Requirements for accurate estimation of anisotropic material parameters by magnetic resonance elastography: A computational study

Post-mortem changes of anisotropic mechanical properties in the porcine brain assessed by MR elastography

Knowledge of the mechanical properties of brain tissue in vivo is essential to understanding the mechanisms underlying traumatic brain injury (TBI) and to creating accurate computational models of TBI and neurosurgical simulation. Brain white matter, which is composed of aligned, myelinated, axonal fibers, is structurally anisotropic. White matter in vivo also exhibits mechanical anisotropy, as measured by magnetic resonance elastography (MRE), but measurements of anisotropy obtained by mechanical testing of white matter ex vivo have been inconsistent. The minipig has a gyrencephalic brain with similar white matter and gray matter proportions to humans and therefore provides a relevant model for human brain mechanics. In this study, we compare estimates of anisotropic mechanical properties of the minipig brain obtained by identical, non-invasive methods in the live (in vivo) and dead animals (in situ). To do so, we combine wave displacement fields from MRE and fiber directions derived from diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) with a finite element-based, transversely-isotropic nonlinear inversion (TI-NLI) algorithm. Maps of anisotropic mechanical properties in the minipig brain were generated for each animal alive and at specific times post-mortem. These maps show that white matter is stiffer, more dissipative, and more anisotropic than gray matter when the minipig is alive, but that these differences largely disappear post-mortem, with the exception of tensile anisotropy. Overall, brain tissue becomes stiffer, less dissipative, and less mechanically anisotropic post-mortem. These findings emphasize the importance of testing brain tissue properties in vivo.

Statement of Significance

In this study, MRE and DTI in the minipig were combined to estimate, for the first time, anisotropic mechanical properties in the living brain and in the same brain after death. Significant differences were observed in the anisotropic behavior of brain tissue post-mortem. These results demonstrate the importance of measuring brain tissue properties in vivo as well as ex vivo, and provide new quantitative data for the development of computational models of brain biomechanics.

Mechanical Properties of White Matter Tracts in Aging Assessed via Anisotropic MR Elastography

Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is a promising neuroimaging technique to probe tissue microstructure, which has revealed widespread softening with loss of structural integrity in the aging brain. Traditional MRE approaches assume mechanical isotropy. However, white matter is known to be anisotropic from aligned, myelinated axonal bundles, which can lead to uncertainty in mechanical property estimates in these areas when using isotropic MRE. Recent advances in anisotropic MRE now allow for estimation of shear and tensile anisotropy, along with substrate shear modulus, in white matter tracts. The objective of this study was to investigate age-related differences in anisotropic mechanical properties in human brain white matter tracts for the first time. Anisotropic mechanical properties in all tracts were found to be significantly lower in older adults compared to young adults, with average property differences ranging between 0.028-0.107 for shear anisotropy and between 0.139-0.347 for tensile anisotropy. Stiffness perpendicular to the axonal fiber direction was also significantly lower in older age, but only in certain tracts. When compared with fractional anisotropy measures from diffusion tensor imaging, we found that anisotropic MRE measures provided additional, complementary information in describing differences between the white matter integrity of young and older populations. Anisotropic MRE provides a new tool for studying white matter structural integrity in aging and neurodegeneration.

Mechanical stiffness and anisotropy measured by MRE during brain development in the minipig

The relationship between brain development and mechanical properties of brain tissue is important, but remains incompletely understood, in part due to the challenges in measuring these properties longitudinally over time. In addition, white matter, which is composed of aligned, myelinated, axonal fibers, may be mechanically anisotropic. Here we use data from magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) and diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) to estimate anisotropic mechanical properties in six female Yucatan minipigs at ages from 3 to 6 months. Fiber direction was estimated from the principal axis of the diffusion tensor in each voxel. Harmonic shear waves in the brain were excited by three different configurations of a jaw actuator and measured using a motion-sensitive MR imaging sequence. Anisotropic mechanical properties are estimated from displacement field and fiber direction data with a finite element- based, transversely-isotropic nonlinear inversion (TI-NLI) algorithm. TI-NLI finds spatially resolved TI material properties that minimize the error between measured and simulated displacement fields. Maps of anisotropic mechanical properties in the minipig brain were generated for each animal at all four ages. These maps show that white matter is more dissipative and anisotropic than gray matter, and reveal significant effects of brain development on brain stiffness and structural anisotropy. Changes in brain mechanical properties may be a fundamental biophysical signature of brain development.

In vivoestimation of anisotropic mechanical properties of the gastrocnemius during functional loading with MR elastography

Objective.In vivoimaging assessments of skeletal muscle structure and function allow for longitudinal quantification of tissue health. Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) non-invasively quantifies tissue mechanical properties, allowing for evaluation of skeletal muscle biomechanics in response to loading, creating a better understanding of muscle functional health.Approach. In this study, we analyze the anisotropic mechanical response of calf muscles using MRE with a transversely isotropic, nonlinear inversion algorithm (TI-NLI) to investigate the role of muscle fiber stiffening under load. We estimate anisotropic material parameters including fiber shear stiffness (μ1), substrate shear stiffness (μ2), shear anisotropy (ϕ), and tensile anisotropy (ζ) of the gastrocnemius muscle in response to both passive and active tension.Main results. In passive tension, we found a significant increase inμ1,ϕ,andζwith increasing muscle length. While in active tension, we observed increasingμ2and decreasingϕandζduring active dorsiflexion and plantarflexion-indicating less anisotropy-with greater effects when the muscles act as agonist.Significance. The study demonstrates the ability of this anisotropic MRE method to capture the multifaceted mechanical response of skeletal muscle to tissue loading from muscle lengthening and contraction.

Estimation of anisotropic properties of CMR patient-specific left ventricle using the virtual field method

Left ventricle (LV) myocardial dysfunction has been recently investigated using the estimation of isotropic myocardial stiffness from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). However, Myocardium is known to have a 3D complex geometry with anisotropic stiffness. The assessment of the anisotropy properties characterizes structural changes in myocardium as a consequence of heart failure (HF). From image data, the virtual field method (VFM) can determine material stiffness in a non-invasive manner. In the present work, the objective is to compare two inverse identification methods, given the isotropic and anisotropic models in the characterization of properties of myocardium in acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) survivors using VFM and MRI. Two types of VFM approach are presented. Using the first, the virtual displacements (VFs) allow whole-field LV to be imposed into VFM formulation and caused to directly estimate two independent parameters from isotropic constitutive relation. With the second, anisotropic parameters are estimated using piece-wise (Finite element-based) VFM. The resulting values showed significant differences between the subjects in comparative study of leukemia survivors, and variance in estimated parameters by two different VFM approach. This approach would be an efficient tool to characterize early cardiac dysfunction. This work elucidates the benefits and shortcomings of using VFM to determine anisotropic parameters of LV myocardium in linear elastic and of using the FEM application to generate meshes of patient-specific LVs from MRI images.

Quantifying stability of parameter estimates forin vivonearly incompressible transversely-isotropic brain MR elastography

Easily computable quality metrics for measured medical data at point-of-care are important for imaging technologies involving offline reconstruction. Accordingly, we developed a new data quality metric forin vivotransversely-isotropic (TI) magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) based on a generalization of the widely accepted octahedral shear-strain calculation. The metric uses MRE displacement data and an estimate of the TI property field to yield a 'stability map' which predicts regions of low versus high accuracy in the resulting material property reconstructions. We can also calculate an average TI parameter stability (TIPS) score over all voxels in a region of interest for a given measurement to indicate how reliable the recovered mechanical property estimate for the region is expected to be. The calculation is rapid and places little demand on computing resources compared to the computationally intensive material property reconstruction from non-linear inversion (TI-NLI) of displacement fields, making it ideal for point-of-care evaluation of data quality. We test the predictions of the stability map for both simulated phantoms andin vivohuman brain data. We used a range of different displacement datasets from vibrations applied in the anterior-posterior (AP), left-right (LR) and combined AP + LR directions. The TIPS and variability maps (noise sensitivity or variation from the mean of repeated MRE scans) were consistently anti-correlated. Notably, Spearman correlation coefficients ∣R∣>0.6 were found between variability and TIPS score for individual white matter tracts within vivodata. These observations demonstrate the reliability and promise of this data quality metric to screen data rapidly in realistic clinical MRE applications.

The combined importance of finite dimensions, anisotropy, and pre-stress in acoustoelastography

Dynamic elastography, whether based on magnetic resonance, ultrasound, or optical modalities, attempts to reconstruct quantitative maps of the viscoelastic properties of biological tissue, properties that are altered by disease and injury, by noninvasively measuring mechanical wave motion in the tissue. Most reconstruction strategies that have been developed neglect boundary conditions, including quasistatic tensile or compressive loading resulting in a nonzero prestress. Significant prestress is inherent to the functional role of some biological tissues currently being studied using elastography, such as skeletal and cardiac muscle, arterial walls, and the cornea. In the present article, we review how prestress alters both bulk mechanical wave motion and wave motion in one- and two-dimensional waveguides. Key findings are linked to studies on skeletal muscle and the human cornea, as one- and two-dimensional waveguide examples. This study highlights the underappreciated combined acoustoelastic and waveguide challenge to elastography. Can elastography truly determine viscoelastic properties of a material when what it is measuring is affected by both these material properties and unknown prestress and other boundary conditions?

In silicoevaluation and optimisation of magnetic resonance elastography of the liver

Objective.Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is widely adopted as a biomarker of liver fibrosis. However,in vivoMRE accuracy is difficult to assess.Approach.Finite element model (FEM) simulation was employed to evaluate liver MRE accuracy and inform methodological optimisation. MRE data was simulated in a 3D FEM of the human torso including the liver, and compared with spin-echo echo-planar imaging MRE acquisitions. The simulated MRE results were compared with the ground truth magnitude of the complex shear modulus (∣G*∣) for varying: (1) ground truth liver ∣G*∣; (2) simulated imaging resolution; (3) added noise; (4) data smoothing. Motion and strain-based signal-to-noise (SNR) metrics were evaluated on the simulated data as a means to select higher-quality voxels for preparation of acquired MRE summary statistics of ∣G*∣.Main results.The simulated MRE accuracy for a given ground truth ∣G*∣ was found to be a function of imaging resolution, motion-SNR and smoothing. At typical imaging resolutions, it was found that due to under-sampling of the MRE wave-field, combined with motion-related noise, the reconstructed simulated ∣G*∣ could contain errors on the scale of the difference between liver fibrosis stages, e.g. 54% error for ground truth ∣G*∣ = 1 kPa. Optimum imaging resolutions were identified for given ground truth ∣G*∣ and motion-SNR levels.Significance.This study provides important knowledge on the accuracy and optimisation of liver MRE. For example, for motion-SNR ≤ 5, to distinguish between liver ∣G*∣ of 2 and 3 kPa (i.e. early-stage liver fibrosis) it was predicted that the optimum isotropic voxel size is 4-6 mm.

Magnetic Resonance Elastography Reconstruction for Anisotropic Tissues

Elastography has become widely used clinically for characterising changes in soft tissue mechanics that are associated with altered tissue structure and composition. However, some soft tissues, such as muscle, are not isotropic as is assumed in clinical elastography implementations. This limits the ability of these methods to capture changes in anisotropic tissues associated with disease. The objective of this study was to develop and validate a novel elastography reconstruction technique suitable for estimating the linear viscoelastic mechanical properties of transversely isotropic soft tissues. We derived a divergence-free formulation of the governing equations for acoustic wave propagation through a linearly transversely isotropic viscoelastic material, and transformed this into a weak form. This was then implemented into a finite element framework, enabling the analysis of wave input data and tissue structural fibre orientations, in this case based on diffusion tensor imaging. To validate the material constants obtained with this method, numerous in silico phantom experiments were run which encompassed a range of variations in wave input directions, material properties, fibre structure and noise. The method was also tested on ex vivo muscle and in vivo human volunteer calf muscles, and compared with a previous curl-based inversion method. The new method robustly extracted the transversely isotropic shear moduli (G_⊥^', G_∥^', G^″) from the in silico phantom tests with minimal bias, including in the presence of experimentally realistic levels of noise in either fibre orientation or wave data. This new method performed better than the previous method in the presence of noise. Anisotropy estimates from the ex vivo muscle phantom agreed well with rheological tests. In vivo experiments on human calf muscles were able to detect increases in muscle shear moduli with passive muscle stretch. This new reconstruction method can be applied to quantify tissue mechanical properties of anisotropic soft tissues, such as muscle, in health and disease.

Analytical solution based on spatial distortion for a time-harmonic Green's function in a transverse isotropic viscoelastic solid

A strategy of spatial distortion to make an anisotropic problem become isotropic has been previously validated in two-dimensional transverse isotropic (TI) viscoelastic cases. Here, the approach is extended to the three-dimensional problem by considering the time-harmonic point force response (Green's function) in a TI viscoelastic material. The resulting wave field, exactly solvable using a Radon transform with numerical integration, is approximated via spatial distortion of the closed form analytical solution to the isotropic case. Different distortions are used, depending on whether the polarization of the wave motion is orthogonal to the axis of isotropy, with the approximation yielding differing levels of accuracy.

Harnessing brain waves: a review of brain magnetic resonance elastography for clinicians and scientists entering the field

Brain magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is an imaging technique capable of accurately and non-invasively measuring the mechanical properties of the living human brain. Recent studies have shown that MRE has potential to provide clinically useful information in patients with intracranial tumors, demyelinating disease, neurodegenerative disease, elevated intracranial pressure, and altered functional states. The objectives of this review are: (1) to give a general overview of the types of measurements that have been obtained with brain MRE in patient populations, (2) to survey the tools currently being used to make these measurements possible, and (3) to highlight brain MRE-based quantitative biomarkers that have the highest potential of being adopted into clinical use within the next 5 to 10 years. The specifics of MRE methodology strategies are described, from wave generation to material parameter estimations. The potential clinical role of MRE for characterizing and planning surgical resection of intracranial tumors and assessing diffuse changes in brain stiffness resulting from diffuse neurological diseases and altered intracranial pressure are described. In addition, the emerging technique of functional MRE, the role of artificial intelligence in MRE, and promising applications of MRE in general neuroscience research are presented.

MR elastography: Principles, guidelines, and terminology

Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is a phase contrast-based MRI technique that can measure displacement due to propagating mechanical waves, from which material properties such as shear modulus can be calculated. Magnetic resonance elastography can be thought of as quantitative, noninvasive palpation. It is increasing in clinical importance, has become widespread in the diagnosis and staging of liver fibrosis, and additional clinical applications are being explored. However, publications have reported MRE results using many different parameters, acquisition techniques, processing methods, and varied nomenclature. The diversity of terminology can lead to confusion (particularly among clinicians) about the meaning of and interpretation of MRE results. This paper was written by the MRE Guidelines Committee, a group formalized at the first meeting of the ISMRM MRE Study Group, to clarify and move toward standardization of MRE nomenclature. The purpose of this paper is to (1) explain MRE terminology and concepts to those not familiar with them, (2) define "good practices" for practitioners of MRE, and (3) identify opportunities to standardize terminology, to avoid confusion.

Enhanced complex local frequency elastography method for tumor viscoelastic shear modulus reconstruction

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The Mayo Clinic provides a magnetic resonance (MR) elastography software named MRE Wave, which uses the conventional local frequency elastography (LFE) method. However, MRE Wave is unable to supply complex viscoelasticity maps for elastography. We sought to improve the local frequency estimation algorithm used in LFE, which we refer to as the Enhanced Complex Local Frequency Elastography (EC-LFE) algorithm.

METHODS

The proposed algorithm uses wave equations under the hypotheses of being linear, isotropic, and locally homogeneous. Two 2D simulation models were used to investigate the accuracy and sensitivity of the EC-LFE algorithm for detecting small tumors. The corresponding statistical parameters were the relative root mean square (RMS) error and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). EC-LFE was investigated with two different parameter sets, one with an optimally chosen parameter ξ (EC-LFE Adj, for short) and the other with ξ = 0 (EC-LFE0). We compared the MRE Wave and the EC-LFE using series signal-to-noise (SNR) wave data.

RESULTS

The elasticity RMS error of the MRE Wave software was about 1%, and that of the EC-LFE0 and EC-LFE Adj were about 0.2%. The elasticity standard deviation of the MRE Wave software was about 3% of the mean value, and those of the EC-LFE0 and EC-LFE Adj were about 1% of the mean value. The elasticity CNR value of EC-LFE0 reached 1.93 times that of the MRE Wave in the region of small tumors (less than 10-point sampling). The viscosity RMS errors of the EC-LFE0 could be less than 5%.

CONCLUSION

Compared to conventional methods, the EC-LFE was more accurate and sensitive for small tumor detection and exhibited higher noise immunity. The improved algorithm output more parameters and outperformed than the MRE Wave, thereby rendering them more suitable for clinical applications.

Requirements for accurate estimation of shear modulus by magnetic resonance elastography: A computational comparative study

BACKGROUND

Magnetic resonance (MR) elastography is a non-destructive method of measuring biological tissue and is conducive to the early detection of tumors. Researchers usually set different assumptions according to different research objects, then establish and solve wave equations to estimate the shear modulus. Establishing a more reasonable model for a measured object estimates a more accurate shear modulus. Different assumptions of the mathematical model, and the method used to solve the wave equation causes deviation of the estimation.

OBJECTIVE

This study focused on shear modulus deviations caused by differences in calculation methods. The author demonstrated a method to ensure that the measuring range of the selected reconstruction algorithm with selected drive frequency covers the elasticity range of the target tissue. It is hoped to arouse the interest of researchers to introduce new transform domain methods to the field of MR elastography.

METHOD

In linear, isotropic and local homogeneity assumptions, the typical representative of two different calculation methods are algebraic inversion of the differential equation (AIDE) algorithm and local frequency elastography (LFE) algorithm. To compare the accuracy of these calculation methods, the author adopted a digital phantom that can set the parameter values accurately. It is assumed that the phantom tissue was linear and isotropic, and that the driving wave was sinusoidal. The displacement distribution of waves in the tissue was calculated by the finite element simulation method in two different resolutions with the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) set to 40 dB and the threshold of relative mean error (RME) no more than 10%. The wavelength-to-pixel-size ratios of the two methods under the setting threshold of RME were compared.

RESULTS

The lower threshold of wavelength-to-pixel-size ratio for AIDE was close to 10, while that for LFE was nearly 2 (the limitation of Shannon's law) under the setting precision. Thus, the measuring range of the AIDE method was less than that of LFE at the same experimental conditions.

CONCLUSION

The driving frequency selection range of the spatial frequency domain method is wider than that of the spatial domain method. It is worthwhile for researchers to devote more time to introducing new transformation domain method for MR elastography.

Multi-Excitation Magnetic Resonance Elastography of the Brain: Wave Propagation in Anisotropic White Matter

Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) has emerged as a sensitive imaging technique capable of providing a quantitative understanding of neural microstructural integrity. However, a reliable method for the quantification of the anisotropic mechanical properties of human white matter is currently lacking, despite the potential to illuminate the pathophysiology behind neurological disorders and traumatic brain injury. In this study, we examine the use of multiple excitations in MRE to generate wave displacement data sufficient for anisotropic inversion in white matter. We show the presence of multiple unique waves from each excitation which we combine to solve for parameters of an incompressible, transversely isotropic (ITI) material: shear modulus, μ, shear anisotropy, ϕ, and tensile anisotropy, ζ. We calculate these anisotropic parameters in the corpus callosum body and find the mean values as μ = 3.78 kPa, ϕ = 0.151, and ζ = 0.099 (at 50 Hz vibration frequency). This study demonstrates that multi-excitation MRE provides displacement data sufficient for the evaluation of the anisotropic properties of white matter.

Statistical Characterization of Human Brain Deformation During Mild Angular Acceleration Measured In Vivo by Tagged Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Understanding of in vivo brain biomechanical behavior is critical in the study of traumatic brain injury (TBI) mechanisms and prevention. Using tagged magnetic resonance imaging, we measured spatiotemporal brain deformations in 34 healthy human volunteers under mild angular accelerations of the head. Two-dimensional (2D) Lagrangian strains were examined throughout the brain in each subject. Strain metrics peaked shortly after contact with a padded stop, corresponding to the inertial response of the brain after head deceleration. Maximum shear strain of at least 3% was experienced at peak deformation by an area fraction (median±standard error) of 23.5±1.8% of cortical gray matter, 15.9±1.4% of white matter, and 4.0±1.5% of deep gray matter. Cortical gray matter strains were greater in the temporal cortex on the side of the initial contact with the padded stop and also in the contralateral temporal, frontal, and parietal cortex. These tissue-level deformations from a population of healthy volunteers provide the first in vivo measurements of full-volume brain deformation in response to known kinematics. Although strains differed in different tissue type and cortical lobes, no significant differences between male and female head accelerations or strain metrics were found. These cumulative results highlight important kinematic features of the brain's mechanical response and can be used to facilitate the evaluation of computational simulations of TBI.

Analytical solution for converging elliptic shear wave in a bounded transverse isotropic viscoelastic material with nonhomogeneous outer boundary

Dynamic elastography methods-based on optical, ultrasonic, or magnetic resonance imaging-are being developed for quantitatively mapping the shear viscoelastic properties of biological tissues, which are often altered by disease and injury. These diagnostic imaging methods involve analysis of shear wave motion in order to estimate or reconstruct the tissue's shear viscoelastic properties. Most reconstruction methods to date have assumed isotropic tissue properties. However, application to tissues like skeletal muscle and brain white matter with aligned fibrous structure resulting in local transverse isotropic mechanical properties would benefit from analysis that takes into consideration anisotropy. A theoretical approach is developed for the elliptic shear wave pattern observed in transverse isotropic materials subjected to axisymmetric excitation creating radially converging shear waves normal to the fiber axis. This approach, utilizing Mathieu functions, is enabled via a transformation to an elliptic coordinate system with isotropic properties and a ratio of minor and major axes matching the ratio of shear wavelengths perpendicular and parallel to the plane of isotropy in the transverse isotropic material. The approach is validated via numerical finite element analysis case studies. This strategy of coordinate transformation to equivalent isotropic systems could aid in analysis of other anisotropic tissue structures.

Relative identifiability of anisotropic properties from magnetic resonance elastography

Although magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) has been used to estimate isotropic stiffness in the heart, myocardium is known to have anisotropic properties. This study investigated the determinability of global transversely isotropic material parameters using MRE and finite-element modeling (FEM). A FEM-based material parameter identification method, using a displacement-matching objective function, was evaluated in a gel phantom and simulations of a left ventricular (LV) geometry with a histology-derived fiber field. Material parameter estimation was performed in the presence of Gaussian noise. Parameter sweeps were analyzed and characteristics of the Hessian matrix at the optimal solution were used to evaluate the determinability of each constitutive parameter. Four out of five material stiffness parameters (Young's modulii E1 and E3 , shear modulus G13 and damping coefficient s), which describe a transversely isotropic linear elastic material, were well determined from the MRE displacement field using an iterative FEM inversion method. However, the remaining parameter, Poisson's ratio, was less identifiable. In conclusion, Young's modulii, shear modulii and damping can theoretically be well determined from MRE data, but Poisson's ratio is not as well determined and could be set to a reasonable value for biological tissue (close to 0.5).

Stiffness and Beyond: What MR Elastography Can Tell Us About Brain Structure and Function Under Physiologic and Pathologic Conditions

Brain magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) was developed on the basis of a desire to "palpate by imaging" and is becoming a powerful tool in the investigation of neurophysiological and neuropathological states. Measurements are acquired with a specialized MR phase-contrast pulse sequence that can detect tissue motion in response to an applied external or internal excitation. The tissue viscoelasticity is then reconstructed from the measured displacement. Quantitative characterization of brain viscoelastic behaviors provides us an insight into the brain structure and function by assessing the mechanical rigidity, viscosity, friction, and connectivity of brain tissues. Changes in these features are associated with inflammation, demyelination, and neurodegeneration that contribute to brain disease onset and progression. Here, we review the basic principles and limitations of brain MRE and summarize its current neuroanatomical studies and clinical applications to the most common neurosurgical and neurodegenerative disorders, including intracranial tumors, dementia, multiple sclerosis, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and traumatic brain injury. Going forward, further improvement in acquisition techniques, stable inverse reconstruction algorithms, and advanced numerical, physical, and preclinical validation models is needed to increase the utility of brain MRE in both research and clinical applications.

Stiffness reconstruction methods for MR elastography

Assessment of tissue stiffness is desirable for clinicians and researchers, as it is well established that pathophysiological mechanisms often alter the structural properties of tissue. Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) provides an avenue for measuring tissue stiffness and has a long history of clinical application, including staging liver fibrosis and stratifying breast cancer malignancy. A vital component of MRE consists of the reconstruction algorithms used to derive stiffness from wave-motion images by solving inverse problems. A large range of reconstruction methods have been presented in the literature, with differing computational expense, required user input, underlying physical assumptions, and techniques for numerical evaluation. These differences, in turn, have led to varying accuracy, robustness, and ease of use. While most reconstruction techniques have been validated against in silico or in vitro phantoms, performance with real data is often more challenging, stressing the robustness and assumptions of these algorithms. This article reviews many current MRE reconstruction methods and discusses the aforementioned differences. The material assumptions underlying the methods are developed and various approaches for noise reduction, regularization, and numerical discretization are discussed. Reconstruction methods are categorized by inversion type, underlying assumptions, and their use in human and animal studies. Future directions, such as alternative material assumptions, are also discussed.

Anisotropic composite material phantom to improve skeletal muscle characterization using magnetic resonance elastography

The presence and progression of neuromuscular pathology, including spasticity, Duchenne's muscular dystrophy and hyperthyroidism, has been correlated with changes in the intrinsic mechanical properties of skeletal muscle tissue. Tools for noninvasively measuring and monitoring these properties, such as Magnetic Resonance Elastography (MRE), could benefit basic research into understanding neuromuscular pathologies, as well as translational research to develop therapies, by providing a means of assessing and tracking their efficacy. Dynamic elastography methods for noninvasive measurement of tissue mechanical properties have been under development for nearly three decades. Much of the technological development to date, for both Ultrasound (US)-based and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)-based strategies, has been grounded in assumptions of local homogeneity and isotropy. Striated skeletal and cardiac muscle, as well as brain white matter and soft tissue in some other organ regions, exhibit a fibrous microstructure which entails heterogeneity and anisotropic response; as one seeks to improve the accuracy and resolution in mechanical property assessment, heterogeneity and anisotropy need to be accounted for in order to optimize both the dynamic elastography experimental protocol and the interpretation of the measurements. Advances in elastography methodology at every step have been aided by the use of tissue-mimicking phantoms. The aim of the present study was to develop and characterize a heterogeneous composite phantom design with uniform controllable anisotropic properties meant to be comparable to the frequency-dependent anisotropic properties of skeletal muscle. MRE experiments and computational finite element (FE) studies were conducted on a novel 3D-printed composite phantom design. The displacement maps obtained from simulation and experiment show the same elliptical shaped wavefronts elongated in the plane where the structure presents higher shear modulus. The model exhibits a degree of anisotropy in line with literature data from skeletal muscle tissue MRE experiments. FE simulations of the MRE experiments provide insight into proper interpretation of experimental measurements, and help to quantify the importance of heterogeneity in the anisotropic material at different scales.

Estimation of transversely isotropic material properties from magnetic resonance elastography using the optimised virtual fields method

Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) has been used to estimate isotropic myocardial stiffness. However, anisotropic stiffness estimates may give insight into structural changes that occur in the myocardium as a result of pathologies such as diastolic heart failure. The virtual fields method (VFM) has been proposed for estimating material stiffness from image data. This study applied the optimised VFM to identify transversely isotropic material properties from both simulated harmonic displacements in a left ventricular (LV) model with a fibre field measured from histology as well as isotropic phantom MRE data. Two material model formulations were implemented, estimating either 3 or 5 material properties. The 3-parameter formulation writes the transversely isotropic constitutive relation in a way that dissociates the bulk modulus from other parameters. Accurate identification of transversely isotropic material properties in the LV model was shown to be dependent on the loading condition applied, amount of Gaussian noise in the signal, and frequency of excitation. Parameter sensitivity values showed that shear moduli are less sensitive to noise than the other parameters. This preliminary investigation showed the feasibility and limitations of using the VFM to identify transversely isotropic material properties from MRE images of a phantom as well as simulated harmonic displacements in an LV geometry.

Pre-clinical MR elastography: Principles, techniques, and applications

Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is a method for measuring the mechanical properties of soft tissue in vivo, non-invasively, by imaging propagating shear waves in the tissue. The speed and attenuation of waves depends on the elastic and dissipative properties of the underlying material. Tissue mechanical properties are essential for biomechanical models and simulations, and may serve as markers of disease, injury, development, or recovery. MRE is already established as a clinical technique for detecting and characterizing liver disease. The potential of MRE for diagnosing or characterizing disease in other organs, including brain, breast, and heart is an active research area. Studies involving MRE in the pre-clinical setting, in phantoms and artificial biomaterials, in the mouse, and in other mammals, are critical to the development of MRE as a robust, reliable, and useful modality.

Measurement of anisotropic mechanical properties in porcine brain white matter ex vivo using magnetic resonance elastography

The mechanical properties of brain tissue, particularly those of white matter (WM), need to be characterized accurately for use in finite element (FE) models of brain biomechanics and traumatic brain injury (TBI). Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is a powerful tool for non-invasive estimation of the mechanical properties of soft tissues. While several studies involving direct mechanical tests of brain tissue have shown mechanical anisotropy, most MRE studies of brain tissue assume an isotropic model. In this study, an incompressible transversely isotropic (TI) material model parameterized by minimum shear modulus (μ₂), shear anisotropy parameter (ϕ), and tensile anisotropy parameter (ζ) is applied to analyze MRE measurements of ex vivo porcine white matter (WM) brain tissue. To characterize shear anisotropy, "slow" (pure transverse) shear waves were propagated at 100, 200 and 300Hz through sections of ex vivo brain tissue including both WM and gray matter (GM). Shear waves were found to propagate with elliptical fronts, consistent with TI material behavior. Shear wave fields were also analyzed within regions of interest (ROI) to find local shear wavelengths parallel and perpendicular to fiber orientation. FE simulations of a TI material with a range of plausible shear modulus (μ₂) and shear anisotropy parameters (ϕ) were run and the results were analyzed in the same fashion as the experimental case. Parameters of the FE simulations which most closely matched each experiment were taken to represent the mechanical properties of that particular sample. Using this approach, WM in the ex vivo porcine brain was found to be mildly anisotropic in shear with estimates of minimum shear modulus (actuation frequencies listed in parenthesis): μ₂= 1.04 ± 0.12 kPa (at 100Hz), μ₂= 1.94 ± 0.29 kPa (at 200Hz), and μ₂= 2.88 ± 0.34 kPa (at 300Hz) and corresponding shear anisotropy factors of ϕ= 0.27 ± 0.09 (at 100Hz), ϕ= 0.29 ± 0.14 (at 200Hz) and ϕ= 0.34 ± 0.13 (at 300Hz). Future MRE studies will focus on tensile anisotropy, which will require both slow and fast shear waves for accurate estimation.

MR elastography of the brain and its application in neurological diseases

Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is an imaging technique for noninvasively and quantitatively assessing tissue stiffness, akin to palpation. MRE is further able assess the mechanical properties of tissues that cannot be reached by hand including the brain. The technique is a three-step process beginning with the introduction of shear waves into the tissue of interest by applying an external vibration. Next, the resulting motion is imaged using a phase-contrast MR pulse sequence with motion encoding gradients that are synchronized to the vibration. Finally, the measured displacement images are mathematically inverted to compute a map of the estimated stiffness. In the brain, the technique has demonstrated strong test-retest repeatability with typical errors of 1% for measuring global stiffness, 2% for measuring stiffness in the lobes of the brain, and 3-7% for measuring stiffness in subcortical gray matter. In healthy volunteers, multiple studies have confirmed that stiffness decreases with age, while more recent studies have demonstrated a strong relationship between viscoelasticity and behavioral performance. Furthermore, several studies have demonstrated the sensitivity of brain stiffness to neurodegeneration, as stiffness has been shown to decrease in multiple sclerosis and in several forms of dementia. Moreover, the spatial pattern of stiffness changes varies among these different classes of dementia. Finally, MRE is a promising tool for the preoperative assessment of intracranial tumors, as it can measure both tumor consistency and adherence to surrounding tissues. These factors are important predictors of surgical difficulty. In brief, MRE demonstrates potential value in a number of neurological diseases. However, significant opportunity remains to further refine the technique and better understand the underlying physiology.