New insights into the photoswitching mechanisms of normal dithienylethenes

Predictive Guidelines for Electrocyclization of Dithienylethenes

Molecular photoswitches undergo a structural transformation upon photoexcitation to interconvert between two or more stable forms. In some cases, the structural rearrangement involves the transition between ring-open and ring-closed forms. In this work, we develop simple guidelines for the design of organic molecules able to undergo photochemical electrocyclization, using electronic structure calculations on dithienylethene (DTE)-based compounds. We conclude that the ability to photocyclize can be predicted from the localization and symmetry of frontier molecular orbitals. These ideas are based on the Woodward-Hoffmann rules but go beyond them, allowing us to address a more general family of chromophores. Our methodology has been experimentally validated in a novel series of quinoline-based DTEs, where the ability for photocyclization depends on specific chemical modifications. We use the DTE scaffold as the workhorse model in our study; however, these simple yet powerful guidelines are expected to be generally valid to guide the design of other diarylethenes.

New insights into the photocyclization reaction of a popular diarylethene switch: a nonadiabatic molecular dynamics study

Diarylethene (DAE) molecular switches have continued to attract the attention of researchers for over 20 years. Their remarkable photophysical properties endow them with countless applications in photonics and molecular technologies. However, despite extensive experimental and theoretical research, the mechanism of DAE photoswitching is not yet fully rationalized. In this work, we investigate the ring closure dynamics of a popular DAE switch, 1,2-bis(3-methyl-5-phenyl-2 thienyl)perfluorocyclopentene (PT), using nonadiabatic molecular dynamics (NAMD) simulations. Employing the fewest switches surface hopping protocol, along with the semi-empirical multireference ODM2/MRCI-SD method, we investigate possible reaction pathways for this photoprocess, as well as their timescales and resulting photoproducts. Furthermore, using a dynamic configuration-space sampling procedure, we elucidate the role of triplet states in the photocyclization of PT, supporting available experimental data for the closely related DMPT molecule, which indicate an ultrafast intersystem crossing (ISC) transition competing with the singlet-driven photoswitching reaction. Our findings not only corroborate experimental studies on DAE switches, but also provide new mechanistic insights into the potential use in the rational design of DAE switches tailored for specific technological applications.

Light-Induced Dyotropic Rearrangement of Diarylethenes: Scope, Mechanism, and Prospects

Irreversible two-photon photorearrangement of 1,2-diarylethenes is a unique process providing access to complex 2a1 ,5a-dihydro-5,6-dithiaacenaphthylene (DDA) heterocyclic core. This reaction was serendipitously discovered during studies on photoswitchable diarylethenes and was initially considered as a highly undesired process. However, in recent years, it has been recognized as an efficient photochemical reaction, interesting by itself and as a promising synthetic method for the synthesis of challenging molecules. Herein, we discuss the state-of-the-art in studies on this notable process.

Tuning the photochemical ring-closing reaction efficiency in diarylethene-based photoswitches through engineering of internal charge transfer

The photochemical quantum yield is one of the key features for a photoswitch and its tuning is challenging. In an attempt to tackle this issue within the popular diarylethene-based switches, we have explored the potential to use internal charge transfer (CT), a readily controllable parameter, for an effective modulation of the photocyclization quantum yield. For this, a homogeneous family of terarylenes, a sub-class of diarylethenes, with different CT characters, but the same photochromic core was designed and its photochromic properties were fully investigated. A clear correlation was found between the cyclization quantum yield and the CT character of the switch. More precisely, almost linear relationships were established between the ring-closing quantum yield and (i) the electron density variation accompanying the S₀ → S₁ transition and (ii) the percentage of LUMO on the reactive carbon atoms. Such a correlation was rationalized by a joint spectroscopic analysis and theoretical modelling of both ground and first excited states, introducing the concept of "early" or "late" photochromes. Encouragingly, such a potentally predictive model also seemed relevant when applied to some other diarylethene-based switches reported in the literature.

Photorelease Reaction Mechanism Study of a Diarylethene Caged Dual Functions Compound

Femtosecond transient absorption, nanosecond transient absorption, and nanosecond resonance Raman spectroscopy techniques coupled with density functional theory calculations were performed to unravel the photocyclization and photorelease mechanisms of a diarylethene based compound (1o) containing two caged groups (OMe and OAc). Since the ground state parallel (P) conformer of 1o with a large dipole moment is stable in DMSO, the fs-TA transformations observed for 1o in DMSO mainly have contributions from the P conformer, which undergoes an intersystem crossing to generate a corresponding triplet state species. In a less polar solvent like 1,4-dioxane, in addition to the P path behavior of 1o, an antiparallel (AP) conformer can also take place to give a photocyclization reaction from the Franck-Condon state and finally give a deprotection via this pathway. This work provides a deeper understanding for these reactions, which not only facilitate the applications of diarylethene compounds but also help for the future design of functionalized diarylethene derivatives for particular applications.

A photo-switchable molecular capsule: sequential photoinduced processes

The metastable trilacunary heteropolyoxomolybdate [PMo₉O₃₁(py)₃]^3- - {PMo₉}; py = pyridine) and the ditopic pyridyl bearing diarylethene (DAE) (C₂₅H₁₆N₂F₆S₂) self-assemble via a facile ligand replacement methodology to yield the photo-active molecular capsule [(PMo₉O₃₁)₂(DAE)₃]^6-. The spatial arrangement and conformation of the three DAE ligands are directed by the surface chemistry of the molecular metal oxide precursor with exclusive ligation of the photo-active antiparallel rotamer to the polyoxometalate (POM) while the integrity of the assembly in solution has been verified by a suite of spectroscopic techniques. Electrocyclisation of the three DAEs occurs sequentially and has been investigated using a combination of steady-state and time-resolved spectroscopies with the discovery of a photochemical cascade whereby rapid photoinduced ring closure is followed by electron transfer from the ring-closed DAE to the POM in the latent donor-acceptor system on subsequent excitation. This interpretation is also supported by computational and detailed spectroelectrochemical analysis. Ring-closing quantum yields were also determined using a custom quantum yield determination setup (QYDS), providing insight into the impact of POM coordination on these processes.

Photo-induced 6π-electrocyclisation and cycloreversion of isolated dithienylethene anions

The diarylethene chromophore is commonly used in light-triggered molecular switches. The chromophore undergoes reversible 6π-electrocyclisation (ring closing) and cycloreversion (ring opening) reactions upon exposure to UV and visible light, respectively, providing bidirectional photoswitching. Here, we investigate the gas-phase photoisomerisation of meta- (m) and para- (p) substituted dithienylethene carboxylate anions (DTE^-) using tandem ion mobility mass spectrometry coupled with laser excitation. The ring-closed forms of p-DTE^- and m-DTE^- are found to undergo cycloreversion in the gas phase with maximum responses associated with bands in the visible (λ_max ≈ 600 nm) and the ultraviolet (λ_max ≈ 360 nm). The ring-open p-DTE^- isomer undergoes 6π-electrocyclisation in the ultraviolet region at wavelengths shorter than 350 nm, whereas no evidence is found for the corresponding electrocyclisation of ring-open m-DTE^-, a situation attributed to the fact that the antiparallel geometry required for electrocyclisation of m-DTE^- is energetically disfavoured. This highlights the influence of the carboxylate substitution position on the photochemical properties of DTE molecules. We find no evidence for the formation in the gas phase of the undesirable cyclic byproduct, which causes fatigue of DTE photoswitches in solution.

Excited state dynamics of normal dithienylethene molecules either isolated or deposited on an argon cluster

Real-time dynamics of the electronically excited open-ring isomer of 1,2-bis(2-methylbenzo[b]thiophen-3-yl)perfluorocyclopentene (BTF6) and 1,2-bis(2,4-dimethyl-5-phenyl-3-thienyl)perfluorocyclopentene (PTF6) molecules was investigated using a set-up that associates a molecular beam, femtosecond lasers and velocity map imaging. The molecules were either free in the gas phase or bound to an argon cluster. DFT and TDDFT calculations were performed on BTF6. The calculated vertical excitation energies indicate an excitation by the pump laser towards a superposition of S₅ and S₆ states. The free molecule dynamics was found to follow a three wavepacket model. One describes the parallel conformer (P) of these molecules. It is unreactive with respect to the ring closure reaction which is responsible for the photochromic property of these molecules. It has no observable decay at the experiment time scale (up to 350 ps). The other two wavepackets describe the reactive antiparallel conformer (AP). They are formed by an early splitting of the wavepacket that was launched initially by the pump laser. They can be considered as generated by excitation of different, essentially uncoupled, deformation modes. They subsequently evolve along independent pathways. One is directed ballistically towards a conical intersection (CI) and decays through the CI to a potential energy surface where it can no longer be detected. The other fraction of the wavepacket decays also towards undetected states but in this case the driving mechanism is a non-adiabatic electronic relaxation within a potential well of the energy surfaces where it was launched. When BTF6 and PTF6 molecules are bound to an argon cluster, the same three wavepacket model applies. The vibronic relaxation timespan is enhanced by a factor 5 and a larger fraction of AP conformers follows this pathway. In contrast, the time constant associated with the ballistic movement is enhanced by only a factor of 2.

Future-Oriented Advanced Diarylethene Photoswitches: From Molecular Design to Spontaneous Assembly Systems

Diarylethene (DAE) photoswitch is a new and promising family of photochromic molecules and has shown superior performance as a smart trigger in stimulus-responsive materials. During the past few decades, the DAE family has achieved a leap from simple molecules to functional molecules and developed toward validity as a universal switching building block. In recent years, the introduction of DAE into an assembly system has been an attractive strategy that enables the photochromic behavior of the building blocks to be manifested at the level of the entire system, beyond the DAE unit itself. This assembly-based strategy will bring many unexpected results that promote the design and manufacture of a new generation of advanced materials. Here, recent advances in the design and fabrication of diarylethene as a trigger in materials science, chemistry, and biomedicine are reviewed.

Molecular photoswitches in aqueous environments

Molecular photoswitches enable dynamic control of processes with high spatiotemporal precision, using light as external stimulus, and hence are ideal tools for different research areas spanning from chemical biology to smart materials. Photoswitches are typically organic molecules that feature extended aromatic systems to make them responsive to (visible) light. However, this renders them inherently lipophilic, while water-solubility is of crucial importance to apply photoswitchable organic molecules in biological systems, like in the rapidly emerging field of photopharmacology. Several strategies for solubilizing organic molecules in water are known, but there are not yet clear rules for applying them to photoswitchable molecules. Importantly, rendering photoswitches water-soluble has a serious impact on both their photophysical and biological properties, which must be taken into consideration when designing new systems. Altogether, these aspects pose considerable challenges for successfully applying molecular photoswitches in aqueous systems, and in particular in biologically relevant media. In this review, we focus on fully water-soluble photoswitches, such as those used in biological environments, in both in vitro and in vivo studies. We discuss the design principles and prospects for water-soluble photoswitches to inspire and enable their future applications.

"On-The-Fly" Non-Adiabatic Dynamics Simulations on Photoinduced Ring-Closing Reaction of a Nucleoside-Based Diarylethene Photoswitch

Nucleoside-based diarylethenes are emerging as an especial class of photochromic compounds that have potential applications in regulating biological systems using noninvasive light with high spatio-temporal resolution. However, relevant microscopic photochromic mechanisms at atomic level of these novel diarylethenes remain to be explored. Herein, we have employed static electronic structure calculations (MS-CASPT2//M06-2X, MS-CASPT2//SA-CASSCF) in combination with non-adiabatic dynamics simulations to explore the related photoinduced ring-closing reaction of a typical nucleoside-based diarylethene photoswitch, namely, PS-IV. Upon excitation with UV light, the open form PS-IV can be excited to a spectroscopically bright S₁ state. After that, the molecule relaxes to the conical intersection region within 150 fs according to the barrierless relaxed scan of the C1–C6 bond, which is followed by an immediate deactivation to the ground state. The conical intersection structure is very similar to the ground state transition state structure which connects the open and closed forms of PS-IV, and therefore plays a crucial role in the photochromism of PS-IV. Besides, after analyzing the hopping structures, we conclude that the ring closing reaction cannot complete in the S₁ state alone since all the C1–C6 distances of the hopping structures are larger than 2.00 Å. Once hopping to the ground state, the molecules either return to the original open form of PS-IV or produce the closed form of PS-IV within 100 fs, and the ring closing quantum yield is estimated to be 56%. Our present work not only elucidates the ultrafast photoinduced pericyclic reaction of the nucleoside-based diarylethene PS-IV, but can also be helpful for the future design of novel nucleoside-based diarylethenes with better performance.

Thermodynamic driving forces of guest confinement in a photoswitchable cage

Photoswitchable cages that confine small guest molecules inside their cavities offer a way to control the binding/unbinding process through irradiation with light of different wavelengths. However, detailed characterization of the structural and thermodynamic consequences of photoswitching is very challenging to achieve by experiments alone. Thus, all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were carried out to gain insight into the relationship between the structure and binding affinity. Binding free energies of the B₁₂F₁₂^2- guest were obtained for all photochemically accessible forms of a photoswitchable dithienylethene (DTE) based coordination cage. The MD simulations show that successive photo-induced closure of the four individual DTE ligands that form the cage gradually decreases the binding affinity. Closure of the first ligand significantly lowers the unbinding barrier and the binding free energy, and therefore favours guest unbinding both kinetically and thermodynamically. The analysis of different enthalpy contributions to the free energy shows that binding is enthalpically unfavourable and thus is an entropy-driven process, in agreement with the experimental data. Separating the enthalpy into the contributions from electrostatic, van der Waals, and bonded interactions in the force field shows that the unfavourable binding enthalpy is due to the bonded interactions being more favourable in the dissociated state, suggesting the presence of structural strain in the bound complex. Thus, the simulations provide microscopic explanations for the experimental findings and provide a possible route towards the targeted design of switchable nanocontainers with modified binding properties.

Regulation of an Ambient-Light-Induced Photocyclization Pathway (Norrish-Yang Versus 6π) by Substituent Choice

Photocyclization, irrespective of whether multiple steps (e.g., Norrish-Yang cyclization) or a single concerted step (e.g., 6π photocyclization) are involved, is an intramolecular photochemical process resulting in the formation of one new single bond to afford a ring system. In particular, visible-light-induced photocyclization offers a green and sustainable route to organic cyclic compounds that are difficult to access by thermal reactions. Herein, we describe the ambient light-induced intramolecular photocyclization of a series of donor/acceptor chromophores 1 d-3 d containing two types of photoresponsive motifs, namely an electron-deficient BF₂ -chelated ketone fused with an electron-rich thiophene, and probe the solution-phase and solid-state photochromic performance of these compounds. The results reveal that simple variation of R substituents on the diaryl moiety allows one to control the intramolecular photocyclization mechanism with high photochemical selectivity, e.g., under ambient light, methyl-substituted 1 d and 2 d undergo reversible 6π photocyclization, whereas ethyl-substituted 3 d exclusively undergoes irreversible Norrish-Yang photocyclization. Single-crystal X-ray analysis of Norrish-Yang cyclization products reveals the formation of four pairs of conformational enantiomers differing in the dihedral angle between benzothiophene and the BF₂ core, namely (±)N-3 d@68°, (±)N-3 d@-77°, (±)N-3 d@-78°, and (±)N-3 d@-102°. The UV/Vis absorption spectra of 1 d-3 d cover a broad visible-light region (380-572 nm), while DFT and TD-DFT calculations reveal that absorption in this region is dominated by the charge-transfer (CT) transition from the thiophene-centered HOMO to the LUMO of the electron-deficient π-conjugated BF₂ -chelated unit and the n→π* and π→π* transitions within the latter unit. The spatial separation of the HOMO and LUMO of these dyes promotes triplet-state generation and self-photosensitizes intramolecular photocyclization in the visible-light region. Three-dimensional time-resolved and steady-state emission spectra of 3 d show that the Norrish-Yang photocyclization takes place within milliseconds with excellent conversion efficiency (96 %).

Mechanistic Insights into the Triplet Sensitized Photochromism of Diarylethenes

Operating photoswitchable molecules repetitively and reliably is crucial for most of their applications, in particular in (opto)electronic devices, and related to reversibility and fatigue resistance, which both critically depend on the photoisomerization mechanism defined by the substitution pattern. Two diarylethene photoswitches bearing biacetyl triplet sensitizers either at the periphery or at the core were investigated using both stationary as well as transient UV/Vis absorption spectroscopy ranging from the femtosecond to the microsecond time scale. The diarylethene with two biacetyl moieties at the periphery is switching predominantly from the triplet excited state, giving rise to an enhanced fatigue resistance. In contrast, the diarylethene bearing one diketone at the photoreactive inner carbon atom cyclizes from the singlet excited state and shows significantly higher quantum yields for both cyclization and cycloreversion.

Understanding the properties of dithienylethenes functionalized for supramolecular self-assembly: a molecular modeling study

A dithienylethene (DTE) photochromic compound functionalized by ureidopyrimidinone (UPy) quadruple hydrogen bonding blocks was synthesized by Takeshita and coworkers [Takeshita et al., Chem. Commun., 2005, 761] in order to form a light-responsive supramolecular self-assembling system. In solution, the formation of supramolecular assemblies was only observed for one DTE isomer, namely the closed-form isomer. To rationalize this experimental finding, with the help of Molecular Dynamics (MD) and (time-dependent) DFT calculations, the behaviour of open-form and closed-form monomers, dimers, hexamers and π-stacked dimers in solution is investigated. Our simulations show that, for the open-form oligomers, the progression of the supramolecular assembly is hindered due to (i) the possible formation of a very stable cyclic dimer for the open-form parallel isomer, (ii) the relative flexibility of the open-form oligomers compared to their closed-form counterparts, and (iii) the possible existence of π-stacked dimers that constitute bottlenecks blocking the progression of the supramolecular self-assembly.

Ultrafast ring closing of a diarylethene-based photoswitchable nucleoside

Deoxyuridine nucleosides embodied into diarylethenes form an especial class of photoswitchable compounds that are designed to stack and pair with DNA bases. The molecular geometry can be switched between "open" and "closed" isomers by a pericyclic reaction that affects the stability of the surrounding double helix. This potentially enables light-induced control of DNA hybridization at microscopic resolution. Despite its importance for the optimization of DNA photoswitches, the ultrafast photoisomerization mechanism of these diarylethenes is still not well understood. In this work, femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy is applied to study the ring closing reaction upon UV excitation with 45 fs pulses. Excited-state absorption decays rapidly and gives rise to the UV-Vis difference spectrum of the "closed" form within ≈15 ps. Time constants of 0.09, 0.49 and 6.6 ps characterize the multimodal dynamics, where a swift recurrence in the signal anisotropy indicates transient population of the intermediate 21A-like state.

Unraveling ultrafast dynamics of the photoswitchable bridged dithienylethenes under structural constraints

The excited state dynamics of constrained photochromic benzodithienylethenes were addressed by considering the bridging with polyether chains (from x = 4 to 6 units) at the ortho and meta positions of the aryl group, named DTE-o_x and DTE-m_x, via time-resolved absorption spectroscopy supported with (TD)-DFT calculations. The photochromic parameters and geometrical structures of these series are discussed. A novel photocyclization pathway via a triplet state, evidenced recently (Hamdi et al., Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2016, 18, 28091-28100), is largely dependent on the length and the position of the polyether chain. For the first time, by comparing the two series, we revealed, for the DTE-o_x series, an interconversion not only in the ground state but also between the triplet states of the anti-parallel and parallel open form conformers.