Investigating heparin affinity chromatography for extracellular vesicle purification and fractionation

Generating suspension-adapted human mesenchymal stromal cells (S-hMSCs) for the scalable manufacture of extracellular vesicles

BACKGROUD

Human mesenchymal stromal cells (hMSCs) are a naturally adherent cell type and one of the most studied cellular agents used in cell therapy over the last 20 years. Their mechanism of action has been primarily associated with paracrine signaling, which has contributed to an increase in the number of studies focused on hMSC-related extracellular vesicles (EVs).

METHODS

In this study, we demonstrate for the first time that human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) immortalized hMSCs can be adapted to suspension culture, eliminating the need for microcarriers or other matrixes to support cell growth.

RESULTS

This novel cell line, named suspension hMSCs (S-hMSCs), has a doubling time of approximately 55 hours, with a growth rate of 0.423/d. Regarding its immunophenotype characteristics, S-hMSCs retained close to 90% of CD73 and CD105 expression levels, with the CD90 receptor being downregulated during the adherent to suspension adaptation process. An RNA sequencing analysis showed an upregulation of the transcripts coding for CD44, CD46 and CD47 compared to the expression levels in AT-hMSCs and hTERT-hMSCs. The cell line herein established was able to generate EVs using a chemically defined medium formulation with these nanoparticles averaging 150 nm in size and displaying the markers CD63, CD81, and TSG101, while not expressing the negative marker calnexin.

CONCLUSION

This body of evidence, combined with the visual confirmation of EV presence using transmission electron microscopy, demonstrates the EV-producing capabilities of the novel S-hMSCs. This cell line provides a platform for process development, drug discovery and translational studies in the EV field.

Discovery of Therapeutic Antibodies Targeting Complex Multi-Spanning Membrane Proteins

Complex integral membrane proteins, which are embedded in the cell surface lipid bilayer by multiple transmembrane spanning polypeptides, encompass families of proteins that are important target classes for drug discovery. These protein families include G protein-coupled receptors, ion channels, transporters, enzymes, and adhesion molecules. The high specificity of monoclonal antibodies and the ability to engineer their properties offers a significant opportunity to selectively bind these target proteins, allowing direct modulation of pharmacology or enabling other mechanisms of action such as cell killing. Isolation of antibodies that bind these types of membrane proteins and exhibit the desired pharmacological function has, however, remained challenging due to technical issues in preparing membrane protein antigens suitable for enabling and driving antibody drug discovery strategies. In this article, we review progress and emerging themes in defining discovery strategies for a generation of antibodies that target these complex membrane protein antigens. We also comment on how this field may develop with the emerging implementation of computational techniques, artificial intelligence, and machine learning.

Peptide ligands for the universal purification of exosomes by affinity chromatography

Exosomes are gaining prominence as vectors for drug delivery, vaccination, and regenerative medicine. Owing to their surface biochemistry, which reflects the parent cell membrane, these nanoscale biologics feature low immunogenicity, tunable tissue tropism, and the ability to carry a variety of payloads across biological barriers. The heterogeneity of exosomes' size and composition, however, makes their purification challenging. Traditional techniques, like ultracentrifugation and filtration, afford low product yield and purity, and jeopardizes particle integrity. Affinity chromatography represents an excellent avenue for exosome purification. Yet, current affinity media rely on antibody ligands whose selectivity grants high product purity, but mandates the customization of adsorbents for exosomes with different surface biochemistry while their binding strength imposes elution conditions that may harm product's activity. Addressing these issues, this study introduces the first peptide affinity ligands for the universal purification of exosomes from recombinant feedstocks. The peptides were designed to (1) possess promiscuous biorecognition of exosome markers, without binding process-related contaminants and (2) elute the product under conditions that safeguard product stability. Selected ligands SNGFKKHI and TAHFKKKH demonstrated the ability to capture of exosomes secreted by 14 cell sources and purified exosomes derived from HEK293, PC3, MM1, U87, and COLO1 cells with yields of up to 80% and up-to 50-fold reduction of host cell proteins (HCPs) upon eluting with pH gradient from 7.4 to 10.5, recommended for exosome stability. SNGFKKHI-Toyopearl resin was finally employed in a two-step purification process to isolate exosomes from HEK293 cell fluids, affording a yield of 68% and reducing the titer of HCPs to 68 ng/mL. The biomolecular and morphological features of the isolated exosomes were confirmed by analytical chromatography, Western blot analysis, transmission electron microscopy, nanoparticle tracking analysis.

High throughput and rapid isolation of extracellular vesicles and exosomes with purity using size exclusion liquid chromatography

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) have emerged as potential biomarkers for diagnosing a range of diseases without invasive procedures. Extracellular vesicles also offer advantages compared to synthetic vesicles for delivery of various drugs; however, limitations in segregating EVs from other particles and soluble proteins have led to inconsistent EV retrieval rates with low levels of purity. Here, we report a new high-yield (88.47 %) and rapid (<20 min) EV isolation method termed size exclusion - fast protein liquid chromatography (SE-FPLC). We show SE-FPLC can effectively isolate EVs from multiple sources including EVs derived from human and mouse cells and serum samples. The results indicate that SE-FPLC can successfully remove highly abundant protein contaminants such as albumin and lipoprotein complexes, which can represent a major hurdle in large scale isolation of EVs. The high-yield nature of SE-FPLC allows for easy industrial scaling up of EV production for various clinical utilities. SE-FPLC also enables analysis of small volumes of blood for use in point-of-care diagnostics in the clinic. Collectively, SE-FPLC offers many advantages over current EV isolation methods and offers rapid clinical translation.

Snorkel-tag based affinity chromatography for recombinant extracellular vesicle purification

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are lipid nanoparticles and play an important role in cell-cell communications, making them potential therapeutic agents and allowing to engineer for targeted drug delivery. The expanding applications of EVs in next generation medicine is still limited by existing tools for scaling standardized EV production, single EV tracing and analytics, and thus provide only a snapshot of tissue-specific EV cargo information. Here, we present the Snorkel-tag, for which we have genetically fused the EV surface marker protein CD81, to a series of tags with an additional transmembrane domain to be displayed on the EV surface, resembling a snorkel. This system enables the affinity purification of EVs from complex matrices in a non-destructive form while maintaining EV characteristics in terms of surface protein profiles, associated miRNA patterns and uptake into a model cell line. Therefore, we consider the Snorkel-tag to be a widely applicable tool in EV research, allowing for efficient preparation of EV standards and reference materials, or dissecting EVs with different surface markers when fusing to other tetraspanins in vitro or in vivo.

Chinese hamster ovary cell line engineering strategies for modular production of custom extracellular vesicles

Continuously secreted by all cell types, extracellular vesicles (EVs) are small membrane-bound structures which shuttle bioactive cargo between cells across their external environment. Their central role as natural molecular messengers and ability to cross biological barriers has garnered significant attention in the use of EVs as therapeutic delivery vehicles. Still, harnessing the potential of EVs is faced with many obstacles. A cell line engineering approach can be used to exploit EVs to encapsulate a bespoke cargo of interest. However, full details regarding native EV-loading mechanisms remain under debate, making this a challenge. While Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells are well known to be the preferred host for recombinant therapeutic protein production, their application as an EV producer cell host has been largely overlooked. In this study, we engineered CHO DG44 cells to produce custom EVs with bespoke cargo. To this end, genetic constructs employing split green fluorescent protein technology were designed for tagging both CD81 and protein cargoes to enable EV loading via self-assembling activity. To demonstrate this, NanoLuc and mCherry were used as model reporter cargoes to validate engineered loading into EVs. Experimental findings indicated that our custom EV approach produced vesicles with up to 15-fold greater cargo compared with commonly used passive loading strategies. When applied to recipient cells, we observed a dose-dependent increase in cargo activity, suggesting successful delivery of engineered cargo via our custom CHO EVs.

Comprehensive review of MS-based studies on N-glycoproteome and N-glycome of extracellular vesicles

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are lipid bilayer-enclosed particles that can be released by all type of cells. Whereas, as one of the most common post-translational modifications, glycosylation plays a vital role in various biological functions of EVs, such as EV biogenesis, sorting, and cellular recognition. Nevertheless, compared with studies on RNAs or proteins, those investigating the glycoconjugates of EVs are limited. An in-depth investigation of N-glycosylation of EVs can improve the understanding of the biological functions of EVs and help to exploit EVs from different perspectives. The general focus of studies on glycosylation of EVs primarily includes isolation and characterization of EVs, preparation of glycoproteome/glycome samples and MS analysis. However, the low content of EVs and non-standard separation methods for downstream analysis are the main limitations of these studies. In this review, we highlight the importance of glycopeptide/glycan enrichment and derivatization owing to the low abundance of glycoproteins and the low ionization efficiency of glycans. Diverse fragmentation patterns and professional analytical software are indispensable for analysing glycosylation via MS. Altogether, this review summarises recent studies on glycosylation of EVs, revealing the role of EVs in disease progression and their remarkable potential as biomarkers.

Exosome subpopulations: The isolation and the functions in diseases

Exosomes are nanoscale extracellular vesicles secreted by cells. Exosomes mediate intercellular communication by releasing their bioactive contents (e.g., DNAs, RNAs, lipids, proteins, and metabolites). The components of exosomes are regulated by the producing cells of exosomes. Due to their diverse origins, exosomes are highly heterogeneous in size, content, and function. Depending on these characteristics, exosomes can be divided into multiple subpopulations which have different functions. Efficient enrichment of specific subpopulations of exosomes helps to investigate their biological functions. Accordingly, numerous techniques have been developed to isolate specific subpopulations of exosomes. This review systematically introduces emerging new technologies for the isolation of different exosome subpopulations and summarizes the critical role of specific exosome subpopulations in diseases, especially in tumor occurrence and progression.

Chromatographic purification of small extracellular vesicles using an affinity column for phospholipid membranes

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to investigate whether chromatography using an ExoPUA column, an affinity column for phospholipid membranes, could potentially serve as an efficient, rapid, scalable, and reproducible method for purifying small extracellular vesicles (sEVs).

RESULTS

We used the ExoPUA column connected to a fast-performance liquid chromatography system. One-step chromatographic purification of sEVs from culture supernatant using the ExoPUA protocol resulted in an 82 ± 16-fold increase in purity with a yield of 38 ± 5% of sEVs. The purified sEVs contained CD9, CD63, TSG101, and miRNA (miR-21), but not the endoplasmic reticulum protein Calnexin. Transmission electron microscopy indicated that the purified sEVs were intact. The purification performance of the ExoPUA protocol showed superior results in terms of yield compared to that of the differential ultracentrifugation method, the most commonly used method for purifying sEVs in laboratories, and purity compared to that of the DEAE chromatography protocol.

CONCLUSION

The sEVs were effectively purified in the bind-elute mode and the ExoPUA column can be refreshed and sterilized with sodium hydroxide (NaOH), having high potential for multiple sEV purification in a scalable and industrial manner.

The Tumorigenicity of Breast Cancer Cells Is Reduced upon Treatment with Small Extracellular Vesicles Isolated from Heparin Treated Cell Cultures

As a member of the HPSG family, heparin is often used as a specific probe of their role in cell physiology; indeed, we have previously shown a reduction in the tumorigenicity of breast cancer cells when cultured in its presence. However, a partial reversal of the anti-tumorigenic effect occurred when the treated cells were cultured in fresh medium without heparin, which led us to consider whether a more persistent effect could be achieved by treatment of the cells with small extracellular vesicles (sEV) from heparin-treated cells. The tumorigenicity was analyzed using sEV isolated from the culture medium of heparin-treated MCF-7 and MDA-MB231 breast cancer cells (sEV-HT) or from conditioned medium following the termination of treatment (heparin discontinued, sEV-HD). Tumorigenicity was reduced in cells cultured in the presence of sEV-HT compared to that of cells cultured in the presence of sEV from untreated cells (sEV-Ctrl). sEV-HD were also observed to exert an anti-tumorigenic effect on the expression of pro-tumorigenic and cell cycle regulatory proteins, as well as signaling activities when added to fresh cultures of MCF-7 and MDA-MB231 cells. The anti-tumorigenic activity of the heparin-derived sEV may arise from observed changes in the miRNA content or from heparin, which was observed to be bound to the sEV. sEV may constitute a relatively stable reservoir of circulating heparin, allowing heparin activity to persist in the circulation even after therapy has been discontinued. These findings can be considered as a special additional pharmacological characteristic of heparin clinical therapy.

Standardization Approaches for Extracellular Vesicle Loading with Oligonucleotides and Biologics

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are widely recognized for their potential as drug delivery systems. EVs are membranous nanoparticles shed from cells. Among their natural features are their ability to shield cargo molecules against degradation and enable their functional internalization into target cells. Especially biological or bio-inspired large molecules (LMs), like nucleic acids, proteins, peptides, and others, may profit from encapsulation in EVs for drug delivery purposes. In the last years, a variety of loading protocols are explored for different LMs. The lack of standardization in the EV drug delivery field has impeded their comparability so far. Currently, the first reporting frameworks and workflows for EV drug loading are proposed. The aim of this review is to summarize these evolving standardization approaches and set recently developed methods into context. This will allow for enhanced comparability of future work on EV drug loading with LMs.

Development of tandem cation exchange chromatography for high purity extracellular vesicle isolation: The effect of ligand steric availability

Purification of extracellular vesicles for research and therapeutic applications requires updated methodology to address the limitations of traditional ultracentrifugation and other size-based separation techniques. Their downfalls include induced extracellular vesicle aggregation, low yields, poor scalability and one-dimensionality of the separation process, as the size or sedimentation speed of extracellular vesicles is often the only selection criterion. Ion exchange chromatography is a promising alternative or supplementary method candidate, as it offers a different approach for extracellular vesicle separation, which is surface charge. For now, mostly anion exchange chromatography has been evaluated for extracellular vesicle purification, as it successfully relies on the strongly negative surface charge of extracellular vesicles. However, as extracellular vesicles are very complex in their structure, also cation exchange chromatography could be applicable, due to individual cationic domains on the extracellular vesicle surface. Here, we compare anion exchange chromatography to different types of cation exchange chromatography for the purification of platelet extracellular vesicle samples also containing plasma-derived impurities. We found that the choice of resin structure used for cation exchange chromatography is critical for binding platelet extracellular vesicles, as a conventional-type cation exchanger was found to only capture and elute less than 20% of extracellular vesicles. With the tentacle-type resin, it was possible to obtain comparable platelet extracellular vesicle yields (over 90%) with cation exchange chromatography compared to anion exchange chromatography, as well as superior purity, especially when it was combined to conventional cation exchange resin.

Emerging Roles of Using Small Extracellular Vesicles as an Anti-Cancer Drug

Small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) are emerging as a novel therapeutic strategy for cancer therapy. Tumor-cell-derived sEVs contain biomolecules that can be utilized for cancer diagnosis. sEVs can directly exert tumor-killing effects or modulate the tumor microenvironment, leading to anti-cancer effects. In this review, the application of sEVs as a diagnostic tool, drug delivery system, and active pharmaceutical ingredient for cancer therapy will be highlighted. The therapeutic efficacies of sEVs will be compared to conventional immune checkpoint inhibitors. Additionally, this review will provide strategies for sEV engineering to enhance the therapeutic efficacies of sEVs. As a bench-to-bedside application, we will discuss approaches to encourage good-manufacturing-practice-compliant industrial-scale manufacturing and purification of sEVs.

Large-scale heparin-based bind-and-elute chromatography identifies two biologically distinct populations of extracellular vesicles

Purifying extracellular vesicles (EVs) has been challenging because EVs are heterogeneous in cargo yet share similar sizes and densities. Most surface marker-based affinity separation methods are limited to research or diagnostic scales. We report that heparin chromatography can separate purified EVs into two distinct subpopulations as ascertained by MS/MS: a non-heparin-binding (NHB) fraction that contains classical EV markers such as tetraspanins and a heparin-binding (HB) fraction enriched in fibronectins and histones. Both fractions were similarly fusogenic but induced different transcriptional responses in endothelial cells. While EVs that were purified by conventional, non-affinity methods alone induced ERK1/2 phosphorylation and Ki67, the NHB fraction did not. This result suggests heparin chromatography as an additional novel fractionation step that is inherently scalable, does not lead to loss of material, and separates inflammatory and pyrogenic EVs from unreactive EVs, which will improve clinical applications.

Alternative biological sources for extracellular vesicles production and purification strategies for process scale-up

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are phospholipidic bi-layer enclosed nanoparticles secreted naturally by all cell types. They are attracting increasing attention in the fields of nanomedicine, nutraceutics and cosmetics as biocompatible carriers for drug delivery, with intrinsic properties beneficial to human health. Scientific work now focuses on developing techniques for isolating EVs that can translate into industrial-scale production and meet rigorous clinical requirements. The science of EVs is ongoing, and many pitfalls must be addressed, such as the requirement for standard, reproducible, inexpensive, and Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) adherent EV processing techniques. Researchers are exploring the use of alternative sources to EVs derived from mammalian cultures, such as plant EVs, as well as the use of bacteria, algae and milk. Regarding the downstream processing of EVs, many alternative techniques to the ultracentrifugation (UC) protocols most commonly used in the laboratory are emerging. In the context of process scale-up, membrane-based processes for isolation and purification of EVs are the most promising, either as stand-alone processes or in combination with chromatographic techniques. This review discusses current trends on EVs source selection and EVs downstream processing techniques, with a focus on plant-derived EVs and membrane-based techniques for EVs enrichment.

High-Yield Separation of Extracellular Vesicles Using Programmable Zwitterionic Coacervates

Programmable coacervates based on zwitterionic polymers are designed as dynamic materials for ion exchange bioseparation. These coacervates are proposed as promising materials for the purification of soft nanoparticles such as liposomes and extracellular vesicles (EVs). It is shown that the stimulus-responsiveness of the coacervates and the recruitment of desired molecules can be independently programmed by polymer design. Moreover, the polymeric coacervates can recruit and release intact liposomes, human EVs, and nanoalgosomes in high yields and separate vesicles from different types of impurities, including proteins and nucleic acids. This approach combines the speed and simplicity of precipitation methods and the programmability of chromatography with the gentleness of aqueous two-phase separation, thereby guaranteeing product stability. This material represents a promising alternative for providing a low-shear, gentle, and selective purification method for EVs.

Synergistic siRNA Loading of Extracellular Vesicles Enables Functional Delivery into Cells

RNA interference opened new approaches for disease treatment but safe and efficient cell delivery remains a bottleneck. Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are known to naturally shuttle RNA. Due to their potent cell internalization and low-cost scalability, milk-derived EVs in particular are considered promising RNA delivery systems. However, low drug loading currently impedes their use. Here, innovative exogenous loading strategies for small interfering RNA (siRNA) are explored and systematically compared regarding encapsulation efficiency, loading capacity, and loading concentration. Firstly, siRNA is pre-accumulated in liposomes or stabilized calcium phosphate nanoparticles (CaP-NP). The selected systems, which exhibited neutral or negative zeta potentials, are then applied for EV loading. Secondly, EVs are concentrated and applied to protocols known for liposome loading: dehydration-rehydration of vesicles, based on freeze-drying, and mixing by dual asymmetric centrifugation (DAC) after ultracentrifugation. Additionally, DAC after EV ultracentrifugation is combined with CaP-NP leading to a synergistic loading performance. The balance between energy input for siRNA loading and EV integrity is evaluated by monitoring the EV size, marker proteins, and morphology. For the EV-based siRNA formulation via DAC plus CaP-NP, EV properties are sufficiently maintained to protect the siRNA from degradation and deliver cell-death siRNA dose-dependently in Caco-2 cells.

Molecular mechanisms and clinical applications of exosomes in prostate cancer

Prostate cancer (PC) is a common tumor in men, and the incidence rate is high worldwide. Exosomes are nanosized vesicles released by all types of cells into multiple biological fluid types. These vesicles contribute to intercellular communication by delivering both nucleic acids and proteins to recipient cells. In recent years, many studies have explored the mechanisms by which exosomes mediate the epithelial-mesenchymal transition, angiogenesis, tumor microenvironment establishment, and drug resistance acquisition in PC, and the mechanisms that have been identified and the molecules involved have provided new perspectives for the possible discovery of novel diagnostic markers in PC. Furthermore, the excellent biophysical properties of exosomes, such as their high stability, high biocompatibility and ability to cross biological barriers, have made exosomes promising candidates for use in novel targeted drug delivery system development. In this review, we summarize the roles of exosomes in the growth and signal transmission in PC and show the promising future of exosome contributions to PC diagnostics and treatment.