Cell allocation in mammalian CNS formation: evidence from murine interspecies aggregation chimeras

Origins, Development, and Compartmentation of the Granule Cells of the Cerebellum

Granule cells (GCs) are the most numerous cell type in the cerebellum and indeed, in the brain: at least 99% of all cerebellar neurons are granule cells. In this review article, we first consider the formation of the upper rhombic lip, from which all granule cell precursors arise, and the way by which the upper rhombic lip generates the external granular layer, a secondary germinal epithelium that serves to amplify the upper rhombic lip precursors. Next, we review the mechanisms by which postmitotic granule cells are generated in the external granular layer and migrate radially to settle in the granular layer. In addition, we review the evidence that far from being a homogeneous population, granule cells come in multiple phenotypes with distinct topographical distributions and consider ways in which the heterogeneity of granule cells might arise during development.

Insights into cerebellar development and connectivity

The cerebellum has a well-established role in controlling motor functions such coordination, balance, posture, and skilled learning. There is mounting evidence that it might also play a critical role in non-motor functions such as cognition and emotion. It is therefore not surprising that cerebellar defects are associated with a wide array of diseases including ataxia, dystonia, tremor, schizophrenia, dyslexia, and autism spectrum disorder. What is intriguing is that a seemingly uniform circuit that is often described as being "simple" should carry out all of these behaviors. Analyses of how cerebellar circuits develop have revealed that such descriptions massively underestimate the complexity of the cerebellum. The cerebellum is in fact highly patterned and organized around a series of parasagittal stripes and transverse zones. This topographic architecture partitions all cerebellar circuits into functional modules that are thought to enhance processing power during cerebellar dependent behaviors. What are arguably the most remarkable features of cerebellar topography are the developmental processes that produce them. This review is concerned with the genetic and cellular mechanisms that orchestrate cerebellar patterning. We place a major focus on how Purkinje cells control multiple aspects of cerebellar circuit assembly. Using this model, we discuss evidence for how "zebra-like" patterns in Purkinje cells sculpt the cerebellum, how specific genetic cues mediate the process, and how activity refines the patterns into an adult map that is capable of executing various functions. We also discuss how defective Purkinje cell patterning might impact the pathogenesis of neurological conditions.

Ribosomal protein L24 defect in belly spot and tail (Bst), a mouse Minute

Ribosomal protein mutations, termed Minutes, have been instrumental in studying the coordination of cell and tissue growth in Drosophila. Although abundant in flies, equivalent defects in mammals are relatively unknown. Belly spot and tail (Bst) is a semidominant mouse mutation that disrupts pigmentation, somitogenesis and retinal cell fate determination. Here, we identify Bst as a deletion within the Rpl24 riboprotein gene. Bst significantly impairs Rpl24 splicing and ribosome biogenesis. Bst/+ cells have decreased rates of protein synthesis and proliferation, and are outcompeted by wild-type cells in C57BLKS<-->ROSA26 chimeras. Bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) and cDNA transgenes correct the mutant phenotypes. Our findings establish Bst as a mouse Minute and provide the first detailed characterization of a mammalian ribosomal protein mutation.

Neural differentiation and incorporation of bone marrow-derived multipotent adult progenitor cells after single cell transplantation into blastocyst stage mouse embryos

Previously we reported the characterization of multipotent adult progenitor cells (MAPCs) isolated from the bone marrow of rodents. In that study, single murine MAPCs derived from ROSA-26, beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal)-positive transgenic mice were injected into E3.5 C57/B16 mouse blastocysts. The resultant chimeric blastocysts were then implanted into pseudopregnant females and were allowed to develop naturally through birth and into adulthood. Chimeric mice were sacrificed 6 to 20 weeks after birth, and were processed for histological analysis. Beta-galactosidase activity was identified in all organs and tissues examined, and tissue-specific differentiation and engraftment was confirmed by colabeling with antibodies that recognize beta-Gal and tissue-specific markers. In the present study we have examined neural engraftment derived from the clonal expansion of a single MAPC during rodent development, and characterized the neural phenotype of MAPCs in the resultant chimeric animals. Donor cell-derived beta-Gal activity was evident throughout the brain. Double and triple immunofluorescent labeling studies revealed MAPC-derived neurons (NeuN/beta-Gal) and astrocytes (GFAP/beta-Gal) in the cortex, striatum, medial septal nucleus, hippocampus, cerebellum, substantia nigra, and thalamus. More specifically, donor-derived neurons contributed to each of the cellular layers of the cortex; the pyramidal and granule cell layers, as well as the hilus, of the hippocampus; Purkinje and granule cell layers in the cerebellum; and GABAergic cells in the caudate and putamen. This study characterizes the potential for MAPCs to differentiate into specific neuronal and glial phenotypes, and to integrate normally during development, after implantation into blastocysts, and provides additional evidence that MAPCs exhibit properties similar to embryonic stem cells.

Clonal architecture of the mouse hippocampus

Experimental mouse chimeras have proven useful in analyzing the cell lineages of various tissues. Here we use experimental mouse chimeras to study cell lineage of the hippocampus. We examined clonal architecture and lineage relationships of the hippocampal pyramidal cells, dentate granule cells, and GABAergic interneurons. We quantitatively analyzed like-genotype cohorts of these neuronal populations in the hippocampus of the most highly skewed chimeras to provide estimates of the size of the progenitor pool that gives rise to these neuronal groups. We also compared the percentage chimerism across various brain structures to gain insights into the origins of the hippocampus relative to other neighboring regions of the brain. Our qualitative analyses demonstrate that like-genotype cohorts of pyramidal cells are aligned in radial arrays across the pyramidal cell layer, whereas like-genotype cohorts in the C-shaped dentate gyrus colonize either the outer shell or inner core of the granule cell layer in a symmetrical manner. Clonally related populations of GABAergic interneurons are dispersed throughout the hippocampus and originate from progenitors that are separate from either pyramidal or granule cells. Granule and pyramidal cells, however, are closely linked in their lineages. Our quantitative analyses yielded estimates of the size of the progenitor pools that establish the pyramidal, granule, and GABAergic interneuronal populations as consisting of 7000, 400, and 40 progenitors, respectively, for each side of the hippocampus. Last, we found that the hippocampal pyramidal and granule cells share a lineage with cortical and diencephalic cells, pointing toward a common lineage that crosses the di-telencephalic boundaries.

The community effect and Purkinje cell migration in the cerebellar cortex: analysis of scrambler chimeric mice

The Disabled-1 protein in mouse is known to be an intercellular signaling component of the Reelin molecular pathway that subserves neuronal migration in several structures in the brain and spinal cord. The scrambler mutant mouse, which is phenotypically identical to the reeler mouse, is due to a mutation in the disabled-1 gene (Howell et al., 1997; Sheldon et al., 1997). The Purkinje cells of the cerebellum express Disabled-1 and experience a massive failure of migration in the scrambler mutant mouse (Howell et al., 1997; Sheldon et al., 1997; Gallagher et al., 1998; Rice et al., 1998). We sought to define the developmental basis of this mutation by studying the Purkinje cell population in experimental mouse aggregation chimeras using a cell marker that permitted the identification of neurons derived from the mutant lineage. We found that a genetically normal component to the environment cannot assist scrambler mutant Purkinje cells in the migratory process. However, the presence of a mutant component to the environment can cause the ectopia of wild-type Purkinje cells. There appears to be a linear relationship between the percentage of the cerebellum that is genetically mutant and the number of wild-type Purkinje cells that express a mutant phenotype. These studies point to the interplay between cell-intrinsic and cell-extrinsic properties in the migration of neurons to form laminated structures during CNS development.

The development of neural stem cells

The discovery of stem cells that can generate neural tissue has raised new possibilities for repairing the nervous system. A rush of papers proclaiming adult stem cell plasticity has fostered the notion that there is essentially one stem cell type that, with the right impetus, can create whatever progeny our heart, liver or other vital organ desires. But studies aimed at understanding the role of stem cells during development have led to a different view - that stem cells are restricted regionally and temporally, and thus not all stem cells are equivalent. Can these views be reconciled?

Granule cells and cerebellar boundaries: analysis of Unc5h3 mutant chimeras

Mutations in the Unc5h3 gene, a receptor for the netrin 1 ligand, result in abnormal migrations of both Purkinje and granule cells to regions outside the cerebellum and of granule cells to regions within the cerebellum. Because both Purkinje and granule cells express this molecule, we sought to determine whether one or both of these cell types are the primary target of the mutation. Chimeric mice were made between wild-type ROSA26 transgenic mouse embryos (whose cells express beta-galactosidase) and Unc5h3 mutant embryos. The resulting chimeric brains exhibited a range of phenotypes. Chimeras that had a limited expression of the extracerebellar phenotype (movement of cerebellar cells into the colliculus and midbrain tegmentum) and the intracerebellar phenotype (migration of granule cells into white matter) had a normal-appearing cerebellum, whereas chimeras that had more ectopic cells had attenuated anterior cerebellar lobules. Furthermore, the colonization of colliculus and midbrain tegmentum by cerebellar cells was not equivalent in all chimeras, suggesting different origins for extracerebellar ectopias in these regions. The granule cells of the extracerebellar ectopias were almost entirely derived from Unc5h3/Unc5h3 mutant embryos, whereas the ectopic Purkinje cells were a mixture of both mutant and wild-type cells. Intracerebellar ectopias in the chimera were composed exclusively of mutant granule cells. These findings demonstrate that both inside and outside the cerebellum, the granule cell is the key cell type to demarcate the boundaries of the cerebellum.

Granule cell dispersion is restricted across transverse boundaries in mouse chimeras

The granular layer of the developing and adult cerebellum is marked by the presence of several transverse boundaries, revealed in gene expression patterns or as a consequence of genetic mutations. It is unclear whether these boundaries represent fundamental differences between granule cell populations or if they are a secondary response to regional differences in the underlying Purkinje cells. One possibility is that boundaries mark different spatial domains of granule cells in a lineage-dependent fashion. To test this hypothesis, we have analysed a series of murine embryonic stem cell chimeras marked by the constitutive expression of beta-galactosidase in donor granule cells. The chimeras show a consistent spatial restriction boundary, located in the granular layer of lobule VI in the vermis and extending laterally into crus I of the hemispheres. A second boundary was found separating lobules IX and X in the vermis. No correlation was found between the genotypes of molecular layer interneurons and the underlying granule cells, suggesting that they arise independently. No transverse boundaries were observed for the molecular layer interneurons, consistent with the hypothesis that they are not generated from precursors in the external granular layer. These results indicate that the granular layer of the cerebellum comprises cellular domains with different histories separated by consistent spatial restriction boundaries.

Novel receptor protein tyrosine phosphatase (RPTPrho) and acidic fibroblast growth factor (FGF-1) transcripts delineate a rostrocaudal boundary in the granule cell layer of the murine cerebellar cortex

We have identified a novel receptor-like protein tyrosine phosphatase (RPTPrho) transcript whose expression in the cerebellar cortex is restricted to the granule cell layer of lobules 1-6. Acidic fibroblast growth factor (FGF-1) mRNA follows a similar cerebellar expression pattern. Together, the two markers define a sharp boundary in lobule 6, slightly caudal to the primary fissure. Anterior and posterior compartments became discernible only during postnatal weeks two and six, for RPTPrho and FGF-1, respectively. A rostrocaudal boundary in lobule 6 of the murine cerebellar cortex has also been identified morphologically by the effects of the meander tail mutation. The position of the RPTPrho and FGF-1 boundary on the rostrocaudal axis of the cerebellar cortex was close to, but not coincident with, the caudal extent of the disorganized anterior lobe of meander tail and the rostral extent of Otx-2 expression. The restricted pattern of FGF-1 and RPTPrho implies that these molecules may have specific signaling roles in the tyrosine phosphorylation/dephosphorylation pathway in the anterior compartment of the adult cerebellar cortex.

meander tail acts intrinsic to granule cell precursors to disrupt cerebellar development: analysis of meander tail chimeric mice

The murine mutation meander tail (gene symbol: mea) causes a near-total depletion of granule cells in the anterior lobe of the cerebellum, as well as aberrantly located Purkinje cells with misoriented dendrites and radial glia with stunted processes. Whether one, two or all three of these cell types is the primary cellular target(s) of the mutant gene is unknown. This issue is addressed by examining cerebella from adult chimeras in which both the genotype and phenotype of individual cells are marked and examined. From this analysis, three novel observations are made. First, genotypically mea/mea Purkinje cells and glial cells exhibit normal morphologies in the cerebella of chimeric mice indicating that the mea gene acts extrinsically to these two cell populations. Second, few genotypically mea/mea granule cells are present in the anterior lobe or, unexpectedly, in the posterior lobe. These findings indicate that the mea gene acts intrinsically to the granule cell or its precursors to perturb their development. Third, there are near-normal numbers of cerebellar granule cells in the chimeric cerebellum. This result suggests that mea/mea cells are out-competed and subsequently replaced by an increased cohort of wild-type granule cells resulting from an upregulation of wild-type granule cells in the chimeric environment. We propose that the wild-type allele of the mea gene is critical for the developmental progression of the early granule cell neuroblast.

Quantitative and spatial information on the composition of chimaeric fetal mouse eyes from single histological sections

The spatial distribution of cells in chimaeric tissues, composed of two genotypes, provides insights into the extent of cell mixing during development and growth. However, direct measurement of patch sizes is not usually meaningful because, when the proportion of one genotype is high, a single patch may encompass several adjacent coherent clones of like genotype (clone aggregation). Two previously used methods of comparing patch lengths were evaluated to overcome this problem. The corrected mean patch length (corrected for the predicted effects of random clone aggregation) is a more useful summary statistic than the median patch length of the minor genotype, because its use is not restricted to grossly unbalanced chimaeras, but its validity has been questioned. The two methods gave almost identical numerical summaries of patch sizes in the retinal pigment epithelium of fetal chimaeras, thereby validating the use of the corrected mean patch length for this tissue. The present study also showed that the corrected patch length was unaffected by the presence of cells hemizygous for the TgN(Hbb-b1)83Clo transgene and that the proportion of pigmented cells in a single histological section was representative of the overall composition of the chimaeric fetus.

Restrictive clonal allocation in the chimeric mouse brain

Whether, and to what extent, lineage restriction contributes to the organization of the mammalian brain remains unclear. Here we address this issue by examining the distribution of clonally related cells in chimeric mice generated by injecting genetically tagged embryonic stem (ES) cells into blastocyst embryos. Our examination of postnatal chimeric brains revealed that the vast majority of labeled ES cell descendents were confined within a different subset of brain regions in each animal. Moreover, the deployment of labeled cells in different brain regions was distinctive. The pattern of ordered and binomial colonization suggested that early diversified founder cells may constrain the fates of their descendants through a restriction of dispersion. In addition, the symmetrical distribution of ES cell descendants suggests that bilaterally corresponding structures may arise from a common set of progenitor cells. Finally, clones of cells formed a continuous band within the deep strata of the neocortex. This later finding in conjunction with the radial distribution of clones in remaining layers observed in previous studies indicates that the cerebral neocortex may derive from two groups of founder cells, which is consistent with the hypothesis of dual phylogenetic origins of the mammalian cerebral cortex.

Analysis of gene action in the meander tail mutant mouse: examination of cerebellar phenotype and mitotic activity of granule cell neuroblasts

The meander tail (mea) gene results in a stereotypic pattern of cerebellar abnormalities, most notably the virtual depletion of granule cells in the anterior lobe of the cerebellum. The causal basis of this mutation is unknown. In this paper we have taken a three-part approach to the analysis of mea gene action. First, we quantitatively determined the effect of the mea gene on granule cell and Purkinje cell number. We found, in addition to the marked depletion of anterior lobe granule cells ( > 90%), there were also significantly fewer granule cells in the posterior lobe (20-30%) without a concomitant loss of Purkinje cells. Second, we explored the relationship between granule cell depletion caused by the mea gene and by the mitotic poison, 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine (FdU). Prenatal and postnatal ICR mice were treated with FdU to ascertain the regimen that best produces a meander tail-like cerebellar phenotype. The similarity of the effects of the mea gene and injections of FdU at E17 and PO suggests the hypothesis that the mea gene acts to disrupt the cell cycle of cerebellar granule cell precursors. Thus, the third part of this study was to test this hypothesis by using injections of either BrdU (5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine) or 3H-thymidine into homozygous and heterozygous meander tail littermates at E17 or PO. After processing the tissue for BrdU immunocytochemistry or 3H-thymidine autoradiography, counts were made of the number of labeled and unlabeled external granule layer (EGL) cells to determine the percentage that had incorporated the mitotic label (labeling index). No difference in the labeling index was found between homozygous meander tail mice and normal, heterozygous littermate controls. Therefore, the mitotic activity of the EGL neuroblasts is not disrupted by the mea gene. Furthermore, while a mitotic poison can produce a phenotype similar to the action of the mea gene, mea is phenomenologically different from FdU treatment.

Separation of activation and pattern in grooming development of weaver mice

The effects of environmental conditions and age on grooming behavior were examined in weaver mutant mice and control littermates. Due to deficits in both the cerebellum and the dopaminergic system, weaver mice provide an opportunity to investigate how both of these systems are involved in grooming. Although homozygous weaver (wv/wv mice display deficiencies in grooming behavior, our results indicate that these effects are both context and age dependent. Overall wv/wv mice spent less time grooming than did controls. However, during the post-swim period wv/wv, after day 13, reached the grooming levels of pre-swim control mice. After day 15 wv/wv mice showed a higher number of post-swim grooming bouts relative to pre-swim, and in fact exceeded the number of bouts performed by controls in either pre- or post-swim conditions. Although controls displayed longer bouts than mutants overall, during the post-swim period wv/wv mice, after day 13, produced bouts as long as the control animals did pre-swim. This could in part reflect activation by previous swimming. Our data indicate these activational effects can be separated from balance or posture problems. From examination of the individual grooming stroke types used by the two groups, it is evident that the strokes used by mutant animals clustered around the early grooming sequence phase. In contrast, some of the later strokes were never used by the wv/wv mice during the entire developmental period studied. Our results emphasize the importance of using multiple measures of an action sequence and testing under different conditions.

Clonal architecture of the mouse retina

The study of chimeric retinas has yielded insight on the early development of retina. The close match in chimerism ratios between right and left retinas is significant and supports the idea that both retinas originate from a common population of progenitors. We are able to estimate numbers of progenitor cells that contribute to the formation of the retina and the approximate time at which this small group is isolated from surrounding prosencephalic cell fields. These cells undergo at least five rounds of division before the first retinal neurons are generated. The mouse retina is not build from the center outward. There is simultaneous expansion and differentiation in all parts of the retina and as a result clones are not arranged in wedges. Instead the mouse retina is a patchwork of clones that do not differ greatly in size from center to periphery. The most consistent radial feature in mouse retina is a raphe left at the line of fusion of the margins of the ventral fissure. Processes that shape the clonal patchwork are both passive and active, intrinsic and extrinsic. Certain features of the clonal architecture of the retina, such as the size differences of clones are primarily passive responses to extrinsic forces on progenitor cells and their progeny. The fifteen-fold range in the size of cohorts is not due to intrinsic differences in the proliferative capacity of individual progenitor cells, but is due to the extent of cell movement and mixing at early stages of development. In contrast, active or intrinsic processes are illustrated by the partial (and still controversial) restriction of retinal progenitors, the possible clonal differences between ganglion cells with crossed and uncrossed projections, and the consistent differences in ratios of albino and pigmented genotypes in peripheral and central retina.

Getting there and being there in the cerebral cortex

The mammalian neocortex is composed of functional areas that are specified to process particular aspects of information. How is this specification achieved during development? Since cells migrate to their final positions in the developing nervous system, a central issue is the relation between cellular migration and positional information. This review combines evidence for early positional specification in the developing cortex with evidence for cellular dispersion during migration. A model is suggested whereby stable cues provide positional information and minorities of 'displaced' cells are respecified accordingly. Comparison with other parts of the CNS reveals that cellular dispersal is ubiquitous and has to be included in any mechanism relaying positional specification. Ontogenetic and phylogenetic considerations suggest that radial glial cells might provide the positional information in the developing nervous system.

Chick/quail chimeras with partial cerebellar grafts: an analysis of the origin and migration of cerebellar cells

Chick/quail chimeras with partial cerebellar grafts have been performed to obtain further information about the origin and migratory movements of cerebellar cortical neurons. The grafts were performed by exchanging between these two species a precise, small portion of the E2 cerebellar primordium, as defined in Martinez and Alvarado-Mallart (Eur. J. Neurosci. 1:549-560, 1989). All grafts were done unilaterally. The chimeric cerebella, fixed at various developmental stages, were analyzed in serial Feulgen-stained preparations to map the distribution of donor and host cells in the ependymal layer (considered to be reminiscent of the primary germinative neuroepithelium) and in the various cortical layers. In some of the oldest cases, we also used antiquail immunostaining to recognize quail cells. In the ependymal layer, it has been possible to conclude that each hemicerebellar primordium undergoes a morphogenetic rotation that changes its rostrocaudal axis to a rostromedio-caudolateral direction. However, important individual variations were observed among the chimeric embryos with respect to the ependymal area expected to be formed by donor cells. These variations cannot be explained solely on the basis of microsurgical procedure; however, they suggest the existence of important reciprocal interaction between host and grafted neuroepithelia. Therefore, it was not possible to draw a precise fate map of the E2 cerebellar primordium. Nevertheless, the dispersion of grafted cells in the cerebellar cortex, when compared to the real extent of the ependymal grafted area in each particular case, provided important data: (1) The external granular layer (EGL), the secondary germinative epithelium, seems not to originate exclusively from the "germinative trigone," as is usually considered the case. It emerges from a larger but restricted portion of the primary cerebellar matrix extending about the caudal fourth or third of the ventricular epithelium, as defined after its morphogenetic rotation. (2) The Purkinje cells (PCs) develop from all areas of the cerebellar epithelium. Although the distribution of donor PCs parallels the grafted ventricular layer mediolaterally, donor PCs extend more in the rostrocaudal dimension. The PC layer is formed mainly by donor cells in the lobules underlain by the grafted ependymal layer. However, donor PCs are also observed in cortical lobules surmounting the host ventricular layer. In these lobules, the donor PCs form clusters of various widths interrupting the host PCs. Reciprocally, clusters of host PCs are also found in the lobules formed mainly by donor PCs. The alternate small clusters of donor or host PCs are surrounded by Bergmann fibers of the other species' origin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Lineage versus environment in embryonic retina: a revisionist perspective

The idea that microenvironmental cues act alone late in development to determine a cell's phenotype has dominated recent discussion of, retinal development, and has successfully displaced the notion of any role for cell lineage in the process of cell determination. We argue that there is, in fact, evidence favoring a degree of lineage restriction during the development of the vertebrate retina. We propose that environmental factors modulate a process of progressive lineage restriction. In this model, progenitor cells are viewed as having unequal potential, and their progeny are viewed as being committed to one of the major retinal cell classes before the stage at which they become postmitotic.

Cell mixing in the spinal cords of mouse chimeras

With the aim of determining whether there is significant cell mixing during development of the spinal cord, experimental chimeric mice containing two genetically distinct cell populations were produced by aggregating BALB/c or BALB/c x LPT hybrid embryos with C3H/HeN embryos. The BALB/c and LPT hybrid spinal cord cells were distinguished histochemically from the C3H/HeN spinal cord cells by using beta-glucuronidase as an independent cell genotype marker. BALB/c and LPT hybrid cells have high levels of beta-glucuronidase activity, while the C3H/HeN cells have low levels. The spinal cords of the chimeras were dissected out regionally (i.e., cervical, thoracic, and lumbar areas) and were sectioned serially. Each region was then analyzed by scoring large- and medium-sized neuronal cell bodies (greater than or equal to 10 microns) whose genotypes were distinguished by their beta-glucuronidase levels. Observations of seven chimeric mice, with coat colors that varied from one extreme (5% albino) to the other (90% albino), suggest that each chimeric spinal cord is a relatively homogeneous population throughout its length. On average only 4 to 5 percentage point differences were observed when comparing left-right, cranial-caudal, and dorsal-ventral regions within a given chimera. The cell mixing, however, is not total, and regional variations were noted. Maximum left-right differences between different spinal cord levels never exceeded 18 percentage points, while in the entire cord the maximum left-right difference was 11 percentage points. When considering dorsal-ventral differences, 18 and 15 percentage points were observed within the spinal cord levels and the entire cord, respectively. However, when comparisons were made between smaller subregions (e.g., right-dorsal-cervical vs left-ventral-lumbar), larger differences of up to 30 percentage points were observed. In addition, the genotype proportions in the spinal cord were closely correlated with the visually estimated proportions of coat color genotypes.

Structure of clonal and polyclonal cell arrays in chimeric mouse retina

One of the most striking results of recent cell-lineage studies of vertebrate retina is the marked variability in the size and types of clones marked by retroviral transfection and dye injection of embryonic progenitor cells. Is this variability due to microenvironmental modulation of cell determination, to lineage restriction, or to experimental perturbation of the progenitor cells? We have taken advantage of species-specific DNA probes to mark groups of lineage-related cells in experimental mouse chimeras. This method of marking cells has two distinct advantages over previous methods: direct manipulation of progenitor cells is avoided, and clones are established at an earlier stage of retinal development. The most notable feature of retinal cohorts in chimeras is their structural uniformity--each is a solid radial array that contains the same ratio of major cell types as the retina itself. This is true even of the smallest monoclonal cohorts, which contain fewer than 200 cells. Our results provides compelling empirical support for the hypothesis that the murine retina is made up of hundreds of relatively homogeneous radial units, each derived from single retinal precursor cells. This finding is inconsistent with micro-environmental modulation of clone structure early in development. We raise the possibility that the heterogeneity among clones marked by dye injection and transfection is due to progressive lineage restriction or to experimental perturbation of the retinal progenitor cells.

Neuronal precursor cells in the rat hippocampal formation contribute to more than one cytoarchitectonic area

We have tested the hypothesis that cell lineage restriction boundaries define the borders between cytoarchitectonic areas in the cerebral cortex. Clonally related cells were identified using a retroviral marking technique, and the dispersion of neuronal clones was examined with respect to the transitions between cortical areas. We chose to study the hippocampal formation because we found that clones of hippocampal neurons, unlike those in neocortex, are compact and readily identifiable in the adult and that transitions between areas in the hippocampus are sharp relative to the spread of a typical clone. We conclude, contrary to the hypothesis, that clones of neurons transgress the boundaries between areas in the hippocampal formation, that border-crossing clones are observed as frequently as would be expected if clones spread freely over the hippocampus with no constraint imposed by area borders, and that different types of pyramidal neurons, characteristic of different areas, may appear to a single clone. different areas, may appear in a single clone.

Cell lineage and cell migration in the developing cerebral cortex

Modern techniques which trace lineages of individual progenitor cells have provided some clues about the processes that determine cell fate in the brain, and have also given us some information about migratory patterns of clonally related cells. In many parts of the central nervous system, progenitors are multipotent; single clones can contain multiple neuronal types or even mixtures of neurons and glia. In addition, one can observe a wide distribution in clone size, even when marking is done in a narrow time window. This suggests that progenitor cells may be fairly plastic and responsive to environmental signals. In the developing cortex, clonally related cells are initially grouped near each other, as in the retina and tectum. However, the subsequent migration of these cells from the ventricular zone to the cortex along glial fibers is accompanied by a progressive dispersion of clonally related neurons.

Neuronal lineages in chimeric mouse forebrain are segregated between compartments and in the rostrocaudal and radial planes

On the basis of neuronal phenotypes and the mode of development of the mammalian forebrain, the cerebral cortex can be subdivided into deep versus superficial layers, and the striatum into patch versus matrix compartments. Interspecific chimeric Mus musculus----Mus caroli mice were used to determine the contribution of lineage to cellular position within these forebrain compartments. Statistical analysis revealed evidence of both spatial and compartmental lineage segregation. A significant difference in genotype ratio depending on chimeric specimen was observed between areas (regardless of compartment) that were separated by greater than 300 microns in the rostrocaudal plane. Differences were observed between early-born (striatal patch and deep cortex) versus late-born (striatal matrix and superficial cortex) neurons, but not between neurons of cortex as a whole versus neurons of striatum as a whole. The difference between early- and late-born neurons was primarily due to the difference between deep and superficial cortical neurons. On a finer scale of analysis, differences in genotype ratios were seen between radially aligned deep versus superficial cortical compartments, in both the neuronal and glial populations. This evidence is consistent with an early positional and compartmental segregation of forebrain progenitor cells.

Patterns of cell lineage in the cerebral cortex reveal evidence for developmental boundaries

Experimental aggregation chimeric mice offer a perspective on cell lineage relationships that is complementary to that of prospective tracing methods such as dye injections or recombinant retroviruses. To create a lineage map of cerebral cortex, the position and genotype of cortical neurons in three-dimensional space were reconstructed with the aid of a computer-assisted mapping system. Chi-square statistical analyses indicate that the spatial distribution of cell lineages in the cerebral cortex is highly nonrandom. When individual dimensions are analyzed separately, a high degree of order is found in the spatial distribution of neuronal genotype ratios in the anterior-posterior dimension but not in the medial-lateral dimension. This suggests an arrangement of lineage-related neurons into "slabs" or "stripes" of cells that are organized in the plane perpendicular to the neuraxis. Additionally, a highly significant variation in genotype ratios was found in the radial dimension (i.e., among cortical cell layers). These data suggest the hypothesis that separate sets of progenitor cells give rise to the superficial and deep layers of cortex. Taken together, our data are consistent with a picture of the developing nervous system in which early developmental restrictions to cell mixing set up boundaries that may be of considerable developmental genetic importance.