Toxicology studies of a chemical mixture of 25 groundwater contaminants. II. Immunosuppression in B6C3F1 mice

Exposure to Trace Elements and Risk of Skin Cancer: A Systematic Review of Epidemiologic Studies

Exposure to environmental trace elements has been studied in relation to many cancers. However, an association between exposure to trace elements and skin cancer remains less understood. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review of published epidemiologic literature examining the association between exposure to trace elements, and risk of melanoma and keratinocyte carcinoma in humans. We identified epidemiologic studies investigating exposure to arsenic, cadmium, chromium, copper, iron, selenium, and zinc and risk of skin cancer in humans. Among the minerals, arsenic, selenium, and zinc had more than five studies available. Exposure to arsenic was associated with increased risk of keratinocyte carcinoma, while too few studies existed on melanoma to draw conclusions. Exposure to selenium was associated with possible increased risk of keratinocyte carcinoma. Studies of zinc and skin cancer were case-control in design and were found to have inconsistent associations. The data on the association between cadmium, chromium, copper, and iron and risk of skin cancer remain too sparse to draw any conclusions. In summary, epidemiologic studies on exposure to trace elements and cutaneous malignancies are limited. Studies with larger sample sizes and prospective designs are warranted to improve our knowledge of trace elements and skin cancer.

Assessment of groundwater quality using DEA and AHP: a case study in the Sereflikochisar region in Turkey

This study investigated the spatial distribution of groundwater quality in Sereflikochisar Basin, in the Central Anatolian region of Turkey using different hydrochemical, statistical, and geostatistical methods. A total of 51 groundwater samples were collected from the observation wells in the study area to evaluate the characteristics of the groundwater quality. As a relatively simple and practical method, a groundwater quality index (GWQI) was developed to evaluate the overall groundwater quality. In this process, complex decision-making techniques such as analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and data envelopment analysis (DEA) were used. Based on these models, two new indices (A-GWQI and D-GWQI) were proposed. According to the D-GWQI score (from 0.6 to 1), water quality was classified in four categories as unsuitable (0.6–0.7), permissible (0.7–0.8), good (0.8–0.9), and excellent (0.9–1). The spatial distribution maps of the groundwater quality were created using the Kriging method. For each map, seven different semivariogram models were tested and the best-fitted model was chosen based on their root mean square standardized error. These maps showed that the areas with high groundwater quality were in the eastern and southern parts of the study area where the D-GWQI scores were greater than 0.8. Depending on the distance from the Salt Lake, the characteristics of groundwater changed from NaCl to NaHCO3 and CaHCO3 facies. This study shows how to determine the spatial distribution of the groundwater quality and identify the impact of salt lakes on the groundwater quality in inland aquifers. The findings of this study can be applied to ensure the quality of groundwater used for drinking and irrigation purposes in the study area.

Melanocytes and keratinocytes have distinct and shared responses to ultraviolet radiation and arsenic

The rise of melanoma incidence in the United States is a growing public health concern. A limited number of epidemiology studies suggest an association between arsenic levels and melanoma risk. Arsenic acts as a co-carcinogen with ultraviolet radiation (UVR) for the development of squamous cell carcinoma and proposed mechanisms include generation of oxidative stress by arsenic and UVR and inhibition of UVR-induced DNA repair by arsenic. In this study, we investigate similarities and differences in response to arsenic and UVR in keratinocytes and melanocytes. Normal melanocytes are markedly more resistant to UVR-induced cytotoxicity than normal keratinocytes, but both cell types are equally sensitive to arsenite. Melanocytes were more resistant to arsenite and UVR stimulation of superoxide production than keratinocytes, but the concentration of arsenite necessary to inhibit the activity of the DNA repair protein poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase and enhance retention of UVR-induced DNA damage was essentially equivalent in both cell types. These findings suggest that although melanocytes are less sensitive than keratinocytes to initial UVR-mediated DNA damage, both of these important target cells in the skin share a mechanism related to arsenic inhibition of DNA repair. These findings suggest that concurrent chronic arsenic exposure could promote retention of unrepaired DNA damage in melanocytes and act as a co-carcinogen in melanoma.

Assessment of the immunotoxic potential of trichloroethylene and perchloroethylene in rats following inhalation exposure

The immunotoxic potential of trichloroethylene (TCE) and perchloroethylene (PERC) was assessed after inhalation exposure through the evaluation of the antibody forming cell (AFC) response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC). Female Sprague-Dawley rats were exposed to TCE or PERC vapor at 0, 100, 300, or 1000 ppm for 6 h/day, 5 days/week for 4 weeks (20 exposure days). Additional 0 ppm control groups were included and were dosed with cyclophosphamide via intraperitoneal injection to serve as positive immunosuppressive controls in the SRBC assay. Additional end-points evaluated included liver, kidney, spleen, and thymus weights, hematology, cellular differentials in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid, histopathology of select tissues, and assessment of the phagocytic activity of pulmonary alveolar macrophage (PERC only). Exposure to the high concentration of TCE (1000 ppm) resulted in increases in relative liver and kidney weights and suppression of AFC responses (AFC/spleen and AFC/10(6) spleen cells) by ≈ 70%, while no treatment-related effects were noted at 100 and 300 ppm. Animals exposed to PERC at levels of 300 or 1000 ppm had statistically significant increases in relative liver weights that were accompanied by very slight hypertrophy of the centrilobular hepatocytes. Animals exposed to PERC did not demonstrate a treatment-related effect on the AFC response and no effect was noted on the phagocytic activity of pulmonary alveolar macrophages. The results of these studies indicate that TCE had immunotoxic potential only at high exposure concentrations (1000 ppm), while PERC, at similar exposure concentrations, did not display any evidence of immunotoxicity.

Review of risk from potential emerging contaminants in UK groundwater

This paper provides a review of the types of emerging organic groundwater contaminants (EGCs) which are beginning to be found in the UK. EGCs are compounds being found in groundwater that were previously not detectable or known to be significant and can come from agricultural, urban and rural point sources. EGCs include nanomaterials, pesticides, pharmaceuticals, industrial compounds, personal care products, fragrances, water treatment by-products, flame retardants and surfactants, as well as caffeine and nicotine. Many are relatively small polar molecules which may not be effectively removed by drinking water treatment. Data from the UK Environment Agency's groundwater screening programme for organic pollutants found within the 30 most frequently detected compounds a number of EGCs such as pesticide metabolites, caffeine and DEET. Specific determinands frequently detected include pesticides metabolites, pharmaceuticals including carbamazepine and triclosan, nicotine, food additives and alkyl phosphates. This paper discusses the routes by which these compounds enter groundwater, their toxicity and potential risks to drinking water and the environment. It identifies challenges that need to be met to minimise risk to drinking water and ecosystems.

Chemical mixture toxicology: from descriptive to mechanistic, and going on to in silico toxicology

Because of the pioneering vision of certain leaders in the biomedical field, the last two decades witnessed rapid advances in the area of chemical mixture toxicology. Earlier studies utilized conventional toxicology protocol and methods, and they were mainly descriptive in nature. Two good examples might be the parallel series of studies conducted by the U.S. National Toxicology Program and TNO in The Netherlands, respectively. As a natural course of progression, more and more sophistication was incorporated into the toxicology studies of chemical mixtures. Thus, at least the following seven areas of scientific achievements in chemical mixture toxicology are evident in the literature: (a) the application of better and more robust statistical methods; (b) the exploration and incorporation of mechanistic bases for toxicological interactions; (c) the application of physiologically based pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PBPK/PD) modeling; (d) the studies on more complex chemical mixtures; (e) the use of science-based risk assessment approaches; (f) the utilization of functional genomics; and (g) the application of technology. Examples are given for the discussion of each of these areas. Two important concepts emerged from these studies and they are: (1) dose-dependent toxicologic interactions; and (2) "interaction thresholds". Looking into the future, one of the most challenging areas in chemical mixture research is finding the answer to the question "when one tries to characterize the health effects of chemical mixtures, how does one deal with the infinite number of combination of chemicals, and other possible stressors?" Undoubtedly, there will be many answers from different groups of researchers. Our answer, however, is first to focus on the finite (biological processes) rather than the infinite (combinations of chemical mixtures and multiple stressors). The idea is that once we know a normal biological process(es), all stimuli and insults from external stressors are merely perturbations of the normal biological process(es). The next step is to "capture" the biological process(es) by integrating the recent advances in computational technology and modern biology. Here, the computer-assisted Reaction Network Modeling, linked with PBPK modeling, offers a ray of hope to dealing with the complex biological systems.

Species differences in the structure and function of the immune system

With the recent publication of regulatory guidelines from both the FDA and the CPMP addressing the investigation of immunotoxicity of new chemical entities has come the requisite increased application of immunotoxicology protocols. Importantly, the fulfillment of these protocols may require the use of different species, and while in many cases information concerning the structure and function of the immune system can be readily translated across species, there are numerous and significant species differences that need to be considered. In some cases, the generation of meaningful immunotoxicology data can be adversely affected by the choice of a species that does not adequately share the immune function of concern with man. Likewise immunotoxicology testing in one species may produce negative data in one species but positive data in another. Knowing the mechanistic basis through an understanding of species differences in the structure and function of the immune system is pivotal to success. This becomes especially true as pharmaceutical companies design and develop highly specific immunomodulatory molecules that demonstrate species-specific pharmacology. This review is an exploration of various species differences in the structure and function of the immune system and an attempt to identify those differences that may be important in the conduct of immunotoxicity tests.

Effects of subchronic exposure to a complex mixture of persistent contaminants in male rats: systemic, immune, and reproductive effects

Human populations throughout the world are exposed daily to low levels of environmental contaminants. The consequences of potential interactions of these compounds to human endocrine, reproductive, and immune function remain unknown. The current study examines the effects of subchronic oral exposure to a complex mixture of ubiquitous persistent environmental contaminants that have been quantified in human reproductive tissues. The dosing solution used in this study contained organochlorines (2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin [TCDD], polychlorinated biphenyls [PCBs],p,p'-dichlorodiphenoxydichloroethylene [p,p'-DDE],p,p-dichlorodiphenoxytrichloroethane [p,p'-DDT], dieldrin, endosulfan, methoxychlor, hexachlorobenzene, and other chlorinated benzenes, hexachlorocyclohexane, mirex and heptachlor) as well as metals (lead and cadmium). Each chemical was included in the mixture at the minimum risk level (MRL) or tolerable daily intake (TDI) as determined by the U.S. EPA or ATSDR or, for TCDD, at the no observable effect level (NOEL) used to calculate the TDI. Sexually mature male rats were exposed to this complex mixture at 1, 10, 100, and 1000 times the estimated safe levels daily for 70 days. On day 71, all animals were sacrificed and a variety of physiological systems assessed for toxic effects. Evidence of hepatotoxicity was seen in the significant enlargement of the liver in the 1000x group, reduced serum LDH activity (100x), and increased serum cholesterol and protein levels (both 1000x). Hepatic EROD activities were elevated in animals exposed to10x and above. The mixture caused decreased proliferation of splenic T cells at the highest dose and had a biphasic effect on natural killer cell lytic activity with an initial increase in activity at 1x followed by a decrease to below control levels in response to 1000x. No treatment-related effects were seen on bone marrow micronuclei, daily sperm production, serum LH, FSH, or prolactin levels or weights of most organs of the reproductive tract. The weights of the whole epididymis and of the caput epididymis were significantly decreased at 10x and higher doses, although no effect was seen on cauda epididymal weight. The sperm content of the cauda epididymis was increased at the 1x level but not significantly different from control at higher dose levels. A slight, but significant, increase in the relative numbers of spermatids was seen in the animals from the 1000x group with a trend towards reduced proportion of diploid cells at the same dose. Only minor, nondose related changes were seen in parameters related to condensation of chromatin, as determined by flow cytometry, in epididymal sperm. We conclude that the mixture induced effects on the liver and kidney and on general metabolism at high doses but caused only minor effects on immune function, reproductive hormone levels, or general indices of reproductive function measures. These data suggest that additive or synergistic effects of exposure to contaminants resulting in residue levels representative of contemporary human tissue levels are unlikely to result in adverse effects on immune function or reproductive physiology in male rats.

Beyond risk: an ecological paradigm to prevent global chemical pollution

Since World War II, synthetic chemical pollutants have accumulated in the environment and food webs on a global basis, have damaged wildlife populations, and may pose large-scale hazards to human health. Despite the global nature of this problem, the vast majority of environmental regulations focus on preventing local risks using risk assessment of individual compounds, discharge permits, and control and disposal technologies. The current approach has failed to prevent global contamination and environmental damage because it underestimates the scale, complexity, and diversity of the hazards of chemical pollution. Fundamental shifts in the mode of chemical assessment and policy are required; a new framework should focus on chemical classes rather than individual substances, convert industrial processes to prevent the production and use of persistent and/or bioaccumulative substances, and shift the default state of pollution policy in the face of uncertainty from permission to restriction.

Indicators of immunotoxicity in populations of cotton rats (Sigmodon hispidus) inhabiting an abandoned oil refinery

Wildlife species inhabiting contaminated sites are often exposed to complex mixtures of chemicals, many of which have known effects on physiological and biochemical function. Although sensitivity of the immune system to chemical exposure has been documented in laboratory animal and wildlife species, little work has been conducted on feral wildlife populations inhabiting contaminated sites. Immune function was measured in populations of wild cotton rats (Sigmodon hispidus) inhabiting replicated reference and contaminated study sites at an abandoned oil refinery in Oklahoma four times from 1991 to 1992. Several measures of immunocompetence were examined including immune organ mass and cellularity, hematology, in vivo hypersensitivity, macrophage function, killer cell activity, and lymphoproliferative responsiveness. In vitro proliferation of splenocytes, either spontaneous or induced with concanavalin A (Con A), was the most consistent and reliable indicator of immunotoxicity. Spontaneous proliferation of splenocytes was 48 and 24% higher for cotton rats collected from contaminated than reference sites in September 1991 and September 1992, respectively. Likewise, Con A-induced proliferation of splenocytes ranged form 20 to 53% higher in animals collected from contaminated than reference sites in three of four collection periods. The percentage of splenocytes (mean+/-SE) staining positive for Con A receptors was lower on contaminated sites (73.7+/-1.2%) than reference sites (77.0+/-1.4%) in September 1991. Other measures of immune function including macrophage metabolism, hypersensitivity, blood cellularity, and mass and cellularity of immune organs varied between contaminated and reference sites.

Endocrine, immune, and behavioral effects of aldicarb (carbamate), atrazine (triazine) and nitrate (fertilizer) mixtures at groundwater concentrations

This paper describes the results of 5 years of research on interactive effects of mixtures of aldicarb, atrazine, and nitrate on endocrine, immune, and nervous system function. The concentrations of chemicals used were the same order of magnitude as current maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) for all three compounds. Such levels occur in groundwater across the United States. Dosing was through voluntary consumption of drinking water. We used fractional and full factorial designs with center replicates to determine multifactor effects. We used chronic doses in experiments that varied in duration from 22 to 103 days. We tested for changes in thyroid hormone levels, ability to make antibodies to foreign proteins, and aggression in wild deer mice, Peromyscus maniculatus, and white outbred Swiss Webster mice, Mus musculus, ND4 strain. Endocrine, immune, and behavior changes occurred due to doses of mixtures, but rarely due to single compounds at the same concentrations. Immune assay data suggest the possibility of seasonal effects at low doses. We present a multiple-level model to help interpret the data in the context of human health and biological conservation concerns. We discuss six testing deficiencies of currently registered pesticides, and suggest areas of human health concerns if present trends in pesticide use continue.

Drinking water contaminants (arsenic, cadmium, lead, benzene, and trichloroethylene). 1. Interaction of contaminants with nutritional status on general performance and immune function in broiler chickens

The objective of this study was to examine possible interactions between drinking water contaminants and suboptimal nutritional status for performance and immune function in male broiler chickens. Experimental drinking water contained a mixture of arsenic, benzene, cadmium, lead, and trichloroethylene (TCE) at low concentrations (0.80, 1.3, 5.0, 6.7, and 0.65 ppm) and high concentrations (8.6, 13, 50, 67, and 6.5 ppm). These chemicals were selected because they are among the most common contaminants found in ground water near hazardous waste sites. The experimental diets included feed containing 50% added vitamins and minerals (V&M) and feed without added V&M. Increasing levels of drinking water contaminants and decreasing levels of V&M in diet resulted in significantly (P < or = 0.05) decreased water and feed intake, decreased weight gain, and suppression of natural, humoral, and cell-mediated immune response. In a paired-water study, feed consumption, body weight, and immune function were decreased in chickens provided low and high concentrations of the chemical mixture in drinking water compared with chickens given control drinking water equal to the volumes consumed by the chickens given the low and high concentration of mixture, respectively. A deficiency of dietary V&M caused increased sensitivity to adverse effects of drinking water contaminants.

Integrated approaches for the analysis of toxicologic interactions of chemical mixtures

Although an overwhelmingly large portion of the resources in toxicologic research is devoted to single chemical studies, the toxicology of chemical mixtures, not single chemicals, is the real issue regarding health effects of environmental and/or occupational exposure to chemicals. The relative lack of activities in the area of toxicology of chemical mixtures does not suggest ignorance of the importance of the issue by the toxicology community. Instead, it is a reflection of the difficulty, complexity, and controversy surrounding this area of research. Until recently, much of the literature on the toxicology of chemical mixtures has been either very focused on certain specific interaction studies or slanted toward broad-based, relatively vague theoretical deliberation. The typical interaction study involved binary mixtures at relatively high dose levels with acute toxicities as endpoints. Although the theoretical papers have been valuable contributions, little is available on actual, practical experimental approaches toward a systematic solution of this immensely complex area of research. We present here a broad discussion on the important issues of the toxicology of chemical mixtures. First, we provide some background information with respect to the problem and significance of toxicology of chemical mixtures in relation to some of the real life issues. Second, we review and compare the existing experimental approaches relevant to toxicologic interactions of chemical mixtures. Third, we propose three integrated approaches that involve the combination of physiologically based pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PBPK/PD) modeling with: (1) Monte Carlo simulation, (2) median effect principle (MEP), and (3) response surface methodology (RSM). These modeling approaches, coupled with very focused mechanistically based toxicology studies, could be the basis for solving the problems of toxicology and risk assessment of chemical mixtures.

Some current approaches for studying combination toxicology in chemical mixtures

Using conventional toxicology methodologies and at the mode and rate of studying chemicals in the last 25 yr, it is doubtful that society will ever have adequate toxicology information on the majority of the chemicals we used now on in the future. Considering further the issue of health effects of chemical mixture exposure (i.e. real-world issues), the problem of not being able to obtain adequate toxicology information is amplified. From a different perspective, concerns over animal rights have raised the consciousness of many biomedical researchers regarding animal experimentation. As many as 17-100 million animals are estimated to be killed for biomedical research in the US alone each year; therefore, minimizing animal usage judiciously in toxicological research should be in the mind of every responsible toxicologist. From these considerations, it is apparent that new, alternative, less animal-intensive, shorter-term and less expensive toxicology methods must be developed if there is to be a reasonable chance to deal with the hundreds of thousand of chemicals, as well as the near-infinite number of chemical mixtures, in the environment. Some of the recent advances indeed are heading towards that direction. In this article, a number of approaches for research work on combination toxicology of chemical mixtures are given; the examples are selected based on one or more of the following criteria: (1) minimizing animal usage; (2) shortening experimental durations; (3) studying environmentally realistic concentrations; (4) utilizing statistical/mathematical modelling; (5) advancing efficient experimental designs and (6) developing predictive toxicology.

1995 STP Young Investigator Award recipient. Increased rate of apoptosis correlates with hepatocellular proliferation in Fischer-344 rats following long-term exposure to a mixture of groundwater contaminants

Apoptosis was evaluated in the livers of Fischer-344 rats following observations of increased hepatocellular proliferation from exposures, at low parts per million (ppm) levels, to a drinking water mixture of 7 groundwater contaminants during a 6-mo time-course study. The 7 chemicals used are among the most frequently detected contaminants associated with hazardous waste sites: arsenic, benzene, chloroform, chromium, lead, phenol, and trichloroethylene. Significant increases in 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine hepatocellular labeling were present in a unique pattern surrounding large hepatic veins (0.5-2.0 mm). This did not appear to be a regenerative response due to cytotoxicity, as assessed by the absence of increased plasma enzyme activity and the absence of hepatocellular lesions. Immunohistochemical staining for apoptosis, using the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP-biotin nick end labeling (TUNEL) method showed patterns of labeling in treated animals that directly correlated to areas of increased hepatocyte proliferation. Apoptotic activity was maximum at the 1-mo exposure time point, whereas proliferating hepatocytes reached a maximum rate at the 10-day time point. This may have been triggered as a compensatory response to the increased cell proliferation or as a protective response to remove cells with altered DNA due to chemical mixture exposure. The principal findings of this paper are that (a) apoptosis directly correlated with changes in cell proliferation: (b) observed effects were produced by repeated exposures to a relatively low-level chemical mixture; and (c) the TUNEL method detected apoptotic cells at very early and late stages, potentially increasing the observable time period for apoptosis.

Postural stability assessment in sewer workers

In this study, postural stability was measured with a microcomputer-based force platform as an indirect assessment of central nervous system effect in 28 sewer workers (age range 23.4 to 64.5 years, standard deviation of 8.7 years). All workers performed four 30-second postural sway tests. The organic-solvent exposure was measured by a photo-ionization detector. The photo-ionization detector was calibrated to measure volatile organic solvents in total benzene equivalence, and concentrations were measured in various parts of the plant. The mean exposure was .32 parts per million (ppm) benzene equivalent (range of .02 to .95 ppm, standard deviation .19 ppm). Based on a covariate adjusted linear multiple-regression model, a statistically significant (p < .05) positive correlation was demonstrated between postural sway and organic-solvent exposure. These workers also had increased postural sway compared with a nonexposed population. The statistically significant correlation between postural sway determinations and organic-solvent exposure was surprising given the very low exposures measured. It is possible that the organic-solvent exposure might not be the causative agent, but rather that the solvents themselves correlate with some other causative exposure, ie, total volatile organics as implicated in the cause of sick-building syndrome.

Chemical mixtures: challenge for toxicology and risk assessment

It is now well-recognized that human environmental exposures are not to single chemicals. Rather, humans are exposed, either concurrently or sequentially, to multiple chemicals. Challenges that chemical mixtures pose for risk assessment and toxicology are presented. Challenge areas include increasing the peer-reviewed publication of human studies, improving access to peer-reviewed data and examining multiple target organs. Two difficult challenges are development of a common, consistent language and the use of appropriate and innovative experimental designs and analyses. The challenge of elucidation of mechanism(s) offers a rational basis for extrapolation across dose levels, exposure durations and exposure routes as well as to other species and to other similar chemicals. Of particular importance is focusing effort on those areas of investigation where answers have the greatest potential for reducing uncertainty in risk assessments for chemical mixtures and on those chemical mixtures and multiple chemical exposures that have the greatest potential impact on human health. A particularly fruitful area for future investigation is determination of the likelihood of nonadditive interactions in humans exposed to multiple chemicals at environmental exposure levels.

The application of physiologically based pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PBPK/PD) modeling for exploring risk assessment approaches of chemical mixtures

When dealing with health impacts of environmental or occupational exposure such as groundwater contamination from or remediation effort associated with hazardous waste sites, we are obviously not facing individual, single chemicals. Thus, we are immediately confronted with the following questions: (1) Is single chemical risk assessment approach applicable to the multiple chemicals in hazardous waste sites? (2) How do we handle risk assessment of chemical mixtures? Although there were pioneering and commendable efforts from the USEPA to formulate guidelines for risk assessment of chemical mixtures, these guidelines were principally based on additivity concept. As new scientific advances are made, improvement and refinement of risk assessment methodology will be anticipated. At Colorado State University (CSU), our research effort is devoted to the challenges and potential applications of physiologically based pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PBPK/PD) modeling in the risk assessment of chemical mixtures. With the ultimate goal of Predictive Toxicology, 3 specific research projects are described: (1) PBPK/PD modeling of toxicologic interactions between trichloroethylene (TCE) and 1,1-dichloroethylene (1,1-DCE) and the investigation and defining of an 'Interaction Threshold'; (2) PBPK/PD modeling of toxicologic interactions between Kepone and carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) and the coupling of Monte Carlo simulation for the prediction of acute toxicity; (3) PBPK modeling of the inhibition of pharmacokinetics and enzyme kinetics of TCE caused by low-level, repeated dosing of a chemical mixture of 7 groundwater contaminants. Since this paper is meant to be a commentary and the emphasis is on approaches for dealing with chemical mixtures, detailed presentation of data is avoided. These examples illustrate partially our ongoing research activities and the related ideas with respect to possible novel risk assessment applications to chemical mixtures.

Toxicology studies of a chemical mixture of 25 groundwater contaminants: hepatic and renal assessment, response to carbon tetrachloride challenge, and influence of treatment-induced water restriction

Because groundwater contamination is an important environmental concern, we examined the hepatic and renal effects of repeated exposure to a mixture of 25 chemicals frequently found in groundwater near hazardous-waste disposal sites and the effect of such exposure on carbon tetrachloride (CCI4) toxicity. Adult male F-344 rats received ad libitum deionized water and feed (Ad Lib Water) or ad libitum 10% MIX (referring to 10% of a technically achievable stock mixture) and feed for 14 d. Because exposure to the 25-chemical mixture via the drinking water resulted in decreased water and feed consumption, restricted deionized water and feed controls (Restricted Water) were included. On d 14, rats were gavaged with 0, 0.0375, 0.05, 0.075 or 0.15 ml CCl4/kg, and hepatic and renal toxicity assessed 24 h later. Little or no hepatic and renal toxicity was observed in rats exposed to 10% MIX alone. No hepatic or renal lesions occurred that could be attributed to 10% MIX alone. Slight but statistically significant alterations, of uncertain biological significance, resulted from the water treatments: 10% MIX increased alanine aminotransferase, urea nitrogen (BUN), and BUN/creatinine ratio; Restricted Water increased 5'-nucleotidase and decreased alkaline phosphatase. Relative kidney weight was increased by both 10% MIX and Restricted Water. CCI4 resulted in significant dosage-dependent hepatotoxicity in all three water treatment groups but had little or no effect on renal indicators of toxicity. Relative to Ad Lib Water, significantly greater hepatotoxicity occurred in both 10% MIX and Restricted Water rats. The response to CCI4 in the Restricted Water rats was similar to that of 10% MIX rats, indicating that a substantial portion of the effect of 10% MIX on CCI4 hepatotoxicity is due to decreased water and feed intake.

Denver Potable Water Reuse Demonstration Project: comprehensive chronic rat study

The health effects testing program for the Denver Water Department's Potable Water Reuse Demonstration Project was designed to evaluate the relative health effects of highly treated reclaimed water derived from secondary wastewater in comparison with Denver's present high-quality drinking water. The 1 x 10(6) gal/day treatment plant provided 500-fold concentrates of water that had been treated by multiple processes to remove microbial and chemical contaminants. Fischer 344 rats were exposed to the complex mixture solutions for up to 2 yr to evaluate chronic toxicity and oncogenicity effects. The following parameters were evaluated: clinical observations, survival rate, growth, food and water consumption, haematology, clinical chemistry, urinalysis, organ weights, gross autopsy and histopathological examination of all lesions, major tissues and organs. Clinical pathology, gross pathology, and microscopic pathology conducted at wk 26 and 65 and at the end of the study did not reveal any findings that could be considered to be treatment related. Administration of drinking water concentrates at up to 500 times the original concentration in the original water samples to F344 rats for up to 104 wk did not result in any overt toxicological or carcinogenic effects.

Groundwater pesticides: interactive effects of low concentrations of carbamates aldicarb and methomyl and the triazine metribuzin on thyroxine and somatotropin levels in white rats

Using full-factorial design experiments for three variables at two levels each and center replicates, we examined the effects of common agricultural carbamate insecticides, aldicarb and methomyl, and a triazine herbicide, metribuzin, on hormone levels in Sprague-Dawley rats. Fifty-four female rats were sampled at 2 and 6 wk during a 6-wk exposure to individual chemicals or to combinations of them. Some main effects and interaction effects were significant. For example, rats treated with the herbicide (metribuzin) were hyperthyroid. The interactions of all three chemicals also significantly increased thyroxine levels. One year later, we repeated these experiments for 16 wk using 54 male rats; the results were very similar. Metribuzin alone significantly increased thyroxine throughout the second study (at 7, 13, and 16 wk). Somatotropin levels were significantly altered after 13 wk of exposure. The same concentrations and mixtures of these three pesticides have now been shown to be implicated in learning impairment and other neurological functions, immune parameter changes, and endocrine changes. These findings support the concept of the interconnectedness of the nervous, endocrine, and immune systems and raise the likelihood of impacts on all three systems if one is shown to be affected. Development, growth, and reproduction all depend on the proper function of these three systems. These results strongly suggest the need to reassess currently allowed "safe" levels of chemicals based on adult dosages that are accepted in ground-water and in our food supplies.

Enhancement of myelotoxicity induced by repeated irradiation in mice exposed to a mixture of groundwater contaminants

As part of a program on the toxicology of chemical mixtures at the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences/National Toxicology Program (NIEHS/NTP), hematopoietic functions were studied in female B6C3F1 mice treated with 0, 1%, and 5% of a chemical mixture stock of 25 groundwater contaminants in drinking water for 31.5 weeks. The toxicologic interaction between continuous exposure to groundwater contaminants and stress induced by multiple irradiation on hematopoiesis was investigated. For those mice receiving both the chemical mixture and irradiation, the exposure to the former was continuous throughout the 31.5-week experimental period, whereas whole body irradiations (4 times at 200 rads/each) were carried out at 7-week intervals with the first one at 3.5 weeks. Myelotoxicity assessment was made by determining the number of granulocyte-macrophage progenitor cells (CFU-GM) 1 week after each irradiation and also at 6 weeks following irradiation as a measure of recovery from stress. Non-irradiated mice treated with 5% chemical mixture solution showed suppression of CFU-GM after 15.5 weeks and became progressively more affected (only 70% of controls by 31.5 weeks of treatment). The population of CFU-GM in mice treated with 5% chemical mixture for 4.5 weeks plus irradiation (1 week after first irradiation) was only 22% of the non-irradiated vehicle control group. This combined (i.e., chemical mixture plus irradiation) suppression of CFU-GM intensified after repeated irradiation until the number of CFU-GM was only 10.7% following the fourth irradiation at 25.5 weeks. Thus, irradiation caused a significant reduction in CFU-GMs in all mice but the effects were more pronounced in mice treated with a chemical mixture.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Toxicology of chemical mixtures: experimental approaches, underlying concepts, and some results

The toxicology of chemical mixtures will be the toxicology of the 1990s and beyond. While this branch of toxicology most closely reflects the actual human exposure situation, there is yet no standard protocol or consensus methodology for investigating the toxicology of mixtures. Thus, in this emerging science, experimentation is required just to develop a broadly applicable evaluation system. Several examples are discussed to illustrate the different experimental designs and the concepts behind each. These include the health effects studies of Love Canal soil samples, the Lake Ontario Coho salmon, the water samples repurified from secondary sewage in the city of Denver Potable Water Reuse Demonstration Plant, and the National Toxicology Program (NTP) effort on a mixture of 25 frequently detected groundwater contaminants derived from hazardous waste disposal sites. In the last instance, an extensive research program has been ongoing for the last 2 years at the NTP, encompassing general toxicology, immunotoxicology, developmental and reproductive toxicology, biochemical toxicology, myelotoxicology, genetic toxicology, neurobehavioral toxicology, and hepato- and renal toxicology.