Self and non-self antigen in diabetic autoimmunity: molecules and mechanisms

No human protein is exempt from bacterial motifs, not even one

The hypothesis that mimicry between a self and a microbial peptide antigen is strictly related to autoimmune pathology remains a debated concept in autoimmunity research. Clear evidence for a causal link between molecular mimicry and autoimmunity is still lacking. In recent studies we have demonstrated that viruses and bacteria share amino acid sequences with the human proteome at such a high extent that the molecular mimicry hypothesis becomes questionable as a causal factor in autoimmunity. Expanding upon our analysis, here we detail the bacterial peptide overlapping to the human proteome at the penta-, hexa-, hepta- and octapeptide levels by exact peptide matching analysis and demonstrate that there does not exist a single human protein that does not harbor a bacterial pentapeptide or hexapeptide motif. This finding suggests that molecular mimicry between a self and a microbial peptide antigen cannot be assumed as a basis for autoimmune pathologies. Moreover, the data are discussed in relation to the microbial immune escape phenomenon and the possible vaccine-related autoimmune effects.

Molecular mimicry: its evolution from concept to mechanism as a cause of autoimmune diseases

On a clonal level, certain antibodies and T cells can interact with dissimilar antigens found in microbes and in host cells. More than 5% of over 800 monoclonal antibodies derived from multiple RNA and DNA viruses, as well as from a large number of T cell clones, engage in such interactions. Several of these cross-reactions, which we termed molecular mimicry, are against unique host proteins involved in autoimmune responses and diseases. Thus, molecular mimicry initiated as a host response to a virus or a microbial infection, but alternatively cross-reacting with an appropriate host-antigen, can be a mechanism for instigating an autoimmune disease. Molecular mimicry provides an explanation for the genetic observation that identical twins rarely manifest the same autoimmune disease and the documented epidemiologic evidence that microbial and/or viral infections often precede autoimmune disorders.

Antigen-based vs. systemic immunomodulation in type 1 diabetes: the pros and cons

In type 1 diabetic patients insulin-producing pancreatic β-cells are destroyed by an orchestrated immune process involving self-reactive auto-antigen-specific CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cells. Efforts to reverse or prevent this destructive immunological cascade have led to promising results in animal models, however, the transition to the clinic has yet been unsuccessful. In addition, current clinical studies lack reliable biomarkers to circumscribe end-point parameters and define therapeutic success. Here, we give a current overview of both antigen-specific and non-specific systemic immunomodulatory approaches with a focus on the therapies verified or under evaluation in a clinical setting. While both approaches have their advantages and disadvantages, rationally designed combination therapies may yield the highest therapeutic efficacy. In order for future strategies to be effective, new well-defined biomarkers need to be developed and the extrapolation process of dose, timing and frequency from in vivo models to patients needs to be carefully reconsidered.

Viruses and autoimmunity

Viruses have been suspected as causes and contributors of human autoimmune diseases (AID), although direct evidence for the association is lacking. However, several animal models provide strong evidence that viruses can induce AIDs as well as act to accelerate and exacerbate lesions in situations where self-tolerance is broken. Many models support the hypothesis by acting as molecular mimics that stimulate self-reactive lymphocytes. Mimicry alone is usually inadequate and with human AID, no compelling evidence supports a role for viruses that are acting as molecular mimics. Alternative mechanisms by which viruses participate in autoimmunity are non-specific, involving a mechanistically poorly understood process termed bystander activation or perhaps viral interference with regulatory cell control systems. This review briefly discusses examples where viruses are involved, taking the viewpoint that molecular mimicry is over emphasized as a critical mechanism during AID pathogenesis.

Viruses and autoimmunity

Viruses have been suspected as causes and contributors of human autoimmune diseases (AID), although direct evidence for the association is lacking. However, several animal models provide strong evidence that viruses can induce AIDs as well as act to accelerate and exacerbate lesions in situations where self-tolerance is broken. Many models support the hypothesis by acting as molecular mimics that stimulate self-reactive lymphocytes. Mimicry alone is usually inadequate and with human AID, no compelling evidence supports a role for viruses that are acting as molecular mimics. Alternative mechanisms by which viruses participate in autoimmunity are non-specific, involving a mechanistically poorly understood process termed bystander activation or perhaps viral interference with regulatory cell control systems. This review briefly discusses examples where viruses are involved, taking the view point that molecular mimicry is over emphasized as a critical mechanism during AID pathogenesis.

Study design of the Trial to Reduce IDDM in the Genetically at Risk (TRIGR)

The hypothesis for this study is that weaning to an extensively hydrolyzed infant formula will decrease the incidence of type 1 diabetes (T1D), as it does in all relevant animal models for the disease. This will be tested in children who carry risk-associated human leukocyte antigen genotypes and have a first-degree relative with T1D. The trial will use a double-blind, prospective, placebo-controlled intervention protocol, comparing casein hydrolysate with a conventional cow's milk (CM)-based formula. A secondary aim is to determine relationships between CM antibodies, a measure of CM exposure, and diabetes-associated autoantibodies. To achieve an 80% power for the detection of a 40% intervention-induced difference in the development of autoantibodies and subsequent diabetes, the study requires 2032 subjects. A multicenter, international, collaborative effort is necessary to achieve recruitment targets. A collaborative international study group of 78 clinical centers in 15 countries has therefore been assembled for this purpose.

Different Diabetogenic Potential of Autoaggressive CD8+ Clones Associated with IFN-γ-Inducible Protein 10 (CXC Chemokine Ligand 10) Production but Not Cytokine Expression, Cytolytic Activity, or Homing Characteristics

Type 1 diabetes mellitus is an autoimmune disease characterized by T cell-mediated destruction of the insulin-producing beta cells in the islets of Langerhans. From studies in animal models, CD8(+) T cells recognizing autoantigens such as islet-specific glucose-6-phosphatase catalytic subunit-related protein, insulin, or glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) are believed to play important roles in both the early and late phases of beta cell destruction. In this study, we investigated the factors governing the diabetogenic potential of autoreactive CD8(+) clones isolated from spleens of NOD mice that had been immunized with GAD65(515-524) or insulin B-chain(15-23) peptides. Although these two clones were identical in most phenotypic and functional aspects, for example cytokine production and killing of autologous beta cells, they differed in the expression of IFN-gamma-inducible protein-10, which was only produced at high levels by the insulin-specific clone, but not by the GAD65-specific clone, and other autoantigen-specific nonpathogenic CD8 T cell clones. Interestingly, upon i.p. injection into neonatal mice, only the insulin B-chain(15-23)-reactive CD8(+) T clone accelerated diabetes in all recipients after 4 wk, although both insulin- and GAD-reactive clones homed to pancreas and pancreatic lymph nodes with similar kinetics. Diabetes was associated with increased pancreatic T cell infiltration and, in particular, recruitment of macrophages. Thus, secretion of IFN-gamma-inducible protein-10 by autoaggressive CD8(+) lymphocytes might determine their diabetogenic capacity by affecting recruitment of cells to the insulitic lesion.

Autoimmune islet destruction in spontaneous type 1 diabetes is not beta-cell exclusive

Pancreatic islets of Langerhans are enveloped by peri-islet Schwann cells (pSC), which express glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) and S100beta. pSC-autoreactive T- and B-cell responses arise in 3- to 4-week-old diabetes-prone non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice, followed by progressive pSC destruction before detectable beta-cell death. Humans with probable prediabetes generate similar autoreactivities, and autoantibodies in islet-cell autoantibody (lCA) -positive sera co-localize to pSC. Moreover, GFAP-specific NOD T-cell lines transferred pathogenic peri-insulitis to NOD/severe combined immunodeficient (NOD/SCID) mice, and immunotherapy with GFAP or S100beta prevented diabetes. pSC survived in rat insulin promoter Iymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (rip-LCMV) glycoprotein/CD8+ T-cell receptor(gp) double-transgenic mice with virus-induced diabetes, suggesting that pSC death is not an obligate consequence of local inflammation and beta-cell destruction. However, pSC were deleted in spontaneously diabetic NOD mice carrying the CD8+/8.3 T-cell receptor transgene, a T cell receptor commonly expressed in earliest islet infiltrates. Autoimmune targeting of pancreatic nervous system tissue elements seems to be an integral, early part of natural type 1 diabetes.

ICA69(null) nonobese diabetic mice develop diabetes, but resist disease acceleration by cyclophosphamide

ICA69 (islet cell Ag 69 kDa) is a diabetes-associated autoantigen with high expression levels in beta cells and brain. Its function is unknown, but knockout of its Caenorhabditis elegans homologue, ric-19, compromised neurotransmission. We disrupted the murine gene, ica-1, in 129-strain mice. These animals aged normally, but speed-congenic ICA69(null) nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice developed mid-life lethality, reminiscent of NOD-specific, late lethal seizures in glutamic acid decarboxylase 65-deficient mice. In contrast to wild-type and heterozygous animals, ICA69(null) NOD congenics fail to generate, even after immunization, cross-reactive T cells that recognize the dominant Tep69 epitope in ICA69, and its environmental mimicry Ag, the ABBOS epitope in BSA. This antigenic mimicry is thus driven by the endogenous self Ag, and not initiated by the environmental mimic. Insulitis, spontaneous, and adoptively transferred diabetes develop normally in ICA69(null) NOD congenics. Like glutamic acid decarboxylase 65, ICA69 is not an obligate autoantigen in diabetes. Unexpectedly, ICA69(null) NOD mice were resistant to cyclophosphamide (CY)-accelerated diabetes. Transplantation experiments with hemopoietic and islet tissue linked CY resistance to ICA69 deficiency in islets. CY-accelerated diabetes involves not only ablation of lymphoid cells, but ICA69-dependent drug toxicity in beta cells that boosts autoreactivity in the regenerating lymphoid system.

Type I diabetes and multiple sclerosis patients target islet plus central nervous system autoantigens; nonimmunized nonobese diabetic mice can develop autoimmune encephalitis

Type I diabetes and multiple sclerosis (MS) are distinct autoimmune diseases where T cells target either islet or CNS self-proteins. Unexpectedly, we found that autoreactive T cells in diabetic patients, relatives with high diabetes risk, nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, and MS patients routinely target classical islet as well as CNS autoantigens. The pathogenic potential of CNS autoreactivity was testable in NOD mice. Pertussis holotoxin, without additional Ags or adjuvants, allowed development of an NOD mouse-specific, autoimmune encephalitis with variable primary-progressive, monophasic, and relapsing-remitting courses. T cells from diabetic donors transferred CNS disease to pertussis toxin-pretreated NOD.scid mice, with accumulation of CD3/IFN-gamma transcripts in the brain. Diabetes and MS appear more closely related than previously perceived. NOD mouse-specific, autoimmune encephalitis provides a new MS model to identify factors that determine alternative disease outcomes in hosts with similar autoreactive T cell repertoires.

Peptide dose, MHC affinity, and target self-antigen expression are critical for effective immunotherapy of nonobese diabetic mouse prediabetes

Cross-reactive T cells that recognize both Tep69 (dominant nonobese diabetic (NOD) T cell epitope in ICA69 (islet cell autoantigen of 69 kDa)) and ABBOS (dominant NOD T cell epitope in BSA) are routinely generated during human and NOD mouse prediabetes. Here we analyzed how systemic administration of these mimicry peptides affects progressive autoimmunity in adoptively transferred and cyclophosphamide-accelerated NOD mouse diabetes. These models were chosen to approximate mid to late stage prediabetes, the typical status of probands in human intervention trials. Unexpectedly, high dose (100 microg) i.v. ABBOS prevented, while Tep69 exacerbated, disease in both study models. Peptide effects required cognate recognition of endogenous self-Ag, because both treatments were ineffective in ICA69null NOD congenic mice adoptively transferred with wild-type, diabetic splenocytes. The affinity of ABBOS for NOD I-A(g7) was orders of magnitude higher than that of Tep69. This explained 1) the expansion of the mimicry T cell pool following i.v. Tep69, 2) the long-term unresponsiveness of these cells after i.v. ABBOS, and 3) precipitation of the disease after low dose i.v. ABBOS. Disease precipitation and prevention in mid to late stage prediabetes are thus governed by affinity profiles and doses of therapeutic peptides. ABBOS or ABBOS analogues with even higher MHC affinity may be candidates for experimental intervention strategies in human prediabetes, but the dose translation from NOD mice to humans requires caution.

Persistent T Cell Anergy in Human Type 1 Diabetes

An anergic phenotype has been observed in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice and some autoreactive T cells from patients with type I diabetes. To better understand this phenomenon, we measured T cell proliferative responses to 10 diabetes-associated and up to 9 control Ags/peptides in 148 new diabetic children, 51 age- and MHC (DQ)-matched siblings (sibs), 31 patients with longstanding diabetes, and 40 healthy controls. Most (78–91%) patient and sib responses to glutamate decarboxylase of 65 kDa (GAD65), islet cell cytoplasmic autoantibody (ICA) 69, diabetes-associated T cell epitopes in ICA69 (Tep69), and heat shock protein (Hsp) 60 involved anergic T cells that required exogenous IL-2 to proliferate. Responses to proinsulin, IA-2 (and tetanus toxoid) required no IL-2 and generated sufficient cytokine to rescue anergic T cell responses. Most new patients (85%) had autoreactive T cells, three quarters targeting more than half of the diabetes Ags. Only 7.8% of the sibs and none of the controls had such multiple T cell autoreactivities, which thus characterize overt disease. Multiple anergic and nonanergic T cell autoreactivities were sustained during 2 yr follow-up after onset and in patients with longstanding (3–26 yr) diabetes. Activated patient T cells survived severe IL-2 deprivation, requiring 20–100 times less IL-2 than normal T cells to escape apoptosis. Diabetic T cell anergy thus persists for decades and is Ag and host specific but not related to disease course. Rescue by IL-2 from bystander T cells and high resistance to apoptosis may contribute to this persistence. These data explain some of the difficulties in the routine detection of disease-associated T cells, and they emphasize challenges for immunotherapy and islet transplantation.

Type 1 diabetes: the facts fit a deficient inhibitory signal given by MHC class II

This paper presents a hypothesis regarding the aetiology of Type 1 (autoimmune) diabetes, which suggests that autoimmunity is normally prevented by an inhibitory or negative signal delivered by MHC molecules, and that in Type 1 diabetes it is the inability of beta cells to deliver sufficient negative signal from MHC Class II that drives the underlying autoimmune process. Based on a broad survey of the diabetes literature, a list of clinical, pathological, experimental and epidemiological 'facts' about Type 1 diabetes is presented which are considered to be widely accepted as proven. The new theory is then compared to other recent theories on the aetiology of diabetes with regard to its ability to explain these accepted 'facts'.

Molecular mimicry and immune-mediated diseases

Molecular mimicry has been proposed as a pathogenetic mechanism for autoimmune disease, as well as a probe useful in uncovering its etiologic agents. The hypothesis is based in part on the abundant epidemiological, clinical, and experimental evidence of an association of infectious agents with autoimmune disease and observed cross-reactivity of immune reagents with host 'self' antigens and microbial determinants. For our purpose, molecular mimicry is defined as similar structures shared by molecules from dissimilar genes or by their protein products. Either the molecules' linear amino acid sequences or their conformational fits may be shared, even though their origins are as separate as, for example, a virus and a normal host self determinant. An immune response against the determinant shared by the host and virus can evoke a tissue-specific immune response that is presumably capable of eliciting cell and tissue destruction. The probable mechanism is generation of cytotoxic cross-reactive effector lymphocytes or antibodies that recognize specific determinants on target cells. The induction of cross-reactivity does not require a replicating agent, and immune-mediated injury can occur after the immunogen has been removed a hit-and-run event. Hence, the viral or microbial infection that initiates the autoimmune phenomenon may not be present by the time overt disease develops. By a complementary mechanism, the microbe can induce cellular injury and release self antigens, which generate immune responses that cross-react with additional but genetically distinct self antigens. In both scenarios, analysis of the T cells or antibodies specifically engaged in the autoimmune response and disease provides a fingerprint for uncovering the initiating infectious agent.

Molecular cloning of murine ICA69: diabetes-prone mice recognize the human autoimmune-epitope, Tep69, conserved in splice variants from both species

The islet cell antigen ICA69 is an autoimmune target in most patients with insulin-dependent diabetes. Understanding its role in diabetic autoimmunity would be facilitated by an animal model. We therefore cloned mouse ICA69. The different splice variants now identified conserve Tep69, the single T cell epitope recognized by patient T cells. We show that diabetes-prone NOD mice had Tep69-specific, autoreactive T cell repertoires and thus provide a relevant model for the study of ICA69's role in diabetic autoimmunity.