Dissection of an enzyme by protein engineering. The N and C-terminal fragments of barnase form a native-like complex with restored enzymic activity

Folding of the nascent polypeptide chain of a histidine phosphocarrier protein in vitro

The phosphotransferase system (PTS), a metabolic pathway formed by five proteins, modulates the use of sugars in bacteria. The second protein in the chain is the histidine phosphocarrier, HPr, with the binding site at His15. The HPr kinase/phosphorylase (HPrK/P), involved in the bacterial use of carbon sources, phosphorylates HPr at Ser46, and it binds at its binding site. The regulator of sigma D protein (Rsd) also binds to HPr at His15. We have designed fragments of HPr, growing from its N-terminus and containing the His15. In this work, we obtained three fragments, HPr38, HPr58 and HPr70, comprising the first thirty-eight, fifty-eight and seventy residues of HPr, respectively. All fragments were mainly disordered, with evidence of a weak native-like, helical population around the binding site, as shown by fluorescence, far-ultraviolet circular dichroism, size exclusion chromatography and nuclear magnetic resonance. Although HPr38, HPr58 and HPr70 were disordered, they could bind to: (i) the N-terminal domain of first protein of the PTS, EIN; (ii) Rsd; and, (iii) HPrK/P, as shown by fluorescence and biolayer interferometry (BLI). The association constants for each protein to any of the fragments were in the low micromolar range, within the same range than those measured in the binding of HPr to each protein. Then, although acquisition of stable, native-like secondary and tertiary structures occurred at the last residues of the polypeptide, the ability to bind protein partners happened much earlier in the growing chain. Binding was related to the presence of the native-like structure around His15.

Biophysical analysis of the MHR motif in folding and domain swapping of the HIV capsid protein C-terminal domain

Infection by human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) depends on the function, in virion morphogenesis and other stages of the viral cycle, of a highly conserved structural element, the major homology region (MHR), within the carboxyterminal domain (CTD) of the capsid protein. In a modified CTD dimer, MHR is swapped between monomers. While no evidence for MHR swapping has been provided by structural models of retroviral capsids, it is unknown whether it may occur transiently along the virus assembly pathway. Whatever the case, the MHR-swapped dimer does provide a novel target for the development of anti-HIV drugs based on the concept of trapping a nonnative capsid protein conformation. We have carried out a thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of the domain-swapped CTD dimer in solution. The analysis includes a dissection of the role of conserved MHR residues and other amino acids at the dimerization interface in CTD folding, stability, and dimerization by domain swapping. The results revealed some energetic hotspots at the domain-swapped interface. In addition, many MHR residues that are not in the protein hydrophobic core were nevertheless found to be critical for folding and stability of the CTD monomer, which may dramatically slow down the swapping reaction. Conservation of MHR residues in retroviruses did not correlate with their contribution to domain swapping, but it did correlate with their importance for stable CTD folding. Because folding is required for capsid protein function, this remarkable MHR-mediated conformational stabilization of CTD may help to explain the functional roles of MHR not only during immature capsid assembly but in other processes associated with retrovirus infection. This energetic dissection of the dimerization interface in MHR-swapped CTD may also facilitate the design of anti-HIV compounds that inhibit capsid assembly by conformational trapping of swapped CTD dimers.

Dynamics and mechanisms of coupled protein folding and binding reactions

Protein folding coupled to binding of a specific ligand is frequently observed in biological processes. In recent years numerous studies have addressed the structural properties of the unfolded proteins in the absence of their ligands. Surprisingly few time-resolved investigations on coupled folding and binding reactions have been published up to date and the dynamics and kinetic mechanisms of these processes are still only poorly understood. Especially, it is still unsolved for most systems which conformation of the protein is recognized by the ligand (conformational selection vs. folding-after-binding) and whether the ligand influences the folding kinetics. Here we review experimental methods, kinetic models and time-resolved experimental studies of coupled folding and binding reactions.

Toward a general approach for RNA-templated hierarchical assembly of split-proteins

The ability to conditionally turn on a signal or induce a function in the presence of a user-defined RNA target has potential applications in medicine and synthetic biology. Although sequence-specific pumilio repeat proteins can target a limited set of ssRNA sequences, there are no general methods for targeting ssRNA with designed proteins. As a first step toward RNA recognition, we utilized the RNA binding domain of argonaute, implicated in RNA interference, for specifically targeting generic 2-nucleotide, 3' overhangs of any dsRNA. We tested the reassembly of a split-luciferase enzyme guided by argonaute-mediated recognition of newly generated nucleotide overhangs when ssRNA is targeted by a designed complementary guide sequence. This approach was successful when argonaute was utilized in conjunction with a pumilio repeat and expanded the scope of potential ssRNA targets. However, targeting any desired ssRNA remained elusive as two argonaute domains provided minimal reassembled split-luciferase. We next designed and tested a second hierarchical assembly, wherein ssDNA guides are appended to DNA hairpins that serve as a scaffold for high affinity zinc fingers attached to split-luciferase. In the presence of a ssRNA target containing adjacent sequences complementary to the guides, the hairpins are brought into proximity, allowing for zinc finger binding and concomitant reassembly of the fragmented luciferase. The scope of this new approach was validated by specifically targeting RNA encoding VEGF, hDM2, and HER2. These approaches provide potentially general design paradigms for the conditional reassembly of fragmented proteins in the presence of any desired ssRNA target.

Structural and thermodynamic analysis of a conformationally strained circular permutant of barnase

Circular permutation of a protein covalently links its original termini and creates new ends at another location. To maintain the stability of the permuted structure, the termini are typically bridged by a peptide long enough to span the original distance between them. Here, we take the opposite approach and employ a very short linker to introduce conformational strain into a protein by forcing its termini together. We join the N- and C-termini of the small ribonuclease barnase (normally 27.2 A distant) with a single Cys residue and introduce new termini at a surface loop, to create pBn. Compared to a similar variant permuted with an 18-residue linker, permutation with a single amino acid dramatically destabilizes barnase. Surprisingly, pBn is folded at 10 degrees C and possesses near wild-type ribonuclease activity. The 2.25 A X-ray crystal structure of pBn reveals how the barnase fold is able to adapt to permutation, partially defuse conformational strain, and preserve enzymatic function. We demonstrate that strain in pBn can be relieved by cleaving the linker with a chemical reagent. Catalytic activity of both uncleaved (strained) pBn and cleaved (relaxed) pBn is proportional to their thermodynamic stabilities, i.e., the fraction of folded molecules. The stability and activity of cleaved pBn are dependent on protein concentration. At concentrations above approximately 2 microM, cleaving pBn is predicted to increase the fraction of folded molecules and thus enhance ribonuclease activity at 37 degrees C. This study suggests that introducing conformational strain by permutation, and releasing strain by cleavage, is a potential mechanism for engineering an artificial zymogen.

High-throughput analysis of the protein sequence-stability landscape using a quantitative yeast surface two-hybrid system and fragment reconstitution

Stability evaluation of many mutants can lead to a better understanding of the sequence determinants of a structural motif and of factors governing protein stability and protein evolution. The traditional biophysical analysis of protein stability is low throughput, limiting our ability to widely explore sequence space in a quantitative manner. In this study, we have developed a high-throughput library screening method for quantifying stability changes, which is based on protein fragment reconstitution and yeast surface display. Our method exploits the thermodynamic linkage between protein stability and fragment reconstitution and the ability of the yeast surface display technique to quantitatively evaluate protein-protein interactions. The method was applied to a fibronectin type III (FN3) domain. Characterization of fragment reconstitution was facilitated by the co-expression of two FN3 fragments, thus establishing a yeast surface two-hybrid method. Importantly, our method does not rely on competition between clones and thus eliminates a common limitation of high-throughput selection methods in which the most stable variants are recovered predominantly. Thus, it allows for the isolation of sequences that exhibit a desired level of stability. We identified more than 100 unique sequences for a beta-bulge motif, which was significantly more informative than natural sequences of the FN3 family in revealing the sequence determinants for the beta-bulge. Our method provides a powerful means for the rapid assessment of the stability of many variants, for the systematic assessment of the contribution of different factors to protein stability, and for enhancement of the protein stability.

Intra- versus intermolecular interactions in monellin: contribution of surface charges to protein assembly

The relative significance of weak non-covalent interactions in biological context has been much debated. Here, we have addressed the contribution of Coulombic interactions to protein stability and assembly experimentally. The sweet protein monellin, a non-covalently linked heterodimeric protein, was chosen for this study because of its ability to spontaneously reconstitute from separated fragments. The reconstitution of monellin mutants containing large surface charge perturbations was compared to the thermostability of structurally equivalent single-chain monellin containing the same sets of mutations under varying salt concentrations. The affinity between monellin fragments is found to correlate with the thermostability of single chain monellin, indicating the involvement of the same underlying Coulombic interactions. This confirms that there are no principal differences in the interactions involved in folding and binding. Based on comparison with a previous mutational study involving hydrophobic core residues, the relative contribution of Coulombic interactions to stability and affinity is modest. However, the Coulombic perturbations only affect the association rates of reconstitution in contrast to perturbations involving hydrophobic residues, which affect primarily the dissociation rates. These results indicate that Coulombic interactions are likely to be of main importance for the association of protein assembly, relevant for functions of proteins.

Equilibrium Φ-Analysis of a Molten Globule: The 1-149 Apoflavodoxin Fragment

The apoflavodoxin fragment comprising residues 1-149 that can be obtained by chemical cleavage of the C-terminal alpha-helix of the full-length protein is known to populate a molten globule conformation that displays a cooperative behaviour and experiences two-state urea and thermal denaturation. Here, we have used a recombinant form of this fragment to investigate molten globule energetics and to derive structural information by equilibrium Phi-analysis. We have characterized 15 mutant fragments designed to probe the persistence of native interactions in the molten globule and compared their conformational stability to that of the equivalent full-length apoflavodoxin mutants. According to our data, most of the mutations analysed modify the stability of the molten globule fragment following the trend observed when the same mutations are implemented in the full-length protein. However, the changes in stability observed in the molten globule are much smaller and the Phi-values calculated are (with a single exception) below 0.4. This is consistent with an overall and significant debilitation of the native structure. Nevertheless, the fact that the molten globule fragment can be stabilised using as a guide the native structure of the full-length protein (by increasing helix propensity, optimising charge interactions and filling small cavities) suggests that the overall structure of the molten globule is still quite close to native, in spite of the lowered stability observed.

High-affinity fragment complementation of a fibronectin type III domain and its application to stability enhancement

The tenth fibronectin type III (FN3) domain of human fibronectin (FNfn10), a prototype of the ubiquitous FN3 domain, is a small, monomeric beta-sandwich protein. In this study, we have bisected FNfn10 in each loop to generate a total of six fragment pairs. We found that fragment pairs bisected at multiple loops of FNfn10 show complementation in vivo as tested with a yeast two-hybrid system. The dissociation constant of these fragment pairs determined in vitro were as low as 3 nM, resulting in one of the tightest fragment complementation systems reported so far. Furthermore, we show that the affinity of fragment complementation is correlated with the stability of the uncut parent protein. Exploring this correlation, we screened a yeast two-hybrid library of one fragment and identified mutations that suppress the effect of a destabilizing mutation in the other fragment. One of the identified mutations significantly increased the stability of the uncut wild-type protein, proving that fragment complementation can be used as a novel strategy for the selection of proteins with enhanced stability.

Quantitative measurement of protein stability from unfolding equilibria monitored with the fluorescence maximum wavelength

The fluorescence of tryptophan is used as a signal to monitor the unfolding of proteins, in particular the intensity of fluorescence and the wavelength of its maximum lambda(max). The law of the signal is linear with respect to the concentrations of the reactants for the intensity but not for lambda(max). Consequently, the stability of a protein and its variation upon mutation cannot be deduced directly from measurements made with lambda(max). Here, we established a rigorous law of the signal for lambda(max). We then compared the stability DeltaG(H(2)O) and coefficient of cooperativity m for a two-state equilibrium of unfolding, monitored with lambda(max), when the rigorous and empirical linear laws of the signal are applied. The corrective terms involve the curvature of the emission spectra at their lambda(max) and can be determined experimentally. The rigorous and empirical values of the cooperativity coefficient m are equal within the experimental error for this parameter. In contrast, the rigorous and empirical values of the stability DeltaG(H(2)O) generally differ. However, they are equal within the experimental error if the curvatures of the spectra for the native and unfolded states are identical. We validated this analysis experimentally using domain 3 of the envelope glycoprotein of the dengue virus and the single-chain variable fragment (scFv) of antibody mAbD1.3, directed against lysozyme.

Allosteric switching by mutually exclusive folding of protein domains

Many proteins are built from structurally and functionally distinct domains. A major goal is to understand how conformational change transmits information between domains in order to achieve biological activity. A two-domain, bi-functional fusion protein has been designed so that the mechanical stress imposed by the folded structure of one subunit causes the other subunit to unfold, and vice versa. The construct consists of ubiquitin inserted into a surface loop of barnase. The distance between the amino and carboxyl ends of ubiquitin is much greater than the distance between the termini of the barnase loop. This topological constraint causes the two domains to engage in a thermodynamic tug-of-war in which only one can exist in its folded state at any given time. This conformational equilibrium, which is cooperative, reversible, and controllable by ligand binding, serves as a model for the coupled binding and folding mechanism widely used to mediate protein-protein interactions and cellular signaling processes. The position of the equilibrium can be adjusted by temperature or ligand binding and is monitored in vivo by cell death. This design forms the basis for a new class of cytotoxic proteins that can be activated by cell-specific effector molecules, and can thus target particular cell types for destruction.

A novel, two-component system for cell lethality and its use in engineering nuclear male-sterility in plants

Ablation of cells by the controlled expression of a lethal gene can be used to engineer plant traits such as male sterility and disease resistance. However, it may not be possible to achieve sufficient specificity of expression to prevent secondary effects in non-targeted tissues. In this paper we demonstrate that the extracellular ribonuclease, barnase, can be engineered into two complementary fragments, allowing overlapping promoter specificity to be used to enhance targeting specificity. Using a transient system, we first show that barnase can be split into two inactive peptide fragments, that when co-expressed can complement each other to reconstitute barnase activity. When a luciferase reporter gene was introduced into plant cells along with genes encoding both partial barnase peptides, a substantial reduction in luciferase activity was seen. Cytotoxicity of the reconstituted barnase was demonstrated by crossing together parents constitutively expressing each of the barnase fragments, then assaying their progeny for the presence of both partial barnase genes. None of over 300 tomato seeds planted resulted in a viable progeny that inherited both transgenes. When expression of the partial barnase genes was instead targeted to the tapetum, male sterility resulted. All 13 tomato progeny that inherited both transgenes were male sterile, whereas the three progeny inheriting only the N-terminal barnase gene were male fertile. Finally, we describe how male sterility generated by this type of two-component system can be used in hybrid seed production.

Evidence for an initiation site for hen lysozyme folding from the reduced form using its dissected peptide fragments

We prepared two dissected fragments of hen lysozyme and examined whether or not these two fragments associated to form a native-like structure. One (Fragment I) is the peptide fragment Asn59-homoserine-105 containing Cys64-Cys80 and Cys76-Cys94. The other (Fragment II) is the peptide fragment Lys1-homoserine-58 connected by two disulfide bridges, Cys6-Cys127 and Cys30-Cys115, to the peptide fragment Asn106-Leu129. It was found that the Fragment I immobilized in the cuvette formed an equimolar complex with Fragment II (K(d) = 3.3x10(-4) M at pH 8 and 25 degrees C) by means of surface plasmon resonance. Moreover, from analyses by circular dichroism spectroscopy and ion-exchange chromatography of the mixture of Fragments I and II at pH 8 under non-reducing conditions, it was suggested that these fragments associated to give the native-like structure. However, the mutant Fragment I in which Cys64-Cys80 and Cys76-Cys94 are lacking owing to the mutation of Cys to Ala, or the mutant fragment in which Trp62 is mutated to Gly, did not form the native-like species with Fragment II, because the mutant Fragment I derived from mutant lysozymes had no local conformation due to mutations. Considering our previous results where the preferential oxidation of two inside disulfide bonds, Cys64-Cys80 and Cys76-Cys94, occurred in the refolding of the fully reduced Fragment I, we suggest that the peptide region corresponding to Fragment I is an initiation site for hen lysozyme folding.

Reconstitution of a native-like SH2 domain from disordered peptide fragments examined by multidimensional heteronuclear NMR

The N-terminal SH2 domain from the p85alpha subunit of phosphatidylinositol 3' kinase is cleaved specifically into 9- and 5-kD fragments by limited proteolytic digestion with trypsin. The noncovalent SH2 domain complex and its constituent tryptic peptides have been investigated using high-resolution heteronuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). These studies have established the viability of the SH2 domain as a fragment complementation system. The individual peptide fragments are predominantly unstructured in solution. In contrast, the noncovalent 9-kD + 5-kD complex shows a native-like (1)H-(15)N HSQC spectrum, demonstrating that the two fragments fold into a native-like structure on binding. Chemical shift analysis of the noncovalent complex compared to the native SH2 domain reveals that the highest degree of perturbation in the structure occurs at the cleavage site within a flexible loop and along the hydrophobic interface between the two peptide fragments. Mapping of these chemical shift changes on the structure of the domain reveals changes consistent with the reduction in affinity for the target peptide ligand observed in the noncovalent complex relative to the intact protein. The 5-kD fragment of the homologous Src protein is incapable of structurally complementing the p85 9-kD fragment, either in complex formation or in the context of the full-length protein. These high-resolution structural studies of the SH2 domain fragment complementation features establish the suitability of the system for further protein-folding and design studies.

Conformational characterization of designed minibarnase

We have designed a minibarnase by removing one module from barnase, a bacterial RNase from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens. Barnase, consisting of 110 amino acid residues, is decomposed into six modules, M1-M6. Module is defined as a peptide segment consisting of contiguous amino acid residues that makes a small compact conformation within a globular domain. To understand the role of module in protein architecture, we analyzed NMR and CD spectra of a minibarnase, which lacked 26 amino acid residues corresponding to module M2. We demonstrated the formation of hydrophobic cores in the minibarnase similar to those of barnase. Although its conformational stability against acids and heat was reduced in comparison with barnase, the minibarnase retained cooperative folding character (two-state folding). Therefore, the folding of the minibarnase consisting of modules M1 and M3-M6 is independent to some extent of module M2. This finding may be useful for future module-based protein design.

A rapid test for identification of autonomous folding units in proteins

The structure of a protein is dictated by a large number of weak interactions that cooperatively stabilize the native state. Usually, excised fragments smaller than a domain have little if any residual structure. When autonomous units of structure are found within domains, this challenges common assumptions about the cooperativity of protein structure. Such autonomous folding units (AFUs) are of wide interest and have applications in protein engineering and as simple model systems for studying the determinants of stability and specificity. A new method of identifying AFUs within proteins is presented here. The rapid autonomous fragment test (RAFT) identifies AFUs based on analysis of inter-residue contacts present in the three-dimensional structure of a protein. RAFT is fast enough to mine the entire PDB for AFUs and provide a library of potential small stable folds. We show that RAFT is able to predict whether a protein fragment will be structured if isolated from its parent domain.

Protein stabilization through phage display

RNase S consists of two proteolytic fragments of RNase A, residues 1-20 (S20) and residues 21-124 (S pro). A 15-mer peptide (S15p) with high affinity for S pro was selected from a phage display library. Peptide residues that are buried in the structure of the wild type complex are conserved in S15p though there are several changes at other positions. Isothermal titration calorimetry studies show that the affinity of S15p is comparable to that of the wild type peptide at 25 degrees C. However, the magnitudes of DeltaH(o) and DeltaC(p) are lower for S15p, suggesting that the thermal stability of the complex is enhanced. In agreement with this prediction, at pH 6, the T(m) of the S15p complex was found to be 10 degrees C higher than that of the wild type complex. This suggests that for proteins where fragment complementation systems exist, phage display can be used to find mutations that increase protein thermal stability.

Stability and folding of the protein complexes of barnase

Native-like complexes of proteins, formed by the association of two complementary fragments comprising the entire sequence of the protein, can be used to gain insight into the stability and folding of the intact protein. We have studied the structural, thermodynamic and kinetic properties of four barnase complexes, with the cleavage site at different positions of the amino-acid chain (CB36, at position 36; CB56, at position 56; CB68, at position 68; and CB79, at position 79). The four barnase complexes have native-like structure as shown by fluorescence, far-and near-UV CD, size-exclusion chromatography and NMR. The NMR characterization indicated that the structural changes were mainly located in regions close to the cleavage site. The main core of the protein was fully formed and the overall structure was similar to that of intact barnase. The thermal and chemical denaturation showed that all complexes were substantially destabilized. CB56 displayed two denaturation transitions, probably because of the presence of partially folded conformations around the cleavage site. The rate constant for the association/folding of fragments decreased with the decreasing length of the C-terminal fragment. Thus, the larger the fragment (and, consequently, the larger the amount of residual native-like structure), the faster the association. These findings are consistent with the proposed model of barnase folding.

A mini-protein designed by removing a module from barnase: molecular modeling and NMR measurements of the conformation

A globular domain can be decomposed into compact modules consisting of contiguous 10-30 amino acid residues. The correlation between modules and exons observed in different proteins suggests that each module was encoded by an ancestral exon and that modules were combined into globular domains by exon fusion. Barnase is a single domain RNase consisting of 110 amino acid residues and was decomposed into six modules. We designed a mini-protein by removing the second module, M2, from barnase in order to gain an insight into the structural and functional roles of the module. In the molecular modeling of the mini-protein, we evaluated thermodynamic stability and aqueous solubility together with mechanical stability of the model. We chemically synthesized a mini-barnase with (15)N-labeling at 10 residues, whose corresponding residues in barnase are all found in the region around the hydrophobic core. Circular dichroism and NMR measurements revealed that mini-barnase takes a non-random specific conformation that has a similar hydrophobic core structure to that of barnase. This result, that a module could be deleted without altering the structure of core region of barnase, supports the view that modules act as the building blocks of protein design.

Foldability of barnase mutants obtained by permutation of modules or secondary structure units

Modules, defined as stable, compact structure units in a globular protein, are good candidates for the construction of novel foldable proteins by permutation. Here we decomposed barnase into six modules (M1-M6) and constructed 23 barnase mutants containing permutations of the internal four (M2-M5) out of six modules. Globular proteins can also be subdivided into secondary structure units based on the extended structures that control the mutual relationships of the modules. We also decomposed barnase into six secondary structure units (S1-S6) and constructed 21 barnase mutants containing permutations of the internal four (S2-S5) out of six secondary structure units. Foldability of these two types of mutants was assessed by means of circular dichroism, fluorescence, and 1H-NMR measurements. A total of 15 of 23 module mutants and 15 of 21 secondary structure unit mutants formed definite secondary structures, such as alpha-helix and beta-sheet, at 20 microM owing to intermolecular interactions, but most of them converted to random coil structures at a lower concentration (1 microM). Of the 44 mutants, only two, M3245 and S2543, gave distinct near-UV CD spectra. S2543 especially showed definite signal dispersion in the amide and methyl regions of the 1H-NMR spectrum, though M3245 did not. Furthermore, urea-induced unfolding of S2543 monitored by far-UV CD and fluorescence measurements showed a distinct cooperative transition. These results strongly suggest that S2543 takes partially folded conformations in aqueous solution. Our results also suggest that building blocks such as secondary structure units capable of taking different stable conformations by adapting themselves to the surrounding environment, rather than building blocks such as modules having a specified stable conformation, are required for the formation of foldable proteins. Therefore, the use of secondary structure units for the construction of novel globular proteins is likely to be an effective approach.

Trimeric domain-swapped barnase

The structure of a trimeric domain-swapped form of barnase (EC 3.1. 27.3) was determined by x-ray crystallography at a resolution of 2.2 A from crystals of space group R32. Residues 1-36 of one molecule associate with residues 41-110 from another molecule related through threefold symmetry. The resulting cyclic trimer contains three protein folds that are very similar to those in monomeric barnase. Both swapped domains contain a nucleation site for folding. The formation of a domain-swapped trimer is consistent with the description of the folding process of monomeric barnase as the formation and subsequent association of two foldons.

Exploring the folding funnel of a polypeptide chain by biophysical studies on protein fragments

We are examining possible roles of native and non-native interactions in early events in protein folding by a systematic analysis of the structures of fragments of proteins whose folding pathways are well characterised. Seven fragments of the 110-residue protein barnase, corresponding to the progressive elongation from its N terminus, have been characterised by a battery of biophysical and spectroscopic methods. Barnase is a multi-modular protein that folds via an intermediate in which the C-terminal region of its major alpha-helix (alpha-helix1, residues Thr6-His18) is substantially formed as is also its anti-parallel beta-sheet, centred around a beta-hairpin (residues Ser92-Leu95). Fragments up to, and including, residues 1-95 (fragment B95), appeared to be mainly disordered, although a small amount of helical secondary structure in each was inferred from far-UV CD experiments, and fluorescence studies indicated some native-like tertiary interactions in B95. The largest fragment (residues 1-105, B105) is compactly folded. The secondary structure in alpha-helix1 in the seven fragments was found by NMR to increase with increasing chain length faster than the build-up of tertiary interactions, indicating that alpha-helix1 is being stabilised by non-native interactions. This behaviour contrasts with that in fragments of the 64-residue chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2), in which tertiary and secondary structures build up in parallel with increasing length. CI2 consists of a single module of structure that folds without a detectable intermediate. The largest fragment of barnase, B105, has interactions that resemble its folding intermediate, whereas one of the largest fragments of CI2 (residues 1-60) resembles the folding transition state. The folding pathways of both proteins are consistent with a scheme in which there are low levels of native-like secondary structure in the denatured state that become stabilised by long-range interactions as folding proceeds. Neither protein forms a stable fold when lacking the last ten residues at the C terminus. Since at least 20 amino acid residues are bound to the ribosome during protein biosynthesis, these small proteins do not fold until they have left the ribosome, and so the studies of the folding of such proteins in vitro may be relevant to their folding in vivo, especially as the molecular chaperone GroEL binds only weakly to denatured CI2 and does not discernibly alter the folding mechanism of barnase.

Conformational analysis of peptide fragments derived from the peripheral subunit-binding domain from the pyruvate dehydrogenase multienzyme complex of Bacillus stearothermophilus: evidence for nonrandom structure in the unfolded state

There is currently a great deal of interest in the early events in protein folding. Two issues that have generated particular interest are the nature of the unfolded state under native conditions and the role of local interactions in folding. Here, we report the results of a study of a set of peptides derived from a small two-helix protein, the peripheral subunit-binding domain of the pyruvate dehydrogenase multienzyme complex. Five peptides of overlapping sequence were prepared, including sequences corresponding to each of the helices and to the region connecting them. The peptides were characterized by CD and, where possible, nmr. A peptide corresponding to the second helix is between 12 and 17% helical at neutral pH. CD also indicates a lower percentage of helical structure in the peptide corresponding to the first alpha-helix, although the values of the alpha-proton chemical shifts suggest some preference for nonrandom structure. Peptides corresponding to the interhelical loop, which in the full domain contains two overlapping beta-turns and a 5-residue 3(10)-helix, are less structured. There is no significant change in the helicity of any of these peptides with pH. To test for fragment complementation, CD spectra of the two peptides derived from each helix and the long connecting peptide were compared to the spectra of each possible pair, as well as to a mixture containing all three. No increase in structure was observed. We complement our peptide studies by characterizing a point mutant, D34V, which disrupts a critical hydrogen bonding network. This mutant is unable to fold and provides a useful model of the denatured state. The mutant is between 9 and 16% helical as judged by CD. The modest amount of helical structure formed in some of the peptide fragments and in the point mutant suggests that the denatured state of the peripheral subunit binding domain is not completely unstructured. This may contribute to the very rapid folding observed for the intact protein.

Apoflavodoxin: structure, stability, and FMN binding

Flavodoxins are one domain alpha/beta electron transfer proteins that participate in photosynthetic reactions. All flavodoxins carry a molecule of flavin mononucleotide (FMN), non-covalently bound, that confers redox properties to the protein. There are two structurally distinct flavodoxins, short ones and long flavodoxins; the latter contain an extra loop with unknown function. We have undertaken the study of the stability and folding of the apoflavodoxin from Anabaena (a long flavodoxin) and the analysis of the interaction between the apoflavodoxin and FMN. Our studies indicate that apoflavodoxin folds in a few seconds to a form that is competent in FMN binding. The stability of this apoflavodoxin is low and its urea denaturation can be described by a two-state mechanism. The role of the different parts of the apoflavodoxin in the stability and structure of the whole protein is being investigated using mutagenesis and specific cleavage to generate apoflavodoxin fragments. The X-ray structure of apoflavodoxin is very similar to that of its complex with FMN, the main difference being the conformation of the two aromatic residues that sandwich FMN in the complex. In apoflavodoxin these groups interact with each other so closing the FMN binding site. Despite this fact, apoflavodoxin binds FMN tightly and rapidly, and the resulting holoflavodoxin displays a high conformational stability. We have found that one role of the aromatic residues that interact with FMN is to help to retain bound the reduced form of the cofactor whose complex with apoflavodoxin is otherwise too weak.

Kinetic epitope mapping of the chicken lysozyme.HyHEL-10 Fab complex: delineation of docking trajectories

The rate constants, k(on), for the formation of hen (chicken) lysozyme (HEWL). Fab-10 complexes have been determined for wild-type (WT) and epitope-mutated lysozymes by a homogeneous solution method based on the 95% reduced enzymatic activity of the complex. The values fall within a narrow 10-fold range [(0.18 to 1.92) x 10(6) M(-1)s(-l)]. The affinity constants, K(D), cover a broader, 440-fold, range from 0.075 to 33 nM. Values of K(D) as high as 7 microM were obtained for the complexes prepared from some mutations at HEWL positions 96 and 97, but the associated kinetic constants could not be determined. The values of k(on) are negatively correlated with side-chain volume at position 101HEWL, but are essentially independent of this parameter for position 21HEWL substitutions. The multiple mutations made at positions 21HEWL and 101HEWL provide sufficient experimental data on complex formation to evaluate phi values [phi = (deltadeltaGon)/(deltadeltaG(D))] at these two positions to begin to define trajectories for protein-protein association. The data, when interpreted within the concept of a two-step association sequence embracing a metastable encounter complex intermediate, argue that the rate determining step at position 21HEWL (phiavg = 0.2) is encounter complex formation, but the larger phi(avg) value of 0.36 experienced for most position 101HEWL mutations indicates a larger contribution from the post-encounter annealing process at this site for these replacements.

Structure and function of microplasminogen: reconstitution of microplasminogen and microplasmin from isolated fragments

We describe limited chemical proteolysis of microplasminogen/microplasmin (mPlg/mPlm) and their reconstitution from isolated fragments. A V141-->M141 substitution in methionineless human mPlg/mPlm allowed the protein(s) to be cleaved in CNBr/formic acid. The resulting two fragments (141 and 118 residues, respectively), each internally disulfide bonded, were separated by preparative non-reducing gradient SDS-PAGE, and could then be mixed to reconstitute the characteristic mPlg/mPlm, including their activation by urokinase (uPA) and streptokinase (SK), and inhibition by macromolecular inhibitors. The isolated larger, N-terminal fragment, which contains the mPlg activation site in a normal disulfide configuration, was not cleaved by uPA in the absence of its smaller C-terminal companion, showing that the linear amino acid sequence is not by itself sufficient to confer substrate character, even when its conformation is constrained by the disulfide structure.

Control of protein splicing by intein fragment reassembly

Inteins are protein splicing elements that mediate their excision from precursor proteins and the joining of the flanking protein sequences (exteins). In this study, protein splicing was controlled by splitting precursor proteins within the Psp Pol-1 intein and expressing the resultant fragments in separate hosts. Reconstitution of an active intein was achieved by in vitro assembly of precursor fragments. Both splicing and intein endonuclease activity were restored. Complementary fragments from two of the three fragmentation positions tested were able to splice in vitro. Fragments resulting in redundant overlaps of intein sequences or containing affinity tags at the fragmentation sites were able to splice. Fragment pairs resulting in a gap in the intein sequence failed to splice or cleave. However, similar deletions in unfragmented precursors also failed to splice or cleave. Single splice junction cleavage was not observed with single fragments. In vitro splicing of intein fragments under native conditions was achieved using mini exteins. Trans-splicing allows differential modification of defined regions of a protein prior to extein ligation, generating partially labeled proteins for NMR analysis or enabling the study of the effects of any type of protein modification on a limited region of a protein.

Molecular dynamics simulation of the unfolding of barnase: characterization of the major intermediate

The folding/unfolding pathway of barnase has been studied extensively using the protein engineering method, which has provided indirect structural information for the transition state and the major folding intermediate. To further characterize the structural properties of the intermediate, we have simulated the thermal denaturation of barnase beginning from the average NMR structure. Our results indicate that there are at least two intermediates on the unfolding pathway. The three hydrophobic cores are partially formed in the major intermediate (I1), with core1 and core3 being slightly stronger than core2. Helix alpha 1 is substantially formed, with the center being stronger than the termini. The first turn of alpha 2 is lost and alpha 3 is unfolded. The center of the beta-sheet is substantially formed, but the edges are disrupted. These structural characteristics are in good qualitative agreement with the experimental data. For semi-quantitative comparison with experimental data, the extent of native structure of individual residues is characterized by a structure index, S, that reflects both secondary and tertiary structure. There is good agreement between S and the experimentally measured phi values, which are based on energetics, except for three residues. These residues are polar and non-conservative mutations were made to obtain phi values, which can complicate structural interpretations. These residues make strong side-chain interactions in I1, but the backbone structure is disrupted, leading to low S values. Thus, this discordance highlights possible limitations in both the phi value and S value analyses: strong polar interactions in the intermediate may give rise to high phi values that are not reflective of structure per se; however, due to sampling limitations, any one simulation is not expected to capture all of the features of the true conformational ensemble. In any case, these simulations provide an experimentally testable, atomic-level structural model for the major folding intermediate of barnase, as well as the detailed pathway from the native to the intermediate state.

Localization of human intestinal defensin 5 in Paneth cell granules

Antibiotic peptides of higher animals include the defensins, first discovered in phagocytic cells but recently also found to be produced by epithelial cells. We biosynthesized recombinant human intestinal defensin 5 (rHD-5) using the baculovirus-insect cell expression system. Since insect cells process defensin incompletely and secrete the precursor proHD-5, we substituted a methionine for an alanine at a likely processing site to allow selective chemical cleavage with cyanogen bromide, and rHD-5 was used to elicit polyclonal antibodies. By the immunoperoxidase-staining technique, the antibodies selectively stained Paneth cells of the normal adult small intestine. Immunogold electron microscopy further localized HD-5 to the Paneth cell secretory granules. Since some defensins exert activity cytotoxic to mammalian cells, we assayed the effect of rHD-5 on the human intestinal cell lines Caco2 and Int407. proHD-5 did not exert cytotoxic activity, and rHD-5 showed only minimal activity against Int407 and was inert against Caco2. Since Paneth cells release their granules adjacent to the mitotic cells of the intestinal crypts, HD could protect this cell population against invasion and parasitization by microbes.

Synergy in protein engineering. Mutagenic manipulation of protein structure to simplify semisynthesis

Semisynthesis is a chemical technique of protein engineering that provides a valuable complement to directed mutagenesis. It is the method of choice when the structural modification requires, for example, a noncoded amino acid. The process involves specific and limited protein fragmentation, structural manipulation of the target sequence, and subsequent religation of fragments to give the mutant holoprotein. We suggested and demonstrated that mutagenesis and semisynthesis could be used synergistically to achieve protein engineering goals otherwise unobtainable, if mutagenesis was used to shuffle methionine residues in the yeast cytochrome c sequence (Wallace, C. J. A., Guillemette, J. G., Hibiya, Y., and Smith, M. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 21355-21357). These residues can not only be sites of specific cleavage by CNBr but also of spontaneous peptide bond synthesis between fragments in noncovalent complexes, which greatly facilitates the semisynthetic process. We have now used an informed "methionine scan" of the protein sequence to discover other useful sites and to characterize the factors that promote this extraordinary and convenient autocatalytic religation. Of eight sites canvassed, in a wide range of settings, five efficiently provoked peptide bond synthesis. The principal factor determining efficiency seems to be the hydropathy of the religation site. The mutants created have also provided some new insights on structure-function relationships in the cytochrome.

A plasmid vector with positive selection and directional cloning based on a conditionally lethal gene

A plasmid vector with a multiple cloning site (MCS) for positive selection of cloned inserts in Escherichia coli (Ec) has been devised, based on the expression plasmid (pMT416) for the bacterial ribonuclease barnase (Barn). The host is protected from the lethal effect of moderate expression of barn by expression of the gene bars, encoding its inhibitor, barstar (Bars), placed on the same plasmid. Full expression, however, is lethal. Induction is also lethal with the derived plasmid, pMT440, which has the pUC19 MCS inserted into barn. Under inducing conditions, transformation by the vector is lethal unless the product of the modified barn is inactivated by insertion of cloned DNA fragments into the MCS. Plasmid pMT440 is, therefore, a generally useful selective cloning vector not requiring any special strain of Ec.

Structure and function of microplasminogen: I. Methionine shuffling, chemical proteolysis, and proenzyme activation

We have cloned and expressed microplasminogen (mPlg), consisting of the N-terminal undecapeptide of human glu-Plg spliced to its proenzyme domain. This truncated (approximately 28 kDa) proenzyme retained the distinctive catalytic activities of the larger parent. Replacement of M residues followed by M shuffling permitted subsequent scission by site-directed chemical proteolysis (in CNBr/formic acid) without impairing any of the protein's characteristic properties. Activation of chymotrypsinogen-related zymogens occurs by limited proteolysis; the newly liberated, highly conserved N-terminus (VVGG) forms a salt bridge with an aspartyl residue immediately upstream of the active site serine. The role of both of these elements in mPlg activation was probed using protein engineering and site-directed proteolysis to alter the length and amino acid composition of the N-terminus, and to replace the aspartate. All modifications affected both Km and Kcat. The results identify some structural parameters of the N-terminus required for proenzyme activation.

Reconstitution of Escherichia coli RNase HI from the N-fragment with high helicity and the C-fragment with a disordered structure

The Escherichia coli RNase HI variant with the Lys86-->Ala mutation is purified in two forms, as nicked and intact proteins. The nicked K86A protein, in which the N-fragment (Met1-Lys87) and the C-fragment (Arg88-Val155) remain associated, is enzymatically active. These N- and C-fragments were isolated and examined for reassociation. These peptides did not associate to form the nicked K86A protein at pH 3.0 in the absence of salt, but were associated, with a yield of 30-80%, when the pH was raised to 5.5 or when salt was added. Measurements of the CD spectra show that the alpha-helices are partially formed in the N-fragment at pH 3.0 in the absence of salt and are almost fully formed either at pH 5.5 or at pH 3.0 in the presence of 0.15 M NaCl. In contrast, the C-fragment remains almost fully disordered under these conditions. The N-fragment with this high (native-like) helicity shows the characteristics of a molten globule with respect to the content of the secondary and tertiary structures, the ability to bind a fluorescent probe (1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid), and the behavior on the thermal transition. These results suggest that the N-fragment contains an initial folding site, probably the alpha I-helix, and the completion of the folding in this site provides a surface that facilitates the folding of the C-fragment. This folding process may represent that of the intact RNase HI molecule.

Detection of a stable intermediate in the thermal unfolding of a cysteine-free form of dihydrofolate reductase from Escherichia coli

The reversible temperature-induced unfolding of a cysteine-free mutant (C85S/C152E, des-Cys) of dihydrofolate reductase from Escherichia coli has been studied by absorbance and by both far- and near-ultraviolet circular dichroism spectroscopies. The non-coincidence of all three transition curves demonstrated the existence of a highly populated partially-folded form near 39 degrees C at pH 7.8. This intermediate retains substantial secondary structure and partially excludes one or more of the five tryptophans from solvent; however, the intermediate has lost specific tertiary packing around its aromatic residues. Increases in enthalpy, entropy, and heat capacity are observed for both the native/intermediate and intermediate/unfolded transitions; the majority of the changes in these parameters occurs in the first transition. These results suggest that the thermal unfolding reaction of des-Cys dihydrofolate reductase involves a stable intermediate whose properties resemble those of a molten globule.

Complement assembly of two fragments of the streptococcal protein G B1 domain in aqueous solution

We examined the complementation of various pairs of fragments derived from the streptococcal protein G B1 domain by NMR and CD. Most were not associated; however, one pair of fragments (1-40) and (41-56) interacted sufficiently enough to regenerated a stable 1:1 complex, Kd = 9 x 10(-6) M. A 2D-NMR analysis showed that the structure of the complex resembled that of native domain. Here we discuss the complementation from the viewpoint of the folding pathway of the protein.

Protein stability as a function of denaturant concentration: the thermal stability of barnase in the presence of urea

The conventional procedure for analyzing urea denaturation curves assumes that the free energy of unfolding (delta GU-F) is linearly related to [urea] that is, delta GU-F = delta GH2O(U-F)--m[urea], where m is a constant, specific for each protein, and delta GH2O(U-F) is the free energy of unfolding in water. This relationship can be measured directly, however, over only a small concentration range of approximately +/- 0.8 M urea around the midpoint of the unfolding transition. A nagging discrepancy (1.6 kcal mol-1) between delta GH2O(U-F) at 298 K of barnase extrapolated from such an equation and the equivalent value obtained from thermal unfolding measurements has stimulated a re-evaluation of the equation. Differential scanning calorimetric measurements have been made of the thermal unfolding of barnase in the presence of concentrations of urea between 0 and 4.5 M, the midpoint of the unfolding transition at 298 K, to test the denaturation equation over a wide range of [urea]. Values for delta GU-F at 298 K (delta G298U-F) for each concentration of urea were extrapolated from the calorimetrically measured enthalpies and the denaturational heat capacity change (delta Cdp) measured for that concentration of urea. A plot of delta G298U-F against [urea] deviates systematically from linearity and fits better the equation: delta G298U-F = 10.5 +/- 0.08 - ((2.65 +/- 0.05) x [urea]) + ((0.08 +/- 0.01) x [urea]2) kcal mol-1. The curvature in the plot leads to apparent values of m that increase when measurements are made at lower concentrations of urea. This could account for increases in m at low values of pH or in destabilized mutants since the protein denatures at lower concentrations of urea. It has been shown previously that small curvature in the free energy of unfolding versus [urea] leads to negligible errors in measurements of delta delta GU-F, the change in free energy of unfolding on mutation, providing that the curvature is similar for all mutants. The calorimetrically measured enthalpies of unfolding are decreased in the presence of urea while delta Cdp is increased. Both of these observations are consistent with an overall exothermic interaction between urea and protein with a net increase on unfolding.

NMR study of the reconstitution of the beta-sheet of thioredoxin by fragment complementation

The study of complementary protein fragments is thought to be generally useful to identify early folding intermediates. A prerequisite for these studies is the reconstitution of the native-like structure by fragment complementation. Structural analysis of the complementation of the domain-sized proteolytic fragments of E. coli thioredoxin, using a combination of H-exchange and 2D NMR experiments as a fingerprint technique, provide evidence for the extensive reconstitution of a native beta-sheet, with local conformational adjustments near the cleavage site. Remarkably, the antiparallel beta-strand between the fragments shows a native-like protection of the amide protons to solvent exchange. Our results indicate that these fragments can be useful to study the early events in the still little understood formation of beta-sheets.

Folding of a nascent polypeptide chain in vitro: cooperative formation of structure in a protein module

We have prepared a family of peptide fragments of the 64-residue chymotrypsin inhibitor 2, corresponding to its progressive elongation from the N terminus. The growing polypeptide chain has little tendency to form stable structure until it is largely synthesized, and what structures are formed are nonnative and lack, in particular, the native secondary structural elements of alpha-helix and beta-sheet. These elements then develop as sufficient tertiary interactions are made in the nearly full-length chain. The growth of structure in the small module is highly cooperative and does not result from the hierarchical accretion of substructures.

Protein folding. An unfolding story

A unified and coherent picture for the mechanism of protein folding is emerging. The crucial factor in folding is the cooperativity of multiple interactions that is required for stability of the folded state.

The structure of the transition state for the association of two fragments of the barley chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 to generate native-like protein: implications for mechanisms of protein folding

Possible early events in protein folding may be studied by dissecting proteins into complementary fragments. Two fragments of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 [CI2-(20-59) and CI2-(60-83)] associate to form a native-like structure in a second-order reaction that combines collision and rearrangement. The transition state of the reaction, analyzed by the protein engineering method on 17 mutants, is remarkably similar to that for the folding of the intact protein--a structure that resembles an expanded version of the folded structure with most interactions significantly weakened. The exception is that the N-terminal region of the single alpha-helix (the N-capping box) is completely formed in the transition state for association of the fragments, whereas it is reasonably well formed for the intact protein. Preliminary evidence on the structures of the individual fragments indicates that both are mainly nonnative, lacking native secondary structure and having regions of nonnative buried hydrophobic clusters. The association reaction does not result from the collision of a subpopulation of two fully native-like fragments but involves a considerable rearrangement of structure.

Rationally designing the accumulation of a folding intermediate of barnase by protein engineering

A method for the stabilization of transient folding intermediates is presented. Barnase folds and unfolds via such an intermediate. Mutations that destabilize the folded state relative to the folding intermediate had been previously identified from the free energy profiles for the unfolding of mutant proteins. It is predicted that the accumulation of such mutations should lead to the intermediate being the most stable species at certain concentrations of denaturant. Mutants were prepared that contained combinations of such mutations. The behavior of these mutants on urea denaturation was studied by probes for tertiary structure (fluorescence, near-UV CD), secondary structure (far-UV CD), and hydrodynamic volume (size-exclusion chromatography). Whereas wild-type shows a two-state transition in all cases, with the same thermodynamic values being found by all probes, some of the mutants show different transitions with different structural probes. On increasing concentration of denaturant, the tertiary structure of these mutants is lost before all the secondary structure and before the protein shows the maximum expanded volume that is characteristic of the unfolded state. These mutants thus accumulate an intermediate state at equilibrium under certain urea concentrations. The intermediate state retains some degree of secondary structure but has a disrupted tertiary structure, and its degree of compactness is intermediate between the folded and the unfolded forms, probably expanding with increasing concentration of denaturant. The accumulation of the intermediate should allow its direct characterization by spectroscopy, especially NMR.