Toxicity of biochar influenced by aging time and environmental factors

Negative impacts of perishable waste biochar to Escherichia coli and exploring potential damage factors

Agricultural application of pyrolysis‑carbonized perishable wastes can target reduction treatment and resource utilization of the wastes. However, potential undesirable impact has rarely been assessed. In this study, the adverse effect of perishable waste biochars (PWB) from different pyrolysis temperatures on Escherichia coli (E. coli) was explored and the potential risk factors were further analyzed. The results showed that PWBs pyrolyzed at 350, 500, and 650 °C inhibited the growth of E. coli, and PWB pyrolyzed at 500 °C showed the most inhibition. The exposure to PWB damaged the antioxidative system, as revealed by the concentration-dependent increasing of intracellular ROS. In addition, the toxicity at the gene level in terms of cell division and growth inhibition, the damage of cell membrane, antioxidant system disturbance, and DNA damage occurred, resulting in loss of the cell rules of morphology and eventual death. According to our results, the inhibitory effect on the growth of E. coli was mainly caused by PWB solids, accounting for >70 %. The membrane disruption and oxidative damage of E. coli by PWB were possibly induced by the direct physical interaction between cell and char particles. The growth of E. coli can be partly influenced by PWB extraction solutions that varied between PWB types, due to the differences in pH, released DOC and the production of extracellular ∙OH. The exploration of these potential hazards could provide new insights into the fate and toxicity of PWB in the environment and help guide the safe and sustainable applications for PWB.

Conversion of locally available materials to biochar and activated carbon for drinking water treatment

For environmental sustainability and to achieve sustainable development goals (SDGs), drinking water treatment must be done at a reasonable cost with minimal environmental impact. Therefore, treating contaminated drinking water requires materials and approaches that are inexpensive, produced locally, and effortlessly. Hence, locally available materials and their derivatives, such as biochar (BC) and activated carbon (AC) were investigated thoroughly. Several researchers and their findings show that the application of locally accessible materials and their derivatives are capable of the adsorptive removal of organic and inorganic contaminants from drinking water. The application of locally available materials such as lignocellulosic materials/waste and its thermo-chemically derived products, including BC and AC were found effective in the treatment of contaminated drinking water. Thus, this review aims to thoroughly examine the latest developments in the use of locally accessible feedstocks for tailoring BC and AC, as well as their features and applications in the treatment of drinking water. We attempted to explain facts related to the potential mechanisms of BC and AC, such as complexation, co-precipitation, electrostatic interaction, and ion exchange to treat water, thereby achieving a risk-free remediation approach to polluted water. Additionally, this research offers guidance on creating efficient household treatment units based on the health risks associated with customized adsorbents and cost-benefit analyses. Lastly, this review work discusses the current obstacles for using locally accessible materials and their thermo-chemically produced by-products to purify drinking water, as well as the necessity for technological interventions.

Biotoxicity attenuation and the underlying physicochemical mechanism of biochar aged under simulated natural environmental conditions

Biochar (BC), with the benefits of enhancing soil fertility, absorbing heavy metals, carbon sequestration, and mitigating the greenhouse effect, has been extensively used for soil remediation. However, the long-term changes in the biotoxicity of BC under complex environmental conditions, which are the key factors influencing the sustainable application of BC in soil, are still unclear. Herein, the biotoxicity of BC aged with various processes, including dry‒wet cycle (DW) aging, freeze‒thaw cycle (FT) aging, ultraviolet irradiation (UV) aging, and low molecular weight organic acid (OA) aging, was systematically investigated by Escherichia coli (E. coli) culture experiments. The toxicity attenuation rate (%·week-1) was proposed to more concisely and clearly compare the influence of different aging methods on BC toxicity. The results indicated that after 5 weeks of aging, the toxicity attenuation rate during the four aging modes followed the order OA aging > FT aging > UV aging > DW aging. BC was nontoxic after 1 week of OA aging, 4 weeks of FT aging, 7 weeks of UV aging, and 14 weeks of DW aging. Spectroscopic characterizations revealed that humic acids in the dissolved organic matter of BC were the main reason for the biotoxicity. In addition, the attenuation of environmentally persistent free radicals on BC during aging was also an important factor for reducing environmental toxicity. This work provides insight into the detoxification mechanism of the BC aging process under ordinary environmental conditions and guidance for the safe application of BC in soil.

Effects of biochar on the manganese enrichment and oxidation by a microalga Scenedesmus quadricauda in the aquatic environment

Microalgae play a significant impact in the biogeochemical cycle of Mn(II) in the aquatic ecosystem. Meanwhile, the inflow of biochar into the water bodies is bound to impact the aquatic organisms. However, the influence of biochar on the manganese transformation in algae-rich water has not drawn much attention. Thus, we studied the effects of rice straw biochar on manganese enrichment and oxidation by a common type of algae in freshwater (Scenedesmus quadricauda). The results showed that Mn(II) was absorbed intracellularly and adsorbed extracellularly by active algal cells. A significant portion of enriched Mn(II) was oxidized to amorphous precipitates MnO2, MnOOH, and Mn2O3. Moreover, the extracellular bound Mn(II) content in the coexistent system of algae and biochar increased compared with the pure Scenedesmus quadricauda system. Nevertheless, the intracellular Mn content was continually lowered as the biochar dose rose from an initial 0.2 to 2.0 g·L-1, suggesting that Mn assimilation of the cell was suppressed. It was calculated that the total enrichment ability of Scenedesmus quadricauda in the algae-biochar coexistent system was 0.31- 15.32 mg Mn/g biomass, more than that in the pure algae system. More importantly, with biochar in the algae system, the amount of generated MnOx increased, and more Mn(II) was oxidized into highly-charged Mn(IV). This was probably because the biochar could relieve the stress of massive Mn(II) on algae and support the MnOx precipitates. In brief, moderate biochar promoted the Mn(II) accumulation by algal cells and its oxidation activity. This study offers deeper insight into the bioconversion of Mn(II) by algae and the potential impact of biochar application to the aquatic system.

Persistent free radicals generated from a range of biochars and their physiological effects on wheat seedlings

Biochar is a promising soil conditioner and environmental remediation material. However, the amount, type, and environmental effect and risk of persistent free radicals (PFRs) associated with biochar need to be better understood. Thus, this study characterized PFRs in a range of biochar types and their effects on the growth and oxidative stress of wheat seedlings. Among the biochars prepared by pyrolysis of different types of biomass at 500 °C, the concentrations of PFRs in cow dung and egg shell biochar were the highest and the lowest, respectively. They both increased with artificial weathering treatment but decreased with aging. The dominant types of biochar PFRs were transformed from carbon-centered to oxygen and carbon/oxygen-centered free radicals with weathering. The amount and type of biochar PFRs in mixtures of biochar and soil varied with soil type and biochar dose. After 30 d incubation in different soil-biochar mixtures, measures of wheat plant germination and growth and antioxidant enzyme activity showed increases at lower biochar doses but decreases at higher doses. Catalase activity was 38.1 % greater at 20 g·kg-1 biochar dosage and 25.2 % less at 80 g·kg-1 dosage, on average. In contrast, leaf malondialdehyde content and staining by Evans Blue, both indicators of plant cell membrane damage, generally increased with increasing biochar dosages. Finally, soil hydrolase enzyme activity also displayed an inverted U-shaped dose response. The toxicity indicators showed an increasing trend with higher PFR concentrations in the soil-biochar combinations. While these findings provide evidence for significant potential agricultural and ecological risks associated with the application of biochar due to PFRs damage, it also points to ways that these risks could be mediated such as through biochar dosage restrictions and pre-aging. This study provides new insights into the potential toxicological mechanism and ecological risks associated with the application of biochar in agricultural and environmental settings.

Effect of zinc-biochar composite aging on its physicochemical and ecotoxicological properties

The stability of Zn-biochar composites is determined by environmental factors, including the aging processes. This paper focused on the ecotoxicological evaluation of Zn-biochar (Zn-BC) composites subjected to chemical aging. Pristine biochars and composites produced at 500 or 700 °C were incubated at 60 and 90 °C for six months. All biochars were characterized in terms of their physicochemical (elemental composition, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), X-ray powder diffraction (XRD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), Raman spectroscopy and porous structure), ecotoxicological properties (tested with Folsomia candida and Aliivibrio fischeri) and contaminant content (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), heavy metals (HM) and environmentally persistent free radicals (EPFR)). An increase in the number of surface oxygen functional groups and increased hydrophilicity and polarity of all Zn-BC composites were observed due to oxidation during aging. It was also found that Zn-BC aging at 90 °C resulted in a 28-30% decrease in solvent-extractable PAHs (Ʃ16 Ctot PAHs) compared to nonaged composites. The aging process at both temperatures also caused a 104 fold reduction in EPFRs in Zn-BC composites produced at 500 °C. The changes in the physicochemical properties of Zn-BC composites after chemical aging at 90 °C (such as pH and HM content) caused an increase in the toxicity of the composites to Folsomia candida (reproduction inhibition from 19 to 24%) and Aliivibrio fischeri (luminescence inhibition from 96 to 99%). The aging of composites for a long time may increase the adverse environmental impact of BC-Zn composites due to changes in physicochemical properties (itself and its interactions with pollutants) and the release of Zn from the composite.

Systematic assessment of the ecotoxicological effects and mechanisms of biochar-derived dissolved organic matter (DOM) on the earthworm Eisenia fetida

Biochar-derived dissolved organic matter (DOM) contains toxic substances that are first released into the soil after biochar application. However, the ecological risks of biochar-derived DOM on soil invertebrate earthworms are unclear. Therefore, this study investigated the ecological risks and toxic mechanisms of sewage sludge biochar (SSB)-derived DOM on the earthworm Eisenia fetida (E. fetida) via microcosm experiments. DOM exposure induced earthworm death, growth inhibition, and cocoon decline. Moreover, DOM, especially the 10% DOM300 (derived from SSB prepared at 300 °C) treatments, disrupted the antioxidant defense response and lysosomal stability in earthworms. Integrated biomarker response v2 (IBRv2) analysis was performed to assess the comprehensive toxicity of DOM in E. fetida, and the results revealed that DOM300 might exert more hazardous effects on earthworms than DOM500 (prepared at 500 °C) and DOM700 (prepared at 700 °C), as revealed by increases in the IBRv2 value of 3.48-18.21. Transcriptome analysis revealed that 10% DOM300 exposure significantly disrupted carbohydrate and protein digestion and absorption and induced endocrine disorder. Interestingly, 10% DOM300 exposure also significantly downregulated the expression of genes involved in signaling pathways, e.g., the P13K-AKT, cGMP-PKG, and ErbB signaling pathways, which are related to cell growth, survival, and metabolism, suggesting that DOM300 might induce neurotoxicity in E. fetida. Altogether, these results may contribute to a better understanding of the toxicity and defense mechanisms of biochar-derived DOM on earthworms, especially during long-term applications, and thus provide guidelines for using biochar as a soil amendment.

Synthesis of Cu2+ doped biochar and its inactivation performance of Microcystis aeruginosa: Significance of synergetic effect

The harmful cyanobacteria bloom is frequently occurring in the aquatic environment and poses a tremendous threat to both aquatic organisms and ecological function. In this study, a series of Cu2+ doped biochar (BC) composites (Cu-BCs) with different loading ratios (0.1 %-5 wt %) (Cu-BC-0.1/0.5/1/2.5/5) was successfully fabricated through a one-step adsorption method for in-situ inactivation of Microcystis aeruginosa and simultaneous removal of microcystin-LR (MC-LR). Compared with the single BC/CuSO4 and other Cu-BCs composites, the Cu-BC-2.5 exhibited the best algae inactivation performance with the lowest 72 h medium effective concentration (EC50) value of 0.34 mg/L and highest chlorophyll α degradation efficiency of 8.31 g/g. Notably, the as-prepared Cu-BC-2.5 maintained good inactivation performance in the near-neutral pH (6.5-8.5), and the presence of humic acid and salts such as Na2CO3 and NaCl. The outstanding inhibitory effect of the Cu-BC-2.5 could be explained by the synergetic effect between biochar and Cu2+, which greatly elevated reactive oxygen species (ROS) intensity and in turn led to severe membrane damage and collapse of the antioxidant system. Additionally, the Cu-BC-2.5 could simultaneously remove the released microcystin-LR (MC-LR) throughout the inactivation process and prevent secondary pollution, thus offering a new insight into the alleviation of harmful cyanobacteria in aquatic environment.

Quantitative analysis of the current status and research trends of biochar research - A scientific bibliometric analysis based on global research achievements from 2003 to 2023

Biochar has excellent physical and chemical properties such as porosity, high carbon content, high cation exchange capacity, and rich surface functional groups and has been widely used in environmental remediation. Over the past 20 years, although various reviews have described the application of biochar as an environmentally friendly multifunctional material in environmental remediation, no comprehensive summary and analysis of the research trends in this field exists. To promote the rapid and stable development of the field of biochar, the current state of research on biochar is clarified using the bibliometric method in this report, and potential development directions and challenges for the future are identified. All relevant biochar literature from 2003-2023 was collected from the Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure and Web of Science Core Collection. A total of 6,119 published Chinese papers and 25,174 English papers were selected for the quantitative analysis. CiteSpace, VOSviewer, and Scimago graphics software was used to summarize the numbers of papers published over the years, as well as the countries, institutions, and authors that published the most articles. Secondly, using keyword co-occurrence and emergence analysis, the recognized research hotspots in different areas such as adsorbents, soil remediation, catalytic oxidation, supercapacitors, and "biochar-microbial" synergy were analyzed. Finally, the prospects and challenges of biochar were assessed to provide new perspectives for further promoting its development in technological, economic, environmental, and other aspects.

Effects of particle size and pyrolytic temperature of biochar on the transformation behavior of antibiotic resistance genes

Rampant use of antibiotics has caused a rapid dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in environment, posing great threats to ecosystems and human health. Applying biochar (BC) in natural systems to combat the spread of ARGs arises as an attention-grabbing solution. Unfortunately, the effectiveness of BC is still unmanageable due to the incomprehensive knowledge over correlations between BC properties and extracellular ARGs transformation. To pinpoint the crucial factors, we primarily explored transformation behaviors of plasmid-mediated ARGs exposed to BC (in suspensions or extraction solutions), adsorption capacities of ARGs on BC, and growth inhibition of E. coli imposed by BC. Specifically, the effects of BC properties including particle size (large-particulate 150 μm and colloidal 0.45-2 μm) and pyrolytic temperature (300, 400, 500, 600, and 700 °C) on the ARGs transformation were emphasized. Results showed that both large-particulate BC and colloidal BC, irrespective of their pyrolytic temperature, would induce significant inhibitory effects on the ARGs transformation, while the BC extraction solutions showed little effect except BC pyrolyzed at 300 °C. Correlation analysis uncovered that the inhibition effect of BC on ARGs transformation was tightly correlated with its adsorption capacity towards plasmid. Accordingly, greater inhibitory effects from those BCs with higher pyrolytic temperatures and smaller particle sizes mainly originated from their greater adsorption capacities. Intriguingly, E. coli was unable to ingest the plasmid adsorbed on BC, which led to ARGs blocked outside the cell membrane, although this inhibitory effect was partially affected by survival inhibition of BC on E. coli. Particularly, significant plasmid aggregation could occur in the extraction solution of large-particulate BC pyrolyzed at 300 °C, leading to a significant inhibition of ARGs transformation. Overall, our findings complete the insufficient understanding over the effects of BC on ARGs transformation behavior, and potentially provide new insights to scientific communities in mitigating ARGs spreading.

Potential disintegration and transport of biochar in the soil-water environment: A case study towards purple soil

Biochar has been widely applied in soil and water. However, the fate and transport of biochar are not yet fully understood. Here, biochar's disintegration, transport, and the effect of temperature on biochar transport in soil (purple soil)-water systems were investigated. The results showed that the potentially transportable components (PTC) of biochar for corn straw, wheat straw, rice straw, rice husk and wood biochar reached 6.22-7.60%, 5.96-12.29%, 11.77-12.45%, 5.34-6.26% and 5.08-6.14% by mass, respectively. An external force (ultrasound exposure) intensified the physical disintegration, including colloidal and nanoparticles from larger particles, thereby increasing the transport potential. The mass recovery rates of PTC for rice straw biochar after penetrating through soil at 5, 20 and 35 °C reached 44.25%, 32.97% and 10.98%, respectively, which was supported by the Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) theory results. Elevated temperatures increased the hydrodynamic average diameter of PTC, and the Zeta potential of PTC and soil at 35 °C were less negative than those at 5 and 20 °C. As a result, biochar's transportability decreases with increasing temperature in the soil-water system, during which the enhanced PTC aggregation and the decreased electrostatic repulsion between biochar and soil particles played a crucial role. The increase in electrical conductivity in the soil-water system may be the main reason for the decrease in electrostatic repulsion at higher temperatures. The findings are helpful for an in-depth understanding of the environmental fate and managing the transport risk of biochar.

Vermitoxicity of aged biochar and exploring potential damage factors

Although biochar is a promising soil amendment, its characteristics change owing to its aging in soil. Studies have shown that some aged biochar is hazardous to plants and soil microbiota. Earthworms are well-known soil ecosystem engineers; nevertheless, the toxic effects of aged biochar on them (vermitoxicity) are yet unknown, and it is necessary to explore the potential risk factors. Here, a series of soil culture experiments were conducted to systematically examine the vermitoxicity of aged biochar at various levels utilizing the earthworm Eisenia fetida and corncob biochar.. Acute toxicity bioassays were also used to evaluate several potential harm factors utilizing modified aged biochar/leaching solutions. The findings showed that both fresh and aged biochar might have adverse effects on earthworms, and that aged biochar was more toxic than fresh biochar with LC₅₀s reduced to 6.89%. Specifically, aged biochar caused earthworm death, growth inhibition with a maximum of 36.6%, and avoidance with 100% avoidance at the application rates of 2% at the individual-behavioral level. At the cellular and physiological-biochemical levels, aged biochar damaged coelomocyte lysosomal membrane stability, disrupted antioxidant enzyme activities, and improved the malondialdehyde (MDA) content in earthworms. Heat-treated and pH-modified aged biochar exhibited less acute toxicity on earthworms than aged biochar, whereas aqueous and acetone extracts showed weak vermitoxicity. As a result, earthworms may be harmed by volatile organic compounds (VOCs), an improper pH, and aqueous and acetone extracts. Additionally, the range of neural red retention times (NRRTs) was reviewed as ∼20-70 min mostly. This study, as far as we know, is the first to evaluate the vermitoxicity of aged biochar and its potential damage factors. The results may enhance our understanding of ecological toxicity of biochar, particularly over the long term, and lead to the development of application standards for biochar amendments to the soil.

Effects of partial replacement of dietary flour meal with seaweed polysaccharides on the resistance to ammonia stress in the intestine of hybrid snakehead (Channa maculatus ♀ × Channa argus ♂)

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of partial replacement of dietary flour meal with seaweed polysaccharides on survival rate, histology, intestinal oxidative stress levels, and expression of immune-related genes in hybrid snakeheads under acute ammonia stress. Four experimental diets were set: (C) basal diet with 0% of seaweed polysaccharides as the control group, (MR) basal diet with 10% of seaweed polysaccharides, (HR) basal diet with 15% of seaweed polysaccharides, (HF) basal diet with 10% of fish oil. After 60 days of feeding, fish fed with the diet of C group were sampled as the control group, and other fish were exposed to ammonia nitrogen for 48 h. Two concentrations of total ammonia nitrogen (TAN) were used in this study: 120 mg/L TAN (low concentration exposure group), and 1200 mg/L TAN (high concentration exposure group). After exposure to ammonia nitrogen for 48 h, fish were sampled. The results indicated that adding seaweed polysaccharides to the diet could improve the survival rate of hybrid snakeheads under high concentration of ammonia stress. Histopathological analysis demonstrated multiple abnormalities in gills and intestines after exposure to two concentrations of TAN. The activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT), glutathione (GSH), and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) were all increased in the MR group under two concentrations of TAN stress. The mRNA abundance of immune-related genes in fish intestinal tissues was significantly induced or inhibited. These results suggested that partial replacement of dietary flour meal with seaweed polysaccharides improved the ability of hybrid snakeheads to resist ammonia stress.