Two-locus mitochondrial and nuclear gene models for mitochondrial disorders

Our current understanding of the toxicity of altered mito-ribosomal fidelity during mitochondrial protein synthesis: What can it tell us about human disease?

Altered mito-ribosomal fidelity is an important and insufficiently understood causative agent of mitochondrial dysfunction. Its pathogenic effects are particularly well-known in the case of mitochondrially induced deafness, due to the existence of the, so called, ototoxic variants at positions 847C (m.1494C) and 908A (m.1555A) of 12S mitochondrial (mt-) rRNA. It was shown long ago that the deleterious effects of these variants could remain dormant until an external stimulus triggered their pathogenicity. Yet, the link from the fidelity defect at the mito-ribosomal level to its phenotypic manifestation remained obscure. Recent work with fidelity-impaired mito-ribosomes, carrying error-prone and hyper-accurate mutations in mito-ribosomal proteins, have started to reveal the complexities of the phenotypic manifestation of mito-ribosomal fidelity defects, leading to a new understanding of mtDNA disease. While much needs to be done to arrive to a clear picture of how defects at the level of mito-ribosomal translation eventually result in the complex patterns of disease observed in patients, the current evidence indicates that altered mito-ribosome function, even at very low levels, may become highly pathogenic. The aims of this review are three-fold. First, we compare the molecular details associated with mito-ribosomal fidelity to those of general ribosomal fidelity. Second, we gather information on the cellular and organismal phenotypes associated with defective translational fidelity in order to provide the necessary grounds for an understanding of the phenotypic manifestation of defective mito-ribosomal fidelity. Finally, the results of recent experiments directly tackling mito-ribosomal fidelity are reviewed and future paths of investigation are discussed.

The exome sequencing identified the mutation in YARS2 encoding the mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase as a nuclear modifier for the phenotypic manifestation of Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy-associated mitochondrial DNA mutation

Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) is the most common mitochondrial disorder. Nuclear modifier genes are proposed to modify the phenotypic expression of LHON-associated mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations. By using an exome sequencing approach, we identified a LHON susceptibility allele (c.572G>T, p.191Gly>Val) in YARS2 gene encoding mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase, which interacts with m.11778G>A mutation to cause visual failure. We performed functional assays by using lymphoblastoid cell lines derived from members of Chinese families (asymptomatic individuals carrying m.11778G>A mutation, or both m.11778G>A and heterozygous p.191Gly>Val mutations and symptomatic subjects harboring m.11778G>A and homozygous p.191Gly>Val mutations) and controls lacking these mutations. The 191Gly>Val mutation reduced the YARS2 protein level in the mutant cells. The aminoacylated efficiency and steady-state level of tRNA(Tyr) were markedly decreased in the cell lines derived from patients both carrying homozygous YARS2 p.191Gly>Val and m.11778G>A mutations. The failure in tRNA(Tyr) metabolism impaired mitochondrial translation, especially for polypeptides with high content of tyrosine codon such as ND4, ND5, ND6 and COX2 in cells lines carrying homozygous YARS2 p.191Gly>Val and m.11778G>A mutations. The YARS2 p.191Gly>Val mutation worsened the respiratory phenotypes associated with m.11778G>A mutation, especially reducing activities of complexes I and IV. The respiratory deficiency altered the efficiency of mitochondrial ATP synthesis and increased the production of reactive oxygen species. Thus, mutated YARS2 aggravates mitochondrial dysfunctions associated with the m.11778G>A mutation, exceeding the threshold for the expression of blindness phenotype. Our findings provided new insights into the pathophysiology of LHON that were manifested by interaction between mtDNA mutation and mutated nuclear-modifier YARS2.

Mitochondrial 12S rRNA mutations associated with aminoglycoside ototoxicity

The mitochondrial 12S rRNA is a hot spot for mutations associated with both aminoglycoside-induced and nonsyndromic hearing loss. Of those, the homoplasmic 1555A>G and 1494C>T mutations at the highly conserved decoding region of the 12S rRNA have been associated with hearing loss worldwide. In particular, these two mutations account for a significant number of cases of aminoglycoside ototoxicity. The 1555A>G or 1494C>T mutation is expected to form a novel 1494C-G1555 or 1494U-A1555 base-pair at the highly conserved A-site of 12S rRNA. These transitions make the human mitochondrial ribosomes more bacteria-like and alter binding sites for aminoglycosides. As a result, the exposure to aminoglycosides can induce or worsen hearing loss in individuals carrying one of these mutations. Biochemical characterization demonstrated an impairment of mitochondrial protein synthesis and subsequent defects in respiration in cells carrying the A1555G or 1494C>T mutation. Furthermore, a wide range of severity, age-at-onset and penetrance of hearing loss was observed within and among families carrying these mutations. Nuclear modifier genes, mitochondrial haplotypes and aminoglycosides should modulate the phenotypic manifestation of the 12S rRNA 1555A>G and 1494C>T mutations. Therefore, these data provide valuable information and technology: (1) to predict which individuals are at risk for ototoxicity; (2) to improve the safety of aminoglycoside antibiotic therapy; and (3) eventually to decrease the incidence of hearing loss.

Influence of mutation type on clinical expression of Leber hereditary optic neuropathy

PURPOSE

The aim of this research was to determine the molecular factors of influence on the clinical expression of Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON), which might aid in counseling LHON patients and families. The prevalence of LHON in the Dutch population was determined.

DESIGN

Observational, retrospective population cohort study.

METHODS

The clinical characteristics of LHON patients of 25 families, previously described in 1963, were reevaluated. The mutation and haplotype were determined in the DNA of one affected LHON patient per family. The genotype of their relatives could be deducted, enabling us to evaluate retrospectively the genotype-phenotype correlation. The prevalence of LHON was determined on the basis of anamnestic evaluation of patients in 1963 and by using population registers of that period.

RESULTS

The LHON mutation does not influence disease penetrance (50% in male subjects; 10% to 20% in female subjects). More than half of the patients with the 14484 mutation exhibit a partial recovery of vision, regardless of the acuteness of disease onset (P = .001), whereas only 22% of the 11778 carriers and 15.4% of the 3460 carriers recovered. The recovery did not take place within the first year after onset and was uncommon after four years. The onset of LHON is in general very acute but might be more gradual in 11778 carriers and in children. The calculated prevalence of LHON in the Dutch population (1/39,000) is very likely an underestimation caused by a selection bias of familial cases in the original study.

CONCLUSIONS

The LHON genotype influences the recovery of vision and disease onset but is unrelated to age, acuteness of onset, or gender. The genotype does not influence disease penetrance. Children might exhibit a slower onset of disease.

[Mitochondrial hearing impairment. Background, genetic predisposition and possibilities for diagnosis]

Hearing impairment (HI) is one of the most common neurosensory disorders, with sensorineural hereditary HI being the most common form. Mitochondrial maternally inherited HI appears to be increasing in frequency. The incidence of mitochondrial defects causing HI is estimated to be between 6 and 33% of all hearing deficiencies, with an even higher percentage for some syndromic cases. This review summarises the syndromic and non-syndromic characteristics of sensorineural HI based on mutations in mitochondrially encoded genes, the relationship to aminoglycoside-induced HI and related diagnostic tools.

A human mitochondrial GTP binding protein related to tRNA modification may modulate phenotypic expression of the deafness-associated mitochondrial 12S rRNA mutation

Human mitochondrial 12S rRNA A1555G mutation has been found to be associated with deafness. However, putative nuclear modifier gene(s) has been proposed to regulate the phenotypic expression of this mutation. In yeast cells, mutant alleles of MSS1, encoding a mitochondrial GTP-binding protein, manifest a respiratory-deficient phenotype only when coupled with mitochondrial 15S rRNA P(R)(454) mutation corresponding to human A1555G mutation. This suggests that an MSS1-like modifier gene may influence the phenotypic expression of the A1555G mutation. We report here the identification and characterization of human MSS1 homolog, GTPBP3, the first identified vertebrate gene related to mitochondrial tRNA modification. The Gtpbp3 is the mitochondrial GTPase evolutionarily conserved from bacteria to mammals. Functional conservation of this protein is supported by the observation that isolated human GTPBP3 cDNA can complement the respiratory-deficient phenotype of yeast mss1 cells carrying P(R)(454) mutation. GTPBP3 is ubiquitously expressed in various tissues as multiple transcripts, but with a markedly elevated expression in tissues of high metabolic rates. We showed that Gtpbp3 localizes in mitochondrion. These observations suggest that the human GTPBP3 is a structural and functional homolog of yeast MSS1. Thus, allelic variants in GTPBP3 could, if they exist, modulate the phenotypic manifestation of human mitochondrial A1555G mutation.

Isolation and characterization of the putative nuclear modifier gene MTO1 involved in the pathogenesis of deafness-associated mitochondrial 12 S rRNA A1555G mutation

The human mitochondrial 12 S rRNA A1555G mutation has been found to be associated with aminoglycoside-induced and non-syndromic deafness. However, putative nuclear modifier gene(s) have been proposed to regulate the phenotypic expression of this mutation. In yeast, the mutant alleles of MTO1, encoding a mitochondrial protein, manifest respiratory-deficient phenotype only when coupled with the mitochondrial 15 S rRNA P(R)454 mutation corresponding to human A1555G mutation. This suggests that the MTO1-like modifier gene may influence the phenotypic expression of human A1555G mutation. Here we report the identification of full-length cDNA and elucidation of genomic organization of the human MTO1 homolog. Human Mto1 is an evolutionarily conserved protein that implicates a role in the mitochondrial tRNA modification. Functional conservation of this protein is supported by the observation that isolated human MTO1 cDNA can complement the respiratory deficient phenotype of yeast mto1 cells carrying P(R)454 mutation. MTO1 is ubiquitously expressed in various tissues, but with a markedly elevated expression in tissues of high metabolic rates including cochlea. These observations suggest that human MTO1 is a structural and functional homolog of yeast MTO1. Thus, it may play an important role in the pathogenesis of deafness-associated A1555G mutation in 12 S rRNA gene or mutations in tRNA genes.

Does accounting for mitochondrial genetic variation improve the fit of genetic models?

We describe a simple variance component model for estimating the effect of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) inheritance on quantitative trait variation. The model is applied to quantitative trait Q5 in the simulated general population data from Genetic Analysis Workshop (GAW) 12. Although the mitochondrial effect on Q5 is small (5.3%) and the power of the method to detect the effect is correspondingly low, analysis over the available population replicates demonstrates that the effect of maternal relatedness can be detected and estimated accurately.

Testing for contributions of mitochondrial DNA mutations to complex diseases

Several complex disorders are suspected of being associated with mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations. We studied the statistical properties of a test based on proband-relative pairs to identify potential mtDNA mutation involvement in a complex disorder. The test compares the recurrence risk of relatives of probands along the mitochondrial lineage with that of relatives along the nonmitochondrial lineage. If mtDNA mutations are involved, the recurrence risk will be higher among relatives in the mitochondrial lineage. The form of the test is independent of the assumed models of inheritance and interaction of the nuclear autosomal mutations with mtDNA mutations. The power of the test, however, differs among the different models and by the type of proband-relative pairs used in the test. We considered heterogeneity models with and without phenocopies, a three-state heteroplasmic mtDNA transmission model, and a multiplicative epistasis model. Under the heterogeneity model, the power of the test increases as the relationship between the proband and the relative becomes more distant. Under the multiplicative epistasis model, the power of the test decreases as the relationship between the proband and the relative becomes more distant.

Mitochondrial encephalomyopathies: the enigma of genotype versus phenotype

Over the past decade a large body of evidence has accumulated implicating defects of human mitochondrial DNA in the pathogenesis of a group of disorders known collectively as the mitochondrial encephalomyopathies. Although impaired oxidative phosphorylation is likely to represent the final common pathway leading to cellular dysfunction in these diseases, fundamental issues still remain elusive. Perhaps the most challenging of these is to understand the mechanisms which underlie the complex relationship between genotype and phenotype. Here we examine this relationship and discuss some of the factors which are likely to be involved.

Hearing loss with a mitochondrial gene mutation is highly prevalent in Japan

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Mutations in the mitochondrial genome may predispose people to sensorineural hearing loss. An adenine to guanine point mutation in the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene at nucleotide 3,243 is one of the deaf-related mutations. This mutation is reported to be associated with 0.9% of diabetes mellitus patients. However, the prevalence of this mutation in hearing-impaired patients still remains unknown. The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of this mutation among bilaterally sensorineural hearing-impaired patients in Japan.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective survey of 100 patients with bilateral sensorineural hearing loss without any evident causes.

METHODS

Mitochondrial DNA fragments from the patients were amplified by polymerase chain reaction, followed by a restriction enzyme fragment length polymorphism method.

RESULTS

Three patients with this mutation were identified. Their clinical profiles were different from the category which had been considered as hearing loss caused by this mitochondrial gene mutation.

CONCLUSIONS

The mutation is associated with approximately 3% of bilateral sensorineural hearing loss cases of unknown origin and is possibly distributed widely in sensorineural hearing-impaired patients in Japan.

Evidence for complex nuclear inheritance in a pedigree with nonsyndromic deafness due to a homoplasmic mitochondrial mutation

The relationship between mitochondrial genotype and clinical phenotype is complicated in most instances by the heteroplasmic nature of pathogenic mitochondrial mutations. We have previously shown that maternally inherited hearing loss in a large Arab-Israeli kindred is due to the homoplasmic A1555G mutation in the mitochondrial 12S ribosomal RNA gene [Prezant et al., 1993: Nat Genet 4:289-294]. Family members with this mutation have phenotypes ranging from profound hearing loss to completely normal hearing, and we have shown that there is genetic and biochemical evidence for nuclear gene involvement in this family [Bu et al., 1993: Genet Epidemiol 9:27-44; Guan et al., 1996: Hum Mol Genet 5:963-971]. To identify such a nuclear locus, two candidate genes were excluded through linkage analysis and sequencing, and a genome-wide linkage search in family members who all have the identical homoplasmic mitochondrial mutation, but differ in their hearing status, was performed. In two stages a total of 560 polymorphic genetic markers was genotyped, and the data were analyzed under model-dependent and model-free assumptions. No chromosomal region was identified as a major contributor to the phenotypic expression of the mitochondrial mutation. Thus, in this simplified paradigm of a homoplasmic mitochondrial mutation in a single kindred who all live in the similar environment of a small village, the penetrance of the mitochondrial mutation appears to depend on the interaction of multiple nuclear genes.

Complex I function in familial and sporadic dystonia

A significant proportion of patients with inborn errors of the mitochondrial respiratory chain exhibit movement disorders, particularly dystonia. Point mutations of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) are usually expressed systemically, and defects of platelet respiratory chain function have been described in patients with mtDNA mutations and Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON). Recent reports have documented families with dystonia in association with LHON and mtDNA complex I gene mutations. We have examined mitochondrial function in platelet mitochondria from patients with familial generalized dystonia (linked or not linked to 9q34) and sporadic focal dystonia. We confirm a previous report of a specific complex I defect in patients with sporadic focal dystonia but could not find any abnormality in patients with familial generalized dystonia, linked or not to 9q34. These results support the existence of a mitochondrial deficiency in sporadic focal dystonia and provide a biochemical dimension to the clinical and genetic distinction between focal and generalized familial dystonia.

Genetic epidemiologic methods to screen for matrilineal inheritance in mitochondrial disorders

We propose a method to screen for the matrilineal inheritance in mitochondrial disorders by comparing the risk of disease in a person whose mother is affected or whose maternal grandmother or aunt or uncle is affected to the risk of disease in a person whose father is affected or whose paternal grandmother or aunt or uncle is affected using a modification of the reconstructed cohort design. Sampling of pedigrees is accomplished via probands and must not be influenced by family history. The cohort of the proband's offspring, and offspring of the proband's siblings, can be analyzed using survival analysis. Cox proportional hazards model, Bonney's [(1986) Biometrics 42:611-625] model, and Liang's [(1991) Genet Epidemiol 8:329-338] model. Mitochondrial transmission can be distinguished from X-linked transmission by examining sex-specific patterns of disease expression in matrilineally transmitted diseases. To illustrate our epidemiologic method, we apply our screening method to pedigrees of two disorders which have been proposed to have a mitochondrial DNA component to their inheritance.

Familial mitochondrial encephalomyopathy with deaf-mutism, ophthalmoplegia and leukodystrophy

We report two sisters (32 and 36 years old) with familial deaf-mutism, progressive external ophthalmoplegia, leukodystrophy and mitochondrial myopathy. T2-weighted brain MRI demonstrated diffuse symmetrical high intensity areas in the white matter. Their muscle biopsies showed ragged-red fibers and cytochrome c oxidase (CCO)-negative fibers. CCO activity in biopsied muscle decreased to about 20% of normal control. They had no deletions of the mitochondrial DNA and no point mutations in mitochondrial tRNA. Their brother was diagnosed as having Kugelberg-Welander disease, grand mal seizures and urinary dysfunction. Their parents and grandparents had consanguinity. Three relatives were found to have deaf-mutism without accompanying ophthalmoplegia. This rare combination of mitochondrial encephalomyopathy and familial deaf-mutism might be caused by a nuclear DNA mutation in these sisters.

Wolfram syndrome: a mitochondrial-mediated disorder?

Mitochondrial DNA mutations cause several human diseases, (eg, Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy). Wolfram syndrome (characterised by diabetes insipidus, diabetes mellitus, optic atrophy, and deafness) also has, in some cases, a mitochondrial origin. The disease, often familial, has been well documented as an autosomal recessive disorder, and most of the clinical phenotypes are consistent with an ATP supply defect that is often seen in mitochondrial-mediated disorders. We propose a dual genome defect model for Wolfram syndrome in which nuclear genetic defects or mitochondrial genetic defects can independently lead to the disease. This model suggests that besides a mitochondrial gene defect alone, a nuclear gene defect, which interferes with the normal function of mitochondria (probably with a normal mitochondrial genome), can also be the underlying explanation for the pleiotropic features of Wolfram syndrome. This hypothesis explains how an autosomal recessive disorder can result in mitochondrial dysfunction, and has a general application in the identification of candidate genes for the various important phenotypes (eg, deafness and diabetes mellitus) seen in mitochondrial disorders.

Mitochondrial ribosomal RNA mutation associated with both antibiotic-induced and non-syndromic deafness

Maternally transmitted non-syndromic deafness was described recently both in pedigrees with susceptibility to aminoglycoside ototoxicity and in a large Arab-Israeli pedigree. Because of the known action of aminoglycosides on bacterial ribosomes, we analysed the sequence of the mitochondrial rRNA genes of three unrelated patients with familial aminoglycoside-induced deafness. We also sequenced the complete mitochondrial genome of the Arab-Israeli pedigree. All four families shared a nucleotide 1555 A to G substitution in the 12S rRNA gene, a site implicated in aminoglycoside activity. Our study offers the first description of a mitochondrial rRNA mutation leading to disease, the first cases of non-syndromic deafness caused by a mitochondrial DNA mutation and the first molecular genetic study of antibiotic-induced ototoxicity.

A form of sensorineural deafness is determined by a mitochondrial and an autosomal locus: evidence from pedigree segregation analysis

We have previously reported a large Israeli-Arab pedigree with sensorineural deafness possibly determined simultaneously by two loci--one mitochondrial, and one autosomal recessive. This was analyzed by extending classic segregation analysis methods to the many nuclear families derived from the maternal line pedigree. Here we expand this pedigree and extend our analysis by using the regressive models for segregation analysis on the entire pedigree. The corresponding REGD computer program was utilized and the marrying-in males' and paternal line members' affection statuses were assigned as unknown to accommodate the exclusive maternal transmission pattern. For the autosomal locus, a simple autosomal recessive (q = 0.52) model with a nearly complete penetrance (0.93) was found to be the best-fitting model. Equally importantly, we were also able to use the power of the regressive models to test the hypothesis of mitochondrial heteroplasmy as an alternative for the proposed autosomal locus. We found no evidence for the heteroplasmy hypothesis as an explanation for the incomplete maternal transmission of deafness in this pedigree. Thus, even if the mitochondrial mutation occurred in a heteroplasmic distribution in the family members, this could not explain the familial aggregation in this pedigree, and an autosomal recessive locus is still required. These results provide further support for the concept that the sensorineural deafness occurring in this large Israeli-Arab pedigree results from simultaneous involvement of two genes at two different loci, one mitochondrial and likely homoplasmic, and the other autosomal and recessive.

Biochemical characterization of a pedigree with mitochondrially inherited deafness

A large kindred with a predicted 2-locus inheritance of sensorineural deafness, caused by the combination of a mitochondrial and an autosomal recessive mutation, was examined at the biochemical level. Because of the mitochondrial inheritance of this disease, we looked for defects in the oxidative phosphorylation Complexes I, III, IV, and V, the 4 enzymes that include all of the 13 mitochondrially encoded polypeptides. Biosynthetic labelling of lymphoblastoid cells from deaf patients, unaffected siblings, and an unrelated control showed no difference in size, abundance, rate of synthesis, or chloramphenicol-sensitivity of the mitochondrially encoded subunits. Since overall mitochondrial protein synthesis appears normal, these results suggest that the mitochondrial mutation is unlikely to be in a tRNA or rRNA gene. No change in enzymatic levels was seen in lymphoblastoid mitochondria of the deaf patients, compared to unaffected sibs and controls, for Complexes I and IV. Both affected and unaffected family members showed an increase in Complex III activity compared to controls, which may reflect the mitochondrial DNA shared by maternal relatives, or be due to other genetic differences. Complex V activity was increased in deaf individuals compared to their unaffected sibs. Since the family members share the presumptive mitochondrial mutation, differences between deaf and unaffected individuals likely reflect the nuclear background and suggest that the autosomal recessive mutation may be related to the increase in Complex V activity. These biochemical studies provide a guide for sequence analysis of the patients' mitochondrial DNA and for linkage studies in this kindred.