Bi(III) Binding Stoichiometry and Domain-Specificity Differences Between Apo and Zn(II)-bound Human Metallothionein 1a

Bismuth is a xenobiotic metal with a high affinity to sulfur that is used in a variety of therapeutic applications. Bi(III) induces the cysteine-rich metallothionein (MT), a protein known to form two-domain cluster structures with certain metals such as Zn(II), Cd(II), or Cu(I). The binding of Bi(III) to MTs has been previously studied, but there are conflicting reports on the stoichiometry and binding pathway, which appear to be highly dependent on pH and initial metal-loading status of the MT. Additionally, domain specificity has not been thoroughly investigated. In this paper, ESI-MS was used to determine the binding constants of [Bi(EDTA)]- binding to apo-MT1a and its individual αMT fragment. The results were compared to previous experiments using βMT1a and βαMT3. Domain specificity was investigated using proteolysis methods and the initial cooperatively formed Bi2MT was found to bind to cysteines that spanned across the traditional metal binding domain regions. Titrations of [Bi(EDTA)]- into Zn7MT were performed and were found to result in a maximum stoichiometry of Bi7MT, contrasting the Bi6MT formed when [Bi(EDTA)]- was added to apo-MT. These results show that the initial structure of the apo-MT determines the stoichiometry of new incoming metals and explains the previously observed differences in stoichiometry.

ESI-MS analysis of Cu(I) binding to apo and Zn7 human metallothionein 1A, 2, and 3 identifies the formation of a similar series of metallated species with no individual isoform optimization for Cu(I)

Metallothioneins (MTs) are cysteine-rich proteins involved in metal homeostasis, heavy metal detoxification, and protection against oxidative stress. Whether the four mammalian MT isoforms exhibit different metal binding properties is not clear. In this paper, the Cu(I) binding properties of the apo MT1A, apo MT2, and apo MT3 are compared and the relative Cu(I) binding affinities are reported. In all three isoforms, Cu4, Cu6, and Cu10 species form cooperatively, and MT1A and MT2 also form a Cu13 species. The Cu(I) binding properties of Zn7-MT1A, Zn7-MT2, and Zn7-MT3 are compared systematically using isotopically pure 63Cu(I) and 68Zn(II). The species formed in each MT isoform were detected through electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry and further characterized using room temperature phosphorescence spectroscopy. The mixed metal Cu, Zn species forming in MT1A, MT2, and MT3 have similar stoichiometries and their emission spectral properties indicate that analogous clusters form in the three isoforms. Three parallel metallation pathways have been proposed through analysis of the detailed Cu, Zn speciation in MT1A, MT2, and MT3. Pathway ① results in Cu5Zn5-MT and Cu9Zn3-MT. Pathway ② involves Cu6Zn4-MT and Cu10Zn2-MT. Pathway ③ includes Cu8Zn4-MT. Speciation analysis indicates that Pathway ② is the preferred pathway for MT2. This is also evident in the phosphorescence spectra with the 750 nm emission from Cu6Zn4-MT being most prominent in MT2. We see no evidence for different MT isoforms being optimized or exhibiting preferences for certain metals. We discuss the probable stoichiometry for MTs in vivo based on the in vitro determined binding constants.

Supermetalation of Cd-MT3 beyond the two-domain model

The flexibility of mammalian metallothioneins (MTs) has contributed to the difficulty in obtaining structural information for this family of metalloproteins that bind divalent metals with its twenty cysteines. While the two-domain structure for Cd7MT is well-established as a Cd4S11 and Cd3S9, a third structure has been reported when 8 Cd(II) ions bind to MT1. Isoform 3 of the MT family, MT3, has been of interest to the research community since its isolation as a growth inhibitory factor isolated in brain tissue, and has since been noted as a prominent participant in the mediation of neurodegenerative diseases and regular brain development. The differences between MT3 and the other isoforms of MT include an additional hexapeptide insertion of acidic residues in the α domain as well as the introduction of two prolines in the β domain. It is unclear whether these changes impact the metalation properties of MT3. We report the formation of a Cd8MT3 species is characterized by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and UV-visible absorption spectroscopy. We report that the spectroscopic properties of this supermetalated Cd8MT3 are similar to those of the supermetalated Cd8MT1, with a clear indication of changes in structure from "fully-metalated" Cd7MT3 to supermetalated Cd8MT3 from circular dichroism spectra and both 1D 113Cd and 2D 1H-113Cd HSQC NMR spectra. We conclude that the metalation properties are not impacted significantly due to the amino acid changes in MT3, and that the cysteinyl thiols are the key players in determining the capacity of metal-binding and the structure of metal-thiolate clusters.

Copper trafficking systems in cells: insights into coordination chemistry and toxicity

Transition metal ions, such as copper, are indispensable components in the biological system. Copper ions which primarily exist in two major oxidation states Cu(I) and Cu(II) play crucial roles in various cellular processes including antioxidant defense, biosynthesis of neurotransmitters, and energy metabolism, owing to their inherent redox activity. The disturbance in copper homeostasis can contribute to the development of copper metabolism disorders, cancer, and neurodegenerative diseases, highlighting the significance of understanding the copper trafficking system in cellular environments. This review aims to offer a comprehensive overview of copper homeostatic machinery, with an emphasis on the coordination chemistry of copper transporters and trafficking proteins. While copper chaperones and the corresponding metalloenzymes are thoroughly discussed, we also explore the potential existence of low-molecular-mass metal complexes within cellular systems. Furthermore, we summarize the toxicity mechanisms originating from copper deficiency or accumulation, which include the dysregulation of oxidative stress, signaling pathways, signal transduction, and amyloidosis. This perspective review delves into the current knowledge regarding the intricate aspects of the copper trafficking system, providing valuable insights into potential treatment strategies from the standpoint of bioinorganic chemistry.

Metallothionein-3: 63 Cu(I) binds to human 68 Zn7 -βα MT3 with no preference for Cu4 -β cluster formation

Human metallothioneins (MTs) are involved in binding the essential elements, Cu(I) and Zn(II), and the toxic element, Cd(II), in metal-thiolate clusters using 20 reduced cysteines. The brain-specific MT3 binds a mixture of Cu(I) and Zn(II) in vivo. Its metallation properties are critically important because of potential connections between Cu, Zn and neurodegenerative diseases. We report that the use of isotopically pure 63 Cu(I) and 68 Zn(II) greatly enhances the element resolution in the ESI-mass spectral data revealing species with differing Cu:Zn ratios but the same total number of metals. Room temperature phosphorescence and circular dichroism spectral data measured in parallel with ESI-mass spectral data identified the presence of specific Cu(I)-thiolate clusters in the presence of Zn(II). A series of Cu(I)-thiolate clusters form following Cu(I) addition to apo MT3: the two main clusters that form are a Cu6 cluster in the β domain followed by a Cu4 cluster in the α domain. 63 Cu(I) addition to 68 Zn7 -MT3 results in multiple species, including clustered Cu5 Zn5 -MT3 and Cu9 Zn3 -MT3. We assign the domain location of the metals for Cu5 Zn5 -MT3 as a Cu5 Zn1 -β cluster and a Zn4 -α cluster and for Cu9 Zn3 -MT3 as a Cu6 -β cluster and a Cu3 Zn3 -α cluster. While many reports of the average MT3 metal content exist, determining the exact Cu,Zn stoichiometry has proven very difficult even with native ESI-MS. The work in this paper solves the ambiguity introduced by the overlap of the naturally abundant Cu(I) and Zn(II) isotopes. Contrary to other reports, there is no indication of a major fraction of Cu4 -β-Znn -α-MT3 forming.

Xenobiotic Bi3+ Coordination by Cysteine-Rich Metallothionein-3 Reveals a Cooperatively Formed Thiolate-Sharing Bi2S5 Cluster

The field of designing artificial metalloproteins has yet to effectively tackle the incorporation of multimetal clusters, which is a key component of natural metalloproteins, such as metallothioneins (MTs) and calmodulin. MT is a physiological, essential, cysteine-rich metalloprotein that binds to a variety of metals but is only known to form metal-thiolate clusters with Cd2+, Zn2+, and Cu+. Bismuth is a xenobiotic metal and a component of metallodrugs used to treat gastric ulcers and cancer, as well as an emerging metal used in industrial practices. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, UV-visible spectroscopy, and extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy were used to probe the Bi3+ binding site structures in apo-MT3 (brain-located MT) at pH 7.4 and 2 and provide the complete set of binding affinities. We discovered the highly cooperative formation of a novel Bi3+ species, Bi2MT3, under physiological conditions, where each Bi3+ ion is coordinated by three cysteinyl thiolates, with one of the thiolates bridging between the two Bi3+ ions. This cluster structure was associated with a strong visible region absorption band, which was disrupted by the addition of Zn2+ and reversibly disrupted by acidification and increased temperature. This is the first reported presence of bridging cysteines for a xenobiotic metal in MT3 and the Bi2MT structure is the first Bi cluster found in a metalloprotein.

Structural Characterization of Cu(I)/Zn(II)-metallothionein-3 by Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry and Top-Down Mass Spectrometry

Mammalian zinc metallothionein-3 (Zn7MT3) plays an important role in protecting against copper toxicity by scavenging free Cu(II) ions or removing Cu(II) bound to β-amyloid and α-synuclein. While previous studies reported that Zn7MT3 reacts with Cu(II) ions to form Cu(I)4Zn(II)4MT3ox containing two disulfides (ox), the precise localization of the metal ions and disulfides remained unclear. Here, we undertook comprehensive structural characterization of the metal-protein complexes formed by the reaction between Zn7MT3 and Cu(II) ions using native ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS). The complex formation mechanism was found to involve the disassembly of Zn3S9 and Zn4S11 clusters from Zn7MT3 and reassembly into Cu(I)xZn(II)yMT3ox complexes rather than simply Zn(II)-to-Cu(I) exchange. At neutral pH, the β-domain was shown to be capable of binding up to six Cu(I) ions to form Cu(I)6Zn(II)4MT3ox, although the most predominant species was the Cu(I)4Zn(II)4MT3ox complex. Under acidic conditions, four Zn(II) ions dissociate, but the Cu(I)4-thiolate cluster remains stable, highlighting the MT3 role as a Cu(II) scavenger even at lower than the cytosolic pH. IM-derived collision cross sections (CCS) reveal that Cu(I)-to-Zn(II) swap in Zn7MT3 with concomitant disulfide formation induces structural compaction and a decrease in conformational heterogeneity. Collision-induced unfolding (CIU) experiments estimated that the native-like folded Cu(I)4Zn(II)4MT3ox conformation is more stable than Zn7MT3. Native top-down MS demonstrated that the Cu(I) ions are exclusively bound to the β-domain in the Cu(I)4Zn(II)4MT3ox complex as well as the two disulfides, serving as a steric constraint for the Cu(I)4-thiolate cluster. In conclusion, this study enhances our comprehension of the structure, stability, and dynamics of Cu(I)xZn(II)yMT3ox complexes.

Arsenic binding to human metallothionein-3

Arsenic poisoning is of great concern with respect to its neurological toxicity, which is especially significant for young children. Human exposure to arsenic occurs worldwide from contaminated drinking water. In human physiology, one response to toxic metals is through coordination with the metallochaperone metallothionein (MT). Central nervous system expression of MT isoform 3 (MT3) is thought to be neuroprotective. We report for the first time on the metalation pathways of As3+ binding to apo-MT3 under physiological conditions, yielding the absolute binding constants (log Kn, n = 1-6) for each sequential As3+ binding event: 10.20, 10.02, 9.79, 9.48, 9.06, and 8.31 M-1. We report on the rate of the reaction of As3+ with apo-MT3 at pH 3.5 with rate constants (kn, n = 1-6) determined for each sequential As3+ binding event: 116.9, 101.2, 85.6, 64.0, 43.9, and 21.0 M-1 s-1. We further characterize the As3+ binding pathway to fully metalated Zn7MT3 and partially metalated Zn-MT3. As3+ binds rapidly with high binding constants under physiological conditions in a noncooperative manner, but is unable to replace the Zn2+ in fully-metalated Zn-MT3. As3+ binding to partially metalated Zn-MT3 takes place with a rearrangement of the Zn-binding profile. Our work shows that As 3+ rapidly and efficiently binds to both apo-MT3 and partially metalated Zn-MT3 at physiological pH.

An ion mobility-mass spectrometry study of copper-metallothionein-2A: binding sites and stabilities of Cu-MT and mixed metal Cu-Ag and Cu-Cd complexes

The presence of Cu, a highly redox active metal, is known to damage DNA as well as other cellular components, but the adverse effects of cellular Cu can be mitigated by metallothioneins (MT), small cysteine rich proteins that are known to bind to a broad range of metal ions. While metal ion binding has been shown to involve the cysteine thiol groups, the specific ion binding sites are controversial as are the overall structure and stability of the Cu-MT complexes. Here, we report results obtained using nano-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and ion mobility-mass spectrometry for several Cu-MT complexes and compare our results with those previously reported for Ag-MT complexes. The data include determination of the stoichiometries of the complex (Cui-MT, i = 1-19), and Cu+ ion binding sites for complexes where i = 4, 6, and 10 using bottom-up and top-down proteomics. The results show that Cu+ ions first bind to the β-domain to form Cu4MT then Cu6MT, followed by addition of four Cu+ ions to the α-domain to form a Cu10-MT complex. Stabilities of the Cui-MT (i = 4, 6 and 10) obtained using collision-induced unfolding (CIU) are reported and compared with previously reported CIU data for Ag-MT complexes. We also compare CIU data for mixed metal complexes (CuiAgj-MT, where i + j = 4 and 6 and CuiCdj, where i + j = 4 and 7). Lastly, higher order Cui-MT complexes, where i = 11-19, were also detected at higher concentrations of Cu+ ions, and the metalated product distributions observed are compared to previously reported results for Cu-MT-1A (Scheller et al., Metallomics, 2017, 9, 447-462).

63Cu(I) binding to human kidney 68Zn7-βα MT1A: determination of Cu(I)-thiolate cluster domain specificity from ESI-MS and room temperature phosphorescence spectroscopy

Mammalian metallothioneins (MTs) are important proteins in Zn(II) and Cu(I) homeostasis with the Zn(II) and Cu(I) binding to the 20 cysteines in metal-thiolate clusters. Previous electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometric (MS) analyses of Cu(I) binding to Zn7-MT were complicated by significant overlap of the natural abundance isotopic patterns for Zn(II) and Cu(I) leading to impossibly ambiguous stoichiometries. In this paper, isotopically pure 63Cu(I) and 68Zn(II) allowed determination of the specific stoichiometries in the 68 Zn,63Cu-βα MT1A species formed following the stepwise addition of 63Cu(I) to 68Zn7-βα MT1A. These species were characterized by ESI-MS and room temperature emission spectroscopy. The key species that form and their emission band centres are Zn5Cu5-βα MT1A (λ = 684 nm), Zn4Cu6-βα MT1A (λ = 750 nm), Zn3Cu9-βα MT1A (λ = 750 nm), Zn2Cu10-βα MT1A (λ = 750 nm), and Zn1Cu14-βα MT1A (λ = 634 nm). The specific domain stoichiometry of each species was determined by assessing the species forming following 63Cu(I) addition to the 68Zn3-β MT1A and 68Zn4-α MT1A domain fragments. The domain fragment emission suggests that Zn5Cu5-βα MT1A contains a Zn1Cu5-β cluster and the Zn4Cu6-βα MT1A, Zn3Cu9-βα MT1A, and Zn2Cu10-βα MT1A each contain a Cu6-β cluster. The species forming with >10 mol. eq. of 63Cu(I) in βα-MT1A exhibit emission from the Cu6-β cluster and an α domain cluster. This high emission intensity is seen at the end of the titrations of 68Zn7-βα MT1A and the 68Zn4-α MT1A domain fragment suggesting that the initial presence of the Zn(II) results in clustered Cu(I) binding in the α domain.

Metal binding and interdomain thermodynamics of mammalian metallothionein-3: enthalpically favoured Cu+ supplants entropically favoured Zn2+ to form Cu4 + clusters under physiological conditions

Metallothioneins (MTs) are a ubiquitous class of small metal-binding proteins involved in metal homeostasis and detoxification. While known for their high affinity for d¹⁰ metal ions, there is a surprising dearth of thermodynamic data on metals binding to MTs. In this study, Zn²⁺ and Cu⁺ binding to mammalian metallothionein-3 (MT-3) were quantified at pH 7.4 by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). Zn²⁺ binding was measured by chelation titrations of Zn₇MT-3, while Cu⁺ binding was measured by Zn²⁺ displacement from Zn₇MT-3 with competition from glutathione (GSH). Titrations in multiple buffers enabled a detailed analysis that yielded condition-independent values for the association constant (K) and the change in enthalpy (ΔH) and entropy (ΔS) for these metal ions binding to MT-3. Zn²⁺ was also chelated from the individual α and β domains of MT-3 to quantify the thermodynamics of inter-domain interactions in metal binding. Comparative titrations of Zn₇MT-2 with Cu⁺ revealed that both MT isoforms have similar Cu⁺ affinities and binding thermodynamics, indicating that ΔH and ΔS are determined primarily by the conserved Cys residues. Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) analysis and low temperature luminescence measurements of Cu-replete samples showed that both proteins form two Cu₄ ⁺-thiolate clusters when Cu⁺ displaces Zn²⁺ under physiological conditions. Comparison of the Zn²⁺ and Cu⁺ binding thermodynamics reveal that enthalpically-favoured Cu⁺, which forms Cu₄ ⁺-thiolate clusters, displaces the entropically-favoured Zn²⁺. These results provide a detailed thermodynamic analysis of d¹⁰ metal binding to these thiolate-rich proteins and quantitative support for, as well as molecular insight into, the role that MT-3 plays in the neuronal chemistry of copper.

The Bioinorganic Chemistry of Mammalian Metallothioneins

The functions, purposes, and roles of metallothioneins have been the subject of speculations since the discovery of the protein over 60 years ago. This article guides through the history of investigations and resolves multiple contentions by providing new interpretations of the structure-stability-function relationship. It challenges the dogma that the biologically relevant structure of the mammalian proteins is only the one determined by X-ray diffraction and NMR spectroscopy. The terms metallothionein and thionein are ambiguous and insufficient to understand biological function. The proteins need to be seen in their biological context, which limits and defines the chemistry possible. They exist in multiple forms with different degrees of metalation and types of metal ions. The homoleptic thiolate coordination of mammalian metallothioneins is important for their molecular mechanism. It endows the proteins with redox activity and a specific pH dependence of their metal affinities. The proteins, therefore, also exist in different redox states of the sulfur donor ligands. Their coordination dynamics allows a vast conformational landscape for interactions with other proteins and ligands. Many fundamental signal transduction pathways regulate the expression of the dozen of human metallothionein genes. Recent advances in understanding the control of cellular zinc and copper homeostasis are the foundation for suggesting that mammalian metallothioneins provide a highly dynamic, regulated, and uniquely biological metal buffer to control the availability, fluctuations, and signaling transients of the most competitive Zn(II) and Cu(I) ions in cellular space and time.

An Integrated Mass Spectrometry and Molecular Dynamics Simulations Approach Reveals the Spatial Organization Impact of Metal-Binding Sites on the Stability of Metal-Depleted Metallothionein-2 Species

Mammalian metallothioneins (MTs) are a group of cysteine-rich proteins that bind metal ions in two α- and β-domains and represent a major cellular Zn(II)/Cu(I) buffering system in the cell. At cellular free Zn(II) concentrations (10-11-10-9 M), MTs do not exist in fully loaded forms with seven Zn(II)-bound ions (Zn7MTs). Instead, MTs exist as partially metal-depleted species (Zn4-6MT) because their Zn(II) binding affinities are on the nano- to picomolar range comparable to the concentrations of cellular Zn(II). The mode of action of MTs remains poorly understood, and thus, the aim of this study is to characterize the mechanism of Zn(II) (un)binding to MTs, the thermodynamic properties of the Zn1-6MT2 species, and their mechanostability properties. To this end, native mass spectrometry (MS) and label-free quantitative bottom-up and top-down MS in combination with steered molecular dynamics simulations, well-tempered metadynamics (WT-MetaD), and parallel-bias WT-MetaD (amounting to 3.5 μs) were integrated to unravel the chemical coordination of Zn(II) in all Zn1-6MT2 species and to explain the differences in binding affinities of Zn(II) ions to MTs. Differences are found to be the result of the degree of water participation in MT (un)folding and the hyper-reactive character of Cys21 and Cys29 residues. The thermodynamics properties of Zn(II) (un)binding to MT2 are found to differ from those of Cd(II), justifying their distinctive roles. The potential of this integrated strategy in the investigation of numerous unexplored metalloproteins is attested by the results highlighted in the present study.

A di-Copper Peptidyl Complex Mimics the Activity of Catalase, a Key Antioxidant Metalloenzyme

Catalases (CAT) are antioxidant metalloenzymes necessary for life in oxygen-metabolizing cells to regulate H₂O₂ concentration by accelerating its dismutation. Many physiopathological situations are associated with oxidative stress resulting from H₂O₂ overproduction, during which antioxidant defenses are overwhelmed. We have used a combinatorial approach associated with an activity-based screening to discover a first peptidyl di-copper complex mimicking CAT. The complex was studied in detail and characterized for its CAT activity both in solutions and in cells using different analytical methods. The complex exhibited CAT activity in solutions and, more interestingly, on HyPer HeLa cells that possess a genetically encoded ratiometric fluorescent sensors of H₂O₂. These results highlight the efficiency of a combinatorial approach for the discovery of peptidyl complexes that exhibit catalytic activity.