The Ras/Erk pathway induces primitive endoderm but prevents parietal endoderm differentiation of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells

Metabolic profile and differentiation potential of extraembryonic endoderm-like cells

Glucose metabolism has a crucial role for providing substrates required to generate ATP and regulate the epigenetic landscape. We reported that F9 embryonal carcinoma stem-like cells require cytosolic reactive oxygen species to differentiate into extraembryonic endoderm; however, mitochondrial sources were not examined. To extend these studies, we examined the metabolic profile of early and late-passage F9 cells, and show that their ability to differentiate is similar, even though each population has dramatically different metabolic profiles. Differentiated early-passage cells relied on glycolysis, while differentiated late-passage cells transitioned towards oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS). Unexpectedly, electron transport chain protein stoichiometry was disrupted in differentiated late-passage cells, whereas genes encoding mitofusion 1 and 2, which promote mitochondrial fusion and favor OXPHOS, were upregulated in differentiated early-passage cells. Despite this, early-passage cells cultured under conditions to promote glycolysis showed enhanced differentiation, whereas promoting OXPHOS in late-passage cells showed a similar trend. Further analysis revealed that the distinct metabolic profiles seen between the two populations is largely associated with changes in genomic integrity, linking metabolism to passage number. Together, these results indicate that passaging has no effect on the potential for F9 cells to differentiate into extraembryonic endoderm; however, it does impact their metabolic profile. Thus, it is imperative to determine the molecular and metabolic status of a stem cell population before considering its utility as a therapeutic tool for regenerative medicine.

Frizzled gene expression and negative regulation of canonical WNT-β-catenin signaling in mouse F9 teratocarcinoma cells

Mouse F9 cells differentiate into primitive endoderm (PrE) following the activation of the canonical WNT-β-catenin pathway. The upregulation of Wnt6 and activation of β-catenin-TCF-LEF-dependent transcription is known to accompany differentiation, but the Frizzled (FZD) receptor responsible for transducing the WNT6 signal is not known. Eight of the 10 Fzd genes were found to be expressed in F9 cells, with Fzd7 being the most highly expressed, and chosen for further analysis. To alter steady-state Fzd7 levels and test the effect this has on differentiation, siRNA and overexpression approaches were used to knock-down and ectopically express the Fzd7 message, respectively. siRNA knock-down of Fzd7 resulted in reduced DAB2 levels, and the overexpression activated a TCF-LEF reporter, but neither approach affected differentiation. Our focus turned to how canonical WNT6 signaling was attenuated to allow PrE cells to form parietal endoderm (PE). Dkk1, encoding a WNT antagonist, was examined and results showed that its expression increased in F9 cells treated with retinoic acid (RA) or overexpressing Wnt6. F9 cells overexpressing human DKK1 or treated with DKK1-conditioned medium and then treated with RA failed to differentiate, indicating that a negative feedback loop involving WNT6 and DKK1 attenuates canonical WNT-β-catenin signaling, thereby allowing PE cells to differentiate.

Role of retinoic acid and platelet-derived growth factor receptor cross talk in the regulation of neonatal gonocyte and embryonal carcinoma cell differentiation

Neonatal gonocytes are direct precursors of spermatogonial stem cells, the cell pool that supports spermatogenesis. Although unipotent in vivo, gonocytes express pluripotency genes common with embryonic stem cells. Previously, we found that all-trans retinoic acid (RA) induced the expression of differentiation markers and a truncated form of platelet-derived growth factor receptor (PDGFR)β in rat gonocytes, as well as in F9 mouse embryonal carcinoma cells, an embryonic stem cell-surrogate that expresses somatic lineage markers in response to RA. The present study is focused on identifying the signaling pathways involved in RA-induced gonocyte and F9 cell differentiation. Mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase (MEK) 1/2 activation was required during F9 cell differentiation towards somatic lineage, whereas its inhibition potentiated RA-induced Stra8 expression, suggesting that MEK1/2 acts as a lineage specification switch in F9 cells. In both cell types, RA increased the expression of the spermatogonial/premeiotic marker Stra8, which is in line with F9 cells being at a stage before somatic-germline lineage specification. Inhibiting PDGFR kinase activity reduced RA-induced Stra8 expression. Interestingly, RA increased the expression of PDGFRα variant forms in both cell types. Together, these results suggest a potential cross talk between RA and PDGFR signaling pathways in cell differentiation. RA receptor-α inhibition partially reduced RA effects on Stra8 in gonocytes, indicating that RA acts in part via RA receptor-α. RA-induced gonocyte differentiation was significantly reduced by inhibiting SRC (v-src avian sarcoma [Schmidt-Ruppin A-2] viral oncogene) and JAK2/STAT5 (Janus kinase 2/signal transducer and activator of transcription 5) activities, implying that these signaling molecules play a role in gonocyte differentiation. These results suggest that gonocyte and F9 cell differentiation is regulated via cross talk between RA and PDGFRs using different downstream pathways.

GATA6 and FOXA2 regulate Wnt6 expression during extraembryonic endoderm formation

One of the earliest epithelial-to-mesenchymal transitions in mouse embryogenesis involves the differentiation of inner cell mass cells into primitive and then into parietal endoderm. These processes can be recapitulated in vitro using F9 teratocarcinoma cells, which differentiate into primitive endoderm when treated with retinoic acid (RA) and into parietal endoderm with subsequent treatment with dibutyryl cyclic adenosine monophosphate (db-cAMP). Our previous work on how primitive endoderm develops revealed that the Wnt6 gene is upregulated by RA, leading to the activation of the canonical WNT-β-catenin pathway. The mechanism by which Wnt6 is regulated was not determined, but in silico analysis of the human WNT6 promoter region had suggested that the GATA6 and FOXA2 transcription factors might be involved [1]. Subsequent analysis determined that both Gata6 and Foxa2 mRNA are upregulated in F9 cells treated with RA or RA and db-cAMP. More specifically, overexpression of Gata6 or Foxa2 alone induced molecular and morphological markers of primitive endoderm, which occurred concomitantly with the upregulation of the Wnt6 gene. Gata6- or Foxa2-overexpressing cells were also found to have increased levels in T-cell factor (TCF)-dependent transcription, and when these cells were treated with db-cAMP, they developed into parietal endoderm. Chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis revealed that GATA6 and FOXA2 were bound to the Wnt6 promoter, and overexpression studies showed that these transcription factors were sufficient to switch on the gene expression of a Wnt6 reporter construct. Together, these results provide evidence for the direct regulation of Wnt6 that leads to the activation of the canonical WNT-β-catenin pathway and subsequent induction of primitive extraembryonic endoderm.

The histone demethylase Kdm3a is essential to progression through differentiation

Histone demethylation has important roles in regulating gene expression and forms part of the epigenetic memory system that regulates cell fate and identity by still poorly understood mechanisms. Here, we examined the role of histone demethylase Kdm3a during cell differentiation, showing that Kdm3a is essential for differentiation into parietal endoderm-like (PE) cells in the F9 mouse embryonal carcinoma model. We identified a number of target genes regulated by Kdm3a during endoderm differentiation; among the most dysregulated were the three developmental master regulators Dab2, Pdlim4 and FoxQ1. We show that dysregulation of the expression of these genes correlates with Kdm3a H3K9me2 demethylase activity. We further demonstrate that either Dab2 depletion or Kdm3a depletion prevents F9 cells from fully differentiating into PE cells, but that ectopic expression of Dab2 cannot compensate for Kdm3a knockdown; Dab2 is thus necessary, but insufficient on its own, to promote complete terminal differentiation. We conclude that Kdm3a plays a crucial role in progression through PE differentiation by regulating expression of a set of endoderm differentiation master genes. The emergence of Kdm3a as a key modulator of cell fate decision strengthens the view that histone demethylases are essential to cell differentiation.

Functional specificity of ras isoforms: so similar but so different

H-ras, N-ras, and K-ras are canonical ras gene family members frequently activated by point mutation in human cancers and coding for 4 different, highly related protein isoforms (H-Ras, N-Ras, K-Ras4A, and K-Ras4B). Their expression is nearly ubiquitous and broadly conserved across eukaryotic species, although there are quantitative and qualitative differences of expression depending on the tissue and/or developmental stage under consideration. Extensive functional studies have determined during the last quarter century that these Ras gene products are critical components of signaling pathways that control eukaryotic cell proliferation, survival, and differentiation. However, because of their homology and frequent coexpression in various cellular contexts, it remained unclear whether the different Ras proteins play specific or overlapping functional roles in physiological and pathological processes. Initially, their high degree of sequence homology and the observation that all Ras isoforms share common sets of downstream effectors and upstream activators suggested that they were mostly redundant functionally. In contrast, the notion of functional specificity for each of the different Ras isoforms is supported at present by an increasing body of experimental observations, including 1) the fact that different ras isoforms are preferentially mutated in specific types of tumors or developmental disorders; 2) the different transforming potential of transfected ras genes in different cell contexts; 3) the distinct sensitivities exhibited by the various Ras family members for modulation by different GAPs or GEFs; 4) the demonstration that different Ras isoforms follow distinct intracellular processing pathways and localize to different membrane microdomains or subcellular compartments; 5) the different phenotypes displayed by genetically modified animal strains for each of the 3 ras loci; and 6) the specific transcriptional networks controlled by each isoform in different cellular settings.

Control of embryonic stem cell lineage commitment by core promoter factor, TAF3

Deciphering the molecular basis of pluripotency is fundamental to our understanding of development and embryonic stem cell function. Here, we report that TAF3, a TBP-associated core promoter factor, is highly enriched in ES cells. In this context, TAF3 is required for endoderm lineage differentiation and prevents premature specification of neuroectoderm and mesoderm. In addition to its role in the core promoter recognition complex TFIID, genome-wide binding studies reveal that TAF3 localizes to a subset of chromosomal regions bound by CTCF/cohesin that are selectively associated with genes upregulated by TAF3. Notably, CTCF directly recruits TAF3 to promoter distal sites and TAF3-dependent DNA looping is observed between the promoter distal sites and core promoters occupied by TAF3/CTCF/cohesin. Together, our findings support a new role of TAF3 in mediating long-range chromatin regulatory interactions that safeguard the finely-balanced transcriptional programs underlying pluripotency.

Ectopic expression of GATA6 bypasses requirement for Grb2 in primitive endoderm formation

Gene knockouts in mice have showed that Grb2 and GATA6 are essential for the formation of primitive endoderm in blastocysts. Here, we confirmed that implanted Grb2-null blastocysts lack primitive or extraembryonic endoderm cells either at E4.5 or E5.5 stages. We analyzed the relationship between Grb2 and GATA6 in the differentiation of embryonic stem (ES) cells to primitive endoderm in embryoid body models. Upon transfection with GATA6 expression vector, Grb2-null ES cells underwent endoderm differentiation as indicated by the expression of the extraembryonic endoderm markers Dab2 and GATA4. Transfection of GATA4 expression vector also had the same differentiation potency. When GATA6- or GATA4-transfected Grb2-null ES cells were allowed to aggregate, fragments of an endoderm layer formed on the surface of the spheroids. The results suggest that GATA6 is downstream of Grb2 in the inductive signaling pathway and the expression of GATA6 is sufficient to compensate for the defects caused by Grb2 deficiency in the development of the primitive and extraembryonic endoderm.

NF1 is a tumor suppressor in neuroblastoma that determines retinoic acid response and disease outcome

Retinoic acid (RA) induces differentiation of neuroblastoma cells in vitro and is used with variable success to treat aggressive forms of this disease. This variability in clinical response to RA is enigmatic, as no mutations in components of the RA signaling cascade have been found. Using a large-scale RNAi genetic screen, we identify crosstalk between the tumor suppressor NF1 and retinoic acid-induced differentiation in neuroblastoma. Loss of NF1 activates RAS-MEK signaling, which in turn represses ZNF423, a critical transcriptional coactivator of the retinoic acid receptors. Neuroblastomas with low levels of both NF1 and ZNF423 have extremely poor outcome. We find NF1 mutations in neuroblastoma cell lines and in primary tumors. Inhibition of MEK signaling downstream of NF1 restores responsiveness to RA, suggesting a therapeutic strategy to overcome RA resistance in NF1-deficient neuroblastomas.

The phosphoinositide-3-kinase/Akt pathway mediates the transient increase in Nanog expression during differentiation of F9 cells

Nanog is a key determinant that maintains self-renewal and pluripotency of embryonic stem cells and represses their differentiation to endoderm. In this study, we examined the regulation of Nanog expression by phosphoinositide-3-kinase (PI3K)/Akt pathway during retinoic acid (RA)-induced differentiation of F9 embryonic carcinoma cells. Nanog protein expression was transiently upregulated up to 6 h after RA treatment and then declined. In agreement, a murine Nanog promoter reporter assay revealed that promoter activity increased during early stage of differentiation, but decreased when F9 cells became fully differentiated. RA treatment of F9 cells also led to a transient and parallel increase in both Akt and glycogen synthase kinase 3beta phosphorylations. Nanog expression was diminished in the early stage by LY294002, a PI3K inhibitor, but was not affected in the late stage despite considerable inhibition of Akt phosphorylation and endoderm marker expression by the inhibitor. These data suggest that RA-induced PI3K/Akt activation in the early stage of differentiation is required for Nanog expression, which becomes independent of PI3K/Akt signaling once the differentiation is established. Thus, Nanog expression appears to be differently regulated by the PI3K/Akt pathway depending on differentiation stage.

FGF signalling as a mediator of lineage transitions--evidence from embryonic stem cell differentiation

The fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signalling pathway is one of the most ubiquitous in biology. It has diverse roles in development, differentiation and cancer. Embryonic stem (ES) cells are in vitro cell lines capable of differentiating into all the lineages of the conceptus. As such they have the capacity to differentiate into derivatives of all three germ layers and to some extent the extra-embryonic lineages as well. Given the prominent role of FGF signalling in early embryonic development, we explore the role of this pathway in early ES cell differentiation towards the major lineages of the embryo. As early embryonic differentiation is intricately choreographed at the level of morphogenetic movement, adherent ES cell culture affords a unique opportunity to study the basic steps in early lineage specification in the absence of ever shifting complex in vivo microenvironments. Thus recent experiments in ES cell differentiation are able to pinpoint specific FGF dependent lineage transitions that are difficult to resolve in vivo. Here we review the role of FGF signalling in early development alongside the ES cell data and suggest that FGF dependent signalling via phospho-Erk activation maybe a major mediator of transitions in lineage specification.

Coordinate Gα13 and Wnt6-β-catenin signaling in F9 embryonal carcinoma cells is required for primitive endoderm differentiation

The mouse F9 embryonal carcinoma cell line is ideally suited to study the epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition accompanying the differentiation of primitive to parietal extraembryonic endoderm. In F9 cells, the application of exogenous agents including retinoic acid or activation of signal transduction cascades downstream of G-proteins triggers widespread changes in gene expression and leads to the formation of primitive endoderm. The epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition is completed and parietal endoderm develops as of result of increasing PKA activity in primitive endoderm cells. Expression of a constitutively active form of Gα13(Q226L) is sufficient to induce F9 cells into parietal endoderm and a model is emerging that a signaling axis linking G-protein signaling to RhoA and the ERM protein moesin is required for differentiation. In this study, we found that expression of either p115RhoGEF or a constitutively active, GTPase-deficient form of RhoA(L63) promoted primitive, but not parietal, endoderm formation. The overexpression of Gα13(Q226L) or p115RhoGEF, but not Rho(L63), caused β-catenin to translocate to the nucleus. Surprisingly, the stimulation of the Wnt-β-catenin pathway was accompanied by nuclear β-catenin and primitive endoderm formation, even when a dominant negative was used to block the signaling axis at the level of p115RhoGEF or when ROCK activity was inhibited using the pharmacological agent Y-27632. Together, results indicate that the coordinate signaling by two independent pathways, one involving canonical Wnt-β-catenin activation of target genes and the other with Gα13 signaling to ERM proteins to modulate cytoarchitectural changes, is required during the retinoic acid induced differentiation of F9 cells to primitive endoderm.

Isoform-specific ras functions in development and cancer

The three closely related mammalian ras genes, Hras, Nras and Kras, have each been implicated in human tumorigenesis by virtue of mutational activation. However, while these genes encode proteins with very similar biochemical properties, activating ras alleles corresponding to the various isoforms have been linked to particular malignancies. Accumulating evidence suggests that these proteins exert distinct activities in a tissue-specific context, apparently reflecting developmental lineage-specific roles for the various ras isoforms. Some of these distinct functions appear to reflect differences in their C-termini, which determine distinct subcellular localization, thereby suggesting a role for compartmentalized signaling. In this review, we discuss the biological functions of the ras isoforms in the context of tissue-specific function as it relates to ras function in development and human cancer.

Integrins are required for the differentiation of visceral endoderm

Integrins of the beta1 subfamily are highly expressed in the early mouse embryo and are essential for the formation of primitive germ layers from the inner cell mass (ICM). We investigated the mechanisms by which alphabeta1 integrins regulate ICM morphogenesis by using the embryonic-stem-cell-derived embryoid body (EB), a model for peri-implantation development. Ablation of integrin beta1 in EBs resulted in endoderm detachment and in maturation defects, which were manifested by the mislocalization of GATA4 in the cytoplasm and the markedly reduced synthesis of basement membrane (BM) components and the lineage marker disabled homolog 2. The mutant endoderm cells failed to spread on BM substrates, but could spread on vitronectin, which induced upregulation of alphavbeta3 integrin and integrin-dependent GATA4 nuclear translocation. Forced expression of integrin beta3 in the mutant EBs completely rescued endoderm morphogenesis, suggesting that integrin beta3 can substitute for integrin beta1 in the endoderm. Furthermore, the mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPKs) ERK1 and ERK2 (ERK1/2) and p38 were activated in endoderm in an integrin-dependent fashion. Pharmacological inhibition of ERK1/2 or p38 MAPK blocked vitronectin-induced GATA4 nuclear translocation and endoderm maturation, whereas expression of a constitutively active ERK kinase (MEK1) or p38 MAPK in the mutant cells rescued endoderm maturation in integrin-beta1-null endoderm cells. Collectively, these results suggest that integrins are required for both the stable adhesion and maturation of visceral endoderm, the latter being mediated through the activation of ERK1/2 and p38 MAPK.

Activated Kras, but not Hras or Nras, may initiate tumors of endodermal origin via stem cell expansion

The three closely related human Ras genes, Hras, Nras, and Kras, are all widely expressed, engage a common set of downstream effectors, and can each exhibit oncogenic activity. However, the vast majority of activating Ras mutations in human tumors involve Kras. Moreover, Kras mutations are most frequently seen in tumors of endodermally derived tissues (lung, pancreas, and colon), suggesting that activated Kras may affect an endodermal progenitor to initiate oncogenesis. Using a culture model of retinoic acid (RA)-induced stem cell differentiation to endoderm, we determined that while activated HrasV12 promotes differentiation and growth arrest in these endodermal progenitors, KrasV12 promotes their proliferation. Furthermore, KrasV12-expressing endodermal progenitors fail to differentiate upon RA treatment and continue to proliferate and maintain stem cell characteristics. NrasV12 neither promotes nor prevents differentiation. A structure-function analysis demonstrated that these distinct effects of the Ras isoforms involve their variable C-terminal domains, implicating compartmentalized signaling, and revealed a requirement for several established Ras effectors. These findings indicate that activated Ras isoforms exert profoundly different effects on endodermal progenitors and that mutant Kras may initiate tumorigenesis by expanding a susceptible stem/progenitor cell population. These results potentially explain the high frequency of Kras mutations in tumors of endodermal origin.

Wnt6 induces the specification and epithelialization of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells to primitive endoderm

Epithelial-to-mesenchymal transitions (EMTs) play key roles in the normal development of an organism as well as its demise following the metastasis of a malignant tumour. An EMT during early mouse development results in the differentiation of primitive endoderm into the parietal endoderm that forms part of the parietal yolk sac. In the embryo, primitive endoderm develops from cells in the inner cell mass, but the signals that instruct these cells to become specified and adopt an epithelial fate are poorly understood. The mouse F9 teratocarcinoma cell line, a model that can recapitulate the in vivo primitive to parietal endoderm EMT, has been used extensively to elucidate the signalling cascades involved in extraembryonic endoderm differentiation. Here, we identified Wnt6 as a gene up-regulated in F9 cells in response to RA and show that Wnt6 expressing cells or cells exposed to Wnt6 conditioned media form primitive endoderm. Wnt6 induction of primitive endoderm is accompanied by beta-catenin and Snail1 translocation to the nucleus and the appearance of cytokeratin intermediate filaments. Attenuating glycogen synthase kinase 3 activity using LiCl gave similar results, but the fact that cells de-differentiate when LiCl is removed reveals that other signalling pathways are required to maintain cells as primitive endoderm. Finally, Wnt6-induced primitive endodermal cells were tested to determine their competency to complete the EMT and differentiate into parietal endoderm. Towards that end, results show that up-regulating protein kinase A activity is sufficient to induce markers of parietal endoderm. Together, these findings indicate that undifferentiated F9 cells are responsive to canonical Wnt signalling, which negatively regulates glycogen synthase kinase 3 activity leading to the epithelialization and specification of primitive endoderm competent to receive additional signals required for EMT. Considering the ability of F9 cells to mimic an in vivo EMT, the identification of this Wnt6-beta-catenin-Snail signalling cascade has broad implications for understanding EMT mechanisms in embryogenesis and metastasis.

Evolution of the mechanisms and molecular control of endoderm formation

Endoderm differentiation and movements are of fundamental importance not only for subsequent morphogenesis of the digestive tract but also to enable normal patterning and differentiation of mesoderm- and ectoderm-derived organs. This review defines the tissues that have been called endoderm in different species, their cellular origin and their movements. We take a comparative approach to ask how signaling pathways leading to embryonic and extraembryonic endoderm differentiation have emerged in different organisms, how they became integrated and point to specific gaps in our knowledge that would be worth filling. Lastly, we address whether the gastrulation movements that lead to endoderm internalization are coupled with its differentiation.

Cytodifferentiation by retinoids, a novel therapeutic option in oncology: rational combinations with other therapeutic agents

Retinoic acid (RA) and derivatives are promising antineoplastic agents endowed with both therapeutic and chemopreventive potential. Although the treatment of acute promyelocytic leukemia with all-trans retinoic acid is an outstanding example, the full potential of retinoids in oncology has not yet been explored and a more generalized use of these compounds is not yet a reality. One way to enhance the therapeutic and chemopreventive activity of RA and derivatives is to identify rational combinations between these compounds and other pharmacological agents. This is now possible given the information available on the biochemical and molecular mechanisms underlying the biological activity of retinoids. At the cellular level, the antileukemia and anticancer activity of retinoids is the result of three main actions, cytodifferentiation, growth inhibition, and apoptosis. Cytodifferentiation is a particularly attractive modality of treatment and differentiating agents promise to be less toxic and more specific than conventional chemotherapy. This is the result of the fact that cytotoxicity is not the primary aim of differentiation therapy. At the molecular level, retinoids act through the activation of nuclear retinoic acid receptor-dependent and -independent pathways. The cellular pathways and molecular networks relevant for retinoid activity are modulated by a panoply of other intracellular and extracellular pathways that may be targeted by known drugs and other experimental therapeutics. This chapter aims to summarize and critically discuss the available knowledge in the field.

Gα13 activation rescues moesin-depletion induced apoptosis in F9 teratocarcinoma cells

Mouse F9 cells differentiate into primitive endoderm when treated with retinoic acid (RA) and into parietal endoderm in response to RA and dibutyryl (db-) cAMP. G protein signaling either blocks or mimics RA-induced differentiation, the latter signaling through the Wnt-beta-catenin pathway. In our study, we found that a constitutively active Galpha13 mutant induces F9 cells to differentiate into parietal endoderm in the absence of exogenous agents. Galpha13 expression and subsequent differentiation are accompanied by beta-catenin translocation to the nucleus. Differentiation and changes in cell morphology are supported by rearrangements to the F-actin cytoskeleton. ERM (ezrin-radixin-moesin) proteins, known to link F-actin to transmembrane receptors, are also redistributed during differentiation. Furthermore, morpholino antisense and shRNA approaches show that moesin expression is essential since its knockdown leads to altered F-actin distribution and subsequent apoptosis. Moesin-depleted cells, however, remain attached to the substrate when Galpha13 is constitutively expressed, but they do not differentiate into extraembryonic endoderm. Our study demonstrates a link between Galpha13 signaling that regulates differentiation of F9 cells through primitive to parietal endoderm and a moesin requirement for cell survival.

The Grb2/Mek pathway represses Nanog in murine embryonic stem cells

The homeobox gene Nanog is a key intrinsic determinant of self renewal in embryonic stem (ES) cells, and its repression leads ES cells to selectively differentiate into primitive endoderm. Although Nanog repression occurs at the outermost layer of ES cell aggregates independent of the leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF)/STAT3 pathway, it is largely undetermined what external cues and intracellular signals cause the event. Of interest, addition of the tyrosine phosphatase inhibitor, sodium vanadate, selectively repressed Nanog transcription without any detectable changes in upstream transcriptional regulators Oct3/4 and Sox2. Furthermore, sodium vanadate induced primitive endoderm differentiation, even in the inner cells of ES cell aggregates. Expression of Gata6 and Zfp42, two putative downstream Nanog effectors, was also increased and decreased by the addition of sodium vanadate, respectively, but these changes were eliminated by exogenous Nanog expression. The effects of sodium vanadate were abrogated by Grb2 deficiency or by the addition of the Mek inhibitor, PD98059. Indeed, PD98059 prevented Nanog repression induced by ES cell aggregation as well. Furthermore, transfection of a constitutive active Mek mutant into ES cells induced Nanog repression and primitive endoderm differentiation. These data indicate that the Grb2/Mek pathway primarily mediates Nanog gene repression upon ES cell differentiation into primitive endoderm.

Imprinted X-inactivation in extra-embryonic endoderm cell lines from mouse blastocysts

The extra-embryonic endoderm lineage plays a major role in the nutritive support of the embryo and is required for several inductive events, such as anterior patterning and blood island formation. Blastocyst-derived embryonic stem (ES) and trophoblast stem (TS) cell lines provide good models with which to study the development of the epiblast and trophoblast lineages,respectively. We describe the derivation and characterization of cell lines that are representative of the third lineage of the blastocyst –extra-embryonic endoderm. Extra-embryonic endoderm (XEN) cell lines can be reproducibly derived from mouse blastocysts and passaged without any evidence of senescence. XEN cells express markers typical of extra-embryonic endoderm derivatives, but not those of the epiblast or trophoblast. Chimeras generated by injection of XEN cells into blastocysts showed exclusive contribution to extra-embryonic endoderm cell types. We used female XEN cells to investigate the mechanism of X chromosome inactivation in this lineage. We observed paternally imprinted X-inactivation, consistent with observations in vivo. Based on gene expression analysis, chimera studies and imprinted X-inactivation, XEN cell lines are representative of extra-embryonic endoderm and provide a new cell culture model of an early mammalian lineage.

Association of the transcriptional corepressor TIF1beta with heterochromatin protein 1 (HP1): an essential role for progression through differentiation

The transcriptional intermediary factor 1beta (TIF1beta) is a corepressor for KRAB-domain-containing zinc finger proteins and is believed to play essential roles in cell physiology by regulating chromatin organization at specific loci through association with chromatin remodeling and histone-modifying activities and recruitment of heterochromatin protein 1 (HP1) proteins. In this study, we have engineered a modified embryonal carcinoma F9 cell line (TIF1beta(HP1box/-)) expressing a mutated TIF1beta protein (TIF1beta(HP1box)) unable to interact with HP1 proteins. Phenotypic analysis of TIF1beta(HP1box/-) and TIF1beta(+/-) cells shows that TIF1beta-HP1 interaction is not required for differentiation of F9 cells into primitive endoderm-like (PrE) cells on retinoic acid (RA) treatment but is essential for further differentiation into parietal endoderm-like (PE) cells on addition of cAMP and for differentiation into visceral endoderm-like cells on treatment of vesicles with RA. Complementation experiments reveal that TIF1beta-HP1 interaction is essential only during a short window of time within early differentiating PrE cells to establish a selective transmittable competence to terminally differentiate on further cAMP inducing signal. Moreover, the expression of three endoderm-specific genes, GATA6, HNF4, and Dab2, is down-regulated in TIF1beta(HP1box/-) cells compared with wild-type cells during PrE differentiation. Collectively, these data demonstrate that the interaction between TIF1beta and HP1 proteins is essential for progression through differentiation by regulating the expression of endoderm differentiation master players.

Retinoic acid decreases fetal lung mesenchymal cell proliferation in vivo and in vitro

Retinoic acid (RA) is an important coordinator of mammalian organogenesis. RA is implicated in critical lung developmental events. Cell proliferation is precisely regulated during development. We investigated the effect of RA on proliferating mesenchymal cells in both whole organ lung cultures and cell cultures. The potential pathways required for the response were studied in cultures of lung mesenchymal cells from embryonic day (e) 12. We observed an RA-dependent reduction in proliferation of mesenchymal cells in both whole organ and in cell culture. In mesenchymal cell cultures, RA decreased proliferation in lung mesenchymal cells by 72%. This was associated with a decrease of erk-1/2 activity by 68%. Mesenchymal cell proliferation is erk-1/2 dependent. Erk-1/2 can be activated by G-protein coupled receptors (GPCR) or tyrosine kinase receptors (RTK). RA treatment altered both the RTK and the GPCR pathways in primary lung mesenchymal cells. The Epidermal Growth Factor (EGF) dependent erk-1/2 activation was increased by 35% whereas the G(i)-protein cascade was inhibited by 44% in cells treated with RA. Our results suggest that RA decreases proliferation of lung mesenchyme via a G(i)-protein and the erk-1/2 signaling cascade.

Maspin plays an essential role in early embryonic development

Maspin (Mp) is a member of the serpin family with inhibitory functions against cell migration, metastasis and angiogenesis. To identify its role in embryonic development in vivo, we generated maspin knockout mice by gene targeting. In this study, we showed that homozygous loss of maspin expression was lethal at the peri-implantation stage. Maspin was specifically expressed in the visceral endoderm after implantation; deletion of maspin interfered with the formation of the endodermal cell layer, thereby disrupting the morphogenesis of the epiblast. In vitro, the ICM of the Mp–/– blastocysts failed to grow out appropriately. Data from embryoid body formation studies indicated that the Mp–/– EBs had a disorganized, endodermal cell mass and lacked a basement membrane layer. We showed that the embryonic ectoderm lineage was lost in the Mp–/– EBs,compared with that of the Mp+/+ EBs. Re-expression of maspin partially rescued the defects observed in the Mp–/– EBs, as evidenced by the appearance of ectoderm cells and a layer of endoderm cells surrounding the ectoderm. In addition, a maspin antibody specifically blocked normal EB formation,indicating that maspin controls the process through a cell surface event. Furthermore, we showed that maspin directly increased endodermal cell adhesion to laminin matrix but not to fibronectin. Mp+/–endodermal cells grew significantly slower than Mp+/+endodermal cells on laminin substrate. We conclude that deletion of maspin affects VE function by reducing cell proliferation and adhesion, thereby controlling early embryonic development.

Lineage allocation and asymmetries in the early mouse embryo

The mouse blastocyst, at the time of implantation, has three distinct cell lineages: epiblast (EPI), trophoblast and primitive endoderm (PE). Interactions between these three lineages and their directional growth and migration are critical for establishing the initial asymmetries that result in anterior-posterior patterning of the embryo proper. We have re-investigated the timing of specification of the three lineages in relation to the differential allocation of progeny of the first two blastomeres to the embryonic versus abembryonic axis of the blastocyst. We find that the majority of cells of the inner cell mass (ICM) are specified to be EPI or PE by the mid 3.5 day blastocyst and that this is associated with localized expression of GATA-6 in the ICM. We propose a model for molecular specification of the blastocyst lineages in which a combination of cell division order, signal transduction differences between inner and outer cells and segregation of key transcription factors can produce a blastocyst in which all three lineages are normally set up in an ordered, lineage-dependent manner, but which can also reconstruct a blastocyst when division order or cell interactions are disturbed.

Sphingosine-1-phosphate lyase is involved in the differentiation of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells to primitive endoderm

Sphingosine 1-phosphate (S1P) is a bioactive lipid molecule that acts both extracellularly and intracellularly. The SPL gene encodes a mammalian S1P lyase that degrades S1P. Here, we have disrupted the SPL gene in mouse F9 embryonal carcinoma cells by gene targeting. This is the first report of gene disruption of mammalian S1P lyase. The SPL-null cells exhibited no S1P lyase activity, and intracellular S1P was increased approximately 2-fold, compared with wild-type cells. Treatment of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells with retinoic acid induces differentiation to primitive endoderm (PrE). An acceleration in this PrE differentiation was observed in the SPL-null cells. This effect was apparently caused by the accumulated S1P, since N,N-dimethylsphingosine, a S1P synthesis inhibitor, had an inhibitory effect on the PrE differentiation. Moreover, F9 cells stably expressing sphingosine kinase also exhibited an acceleration in the differentiation. Exogenous S1P had no effect on differentiation, indicating that intracellular but not extracellular S1P is involved. Moreover, we determined that expression of the SPL protein is up-regulated during the progression to PrE. We also showed that sphingosine kinase activity is increased in PrE-differentiated cells. These results suggest that intracellular S1P has a role in the PrE differentiation and that SPL may be involved in the regulation of intracellular S1P levels during this differentiation.

Disabled-2 is essential for endodermal cell positioning and structure formation during mouse embryogenesis

The signal transduction adapter protein Disabled-2 (Dab2) is one of the two mammalian orthologs of the Drosophila Disabled. The brain-specific Disabled-1 (Dab1) functions in positional organization of brain cells during development. Dab2 is widely distributed and is highly expressed in many epithelial cell types. The dab2 gene was interrupted by in-frame insertion of beta-galactosidase (LacZ) in embryonic stem cells and transgenic mice were produced. Dab2 expression was first observed in the primitive endoderm at E4.5, immediately following implantation. The homozygous Dab2-deficient mutant is embryonic lethal (earlier than E6.5) due to defective cell positioning and structure formation of the visceral endoderm. In E5.5 dab2 (-/-) conceptus, visceral endoderm-like cells are present in the deformed primitive egg cylinder; however, the visceral endoderm cells are not organized, the cells of the epiblast have not expanded, and the proamniotic cavity fails to form. Disorganization of the visceral endodermal layer is evident, as cells with positive visceral endoderm markers are scattered throughout the dab2 (-/-) conceptus. Only degenerated remains were observed at E6.5 for dab2 (-/-) embryos, and by E7.5, the defective embryos were completely reabsorbed. In blastocyst in vitro culture, initially cells with characteristics of endoderm, trophectoderm, and inner cell mass were observed in the outgrowth of the hatched dab2 (-/-) blastocysts. However, the dab2 (-/-) endodermal cells are much more dispersed and disorganized than those from wild-type blastocysts, the inner cell mass fails to expand, and the outgrowth degenerates by day 7. Thus, Dab2 is required for visceral endodermal cell organization during early mouse development. The absence of an organized visceral endoderm in Dab2-deficient conceptus leads to the growth failure of the inner cell mass. We suggest that Dab2 functions in a signal pathway to regulate endodermal cell organization using endocytosis of ligands from the blastocoel cavity as a positioning cue.

Retinoic acid induces parietal endoderm but not primitive endoderm and visceral endoderm differentiation in F9 teratocarcinoma stem cells with a targeted deletion of the Rex-1 (Zfp-42) gene

Cultured murine F9 teratocarcinoma stem cells resemble pluripotent stem cells of the inner cell mass of the mouse blastocyst and, depending upon their treatment, can be induced to differentiate along the primitive endoderm, the parietal endoderm (PE), or the visceral endoderm (VE) pathway. The Rex-1 gene encodes a zinc finger family transcription factor which is expressed at high levels in undifferentiated F9 stem cells, embryonic stem cells, and in other types of stem cells. To examine whether the Rex-1 protein plays a role in F9 cell differentiation, homologous recombination was employed to generate F9 cell lines which lack both alleles of Rex-1. F9 wild type cells in monolayer culture require both retinoic acid and cyclic AMP analogs to differentiate into PE, whereas the F9 Rex-1(-/-) cells differentiate into PE, as assessed by several molecular markers, including thrombomodulin and laminin B1, in the presence of RA alone. The F9 Rex-1(-/-) cells do not completely differentiate into VE after RA treatment in aggregate culture; they do not express alpha-fetoprotein, a definitive marker of VE differentiation. These results indicate that the Rex-1 transcription factor regulates the differentiation of F9 stem cells along several distinct cell lineages found in the early embryo.

Orchestration of multiple arrays of signal cross-talk and combinatorial interactions for maturation and cell death: another vision of t(15;17) preleukemic blast and APL-cell maturation

Despite intensive molecular biology investigations over the past 10 years, and an important breakthrough on how PML-RARalpha, the fusion protein resulting from t(15;17), can alter RARalpha and PML functions, no definitive views on how leukemia is generated and by what mechanism(s) the normal phenotype is restored, are yet available. 'Resistances' to pharmacological levels of all-trans-retinoic acid (ATRA) have been observed in experimental in vivo and in vitro models. In this review, we emphasize the key role played by signal cross-talk for both normal and neoplastic hemopoiesis. After an overview of reported experimental data on APL-cell maturation and apoptosis, we apply our current knowledge on signaling pathways to underline those which might generate signal cross-talks. The design of biological models suitable to decipher the integration of signal cross-talks at the transcriptional level should be our first priority today, to generate some realistic therapeutic approaches After 'Ten Years of Molecular APL', we still know very little about how the disease develops and how effective medicines work.

MST4, a new Ste20-related kinase that mediates cell growth and transformation via modulating ERK pathway

In this study, we report the cloning and characterization of a novel human Ste20-related kinase that we designated MST4. The 416 amino acid full-length MST4 contains an amino-terminal kinase domain, which is highly homologous to MST3 and SOK, and a unique carboxy-terminal domain. Northern blot analysis indicated that MST4 is highly expressed in placenta, thymus, and peripheral blood leukocytes. Wild-type but not kinase-dead MST4 can phosphorylate myelin basic protein in an in vitro kinase assay. MST4 specifically activates ERK but not JNK or p38 MAPK in transient transfected cells or in stable cell lines. Overexpression of dominant negative MEK1 or treatment with PD98059 abolishes MST4-induced ERK activity, whereas dominant-negative Ras or c-Raf-1 mutants failed to do so, indicating MST4 activates MEK1/ERK via a Ras/Raf-1 independent pathway. HeLa and Phoenix cell lines overexpressing wild-type, but not kinase-dead, MST4 exhibit increased growth rate and form aggressive soft-agar colonies. These phenotypes can be inhibited by PD98059. These results provide the first evidence that MST4 is biologically active in the activation of MEK/ERK pathway and in mediating cell growth and transformation.

The regulation of embryonic stem cell differentiation by leukaemia inhibitory factor (LIF)

LIF (leukaemia inhibitory factor) is commonly used to maintain mouse embryonic stem cells in an undifferentiated state. These cells spontaneously differentiate when allowed to aggregate in the absence of LIF, forming embryoid bodies in which early embryonic cell lineages develop. Using embryoid bodies cultured in the presence and absence of LIF, we show that although LIF inhibited the development of visceral and parietal endodermal cells, it did not affect the differentiation of the primitive endodermal cell precursors of these extraembryonic cell lineages. Furthermore, deposition of the basement membrane produced by the primitive endodermal cells, which separates them from the remaining cells of the embryoid body, still occurred. The differentiation of primitive ectodermal cells and their progeny was inhibited by LIF, as evidenced by the lack of expression of FGF-5, muscle, and neuronal markers. However, cavitation of the embryoid body and maintenance of the cells in contact with the primitive endodermal basement membrane as an epiblast epithelium still occurred normally in the presence of LIF. These results indicate that cavitation and formation of the epiblast epithelium are regulated by mechanisms distinct from those controlling the differentiation of epiblast cell lineages. Furthermore, although epithelium formation and cavitation do not require the differentiation of visceral endodermal cells, the results are consistent with the hypothesis that the primitive endodermal basement membrane is sufficient to induce the epithelialization of undifferentiated embryonic stem cells necessary for cavitation.

Disassociation of MAPK activation and c-Fos expression in F9 embryonic carcinoma cells following retinoic acid-induced endoderm differentiation

Retinoic acid induces cell differentiation and suppresses cell growth in a wide spectrum of cell lines, and down-regulation of activator protein-1 activity by retinoic acid contributes to these effects. In embryonic stem cell-like F9 teratocarcinoma cells, which are widely used to study retinoic acid actions on gene regulation and early embryonic differentiation, retinoic acid treatment for 4 days resulted in suppression of cell growth and differentiation into primitive and then visceral endoderm-like cells, accompanied by a suppression of serum-induced c-Fos expression. The MAPK (ERK) pathway was involved in mitogenic signaling in F9 cells stimulated with serum. Surprisingly, although c-Fos expression was reduced, the MAPK activity was not decreased by retinoic acid treatment. We found that retinoic acid treatment inhibited the phosphorylation of Elk-1, a target of activated MAPK required for c-Fos transcription. In F9 cells, the MAPK/MEK inhibitor PD98059 suppressed Elk-1 phosphorylation and c-Fos expression, indicating that MAPK activity is required for Elk-1 phosphorylation/activation. Phosphoprotein phosphatase 2B (calcineurin), the major phosphatase for activated Elk-1, is not the target in the disassociation of MAPK activation and c-Fos expression since its inhibition by cyclosporin A or activation by ionomycin had no significant effects on serum-stimulated c-Fos expression and Elk-1 phosphorylation. Thus, we conclude that retinoic acid treatment to induce F9 cell differentiation uncouples Ras/MAPK activation from c-Fos expression by reduction of Elk-1 phosphorylation through a mechanism not involving the activation of phosphoprotein phosphatase 2B.

Disabled-2 exerts its tumor suppressor activity by uncoupling c-Fos expression and MAP kinase activation

Disabled-2 (Dab2) is a putative tumor suppressor in breast and ovarian cancers. Its expression is lost in a majority of tumors, and homozygous deletions have been identified in a small percentage of tumors. Dab2 expression is absent or very low in the majority of breast and ovarian cancer cell lines, including MCF-7 and SK-Br-3 breast cancer cells. Transfection and expression of Dab2 in MCF-7 and SK-Br-3 cells suppress tumorigenicity. The cells reach a much lower saturation density and have reduced ability to form colonies on agar plates. In examining the signal transduction pathway of Dab2-transfected cells, we found that serum-stimulated c-Fos expression was greatly suppressed; however, the effects of Dab2 on MAPK family kinases were not as consistent. In MCF-7 and SK-Br-3 cells, although c-Fos expression was suppressed, the Erk1/2, JNK, and p38(MAPK) activities were unchanged or even increased. Serum-stimulated c-Fos expression is dependent on MAPK/Erk activity because the MEK inhibitor PD98059 suppresses Erk activity and c-Fos expression. Therefore, Dab2 appears to uncouple MAPK activation and c-fos transcription. Thus, we conclude that Dab2 re-expression suppresses tumorigenicity by reducing c-Fos expression at a site downstream of the activation of MAPK family kinases. Because Dab2 is frequently lost in cancer, the uncoupling of MAPK activation and c-Fos expression may be a favored target for inactivation in tumorigenicity.

New thoughts on the role of the beta-gamma subunit in G-protein signal transduction

Heterotrimeric G proteins are involved in numerous biological processes, where they mediate signal transduction from agonist-bound G-protein-coupled receptors to a variety of intracellular effector molecules and ion channels. G proteins consist of two signaling moieties: a GTP-bound alpha subunit and a beta-gamma heterodimer. The beta-gamma dimer, recently credited as a significant modulator of G-protein-mediated cellular responses, is postulated to be a major determinant of signaling fidelity between G-protein-coupled receptors and downstream effectors. In this review we have focused on the role of beta-gamma signaling and have included examples to demonstrate the heterogeneity in the heterodimer composition and its implications in signaling fidelity. We also present an overview of some of the effectors regulated by beta-gamma and draw attention to the fact that, although G proteins and their associated receptors play an instrumental role in development, there is rather limited information on beta-gamma signaling in embryogenesis.

Regulation of laminin and COUP-TF expression in extraembryonic endodermal cells

Laminin expression and the subsequent deposition of a basement membrane by primitive endoderm cells is necessary for early mammalian development. We demonstrate that the transcription factors COUP-TF I and II are up-regulated in primitive endoderm cells faster than LAMB1 and LAMC1, and that either COUP-TF is sufficient to induce expression of these laminin genes.

The retinoids and cancer prevention mechanisms

Carcinogenesis is a multistep process that converts normal cells into malignant cells. Once transformed, malignant cells acquire the ability to invade and metastasize, leading to clinically evident disease. During this continuum from normal to metastatic cells, carcinogenic steps can be arrested or reversed through pharmacological treatments, known as cancer chemoprevention. Chemoprevention strategies represent therapeutic interventions at early stages of carcinogenesis, before the onset of invasive cancer. Effective chemoprevention should reduce or avoid the clinical consequences of overt malignancies by treating early neoplastic lesions before development of clinically apparent signs or symptoms. Preclinical, clinical, and epidemiological data provide considerable support for cancer chemoprevention as an attractive therapeutic strategy. This clinical approach was validated in the recent tamoxifen randomized trial, demonstrating that a selective estrogen receptor modulator reduces the risk of breast cancer in women at high risk for this malignancy. Derivatives of vitamin A, the retinoids, have reported activity in treating specific premalignant lesions and reducing incidence of second primary tumors in patients with prior head and neck, lung or liver cancers. Whether the retinoids will prevent primary cancers at these sites is not yet known. Notably, a carotenoid (beta-carotene) was shown as inactive in primary prevention of lung cancers in high-risk individuals. This underscores the need for relevant in vitro models to identify pathways signaling chemopreventive effects. These models should assess the activity of candidate chemoprevention agents before the conduct of large and costly prevention trials. An improved understanding of cancer prevention mechanisms should aid in the discovery of new therapeutic targets and chemoprevention agents. Ideally, these agents should have tolerable clinical toxicities suitable for chronic administration to individuals at high risk for developing primary or second cancers. This article reviews what is now known from clinical and preclinical studies about the retinoids as cancer prevention agents.

Circadian and photic regulation of MAP kinase by Ras- and protein phosphatase-dependent pathways in the chick pineal gland

Chick pineal mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) exhibits circadian activation and light-dependent deactivation at nighttime. Here we report that, in the chick pineal gland, levels of active forms of MAPK, MEK, Raf-1 and Ras exhibited synchronous circadian rhythms with peaks during the subjective night, suggesting a sequential activation of components in the classical Ras-MAPK pathway in a circadian manner. In contrast, the light-dependent deactivation of MAPK was not accompanied by any change of MEK activity, but it was attributed to the light-dependent activation of protein phosphatase dephosphorylating MAPK. These results indicate that the photic and clock signals regulate MAPK activity via independent pathways, and suggest a pivotal role of MAPK in photic entrainment and maintenance of the circadian oscillation.

Interdependent action of RalGEF and Erk in Ras-induced primitive endoderm differentiation of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells

Previous work by us and others has implicated a role for Ral guanine exchange factors (RalGEFs) in Ras-induced cell growth and oncogenic transformation. Here we show for the first time that RalGEFs are involved in Ras-induced differentiation as well. Expression of oncogenic Ras in F9 embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells is known to induce differentiation to a primitive endoderm (PrE)-like phenotype, but the downstream signal transduction mechanisms involved are unclear. We found that PrE differentiation is induced by the Ras effector domain mutants, RasV12G37 and RasV12E38, but not by RasV12C40. Accordingly, expression of constitutively active forms of RalGEF (Rlf-CAAX) or Rafl (Raf-CAAX) is sufficient to induce differentiation. Inhibition of RalGEF activity by expression of dominant negative Ral completely abolishes Rlf-CAAX- and RasV12G37-induced differentiation, while it reduces differentiation by RasV12 and Raf-CAAX. Finally, while Rlf-CAAX does not increase Erk activity, inhibition of MEK blocks both Ras- as well as Rlf-CAAX-induced differentiation, suggesting that RalGEFs induce PrE differentiation in a manner depending on basal MEK or Erk activity. Based on these results we conclude that Ras induces PrE differentiation of F9 EC cells via an interplay of Erk-and RalGEF-mediated pathways.

Parathyroid hormone-related peptide (PTHrP) induces parietal endoderm formation exclusively via the type I PTH/PTHrP receptor

A number of studies suggest a role for PTHrP and the classical PTH/PTHrP receptor (type I) in one of the first differentiation processes in mouse embryogenesis, i.e. the formation of parietal endoderm (PE). We previously reported that although in type I receptor (-/-) embryos PE formation seemed normal, the embryos were smaller from at least day 9.5 p.c. and 60% had died before day 12.5 p.c. Here we show that the observed growth defect commences even earlier, at day 8.5 p.c. Using two novel antibodies, we show that the expression of the type I receptor protein at this stage is confined to extraembryonic endoderm only. In addition, we show that large amounts of PTHrP protein are present in the adjacent trophoblast giant cells, suggesting a paracrine interaction of PTHrP and the type I PTH/PTHrP receptor in PE formation. The involvement in PE differentiation of other recently described receptors for PTHrP would explain a possible redundancy for the type I receptor in PE formation. However, deletion of the type I PTH/PTHrP receptor in ES cells by homologous recombination completely prevents PTHrP-induced PE differentiation. Based upon these observations, we propose that PTHrP and the type I PTH/PTHrP receptor, although not required for the initial formation of PE, are required for its proper differentiation and/or functioning.