Fiproles as a proxy for ecological risk assessment of mixture of fipronil and its degradates in effluent-dominated surface waters

Pesticides in wastewater treatment plant effluents in the Yeongsan River Basin, Korea: Occurrence and environmental risk assessment

Pesticides are among the main drivers posing risks to aquatic environments, with effluents from wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) serving as a major source. This study aimed to identify the primary pesticides for which there was a risk of release into aquatic environments through WWTP effluents, thereby enabling more effective contamination management in public water bodies. In this study, monitoring, risk assessment, and risk-based prioritization of 87 pesticides in effluents from three WWTPs in the Yeongsan River Basin, Korea, were conducted. A total of 59 pesticides were detected at concentrations from 0.852 ng/L to 82.044 μg/L and exhibited variable patterns across different WWTP locations. An environmental risk assessment based on the risk quotient (RQ) of individual pesticides identified 13 substances implicated in significant ecotoxicological risks, as they exceeded RQ values of 1 at least once. An optimized risk (RQf)-based prioritization, considering the frequency of the measured environmental concentration (MEC) exceeding the predicted environmental concentration (PNEC), was conducted to identify pesticides that potentially posed risks and thus should be managed as a priority. Four pesticides had an RQf value >1; metribuzin exhibited the highest RQf value of 4.951, followed by 3-phenoxybenzoic acid, atrazin-2-hydroxy, and atrazine. Additionally, five pesticides (terbuthylazine, methabenzthiazuron, diuron, thiacloprid, and fipronil) and another four pesticides (propazine, imidacloprid, hexaconazole, and hexazione) had RQf values >0.1 and > 0.01, respectively. By calculating the contributions of individual pesticides to the RQf of these mixtures (RQf, mix) based on the concentration addition model, it was determined that >95 % of the sum of RQf, mix was driven by the top seven pesticides. These findings highlight the importance of prioritizing pesticides for effective management of contamination sources.

Ecological implications and drivers of emerging contaminants in Dongting Lake of Yangtze River Basin, China: A multi-substance risk analysis

Emerging contaminants (ECs) are increasingly recognized as a global threat to biodiversity and ecosystem health. However, the cumulative risks posed by ECs to aquatic organisms and ecosystems, as well as the influence of anthropogenic activities and natural factors on these risks, remain poorly understood. This study assessed the mixed risks of ECs in Dongting Lake, a Ramsar Convention-classified Typically Changing Wetland, to elucidate the major EC classes, key risk drivers, and magnitude of anthropogenic and natural impacts. Results revealed that ECs pose non-negligible acute (30% probability) and chronic (70% probability) mixed risks to aquatic organisms in the freshwater lake ecosystem, with imidacloprid identified as the primary pollutant stressor. Redundancy analysis (RDA) and structural equation modeling (SEM) indicated that cropland and precipitation were major drivers of EC contamination levels and ecological risk. Cropland was positively associated with EC concentrations, while precipitation exhibited a dilution effect. These findings provide critical insights into the ecological risk status and key risk drivers in a typical freshwater lake ecosystem, offering data-driven support for the control and management of ECs in China.

Quantitative differentiation of toxicity contributions and predicted global risk of fipronil and its transformation products to aquatic invertebrates

Biotransformation often alters chemical toxicity, yet its impacts on risk assessment are hardly quantified due to the challenges in acquiring internal exposure-based thresholds for chemicals that are readily metabolizable. Here, we integrated toxic unit and toxicokinetics to quantitatively assess toxicity contributions and potential risk of both parent compound and transformation products (TPs) to aquatic organisms, using fipronil (FIP) as a representative toxicant. In aquatic invertebrates Chironomus dilutus and Hyalella azteca, approximately 90 % of FIP was transformed to fipronil sulfone (SUL). FIP and SUL exhibited similar intrinsic toxicity to these organisms, which was contrary to conventional perception that SUL was more toxic than FIP. However, biotransformation was still important in risk assessment because the TP had 10-fold slower depuration rate than FIP. The amphipod H. azteca was found to be as sensitive to FIPs as the insect C. dilutus, which was previously considered ten times more sensitive based on external thresholds. This discrepancy has led to overlooking the toxicity of FIP to H. azteca in regional risk assessments. Lastly, we predicted the lethal risk of FIPs in global surface water. When using external thresholds for prediction, FIPs in 3.4 % of the water samples were lethally toxic to H. azteca, and the percentage of water samples at risk increased to 14 % when internal thresholds were used and SUF dominated the risk. This study presents an improved method for quantifying aquatic risk of readily metabolized toxicants. Our findings underscore the urgency of considering TPs in water quality assessments, especially for sensitive species that are at risk in the environment.

Tracing the attenuation of fipronil and its transformation products from a rice paddy field to receiving rivers using polar organic chemical integrative samplers

Irrational use of fipronil for rice pest control often occurred, resulting in high concentrations of fipronil and its transformation products (TPs) (collectively termed fiproles) in aquatic sediment, calling for a better understanding of the migration and transformation of fipronil in surface water as well as efficient methods for source identification. Herein, the fate and transport of fiproles from a paddy field to receiving rivers were assessed in Poyang Lake basin, Jiangxi, China using polar organic chemical integrative samplers with mixed-mode adsorbents (POCIS-MMA). Average concentrations of fiproles in water were 6.16 ± 6.32 ng/L, with median, minimum, and maximum values being 2.99 ± 0.67, 0.40 ± 0.08, and 18.6 ± 3.1 ng/L, respectively. In all samples, over half of fiproles (55.9 %-90.8 %) presented in the form of TPs and fipronil desulfinyl was the dominant TP. Two approaches were applied for source identification, including the change of molar concentration ratios of fipronil to its TPs and the relative attenuation values of fiproles normalized to a reference compound (acetamiprid) that was stable in aquatic environment. While the paddy field upstream was the main source of waterborne fiproles, additional input sources in the downstream region were identified. The present study indicated that the combination of attenuation of molar concentration ratios of micro-pollutants to their respective TPs and relative attenuation values of micro-pollutants' concentrations normalized to a reference compound measured by POCIS is an effective means to study the migration and transformation of micro-pollutants in field.

Occurrence and ecological risks of flonicamid and its metabolites in multiple substrates from intensive rice-vegetable rotations in tropical China

Rice-vegetable rotations are dominant in (sub)-tropical agriculture worldwide. However, fate and risks of the insecticide flonicamid (FLO) and its main degradates (collectively called FLOMs) in multiple substrates from those cropping systems remain largely unknown. In this study, we characterized residual concentrations, driving factors, transport, and potential ecological risks of FLOMs in different substrates in 28 tropical rice-vegetable rotations. Concentrations (median) of FLOMs were 0.013-3.03 (0.42) ng g-1 in plants, 0.012-1.92 (0.23) ng g-1 in soil, 0.029-0.63 (0.126) μg L-1 in water, and 0.002-0.398 (0.055) ng g-1 in sediments. Flonicamid and its metabolite N-(4-trifluoromethylnicotinoyl) glycine were the dominant species in the four substrates (84.1 % to 88.5 %). Plants had the highest levels of FLOMs, with the highest bioconcentration factor in peppers. According to boosted regression trees coupled with a partial least squares structural equation model, levels and composition of FLOMs showed high spatiotemporal and crop-related patterns in different substrates, with patterns highly codetermined by agricultural practices (e.g., crop type and FLO/neonicotinoid/pyrethroid applications), substrate parameters (e.g., pH, organic matter or total organic carbon), and climate features (e.g., wet/dry seasons). Moreover, a fugacity method indicated differences in transport and partitioning patterns in different substrates during rice and vegetable planting periods. Integrated substrate risk assessment of FLOMs contamination was conducted based on species-sensitive distributions and substrate weight index. Although overall risks of FLOM contamination in tropical rice-vegetable rotations were negligible to low, the highest risks were in soils, vegetable planting periods, and a central intensively planted area.

Colorimetric and ratiometric supramolecular AIE fluorescent probe for the on-site monitoring of fipronil

The overuse of fipronil (FPN, a broad-spectrum insecticide) in agriculture has brought great concerns for environmental pollution and food safety. The development of a rapid, reliable, and portable analytical method for the on-site monitoring of FPN is therefore of great significance but is full of challenge. Herein, a novel supramolecular probe using human serum albumin (HSA) as the host and an aggregation-induced emission-active fluorescence probe LIQ-TPA-TZ as the guest was developed for the colorimetric and ratiometric detection of FPN, displaying fast response (30 s), high sensitivity (LOD ∼ 0.05 μM), and good selectivity and anti-interference performance. Moreover, portable paper-based test strips could be facilely obtained and utilized for the determination of FPN, showing colorimetric changes from yellow to orange. This supramolecular probe also demonstrated great potential in real applications for choosing the best cleaning method to reduce the residue rate of FPN on apples. This study provides a versatile tool for the fast and real-time analysis of FPN, which greatly benefits the on-site determination of pesticides with the use of simple testing apparatus.

Deep mining of reported emerging contaminants in China's surface water in the past decade: Exposure, ecological effects and risk assessment

The identification and management of high-risk contaminants have raised great concern from governments. Facing the growing amount of data on the occurrence of emerging contaminants (ECs) in surface water, a deep mining and quality control strategy was developed to integrate data on all reported ECs in Chinese surface water over the past decade, and an exposure and effect database was further built. In addition, multilevel risk characterization was carried out to prioritize high-risk areas, contaminants and endpoints. A total of 1038 ECs, mainly pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) and industrial chemicals, were curated, with concentrations ranging from 0.02 pg/L to 533 µg/L. For individual risk, all the provinces had acceptable risks except for Henan, which was characterized with a medium chronic risk. Nine ECs, including 4-nonylphenol and estrone, dominated individual risks. Conversely, for multisubstance risk, 76.20% and 73.87% of aquatic organisms were affected acutely and chronically at the national level, with acute and chronic risks exceeding the safety threshold of 5% in 11 and 19 provinces, respectively. Nineteen ECs, including sitosterol and chyfluthrin, dominated the multisubstance risk. In addition, 9 MoAs mainly inducing electron transfer inhibition, neurotoxicity and narcosis toxicity are high-risk endpoints. The study revealed the ecological risk status and key risk entities of Chinese surface waters, which provided the latest data to support the control of ECs in China.

Influence of dissolved organic carbon on multimedia distribution and toxicity of fipronil and its transformation products in lotic waterways

Environmental fate and ecological impacts of fipronil and its transformation products (FIPs) in aquatic environment have caused worldwide attention, however, the influence of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) on multimedia distribution, bioavailability, and toxicity of FIPs in field waterways was largely unknown. Here, we collected 11 companion water and sediment samples along a lotic stream in Guangzhou, South China. FIPs were ubiquitous with total water concentrations ranging from 1.22 to 43.2 ng/L (14.8 ± 12.9 ng/L) and fipronil sulfone was predominant in both water and sediment. More than 70% of FIPs in aqueous phase were bound to DOC and the K_DOC values of FIPs were approximately 1-2 orders of magnitude higher than K_d-s/K_OC, emphasizing the significance of DOC in phase partitioning and transport of FIPs in aquatic environment. Water and sediment samples were more toxic to Chironomus dilutus than Hyallela azteca, and FIPs (especially fipronil sulfone) pronouncedly contributed toxicity to C. dilutus. Toxic units (TU) based on freely dissolved concentrations in water determined by solid phase microextraction significantly improved toxicity estimation of FIPs to the invertebrates compared to TUs based on aqueous concentrations. The present study highlights the significance of DOC association on fate and ecological risk of hydrophobic insecticides in lotic ecosystem.

Assessing bioaccumulation potential of sediment associated fipronil degradates in oligochaete Lumbriculus variegatus based on passive sampler measured bioavailable concentration

The degradates of fipronil have equivalent or even more toxicity to non-target aquatic invertebrates. To assess their environmental risks, information of bioaccumulation is required. Currently, little is known about the bioaccumulative property of fipronil degradates in sediment, while it is well known that passive sampler may measure bioavailable concentration (C_free) which links with the environmental effect more tightly than the total environment concentration. The goal of the present study was to characterize bioaccumulation potential in oligochaete Lumbriculus variegatus for a fipronil degradate sulfide. The sediment organic carbon-water partition coefficient (K_OC) was measured with polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) film passive sampler, and K_OC was used to bridge the gap between biota-sediment accumulation factor (BSAF) and bioconcentration factor (BCF). The bioavailable concentration (C_free)-based K_OC values were 5371 ± 152 and 5013 ± 152 (mL/g OC) for fipronil sulfide (FSI) and sulfone (FSO), respectively. Since the two fipronil degradates were produced continuously in sediment by the parent compound, the time-weighted-average (TWA) concentration of FSI in the sediment was estimated from a bioassay with L. variegatus to calculate BSAF value (0.581 ± 0.211 g OC/g lipid) and BCF (3046 ± 1103 or log 3.48 ± 0.16 mL/g). This approach is able to estimate the C_free-based K_OC and BCF values of fipronil degradate in sediment with ongoing degradation of the parent compound.

Scrutinizing surficial sediment along a 600-km-long urban coastal zone: Occurrence and risk assessment of fipronil and its three degradates

Contamination in the coastal zone is closely linked to urbanization and has become a global issue. The coastal aquatic environment is the terminal sink for many chemicals; however, little is known about the occurrence and variation among habitats as well as integrative toxicity for pesticides, i.e., fipronil, and its three major degradates (-desulfinyl, -sulfide, and -sulfone, fiproles hereafter) in sediments in urban coastlines. In the present study, we report results of a random stratified survey for fiproles in surficial sediments in five embayment habitats (strata) along the Southern California Bight (SCB), USA coastline. Fiproles were present in a small areal extent (6.8%) of the SCB embayment, and detected in 14 out of 174 stations with a total concentration of the four analytes ranging from 0.50 to 17.5 μg/kg dry weight. The area-weighted mean concentrations were 3.16 ± 3.37, 0.584 ± 0.558, 0.071 ± 0.103, and 0.005 ± 0.009 μg/kg in brackish estuaries, estuaries, bays, and marinas, respectively, with the results below the detection limits in ports. Fipronil sulfone had the greatest detection frequency (8.05%) and highest mean concentration (3.24 ± 3.36 μg/kg) among the four compounds. A screening-level deterministic risk assessment for invertebrates found that, region-wide, fiproles generally posed an insignificant to low acute risk to the amphipod Eohaustorius estuarius in 7.36% of the SCB embayment area. In addition, high risk to the midge Chironomus dilutus was found in 77.5% of the fiproles-detectable area in the brackish estuary stratum that is a part of the Los Angeles River. Fipronil sulfone was identified as the major contributor of these effects. The results of this study establish a baseline of occurrence and toxicity potential for fiproles in coastal sediments of southern California.

Biodegradation of fipronil: current state of mechanisms of biodegradation and future perspectives

Fipronil is a broad-spectrum phenyl-pyrazole insecticide that is widely used in agriculture. However, in the environment, its residues are toxic to aquatic animals, crustaceans, bees, termites, rabbits, lizards, and humans, and it has been classified as a C carcinogen. Due to its residual environmental hazards, various effective approaches, such as adsorption, ozone oxidation, catalyst coupling, inorganic plasma degradation, and microbial degradation, have been developed. Biodegradation is deemed to be the most effective and environmentally friendly method, and several pure cultures of bacteria and fungi capable of degrading fipronil have been isolated and identified, including Streptomyces rochei, Paracoccus sp., Bacillus firmus, Bacillus thuringiensis, Bacillus spp., Stenotrophomonas acidaminiphila, and Aspergillus glaucus. The metabolic reactions of fipronil degradation appear to be the same in different bacteria and are mainly oxidation, reduction, photolysis, and hydrolysis. However, the enzymes and genes responsible for the degradation are somewhat different. The ligninolytic enzyme MnP, the cytochrome P450 enzyme, and esterase play key roles in different strains of bacteria and fungal. Many unanswered questions exist regarding the environmental fate and degradation mechanisms of this pesticide. The genes and enzymes responsible for biodegradation remain largely unexplained, and biomolecular techniques need to be applied in order to gain a comprehensive understanding of these issues. In this review, we summarize the literature on the degradation of fipronil, focusing on biodegradation pathways and identifying the main knowledge gaps that currently exist in order to inform future research. KEY POINTS: • Biodegradation is a powerful tool for the removal of fipronil. • Oxidation, reduction, photolysis, and hydrolysis play key roles in the degradation of fipronil. • Possible biochemical pathways of fipronil in the environment are described.

Direct analysis of metabolites in the liver tissue of zebrafish exposed to fiproles by internal extractive electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Exploring the metabolic disturbance of fipronil and its derivatives in aquatic organisms may provide a more comprehensive understanding of the impact of fipronil on the ecological environment. In this work, internal extractive electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (iEESI-MS) was used to directly analyze metabolites in the liver tissue of zebrafish exposed to fipronil and its three derivatives. Partial least squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) revealed that 32 signals were considered as differential signals in zebrafish after the exposure treatment of fipronil and its derivatives, including phosphatidylcholines (PCs), lysophosphatidylcholines (LPCs), phosphatidylethanolamines (PEs), fatty acids and so on. The pathway analysis result showed that both fipronil and its derivatives have a significant impact on the glycerophospholipid metabolism of zebrafish. Besides, the intensities of PC signals in the liver samples of each group showed such a trend: mixed fiprole exposed group > fipronil sulfone exposed group ≈ fipronil sulfide exposed group > fipronil exposed group > fipronil desulfinyl exposed group > control group, indicating that mixed exposure of fipronil and its derivatives exhibited more significant metabolic disturbance in zebrafish. Taken together, iEESI-MS is applied to environmental toxicology and investigating the metabolic disturbance induced by fipronil and its derivatives in aquatic organisms, providing a new analytical method for this field.