Macromolecular selectivity of chick chorioallantoic membrane microvessels during normal angiogenesis and endothelial differentiation

Chorioallantoic Membrane Models of Various Avian Species: Differences and Applications

The chorioallantoic membrane model (CAM) of an avian embryo is used as an experimental model in various fields of research, including angiogenesis research and drug testing, xenografting and cancer research, and other scientific and commercial disciplines in microbiology, biochemistry, cosmetics, etc. It is a low-cost, low-maintenance, and well-available in vivo animal model that is non-sentient and can be used as an alternative for other mammal experimental models. It respects the principles of the "3R" rule (Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement)-conditions set out for scientific community providing an essential framework for conducting a more human animal research, which is also in line with constantly raising public awareness of welfare and the ethics related to the use of animal experimental models. In this review, we describe the chorioallantoic membrane of an avian embryo, focusing on its properties and development, its advantages and disadvantages as an experimental model, and the possibilities of its application in various fields of biological research. Since the most common chicken CAM model is already well known and described in many publications, we are particularly focusing on the advantages and application of less known avian species that are used for the CAM model-quail, turkey, and duck.

Dynamics of the Developing Chick Chorioallantoic Membrane Assessed by Stereology, Allometry, Immunohistochemistry and Molecular Analysis

The chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) is a widely used model for the study of angiogenesis, tumour growth, as well as drug efficacy. In spite of this, little is known about the developmental alteration from its appearance to the time of hatching. In the current study the CAM has been studied by classical stereology and allometry. Expression levels of selected angiogenesis-related molecules were estimated by RT-PCR and cell dynamics assessed by proliferation and apoptosis assays. Absolute CAM volume increased from a low of 0.47 ± 0.11 cm3 at embryonic day 8 (E8) to a high of 2.05 ± 0.27 cm3 at E18, and then decreased to 1.6 ± 0.47 cm3 at E20. On allometric analysis, three growth phases were identifiable. Between E8-13 (phase I), the CAM grew fastest; moderately in phase II (E13-18) but was regressing in phase III (E18-20). The chorion, the mesenchyme and the allantoic layers grew fastest in phase I, but moderately in phase II. The mesenchyme grew slowly in phase III while the chorion and allantois were regressing. Chorionic cell volume increased fastest in phase I and was regressing in phase III. Chorionic capillaries grew steadily in phase I and II but regressed in phase III. Both the chorion and the allantois grew by intrinsic cell proliferation as well as recruitment of cells from the mesenchyme. Cell proliferation was prominent in the allantois and chorion early during development, declined after E17 and apoptosis started mainly in the chorion from E14. VEGFR2 expression peaked at E11 and declined steadily towards E20, VEGF peaked at E13 and E20 while HIF 1α had a peak at E11 and E20. Studies targeting CAM growth and angiogenesis need to take these growth phases into consideration.

Microvascular growth, development, and remodeling in the embryonic avian kidney: the interplay between sprouting and intussusceptive angiogenic mechanisms

Embryonic development is associated with extensive vascular growth and remodeling. We used immunohistochemical, light and electron microscopical techniques, as well as vascular casting methods to study the developing chick embryo kidney with special attention to the interplay between sprouting and intussusceptive vascular growth modes. During inauguration at embryonic day 5 (E5), the early mesonephros was characterised by extensive microvascular sprouting. By E7, the vascular growth mode switched to intussusception, which contributed to rapid kidney vasculature growth up to E11, when the first obvious signs of vascular degeneration were evident. The metanephros underwent similar phases of vascular development inaugurating at E8 with numerous capillary sprouts and changing at E13 to intussusceptive growth, which was responsible for vascular amplification and remodeling. A phenomenal finding was that future renal lobules arose as large glomerular tufts, supplied by large vessels, which were split into smaller intralobular feeding and draining vessels with subsequent formation of solitary glomeruli. This glomerular duplication was achieved by intussusception, i.e., by formation of pillars in rows and their successive merging to delineate the vascular entities. Ultimately, the maturation of the vasculature was achieved by intussusceptive pruning and branching remodeling. An interesting finding was that strong VEGF expression was associated with the sprouting phase of angiogenesis while bFGF was upregulated during the phase of intussusceptive microvascular growth. We conclude that microvascular growth and remodeling in avian kidney follows an adroitly crafted pattern, which entails a precise spaciotemporal interplay between sprouting and intussusceptive angiogenic growth modes supported partly by VEGF and bFGF.

TaqMan®-based quantification of invasive cells in the chick embryo metastasis assay

The chick embryonic metastasis (CEM) assay is a fast in vivo method to investigate the invasive properties of tumor cells. Until now, most quantification methods were semiquantitative and time-consuming. Here we describe a rapid quantification method using TaqMan® technology to quantify the invaded tumor cells in the chorioallantoic membrane of fertilized eggs. This method is based on specific detection of human ALU sequences. Moreover, it provides high sensitivity over a wide linearity range.

Chorioallantoic membrane angiogenesis model for tissue engineering: a new twist on a classic model

Tissue-engineering (TE) applications include the isolation, culture, and seeding of cells into a suitable matrix or scaffold before in vivo transplantation. After transplantation, vascularization of the scaffold is a principal limiting factor for cell viability for the first 6-8 days posttransplantation. A model for systematic analysis of this process has been developed. Fertilized White Leghorn eggs were incubated (at 37.8 degrees C in 60% relative humidity) and opened on day 3 of incubation. Preadipocyte-seeded fibrin constructs were implanted in a specially designed plastic cylinder and placed through the opening on the surface of the chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) on day 8 of incubation. Vascularization of the constructs by chorioallantoic blood vessels was assessed for up to 8 days posttransplantation. The survival rate for embryos receiving transplanted constructs was about 90%. Histology confirmed transplant cell viability at day 4 posttransplantation and vascularization of the constructs by avian endothelial cells began at this time. A new in vivo model to study the effect of angiogenesis in TE constructs, including assessments of viability, proliferation, and differentiation of transplanted cells and biomaterial properties, is presented. Advantages include easy access to the vascular network of the CAM, lack of immunocompetence, low costs, and avoidance of animal experiments.

Intussusceptive angiogenesis--the alternative to capillary sprouting

In contrast to sprouting angiogenesis, which is a well established mode of new blood vessel formation, intussusceptive angiogenesis (IA) is a relatively new concept in vascular biology. It was first discovered in the lung as a means of capillary network growth (intussusceptive microvascular growth). The mechanism consists in the repeated insertion of new slender transcapillary tissue pillars, which subsequently increase in size, thus allowing the capillary network to grow in itself (i.e., by intussusception). It could be shown that IA was present in all organs and species investigated so far, so that it appears to be an ubiquitous phenomenon in vertebrates at least. It was not a surprise therefore to find that IA also played a role in tumour vascularisation. Morphological analysis has yet brought evidence for 6 different modes of pillar formation. They all have in common that, at one time, two endothelial leaflets (e.g. of opposite capillary walls) come into close contact, form new junctional complexes, then thin out to finally give way to the invading interstitial tissue, particularly to fibroblasts, myofibroblasts and pericytes. Once such a transcapillary pillar is formed, it can subsequently grow to the size of a normal intercapillary mesh. The addition of collagen fibrils to the pillar core will stabilize the pillar mechanically. Recent observations allowed to extend the IA concept further: The same structural mechanism of intussusceptive pillar formation was shown to contribute also to the formation of vascular trees (arborisation) and to be involved in vascular remodeling. Although numerous growth factors and receptors have already been suggested as being active in IA, very few hard facts are at present available which would allow to get a comprehensive view of IA regulation.

Chorioallantoic membrane capillary bed: a useful target for studying angiogenesis and anti-angiogenesis in vivo

The chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) is an extraembryonic membrane that is commonly used in vivo to study both angiogenesis and anti-angiogenesis. This review 1) summarizes the current knowledge about the structure of the CAM's capillary bed; 2) discusses the controversy about the existence of a single blood sinus or a capillary plexus underlying the chorionic epithelium; 3) describes a new model of the CAM vascular growth, namely the intussusceptive mode; 4) reports findings regarding the role played by endogenous fibroblast growth factor-2 in CAM vascularization; and 5) addresses the use and limitations of the CAM as a model for studying angiogenesis and anti-angiogenesis.

Vascular remodelling during the normal and malignant life cycle of the mammary gland

The mammary gland life cycle is exemplified by massive, physiologically dictated changes in cell number and composition, architecture, and functionality. These drastic upheavals, by necessity, also involve the mammary endothelium, which undergoes angiogenic expansion during pregnancy and lactation followed by ordered regression during involution. In this review, we summarise data obtained using the Mercox methyl methacrylate corrosion cast technique to analyse the mammary gland vasculature during normal development and carcinogenesis. Concomitant with epithelial cell expansion, the mammary vasculature grows during the first half of pregnancy by sprouting angiogenesis whereas the last half of pregnancy and lactation are characterised by the non-proliferative intussusceptive angiogenesis. The vasculature of the lactating gland is composed of a well-developed capillary meshwork enveloping the secretory alveoli with basket-like honeycomb structures. During involution, regression of the vasculature is achieved by regional collapse of the honeycomb structures, capillary retraction, and endothelial attenuation. This process appears partly to involve apoptosis. However, an additional mechanism involving remodelling without cell death, which we have termed angiomeiosis, must exist to explain the morphological observations. Interestingly, in mammary tumours of neuT transgenic mice, both sprouting and intussusceptive angiogenesis was observed simultaneously in the same nodules, a finding with potential implications for cancer therapy. The underlying molecular mechanisms controlling angiogenic modulation in the mammary gland, particularly angiogenic regression and the endothelial:parenchymal interplay, are poorly understood. However, the data summarised in this review indicate that precisely these molecular mechanisms offer novel alternatives for specific and effective treatment of breast cancer.

Differentiation of endothelial barrier function during normal angiogenesis requires homotypic VE-cadherin adhesion

Endothelial cells express two principal cadherins: VE-cadherin and N-cadherin. We established previously that only VE-cadherin expression was increased during differentiation of barrier function by angiogenic endothelium of the chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM). Presently anti-VE-cadherin mAb, applied to the CAM at day 4.5 of gestation, served to inhibit the abrupt reduction of macromolecular extravasation that occurs normally at day 5.0. Neither anti-N-cadherin nor nonimmune IgG, on the other hand, prevented this temporal decrease of endothelial permeability. Despite the differential permeability responses, morphometric evaluations defined a reduction of mean paracellular cleft width after the application of either anti-VE-cadherin or anti-N-cadherin. Hence, alteration of molecular sieving characteristics within the junctional clefts, rather than modification of cleft dimensions; likely served as the principal modulator of macromolecular extravasation after inhibition of homotypic VE-cadherin adhesion. These results provide support to the concept that VE-cadherin contributes to the normal differentiation of endothelial barrier function during CAM angiogenesis in vivo.

Histology and ultrastructure of the chorioallantoic membrane of the mallard duck (Anas platyrhynchos)

The histology and fine structure of the chorioallantoic membrane of the mallard duck (Anas platyrhynchos), and the density of vessels per millimeter of membrane were assessed between days 12 and 24 of incubation. Light and transmission electron microscopy of the chorioallantoic membrane of the mallard duck after various days of incubation was carried out. Blood vessels within the mesoderm were counted per millimeter of membrane by light microscopy (40x). The chorioallantoic membrane had three distinct layers from day 12 to 24 of incubation, the chorionic epithelium, the mesoderm, and the allantoic epithelium. After day 12, chorionic epithelium consisted of two layers of flattened, elongated epithelial cells interfaced by numerous desmosomes, and separated from the underlying mesoderm by a basement membrane. At this stage, the allantoic epithelium consisted of a single layer of flattened, overlapping cells. Blood capillaries were observed in the mesoderm close to the chorionic epithelium on days 12 and 13; by day 14, these capillaries were located within the chorionic epithelium, forming a capillary sinus. Between days 14 and 16, the chorion underwent cellular and cytological differentiation into three cell types: capillary covering cells, villus cavity cells, and less differentiated basal cells. The mesoderm was composed of a loose matrix of mesenchymal cells and collagen fibrils through which coursed blood and lymphatic vessels. The vascular density in the mesoderm increased rapidly from 4.2+/-0.6 vessels per mm (n = 12) on day 12 to a maximum of 9.4+/-0.3 vessels per mm (n = 15) by day 16. From day 16, the allantoic epithelium had two to three layers of elongated and overlapping cells. The luminal layer of allantoic epithelial cells had microvillus projections and varying numbers of membrane-bound dense vesicles at all stages from day 12 onward. The histologic and ultrastructural features of mallard duck chorioallantoic membrane from day 12 to 24 of incubation were very similar to those described in the chorioallantoic membrane of the chicken (Gallus gallus) from day 8 to 20 of incubation. Much of the information available concerning the CAM of the chicken also may apply to the CAM of the mallard, with timing adjusted to match the developmental time-frame recorded here.

Intussusceptive angiogenesis: its role in embryonic vascular network formation

Intussusceptive angiogenesis is a novel mode of blood vessel formation and remodeling, which occurs by internal division of the preexisting capillary plexus without sprouting. In this study, the process is demonstrated in developing chicken eye vasculature and in the chorioallantoic membrane by methylmethacrylate (Mercox) casting, transmission electron microscopy, and in vivo observation. In a first step of intussusceptive angiogenesis, the capillary plexus expands by insertion of numerous transcapillary tissue pillars, ie, by intussusceptive microvascular growth. In a subsequent step, a vascular tree arises from the primitive capillary plexus as a result of intussusceptive pillar formation and pillar fusions, a process we termed "intussusceptive arborization." On the basis of the morphological observations, a 4-step model for intussusceptive arborization is proposed, as follows: phase I, numerous circular pillars are formed in rows, thus demarcating future vessels; phase II, formation of narrow tissue septa by pillar reshaping and pillar fusions; phase III, delineation, segregation, growth, and extraction of the new vascular entity by merging of septa; and phase IV, formation of new branching generations by successively repeating the process, complemented by growth and maturation of all components. In contrast to sprouting, intussusceptive angiogenesis does not require intense local endothelial cell proliferation; it is implemented primarily by rearrangement and attenuation of the endothelial cell plates. In summary, transcapillary pillar formation, ie, intussusception, is a central and probably widespread process, which plays a role not only in capillary network growth and expansion (intussusceptive microvascular growth), but also in vascular plexus remodeling and tree formation (intussusceptive arborization).

Increased expression of VE-cadherin correlates temporally with differentiation of a restrictive endothelial barrier during normal angiogenesis in vivo

The purpose of this study was to evaluate temporal expression of VE- and N-cadherins within the angiogenic chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM). Whether their relative patterns of expression changed in conjunction with abrupt differentiation of the restrictive CAM endothelial barrier between days 4.5 and 5.0 of the 21 days gestation was evaluated. Immunoblots against VE-cadherin depicted an increase of VE-cadherin expression between days 4.5 and 5.0, but no change in expression was detected between days 5.0 and 6.0. N-cadherin expression, on the other hand, remained uniform from day 4.5 to day 6.0. Immunogold-labeled anti-VE-cadherin was found exclusively on the CAM endothelium, and principally along the lateral inter-endothelial junctions. Hence, VE-cadherin expression by the angiogenic endothelium was similar to that of adult endothelium. That VE-cadherin expression by the CAM endothelium was increased between days 4.5 and 5.0 serves to suggest a temporal correlation with the ontogeny of restrictive barrier function in angiogenic endothelium in vivo.

Microvessels of the chick chorioallantoic membrane uniformly restrict albumin extravasation during angiogenesis and endothelial cytodifferentiation

The present study served to evaluate extravasation of albumin across the microvascular endothelium of the chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) during the establishment of endothelial barrier functions (days 4.5 to 6.0), during a rapid phase of normigenesis (day 10), and after initiation of endothelial cytodifferentiation (day 14). CAM preparations in shell-less cultures were evaluated by intravital fluorescence confocal microscopy and videodensitometry after microinjections of chicken serum albumin (CSA) conjugated to Fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) (1% in Avian Ringers). At each observed temporal stage, FITC-CSA extravasation from the CAM pre-capillaries, capillaries, and post-capillaries was uniformly negligible. Since the endothelial glycocalyx imparts a net negative luminal charge, impedance of CSA transport by mutual charge repulsion was also evaluated. Accordingly, CAM microvessels were pre-infused with protamine sulfate (100 microliters/ml) to neutralize the negative charge. However, interstitial accumulation of FITC-CSA remained negligible. Thus, the presence of tight junctional clefts and paucity of plasmalemmal vesicles during CAM normigenesis probably serve as the principal morphologic correlates to the observed albumin restriction. Further, the normigenic CAM endothelium presents a more restrictive barrier to macromolecules than that of most angiogenic endothelia.

Independence of metastatic ability and extravasation: metastatic ras-transformed and control fibroblasts extravasate equally well

Escape of cancer cells from the circulation (extravasation) is thought to be a major rate-limiting step in metastasis, with few cells being able to extravasate. Furthermore, highly metastatic cells are believed to extravasate more readily than poorly metastatic cells. We assessed in vivo the extravasation ability of highly metastatic ras-transformed NIH 3T3 cells (PAP2) versus control nontumorigenic nontransformed NIH 3T3 cells and primary mouse embryo fibroblasts. Fluorescently labeled cells were injected intravenously into chicken embryo chorioallantoic membrane and analyzed by intravital videomicroscopy. The chorioallantoic membrane is an appropriate model for studying extravasation, since, at the embryonic stage used, the microvasculature exhibits a continuous basement membrane and adult permeability properties. The kinetics of extravasation were assessed by determining whether individual cells (n = 1481) were intravascular, extravascular, or in the process of extravasation, at 3, 6, and 24 h after injection. Contrary to expectations, our results showed that all three cell types extravasated with the same kinetics. By 24 h after injection > 89% of observed cells had completed extravasation from the capillary plexus. After extravasation, individual fibroblasts of all cell types demonstrated preferential migration within the mesenchymal layer toward arterioles, not to venules or lymphatics. Thus in this model and for these cells, extravasation is independent of metastatic ability. This suggests that the ability to extravasate in vivo is not necessarily predictive of subsequent metastasis formation, and that postextravasation events may be key determinants in metastasis.

Distribution of anionic sites on microvascular endothelium of the chick chorioallantoic membrane

It is generally accepted that luminal surfaces of adult microvascular endothelia present an anionic barrier that limits passage of anionic macromolecules. To assess the ontogeny of the barrier, temporal and spatial expression of endothelial anionic sites was evaluated in the chorioallantoic membrane of chicken embryos from days 4.5 to 18 of incubation. After an initial flush, the vessels were perfused with cationic ferritin (CF, 1.0 mg/ml in PBS) for 2 min. Following a second flush to remove unbound CF, the chick chorioallontoic membranes (CAMs) were fixed and processed for electron microscopy. Continuous CF binding was revealed on the luminal endothelium, the junctional clefts and the plasmalemmal vesicles from days 4.5 to 14. However, by day 18, anionic sites had become discontinuous. Prior perfusion with protamine sulfate abolished CF binding and facilitated native ferritin binding. Further ultrastructural evaluation, using peroxidase labeled LFA lectin, revealed sialic acid moieties in patches on the CAM endothelium. Thus, in early chick embryogenesis, the CAM endothelium displays a continuous pattern of luminal anionic sites comprised in part of sialic acid. As the CAM ages, endothelial anionic sites become reduced. That the expression of endothelial anionic domains remained constant despite changes in CAM microvascular permeability in early development (Rizzo et al., 1995a) serves to suggest a minimal role for anionic domains in the development of microvascular permselectivity during normal angiogenesis.

Embryonic angiogenesis: a review

Supply with nutrients is essential from early embryonic stages onwards. Therefore, circulatory organs form the first functioning organ system. With the exception of the heart, this system is at first formed by only one cell type, the endothelial cell. Emergence, behavior, and differentiation of endothelial cells are discussed in this review. At first, endothelial cells develop from angioblasts (primary angiogenesis/angioblastic development), later they develop from preexisting endothelial cells (secondary angiogenesis/angiotrophic growth). The composition of the extracellular matrix may promote or inhibit angiogenesis. Various growth factors which can be bound to the extracellular matrix may have been found, but only two of them (VEGF, P1GF) seem to influence endothelial cell behavior directly. Heterogeneity and organ-typical differentiation of endothelial cells seem to be dependent on cell-cell signaling within each organ.

Macromolecular permeability of chick wing microvessels: an intravital confocal study

The development of the vertebrate limb requires the formation of a normal vasculature to nurture the soft and hard tissue phenotypes. The pattern of embryonic limb bud vessels has been extensively studied, but little is known about the permeability characteristics of the developing circulation. In the present study, the microvascular endothelial cell phenotype was examined by in vivo confocal microscopy following the systemic injection of a graded series of fluorescent dextrans (40,000, 70,000, 150,000 molecular weight) into chick embryos at stages 21-23 in order to determine how selective is the endothelial lining of microvessels as a partition between the blood vessels and the interstitium. Videodensitometry, over a gray scale range of 0-255, was used to quantitate the amount of tracer found within the interstitial compartment of the limb. The tracers of larger molecular weight (70,000, 150,000) were confined exclusively to the vascular lumina, whereas that of smaller molecular weight (40,000) was found to cause perivascular brightening due to extravasation into the surrounding interstitium. The reported differences in permeability were not dependent upon the stage of the embryo used in this study, but were due to the size of the tracer. These data indicate that embryonic wing microvessels demonstrate permselectivity to macromolecular efflux across the endothelium. The present results provide a basis for additional studies concerned with the dynamic characteristics of the limb microvasculature and challenge our concepts about the role of diffusible morphogens in vertebrate limb development.

Differentiation of the microvascular endothelium during early angiogenesis and respiratory onset in the chick chorioallantoic membrane

The present study served to determine the extent of microvascular endothelial differentiation during early stages of morphogenesis (days 4.5-5.5 of the 21-day incubation) in the chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM). CAM's, which serve as the embryonic lung, were prepared for intravital injections of a graded series of FITC-dextrans and subsequent ultrastructural morphometric analyses of the microvascular units. The precapillary, capillary, and postcapillary microvascular segments presented a continuous endothelium that was substantially thicker than that of adult lung endothelia (DeFouw, 1988). Further, plasmalemmal vesicles were uniformly sparse, while endothelial vacuoles, of variable diameters, were present continuously in the proliferating microvascular units. Average widths and depths of the interendothelial clefts were uniform and suggested complete structural differentiation from the onset of CAM morphogenesis. Based on our recent estimates of CAM microvascular permeability coefficients (Rizzo et al., 1995), the observed endothelial ultrastructure was associated with microvascular selectivity comparable to that of adult pulmonary microvessels (Lanken et al., 1985). Therefore, despite incomplete ultrastructural differentiation of the early CAM microvascular endothelium, these angiogenic microvessels presented adult-like barrier properties. Further they were less permeable than (Wu et al., 1993; Yuan et al., 1993) and ultrastructurally distinct from (Kohn et al., 1992) certain tumorigenic microvessels. Thus, angiogenesis is likely not a routinely homogeneous process, and CAM microvascular permeability characteristics may be teleologically significant.