Risk assessment and chemical fractionation of selected elements in surface sediments from Lake Qarun, Egypt using modified BCR technique

Recovery of Zn and Cu from municipal solid waste incineration fly ash by integrating ammonium leaching and ammonia removal

This study introduces an environmentally friendly process for recovering zinc (Zn) and copper (Cu) from municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash using ammonium chloride leaching and ammonia removal. The leaching rates for Zn and Cu were 54.39% and 86.23%, respectively, with total recovery rates reaching 52.21% and 85.28%, respectively. The recovered precipitate demonstrated significant Zn (33.62%) and Cu (14.19%) contents, making it ideal for metal smelting. The ammonium leaching process also showcased effective reduction and dechlorination effects on the fly ash. The treated fly ash had a reduced mass of only 30.63% of the original, and chlorine content decreased from 26.23% to 0.84%. The results of this study support the sustainable utilization of MSWI fly ash by facilitating valuable resource recovery and promoting its conversion into construction materials.

Distribution, speciation, and bioaccumulation of potentially toxic elements in the grey mangroves at Indian Sundarbans, in relation to vessel movements

Sundarban is the world's largest mangrove wetland and home of 4.6 million people (Indian part), whose principal mode of communication is motorized boats (ferries). This study shed light on the role played by ferry movement in the speciation (following the BCR three-step sequential extraction method), ecological impact and bioaccumulation of potentially toxic elements (PTEs) in plant tissues (root and lamina) of grey mangrove (Avicennia marina) found near the five ferry ghats (ports). One-way ANOVA showed variation in major soil parameters (silt, clay, organic carbon, pH, Electrical conductivity) and PTEs (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, and Pb) between sites. Sequential extraction revealed that Cd was present in the 'exchangeable' form across the sites, Pb was in the 'reducible' form, and the rest of the PTEs were majorly found in 'residual' phase. Pollution indices revealed moderate to heavy contamination and considerable potential ecological risk due to Cd. Pearson correlation statistics and concentration variations indicate a relation between Pb and ferry movement frequency in the sites. Higher bioconcentration of Pb in the roots of A. marina, indicates phytostabilization action. Translocation factor for Cd in the leaves, indicates phytoextraction by A. marina. Principal component analysis (PCA) and hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) showed a close association between vehicle movement and Hg, Pb, Silt fraction, electrical conductivity, Cr, and As. This study recommends regular pollution monitoring across Sundarbans, as the PTEs in sediment-plant matrix can impact the higher trophic levels, human health through possible biomagnification in the detritus food chain, and can adversely impact the existing conservation initiatives.

A double-edged sword: Reductive soil disinfestation changes the fates of trace metal elements in soil

Although the effects of reductive soil disinfestation (RSD) in soil sterilization have been proven in several countries, the potential risks of trace metal elements (TMEs) caused by RSD require further assessment. Here, freshly Cd-spiked soil and historically contaminated greenhouse soil were exposed to RSD and the fates of TMEs, Cd, Co, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn, were investigated. All RSD treatments lasted for 21 days and subsamples were collected at different time intervals. Samples were open-air incubated for another 7 days until day 28 to simulate the situation after drainage. The bioavailability and geochemical fractionation of TMEs were investigated based on single and sequential extraction procedures and the environmental risks were assessed. The results showed that RSD increased the relative abundance of Firmicutes and Bacteroidetes, and the content of functional groups, including Fe, Mn, and S compounds respirations increased after RSD, highlighting the possible reductive dissolution of FeMn oxides and precipitation of TMEs. The dissolution decreased the reducible fractions of TMEs and increased the acid-soluble fractions of Co, Ni, Pb, and Zn, in the European Community Bureau of Reference results, reflecting the activation of TMEs in soils. However, the precipitation of sulfate resulted in the stabilization of Cd and Cu in two types of soils, increased their residual fractions, and decreased their acid-soluble fractions and bioavailabilities. After drainage, because the influence caused by precipitation rapidly disappeared and the impact of FeMn oxides dissolution remained, the acid-solubility of TMEs was greater than their initial status in the two soils. Furthermore, as a highly toxic metal, the activation of Cd at 28 days caused the rapid increase of ecological risks, which is particularly concerning. The results suggest that RSD temporarily increases the potential risks of TMEs and that certain measures must be taken.

Distribution, bioavailability, and ecological risk assessment of potentially toxic heavy metals in El-Burullus Lake sediments, Egypt

El-Burullus Lake is the second largest coastal lagoon in Egypt in addition to its connection to the Mediterranean Sea. In this study, geochemical fractionations of heavy metals (Fe, Pb, Cd, Cu, Cr and Zn) were investigated after the great efforts made to rehabilitate and restore the lake by the Egyptian Government. The results indicated that F4 (residual fraction) was the dominant fraction for all studied metals followed by F3 (oxidizable fraction). That means the majority of studied metals source in the lake is lithogenic. Contamination by each individual heavy metal or multi elements was low according to individual contamination factor (ICF) and global contamination factor (GCF). Risk assessment code (RAC) classification showed that Cd and Cu exhibited low risk, Zn was of moderate risk, whereas, other metals are safe. The toxicity calculated by toxic risk index (TRI) indicating that no toxic risk was expected in the Lake.

Environmental risk assessment of potentially toxic elements in Doce River watershed after mining sludge dam breakdown in Mariana, MG, Brazil

Faced with a potential risk of a colossal amount of sludge released into the Doce River basin in the most shocking Brazilian mining disaster, we proposed to assess the environmental risk from a new perspective: Understanding the mobilization of potentially toxic elements (PTE) with the geochemical fractions. Soil and sediment samples were taken in nine sites throughout the basin and characterized. The environmental risk was assessed from the PTE sequential extraction in three fractions: soluble, reducible, and oxidizable, in addition to the pseudo-total concentration. The potential mobile fraction (PMF) showed a considerable PTE mobilization from the soil and sediment samples. Principal component statistical analysis indicated the sludge as the single source of PTE. The risk assessment depended on the fractional distribution and the PTE enrichment degree in the affected samples. The fractional distribution contributed mainly to Mn, Sb, and Pb mobility, with PMF of 96%, 81%, and 100%, respectively. The mobilization of Cd, Co, Ag, Ni, Pb, Zn, and Cu was predominantly related to the degree of enrichment. The risk assessment from the geochemical fractions pointed to the magnitude of the disaster and the dispersion of PTE with severe effects on the affected populations. Therefore, more strongly enforced regulations in the basin are needed, in addition to the urgent use of more secure containment dams. It is also essential to emphasize the transferability of the design of this study to other environmental units in mining disaster conditions.

Distribution, risk assessment, and source identification of trace metal pollution along the Babolsar coastal area, Caspian Sea

The Caspian Sea is exposed to numerous anthropogenic activities such as untreated wastewater discharge and agricultural activities which increased trace metals contamination. The current study was employed to assess the distribution, ecological risk assessment, and source identification of some trace metals in 125 samples of surface sediments and soil from 6 distinctive sections of Babolsar in the coastal line of the Caspian Sea. The sediment quality guidelines (SQGs) and individual risk assessment indices including enrichment factor (EF), geo-accumulation index (Igeo), contamination factor (Cf), and potential risk factor (Er) suggested a hazardous level of Cd and Cr contamination. There was a relatively high level of Pb contamination while other studied trace metals were at a low contamination level. Cumulative risk indices such as modified degree of contamination (mCD), pollution load index (PLI), and the potential ecological risk index (RI) identified that the river, wetland, and farmland sites were more contaminated compared to the Caspian Sea samples which exhibited a moderate level of contamination. The lowest level of contamination was recorded in the coastline and river delta sites. Two analytical methods including Pearson's correlation coefficient and multivariate clustering dendrogram were also applied to identify the potential sources of contamination. The results suggested that wastewaters, nitrogen, and phosphate fertilizers were the main anthropogenic source of Cd, Co, Pb, and Ni while fossil fuels and transportation activities were the predominant sources of anthropogenic Cu, V, and Zn contamination. Further studies about trace metals risk assessment and fractionation could contribute to more effective decisions for reducing the anthropogenic trace metal pollution in the Caspian Sea.

Speciation and risk assessment of Zn, Pb, and Cd in bottom sediments of two small upland dam reservoirs, Poland

Sediments of two small dam reservoirs in Poland, Zalew Zemborzycki (ZZ) and Brody Iłżeckie (BI), were studied. Sediments from both reservoirs were sampled at 17 sites in the transects perpendicular to the shoreline, at the river inflow and the frontal dam and analysed using the BCR procedure for speciation of zinc (Zn), lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd). The risk assessment code (RAC) and the individual contamination factor (ICF) were determined. In BI, the sediments were removed from the considerable part of the reservoir, creating an opportunity to study the effect of dredging on the speciation of trace metals. Trace metals partitioning was differentiated according to the transect/site and in the case of BI sediments also on the transect location in the dredged or undredged part of the reservoir. Considering ZZ sediments, the order of fractions for Zn, Pb and Cd according to a decreasing overall mean percentage contribution to total metal content was the same: F4 (residual) >F3 (oxidisable) >F2 (reducible) >F1 (acid soluble). In sediments of ZZ at most sites, the RAC for Zn, Pb and Cd revealed low or medium risk and ICF low or moderate contamination. For BI sediments, the order of fractions for Pb was similar while for Zn and Cd quite the opposite compared to the sediments of ZZ and it was: Pb-F4>F3>F1>F2, Zn-F1>F3>F2>F4, Cd-F1>F2>F3>F4. For BI sediments, RAC values for Zn, on average, indicated high and very high ecological risk; for Pb low and moderate risk and for Cd - high risk in the initial part and dredged part and according to the average value in the reservoir, while a medium risk in undredged part sediments. The ICF index showed high contamination with Cd for all BI sediments. The sequential analysis showed that Pb is poorly mobile as in sediments of both reservoirs residual fractions accounted, on average, for about 60% of the total content.

Fractionation analysis and risk assessment of potential toxic elements in reservoir sediments in central China

The pollution of potential toxic elements (PTEs) in the environment is a persistent issue and draws public attention constantly. However, there is no study comprehensively assessing the PTE pollution of water supply reservoirs in central China. This study determined the total contents and fractions of seven PTEs in 10 water supply reservoirs of central China, and evaluated PTE pollution risks by adopting various models. The results indicated that PTE pollution in water supply reservoirs was lower comparing that in estuary or river sediments, and Mn (manganese) was the predominant PTE in central China reservoirs. Fractionation analysis revealed that for B1 fraction (exchangeable/acid-soluble fraction) of Mn, Zn (zinc) and B2 fraction (reducible fraction) of Pb (lead) was high, while the effective state portion of Cr (chromium) was small. The monomial potential ecological risk indices and Igeo values were low among most samples, indicating overall modest PTE pollution. However, the results of the individual contamination factor (ICF) suggested that Pb might lead to potential health risks to human beings.

Assessing the environmental risk and mobility of cobalt in sediment near nonferrous metal mines with risk assessment indexes and the diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) technique

The Jialing River is the tributary of the Yangtze River with the largest drainage area. In recent years, the Jialing River has suffered a series of environmental problems, such as discharge of industrial effluent and sand mining activities, which have severely threatened the aquatic ecosystem of the river. In the present study, we employed risk assessment indexes, sequential extraction and the diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) technique to assess environmental risks and study the remobilization of cobalt (Co) in sediments. The potential ecological risk index and risk assessment code results demonstrated that Co may pose a low environmental and ecological risk to the local aquatic environment. However, BCR sequential extraction showed that the sum of the F1, F2 and F3 fractions of Co still accounted for over 50% of the Co in the study areas, indicating that sediments may be a source of Co release. The DGT results showed an increasing trend for DGT-labile Co in deep sediments (-8 cm to -12 cm), and the calculated flux values ranged from 0.08 to 15.54 ng cm²·day^-1, indicating that Co tends to transfer across the sediment-water interface at all sampling sites. Correlation analysis showed that F1-Co, F2-Co and F3-Co are the fractions readily captured by DGT and can be used for predicting Co remobilization in sediment. Sand mining activities contribute substantially to the release of Co from the F1 and F3 fractions as a result of strong stirring of sediments and introduction of oxygen into the sediments. The reductive dissolution of iron (Fe) and manganese (Mn) hydroxides or oxides causes the release of Co and Fe/Mn in the sediment, which leads to Co release from the reducible fraction. The above work suggests that sand mining in the Jialing River should be reasonably regulated to prohibit illegal sand mining activities.

Partitioning behavior and ecological risk of arsenic and antimony in the sediment-porewater profile system in the Three Gorges Reservoir, China

Arsenic and antimony are widely distributed toxic metalloids in aquatic environments. However, their partitioning behaviors in the sediment profile remain not well understood. Here, partitioning behaviors, diffusive fluxes, as well as the ecological risks of As and Sb in the sediment-porewater profile system in the tributaries of the Three Gorges Reservoir (TGR) were investigated. As and Sb showed markedly different spatial variations in the longitudinal profiles of both porewater and sediment samples. Specifically, the concentration of As showed an accumulation trend with depth, while that of Sb showed a relatively complicated trend. Further, As showed lower sediment-porewater partitioning coefficient (K_d) values, suggesting that it had a relatively lower sediment affinity and a higher mobility than Sb. Its residual fraction (30%-60%) was also lower than that of Sb. This phenomenon could be attributed to the chemical fractions of the trace metals and the pH value of the sediments. Furthermore, the K_d values corresponding to As were influenced by both the residual fraction (r = 0.338, p < 0.05) and the exchangeable fraction (r = -0.643, p < 0.01), while those corresponding to Sb were only influenced by pH. Additionally, even though these two trace metals showed low ecological and mobility risks, the diffusive fluxes at the sediment-water interface suggested that the sediment acted as a source of As and a sink for Sb relative to the overlying water. This study indicated that As and Sb had different partitioning behaviors and release risks in the sediment-porewater profile system, enhanced the understanding the transport and fate of As and Sb in the aquatic environment.

Occurrence and Ecological Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals from Wuliangsuhai Lake, Yellow River Basin, China

As one of the eight largest freshwater lakes in China, Wuliangsuhai Lake is an extremely rare large lake with biodiversity and environmental protection functions in one of the world’s arid or semi-arid areas and it plays a pivotal role in protecting the ecological security of the Yellow River Basin. Heavy metals in sediment interstitial water, surface sediments, and sediment cores of Wuliangsuhai Lake were investigated and analyzed, and the pollution degree evaluated based on multiple assessment methods. The bioavailability of heavy metals of the surface sediments was evaluated by calculating the ratio of chemical fractions of heavy metals. The toxicity assessment of sediment interstitial water indicated that Ni, Zn, As, and Cd would not be toxic to aquatic ecosystems, however, Hg and Cr in some regions may cause acute toxicity to the benthos. The ecological assessment results of the surface sediments indicated that some areas of the lake are heavily polluted and the main polluting elements are Cd and Hg. Cd has the highest bioavailability because of its high exchangeable fraction ratio. In addition, exogenous pollution accumulated within 20 cm of the sediment cores, and then, with the increasing of the depth, the pollution degree and ecological risk decreased.

Partitioning and Availability of Metals from Water Suspended Sediments: Potential Pollution Risk Assessment

The water management initiatives in freshwater systems focus on water availability to preserve this resource for human uses and the health of aquatic ecosystems. This work presents an assessment of the potential pollution risk caused by the metal availability in suspended sediments. The objective of this study was to determine the partitioning, association, and geochemical fractionation of metals in suspended sediments from a surface water body. Additionally, the environmental assessment for this reservoir was estimated using geoaccumulation, enrichment, and pollution indices of metals and the related potential risk by their elemental availability (RAC). Chemical, mineralogical, and morphological characterizations were obtained by inductively coupled plasma spectrometry, alpha spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography, and scanning electron microscopy. Clay, quartz, montmorillonite, and calcite were the main minerals of suspended sediments. Chemical fractionation was the parameter affecting the concentrations of metals in suspended sediments. The sediment composition is of natural origin; however, these finer particles can promote the scavenging of toxic metals. It contributes to obtaining moderate to high levels for enrichment/contamination indices. Although Ca, Mg, Sr, and U were the most accessible metals for aquatic biota, Pb and Mn in the exchangeable phase of suspended sediments are the potentially toxic elements in this aquatic ecosystem.

Utilization of Pollution Indices, Hyperspectral Reflectance Indices, and Data-Driven Multivariate Modelling to Assess the Bottom Sediment Quality of Lake Qaroun, Egypt

Assessing the environmental hazard of potentially toxic elements in bottom sediments has always been based entirely on ground samples and laboratory tests. This approach is remarkably accurate, but it is slow, expensive, damaging, and spatially constrained, making it unsuitable for monitoring these parameters effectively. The main goal of the present study was to assess the quality of sediment samples collected from Lake Qaroun by using different groups of spectral reflectance indices (SRIs), integrating data-driven (Artificial Neural Networks; ANN) and multivariate analysis such as multiple linear regression (MLR) and partial least square regression (PLSR). Jetty cruises were carried out to collect sediment samples at 22 distinct sites over the entire Lake Qaroun, and subsequently 21 metals were analysed. Potential ecological risk index (RI), organic matter (OM), and pollution load index (PLI) of lake’s bottom sediments were subjected to evaluation. The results demonstrated that PLI showed that roughly 59% of lake sediments are polluted (PLI > 1), especially samples of eastern and southern sides of the lake’s central section, while 41% were unpolluted (PLI < 1), which composed samples of the western and western northern regions. The RI’s findings were that all the examined sediments pose a very high ecological risk (RI > 600). It is obvious that the three band spectral indices are more efficient in quantifying different investigated parameters. The results showed the efficiency of the three tested models to predict OM, PLI, and RI, revealing that the ANN is the best model to predict these parameters. For instance, the determination coefficient values of the ANN model of calibration datasets for predicting OM, PLI, and RI were 0.999, 0.999, and 0.999, while they were 0.960, 0.897, and 0.853, respectively, for the validation dataset. The validation dataset of the PLSR produced R2 values higher than with MLR for predicting PLI and RI. Finally, the study’s main conclusion is that combining ANN, PLSR, and MLR with proximal remote sensing could be a very effective tool for the detection of OM and pollution indices. Based on our findings, we suggest the created models are easy tools for forecasting these measured parameters.

Environmental Pollution Indices and Multivariate Modeling Approaches for Assessing the Potentially Harmful Elements in Bottom Sediments of Qaroun Lake, Egypt

This research intends to offer a scientific foundation for environmental monitoring and early warning which will aid in the environmental protection management of Qaroun Lake. Qaroun Lake is increasingly influenced by untreated wastewater discharge from many anthropogenic activities, making it vulnerable to pollution. For that, six environmental pollution indices, namely contamination factor (Cf), enrichment factor (EF), geo-accumulation index (Igeo), degree of contamination (Dc), pollution load index (PLI), and potential ecological risk index (RI), were utilized to assess the bottom sediment and to determine the different geo-environmental variables affecting the lake system. Cluster analysis (CA), and principal component analysis (PCA) were used to explore the potential pollution sources of heavy metal. Moreover, the efficiency of partial least-square regression (PLSR) and multiple linear regression (MLR) were tested to assess the Dc, PLI, and RI depending on the selected elements. The sediment samples were carefully collected from 16 locations of Qaroun Lake in two investigated years in 2018 and 2019. Total concentrations of Al, As, Ba, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Ga, Hf, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Ni, P, Pb, Sb, Se, Zn, and Zr were quantified using inductively coupled plasma mass spectra (ICP-MS). According to the Cf, EF, and Igeo results, As, Cd, Ga, Hf, P, Sb, Se, and Zr demonstrated significant enrichment in sediment and were derived from anthropogenic sources. According to Dc results, all collected samples were categorized under a very high degree of contamination. Further, the results of RI showed that the lake is at very high ecological risk. Meanwhile, the PLI data indicated 59% of lake was polluted and 41% had PLI < 1. The PLSR and MLR models based on studied elements presented the highest efficiency as alternative approaches to assess the Dc, PLI, and RI of sediments. For examples, the validation (Val.) models presented the best performance of these indices, with R2val = 0.948–0.989 and with model accuracy ACCv = 0.984–0.999 for PLSR, and with R2val = 0.760–0.979 and with ACCv = 0.867–0.984 for MLR. Both models for Dc, PLI, and RI showed that there was no clear overfitting or underfitting between measuring, calibrating, and validating datasets. Finally, the combinations of Cf, EF, Igeo, PLI, Dc, RI, CA, PCA, PLSR, and MLR approaches represent valuable and applicable methods for assessing the risk of potentially harmful elemental contamination in the sediment of Qaroun Lake.

A Comprehensive Exploration on Pollution Characteristics and Ecological Risks of Heavy Metals in Surface Paddy Soils around a Large Copper Smelter, Southeast China

To assess heavy metal pollution and ecological risk, a total of 28 surface paddy soil samples were collected and analyzed around a famous copper smelter in Guixi, China. The results showed that all sites were heavily contaminated by both Cu and Cd, compared with soil background values, whose average concentrations exceeded the standard by 5.7 and 12.3 times, respectively, posing a slight ecological risk related to Cu (potential ecological risk index <40) and an extremely serious ecological risk related to Cd (potential ecological risk index >320). The risks were also demonstrated through the speciation analyses of Cu (CaCl2-Cu 2.63%, acid-soluble Cu 8.67%, and residual Cu 74.17%, on average) and Cd (CaCl2-Cd 47.30%, acid-soluble Cd 45.02%, and residual Cd 28.87%, on average) in the surface paddy soil, including the use of a CaCl2 extraction procedure and the BCR (Community Bureau of Reference) sequential extraction scheme. Several soil properties (residual carbon, cation exchange capacity, and soil texture) were significantly correlated with soil Cd but made a small contribution to their variability with a poor linear fit because of external Cd input to the soil, while soil total potassium largely influenced the soil Cu species except for residual Cu. Therefore, an effective Cu pollution regulation strategy through soil potassium control is suggested for this smelter soil.

A novel remediation method of cadmium (Cd) contaminated soil: Dynamic equilibrium of Cd2+ rapid release from soil to water and selective adsorption by PP-g-AA fibers-ball at low concentration

The acid-extractable fraction Cd(II) in soil accumulates easily in organisms, migrates and transforms in the ecological environment, which has posed potential health risks to human. This study found that the acid-extractable fraction Cd(II) in soil could be released rapidly into water at very low Cd²⁺ concentration. Carboxylated polypropylene (PP-g-AA) fibers-ball with high selectivity as adsorbent was used in the Cd(II) contaminated soil-water system. It could remove promptly trace Cd²⁺ from water even in the presence of interfering metal ions. Moreover, Cd(II) desorbed from soil to water could be continuously adsorbed by PP-g-AA fibers-ball, which kept the Cd²⁺ concentration always at a low level. This forms a dynamic equilibrium of rapid release- selective adsorption toward the acid-extractable fraction Cd(II) in the soil-water system. Here, the migratory pathway for the acid-extractable fraction Cd(II) to be released from contaminated soil to water and adsorbed simultaneously on the surface of PP-g-AA fibers-ball was established. This work offers a novel protocol that can remove more than 90% of the acid-extractable fraction Cd(II) from contaminated soil within 12 h, thereby contributes better to mitigate the risk of Cd(II) from soil to the food chain without changing the physical and chemical properties of soil.

Integrated Assessment of Affinity to Chemical Fractions and Environmental Pollution with Heavy Metals: A New Approach Based on Sequential Extraction Results

To assess the affinity degree of heavy metals (HMs) to geochemical phases, many indices with several limitations are used. Thus, this study aims to develop a new complex index for assessing contamination level and affinity to chemical fractions in various solid environmental media. For this, a new integrated approach using the chemical affinity index (CAF) is proposed. Comparison of CAF with %F on the literature examples on fractionation of HMs from soils, bottom sediments, atmospheric PM₁₀, and various particle size fractions of road dust proved a less significant role of the residual HMs fraction and a greater contribution of the rest of the chemical fractions in the pollution of all studied environments. This fact is due to the normalization relative to the global geochemical reference standard, calculations of contribution of an individual element to the total pollution by all studied HMs, and contribution of the particular chemical fraction to the total HMs content taken into account in CAF. The CAF index also shows a more significant role in pollution and chemical affinity of mobile and potentially mobile forms of HMs. The strong point of CAF is the stability of the obtained HM series according to the degree of chemical affinity and contamination. Future empirical studies are necessary for the more precise assessment of CAF taking into account the spatial distribution of HMs content, geographic conditions, geochemical factors, the intensity of anthropogenic impact, environmental parameters (temperature, humidity, precipitation, pH value, the content of organic matter, electrical conductivity, particle size distribution, etc.). The combined use of CAF along with other indices allows a more detailed assessment of the strength of HMs binding to chemical phases, which is crucial for understanding the HMs’ fate in the environment.

Metal bioavailability, toxicity, and ecological risk due to sediments of a lately rehabilitated lake (Mariut, Egypt)

Sediments from Lake Mariut, Egypt, after its rehabilitation, and its anoxic diverted polluted drains were subjected to five sequential steps to define different geochemical fractions of eight studied metals. Results cleared out that 30-50% of its total Cd and total Co contents are easily bioavailable with a high-risk assessment code (RAC) to enter the food chain in the lake basin. Whereas Cu and Fe are safe and the remaining studied metals, i.e., Mn, Zn, Pb, and Cr are of medium risk for the environment. Individual contamination factor (ICF) is high (> 6) for all the studied metals except for Fe and Cu which are tightly held in sediments confirming their safeness to biota. Cadmium accounted for > 94% of the total risk in the study area. Metal pollution loading (MPL) from the sediments was found in the order: Fe > Mn > Zn > Pb > Cu > Cr > Co > Cd.

Application of DGT/DIFS to assess bioavailable Cd to maize and its release in agricultural soils

Tianjin, as an important maize production region in China, has a long history of sewage irrigation resulting in the soil cadmium (Cd) contamination. In this study, single extractions of CaCl₂ and HNO₃, BCR sequential extraction and the diffusive gradients in thin films technique (DGT) were used to measure the bioavailable Cd content in soils. The Cd content in soil samples all exceeded the background values, with 14.3% and 33.3% of sites in the Baodi District (BDD) and Jinghai District (JHD) exceeding the risk control values, respectively. The average content of Cd in maize samples is lower than the pollution control values, which may be related to the higher pH (8.53) and organic matter (OM) content (15.01 g kg^-1) in soils. Bioavailable Cd measured by DGT correlated well with Cd in maize grains (R² =0.92). The DGT and DIFS model predicted the metals release from the agricultural lands, the total concentration of Cd in soil was relatively low, but the labile Cd in the soils has adequate metal release capability. This study shows that DGT is efficient in predicting Cd accumulation in grains from contaminated soils.

Fast and easily obtained information about mobilizable metals from sediment samples. Extraction assisted by benzothiophene-based ionic liquids

A fast and easy method for trace metal extraction on sediments was developed in our laboratories. Three new stable S-metylbenzothiophenium salts were employed along with microwaves to modify the BCR protocol to obtain the concentration of metals of the first two fractions in only one step. The optimum conditions were obtained with 0.125 g of sediment irradiated at 250 W for 30 s at 120 °C, in 5 ml of an aqueous mixture of 10 mM of 1,2-dimethylbenzothiophenium tetrafluoroborate and 0.5 M of hydroxylamine chlorhydrate at pH 2. The method validation was carried out employing BCR 701. The extracted metals were determined by ICP OES. A student's paired t-test was applied with the reference method, giving satisfactory results.

Bioavailability and risk assessment of trace metals in sediments of a high-altitude eutrophic lake, Ooty, Tamil Nadu, India

Ooty lake, in the southern part of India, has raised huge concern about the role of metals in a lake due to increasing anthropogenic activities. Present study is aimed at understanding fate of trace metals in a lake's sediment. Sixteen sediment samples collected from bottom of the lake at various locations during March 2017 were analysed for trace metals cobalt, chromium, copper, iron, lead, manganese, nickel and zinc. Fe and Mn dominate total metal concentration followed by Ni and Cr. A high concentration of Cr, Cu, Ni and Zn in residual fraction indicates weathering as the source for these metals. A significant concentration of metals in exchangeable, reducible and oxidisable fraction indicates adsorbtion/chelation of these metals with oxides and organic matter due to change in oxic state. Geo-accumulation index for metals show unpolluted to moderate nature of sediments at all sampling locations. Moderate to significant enrichment factor of Cr, Ni and Zn indicates influence of anthropogenic sources. Co, Pb and Zn show a high amount of bioavailability for aquatic life. Other metals (Cr, Ni, Fe and Mn) show scarce to moderate bioavailability. On the other hand, a global contamination factor denotes moderate to high metal contamination of sediments in the entire lake. Statistical analysis of metals shows good inter-element correlation among metals Fe, Cr, Ni, Co, Cu and Zn indicating natural source. Influence of domestic sewage and recreational activities as the main/additional source is revealed by negative loading of Pb and Zn in principal component analysis. The present study, in essence, has identified rock weathering, as a major source of trace meals in the sediments of Ooty lake entering through stream and surface runoff from an adjacent forest area. The study has also identified high bioavailability of Pb and Zn, which is derived through the recreational activities (boating) causing permanent adverse impact.

Anomalous Fluctuation of Halogens in Relation to the Pollution Status along Lake Mariout, Egypt

This paper aimed to study the anomalous fluctuation of halogens with respect to the pollution status in surface water (w), pore water (p), and sediments (s) of Lake Mariout. It provided a framework for understanding the distribution of dissolved and precipitated halogen salts related to the pollution status of the lake. The study cleared out that bromide was only the most abundant halogen in the three studied partitions. On contrast, sediment’s partition contained the lowest chloride content. Fluoride minerals, especially, fluorapatites and carbonate-fluorapatite (FAP and CFAP), had high Saturation Index (SI) values in surface water (42.77–51.95 and 16.04–60.89, respectively) and in pore water (51.26–54.60 and 17.52–78.33, respectively). Bromide and chloride were mainly found in the soluble forms in the surface water and pore waters. Iodide salts, (Ca(IO3)2 and Ca(IO3)2.6H2O), were moderately precipitated in surface and pore waters. Thus, SI content reflected that halogens, especially fluoride and iodide, played a vital role in reducing lake pollution. Fluorite (CaF2) and sellaïte (MgF2) could only be formed in pore water, while calcite and aragonite could be deposited from surface water. In addition, Cl was mainly found in the forms of NaCl, CaCl2, MgCl2, and KCl in surface and pore waters. The multivariate analysis revealed that fluoride precipitate may serve in decreasing the dissolved salt pollution. Multivariate analysis showed that in the long run, the fluoride precipitation in FAP and CFAP can significantly adsorb and absorb various pollutants and can protect the lake from pollution. The ecological risk assessment conducted by calculating the enrichment factor (EF) showed that the lake was still unpolluted. Regarding human health risks, at appropriate levels of human health and safety, the hazard quotient (HQ) and hazard index (HI) of halogens found to be lower than these reported levels. Hence, ingestion and dermal absorption routes of halogens by surface water and sediments did not pose any adverse effects to population reflecting uncontaminated status of Lake Mariout.

Comprehensive characterization and environmental risk assessment of end-of-life automotive catalytic converters to arrange a sustainable roadmap for future recycling practices

Environmentally appropriate economic recycling of spent automotive catalytic converters (SACCs) is difficult due to their complexity. The prominent reason is the lack of knowledge and comprehensive characterization of SACCs. This study focused on the characterization of SACCs in terms of their structural, morphological, physiochemical, surface, and thermal properties. The accurate determination of metals content, including 4975 mg/kg platinum group metals, 42,119 mg/kg rare earth elements, and other base metals, showed a great potential wealth in SACCs. Besides, the sequential extraction method was applied for metals fractionation, which represents a unique harsh recycling approach needed due to the stable structure of SACCs, metals embedded in silicate phases, and the presence of barely soluble metal phosphates. This waste was also examined for environmental criteria and leaching tests, including Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure, Waste Extraction Test, and Synthetic Precipitation Leaching Procedure. The findings declare that Waste Extraction Test was the most aggressive procedure to assess mobility. The contamination indexes, such as risk assessment code, contamination factor, and global contamination factor, were also investigated, which show SACCs must be regarded as hazardous waste. As an example, the global contamination factor of 11.87 depicts SACCs have a moderate contamination degree.

Gold mining tailing: Environmental availability of metals and human health risk assessment

The gold ore from sulfide minerals is, in general, ore dressed by means of nine stages among which stand out flotation and cyanidation. The residues of these steps, containing potentially toxic elements, such as As, Cd, Cr, Mn, Zn and Pb disposed of tailings dams, which might be a source of environmental contamination if not suitably disposed and/or in cases of accidents and overflows. Sequential extraction schemes (SES) have been used to estimate the potential environmental availability of contaminants from environmental matrices and, lately, from residues. This research evaluates the environmental availability of As, Cr, Cd, Mn, Pb, and Zn, by using two different SES, Tessier and Marin (BCR) in cyanidation residues. The analytes were quantified by inductively coupled plasma with optical emission spectrometry (ICP OES). A human health risk assessment was performed considering a scenario of soil contamination by the tailing after failure dam, based on the potential environment availability of metals, resulted from distinct SES studied. The results showed that Mn and Pb are the most labile, and therefore the most dangerous and bioavailable for the surrounding environment (≥75%). Moreover, the scenario simulated demonstrated the risk for human health mostly due to As, Cd and Zn.

Chemical fractionation and risk assessment of surface sediments in Luhun Reservoir, Luoyang city, China

To understand the potential risks of heavy metals, including their bioavailability and toxicity, 15 surface sediment samples were collected from Luhun Reservoir in Luoyang city, China. Total concentrations and chemical fractions of Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn were analyzed. Various rating methods were used to evaluate the degree, risk, and toxicity of the heavy metal pollution. Results showed that Cd and Pb were preferentially associated with exchangeable (55.77-69.76%) and reducible (53.54-69.43%) fractions, respectively, and therefore exhibited high potential availability. Cr (57.14-86.56%) and Ni (32.21-72.77%) occurred primarily in the residual fraction. Metal concentrations in the effective fraction of the sediment decreased in the order: Cd (96.32%) > Pb (91.61%) > Cu (64.54%) > Zn (57.23%) > Ni (41.51%) > Cr (21.68%). Risk assessment indicated that the risk for Cd is extremely high (62.96%); Cu, Pb, and Zn are ranked as medium risk. Based on the potential ecological risk index, these metals (especially Cd) showed higher potential risk near the dam region. Toxic unit values (2.89-6.05) in more than 60% of sediment sites exceeded a value of 4, and Pb had a relatively higher contribution (1.06-2.65). Cd and Pb are the main contaminants in sediments of Luhun Reservoir and should be paid more attention in the future.

Pollution and health risk assessment of toxic metal(loid)s in soils under different land use in sulphide mineralized areas

Toxic metal(loid) pollution in sulphide mineralized area has been increasingly concerned. In the present study, the pollution characteristics and the health risk of Hg, As, Tl and other metal(loid)s in soils under different land use, from a rural area impacted by Tl-Hg-rich sulphide mineralization, were assessed using statistical analysis, enrichment factor (EF), potential ecological risk index (RI) and health risk assessment model. The results showed that Tl, Hg and As were highly enriched in the mine area due to the historic sporadic mining activities, and Tl, Hg and Sb were enriched in the peripheral area. Hg and Tl pollution in soils of the mine area impacted by past mining activities posed high ecological risk. High contents and enrichment of Tl and Hg in forest/grass land had a greater impact on the ecological risk in the mine area; whereas Tl and Hg in the grain land and vegetable land dominated the soil ecological risk in the peripheral area. Human health risk assessment indicated that children are more sensitive and vulnerable to toxic metal(loid)s in soils than the adults. Hg, Tl and As have potential non-carcinogenic risk to local children and adults. The HQ levels for different exposure pathways of toxic metal(loid)s were in the order of ingestion > dermal contact > air inhalation for Tl and As, and dermal contract > ingestion > air inhalation for Hg. For carcinogenic risk, all the mean CR values of ingestion in the mine area were higher than 10^-4, indicating seriously potential risk. The descending order of ILCR via different pathways was the same as the HQ, for which ingestion was predominant, followed by dermal and air inhalation. The findings may help provide basic knowledge and guidelines for toxic metal(loid) pollution remediation in similar sulphide mineralized areas.

Speciation and risk assessment of selected trace metals in bottom sediment of coral reef ecosystems of the Persian Gulf

To evaluate the hazard assessment of anthropogenic activities on coastal ecosystems, fractionation and bioaccumulation of trace metals were carried out for sediment and coral samples of three distinct habitats including petroleum exploration area of Kharg, the rural harbor of Chirouyeh, and unpopulated area of Hendorabi. Fractionation results suggested that Ni (~ 51%), Pb (~ 49%), and V (~ 45%) in Kharg; Ni (~ 46%), Pb (~ 84%), and Zn (~ 47%) in Chirouyeh; and Cd (~ 51%) in Hendorabi were the predominant metals in the non-resistant fractions of the sediment samples. Risk Assessment Code (RAC), individual contamination factor (ICF), and global contamination factor (GCF) were derived. The highest relative risk for Cd, Cu, and Ti was observed in Kharg, whereas the highest relative risk for Ni, Pb, V, and Zn was recorded in Chirouyeh. The lowest risk for almost all of the trace metals was observed in Hendorabi. Biota-sediment accumulation factor (BSAF) values of coral samples revealed that species examined in the present study are reliable biomonitors for Cd, Ni, Pb, and Zn contamination. Principal component analysis (PCA) and Pearson's correlation coefficient (PCC) suggested that Pb, Ni, and Zn can be considered the main pollutants of the Persian Gulf which originated mainly from petroleum industries. Furthermore, the metal uptake rates of coral samples seemed to be dependent on bioabsorption pathways and coral species. Overall, the present work constitutes a good basis for further studies on trace metal fractionation, risk assessment, and source apportionment in the Persian Gulf, which could contribute to more effective decisions for reducing the anthropogenic trace metal pollution.

Evaluation of the BCR sequential extraction scheme for trace metal fractionation of alkaline municipal solid waste incineration fly ash

The BCR sequential extraction scheme (SES), initially developed for soils and sediments, is frequently adopted to evaluate the environmental risks of municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash. Within the procedure, metals are liberated from the matrix hosting them relying on the selectivity of the chosen chemical reagents or operation conditions. However, the effect of the high content of alkaline substances in MSWI fly ash on the selectivity of acetic acid to acid-soluble fraction metals was ignored. In this study, the feasibility of the BCR SES for evaluating MSWI fly ash was assessed by adjusting the acetic acid washing times in the acid-soluble extraction step. The metal fractionation, as well as mineralogy, morphology, and surface chemistry of the residues after three successive acid washing processes, were analyzed. The results reveal that only easily soluble salts, but not hydroxides, are entirely extracted after the first acid washing (pH∼12.0). Importantly, carbonates (generally reported as an indicator of the complete release of acid-soluble metals) are mostly decomposed only after the third acid washing (pH∼3.8). The incomplete dissolution of calcium carbonates in a single-step acid washing may convey misleading results of metal fractionation and underestimates the environmental risk of potentially toxic elements. Therefore, complete removal of carbonates should be employed as the endpoint of the acid-soluble fraction extraction step in the evaluation of MSWI fly ash. This work can help in selecting proper strategies for fly ash management and developing proper sequential extraction schemes for similar high-alkalinity hazardous waste risk assessment.

Geospeciation, toxicological evaluation, and hazard assessment of trace elements in superficial and deep sediments

To evaluate the hazard assessment of dredging and disposal of sediments, an in-depth chemical and toxicological characterization of sediments was carried out in Venice Lagoon. The bioaccessible and mobile concentration of trace elements in superficial and deep sediments (in the Holocene-Pleistocene limit) can deeply affect the quality of the aquatic ecosystem. Geospeciation and total concentration of trace elements in sediment cores were assessed and several toxicological tests were carried out. The indices of contamination (e.g., geochemical accumulation index, I_geo, pollution load index, PLI) and of speciation (individual contamination factor, ICF and global contamination factor, GCF) were evaluated. Factor Analysis (FA) was performed to explore possible significant correlations between toxicity data and sediment chemistry. Results underlined that the total concentration of trace elements cannot adequately assess the hazard, while bioavailability, mobility, and toxicity of trace elements allow a thorough evaluation of the environmental threats. The integration of results from chemical characterization ex ante and toxicity assays will provide for a better sustainable handling and management of sediments.

Spatial distribution and ecological risk assessment of trace metals in surface sediments of Lake Qaroun, Egypt

A suite of trace metals was determined in twenty surface sediments collected from Lake Qaroun, which is designated as a natural reserve in 1989 to examine their spatial distribution and their potential environmental impact on the lake. Contamination factor (C_f), enrichment factor (EF), geoaccumulation index (I_geo), and pollution load index (PLI) are applied to evaluate the quality of the lake. The highest concentrations were detected in the eastern portion of the lake near Al-Bats drain. The levels of Ba exceeded the toxicity reference value (TRV) (20 ng/g dw) set by US EPA for all sediments, while sediments collected from Al-Bats region exceeded the TRV for Zn (68 ng/g dw). Arsenic, Ba, Sn, Co, Cu, and Hg are poorly correlated with background value of Fe suggesting anthropogenic activities over the entire lake. The values of C_f and I_geo confirmed that the eastern portion of the lake has been found moderately to considerably contaminated by As, Sn, and Zn. Sediments collected from the eastern location (S1) were very highly enriched of Sn (22.47); however, the other eastern locations were highly enriched of Sn, As, Cd, Co, and Ba. It is clear that sites near Al-Bats and El-Wadi drains are hot spots, which got immense amounts of domestic, agricultural, and industrial wastes. Behind the influence of these discharges, concentrations are decreased. The PLI over the entire lake ranged from 0.247 to 0.801 for all sites, which reflect unpolluted status.

An insight into fractionation, toxicity, mobility and source apportionment of metals in sediments from El Temsah Lake, Suez Canal

El Temsah Lake is one of the most important wetlands in the Suez Canal area and the major source of fish for the area. In this study, the relative role of sediments' geochemical properties and metals geochemical fractionation in determining Cd, Cr, Fe, Mn, Ni, and Pb mobility and toxicity was especially concerned. The results reflected that the increasing order of contamination for the investigated metals according to individual contamination factor (ICF) was: Cr > Mn > Ni > Pb > Cd > Fe. Risk assessment code (RAC) classification showed that the relative amounts of easily dissolved phases of metals in the sediments followed the order of Ni > Cr > Cd > Pb > Fe > Mn. The toxicity as indicated by toxic unit (TU) due to an individual metal followed a descending order of Ni > Cr > Pb > Cd, indicating that Ni and Cr accounted for the majority of the overall sediment toxicity while, Cd contributed the least to the ΣTU. This work constitutes a good basis for further studies about metal fractionation in El Temsah Lake which might help policy makers to take effective decisions for proper management of the lake.

Spatial distribution and risk assessment of heavy metals in contaminated paddy fields - A case study in Xiangtan City, southern China

An extensive investigation on spatial distribution and environmental risk assessment based on total content and fractions of heavy metals, as well as the cancer risk of Cd from seven adjacent contaminated paddy fields at Xiangtan City, southern China, was conducted in this study. A total of 63 soil samples were analyzed for soil physical properties and concentrations of eight heavy metals (Cd, Cr, Co, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb, Zn). The results showed that concentrations of metals except for Cr, Mn and Ni exceeded the background values to varying degrees, and particularly, content of Cd was as 57.4-612 times higher than background values. Principal components analysis and correlation analysis revealed three groups: industry activities for Cd and Zn; natural sources mainly for Cu, Pb, Ni and Cr, with some slight anthropogenic activities for Cu and Pb accumulation; and manganese ore associated with cobalt for Co and Mn. Combined with different indices, Cd and Zn were the major contributors to the ecological risk, and cancer risk of Cd indicated an unacceptable degree in this area. Altogether, results from this study will facilitate a better understanding of metals distribution characteristics and provide a scientific basis for further comprehensive management for these paddy fields. Combination of functional microbial agent and plants promises to be a feasible and effective remediation method for cadmium pollution in the study area.

Environmental significance and geochemical speciation of trace elements in Lower Baram River sediments

The geochemistry and distribution of major, trace and rare earth elements (REE's) was studied in the surface sediments of the Lower Baram River during two seasons: the Monsoon (MON) and Post - monsoon (POM). The major geochemical processes controlling the distribution and mobility of major, trace and REE's in the Lower Baram River surface sediments was revealed through factor analysis. The risk assessment of major and trace element levels was studied at three specific levels; i.e. the enrichment level [Contamination Factor (C_f), with the geo-accumulation index (Igeo)], the availability level [metals bound to different fractions, risk assessment code (RAC)], and the biological toxicity level [effect range low (ERL) and effect range medium (ERM)]. The results of all the indices indicate that Cu is the element of concern in the Lower Baram River sediments. The geochemical fractionation of major and trace elements were studied through sequential extraction and the results indicated a higher concentration of Mn in the exchangeable fraction. The element of concern, Cu, was found to be highly associated in the organic bound (F4) fraction during both seasons and a change in the redox, possibly due to storms or dredging activities may stimulate the release of Cu into the overlying waters of the Lower Baram River.

Risk assessment of heavy metals in pipe scales and loose deposits formed in drinking water distribution systems

The accumulation of inorganic contaminants in drinking water distribution systems (DWDS) can greatly threaten water quality and safety. This work mainly focused on the accumulation, speciation and risk assessment of inorganic contaminants found in pipe scales and loose deposits in DWDS. Global contamination factor (GCF), risk assessment code (RAC) and consensus-based sediment quality guidelines (CBSQGs) were adopted for the potential health risk assessment of inorganic contaminants. The Tessier sequential extraction method was used to study the speciation distribution of inorganic contaminants in fourteen samples (six pipe scale samples, eight loose deposit samples) collected from real DWDS. The significant correlation between Al and Mn showed there was a co-occurrence behavior of Al and Mn in pipe scales and loose deposits. In addition to the possible interactions between Al and Mn, Ba, Cu and As were possibly accumulated during the formation of Al and Mn commixtures. Mn, Cu, Pb, Zn, Ni, Co and Ba in the samples were mainly associated with the Fe-Mn oxides fraction, which indicated Fe-Mn oxides might play an important role in the accumulation and release of these inorganic contaminants. Fe, Al, As, Cr, V and Cd mainly existed in the residual fraction, which indicated their low mobility. The GCF results demonstrated that most of the sample sites had a certain environmental risk. The RAC results showed that high risk mainly resulted from Cd both in pipe scales and loose deposits. According to the CBSQGs evaluation, heavy metals in loose deposits were more harmful, and Ba exhibited the highest risk among all heavy metals.

A comprehensive risk assessment of metals in riverine surface sediments across the rural-urban interface of a rapidly developing watershed

Metal contamination in aquatic environments is a severe global concern to human health and aquatic ecosystems. This study used several risk assessment indices, to evaluate metal (Cu, Zn, Pb, Cd and Cr) environmental risk of riverine surface sediments across the rural-urban interface of the rapidly developing Wen-Rui Tang River watershed in eastern China. Risk assessments were determined for 38 sites based on the potential ecological risk index (RI), consensus-based sediment quality guidelines (SQGs) and risk assessment code (RAC). Land-use cluster analysis showed that sediments were severely contaminated, especially for Cd, whose concentrations were ∼100 times higher than background levels and had a high proportion in the bioaccessible fraction. According to RI, E_r^Cd was identified with extremely high risk potential, resulting in the highest ecological risk of Cluster 4 (industrial). Similarly, risk within Cluster 4 (industrial) was also ranked highest by SQGs assessment due to the high proportion of industrial land use. Zinc was determined with high risk due to its high concentration compared to its effect range medium (ERM) value. Discrepancies in predicting environmental risks from metals among the three indices were mainly attributed to the contrasting definitions of these metrics. Environmental risk uncertainty derived from spatial variation was further estimated by Monte Carlo simulation and ranked as: Zn > Cd > Cr > Pb > Cu. This comprehensive environmental risk assessment provides important information to guide remediation strategies for management of metal contamination at the watershed scale.

Relation between different metal pollution criteria in sediments and its contribution on assessing toxicity

Several tools have been developed and applied to evaluate the metal pollution status of sediments and predict their potential ecological risk assessment. To date, a comprehensive relationship between the information given by these sediment tools for predicting metal bioavailability and the effective toxicity observed is lacking. In this work, the possible inter-correlations between the data outcoming from using several qualitative evaluation tools of the sediment contamination (contamination factor, CF, the enrichment factor, EF, or the geoaccumulation index, Igeo), metal speciation on sediments (evaluated by the modified BCR sequential extraction procedure) and free metal concentrations in pore waters were studied. It was also our aim to evaluate if these assessment tools could be used for predicting the pore waters toxicity data as toxicity proxy. Principal component analysis and cluster analysis revealed that two quality indices used (CF and EF) were highly correlatable with the more labile fractions from BCR sediment speciation. However, neither of these parameters did correlate with the toxicity of pore waters measured by the chronic toxicity (72 h) in Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata. In contrast, the toxic effects of the given total metal load in sediments were better evaluated by using an additive metal approach using pore water free metal concentrations.