Integrative response of arsenic uptake, speciation and detoxification by Salix atrocinerea

Valorization of steelmaking slag and coal fly ash as amendments in combination with Betula pubescens for the remediation of a highly As- and Hg-polluted mining soil

Soil pollution by As and Hg is a pressing environmental issue given their persistence. The intricate removal processes and subsequent accumulation of these elements in soil adversely impact plant growth and pose risks to other organisms in the food chain and to underground aquifers. Here we assessed the effectiveness of non-toxic industrial byproducts, namely coal fly ash and steelmaking slag, as soil amendments, both independently and in conjunction with an organic fertilizer. This approach was coupled with a phytoremediation technique involving Betula pubescens to tackle soil highly contaminated. Greenhouse experiments were conducted to evaluate amendments' impact on the growth, physiology, and biochemistry of the plant. Additionally, a permeable barrier made of byproducts was placed beneath the soil to treat leachates. The application of the byproducts reduced pollutant availability, the production of contaminated leachates, and pollutant accumulation in plants, thereby promoting plant development and survival. Conversely, the addition of the fertilizer alone led to an increase in As accumulation in plants and induced the production of antioxidant compounds such as carotenoids and free proline. Notably, all amendments led to increased thiolic compound production without affecting chlorophyll synthesis. While fertilizer application significantly decreased parameters associated with oxidative stress, such as hydrogen peroxide and malondialdehyde, no substantial reduction was observed after byproduct application. Thermal desorption analysis of the byproducts revealed Hg immobilization mechanisms, thereby indicating retention of this metalloid in the form of Hg chloride. In summary, the revalorization of industrial byproducts in the context of the circular economy holds promise for effectively immobilizing metal(loid)s in heavily polluted soils. Additionally, this approach can be enhanced through synergies with phytoremediation.

Molecular level toxicity effects of As(V) on Folsomia candida: Integrated transcriptomics and metabolomics analyses

Arsenic (As) is a widespread metalloid with well-known toxicity. To date, numerous studies have focused on individual level toxicity (e.g., growth and reproduction) of As to typical invertebrate springtails in soils, however, the molecular level toxicity and mechanism was poorly understood. Here, an integrated transcriptomics and metabolomics approach was used to reveal responses of Folsomia candida exposed to As(V) of 10 and 60 mg kg-1 at which the individual level endpoints were influenced. Transcriptomics identified 5349 and 4020 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in low and high concentration groups, respectively, and the most DEGs were down-regulated. Enrichment analysis showed that low and high concentrations of As(V) significantly inhibited chromatin/chromosome-related biological processes (chromatin/chromosome organization, nucleosome assembly and organization, etc.) in springtails. At high concentration treatment, structural constituent of cuticle, chitin metabolic process and peptidase activity (serine-type peptidase activity, endopeptidase activity, etc.) were inhibited or disturbed. Moreover, the apoptosis pathway was significantly induced. Metabolomics analysis identified 271 differential changed metabolites (DCMs) in springtails exposed to high concentration of As. Steroid hormone biosynthesis was the most significantly affected pathway. Several DCMs that related to chitin metabolism could further support above transcriptomic results. These findings further extended the knowledge of As toxic mechanisms to soil fauna and offer important information for the environmental risk assessment.

Physiological response of adult Salix aurita in wetland vegetation affected by flooding with As-rich fine pyrite particles

An uncontrolled, natural episode of flooding with waters contaminated with As-rich pyrite (FeAsS) particles caused serious ecological damage leading to necrosis of plants growing in a fresh wet meadow located in an area characterized by unique geological structures rich in arsenopyrites. One of the few plant species capable of surviving this event was Salix aurita L., which grew in numbers in the analyzed area, but individual plants were affected differently by toxic flooding. No significant phenotypic changes (Group I), through partial leaf and/or stem necrosis (Group II) up to necrosis of the whole parental plant and root suckers (Group III), were observed for various willow clumps. These varied phenotypic responses of S. aurita to As-rich sediments were compared with the biochemical status of the foliage of willow trees, and with their rhizosphere physiological parameters. Our in situ study revealed that the biochemical status of leaves reflects the phenotypic damage incurred by adult willows growing in their natural environment and affected by the flooding. In leaves of willows with increasingly negative phenotypic changes (Groups I → II → III) as well as increasing levels of reactive oxygen species, malondialdehyde and decreased levels of glutathione and thiol groups were detected. Phytochelatins, commonly considered major As chelators, were not detected in S. aurita leaves. Despite a decrease in the size of leaves with the intensity of tree damage, all leaves expressed a normal level of leaf pigments. Phenotypic changes observed for particular willow clumps were only partly related to soil As levels. Moreover, As and S (but not Fe) foliar levels were related but did not correspond strictly with foliar biochemical features, or with soil As levels, soil pH or soil microbial activity, with the latter two drastically decreased in the rhizospheres of willows from Groups II and III.

Phytochelatins: Sulfur-Containing Metal(loid)-Chelating Ligands in Plants

Phytochelatins (PCs) are small cysteine-rich peptides capable of binding metal(loid)s via SH-groups. Although the biosynthesis of PCs can be induced in vivo by various metal(loid)s, PCs are mainly involved in the detoxification of cadmium and arsenic (III), as well as mercury, zinc, lead, and copper ions, which have high affinities for S-containing ligands. The present review provides a comprehensive account of the recent data on PC biosynthesis, structure, and role in metal(loid) transport and sequestration in the vacuoles of plant cells. A comparative analysis of PC accumulation in hyperaccumulator plants, which accumulate metal(loid)s in their shoots, and in the excluders, which accumulate metal(loid)s in their roots, investigates the question of whether the endogenous PC concentration determines a plant's tolerance to metal(loid)s. Summarizing the available data, it can be concluded that PCs are not involved in metal(loid) hyperaccumulation machinery, though they play a key role in metal(loid) homeostasis. Unraveling the physiological role of metal(loid)-binding ligands is a fundamental problem of modern molecular biology, plant physiology, ionomics, and toxicology, and is important for the development of technologies used in phytoremediation, biofortification, and phytomining.

Recent advancements in toxicology, modern technology for detection, and remedial measures for arsenic exposure: review

Arsenic toxicity has become a major global health concern for humans and animals due to extensive environmental and occupational exposure to arsenic-contaminated water, air, soil, and plant and animal origin food. It has a wide range of detrimental effects on animals, humans, and the environment. As a result, various experimental and clinical studies were undertaken and are undergoing to understand its source of exposures, pathogenesis, identify key biomarkers, the medical and economic impact on affected populations and ecosystems, and their timely detection and control measures. Despite these extensive studies, no conclusive information for the prevention and control of arsenic toxicity is available, owing to complex epidemiology and pathogenesis, including an imprecise approach and repetitive work. As a result, there is a need for literature that focuses on recent studies on the epidemiology, pathogenesis, detection, and ameliorative measures of arsenic toxicity to assist researchers and policymakers in the practical future planning of research and community control programs. According to the preceding viewpoint, this review article provides an extensive analysis of the recent progress on arsenic exposure to humans through the environment, livestock, and fish, arsenic toxicopathology, nano-biotechnology-based detection, and current remedial measures for the benefit of researchers, academicians, and policymakers in controlling arsenic eco-toxicology and directing future research. Arsenic epidemiology should therefore place the greatest emphasis on the prevalence of different direct and indirect sources in the afflicted areas, followed by control strategies.

Antimony speciation, phytochelatin stimulation and toxicity in plants

Antimony (Sb) is a toxic metalloid that has been listed as a priority pollutant. The environmental impacts of Sb have recently attracted attention, but its phytotoxicity and biological transformation remain poorly understood. In this study, Sb speciation and transformation in plant roots was quantified by Sb K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy. In addition, the phytotoxicity of antimonate (Sb^V) on six plant species was assessed by measuring plant photosynthesis, growth, and phytochelatin production induced by Sb^V. Linear combination fitting of the Sb K-edge X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES) spectra indicated reduction of Sb^V was limited to ∼5-33% of Sb. The data confirmed that Sb-polygalacturonic acid was the predominant chemical form in all plant species (up to 95%), indicating Sb was primarily bound to the cell walls of plant roots. Shell fitting of Sb K-edge X-ray absorption fine-structure (EXAFS) spectra confirmed Sb-O and Sb-C were the dominant scattering paths. The fitting indicated that Sb^V was bound to hydroxyl functional groups of cell walls, via development of a local coordination environment analogous to Sb-polygalacturonic acid. This is the first study to demonstrate the key role of plant cell walls in Sb metabolism.

Bacterial inoculant-assisted phytoremediation affects trace element uptake and metabolite content in Salix atrocinerea

Natural plant-associated microorganisms are of critical importance to plant growth and survival in field conditions under toxic concentrations of trace elements (TE) and these plant-microbial processes can be harnessed to enhance phytoremediation. The total bacterial diversity from grey willow (Salix atrocinerea) on a brownfield heavily-polluted with lead (Pb) and arsenic (As) was studied through pyrosequencing. Culturable bacteria were isolated and in vitro tested for plant growth-promotion (PGP) traits, arsenic (As) tolerance and impact on As speciation. Two of the most promising bacterial strains - the root endophyte Pantoea sp. AV62 and the rhizospheric strain Rhodococcus erythropolis AV96 - were inoculated in field to S. atrocinerea. This bioaugmentation resulted in higher As and Pb concentrations in both, roots and leaves of bacterial-inoculated plants as compared to non-inoculated plants. In consequence, bacterial bioaugmentation also affected parameters related to plant growth, oxidative stress, the levels of phytochelatins and phenylpropanoids, together with the differential expression of genes related to these tolerance mechanisms to TE in leaves. This study extends our understanding about plant-bacterial interactions and provides a solid basis for further bioaugmentation studies aiming to improve TE phytoremediation efficiency and predictability in the field.

Water and soil contaminated by arsenic: the use of microorganisms and plants in bioremediation

Owing to their roles in the arsenic (As) biogeochemical cycle, microorganisms and plants offer significant potential for developing innovative biotechnological applications able to remediate As pollutions. This possible use in bioremediation processes and phytomanagement is based on their ability to catalyse various biotransformation reactions leading to, e.g. the precipitation, dissolution, and sequestration of As, stabilisation in the root zone and shoot As removal. On the one hand, genomic studies of microorganisms and their communities are useful in understanding their metabolic activities and their interaction with As. On the other hand, our knowledge of molecular mechanisms and fate of As in plants has been improved by laboratory and field experiments. Such studies pave new avenues for developing environmentally friendly bioprocessing options targeting As, which worldwide represents a major risk to many ecosystems and human health.

Safe, efficient, and economically beneficial remediation of arsenic-contaminated soil: possible strategies for increasing arsenic tolerance and accumulation in non-edible economically important native plants

Anthropogenic activities, geological processes, and biogenic sources have led to the enhanced concentration of arsenic (As), a toxic metalloid in water and soil. Non-edible, economically important plants can be employed for safe As phytoremediation in addition to generating extra income. However, these plants may get affected by stressful local environmental conditions. Native plant species are adapted to local environmental conditions and hence overcome this problem. Native non-edible economic plant species which show high As tolerance and accumulation are promising candidate for safe, efficient, and economically beneficial phytoremediation of As-contaminated sites. The current review discusses the potential of native economic plant species that can be used in As phytoremediation programme. However, since their phytoremediation potential is moderate, possible strategies for increasing As  olerance and accumulation, especially genetic modification, have been discussed in detail. Knowledge gained from the review can be used for the development of As tolerance and accumulation in non-edible economic native plants.

Arsenic acquisition, toxicity and tolerance in plants - From physiology to remediation: A review

Globally, environmental contamination by potentially noxious metalloids like arsenic is becoming a critical concern to the living organisms. Arsenic is a non-essential metalloid for plants and can be acclimatised in plants to toxic levels. Arsenic acquisition by plants poses serious health risks in human due to its entry in the food chain. High arsenic regimes disturb plant water relations, promote the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and induce oxidative outburst in plants. This review evidences a conceivable tie-up among arsenic levels, speciation, its availability, uptake, acquisition, transport, phytotoxicity and arsenic detoxification in plants. The role of different antioxidant enzymes to confer plant tolerance towards the enhanced arsenic distress has also been summed up. Additionally, the mechanisms involved in the modulation of different genes coupled with arsenic tolerance have been thoroughly discussed. This review is intended to present an overview to rationalise the contemporary progressions on the recent advances in phytoremediation approaches to overcome ecosystem contamination by arsenic.

Short-term experiment for the in situ stabilization of a polluted soil using mining and biomass waste

Mining and biomass waste were used to remediate a brownfield affected by As, Cd, Cu, Pb and Zn pollution in a pilot scale experiment, and a plant used for phytoremediation purposes was used as an indicator of possible toxicological effects. To carry out the experiments, plots in field conditions were treated with magnesite (mining waste), magnesite-sludge compost, and magnesite-biochar respectively, while untreated soil was used as a control. The plots were then irrigated and left for one week, after which seeds of the ryegrass Lolium perenne L. were sown. Soil properties such as metal(loid) availability, pH, phosphorus availability, total nitrogen, organic carbon, and nutrients were monitored for two months. Finally, the ryegrass was harvested and pollutant concentrations were analyzed in the aerial parts. Magnesite proved to be an excellent amendment for metal(loid) immobilization, although the notable increase in soil pH and Mg content inhibited plant growth. However, the application of magnesite in combination with the sludge compost (rich in N and P) favored plant growth and also immobilized metals, although As availability increased. In contrast, the analysis of plants in this treatment revealed lower As and metal concentrations than those grown in the untreated soil. In turn, the application of magnesite and biochar was also effective in reducing metal(loid) availability; however, the plants did not grow under these conditions, probably due to the low N and P content of biochar. In this regard, the combined application of mining waste and sludge compost emerges as a useful nature-based solution for soil remediation in the context of the circular economy.

Physiological responses, tolerance, and remediation strategies in plants exposed to metalloids

Metalloids are a subset of particular concern to risk assessors and toxicologists because of their well-documented potential hazards to plant system. Most of the metalloids are major environmental contaminants which affect crop productivity when present in high concentrations in soil. Metalloids are coupled with carrier proteins of the plasma membrane and translocated to various organs causing changes in key metabolic processes, damages cell biomolecules, and finally inhibit its growth. Phytoremediation-based approaches help in understanding the molecular and biochemical mechanisms for prerequisite recombinant genetic approaches. Recent advancements in proteomics and plant genomics help in understanding the role of transcription factors, metabolites, and genes in plant system which confers metal tolerance. The present review summarizes our current status of knowledge in this direction related to various physiological responses, detoxification mechanisms, and remediation strategies of metalloids in crop plants in relation to plant-metalloid tolerance. Further, the role of various transcription factors and miRNAs in conferring metal tolerance is also briefed. Hence, the present review mainly focused on the alterations in the physiological activities of plants due to metalloid toxicity and the various mechanisms which get activated inside the plants to mitigate their toxic effects.

Arsenate-reducing bacteria affect As accumulation and tolerance in Salix atrocinerea

Arsenic (As)-reducing bacteria are able to influence As-speciation and, in this way, change As bio-availability. In consequence, this has an impact on As uptake by plants growing on polluted soil and on the effectiveness of the phytoremediation process. To be able to efficiently utilize these bacteria for As-phytoremediation in the field, a better understanding of the plant-bacterial interactions involved in As-tolerance or toxicity is needed. In this work, seedlings of a clone of Salix atrocinerea derived from a specimen naturally growing on an As-polluted brownfield were grown under gnotobiotic conditions exposed to As, and in the presence or absence of two of its field-associated and in vitro characterized plant growth-promoting (PGP) bacteria. The inoculation with Pantoea sp., induced a moderate reduction of AsV to AsIII in the exposure medium that, together with a coordinated plant response of As uptake, chelation and sequestration, increased As accumulation in roots; which is reflected into a higher phytostabilization. However, inoculation with Rhodococcus erythropolis due to a higher disproportionate reduction of AsV to AsIII in the medium caused less As accumulation in roots that non-bioaugmented plants and despite the lower As content, the concentrations of AsIII present in the medium and the damage suffered in roots and leaves, indicated that As tolerance mechanisms (such as prevention of AsIII uptake and efflux) did not occur in time to avoid physical disturbance and plants growth reduction. Interestingly, by two different metabolic pathways -coordinated by different key transporters mediating As uptake, tolerance, distribution and vacuolar accumulation at the roots- both bacteria limited As accumulation in Salix shoots. Our results provide for the first time a detailed insight in the plant-bacterial responses and physiological changes contributing to As tolerance in S. atrocinerea, that will facilitate the design of effective strategies for exploitation of plant-associated microorganisms for phytoremediation.

Time-dependent changes of arsenic and its selected forms in a hydroponic experiment with Quercus robur L

Mutual transformations of particular As forms are dynamic. Therefore hydroponic experiments need to account for this variation. For this reason, the aim of the study was to determine the time-dependent changes of As_total and selected forms of this metalloid (As(III), As(V), DMA or the sum of other organic forms) in modified Knop's solution and organs (root, low and high stem) of 2-year-old Quercus robur L. seedlings within a 33-day long hydroponic experiment. The results indicate the varying speed of As uptake and transport to aerial plant parts. A decrease in contents of As forms in organs of seedlings exposed to individual As forms varied, which indicates simultaneous transformations of As forms both in Knop's solution and plant organs. The obtained results indicate the need to analyse the main forms of As both in the nutrient solution and plant organs to assess the actual effectiveness of As phytoextraction by plants. It is necessary because, as demonstrated in this work, the addition of a specific As form does not mean that the capacity of a given plant relative to this form specifically is assessed. Capsule: The form of arsenic added to the medium undergoes dynamic changes affecting the phytoextraction of this metalloid in Quercus robur L. organs.

Arsenic phytovolatilization and epigenetic modifications in Arundo donax L. assisted by a PGPR consortium

Arsenic-(As) pollution is an increasing threat across the globe and it is reaching harmful values in several areas of the world. In this perspective, we assayed bio-phyto-remediation technology using Arundo donax L., assisted by Plant Growth Promoting Bacteria (PGPB) consortium (BC) constituted of two strains of Stenotrophomonas maltophilia sp. and one of Agrobacterium sp.; furthermore, we assayed the epigenetic response to As pollution. The three bacterial strains initially evaluated for their As tolerance, revealed different resistance to both forms of As[As(III) and As(V)] however at concentration greater than those foreseen in the phytoremediation experiment (2.0, 10.0, 20.0 mgL^-1 of NaAsO₂). At the end of the trial plant biomass and As concentration were measured. Plants did not show any visible signs of toxicity, rather the leaf and stem biomass slightly increased in the presence of As and/or PGPBs; moreover, although the Bioaccumulation Factor was double in the presence of BC, the absolute values of As accumulation in the Arundo plants were very low, both in the presence or absence of BC and only detectable in the presence of the highest As dose (20 mgL^-1 As). In this case, regardless the presence of PGPB, ≈25% of As remained in the sand and ≈0.15% was accumulated in the plant, whilst the remaining 75% was volatilized by transpiration. Finally, the methylation sensitive amplified polymorphisms (MSAP) of leaves were analyzed in order to investigate their epigenetic response to As and/or BC. Our results suggest that epigenetic modifications are involved in stress response and As detoxification.

Changes in the gene expression profile of Arabidopsis thaliana under chromium stress

Based on previous studies and preliminary test results, 200 μM was used as the test concentration of chromium (Cr), and changes in the gene expression profile of Arabidopsis thaliana in response to 24-h treatments of Cr(III) and Cr(VI) were analyzed using the Arabidopsis ATH1 Genome Array. The results were as follows. There were 238 upregulated genes and 858 downregulated genes in response to treatments with Cr(III) and Cr(VI). For Cr(III) and Cr(VI) treatments, there were 185 and 587 specifically upregulated genes as well as 220 and 956 specifically downregulated genes, respectively. Among the common differentially expressed genes (DEGs), the expression levels of genes involved in redox, secondary metabolism, and energy metabolism processes were significantly downregulated, while those of genes related to the stress response, photosynthesis, and sulfur metabolism were significantly upregulated. These findings indicated that Cr seriously affected the normal activities of A. thaliana cells. Some genes associated with stress and regulation were upregulated to adapt to the stress caused by Cr. Among the unique DEGs, the expression levels of genes involved in indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) regulatory pathway were significantly increased in response to Cr(III) treatment; the expression levels of genes involved in the abscisic acid (ABA) regulation pathway and carotenoid synthesis were significantly increased following Cr(VI) treatment. These results revealed some differences in response to Cr(III) and Cr(VI) in A. thaliana.