Fatigue performance of additively manufactured meta-biomaterials: The effects of topology and material type

Optimization of functionally graded solid-network TPMS meta-biomaterials

The current study enhances the performance of solid-network triply periodic minimal surface (TPMS) cellular materials through using cell size grading along with the Taguchi method. Cell size grading is a novel technique used to control the size of pores and the surface area without changing the relative density. In this context, experimental compression testing was conducted on six distinct geometries of cell size graded TPMS structures (Diamond, Fischer-Koch S, Gyroid, IWP, Primitive, and Schoen-F-RD) manufactured with dental resin using a masked stereolithography (MSLA) printer. The findings indicated that mean total energy absorption was greater for smaller initial cell sizes (4 and 6 mm) compared to larger sizes (12 mm). Consistent patterns were also observed with respect to final cell sizes. Upon examination of the stress-strain relationships between D and I-WP, it is evident that D exhibits a higher initial peak stress point. However, subsequent to a significant decline, it exhibits a tremendous degree of volatility before recovering. Conversely, I-WP demonstrated greater stability throughout the experiments, with a notably greater maximum stress effect. A significant influence was observed from the initial cell size on stress, with larger sizes leading to a reduction in absorbed energy. The acquired results serve as an essential basis for the identification of optimized designs that may be implemented to enhance the structures' durability.

Research Progress on Laser Powder Bed Fusion Additive Manufacturing of Zinc Alloys

Zinc, along with magnesium and iron, is considered one of the most promising biodegradable metals. Compared with magnesium and iron, pure Zn exhibits poor mechanical properties, despite its mild biological corrosion behavior and beneficial biocompatibility. Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF), unlike traditional manufacturing techniques, has the capability to rapidly manufacture near-net-shape components. At present, although the combination of LPBF and Zn has made great progress, it is still in its infancy. Element loss and porosity are common processing problems for LPBF Zn, mainly due to evaporation during melting under a high-energy beam. The formation quality and properties of the final material are closely related to the alloy composition, design and processing. This work reviews the state of research and future perspective on LPBF zinc from comprehensive assessments such as powder characteristics, alloy composition, processing, formation quality, microstructure, and properties. The effects of powder characteristics, process parameters and evaporation on formation quality are introduced. The mechanical, corrosion, and biocompatibility properties of LPBF Zn and their test methodologies are introduced. The effects of microstructure on mechanical properties and corrosion properties are analyzed in detail. The practical medical application of Zn is introduced. Finally, current research status is summarized together with suggested directions for advancing knowledge about LPBF Zn.

Mimicking the mechanical properties of cortical bone with an additively manufactured biodegradable Zn-3Mg alloy

Additively manufactured (AM) biodegradable zinc (Zn) alloys have recently emerged as promising porous bone-substituting materials, due to their moderate degradation rates, good biocompatibility, geometrically ordered microarchitectures, and bone-mimicking mechanical properties. While AM Zn alloy porous scaffolds mimicking the mechanical properties of trabecular bone have been previously reported, mimicking the mechanical properties of cortical bone remains a formidable challenge. To overcome this challenge, we developed the AM Zn-3Mg alloy. We used laser powder bed fusion to process Zn-3Mg and compared it with pure Zn. The AM Zn-3Mg alloy exhibited significantly refined grains and a unique microstructure with interlaced α-Zn/Mg2Zn11 phases. The compressive properties of the solid Zn-3Mg specimens greatly exceeded their tensile properties, with a compressive yield strength of up to 601 MPa and an ultimate strain of >60 %. We then designed and fabricated functionally graded porous structures with a solid core and achieved cortical bone-mimicking mechanical properties, including a compressive yield strength of >120 MPa and an elastic modulus of ≈20 GPa. The biodegradation rates of the Zn-3Mg specimens were lower than those of pure Zn and could be adjusted by tuning the AM process parameters. The Zn-3Mg specimens also exhibited improved biocompatibility as compared to pure Zn, including higher metabolic activity and enhanced osteogenic behavior of MC3T3 cells cultured with the extracts from the Zn-3Mg alloy specimens. Altogether, these results marked major progress in developing AM porous biodegradable metallic bone substitutes, which paved the way toward clinical adoption of Zn-based scaffolds for the treatment of load-bearing bony defects. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Our study presents a significant advancement in the realm of biodegradable metallic bone substitutes through the development of an additively manufactured Zn-3Mg alloy. This novel alloy showcases refined grains and a distinctive microstructure, enabling the fabrication of functionally graded porous structures with mechanical properties resembling cortical bone. The achieved compressive yield strength and elastic modulus signify a critical leap toward mimicking the mechanical behavior of load-bearing bone. Moreover, our findings reveal tunable biodegradation rates and enhanced biocompatibility compared to pure Zn, emphasizing the potential clinical utility of Zn-based scaffolds for treating load-bearing bony defects. This breakthrough opens doors for the wider adoption of zinc-based materials in regenerative orthopedics.

Additive manufacturing of degradable metallic scaffolds for material-structure-driven diabetic maxillofacial bone regeneration

The regeneration of maxillofacial bone defects associated with diabetes mellitus remains challenging due to the occlusal loading and hyperglycemia microenvironment. Herein, we propose a material-structure-driven strategy through the additive manufacturing of degradable Zn-Mg-Cu gradient scaffolds. The in situ alloying of Mg and Cu endows Zn alloy with admirable compressive strength for mechanical support and uniform degradation mode for preventing localized rupture. The scaffolds manifest favorable antibacterial, angiogenic, and osteogenic modulation capacity in mimicked hyperglycemic microenvironment, and Mg and Cu promote osteogenic differentiation in the early and late stages, respectively. In addition, the scaffolds expedite diabetic maxillofacial bone ingrowth and regeneration by combining the metabolic regulation effect of divalent metal cations and the hyperboloid and suitable permeability of the gradient structure. RNA sequencing further reveals that RAC1 might be involved in bone formation by regulating the transport and uptake of glucose related to GLUT1 in osteoblasts, contributing to cell function recovery. Inspired by bone healing and structural cues, this study offers an essential understanding of the designation and underlying mechanisms of the material-structure-driven strategy for diabetic maxillofacial bone regeneration.

Biodegradation-affected fatigue behavior of extrusion-based additively manufactured porous iron-manganese scaffolds

Additively manufactured (AM) biodegradable porous iron-manganese (FeMn) alloys have recently been developed as promising bone-substituting biomaterials. However, their corrosion fatigue behavior has not yet been studied. Here, we present the first study on the corrosion fatigue behavior of an extrusion-based AM porous Fe35Mn alloy under cyclic loading in air and in the revised simulated body fluid (r-SBF), including the fatigue crack morphology and distribution in the porous structure. We hypothesized that the fatigue behavior of the architected AM Fe35Mn alloy would be strongly affected by the simultaneous biodegradation process. We defined the endurance limit as the maximum stress at which the scaffolds could undergo 3 million loading cycles without failure. The endurance limit of the scaffolds was determined to be 90 % of their yield strength in air, but only 60 % in r-SBF. No notable crack formation in the specimens tested in air was observed even after loading up to 90 % of their yield strength. As for the specimens tested in r-SBF, however, cracks formed in the specimens subjected to loads exceeding 60 % of their yield strength appeared to initiate on the periphery and propagate toward the internal struts. Altogether, the results show that the extrusion-based AM porous Fe35Mn alloy is capable of tolerating up to 60 % of its yield strength for up to 3 million cycles, which corresponds to 1.5 years of use of load-bearing implants subjected to repetitive gait cycles. The fatigue performance of the alloy thus further enhances its potential for trabecular bone substitution subjected to cyclic compressive loading. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Fatigue behavior of extrusion-based AM porous Fe35Mn alloy scaffolds in air and revised simulated body fluid was studied. The Fe35Mn alloy scaffolds endured 90 % of their yield strength for up to 3 × 106 loading cycles in air. Moreover, the scaffolds tolerated 3 × 106 loading cycles at 60 % of their yield strength in revised simulated body fluid. The Fe35Mn alloy scaffolds exhibited a capacity of withstanding 1.5-year physiological loading when used as bone implants.

Orthopedic meta-implants

Meta-biomaterials, engineered materials with distinctive combinations of mechanical, physical, and biological properties stemming from their micro-architecture, have emerged as a promising domain within biomedical engineering. Correspondingly, meta-implants, which serve as the device counterparts of meta-biomaterials, offer exceptional functionalities, holding great potential for addressing complex skeletal diseases. This paper presents a comprehensive overview of the various types of meta-implants, including hybrid, shape-morphing, metallic clay, and deployable meta-implants, highlighting their unprecedented properties and recent achievement in the field. This paper also delves into the potential future developments of meta-implants, addressing the exploration of multi-functionalities in meta-biomaterials and their applications in diverse biomedical fields.

The role of stiffness-matching in avoiding stress shielding-induced bone loss and stress concentration-induced skeletal reconstruction device failure

It is well documented that overly stiff skeletal replacement and fixation devices may fail and require revision surgery. Recent attempts to better support healing and sustain healed bone have looked at stiffness-matching of these devices to the desired role of limiting the stress on fractured or engrafted bone to compressive loads and, after the reconstructed bone has healed, to ensure that reconstructive medical devices (implants) interrupt the normal loading pattern as little as possible. The mechanical performance of these devices can be optimized by adjusting their location, integration/fastening, material(s), geometry (external and internal), and surface properties. This review highlights recent research that focuses on the optimal design of skeletal reconstruction devices to perform during and after healing as the mechanical regime changes. Previous studies have considered auxetic materials, homogeneous or gradient (i.e., adaptive) porosity, surface modification to enhance device/bone integration, and choosing the device's attachment location to ensure good osseointegration and resilient load transduction. By combining some or all of these factors, device designers work hard to avoid problems brought about by unsustainable stress shielding or stress concentrations as a means of creating sustainable stress-strain relationships that best repair and sustain a surgically reconstructed skeletal site. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Although standard-of-care skeletal reconstruction devices will usually allow normal healing and improved comfort for the patient during normal activities, there may be significant disadvantages during long-term use. Stress shielding and stress concentration are amongst the most common causes of failure of a metallic device. This review highlights recent developments in devices for skeletal reconstruction that match the stiffness, while not interrupting the normal loading pattern of a healthy bone, and help to combat stress shielding and stress concentration. This review summarises various approaches to achieve stiffness-matching: application of materials with modulus close to that of the bone; adaptation of geometry with pre-defined mechanical properties; and/or surface modification that ensures good integration and proper load transfer to the bone.

Titanium Alloy Implants with Lattice Structures for Mandibular Reconstruction

In recent years, the field of mandibular reconstruction has made great strides in terms of hardware innovations and their clinical applications. There has been considerable interest in using computer-aided design, finite element modelling, and additive manufacturing techniques to build patient-specific surgical implants. Moreover, lattice implants can mimic mandibular bone's mechanical and structural properties. This article reviews current approaches for mandibular reconstruction, their applications, and their drawbacks. Then, we discuss the potential of mandibular devices with lattice structures, their development and applications, and the challenges for their use in clinical settings.

The effect of nodal connectivity and strut density within stochastic titanium scaffolds on osteogenesis

Modern orthopaedic implants use lattice structures that act as 3D scaffolds to enhance bone growth into and around implants. Stochastic scaffolds are of particular interest as they mimic the architecture of trabecular bone and can combine isotropic properties and adjustable structure. The existing research mainly concentrates on controlling the mechanical and biological performance of periodic lattices by adjusting pore size and shape. Still, less is known on how we can control the performance of stochastic lattices through their design parameters: nodal connectivity, strut density and strut thickness. To elucidate this, four lattice structures were evaluated with varied strut densities and connectivity, hence different local geometry and mechanical properties: low apparent modulus, high apparent modulus, and two with near-identical modulus. Pre-osteoblast murine cells were seeded on scaffolds and cultured in vitro for 28 days. Cell adhesion, proliferation and differentiation were evaluated. Additionally, the expression levels of key osteogenic biomarkers were used to assess the effect of each design parameter on the quality of newly formed tissue. The main finding was that increasing connectivity increased the rate of osteoblast maturation, tissue formation and mineralisation. In detail, doubling the connectivity, over fixed strut density, increased collagen type-I by 140%, increased osteopontin by 130% and osteocalcin by 110%. This was attributed to the increased number of acute angles formed by the numerous connected struts, which facilitated the organization of cells and accelerated the cell cycle. Overall, increasing connectivity and adjusting strut density is a novel technique to design stochastic structures which combine a broad range of biomimetic properties and rapid ossification.

Topology optimization on metamaterial cells for replacement possibility in non-pneumatic tire and the capability of 3D-printing

One of the applications of mechanical metamaterials is in car tires, as a non-pneumatic tire (NPT). Therefore, to find a suitable cell to replace the pneumatic part of the tire, three different solution methods were used, including topology optimization of the cubic unit cell, cylindrical unit cell, and fatigue testing cylindrical sample (FTCS). First, to find the mechanical properties, a tensile test was conducted for materials made of polylactic acid (PLA) and then, the optimization was done based on the weight and overhang control for the possibility of manufacturing with 3D printers, as constraints, besides, the objective of minimum compliance. In the optimization of the cubic unit cell, the sample with a minimum remaining weight of 35% was selected as the optimal sample. However, for the cylindrical unit cell, a sample with a weight limit of 20% was the most optimal state. In contrast, in the FTCS optimization, a specimen with lower remaining weight equal to 60% of the initial weight was selected. After obtaining the answer, five cells in the FTCS and two mentioned cells were evaluated under compressive testing. The samples were also subjected to bending fatigue loadings. The results demonstrated that cellular structures with 15% of lower weight than the optimized samples had the same fatigue lifetime. In the compressive test, the line slope of the specimens with cellular structures in the elastic region of the force-displacement diagram was reduced by 37%, compared to the completely solid samples. However, the weight of these samples decreased by 59%. Furthermore, the fracture surface was also investigated by field-emission scanning electron microscopy. It was observed that a weak connection between the layers was the cause of failure.

Auxeticity as a Mechanobiological Tool to Create Meta-Biomaterials

Mechanical and morphological design parameters, such as stiffness or porosity, play important roles in creating orthopedic implants and bone substitutes. However, we have only a limited understanding of how the microarchitecture of porous scaffolds contributes to bone regeneration. Meta-biomaterials are increasingly used to precisely engineer the internal geometry of porous scaffolds and independently tailor their mechanical properties (e.g., stiffness and Poisson's ratio). This is motivated by the rare or unprecedented properties of meta-biomaterials, such as negative Poisson's ratios (i.e., auxeticity). It is, however, not clear how these unusual properties can modulate the interactions of meta-biomaterials with living cells and whether they can facilitate bone tissue engineering under static and dynamic cell culture and mechanical loading conditions. Here, we review the recent studies investigating the effects of the Poisson's ratio on the performance of meta-biomaterials with an emphasis on the relevant mechanobiological aspects. We also highlight the state-of-the-art additive manufacturing techniques employed to create meta-biomaterials, particularly at the micrometer scale. Finally, we provide future perspectives, particularly for the design of the next generation of meta-biomaterials featuring dynamic properties (e.g., those made through 4D printing).

Design and performance analysis of 3D-printed stiffness gradient femoral scaffold

Studies on 3D-printed porous bone scaffolds mostly focus on materials or structural parameters, while the repair of large femoral defects needs to select appropriate structural parameters according to the needs of different parts. In this paper, a kind of stiffness gradient scaffold design idea is proposed. Different structures are selected according to the different functions of different parts of the scaffold. At the same time, an integrated fixation device is designed to fix the scaffold. Finite element method was used to analyze the stress and strain of homogeneous scaffolds and the stiffness gradient scaffolds, and the relative displacement and stress between stiffness gradient scaffolds and bone in the case of integrated fixation and steel plate fixation. The results showed that the stress distribution of the stiffness gradient scaffolds was more uniform, and the strain of host bone tissue was changed greatly, which was beneficial to the growth of bone tissue. The integrated fixation method is more stable, less stress and evenly distributed. Therefore, the integrated fixation device combined with the design of stiffness gradient can repair the large femoral bone defect well.

Reconstruction of massive bone defects after femoral tumor resection using two new-designed 3D-printed intercalary prostheses: a clinical analytic study with the cooperative utilization of multiple technologies

BACKGROUND

To reconstruct massive bone defects of the femoral diaphysis and proximal end with limited bilateral cortical bone after joint-preserving musculoskeletal tumor resections, two novel 3D-printed customized intercalary femoral prostheses were applied.

METHODS

A series of nine patients with malignancies who received these novel 3D-printed prostheses were retrospectively studied between July 2018 and November 2021. The proximal and diaphyseal femur was divided into three regions of interest (ROIs) according to anatomic landmarks, and anatomic measurements were conducted on 50 computed tomography images showing normal femurs. Based on the individual implant-involved ROIs, osteotomy level, and anatomical and biomechanical features, two alternative 3D-printed prostheses were designed. In each patient, Hounsfield Unit (HU) value thresholding and finite element analysis were conducted to identify the bone trabecula and calcar femorale and to determine the stress distribution, respectively. We described the characteristics of each prosthesis and surgical procedure and recorded the intraoperative data. All patients underwent regular postoperative follow-up, in which the clinical, functional and radiographical outcomes were evaluated.

RESULTS

With the ROI division and radiographic measurements, insufficient bilateral cortical bones for anchoring the traditional stem were verified in the normal proximal femur. Therefore, two 3D-printed intercalary endoprostheses, a Type A prosthesis with a proximal curved stem and a Type B prosthesis with a proximal anchorage-slot and corresponding locking screws, were designed. Based on HU value thresholding and finite element analysis, the 3D-printed proximal stems in all prostheses maximally preserved the trabecular bone and calcar femorale and optimized the biomechanical distribution, as did the proximal screws. With the 3D-printed osteotomy guide plates and reaming guide plates, all patients underwent the operation uneventfully with a satisfactory duration (325.00 ± 62.60 min) and bleeding volume (922.22 ± 222.36 ml). In the follow-up, Harris Hip and Musculoskeletal Tumor Society scores were ameliorated after surgery (P < 0.001 and P < 0.001, respectively), reliable bone ingrowth was observed, and no major complications occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

Two novel 3D-printed femoral intercalary prostheses, which achieved acceptable overall postoperative outcomes, were used as appropriate alternatives for oncologic patients with massive bone defects and limited residual bone and increased the opportunities for joint-preserving tumor resection. Several scientific methodologies utilized in this study may promote the clinical design proposals of 3D-printed implants.

Corrosion fatigue behavior and anti-fatigue mechanisms of an additively manufactured biodegradable zinc-magnesium gyroid scaffold

Additively manufactured biodegradable zinc (Zn) alloy scaffolds constitute an important branch in orthopedic implants because of their moderate degradation behavior and bone-mimicking mechanical properties. This work investigated the corrosion fatigue response of a zinc-magnesium (Zn-Mg) alloy gyroid scaffold fabricated via laser-powder-bed-fusion additive manufacturing at the first time. The high-cycle compression-compression fatigue testing of the printed Zn-Mg scaffold was conducted in simulated body fluid, showing its favorable fatigue strength, structural reliability, and anti-fatigue capability. The printed Zn-Mg scaffold obtained a 227% higher fatigue strength than that of the printed Zn scaffold but 17% lower strain accumulation at 10⁶ cycles. The accumulative strain of the Zn-Mg scaffold at its fatigue strength was dominant by fatigue ratcheting, since the fatigue damage strain of the scaffold was approximately zero. The corrosion products (ZnO and Zn(OH)₂) were conducive to the inhibition of fatigue ratcheting and fatigue damage. Dislocation pile-up and solid solution phases at the grain boundaries of the Zn-Mg scaffold could retard the spreading of the crack tip and impede excessive grain coarsening, improving its fatigue endurance limit. Notably, the printed Zn-Mg scaffold could dissipate the fatigue energy through moderate grain boundary migration, thus reducing its plastic deformation. These findings illuminated the anti-fatigue mechanisms related to microstructural features and corrosive environments and highlighted the promising prospects of additively manufactured Zn-Mg scaffolds in orthopedic applications. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: : Additive manufacturing (AM) of biodegradable metals shows unprecedented prospects for bone tissue regeneration medicine. The corrosion fatigue property is one of the key determinants in the performance of AM biodegradable scaffolds. In this study, a Zn-Mg gyroid scaffold was additively manufactured with admirable fatigue endurance limit and anti-fatigue capability. We reported that the corrosion fatigue performance was highly relevant to the microstructural features, validating that the grain boundary engineering strategy improved fatigue strength and inhibited crack penetration. Notably, moderate grain boundary migration could dissipate fatigue energy and reduce plastic deformation. Furthermore, corrosion products were conducive to impeding fatigue ratcheting and fatigue damage, indicating the promising potential of AM Zn-Mg scaffolds in treating load-bearing bone defects.

Mineralized Enzyme-Based Biomaterials with Superior Bioactivities for Bone Regeneration

The formation and metabolic balance of bone tissue is a controllable process of biomineralization, which is regulated by various cells, biomolecules, and ions. Enzyme molecules play an important role in this process, and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) is one of the most critical factors. In this study, inspired by the process of bone biomineralization, a biomimetic strategy is achieved for the preparation of mineralized ALP nanoparticles (MALPNs), by taking advantages of the unique reaction between ALP and calcium ions in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium. Benefiting from the mild biomineralization reaction, the MALPN system highly maintains the activity of ALP. Furthermore, the in vitro studies show that the MALPN system significantly enhances the proliferation of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells and upregulates their osteogenic differentiation. When evaluated as synthetic graft materials for bone regeneration, the MALPN-incorporated gelatin methacryloyl graft shows excellent mechanical properties, a sustained release profile of ALP, and high biocompatibility and efficacy in guiding bone regeneration and vascularization for critical-sized rat calvarial defect. Moreover, we also demonstrate that the biomimetic mineralization strategy can be adopted for other proteins such as acid phosphatase, bovine serum albumin, fibrinogen, and gelatin, suggesting its universality for constructing mineralized protein-/enzyme-based bioactive materials for the application of tissue regeneration.

Additive Manufacturing of Biomaterials-Design Principles and Their Implementation

Additive manufacturing (AM, also known as 3D printing) is an advanced manufacturing technique that has enabled progress in the design and fabrication of customised or patient-specific (meta-)biomaterials and biomedical devices (e.g., implants, prosthetics, and orthotics) with complex internal microstructures and tuneable properties. In the past few decades, several design guidelines have been proposed for creating porous lattice structures, particularly for biomedical applications. Meanwhile, the capabilities of AM to fabricate a wide range of biomaterials, including metals and their alloys, polymers, and ceramics, have been exploited, offering unprecedented benefits to medical professionals and patients alike. In this review article, we provide an overview of the design principles that have been developed and used for the AM of biomaterials as well as those dealing with three major categories of biomaterials, i.e., metals (and their alloys), polymers, and ceramics. The design strategies can be categorised as: library-based design, topology optimisation, bio-inspired design, and meta-biomaterials. Recent developments related to the biomedical applications and fabrication methods of AM aimed at enhancing the quality of final 3D-printed biomaterials and improving their physical, mechanical, and biological characteristics are also highlighted. Finally, examples of 3D-printed biomaterials with tuned properties and functionalities are presented.

Mechanical and Fatigue Behavior of Cellular Structure Ti-6Al-4V Alloy Femoral Stems: A Finite Element Analysis

Repetitive loads acting on the hip joint fluctuate according to the type of activities produced by the human body. Repetitive loading is one of the factors that leads to fatigue failure of the implanted stems. The objective of this study is to develop lightweight femoral stems with cubic porous structures that will survive under fatigue loading. Cubic porous structures with different volumetric porosities were designed and subjected to compressive loading using finite element analysis (FEA) to measure the elastic moduli, yield strength, and ultimate tensile strength. These porous structures were employed to design femoral stems containing mechanical properties under compressive loading close to the intact bone. Several arrangements of radial geometrical porous functionally graded (FG) and homogenous Ti-6Al-4V porous femoral stems were designed and grouped under three average porosities of 30%, 50%, and 70% respectively. The designed stems were simulated inside the femoral bone with physiological loads demonstrating three walking speeds of 1, 3, and 5 km/h using ABAQUS. Stresses at the layers of the functionally graded stem were measured and compared with the yield strength of the relevant porous structure to check the possibility of yielding under the subjected load. The Soderberg approach is employed to compute the safety factor (Nf > 1.0) for each design under each loading condition. Several designs were shortlisted as potential candidates for orthopedic implants.

Static and Fatigue Load Bearing Investigation on Porous Structure Titanium Additively Manufactured Anterior Cervical Cages

This study investigates the static and fatigue behavior of porous and conventional anterior cervical cages. Porous structure titanium anterior cervical cages were manufactured using direct selective laser sintering technique. Four different types of cervical cages were designed and manufactured, among which three designs consist of porous structure (type 1, type 2, and type 3) and manufactured using metal 3D printing. Remaining one design (type 4) was manufactured using conventional machining and did not consist any porous structure. All types of manufactured cages were tested in compression under static and fatigue loading conditions as per ASTM F2077 standard. Static and fatigue subsidence testing was performed using ASTM F2267 standard. Static compression testing results of type 1 and type 4 cages reported higher yield load when compared to the type 2 and type 3 cages. Static subsidence testing results reported almost 11% less subsidence rate for additively manufactured cages than the conventional cages. Fatigue subsidence testing results showed that type 2 and type 3 cages can withstood approximately 21% higher number of cycles before subsidence as compare to the type 1 and type 4 cages. During fatigue testing, all the cages design survived 5 million cycles at the 3000 N loading. For 6000 N and 8000 N, loading rate type 2 and type 3 cages showed lower fatigue life when compared to other cages design. Since fatigue life of type 2 and type 3 cage designs were reported lower than other cages design, it is concluded that the performance of the additively manufactured porous cages can be significantly varied based upon the cage design features.

On-Growth and In-Growth Osseointegration Enhancement in PM Porous Ti-Scaffolds by Two Different Bioactivation Strategies: Alkali Thermochemical Treatment and RGD Peptide Coating

A lack of primary stability and osteointegration in metallic implants may result in implant loosening and failure. Adding porosity to metallic implants reduces the stress shielding effect and improves implant performance, allowing the surrounding bone tissue to grow into the scaffold. However, a bioactive surface is needed to stimulate implant osteointegration and improve mechanical stability. In this study, porous titanium implants were produced via powder sintering to create different porous diameters and open interconnectivity. Two strategies were used to generate a bioactive surface on the metallic foams: (1) an inorganic alkali thermochemical treatment, (2) grafting a cell adhesive tripeptide (RGD). RGD peptides exhibit an affinity for integrins expressed by osteoblasts, and have been reported to improve osteoblast adhesion, whereas the thermochemical treatment is known to improve titanium implant osseointegration upon implantation. Bioactivated scaffolds and control samples were implanted into the tibiae of rabbits to analyze the effect of these two strategies in vivo regarding bone tissue regeneration through interconnected porosity. Histomorphometric evaluation was performed at 4 and 12 weeks after implantation. Bone-to-implant contact (BIC) and bone in-growth and on-growth were evaluated in different regions of interest (ROIs) inside and outside the implant. The results of this study show that after a long-term postoperative period, the RGD-coated samples presented higher quantification values of quantified newly formed bone tissue in the implant's outer area. However, the total analyzed bone in-growth was observed to be slightly greater in the scaffolds treated with alkali thermochemical treatment. These results suggest that both strategies contribute to enhancing porous metallic implant stability and osteointegration, and a combination of both strategies might be worth pursuing.

Mechanisms of fatigue crack initiation and propagation in auxetic meta-biomaterials

The fatigue performance of additively manufactured auxetic meta-biomaterials made from commercially pure titanium has been studied only recently. While certain assumptions have been made regarding the mechanisms underlying their fatigue failure, the exact mechanisms are not researched yet. Here, we studied the mechanisms of crack formation and propagation in cyclically loaded auxetic meta-biomaterials. Twelve different designs were subjected to compression-compression fatigue testing while performing full-field strain measurement using digital image correlation (DIC). The fatigue tests were stopped at different points before complete specimen failure to study the evolution of damage in the micro-architecture of the specimens using micro-computed tomography (micro-CT). Furthermore, finite element models were made to study the presence of stress concentrations. Structural weak spots were found in the inverted nodes and the vertical struts located along the outer rim of the specimens, matching the maximum principal strain concentrations and fracture sites in the DIC and micro-CT data. Cracks were often found to originate from internal void spaces or from sites susceptible to mode-I cracking. Many specimens maintained their structural integrity and exhibited no signs of rapid strain accumulation despite the presence of substantial crack growth. This observation underlines the importance of such microscale studies to identify accumulated damage that otherwise goes unnoticed. The potential release of powder particles from damaged lattices could elicit a foreign body response, adversely affecting the implant success. Finding the right failure criterion, therefore, requires more data than only those pertaining to macroscopic measurements and should always include damage assessment at the microscale. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The negative Poisson's ratio of auxetic meta-biomaterials makes them expand laterally in response to axial tension. This extraordinary property has great potential in the field of orthopedics, where it could enhance bone-implant contact. The fatigue performance of additively manufactured auxetic meta-biomaterials has only recently been studied and was found to be superior to many other bending- and stretch-dominated micro-architectures. In this study, we go beyond these macroscopic measurements and focus on the crack initiation and propagation. Full-field strain measurements and 3D imaging are used to paint a detailed picture of the mechanisms underlying fatigue. Using these data, specific aspects of the design and/or printing process can be targeted to improve the performance of auxetic meta-biomaterials in load-bearing applications.

Biomechanics of Additively Manufactured Metallic Scaffolds-A Review

This review paper is related to the biomechanics of additively manufactured (AM) metallic scaffolds, in particular titanium alloy Ti6Al4V scaffolds. This is because Ti6Al4V has been identified as an ideal candidate for AM metallic scaffolds. The factors that affect the scaffold technology are the design, the material used to build the scaffold, and the fabrication process. This review paper includes thus a discussion on the design of Ti6A4V scaffolds in relation to how their behavior is affected by their cell shapes and porosities. This is followed by a discussion on the post treatment and mechanical characterization including in-vitro and in-vivo biomechanical studies. A review and discussion are also presented on the ongoing efforts to develop predictive tools to derive the relationships between structure, processing, properties and performance of powder-bed additive manufacturing of metals. This is a challenge when developing process computational models because the problem involves multi-physics and is of multi-scale in nature. Advantages, limitations, and future trends in AM scaffolds are finally discussed. AM is considered at the forefront of Industry 4.0, the fourth industrial revolution. The market of scaffold technology will continue to boom because of the high demand for human tissue repair.

Fatigue and dynamic biodegradation behavior of additively manufactured Mg scaffolds

Additive manufacturing (AM) has enabled the fabrication of biodegradable porous metals to satisfy the desired characteristics for orthopedic applications. The geometrical design on AM biodegradable metallic scaffolds has been found to offer a favorable opportunity to regulate their mechanical and degradation performance in previous studies, however mostly confined to static responses. In this study, we presented the effect of the geometrical design on the dynamic responses of AM Mg scaffolds for the first time. Three different types of porous structures, based on various unit cells (i.e., biomimetic, diamond, and sheet-based gyroid), were established and then subjected to selective laser melting (SLM) process using group-developed Mg-Nd-Zn-Zr alloy (JDBM) powders. The topology after dynamic electropolishing, dynamic compressive properties, and dynamic biodegradation behavior of the AM Mg scaffolds were comprehensively evaluated. It was found that dynamic electropolishing effectively removed the excessive adhered powders on the surfaces and resulted in similar geometrical deviations amongst the AM Mg scaffolds, independent of their porous structures. The geometrical design significantly affected the compressive fatigue properties of the AM Mg scaffolds, of which the sheeted-based gyroid structure demonstrated a superior fatigue endurance limit of 0.85 at 10⁶ cycles. Furthermore, in vitro dynamic immersion behaviors of the AM Mg scaffolds revealed a decent dependence on local architectures, where the sheeted-based gyroid scaffold experienced the lowest structural loss with a relatively uniform degradation mode. The obtained results indicate that the geometrical design could provide a promising strategy to develop desirable bone substitutes for the treatment of critical-size load-bearing defects. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Additive manufacturing (AM) has provided unprecedented opportunities to fabricate geometrically complex biodegradable scaffolds where the topological design becomes a key determinant on comprehensive performance. In this paper, we fabricate 3 AM biodegradable Mg scaffolds (i.e., biomimetic, diamond, and sheet-based gyroid) and report the effect of the geometrical design on the dynamic responses of AM Mg scaffolds for the first time. The results revealed that the sheeted-based gyroid scaffold exhibited the best combination of superior compressive fatigue properties and relatively uniform dynamic biodegradation mode, suggesting that the regulation of the porous structures could be an effective approach for the optimization of AM Mg scaffolds as to satisfy clinical requirements in orthopedic applications.

3D-Printed Porous Tantalum Coated with Antitubercular Drugs Achieving Antibacterial Properties and Good Biocompatibility

Treatment of bone and joint tuberculosis remains a challenge. The development of tissue-engineered drug-loaded biomaterials has increased the therapeutic options. However, for the treatment of osteoarticular tuberculosis with severe local infection risks and high weight-bearing requirements, it is still necessary to design materials consistent with bone biomechanics, cytocompatibility, and osteogenesis and to provide more effective antimicrobial functions. The antitubercular drugs isoniazid and rifampicin are loaded with gellan gum, and a 3D-printed porous tantalum surface is treated with polydopamine to increase adhesion. The osteogenic induction and differentiation are tested using alkaline phosphatase, alizarin red staining, sirius red staining, and polymerase chain reaction testing. Bone regeneration in vivo is measured by X-ray, micro-computerized tomography, hard tissue sections, and fluorescence staining. The drug is released slowly in vitro and in vivo, increasing the duration of antibacterial action. The composite bio-scaffolds inhibit Staphylococcus aureus growth, have good biocompatibility, and does not inhibit the induction of osteogenic differentiation of rat bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells. The composite bio-scaffold can simultaneously achieve localized long-term controlled drug release and bone regeneration and is a promising route for bone and joint tuberculosis treatment.

Fatigue behaviour and biocompatibility of additively manufactured bioactive tantalum graded lattice structures for load-bearing orthopaedic applications

Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) additive manufacturing of pure tantalum and their graded lattice structures was systematically investigated, with emphasis on their microstructure evolution, phase formation, surface energy and biological properties in comparison with conventionally forged pure Ta. The LPBF fabricated Ta (LPBF-Ta) exhibited lower contact angles and higher surface energy than the forged-Ta which indicated the better wettability of the LPBF-Ta. The adhesion and proliferation of rat bone marrow stromal cells (rBMSCs) were also enhanced for the LPBF-Ta when compared to forged-Ta. Three different Ta graded gyroid lattice structures (i.e., uniform structure, Y-gradient structure, Z-gradient structure) were designed and fabricated using the same optimised LPBF parameters. Y-gradient structures exhibited the best plateau stress and compressive modulus among three different graded structures due to the maximum local volume fraction on the fracture plane. In fatigue response, Y-gradient outperformed the other two gyroid structures under varying stresses. In terms of cell culture response, the uniform structures performed the best biocompatibility due to its suitable pore size for cell adhesion and growth. This study provides new and in-depth insights into the LPBF additive manufacturing of pure Ta graded lattice structures with desired fatigue and biological properties for load-bearing orthopaedic applications.

Morphological and mechanical characterisation of three-dimensional gyroid structures fabricated by electron beam melting for the use as a porous biomaterial

Additive manufactured porous biomaterials based on triply periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS) are a highly discussed topic in the literature. With their unique properties in terms of open porosity, large surface area and surface curvature, they are considered to have bone mimicking properties and remarkable osteogenic potential. In this study, scaffolds of gyroid unit cells of different sizes consisting of a Ti6Al4V alloy were manufactured additively by electron beam melting (EBM). The scaffolds were analysed by micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) to determine their morphological characteristics and, subsequently, subjected to mechanical tests to investigate their quasi-static compressive properties and fatigue resistance. All scaffolds showed an average open porosity of 71-81%, with an average pore size of 0.64-1.41 mm, depending on the investigated design. The design with the smallest unit cell shows the highest quasi-elastic gradient (QEG) as well as the highest compressive offset stress and compression strength. Furthermore, the fatigue resistance of all unit cell size (UCS) variations showed promising results. In detail, the smallest unit cells achieved fatigue strength at 10⁶ cycles at 45% of their compressive offset stress, which is comparatively good for additively manufactured porous biomaterials. In summary, it is demonstrated that the mechanical properties can be significantly modified by varying the unit cell size, thus enabling the scaffolds to be specifically tailored to avoid stress shielding and ensure implant safety. Together with the morphological properties of the gyroid unit cells, the fabricated scaffolds represent a promising approach for use as a bone substitute material.

Influence of porous tantalum scaffold pore size on osteogenesis and osteointegration: A comprehensive study based on 3D-printing technology

The emerging role of porous tantalum (Ta) scaffold for bone tissue engineering is noticed due to its outstanding biological properties. However, it is controversial which pore size and porosity are more conducive for bone defect repair. In the present work, porous tantalum scaffolds with pore sizes of 100-200, 200-400, 400-600 and 600-800 μm and corresponding porosities of 25%, 55%, 75%, and 85% were constructed, using computer aided design and 3D printing technologies, then comprehensively studied by in vitro and in vivo studies. We found that Ta scaffold with pore size of 400-600 μm showed stronger ability in facilitating cell adhesion, proliferation, and osteogenic differentiation in vitro. In vivo tests identified that porous tantalum scaffolds with pore size of 400-600 μm showed better performance of bone ingrowth and integration. In mechanism, computational fluid dynamics analysis proved porous tantalum scaffolds with pore size of 400-600 μm hold appropriate permeability and surface area, which facilitated cell adhesion and proliferation. Our results strongly indicate that pore size and porosity are essential for further applications of porous tantalum scaffolds, and porous tantalum scaffolds with pore size 400-600 μm are conducive to osteogenesis and osseointegration. These findings provide new evidence for further application of porous tantalum scaffolds for bone defect repair.

Influence of relative density on quasi-static and fatigue failure of lattice structures in Ti6Al4V produced by laser powder bed fusion

Lattice structures produced by additive manufacturing have been increasingly studied in recent years due to their potential to tailor prescribed mechanical properties. Their mechanical performances are influenced by several factors such as unit cell topology, parent material and relative density. In this study, static and dynamic behaviors of Ti6Al4V lattice structures were analyzed focusing on the criteria used to define the failure of lattices. A modified face-centered cubic (FCCm) lattice structure was designed to avoid the manufacturing problems that arise in the production of horizontal struts by laser powder bed fusion. The Gibson-Ashby curves of the FCCm lattice were obtained and it was found that relative density not only affects stiffness and strength of the structures, but also has important implications on the assumption of macroscopic yield criterion. Regarding fatigue properties, a stiffness based criterion was analyzed to improve the assessment of lattice structure failure in load bearing applications, and the influence of relative density on the stiffness evolution was studied. Apart from common normalization of S-N curves, a more accurate fatigue failure surface was developed, which is also compatible with stiffness based failure criteria. Finally, the effect of hot isostatic pressing in FCCm structures was also studied.

Additively-manufactured PEEK/HA porous scaffolds with highly-controllable mechanical properties and excellent biocompatibility

Polyetheretherketone (PEEK) was widely applied into fabricating of orthopaedic implants, benefitting its excellent biocompatibility and similar mechanical properties to native bones. However, the inertness of PEEK hinders its integration with the surrounding bone tissue. Here PEEK scaffolds with a series of hydroxyapatite (HA) contents in gradient were manufactured via fused filament fabrication (FFF) 3D printing techniques. The influence of the pore size, HA content and printing direction on the mechanical properties of the PEEK/HA scaffolds was systematically evaluated. By adjusting the pore size and HA contents, the elastic modulus of the PEEK/HA scaffolds can be widely tuned in the range of 624.7-50.6 MPa, similar to the variation range of natural cancellous bone. Meanwhile, the scaffolds exhibited higher Young's modulus and lower compressive strength along Z printing direction. The mapping relationship among geometric parameters, HA content, printing direction and mechanical properties was established, which gave more accurate predictions and controllability of the modulus and strength of scaffolds. The PEEK/HA scaffolds with the micro-structured surface could promote cell attachment and mineralization in vitro. Therefore, the FFF-printed PEEK/HA composites scaffolds can be a good candidate for bone grafting and tissue engineering.

Numerical and Experimental Investigation of Cumulative Fatigue Damage under Random Dynamic Cyclic Loads of Lattice Structures Manufactured by Laser Powder Bed Fusion

Lattice structures are lightweight engineering components suitable for a great variety of applications, including those in which the structural integrity under vibration fatigue is of paramount importance. In this work, we experimentally and numerically investigate the dynamic response of two distinct lattice configurations, in terms of fatigue damage and life. Specifically, Face-Centered-Cubic (FCC) and Diamond lattice-based structures are numerically studied and experimentally tested under resonant conditions and random vibrations, until their failure. To this end, Finite Element (FE) models are employed to match the dynamic behavior of the system in the neighborhood of the first natural frequency. The FE models are employed to estimate the structural integrity by way of frequency and tip acceleration drops, which allow for the identification of the failure time and a corresponding number of cycles to failure. Fatigue life under resonant conditions is well predicted by the application of conventional multiaxial high cycle fatigue criteria to the local state of stress. The same approach, combined with the Rainflow algorithm and Miner’s rule, provides good results in predicting fatigue damage under random vibrations.

Plasma Spray vs. Electrochemical Deposition: Toward a Better Osteogenic Effect of Hydroxyapatite Coatings on 3D-Printed Titanium Scaffolds

Surface modification of three-dimensional (3D)-printed titanium (Ti) scaffolds with hydroxyapatite (HA) has been a research hotspot in biomedical engineering. However, unlike HA coatings on a plain surface, 3D-printed Ti scaffolds have inherent porous structures that influence the characteristics of HA coatings and osteointegration. In the present study, HA coatings were successfully fabricated on 3D-printed Ti scaffolds using plasma spray and electrochemical deposition, named plasma sprayed HA (PSHA) and electrochemically deposited HA (EDHA), respectively. Compared to EDHA scaffolds, HA coatings on PSHA scaffolds were smooth and continuous. In vitro cell studies confirmed that PSHA scaffolds have better potential to promote bone mesenchymal stem cell adhesion, proliferation, and osteogenic differentiation than EDHA scaffolds in the early and late stages. Moreover, in vivo studies showed that PSHA scaffolds were endowed with superior bone repair capacity. Although the EDHA technology is simpler and more controllable, its limitation due to the crystalline and HA structures needs to be improved in the future. Thus, we believe that plasma spray is a better choice for fabricating HA coatings on implanted scaffolds, which may become a promising method for treating bone defects.

Fatigue performance of auxetic meta-biomaterials

Meta-biomaterials offer a promising route towards the development of life-lasting implants. The concept aims to achieve solutions that are ordinarily impossible, by offering a unique combination of mechanical, mass transport, and biological properties through the optimization of their small-scale geometrical and topological designs. In this study, we primarily focus on auxetic meta-biomaterials that have the extraordinary ability to expand in response to axial tension. This could potentially improve the longstanding problem of implant loosening, if their performance can be guaranteed in cyclically loaded conditions. The high-cycle fatigue performance of additively manufactured (AM) auxetic meta-biomaterials made from commercially pure titanium (CP-Ti) was therefore studied. Small variations in the geometry of the re-entrant hexagonal honeycomb unit cell and its relative density resulted in twelve different designs (relative density: ~5-45%, re-entrant angle = 10-25°, Poisson's ratio = -0.076 to -0.504). Micro-computed tomography, scanning electron microscopy and mechanical testing were used to respectively measure the morphological and quasi-static properties of the specimens before proceeding with compression-compression fatigue testing. These auxetic meta-biomaterials exhibited morphological and mechanical properties that are deemed appropriate for bone implant applications (elastic modulus = 66.3-5648 MPa, yield strength = 1.4-46.7 MPa, pore size = 1.3-2.7 mm). With an average maximum stress level of 0.47 σ_y at 10⁶ cycles (range: 0.35 σ_yσ_y- 0.82 σ_yσ_y), the auxetic structures characterized here are superior to many other non-auxetic meta-biomaterials made from the same material. The optimization of the printing process and the potential application of post-processing treatments could improve their performance in cyclically loaded settings even further. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Auxetic meta-biomaterials have a negative Poisson's ratio and, therefore, expand laterally in response to axial tension. Recently, they have been found to restore bone-implant contact along the lateral side of a hip stem. As a result, the bone will be compressed along both of the implant's contact lines, thereby actively reducing the risk of implant failure. In this case the material will be subjected to cyclic loading, for which no experimental data has been reported yet. Here, we present the first ever study of the fatigue performance of additively manufactured auxetic meta-biomaterials based on the re-entrant hexagonal honeycomb. These results will advance the adoption of auxetic meta-biomaterials in load-bearing applications, such as the hip stem, to potentially improve implant longevity.

Advances in Laser Additive Manufacturing of Ti-Nb Alloys: From Nanostructured Powders to Bulk Objects

The additive manufacturing of low elastic modulus alloys that have a certain level of porosity for biomedical needs is a growing area of research. Here, we show the results of manufacturing of porous and dense samples by a laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) of Ti-Nb alloy, using two distinctive fusion strategies. The nanostructured Ti-Nb alloy powders were produced by mechanical alloying and have a nanostructured state with nanosized grains up to 90 nm. The manufactured porous samples have pronounced open porosity and advanced roughness, contrary to dense samples with a relatively smooth surface profile. The structure of both types of samples after LPBF is formed by uniaxial grains having micro- and nanosized features. The inner structure of the porous samples is comprised of an open interconnected system of pores. The volume fraction of isolated porosity is 2 vol. % and the total porosity is 20 vol. %. Cell viability was assessed in vitro for 3 and 7 days using the MG63 cell line. With longer culture periods, cells showed an increased cell density over the entire surface of a porous Ti-Nb sample. Both types of samples are not cytotoxic and could be used for further in vivo studies.

Additively manufactured space-filling meta-implants

The unprecedented properties of meta-biomaterials could pave the way for the development of life-lasting orthopedic implants. Here, we used non-auxetic meta-biomaterials to address the shortcomings of the current treatment options in acetabular revision surgery. Due to the severe bone deficiencies and poor bone quality, it can be very challenging to acquire adequate initial implant stability and long-term fixation. More advanced treatments, such as patient-specific implants, do guarantee the initial stability, but are formidably expensive and may eventually fail due to stress shielding. We, therefore, developed meta-implants furnished with a deformable porous outer layer. Upon implantation, this layer plastically deforms into the defects, thereby improving the initial stability and homogeneously stimulating the surrounding bone. We first studied the space-filling behavior of additively manufactured pure titanium lattices, based on six different unit cells, in a compression test complemented with full-field strain measurements. The diamond, body-centered cubic, and rhombic dodecahedron unit cells were eventually selected for the design of the deformable porous outer layer. Each design came in three different relative density profiles, namely maximum (MAX), functionally graded (FG), and minimum (MIN). After their compression in bone-mimicking molds with simulated acetabular defects, the space-filling behavior of the implants was evaluated using load-displacement curves, micro-CT images, and 3D reconstructions. The meta-implants with an FG diamond infill exhibited the most promising space-filling behavior. However, the required push-in forces exceed the impact forces currently applied in surgery. Future research should, therefore, focus on design optimization, to improve the space-filling behavior and to facilitate the implantation process for orthopedic surgeons. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Ideally, orthopedic implants would last for the entire lifetime of the patient. Unfortunately, they rarely do. Critically sized defects are a common sight in the revision of acetabular cups, and rather difficult to treat. The permanent deformation of lattice structures can be used to create shape-morphing implants that would fill up the defect site, and thereby restore the physiological loading conditions. Bending-dominated structures were incorporated in the porous outer layer of the space-filling meta-implants for their considerable lateral expansion in response to axial compression. A functionally graded density offered structural integrity at the joint while enhancing the deformability at the bone-implant interface. With the use of a more ductile metal, CP-Ti, these meta-implants could be deformed without strut failure.

Self-defending additively manufactured bone implants bearing silver and copper nanoparticles

Effective preventive measures against implant-associated infection (IAI) are desperately needed. Therefore, the development of self-defending implants with intrinsic antibacterial properties has gained significant momentum. Biomaterials biofunctionalized with silver (Ag) have resulted in effective antibacterial biomaterials, yet regularly induce cytotoxicity. In this study, the use of both Ag and copper (Cu) nanoparticles (NPs) on TiO2 surfaces was investigated to generate antibacterial and osteoconductive biomaterials. Hence, additively manufactured Ti-6Al-4V volume-porous implants were biofunctionalized with plasma electrolytic oxidation (PEO) through the incorporation of varying ratios of Ag and/or Cu NPs in the TiO2 layer covering the implant surface. For all experimental groups, the surface morphology, chemical composition, ion release profile, generation of reactive ion species, antibacterial activity against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) in vitro and ex vivo, as well as the response of pre-osteoblastic MC3T3-E1 cells in metabolic activity and differentiation assays were determined. PEO biofunctionalization resulted in rough and highly porous surfaces that released Ag and Cu ions for 28 days and generated hydroxyl as well as methyl radicals. A strong synergistic bactericidal behavior between Ag and Cu ions was detected, which allowed to decrease the concentration of Ag ions by 10-fold, while maintaining the same level of antibacterial activity. Antibacterial agar diffusion and quantitative assays indicated strong antibacterial activity in vitro for the implants containing Ag and Ag/Cu, while no antibacterial activity was observed for implants bearing only Cu NPs. Moreover, the biofunctionalized implants with ratios of up to 75% Ag and 25% Cu NP totally eradicated all bacteria in an ex vivo model using murine femora. Meanwhile, the biofunctionalized implants did not show any signs of cytotoxicity, while implants bearing only Cu NPs improved the metabolic activity after 7 and 11 days. The biomaterials developed here, therefore, exploit the synergistic behavior of Ag and Cu to simultaneously offer strong antibacterial behavior while fully mitigating the cytotoxicity of Ag against mammalian cells.

Osteogenic and antibacterial surfaces on additively manufactured porous Ti-6Al-4V implants: Combining silver nanoparticles with hydrothermally synthesized HA nanocrystals

The recently developed additively manufacturing techniques have enabled the fabrication of porous biomaterials that mimic the characteristics of the native bone, thereby avoiding stress shielding and facilitating bony ingrowth. However, aseptic loosening and bacterial infection, as the leading causes of implant failure, need to be further addressed through surface biofunctionalization. Here, we used a combination of (1) plasma electrolytic oxidation (PEO) using Ca-, P-, and silver nanoparticle-rich electrolytes and (2) post-PEO hydrothermal treatments (HT) to furnish additively manufactured Ti-6Al-4V porous implants with a multi-functional surface. The applied HT led to the formation of hydroxyapatite (HA) nanocrystals throughout the oxide layer. This process was controlled by the supersaturation of Ca²⁺ and PO₄^3- during the hydrothermal process. Initially, the high local supersaturation resulted in homogenous nucleation of spindle-like nanocrystals throughout the surface. As the process continued, the depletion of reactant ions in the outermost surface layer led to a remarkable decrease in the supersaturation degrees. High aspect-ratio nanorods and hexagonal nanopillars were, therefore, created. The unique hierarchical structure of the microporous PEO layer (pore size < 3 μm) and spindle-like HA nanocrystals (<150 nm) on the surface of macro-porous additively manufactured Ti-6Al-4V implants provided a favorable substrate for the anchorage of cytoplasmic extensions assisting cell attachment and migration on the surface. The results of our in vitro assays clearly showed the important benefits of the HT and the spindle-like HA nanocrystals including a significantly stronger and much more sustained antibacterial activity, significantly higher levels of pre-osteoblasts metabolic activity, and significantly higher levels of alkaline phosphatase activity as compared to similar PEO-treated implants lacking the HT.

Improving the Accuracy of Analytical Relationships for Mechanical Properties of Permeable Metamaterials

Permeable porous implants must satisfy several physical and biological requirements in order to be promising materials for orthopaedic application: they should have the proper levels of stiffness, permeability, and fatigue resistance approximately matching the corresponding levels in bone tissues. This can be achieved using designer materials, which exhibit exotic properties, commonly known as metamaterials. In recent years, several experimental, numerical, and analytical studies have been carried out on the influence of unit cell micro-architecture on the mechanical and physical properties of metamaterials. Even though experimental and numerical approaches can study and predict the behaviour of different micro-structures effectively, they lack the ease and quickness provided by analytical relationships in predicting the answer. Although it is well known that Timoshenko beam theory is much more accurate in predicting the deformation of a beam (and as a result lattice structures), many of the already-existing relationships in the literature have been derived based on Euler–Bernoulli beam theory. The question that arises here is whether or not there exists a convenient way to convert the already-existing analytical relationships based on Euler–Bernoulli theory to relationships based on Timoshenko beam theory without the need to rewrite all the derivations from the start point. In this paper, this question is addressed and answered, and a handy and easy-to-use approach is presented. This technique is applied to six unit cell types (body-centred cubic (BCC), hexagonal packing, rhombicuboctahedron, diamond, truncated cube, and truncated octahedron) for which Euler–Bernoulli analytical relationships already exist in the literature while Timoshenko theory-based relationships could not be found. The results of this study demonstrated that converting analytical relationships based on Euler–Bernoulli to equivalent Timoshenko ones can decrease the difference between the analytical and numerical values for one order of magnitude, which is a significant improvement in accuracy of the analytical formulas. The methodology presented in this study is not only beneficial for improving the already-existing analytical relationships, but it also facilitates derivation of accurate analytical relationships for other, yet unexplored, unit cell types.

3D printed auxetic nasopharyngeal swabs for COVID-19 sample collection

The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in worldwide shortages of nasopharyngeal swabs required for sample collection. While the shortages are becoming acute due to supply chain disruptions, the demand for testing has increased both as a prerequisite to lifting restrictions and in preparation for the second wave. One of the potential solutions to this crisis is the development of 3D printed nasopharyngeal swabs that behave like traditional swabs. However, the opportunity to digitally conceive and fabricate swabs allows for design improvements that can potentially reduce patient pain and discomfort. The study reports the progress that has been made on the development of auxetic nasopharyngeal swabs that can shrink under axial resistance. This allows the swab to navigate through the nasal cavity with significantly less stress on the surrounding tissues. This is achieved through systematically conceived negative Poisson's ratio (-υ) structures in a biocompatible material. Finite element (FE) and surrogate modelling techniques were employed to identify the most optimal swab shape that allows for the highest negative strain (-εlat) under safe stress (σvon). The influence and interaction effects of the geometrical parameters on the swab's performance were also characterised. The research demonstrates a new viewpoint for the development of functional nasopharyngeal swabs that can be 3D printed to reduce patient discomfort. The methodology can be further exploited to address various challenges in biomedical devices and redistributed manufacturing.

3D-printed porous tantalum: recent application in various drug delivery systems to repair hard tissue defects

INTRODUCTION

The treatment of hard tissue defects, especially those of bone and cartilage, induced by infections or tumors remains challenging. Traditional methods, including debridement with systematic chemotherapy, have shortcomings owing to their inability to eliminate infections and high systematic toxicity.

AREA COVERED

This review comprehensively summarizes and discusses the current applications of 3D-printed porous tantalum (3D-P-p-Ta), a novel drug delivery strategy, in drug delivery systems to repair hard tissue defects, as well as the limitations of existing data and potential future research directions.

EXPERT OPINION

Drug delivery systems have advanced medical treatments, with the advantages of high local drug concentration, long drug-release period, and minimal systematic toxicity. Due to its excellent biocompatibility, ideal mechanical property, and anti-corrosion ability, porous tantalum is one of the most preferable loading scaffolds. 3D printing allows for freedom of design and facilitates the production of regular porous implants with high repeatability. There are several reports on the application of 3D-P-p-Ta in drug delivery systems for the management of infection- or tumor-associated bone defects, yet, to the best of our knowledge, no reviews have summarized the current research progress.

Design and analysis of a compliant 3D printed energy harvester housing for knee implants

Instrumented implants have the potential to detect abnormal loading patterns which could be deleterious to implant longevity, indicating a need for intervention which could reduce the need for more complicated revision surgeries. Reliably powering such devices has been one obstacle preventing widespread usage of instrumented implants in clinical populations. This study presents a 3D-printed titanium interpositional device designed to integrate triboelectric generators (TEGs) into a commercially available total knee replacement (TKR). The device's stiffness, durability, and efficacy as a TEG housing were determined. Surprisingly, the stiffness of the 3D printed prototype was 73% less than what was calculated in a corresponding computational model, and under long-term durability testing failed after approximately 30,000 cycles of simulated gait loading. Under cyclical compressive loading, TEGs embedded in the device were able to generate 10.05 μW of power which is sufficient to run the frontend electronics for a load measurement system. The stiffness discrepancy between the computational and experimental models and the premature fatigue failure are suspected to be a result of internal porosity, unfused material and surface roughness of the 3D printed metal. Further refinements in design and manufacturing of the compliant device are required to improve its durability and TEG power output.

Additively manufactured functionally graded biodegradable porous zinc

Topological design provides additively manufactured (AM) biodegradable porous metallic biomaterials with a unique opportunity to adjust their biodegradation behavior and mechanical properties, thereby satisfying the requirements for ideal bone substitutes. However, no information is available yet concerning the effect of topological design on the performance of AM porous zinc (Zn) that outperforms Mg and Fe in biodegradation behavior. Here, we studied one functionally graded and two uniform AM porous Zn designs with diamond unit cell. Cylindrical specimens were fabricated from pure Zn powder by using a powder bed fusion technique, followed by a comprehensive study on their static and dynamic biodegradation behaviors, mechanical properties, permeability, and biocompatibility. Topological design, indeed, affected the biodegradation behavior of the specimens, as evidenced by 150% variations in biodegradation rate between the three different designs. After in vitro dynamic immersion for 28 days, the AM porous Zn had weight losses of 7-12%, relying on the topological design. The degradation rates satisfied the desired biodegradation time of 1-2 years for bone substitution. The mechanical properties of the biodegraded specimens of all the groups maintained within the range of those of cancellous bone. As opposed to the trends observed for other biodegradable porous metals, after 28 days of in vitro biodegradation, the yield strengths of the specimens of all the groups (σy = 7-14 MPa) increased consistently, as compared to those of the as-built specimens (σy = 4-11 MPa). Moreover, AM porous Zn showed excellent biocompatibility, given that the cellular activities in none of the groups differed from the Ti controls for up to 72 h. Using topological design of AM porous Zn for controlling its mechanical properties and degradation behavior is thus clearly promising, thereby rendering flexibility to the material to meet a variety of clinical requirements.

Exploring Macroporosity of Additively Manufactured Titanium Metamaterials for Bone Regeneration with Quality by Design: A Systematic Literature Review

Additive manufacturing facilitates the design of porous metal implants with detailed internal architecture. A rationally designed porous structure can provide to biocompatible titanium alloys biomimetic mechanical and biological properties for bone regeneration. However, increased porosity results in decreased material strength. The porosity and pore sizes that are ideal for porous implants are still controversial in the literature, complicating the justification of a design decision. Recently, metallic porous biomaterials have been proposed for load-bearing applications beyond surface coatings. This recent science lacks standards, but the Quality by Design (QbD) system can assist the design process in a systematic way. This study used the QbD system to explore the Quality Target Product Profile and Ideal Quality Attributes of additively manufactured titanium porous scaffolds for bone regeneration with a biomimetic approach. For this purpose, a total of 807 experimental results extracted from 50 different studies were benchmarked against proposed target values based on bone properties, governmental regulations, and scientific research relevant to bone implants. The scaffold properties such as unit cell geometry, pore size, porosity, compressive strength, and fatigue strength were studied. The results of this study may help future research to effectively direct the design process under the QbD system.

Additively manufactured biodegradable porous metals

Partially due to the unavailability of ideal bone substitutes, the treatment of large bony defects remains one of the most important challenges of orthopedic surgery. Additively manufactured (AM) biodegradable porous metals that have emerged since 2018 provide unprecedented opportunities for fulfilling the requirements of an ideal bone implant. First, the multi-scale geometry of these implants can be customized to mimic the human bone in terms of both micro-architecture and mechanical properties. Second, a porous structure with interconnected pores possesses a large surface area, which is favorable for the adhesion and proliferation of cells and, thus, bony ingrowth. Finally, the freeform geometrical design of such biomaterials could be exploited to adjust their biodegradation behavior so as to maintain the structural integrity of the implant during the healing process while ensuring that the implant disappears afterwards, paving the way for full bone regeneration. While the AM biodegradable porous metals that have been studied so far have shown many unique properties as compared to their solid counterparts, the unprecedented degree of flexibility in their geometrical design has not yet been fully exploited to optimize their properties and performance. In order to develop the ideal bone implants, it is important to take advantage of the full potential of AM biodegradable porous metals through detailed and systematic study on their biodegradation behavior, mechanical properties, biocompatibility, and bone regeneration performance. This review paper presents the state of the art in AM biodegradable porous metals and is focused on the effects of material type, processing, geometrical design, and post-AM treatments on the mechanical properties, biodegradation behavior, in vitro biocompatibility, and in vivo bone regeneration performance of AM porous Mg, Fe, and Zn as well as their alloys. We also identify a number of knowledge gaps and the challenges encountered in adopting AM biodegradable porous metals for orthopedic applications and suggest some promising areas for future research.

Three-Dimensional, MultiScale, and Interconnected Trabecular Bone Mimic Porous Tantalum Scaffold for Bone Tissue Engineering

To investigate the biocompatibility and bone ingrowth properties of a novel trabecular bone mimic porous tantalum scaffold which holds potential for bone tissue engineering, a novel three-dimensional, multiscale interconnected porous tantalum scaffold was designed and manufactured. The morphology of the novel scaffold was observed with the use of scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and industrial computerized tomography. Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) were cultured with novel porous tantalum powder, SEM was carried out for the observation of cell morphology and adhesion, and cytotoxicity was evaluated by the MTT assay. Canine femoral shaft bone defect models were established, and novel porous tantalum rods were used to repair the bone defect. Repair effects and bone integration were evaluated by hard tissue slice examination and push-out tests at the indicated time. We found that the novel porous tantalum scaffold is a trabecular bone mimic, having the characteristics of being three-dimensional, multiscaled, and interconnected. The MSCs adhered to the surface of tantalum and proliferated with time, the tantalum extract did not have a cytotoxic effect on MSCs. In the bone defect model, porous tantalum rods integrated tightly with the host bone, and new bone formation was found on the scaffold-host bone interface both 3 and 6 months after the implantation. Favorable bone ingrowth was observed in the center of the tantalum rod. The push-out test showed that the strength needed to push out the tantalum rod is comparable for both 3 and 6 months when compared with the normal femoral shaft bone tissue. These findings suggested that the novel trabecular bone mimic porous tantalum scaffold is biocompatible and osteoinductive, which holds potential for bone tissue engineering application.

A novel design, analysis and 3D printing of Ti-6Al-4V alloy bio-inspired porous femoral stem

The current study is proposing a design envelope for porous Ti-6Al-4V alloy femoral stems to survive under fatigue loads. Numerical computational analysis of these stems with a body-centered-cube (BCC) structure is conducted in ABAQUS. Femoral stems without shell and with various outer dense shell thicknesses (0.5, 1.0, 1.5, and 2 mm) and inner cores (porosities of 90, 77, 63, 47, 30, and 18%) are analyzed. A design space (envelope) is derived by using stem stiffnesses close to that of the femur bone, maximum fatigue stresses of 0.3σ_ys in the porous part, and endurance limits of the dense part of the stems. The Soderberg approach is successfully employed to compute the factor of safety N_f > 1.1. Fully porous stems without dense shells are concluded to fail under fatigue load. It is thus safe to use the porous stems with a shell thickness of 1.5 and 2 mm for all porosities (18-90%), 1 mm shell with 18 and 30% porosities, and 0.5 mm shell with 18% porosity. The reduction in stress shielding was achieved by 28%. Porous stems incorporated BCC structures with dense shells and beads were successfully printed.

Functionality-packed additively manufactured porous titanium implants

The holy grail of orthopedic implant design is to ward off both aseptic and septic loosening for long enough that the implant outlives the patient. Questing this holy grail is feasible only if orthopedic biomaterials possess a long list of functionalities that enable them to discharge the onerous task of permanently replacing the native bone tissue. Here, we present a rationally designed and additive manufacturing (AM) topologically ordered porous metallic biomaterial that is made from Ti-6Al-4V using selective laser melting and packs most (if not all) of the required functionalities into a single implant. In addition to presenting a fully interconnected porous structure and form-freedom that enables realization of patient-specific implants, the biomaterials developed here were biofunctionalized using plasma electrolytic oxidation to locally release both osteogenic (i.e. strontium) and antibacterial (i.e. silver ions) agents. The same single-step biofunctionalization process also incorporated hydroxyapatite into the surface of the implants. Our measurements verified the continued release of both types of active agents up to 28 days. Assessment of the antibacterial activity in vitro and in an ex vivo murine model demonstrated extraordinarily high levels of bactericidal effects against a highly virulent and multidrug-resistant Staphylococcus aureus strain (i.e. USA300) with total eradication of both planktonic and adherent bacteria. This strong antibacterial behavior was combined with a significantly enhanced osteogenic behavior, as evidenced by significantly higher levels of alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity compared with non-biofunctionalized implants. Finally, we discovered synergistic antibacterial behavior between strontium and silver ions, meaning that 4-32 folds lower concentrations of silver ions were required to achieve growth inhibition and total killing of bacteria. The functionality-packed biomaterial presented here demonstrates a unique combination of functionalities that make it an advanced prototype of future orthopedic biomaterials where implants will outlive patients.

Immunomodulation of surface biofunctionalized 3D printed porous titanium implants

Additive manufacturing (AM) techniques have provided many opportunities for the rational design of porous metallic biomaterials with complex and precisely controlled topologies that give rise to unprecedented combinations of mechanical, physical, and biological properties. These favorable properties can be enhanced by surface biofunctionalization to enable full tissue regeneration and minimize the risk of implant-associated infections (IAIs). There is, however, an increasing need to investigate the immune responses triggered by surface biofunctionalized AM porous metals. Here, we studied the immunomodulatory effects of AM porous titanium (Ti-6Al-4V) printed using selective laser melting, and of two additional groups consisting of AM implants surface biofunctionalized using plasma electrolytic oxidation (PEO) with/without silver nanoparticles. The responses of human primary macrophages and human mesenchymal stromal cells (hMSCs) were studied in terms of cell viability, cell morphology and biomarkers of macrophage polarization. Non-treated AM porous titanium triggered a strong pro-inflammatory response in macrophages, albeit combined with signs of anti-inflammatory effects. The PEO treatment of AM porous titanium implants showed a higher potential to induce polarization towards a pro-repair macrophage phenotype. We detected no cytotoxicity against hMSCs in any of the groups. However, the incorporation of silver nanoparticles resulted in strong cytotoxicity against attached macrophages. The results of this study indicate the potential immunomodulatory effects of the AM porous titanium enhanced with PEO treatment, and point towards caution and further research when using silver nanoparticles for preventing IAIs.

Corrosion fatigue behavior of additively manufactured biodegradable porous zinc

Additively manufactured (AM) biodegradable porous zinc exhibits great potential as a promising bone-substituting biomaterial. However, there is no information whatsoever available regarding its corrosion fatigue behavior. In this study, we used direct metal printing to fabricate topologically ordered biodegradable porous zinc based on a diamond unit cell. We compared the compression-compression fatigue behavior of AM porous zinc in air and in revised simulated body fluid (r-SBF). The fatigue strength of AM porous zinc was high in air (i.e., 70% of its yield strength) and even higher in r-SBF (i.e., 80% of its yield strength). The high value of the relative fatigue strength in air could be attributed to the good ductility of pure zinc itself. The formation of corrosion products around the strut junctions might explain the higher fatigue strength of AM zinc in r-SBF. Furthermore, we compared the fatigue behavior of a uniform design of the AM porous zinc with a functionally graded design. The functionally graded structure exhibited higher relative fatigue strengths than the uniform structure. The inspection of the fatigue crack distribution revealed that the functionally graded design controlled the sequence of crack initiation, which occurred early in the thicker struts and moved towards the thinner struts over time. The theoretical fatigue life models suggest that optimizing the functionally graded structure could be used as an effective means to improve the fatigue life of AM porous zinc. In conclusion, the favorable fatigue behavior of AM porous zinc further highlights its potential as a promising bone-substituting biomaterial. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Additively manufactured (AM) biodegradable porous zinc exhibits great potential for the treatment of large bony defects. However, there is no information available regarding its corrosion fatigue behavior. Here, we compared the fatigue behavior of AM porous zinc in air and in revised simulated body fluid (r-SBF). The fatigue strength of AM porous Zn was even higher in r-SBF than in air, which were attributed to the formation of corrosion products. Furthermore, we found that the functionally graded structure controlled the sequence of crack initiation in differently sized struts and exhibited higher relative fatigue strengths than the uniform structure, suggesting that optimizing the functionally graded structure could be an effective means to improve the fatigue life of AM porous Zn.

Additively manufactured biodegradable porous zinc

Additively manufacturing (AM) opens up the possibility for biodegradable metals to possess uniquely combined characteristics that are desired for bone substitution, including bone-mimicking mechanical properties, topologically ordered porous structure, pore interconnectivity and biodegradability. Zinc is considered to be one of the promising biomaterials with respect to biodegradation rate and biocompatibility. However, no information regarding the biodegradability and biocompatibility of topologically ordered AM porous zinc is yet available. Here, we applied powder bed fusion to fabricate porous zinc with a topologically ordered diamond structure. An integrative study was conducted on the static and dynamic biodegradation behavior (in vitro, up to 4 weeks), evolution of mechanical properties with increasing immersion time, electrochemical performance, and biocompatibility of the AM porous zinc. The specimens lost 7.8% of their weight after 4 weeks of dynamic immersion in a revised simulated body fluid. The mechanisms of biodegradation were site-dependent and differed from the top of the specimens to the bottom. During the whole in vitro immersion time of 4 weeks, the elastic modulus values of the AM porous zinc (E = 700-1000 MPa) even increased and remained within the scope of those of cancellous bone. Indirect cytotoxicity revealed good cellular activity up to 72 h according to ISO 10,993-5 and -12. Live-dead staining confirmed good viability of MG-63 cells cultured on the surface of the AM porous zinc. These important findings could open up unprecedented opportunities for the development of multifunctional bone substituting materials that will enable reconstruction and regeneration of critical-size load-bearing bone defects. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: No information regarding the biodegradability and biocompatibility of topologically ordered AM porous zinc is available. We applied selective laser melting to fabricate topologically ordered porous zinc and conducted a comprehensive study on the biodegradation behavior, electrochemical performance, time-dependent mechanical properties, and biocompatibility of the scaffolds. The specimens lost 7.8% of their weight after4 weeks dynamic biodegradation while their mechanical properties surprisingly increased after 4 weeks. Indirect cytotoxicity revealed good cellular activity up to 72 h. Intimate contact between MG-63 cells and the scaffolds was also observed. These important findings could open up unprecedented opportunities for the development of multifunctional bone substituting materials that mimic bone properties and enable full regeneration of critical-size load-bearing bony defects.

Meta-biomaterials

Meta-biomaterials are designer biomaterials with unusual and even unprecedented properties that primarily originate from their geometrical designs at different (usually smaller) length scales.