Robust biological nitrogen removal by creating multiple tides in a single bed tidal flow constructed wetland

A partial siphon operational strategy strengthens nitrogen removal performance in partially saturated vertical flow constructed wetlands

The carbon‒oxygen balance has always been problematic in constructed wetlands (CWs), putting pressure on stable and efficient nitrogen removal. In this study, a novel partial siphon operational strategy was developed to further optimize the carbon and oxygen distributions of a partially saturated vertical flow CW (SVFCW) to enhance nitrogen removal. The removal performances of the partial siphon SVFCW (S-SVFCW) were monitored and compared with those of the SVFCWs at different partial siphon depths (15 cm, 25 cm and 35 cm) in both the warm and cold seasons. The results showed that the partial siphon operating strategy significantly facilitated the removal of ammonia and total nitrogen (TN) in both the warm and cold seasons. When the partial siphon depth was 25 cm, the S-SVFCWs had the highest TN removal efficiency in both the warm (71%) and cold (56%) seasons, with an average improvement of 46% and 52%, respectively, compared with those of the SVFCWs. The oxidation‒reduction potential (ORP) results indicated that richer OPR environments and longer hydraulic detention times were obtained in the S-SVFCWs, which enriched the denitrification bacteria. Microbial analysis revealed greater nitrification and denitrification potentials in the unsaturated zone with enriched functional genes (e.g., amo_AOA, amo_AOB, nxrA and nirK), which are related to nitrification and denitrification processes. Moreover, the strengthening mechanism was the intensified oxygen supply and carbon utilization efficiency based on the cyclic nitrogen profile analysis. This study provides a novel partial siphon operational strategy for enhancing the nitrogen removal capacity of SVFCWs without additional energy or land requirements.

Exploring organic matter conversion pathway and its effect on nitrogen removal in tidal flow constructed wetlands

Achieving effective nitrogen removal remains a significant challenge faced by constructed wetlands. Although organic matter is a crucial factor influencing nitrogen removal, little attention has been paid to the impact of organic matter conversion pathways on nitrogen removal in constructed wetlands. Here, we showed that endogenous microorganisms performing carbon internalization could be easily enriched in tidal flow constructed wetlands (TFCWs) under its special rhythmic cycle of anaerobic/aerobic operational mode. Endogenous microorganisms could translate influent carbon sources into intracellular carbons during the anaerobic stage and supply the carbon source for endogenous denitrification after the aerobic stage (rest period). Based on these findings, an innovative combined TFCW and Nitrifying-CW system was developed, and robust total nitrogen (TN) removal (82% on average) was achieved even under carbon source limiting conditions. This performance was a substantial improvement compared to the conventional single bed TFCW with multiple "tides" (corresponding to the multiple contact/rest periods) with TN removal of only 54% on average. Simultaneous nitrification-endogenous denitrification (SNED) was found to be the major nitrogen removal pathway in the proposed system. Compared with classical nitrification-denitrification, simultaneous nitrification-endogenous denitrification brings high nitrogen conversion rates and significantly reduces the demand for oxygen and organic carbon. Furthermore, microbial community analysis indicated that endogenous microorganisms such as Candidatus_Competibacter and Defluviicoccus were successfully enriched, accounting for 50.73% and 3.46% in CW1, and 25.25% and 1.76% in CW2, respectively. Together, these mechanisms allow the proposed system to achieve efficient TN removal.

Organic media-based two-stage traditional and electrode-integrated tidal flow wetlands to treat landfill leachate: Influence of aeration strategy and plants

Landfill leachate treatment employing normal and electrode-integrated constructed wetlands is difficult due to the presence of significant amounts of organic compounds, which frequently impede the progression of microbial-based aerobic pollutant removal pathways. As a result, this study examines the effect of supplementary air availability via intermittent and continuous aeration strategies in improving organic, nutrient, and coliform removals of the unplanted, planted (normal and electrode-integrated) two-stage tidal flow constructed wetlands designed to treat landfill leachate. The constructed wetlands were filled with coal and biochar media and planted with Canna indica. Mean chemical oxygen demand (COD), total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), and coliform removal percentages of the externally aerated two-stage unplanted, only planted, planted-microbial fuel cell integrated constructed wetland systems ranged between 96 and 99%, 82 and 93%, 91 and 98%, 86 and 96%, respectively, throughout the experimental campaign. External aeration inhibited the development of a dominant anaerobic environment within the media of the wetland systems and improved overall pollutant removal. The electrode-integrated planted tidal flow wetlands produced better effluent quality than the unplanted or only planted tidal flow systems without electrode assistance. The first stages of the three wetland systems achieved an additional 5-7% COD, 7-12% TN, and 15-22% coliform removal during the continuous aeration period compared to the corresponding performance of the intermittent aeration phase. The pollutant removal performance of the second-stage wetlands decreased during the continuous aeration phase. The media composition supported electrochemically active and inactive microbial-based pollutant removal routes and the chemical adsorption of pollutants. Nitrogen and phosphorus accumulation percentage in plant tissues was low, i.e., 0.4-2.2% and 0.04-0.8%, respectively. During the continuous aeration period, the electrode-integrated tidal flow constructed wetlands achieved higher power density production, i.e., between 859 and 1432 mW (mW)/meter³(m³). This study demonstrates that external aeration might improve pollutant removal performance of the normal, electrodes integrated tidal flow-based constructed wetlands when employed for high organic-strength wastewater treatment such as landfill leachate.

Enhancement of organics and nutrient removal and microbial mechanism in vertical flow constructed wetland under a static magnetic field

Low and unstable pollutant removal is regarded as the bottleneck problem in constructed wetlands (CWs) for wastewater treatment. This study investigated the effect of static magnetic field (MF) on enhancing the purification efficiency and microbial mechanism in vertical flow CW systems for treating domestic wastewater. The results showed that MF-CWs outperformed control systems in terms of treatment performance, with average removal efficiencies of COD, NH₄⁺-N, TN, and TP reaching 92.58%, 73.58%, 72.53%, and 95.83%, respectively. The change of malondialdehyde (MDA), catalase (CAT), and superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity indicated that MF application was beneficial for plant health. Additionally, higher ammonia monooxygenase (AMO) activity in MF-CWs suggested the removal of NH₄⁺-N was facilitated. The high-throughput sequencing results demonstrated that MF application could enrich the functional bacteria such as Patescibacteria phylum, mainly, including Gammaproteobacteria, Betaproteobacteria, and Alphaproteobacteria, which further accelerated pollutants transformation. These findings would be beneficial in understanding pollutant removal processes and their mechanism in CWs with MF application.

Comparison of nitrogen removal performance and mechanism from low-polluted wastewater by constructed wetlands with two oxygen supply strategies: Tidal flow and intermittent aeration

Due to dissolved oxygen (DO) limited nitrogen removal efficiency in constructed wetlands (CWs), two representative oxygen-suppling CWs, i.e., tidal flow constructed wetlands (TFCWs) and intermittently aerated constructed wetlands (IACWs) were proposed to compare the effect of oxygen supply strategies on the nitrogen removal performance and mechanism. Results showed that the removal efficiencies of NH₄⁺-N and COD in IACWs were as high as 90.35-97.14% and 91.14-92.44%, respectively. In terms of TN, TFCWs (83.82%) showed a significantly higher removal efficiency than IACWs, and this result was derived with the flooded/drained phase (FP/DP) ratio of 21 h:3 h in TFCWs, because rhythmic FP and DP formed a high oxygen gradient at different depths of the system, which intensified the nitrification and denitrification simultaneously. The potential nitrifying and denitrifying bacteria (e.g., Nitrospira, Azospira, Haliangium, Bradyrhizobium and Arenimonas) were enriched more significantly in TFCWs compared with IACWs, as well as Bacillus for simultaneous nitrification and denitrification, which promoted nitrogen transformation together. Also, the results of molecular ecological network analysis showed that bacterial community structure in IACWs was more complex and robust than in TFCWs, because there were obviously more nodes and links as well as a higher proportion of negative interference. However, the relationship between genera in TFCWs was closer depending on shorter path distances, and the keystone genus (Nitrosomonas) in related to nitrification was considered to play an important role in nitrogen transformation performance.

Effect of steel slag on ammonia removal and ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms in zeolite-based tidal flow constructed wetlands

The ammonia removal performance of tidal flow constructed wetlands (TFCWs) requires to be improved under high hydraulic loading rates (HLRs). The pH decrease caused by nitrification may adversely affect the NH₄⁺-N removal and ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms (AOMs) of TFCWs. Herein, TFCWs with zeolite (TFCW_Z) and a mixture of zeolite and steel slag (TFCW_S) were built to investigate the influence of steel slag on NH₄⁺-N removal and AOMs. Both TFCWs were operated under short flooding/drying (F/D) cycles and high HLRs (3.13 and 4.69 m³/(m² d)). The results revealed that a neutral effluent pH (6.98-7.82) was achieved in TFCW_S owing to the CaO dissolution of steel slag. The NH₄⁺-N removal efficiencies in TFCW_S (91.2 ± 5.1%) were much higher than those in TFCW_Z (73.2 ± 7.1%). Total nitrogen (TN) removal was poor in both TFCWs mainly due to the low influent COD/TN. Phosphorus removal in TFCW_S was unsatisfactory because of the short hydraulic retention time. The addition of steel slag stimulated the flourishing AOMs, including Nitrosomonas (ammonia-oxidizing bacteria, AOB), Candidatus_Nitrocosmicus (ammonia-oxidizing archaea, AOA), and comammox Nitrospira, which may be responsible for the better ammonia removal performance in TFCW_S. PICRUSt2 showed that steel slag also enriched the relative abundance of functional genes involved in nitrification (amoCAB, hao, and nxrAB) but inhibited genes related to denitrification (nirK, norB, and nosZ). Quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) revealed that complete AOB (CAOB) and AOB contributed more to the amoA genes in TFCW_S and TFCW_Z, respectively. Therefore, this study revealed that the dominant AOMs could be significantly changed in zeolite-based TFCW by adding steel slag to regulate the pH in situ, resulting in a more efficient NH₄⁺-N removal performance.

Wetland Construction, Restoration, and Integration: A Comparative Review

In response to the global loss and degradation of wetland ecosystems, extensive efforts have been made to reestablish wetland habitat and function in landscapes where they once existed. The reintroduction of wetland ecosystem services has largely occurred in two categories: constructed wetlands (CW) for wastewater treatment, and restored wetlands (RW) for the renewal or creation of multiple ecosystem services. This is the first review to compare the objectives, design, performance, and management of CW and RW, and to assess the status of efforts to combine CW and RW as Integrated Constructed Wetlands (ICW). These wetland systems are assessed for their ecological attributes and their relative contribution to ecosystem services. CW are designed to process a wide variety of wastewaters using surface, subsurface, or hybrid treatment systems. Designed and maintained within narrow hydrologic parameters, CW can be highly effective at contaminant transformation, remediation, and sequestration. The ecosystem services provided by CW are limited by their status as high-stress, successionally arrested systems with low landscape connectivity and an effective lifespan. RW are typically situated and designed for a greater degree of connection with regional ecosystems. After construction, revegetation, and early successional management, RW are intended as self-maintaining ecosystems. This affords RW a broader range of ecosystem services than CW, though RW system performance can be highly variable and subject to invasive species and landscape-level stressors. Where the spatial and biogeochemical contexts are favorable, ICW present the opportunity to couple CW and RW functions, thereby enhancing the replacement of wetland services on the landscape.

Seasonal Enhancement of Nitrogen Removal on Domestic Wastewater Treatment Performance by Partially Saturated and Saturated Hybrid Constructed Wetland

The aim of this study is to evaluate seasonal enhancement of nitrogen removal on domestic wastewater treatment performance by partially saturated and saturated HBCWs. To achieve this, two HBCWs consisting of a vertical subsurface flow constructed wetland, followed by a horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetland (VSSF-HSSF) were evaluated. Two saturation levels were used: (a) partially saturated HB1:VSSF1 (0.6 m)-HSSF1 (0.15 m), (b) saturated HB2: VSSF2 (0.8 m)-HSSF2 (0.25 m). Each unit was planted with Schoenoplectus californicus and was operated for 297 days. The removal efficiencies in HB1 and HB2 were above 70%, 86%, 77% and 55% for chemical oxygen demand (COD), total suspended solids (TSS), nitrogen as ammonium (NH4+-N), and total nitrogen (TN), respectively. For VSSF, a higher level of saturation (from 0.6 to 0.8 m) meant a decrease of 17% in the TN removal efficiencies, and for HSSF, an increase from 0.15 to 0.25 m of saturation meant a decrease of 11 and 10% in the NH4+-N and TN removal efficiencies, respectively. Thus, the increase of saturation level in HBCWs reduces the transformation and/or removal of components of the wastewaters to be treated, particularly nitrogen. Through this research, the possibility of optimizing the transformation of nitrogen with partially saturated hybrids can be examined.

Strengthening anoxic glycogen consumption in SNEDPR-CW as a strategy to control PAO-GAO competition under carbon limited condition

Cooperation between Phosphate and Glycogen Accumulating Organisms (PAOs and GAOs) plays a pivotal role in nutrients removal in simultaneous nitrification endogenous denitrification and phosphorous removal (SNEDPR) systems. Recent findings have expanded the application of SNEDPR from activated sludge system to constructed wetland (CW). However, how to regulate competition between PAOs and GAOs in SNEDPR-based CW is still unclear. Here we showed that, GAOs could easily gain dominance over PAOs in SNEDPR-CW under alternating anaerobic/aerobic (A/O) operational mode. Shortening aerobic hydraulic retention time (HRT) at low oxygen concentration was benefit for simultaneous nitrification endogenous denitrification (SNED) and denitrifying dephosphatation but would reduce the overall phosphorus uptake rate and lead to high phosphorus effluent concentrations. Extended aerobic HRT promoted the proliferation of aerobic GAOs over PAOs, decreasing both enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR) and SNED performance. Surprisingly, by switching the operation of system to alternating anaerobic/aerobic/anoxic (A/O/A) mode, an extraordinary nutrients removal performance with mean nitrogen and phosphorus removal efficiency of 84.57% and 89.37% was achieved under carbon sources limited condition. Stoichiometric analysis demonstrated that adding anoxic stage strengthened the intracellular glycogen oxidization of GAOs for denitrification which compromised its subsequent anaerobic carbon sources uptake and PHA storage and provided sufficient carbon sources for PAOs. Microbial community analysis showed that numerical ratio of GAOs to PAOs decreased from 6.67 under A/O to 4.89 under A/O/A mode, which further indicated strengthening glycogen denitrification of GAOs should be an effective way to regulate microbial competition in order to obtain a desired nutrients removal performance in SNEDPR-CW.

Enhanced wastewater nutrients removal in vertical subsurface flow constructed wetland: Effect of biochar addition and tidal flow operation

Dissolved oxygen (DO) and carbon stock in substrate medium play a vital role in the nutrient removal mechanism in a constructed wetland (CW). This study compiles the results of dynamics of DO, ammonium N (NH₄⁺-N), nitrate (NO₃-N), sulfate (SO₄^-2), phosphate (PO₄^-3), chemical oxygen demand (COD), in three setups of vertical-flow constructed wetlands (TFCWs) (SB: substrate + biochar; SBP: substrate + biochar + Colocasia esculenta plantation; SP: substrate + Colocasia esculenta (SP), operated with tidal flow cycles. Experimental analyses illustrated the continuous high DO level (2.743-5.66 mg L^-1) in SB and SBP after the I and II cycle of tidal flow (72 h flooding and 24 h dry phase). COD reduction efficiencies increased from 15.75 - 61.86% to 48.55-96.80% after tidal operation among operating TFCWs. N (NH₄⁺-N) and N (NO₃-N) removal were found to be 88.16%, and 76.02%; 49.32, and 57.85%; and 40.23%, and 48.94 % in SBP, SP and SB, respectively. The theory of improved nitrification and adsorption through biochar amended substratum was proposed for TFCW systems. PO₄^-3 and SO₄^-2 removal improved from 22.63 to 80.50%, and 19.69 to 75.20%, respectively after first tidal operation in all TFCWs. The microbial inhabitation on porous biochar could promote the transformation of available P into microbial biomass and also helped by the plant uptake process while SO₄^-2 reduction in TFCWs could be mainly due to sulfate-reducing bacterial activity and nitrate reduction process, mainly facilitated by high DO and biochar addition in such setups. The study suggests that effluent re-circulation through tidal operation and biochar supplementation in the substratum could be an effective mechanism for the improvement of the working efficiencies of CWs operated with low energy input systems.

Advanced nitrogen and phosphorus removal by combining endogenous denitrification and denitrifying dephosphatation in constructed wetlands

To achieve high-efficiency nutrient removal in constructed wetlands (CWs), a novel simultaneous nitrogen and phosphorus removal (SNPR) process was developed by combining nitrification, endogenous denitrification, and denitrifying phosphorus removal. In SNPR process, denitrifying glycogen-accumulating organisms (DGAOs) and denitrifying polyphosphate-accumulating organisms (DPAOs) utilized NO_x^--N(NO₃^--N or NO₂^--N) as electron acceptor and poly-beta-hydroxy-alkanoates (PHAs) as carbon sources for endogenous denitrification and denitrifying phosphorus removal processes. Results from 217 days of operation showed that a high-level of nitrogen removal efficiency of 83.73% was achieved with influent COD/N of 4. The success was attributed to the fact that most of influent carbon sources could be transformed into PHAs before nitrification via enriching DGAOs and DPAOs in CW, which simultaneously improved nitrification and denitrification due to reducing oxygen and carbon sources consumption by aerobic heterotrophs. Phosphorus was mainly removed via denitrifying phosphorus removal, and PO₄^3--P removal efficiency reached up to 87.84% with even common gravel used as substrate. Stoichiometry analysis revealed that DGAOs were the main organisms providing nitrite to DPAOs, suggesting that the effective PO₄^3--P removal under high DGAO abundance condition might be attributed to the coordination of DGAOs and DPAOs in SNRP processes.

A taxonomy of design factors in constructed wetland-microbial fuel cell performance: A review

The past decade has seen the rapid development of constructed wetland-microbial fuel cell (CW-MFC) technology in many aspects. The first publication on the combination of constructed wetland (CW) and microbial fuel cell (MFC) appeared in 2012, subsequently, research on the subject has grown exponentially to improve the performance of CW-MFCs in their dual roles of wastewater treatment and power generation. Although significant research has been conducted on this technology worldwide, a comprehensive and critical review of effective controlling parameters is lacking. More broadly, research is needed to draw up-to-date conclusions on recent developments and to identify knowledge gaps for further studies. This review paper systematically enumerates and reviews research studies published in this area to determine the key design factors and their role in CW-MFC performance. Moreover, a taxonomy of all CW-MFC design parameters has been synthesised from the literature. Importantly, this original work provides a comprehensive conceptual framework for future researchers, designers, builders, and users to understand CW-MFC technology. Within the taxonomy, parameters are placed in three main categories (physical/environmental, chemical, and biological/electrochemical) and comprehensive details are given for each parameter. Finally, a comprehensive summary of the parameters has been tabulated showing their impact on CW-MFC operation, design recommendations from literature, and the significant research gaps that this review has identified within the existing literature. It is hoped that this paper will provide a clear and rich picture of this technology at its current stage of development and furthermore, will facilitate a deeper understanding of CW-MFC performance for long-term and large-scale development.

Effect of first-stage aeration on treatment of domestic sewage in different hybrid constructed wetlands

Two sets of hybrid constructed wetlands (HCWs) with the first-stage aeration were used to treat actual domestic sewage in this paper, where the effects of three important factors of aeration mode, hydraulic loading rates (HLR), and aeration volume on the removal of pollutants in both HCWs were studied in contrasts. In addition, the pollutant removal efficiency, the contribution of plants, and the characteristics of biofilm in both HCWs were explored. The results of 250-day experiment showed that the TN removal capacity of HCW combining vertical flow CW with horizontal flow CW (VF-HF) was better than HCW's converse combination (HF-VF) in treatingsewage, while the removal efficiency of COD and NH₄⁺-N were similar, and the concentrations of TN and COD in the effluent of VF-HF could successfully meet the National discharge requirements. Compared with the continuous aeration, the intermittent aeration only had a little effect on the removal of COD and NH₄⁺-N, but could improve TN removal performance in both HCWs. Meanwhile, increasing the aeration volume was beneficial to remove NH₄⁺-N but not TN in HCWs. In addition, although the pollutant removal performances in both HCWs were impacted, the removal capacity of TN in VF-HF was only affected a little, when HLR was increased by 50%. The contribution of plants' uptake accounted for about 10% to nitrogen removal and 20% to phosphorus removal in both HCWs. The biomass at the filler surface near the plant rhizosphere was greater than that in the non-rhizosphere zones, and the impact of plant rhizosphere on the nitrification activity of biofilm was significantly greater than that on denitrification activity in both HCWs.

Creating tidal flow via siphon for better pollutants removal in a microbial fuel cell-constructed wetland

Oxygen is the electron acceptor in cathode chamber of microbial fuel cell-constructed wetland system (MFC-CW). The objective of the study lies in creating a "tidal flow" (TF) in cathode chamber via a siphon to enhance the oxygen diffusion, thus promoting the system performance. A laboratory scale MFC-CW with a siphon driven TF recirculation was proposed and designed. It allows the variable water level being created in four operational modes. The results demonstrated the significance of the siphon which was reflected by the attractive wastewater treatment performance. Compared with the tested four operational modes under the same hydraulic condition, the highest total nitrogen removal efficiency of 96.32% and COD removal efficiency of 92.37% were achieved, respectively, in 1st full siphon recirculation mode (FSR) and 2nd FSR operation mode. Indeed, the water level variation range played an important role in pollutants removal performance. Reduced water level variation of the TF in cathode chamber hindered excessive oxygen diffusion into MFC-CW and thus adversely affected the system performance. It is clear that the siphon is a wiser input to bring about the better treatment performance, but it is believed that the enhanced microbial activities behind the oxygen promotion is the driven force to exhibiting a better performance in the MFC-CW system.

Intensified constructed wetlands for the treatment of municipal wastewater: experimental investigation and kinetic modelling

This study reports organics and nutrient removal performances of the intensified constructed wetlands, i.e., tidal flow-based microbial fuel cell (MFC) and tidal flow wetlands that received municipal wastewater. The wetland systems were filled with organic (coco peat, biochar) or waste (Jhama brick, steel slag) materials, planted with Phragmites australis or Chrysopogon zizanioides (Vetiver) species, and operated under three flood periods: 8, 16, 24 h. Input ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N), total nitrogen (TN), phosphorus (P), chemical oxygen demand (COD), and biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) load across the wetland systems ranged between 3-27, 12-78, 0.1-23, 36-1130, and 11-281 g/m2day, respectively; mean removal percentages were 60-83, 74-84, 95-100, 94-98, and 93-97%, respectively, throughout the experimental run. The wetland systems achieved similar organics and P removals; operational and media variation did not influence removal kinetics. All wetland systems achieved the highest TN removal (76-87%) when subjected to 24-h flood period. TN removal performances of waste material-based wetlands were comparable to organic media-based systems. Tidal flow-based MFC wetlands achieved better TN removal than tidal flow wetlands because of supplementary electron production through fuel cell-based organics degradation kinetics. Maximum power production rates across the tidal flow-based MFC wetlands ranged between 53 and 57 mW/m2. Monod kinetics-based continuous stirred tank reactor (CSTR) models predicted NH3-N, TN, and COD removals (in wetland systems) more accurately. Kinetic models confirmed the influence of substrate (i.e., pollutant) and environmental parameters on pollutant removal routes.

Improving removal of antibiotics in constructed wetland treatment systems based on key design and operational parameters: A review

While removal of antibiotics in constructed wetland treatment systems (CWTS) has been described previously, few studies examined the synergistic effect of multiple design and operational parameters for improving antibiotic removal. This review describes the removal of 35 widely used antibiotics in CWTS covering the most common design parameters (flow configuration, substrate, plants) and operational parameters (hydraulic retention time/hydraulic loading rates, feeding mode, aeration, influent quality), and discusses how to tailor those parameters for improving antibiotic removal based on complex removal mechanisms. To achieve an overall efficient removal of antibiotics in CWTS, our principal component analysis indicated that optimization of flow configuration, selection of plant species, and compensation for low microbial activity at low temperature is the priority strategy. For instance, a hybrid-CWTS that integrates the advantages of horizontal and vertical subsurface flow CWTS may provide a sufficient removal performance at reasonable cost and footprint. To target removal of specific antibiotics, future research should focus on elucidating key mechanisms for their removal to guide optimization of the design and operational parameters. More efficient experimental designs (e.g., the Box-Behnken design) are recommended to determine the settings of the key parameters. These improvements would promote development of this environmentally friendly and cost-efficient technology for antibiotic removal.

Application of Alum Sludge in Wastewater Treatment Processes: “Science” of Reuse and Reclamation Pathways

Alum sludge (AlS) refers to the inevitable by-product generated during the drinking water purification process, where Al-salt is used as a coagulant in the water industry. It has long been treated as “waste”, while landfill is its major final disposal destination. In fact, AlS is an underutilized material with huge potential for beneficial reuse as a raw material in various wastewater treatment processes. In the last two decades, intensive studies have been conducted worldwide to explore the “science” and practical application of AlS. This paper focuses on the recent developments in the use of AlS that show its strong potential for reuse in wastewater treatment processes. In particular, the review covers the key “science” of the nature and mechanisms of AlS, revealing why AlS has the potential to be a value-added material. In addition, the future focus of research towards the widespread application of AlS as a raw material/product in commercial markets is suggested, which expands the scope for AlS research and development.

Influence of the flooded time on the performance of a tidal flow constructed wetland treating urban stream water

A vertical subsuperficial tidal flow constructed wetland (TFCW) operated under flooded time (FT) variation, was evaluated in the removal of carbonaceous, nitrogenous, and phosphorous matter from urban stream water. The TFCW downflow (117 L) was filled with bricks (44% porosity) and vegetated with Althernanthera philoxeroides (32 plants m^-2). The TFCW was operated under different flooded times - Stage A (48 h), B (36 h), C (24 h), and D (12 h), organic loading rates of 19.58-43.83 gCOD m^-2 d^-1, 3.68-6.94 gTN m^-2 d^-1 and 0.93-2.00 gTP m^-2 d^-1 and volumetric load rates of 46.8, 58.5, 78.0 and 11.7 L d^-1. No significant differences were observed in the removal efficiencies to Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD 66 to 94%), Total Ammonia Nitrogen (TAN 58 to 87%), and Total Nitrogen (TN 53 to 78%) among the stages, and nitrate concentrations lower than 6 mg L^-1 in the effluent. High Total Phosphorus removal was obtained in FT of 48 h (TP 79%). Total phosphorus loading rate was a limiting factor in TP removal, which reduced along with the reduction of FT. The nitrifying community was present over time since ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (Nitrosospira) and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (Nitrobacter and Nitrospira) were identified in operational stages with variation in relative abundance, but TAN removal efficiency did not show significant differences. There was no change in the denitrifying community structure, indicating that FT did not influence the TN removal. A. philoxeroides was responsible for phytoextraction of 2.1% of TN and 2.7% of TP from the total removed by TFCW. TN removal (65%) was attributed to adsorption in the filtering material and microbial metabolism during the rest time. The findings of this study suggest FT of 12 h to remove COD and TN, and equal to or higher than 48 h to remove TP.

Organics and nutrients removal in vertical flow wetlands: loading fluctuation and alternative media

Two wetland systems (conventional and structurally modified) were studied for the removal of organics and nutrients from municipal wastewater. Each system consisted of three vertical flow (VF) wetlands, which were filled with agricultural, construction waste materials and planted with Phragmites australis and Canna indica. The wetland units were operated under constant and consecutive shock hydraulic load (HL). Input nutrients and organics load across the wetland units ranged between 4.0-116.0 g N/m²d, 0.5-23.0 g P/m²d, 1.0-527.0 g biochemical oxygen demand (BOD)/m²d and 16.0-686.0 g chemical oxygen demand (COD)/m²d. Nitrification and organic carbon availability controlled nitrogen (N) removals in first and third stage VF wetlands, respectively, during constant load phase; organics removals were influenced by dissolved oxygen concentration of municipal wastewater. Second stage VF wetlands (of both systems) were inefficient in terms of COD removals during shock load periods, which were counter-balanced by first and third stages. First stage VF wetlands achieved higher N removal rates than following stages during shock load periods. Wetland maturation provided a buffer against substantial HL increment and sharp input load decrease in latter shock and recovery phases, respectively. Agricultural waste (sugarcane bagasse) provided carbon to support denitrification; construction materials (recycled brick and crushed mortar) removed phosphorus (P) from wastewater through adsorption. Coliform removal in VF wetlands was achieved through media filtration. Structurally modified system achieved higher removals than the conventional system. BOD, COD, total nitrogen and NH₄-N removal percentage across two systems ranged between 76-79%, 59-63%, 73-77% and 90-95%, respectively. In general, this study enlightens potential application of appropriate waste materials for wastewater treatment.

Effects of hydraulic loading rate and substrate on ammonium removal in tidal flow constructed wetlands treating black and odorous water bodies

The efficient removal of ammonium nitrogen (NH₄⁺-N) is vital to eliminating black and odorous water bodies. In this work, tidal flow constructed wetlands with gravel (TFCW-G) and with a mixture of zeolite and gravel (TFCW-Z) were set up to treat black and odorous water bodies at different hydraulic loading rates (HLRs). Results showed that zeolite significantly enhanced nitrogen removal, and the maximum NH₄⁺-N removal efficiency of 96.69% was achieved in TFCW-Z at HLR of 3 m·d^-1 with a flooding and drying cycle of 2 h. Zeolite addition changed the microbial community structure and the abundance of nitrification genes. Comammox Nitrospira was the only enriched strain accounting for NH₄⁺-N removal in TFCW-G, while the co-occurrence of comammox Nitrospira and the canonical and potential ammonia-oxidizing bacteria were identified in TFCW-Z. Summarily, high performance, together with low footprint and low maintenance cost, are characteristics that make the TFCW-Z a promising and competitive alternative.

An algal assisted constructed wetland-microbial fuel cell integrated with sand filter for efficient wastewater treatment and electricity production

In this study we report on a three-stage design of algal assisted constructed wetland -microbial fuel cell incorporated sand filter for efficient treatment of wastewater and bioelectricity generation, simulating a core of it. It aims for the complete removal of organic matter and other inorganic pollutants such as NO₃^-, NH₄⁺ and PO₄^3-. The conductive material equipped anode region of constructed wetland (CW) performed better for organic removal, and the system efficiently removed COD up to 96.37 ± 2.6%. The algal biomass passively aerated the cathode region and resulted in efficient removal of 85.14 ± 10.73% of NH₄⁺ and 69.03 ± 10.14% of PO₄^3-. The additional sand filter provided anaerobic situation favorable for removal of NO₃^- up to 68.41 ± 7.63%. The maximum power and current densities achieved in the system were 33.14 mW m^-3 and 235.0 mA m^-3, respectively.

Effect of different bypass rates and unit area ratio in hybrid constructed wetlands

This study presents the performance of a hybrid constructed wetland (Bp(VF + HF)_2:1) system which consists of an unsaturated vertical flow (VF) unit followed by a saturated down-flow unit simulating horizontal flow (HF) with HF/VF area ratio of 0.5 and influent bypass to the HF unit. Treating synthetic wastewater simulating municipal wastewater, optimum total nitrogen (TN) removal (57%) was reached at 39% bypass and surface loading rate (SLR) of 33 g BOD₅/m² day and 9.7 g TN/m² day (overall system). On the other hand, treating actual municipal wastewater, the system reached 63% TN removal at 30% bypass and SLR of 18 g BOD₅/m² day and 4.7 g TN/m² day. Surface removal rates reached 5.5 and 3.0 g TN/m² day for synthetic and municipal wastewater. Surface nitrification rate in the VF unit was in the range of 5.0-7.4 and 3.6-3.8 g N/m² day for synthetic and municipal wastewater, respectively, indicating a large effect of wastewater characteristics on the nitrification process. Infiltration rate in the VF unit remained high and far from clogging risk. Overall greenhouse gas emissions were 0.11 (N₂O) and 0.41 (CH₄) g/m² day which corresponded to emissions factors (relative to total organic carbon and TN influent) of 0.7% (N₂O) and 3.6% (CH₄). Compared with a similar system with a different HF/VF area ratio of 2.0, organic matter and nitrogen removal efficiency was similar, but surface removal rates were about 3 times higher.

Iron scraps enhance simultaneous nitrogen and phosphorus removal in subsurface flow constructed wetlands

In rural domestic wastewater treatment using subsurface constructed wetland system (SFCWs), the lack of a carbon source for denitrification and limited phosphorus uptake are responsible for low removal of nitrogen and phosphorus, and a suitable substrate is therefore, necessary. Iron is an important component in nitrogen and phosphorus biogeochemical cycles. Few studies have addressed the application of iron in SFCWs. Therefore, we constructed SFCWs that used iron scraps as a substrate. Enhanced nitrification, denitrification and removal of phosphorus were observed. The large proportion of nitrite-oxidising bacteria present in CWs with iron scraps (CW-T) compared to gravel beds indicated that iron may enhance ammonium (NH₄⁺) oxidation. More nitrate-reducing bacteria related to Fe and autotrophic denitrifying bacteria were discovered in the back zone of CW-T and these enhanced denitrification process. Phosphate (PO₄^3-) reacted with ferrous ion (Fe²⁺) and ferric ion (Fe³⁺) to generate the precipitant. Moreover, Fe³⁺ reacted with water to generate iron oxide (FeOOH) that had a large adsorption capacity for phosphorus. After six months of operation, average NH₄⁺-N, total nitrogen and total phosphorus removal rates were 66.98 ± 13.37 %, 71.26 ± 13.57 % and 93.54 ± 6.64 %, respectively. Iron scraps can potentially be utilised in SFCWs in rural domestic wastewater treatment.

Iron sulphides mediated autotrophic denitrification: An emerging bioprocess for nitrate pollution mitigation and sustainable wastewater treatment

Iron sulphides, mainly in the form of mackinawite (FeS), pyrrhotite (Fe_1-xS, x = 0-0.125) and pyrite (FeS₂), are the most abundant sulphide minerals and can be oxidized under anoxic and circumneutral pH conditions by chemoautotrophic denitrifying bacteria to reduce nitrate to N₂. Iron sulphides mediated autotrophic denitrification (ISAD) represents an important natural attenuation process of nitrate pollution and plays a pivotal role in linking nitrogen, sulphur and iron cycles in a variety of anoxic environments. Recently, it has emerged as a promising bioprocess for nutrient removal from various organic-deficient water and wastewater, due to its specific advantages including high denitrification capacity, simultaneous nitrogen and phosphorus removal, self-buffering properties, and fewer by-products generation (sulphate, waste sludge, N₂O, NH₄⁺, etc.). This paper provides a critical overview of fundamental and engineering aspects of ISAD, including the theoretical knowledge (biochemistry, and microbial diversity), its natural occurrence and engineering applications. Its potential and limitations are elucidated by summarizing the key influencing factors including availability of iron sulphides, low denitrification rates, sulphate emission and leaching heavy metals. This review also put forward two key questions in the mechanism of anoxic iron sulphides oxidation, i.e. dissolution of iron sulphides and direct substrates for denitrifiers. Finally, its prospects for future sustainable wastewater treatment are highlighted. An iron sulphides-based biotechnology towards next-generation wastewater treatment (NEO-GREEN) is proposed, which can potentially harness bioenergy in wastewater, incorporate resources (P and Fe) recovery, achieve simultaneous nutrient and emerging contaminants removal, and minimize waste sludge production.

Step-feeding ratios affect nitrogen removal and related microbial communities in multi-stage vertical flow constructed wetlands

Step-feeding (SF) strategies have been adopted in several types of constructed wetlands (CWs) to enhance nitrogen (N) removal. However, it is unclear how SF affects the N-transforming bacterial communities in CWs. Herein, four multi-stage vertical flow constructed wetlands (MS-VFCWs), each including three vertical flow stages (stage 1-3), were operated under different SF ratios (0%, 10%, 20% and 30%) in the stage 2. The physicochemical influent and effluent parameters, i.e., redox potential (ORP), pH value, chemical oxygen demand (COD), total nitrogen (TN), ammonia (NH₄⁺-N), nitrate (NO₃^--N), and nitrite (NO₂^--N), free-ammonia (FA) concentration, COD/TN ratio, as well as the abundance, structure, and activity of N-transforming bacteria were investigated. Results showed that N removal in a multi-stage vertical flow constructed wetland in the absence of SF was 45.0 ± 7.74%. Alternatively, a combined SF ratio of 20% increased N removal to 61.7% ± 4.50%, accounting for a 37.1% increase compared to the SF ratio of 0%. In the microbial community, FA was determined to be the primary physicochemical parameter governing nitrification processes in MS-VFCWs. Further, partial nitrification processes played an important role in ammonium removal during stage 1, while ammonia-oxidizing archaea were major contributors to ammonium removal in stage 3. Furthermore, abundance of nitrite reductase genes (nirS, nirK) and relative abundance of denitrifying bacteria increased with increasing SF ratio; while the nirS/nirK ratio and the alpha diversity of nirK denitrifiers were significantly affected by SF ratios, and the influent NO₃^--N concentration was related to a shift in denitrifier composition toward strains containing the nirS gene. Autotrophic (e.g., Thiobacillus, Sulfurimonas, Arenimonas, Gallionella and Methyloparacoccus) and facultative chemolithoautotrophic (e.g., Pseudomonas and Denitratisoma) denitrifying bacteria were enriched in stage 2. Hence, the synergy between heterotrophic and autotrophic denitrifying bacteria promoted excellent N removal efficiency with a low COD/TN ratio.

Roles of biochar media and oxygen supply strategies in treatment performance, greenhouse gas emissions, and bacterial community features of subsurface-flow constructed wetlands

Biochar-based subsurface-flow constructed wetlands (CWs) with intermittent aeration (IA) or tidal flow (TF) oxygen supply strategies were established to treat domestic wastewater. The results showed that biochar achieved higher nutrient removal and lower greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions than ceramsite while supporting more diverse bacterial communities and higher abundances of functional taxa. Both IA and TF effectively enhanced nutrient removal, though the latter was more efficient and practical, and aeration conditions greatly influenced nutrient removal efficiency. GHG emissions were decreased by IA but were slightly increased by TF. Both oxygen supply methods significantly shaped the biofilm microbial communities and influenced biodiversity and richness, with observably higher proportions of potential nitrifiers and denitrifiers present in aerated CWs. Overall, biochar-based CWs operated with oxygen supply strategies provide superior treatment of decentralized wastewater.

Removal of High-Strength Ammonia Nitrogen in Biofilters: Nitrifying Bacterial Community Compositions and Their Effects on Nitrogen Transformation

Increasing attention has been given to the treatment of livestock and poultry wastewater because of its high ammonium nitrogen (NH4+-N) content and low carbon/nitrogen ratio (C/N). Ceramic filter medium (CFM) and dewatered aluminum sludge (DAS), which are products from cast-off materials, are used as small-scale combined biological filters (CFM-DAS) for wastewater treatment. The high and stale removal efficiency of chemical oxygen demand (COD), NH4+-N, and total nitrogen (TN) in the DAS filter indicate that DAS plays a major role in pollutant removal. Although significant differences are found between the composition of nitrifying bacteria in CFM and DAS, the structures of nitrifying communities are evenly distributed in each layer of CFM or DAS irrespective of the running time. Microbial compositions are attributed to the comprehensive effect of various environmental factors such as pH and TN at effluents. In the DAS, Nitrosospira shows significant negative correlation with the concentrations of NH4+-N in effluents, whereas it has positive correlation with NO3−-N, and Nitrososphaera has a significant negative correlation with NO3−-N in effluents. Pearson correlation test reveals that certain genera may be used in estimating or predicting NH4+-N consumption and NO3−-N accumulation in CFM-DAS for treating sewage with a high NH4+-N content.

Double-layer substrate of shale ceramsite and active alumina tidal flow constructed wetland enhanced nitrogen removal from decentralized domestic sewage

This study explored the application of shale ceramsite (SC) overlaid onto active alumina (AA) to function as a double-layer substrate in tidal flow constructed wetland (TFCW, SC-AA-TFCW) for decentralized domestic sewage treatment. This was compared to AA or SC substrate alone (AA-TFCW or SC-TFCW) for nitrogen removal, variation of dissolved oxygen and porosity in TFCWs, as well as structure of bacterial communities at varied hydraulic load (HL) of 0.204-2.448 m³/m² d with time ratio of the wet and dry phase of 3:1. The results demonstrate that SC-AA-TFCW removed 86% NH₄⁺-N and 79% total nitrogen at HL of 0.612 m³/m² d, which was better than AA-TFCW(76%) or SC-TFCW(49%). The higher nitrogen removal performance in SC-AA-TFCW was mainly attributed to enhanced oxygen transportation due to non-uniform flow field and irregular gap distribution in layered structure, as well as less pore blockage during long-term operation. Denitrifying bacteria including Dechloromonas, Acidovorax, Chryseobacterium and Thermomonas species took up 32% of the microbiome in SC-AA-TFCW, which was higher than in AA-TFCW (17%) and SC-TFCW (7.7%). This study highlighted the importance of layered structures and determined an optimal HL of TFCW to achieve an efficient and stable nitrogen removal for domestic sewage treatment.

Advanced oxygenation efficiency and purification of wastewater using a constant partially unsaturated scheme in column experiments simulating vertical subsurface flow constructed wetlands

The presence of sufficient dissolved oxygen (DO) in a constructed wetland (CW) is vital to the process of removing ammonia nitrogen and organics from wastewater. To achieve total nitrogen removal, which is characterised by enhanced ammonia nitrogen removal, this study offers an efficient strategy to increase the oxygen supply by establishing constant unsaturated zones and baffles in simulating constructed wetlands (SCWs). Henceforth, this strategy is addressed as a partially unsaturated SCW. A centrally located high tube was set up inside the wetland to create an unsaturated zone at a higher level. The effectiveness of the unsaturated zone to supplement the oxygen content was evaluated by comparing with controls (an unaerated SCW and an aerated SCW). The results show the chemical oxygen demand removal rate (85 ± 6%) in the partially unsaturated SCW was equivalent to that in the aerated SCW (83 ± 6%), while the ammonia nitrogen removal rate was 11 times higher compared to that of the unaerated SCW. The removal potential of the partially unsaturated SCW under different HRT (hydraulic retention time)s (12, 24, and 36 h) was examined, and the 36 h-SCW performed the best in the removal of organics and nitrogen. The mechanisms behind the unsaturated zone strategy were studied by analysing water and microbe samples along the pathway. The results from the water quality indicators and the quantitative polymerase chain reactions along the pathway showed the unsaturated zone contributed to the removal of primary organics and ammonia nitrogen. The superior performance of unsaturated zone strategy was discussed further using the enrichment of ammonia-oxidising bacteria, mass of oxygen uptake, and baffle design. The results indicate that the amoA gene/16s rRNA gene abundance ratio and the oxygen uptake (336 ± 44 g m^-3 d^-1) in the partially unsaturated SCW was higher than that observed in the two controls.

Comparative study on pilots between ANAMMOX favored conditions in a partially saturated vertical flow constructed wetland and a hybrid system for rural wastewater treatment

The objective of this research was to evaluate the nitrogen removal in a single stage rural wastewater treatment system. It was a modified subsurface vertical flow (SSVF) constructed wetland. The so-called Anaerobic Ammonium Oxidation(ANAMMOX) process is favored by imposing a saturated zone at the bottom of the basin. The nitrogen removal performances of this modified SSVF were compared to those of a conventional hybrid system where the well-known nitrification-denitrification process is performed. This study was carried out using three lab-scale pilots of constructed wetlands during four months: (1) a hybrid constructed wetlands with a reed-Phragmites australis SSVF bed in serial with a cattail-Typha angustofolia SSHF bed (SSVF_p + SSHF). (2) A reed-Phragmites australis SSVF bed partially saturated at 40% of its depth (SSVF_PS); (3) A cattail-Typha angustofolia SSVF bed partially saturated at 40% of its depth (SSVF_TS). The results showed that the three configurations used in this study were efficient for most of the pollutants reduction. In fact, single-stage reactors have achieved similar chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal in comparison to the two-stage reactor independently of the macrophytes species. However, for Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen (TKN), a slightly higher nitrogen removal efficiency was recorded for (SSVF _p + SSHF) with an average removal rate of 53% versus 48% and 51% for SSVF _PS and SSVF_TS respectively. These findings were highlighted with fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis, which demonstrated the presence of major differences in the community composition and abundance of the bacteria involved with denitrification and nitrification in the three systems. In fact, SSVF_P of the hybrid system was characterized by highest relative abundance of nitrifying bacteria (13% Nitrosomonas, 11% Nitrosospira, 14% Nitrospira and 10% Nitrobacter). While, the SSHF of hybrid system had larger number of denitrifying species than SSVF, with relative abundances of pseudomonas (3%), Paracoccus (9%), Zoogloea (6%), Thauera (4%), Thiobacillus (2%) and Aeromonas (1%). Interestingly, in the SSVF_ST (planted with Thypha angustofolia) where the relative abundance of nitrifying bacteria was very low (4% Nitrosomonas, 4% Nitrosospira, 4% Nitrospira and 1% Nitrobacter), we have detected the presence of ANAMMOX bacteria (3%). Accordingly SSVF_ST in the presence of Thypha angustofolia have favored the development of ANAMMOX activity in comparison to the other configurations.

Effect of oxygen supply strategy on nitrogen removal of biochar-based vertical subsurface flow constructed wetland: Intermittent aeration and tidal flow

Insufficient dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration is recognized as one of the major factors limiting efficient nitrogen removal in constructed wetlands (CWs). This study investigated four biochar-based vertical subsurface flow constructed wetlands (VSFCWs) (system I: intermittent aeration without biochar addition; system II: intermittent aeration with biochar addition; system III: tidal flow without biochar addition; system IV: tidal flow with biochar addition) to compare the effect of oxygen supply strategies on the performance and mechanism of nitrogen removal. The results showed that NH₄⁺N removal efficiencies were 85.83%, 87.88%, 96.19%, and 98.30% for systems I-IV respectively. The abundance of microbes involved in nitrogen transformation also increased in all VSFCWs, particularly in the tidal flow mode with biochar addition. The higher oxygen utilization rate and higher surface area provided by biochar could significantly improve microbial abundance and then enhance nitrogen removal. Most notably, the rate of nitritation (2.92, 3.82, 3.14 and 4.27 mg N L^-1 h^-1) was higher than that of nitration (0.51, 0.66, 0.83 and 0.89 mg N L^-1 h^-1) in systems I-IV, respectively, and the percentages of NO₂^--N denitrified via simultaneous nitrification denitrification (SND) in systems I-IV were 58.20%, 55.10%, 50.89% and 51.89%, respectively. Therefore, in addition to conventional nitrification denitrification, partial nitrification and SND via NO₂^--N were also the significant nitrogen transformation pathways in the four VSFCWs at high DO concentrations (2.43-6.84 mg L^-1). These results demonstrated that the tidal flow biochar-based VSFCWs performed well in nitrogen removal due to efficient oxygen supplementation and enhanced microbial community abundance.

Treatment of heavily polluted river water by tidal-operated biofilters with organic/inorganic media: Evaluation of performance and bacterial community

In this study, biofilters (BFs) packed with inorganic (ceramsite and lava rock) and organic (fibrous carrier and biological ball) materials were applied in a tide-flow mode at three flooded/drained (F/D) time ratios (16/8 h, 12/12 h and 8/16 h) to treat heavily polluted river water. The results showed that higher ammonium and phosphorus removals were achieved with BFs filled with ceramsite (95-97% and 76-77%) and lava rock (87-92% and 84-94%), while fibrous carrier-packed BFs obtained better total nitrogen removal (37-44%). Moreover, the F/D time ratio of 16/8 h was slightly preferable for pollutant removal. High-throughput sequencing analysis illustrated that the relative abundance of potential denitrifiers that developed on organic media was much higher than those on inorganic substrates. The results indicated that the combination of inorganic materials and fibrous carriers as substrates could be an effective strategy for enhancing overall pollutant removal in BFs.

Nitrogen removal of anaerobically digested swine wastewater by pilot-scale tidal flow constructed wetland based on in-situ biological regeneration of zeolite

Dispersed swine wastewater has increasingly aggravated water pollution in China. Anaerobically digested dispersed swine wastewater was targeted and treated by a pilot-scale zoning tidal flow constructed wetland (TFCW) with a bottom wastewater saturation layer. The long-term application of in-situ biological regeneration of biozeolite, nitrogen removal performance, nitrogen removal pathways and microbial community of TFCW were investigated. Results showed that with the surface loads of 0.079, 0.022 and 0.024 kg/(m²·d), TFCW could decrease COD, NH₄N and TN by 84.75%, 74.13% and 67.13% respectively. Influent COD, NH₄N, TN and nitrates/nitrites produced by bioregeneration of NH₄N were mostly removed in zeolite layer and the remaining nitrates/nitrites could be further denitrified in bottom saturation layer. Theory of dynamic process of rapid-adsorption and bioregeneration for NH₄N removal was proposed. When this process reached dynamic equilibrium, the mass of adsorbed NH₄N onto zeolites remained relatively stable. When ambient temperature decreased to 16 °C, TFCW could still remove COD, NH₄N and TN by 73.79%, 72.99% and 70.71% with the surface loads of 0.103, 0.056 and 0.054 kg/(m²·d) respectively. Nitrification-denitrification which accounted for 80.32% of TN removal was the main nitrogen removal pathway. Dominant nitrifiers (Nitrosospira and Rhizomicrobium) and denitrifiers (Ottowia, Thauera and Rhodanobacteria) in biozeolite layer verified the existence of simultaneous nitrification and denitrification.

The use of biochar and crushed mortar in treatment wetlands to enhance the removal of nutrients from sewage

An experimental study was carried out using in pilot-scale constructed wetland systems, operated in parallel to treat raw sewage. Each system consisted of a vertical flow (VF) unit that was filled with biochar as the main media, followed by a horizontal flow (HF) unit filled with crushed cement mortar. Hydraulic loading (HL) ranged 340-680 mm/day was applied on the VF wetland units, where high total nitrogen (TN) mass removal rate (20-23 g N/m² d) was obtained, demonstrating that biochar media had a beneficial effect on the degradation of nitrogenous pollutants. Total phosphorus (TP) removal percentage (concentration based) was ≥ 86% in HF wetlands packed with mortar materials. In one system, the flow direction of the sewage was directed by the deployment of downflow pipes and vertical baffles, aiming to facilitate the formation of aerobic and anaerobic zones in the wetland matrices. The effects of such arrangement were analyzed by comparing pollutant removal efficiencies in the two systems. On average, 99, 96, 93, and 86 percentage removals were obtained for ammonia (NH₄-N), TN, biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), and TP, respectively, during the experiments. Biochar and crushed mortar proved to be a highly effective combination as media in subsurface flow constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment.

Influence of saturated zone depth and vegetation on the performance of vertical flow-constructed wetland with continuous feeding

The object of this study was to investigate the effect of saturated zone depth (SZD) and plant on the removal of organics and nitrogen in four continuous-feed vertical flow-constructed wetlands (VFCWs). Three VFCWs were planted with Iris pseudacorus and operated at different SZDs (19, 51, and 84 cm), and the other one was non-planted and operated at 51 cm SZD. The VFCWs were operated with an organic loading rate (OLR) of 79 g chemical oxygen demand (COD) m^-2 day^-1, a total nitrogen loading rate (NLR) of 11 g N m^-2 day^-1, and a hydraulic loading rate (HLR) of 0.35 m³ m^-2 day^-1. Simultaneous transformation of ammonium and nitrate occurred in all of the four systems. In the planted bed with 51 cm SZD, suitable conditions for nitrification and denitrification could be created and the best performance for total nitrogen (TN) removal was realized via simultaneous nitrification and denitrification (SND), achieving TN removal efficiency of 67.4-80.3%. Higher ammonium nitrogen (NH₄⁺-N) and COD removal efficiency was obtained in the system operated with 19 cm SZD, whereas higher NO₃^--N removal could be achieved in the bed with 84 cm SZD. With the same SZD of 51 cm, the planted VFCW performed preferable removal of COD, NH₄⁺-N, and TN in comparison with the non-planted one. All the VFCWs showed high removal efficiencies for total phosphorus (> 60.15%). Adsorption of phosphorus was primarily observed in the top and upper-middle layers filled with carbon burn slag. It has been proved that the partially saturated VFCW operated with continuous feed could achieve good performance in removal of organic matter and nitrogen by SZD adjustment to develop appropriate aerobic and anoxic regions.

Effects of partially saturated conditions on the metabolically active microbiome and on nitrogen removal in vertical subsurface flow constructed wetlands

Nitrogen dynamics and its association to metabolically active microbial populations were assessed in two vertical subsurface vertical flow (VF) wetlands treating urban wastewater. These VF wetlands were operated in parallel with unsaturated (UVF) and partially saturated (SVF) configurations. The SVF wetland exhibited almost 2-fold higher total nitrogen removal rate (5 g TN m^-2 d^-1) in relation to the UVF wetland (3 g TN m^-2 d^-1), as well as a low NO_x-N accumulation (1 mg L^-1 vs. 26 mg L^-1 in SVF and UVF wetland effluents, respectively). After 6 months of operation, ammonia oxidizing prokaryotes (AOP) and nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) displayed an important role in both wetlands. Oxygen availability and ammonia limiting conditions promoted shifts on the metabolically active nitrifying community within 'nitrification aggregates' of wetland biofilms. Ammonia oxidizing archaea (AOA) and Nitrospira spp. overcame ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) in the oxic layers of both wetlands. Microbial quantitative and diversity assessments revealed a positive correlation between Nitrobacter and AOA, whereas Nitrospira resulted negatively correlated with Nitrobacter and AOB populations. The denitrifying gene expression was enhanced mainly in the bottom layer of the SVF wetland, in concomitance with the depletion of NO_x-N from wastewater. Functional gene expression of nitrifying and denitrifying populations combined with the active microbiome diversity brought new insights on the microbial nitrogen-cycling occurring within VF wetland biofilms under different operational conditions.

Achieving an extraordinary high organic and hydraulic loadings with good performance via an alternative operation strategy in a multi-stage constructed wetland system

In this study, a high organic loading rate of 58-146 g BOD₅/m² day with a hydraulic loading rate (HLR) of 1.63 m³/m² day and retention time (RT) of 16 h was achieved to maximize the treatment capacity of a four-stage alum sludge-based constructed wetland (CW) system. An alternative operation strategy, i.e., the first stage anaerobic up-flow and the remaining stage tidal flow with effluent recirculation, was investigated to achieve the goal with good treatment performance of 82% COD, 91% BOD₅, 92% SS, 94% NH₄-N, and 82% TN removal. Two kinetic models, i.e., first-order model and Monod plus continuous stirred-tank reactor (CSTR) flow model, were employed for predicting the removal dynamics. The results showed that the tidal flow strategy enhances oxygen transport and diffusion, thus improving reduction of organics and NH₄-N. Effluent recirculation could further increase elimination of organics by extending the interaction time and also benefit the denitrification process. In addition, denitrification could be further enhanced by anaerobic up-flow in the first stage.

The effects of different aeration strategies on the performance of constructed wetlands for phosphorus removal

The effects of different aeration methods such as tidal flow (TF), effluent recirculation (ER), and artificial aeration (AA) on the performance of vertical-flow constructed wetland (VFCW), horizontal-flow constructed wetland (HFCW), and hybrid constructed wetland (HCW) are extensively and critically evaluated in this review paper. Aerated constructed wetlands (CWs) demonstrate superior performance compared with non-aerated systems. The removal of total phosphorus (TP) showed substantial variation among different types of CWs and aeration strategies, with mean and standard deviation of 68 ± 20% estimated from all reviewed studies on aerated systems. The TF-VFCW designated the highest removal efficiency and removal rate of 88 ± 6% and 2.6 ± 2.5 g m^-2 day^-1, respectively, followed by the ER-HCW with values of 79 ± 18% and 1.3 ± 0.7 g m^-2 day^-1, respectively. The superior performance of TF-VFCW could be attributed to a positive effect of TF in rejuvenating the wetland with fresh air, thus enhancing dissolved oxygen (DO) in the system, and augmenting phosphorus precipitation and adsorption to the substrate. A positive correlation of TP and orthophosphate (PO₄^3--P) with DO indicates that the improvement in DO levels due to redox manipulation with aeration strategies facilitates the phosphorous removal processes (e.g., through precipitation and adsorption to the substrate). The conflicting results on the impact of AA and ER reported by many studies need the cautious interpretation of their impact and require further studies. Only few studies have examined the impact of oxidation-reduction potential on phosphorous removal, which requires more attention in future research, as it appears as an important factor in enhancing the phosphorus removal.

Existing forms and changes of nitrogen inside of horizontal subsurface constructed wetlands

Horizontal zeolite subsurface constructed wetland system (HZCWs) and horizontal limestone subsurface constructed wetland system (HLCWs) were applied to the removal of nitrogen in lightly polluted wastewater, and the existing forms, changes, and removal mechanism of nitrogen in the constructed wetlands were analyzed. The results indicated that compared with HLCWs, HZCWs exhibited better nitrogen removal effect, and the maximum removal rates of ammonia nitrogen and total nitrogen could reach 96.97 ± 5.29 and 93.12 ± 3.35%, respectively. Besides, analysis of the removal effect on nitrogen in different existing forms on different substrate heights in the constructed wetlands showed that variation of nitrogen removal efficiency had certain regularities, which were related to the interior construction features of the wetland systems, and agreed with the regularities in the changes of the influential factors such as DO inside of the wetlands. In addition, degradation mechanism of pollutions was also analyzed, and the results indicated that the quantity of microorganisms and enzymes, including FDA, catalase, and urease, on the surface of the substrates had significant influence on the removal regularities and effects of the major pollutions in constructed wetlands.

Effect of step-feeding on the performance of lab-scale columns simulating vertical flow-horizontal flow constructed wetlands

The effect of step-feeding (untreated wastewater by-pass) on the performance of lab-scale columns simulating a hybrid vertical flow (VF)-horizontal flow (HF) constructed wetland (CW) system was studied. Step-feeding strategies have been adopted in several kinds of CW, but this is the first report about the use of step-feeding in VF + HF hybrid systems treating domestic wastewater. Applied loading rates were 7-11 g BOD₅/m² day and 2.1-3.4 g TN/m² day (overall system). Removal efficiency reached 98% TSS and COD and 99% BOD₅ on average, whilst a 50% by-pass improved TN removal from 31 to 50%. Maximum surface nitrification rate (5.5 g N/m² day) was obtained in VF unit, whilst maximum denitrification rate (1.8 g N/m² day) was observed in HF unit. Referred to the overall system, maximum surface nitrification and denitrification rates were 2.2 and 1.6 g N/m² day, respectively. However, potential nitrifying and denitrifying activities (batch assays) were 15.0 and 58.9 g N/m² day, respectively. Even at 50% by-pass, operational conditions in HF unit (dissolved oxygen, redox, COD/TN ratio) were not suitable enough for denitrification. However, methane emissions were not observed and nitrous oxide emissions were relatively low.

Treatment of anaerobic digested effluent in biochar-packed vertical flow constructed wetland columns: Role of media and tidal operation

Three types of vertical flow constructed wetland columns (VFCWs), packed with corn cob biochar (CB-CW), wood biochar (WB-CW) and gravel (G-CW) under tidal flow operations, were comparatively evaluated to investigate anaerobic digested effluent treatment performance and mechanisms. It was demonstrated that CB-CW and WB-CW provide significantly higher removal efficiencies for organic matter (>59%), NH₄⁺-N (>76%), TN (>37%) and phosphorus (>71%), compared with G-CW (22%-49%). The higher pollutants removal ability of biochar-packed VFCWs was mainly attribute to the higher adsorption ability and microbial cultivation in the porous biochar media. Moreover, increasing the flooded/drained ratio from 4/8h to 8/4h of the tidal operation further improved around 10% of the removal of both organics and NH₄⁺-N for biochar-packed VFCWs. The phosphorus removal was dependent on the media adsorption capacities through the whole experiment. However, the NH₄⁺-N biodegradation by microbial communities was demonstrated to become the dominant removal mechanism in the long term treatment, which compensated the decreased adsorption capacities of the media. The study supported that the use of biochar would increase the treatment performance and elongate the lifespan of CWs under tidal operation.

The performance of the intensified constructed wetlands for organic matter and nitrogen removal: A review

The effects of different aeration strategies including tidal flow (TF), effluent recirculation (ER) and artificial aeration (AA) on performance of vertical flow constructed wetland (VFCW), horizontal flow constructed wetland (HFCW) and hybrid constructed wetland (HCW) are comprehensively and critically reviewed in this paper. The removal efficiencies of nine types of intensified constructed wetlands (CWs) were examined in detail and their mean and standard deviation were estimated at 89 ± 11%, 84 ± 12%, 81 ± 17% and 63 ± 20% for total suspended solids (TSS), chemical oxygen demand (COD), ammonium-nitrogen (NH₄⁺N) and total nitrogen (TN), respectively. From the studied CWs, ER-HCW, TF-HCW, AA-VFCW and ER-VFCW emerged as the four best performing systems. The overall removal efficiency of TSS, COD, NH₄⁺N and TN by ER-HCW was 98 ± 2%, 85 ± 11%, 83 ± 15% and 73 ± 11%, respectively. Specifically, the ER enhances the interactions between pollutants and micro-organisms, consequently, the efficient removal of NH₄⁺N and TN has been achieved in ER-HCW. The TF has a positive effect in refreshing the wetland with fresh air to enhance the dissolved oxygen (DO) in the system. In case of AA, intermittent aeration is more effective than continuous aeration, as it facilitates the establishment of aerobic and anaerobic conditions suitable for nitrification and denitrification. Statistical analysis shows that DO, organic loading rate and specific surface area requirement are the most significant factors that influence the performance of intensified CWs.

Intensification of constructed wetlands for land area reduction: a review

The large land area requirement of constructed wetlands (CWs) is a major limitation of its application especially in densely populated and mountainous areas. This review paper provides insights on different strategies applied for the reduction of land area including stack design and intensification of CWs with different aeration methods. The impacts of different aeration methods on the performance and land area reduction were extensively and critically evaluated for nine wetland systems under three aeration strategies such as tidal flow (TF), effluent recirculation (ER), and artificial aeration (AA) applied on three types of CWs including vertical flow constructed wetland (VFCW), horizontal flow constructed wetland (HFCW), and hybrid constructed wetland (HCW). The area reduction and pollutant removal efficiency showed substantial variation among different types of CWs and aeration strategies. The ER-VFCW designated the smallest footprint of 1.1 ± 0.5 m² PE^-1 (population equivalent) followed by TF-VFCW with the footprint of 2.1 ± 1.8 m² PE^-1, and the large footprint was of AA-HFCW (7.8 ± 4.7 m² PE^-1). When footprint and removal efficiency both are the major indicators for the selection of wetland type, the best options for practical application could be TF-VFCW, ER-HCW, and AA-HCW. The data and results outlined in this review could be instructive for futures studies and practical applications of CWs for wastewater treatment, especially in land-limited regions.

Integrating pretreatment and denitrification in constructed wetland systems

The aim of this work was to study the operational characteristics and the efficiency of a compact constructed wetland system for municipal wastewater treatment that integrates denitrification in the pre-treatment unit. The proposed system was simulated by two units in series with effluent recirculation, the first one being an anoxic digester, conceived as a hydrolytic up flow sludge bed for solids hydrolysis and denitrification, and the second one a sand column that simulated the operation of a vertical flow constructed wetland. The hybrid system consisted of two small columns of 4 and 10.2cm in diameter (anoxic digester and vertical flow unit, respectively). The unplanted system was operated successively with synthetic and real municipal wastewater over a period of 136days. Hydraulic loading rate ranged from 212 to 318mm/day and surface loading rate from 122 to 145g/m²·day of chemical oxygen demand and 10-15g/m²·day of total nitrogen for the overall system. The overall system reached removals of 91% to 99% for total suspended solids, chemical oxygen demand and biochemical oxygen demand whilst total nitrogen removal ranged from 43% to 61%. In addition to suspended solids removal (up to 78%), the anoxic digester provided high denitrification rates (3-12gN/m²·day) whilst the vertical flow unit provided high nitrification rates (8-15gN/m²·day). Organic matter was mainly removed in the anoxic digester (63-82% chemical oxygen demand) and used for denitrification. Final effluent concentration was lower for ammonia (7.4±2.4mgN/L on average) than for nitrate (19.8±4.4mgN/L), denitrification appearing as the limiting step in nitrogen removal in the system. CH₄ or N₂O emissions were not detected in any of the units of the system indicating very low greenhouse gas emissions.

Removal of organic matter, nitrogen and faecal indicators from diluted anaerobically digested slurry using tidal flow constructed wetlands

The rapid implementation of anaerobic digestion for renewable energy production has resulted in increased generation of anaerobically digested slurry, which contains a variety of pollutants and therefore has the potential to cause serious environmental problems. Tidal flow constructed wetlands, which could generate beneficial oxygen conditions, were investigated for their success in removing nitrogen, organic matter and pathogens in anaerobically digested slurry. The results indicated that tidal operation had a positive effect on promoting NH₄⁺-N and organic matter (chemical oxygen demand (COD)) removal. With an average influent NH₄⁺-N concentration of 288 mg/L and COD concentration of 839 mg/L, the average removal efficiency reached up to 93% (325 g/m² day) for NH₄⁺-N and 53% (603 g/m² day) for COD, with total inorganic nitrogen (TIN) removal efficiency of 51% (226 g/m² day). The nitrogen removal in the tidal-operated CWs is highly dependent on the flooded and drained (F/D) time ratio. Changing flooded time from 3 to 5 h enhanced denitrification (nitrite reductase-K (nirK) abundance) and further resulted in improved TIN removal efficiency of 62% (237 g/m² day). The removal of faecal indicators was also examined, with reduction rate of approximately 0.9 log₁₀ CFU/100 mL for both Escherichia coli and total coliforms, which was independent of the influent loadings and differing flooded/drained time ratio. Tidal flow CWs were demonstrated to have the high potential to treat diluted anaerobically digested slurry.

Nitrogen transforming bacteria within a full-scale partially saturated vertical subsurface flow constructed wetland treating urban wastewater

The aim of this study was to characterize the nitrogen transforming bacterial communities within a partially saturated vertical subsurface flow constructed wetland (VF) treating urban wastewater in southern Brazil. The VF had a surface area of 3144m², and was divided into four wetland cells, out of which two were operated while the other two rested, alternating cycles of 30days. The nitrifying and denitrifying bacterial communities were characterized in wetland cell 3 (764m² surface area) over a period of 12months by using the FISH technique. Samples were collected monthly (from Feb 2014 to Feb 2015) from different layers within the vertical profile, during operation and rest periods, comprising a total of 6 sampling campaigns while the cell was in operation and another 6 when the cell was at rest. This wetland cell operated with an average organic loading rate (OLR) of 4gCODm^-2d^-1 and a hydraulic loading rate of 24.5mmd^-1. The rest periods of the wetland cell presented influences on the abundance of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) (8% and 3% for feed and rest periods, respectively), and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) (5% and 2% for feed and rest periods, respectively). However, there was no influence of the rest periods on the denitrifying bacteria. AOB were only identified in the top layer (AOB β-proteobacteria) in both operational and rest periods. On the other hand, the NOB (Nistrospirae and Nitrospina gracilis) were identified in feed periods just in the top layer and during rest periods just in the intermediate layer. The denitrifying bacteria (Pseudomonas spp. and Thiobacillus denitrificans) were identified from the intermediate layer downwards, and remained stable in both periods. Based on the identified bacterial dynamics, the partially saturated VF wetland operated under low OLR enabled favorable conditions for simultaneous nitrification and denitrification.

Nitrogen dynamics of the aquatic system is an important driving force for efficient sewage purification in single pond natural treatment wetlands at East Kolkata Wetland

At East Kolkata Wetlands, though the domestic city sewage is purified very rapidly, the mechanisms of treatment remains inadequately explored. In this context, the present study investigated nitrogen dynamics of the single pond treatment systems during purification and explored its potential role in sewage treatment. For this purpose the concentrations of different forms of nitrogen present both in water and soil at different time points of purification were measured. The organic nitrogen content decreased sharply, in the early phase, with an increase in ammonium concentration. Notably the reduction in organic nitrogen was significantly higher than the increase in NH₄⁺ which can be attributed to the volatilization of NH₄⁺ under alkaline pH. This volatilization results in reduced oxygen demand. The nitrate-N concentration decreased sharply from soil with a concomitant increase in water column. However the reduction of nitrate in soil was significantly higher than the increase in water column. It indicated the occurrence of denitrification under anoxic condition wherein nitrate serves as terminal electron acceptor. Additionally a part of the nitrate supported planktonic growth. Thus it describes another mechanism of reducing oxygen demand. The initial NH₄⁺-N concentration in the soil was very low and it increased gradually during purification due to increasing soil cation exchange capacity. Thus by trapping NH₄⁺ ion soil contributes towards preventing contamination of water. Thus at EKW, the cumulative activities in water and soil involved in nitrogen dynamics lead to overall reduction of the oxygen demand and contribute towards efficient sewage purification.

Nitrate removal and bioenergy production in constructed wetland coupled with microbial fuel cell: Establishment of electrochemically active bacteria community on anode

The constructed wetland coupled with microbial fuel cell (CW-MFC) systems operated at different substrate concentration and pH influents were evaluated for bioelectricity generation, contaminant removal and microbial community structure. Performance of CW-MFC was evaluated at organic loading rate of 75.3gCODm^-3d^-1 and pH gradients of (5.18±0.14, 7.31±0.13, and 8.75±0.12) using carbon fiber felt as electrodes. Peak power density was observed at slightly neutral influent condition. Compared with the open circuit CW-MFC, average COD and NO₃-N removal efficiency in CW-MFC increased by 8.3% and 40.2% respectively under slightly neutral pH of influents. However, the removal efficiency and bioenergy production have been inhibited with acidic influents. The relative abundance of beta-Proteobacteria, nitrobacteria and denitrifying bacteria was significantly promoted in closed-circuit CW-MFC. Using of CW-MFC as a biochemical method for nitrate removal and bioelectricity generation under slightly neutral and alkaline influent conditions was a promising technology.