Anergic T cells effect linked suppression

Cell-based therapy in allergy

IgE-mediated allergy is an immunological disorder occurring in response to otherwise harmless environmental antigens (i.e., allergens). Development of effective therapeutic or preventive approaches inducing robust tolerance toward allergens remains an unmet goal. Several experimental tolerance approaches have been described. The therapeutic use of regulatory T cells (Tregs) and the establishment of molecular chimerism are two cell-based strategies that are of particular interest. Treg therapy is close to clinical application, but its efficacy remains to be fully defined. Recent proof-of-concept studies demonstrated that transplantation of syngeneic hematopoietic stem cells modified in vitro to express a major allergen leads to molecular chimerism and robust allergen-specific tolerance. Here we review cell-based tolerance strategies in allergy, discussing their potentials and limitations.

Optimal number of regulatory T cells

The adaptive immune system of a vertebrate may attack its own body, causing autoimmune diseases. Regulatory T cells suppress the activity of the autoreactive effector T cells, but they also interrupt normal immune reactions against foreign antigens. In this paper, we discuss the optimal number of regulatory T cells that should be produced. We make the assumptions that some self-reactive immature T cells may fail to interact with their target antigens during the limited training period and later become effector T cells causing autoimmunity, and that regulatory T cells exist that recognize self-antigens. When a regulatory T cell is stimulated by its target self-antigen on an antigen-presenting cell (APC), it stays there and suppresses the activation of other naive T cells on the same APC. Analysis of the benefit and the harm of having regulatory T cells suggests that the optimal number of regulatory T cells depends on the number of self-antigens, the severity of the autoimmunity, the abundance of pathogenic foreign antigens, and the spatial distribution of self-antigens in the body. For multiple types of self-antigen, we discuss the optimal number of regulatory T cells when the self-antigens are localized in different parts of the body and when they are co-localized. We also examine the separate regulation of the abundances of regulatory T cells for different self-antigens, comparing it with the situation in which they are constrained to be equal.

Modeling the role of IL-2 in the interplay between CD4+ helper and regulatory T cells: assessing general dynamical properties

Mathematical models accounting for well-known evidences relating to the dynamics of interleukin 2, helper and regulatory T cells are presented. These models extend an existent model (the so-called cross-regulation model of immunity), by assuming IL-2 as the growth factor produced by helper cells, but used by both helper and regulatory cells to proliferate and survive. Two model variants, motivated by current literature, are explored. The first variant assumes that regulatory cells suppress helper cells by limiting IL-2 production and consuming the available IL-2; i.e. they just trigger competition for IL-2. The second model variant adds to the latter competitive mechanism the direct inhibition of helper cells activation by regulatory cells. The extended models retain key dynamical features of the cross-regulation model. But such reasonable behavior depends on parameter constraints, which happen to be realistic and lead to interesting biological discussions. Furthermore, the introduction of IL-2 in these models breaks the local/specific character of interactions, providing new properties to them. In the extended models, but not in the cross-regulation model, the response triggered by an antigen affects the response to other antigens in the same lymph node. The first model variant predicts an unrealistic coupling of the immune reactions to all the antigens in the lymph node. In contrast, the second model variant allows the coexistent of concomitant tolerant and immune responses to different antigens. The IL-2 derived from an ongoing immune reaction reinforces tolerance to other antigens in the same lymph node. Overall the models introduced here are useful extensions of the cross-regulation formalism. In particular, they might allow future studies of the effect of different IL-2 modulation therapies on CD4+ T cell dynamics.

Recent thymic origin, differentiation, and turnover of regulatory T cells

Regulatory CD4+ T cells (Treg) are essential to maintain self-tolerance. Release of natural Treg from the thymus is believed to commence soon after birth, but it is unclear how many are produced by "conversion" in the periphery, whether numbers are maintained after puberty by general homeostatic mechanisms that regulate lymphocyte numbers, or whether significant numbers are produced by the involuted thymus. To address the origin of Treg in normal adult rats, we focused on recent thymus emigrants (RTE). Approximately 30% of CD4+CD25+forkhead box p3 (Foxp3)+ Treg expressed markers associated with RTE. Following thymectomy, numbers of cells expressing these markers fell by 80% within 30 days. Furthermore, although only approximately 5% of CD4+ single-positive thymocytes expressed Foxp3 within 24 h after intrathymic injection of FITC, more than 30% of the labeled CD4+ RTE were Foxp3+, suggesting that some RTE may acquire Foxp3 in the periphery. Thus, some RTE may acquire Foxp3 rapidly after emigration from the thymus. Treg are dividing rapidly with apparent half-lives of approximately 18 days and approximately 7 days for the CD4+CD25+Foxp3+ and CD4+CD25-Foxp3+ subsets, respectively. The apparently slower turnover of CD4+CD25+Foxp3+ cells is a result of CD4+CD25+Foxp3+ --> CD4+CD25-Foxp3+ conversion, with no loss of regulatory function. Taken together, the data suggest that Treg in adults are relatively short-lived and that their numbers are maintained by rapid cell division and continuous replenishment from the thymus.

A microsphere-based vaccine prevents and reverses new-onset autoimmune diabetes

OBJECTIVE

This study was aimed at ascertaining the efficacy of antisense oligonucleotide-formulated microspheres to prevent type 1 diabetes and to reverse new-onset disease.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

Microspheres carrying antisense oligonucleotides to CD40, CD80, and CD86 were delivered into NOD mice. Glycemia was monitored to determine disease prevention and reversal. In recipients that remained and/or became diabetes free, spleen and lymph node T-cells were enriched to determine the prevalence of Foxp3(+) putative regulatory T-cells (Treg cells). Splenocytes from diabetes-free microsphere-treated recipients were adoptively cotransferred with splenocytes from diabetic NOD mice into NOD-scid recipients. Live-animal in vivo imaging measured the microsphere accumulation pattern. To rule out nonspecific systemic immunosuppression, splenocytes from successfully treated recipients were pulsed with beta-cell antigen or ovalbumin or cocultured with allogeneic splenocytes.

RESULTS

The microspheres prevented type 1 diabetes and, most importantly, exhibited a capacity to reverse clinical hyperglycemia, suggesting reversal of new-onset disease. The microspheres augmented Foxp3(+) Treg cells and induced hyporesponsiveness to NOD-derived pancreatic beta-cell antigen, without compromising global immune responses to alloantigens and nominal antigens. T-cells from successfully treated mice suppressed adoptive transfer of disease by diabetogenic splenocytes into secondary immunodeficient recipients. Finally, microspheres accumulated within the pancreas and the spleen after either intraperitoneal or subcutaneous injection. Dendritic cells from spleen of the microsphere-treated mice exhibit decreased cell surface CD40, CD80, and CD86.

CONCLUSIONS

This novel microsphere formulation represents the first diabetes-suppressive and reversing nucleic acid vaccine that confers an immunoregulatory phenotype to endogenous dendritic cells.

Immunobiology of Rejection and Adaptation

Transplantation is an acceptable therapy for failing organs, however, the balance between prevention of acute rejection and immunosuppressant-induced toxicity remains elusive. Organ transplantation from a genetically disparate donor induces an immune response toward donor antigens in the recipient. An uncontrolled cumulative effect of these responses may jeopardize the recipient's life and destroy the grafted tissue. The donor antigen in the form of passenger leukocytes from the allograft migrating to the organized lymphoid collection is a prerequisite for initiation of acute rejection. In the host lymphoid tissue donor-specific dendritic cells primed with donor peptide activate naïve CD4 helper T cells which in turn activate effector CD8 T-cell clones through the release of cytokines. Activated effector CD8 cells return to the graft and augment destructive activity with the help of adhesive molecules and perforin. This seems to be the mechanism of adaptive immunity to destroy viral pathogens; the pattern of allograft injury is not much different. Adaptation and tolerance are based on the principle of exhaustion of donor-specific immune responses by an activation-deletion-exhaustion pathway.

The role of CD28 and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte antigen-4 (CTLA-4) in regulatory T-cell biology

The profound influence of CD28 and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte antigen-4 (CTLA-4) on T-cell immunity has been known for over a decade, yet the precise roles played by these molecules still continue to emerge. Initially viewed as molecules that provide cell-intrinsic costimulatory and inhibitory signals, recent evidence suggests that both CD28 and CTLA-4 are also important in the homeostasis and function of a population of suppressive cells, termed regulatory T cells (Tregs). Here we review the main features of the CD28 and CTLA-4 system and examine how these impact upon Treg biology.

Regulatory T Cells and Transplantation Tolerance

In the past decade, several types of regulatory T cells (Tregs) have been identified to play a pivotal role in the control of autoimmunity and transplantation tolerance in rodents and in human beings, including innate regulatory NKT cells and gammadelta T cells, naturally occurring FoxP3 expressing CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells, and in-vitro induced Tregs including interleuking-10 (IL-10)-secreting Tr1 CD4(+) T cells, TGF-beta-producing Th3 CD4(+) T cells, anergic CD4(+) T cells, CD8(+)CD28(-) and CD3(+)CD4(-)CD8(-) T cells. Recent studies have shown that innate and adaptive Tregs may be linked and act in concert to mediate immunosuppression. As our understanding of regulatory T cell populations has substantially advanced, compelling evidence support the prospect that in-vitro expanded, patient-tailored Tregs with indirect anti-donor allospecificity could be potential reagents as adoptive cell therapy for individualized medicine to promote clinical transplantation tolerance.

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen-4-dependent down-modulation of costimulatory molecules on dendritic cells in CD4+ CD25+ regulatory T-cell-mediated suppression

We have previously demonstrated that CD4+ CD25+ natural regulatory T cells (Treg cells) induce down-modulation of CD80 and CD86 (B7) molecules on dendritic cells (DCs) in vitro. In this report we show that the extent of down-modulation is functionally significant because Treg-cell conditioned DCs induced poor T-cell proliferation responses. Further, we report that down-modulation was induced rapidly and was inhibited by blocking cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen-4 (CTLA-4), which is constitutively expressed by the Treg cells. Even though Treg cells have previously been reported to kill antigen-presenting cells, the down-modulation was not due to selective killing of DCs expressing high level of the costimulatory molecules. We propose that Treg cells down-modulate B7-molecules on DCs in a CTLA-4-dependent way, thereby enhancing suppression of T-cell activity.

The role of the FOXP3 transcription factor in the immune regulation of allergic asthma

Unbalanced immune reactions against allergens are caused by Th2 cells, which are the basis of immunoglobulin E (IgE)-mediated symptoms of allergy and asthma. Although Th2 cells are essential for allergy, they are not sufficient to cause disease, because regulatory T cells (Tregs) control their activity and expansion. Therefore, Tregs are assumed to play an important role not only in the sensitization but also in established allergic disease under therapy. A key factor of Tregs is FOXP3, which, upon expression, is sufficient to induce regulatory T-cell phenotypes. The initiation and suppressive function of FOXP3 and Tregs in the context of allergic asthma are discussed in this review.

Inhibition of NF-kappa B and oxidative pathways in human dendritic cells by antioxidative vitamins generates regulatory T cells

Dendritic cells (DCs) are central to T cell immunity, and many strategies have been used to manipulate DCs to modify immune responses. We investigated the effects of antioxidants ascorbate (vitamin C) and alpha-tocopherol (vitamin E) on DC phenotype and function. Vitamins C and E are both antioxidants, and concurrent use results in a nonadditive activity. We have demonstrated that DC treated with these antioxidants are resistant to phenotypic and functional changes following stimulation with proinflammatory cytokines. Following treatment, the levels of intracellular oxygen radical species were reduced, and the protein kinase RNA-regulated, eukaryotic translation initiation factor 2alpha, NF-kappaB, protein kinase C, and p38 MAPK pathways could not be activated following inflammatory agent stimulation. We went on to show that allogeneic T cells (including CD4(+)CD45RO, CD4(+)CD45RA, and CD4(+)CD25(-) subsets) were anergized following exposure to vitamin-treated DCs, and secreted higher levels of Th2 cytokines and IL-10 than cells incubated with control DCs. These anergic T cells act as regulatory T cells in a contact-dependent manner that is not dependent on IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, IL-13, and TGF-beta. These data indicate that vitamin C- and E-treated DC might be useful for the induction of tolerance to allo- or autoantigens.

Creation of tolerogenic human dendritic cells via intracellular CTLA4: a novel strategy with potential in clinical immunosuppression

Activation of T lymphocytes requires the recognition of peptide-major histocompatibility complexes (MHCs) and costimulatory signals provided by antigen-presenting cells (APCs). It has been shown that T-cell activation without costimulation can lead to anergy. In this study, we developed a novel strategy to inhibit expression of B7 molecules (CD80/86) by transfecting APCs with a gene construct encoding a modified cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen 4 (CTLA4) molecule (CTLA4-KDEL) that is targeted to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). APCs expressing this construct failed to express CD80/86 on their surface, were unable to stimulate allogeneic and peptide-specific T-cell responses, and induced antigen-specific anergy of the responding T cells. Cells expressing CTLA4-KDEL do not up-regulate the indoleamine 2, 3-dioxygenase enzyme, unlike cells treated with soluble CTLA4-immunoglobin (Ig). This gene-based strategy to knock out surface receptors is an attractive alternative to using immature dendritic cells for preventing transplant rejection and treating of autoimmune diseases.

CD25+CD4+ regulatory T cells generated by exposure to a model protein antigen prevent allograft rejection: antigen-specific reactivation in vivo is critical for bystander regulation

The importance of CD25(+)CD4(+) regulatory T (Treg) cells in the control of immune responses is established, but their antigen specificity in vivo remains unclear. Understanding Treg-cell specificity requirements will be important if their potential is to be developed for immunotherapy. Pretreatment of recipient mice with donor alloantigen plus anti-CD4 antibody generates CD25(+)CD4(+) Treg cells with the capacity to prevent skin allograft rejection in adoptive transfer recipients. Here we demonstrate that, although this regulation can be antigen-specific, reactivation with the original tolerizing alloantigen allows the Treg cells to suppress rejection of third-party allografts. Aware of the limitations of alloantigen pretreatment, we asked whether graft-protective Treg cells could be generated against unrelated, nongraft antigens. We demonstrate that bystander regulation also extends to CD25(+)CD4(+) Treg cells generated in vivo by exposure to nominal antigens under anti-CD4 antibody cover. Providing these Treg cells are reexposed to the tolerizing antigens before adoptive transfer, they prevent the rejection of fully allogeneic skin grafts. That this might form the basis of a clinically relevant tolerance induction strategy is demonstrated by the fact that, when combined with subtherapeutic anti-CD8 antibody, Treg cells generated in response to nongraft antigens facilitate the acceptance of cardiac allografts in primary recipients.

Antigen Nonspecific Suppression of T Cell Responses by Activated Stimulation-Refractory CD4+ T Cells

Several classes of anergic T cells are capable of suppressing naive T cell proliferation and thereby limiting immune responses. Activated T cells, although not anergic, are transiently refractory to restimulation with Ag. We examine in this study whether activated refractory murine T cells can also suppress naive T cell responses. We find that they can, and that they exhibit many of the suppressive properties of anergic T cells. The activated cells strongly diminish Ag-mediated T cell proliferation, an activity that correlates with their refractory period. Suppression is independent of APC numbers and requires cell contact or proximity. Naive T cells stimulated in the presence of activated refractory cells up-regulate CD25 and CD69, but fail to produce IL-2. The addition of IL-2 to culture medium, however, does not prevent the suppression, which is therefore not solely due to the absence of this growth factor. Persistence of the suppressor cells is also not essential. T cells stimulated in their presence and then isolated from them and cultured do not divide. The suppressive cells, however, do not confer a refractory or anergic state on the target T lymphocytes, which can fully respond to antigenic stimulation if removed from the suppressors. Our results therefore provide evidence that activated T cells act as transient suppressor cells, severely constraining bystander T cell stimulation and thereby restricting their response. These results have potentially broad implications for the development and regulation of immune responses.

Role of costimulatory pathways in the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis and experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Multiple sclerosis is an immune-mediated disorder of the central nervous system. T lymphocytes are thought to play a central role in the initiation and potentially in the propagation of this disease. Two signals are required for T-cell activation. The first signal consists of the interaction of the T-cell receptor with antigen presented by the MHC molecule on antigen-presenting cells. The second signal requires engagement of costimulatory receptors on T cells with their ligands on antigen-presenting cells. Several costimulatory pathways have been shown to play an important role in T-lymphocyte activation. Here we will review the current literature on the contribution of the B7-1/2-CD28/CTLA-4, inducible costimulatory molecule-B7h, programmed death pathway 1-programmed death pathway ligand 1/ligand 2, CD40-CD154, OX40-OX40 ligand, and CD137-CD137 ligand pathways to the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis and their potential roles as therapeutic targets.

Regulatory CD8+ T cells control thyrotropin receptor-specific CD4+ clones in healthy subjects

One of the mechanisms ensuring immunological unresponsiveness or tolerance depends on the action of CD8(+) lymphocytes. In this paper, we report that, in healthy subjects, a subset of CD8(+)CD28(-) T cells suppresses the specific response to TSH receptor (TSHR) of CD4(+) clones. Suppression was highly specific, required cell-cell interaction, and was not mediated by cytotoxicity. Co-incubation of CD8(+) and CD4(+) clones, followed by the removal of the CD8(+) cells from the cultures before testing CD4(+) responsiveness to TSHR, demonstrated that CD4(+) cells were anergic since they showed low response to the antigen and a significant impairment of IL-2 production. In CD8-mediated anergy induction, the T-cell receptor (TCR) on both CD4(+) and CD8(+) cells seems to play a role. Our results indicate that one of the mechanisms ensuring peripheral tolerance involve CD8(+)CD28(-) cells. A disregulation in the control of autoreactive clones by this subset might be important for the onset of autoimmune thyroid diseases.

Anergic T cells exert antigen-independent inhibition of cell-cell interactions via chemokine metabolism

Due to their ability to inhibit antigen-induced T-cell activation in vitro and in vivo, anergic T cells can be considered part of the spectrum of immunoregulatory T lymphocytes. Here we report that both murine and human anergic T cells can impair the ability of parenchymal cells (including endothelial and epithelial cells) to establish cell-cell interactions necessary to sustain leukocyte migration in vitro and tissue infiltration in vivo. The inhibition is reversible and cell-contact dependent but does not require cognate recognition of the parenchymal cells to occur. Instrumental to this effect is the increased cell surface expression and enzymatic activity of molecules such as CD26 (dipeptidyl-peptidase IV), which may act by metabolizing chemoattractants bound to the endothelial/epithelial cell surface. These results describe a previously unknown antigen-independent anti-inflammatory activity by locally generated anergic T cells and define a novel mechanism for the long-known immunoregulatory properties of these cells.

Induction of allopeptide-specific human CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells ex vivo

Although CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells are pivotal in the prevention of autoimmunity and appear to mediate transplantation tolerance, little is known concerning their antigen specificity. Here we describe the induction of a human CD4+CD25+ regulatory T-cell line specific for a defined peptide alloantigen (human leukocyte antigen A2 [HLA-A2] 138-170) by priming purified CD4+CD25+ cells ex vivo. The regulatory cells were anergic and retained their ability to suppress antigen-driven responses of CD4+CD25- cells. They inhibited not only interleukin 2 (IL-2) secretion by CD4+CD25- T cells specific for the same peptide but also direct alloresponse of naive CD4+CD25- T cells stimulated by semiallogeneic dendritic cells (DCs) in the presence of the peptide ("linked suppression"). They also suppressed the response of CD4+ T cells specific for viral and bacterial antigens. The suppressive T-cell line showed sustained high CD25 expression. These findings suggest that peripheral CD4+CD25+ regulatory cells are a precommitted cell lineage from which cells with specificity for non-self-peptides can be selected. This may pave the way for inducing and expanding peptide antigen-specific regulatory T cells ex vivo for cell therapy in transplantation, allergy, and autoimmune disease.

Negative T cell costimulation and islet tolerance

Activation of self-reactive T cells that specifically destroy the pancreatic beta-cells is one of the hallmarks in the development of type 1 diabetes. Thus, for prevention and treatment of this autoimmune disease, approaches to induce and maintain T cell tolerance toward the beta-cells, especially in islet transplantation, have been actively pursued. Noticeably, many of the recent protocols for inducing transplant tolerance involve blockade of positive T cell costimulation extrinsically. Though highly effective in prolonging graft survival, these strategies alone might not be universally sufficient to achieve true tolerance. As the mystery of the suppressive and regulatory T cells unfolds, it is becoming appreciated that exploiting the intrinsic molecular and cellular mechanisms that turn off an immune response would perhaps facilitate the current protocols in establishing T cell tolerance. In this perspective, here we summarize the recent findings on the negative costimulation pathways, in particular, the newly identified PD-1 : PD-L interactions. On the basis of these observations, we propose a new principle of curtailing pathogenic T cell response in which blockade of positive T cell costimulation is reinforced by concurrent engagement of the negative costimulation machinery. Such a strategy may hold greater hope for therapeutic intervention of transplant rejection and autoimmune diseases.

Regulatory T cells in the control of transplantation tolerance and autoimmunity

A role for immunoregulatory T cells in the maintenance of self-tolerance and in transplantation tolerance has long been suggested, but the identification of such cells has not been achieved until recently. With the characterisation of spontaneously occurring CD4+CD25+ and NK1.1+ T subpopulations of T cells as regulatory cells in rodents and in humans, together with several in vitro generated regulatory T-cell populations, it seems possible that 'customised' regulatory cells possessing antidonor specificity may become therapeutic tools in clinical transplantation tolerance.

Detection of suppressor T lymphocytes and estimation of their frequency in limiting dilution assays by generalized linear regression modeling

The estimate of the frequency of suppressor T lymphocytes in unfractionated cell populations remains challenging, mainly because these regulatory cells do not display specific immunophenotypic markers. In this paper, we describe a novel theoretical approach for quantifying the frequency of suppressor cells. This method is based on limiting dilution data modeling, and allows the simultaneous estimation of the frequencies of both proliferating and suppressor cells. We used previously published biological data, characterizing the inhibiting activity of suppressor T cell clones. Starting from these data, we propose a mathematical model describing the interaction between suppressor and proliferating T cells, and applied to a Poisson process. Limiting dilution data corresponding to this non-single-hit, suppressor two-target Poisson model were artificially generated, then modeled according to a generalized linear regression procedure. Deviation from the single-hit Poisson model was revealed by a statistical slope test, and a stepwise analysis of the regression appeared to be an efficient method that strongly argued in favor of the presence of suppressor cells. By using the frequency of proliferating T cells calculated in the first step of the regression, we demonstrated the possibility to provide a reasonable estimate of the frequency of suppressor T cells. Based on these findings, a practical decision-making procedure is given to perform standard analyses of limiting dilution data.

Human anergic CD4+ T cells can act as suppressor cells by affecting autologous dendritic cell conditioning and survival

T cell suppression exerted by regulatory T cells represents a well-established phenomenon, but the mechanisms involved are still a matter of debate. Recent data suggest that anergic T cells can suppress responder T cell activation by inhibiting Ag presentation by dendritic cells (DC). In this study, we focused our attention on the mechanisms that regulate the susceptibility of DC to suppressive signals and analyzed the fate of DC and responder T cells. To address this issue, we have cocultured human alloreactive or Ag-specific CD4+ T cell clones, rendered anergic by incubation with immobilized anti-CD3 Ab, with autologous DC and responder T cells. We show that anergic T cells affect either Ag-presenting functions or survival of DC, depending whether immature or mature DC are used as APC. Indeed, MHC and costimulatory molecule expression on immature DC activated by responder T cells is inhibited, while apoptotic programs are induced in mature DC and in turn in responder T cells. Ligation of CD95 by CD95L expressed on anergic T cells in the absence of CD40-CD40L (CD154) interaction are critical parameters in eliciting apoptosis in both DC and responder T cells. In conclusion, these findings indicate that the defective activation of CD40 on DC by CD95L+ CD154-defective anergic T cells could be the primary event in determining T cell suppression and support the role of CD40 signaling in regulating both conditioning and survival of DC.

Mechanisms of immune tolerance to food antigens in humans

Immune responses and the mechanisms of tolerance to the common dietary antigens bovine gamma globulin (BGG), ovalbumin (OVA), and soybean protein were evaluated in normal human volunteers. Humoral and T cell proliferative responses to these antigens were measurable but low, consistent with immune tolerance. There were limited correlations between responses in the systemic and mucosal compartments, and in general the responses to one dietary antigen could not predict the response to another. T cell proliferation to dietary antigens increased significantly by addition of recombinant human interleukin-2 (rhuIL-2). Peripheral blood mononuclear cells stimulated with BGG or OVA expressed IL-2Ralpha chain but not IL-2 mRNA, consistent with T cell anergy. Incubation with exogenous IL-2 alone did not restore T cell proliferation to BGG or OVA. In some individuals T cell proliferation to an unrelated vaccine antigen was suppressed by addition of BGG or OVA, but could be reversed with low doses of rhuIL-2. We conclude that in humans anergy is the major mechanism of tolerance to chronic antigen feeding, and we propose that such anergic, antigen-specific T cells actively contribute to maintenance of homeostasis in the intestine in the face of massive antigen challenge.

An overview of the immune system with specific reference to membrane encapsulation and islet transplantation

The concept of immunoisolation by use of a bioartificial membrane is discussed, concentrating on the immunological mechanisms that are likely to be operative in the light of recent information on the workings of the immune system. Special attention is given to the use of encapsulation for the purpose of treating autoimmune diabetes by implantation of xenogeneic islet tissue. It is argued that the term immunoisolation is misleading because the immune system is always activated by the indirect pathway of antigen presentation and that the term immunomodulation would be more appropriate.

T-cell anergy and peripheral T-cell tolerance

The discovery that T-cell recognition of antigen can have distinct outcomes has advanced understanding of peripheral T-cell tolerance, and opened up new possibilities in immunotherapy. Anergy is one such outcome, and results from partial T-cell activation. This can arise either due to subtle alteration of the antigen, leading to a lower-affinity cognate interaction, or due to a lack of adequate co-stimulation. The signalling defects in anergic T cells are partially defined, and suggest that T-cell receptor (TCR) proximal, as well as downstream defects negatively regulate the anergic T cell's ability to be activated. Most importantly, the use of TCR-transgenic mice has provided compelling evidence that anergy is an in vivo phenomenon, and not merely an in vitro artefact. These findings raise the question as to whether anergic T cells have any biological function. Studies in rodents and in man suggest that anergic T cells acquire regulatory properties; the regulatory effects of anergic T cells require cell to cell contact, and appear to be mediated by inhibition of antigen-presenting cell immunogenicity. Close similarities exist between anergic T cells, and the recently defined CD4+ CD25+ population of spontaneously arising regulatory cells that serve to inhibit autoimmunity in mice. Taken together, these findings suggest that a spectrum of regulatory T cells exists. At one end of the spectrum are cells, such as anergic and CD4+ CD25+ T cells, which regulate via cell-to-cell contact. At the other end of the spectrum are cells which secrete antiinflammatory cytokines such as interleukin 10 and transforming growth factor-beta. The challenge is to devise strategies that reliably induce T-cell anergy in vivo, as a means of inhibiting immunity to allo- and autoantigens.

Alloantigen-induced specific immunological unresponsiveness

When the immune system encounters alloantigen it can respond in any one of a number of different ways. The choice that is made will take into account factors such as where, when and how the contact with the alloantigen takes place, as well as the environmental conditions that prevail at the time the alloantigen is encountered. Alloantigen administration before transplantation either alone or in combination with therapeutic agents that modulate the functional activity of the responding leucocytes can be a powerful way of inducing specific unresponsiveness to alloantigens in vivo. The molecular mechanisms that influence the way the outcome of the immune response to alloantigen develops, either activation or unresponsiveness to the triggering antigen, hold the key to our ability to manipulate the immune system effectively by exposing it to donor antigen for therapeutic purposes. This review will focus on alloantigen-induced immunological unresponsiveness and how insights into the mechanisms of unresponsiveness have driven the development of novel tolerance-induction strategies that show promise for translation into the clinic in the future.

Suppression mediated by anergic CD4+ T cells requires stimulation by MHC-peptide complexes and can be induced in the presence of costimulation

BACKGROUND

In this study, we have investigated the mechanisms involved in both the induction of suppressive anergy, the stability of the anergy induced, and the possible mechanisms by which the response of immunocompetent CD4+ T cells are suppressed.

METHODS

We used immobilized anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody (mAb) to induce anergy in T helper (Th) 1 and Th0 cells reactive with MHC class II molecule H2 I-Ab.

RESULTS

We observed that suppressive anergy was induced independently of costimulation in Th0 but not Th1 cells. Although the anergic and suppressive states of Th0 cells were stable in the presence of exogenous interleukin-2, this was not the case for Th1 cells. No evidence for linked epitope suppression was observed for any of the I-Ab reactive cells investigated. Neither anergy nor suppression was observed in Th0 cells upon restimulation with anti-CD3 in the presence of syngeneic antigen-presenting cells (APCs). However, anergy but not suppression was observed in co-cultures restimulated with anti-T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) mAbs/syngeneic APCs and suppression could be restored by the addition of I-Ab+ APCs.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, these data suggested that the MHC-peptide complex recognized by the Th0 cells was required for suppression of the response of immunocompetent cells. We propose that suppression is mediated either by down-modulation of the MHC-peptide complex recognized by the anergic T cells or that a molecule specific to the MHC-peptide/TCR interaction facilitates negative regulation by APC:T or T:T interactions.

Transplantation tolerance induced by mixed chimerism

Although short- and long-term results after organ transplantation have improved considerably in recent years, morbidity and mortality rates in graft recipients remain high. The induction of lifelong donor-specific tolerance would dramatically improve outcome after organ transplantation. Although many tolerance protocols have been successful in rodent studies, most of these approaches have failed when attempted in large animals or humans. Robust tolerance, in contrast, has been demonstrated with mixed chimerism regimens not only in rodents but also in large animal models, including non-human primates. Furthermore, mixed chimerism protocols have been developed that would be feasible in cadaveric, and thus in thoracic, transplantation. The induction of mixed hematopoietic chimerism is therefore an attractive experimental approach for development of clinical tolerance protocols. One of the obstacles to widespread clinical application of this concept is the remaining toxicity of the host conditioning. Recent advances, however, have led to substantially milder protocols that could become clinically acceptable in the foreseeable future. This article provides a short overview of the basic mechanisms by which immunologic tolerance may be induced, describes the concept of mixed chimerism as a promising approach for clinical tolerance induction, and reviews recent progress in developing clinically feasible mixed chimerism protocols.

Three-cell interactions in T cell-mediated suppression? A mathematical analysis of its quantitative implications

Aiming to further our understanding of T cell-mediated suppression, we investigate the plausibility of the hypothesis that regulatory T cells suppress other T cells (target cells), while both cells are conjugated with one APC. We use a mathematical model to analyze the proliferation inhibition scored during in vitro suppression assays. This model is a radical simplification of cell culture reality, assuming that thymidine incorporation is proportional to the number of target cells that would instantaneously form conjugates with APCs that are free of regulatory cells. According to this model the inhibition index should be mainly determined by the number of regulatory cells per APC and should be insensitive to the number of target cells. We reanalyzed several published data sets, confirming this expectation. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the instantaneous inhibition index has an absolute limit as a function of the number of regulatory cells per APC. By calculating this limit we find that the model can explain the data under two non-mutually exclusive conditions. First, only approximately 15% of APCs used in the suppression assays form conjugates with T cells. Second, the growth of the regulatory cell population depends on the target cells, such that the number of regulatory cells per APC increases when they are cocultured with target cells and overcomes its limit. However, if neither of these testable conditions is fulfilled, then one could conclude that suppression in vitro does not require the formation of multicellular conjugates.

CTLA4Ig-induced linked regulation of allogeneic T cell responses

The mechanisms by which CTLA4Ig exerts its powerful immunomodulatory effects are not clear. We show here that CTLA4Ig can induce linked regulation of allogeneic porcine T cell responses in vitro. Naive miniature swine SLA(dd) T cells were rendered hyporesponsive to specific allogeneic Ag after coculturing with MHC-mismatched SLA(cc) stimulators in the presence of CTLA4Ig. These Ag-specific hyporesponsive T cells were subsequently able to actively inhibit the allogeneic responses of naive syngeneic T cells in an MHC-linked fashion, as the responses of naive SLA(dd) responders against specific SLA(cc) and (SLA(ac))F(1) stimulators were inhibited, but allogeneic responses against a 1:1 mixture of SLA(aa) (I(a), II(a)) and SLA(cc) (I(c), II(c)) were maintained. This inhibition could be generated against either class I or class II Ags, was radiosensitive, and required cell-cell contact. Furthermore, the mechanism of inhibition was not dependent upon a deletional, apoptotic pathway, but it was reversed by anti-IL-10 mAb. These data suggest that CTLA4Ig-induced inhibition of naive allogeneic T cell responses can be mediated through the generation of regulatory T cells via an IL-10-dependent mechanism.

Modelling T-cell-mediated suppression dependent on interactions in multicellular conjugates

Tolerance to peripheral body antigens involves multiple mechanisms, namely T-cell-mediated suppression of potentially autoimmune cells. Recent in vivo and in vitro evidence indicates that regulatory T cells suppress the response of effector T cells by a mechanism that requires the simultaneous conjugation of regulatory and effector T cells with the same antigen-presenting cell (APC). Despite this strong requirement, it is not yet clear what happens while both cells are conjugated. Several hypotheses are discussed in the literature. Suppression may result from simple competition of regulatory and effector cells for activation resources on the APC; regulatory T cells may deliver an inhibitory signal to effector T cells in the same conjugate; or effector T cells may acquire the regulatory phenotype during their interaction with regulatory T cells. The present article tries to further our understanding of T-cell-mediated suppression, and to narrow-down the number of candidate mechanisms. We propose the first general formalism describing the formation of multicellular conjugates of T cells and APCs. Using this formalism we derive three particular models, representing alternative mechanisms of T-cell-mediated suppression. For each model, we make phase plane and bifurcation analysis, and identify their pros and cons in terms of the relationship with the large body of experimental observations on T-cell-mediated suppression. We argue that accounting for the quantitative details of adoptive transfers of tolerance requires models with bistable regimes in which either regulatory cells or effectors cells dominate the steady state. From this analysis, we conclude that the most plausible mechanism of T-cell-mediated suppression requires that regulatory T cells actively inhibit the growth of effector T cells, and that the maintenance of the population of regulatory T cells is dependent on the effector T cells. The regulatory T cell population may depend on a growth factor produced by effector T cells and/or on a continuous differentiation of effector cells to the regulatory phenotype.

Peptide analogues as a strategy to induce tolerance in T cells with indirect allospecificity

BACKGROUND

It has been demonstrated that indirect recognition of allogeneic MHC molecules might play an important role in provoking graft rejection. Although direct recognition of allogeneic molecules on antigen presenting cells of the graft may induce a state of tolerance, the continuous presentation of processed alloantigens by specialized antigen presenting cells does not allow the same phenomenon to occur. Tolerance to interleukin-2 secreting T cells can be achieved in different ways, among these is the exposure to mutants of the wild type allopeptide. We have investigated whether peptide analogues of the allopeptide can induce tolerance in T cells with indirect allospecificity.

METHODS

T cell clones with indirect anti-HLA-A2-specificity generated from a HLA-A2-DRB1*1502+ patient who chronically rejected a HLA-A2-expressing kidney allograft were used for this study. Nine peptide analogues of HLA-A2 (residues: 103-120) were produced with single amino acid substitutions at the putative T cell receptor for antigen contact positions. Their effect on the proliferation of a panel of T cell clones was evaluated.

RESULTS

Peptide analogues and wild type peptide had similar capacity to bind to the restriction molecule HLA-DRB1*1502. Co-presentation of the peptide analogues 111R/A, H, K and 114H/K, with the wild type peptide inhibited T cell responses, indicative of antagonism. In addition, one analogue 112G/S induced unresponsiveness in the T cells to subsequent culture with the wild type peptide.

CONCLUSIONS

The data presented here suggest that using reagents such as altered peptides may represent a strategy to prevent the activation of T cells with indirect alloreactivity and allograft rejection in vivo.

Anergic T cells inhibit the antigen-presenting function of dendritic cells

The phenomena of infectious tolerance and linked-suppression are well established, but the mechanisms involved are incompletely defined. Anergic T cells can inhibit responsive T cells in vitro and prolong skin allograft survival in vivo. In this study the mechanisms underlying these events were explored. Allospecific mouse T cell clones rendered unresponsive in vitro inhibited proliferation by responsive T cells specific for the same alloantigens. The inhibition required the presence of APC, in that the response to coimmobilized anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 Abs was not inhibited. Coculture of anergic T cells with bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (DC) led to profound inhibition of the ability of the DC to stimulate T cells with the same or a different specificity. After coculture with anergic T cells expression of MHC class II, CD80 and CD86 by DC were down-regulated. These effects did not appear to be due to a soluble factor in that inhibition was not seen in Transwell experiments, and was not reversed by addition of neutralizing anti-IL-4, anti-IL-10, and anti-TGF-beta Abs. Taken together, these data suggest that anergic T cells function as suppressor cells by inhibiting Ag presentation by DC via a cell contact-dependent mechanism.

Regulatory T cells in autoimmmunity*

Clonal deletion of autoreactive T cells in the thymus is not the sole mechanism for the induction of tolerance to self-antigens since partial depletion of peripheral CD4(+) T cells from neonatal and adult animals results in the development of organ-specific autoimmunity. Reconstitution of these immunodeficient animals with populations of regulatory CD4(+)T cells prevents the development of autoimmunity. The lineage of regulatory CD4(+) T cells is generated in the thymus and can be distinguished from effector cells by the expression of unique membrane antigens. The target antigens for these suppressor populations and their mechanisms of action remain poorly defined. Depletion of regulatory T cells may be useful in the induction of immunity to weak antigens, such as tumor-specific antigens. Conversely, enhancement of regulatory T cell function may be a useful adjunct to the therapy of autoimmune diseases and for prevention of allograft rejection.

The role of the immune system in conjunctival wound healing after glaucoma surgery

The immune system has a fundamental role in the development and regulation of ocular healing, which plays an important role in the pathogenesis of most blinding diseases. This review discusses the mechanisms of normal wound healing, describing the animal and fetal wound healing models used to provide further insight into normal wound repair. In particular, conjunctival wound repair after glaucoma filtration surgery will be used to illustrate the contributions that the different components of the immune system make to the healing process. The potential role of macrophages, the possible regulatory effect of lymphocytes, and the important role of growth factors and cytokines in the wound healing reaction are discussed. The significance of the immune system in the pathogenesis of aggressive conjunctival scarring is addressed, particularly assessing the predisposing factors, including drugs, age, and ethnicity. The rationale behind the pharmacological agents currently used to modulate the wound healing response and the effects these drugs have on the function of the immune system are described. Finally, potential new therapeutic approaches to regulating the wound healing response are reported.

Regulation of human cell engraftment and development of EBV-related lymphoproliferative disorders in Hu-PBL-scid mice

Human PBMC engraft in mice homozygous for the severe combined immunodeficiency (Prkdcscid) mutation (Hu-PBL-scid mice). Hu-PBL-NOD-scid mice generate 5- to 10-fold higher levels of human cells than do Hu-PBL-C.B-17-scid mice, and Hu-PBL-NOD-scid beta2-microglobulin-null (NOD-scid-B2mnull) mice support even higher levels of engraftment, particularly CD4+ T cells. The basis for increased engraftment of human PBMC and the functional capabilities of these cells in NOD-scid and NOD-scid-B2mnull mice are unknown. We now report that human cell proliferation in NOD-scid mice increased after in vivo depletion of NK cells. Human cell engraftment depended on CD4+ cells and required CD40-CD154 interaction, but engrafted CD4+ cells rapidly became nonresponsive to anti-CD3 Ab stimulation. Depletion of human CD8+ cells led to increased human CD4+ and CD20+ cell engraftment and increased levels of human Ig. We further document that Hu-PBL-NOD-scid mice are resistant to development of human EBV-related lymphoproliferative disorders. These disorders, however, develop rapidly following depletion of human CD8+ cells and are prevented by re-engraftment of CD8+ T cells. These data demonstrate that 1) murine NK cells regulate human cell engraftment in scid recipients; 2) human CD4+ cells are required for human CD8+ cell engraftment; and 3) once engrafted, human CD8+ cells regulate human CD4+ and CD20+ cell expansion, Ig levels, and outgrowth of EBV-related lymphoproliferative disorders. We propose that the Hu-PBL-NOD-scid model is suitable for the in vivo analysis of immunoregulatory interactions between human CD4+ and CD8+ cells.

Distinct requirements for C-C chemokine and IL-2 production by naive, previously activated, and anergic T cells

Ag presented by activated APCs promote immunogenic responses whereas Ag presented by resting APCs leads to tolerance. In such a model, the regulation of cytokine release by the presence or absence of costimulation might potentially play a critical role in dictating the ultimate outcome of Ag recognition. C-C chemokines are a structurally defined family of chemoattractants that have diverse effects on inflammation. We were interested in determining the activation requirements for chemokine production by CD4+ T cells. Our data demonstrate for T cell clones and previously activated T cells from TCR-transgenic mice that stimulation with anti-TCR alone results in the production of copious amounts of macrophage-inflammatory protein-1alpha (MIP-1alpha) and other C-C chemokines, and that addition of anti-CD28 gives very little augmentation. Furthermore, MIP-1alpha production is nearly equivalent from both anergic and nonanergic cells. For naive T cells, anti-CD3 stimulation alone led to as much MIP-1alpha production as Ag + APC stimulation. The addition of costimulation gave a 3-10-fold enhancement, but this was 70-fold less than the effect of costimulation on IL-2 production. Thus, although C-C chemokines play a broad role in influencing inflammation, their production by signal 1 alone makes them unlikely to play a critical role in the decision between a tolerogenic and an immunogenic response. Furthermore, the production of MIP-1alpha by anergic T cells, as well as following signal 1 alone, raises the possibility that in vivo this chemokine serves to recruit activated T cells to become tolerant.

IL-2 unresponsiveness in anergic CD4+ T cells is due to defective signaling through the common gamma-chain of the IL-2 receptor

Repeated administration of the superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin A to mice transduces a state of anergy in the CD4+ T cell compartment, characterized by inhibition of IL-2 production and clonal expansion in vivo. In contrast to what has been reported on anergic T cell clones in vitro, culture of in vivo anergized CD4+ T cells in the presence of exogenous IL-2 did not overcome the block in responsiveness. In this study, we demonstrate that CD4+ T cells from mice anergized with staphylococcal enterotoxin A also exhibit a reduced proliferative capacity in response to IL-7 and IL-15, cytokines that share a common gamma-chain with the IL-2R. Flow-cytometric analysis revealed only modest changes in the expression of the different IL-2R chains. In a number of experiments, our results also provide evidence that excludes a major role of the IL-2R alpha-chain in this system. According to these results, the inability of anergic cells to respond to IL-2 is not mainly due to a down-regulation of the high affinity IL-2R, but to a perturbation in intracellular signaling. Our study confirmed that the activation and tyrosine phosphorylation of Janus-associated kinase 3 and STAT5 were considerably weaker after anergy induction. Moreover, anergic CD4+ T cells showed significantly reduced DNA-binding ability to STAT5-specific elements. Taken together, we suggest that the observed IL-2 unresponsiveness in anergic CD4+ T cells could be due to a defect in signaling through the common gamma-chain of the IL-2R.

The third function of the thymus

Nonresponsiveness of mammalian T cells to self-antigens is not totally accounted for in terms of clonal deletion, T-cell anergy and T-cell ignorance: studies have shown that the T-cell repertoire of healthy individuals contains cells with the potential to cause autoimmune disease. This article describes a T-cell-mediated mechanism that prevents the realization of this potential and indicates how its failure can lead to the development of autoimmunity.

Treatment of allograft recipients with donor-specific transfusion and anti-CD154 antibody leads to deletion of alloreactive CD8+ T cells and prolonged graft survival in a CTLA4-dependent manner

A two-element protocol consisting of one donor-specific transfusion (DST) plus a brief course of anti-CD154 mAb greatly prolongs the survival of murine islet, skin, and cardiac allografts. To study the mechanism of allograft survival, we determined the fate of tracer populations of alloreactive transgenic CD8+ T cells in a normal microenvironment. We observed that DST plus anti-CD154 mAb prolonged allograft survival and deleted alloreactive transgenic CD8+ T cells. Neither component alone did so. Skin allograft survival was also prolonged in normal recipients treated with anti-CD154 mAb plus a depleting anti-CD8 mAb and in C57BL/6-CD8 knockout mice treated with anti-CD154 mAb monotherapy. We conclude that, in the presence of anti-CD154 mAb, DST leads to an allotolerant state, in part by deleting alloreactive CD8+ T cells. Consistent with this conclusion, blockade of CTLA4, which is known to abrogate the effects of DST and anti-CD154 mAb, prevented the deletion of alloreactive transgenic CD8+ T cells. These results document for the first time that peripheral deletion of alloantigen-specific CD8+ T cells is an important mechanism through which allograft survival can be prolonged by costimulatory blockade. We propose a unifying mechanism to explain allograft prolongation by DST and blockade of costimulation.

Suppressor effector function of CD4+CD25+ immunoregulatory T cells is antigen nonspecific

CD4+CD25+ T cells represent a unique population of "professional" suppressor T cells that prevent induction of organ-specific autoimmune disease. In vitro, CD4+CD25+ cells were anergic to simulation via the TCR and when cultured with CD4+CD25- cells, markedly suppressed polyclonal T cell proliferation by specifically inhibiting the production of IL-2. Suppression was cytokine independent, cell contact dependent, and required activation of the suppressors via their TCR. Further characterization of the CD4+CD25+ population demonstrated that they do not contain memory or activated T cells and that they act through an APC-independent mechanism. CD4+CD25+ T cells isolated from TCR transgenic (Tg) mice inhibited responses of CD4+CD25- Tg T cells to the same Ag, but also inhibited the Ag-specific responses of Tg cells specific for a distinct Ag. Suppression required that both peptide/MHC complexes be present in the same culture, but the Ags could be presented by two distinct populations of APC. When CD4+CD25+ T cells were cultured with anti-CD3 and IL-2, they expanded, remained anergic, and in the absence of restimulation via their TCR, suppressed Ag-specific responses of CD4+CD25- T cells from multiple TCR transgenics. Collectively, these data demonstrate that CD4+CD25+ T cells require activation via their TCR to become suppressive, but once activated, their suppressor effector function is completely nonspecific. The cell surface molecules involved in this T-T interaction remain to be characterized.

Antigen presentation by parenchymal cells: a route to peripheral tolerance?

T-cell activation and the development of efficient immune responses requires the delivery, by the antigen-presenting cell, of two distinct signals. The first results from the engagement of the TCR:CD3:CD4 complex, and the second from the interaction of CD28 with the B7 family of co-stimulatory molecules. In this context, the physiological significance and the functional consequences of antigen presentation by B7-deficient parenchymal cells, which express MHC class II molecules as a result of inflammation, remains a matter of debate. In this paper we have attempted to critically review the often conflicting reports on the functional effects of antigen presentation by epithelial and endothelial cells to T cells, both in vitro and in vivo. Our own findings are summarised in a model which is consistent with the suggestion of an important role for antigen presentation by parenchymal cells in the induction and the maintenance of peripheral tolerance.

IL-2 Mediates Protection Against Abscess Formation in an Experimental Model of Sepsis

Little is known regarding the mechanism by which T cells control intraabdominal abscess formation. Treating animals with polysaccharide A (PS A) from Bacteroides fragilis shortly before or after challenge protects against abscess formation subsequent to challenge with different abscess-inducing bacteria. Although bacterial polysaccharides are considered to be T cell-independent Ags, T cells from PS A-treated animals mediate this protective activity. In the present study, we demonstrate that CD4+ T cells transfer PS A-mediated protection against abscess formation, and that a soluble mediator produced by these cells confers this activity. Cytokine mRNA analysis showed that T cells from PS A-treated animals produced transcript for IL-2, IFN-γ, and IL-10, but not for IL-4. The addition of IL-2-specific Ab to T cell lysates taken from PS A-treated animals abrogated the ability to transfer protection, whereas the addition of Abs specific for IFN-γ and IL-10 did not affect protection. Finally, administration of rIL-2 to animals at the time of bacterial challenge prevented abscess formation in a dose-dependent manner. These data demonstrate that PS A-mediated protection against abscess formation is dependent upon a CD4+ T cell-dependent response, and that IL-2 is essential to this immune mechanism.