Biodegradation of tributyl phosphate, an organosphate triester, by aerobic granular biofilms

OPFR removal by white rot fungi: screening of removers and approach to the removal mechanism

The persistent presence of organophosphate flame retardants (OPFRs) in wastewater (WW) effluents raises significant environmental and health concerns, highlighting the limitations of conventional treatments for their remotion. Fungi, especially white rot fungi (WRF), offer a promising alternative for OPFR removal. This study sought to identify fungal candidates (from a selection of four WRF and two Ascomycota fungi) capable of effectively removing five frequently detected OPFRs in WW: tributyl phosphate (TnBP), tributoxy ethyl phosphate (TBEP), trichloroethyl phosphate (TCEP), trichloro propyl phosphate (TCPP) and triethyl phosphate (TEP). The objective was to develop a co-culture approach for WW treatment, while also addressing the utilization of less assimilable carbon sources present in WW. Research was conducted on carbon source uptake and OPFR removal by all fungal candidates, while the top degraders were analyzed for biomass sorption contribution. Additionally, the enzymatic systems involved in OPFR degradation were identified, along with toxicity of samples after fungal contact. Acetate (1.4 g·L-1), simulating less assimilable organic matter in the carbon source uptake study, was eliminated by all tested fungi in 4 days. However, during the initial screening where the removal of four OPFRs (excluding TCPP) was tested, WRF outperformed Ascomycota fungi. Ganoderma lucidum and Trametes versicolor removed over 90% of TnBP and TBEP within 4 days, with Pleorotus ostreatus and Pycnoporus sanguineus also displaying effective removal. TCEP removal was challenging, with only G. lucidum achieving partial removal (47%). A subsequent screening with selected WRF and the addition of TCPP revealed TCPP's greater susceptibility to degradation compared to TCEP, with T. versicolor exhibiting the highest removal efficiency (77%). This observation, plus the poor degradation of TEP by all fungal candidates suggests that polarity of an OPFR inversely correlates with its susceptibility to fungal degradation. Sorption studies confirmed the ability of top-performing fungi of each selected OPFR to predominantly degrade them. Enzymatic system tests identified the CYP450 intracellular system responsible for OPFR degradation, so reactions of hydroxylation, dealkylation and dehalogenation are possibly involved in the degradation pathway. Finally, toxicity tests revealed transformation products obtained by fungal degradation to be more toxic than the parent compounds, emphasizing the need to identify them and their toxicity contributions. Overall, this study provides valuable insights into OPFR degradation by WRF, with implications for future WW treatment using mixed consortia, emphasizing the importance of reducing generated toxicity.

Growth-dependent cr(VI) reduction by Alteromonas sp. ORB2 under haloalkaline conditions: toxicity, removal mechanism and effect of heavy metals

Bacterial reduction of hexavalent chromium (VI) to chromium (III) is a sustainable bioremediation approach. However, the Cr(VI) containing wastewaters are often characterized with complex conditions such as high salt, alkaline pH and heavy metals which severely impact the growth and Cr(VI) reduction potential of microorganisms. This study investigated Cr(VI) reduction under complex haloalkaline conditions by an Alteromonas sp. ORB2 isolated from aerobic granular sludge cultivated from the seawater-microbiome. Optimum growth of Alteromonas sp. ORB2 was observed under haloalkaline conditions at 3.5-9.5% NaCl and pH 7-11. The bacterial growth in normal culture conditions (3.5% NaCl; pH 7.6) was not inhibited by 100 mg/l Cr(VI)/ As(V)/ Pb(II), 50 mg/l Cu(II) or 5 mg/l Cd(II). Near complete reduction of 100 mg/l Cr(VI) was achieved within 24 h at 3.5-7.5% NaCl and pH 8-11. Cr(VI) reduction by Alteromonas sp. ORB2 was not inhibited by 100 mg/L As(V), 100 mg/L Pb(II), 50 mg/L Cu(II) or 5 mg/L Cd(II). The bacterial cells grew in the medium with 100 mg/l Cr(VI) contained lower esterase activity and higher reactive oxygen species levels indicating toxicity and oxidative stress. In-spite of toxicity, the cells grew and reduced 100 mg/l Cr(VI) completely within 24 h. Cr(VI) removal from the medium was driven by bacterial reduction to Cr(III) which remained in the complex medium. Cr(VI) reduction was strongly linked to aerobic growth of Alteromonas sp. The Cr(VI) reductase activity of cytosolic protein fraction was pronounced by supplementing with NADPH in vitro assays. This study demonstrated a growth-dependent aerobic Cr(VI) reduction by Alteromonas sp. ORB2 under complex haloalkaline conditions akin to wastewaters.

Removal of pesticides from secondary treated urban wastewater by reverse osmosis

The residues of pesticides that reach water resources from agricultural activities in several ways contaminate drinking water resources and threaten aquatic life. This study aimed to investigate the performance of three reverse osmosis (RO) membranes (BW30-LE, SW30-XLE, and GE-AD) in rejecting four different pesticides (tributyl phosphate, flutriafol, dicofol, and irgarol) from secondary treated urban wastewater and also to elucidate the mechanisms underlying the rejection of these pesticides. RO experiments were conducted using pesticide-spiked wastewater samples under 10 and 20 bar transmembrane pressures (TMP) and membrane performances were evaluated. Overall, all the membranes tested exhibited over 95% rejection performances for all pesticides at both TMPs. The highest rejections for tributyl phosphate (99.0%) and irgarol (98.3%) were obtained with the BW30-LE membrane, while for flutriafol (99.9%) and dicofol (99.1%) with the GE-AD membrane. The increase in TMP from 10 to 20 bar did not significantly affect the rejections of all pesticides. The rejection performances of RO membranes were found to be governed by projection area as well as molecular weight and hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity of pesticides. Among the membranes tested, the SW30-XLE membrane was the most prone to fouling due to the higher roughness.

Degradation of the mixed organic solvents of tributyl phosphate and n-dodecane by heterogeneous Fenton-like oxidation using nanoscale zero-valent iron as the catalyst

The treatment and disposal of spent radioactive organic solvents, i.e., tributyl phosphate (TBP) and diluent (such as kerosene, n-dodecane, etc.), produced in the reprocessing of spent fuel in the closed cycle are crucial for the sustainable development of the nuclear industry. In this study, the synthesized nanoscale zero-valent iron (nZVI) was used as the heterogeneous Fenton-like catalyst to promote the generation of hydroxyl radicals (•OH) by reacting with H₂O₂ to degrade the mixed organic solvents of TBP and n-dodecane. nZVI was characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM), nitrogen adsorption/desorption isotherms, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) to investigate the micro-morphology, nano-particle size, and surface valence state. The change of Fe²⁺/Fe³⁺ concentration ratio during the reaction was measured to clarify the performance of nZVI. The effects of temperature, catalyst dosage, H₂O₂ dosage, and acidifier concentration on the degradation of TBP and n-dodecane were studied, and the results were complemented by the COD of the aqueous solution and the volume reduction rate of the organic phase. The mixed organic solvents of TBP and n-dodecane containing Co²⁺ were used to simulate the spent radioactive organic solvents and to study the distribution of nuclides after the reaction. The results showed that most of the radioactivity was in the residual solution, and the condensate contained almost no radioactivity. The degradation of TBP and n-dodecane was carried out separately, which showed that n-dodecane was more difficult to degrade. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were applied to determine the adsorption energy of organic solvents and nZVI. According to the Fourier transform infrared spectra (FTIR) and their corresponding DFT calculations, liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) of the sample after the reaction, the possible intermediates were analyzed, and the degradation mechanism was speculated.

Degradation mechanism of tributyl phosphate by UV/H2O2 treatment and parameters optimization towards the design of a pilot reactor

While activated sludge treatment is currently the preferred process for the removal of tributyl phosphate (TBP) at the mg.L^-1 level, it is well known that this recalcitrant molecule is incompletely degraded, stimulating research into alternative approaches, such as advanced oxidation. The aim of this study was to characterize the degradation mechanism of TBP during ultraviolet/H₂O₂ treatment using ³¹P NMR, ionic chromatography and total organic carbon analysis. The effects of initial pH, amount of oxidant and pollutant concentration were also assessed using an experimental design approach. The results of this parametric study show that ultraviolet/H₂O₂ photo-oxidation efficiently degrades TBP at concentrations up to 600 mg.L^-1, with >90% phosphate release and up to 95% removal of total organic carbon within 1 h. The data also show that the main reaction intermediates are short carboxylic acids, resulting from the released alkyl groups, meaning that an interesting application of this process may be to rapidly pre-treat industrial effluent upstream of activated sludge reactors.

Whole-Genome Sequencing of Sphingobium sp. Strain RSMS, a Highly Efficient Tributyl Phosphate-Degrading Bacterium

Sphingobium sp. strain RSMS was described earlier as an efficient degrader of tributyl phosphate, an organic pollutant. This report describes the generation and annotation of the genome sequence of Sphingobium sp. strain RSMS, which will facilitate future studies to identify genetic elements responsible for the degradation of tributyl phosphate.

Sphingobium sp. strain RSMS was described earlier as an efficient degrader of tributyl phosphate, an organic pollutant. This report describes the generation and annotation of the genome sequence of Sphingobium sp. strain RSMS, which will facilitate future studies to identify genetic elements responsible for the degradation of tributyl phosphate.

The impact of discharge reduction activities on the occurrence of contaminants of emerging concern in surface water from the Pearl River

"Swimming across the Pearl River" is an annual large-scale sporting event with great popularity in Guangzhou. To reduce the risk of swimmers' exposure to various contaminants in the Pearl River during swimming activities, the local government limits direct sewage and effluent discharge from urban channels during the event. However, the impact of discharge reduction on some contaminants of emerging concern (CECs), such as organophosphorus flame retardants (OPFRs), bisphenol analogues (BPs), and triclosan remains unknown. In the present study, the concentrations of CECs, as well as ammonia-nitrogen (NH₃-N), dissolved organic carbon, and chemical oxygen demand, were measured in aqueous and suspended particulate matter (SPM) from the Guangzhou reaches of the Pearl River. The concentration ranges of sixteen OPFRs, eight BPs, and triclosan were 21.2-91.0, 8.46-37.3, and 1.47-5.62 ng/L, respectively, in aqueous samples, and 25.2-492, 14.0-86.3, and 0.69-17.5 ng/g, respectively, in SPM samples. Hydrophobic and π-π interactions could be contributing to the distribution of CECs. Principal component analysis indicated that consumer materials, manufacturing, and domestic sewage might be the main sources of the CECs. In addition, our study showed that the concentrations of CECs did not change considerably before or after discharge reduction activities, although NH₃-N showed a substantial decrease following pollution control measure. The results demonstrated that temporary reductions of contaminant discharges to the Pearl River had only limited effect on the levels of CECs. Further research is needed to investigate the distributions and potential health risks of CECs in the Pearl River.

Elucidating the biodegradation mechanism of tributyl phosphate (TBP) by Sphingomonas sp. isolated from TBP-contaminated mine tailings

Tributyl phosphate (TBP) is recognised as a global environmental contaminant because of its wide use in floatation reagents, nuclear fuel reprocessing and plasticisers. This contaminant is hardly degraded by hydrolysis in the environment due to its special physicochemical properties. In this study, one TBP-degrading strain was isolated from TBP-contaminated abandoned mine tailings, and 16S rRNA identification revealed that the strain belonged to the genus Sphingomonas. Results validated that the strain could utilise TBP as the sole carbon source, and vitamin was not the essential factor for its growth. Liquid chromatography time-of-flight mass spectrometry analysis identified di-n-butyl phosphate (DnBP) and mono-n-butyl phosphate (MnBP) as the intermediate metabolites for TBP biodegradation. No obvious change in carbon and hydrogen isotope composition was observed in biodegradation processes (cell suspension and crude extract degradation), which indicated that the first irreversible bond cleavage did not involve carbon or hydrogen. Hence, the TBP degradation scheme by Sphingomonas sp. proposed that the first irreversible step of TBP transferred to DnBP would lead to PO bond cleavage. This study combined the identification of products and isotope fractionation in substrates to investigate the transformation mechanism, thereby providing an eco-friendly and cost-effective way for the in situ bioremediation of TBP-contaminated sites by the isolated TBP degradation strain.

Carbon and hydrogen stable isotope analysis for characterizing the chemical degradation of tributyl phosphate

Tributyl phosphate (TBP) belongs to the group of trialkyl substituted organophosphate esters. Its chemical reactivity depends on the stability of various chemical bonds. TBP was used as a model compound for the development of a concept using stable isotope fractionation associated with bond cleavage reactions for better understanding the fate of TBP in the environment. Carbon isotope enrichment factors (ε_C) of TBP hydrolysis were found to be pH dependent (-3.8 ± 0.3‰ at pH 2, -4.6 ± 0.5‰ at pH 7, -2.8 ± 0.1‰ at pH 9, no isotope fractionation at pH 12), which is in accordance with the mode of a S_N2 hydrolytic bond cleavage. Hydrogen isotope fractionation was negligible as no H bond cleavage is involved during hydrolysis. The apparent carbon kinetic isotope effect (AKIE_C) ranged from 1.045 to 1.058. In contrast to hydrolysis, both carbon and hydrogen isotope fractionation were observed during radical oxidation of TBP by OH and SO₄^-, yielding ε_C from -0.9 ± 0.1‰ to -0.5 ± 0.1‰ and ε_H from -20 ± 2‰ to -11 ± 1‰. AKIE_C and AKIE_H varied from 1.007 to 1.011 and from 1.594 to 2.174, respectively. The correlation of ²H and ¹³C isotope fractionation revealed Λ values ranging from 17 ± 1 to 25 ± 6. Results demonstrated that the correlation of ²H and ¹³C isotope fractionation of TBP allowed to identify radical reactions and to distinguish them from hydrolysis. The presented dual isotope analysis approach has diagnostic value for characterizing the chemical transformation of TBP in the environment.

Bioaccumulation of persistent and emerging pollutants in wild sea urchin Paracentrotus lividus

Marine pollution has been increasing as a consequence of anthropogenic activities. The preservation of marine ecosystems, as well as the safety of harvested seafood, are nowadays a global concern. Here, we report for the first time the contamination levels of a large set of 99 emerging and persistent organic contaminants (butyltins (BTs), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), pesticides including pyrethroids, pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PCPs) and flame retardants) in roe/gonads of sea urchin Paracentrotus lividus. Sea urchins are a highly prized worldwide delicacy, and the harvesting of this seafood has increased over the last decades, particularly in South West Atlantic coast, where this organism is harvested mainly for exportation. Sampling was performed in three harvesting sites of the NW Portuguese coast subjected to distinct anthropogenic pressures: Carreço, Praia Norte and Vila Chã, with sea urchins being collected in the north and south areas of each site. Butyltins and pharmaceuticals were not found at measurable levels. Several PAHs, four pyrethroids insecticides, four PCPs and eleven flame retardants were found in roe/gonads of sea urchins, though in general at low levels. Differences among harvesting sites and between areas within each site were found, the lowest levels of contaminants being registered in Carreço. The accumulation of contaminants in sea urchins' roe/gonads seemed to reflect the low anthropogenic pressure felt in the sampling sites. Nevertheless, taking into account the low accumulated levels of chemicals, results indicate that sea urchins collected in South West Atlantic coast are safe for human consumption.

Textile dye biodecolourization and ammonium removal over nitrite in aerobic granular sludge sequencing batch reactors

Biodecolourization of azo dye and removal of ammonium by aerobic granular sludge (AGS) was investigated under different growth conditions. AGS not previously exposed to azo dye was able to effectively decolourize azo dye under anaerobic and microaerophilic conditions. Azo dye, total organic carbon and ammoniacal nitrogen removal efficiencies of 89-100%, 79-95% and 92-100%, respectively, were achieved in the AGS reactor operated for 80days under microaerophilic conditions. Removal of carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus was not impacted by azo dye loading. Azo dye, organic carbon and ammonium were majorly removed in the anoxic period wherein bulk dissolved oxygen was ranged from 0.5 and <0.08mgL^-1. Removal of 60mgL^-1 NH₄⁺-N was associated only with smaller amounts of nitrite build-up (∼5mgL^-1 NO₂^--N) and negligible nitrate concentrations. Profiles of nitrogen compounds in individual sequencing batch reactor cycles supported the occurrence of ammonium removal over nitrite pathway. Bacterial community analysis showed enrichment of specific microorganisms capable of decolourizing azo dyes in the dye-decolourizing AGS. Dye decolourization and nutrient removal by AGS under microaerophilic conditions is a novel finding and can be further developed for treating textile wastewaters onsite or after dilution with sewage.

Microbial community structure in aerobic and fluffy granules formed in a sequencing batch reactor supplied with 4-chlorophenol at different settling times

Toxic compounds, such as 4-chlorophenol (4-CP), which is a common pollutant in wastewater, are removed efficiently from sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) by microorganisms. The bacterial community in aerobic granules formed during the removal of 4-CP in a SBR was monitored for 63days. The SBR reactor was operated with a constant filling and withdrawal time of 7 and 8min and decreasing settling time (30, 5, 3 and 2min) to induce the formation of aerobic granules. During the acclimation period lasting 15days (30min settling time) had a strong effect on the bacterial community. From day 18 onwards, Sphingobium and Comamonadaceae were detected. Rhizobiaceae were dominant from day 24 to day 28 when stable aerobic granules were formed. At day 35, fluffy granules were formed, but the bacterial community structure did not change, despite the changes in the reactor operation to inhibit filamentous bacteria growth. This is the first report on changes in the bacterial community structure of aerobic and fluffy granules during granulation process in a reactor fed with 4-CP and the prediction of its metabolic pathways.

Sustainable bioreduction of toxic levels of chromate in a denitrifying granular sludge reactor

Biological removal of chromate [Cr(VI)] in the presence or absence of nitrate by granular sludge biofilms was investigated in batch experiments and in a sequencing batch reactor (SBR). Denitrifying granular sludge cultivated from activated sludge was able to directly reduce Cr(VI) in the presence of an electron donor. Bioreduction was dependent on the initial Cr(VI) and the granular sludge concentrations. Bioreduction of Cr(VI) was followed by Cr(III) precipitation or entrapment in the granular sludge which was corroborated with decrease in total soluble Cr and increase in inorganic content of biomass. Batch experiments revealed that Cr(VI) addition has no major influence on high-strength nitrate (3000 mg L^-1) denitrification, but nitrite denitrification was slowed-down. However, SBR experiment demonstrated successful denitrification as well as Cr(VI) removal due to enrichment of Cr(VI)-tolerant denitrifying bacteria. In fact, stable SBR performance in terms of complete and sustained removal of 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.5 and 0.75 mM Cr(VI) and denitrification of 3000 mg L^-1 was observed during 2 months of operation. Active biomass and electron donor-dependent Cr(VI) removal, detection of Cr(III) in the biomass and recovery of ~ 92% of the Cr from the granular sludge biofilms confirms bioreduction followed by precipitation or entrapment of Cr(III) as the principal chromate removal mechanism. Metagenomic bacterial community analysis showed enrichment of Halomonas sp. in denitrifying granular sludge performing either denitrification or simultaneous reduction of nitrate and chromate.

Aerobic granular sludge technology: Mechanisms of granulation and biotechnological applications

Aerobic granular sludge (AGS) is a novel microbial community which allows simultaneous removal of carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus and other pollutants in a single sludge system. AGS is distinct from activated sludge in physical, chemical and microbiological properties and offers compact and cost-effective treatment for removing oxidized and reduced contaminants from wastewater. AGS sequencing batch reactors have shown their utility in the treatment of abattoir, live-stock, rubber, landfill leachate, dairy, brewery, textile and other effluents. AGS is extensively researched for wide-spread implementation in sewage treatment plants. However, formation of AGS takes relatively much longer time while treating low-strength wastewaters like sewage. Strategies like increased volumetric flow by means of short cycles and mixing of sewage with industrial wastewaters can promote AGS formation while treating low-strength sewage. This article reviewed the state of research on AGS formation mechanisms, bioremediation capabilities and biotechnological applications of AGS technology in domestic and industrial wastewater treatment.

Halogen-free organophosphorus flame retardants caused oxidative stress and multixenobiotic resistance in Asian freshwater clams (Corbicula fluminea)

Halogen-free organophosphorus flame retardants are widespread in aquatic environments. Although it has been documented that they affect the behavior and reproduction of aquatic species, researches investigating cellular detoxification and the defense system in bivalves are scarce. In this study, adult Asian clams (C. fluminea) were exposed to tris (2-butoxyethyl) phosphate (TBEP) and tributyl phosphate (TBP) at 20, 200, and 2000 μg/L for 28 d. The results showed no noticeable difference in siphoning behavior. However, the siphoning behavior displayed a trend toward a slight decrease in the treatment groups. GR activity was markedly reduced compared with the control groups, whereas the levels of cyp4 significantly increased following the 2000 μg/L TBP treatments (p < 0.05). Moreover, the levels of gsts1 and gstm1 significantly decreased following all TBEP treatments and were significantly inhibited by 20 μg/L TBP (p < 0.05). The adverse effects on antioxidant enzymes suggested that C. fluminea mainly relies on the antioxidant system to reduce damage without an increase in MDA levels following exposure to a low concentration. Moreover, mRNA expression levels of heat shock proteins (hsp 22, 40, 60, 70, and 90) were significantly down-regulated with TBEP and TBP treatments lower than 200 μg/L (p < 0.05), whereas significant up-regulations were observed for hsp 22 and hsp 70 in response to 2000 μg/L TBP treatment (p < 0.05). Up-regulation of ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter genes (abcb1 and abcc1) showed that TBEP and TBP could activate the multixenobiotic resistance (MXR) system to discharge xenobiotics in C. fluminea, which kept its shell closed at high concentrations to prevent xenobiotic entry. Our results provide a new insight into the different mechanisms of cellular detoxification and the MXR system of C. fluminea in response to low and high concentrations of TBEP and TBP.

Inhibitory effects of tributyl phosphate on algal growth, photosynthesis, and fatty acid synthesis in the marine diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum

The widely used solvent extractant, tributyl phosphate (TBP), primarily used as a solvent for the conventional processing of nuclear fuel, has come under scrutiny recently due to concerns surrounding potential environmental contamination and toxicity. In this study, we found that, in Phaeodactylum tricornutum, administration of TBP severely inhibited algal cell growth by reducing photosynthetic efficiency and inducing oxidative stress. We further explored the effect of TBP by examining the gene expression of the photosynthetic electron transport chain and its contribution to reactive oxygen species (ROS) burst. Our data revealed that TBP affected both fatty acid content and profile by regulating the transcription of genes related to glycolysis, fatty acid biosynthesis, and β-oxidation. These results demonstrated that TBP did in fact trigger the synthesis of ROS, disrupting the subcellular membrane structure of this aquatic organism. Our study brings new insight into the fundamental mechanism of toxicity exerted by TBP on the marine alga P. tricornutum.

Recent advances in nutrient removal and recovery in biological and bioelectrochemical systems

Nitrogen and phosphorous are key pollutants in wastewater to be removed and recovered for sustainable development. Traditionally, nitrogen removal is practiced through energy intensive biological nitrification and denitrification entailing a major cost in wastewater treatment. Recent innovations in nitrogen removal aim at reducing energy requirements and recovering ammonium nitrogen. Bioelectrochemical systems (BES) are promising for recovering ammonium nitrogen from nitrogen rich waste streams (urine, digester liquor, swine liquor, and landfill leachate) profitably. Phosphorus is removed from the wastewater in the form of polyphosphate granules by polyphosphate accumulating organisms. Alternatively, phosphorous is removed/recovered as Fe-P or struvite through chemical precipitation (iron or magnesium dosing). In this article, recent advances in nutrients removal from wastewater coupled to recovery are presented by applying a waste biorefinery concept. Potential capabilities of BES in recovering nitrogen and phosphorous are reviewed to spur future investigations towards development of nutrient recovery biotechnologies.