Normal mice express idiotypes related to autoantibody idiotypes of lupus mice

Hematopoietic stem and multipotent progenitor cells produce IL-17, IL-21 and other cytokines in response to TLR signals associated with late apoptotic products and augment memory Th17 and Tc17 cells in the bone marrow of normal and lupus mice

We studied effects of early and late apoptotic (necroptotic) cell products, related damage associated alarmins and TLR agonists, on hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPC). Surprisingly, normal HSPC themselves produced IL-17 and IL-21 after 1½days of stimulation, and the best stimulators were TLR 7/8 agonist; HMGB1-DNA; TLR 9 agonist, and necroptotic B cells. The stimulated HSPC expressed additional cytokines/mediators, directly causing rapid expansion of IL-17(+) memory CD4 T (Th17), and CD8 T (Tc17) cells, and antigen-experienced IL-17(+) T cells with "naïve" phenotype. In lupus marrow, HSPC were spontaneously pre-stimulated by endogenous signals to produce IL-17 and IL-21. In contrast to HSPC, megakaryocyte progenitors (MKP) did not produce IL-17, and unlike HSPC, they could process and present particulate apoptotic autoantigens to augment autoimmune memory Th17 response. Thus abnormally stimulated primitive hematopoietic progenitors augment expansion of IL-17 producing immune and autoimmune memory T cells in the bone marrow, which may affect central tolerance.

T-helper cell intrinsic defects in lupus that break peripheral tolerance to nuclear autoantigens

Special populations of T helper cells drive B cells to produce IgG class switched, pathogenic autoantibodies in lupus. The major source of antigenic determinants (epitopes) that trigger interactions between lupus T and B cells is nucleosomes of apoptotic cells. These epitopes can be used for antigen-specific therapy of lupus. Secondly, the autoimmune T cells of lupus are sustained because they resist anergy and activation-induced programmed cell death by markedly upregulating cyclooxygenase (COX) 2 along with the antiapoptotic molecule c-FLIP. Only certain COX-2 inhibitors block pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibody production in lupus by causing death of autoimmune T helper cells. Hence COX-2 inhibitors may work independently of their ability to block the enzymatic function of COX-2, and structural peculiarities of these select inhibitors may lead to better drug discovery and design.

Autoreactive responses to an environmental factor. 2. Phthalate-induced anti-DNA specificity is downregulated by autoreactive cytotoxic T cells

An environmental factor (phthalate) was shown, in our previous study, to induce serum anti-DNA responses in BALB/c, NZB and lupus-prone NZB/W F1 mice. Out of such anti-phthalate responses, cross-reactive populations were identified that strongly bind phthalate, DNA, or both. A phthalate-specific BALB/c monoclonal antibody, 2C3-Ig (gamma1,kappa), showed considerable affinity for DNA and had extensive sequence homology with the heavy and light chain variable regions of a known anti-DNA immunoglobulin, BV04-01, from lupus-prone NZB/W F1 mice. This study was initiated to address how BALB/c mice, but not NZB/W F1 mice, are protected from these adverse autoreactive B cells. Using 2C3 hybridoma cells as the prototype autoreactive BALB/c B cell, we determined whether its DNA-binding monoclonal antibody would induce any regulatory cell-mediated immune responses. Synthetic idiopeptides corresponding to the heavy and light chain variable regions of 2C3-Ig were found to be effective at inducing specific effector cells in BALB/c mice, but not in lupus-prone F1 mice. The splenocytes from BALB/c mice incubated in vitro with the idiopeptides, particularly the complementarity-determining region 1 (VL1) of the 2C3-Ig light chain, showed significant proliferative and cytolytic responses. A CD8+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response was elicited that recognized the VL1 peptide presented by the Kd allele, and affected the growth of 2C3 cells. In vivo depletion of CD8+ T cells in BALB/c mice significantly decreased this CTL activity but increased the anti-DNA humoral response. These results suggest that autoreactive CTLs are induced in non-autoimmune prone mice as a mechanism to downregulate self-reactive B cells.

Autoreactive responses to an environmental factor: 1. phthalate induces antibodies exhibiting anti-DNA specificity

Environmental factors have been implicated in the induction of autoimmune disorders. We report here that a common chemical, phthalate, used widely in synthetic polymers and cosmetics induces serum anti-self DNA antibodies in BALB/c, NZB and autoimmune-prone NZB/W F1 mice. The latter group experiences a high mortality, and significantly higher anti-DNA antibody levels along with nephritis and other histopathologic changes in kidney. Comparison of amino acid sequences of an anti-phthalate BALB/c B-cell hybrid, 2C3 with the known database at the National Center for Biotechnology Information reveals a striking homology between the variable regions of 2C3-Ig (gamma1, kappa) and an anti-DNA antibody, BV04-01 (gamma2b,kappa) isolated from the lupus-prone NZB/W F1 mice. The homology is 98% for kappa light chain and 70% for gamma heavy chain. Like 2C3-Ig, BV04-01 also has specificity for d(pT)4. Furthermore, the light chains of both 2C3-Ig and BV04-01 are products of Vkappa1 gene. To understand the nature of anti-phthalate responses in general, hybridomas generated from phthalate-keyhole limpet haemocyanin-primed BALB/c splenocytes were characterized. The study identifies cross-reactive populations that strongly bind phthalate, DNA, or both. Of the 14 hybridomas evaluated, six express the same Vkappa1 gene-derived light chain as 2C3, and bind both phthalate and ds and ss-DNA. They specifically recognize the oligonucleotides, d(pT)4, and d(pT)10. Additionally, when antisera raised against idiopeptides corresponding to 2C3-Ig hypervariable regions are allowed to react with 2C3-Ig, their binding is blocked specifically by both d(pT)4 and phthalate. This study clearly demonstrates that phthalate exposure leads to activation of a significant number of autoreactive B-cells, with the consequence of a significant pathogenic progression in susceptible NZB/W F1 mice but not in non-autoimmune-prone BALB/c.

Major peptide autoepitopes for nucleosome-centered T and B cell interaction in human and murine lupus

The potential cross-reactivity of normal T and B cells to nuclear antigens is vast, probably due to their "education" by apoptotic cell antigens in generative lymphoid organs. Despite this "nucleocentric repertoire," as we call it, the peripheral immune system normally remains tolerant or ignorant of the products of apoptosis. However, the T helper (Th) cells, and also B cells of lupus, have a regulatory defect in the expression of CD40 ligand (CD40L). A sustained hyper-expression of CD40L by lupus T cells can be triggered by sub-threshold stimuli, and is associated with impaired phosphorylation of Cbl-b, a critical downregulatory molecule in T cell signal transduction. This CD40L hyper-expression abnormally prolongs co-stimulatory signals to autoimmune B cells, and it probably instigates APC (dendritic cells, resting anti-DNA B cells, and macrophages) to present apoptotic cell autoantigens in an immunogenic fashion. We have identified the dominant nucleosomal epitopes that are critical for cognate interactions between autoimmune Th cells and anti-DNA B cells in lupus. By scanning of overlapping synthetic peptides, and by mass spectrometry of naturally processed peptides, five major epitopes in nucleosomal histones were localized, namely H1'(22-42), H2B(10-33), H3(85-105), H4(16-39), and H4(71-94). The autoimmune T cells as well as B cells of lupus recognize these epitopes, and with age, autoantibodies against the peptide epitopes cross-react with nuclear autoantigens. Moreover, the peptide autoepitopes can be promiscuously presented and recognized by lupus T cells in the context of diverse MHC alleles. This cross-reactivity opens up the possibility of developing "universally" tolerogenic peptides for therapy of lupus in humans despite their MHC diversity. Indeed, tolerogenic therapy with a single histone peptide epitope can halt the progression of established glomerulonephritis in lupus-prone mice by "tolerance spreading" that inactivates a broad spectrum of autoimmune T and B cells in concert.

Regulatory defects in Cbl and mitogen-activated protein kinase (extracellular signal-related kinase) pathways cause persistent hyperexpression of CD40 ligand in human lupus T cells

To identify intrinsic defects in lupus, we studied short-term, CD4(+) T cell lines that were established from 16 lupus patients (active or inactive) and 15 normal subjects by stimulating once with anti-CD3, anti-CD28, and IL-2. After resting, the pure CD4(+) T cells were exposed to anergy-inducing stimulation with plate-bound anti-CD3 mAb in the absence of APC. Lupus T cells showed prolonged high level expression of CD40 ligand (CD40L, CD154) even in the face of anergy protocol, which shut down CD40L expression in normal T cells. The sustained CD40L expression in lupus T cells did not correlate with memory status or Th deviation, and was relatively independent of IL-2 or other autocrine or paracrine signals via CD28 or CTLA-4. Cyclosporin A could block CD40L expression by lupus T cells when added early during the anti-CD3 stimulation period, but only partially when added later, indicating that another mechanism regulates the prolonged hyperexpression of CD40L besides the Ca(2+) --> calcineurin-dependent NF-AT pathway. When exposed to the anergy protocol, lupus T cells, in marked contrast to normal T cells, did not phosphorylate Cbl/Cbl-b but continued to express strongly phosphorylated extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK); U0126, a specific inhibitor of mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase --> ERK, could block both the early and the prolonged hyperexpression of CD40L. Thus, pathways regulating the activities of Cbl and one particular mitogen-activated protein kinase, ERK, are involved in the prolonged hyperexpression of CD40L in lupus T cells.

Estrogen enhancement of anti-double-stranded DNA antibody and immunoglobulin G production in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

OBJECTIVE

To study the in vitro effect of estrogen on IgG anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibody and total IgG production in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), in order to elucidate its regulatory role in SLE.

METHODS

PBMC from SLE patients and normal donors were cultured with 17beta-estradiol (E2). IgG anti-dsDNA antibodies, total IgG, and cytokine activity in the culture supernatants were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

RESULTS

E2 enhanced production of IgG anti-dsDNA antibodies as well as total IgG in PBMC from SLE patients. Anti-dsDNA production in patients with inactive disease was less responsive to E2 than that in patients with active disease. E2 also enhanced total IgG, but not anti-dsDNA, production in the PBMC of normal donors. Antibody production was increased by E2 to a lesser extent in patients' B cells than in their PBMC. Anti-interleukin-10 (anti-IL-10) antibodies partially blocked the E2-induced increase in antibody production in patients' PBMC, but anti-IL-10 had no effect on B cells. E2 increased IL-10 production by patients' monocytes. Exogenous IL-10 acted additively with E2 in increasing antibody production in patients' B cells.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that E2 may polyclonally increase the production of IgG, including IgG anti-dsDNA, in SLE patients' PBMC by enhancing B cell activity and by promoting IL-10 production in monocytes. These findings support the involvement of E2 in the pathogenesis of SLE.

Promiscuous presentation and recognition of nucleosomal autoepitopes in lupus: role of autoimmune T cell receptor alpha chain

T cells specific for nucleosomal autoepitopes are selectively expanded in lupus mice and these Th cells drive autoimmune B cells to produce pathogenic antinuclear antibodies. We transfected the TCR-alpha and -beta chain genes of a representative, pathogenic autoantibody-inducing Th clone specific for the nucleosomal core histone peptide H471-94 into TCR-negative recipient cells. Although the autoimmune TCRs were originally derived from SNF1 (I-Ad/q) mice, the transfectants could recognize the nucleosomal autoepitope presented by APC-bearing I-A molecules of all haplotypes tested, as well as human DR molecules. Competition assays indicated that the autoepitopes bound to the MHC class II groove. Most remarkably, MHC-unrestricted recognition of the nucleosomal peptide epitope was conferred by the lupus TCR-alpha chain even when it paired with a TCR-beta chain of irrelevant specificity. Several other disease-relevant Th clones and splenic T cells of lupus mice had similar properties. The TCR-alpha chains of these murine lupus Th clones shared related motifs and charged residues in their CDRs, and similar motifs were apparent even in TCR-alpha chains of human lupus Th clones. The lupus TCR-alpha chains probably contact the nucleosomal peptide complexed with MHC with relatively high affinity/avidity to sustain TCR signaling, because CD4 coreceptor was not required for promiscuous recognition. Indeed, pathogenic autoantibody-inducing, CD4-negative, TCR-alphabeta+ Th cells are expanded in systemic lupus erythematosus. These results have implications regarding thymic selection and peripheral expansion of nucleosome-specific T cells in lupus. They also suggest that universally tolerogenic epitopes could be designed for therapy of lupus patients with diverse HLA alleles. We propose to designate nucleosomes and other antigens bearing universal epitopes "Pantigens" (for promiscuous antigens).

Testosterone suppresses anti-DNA antibody production in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

OBJECTIVE

To study the in vitro effect of testosterone on anti-DNA antibody production in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in order to elucidate its regulatory role in SLE.

METHODS

PBMC from SLE patients were cultured with testosterone. IgG anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibody, total IgG, and cytokine activity in the supernatants were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

RESULTS

Testosterone suppressed both IgG anti-dsDNA antibody and total IgG production in PBMC from SLE patients. Antibody production in B cells was also suppressed by testosterone, although the magnitude of its effect on B cells was lower than that on PBMC. Interleukin-6 (IL-6) partially restored the testosterone-induced decrease in antibody levels in PBMC. Testosterone reduced IL-6 production in monocytes.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that testosterone may directly suppress anti-DNA antibody production in PBMC from SLE patients by inhibiting B cell hyperactivity and, indirectly, by down-regulating IL-6 production in monocytes. These results support the therapeutic effects of testosterone on SLE.

Light chain usage in anti-double-stranded DNA B cell subsets: role in cell fate determination

Two major mechanisms for the regulation of autoreactive B cells that arise in the bone marrow are functional silencing (anergy) and deletion. Studies to date suggest that low avidity interactions between B cells and autoantigen lead to B cell silencing, whereas high avidity interactions lead to deletion. Anti-double stranded (ds) DNA antibodies represent a pathogenic autospecificity in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE). An understanding of their regulation is critical to an understanding of SLE. We now demonstrate in a transgenic model in which mice express the heavy chain of a potentially pathogenic anti-DNA antibody that antibody affinity for dsDNA does not alone determine the fate of anti-dsDNA B cells. B cells making antibodies with similar affinities for dsDNA are regulated differently, depending on light chain usage. A major implication of this observation is that dsDNA may not be the self antigen responsible for cell fate determinations of anti-dsDNA B cells. Light chain usage may determine antigenic cross-reactivity, and cross-reactive antigens may regulate B cells that also bind dsDNA.

Cross-reactions and specificities of monoclonal antibodies against myelin basic protein and against the synthetic copolymer 1

Antibody cross-reactivity is here demonstrated between basic protein (BP), the encephalitogenic molecule of myelin, and copolymer 1 (Cop 1), the synthetic amino acid copolymer, which has a suppressive effect on experimental allergic encephalomyelitis and is effective in reducing the number of relapses in exacerbating-remitting multiple sclerosis. This cross-reactivity is conclusively established using mouse monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). About a third of anti-rat BP mAbs and most of anti-mouse BP mAbs cross-reacted with Cop 1. This cross-reactivity could be demonstrated with anti-BP mAbs of different specificities. In addition, several anti-Cop 1 hybridomas cross-reacted with BP. This cross-reactivity was verified in several assay systems, including competitive inhibition experiments. Moreover, some anti-BP mAbs and anti-Cop 1 mAbs reacted in a heteroclitic manner and favored the cross-reactive antigen over the immunogen. In contrast to the mAbs, no cross-reactivity could be demonstrated with the antisera of immunized mice. This observation may reflect the different B-cell populations expressed in the mAb response as compared to the polyclonal response. Thus, the use of mAbs has uncovered specificities that are not evident in antisera and has revealed pronounced cross-reactivity between BP and Cop 1 at the B-cell level. These results further establish the immunological interrelationships between Cop 1 and BP, demonstrated earlier at the T-cell level.

Detection of human and murine common idiotypes of DNA antibodies in tissues and sera of patients with autoimmune diseases

The expression in tissue and serum of a panel of murine and human common DNA antibody idiotypes (Ids) (BEG 2, PR 4, F-423, I-402, II-28, IV-228, V-88) has been investigated. The murine V-88 Id was detected in eight out of 10 and the human BEG 2 Id in five out of 10 labial biopsies from patients with Sjögren's syndrome. The murine F-423, I-402 and IV-228 Ids were identified in one out of 10 biopsies. In each case the pattern of staining was similar with staining of the acinar basement membrane and a cell population. Using double-labelling immunohistochemistry this cell population were identified as plasma cells. No staining was seen in four normal labial biopsies. The V-88 Id was detected on the epithelial aspect of the thickened basement membrane in three out of nine renal biopsies from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). None of the other Ids (BEG 2, PR4, IV-228, F-423 or I-402) could be detected in renal tissue. None of the Ids were found in skin biopsies from SLE patients. Id V-88 may, like the 16/6 Id to which it is phenotypically related, play a role in the pathogenesis of renal lesions in SLE. The BEG 2 Id could be detected in the serum of patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and active untreated tuberculosis. Ids II-28, V-88 and I-402 were elevated in serum from patients with Sjögren's syndrome and II-28 Id in serum from patients with myositis and RA. None of the Ids were elevated in serum from patients with SLE. Apart from the BEG 2 Id, none of the Ids were elevated in serum from patients with tuberculosis or Gram-negative infections. The presence of murine Ids in human tissue and serum suggests that they are cross-species idiotypes and have been conserved through evolution.

Immunogenic DNA-related factors. Nucleosomes spontaneously released from normal murine lymphoid cells stimulate proliferation and immunoglobulin synthesis of normal mouse lymphocytes

The cell-free supernatants of normal spleen and thymus lymphocytes in short-term culture release low molecular weight (LMW) DNA protein molecules that have an immunoproliferative effect (polyclonal B cell activation) in vitro. We have determined that the protein-LMW DNA complexes responsible for these effects are nucleosomal constituents of chromatin, since the mitogenically active fractions of these cell-free supernatants contain the constituents of core histones (H3, H2A, H2B, H4) together with LMW DNA (140-180 bp), and since the immunoproliferative effects of these cell-free supernatants could be mimicked by various other nucleoprotein preparations (including calf thymus and chicken erythrocyte nucleosomes). The spontaneous cellular release of cleaved chromatin constituents in vitro can be attributed to a form of programmed cell death termed apoptosis, since the cultured spleen cells exhibited (a) morphologic evidence consistent with this process by electron microscopy, and (b) evidence of intracellular cleavage of chromatin which, like apoptosis, could be blocked with ZnSO4. This resulted in inhibition of the extracellular release of nucleosomal constituents as well as the immunoproliferative effects of the cell-free supernatants. The immunoproliferative effect of nucleosomes released from cells during apoptosis could be responsible for previously observed spontaneous in vitro anti-DNA and anti-histone antibody responses of murine spleen cells, and in vivo in normal lymphoid tissues, resulting in renewed cellular proliferation after cell death. In pathological states, this could result in abnormal polyclonal B cell proliferation and autoantibody formation.

A human fetal monoclonal DNA-binding antibody shares idiotypes with fetal and adult murine monoclonal DNA-binding antibodies

A human DNA-binding monoclonal antibody was produced by fusing the hepatocytes from a 12-week-old human fetus with the lymphoblastoid cell line GM 4672 using polyethylene glycol. This antibody, designated BEG 2, binds to single-stranded (ss) DNA but also binds to double-stranded (ds) DNA, poly(dT), polyI and poly(ADP-ribose), but not to RNA, cardiolipin or K-30. The binding of BEG 2 to these polynucleotides can be inhibited by incubation with polynucleotides in the fluid phase. A rabbit polyclonal anti-idiotype was raised, and using this reagent it was shown that the BEG 2 idiotype is present in normal human serum (7%), systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) sera (8%) and rheumatoid arthritis sera (23%). The extent of idiotypic sharing between BEG 2 and murine monoclonal DNA-binding antibodies, in particular monoclonal antibody (mAb) 423 (derived from a 15-day-old fetal MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr mouse) and mAb 402 (derived from an adult MRL/lpr mouse), was also investigated. Using a competition ELISA, it was shown that preincubation of BEG 2 with rabbit anti-423 and rabbit anti-402 inhibits the binding of BEG 2 to DNA, and the binding of 402 to DNA by anti-BEG 2 and anti-423. These data suggest that mAb BEG 2, 423 and 402 share common idiotypes, that autoreactivity is present in early fetal life, and that autoantibodies may be encoded for by germline genes, which have been conserved through evolution.

Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis of the V kappa locus in human lupus

To evaluate the degree of genetic polymorphism of the V kappa repertoire in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), we performed Southern blot hybridizations with human gene probes corresponding to the four human V kappa gene families. In a comparative analysis, non-lymphoid cell DNA samples from three patients with idiopathic SLE, eight subjects with susceptibility to drug-induced lupus and seven control individuals were digested with the restriction endonucleases Bam HI, Bg 1 II, Eco RI and Hind III, and hybridized sequentially to the four V kappa family-specific probes. The restriction patterns on Southern blots revealed a low degree of polymorphism of the human V kappa gene repertoires of SLE patients and control individuals. This analysis, together with previous parallel studies of the V kappa locus in lupus-prone mice, implies that autoantibody hyperproduction in lupus is not associated with major modifications in the structure or genomic organization of immunoglobulin light chain genes.

Expression in systemic lupus erythematosus of an idiotype common to DNA-binding and nonbinding monoclonal antibodies produced by normal human lymphoid cells

Rabbit antiserum raised against a normal-derived monoclonal anti-DNA antibody KIM 4.6.3 (IgM lambda) was used for idiotype analyses. This anti-serum (anti-4.6.3 ID) was rendered specific for KIM 4.6.3 idiotype (4.6.3 ID) by absorption with normal human IgM and IgG. The specificity of anti-4.6.3 was shown by its ability to bind to KIM 4.6.3 antibody but not to normal human IgM and IgG, by inhibition of anti-4.6.3 ID reactivity with KIM 4.6.3 antibody by the homologous monoclonal antibody and by the ability of anti-4.6.3 ID to inhibit the binding of single stranded DNA with KIM 4.6.3 antibody. The 4.6.3 ID was found to be commonly expressed since it was detected among 33% (10/30) DNA and 32% (23/72) non-DNA-reactive monoclonal antibodies that were obtained from five different unrelated normal individuals. The binding to ssDNA of the majority of idiotype positive anti-DNA antibodies however was not blocked by anti-4.6.3 ID suggesting that among these other monoclonal antibodies its expression is outside of the antigen binding site. The 4.6.3 ID, which was present among some normal-derived monoclonal IgM molecules was also found at a high frequency (90%) in the sera of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) but only at a low frequency (24%) and concentration in normal sera. The level of 4.6.3 ID in SLE did not correlate with serum IgM and IgG nor with anti-DNA antibody concentrations. Idiotypic relatedness between SLE serum antibodies and monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies of normals implies the existence of a cross-reactive idiotype family and implies that a conserved common gene or closely related genes exist in the germ line encoding these 4.6.3 ID positive antibodies some of which are not exclusively associated with nucleic acid reactivity. The expression of these germ line genes in vivo thus distinguishes SLE from normals.

Epibodies in autoimmunity: antisera against autoantibodies to the renal glomerular basement membrane react with idiotypes as well as with autoantigens

The results reported here show that we have experimentally produced xenogeneic anti-idiotypic antibodies to rat autoantibodies specific for the renal GBM and one of its components, laminin. Cross-reactive idiotypes have been detected by anti-idiotypic antibodies (anti-Id) on autoantibodies to the GBM (anti-GBM) from rats of different strains, confirming the results obtained in other autoantibody systems. During the course of studies aimed at determining whether anti-Id were directed to the paratope of anti-GBM antibodies, we have observed the presence of anti-GBM (and anti-laminin) antibodies in rabbit sera with anti-Id. Affinity chromatography experiments suggest that anti-GBM reactions detected with our anti-Id sera may be caused by a heterogeneous combination of anti-Id. Thus, Ab2 alpha (and/or Ab2 gamma, all reacting with Ab1), Ab2 epsilon (epibodies, that bind to both Ab1 and GBM) and Ab3 (similar to Ab1 and therefore, reacting with GBM) may be present in our anti-Id sera. It has been suggested that antibodies displaying epibody properties may be involved in the mutual regulation of autoreactive clones and represent an important component of the autoimmune process.

Immunochemistry of DNA

Since the first reports of anti-DNA antibodies in sera of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in 1957, studies of nucleic acid immunochemistry have grown in two directions. One has been the analysis of the specificity, the nature and the origins of these autoantibodies. The second has been exploration of anti-nucleic acid antibodies that can be induced experimentally, their specificities, and their application as biochemical reagents. Although the properties of autoantibodies and experimentally induced antibodies differ in certain respects, these two lines of research are complementary and provide important information for each other. For example, the production of autoantibodies by adjuvant-stimulated B cells yields a background that has to be considered in evaluating the specificity of weak responses to experimental nucleic acid immunogens: in turn, the possibilities and limitations of experimental immunization should be considered in evaluating possible stimuli for autoantibody production. Several aspects of nucleic acid immunochemistry have been described and evaluated in previous reviews. Following some general statements of historical perspective, this review will emphasize questions addressed and findings of about the last five years.

Anti-DNA antibodies, autoimmunity and the immunoglobulin repertoire

The advent of hybridoma and recombinant DNA technology about a decade ago has allowed a detailed analysis the structure, properties and molecular genetics of antibodies. These techniques, combined with studies of idiotypes and of Abelson-transformed and other cell lines, have resulted in major findings which are of particular importance to both the normal immune system and to autoimmunity. The rearrangement and expression of antibody genes in the normal immune system are discussed first, as a background for an appreciation of the significance of the molecular genetics of autoantibodies. We then turn to autoantibody genes, with an emphasis on anti-DNA antibodies and their role in the autoimmune disease, systemic lupus erythematosus. A model for the genetics of lupus which includes a possible role for Ig genes is considered.

Islet cell surface antibodies in Graves' disease; as organ non-specific antibodies

To define ICA positiveness and its clinical correlation in AITD, ICSA were checked in Graves’ patients by indirect IF test using rat insulinoma (RINr) cells. Also Ig adherence to rat thyroid (FRTL5) and EB virus cloned human B lymphocytes that do not produce immunoglobulins were measured as the same method of ICSA with determination of organ specific antibodies in the sera.

The incidence of ICSA in Graves’ disease was 23.1 % (9/39) and the degree of the positiveness measured as % binding was roughly correlated to those of Ig adherence to FRTL5 and B cells. This ability to bind multiple organs of different species was not found to have any correlation with the titers of organ specific antibodies, but the incidence of organ specific antibody positiveness was much higher in the ICSA positive sera. Also there was a significant difference on the absorption pattern to FRTL5 and RINr cells between the sera of ICSA positive IDDM and Graves’ patients, where absorption and % binding to FRTL5, cell in ICSA positive diabetic sera were significantly lower than those to RINr cells in ICSA positive Graves’.

Induction of a cationic shift in IgG anti-DNA autoantibodies. Role of T helper cells with classical and novel phenotypes in three murine models of lupus nephritis

We investigated the underlying mechanisms of systemic autoimmune disease in MRL-+/+, (NZB X NZW)F1, and (NZB X SWR)F1 mice, since these strains develop glomerulonephritis without the superimposition of any secondary lupus-accelerating genes. All three strains manifested a common immunoregulatory defect specific for the production of pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies that are of IgG class and cationic in charge. At or just before the age they began to develop lupus nephritis, spleen cells of the mice contained a subpopulation of Th cells that selectively induced their B cells in vitro to produce highly cationic IgG autoantibodies to both single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). By contrast, T cells from younger preautoimmune mice were incapable of providing this help. Moreover, only B cells of the older lupus mice could be induced to secrete cationic anti-DNA antibodies of IgG class. B cells of young lupus mice could not produce the cationic autoantibodies even with the help of T cells from the older mice, nor upon stimulation with mitogens. In the older lupus mice we found two sets of Th cells that spontaneously induced the cationic shift in autoantibodies; one set belonged to the classical Th category with L3T4+,Lyt-2- phenotype, whereas the other surprisingly belonged to a double-negative (L3T4-,Lyt-2-), Lyt-1+ subpopulation. The latter set of unusual Th cells were unexpected in these lupus mice since they lacked the lpr (lympho-proliferation) gene. Thus three apparently different murine models of systemic lupus erythematosus possess a common underlying mechanism specific for the spontaneous production of pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies.

The sera of patients with Klebsiella infections contain a common anti-DNA idiotype (16/6) Id and anti-polynucleotide activity

In view of recent reports linking Klebsiella pneumoniae with autoimmunity, we have examined the sera of 52 patients with urinary tract infection or septicaemia from this Gram-negative pathogen, for the presence of antibodies to DNA, polynucleotides, cardiolipin and a common anti-DNA idiotype 16/6. Up to 27% of these patients had anti-polynucleotide antibodies detectable, and in 37% the 16/6 idiotype was found. Absorption of the sera of two patients, with no DNA binding, against the Klebsiella polysaccharide K-30 induced a significant fall in both their anti-K30 antibody and 16/6 idiotype levels. Among 52 patients with other Gram negative infections a maximum of 17% and 19% respectively, had anti-DNA antibodies and the 16/6 idiotype present in their serum. In 37 normal controls, the rate of antibody and idiotype detection was 5% or less. The presence of autoantibodies in the serum of patients with Klebsiella infections may be the result of non-specific stimulation due to bacterial polyclonal activation. However, there might also be a specific stimulus triggered by idiotypic cross-reaction between autoantibodies and anti-Klebsiella antibodies.

Idiotypic markers of polyclonal B cell activation. Public idiotypes shared by monoclonal antibodies derived from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus or leprosy

We investigated idiotypic markers of monoclonal antibodies derived from patients with polyclonal B-cell activation. Four monoclonal antibodies with different ligand binding specificities derived from a patient with lepromatous leprosy and three monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies from two patients with SLE were studied. Three new public idiotopes, which were common to monoclonal antibodies from all three patients, were defined by five polyclonal rabbit antiidiotypes, two monoclonal mouse antiidiotopes, and a monoclonal mouse antibody against a synthetic peptide that contains residues of the heavy chain CDR-1 of a monoclonal lupus anti-DNA antibody. The antibody against the synthetic idiotype was found to react with native immunoglobulins in solution. One idiotope was found to be consistently immunogenic in all animals tested. Since the three patients are of different ethnic origins, these shared idiotypes are probably encoded by germline V genes. These genes may be recurrently expressed in states of polyclonal B-cell activation, regardless of etiology. The results suggest that some autoantibodies arise by expansion of a pool of precursors in the normal antibody repertoire.

Parallel sets of autoantibodies in MRL-lpr/lpr mice. An anti-DNA, anti-SmRNP, anti-gp70 network

The public idiotype Id-H130 occurs in MRL-lpr/lpr serum both on a high proportion of anti-DNA autoantibodies as well as on antibodies that do not bind to DNA. To define members of the latter population, we prepared hybridomas and selected Id-H130+ mAbs that did not bind to DNA. One such antibody, mAb 28/12, was found to be an anti-SmRNP antibody. To determine whether mAb 28/12 had rheumatoid factor activity, we tested its ability to bind, in a solid-phase assay, to 16 mouse IgM mAbs. mAb 28/12 bound to only four of the panel, two anti-DNA antibodies (mAbs 512 and 319) and two anti-gp70 antibodies (mAbs 514 and 1417). In a liquid-phase competition assay with a panel of 32 monoclonal IgM and IgG antibodies, including allotype-matched Igs, mAb 28/12 reacted only with mAbs 512, 319, 514, and 1417. The binding of mAb 28/12 to mAbs 512 and 319 was displaced by DNA, but not by RNA, indicating that the idiotype it defines (Id-28/12) is in the antigen-binding region of the two anti-DNA antibodies. In the two anti-gp70 antibodies (mAbs 514 and 1417), Id-28/12 seems to occur in the framework region. To determine if all four Id-28/12+ antibodies shared a common antigen-binding property, they were tested for their ability to react with DNA and gp70. The two anti-gp70 antibodies did not bind to DNA. However, the two anti-DNA antibodies were found to immunoprecipitate viral proteins from retrovirus-infected cells. mAb 512 reacted with gp70, both in cell membrane lysates and in purified form; mAb 319 reacted with gp85, which contains both gp70 and the retroviral protein p15. Antibodies with properties similar to those of mAb 28/12 were found in MRL-lpr/lpr serum. It was possible, by affinity chromatography on an anti-gp70 antibody column, to isolate from serum those anti-(anti-gp70) antibodies with anti-SmRNP activity. These results show that parallel sets of autoantibodies, which share a common idiotype, but which bind to different autoantigens, occur in MRL-lpr/lpr mice. Some populations of anti-DNA, anti-SmRNP, and anti-gp70 antibodies appear to constitute a network of autoantibodies in that strain. We speculate that part of the anti-SmRNP population of autoantibodies can arise by mutation of germline-encoded anti-DNA antibodies.

A common anti-DNA idiotype in sera of patients with active pulmonary tuberculosis

The sera of 57 patients with active, untreated pulmonary tuberculosis were examined for the presence of a common anti-DNA idiotype, 16/6. Thirty-four of the 57 sera (60%) had an increased level of the idiotype, as measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay using a specific rabbit anti-16/6 serum. Of 28 matched control sera, only 1 (4%) was found to be positive for the idiotype. The sera of patients with tuberculosis also showed increased activity against a variety of antigens with which lupus autoantibodies are known to crossreact (e.g., single-stranded DNA, double-stranded DNA, polynucleotides, and cardiolipin). A correlation was observed between serum IgG and IgM levels and the 16/6 idiotype levels.

Autoantibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus and normal subjects

The presence of various antibodies in serum samples from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and from healthy subjects was investigated by ELISA, using a panel of natural antigens. Fifty-eight serum samples from 58 healthy women and 50 serum samples from 30 patients with active SLE were tested with 9 natural antigens (ds-DNA, actin, tubulin, thyroglobulin, myosin, myoglobin, human transferrin, human interferon a and BSA FV). It was found that the proportion of positive sera from healthy women at a dilution of 1/20 was almost the same as that of lupus sera at a dilution of 1/150 for nearly all antigens, while at a dilution of 1/150 the proportion of positive sera from patients with SLE was significantly higher for nearly all antigens. In lupus sera a high degree of correlation was observed between titers of anti-DNA and titers of the other antibodies. One hundred eighty-eight serum samples from 53 SLE patients, taken during exacerbation and remission of the disease were tested with ds-DNA, actin and tubulin. Antibodies (IgG) to ds-DNA actin and tubulin were found in the majority of serum samples taken during the active phase of the disease. On the other hand, very few serum samples taken during remission were found to be positive. A high degree of correlation was found between the OD of anti-actin/anti-ds-DNA (r = 0.769) and anti-tubulin/anti-ds-DNA (r = 0.829). In a competitive enzyme immunoassay for DNA, actin, tubulin, myosin and thyroglobulin, a high degree of inhibition was observed with the homologous antigens.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The in vitro production of antibodies to mitochondrial antigens by peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients with primary biliary cirrhosis

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 7 patients with primary biliary cirrhosis and 7 healthy control subjects were studied for their ability to produce antibodies to mitochondrial antigens in vitro. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were collected by lymphapheresis and cultured with or without pokeweed mitogen for 10 days. The culture supernatants were then tested for antibodies to mitochondrial antigens by both immunofluorescence microscopy and a microtiter ELISA. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 5 of 7 patients with primary biliary cirrhosis but from none of the healthy controls produced antibodies to mitochondrial antigens spontaneously (without pokeweed mitogen stimulation). In contrast, peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 6 of 7 patients with primary biliary cirrhosis and from 6 of 7 control subjects synthesized detectable levels of antibodies to mitochondrial antigens after stimulation with pokeweed mitogen. In general, peripheral blood mononuclear cells from the primary biliary cirrhosis patients produced higher titers of antibodies to mitochondrial antigens in culture than cells from healthy controls. Furthermore, the antibodies to mitochondrial antigens reactivity produced by peripheral blood mononuclear cells of primary biliary cirrhosis patients exhibited a specificity for the M2 mitochondrial antigen which is present on the inner membrane of mitochondrial cristae and which is closely associated with a mitochondrial ATPase activity. In contrast, the antibodies to mitochondrial antigens reactivity produced by peripheral blood mononuclear cells of healthy controls appeared to be directed at a broader range of mitochondrial antigens. These findings indicate that, inpatients with primary biliary cirrhosis, there is a marked expansion of B lymphocyte clones that produce an antibody to a specific mitochondrial antigen.

Origins of pathogenic anti-DNA idiotypes in the NZB X SWR model of lupus nephritis

The investigations with the NZB X SWR model show that the development of systemic autoimmune disease is a multistep, multigene process. Severe lupus nephritis in the NZB X SWR hybrids results from the interaction of genes inherited from both the autoimmune NZB and the normal SWR parents. A similar genetic interaction occurs in the NZB X NZW hybrids, but in this model, both the parental strains are abnormal and the nature of the gene products or their mechanism of action is unknown. In the NZB X SWR model, we have been able to identify a restricted subpopulation of nephritogenic anti-DNA antibody idiotypes that are encoded by genes of the normal SWR parents. Thus, these are one set of genes that determine the development of severe lupus nephritis in the F1 hybrids. In addition, another set of genes allows for the expansion of B cells that produce such pathogenic anti-DNA idiotypes in the F1 hybrids since such B-cell clones remain dormant in the normal SWR parents. The latter category of genes, presumably specifying defects in immunoregulation, are probably inherited from the NZB parents or may be the result of complementation of genes inherited from both parents. Further investigations with the NZB X SWR model will help us define the immunoregulatory defects in SLE that are specific for the T and B cells involved in pathogenic autoantibody production.

Distribution of an anti-DNA idiotype among autoantibodies in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) or rheumatoid arthritis (RA)

Autoantibodies from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, or other connective tissue disorders were probed for the presence of a cross-reactive idiotype (AM Id) originally defined on human anti-double-stranded DNA antibodies. The AM Id was distributed primarily among antibodies to double-stranded DNA, single-stranded DNA, or cardiolipin in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus and antibodies to single-stranded DNA or cardiolipin and rheumatoid factor in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, thus tending to codistribute with the predominant primary autoantibodies in both diseases. Strong associations were observed particularly between the AM Id and anti-single-stranded DNA antibodies in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus and the AM Id and anticardiolipin antibodies in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Affinity absorption experiments with sera from individual lupus patients showed that up to 41% of the anti-single-stranded DNA antibodies were Id positive. The results indicate that the AM Id may be widely distributed among antibodies that have a potential for binding DNA.

Herpes simplex virus-enhanced production of autoantibodies against myelin basic protein in mice

In 5 per cent of untreated and apparently healthy Swiss albino mice antibodies were demonstrable against myelin basic protein (MBP) prepared from human brain tissue. Associated with infection with herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 1, enhancement of the antibody formation against MBP was encountered. Thus of infected but symptom-free animals 15-25 per cent revealed anti-MBP antibodies. The latter type of antibodies appeared later than antibodies against HSV and were found predominantly in animals inoculated via the intraperitoneal route. No signs of demyelination in spinal cords or spinal nerve roots were observed in MBP antibody-positive HSV-immunized animals. Results reported may indicate triggering of an autoantibody formation against MBP and are discussed in relation to demyelinating disease.

Autoantibodies and their relation to rheumatic diseases

The use of tissue culture substrates for immunofluorescence determinations of nuclear, cytoplasmic, and mitotic cell-related autoantibodies has resulted in the delineation of diverse new specificities, whose clinical correlates are now becoming apparent. This review details both major and minor autoantibody specificities, the status of knowledge regarding their target antigens, and the relation of these serologic systems to distinctive rheumatic disease syndromes.

Idiotypes of monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies produced in autoimmune B/W mice are expressed in normal mice

An anti-idiotypic antiserum was prepared in a rabbit immunized against a pool of six monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies generated in B/W mice. This antiserum detected idiotypic determinants in four of the six monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies but also in the serum of several non autoimmune strains (BALB/c, NZB X BALB/c) F1 hybrids & CBA/LH). The antiserum also reacted, but only to a weak degree, with B/W mouse sera. These results indicate that some idiotypes of anti-DNA antibodies produced by autoimmune B/W mice are present in normal mouse sera.

Anti-idiotypic antibodies against a human multiple organ-reactive autoantibody. Detection of idiotopes in normal individuals and patients with autoimmune diseases

We have recently isolated and characterized a human monoclonal autoantibody, MOR-h1 (multiple organ-reactive human 1), that reacts with antigens in multiple organs and have shown that this antibody binds to human growth hormone and a 35,000-mol wt protein. In the present study we generated three monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies (4E6, 3E5, and 3F6) against MOR-h1. These anti-idiotypic antibodies specifically reacted with MOR-h1 and not with 26 other multiple organ-reactive monoclonal IgM autoantibodies nor with pooled human IgM (myeloma proteins). The binding of the anti-idiotypic antibodies to MOR-h1 was inhibited by both human growth hormone and the 35,000-mol wt protein, which strongly suggests that these antibodies react with epitopes at or near the paratope on MOR-h1. The results of competitive binding experiments revealed that the epitope recognized by 4E6 is distinct from that recognized by 3E5 and 3F6. Using these anti-idiotypic antibodies, lymphocytes and sera from normal individuals were tested for the presence of the 4E6 and 3E5/3F6 idiotopes. By indirect immunofluorescence, the 4E6 idiotope was detected on an average of 1.1% of normal circulating B lymphocytes, and by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays, the 4E6 and to a lesser extent the 3E5/3F6 idiotopes were found on IgG molecules in sera of normal individuals. In spite of the expression of idiotopes known to be present on MOR-h1, no MOR-h1-like antibody activity was detected in normal sera. Examination of sera from patients with several autoimmune diseases failed to show an increased expression of the 4E6 idiotope as compared with normal controls. These data suggest that anti-idiotypic antibody 4E6 recognizes a public idiotope, the expression of which is not restricted to autoimmune disease.

Detection of cross-reactive anti-DNA antibody idiotypes in the serum of systemic lupus erythematosus patients and of their relatives

Two common cross-reacting anti-DNA antibody idiotypes designated 16/6 and 32/15, previously identified in the serum of patients who have systemic lupus erythematosus, were found in 24% and 7%, respectively, of 147 first-degree relatives. These findings imply that high-frequency germ-line genes exist among lupus relatives, as well as patients. These dominant or public anti-DNA antibody idiotypes are not likely to be pathogenic factors, but are probably a genetically associated phenomenon.

Genetic elements used for a murine lupus anti-DNA autoantibody are closely related to those for antibodies to exogenous antigens

The mRNAs encoding heavy and light chains of a hybridoma-derived monoclonal IgM kappa anti-DNA autoantibody from lupus-prone MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr mice (Ighj) have been transcribed into cDNA copies and molecularly cloned, and their complete nucleotide sequences have been determined. The mRNA for the heavy chain variable region, including leader peptide and 5' untranslated region, is transcribed from a heavy chain variable region (VH) gene closely related (and possibly allelic) to VH genes of the C57BL/6 (Ighb) nitrophenyl antibody family. The deduced amino acid sequence corresponding to the light chain variable region of this autoantibody shows extensive similarities with non-autoantibody molecules of the V kappa 1 group, suggesting a common variable gene origin. The joining segments, constant regions, and 3' untranslated regions of both the heavy and light chain mRNAs are nearly identical to corresponding sequences of non-autoantibodies from normal mice. Our findings suggest that this anti-DNA autoantibody originated from the same germline repertoire as antibodies to exogenous antigens.

Spontaneous in vitro production of anti-DNA and anti-RNA by systemic lupus erythematosus and normal peripheral blood mononuclear cells

The spontaneous in vitro production of anti-DNA and anti-RNA by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and from normal subjects was evaluated employing sensitive solid-phase assays that are specific for these antibodies. PBMC from SLE patients produced more IgG anti-DNA and anti-RNA than did normal PBMC (P less than 0.01). In vitro production of IgG anti-DNA appeared to correlate with serum DNA bindings (r = 0.72, P less than 0.005). Similar amounts of IgM anti-DNA and anti-RNA were produced by both SLE and normal PBMC. However, IgM anti-DNA antibodies always appeared to be directed against determinants on denatured DNA. Only PBMC from SLE patients produced IgG antibodies to native DNA.

Origins of anti-DNA autoantibodies

Images

Induction of severe autoimmune disease in normal mice by simultaneous action of multiple immunostimulators

Either of two immunostimulating factors (lpr, lipopolysaccharide) enhanced the pathogenic autoimmune responses of MRL/n mice, but the serologic and immunopathologic characteristics differed. In contrast, either factor acting alone, caused minimal immunopathology in normal mice, despite autoantibody induction. Combined immunostimulation, however, caused fatal glomerulonephritis in normal-background C57BL/6 mice. These results show the profound influence of the background genome on the effects of immunostimulating agents, and show that resistance to autoimmune disease in immunologically normal mice is not absolute.

Characterization of a human monoclonal IgM with antibody activity to dsDNA

We report here the characterization and fine specificity of a human monoclonal IgM lambda reacting with double stranded DNA. The purified IgM and its Fab fragment bind to DNA in the Farr or Crithidia lucilae assays as well as in an immunoenzymatic test. In the latter case, binding was inhibited by native DNA, by DNA alternative co-polymers and by some homopolymers only, but not by monodeoxyribonucleotides and ribonucleotides. Since cardiolipin and phosphatidic acid were good inhibitors, these data suggest that the monoclonal IgM reacts with the sugar phosphate backbone of deoxyribonucleic acids. Interestingly, the patient was affected with both Waldenström's macroglobulinaemia and pernicious anaemia without any symptoms of systemic lupus erythematosus.