Low natural in vivo resistance to syngeneic leukaemias in natural killer-deficient mice

Murine Models of Familial Cytokine Storm Syndromes

Hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (HLH) is a hyperinflammatory disease caused by mutations in effectors and regulators of cytotoxicity in cytotoxic T cells (CTL) and natural killer (NK) cells. The complexity of the immune system means that in vivo models are needed to efficiently study diseases like HLH. Mice with defects in the genes known to cause primary HLH (pHLH) are available. However, these mice only develop the characteristic features of HLH after the induction of an immune response (typically through infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus). Nevertheless, murine models have been invaluable for understanding the mechanisms that lead to HLH. For example, the cytotoxic machinery (e.g., the transport of cytotoxic vesicles and the release of granzymes and perforin after membrane fusion) was first characterized in the mouse. Experiments in murine models of pHLH have emphasized the importance of cytotoxic cells, antigen-presenting cells (APC), and cytokines in hyperinflammatory positive feedback loops (e.g., cytokine storms). This knowledge has facilitated the development of treatments for human HLH, some of which are now being tested in the clinic.

Modulation of natural killer cell exhaustion in the lungs: the key components from lung microenvironment and lung tumor microenvironment

Lung cancer is the leading cause of tumor-induced death worldwide and remains a primary global health concern. In homeostasis, due to its unique structure and physiological function, the lung microenvironment is in a state of immune tolerance and suppression, which is beneficial to tumor development and metastasis. The lung tumor microenvironment is a more complex system that further enhances the immunosuppressive features in the lungs. NK cells are abundantly located in the lungs and play crucial roles in lung tumor surveillance and antitumor immunity. However, the immunosuppressive microenvironment promotes significant challenges to NK cell features, leading to their hypofunction, exhaustion, and compromised antitumor activity. Thus, understanding the complex interactions among the lung microenvironment, lung tumor microenvironment, and NK cell exhaustion is critical for the development of effective cancer immunotherapeutic strategies. The present review will discuss NK cell hypofunction and exhaustion within the lung microenvironment and lung tumor microenvironment, focusing on lung tissue-specific factors, including key cytokines and unique environmental components, that modulate NK cell activation and function. Understanding the functional mechanisms of key factors would help to design strategies to reverse NK cell exhaustion and restore their antitumor function within the lung tumor microenvironment.

Boosting vaccine efficacy the natural (killer) way

Coordination of the innate and adaptive immune systems is paramount to the development of protective humoral and cellular immunity following vaccination. Natural killer (NK) cells are front-line soldiers of the innate immune system, and recent studies have revealed functions for NK cells in long-lived immune memory and the regulation of adaptive immune responses. These findings suggest that NK cells may play important roles in the development of efficacious vaccines, as well as, in some contexts, failed immunizations. Here, we review the current understanding of the immunomodulatory and memory differentiation capabilities of NK cells. We examine the context dependency of the mechanisms and the nature of NK cell-mediated modulation of the immune response, and discuss how these insights may impact immunization strategies and the development of next-generation vaccines.

Unexpected role for granzyme K in CD56bright NK cell-mediated immunoregulation of multiple sclerosis

Functional NK cell deficiencies are associated with autoimmune diseases, including multiple sclerosis. NK cells can promote or inhibit adaptive immunity via either cytokine production or cytotoxicity toward immature dendritic cells and activated T cells. In humans, this immunoregulatory role resides in the CD56(bright) NK cell subset, which is selectively expanded by daclizumab, a CD25-blocking Ab that suppresses multiple sclerosis-associated inflammation. The objective of this study was to investigate the molecular mechanisms underlying the cytotoxicity of NK cells toward activated T cells. We demonstrated that NK cells induce caspase-independent apoptosis that requires NK cell degranulation and causes mitochondrial dysfunction in activated T cells. Although both granzyme A and granzyme K (GrK) can mediate this form of apoptosis, quantitatively we observed preferential transfer of GrK to target cells. Consequently, gene silencing of GrK in the NK-92 cell line, which retains functional characteristics of CD56(bright) NK cells, profoundly inhibited the ability of NK-92 cells to kill activated syngeneic T cells. Finally, we demonstrated that daclizumab treatment significantly enhanced this newly defined mechanism of cytotoxicity by CD56(bright) NK cells. Our study describes the important physiological role that GrK plays in immunoregulation of adaptive immunity in humans and indicates that therapeutic exploitation of this pathway is beneficial in controlling autoimmunity.

Enhanced in vivo growth of lymphoma tumors in the absence of the NK-activating receptor NKp46/NCR1

The in vitro elimination of virus-infected and tumor cells by NK cells is regulated by a balance between signals conveyed via specific inhibitory and activating receptors. Whether NK cells and specifically the NK-activating receptor NKp46 (NCR1 in mice) are directly involved in tumor eradication in vivo is still largely unknown. Since the NKp46/NCR1 tumor ligands have not been identified yet, we use a screening technique to identify functional ligands for NKp46/NCR1 which is based on a cell reporter assay and discover a NCR1 ligand in the PD1.6 lymphoma line. To study whether NKp46/NCR1 is important for the eradication of PD1.6 lymphoma in vivo, we used the Ncr1 knockout Ncr1(gfp/gfp) mice generated by our group. Strikingly, all Ncr1 knockout mice developed growing PD1.6 tumors, whereas initial tumor growth was observed in the wild-type mice and tumors were completely rejected as time progressed. The growth of other lymphoma cell lines such as B10 and EL4 was equivalent between the Ncr1 knockout and wild-type mice. Finally, we show that PD1.6 lymphoma cells are less killed both in vitro and in vivo in the absence of NKp46/NCR1. Our results therefore reveal a crucial role for NKp46/NCR1 in the in vivo eradication of some lymphoma cells.

Tumor immune escape mechanisms: impact of the neuroendocrine system

Tumor cells act upon, and react to both their proximate and more distant environment, the mechanisms by which this is achieved being both autocrine and paracrine in nature. This interaction, however, takes place not only between adjacent malignant cells, but also non-malignant cells such as those of the immune system, the latter also partaking in the modeling of the tumor environment. Although tumor cells descend from normal tissue cells and thus bear in classical immunological terms 'self signals', it is evident that the immune system is able to recognize tumor cells as a harassment for the body and in consequence tries to eliminate these cells. On the counterpart, tumor cells acquire various characteristics which allow them to evade this immunological surveillance, and have been collectively coined with the term "tumor escape mechanisms". This review will describe and summarize current understanding of tumor escape strategies, and also more closely elaborate on the modulatory role of the neuroendocrine system in the immune system-tumor cell interaction.

The innate immune response to tumors and its role in the induction of T-cell immunity

Recent genetic studies have resurrected the concept that the adaptive and innate immune systems play roles in tumor surveillance. Natural killer (NK) cells recognize many tumor cells but not normal self cells, and they are thought to aid in the elimination of nascent tumors. Two main strategies are employed by NK cells to recognize tumor targets. Many tumor cells down-regulate class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules, thus releasing the NK cell from the inhibition provided by class I MHC-specific inhibitory receptors ('missing self recognition'). More recently, it has become clear that a stimulatory receptor expressed by NK cells, T cells and macrophages (NKG2D) recognizes ligands (MHC class I chain related [MIC], H6O, retinoic acid early inducible [Rae1] and UL16 binding proteins [ULBP]) that are up-regulated on tumor cells and virally infected cells but are not expressed well by normal cells. Ectopic expression of these ligands on tumor cells leads to the potent rejection of the tumors in vivo. Importantly, mice that previously rejected the ligand+ tumor cells develop T-cell immunity to the parental (ligand-) tumor cells. The recognition of induced-self ligands as a strategy to recognize abnormal self sets a precedent for a new immune recognition strategy of the innate immune system.

Genetic defects in Chediak-Higashi syndrome and the beige mouse

Chediak-Higashi syndrome (CHS) is a rare, autosomal recessive, multisystem disorder in which severe immune deficits are accompanied by abnormalities of pigmentation, blood clotting, and neurologic function. There is no specific treatment, and without bone marrow transplantation, most patients succumb to frequent bacterial infections or to a lymphoproliferative syndrome that appears to result principally from lack of natural killer cell function. Disorders similar to human CHS occur in many mammalian species, the most important being the beige mouse, long considered a likely homologue of human CHS. This supposition has recently been confirmed by the mapping, cloning, and mutation analysis of the homologous human CHS1 and mouse beige genes. Identification of the human CHS1 gene, and the availability of a ready mouse model for human CHS, will likely facilitate investigation of the disease pathophysiology and the development of novel and specific treatments for the disorder.

Human breast cancer cell line xenografts as models of breast cancer. The immunobiologies of recipient mice and the characteristics of several tumorigenic cell lines

The ability to maintain and study human tissues in an in vivo environment has proved to be a valuable tool in breast cancer research for several decades. The most widely studied tissues have been xenografts of established human breast cancer cell lines into athymic nude mice. Human breast tumor xenografts provide the opportunity to study various important interactions between the tumor and host tissues, including endocrinologic, immunologic, and tumor-stroma interactions. The nude mouse is not the only immune-deficient recipient system in which to study xenografts. Additional single and combined mutant strains have been used successfully, including mice homozygous for the severe combined immune deficiency mutation (scid), both the beige (bg) and nude (nu) mutations in combination (bg/nu), and mice bearing the combined bg/nu/xid mutations. The differing immunobiologies are discussed, with particular reference to the immunobiology of breast cancer, as are the characteristics of several of the more frequently utilized breast cancer xenografts and cell lines. The ability of several endocrine treatments to modulate effectors of cell mediated immunity, e.g., estrogens and antiestrogens, and the effect of site of inoculation on tumor take and metastasis, also are described.

Tumor heterogeneity and immunotherapy of cancer

Tumor heterogeneity is the presence of intercellular differences, either from clonal origin or present within subpopulations of tumor cells. Recent advances in immuno-histology, flow cytometric analysis, molecular biological techniques, and tissue culture methods makes it possible to investigate tumor heterogeneity in detail. In this review data are presented to document that this hallmark of neoplastic disease results from DNA-instability and the interactions of tumor cells with their environment. The present inability to treat most patients effectively with immunotherapy may partly be due to the occurrence of tumor heterogeneity. Therefore, the heterogeneity of the tumor phenotype is discussed in conjunction with the various immunotherapeutic treatment modalities. In addition to local cytokine production by immune cells and tumor cells, and limited access of either antibodies or immune cells into the tumor, tumor heterogeneity is an important factor that determines the progress of immunotherapy of cancer. Therefore, accurate quantitative methods using antibodies and molecular probes to identify HLA-associated target peptides, tumor-associated antigens and accessory molecules, to predict which patients will have a high probability of responding to treatment, are needed.

Effect of arginase on splenic killer cell activity in patients with gastric cancer

Arginase has been detected in high levels in gastric cancer tissues. The effect of arginase on the activities of splenic natural killer (NK) cell, phytohemagglutinin activated killer (PAK) cell, and interleukin-2 activated killer (LAK) cell in patients with gastric cancer (N = 12) was evaluated in vitro. These activities in patients (N = 10) with trauma and benign lesions were used as control. The splenic NK and PAK cell activities in patients with gastric cancer were significantly lower than in the controls (P < 0.05), whereas LAK cell activity did not have significant difference. Arginase inhibited all splenic killer cell activities to a similar degree between patients with gastric cancer and the controls. The inhibition was dose-related. These data suggest that arginase may play a positive role in the spread of gastric cancer cells. However, LAK may be a potential approach of immunoadoptive therapy in the future.

Impaired interferon production and natural killer cell activation in patients with the skin cancer-prone disorder, xeroderma pigmentosum

Xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder with sun sensitivity, markedly increased skin cancer susceptibility, and defective DNA repair without consistently identified symptoms of immune deficiency. We examined natural killer (NK) cell activity and interferon production in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of eight XP patients who had multiple primary skin cancers. The XP patients had normal numbers of T cells and NK cells, as well as normal lymphokine-activated killer cell activity and normal tumor necrosis factor-alpha production. Unstimulated NK cell function was 40% of normal controls in five XP patients, but was normal in three other XP patients. However, PBL from all the XP patients tested showed no enhancement of NK activity by the interferon inducer, polyinosinic acid:polycytidilic acid (polyIC) but enhancement by interferon-alpha was normal, suggesting an impairment in interferon production. Parallel studies in non-XP skin cancer patients revealed that both unstimulated and polyIC-enhanced NK activity were normal. Further investigation using PBL from XP patients revealed that the production of interferon-gamma after stimulation with interferon inducers (polyIC, interleukin 2, or K562 tumor cells) was 13-43% of normals. These data indicate that XP lymphocytes have a defect in production of interferons and suggest that defective interferon production, as well as DNA repair defects, may play an important role in the susceptibility of XP patients to skin cancer.

Sensitized T lymphocytes render DBA/2 beige mice responsive to IFN alpha/beta therapy of Friend erythroleukemia visceral metastases

Interferon alpha/beta (IFN alpha/beta) is highly effective in inhibiting the development of Friend erythroleukemia cell (FLC) visceral metastases in DBA/2 mice injected intravenously (i.v.) with FLC, but does not protect FLC-injected DBA/2 beige (bg/bg) mice. Use of IFN alpha/beta-resistance FLC indicated that IFN was acting through host mechanisms in DBA/2 mice and thus pointed to a defect in some host mechanism in bg/bg mice essential for IFN's anti-metastatic action. We undertook experiments to restore in bg/bg mice the marked anti-FLC metastatic effect of IFN alpha/beta observed in DBA/2 and +/bg mice. Adoptive transfer of spleen cells from normal syngeneic mice to IFN-treated bg/bg mice was ineffective, but the transfer of splenic T lymphocytes from FLC-immunized DBA/2 or +/bg mice markedly increased the survival time of FLC-injected bg/bg mice provided that these mice were also treated with IFN alpha/beta. Neither treatment alone resulted in an increase in survival time. As few as 1 x 10(7) immune spleen cells were effective in IFN-treated FLC-injected bg/bg mice. The T-cell immune response to FLC of bg/bg mice was diminished compared with that of +/bg mice. Likewise, only combination therapy of immune spleen cells and IFN alpha/beta resulted in an increased survival time of ESb-lymphoma-injected bg/bg mice. Our results indicate the essential participation both of T-cell-mediated immune mechanisms and of IFN alpha/beta in the inhibition of FLC visceral metastases.

Suppression of natural killer cell activity by sera from patients with endometriosis

OBJECTIVE

We determined the effect of sera from patients who have endometriosis on natural killer cell activity.

STUDY DESIGN

The natural killer cell activity of lymphocytes from healthy volunteers was examined after incubation with sera from patients who had endometriosis or from controls, with K562 cells used as targets.

RESULTS

Lymphocytes treated with sera from patients who had endometriosis expressed significantly lower levels of cytotoxicity compared with lymphocytes treated with control sera. This suppression of cytotoxicity was dose dependent, and the degree of suppression was proportional to the incubation time of the effector cells with the sera. Decreased cytotoxicity after serum treatment was also observed with sera from patients who had been treated with danazol.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings show that humoral factors that can inhibit natural killer cell activity in vitro are present in the peripheral blood of patients who have endometriosis; moreover, they suggest that the suppressed natural killer cell activity may allow the development of endometrial cells at ectopic sites.

Graft versus leukaemia effects after marrow transplantation in man

A graft versus leukaemia (GvL) effect makes a significant contribution to the lower risk of relapse seen in patients after BMT compared with patients receiving chemotherapy alone. Both T cell-dependent and T cell-independent effectors of GvL exist, and both may play an important role in the elimination of minimal residual disease after BMT. There is evidence that GvL activity may be separable from GvHD either by identifying T cell clones recognizing specific leukaemia antigens or by using immunomodulatory drugs or cytokines to enhance T cell-independent GvL mechanisms which operate without alloreactivity and therefore without concomitant exacerbation of GvHD. These approaches should improve survival after both autologous and allogeneic BMT.

Natural killer cell function in children with malignant solid neoplasias

Natural killer (NK) cell numbers and lytic activity were determined in 40 children with various types of solid malignant neoplasias and in 25 control children by NKH-1 monoclonal antibody and cytotoxicity against K562 target cells, respectively. Patients were analyzed at the time of diagnosis before initiation of therapy and followed over a median time of 15.8 months. Mean NK cell numbers and lytic activity were similar among different types of tumor analyzed. Patients with localized disease (stages I, II; n = 25) also showed values not statistically different from those of patients in advanced disease (stages III, IV; n = 15). According to their response to therapy, patients were divided into three groups: group 1 (complete remission; n = 28), group 2 (partial remission; n = 5), and group 3 (progression of disease; n = 6). Patients in group 3 showed at the time of diagnosis a mean NK activity significantly lower than that of patients in groups 1 and 2 and control children (P = 0.007). The defect in NK cell lytic capacity in vitro observed in patients with progressive disease suggests that NK cells play a role in the control of neoplastic growth in vivo and may imply that some children with refractory progressive disease can benefit from immunomodulation destined to improve the lytic potential of NK cells.

Orthotopic implantation is essential for the selection, growth and metastasis of human renal cell cancer in nude mice [corrected]

Human neoplasms are heterogeneous for a variety of biological properties that include invasion and metastasis. The presence of a small subpopulation of cells with a highly metastatic phenotype has important clinical implications for diagnosis and therapy of cancer. For this reason, it is important to develop an animal model for the selection and isolation of metastatic variants from human neoplasms and for testing the metastatic potential of human tumor cells. We have implanted human renal cell carcinoma (HRCC) cells (obtained from a surgical specimen) into different organs of nude mice and then recovered the tumors and established each in culture. The 5 established lines differed in their biological-metastatic properties and had a unique karyotype, indicating that growth at different organs selects for different subpopulations of HRCC. Moreover, the HRCC did not metastasize unless they were implanted orthotopically. These findings indicate that the appropriate nude mouse model for studying the biology and therapy of HRCC must be based on the orthotopic implantation of tumor cells.

Natural cell-mediated immunity in the rabbit

Susceptibility and resistance to tumors represent the interplay of many factors. One factor felt to govern the development of tumors is natural killer and natural cytotoxic cellular activity. The constitutional resistance of rabbits to spontaneous tumor development raises questions regarding the activity of natural cell-mediated immunity in this species. We therefore examined the ability of rabbit spleen, lymph node, and peripheral blood lymphocytes to mediate natural killer cell (NK) and natural cytotoxic cell (NC) activity in vitro. Using classical approaches to the study of NK and NC activity, we found no evidence of these activities in leporine spleen, lymph node, and peripheral blood lymphocytes. Preincubation of these cells with IL-2 did not induce such activity. Antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxic reactivity (ADCC), which is believed to be mediated by NK cells, was also undetectable in rabbit lymphocytes. As controls, lymphocytes from other species were capable of mediating NK, NC, and ADCC functions normally in these experiments. Finally, we were unable to identify a population of large granular lymphocytes, the cells believed to mediate NK activity in other animals. Therefore, we could not demonstrate in the rabbit either natural cell-mediated immunity or the population of cells usually associated with natural cell-mediated immunity. If such activity exists in rabbits, it is different from that seen in other animals. More likely, the basis for the natural resistance of rabbits to tumor development must be sought elsewhere.

The influence of protein malnutrition on T cell, natural killer cell, and lymphokine-activated killer cell function, and on biological responsiveness to high-dose interleukin-2

Protein malnutrition is prevalent in cancer patients, however the influence of protein-calorie malnutrition on anti-tumor immune effector mechanisms is unclear. In addition, the effect of malnutrition on host immunological and biological responsiveness to recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2) is unknown. In Swiss mice (n = 100), we observed that T cell activation, T cell response to rIL-2, T suppressor cell generation, cytotoxic T lymphocyte development, and the cytolytic activity of LAK cells were not significantly impaired by two or three weeks of feeding with a 2.5% protein diet compared with mice fed an isocaloric diet in which protein calories constituted 24% of the total. In CBA/J mice (n = 100), we observed a significant (P less than 0.05) impairment of poly(I:C)-inducible natural killer cell function in mice ingesting the 2.5% diet. In both A/J (n = 40) and Swiss mice (n = 40), cytotoxic responses after 3 days treatment with rIL-2 (5 X 10(6) U/kg body wt. three times daily) were comparable in both dietary groups. These studies demonstrate that protein depletion is associated with impaired poly (I:C)-induced natural killer cell function in CBA/J mice. However, T cell function and biological responsiveness to high-dose rIL-2 were not significantly impaired.

RNK granule extract cytolysis: differential inhibitor production by an NK-resistant vs an NK-sensitive murine lymphoma

Natural killer (NK) cell-resistant tumors exist despite their ability to bind cells from the effector population. Tumor sensitivity to NK activity was therefore examined at the level of susceptibility to cytolysin-containing NK cell cytotoxic granule extracts. The NK-sensitive SL2-5 murine lymphoma was markedly more susceptible than the NK-resistant L5178Y-F9 to solubilized granule preparations from the rat NK tumor cell line RNK-16, and this corresponded also with tumor sensitivity to hypotonic lysis. However, the resistant L5178Y-F9 was better able to inhibit the extract activity than the SL2-5. Dissociation of the binding and lysis phases of the cytolysin reaction based on their differential temperature requirements, 4 degrees C for binding and 37 degrees C for lysis, permitted an examination of the cytolysin/tumor interaction prior to lysis. The residual cytotoxic activity was lower after extract exposure to the L5178Y-F9 compared with the SL2-5 consistent with possible inhibitor production. Finally, supernatant material collected from the L5178Y-F9 was a better inhibitor of granule extract lysis and acted preferentially in the extract-binding phase. The inhibitor appears to be protein in nature, relatively stable, and exhibits molecular weight heterogeneity ranging from 2000 to greater than 300,000.

Immunohistochemical analysis of the relationship between CEA localization and mononuclear cell infiltration in human colorectal carcinoma

Thirty cases of colorectal adenocarcinoma were immunohistochemically examined to clarify the relationship between the degree of differentiation of cancer cells reflected by the mode of CEA localization and the infiltration pattern of mononuclear cells in the carcinoma tissues. Leu 1+, Leu 2a+, Leu 3a + 3b+ T lymphocytes, Leu 7+ cells, and IgA-containing plasma cells tended to be distributed more in areas where CEA was localized over the entire surface of the cancer cells or in their surrounding stroma than where CEA was located along the apical surface or within the cytoplasm. Carcinoma cells with the pattern of CEA staining at the former site were previously shown to be less differentiated than those at the latter. There were also CEA-containing phagocytes which were often observed where T cells and IgA plasma cells had aggregated. We speculated that the dedifferentiation of cancer cells might cause the host immune response, especially the cellular immunity, in malignant lesions.

Panax ginseng as a potential immunomodulator: studies in mice

There has been continuing interest in the development of synthetic and natural compounds which modify the immune response, particularly for the treatment of AIDS and cancer. Panax ginseng, employed for its putative medicinal properties in South Asia, was examined for its immunomodulatory properties in mice. A systematic evaluation of multiple immune system components revealed that Panax ginseng stimulated basal natural killer (NK) cell activity following subchronic exposure and helped stimulate recovery of NK function in cyclophosphamide-immunosuppressed mice but did not further stimulate NK activity in poly I:C treated mice. Other immunological parameters examined, including T and B cell responses were not affected. Panax ginseng provided a degree of protection against infection with L. monocytes but did not inhibit the growth of transplanted syngeneic tumor cells. Increased resistance to L. monocytogenes was not detected in challenged mice previously given immunosuppressive doses of cyclophosphamide. Taken together, these data suggest that Panax ginseng has some immunomodulatory properties, primarily associated with NK cell activity.

The in vivo clearance of Ha-ras transformants by natural killer cells

The experiments in this study were designed to test the hypothesis that natural killer (NK) cells play a role in host surveillance against early neoplastic changes in the malignant process. C3H 10T1/2 mouse fibroblasts were transfected with a pSV2-neo plasmid vector which contains EJ, the mutated c-Ha-ras, regulated by its own promoter. Control cells were transfected with pSV2-neo alone and did not contain the ras gene. Oncogene-transfected cells were compared with control cells for lung colony formation following tail vein injection into C3H mice. Intravenous injection of ras-transfected 10T1/2 cells induced marked lung colony formation in vivo, whereas C3H 10T1/2 parental lines or 10T1/2 cells transfected with pSV2-neo alone induced no lung colonies in C3H mice. The colonising potential of ras transfectants could be decreased by augmentation of NK activity by injection of polyinosinic cytidylic acid and increased by depletion of NK effectors with anti-asialo GM1. Experiments with beige mice demonstrated that the mortality of syngeneic, NK-deficient C3H-bg/bg mice injected with ras tranfectants was significantly greater than similarly treated NK-normal C3H(-)+/bg littermate controls. The results support the view that NK cells are capable in vivo of recognizing early defined stages in the neoplastic process initiated by oncogenes.

The augmentation of lymphokine-activated killer cells induced by partial hepatectomy in mice

Spleen cells that are cultured with interleukin 2 for as short a time as 4 days develop the ability to lyse syngeneic natural killer-resistant tumor cells but not to lyse syngeneic lymphoblasts. When mice were subjected to partial hepatectomy (HEP), the spleen cells exhibited not only an augmentation of natural killer activity, but also an augmentation of in vitro induction of lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cells. Furthermore, the LAK cells exhibited lytic activities against syngeneic lectin-induced lymphoblasts and regenerating liver cells. The sensitivity of regenerating liver cells to lysis by LAK cells was detected as early as one day after HEP, and continued until day 14. Analysis by cell depletion techniques using monoclonal antibodies and complement, as well as discontinuous gradient sedimentation, indicated that the LAK cells activated by HEP were Thy-1+, Lyt-2+, asialo GM1+ and Lyt-1-, lymphocytes with a low density. After the intravenous (i.v.) administration of anti-asialo GM1 before HEP, the in vitro induction of LAK cells was remarkably inhibited.

The C57BL/6 nude, beige mouse: a model of combined T cell and NK effector cell immunodeficiency

This article describes the construction and establishment of a double congenic nude, beige C57BL/6 (B6 nu, bg) mouse strain. The mice do not show higher fragility than C57BL/6 nude mice and the double congenic strain can be maintained under conventional mouse housing conditions. Although the B6 nu, bg display a very low natural killer activity which cannot be enhanced by an interferon inducer (poly(I-C], they lack responsiveness to a T cell mitogen (concanavalin A); and they also show extremely low responsiveness to a B cell mitogen (0128: B12 Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide) probably as a result of combined effects of the beige and nude genes in the C57BL/6 genetic context.

Depressed level of natural killer cells in cancer family syndrome

Individuals from kindred with cancer family syndrome (CFS) have an increased genetic risk for the development of adenocarcinoma of the colon as well as of several other organs. Previous studies have suggested that this high occurrence of adenocarcinoma in this as in other hereditary neoplastic syndromes may be correlated to an underlying abnormality in immunological tumor surveillance. In attempt to define a marker that might identify individuals within CFS kindred at risk of developing cancer, we determined natural killer (NK) cell number and NK cell function in affected and healthy members of a CFS family. We studied 13 cancer-affected patients, 20 unaffected but "at-risk" subjects, 20 healthy subjects and 26 normal individuals matched to the patients with colon cancer on the basis of sex and age. We determined the number of NK cells and their function concurrently, using a monoclonal antibody and a 51Cr-release assay with K562 as target cells. We found that the number of NK cells was significantly (P = 0.00004) reduced in cancer patients as compared with healthy subjects and normal controls. Of the 20 at-risk individuals 9 had levels lower than the norm, while 11 showed normal-values. Consequently, the mean percentage of NK cells of this group does not differ either from that of normal subjects or from that of cancer patients. Mean NK cell function was lower in cancer patients than in healthy members of the CFS family but the differences were not statistically significant. Therefore, the mean NK cell function per single cell, expressed as a ratio between cytotoxicity (LU) and the number of NK1-positive cells, resulted paradoxically in an increase when compared with that of normal subjects. The possible mechanisms for this dichotomy were examined.

The relationship between MHC antigen expression and metastasis

From the studies summarized here a complex picture of the role played by MHC products in determining tumorigenicity and metastasis is emerging. In order to be able to understand this relationship better, it is necessary to consider several factors. 1. Each tumor system or neoplastic tissue is unique, and its behavior reflects the influence of cell-specific characteristics, as well as its ability to modulate other cells and tissues--including cells belonging to the immune system--and also to be modulated by other cells and soluble factors. 2. Since metastasis formation is a multistep process in which only small subpopulations of tumor cells with complex and defined phenotypes are able to colonize secondary tissues, elimination of even one single phenotypic component of this structured process can easily reverse the metastatic capacity of the cells. Acquisition of metastatic ability, on the other hand, would be a more difficult task, since any new characteristic expressed by the cells or induced experimentally, such as gene transfection or results of IFN treatment, must be expressed in a temporal manner and in concert with other cellular characteristics. Therefore, an experimental protocol measuring a specific element in determining metastasis can easily produce conflicting results, depending on the type of cells and genetic background of the host studied. 3. The level of specific MHC products on tumor cells is one among many other cell characteristics that may determine the metastatic potential of cells. Moreover, each of the class 1 MHC products, and the relationship among them, including other than the classical K, L, or D products (Brickell et al., 1983), should be regarded as independent entities, with possible different regulatory roles in cell-cell recognition, in a general sense, which may be involved in determining invasiveness and homing as well as recognition by the immune system. 4. Both specific T-cell and nonspecific natural mediated immunity (which is much less understood) are involved in the selection of the metastatic cell population. 5. Immunogenicity of tumors is not necessarily determined by high levels of MHC antigen expression; it is also dependent on the level of TSA. Thus, immunoselection mediated by T lymphocytes during metastasis formation could be directed against both MHC and TSA antigens. Therefore, low expression of MHC antigens by metastatic cells as a result of immunoselection is not always observed.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Natural killer cell function and lymphoid subpopulations in acute non-lymphoblastic leukaemia in complete remission

A long term follow-up study has been undertaken in 33 patients with acute non-lymphoblastic leukaemia (ANLL) in order to establish whether a correlation exists between the clinical course and the immunologic pattern of lymphoid subpopulations. Peripheral blood lymphoid cells have been investigated longitudinally (each 1 to 4 months) during complete remission (CR), by morphologic, phenotypic and functional analyses. Particular attention has been paid to the evaluation of the natural killer (NK) cell compartment, by the detection of cells expressing an NK-related phenotype and by NK in vitro assay. Among the patients so far evaluable, 20 relapsed (R) and 10 are long survivors in CR 'off therapy' (LS). The most relevant finding was represented by statistically higher values of NK activity observed in LS vs. R patients (P less than 0.01). The removal of adherent cells before the NK assay, performed to investigate the possible inhibitory effect on NK function played by the macrophage component, abolished this difference, due to a selective increase of NK function in the R group. The longitudinal study revealed that NK activity tended to decrease in individual patients who subsequently relapsed. These data suggest a possible role of NK cells in the relapse control of ANLL, although it cannot be excluded that the low level of NK activity observed in the R group is the result of impending relapse rather than its cause.

Efficacy of an immunomodulating drug in immunodeficient and immunocompetent mice

Bacillus subtilis culture filtrate (BSKR) was examined for its immunomodulating ability in the immunodeficient beige mouse and the immunocompetent Han:NMRI mouse strain. Following various application schemes the mice were challenged either subcutaneously with Escherichia coli or intranasally with Streptococcus pneumoniae. The mortality rates and the median of survival time were determined. Following subcutaneous application of BSKR Han:NMRI mice challenged with E. coli showed a decrease in mortality regardless of the application scheme. Using the beige mouse a protective effect was observed only after single applications of relatively low doses. Using Sc. pneumoniae as the challenge organism, a subcutaneous application of BSKR caused a decrease in mortality only if it was given on the day prior to infection. In both infection models the intranasal application of BSKR and/or of saline proved to be beneficial by either significantly decreasing the mortality or considerably increasing the survival time of beige and Han:NMRI mice.

Increase in natural killer activity in cyclosporine-treated renal allograft recipients during rejection

Natural killer (NK) activity was assessed in a prospective fashion in 15 renal transplant recipients receiving single HLA-haplotype matched allografts and maintained on cyclosporine (CYA) immunosuppression. There was marked variability in NK activity pretransplantation in this population; however, a strong correlation (r = 0.92, p less than 0.01) was found between determinations in an individual patient upon repeated testing. No significant depression of NK activity occurred within the first 12 weeks following transplantation. Whole blood CYA levels did not correlate with NK activity. Although NK activity prior to transplantation did not predict clinical outcome of the allograft, a marked rise in NK activity was observed in patients undergoing rejection compared with those not rejecting (p less than 0.01). A large increment in activity was seen in eight of 11 rejection episodes; a similar increase was rarely seen in the absence of rejection. These results indicate that NK activity is stimulated during allograft rejection in CYA treated renal transplant recipients. It remains to be determined whether this rise in NK function represents a manifestation of alloreactivity accompanying the rejection process or whether NK cells directly contribute to allograft destruction.

Growth and metastatic behavior of human tumor cells implanted into nude and beige nude mice

The growth and metastatic behavior of several human tumor lines grown in adult nude mice, nude mice pretreated with antiserum against asialo GM1 glycoprotein, and beige nude mice were studied. The cell lines were all injected s.c. and i.v. A human colon carcinoma line was also injected into the spleen, and two human renal carcinoma lines were injected into renal subcapsule. All the tumor lines grew as fast or faster in adult nude mice compared with beige nude mice. There were no discernible differences in the production of experimental lung metastasis among the three groups of mice, but human colorectal carcinoma cells and human renal carcinoma cells produced more metastases in nude mice than in beige nude mice after intrasplenic or renal subcapsule injection, respectively. In vitro cytotoxicity assays confirmed that adult nude mice had high levels of natural killer (NK) cell activity whereas nude mice pretreated with anti-asialo GM1 serum and beige nude mice did not. The in vitro NK cell activity of nude mice was demonstrable against mouse lymphoma cells but not against human leukemia cells which were sensitive to lysis by human NK cells. These results suggest that the implantation of human tumor cells into beige nude mice, which are deficient in NK cell activity does not provide an advantageous model for the study of growth and metastasis of human neoplasms.

Suppression of basal and Corynebacterium parvum-augmented NK activity during chemically induced tumor development

C3H mice were injected subcutaneously (s.c.) with a tumorigenic dose (150 micrograms/mouse) of 3-methylcholanthrene (MC), followed by a 24-h injection and subsequent weekly injections of Corynebacterium parvum (CP) i.p. for a total of 100 days. Basal and CP-augmented NK cell activities were measured in controls and treatment groups during pre-tumor and tumor development stages. Basal NK activity in spleen, peripheral blood and lung tissue was enhanced by CP, but was suppressed by MC. A resulting transient MC induced suppression of splenic NK activity at 10 days was partially restored and sustained by CP treatment and immunosuppression was again observed in tumor-bearing compared to control mice. Mice treated with MC alone showed a higher tumor incidence than animals treated with MC + CP at 45-60 days, while there was no difference in tumor incidence in these two treatment groups at 100 days post injection. The mechanism of the observed transient immunosuppression induced by MC appears to be related to an early toxic effect on large granular lymphocytes (LGL) which was decreased at 10 days and again at 100 days in tumor-bearing mice. Although MC did not appear to exert an effect on effector:target cell conjugate formation, an early suppression in the lytic activity of LGL, may have predisposed the animal to malignant transformation of susceptible cells at the site of MC injection.

Dietary fat and neoplasia--the role of net energy in enhancement of carcinogenesis: effects of fat and calories on the immune system

The mechanism by which carcinogenesis is enhanced by dietary fat is not understood. We know that a minimum level of essential fatty acids (EFA) is necessary for mammary tumor development and that this level probably exceeds the normal requirements of rats. Once the minimum level of EFA has been supplied, the calorie contribution of dietary fat may account for its enhancement of carcinogenesis. In this regard, we must recognize that the efficiency with which dietary energy is utilized is known to increase as the fat content of the diet is raised. Hence even when fed isocalorically to low fat diets, high fat diets will provide more net energy. Modulation of host immunity has been proposed as a mechanism of action of both fat and calorie intake on neoplasia. We review the literature examining the effects of fat and calories on the cell-mediated immune system, that arm of the immune system most directly responsible for the killing of neoplastic cells.

Polymorphic radiation sensitivity of human natural killer activity: possible role of DNA strand breakage

Natural killer (NK) activity of human mononuclear cells is sensitive to inhibition by radiation, under the control of polymorphic X linked genes. In order to define the mechanism of this inhibition, we have evaluated the ability of treatments known to damage DNA to inhibit NK activity. The alkylating agents streptozotocin (SZ) and N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) were potent inhibitors of NK activity. Further, a specific competitive inhibitor of adenosine diphosphoribosyl polymerase (ADPRP), 3-aminobenzamide, was able to prevent inhibition by gamma-radiation, UV radiation, and the two alkylating drugs, SZ and MNNG, suggesting the ADPRP, known to be activated by DNA strand breakage, mediates the inhibition by these treatments. NK activity of radioresistant subjects was somewhat more resistant to inhibition by SZ or UVR when compared to radiosensitive NK activity but neither of these treatments gave the clear phenotypic distinction of gamma-radiation, suggesting that chemical strand breakage does not precisely model gamma-radiation and also that the mechanism of UVR inhibition may differ from that of gamma-radiation. These results indicate a role for activation of ADPRP in the inhibitory effect of UV and gamma-radiation on human NK activity and suggest that the biochemical basis for polymorphism in the sensitivity of NK activity to gamma-radiation will be found in the sensitivity to ADPRP activation or the level of activation of this enzyme, known to be the key to DNA repair.

Effects of protein depletion on NK cell cytotoxicity and bone marrow cellularity

Tumor bearing patients have repeatedly been shown to develop states of protein (PD). PD has frequently been associated with depression of acquired immunity. In contrast, little is known about the effects of PD on natural killer (NK) cell cytotoxicity and on bone marrow cellularity and how modulation of these parameters by maleic anhydride divinyl ether copolymer (MVE-2) would be affected. BALB/c mice 6-10 weeks old were fed normal diets (18% protein) (ND mice) or protein deficient isocaloric diets (PD mice) for 35 days. On days 5, 9, 15, 23, and 35 assays were performed. Three days prior to each assay day, some groups received MVE-2 i.p. In PD mice spontaneous NK activity was reduced by some 80%. After MVE-2 the levels only rose to half the amount of activity of ND mice, although in both groups an increase of NK activity took place. BMC levels of PD mice were also strongly decreased. After MVE-2, increases of BMC in PD mice were quite weak and did not reach the level of normal unstimulated BMC. In PD mice we found body weight loss of 46%, reduction in albumin and total protein of 22% and complete disappearance of prealbumin after 5 days of diets. Preliminary results indicate that repletion with amino acids (NeoAminomel L12.5 o.K.H. Salvia, Boehringer Mannheim Co.) is able restore NK activities and BMC levels.

Natural killer-mediated lysis of normal and malignant target cells, and its regulation by monocytes

After depletion of monocytes, natural killer (NK) cells were partially purified from peripheral blood by Percoll density gradient sedimentation. The NK cells were then cultured for 1 d and assayed for their cytotoxicity against various types of normal and malignant target cells. All types of target cells tested were found to be susceptible to NK cells. The susceptible targets were autologous T and B lymphocytes, mitogen-induced T and B blasts, monocytes, large granular lymphocytes, autologous or allogeneic lymphoma and leukemia cells isolated from patients, and cultured cell lines, including those resistant to interferon-activated lymphocytes. Such a broad spectrum of cytotoxicity was demonstrated in 1 d of culture, and freshly prepared NK cells were not cytotoxic, or, if anything, were less cytotoxic. Monocytes and their supernatants, added throughout the course of culture, markedly inhibited the development of their cytotoxicity. These results may suggest that, although NK cells having ability to lyse autologous normal and malignant target cells are present in vivo, their lytic activity is regulated by coexisting monocytes.

Spontaneous and induced primary oncogenesis in natural killer (NK)-cell-deficient beige mutant mice

Spontaneous tumor development and primary oncogenesis were compared in a large number of NK4-deficient, homozygous C57Bl/6-bg/bg mice and their NK normal, heterozygous +/bg littermate controls. In a group of 167 retired breeders followed for spontaneous tumors, the probability of survival for mice eventually dying with a tumor was greater for the NK-competent, +/bg than for the NK-deficient, homozygous C57BL/6-bg/bg mice (p = 0.0019), although the higher overall incidence of tumors in the bg/bg group (48%) was not significantly different from that in the +/bg group (37%). In the bg/bg group the incidence of tumor death appeared to increase relatively sharply in the 25- to 29-month age bracket compared to the fairly regular increase in incidence observed in the +/bg group. All the spontaneous tumors except 2 (discovered in +/bg mice) were classified histologically as widely disseminated malignant lymphomas. The other two were one squamous-cell carcinoma and one sarcoma. A total of 73 bg/bg mice injected s.c. with benzo[alpha]pyrene (BP) had a higher overall incidence of tumors (81%) (rhabdomyosarcomas) than 138 +/bg mice (64%) and in the largest group (0.3 mg, n = 85) the bg/bg group developed tumors, at a higher incidence (p = 0.01) and with a shorter latency (p = 0.025) than the +/bg group. On the other hand, mice injected with dimethylbenzanthracene or given 4 weekly doses of 160 rads of gamma irradiation showed no difference in overall tumor incidence. In addition, mice injected with various doses of DMBA-induced murine leukemia virus (DMBA-LV) also showed no significant difference in tumor incidence. Others have reported that some of these treatments (DMBA, split-dose irradiation) cause profound NK suppression, thereby reducing NK differences between the two groups of mice. These results suggest that a partial NK impairment in beige mutant mice early in life may lead to significantly greater rates of death with spontaneous malignant tumors late in life. Some primary oncogenesis treatments (BP) but not others (DMBA, split-dose irradiation, leukemia viruses) cause tumors with a greater incidence and shorter latency in beige mice. The results suggest, but do not prove, that NK cells play a role in surveillance against spontaneously arising, and possibly some types of carcinogen-induced, tumors.

Modulation of human natural killer cell activity by recombinant human interleukin 2

Recombinant human IL-2, secreted by yeast harboring a plasmid containing a synthetic IL-2 gene, is biologically active in augmenting human natural killer (NK) cell activity. A dose-dependent linear stimulation of NK activity was obtained against the chronic myelogenous leukemia cell line K562 over the range 3 to 300 units/ml of IL-2. Enhancement of NK activity was similarly demonstrable against the less NK-sensitive carcinoma cell lines LoVo and SKOSC. IL-2 could also be demonstrated to augment antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against SKOSC targets. IL-2 responsiveness segregated with a non-E-rosetting fraction comprising 11% of postfractionation lymphocytes and containing 94% of the recoverable NK activity, suggesting that IL-2 might operate directly upon the NK cell rather than through an accessory cell. This is believed to be the first demonstration of NK stimulatory activity by the product of a totally synthetic human IL-2 gene. The availability, purity, and NK-enhancing properties of the recombinant IL-2 make it a potentially important agent for clinical trial.

Modulation of human natural killer cell activity by recombinant human interleukin 2

Recombinant human IL-2, secreted by yeast harboring a plasmid containing a synthetic IL-2 gene, is biologically active in augmenting human natural killer (NK) cell activity. A dose-dependent linear stimulation of NK activity was obtained against the chronic myelogenous leukemia cell line K562 over the range of 3 to 300 units/ml of IL-2. Enhancement of NK activity was similarly demonstrable against the less NK-sensitive carcinoma cell lines LoVo and SKOSC. IL-2 could also be demonstrated to augment antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against SKOSC targets. IL-2 responsiveness segregated with a non-E-rosetting fraction comprising 11% of postfractionation lymphocytes, and containing 94% of the recoverable NK activity, suggesting that IL-2 might operate directly upon the NK cell rather than through an accessory cell. This is believed to be the first demonstration of NK stimulatory activity by the product of a totally synthetic human IL-2 gene. The availability, purity, and NK-enhancing properties of the recombinant IL-2 make it a potentially important agent for clinical trial.

Natural killer cells

It is proposed that this article will encompass a review of primarily the human natural killer cell. The following parameters of the human natural killer (NK) cell will be reviewed: its ontogeny; surface membrane characteristics including monoclonal antibody reactivity, cell lineage, the natural killer sensitive targets, and the proposed mechanism of action of natural killer cells cytotoxicity against these NK sensitive targets; the status of natural killer cell in relationship to clinical disease; the alteration of natural killer cells both in vitro and in vivo; and finally postulate relevance of the natural killer cell in context of the evolution or pathophysiology of human disease. There will be an attempt through this review to encompass the more recent publications that pertain to the various sections.

Evaluation of in vivo and in vitro effectivity of immune defense against a spontaneously arising, nonlymphoid rat tumor. I. Analysis of natural immune defense

Possible mechanisms of natural defense against a nonimmunogenic, nonlymphoid rat tumor were evaluated in vitro and examined for effectivity in vivo, using BSp6S, the subcutaneously grown transplantation line of a spontaneously arising fibrosarcoma in the BDX rat strain, which is highly susceptible to natural killer (NK) cells and macrophages (Mø). The role of nonspecific immune defense in vivo was demonstrated by eliminating NK cells by irradiation and Mø by silica treatment. Especially after depletion of NK cells a significant acceleration of tumor growth and a reduction in the number of cells required for tumor takes was observed. Activation of Mø by Corynebacterium parvum (CP) did lead to retardation of tumor growth; prevention of tumor growth was only achieved after inoculation of a marginal dose of tumor cells. Activation of NK cells was of minor influence. It is concluded that NK cells and Mø are the main influences on survival time, the effectiveness of NK cells being limited to early periods of tumor growth.

Natural killer cell activity after open-heart surgery

We studied the effects of elective open-heart surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass on peripheral blood natural killer (NK) cell activity in 12 patients with heart disease. Separated mononuclear cells from patients and control cells taken from healthy volunteers were incubated in microtiter plates for 24 h with 3H-thymidine-labelled K 562 cells as target cells. In this test system, higher counts per minute (cpm) values represent a greater number of surviving target cells and thus weaker NK activity. Results of cultures prepared from blood samples taken preoperatively were compared with those taken 2, 7 and 14 days postoperatively. NK cell activity was depressed (P less than 0.01) for 2 days after surgery. NK cell activity in the control samples did not change significantly. The results show an impairment of NK cell activity immediately after open-heart surgery.