfolding into monomers and enforces compositional control. Advances in all these areas have resulted in significant improvements to our understanding and control of this important class of protein, allowing for the design and application of more chemically complex and well-controlled collagen mimetic biomaterials.

Stabilization of the triple helix in collagen mimicking peptides

Collagen mimics are peptides designed to reproduce structural features of natural collagen. A triple helix is the first element in the hierarchy of collagen folding. It is an assembly of three parallel peptide chains stabilized by packing and interchain hydrogen bonds. In this review we summarize the existing chemical approaches towards stabilization of this structure including the most recent developments. Currently proposed methods include manipulation of the amino acid composition, application of unnatural amino acid analogues, stimuli-responsive modifications, chain tethering approaches, peptide amphiphiles, modifications that target interchain interactions and more. This ability to manipulate the triple helix as a supramolecular self-assembly contributes to our understanding of the collagen folding. It also provides essential information needed to design collagen-based biomaterials of the future.

A host-guest system based on collagen-like triple-helix hybridization

A strategy inspired by tweezer receptors has been employed to develop a new host-guest system. The hybridization into a collagen-like triple helix is the driving force for the recognition that occurs with high affinity and selectivity. Several systems have been screened to find the best host-guest pair and this strategy may be implemented for tag fused protein recognition.

Metal Stabilization of Collagen and de Novo Designed Mimetic Peptides

We explore the design of metal binding sites to modulate triple-helix stability of collagen and collagen-mimetic peptides. Globular proteins commonly utilize metals to connect tertiary structural elements that are well separated in sequence, constraining structure and enhancing stability. It is more challenging to engineer structural metals into fibrous protein scaffolds, which lack the extensive tertiary contacts seen in globular proteins. In the collagen triple helix, the structural adjacency of the carboxy-termini of the three chains makes this region an attractive target for introducing metal binding sites. We engineered His3 sites based on structural modeling constraints into a series of designed homotrimeric and heterotrimeric peptides, assessing the capacity of metal binding to improve stability and in the case of heterotrimers, affect specificity of assembly. Notable enhancements in stability for both homo- and heteromeric systems were observed upon addition of zinc(II) and several other metal ions only when all three histidine ligands were present. Metal binding affinities were consistent with the expected Irving-Williams series for imidazole. Unlike other metals tested, copper(II) also bound to peptides lacking histidine ligands. Acetylation of the peptide N-termini prevented copper binding, indicating proline backbone amide metal-coordination at this site. Copper similarly stabilized animal extracted Type I collagen in a metal-specific fashion, highlighting the potential importance of metal homeostasis within the extracellular matrix.

Matrix metalloproteinase inhibition by heterotrimeric triple-helical Peptide transition state analogues

Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) have been implicated in numerous pathologies. An overall lack of selectivity has rendered active-site-targeted MMP inhibitors problematic. The present study describes MMP inhibitors that function by binding both secondary binding sites (exosites) and the active site. Heterotrimeric triple-helical peptide transition-state analogue inhibitors (THPIs) were assembled utilizing click chemistry. Three different heterotrimers were constructed, allowing for the inhibitory phosphinate moiety to be present uniquely in the leading, middle, or trailing strand of the triple helix. All heterotrimeric constructs had sufficient thermally stability to warrant analysis as inhibitors. The heterotrimeric THPIs were effective against MMP-13 and MT1-MMP, with Ki values spanning 100-400 nM. Unlike homotrimeric THPIs, the heterotrimeric THPIs offered complete selectivity between MT1-MMP and MMP-1. Exosite-based approaches such as this provide inhibitors with desired MMP selectivities.

Stabilization of collagen-model, triple-helical peptides for in vitro and in vivo applications

The triple-helical structure of collagen has been accurately reproduced in numerous chemical and recombinant model systems. Triple-helical peptides and proteins have found application for dissecting collagen-stabilizing forces, isolating receptor- and protein-binding sites in collagen, mechanistic examination of collagenolytic proteases, and development of novel biomaterials. Introduction of native-like sequences into triple-helical constructs can reduce the thermal stability of the triple-helix to below that of the physiological environment. In turn, incorporation of nonnative amino acids and/or templates can enhance triple-helix stability. We presently describe approaches by which triple-helical structure can be modulated for use under physiological or near-physiological conditions.

Modular design in natural and biomimetic soft materials

Under eons of evolutionary and environmental pressure, biological systems have developed strong and lightweight peptide-based polymeric materials by using the 20 naturally occurring amino acids as principal monomeric units. These materials outperform their man-made counterparts in the following ways: 1) multifunctionality/tunability, 2) adaptability/stimuli-responsiveness, 3) synthesis and processing under ambient and aqueous conditions, and 4) recyclability and biodegradability. The universal design strategy that affords these advanced properties involves "bottom-up" synthesis and modular, hierarchical organization both within and across multiple length-scales. The field of "biomimicry"-elucidating and co-opting nature's basic material design principles and molecular building blocks-is rapidly evolving. This Review describes what has been discovered about the structure and molecular mechanisms of natural polymeric materials, as well as the progress towards synthetic "mimics" of these remarkable systems.

Synthesis and biological applications of collagen-model triple-helical peptides

Triple-helical peptides (THPs) have been utilized as collagen models since the 1960s. The original focus for THP-based research was to unravel the structural determinants of collagen. In the last two decades, virtually all aspects of collagen structural biochemistry have been explored with THP models. More specifically, secondary amino acid analogs have been incorporated into THPs to more fully understand the forces that stabilize triple-helical structure. Heterotrimeric THPs have been utilized to better appreciate the contributions of chain sequence diversity on collagen function. The role of collagen as a cell signaling protein has been dissected using THPs that represent ligands for specific receptors. The mechanisms of collagenolysis have been investigated using THP substrates and inhibitors. Finally, THPs have been developed for biomaterial applications. These aspects of THP-based research are overviewed herein.

The Specific Recognition of a Cell Binding Sequence Derived from Type I Collagen by Hep3B and L929 Cells

In this study, the affinity of two different cell types toward a specific cell binding sequence (Gly-Phe-Hyp-Gly-Glu-Arg or GFOGER) derived from type I collagen using peptide template (PT)-assembled collagen peptides of different triple helicity as a model for natural collagen is examined. A series of biophysical studies, including melting curve analysis and circular dichroism spectroscopy, demonstrated the presence of stable triple-helical conformation in the PT-assembled (GPO)3-GFOGER-(GPO)3, (GPO)-GFOGER-(GPO), and (Pro-Hyp-Gly)5 solution. Conversely, non-templated peptides, except (GPO)3-GFOGER-(GPO)3, showed no evidence of assembly into triple-helical structure. Biological assays, including cell adhesion, competitive inhibition, and immunofluorescence staining, revealed a correlation of triple-helical conformation with the cellular recognition of GFOGER in an integrin-specific manner. The triple helix was shown to be important, but not crucial for cell adhesion to native collagen. Hep3B and L929 cells displayed significant differences in the recognition of GFOGER, mainly because of the differences in their expression of specific integrin receptors for collagen. For example, PT-assembled (GPO)3-GFOGER-(GPO)3 was shown to perform comparably to collagen for L929, but not Hep3B, cell adhesion. The result showed that a specific cell binding motif may not fully mimic the extracellular matrix (ECM) microenvironment, suggesting the need to use a combination of two or more cell binding sequences for targeting a wide range of integrin receptors expressed by a specific cell type to better mimic the ECM.

Macrocyclic scaffold for the collagen triple helix

[structure: see text] Three strands of natural collagen are linked by covalent bonds prior to their folding into a triple helix. We report on a synthetic collagen in which the strands are pendent on a rigid macrocyclic scaffold of C(3) symmetry. The scaffold confers substantial conformational stability upon the collagen triple helix and makes its folding independent of concentration, both desirable attributes for exploring and exploiting synthetic collagens.

Peptide dendrimers: applications and synthesis

Peptide dendrimers are radial or wedge-like branched macromolecules consisting of a peptidyl branching core and/or covalently attached surface functional units. The multimeric nature of these constructs, the unambiguous composition and ease of production make this type of dendrimer well suited to various biotechnological and biochemical applications. Applications include use as biomedical diagnostic reagents, protein mimetics, anticancer and antiviral agents, vaccines and drug and gene delivery vehicles. This review focuses on the different types of peptide dendrimers currently in use and the synthetic methods commonly employed to generate peptide dendrimers ranging from stepwise solid-phase synthesis to chemoselective and orthogonal ligation.

Collagen mimetics

Collagen peptidomimetics have been synthesized as an alternative to natural collagen. The incorporation of unnatural residues such as peptoids in the collagen sequences can demonstrate potent and specific biological activity and enhance the biostability against enzymatic degradation. Furthermore, the use of achiral peptoids simplifies synthetic strategies by reducing racemization problems. The peptoid residue N-isobutylglycine (Nleu) has been successfully incorporated into a series of collagen mimetics composed of Gly-Pro-Nleu, Gly-Nleu-Pro, and Gly-Nleu-Nleu. The discovery of template-assembled collagen mimetics and metal binding ability has laid the foundation for new opportunities in the design of novel collagen mimetic complexes. The review summarizes the synthesis and integrated biophysical analyses of the structures of these collagen mimetics. Solid phase segment condensation techniques have been utilized for the synthesis of the single chain and template-assembled analogues. The characterization of the collagen-like structures has been established by temperature-dependent optical rotation measurements. CD, NMR spectroscopy, and molecular modelling simulations.

Synthesis and stabilization of amino and carboxy terminal constrained collagenous peptides

Short collagenous peptides cross-linked at their amino and carboxy termini with Lys-Lys-dimer template(s) were synthesized, and the effect of the cross-linking on their stabilities was investigated by thermal denaturation experiments. Two chemoselective ligations were used for the construction of the amino and the carboxy cross-linked peptides. The thermal transition temperature (Tm) and the standard free energies (deltaG(o)) of the cross-linked collagenous peptides increased, and the thermal stabilization effect corresponded to an elongation by two units of the Gly-Pro-Hyp triad. The van't Hoff enthalpy (deltaH(o)) and the entropy (deltaS(o)) values of the cross-linked peptides increased with chain elongation, although the increments were smaller than those of the linear peptides. When the same chain lengths were compared, the deltaH(o) was increased and the deltaS(o) was nearly the same or increased by the cross-linking. These results suggest that the cross-linking of the collagenous peptides with the Lys-Lys-dimer template(s) for stabilization contributes to the enthalpic effect, rather than the entropic effect.

A recombinant homotrimer of type I procollagen that lacks the central two D-periods. The thermal stability of the triple helix is decreased by 2 to 4 degrees C

A D-period cassette system was developed that can be used to synthesize a variety of recombinant homotrimers of type I procollagen. A construct lacking the central two D-periods of pro alpha 1(I) chains was assembled and expressed as a recombinant protein in the mammalian cell line. The recombinant protein was purified to homogeneity and the thermal stability of the triple helix assayed by rapid protease digestion. The results indicated that deletion of the central 468 amino acids from the major triple helix lowered the thermal stability of the protein by 2 to 4 degrees C. The results therefore begin to define regions of the molecule that vary in their contributions to helical stability.

Design and synthesis of heterotrimeric collagen peptides with a built-in cystine-knot. Models for collagen catabolism by matrix-metalloproteases

A heterotrimeric collagen peptide was designed and synthesized which contains the collagenase cleavage site (P4-P'9/10) of type I collagen linked to a C-terminal cystine-knot, and N-terminally extended with (Gly-Pro-Hyp)5 triplets for stabilization of the triple-helical conformation. By employing a newly developed regioselective cysteine pairing strategy based exclusively on thiol disulfide exchange reactions, we succeeded in assembling in high yields and in a reproducible manner the triple-stranded cystine peptide. While the single chains showed no tendency to self-association into triple helices, the heterotrimer (alpha1 alpha2 alpha1') was found to exhibit a typical collagen-like CD spectrum at room temperature and a melting temperature (Tm) of 33 degrees C. This triple-helical collagen-like peptide is cleaved by the full-length human neutrophil collagenase (MMP-8) at a single locus fully confirming the correct raster of the heterotrimer. Its digestion proceeds at rates markedly higher than that of a single alpha1' chain. In contrast, opposite digestion rates were measured with the catalytic Phe79-MMP-8 domain of HNC. Moreover, the full-length enzyme exhibits Km values of 5 microM and 1 mM for the heterotrimer and the single alpha1' chain, respectively, which compare well with those reported for collagen type I (approximately 1 microM), gelatine (approximately 10 microM) and for octapeptides of the cleavage sequence (> or = 1 mM). The high affinity of the MMP-8 for the triple-helical heterotrimer and the fast digestion of this collagenous peptide confirm the decisive role of the hemopexin domain in recognition and possibly, partial unfolding of collagen.

Perspectives on the synthesis and application of triple-helical, collagen-model peptides

Collagens can be distinguished from other proteins based on their triple-helical structure. Synthetic peptide models have been developed to better understand the triple helix structurally and to evaluate the triple helix as a recognition element for biological processes. Associated triple-helical peptides were first designed and assembled by solid-phase methodology in the late 1960s. Such peptides were used for triple-helical structural characterization by CD, nmr, and ir spectroscopies, and x-ray crystallography, and for studying the structural preferences of hydroxylases. In the late 1970s, methods were developed for covalently linking the three strands of triple-helical peptides. One benefit of "branched" peptides was the enhancement of triple-helical thermal stability. The incorporation of specific collagen sequences into thermally stable synthetic triple helices in the early 1990s has allowed for the mechanistic investigation of collagen-mediated cell adhesion and platelet aggregation. In time, discriminatory therapeutics may result from the continued exploration and further understanding of the biological effects of collagen primary, secondary, and tertiary structures via triple-helical peptide models.

Trimeric assembly of collagen XII: effect of deletion of the C-terminal part of the molecule

The fibril-associated-collagens-with-interrupted-triple-helices (FACITs) are devoid of large C-propeptides like those involved in the trimeric assembly of the fibrillar collagens. Under these conditions, the C-terminal non triple-helical domain (NC1) and the adjacent triple-helical domain (COL1) are likely to be responsible for the trimeric assembly of these collagen molecules. Using a recombinant minigene of one of the FACITs, collagen XII, we show that a deletion covering most of the NC1 domain, except the first seven residues containing a cysteine and constituting the main part of the conserved junction between the COL1 and NC1 domains, does not prevent the formation of trimeric disulfide-bonded assembly of truncated alpha chains. These results suggest that if the non triple-helical NC1 domain is involved in the initial events governing the trimeric assembly, it must be through its amino acid residues participating in the junction. Our data confirm also the results obtained in a previous paper (Mazzorana et al.: J. Biol. Chem. 268:3029-3032, 1993) showing that the formation of disulfide bonds is dependent on hydroxylation and suggesting that the folding of the triple helix (or a part of it) precedes the formation of the disulfide bonds.

A synthetic model of collagen structure taken from bovine macrophage scavenger receptor

A putative collagen structure from macrophage scavenger receptors binds to a wide range of ligands. In order to elucidate the ligand's binding mode, this collagen structure was constructed using short peptides. This was accomplished by the reaction of a tri-bromoacetylated branched peptide with a purified unprotected 25-residue peptide, which contained Cys, 4 repeats of triplet, Gly-Pro-Hyp, and 12 residues from the bovine of the N-terminus cross-linked tripeptide show that it forms a collagen structure below 10 degrees C and an extended structure at high temperature with a midpoint of 20 degrees C.

Solid-phase synthesis and stability of triple-helical peptides incorporating native collagen sequences

A generally applicable solid-phase methodology has been developed for the synthesis of triple-helical polypeptides incorporating native collagen sequences. Three nascent peptide chains are C-terminal linked through one N alpha-amino and two N epsilon-amino groups of Lys, while repeating Gly-Pro-Hyp triplets induce triple helicity. Different protecting group strategies, including several three-dimensionally orthogonal schemes, have been utilized for the synthesis of four homotrimeric triple-helical polypeptides (THPs) of 79-124 residues, three of which incorporate native type IV collagen sequences. Highly efficient assemblies were achieved by 9-fluorenylmethoxycarbonyl (Fmoc) N alpha-amino group protection, in situ 2-(1H-benzotriazole-1-yl)-1,1,3,3-tetramethyluronium hexafluorophosphate mediated couplings, and 1,8-diazabicyclo [5.4.0] undec-7-ene mediated Fmoc group removal. THPs were characterized by Edman degradation sequencing, size-exclusion chromatography, mass spectrometry, reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography, and CD spectroscopy. THP thermal stabilities ranged from 35 to 59 degrees C, with chain length and Hyp content being the influential factors. Melting temperatures and van't Hoff enthalpies for peptide triple-helical denaturation could be correlated well to Hyp content. The THP synthetic protocol developed here will allow for the study of both structure and biological activity of specific collagen sequences in homotrimeric and heterotrimeric forms.

Thermal stability and folding of the collagen triple helix and the effects of mutations in osteogenesis imperfecta on the triple helix of type I collagen

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is an inherited disease in which 90% of the cases result from mutations in the 2 genes, pro alpha 1 and pro alpha 2, coding for type I collagen. Type I collagen is a trimeric molecule, (alpha 1)2 alpha 2, which is dominated both structurally and functionally by the 300 nm triple-helical domain. Most OI mutations occur in this domain and almost all point mutations result in the substitution of other amino acids for the obligate glycine which occurs at every third residue. The phenotypic effects of these mutations are frequently attributed in part to alterations in the stability and rate of folding of the triple helix. In order to better understand the relationship between glycine substitutions and stability we review current concepts of the forces governing triple helical stability, denaturational and predenaturational unfolding, and the techniques of measuring stability. From observations on the stability of several collagen types as well as synthetic tripeptides, we present a model for stability based on the contribution of individual and neighboring tripeptide units to the local stability. Although in preliminary form, this empirical model can account for the observed shifts in the Tm of many of the point mutations described. The folding of the triple helix is reviewed. The involvement of peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerase in this process in vivo is demonstrated by the inhibition of collagen folding in fibroblasts by cyclosporin A. An hypothesis based on the relationship between the thermal stability at the site of mutation and the propensity for renucleation of folding is proposed.

A model for interstitial collagen catabolism by mammalian collagenases

Mammalian collagenases cleave all three alpha chains of native, triple-helical types I, II, and III collagens after the Gly residue of the partial sequence Gly-[Ile or Leu]-[Ala or Leu] at a single locus approximately three-fourths from the amino terminus. There are an additional 31 sites in the triple-helical regions of types I, II, III, and IV collagens that contain the same partial sequence but are not hydrolyzed. A model has been developed to explain this remarkable specificity. The mammalian collagenase cleavage site in interstitial collagens is distinguished by: (a) a low side-chain molal volume-, high imino acid (greater than 33%)-containing region that is tightly triple-helical, consisting of four Gly-X-Y triplets preceding the cleavage site, (b) a low imino acid-containing (less than 17%), loosely triple-helical region consisting of four Gly-X-Y triplets following the cleavage site, and (c) a maximum of one charged residue for the entire 25 residue cleavage site region, which is always an Arg that follows the cleavage site in subsite P'5 or P'8. In addition, the high imino acid-containing region cannot have an imino acid adjacent to the cleaved Gly-[Ile or Leu] bond (i.e. in subsite P2). Careful scrutiny of the 31 non-cleaved sequences reveals that none of those sites shares all of the characteristics of the cleavage site. The criterion of this model thus explain both cleaved and non-cleaved sequences in the triple-helical regions of types I, II, III, and IV collagen, and are supported by all known experimental and theoretical results on collagen catabolism and structure.

Sequence specific thermal stability of the collagen triple helix

Theoretical calculations of the thermal stability of collagen triple helices using empirical values for the contribution of individual tripeptide units are presented and compared with direct measurements of the thermal stability of various types of collagens. Relative stabilities are assigned to the positions of the tripeptide units in the amino acid sequence along the length of the collagen molecule. The sequence specific relative stabilities of type I and type XI collagens are compared. These offer insight into the reasons for the existence of unfolding intermediates in type XI collagen that are absent in type I collagen. The pattern of relative stabilities calculated for mouse type IV collagen is consistent with experimental results which indicate that the amino terminal region is very stable and that the interruptions cause increased flexibility and independently unfolding domains. Mutations in the triple helical domain of human type I procollagen occurring in brittle bone disease (osteogenesis imperfecta) show varying effects on the thermal stability of the molecule. The sequence specific thermal stability calculations shed some light on why some mutations of cysteine for glycine have greater effects on the thermal stability than others.