Ultrasound-assisted heterogeneous Fenton-like process for bisphenol A removal at neutral pH using hierarchically structured manganese dioxide/biochar nanocomposites as catalysts

Ultrasonic treatment of endocrine disrupting compounds, pharmaceuticals, and personal care products in water: An updated review

Pharmaceuticals, personal care products (PPCPs), and endocrine-disrupting compounds (EDCs) have seen a recent sustained increase in usage, leading to increasing discharge and accumulation in wastewater. Conventional water treatment and disinfection processes are somewhat limited in effectively addressing this micropollutant issue. Ultrasonication (US), which serves as an advanced oxidation process, is based on the principle of ultrasound irradiation, exposing water to high-frequency waves, inducing thermal decomposition of H2O while using the produced radicals to oxidize and break down dissolved contaminants. This review evaluates research over the past five years on US-based technologies for the effective degradation of EDCs and PPCPs in water and assesses various factors that can influence the removal rate: solution pH, temperature of water, presence of background common ions, natural organic matter, species that serve as promoters and scavengers, and variations in US conditions (e.g., frequency, power density, and reaction type). This review also discusses various types of carbon/non-carbon catalysts, O3 and ultraviolet processes that can further enhance the degradation efficiency of EDCs and PPCPs in combination with US processes. Furthermore, numerous types of EDCs and PPCPs and recent research trends for these organic contaminants are considered.

A comprehensive review of the "black gold catalysts" in wastewater treatment: Properties, applications and bibliometric analysis

A significant amount of effort has been devoted to the utilization of biochar-based catalysts in the treatment of wastewater. By virtue of its abundant functional groups and high specific surface area, biochar holds significant promise as a catalyst. This article presents a comprehensive systematic review and bibliometric analysis covering the period from 2009 to 2024, focusing on the restoration of wastewater through biochar catalysis. The production, activation, and functionalization techniques employed for biochar are thoroughly examined. In addition, the application of advanced technologies such as advanced oxidation processes (AOPs), catalytic reduction reactions, and biochemically driven processes based on biochar are discussed, with a focus on elucidating the underlying mechanisms and how surface functionalities influence the catalytic performance of biochar. Furthermore, the potential drawbacks of utilizing biochar are also brought to light. To emphasize the progress being made in this research field and provide valuable insights for future researchers, a scientometric analysis was conducted using CiteSpace and VOSviewer software on 595 articles. Hopefully, this review will enhance understanding of the catalytic performance and mechanisms pertaining to biochar-based catalysts in pollutant treatment while providing a perspective and guidelines for future research and development efforts in this area.

Nitrogen-doped metal-free granular activated carbons as economical and easily separable catalysts for peroxymonosulfate and hydrogen peroxide activation to degrade bisphenol A

The fabrication of low-cost, highly efficient, environmentally friendly, and easily separable metal-free heterogeneous catalysts for environmental remediation remains a challenge. In this study, granular nitrogen-doped highly developed porous carbons with a particle size of 0.25-0.30 mm were prepared by preoxidation and subsequent NH3 modification of a commercially available coconut-based activated carbon, and used to activate peroxymonosulphate (KHSO5) or hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) to degrade bisphenol A (BPA). The nitrogen-doped carbon (ACON-950) prepared by NH3 modification at 950 °C, with the addition of only 0.15 g/L could remove 100% of 50 mg/L BPA in 150 min, and more than 90% of the removed BPA was due to degradation. The removal rates of total organic carbon of ACON-950/KHSO5 and ACON-950/H2O2 systems reached 60.4% and 66.2% respectively, indicating the excellent catalytic activity of ACON-950. The reaction rate constant was significantly positively correlated with the absolute content of pyridinic N (N-6) and graphitic N (N-Q) and negatively and weakly positively correlated with pyrrolic N (N-5) and defects. Quenching experiments combined with electron paramagnetic resonance demonstrated that singlet oxygen was the dominant reactive oxidative species for BPA degradation. ACON-950 was characterized before and after the degradation reaction using N2 adsorption-desorption analyzer, Raman spectroscopy, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The results confirmed the prominent contribution of both the N-6 and N-Q to the catalytic performance of nitrogen-doped carbons. The reusability of ACON-950 and its application in actual water bodies further demonstrated its remarkable potential for the remediation of organic pollutants in wastewater.

Recent advances in ultrasound-Fenton/Fenton-like technology for degradation of aqueous organic pollutants

Organic pollutants in water are a serious problem because of their widespread presence, harming the ecosystem and human health. Of the commonly used advanced oxidation processes, a hybrid of ultrasound and the Fenton/Fenton-like technology has received increasing attention in treatment of aqueous organic pollutants. This hybrid is effective in degradation of organic pollutants, but its application has not been summarised. Herein, first, the application and influencing factors of this hybrid technology for organic pollutants degradation are introduced. Second, the mechanism of its action is discussed. Third, the current challenges and future perspectives associated with this technology are proposed. This review provides valuable information regarding this technology, deepens the understanding of its mechanisms of organic pollutants degradation and provides a reference for its use in treatment of aquatic environments.

Comparative investigation of the catalytic application of α/β/γ-MnO2 nanoparticles synthesized by green and chemical approaches

Three phases (α, β, and γ) of manganese dioxide (MnO2) are successfully stabilized in a single entity for the first time. For this purpose, Citrullus colocynthis (bitter apple) extract is used as a natural surfactant in green synthesis. MnO2 nanoparticles were synthesized in the presence and absence of plant extracts under the same conditions. The morphology of both products is analysed by SEM and STEM to understand the role of plant extract in controlling the morphology of particles. The crystallinity and composition are analysed by XRD and confirmed that the product is composed of multiple phases α, β, and γ. The reduction of dyes and nitroarenes is studied using MnO2 nanoparticles (green and chemical products) as catalysts. The apparent rate constant, a percentage reduction, time reduction and reduced concentration compare the activities of both catalysts. After comparative data analysis, the catalytic reduction of picric acid is found fastest among all the substrates. All the results are analysed based on structure, functional group and affinity towards catalysts.

Effects of gas saturation and sparging on sonochemical oxidation activity under different liquid level and volume conditions in 300-kHz sonoreactors: Zeroth- and first-order reaction comparison using KI dosimetry and BPA degradation

The sonochemical oxidation activity was investigated for gas saturation and gas sparging under various liquid levels and volumes in 300 kHz sonoreactors. The liquid levels and volumes ranged from 5λ (25 mm, 0.47 L) to 50λ (250 mm, 4.30 L) and two gas mixtures, Ar:O₂ (75:25) and N₂:O₂ (75:25), were used. Two types of reaction kinetics were observed to quantitatively analyze the sonochemical oxidation reactions: zero-order (KI dosimetry: C₀ = 60.2 mM) and first-order (Bisphenol A (BPA) degradation: C₀ = 0.043 mM). The masses of the sonochemical oxidation reactions were calculated and compared rather than the concentrations to more accurately compare the sonochemical oxidation activity under different liquid volume conditions. First, as the liquid level or volume increased for the zero-order reactions, the concentration of I₃^- ions representing the volume-averaged activity decreased substantially for gas saturation owing to the increase in liquid volume. However, gas sparging substantially enhanced sonochemical oxidation activity, and the mass of I₃^- ions representing the total activity remained constant as the liquid level increased from 20λ because of the improved liquid mixing and a shift in the sonochemical active zone. Second, as evidenced by the zero-order reactions, the concentration of BPA decreased considerably as the liquid level or volume increased in the first-order reactions. When gas sparging was used, higher reaction constants were obtained for both gas mixtures, ranging from 40λ to 50λ. However, a comparison of the sonochemical oxidation activity in terms of the degraded mass of BPA was inapplicable as the concentration of BPA decreased substantially and a lack of reactants occurred for the lower liquid level and volume conditions as the irradiation time elapsed. Instead, using the first-order reaction constant, a comparison of the required reaction times for a specific removal efficiency (30%, 60%, and 90%) was proposed. Gas sparging can substantially reduce the reaction time required for a liquid level of 40λ or higher.

Highly efficient LaMO3 (M = Co, Fe) perovskites catalyzed Fenton's reaction for degradation of direct blue 86

Perovskite-structured catalysts LaMO₃ (M = Co, Fe) were successfully synthesized and attempted to catalyze hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) for the degradation of Direct Blue 86 (DB86), a carcinogenic phthalocyanine dye. The heterogeneous Fenton-like reaction revealed that the oxidative power of the LaCoO₃-catalyzed H₂O₂ (LaCoO₃/H₂O₂) process was higher than that of LaFeO₃/H₂O₂. When LaCoO₃ was calcined at 750 °C for 5 h, 100 mg/L of DB86 could be completely degraded within 5 min via LaCoO₃/H₂O₂ system under H₂O₂ 0.0979 mol/L, initial pH 3.0, LaCoO₃ 0.4 g/L, and 25 °C. The oxidative LaCoO₃/H₂O₂ system has a low activation energy (14.68 kJ/mol) for DB86 degradation, indicating that it is a fast reaction process with highly favorable at high reaction temperatures. For the first time, a cyclic reaction mechanism of catalytic LaCoO₃/H₂O₂ system was proposed based on the evidence of coexisting Co^II and Co^III on the LaCoO₃ surface and the presence of HO^• radicals (major), O₂^•- radicals (minor), and ¹O₂ (minor). LaCoO₃ perovskite catalyst was reusable and still maintained reactive with a satisfactory degradation efficiency within 5 min even after five consecutive uses. This study shows that the as-prepared LaCoO₃ is a highly efficient catalyst for phthalocyanine dye degradation.

Nitrogen doped bimetallic sludge biochar composite for synergistic persulfate activation: Reactivity, stability and mechanisms

As a recycling use of waste activated sludge (WAS), we used high-temperature pyrolysis of WAS to support bimetallic Fe-Mn with nitrogen (N) co-doping (FeMn@N-S), a customized composite catalyst that activates peroxysulphate (PS) for the breakdown of tetracycline (TC). First, the performance of TC degradation was evaluated and optimized under different N doping, pH, catalyst dosages, PS dosages, and contaminant concentrations. Activating PS with FeMn@N-S caused the degradation of 91% of the TC in 120 min. Next, characterization of FeMn@N-S by XRD, XPS and FT-IR analysis highlights N doping is beneficial to take shape more active sites and reduces the loss of Fe and Mn during the degradation reaction. As expected, the presence of Fe-Mn bimetallic on the catalyst surface increases the rate of electron transfer, promoting the redox cycle of the catalyst. Other functional groups on the catalyst surface, such as oxygen-containing groups, accelerated the electron transfer during PS activation. Free radical quenching and ESR analysis suggest that the main contributor to TC degradation is surface-bound SO₄^•-, along with the presence of single linear oxygen (¹O₂) oxidation pathway. Finally, the FeMn@N-S composite catalyst exhibits excellent pH suitability and reusability, indicating a solid practicality of this catalyst in PS-based removal of antibiotics from wastewater.

Ultrasonic Activated Biochar and Its Removal of Harmful Substances in Environment

Biochar has been widely used in the fields of environment and energy, and green preparation can make biochar-based materials more environmentally friendly. Particularly, in the low-temperature pyrolysis of biochar, labile C with low biological toxicity is the main influencing factor of bacteria in soil. Therefore, it is worth studying to develop the fabrication technology of low-temperature pyrolysis biochar with rich pore structure. The mechanical effect of ultrasonic cavitation is considered to be an effective strategy for the preparation of biochar. However, the sonochemical effects on biochar remain to be studied. In this review, ultrasonic modification and ultrasonic-chemical modification on biochar has been reviewed. Metal oxide/biochar composites can also be obtained by an ultrasonic-chemical method. It is worth mentioning that there have been some reports on the regeneration of biochar by ultrasound. In addition to ultrasonic preparation of biochar, ultrasound can also trigger the sonocatalytic performance and promote the adsorption ability of biochar for the removal of harmful substances. The catalytic mechanism of ultrasound/biochar needs to be further investigated. For application, biochar prepared by ultrasound has been used for the removal of heavy metals in water, the adsorption of carbon dioxide, and soil remediation.

A comprehensive review on BPA degradation by heterogeneous Fenton-like processes

Synthetic organic pollutants emanating continuously in the ecosystem have become a global concern because of their toxicity and persistent nature. Bisphenol A (BPA) is one such pollutant which threatens public health and safety. It is a monomer used in manufacturing plastics, polycarbonate resins, epoxy resins and is a well-recognised endocrine disruptor mimicking estrogen. BPA leaches into food and beverages stored in containers causing contamination issues. Its widespread exposure and potential toxicity is an environmental health concern. In this review, a systematic investigation has been carried out on the heterogeneous catalysts used for Fenton-like processes for BPA degradation. The Fenton-like reaction is one such reaction that is used for wastewater remediation purposes. The reaction advances through the generation of powerful oxidizing radicals like •OH and SO₄^•- in the presence of a suitable catalyst. The application of various Fenton catalysts, with their distinguished morphological characteristics, oxidizing properties, toxicity analysis, and the present state of the art of BPA degradation by these catalysts, have been documented in the current work. This review also highlights a few challenges and prospects for analysing degradation products of landfill leachate.

Manganese oxide-modified biochar: production, characterization and applications for the removal of pollutants from aqueous environments - a review

The development of manganese (Mn) oxides (MnOx) modified biochar (MnOBC) for the removal of pollutants from water has received significant attention. However, a comprehensive review focusing on the use of MnOBC for the removal of organic and inorganic pollutants from water is missing. Therefore, the preparation and characterization of MnOBC, and its capacity for the removal of inorganic (e.g., toxic elements) and organic (e.g., antibiotics and dyes) from water have been discussed in relation to feedstock properties, pyrolysis temperature, modification ratio, and environmental conditions here. The removal mechanisms of pollutants by MnOBC and the fate of the sorbed pollutants onto MnOBC have been reviewed. The impregnation of biochar with MnOx improved its surface morphology, functional group modification, and elemental composition, and thus increased its sorption capacity. This review establishes a comprehensive understanding of synthesizing and using MnOBC as an effective biosorbent for remediation of contaminated aqueous environments.

Ciprofloxacin removal by ultrasound-enhanced carbon nanotubes/permanganate process: In situ generation of free reactive manganese species via electron transfer

Recently, free reactive manganese species (RMnS) generated via permanganate catalytic oxidation technology has been applied to contaminants abatement and sludge dewatering. This study proposed a novel free RMnS generation method in ultrasound enhanced carbon nanotube (CNTs)/permanganate process (UCP) for organics removal. Taking ciprofloxacin as a target contaminant, the removal efficiency in the UCP process (9.78 s^-1) was remarkably higher than that of the permanganate (0.71 s^-1) and CNTs/permanganate (2.57 s^-1) processes. CNTs could enrich manganese compounds and ciprofloxacin, and act as an electronic platform for the electronic transfer from ciprofloxacin to manganese compounds for free RMnS generation, which was revealed by DFT calculation and spectrum analysis. Meanwhile, ultrasound further regulated the generation of RMnS as it could transform the inactive solid Mn(IV) into free RMnS. In the UCP process, non-free radical modes including RMnS oxidation (49.8%) and electron transfer (23.5%) were the dominant processes for ciprofloxacin removal in the UCP process, and hydroxyl radical oxidation (13.2%), CNTs adsorption (5.5%), and PM oxidation (8.0%) also contributed to ciprofloxacin removal. Interestingly, CNTs could be well reused in the UCP process as more than 88.75% of ciprofloxacin was removed after five times reuse of CNTs. The UCP process provides a novel strategy for rapid contaminants removal in water treatment via continuous generation of free RMnS.

Biochar Modified by Nano-manganese Dioxide as Adsorbent and Oxidant for Oxytetracycline

Biochar has limited capacity to adsorb oxytetracycline (OTC). Here we have used bamboo willow biochar (BC) as a carrier to produce nMnO₂-loaded biochars (MBC) by a co-precipitation method. Their chemical compositions, morphological features, specific surface area, and surface functional groups were observed or determined. Batch experiments were conducted to assess the effects of reaction time, initial OTC concentrations, pH, salt concentrations, and natural organic matter (NOM) on OTC removal. Kinetics and isotherms indicated that OTC was mainly adsorbed via chemical interactions, and mono- and multi-layer adsorption occurred on the surface. MBC removed 19-25 times more OTC than BC, and the removal was highest at near-neutral pH, not influenced by NaCl (2, 10 mM), slighted reduced by NOM (0-20 mg L^-1), and enhanced by NaHCO₃ (2, 10 mM). Besides being an adsorbent, MBC acted as an oxidant and degraded 58.5% of OTC at 24 h.

Bisphenol A degradation using waste antivirus copper film with enhanced sono-Fenton-like catalytic oxidation

This study investigated the applicability of waste antivirus copper film (CF) as a Fenton-like catalyst. The reaction activity of H₂O₂ and CF in combination was significantly enhanced by ultrasound (US) irradiation, and the synergy factor calculated from bisphenol A (BPA) degradation using CF-H₂O₂-US was 9.64 compare to that of dual factors. Photoluminescence analyses were conducted to compare the generation of hydroxyl radicals during both processes. In this sono-Fenton-like process, BPA degradation was affected by solution pH, temperature, ultrasound power, CF size, H₂O₂ dose, and initial BPA concentration. The BPA degradation curves showed an induction period (first stage) and a rapid degradation period (second stage). Process efficiency was totally and partially enhanced in the presence of chloride and carbonate ions, respectively. Chemical scavenger tests showed that both free and surface-bound hydroxyl radicals participate in BPA degradation under the sono-Fenton-like process using CF. The functional groups and copper crystals on the CF surface remained unchanged after five consecutive reuses, and the BPA degradation efficiency of CF was maintained over 80% during the reuse processes as a sono-Fenton-like catalyst.

A critical review on metal complexes removal from water using methods based on Fenton-like reactions: Analysis and comparison of methods and mechanisms

Metals mainly exist in the form of complexes in urban wastewater, fresh water and even drinking water, which are difficult to remove and further harm human health. Fenton-like reaction has been used for the removal of metal complexes. Effective removal of metal complexes using Fenton-like reaction requires the removal of both metals and organic ligands, meanwhile, the fate of metals and organic pollutions must be clearly understood. Thus, this review summarizes the relevant research on metal complex removal from using Fenton-like reactions in the past ten years, with the detailed removal approaches and mechanisms analyzed. Electro-, photo-, microwave/ultrasound-Fenton reactions or the synergistic Fenton reaction have been shown to exhibit excellent metal complex treatment capabilities. Furthermore, various catalysts, such as transition metals, bimetals and metal-free catalytic systems can expand the potential applications of Fenton-like reactions. Novel Fenton reaction methods without the addition of metals or H₂O₂, with construction of a dual active center catalyst, or with the introduction of other free radicals, are all worthy of further investigation. Due to increasing levels of environmental metal and organic pollutions remediation requirements, more research is required for the development of economical and efficient novel Fenton-like processes.

Manganese doped iron-carbon composite for synergistic persulfate activation: Reactivity, stability, and mechanism

The heterogeneous catalytic process has been under development for aqueous pollutant degradation, yet electron transfer efficiency often limits the effectiveness of catalytic reactions. In this study, a novel composite material, manganese doped iron-carbon (Mn-Fe-C), was tailor designed to promote the catalytic electron transfer. The Mn-Fe-C composite, synthesized via a facile carbothermal reduction method, was characterized and evaluated for its performance to activate persulfate (PS) and degrade Rhodamine Blue (RhB) dye under different pH, catalyst dosages, PS dosages, and pollutant concentrations. Electron spin resonance, along with quenching results by ethanol, tert-butanol, phenol, nitrobenzene and benzoquinone, indicated that surface bounded SO₄^•- was the main contributor for RhB degradation, while the roles of aqueous SO₄^•- and ^•OH were very minor. Through characterization by XRD, XPS and FTIR analysis, it was determined that the electron transfer during activation of PS was accelerated by the oxygen functional groups on catalyst surface and the promoted redox cycle of Fe³⁺ and Fe²⁺ by Mn. Finally, the Mn-Fe-C composite catalyst exhibited an excellent reusability and stability with negligible leached Fe and Mn ions in solutions. Results of this study provide a promising design for heterogeneous catalysts that can effectively activate PS to remove organic pollutants from water at circumneutral pH conditions.

Adsorption of emerging contaminants from water and wastewater by modified biochar: A review

Emerging contaminants (ECs), a group of relatively low-concentration but high-toxicity pollutants in the environment, have attracted widespread attention in recent years. These trace pollutants can be enriched in organisms and finally transferred to human bodies, posing a potential hazard to public health. Biochar, a low-cost and high-efficiency adsorbent, has been used to treat ECs in water. However, due to certain limitations of pristine biochar, such as poor adsorption capacity, narrow adsorption range, and other shortcomings, it is necessary to modify biochar to improve its applications in water treatment for ECs. Currently, there are a lot of reports on the removal of ECs from water by modified biochar. These studies explored different modification methods to functionalize biochar with various physicochemical properties, which resulted in distinct adsorption effects, behaviors and mechanisms of modified biochar on different ECs. There is a need to systematically review and digest the knowledge on the adsorption of ECs on modified biochar. In this review, recent biochar modification methods used in ECs removal are firstly summarized, and the adsorption performance and mechanisms of modified biochar on typical ECs are then systematically reviewed. Finally, the main research directions and trends, as well as recommendations and suggestions for future development are pointed out.

Ultrasonication-promoted synthesis of Ni/mayenite for catalytic reforming of biomass tar

Ultrasound-assisted approach was successfully applied for the synthesis of mayenite from calcium and aluminum hydroxides and then subsequently impregnated with Ni by the wet impregnation method. The synthesis was performed with a 13 mm probe-type ultrasound, operating under an acoustic power of 30.5 W and a frequency of 20 kHz. Ultrasound application was studied in detail from a 3^k experimental design, where the variables studied were ultrasound time (10-50 min) and calcination temperature (900-1200 °C). Ultrasound promoted an effective dispersion of the precursors in a short time of 10 min leading to a high conversion to mayenite after calcination at 1200 °C. Ultrasound treatment also had a positive effect on Ni impregnation, increasing the dispersion of the metal in the support and leading to a stronger interaction of nickel-containing species with mayenite support. The use of ultrasound application has proved to be attractive both for catalyst properties and for facilitating catalyst synthesis.

A Review of Non-Soil Biochar Applications

Biochar is the solid residue that is recovered after the thermal cracking of biomasses in an oxygen-free atmosphere. Biochar has been used for many years as a soil amendment and in general soil applications. Nonetheless, biochar is far more than a mere soil amendment. In this review, we report all the non-soil applications of biochar including environmental remediation, energy storage, composites, and catalyst production. We provide a general overview of the recent uses of biochar in material science, thus presenting this cheap and waste-derived material as a high value-added and carbonaceous source.

Ultrasonic energy-assisted in-situ synthesis of Ru0/PANI/g-C3N4 nanocomposite: Application for picomolar-level electrochemical detection of endocrine disruptor (Bisphenol-A) in humans and animals

Bisphenol A (BPA) is an endocrine-disrupting chemical which resembles structurally the hormone estrogen. Even a trace amount of BPA can bind estrogen receptors resulting in the inducement of reproductive disorders, cancers and problems related to sexual growth such as manliness in female and womanliness in male. So the determination of BPA in human and animal bodies is very essential. For this purpose, a new nanocomposite composed of ruthenium nanoparticles, polyaniline and graphitic carbon nitride (Ru⁰/PANI/g-C₃N₄) has been synthesized ultrasonically (40 ± 3 kHz, 200 W). A modification on glassy carbon electrode (GCE) with the nanocomposite detects BPA in human and animal urine samples with wide linear range (0.01-1.1 µM) and the limit of detection is pico molar-level. The synthesized nanocomposite was characterized by Ultraviolet-Visible and Fourier Transform-Infra Red spectroscopies, thermo gravimetric analysis, transmission electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction study, energy dispersive X-ray analysis, and elemental mapping analysis. This sensing system is selective, stable and reusable, by which the detection of BPA in various physiological fluids is very much possible.