At least one thalamotelencephalic pathway in cartilaginous fishes projects to the medial pallium

The Independent Evolution of Dorsal Pallia in Multiple Vertebrate Lineages

Comparative neurobiologists have long wondered when and how the dorsal pallium (e.g., mammalian neocortex) evolved. For the last 50 years, the most widely accepted answer has been that this structure was already present in the earliest vertebrates and, therefore, homologous between the major vertebrate lineages. One challenge for this hypothesis is that the olfactory bulbs project throughout most of the pallium in the most basal vertebrate lineages (notably lampreys, hagfishes, and lungfishes) but do not project to the putative dorsal pallia in teleosts, cartilaginous fishes, and amniotes (i.e., reptiles, birds, and mammals). To make sense of these data, one may hypothesize that a dorsal pallium existed in the earliest vertebrates and received extensive olfactory input, which was subsequently lost in several lineages. However, the dorsal pallium is notoriously difficult to delineate in many vertebrates, and its homology between the various lineages is often based on little more than its topology. Therefore, we suspect that dorsal pallia evolved independently in teleosts, cartilaginous fishes, and amniotes. We further hypothesize that the emergence of these dorsal pallia was accompanied by the phylogenetic restriction of olfactory projections to the pallium and the expansion of inputs from other sensory modalities. We do not deny that the earliest vertebrates may have possessed nonolfactory sensory inputs to some parts of the pallium, but such projections alone do not define a dorsal pallium.

Immediate early gene expression related to learning and retention of a visual discrimination task in bamboo sharks (Chiloscyllium griseum)

Using the expression of the immediate early gene (IEG) egr-1 as a neuronal activity marker, brain regions potentially involved in learning and long-term memory functions in the grey bamboo shark were assessed with respect to selected visual discrimination abilities. Immunocytochemistry revealed a significant up-regulation of egr-1 expression levels in a small region of the telencephalon of all trained sharks (i.e., 'early' and 'late learners', 'recallers') when compared to three control groups (i.e., 'controls', 'undisturbed swimmers', 'constant movers'). There was also a well-defined difference in egr-1 expression patterns between the three control groups. Additionally, some staining was observed in diencephalic and mesencephalic sections; however, staining here was weak and occurred only irregularly within and between groups. Therefore, it could have either resulted from unintentional cognitive or non-cognitive inducements (i.e., relating to the mental processes of perception, learning, memory, and judgment, as contrasted with emotional and volitional processes) rather than being a training effect. Present findings emphasize a relationship between the training conditions and the corresponding egr-1 expression levels found in the telencephalon of Chiloscyllium griseum. Results suggest important similarities in the neuronal plasticity and activity-dependent IEG expression of the elasmobranch brain with other vertebrate groups. The presence of the egr-1 gene seems to be evolutionarily conserved and may therefore be particularly useful for identifying functional neural responses within this group.

Neuroecology of cartilaginous fishes: the functional implications of brain scaling

It is a widely accepted view that neural development can reflect morphological adaptations and sensory specializations. The aim of this review is to give a broad overview of the current status of brain data available for cartilaginous fishes and examine how perspectives on allometric scaling of brain size across this group of fishes has changed within the last 50 years with the addition of new data and more rigorous statistical analyses. The current knowledge of neuroanatomy in cartilaginous fishes is reviewed and data on brain size (encephalization, n = 151) and interspecific variation in brain organization (n = 84) has been explored to ascertain scaling relationships across this clade. It is determined whether similar patterns of brain organization, termed cerebrotypes, exist in species that share certain lifestyle characteristics. Clear patterns of brain organization exist across cartilaginous fishes, irrespective of phylogenetic grouping and, although this study was not a functional analysis, it provides further evidence that chondrichthyan brain structures might have developed in conjunction with specific behaviours or enhanced cognitive capabilities. Larger brains, with well-developed telencephala and large, highly foliated cerebella are reported in species that occupy complex reef or oceanic habitats, potentially identifying a reef-associated cerebrotype. In contrast, benthic and benthopelagic demersal species comprise the group with the smallest brains, with a relatively reduced telencephalon and a smooth cerebellar corpus. There is also evidence herein of a bathyal cerebrotype; deep-sea benthopelagic sharks possess relatively small brains and show a clear relative hypertrophy of the medulla oblongata. Despite the patterns observed and documented, significant gaps in the literature have been highlighted. Brain mass data are only currently available on c. 16% of all chondrichthyan species, and only 8% of species have data available on their brain organization, with far less on subsections of major brain areas that receive distinct sensory input. The interspecific variability in brain organization further stresses the importance of performing functional studies on a greater range of species. Only an expansive data set, comprised of species that span a variety of habitats and taxonomic groups, with widely disparate behavioural repertoires, combined with further functional analyses, will help shed light on the extent to which chondrichthyan brains have evolved as a consequence of behaviour, habitat and lifestyle in addition to phylogeny.

Experimental study of the connections of the telencephalon in the rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). II: Dorsal area and preoptic region

In this study and the accompanying article (Folgueira et al., 2004a), the fluorescent carbocyanine dye 1,1'-dioctadecyl 3,3,3',3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate (DiI) was used in fixed tissue to comprehensively analyze the connections of the different regions of the telencephalic lobes and the preoptic region of the rainbow trout. Here, we analyze the connections of the dorsal area (D; pallium) of the telencephalon, and the preoptic region, as well as the telencephalic connections of several structures in the diencephalon and brainstem of juvenile trout. The dorsal plus dorsolateral pallial zone of D (Dd+Dl-d) receives afferents from contralateral Dd+Dl-d, the ventral area of the telencephalon, preoptic nucleus, suprachiasmatic nucleus, medial thalamus, preglomerular complex, anterior and lateral tuberal nuclei, posterior tuberal nucleus, posterior hypothalamic lobe, superior raphe nucleus, and the rhombencephalic central gray and reticular formation, and projects to the central zone of D (Dc), medial thalamus, and some caudomedial hypothalamic regions. The medial zone of D (Dm) maintains reciprocal connections with the preglomerular complex and also receives afferents from the preoptic nucleus, suprachiasmatic nucleus, anterior tuberal nucleus, preglomerular tertiary gustatory nucleus, posterior tubercle, superior raphe nucleus, locus coeruleus, and the rhombencephalic central gray, and reticular formation. Dc receives fibers mainly from Dd+Dl-d, preoptic nucleus, preglomerular complex, and torus semicircularis and projects to several extratelencephalic centers, including the paracommissural nucleus, optic tectum, torus semicircularis, thalamus, preglomerular complex, posterior tubercle nuclei, and inferior hypothalamic lobes. The posterior zone of D (Dp) is mainly connected with the olfactory bulbs, the ventral and supracommissural nuclei of the ventral area (subpallium), the preoptic nucleus, and the preglomerular complex and projects to wide hypothalamic and posterior tubercular regions. The preoptic nucleus projects to the olfactory bulb, to most regions of the telencephalic lobes, and to several diencephalic and brainstem structures. These results reveal complex and specialized connectional patterns in the rainbow trout dorsal telencephalon and preoptic region. Most of these connections have not been described previously in salmonids. These connections indicate that the salmonid telencephalon is involved in multisensorial processing and modulation of brain activity.

Connections of the pallial telencephalon in the Senegal bichir, Polypterus

The connections of the dorsal telencephalon (pallium) of the Senegal bichir (Polypterus senegalus) were investigated in order to test the hypothesis that the simple everted pallium of polypterid fishes is directly comparable to the evaginated pallium of most vertebrates. Neuroanatomical tracers (DiI or biotinylinated dextran amines) were injected into the three traditionally recognized divisions of the bichir pallium to determine their afferent and efferent connections. The connections were corroborated with injections into regions identified as projecting to, or receiving input from, one or more pallial divisions. The results suggest that the bichir pallium consists not of three, but only two primary divisions: a dorsomedial one and a dorsolateral one. This reinterpretation refutes the hypothesis of a direct one-to-one comparison with the tripartite pallium of most vertebrates. Homologues of the bichir dorsomedial and dorsolateral pallium are recognized in the lateral and medial pallium of anuran amphibians, respectively. The pallium of bichirs is compared to that of derived ray-finned fishes as a link between derived ray-finned fishes and other vertebrates. The available information on the connections of the pallium of teleosts suggests that only the olfactory recipient (pars posterior) of the pallium can be directly compared to bichirs and amphibians and that the remaining divisions of the pallium in teleosts are uniquely derived features of the teleost telencephalon.

Changing views of brain evolution

Although brain studies began in ancient Egypt, speculations on vertebrate brain evolution occurred only much later, after the publication of Darwin's Origin of Species in 1859. Subsequently, views of brain evolution have been shaped by a complex interplay of theory and technique. Darwin's theory allowed the variation in brain size and complexity to be re-interpreted within an evolutionary context, albeit an erroneous pre-Darwinian context based on scala naturae. With the development of histological techniques, research shifted to descriptions of cellular structure, cellular aggregates and their putative interconnections. In spite of these technical advances, brain evolution continued to be viewed within the context of scala naturae. Following the publication of The Comparative Anatomy of the Nervous System of Vertebrates by Ariëns Kappers, Huber, and Crosby in 1936, there followed a period of stasis, after which biological views of evolution were radically altered by the confluence of genetics, paleontology, and systematics, termed the Evolutionary Synthesis. Against this background, the development of new experimental techniques for establishing neural connections resulted in a new flowering of comparative neuroanatomy. While comparative descriptive and experimental studies of brain organization continue, the rapprochement of embryology and genetics is fueling a new renaissance that promises to increase our understanding of brain evolution and its genetic basis.

Telencephalic connections in the Pacific hagfish (Eptatretus stouti), with special reference to the thalamopallial system

The pallium of hagfishes (myxinoids) is unique: It consists of a superficial "cortical" mantle of gray matter which is subdivided into several layers and fields, but it is not clear whether or how these subdivisions can be compared to those of other craniates, i.e., lampreys and gnathostomes. The pallium of hagfishes receives extensive secondary olfactory projections (Wicht and Northcutt [1993] J. Comp. Neurol. 337:529-542), but there are no experimental data on its nonolfactory connections. We therefore investigated the pallial and dorsal thalamic connections of the Pacific hagfish. Injections of tracers into the pallium labeled many cells bilaterally in the olfactory bulbs. Other pallial afferents arise from the contralateral pallium, the dorsal thalamic nuclei, the preoptic region, and the posterior tubercular nuclei. Descending pallial efferents reach the preoptic region, the dorsal thalamus, and the mesencephalic tectum but not the motor or premotor centers of the brainstem. Injections of tracers into the dorsal thalamus confirmed the presence of reciprocal thalamopallial connections. In addition, these injections revealed that there is no "preferred" pallial target for the ascending thalamic fibers; instead, ascending thalamic and secondary olfactory projections overlap throughout the pallium. The mesencephalic tectum and tegmentum, which receive afferents from a variety of sensory sources, are interconnected with the dorsal thalamus; thus, ascending nonolfactory sensory information may reach myxinoid pallia via a tectal-thalamic-telencephalic route. A comparative analysis of pallial organization reveals that the subdivisions of the pallium in gnathostomes (i.e., medial, dorsal, and lateral pallia) cannot be recognized with certainty in hagfishes.

The evolution of the dorsal thalamus of jawed vertebrates, including mammals: cladistic analysis and a new hypothesis

The evolution of the dorsal thalamus in various vertebrate lineages of jawed vertebrates has been an enigma, partly due to two prevalent misconceptions: the belief that the multitude of nuclei in the dorsal thalamus of mammals could be meaningfully compared neither with the relatively few nuclei in the dorsal thalamus of anamniotes nor with the intermediate number of dorsal thalamic nuclei of other amniotes and a definition of the dorsal thalamus that too narrowly focused on the features of the dorsal thalamus of mammals. The cladistic analysis carried out here allows us to recognize which features are plesiomorphic and which apomorphic for the dorsal thalamus of jawed vertebrates and to then reconstruct the major changes that have occurred in the dorsal thalamus over evolution. Embryological data examined in the context of Von Baerian theory (embryos of later-descendant species resemble the embryos of earlier-descendant species to the point of their divergence) supports a new 'Dual Elaboration Hypothesis' of dorsal thalamic evolution generated from this cladistic analysis. From the morphotype for an early stage in the embryological development of the dorsal thalamus of jawed vertebrates, the divergent, sequential stages of the development of the dorsal thalamus are derived for each major radiation and compared. The new hypothesis holds that the dorsal thalamus comprises two basic divisions--the collothalamus and the lemnothalamus--that receive their predominant input from the midbrain roof and (plesiomorphically) from lemniscal pathways, including the optic tract, respectively. Where present, the collothalamic, midbrain-sensory relay nuclei are homologous to each other in all vertebrate radiations as discrete nuclei. Within the lemnothalamus, the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of mammals and the dorsal lateral optic nucleus of non-synapsid amniotes (diapsid reptiles, birds and turtles) are homologous as discrete nuclei; most or all of the ventral nuclear group of mammals is homologous as a field to the lemniscal somatosensory relay and motor feedback nuclei of non-synapsid amniotes; the anterior, intralaminar and medial nuclear groups of mammals are collectively homologous as a field to both the dorsomedial and dorsolateral (including perirotundal) nuclei of non-synapsid amniotes; the anterior, intralaminar, medial and ventral nuclear groups and the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of mammals are collectively homologous as a field to the nucleus anterior of anamniotes, as are their homologues in non-synapsid amniotes. In the captorhinomorph ancestors of extant land vertebrates, both divisions of the dorsal thalamus were elaborated to some extent due to an increase in proliferation and lateral migration of neurons during development.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Golgi study of the telencephalon of the small-spotted dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula L

The telencephalon of the small-spotted dogfish, Scyliorhinus canicula L., was examined by Nissl and Golgi-aldehyde techniques. On the basis of differences in perikaryal and dendritic morphology and size, several cell types were distinguished in pallial and subpallial regions, most of them reported here for the first time in elasmobranchs. In the pallium, the pallium dorsalis is the richest in cell types (eight types of neurons), whereas the neuron population of the pallium medialis is the most homogeneous. Dendrites of most neuron types in the pallium are smooth or sparsely thorny. Interestingly, the pallium dorsalis and pallium lateralis contain a type of primitive pyramidal cell characterized by the dense appearance of its thorny dendrites. In the subpallium, the area superficialis basalis contains a heterogeneous population (six types of neurons): large radial cells are the most characteristic cell type. Dendrites of these cell types are smooth or sparsely thorny. The cell populations of the nucleus N are roughly similar to those of the area superficialis basalis, but they lack the large radial cells characteristic of this area. The area centralis subpallialis and striatum consist of populations of small neurons. The regio septalis contains a rather homogeneous population of small cells. The populations in the nucleus entopeduncularis and the nucleus interstitialis of the basal forebrain bundle are the least varied and consist of large radial cells and bipolar cells similar to those of the area superficialis basalis. This investigation reveals important differences in cytoarchitecture that should be useful in the interpretation of immunocytochemical, tracing, and electrophysiological studies of the telencephalon of elasmobranchs.

Cell groups afferent to the telencephalon in a cartilaginous fish (Platyrhinoidis triseriata). A WGA-HRP study

Cell groups projecting to the telencephalon in the guitarfish Platyrhinoidis triseriata were localized by retrograde transport of wheat germ agglutinin-horseradish peroxidase (WGA-HRP) from injections into the basal forebrain bundle. Labeled neurons were observed bilaterally in the dorsal and ventral thalamus, hypothalamus, mesencephalon and rostral rhombencephalon. A comparison of the labeled cell groups to those which project to the telencephalon in terrestrial vertebrates reveals many parallels, including position in the brain, similarities in the afferent connections and immunoreactivity. Further data are needed to decide whether the cell groups in Platyrhinoidis are homologous or homoplasious to their counterparts in land vertebrates.

Electrosensory activity in the telencephalon of the axolotl

Electrical shock of the anterior lateral line nerve evokes slow wave potentials in the contralateral corpus striatum and bilaterally in the medial pallium of the telencephalon of axolotls. The onset latency of the evoked response in the medial pallium (70 ms) is considerably longer than that of the corpus striatum (46 ms). Quasi-natural stimuli, such as weak uniform electric fields (100 microV/cm) or water drops striking the surface of the water surrounding the axolotls elicited evoked potentials or multiple unit activity in the corpus striatum but not in the medial pallium. Striatal responses to weak electric fields have a threshold of approximately 50 microV/cm and habituate at rates higher than 1 every 10 s. Multiple-unit responses in the medial pallium were elicited only by gentle strokes to the snout with a brush, and it is possible that trigeminal fibers were inadvertently stimulated in the nerve shock cases. The discovery that the corpus striatum is a major telencephalic target of electrosensory information rather than the medial pallium as reported in elasmobranch fishes, suggests that there are additional electrosensory telencephalic centers in elasmobranchs and/or that homologous nuclei of the midbrain or thalamus have evolved different projections.

Brain variation and phylogenetic trends in elasmobranch fishes

A cladistic analysis utilizing the out-group criterion to establish the phylogenetic polarity of neural features among living chondrichthyans leads to the conclusion that the earliest chondrichthyans possessed relatively small brains. Relative brain size appears to have increased independently in some myliobatiforms and in the common ancestor of heterodontid and galeomorph sharks. Furthermore, the brains of the earliest chondrichthyans must have exhibited a wide rhomboid fossa of the medulla, an unfoliated cerebellar corpus divided into anterior and posterior lobes, a bilobed and laminated optic tectum with the majority of the cell bodies located periventricularly, a moderately developed midbrain octavolateralis complex, and a telencephalon consisting of sessile olfactory bulbs and paired cerebral hemispheres with extensive lateral ventricles and thin walls. The corpus of the cerebellum has increased dramatically in size and has become complexly foliated independently in some batoids and galeomorph sharks. Similarly, the majority of tectal neurons have migrated away from a periventricular zone in all living elasmobranchs resulting in two distinctly derived patterns, compared to that in holocephalimorphs, but the polarity of these patterns among elasmobranchs is uncertain. The midbrain octavolateralis complex is uniquely derived in all living batoids, but two patterns appear to occur in other chondrichthyans, and, again, their polarity is uncertain. Different portions of the telencephalic roof appear to have hypertrophied in holocephalimorphs, in some batoids, and in some galeomorphs. An examination of pertinent details of chondrichthyan general biology reveals that the biological significance of most chondrichthyan neural trends is unknown.

Immunohistochemical study of the telencephalon of the spiny dogfish, Squalus acanthias

The paucity of experimental data and the differences in telencephalic organization between sharks and other jawed vertebrates have complicated telencephalic comparisons. The distribution of neuropeptides has been extremely useful in recognizing and comparing major subdivisions of the telencephalon among vertebrates. Immunohistochemical techniques were therefore used to study the distribution of substance P (SP), leucin-enkephalin (LENK), and serotonin (5HT), as well as tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), an indicator of catecholamines, in the telencephalon of the spiny dogfish. The distribution of SP and LENK provides a clear distinction between pallial and subpallial portions of the telencephalon. Two regions of the ventrolateral telencephalon, area superficialis basalis and area periventricularis ventrolateralis, exhibit histochemical similarities to the pallidal and striatal subdivisions, respectively, of the basal ganglia in amniotes. Lower densities of LENK+ and SP+ perikarya and fibers occur in the medial pallium and the pars centralis of the dorsal pallium. Similar histochemical traits characterize the sensory thalamorecipient telencephalic structures in amniotes. The lateral pallium in dogfishes is distinguished by the presence of large numbers of TH+ neurons with radially oriented processes. The presence of these distinctive cells also in the medial wall of the rostral telencephalon suggests that the lateral pallium has a medial extension that is situated ventral to the medial pallium. Neurons containing TH were widely distributed in the telencephalon of spiny dogfish and were particularly abundant in the dorsal pallium, olfactory pallium, and area superficialis basalis. It is currently unclear whether these TH+ telencephalic neurons are, in fact, catecholaminergic or merely contain a TH-like substance unrelated to catecholamine synthesis.