The anatomical basis of upper limb dystonia: lesson from secondary cases

Dystonia: pathophysiology and the role of acupuncture in treatment

Dystonia is a complex neurological disorder characterized by involuntary muscle contractions, abnormal postures, and repetitive movements, which can lead to significant functional impairment and reduced quality of life. The disorder's pathophysiology involves a range of factors including genetic mutations, neurochemical imbalances, and structural abnormalities in the brain. Acupuncture has emerged as a promising complementary treatment for various types of dystonia, including post-stroke, cerebral palsy (CP)-related, limb, and cervical dystonia, as well as other hyperkinetic movement disorders. Clinical studies indicate that acupuncture may help to alleviate symptoms, decrease muscle spasticity, and improve overall patient outcomes. However, the effectiveness of acupuncture can vary depending on the specific type and severity of dystonia, with some studies reporting significant improvements, while others show more modest results. The variability in treatment response highlights the need for more robust research to better understand the mechanisms underlying acupuncture's effects and to develop standardized treatment protocols. The aim of this review is to provide a comprehensive overview of dystonia's pathophysiology and to assess the current evidence on the role of acupuncture in its treatment, identifying areas in which further research is needed to optimize therapeutic approaches.

Peripheral nerve injury induces dystonia-like movements and dysregulation in the energy metabolism: A multi-omics descriptive study in Thap1+/- mice

DYT-THAP1 dystonia is a monogenetic form of dystonia, a movement disorder characterized by the involuntary co-contraction of agonistic and antagonistic muscles. The disease is caused by mutations in the THAP1 gene, although the precise mechanisms by which these mutations contribute to the pathophysiology of dystonia remain unclear. The incomplete penetrance of DYT-THAP1 dystonia, estimated at 40 to 60 %, suggests that an environmental trigger may be required for the manifestation of the disease in genetically predisposed individuals. To investigate the gene-environment interaction in the development of dystonic features, we performed a sciatic nerve crush injury in a genetically predisposed DYT-THAP1 heterozygous knockout mouse model (Thap1+/-). We employed a multi-omic assessment to study the pathophysiological pathways underlying the disease. Phenotypic analysis using an unbiased deep learning algorithm revealed that nerve-injured Thap1+/- mice exhibited significantly more dystonia like movements (DLM) over the course of the 12-week experiment compared to naive Thap1+/- mice. In contrast, nerve-injured wildtype (wt) mice only showed a significant increase in DLM compared to their naive counterpart during the first weeks after injury. Furthermore, at week 11 after nerve crush, nerve-injured Thap1+/- mice displayed significantly more DLM than nerve-injured wt counterparts. Multi-omic analysis of the cerebellum, striatum and cortex in nerve-injured Thap1+/- mice revealed differences that are indicative of an altered energy metabolism compared to naive Thap1+/- and nerve-injured wt animals. These findings suggest that aberrant energy metabolism in brain regions relevant to dystonia may underlie the dystonic phenotype observed in nerve injured Thap1+/- mice.

Engaging dystonia networks with subthalamic stimulation

Deep brain stimulation is an efficacious treatment for dystonia. While the internal pallidum serves as the primary target, recently, stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) has been investigated. However, optimal targeting within this structure and its surroundings have not been studied in depth. Indeed, historical targets that have been used for surgical treatment of dystonia are directly adjacent to the STN. Further, multiple types of dystonia exist, and outcomes are variable, suggesting that not all types would profit maximally from the same target. Therefore, a thorough investigation of neural substrates underlying stimulation effects on dystonia signs and symptoms is warranted. Here, we analyze a multicenter cohort of isolated dystonia patients with subthalamic implantations (N = 58) and relate their stimulation sites to improvements of appendicular and cervical symptoms as well as blepharospasm. Stimulation of the ventral oral posterior nucleus of thalamus and surrounding regions were associated with improvements in cervical dystonia, while stimulation of the dorsolateral STN was associated with improvements in limb dystonia and blepharospasm. This dissociation was matched by structural connectivity analysis, where the cerebellothalamic, corticospinal, and pallidosubthalamic tracts were associated with improvements of cervical dystonia, while hyperdirect and subthalamopallidal pathways with alleviation of limb dystonia and blepharospasm. On the level of functional networks, improvements of limb dystonia were associated with connectivity to the corresponding somatotopic regions in the primary motor cortex, while alleviation of cervical dystonia to the cingulo-opercular network. These findings shed light on the pathophysiology of dystonia and may guide DBS targeting and programming in the future.

Oromandibular dystonia: from onset to spread a multicenter italian study

BACKGROUND

Detailed information about the epidemiological and phenomenological differences among the aetiological subtypes of oromandibular dystonia (OMD) is lacking. Moreover, the OMD tendency to spread to other body sites has never been investigated.

AIM

To compare the main demographic and clinical features of OMD in different aetiological groups and assess the risk of spread.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analysed data from patients contained in the Italian Dystonia Registry. The risk of spread was assessed by Kaplan Meyer curves and Cox regression analysis.

RESULTS

The study included 273 patients (175 women) aged 55.7 years (SD 12.7) at OMD onset. Female predominance was observed. Idiopathic dystonia was diagnosed in 241 patients, acquired dystonia in 22. In 50/273 patients, dystonia started in the oromandibular region (focal OMD onset); in 96/273 patients the onset involved the oromandibular region and a neighbouring body site (segmental/multifocal OMD onset); and in 127/273 patients OMD was a site of spread from another body region. Sensory trick (ST) and positive family history predominated in the idiopathic group. No dystonia spread was detected in the acquired group, whereas spread mostly occurred within the first five years of history in 34% of the focal OMD onset idiopathic patients. Cox regression analysis revealed ST as a significant predictor of spread (HR, 12.1; 95% CI, 2.5 - 18.8; P = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

This large study provides novel information about the clinical phenomenology of idiopathic and acquired OMD. We pointed out a possible role of oestrogens in favouring dystonia development. Moreover, we described for the first time the association between ST and dystonia spread, revealing possible common pathophysiological mechanisms. Our findings may be suggested as a referral point for future pathophysiological and therapeutic studies on OMD.

Progression to corticobasal syndrome: a longitudinal study of patients with nonfluent primary progressive aphasia and primary progressive apraxia of speech

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Nonfluent variant primary progressive aphasia (nfvPPA) and primary progressive apraxia of speech (PPAOS) can be precursors to corticobasal syndrome (CBS). Details on their progression remain unclear. We aimed to examine the clinical and neuroimaging evolution of nfvPPA and PPAOS into CBS.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective longitudinal study in 140 nfvPPA or PPAOS patients and applied the consensus criteria for possible and probable CBS for every visit, evaluating limb rigidity, akinesia, limb dystonia, myoclonus, ideomotor apraxia, alien limb phenomenon, and nonverbal oral apraxia (NVOA). Given the association of NVOA with AOS, we also modified the CBS criteria by excluding NVOA and assigned every patient to either a progressors or non-progressors group. We evaluated the frequency of every CBS feature by year from disease onset, and assessed gray and white matter volume loss using SPM12.

RESULTS

Asymmetric akinesia, NVOA, and limb apraxia were the most common CBS features that developed; while limb dystonia, myoclonus, and alien limb were rare. Eighty-two patients progressed to possible CBS; only four to probable CBS. nfvPPA and PPAOS had a similar proportion of progressors, although nfvPPA progressed to CBS earlier (p-value = 0.046), driven by an early appearance of limb apraxia (p-value = 0.0041). The non-progressors and progressors both showed premotor/motor cortex involvement at baseline, with spread into prefrontal cortex over time.

DISCUSSION

An important proportion of patients with nfvPPA and PPAOS progress to possible CBS, while they rarely develop features of probable CBS even after long follow-up.

The functional anatomy of dystonia: Recent developments

While dystonia has traditionally been viewed as a disorder of the basal ganglia, the involvement of other key brain structures is now accepted. However, just what these structures are remains to be defined. Neuroimaging has been an especially valuable tool in dystonia, yet traditional cross-sectional designs have not been able to separate causal from compensatory brain activity. Therefore, this chapter discusses recent studies using causal brain lesions, and animal models, to converge upon the brain regions responsible for dystonia with increasing precision. This evidence strongly implicates the basal ganglia, thalamus, brainstem, cerebellum, and somatosensory cortex, yet shows that different types of dystonia involve different nodes of this brain network. Nearly all of these nodes fall within the recently identified two-way networks connecting the basal ganglia and cerebellum, suggesting dysfunction of these specific pathways. Localisation of the functional anatomy of dystonia has strong implications for targeted treatment options, such as deep brain stimulation, and non-invasive brain stimulation.

Clinical and Structural Findings in Patients With Lesion-Induced Dystonia: Descriptive and Quantitative Analysis of Published Cases

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Brain lesions are a well-recognized etiology of dystonia. These cases are especially valuable because they offer causal insight into the neuroanatomical substrates of dystonia. To date, knowledge of lesion-induced dystonia comes mainly from isolated case reports or small case series, restricting broader description and analysis.

METHODS

Cases of lesion-induced dystonia were first identified from a systematic review of published literature. Latent class analysis then investigated whether patients could be classified into subgroups based on lesion location and body regions affected by dystonia. Regression analyses subsequently investigated whether subgroup membership predicted clinical characteristics of dystonia.

RESULTS

Three hundred fifty-nine published cases were included. Lesions causing dystonia occurred in heterogeneous locations, most commonly in the basal ganglia (46.2%), followed by the thalamus (28.1%), brainstem (22.6%), and white matter (21.2%). The most common form of lesion-induced dystonia was focal dystonia (53.2%), with the hand (49.9%) and arm (44.3%) most commonly affected. Of all cases, 86.6% reported co-occurring neurologic manifestations and 26.1% reported other movement disorders. Latent class analysis identified 3 distinct subgroups of patients: those with predominantly limb dystonias, which were associated with basal ganglia lesions; those with hand dystonia, associated with thalamic lesions; and those with predominantly cervical dystonia, associated with brainstem and cerebellar lesions. Regression demonstrated significant differences between these subgroups on a range of dystonia symptoms, including dystonic tremor, symptom latency, other movement disorders, and dystonia variability.

DISCUSSION

Although dystonia can be induced by lesions to numerous brain regions, there are distinct relationships between lesion locations and dystonic body parts. This suggests that the affected brain networks are different between types of dystonia.

Pathophysiological mechanisms of oromandibular dystonia

Oromandibular dystonia (OMD) is a rare form of focal idiopathic dystonia. OMD was clinically identified at the beginning of the 20th century, and the main clinical features have been progressively described over the years. However, OMD has several peculiarities that still remain unexplained, including the high rate of oral trauma, which is often related to the onset of motor symptoms. The purpose of this paper was to formulate a hypothesis regarding the pathophysiology of OMD, starting from the neuroanatomical basis of the masticatory and facial systems and highlighting the features that differentiate this condition from other forms of focal idiopathic dystonia. We provide a brief review of the clinical and etiological features of OMD as well as neurophysiological and neuroimaging findings obtained from studies in patients with OMD. We discuss possible pathophysiological mechanisms underlying OMD and suggest that abnormalities in sensory input processing may play a prominent role in OMD pathophysiology, possibly triggering a cascade of events that results in sensorimotor cortex network dysfunction. Finally, we identify open questions that future studies should address, including the effect of abnormal sensory input processing and oral trauma on the peculiar neurophysiological abnormalities observed in OMD.

Neuropathology of blepharospasm

BACKGROUND

The dystonias are a group of disorders characterized by excessive muscle contractions leading to abnormal repetitive movements or postures. In blepharospasm, the face is affected, leading to excessive eye blinking and spasms of muscles around the eyes. The pathogenesis of blepharospasm is not well understood, but several imaging studies have implied subtle structural defects in several brain regions, including the cerebellum.

OBJECTIVE

To delineate cerebellar pathology in brains collected at autopsy from 7 human subjects with blepharospasm and 9 matched controls.

METHODS

Sections from 3 cerebellar regions were sampled and processed using Nissl and silver impregnation stains. Purkinje neurons were the focus of the evaluation, along with as several other subtle pathological features of cerebellar dysfunction such as Purkinje neuron axonal swellings (torpedo bodies), proliferation of basket cell processes around Purkinje neurons (hairy baskets), empty baskets (missing Purkinje neurons), and displacement of cell soma from their usual location (ectopic Purkinje neurons).

RESULTS

The results revealed a significant reduction in Purkinje neuron and torpedo body density, but no changes in any of the other measures.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings demonstrate subtle neuropathological changes similar to those reported for subjects with cervical dystonia. These findings may underly some of the subtle imaging changes reported for blepharospasm.

Advances in the pathophysiology of adult-onset focal dystonias: recent neurophysiological and neuroimaging evidence

Focal dystonia is a movement disorder characterized by involuntary muscle contractions that determine abnormal postures. The traditional hypothesis that the pathophysiology of focal dystonia entails a single structural dysfunction (i.e. basal ganglia) has recently come under scrutiny. The proposed network disorder model implies that focal dystonias arise from aberrant communication between various brain areas. Based on findings from animal studies, the role of the cerebellum has attracted increased interest in the last few years. Moreover, it has been increasingly reported that focal dystonias also include nonmotor disturbances, including sensory processing abnormalities, which have begun to attract attention. Current evidence from neurophysiological and neuroimaging investigations suggests that cerebellar involvement in the network and mechanisms underlying sensory abnormalities may have a role in determining the clinical heterogeneity of focal dystonias.

Sustained involuntary muscle activity in cerebral palsy and stroke: same symptom, diverse mechanisms

Individuals with lesions of central motor pathways frequently suffer from sustained involuntary muscle activity. This symptom shares clinical characteristics with dystonia but is observable in individuals classified as spastic. The term spastic dystonia has been introduced, although the underlying mechanisms of involuntary activity are not clarified and vary between individuals depending on the disorder. This study aimed to investigate the nature and pathophysiology of sustained involuntary muscle activity in adults with cerebral palsy and stroke. Seventeen adults with cerebral palsy (Gross Motor Function Classification System I–V), 8 adults with chronic stroke and 14 control individuals participated in the study. All individuals with cerebral palsy or stroke showed increased resistance to passive movement with Modified Ashworth Scale >1. Two-minute surface EMG recordings were obtained from the biceps muscle during attempted rest in three positions of the elbow joint; a maximally flexed position, a 90-degree position and a maximally extended position. Cross-correlation analysis of sustained involuntary muscle activity from individuals with cerebral palsy and stroke, and recordings of voluntary isometric contractions from control individuals were performed to examine common synaptic drive. In total, 13 out of 17 individuals with cerebral palsy and all 8 individuals with stroke contained sustained involuntary muscle activity. In individuals with cerebral palsy, the level of muscle activity was not affected by the joint position. In individuals with stroke, the level of muscle activity significantly (P < 0.05) increased from the flexed position to the 90 degree and extended position. Cumulant density function indicated significant short-term synchronization of motor unit activities in all recordings. All groups exhibited significant coherence in the alpha (6–15 Hz), beta (16–35 Hz) and early gamma band (36–60 Hz). The cerebral palsy group had lower alpha band coherence estimates, but higher gamma band coherence estimates compared with the stroke group. Individuals with increased resistance to passive movement due to cerebral palsy or stroke frequently suffer sustained involuntary muscle activity, which cannot exclusively be described by spasticity. The sustained involuntary muscle activity in both groups originated from a common synaptic input to the motor neuron pool, but the generating mechanisms could differ between groups. In cerebral palsy it seemed to originate more from central mechanisms, whereas peripheral mechanisms likely play a larger role in stroke. The sustained involuntary muscle activity should not be treated simply like the spinal stretch reflex mediated symptom of spasticity and should not either be treated identically in both groups.

The Use of Botulinum Toxin for Treatment of the Dystonias

Dystonias are characterized by involuntary muscle contractions, twisting movements, abnormal postures, and often tremor in various body regions. However, in the last decade several studies have demonstrated that dystonias are also characterized by sensory abnormalities. While botulinum toxin is the gold standard therapy for focal dystonia, exactly how it improves this disorder is not entirely understood. Neurophysiological studies in animals and humans have clearly demonstrated that botulinum toxin improves dystonic motor manifestations by inducing chemodenervation, therefore weakening the injected muscles. In addition, neurophysiological and neuroimaging evidence also suggests that botulinum toxin modulates the activity of various neural structures in the CNS distant from the injected site, particularly cortical motor and sensory areas. Concordantly, recent studies have shown that in patients with focal dystonias botulinum toxin ameliorates sensory disturbances, including reduced spatial discrimination acuity and pain. Overall, these observations suggest that in these patients botulinum toxin-induced effects encompass complex mechanisms beyond chemodenervation of the injected muscles.

Possible Post-Traumatic Focal Dystonia Associated with Tau Pathology Localized to Putamen-Globus Pallidus

Background

Dystonia is often associated with damage to basal ganglia (BG), but neuropathological assessments of these cases are infrequent.

Methods

A brain was assessed with possible post-traumatic focal dystonia that appeared after an accident occurred during childhood.

Results

Tau pathology was found within putamen and globus pallidus of the right hemisphere, and chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) was observed in the cortex of the left hemisphere. No diffuse axonal injury (DAI), β-amyloid, ubiquitin, p62, or pTDP43 pathology was found.

Conclusions

Post-traumatic dystonia could be associated with post-traumatic tau pathology formation. However, more cases are necessary to establish causality. The tau lesions found in the BG of this patient did not fit within CTE criteria. We hypothesize that due to the anatomo-histological characteristics of the BG, tau pathology associated with brain traumas produce histopathological patterns different from sulcal-tau pathology, which is the only tau pathology distribution currently accepted as pathognomonic of CTE.

The cerebellum and dystonia

Dystonia is a heterogeneous disorder characterized by involuntary muscle contractions, twisting movements, and abnormal postures in various body regions. It is widely accepted that the basal ganglia are involved in the pathogenesis of dystonia. A growing body of evidence, however, is challenging the traditional view and suggest that the cerebellum may also play a role in dystonia. Studies on animals indicate that experimental manipulations of the cerebellum lead to dystonic-like movements. Several clinical observations, including those from secondary dystonia cases as well as neurophysiologic and neuroimaging studies in human patients, provide further evidence in humans of a possible relationship between cerebellar abnormalities and dystonia. Claryfing the role of the cerebellum in dystonia is an important step towards providing alternative treatments based on noninvasive brain stimulation techniques.

Evolving concepts in the pathogenesis of dystonia

INTRODUCTION

The dystonias are a group of disorders defined by over-contraction of muscles leading to abnormal movements and postures. In recent years, enormous advances have been made in elucidating the neurobiological mechanisms responsible for many types of dystonia.

METHODS

A literature review was conducted focusing on evolving concepts in dystonia genetics, anatomy and physiology.

RESULTS

The list of genes related to dystonia has grown from a relatively small number to more than 100. Concepts regarding the neuroanatomical basis for dystonia have evolved from a relatively narrow focus on dysfunction of the basal ganglia to a broader motor network model in which the basal ganglia, cerebellum, cerebral cortex, and other brain regions play a key role. Physiologically, our understanding of the core abnormalities has matured; and numerous changes in neural signaling have been revealed in the basal ganglia, cerebellum and cortex.

CONCLUSION

Although the dystonias share certain clinical aspects such as over-contraction of muscles leading to abnormal movements and postures, they actually comprise a very clinically and etiologically heterogeneous group of disorders. Understanding their neurobiological basis is important for devising rational therapies appropriately targeted for specific subgroups of patients.

The Anatomical Basis for Dystonia: The Motor Network Model

Background

The dystonias include a clinically and etiologically very diverse group of disorders. There are both degenerative and non-degenerative subtypes resulting from genetic or acquired causes. Traditionally, all dystonias have been viewed as disorders of the basal ganglia. However, there has been increasing appreciation for involvement of other brain regions including the cerebellum, thalamus, midbrain, and cortex. Much of the early evidence for these other brain regions has come from studies of animals, but multiple recent studies have been done with humans, in an effort to confirm or refute involvement of these other regions. The purpose of this article is to review the new evidence from animals and humans regarding the motor network model, and to address the issues important to translational neuroscience.

Methods

The English literature was reviewed for articles relating to the neuroanatomical basis for various types of dystonia in both animals and humans.

Results

There is evidence from both animals and humans that multiple brain regions play an important role in various types of dystonia. The most direct evidence for specific brain regions comes from animal studies using pharmacological, lesion, or genetic methods. In these studies, experimental manipulations of specific brain regions provide direct evidence for involvement of the basal ganglia, cerebellum, thalamus and other regions. Additional evidence also comes from human studies using neuropathological, neuroimaging, non-invasive brain stimulation, and surgical interventions. In these studies, the evidence is less conclusive, because discriminating the regions that cause dystonia from those that reflect secondary responses to abnormal movements is more challenging.

Discussion

Overall, the evidence from both animals and humans suggests that different regions may play important roles in different subtypes of dystonia. The evidence so far provides strong support for the motor network model. There are obvious challenges, but also advantages, of attempting to translate knowledge gained from animals into a more complete understanding of human dystonia and novel therapeutic strategies.

Cerebellum: An explanation for dystonia?

Dystonia is a movement disorder that is characterized by involuntary muscle contractions, abnormal movements and postures, as well as by non-motor symptoms, and is due to abnormalities in different brain areas. In this article, we focus on the growing number of experimental studies aimed at explaining the pathophysiological role of the cerebellum in dystonia. Lastly, we highlight gaps in current knowledge and issues that future research studies should focus on as well as some of the potential applications of this research avenue. Clarifying the pathophysiological role of cerebellum in dystonia is an important concern given the increasing availability of invasive and non-invasive stimulation techniques and their potential therapeutic role in this condition.