Biofilm processes in treating mariculture wastewater may be a reservoir of antibiotic resistance genes

A multi-pronged approach to assessing antimicrobial resistance risks in coastal waters and aquaculture systems

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is a global challenge that has impacted aquaculture and surrounding marine environments. In this study, a year-long monitoring program was implemented to evaluate AMR in two different aquaculture settings (i.e., open cage farming, recirculating aquaculture system (RAS)) and surrounding marine environment within a tropical coastal region. The objectives of this study are to (i) investigate the prevalence and co-occurrence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB), antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), antibiotics (AB) and various associated chemical compounds at these study sites; (ii) explore the contributing factors to development and propagation of AMR in the coastal environment; and (iii) assess the AMR risks from different perspectives based on the three AMR determinants (i.e., ARB, ARGs and AB). Key findings revealed a distinct pattern of AMR across the different aquaculture settings, notably a higher prevalence of antibiotic-resistant Vibrio at RAS outfalls, suggesting a potential accumulation of microorganisms within the treatment system. Despite the relative uniform distribution of ARGs across marine sites, specific genes such as qepA, blaCTX-M and bacA, were found to be abundant in fish samples, especially from the RAS. Variations in chemical contaminant prevalence across sites highlighted possible anthropogenic impacts. Moreover, environmental and seasonal variations were found to significantly influence the distribution of ARGs and chemical compounds in the coastal waters. Hierarchical cluster analysis that was based on ARGs, chemical compounds and environmental data, categorized the sites into three distinct clusters which reflected strong association with location, seasonality and aquaculture activities. The observed weak correlations between ARGs and chemical compounds imply that low environmental concentrations may be insufficient for resistance selection. A comprehensive risk assessment using methodologies such as the multiple antibiotic resistance (MAR) index, comparative AMR risk index (CAMRI) and Risk quotient (RQ) underscored the complexity of AMR risks. This research significantly contributes to the understanding of AMR dynamics in natural aquatic systems and provides valuable insights for managing and mitigating AMR risks in coastal environments.

Degradation of sulfamethazine in coastal aquaculture tailwater by Na2S2O4@iron-electrode electrooxidation combined with ceramic membrane process

Offshore aquaculture's explosive growth improves the public food chain while also unavoidably adding new pollutants to the environment. Consequently, the protection of coastal marine eco-systems depends on the efficient treatment of wastewater from marine aquaculture. For the sulfamethazine (SMZ) of representative sulfonamides and total organic pollutants removal utilizing in-situ high salinity, this work has established an inventive and systematic treatment process coupled with iron-electrode electrochemical and ultrafiltration. Additionally, the activated dithionite (DTN) was being used in the electrochemical and ultrafiltration processes with electricity/varivalent iron (FeII/FeIII) and ceramic membrane (CM), respectively, indicated by the notations DTN@iron-electrode/EO-CM. Quenching experiments and ESR detection have identified plenty of reactive species including SO4·-, ·OH, 1O2, and O2·-, for the advanced treatment. In addition, the mass spectrometry (MS) and the Gaussian simulation calculation for these primary reaction sites revealed the dominate SMZ degradation mechanisms, including cleavage of S-N bond, hydroxylation, and Smile-type rearrangement in DTN@iron-electrode/EO process. The DTN@iron-electrode/EO effluent also demonstrated superior membrane fouling mitigation in terms of the CM process, owing to its higher specific flux. XPS and SEM confirmed the reducing membrane fouling, which showed the formation of a loose and porous cake layer. This work clarified diverse reactive species formation and detoxification with DTN@iron-electrode/EO system and offers a sustainable and efficient process for treating tailwater from coastal aquaculture.

High Efficiency Removal Performance of Tetracycline by Magnetic CoFe2O4/NaBiO3 Photocatalytic Synergistic Persulfate Technology

The widespread environmental contamination resulting from the misuse of tetracycline antibiotics (TCs) has garnered significant attention and study by scholars. Photocatalytic technology is one of the environmentally friendly advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) that can effectively solve the problem of residue of TCs in the water environment. This study involved the synthesis of the heterogeneous magnetic photocatalytic material of CoFe2O4/NaBiO3 via the solvothermal method, and it was characterized using different characterization techniques. Then, the photocatalytic system under visible light (Vis) was coupled with peroxymonosulfate (PMS) to explore the performance and mechanism of degradation of tetracycline hydrochloride (TCH) in the wastewater. The characterization results revealed that CoFe2O4/NaBiO3 effectively alleviated the agglomeration phenomenon of CoFe2O4 particles, increased the specific surface area, effectively narrowed the band gap, expanded the visible light absorption spectrum, and inhibited recombination of photogenerated electron-hole pairs. In the Vis+CoFe2O4/NaBiO3+PMS system, CoFe2O4/NaBiO3 effectively activated PMS to produce hydroxyl radicals (·OH) and sulfate radicals (SO4-). Under the conditions of a TCH concentration of 10 mg/L-1, a catalyst concentration of 1 g/L-1 and a PMS concentration of 100 mg/L-1, the degradation efficiency of TCH reached 94% after 100 min illumination. The degradation of TCH was enhanced with the increase in the CoFe2O4/NaBiO3 and PMS dosage. The solution pH and organic matter had a significant impact on TCH degradation. Notably, the TCH degradation efficiency decreased inversely with increasing values of these parameters. The quenching experiments indicated that the free radicals contributing to the Vis+CoFe2O4/NaBiO3+PMS system were ·OH followed by SO4-, hole (h+), and the superoxide radical (O2-). The main mechanism of PMS was based on the cycle of Co3+ and Co2+, as well as Fe3+ and Fe2+. The cyclic tests and characterization by XRD and FT-IR revealed that CoFe2O4/NaBiO3 had good degradation stability. The experimental findings can serve as a reference for the complete removal of antibiotics from wastewater.

Enhanced degradation of enrofloxacin in mariculture wastewater based on marine bacteria and microbial carrier

This study aimed to isolate marine bacteria to investigate their stress response, inhibition mechanisms, and degradation processes under high-load conditions of salinity and enrofloxacin (ENR). The results demonstrated that marine bacteria exhibited efficient pollutant removal efficiency even under high ENR stress (up to 10 mg/L), with chemical oxygen demand (COD), total phosphorus (TP), total nitrogen (TN) and ENR removal efficiencies reaching approximately 88%, 83%, 61%, and 73%, respectively. The predominant families of marine bacteria were Bacillaceae (50.46%), Alcanivoracaceae (32.30%), and Rhodobacteraceae (13.36%). They responded to ENR removal by altering cell membrane properties, stimulating the activity of xenobiotic-metabolizing enzymes and antioxidant systems, and mitigating ENR stress through the secretion of extracellular polymeric substance (EPS). The marine bacteria exhibited robust adaptability to environmental factors and effective detoxification of ENR, simultaneously removing carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, and antibiotics from the wastewater. The attapulgite carrier enhanced the bacteria's resistance to the environment. When treating actual mariculture wastewater, the removal efficiencies of COD and TN exceeded 80%, TP removal efficiency exceeded 90%, and ENR removal efficiency approached 100%, significantly higher than reported values in similar salinity reactors. Combining the constructed physical and mathematical models of tolerant bacterial, this study will promote the practical implementation of marine bacterial-based biotechnologies in high-loading saline wastewater treatment.

Performance test and analysis of tetracycline degradation using a Micro-Nano Bubble system

Antibiotics and organic residues from Tetracycline (TC) and other pharmaceuticals administered to aquatic living organism have negative impacts on aquatic environment by killing-off non-target living organisms and developing antibiotic-resistant bacteria. In this study, Micro-Nano Bubble (MNB) system was used to remove TC residues. MNB system demonstrated good level of degradation efficiency, as resulted in experiment where in time of 100 min, the TC degraded at rate of 82.66% from its initial concentration of TC when the initial concentration was 1 mg/L. When the initial concentration was increased to 10 mg/L, MNB system degraded TC at 64.35% of their initial, this means MNB system demonstrated good level of efficiency for TC removal and indicated that it is more efficient in TC degradation under the conditions of low initial TC concentration and high availability of dissolved oxygen (DO). In the system as the temperature increased there was a significant decrease in DO saturation which was related to the TC complex structure that contain multiple function groups such as amino groups, hydroxyl and carboxyl which possess high strong affinity with oxygen that leads to their adsorption onto bubble surface. This study provides significant insights into the application of MNB system for the removal of organic residues within aquatic ecosystem and underscores the need for further exploration of MNB technology for environmental remediation.

A systematic review of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in mariculture wastewater: Antibiotics removal by microalgal-bacterial symbiotic system (MBSS), ARGs characterization on the metagenomic

Antibiotic residues in mariculture wastewater seriously affect the aquatic environment. Antibiotic Resistance Genes (ARGs) produced under antibiotic stress flow through the environment and eventually enter the human body, seriously affecting human health. Microalgal-bacterial symbiotic system (MBSS) can remove antibiotics from mariculture and reduce the flow of ARGs into the environment. This review encapsulates the present scenario of mariculture wastewater, the removal mechanism of MBSS for antibiotics, and the biomolecular information under metagenomic assay. When confronted with antibiotics, there was a notable augmentation in the extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) content within MBSS, along with a concurrent elevation in the proportion of protein (PN) constituents within the EPS, which limits the entry of antibiotics into the cellular interior. Quorum sensing stimulates the microorganisms to produce biological responses (DNA synthesis - for adhesion) through signaling. Oxidative stress promotes gene expression (coupling, conjugation) to enhance horizontal gene transfer (HGT) in MBSS. The microbial community under metagenomic detection is dominated by aerobic bacteria in the bacterial-microalgal system. Compared to aerobic bacteria, anaerobic bacteria had the significant advantage of decreasing the distribution of ARGs. Overall, MBSS exhibits remarkable efficacy in mitigating the challenges posed by antibiotics and resistant genes from mariculture wastewater.

Antimicrobial resistance in aquaculture: Occurrence and strategies in Southeast Asia

Aquaculture is a highly important and expanding industry in Southeast Asia (SEA). An upcoming problem is the emergence of antibiotic resistant pathogens due to the unchecked use of antibiotics and human clinical practices. This review focused insight into the occurrence of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and strategies from SEA aquaculture based on the original research publication over the period 2002 to 2023. Amongst the 11 SEA countries, the most AMR report has come from Vietnam, Malaysia, and Thailand, respectively. The AMR found in SEA aquaculture were classified into 17 drug classes. The most reported AMR are aminoglycosides, beta-lactams, (fluoro)quinolones, tetracycline, sulpha group and multi-drug. Beta-lactams, tetracycline, sulpha group are reported in each country with the reported frequencies higher than 40 %. Escherichia coli, Aeromonas and Vibrio are the most widely and frequently reported ARB in SEA aquaculture. Multiple antibiotic resistance (MAR) indexes for the sample containing multiple bacterial isolates were generally low, while the medium numbers of MAR indexes for the typical bacteria species were higher than 0.2 and showed higher MAR levels than the global mean. Most of the detected ARGs are related to beta-lactams, tetracycline, sulpha group, and aminoglycosides. Amongst the beta-lactam resistance genes, blaTEM, and blaSHV are the most frequently detected. Almost all the available information of antibiotics, ARB and ARGs in SEA aquaculture was consistent with the global scale analysis. In addition, factors that contribute to the development and spread of AMR in SEA aquaculture were discussed. Moreover, the national action plan to combat AMR in SEA countries and the available technologies that already applied in the SEA aquaculture are also included in this review. Such findings underline the need for synergistic efforts from scientists, engineers, policy makers, government managers, entrepreneurs, and communities to manage and reduce the burden of AMR in aquaculture of SEA countries.

Effect of antibiotics on the performance of moving bed biofilm reactor for simultaneous removal of nitrogen, phosphorus and copper(II) from aquaculture wastewater

Co-existence of NO3--N, antibiotics, phosphorus (P), and Cu2+ in aquaculture wastewater has been frequently detected, but simultaneous removal and relationship between enzyme and pollutants removal are far from satisfactory. In this study, simultaneous removal of NO3--N, P, antibiotics, and Cu2+ by moving bed biofilm reactor (MBBR) was established. About 95.51 ± 3.40% of NO3--N, 61.24 ± 3.51% of COD, 18.74 ± 1.05% of TP, 88% of Cu2+ were removed synchronously in stage I, and antibiotics removal in stages I-IV was 73.00 ± 1.32%, 79.53 ± 0.88%, 51.07 ± 3.99%, and 33.59 ± 2.73% for tetracycline (TEC), oxytetracycline (OTC), chlortetracycline hydrochloride (CTC), sulfamethoxazole (SMX), respectively. The removal kinetics and toxicity of MBBR effluent were examined, indicating that the first order kinetic model could better reflect the removal of NO3--N, TN, and antibiotics. Co-existence of multiple antibiotics and Cu2+ was the most toxicity to E. coli growth. Key enzyme activity, reactive oxygen species (ROS) level, and its relationship with TN removal were investigated. The results showed that enzymes activities were significantly different under the co-existence of antibiotics and Cu2+. Meanwhile, different components of biofilm were extracted and separated, and enzymatic and non-enzymatic effects of biofilm were evaluated. The results showed that 70.00%- 94.73% of Cu2+ was removed by extracellular enzyme in stages I-V, and Cu2+ removal was mainly due to the action of extracellular enzyme. Additionally, microbial community of biofilm was assessed, showing that Proteobacteria, Bacteroidetes, and Gemmatimonadetes played an important role in the removal of NO3--N, Cu2+, and antibiotics at the phylum level. Finally, chemical bonds of attached and detached biofilm were characterized by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and effect of nitrogen (N) and P was proposed under the co-existence of antibiotics and Cu2+. This study provides a theoretical basis for further exploring the bioremediation of NO3--N, Cu2+, and antibiotics in aquaculture wastewater.

Aerobic granular sludge formation and stability in enhanced biological phosphorus removal system under antibiotics pressure: Performance, granulation mechanism, and microbial successions

Wastewater containing antibiotics can pose a significant threat to biological wastewater treatment processes. This study investigated the establishment and stable operation of enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR) by aerobic granular sludge (AGS) under mixed stress conditions induced by tetracycline (TC), sulfamethoxazole (SMX), ofloxacin (OFL), and roxithromycin (ROX). The results show that the AGS system was efficient in removing TP (98.0%), COD (96.1%), and NH₄⁺-N (99.6%). The average removal efficiencies of the four antibiotics were 79.17% (TC), 70.86% (SMX), 25.73% (OFL), and 88.93% (ROX), respectively. The microorganisms in the AGS system secreted more polysaccharides, which contributed to the reactor's tolerance to antibiotics and facilitated granulation by enhancing the production of protein, particularly loosely bound protein. Illumina MiSeq sequencing revealed that putative phosphate accumulating organisms (PAOs)-related genera (Pseudomonas and Flavobacterium) were enormously beneficial to the mature AGS for TP removal. Based on the analysis of extracellular polymeric substances, extended Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (XDLVO) theory, and microbial community, a three-stage granulation mechanism was proposed including adaption to the stress environment, formation of early aggregates and maturation of PAOs enriched microbial granules. Overall, the study demonstrated the stability of EBPR-AGS under mixed antibiotics pressure, providing insight into the granulation mechanism and the potential use of AGS for wastewater treatment containing antibiotics.

Effects of successional sulfadiazine exposure on biofilm in moving bed biofilm reactor: Secretion of extracellular polymeric substances, community activity and functional gene expression

The effects of sulfadiazine (SDZ) on responses of biofilm in a moving bed biofilm reactor were explored with emphasis on the changes in extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and functional genes. It was found that 3 to 10 mg/L SDZ reduced the protein (PN) and polysaccharide (PS) contents of EPS by 28.7%-55.1% and 33.3%-61.4%, respectively. The EPS maintained high ratio of PN to PS (10.3-15.1), and the major functional groups within EPS remained unaffected to SDZ. Bioinformatics analysis showed that SDZ significantly altered the community activity such as increased expression of s_Alcaligenes faecali. Totally, the biofilm held high SDZ removal rates, which were ascribed to the self-protection by secreted EPS, and genes levels upregulation of antibiotic resistance and transporter protein. Collectively, this study provides more details on the biofilm community exposure to an antibiotic and highlights the role of EPS and functional genes in antibiotic removal.

Variations in antibiotic resistance genes and microbial community in sludges passing through biological nutrient removal and anaerobic digestion processes in municipal wastewater treatment plants

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) represents a relentless, silent pandemic. Contributing to this are wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs), a potential source of antibiotic resistance genes' (ARGs) transmission to the environment, threatening public health. The presence of ARGs in pathogenic bacteria and their release into the environment by WWTPs threatens the public health. The current study investigated changes in ARGs' abundance in biological nutrient removal (BNR) processes and anaerobic digestion (AD) reactors of two WWTPs. Also, microbial community structure, which is known to shape the distribution and abundance of ARGs, was also analyzed. The relative abundance of eight ARGs (tetX, tetA, tetM, TEM, sul1, sul2, ermB and qnrD) was quantified as ARGs' copies/16 S rRNA gene copies using quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR). Microbial community composition was assessed by 16 S rRNA microbiome sequencing analysis. TetX was prevalent among the eight ARGs, followed by TEM and sul1. However, its abundance was decreased in the AD sludges compared to BNR sludges. Proteobacteria was the major bacterial phylum found in all the sludge samples, while Arcobacter, 12up and Acidovorax were the predominant genera. Acinetobacter and Flavobacterium were significantly more abundant in the BNR sludges, while 12up and Aeromonas were predominant in AD sludges. Principal component analysis (PCA) revealed a clear difference in dominant ARGs and bacteria between the sludges in the processes of BNR and AD of the two WWTPs. Clinically relevant bacterial genera, Klebsiella and Enterococcus, found in both the BNR and AD sludges, were significantly correlated with the tetX gene. Throughout this study, the relationship between microbial communities and specific ARGs was revealed, illustrating that the composition of the microbial community could play a vital role in the abundance of ARGs. These results will better inform future studies aimed at controlling the spread of ARGs and their potential hosts from WWTPs.

Effect of external carbon addition and enrofloxacin on the denitrification and microbial community of sequencing batch membrane reactor treating synthetic mariculture wastewater

The effect of sequencing batch membrane bioreactor (SMBR) on external carbon addition and enrofloxacin was investigated to treat synthetic mariculture wastewater. Anoxic/anaerobic and low COD/TN can improve the ammonia oxidation of the system, and the NH₄⁺-N removal efficiency above 99%. External carbon was added and an anoxic environment was set to provide a suitable environment for denitrifying bacteria. When the external carbon source was 50-207 mg/L, the TN removal efficiency (31.82%-37.73%) and the COD of the effluent (28.85-36.58 mg/L) had little change. The partition resistance model showed that cake deposition resistance (R_C,irr) and irreversible resistance (R_PB) were the main components. And with the increase in cleaning times, the fouling rate of membrane components accelerated. Enrofloxacin can promote the TN removal efficiency (45.66%-93.74%) and had a significant effect on TM7a, Cohaesibacter, Vibrio and Phaeobacter.

The responses of marine anammox bacteria-based microbiome to multi-antibiotic stress in mariculture wastewater treatment

Saline mariculture wastewater containing multi-antibiotics poses a challenge to anaerobic ammonia oxidation (anammox) process. Herein, the halophilic marine anammox bacteria (MAB)-based microbiome was used for treating mariculture wastewater (35‰ salinity) under multi-antibiotics (enrofloxacin + oxytetracycline + sulfamethoxazole, EOS) stress. And the main focus of this study lies in the response of MAB-based microbiome against multi-antibiotics stress. It is found that MAB-based microbiome shows stable community structure and contributes high nitrogen removal efficiency (>90%) even under high stress of EOS (up to 4 mg·L^-1). The relative abundance of main functional genus Candidatus Scalindua, responsible for anammox, had little change while controlling the influent EOS concentration within 4 mg·L^-1, whereas, significantly decreased to 2.23% at EOS concentration of as high as 24 mg·L^-1. As an alternative, antibiotic resistance bacteria (ARB) species Rheinheimera dominated the microbial community of MAB-based biological reactor under extremely high EOS stress (e.g. 24 mg·L^-1 in influent). The response mechanism of MAB-based microbiome consists of extracellular and intracellular defenses with dependence of EOS concentration. For example, while EOS within 4 mg·L^-1 in this study, most of the antibiotics were retained by extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) via adsorption; If increasing the EOS concentration to 8 and even 24 mg·L^-1, part of antibiotics could intrude into the cells and cause the intracellular accumulation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) (total abundance up to 2.44 × 10^-1 copies/16S rRNA) for EOS response. These new understandings will facilitate the practical implementation of MAB-based bioprocess for saline nitrogen- and antibiotics-laden wastewater treatment.

The fate of antibiotic resistance genes, microbial community, and potential pathogens in the maricultural sediment by live seaweeds and oxytetracycline

Three common seaweeds including Ulva fasciata, Codium cylindricum and Ishige okamurai were used for the remediation of maricultural wastewater and sediment in the presence/absence of trace level of oxytetracycline (OTC) in lab-scale experiments. Higher NO₃^--N and PO₄^3--P removal rates were achieved due to the presence of seaweeds, and trace OTC also had a positive effect on NO₃^--N removal. A slight variation of 2.10-2.15% were observed in the total relative abundances of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) of different sediment samples after one-month operation. However, the variation of ARGs profiles by the co-existence of different seaweeds and OTC was in the descending order of Ishige okamurai > Codium cylindricum > Ulva fasciata, which was in accordance with the variation of microbial hosts at genus level. The abundance of dominant tetracycline resistance genes promoted by the co-existence of different seaweeds and OTC in compared with the presence of single seaweed or OTC via metagenomic sequencing and qPCR analysis, and the co-existence of Ishige okamurai and OTC exhibited the largest impact. The potential pathogens were more sensitive to the co-existence of seaweed and OTC than single seaweeds. Meanwhile, a variety of ARGs were enriched in the pathogens, and the dominant pathogenic bacteria of Vibrio had 133 Vibrio species with 28 subtypes of ARGs. The variation of ARGs profiles in the sediment were strongly related with the dominant phyla Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria, Firmicutes, Planctomycetes and Cyanobacteria. Besides, Nitrate level exhibited more significant effect on ∑ARGs, ARGs resistant to vancomycin and streptogramin_a, while phosphate level exhibited more positively significant effect on ARGs resistant to fosmidomycin, ATFBT and cephalosporin.

Insight in degradation of tetracycline in mariculture wastewater by ultraviolet/persulfate advanced oxidation process

The direct discharge of trace amounts of antibiotics in mariculture wastewater results in adverse effect on the ecological environment of receiving waters. Hence, the degradation of tetracycline (TC) in mariculture wastewater by the ultraviolet/peroxydisulfate (UV/PS) process was investigated in this study. The results revealed that 95.73% removal of TC with 5 mg/L dosage was achieved after 30 min UV/PS treatment. Chloride ion (Cl^-) in mariculture wastewater slightly inhibited TC degradation by scavenging free radicals. Comparably, bromine ion (Br^-) significantly enhanced the removal of TC and even doubled the degradation rate. Reactive bromine species (RBS) made a major contribution to the TC removal, followed by free chlorine and other reactive chlorine species (RCS). The TC degradation pathway revealed that functional group shedding and ring-opening reactions occurred successively. In addition, TC mineralization rate was low within 30 min, causing the inefficient reduction of acute toxicity of TC and its intermediates, which could be improved by optimizing the process parameters. These results indicated that UV/PS is a new alternative process for the harmless treatment of mariculture wastewater containing the antibiotics.

Sulfamethoxazole removal from mariculture wastewater in moving bed biofilm reactor and insight into the changes of antibiotic and resistance genes

Antibiotics are widely dosed in mariculture sector, resulting in substantial antibiotics residues. Hence, mariculture wastewater is urgent to be treated before discharging. In this study, the anoxic/oxic moving bed biofilm reactor (A/O-MBBR) was used to treat the wastewater containing sulfamethoxazole (SMX) from mariculture, SMX removal mechanism and the variation of antibiotic-resistant genes (ARGs) were investigated. The results showed that 22%-33% of SMX was removed by the bioreactor, where a small amount of SMX was adsorbed and stored by the extracellular polymers and most of SMX (>80%) was biodegraded in the anoxic tank. Occurrence of nitrate in anoxic condition was conducive to SMX degradation. Pseudomonas, Desulfuromusa, and Methanolobus species, as well as microbial catalase contributed to the SMX biotransformation. Quantitative PCR analysis of ARGs (sul1, sul2 and int1) and mRNA (sul1, sul2) showed that SMX enriched SMX-related ARGs and enhanced the expression of corresponding genes. Most of ARGs finally were discharged with effluent. Hence, the effluent from biologically based processes treating mariculture wastewater still contained antibiotics residue and resistance genes, which should be further controlled by suitable techniques.

Metagenomics analysis of probable transmission of determinants of antibiotic resistance from wastewater to the environment - A case study

During mechanical-biological treatment, wastewater droplets reach the air with bioaerosols and pose a health threat to wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) employees and nearby residents. Microbiological pollutants and antimicrobial resistance determinants are discharged to water bodies with treated wastewater (TWW), which poses a potential global epidemiological risk. In the present study, the taxonomic composition of microorganisms was analyzed, and the resistome profile and mobility of genes were determined by metagenomic next-generation sequencing in samples of untreated wastewater (UWW), wastewater collected from an activated sludge (AS) bioreactor, TWW, river water collected upstream and downstream from the wastewater discharge point, and in upper respiratory tract swabs collected from WWTP employees. Wastewater and the emitted bioaerosols near WWTP's facilities presumably contributed to the transmission of microorganisms, in particular bacteria of the phylum Actinobacteria and the associated antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) (including ermB, ant(2″)-I, tetM, penA and cfxA2) to the upper respiratory tract of WWTP employees. The discharged wastewater increased the taxonomic diversity of microorganisms and the concentrations of various ARGs (including bacA, emrE, sul1, sul2 and tetQ) in river water. This study fills in the knowledge gap on the health risks faced by WWTP employees. The study has shown that microbiological pollutants and antimicrobial resistance determinants are also in huge quantities discharged to rivers with TWW, posing a potential global epidemiological threat.

Isolation, characterization and degradation performance of oxytetracycline degrading bacterium Planococcus sp. strain pw2

Oxytetracycline (OTC), is a widely used veterinary antibiotic for treatment and prophylaxis in aquaculture. As an emerging pollutant, OTC in the environment exerts selective pressure on aquatic organisms causing proliferation of antibiotic resistant genes. In the present study, an OTC tolerant isolate labelled as pw2 was selected among the 11 OTC tolerant isolates, isolated from the aquaculture effluent, for investigating its OTC degrading potential. The cell morphology, biochemical characteristics, and 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene sequence of the isolated strain indicated that it belonged to the genus Planococcus. The OTC removal percentage was estimated through measuring its residual concentration in the culture medium with high performance liquid chromatography. The strain exhibited maximum removal efficiency of 90.62%, with initial OTC concentration of 10 µg/ml. The optimum degrading conditions were 35 °C and pH 7. The degradation rate of OTC with (biotic) and without strain pw2 (abiotic) was 3.253 and 1.149 mg/l/d, respectively. The half-life was recorded to be 2.13 d in the presence of strain pw2, in contrast to 6.03 days recorded without strain pw2. The total (biotic + abiotic) OTC degradation efficiency was 75.74, 83.93, 90.62, and 86.47% for the initial OTC concentrations of 1 to 25 µg/ml, respectively. Addition of carbon and nitrogen did not influence the OTC removal which indicates Planococcus sp. pw2 use OTC as sole energy source. Thus, Planococcus sp. pw2 plays a vital role in reducing the OTC concentration in the environment, offering a promising method for treatment of aquaculture effluent containing OTC.

Responses of aerobic granular sludge to fluoroquinolones: Microbial community variations, and antibiotic resistance genes

In this study, aerobic granular sludge (AGS) was operated under high levels of ammonium for removing three fluoroquinolones (FQs), i.e., ciprofloxacin (CFX), ofloxacin (OFX), and norfloxacin (NFX) at 3, 300, and 900 µg/L, respectively. Two key objectives were to investigate the differential distribution of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) in sludge fractions and to evaluate correlations between ARGs and MGEs to nitrifying and denitrifying bacteria. AGS showed excellent stability under the exposure of FQs, with nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) more sensitive to FQs than ammonium-oxidizing bacteria (AOB). Specific oxygen utilization rates (SOUR) showed a reduction of 26.9% for NOB but only 4.0% of the reduced activity of AOB by 3 μg/L FQs. AGS performed better removal efficiencies for CFX and NFX than OFX, and the efficiencies increased with their elevated concentrations, except at 900 μg/L FQs. The elevated FQ concentrations led to a significant enrichment of intI1 and genus Thauera, while qnrD and qnrS showed no accumulation. Compared to nitrifiers, FQs relevant ARGs and the intI1 gene preferred to exist in denitrifiers, and the abundance of denitrifiers behaved a decreasing trend with the sludge size. Two quinoline-degrading bacteria were found in the AGS system, i.e., Alicycliphilus and Brevundimonas, possibly carrying qnrS and qnrD, respectively. Their relative abundance increased with the sludge size, which was 2.18% in sludge <0.5 mm and increased to 3.70% in sludge >2.0 mm, suggesting that the AGS may be a good choice in treating FQs-containing wastewater.

Inhibition of norfloxacin on anaerobic digestion: Focusing on the recoverability and shifted microbial communities

Antibacterial properties of norfloxacin (NOR) could cause adverse impact on engineered biological process. In this study, the objective was to investigate the inhibitory effects of NOR on anaerobic digestion focusing on the recoverability and microbial community changes. The effects of different concentrations of NOR on anaerobic digestion were studied with three continuous feed cycles. Results showed that NOR seriously inhibited the methane production with an 50% inhibitory concentration (IC₅₀) of 0.41 mM. In addition, with extending of exposure time, inhibitory effect increasingly strengthened and the IC₅₀ values decreased to 0.16 mM and 0.07 mM in the second and third feeding cycle, respectively. However, when the inhibitor in supernatant was removed, the performance recovered and the relative methane yield increased by 9 times from 25.38 mL/g VS to 257.05 mL/g VS. The transformation of NOR showed that the degradation of NOR in the anaerobic digestion was difficult and the recovery was due to the removal of NOR. The microbial analysis revealed that the inhibition of NOR on bacteria of Candidatus_Cloacimonas, Petrimonas, Ercella, Sphaerochaeta and hydrogenotrophic methanogens of Methanoculleus and Methanobacterium was recoverable when NOR was removed. However, it was irreversible for acetoclastic methanogen of Methanosaeta. These findings provided comprehensive understanding on the characteristics of NOR inhibition and also provided feasible strategy to recover the NOR inhibited anaerobic digestion.

Effect of sulfamethoxazole and oxytetracycline on enhanced biological phosphorus removal and bacterial community structure

The individual and combined effects of sulfamethoxazole (SMX) and oxytetracycline (OTC) on an enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR) system was investigated. OTC at 5 mg/L resulted in filamentous bulking with a collapse of EBPR system. P removal decreased to 44.8% and COD was mostly removed during the aerobic phase. SMX and OTC had antagonistic effects in EBPR system. The inhibitory effect of SMX and SMX + OTC on P removal, COD removal, glycogen transformation and extracellular polymeric substances content was reversible with prolonged operation, accompanied with increase of polyphosphate accumulating organisms. The presence of nitrification inhibitor allylthiourea, high pH and low tetX abundance limited the removal of SMX and OTC. The bacterial community structure, antibiotic resistance genes abundances and genes functions were also investigated by metagenomic analysis. The results of this study offer insights into the individual and combined environmental risks of SMX and OTC, and their impact on EBPR.

Performance and Microbial Community of Different Biofilm Membrane Bioreactors Treating Antibiotic-Containing Synthetic Mariculture Wastewater

The performance of pollutant removals, tetracycline (TC) and norfloxacin (NOR) removals, membrane fouling mitigation and the microbial community of three Anoxic/Oxic membrane bioreactors (AO-MBRs), including a moving bed biofilm MBR (MBRa), a fixed biofilm MBR (MBRb) and an AO-MBR (MBRc) for control, were compared in treating antibiotic-containing synthetic mariculture wastewater. The results showed that MBRb had the best effect on antibiotic removal and membrane fouling mitigation compared to the other two bioreactors. The maximum removal rate of TC reached 91.65% and the maximum removal rate of NOR reached 45.46% in MBRb. The addition of antibiotics had little effect on the removal of chemical oxygen demand (COD) and ammonia nitrogen (NH₄⁺-N)—both maintained more than 90% removal rate during the entire operation. High-throughput sequencing demonstrated that TC and NOR resulted in a significant decrease in the microbial diversity and the microbial richness MBRs. Flavobacteriia, Firmicutes and Azoarcus, regarded as drug-resistant bacteria, might play a crucial part in the removal of antibiotics. In addition, the dynamics of microbial community had a great change, which included the accumulation of resistant microorganisms and the gradual reduction or disappearance of other microorganisms under antibiotic pressure. The research provides an insight into the antibiotic-containing mariculture wastewater treatment and has certain reference value.

An understated danger: Antimicrobial resistance in aquaculture and pet fish in Switzerland, a retrospective study from 2000 to 2017

Aquaculture is a rapidly growing field of food production. However, morbidity and mortality are higher in aquaculture species than in domestic animals. Bacterial diseases are a leading cause of farmed fish morbidity and are often treated with antimicrobials. Since most Swiss fish farms release effluents directly into surface water without treatment and since aquaculture fish are consumed by humans, antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and multi-resistance in aquaculture fish are important for environmental and public health. In this study, AMR tests for 14 antimicrobials were performed on 1,448 isolates from 1,134 diagnostic laboratory submissions from farmed and ornamental fish submissions for the period from 2000 to 2017. Amoxicillin, gentamycin and norfloxacin had the lowest proportion of resistant samples. However, AMR was highly variable over time. Resistance proportions were higher in: (a) ornamental fish compared with farmed fish, (b) fish from recirculation systems compared with those from other farming systems and (c) isolates originating from skin compared with those originating from inner organs. Multiple resistances were common. The results of this study provide useful data for Swiss fish veterinarians and some interesting hypotheses about risk factors for AMR in aquaculture and pet fish in Switzerland. However, further research is needed to define risk factors.

Bioremediation of Aquaculture Wastewater with Algal-Bacterial Biofilm Combined with the Production of Selenium Rich Biofertilizer

The discharge of aquaculture wastewater and the excessive selenium in aquaculture effluent caused by selenium addition to aquatic feed are posing a serious risk for the marine environment. In this study, batch tests were carried out to investigate the feasibility of utilizing algal–bacterial biofilm for the treatment of selenium-rich aquaculture wastewater. The effects of four different types of commercial biofilm carriers on the attached growth of biofilms and the contaminant removal capacity were examined. The braided cotton biofilm carrier had the best performance on biofilm growth, while in an exponential growth period the dry weight density of the biofilm was above 2.0 g L−1. By utilizing the braided cotton carrier with a hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 6 days, the removal rate of N and P from the raw aquaculture wastewater was 88.5 ± 6.2% and 99.8 ± 0.2%, respectively. After that, the effects of different initial wastewater load ratios (IWLR) and HRT on the effluent quality of the treatment process were studied. The decrease in IWLR and the extension of HRT could improve the treatment performance. The effluent N, P and Se concentrations in the group with 50% IWLR and 6-day HRT were 0.75 ± 0.10 mg L−1, 0.015 ± 0.02 mg L−1, 35.2 ± 3.2 μg L−1, respectively, indicating an effective removal of the main contaminants. The algal–bacterial biofilm harvested from the batch test was rich in N, P and Se, where the Se content was 21.8 ± 3.4 mg kg−1, which has the potential to be used as an Se-rich biofertilizer.

Norfloxacin-induced effect on enhanced biological phosphorus removal from wastewater after long-term exposure

In this study, long-term experiments were performed under synthetic wastewater conditions to evaluated the potential impacts of norfloxacin (NOR) (10, 100 and 500 μg/L) on enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR). Experimental result showed that long-term exposure to 10 μg/L NOR induced negligible effects on phosphorus removal. The presence of 100 μg/L NOR slightly decreased phosphorus removal efficiency to 94.41 ± 1.59 %. However, when NOR level further increased to 500 μg/L, phosphorus removal efficiency was significantly decreased from 97.96 ± 0.8 5% (control) to 82.33 ± 3.07 %. The mechanism study revealed that the presence of 500 μg/L NOR inhibited anaerobic phosphorus release and acetate uptake as well as aerobic phosphorus uptake during long-term exposure. It was also found that 500 μg/L NOR exposure suppressed the activity of key enzymes related to phosphorus removal but promoted the transformations of intracellular polyhydroxyalkanoate and glycogen. Microbial analysis revealed that that the presence of 500 μg/L NOR reduced the abundances of polyphosphate accumulating organisms but increased glycogen accumulating organisms, as compared the control.

MBR-UV/Cl2 system in treating polluted surface water with typical PPCP contamination

This study proposed the membrane bioreactor–ultraviolet/chlorine (MBR-UV/Cl₂) process for treating polluted surface water with pharmaceutical personal care product (PPCP) contamination. Results showed that MBR-UV/Cl₂ effectively removed the organic matters and ammonia at approximately 80% and 95%. MBR-UV/Cl₂ was used in the removal of sulfadiazine(SDZ), sulfamethoxazole(SMZ), tetracycline(TC), oxytetracycline(OTC), ciprofloxacin(CIP), ofloxacin(OFX), erythromycin(ERY), roxithromycin(ROX), ibuprofen(IBU) and, naproxen(NAX) at 12.18%, 95.61%, 50.50%, 52.97%, 33.56%, 47.71%, 87.57%, 93.38%, 93.80%, and 71.46% in which their UV/Cl₂ contribution was 12.18%, 95.61%, 29.04%, 38.14%, 25.94%, 7.20%, 80.28%, 33.79%, 73.08%, and 23.05%, respectively. The removal of 10 typical PPCPs using UV/Cl₂ obtained higher contributions than those of the MBR process, except OTC, ROX, and IBU. The UV/Cl₂ process with 3-min hydraulic retention time and chlorine concentration at 3 mg/L effectively removed the trace of PPCPs. MBR-UV/Cl₂ has the potential to be developed as an effective technology in treating polluted surface water with PPCP contamination.

Performance and microbial communities of different biofilm membrane bioreactors with pre-anoxic tanks treating mariculture wastewater

The performance of pollutant removals, activated sludge characteristics, and microbial communities of two biofilm membrane bioreactors coupled with pre-anoxic tanks (BF-AO-MBRs) (one using fiber bundle bio-carriers (FB-MBR) and the other using suspended bio-carriers (MB-MBR)) were compared at the salinity between zero and 60 g/L. At all salinities, three bioreactors showed good COD average removal efficiencies (>94.1%), and FB-MBR showed the best TN removal efficiency (90.4% at 30 g/L salinity). Moreover, FB-MBR had the faster process start-up time and better salt shock resistance. At high salinities (30-60 g/L), more extracellular polymeric substances were produced by the BF-AO-MBRs to avoid the penetration of salt and protect the bacterial community. Because of the different attachment patterns of biofilms, the microbial community structure in the FB-MBR exposed to 30 g/L salinity had higher nitrite-oxidizing/ammonia-oxidizing bacteria ratio (6.44) with more abundance of denitrifiers, which contribute to higher TN removal efficiency and lower nitrite accumulation.

Moving bed biofilm reactor technology in municipal wastewater treatment: A review

The review encompasses the development of municipal wastewater treatment process using MBBR from early stages, established application, and recent advancements. An overview of main drivers leading to the MBBR technology development over its early stage is discussed. Biocarriers types and features together with biofilm development and role of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) are presented, ultimately, addressing the challenge in decreasing startup time required for full operation. Furthermore, the review investigates the state of the art of MBBR technology for nutrient removal (i.e., COD and BOD, nitrogen and phosphorus) through process functionality and configuration of established (e.g., IFAS) and under development (e.g. PN/A) applications. Reactor operational characteristics such as filling fractions, mixing properties, dissolved oxygen requirements, and loading rates are presented and related to full scale examples. Current literature discussing the most recent studies on MBBR capability in reduction and removal of chemicals of emerging concern (CEC) released is presented. Ultimately, high rate carbon and nitrogen removal through A/B stage process are examined in its main operational parameters and its application towards energy neutrality suggesting novel MBBR application to further reduce energy requirements and plant footprint.

Action of oxytetracycline (OTC) degrading bacterium and its application in Moving Bed Biofilm Reactor (MBBR) for aquaculture wastewater pre-treatment

In this study, the characteristics of biodegradation of oxytetracycline (OTC) by strain Ochrobactrum sp. KSS10 were studied under various environmental conditions, including initial OTC concentrations, variable temperature, initial pH, and diverse carbon sources. The capability of this bacterial strain for performing simultaneous OTC degradation and nitrate reduction was also explored under aerobic conditions. An OTC degradation ratio of 63.33% and a nitrate removal ratio of 98.64% were obtained within 96 h. In addition, removal of OTC and ammonia from synthetic aquaculture wastewater by a Moving Bed Biofilm Reactor (MBBR) and changes in the resistant genes of microbial communities were also investigated. The results demonstrated that the strain KSS10 was the dominant contributor in OTC and ammonia removal in the MBBR chamber. It removed almost all ammonia and approximately 76.42% of OTC. The abundances of genes tetL, tetX and intI1 were reduced by the MBBR, but the abundance of tetG and tetM were increased due to horizontal and vertical gene transfers. Such a result can potentially be used by the strain KSS10 for removing antibiotics and nitrogen from aquaculture wastewater during pre-treatment.

Highly efficient removal of antibiotic rifampicin from aqueous solution using green synthesis of recyclable nano-Fe3O4

Antibiotics in water and soil are persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic to aquatic organisms and human health. To address it, as one of the new technologies, green synthesized magnetic Fe₃O₄ nanoparticles by Excoecaria cochinchinensis extract used to remove rifampicin (RIF) was investigated in this study. Results showed the adsorption efficiency of RIF reached 98.4% and the maximum adsorption capacity is 84.8 mg/g when 20 mL of RIF at a concentration of 20 M was adsorbed by 10 mg Fe₃O₄ at a temperature of 303 K. The morphology of the green Fe₃O₄ characterized by SEM demonstrated the dimensions ranging from 20 to 30 nm. The N₂ adsorption/desorption isotherms revealed that the surface area of Fe₃O₄ was 111.8 m²/g. In addition, adsorption studies indicated that the kinetics fitted the pseudo second-order and isothermal adsorption conformed to the Langmuir isotherm. Furthermore, due to their magnetic properties, the Fe₃O₄ nanoparticles were easily separated and reused and the mechanism for removing RIF occurred through adsorption rather than chemical redox reaction. Finally, the reusability of Fe₃O₄ for adsorption of RIF showed that the removal efficiency decreased to 61.5% after five cycles.

Microbial community evolution and fate of antibiotic resistance genes along six different full-scale municipal wastewater treatment processes

The evolution of microbial community and the fate of ARGs along different full-scale wastewater treatment processes (i.e., Anaerobic-Anoxic-Oxic, Oxidation Ditch, and Cyclic Activated Sludge System) were investigated in this study. We found that the sludges of bioreactors treating similar influent showed the similar microbial communities, independent of the treatment technologies. The horizontal gene transfer (HGT) mainly occurred in aeration tank rather that anaerobic/anoxic tank. More co-occurrence of potential pathogens and ARGs was found in wastewater than in sludge. Microbial biomass was the key driver for the fate of ARGs in wastewater, while mobile genetic elements (MGEs) was the key factor for the fate of ARGs in sludge. Combination of wastewater characteristics, microbial diversity, microbial biomass, and MGEs contributed to the variation of ARGs. Finally, it was found that enhanced nutrients removal process and tertiary treatment would benefit ARGs removal.

Fast-Response and Reusable Oxytetracycline Colorimetric Strips Based on Nickel (II) Ions Immobilized Carboxymethylcellulose/Polyacrylonitrile Nanofibrous Membranes

Driven by economic interests, the abuse of antibiotics has become a significant concern for humans worldwide. As one of the most commonly used antibiotics, oxytetracycline (OTC) residue in animal-derived foods occurs occasionally, which has caused danger to humanity. However, there is still no simple and efficient solution to detect OTC residue. Here, an easily-operated colorimetric strategy for OTC detection was developed based on nickel ions (Ni2+) immobilized carboxymethylcellulose/polyacrylonitrile nanofibrous membranes (Ni@CMC/PAN NFMs). Owing to numerous O- and N-containing groups OTC has a strong tendency to complex with Ni2+ on the strips, inducing a color change from light green to yellow visible to the naked eye. The NFMs structural features, CMC functionalization process, and Ni2+ immobilization amount was carefully regulated to assure OTC detection whilst maintaining the inherent characteristics of NFMs. With the benefits of the large specific surface area (SSA) and small pore size of NFMs, the strips not only exhibited a rapid response (2 min), and low detection limit (5 nM) but also performed with good reversibility and selectivity concerning OTC detection over other antibiotics. The successful development of such enchanting nanofibrous materials may provide a new comprehension into the design and improvement of colorimetric strips.

Responses of biofilm microorganisms from moving bed biofilm reactor to antibiotics exposure: Protective role of extracellular polymeric substances

EPS can affect the migration of antibiotics in biofilm reactors, however the roles of biofilm EPS on the fate of antibiotics and the protective mechanisms to bacterial community remain unknown. We investigated the transport of three representative antibiotics in the biofilm suspension from a moving bed biofilm reactor. Spectral analysis suggested that proteins dominated the interactions between EPS and antibiotics. The adsorbed amounts of antibiotics onto EPS accounted for 14.5%, 88.2% and 13.1% of total concentration for sulfamethizole, tetracycline and norfloxacin, respectively at the biodegradation stage. The respiratory rates and representative enzymatic activities all experienced declines for biofilm without EPS in exposure to antibiotics. Gene sequencing results indicated that the bacterial community in biofilm without EPS was more vulnerable to antibiotics shocks. Our results demonstrated the protective roles of biofilm EPS in resisting antibiotics stresses, which provides important implications for understanding the bioremediation of antibiotics in biofilm systems.

The Rising Tide of Antimicrobial Resistance in Aquaculture: Sources, Sinks and Solutions

As the human population increases there is an increasing reliance on aquaculture to supply a safe, reliable, and economic supply of food. Although food production is essential for a healthy population, an increasing threat to global human health is antimicrobial resistance. Extensive antibiotic resistant strains are now being detected; the spread of these strains could greatly reduce medical treatment options available and increase deaths from previously curable infections. Antibiotic resistance is widespread due in part to clinical overuse and misuse; however, the natural processes of horizontal gene transfer and mutation events that allow genetic exchange within microbial populations have been ongoing since ancient times. By their nature, aquaculture systems contain high numbers of diverse bacteria, which exist in combination with the current and past use of antibiotics, probiotics, prebiotics, and other treatment regimens-singularly or in combination. These systems have been designated as "genetic hotspots" for gene transfer. As our reliance on aquaculture grows, it is essential that we identify the sources and sinks of antimicrobial resistance, and monitor and analyse the transfer of antimicrobial resistance between the microbial community, the environment, and the farmed product, in order to better understand the implications to human and environmental health.