Selective roles of thymus-derived lymphocytes in the antibody response. II. Preferential suppression of high-affinity antibody-forming cells by carrier-primed suppressor T cells

Innate response activator B cells: origins and functions

Innate response activator (IRA) B cells are a subset of B-1a derived B cells that produce the growth factors granulocyte macrophage colony stimulating factor and IL-3. In mouse models of sepsis and pneumonia, B-1a B cells residing in serosal sites recognize bacteria, migrate to the spleen or lung, and differentiate to IRA B cells that then contribute to the host response by amplifying inflammation and producing polyreactive IgM. In atherosclerosis, IRA B cells accumulate in the spleen, where they promote extramedullary hematopoiesis and activate classical dendritic cells. In this review, we focus on the ontogeny and function of IRA B cells in acute and chronic inflammation.

Immunosuppression in murine malaria. IV. The secondary response to bovine serum albumin

The anamnestic antibody response of CBA mice to bovine serum albumin was characterized by a rapid production of high-avidity antibody. After 3 weeks both the total amount of antibody and its avidity declined but still remained above those seen in the primary response for at least 6 weeks. The effects of acute Plasmodium berghei and Plasmodium yoelii yoelii infections upon the induction and the expression of this anamnestic response were studied. Mice infected with these malaria parasites responded poorly to primary immunization and the immunological memory generated was quantitatively subnormal. In addition, presence of the infection during a period between approximately the second and third weeks of the primary response prejudiced the development of high-avidity memory. Optimally primed mice, challenged during a subsequent acute infection, responded well initially, but were unable to maintain the secondary response at a normal level in terms of both quantity and avidity of the antibody. However, if challenge was delayed until after recovery from the infection, a normal secondary response ensued. Antibody concentrations in the sera of primed animals declined rapidly during infection. This was at least partly due to increased catabolism.

Low antibody affinity restricted to the IgA isotype in IgA nephropathy

Antibody affinity affects the handling and behaviour of immune complexes, and experimental studies have shown that animals which produce predominantly low-affinity antibody are prone to immune complex deposition resulting in glomerulonephritis. In order to investigate the potential role of antibody affinity in the pathogenesis of IgA nephropathy, affinity of both IgA and IgG antibody isotypes during secondary response to systemic immunization with tetanus toxoid was studied in 20 patients with IgA nephropathy. Patients with IgA nephropathy produced IgA antibodies of significantly lower affinity than controls (P < 0.001), whereas IgG antibody affinities were similar. Contrasting with controls, patients' IgA antibody affinity was inversely related to antibody concentration, with higher responders producing large amounts of low-affinity antibody. IgG antibody affinity increased with time, and maturation of IgG antibody affinity was similar in both controls and patients. IgA affinity in controls decreased with time, and this lack of IgA affinity maturation may explain the relative unimportance of IgA in normal systemic immunity. This temporal decrease in IgA affinity was not observed in patients with IgA nephropathy. The production of low-affinity IgA in IgA nephropathy may provide an explanation for the predominant deposition of IgA in this disease.

Antibody affinity maturation: the role of CD8+ cells

The cellular control of antibody affinity maturation has been studied in mice genetically selected for their failure to demonstrate an increase in affinity following immunization (low-affinity N/M mice). Depletion of CD8+ cells in low N/M mice by thymectomy and/or anti-CD8 antibody treatment resulted in these animals acquiring the ability to mount an anti-DNP response of progressively increasing affinity. This indicates that CD8+ cells play an important regulatory role in the cellular interactions underlying the process of affinity maturation. In addition, evidence is presented which suggests that the route of immunization may also be critical in determining the affinity of antibody produced.

Prostaglandin E2 production is enhanced in mice genetically selected to produce high affinity antibody responses

Spleen cells from mice selectively bred to produce high affinity antibody responses to protein antigens (HI) had reduced responses to both T and B cell mitogens when compared to those from mice selectively bred to produce low affinity (LO) responses. The reduced response by spleen cells from HI mice was partially reversed by the addition of indomethacin in vitro. Spleen adherent cells from HI mice had increased production of prostaglandin E2 when compared to those from LO mice. In addition, spleen adherent cells from mice which fail to show affinity maturation not only produced lower amounts of PGE2 than those from HI mice but also a decreased proportion of spleen cells adhered to plastic in these mice. To test the possibility that the increased PGE2 production in HI mice was responsible for the production of high affinity antibodies, indomethacin was administered in vivo and resulted in a significant reduction in antibody affinity. The possibility that PGE2 production may control the balance between the TH1 and TH2 cells of Mosmann and Coffman is discussed.

Isoelectric focusing spectra of anti-bacterial alpha-amylase antibody unique for antigen-induced suppression

The effect of intravenous (i.v.) administration of bacterial alpha-amylase (B alpha A) on the IgG antibody response to a subsequent challenge with B alpha A in incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA) varied with the difference in responsiveness of the parental strains. High-responder C3H/He (C3) mice given injections of either 200 or 4 micrograms of B alpha A, which alone were unable to trigger a detectable IgG antibody response, generated an enhanced response to an immunogenic challenge given 25 days after the last i.v. injection. The response of low-responder C57BL/6 (B6) mice previously exposed to B alpha A, following a different kinetic course depending on the exposing dose, reached a plateau lower than the levels of control responses (tentatively designated as high- and low-zone suppression). Prior exposure of (B6 X C3)F1 hybrids to 200 micrograms led to the enhanced response, whereas pretreatment with 4 micrograms rendered them partially tolerant to a subsequent challenge. These results suggest that the capacity to achieve low-zone suppression is inherited as a dominant trait. Isoelectric focusing (IEF) analysis revealed that these enhanced responses expanded antibody heterogeneity in a strictly restricted, strain-specific manner as observed during the normal antibody response, although the rate of expansion was accelerated. The specific antibodies produced by individual high-zone suppressed B6 mice were focused as a limited set of bands in a narrow pH range where the specific antibodies produced early in the normal response were focused. In contrast, the response of low-zone suppressed B6 and F1 hybrid mice was characterized by a unique process of heterogeneity expansion.

Antibody affinity maturation in selectively bred high and low-affinity mice

The affinity of serum antibodies produced by selectively bred lines of mice [high affinity, low affinity, low nonmaturing (N/M)] injected with T-dependent [human serum albumin (HSA), dinitrophenylated bovine gamma-globulin (DNP-BGG)] and T-independent (DNP-Ficoll) antigens in saline and adjuvant has been determined. The lines of mice differ significantly in the affinity of antibody produced to T-dependent antigens injected in saline but not to the T-independent antigen. Unlike mice of the high and low-affinity lines, low-affinity N/M mice failed to show affinity maturation to HSA and DNP-BGG injected in Freund's incomplete adjuvant. However, low-N/M mice responded to DNP-Ficoll injected in adjuvant by the production of antibody of affinity comparable to that produced in the other lines and with a similar maturation in affinity. Carrier priming resulted in the suppression of anti-hapten antibody affinity in all lines but low-N/M mice showed significantly greater suppression late in the response to challenge. Low doses of cyclophosphamide produced a significant increase in affinity in low-N/M mice. These results suggest that the failure of low-N/M mice to show affinity maturation results from increased suppressor T cell activity. The availability of the selectively bred mice provides a useful model for the detailed study of the cellular basis of the control of antibody affinity maturation.

Avidities of hapten-specific antibodies when the responses are modulated by anti-carrier antibodies

Either alone or in combination with antibodies having specificity for the carrier erythrocyte, TNP-ORBC were injected i.p. into CBA/J mice. Five days later, their spleens were removed and evaluated for TNP-specific PFC. The spleens from animals receiving 19S antibody (IgM) with carrier specificity displayed 3-4-fold more direct and indirect hapten-specific PFC than control animals receiving the TNP-erythrocyte conjugate only. Animals receiving 7S antibodies (IgG) with carrier specificity displayed very little change in their direct PFC response to the hapten. However, the indirect response to the hapten was suppressed as much as 16-fold by carrier specific IgG. Evaluation by haptenic inhibition of the relative avidity of the antibodies being secreted by these cells revealed the following: the relative avidity of antibodies secreted by indirect PFC in the spleens of animals receiving TNP-ORBC only was approximately 20-fold higher than antibodies secreted by the direct PFC. The 3-4-fold potentiation of the hapten-specific PFC response by carrier-specific IgM antibody did not result in a change in relative avidity of direct or indirect PFC. IgG with carrier specificity did not change the relative avidity of the antibodies secreted by direct PFC having specificity for the hapten. However, evaluation of the remaining PFC in spleens from animals whose indirect hapten-specific PFC response had been suppressed by carrier-specific IgG revealed that the remaining PFC had a lower avidity than indirect PFC from animals receiving TNP-ORBC only. In other words, carrier-specific IgG selectively induced suppression of high avidity hapten-specific IgG antibody secreting cells.

Affinity and distribution of subpopulations of antibody-producing cells in protein-restricted C57BL/6 mice

To study the effect of protein restriction on the affinity of antibodies produced by plaque-forming cells (PFC), C57BL/6 mice were fed diets containing 4% (R4%), 8% (R8%), or 27% (N) casein for 2 (short-term) or 12 (long-term) weeks and immunized with dinitrophenyl (DNP) bovine gamma-globulin in complete Freund's adjuvant. Affinity was assessed by inhibition of plaque formation in the presence of free hapten. Anti-DNP PFC per 10(7) spleen cells were not diminished in short- and long-term R8% mice, and were increased in the former group at certain times after immunization. Affinity of indirect PFC was increased at Days 14 and 21 after immunization in short-term R8% mice and at Day 7 in R4% mice, and was similar in long-term R8% and N animals. No limitation in the heterogeneity of PFC affinities was observed in the restricted groups. Short-term restricted mice showed a rise of the high-affinity PFC subpopulation. The number of mice with hapten-augmentable PFC was diminished in the short-term R8% group at 7 days after immunization and in long-term restricted mice at 14 days, suggesting depressed levels of auto-anti-idiotypic antibodies in protein restriction.

Selective effect of different retinoids on the primary antibody response in normal chickens

The effect of three retinoids--retinoic acid, etretinate and trimethylmethoxyphenyl(TMMP)-retinoic acid--was studied on mitogen-induced lymphocyte transformation and on primary antibody response against Brucella abortus and bovine serum albumin (BSA). None of the drugs had an effect on lymphocyte transformation. Antibodies of IgG and IgM class were measured with a modified enzyme immunoassay, able to estimate separately the amounts of high avidity and total specific antibodies. No effect was seen on antibodies against B.abortus, a T-independent antigen, but was observed on antibodies against BSA, a T-dependent antigen. Retinoic acid increased primarily IgM anti-BSA antibodies, while TMMP-retinoic acid increased high avidity IgG anti-BSA antibodies. Etretinate had no influence on antibody production. Retinoic acid and TMMP-retinoic acid are able to modulate T-dependent humoral immune response. This selective effect of retinoic acid and TMMP-retinoic acid on T-cells makes them promising tools in the regulation of humoral immune response.

Studies of immune responses in mice prone to autoimmune disorders. I. Heterogeneity of the affinities of antihapten antibodies produced by NZB, NZW, and related strains of mice

Mice of the NZB and NZW strains and their F1 hybrid produce antihapten plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses to T-dependent antigens (trinitrophenylated bovine gamma globulin and dansylated keyhole limpet hemocyanin) which are of unusually restricted heterogeneity of affinity, are relatively lacking in low-affinity PFC, and are of relatively high average affinity. Since some low-affinity PFC are present in NZB mice early after immunization, the results suggest a particularly marked down-regulation of low-affinity antibody production by these strains. The non-autoimmune-prone F1 hybrid (NZB X CBA) produces a typical heterogeneous response containing a high proportion of low-affinity PFC. Thus, the tendency to down-regulate low-affinity PFC is not inherited as a simple Mendelian dominant trait. The response of NZB mice to T-independent antigens does not show the same restricted heterogeneity of affinity. In fact, late after injections of trinitrophenylated Ficoll, NZB mice tend to have more heterogeneous responses than nonautoimmune-prone BALB/c mice in which a marked down-regulation of high-affinity antibody-producing PFC is seen. The possible relationship between these unusual features of the immune response of NZB and some related strains and their tendency to develop autoimmune disease is discussed.

Trypanosome infection of mice depresses antibody affinity and delays affinity maturation

Infection with either a pathogenic species of trypanosome (Trypanosoma brucei brucei) or a non-pathogenic trypanosome (Trypanosoma musculi) had differing effects on the response of mice to a soluble protein antigen (human serum albumin, HSA) injected in either Freund's incomplete adjuvant or in saline. T. brucei suppressed the response to HSA to a level undetectable by ammonium sulphate globulin precipitation, irrespective of the mode of immunization, whereas T. musculi did not suppress the amount of antibody produced in response to either form of antigen presentation. The affinity of the antibody produced in response to antigen in adjuvant was unaffected, but antibody affinity was significantly reduced in infected animals in which the antigen was given in saline. This depression of antibody affinity was related to the period of infection and arose as a result of a delay in the normal maturation of affinity. Furthermore, the depression was only observed when infection preceded the exposure to antigen. Possible mechanisms which may lead to a depression of affinity without a corresponding effect upon antibody levels are discussed in context of current knowledge of immunosuppression in trypanosome infections.

Suppressor T cell memory. II. The role of memory suppressor T cells in tolerance to human gamma globulin

The transient presence of suppressor T cell (Ts) activity in high-dose tolerance to human gamma globulin (HGG), and its (apparent) absence in low-dose tolerance, have been advanced as strong evidence against the concept that Ts play an important role in maintenance of immunological unresponsiveness. To analyze this question, CBA mice were exposed to high or low doses of deaggregated HGG (dHGG) and later challenged with HGG in immunogenic form (aHGG); their capacity to mount a primary or secondary suppressive response was assessed in an adoptive hapten-carrier system. Primary suppression reached a maximum 7 d after high-dose tolerance induction and gradually waned thereafter, being no longer detectable by day 30-35. Subsequent challenge of tolerant mice with aHGG, however, led to a rapid reactivation of suppression that bore the hallmarks of an anamnestic secondary response, and this effect was still demonstrable 135 d after tolerance induction. It was also shown that a single low dose of dHGG was capable of generating memory for suppression despite the absence of detectable primary suppression, indicating that the latter is not a prerequisite for induction of memory cells. The results were interpreted as indicating that tolerance, like immunity, is a manifestation of specific immunological memory. If tolerance to self-antigens is maintained by a similar mechanism, it would be expected that memory Ts could be induced during the early stages of fetal development. Mice were therefore exposed to tolerogen in utero by injection of their mothers with dHGG at day 7 of gestation, and were assessed at various times after birth for the capacity to exhibit primary or secondary suppression in adoptive transfer. Nonspecific suppression masked any specific effects during the first 5 wk of life. Antigen-specific, primary suppression was demonstrable subsequently until 10-12 wk of age, and if the animals were challenged with aHGG before transfer an anamnestic secondary suppressive response could be elicited up to 6 mo of age. These observations are consistent with the notion that memory Ts may play an important role in the maintenance of self-tolerance.

Modulation of allogeneic stimulation in man. I. Characterization of an in vitro induced suppressor macrophage population

Cultured human peripheral blood mononuclear cells suppressed the allogeneic response of fresh autologous lymphocytes. This suppressor activity developed gradually over a period of one week. The cells primarily responsible for this effect were enriched by Ficoll density gradient centrifugation. It was found that the suppressor cell is a large, low density nylon wool adherent, radioresistant, phagocytic, and nonspecific esterase positive mononuclear cell. Moreover, these cells did not form E rosettes and were Fc positive. Electron microscopy confirmed that suppressor cells were macrophage like. Suppressor activity was not due to cytotoxicity, crowding, or steric hinderance by the cultured cells. The suppressor macrophage population did not appear to inhibit the allogeneic response via prostaglandin or arginase release, or interfere with the tritiated thymidine uptake by release of endogenous thymidine. The above system is viewed as an in vitro model of immune regulation by suppressor macrophages, in the context of allogeneic response.

Studies on the control of antibody synthesis. XVII. Effect of specific suppressor cells on the affinity of the antibody response by naive or primed lymphocytes

A comparison was made of the effects of carrier-specific helper T-cell tolerance and carrier-specific suppressor cells on the affinity of the anti-hapten PFC produced in both a primary and secondary anti-hapten response. Carrier-specific suppressor T cells caused a striking preferential loss of high affinity PFC in the primary response, but had only a slight effect on the affinity of the anti-hapten PFC formed in the secondary response. A carrier-specific state of tolerance, induced at a dosage which was shown not to generate significant suppressor cell activity, was associated with minimal alterations in the affinity of the primary anti-hapten PFC response. Carrier specific tolerance, induced in animals which had been previously primed to the hapten on a different carrier, had little or no effect on the affinity of the PFC response.

Studies on B-cell memory. II. T-cell independent antigen can induce B-cell memory

Both athymic nude mice and normal mice primed with a T-cell independent antigen, i.e. dinitrophenylated dextran (DNP-DE), at a sub-immunogenic dose, produced very poor anti-DNP responses to a later challenge with the same antigen. B-cell memory was expressed, however, as an enhanced IgM response after the challenge of the DNP-DE-primed mice with the T-cell dependent antigen (dinitrophenylated haemocyanin, DNP-KLH) in the presence of functional T-cells. Moreover, DNP-DE-primed spleen cells also revealed an enhanced IgM response after adoptive transfer into irradiated recipients and challenge with DNP-DE. The injections of DNP-DE-primed nude mouse serum into unprimed mice resulted in the reduction of anti-DNP response to the immunization with DNP-DE. These results indicate that (a) T-cell independent DNP-DE causes the differentiation of B cells not only into antibody-forming cells but also into memory cells, (b) these memory cells can be triggered in situ by the T-cell dependent DNP-KLH in the presence of helper T cells but not by T-cell independent antigen, and (c) some humoral factor(s) induced by DNP-DE-priming seems to interfere with the expression of B-cell memory only when challenged with T-cell independent DNP-DE.

Suppression of antibody responses by cells from mice painted with picryl chloride

T cells from mice painted with picryl chloride inhibit secondary IgG anti-TNP antibody responses of normal mice to the sensitizer. Like other suppressor T cells produced after painting which inhibit DNA synthesis and the generation of cytotoxic T cells, these cells could be produced in adult thymectomized mice but not by mice treated with high doses of cyclophosphamide (250 mg/kg). The cells had to be injected within 48 h of a primary painting to inhibit the response to challenge 2-3 weeks later. This associated with their ability to inhibit DNA synthesis in draining lymph nodes after a primary painting. Double transfer experiments using spleen and lymph node cells failed to show any further activation or induction of suppressor function after challenge with antigen. As judged by the ability of anti-theta treated cells from suppressed mice to function as anti TNP primed B cells in adoptive responses to TNP-KLH no defect in B-cell memory was found. When, however, the ability of painting with picryl chloride to prime for challenge with TNP-KLH was used as a measure of B-cell function in situ it was found that the cells could inhibit responses. Responses to primary and secondary injections of TNP-KLH were not inhibited.

Immunosuppression in murine malaria. III. Induction of tolerance and of immunological memory by soluble bovine serum albumin

The primary antibody response to alumadsorbed BSA was depressed when initiated during low-grade chronic Plasmodium berghei malaria in mice, as previously reported during acute P.y. yoelii infection. Induction of immunological memory by soluble polymerized BSA was abolished in both infections; in infected hosts this normally immunogenic stimulus resulted in partial tolerance. In contrast to the depression of immune response, neither infection interfered with the induction of low-zone tolerance by monomeric BSA. The rate of non-immune elimination of BSA was found to be normal during acute malaria, and only slightly reduced in chronic infection. These results may be explained in terms of abnormal antigen handling in infected mice, due to some functional defect in macrophages, although this does not seem to be a sufficient explanation for all the phenomena of malaria-associated immunosuppression.

Age-dependent variations of antibody avidity

Age-dependent variations of antibody avidity were studied in the C3HeB/FeJ mouse. Spleen cells from donors of different ages (10--720 days) were transferred and stimulated with TNP-HRBC in lethally irradiated syngenic recipients. The anti-TNP antibody response of the donor cells was estimated from the number of direct PFC per recipient spleen by the Jerne technique with TNP-SRBC. Avidity of the antibodies secreted by PFC was evaluated from the amount of added TNP-BSA that inhibited 50% of the anti-TNP PFC. Under these experimental conditions allowing the exclusion of any influence of the donor milieu during the immune response, age-dependent variations of the antibody response and avidity could be attributed to changes in the donor spleen cell population. Avidity was found to increase with the response and to vary parabolically with age. After appropriate correction of the number of PFC to make it independent from age, avidity values were fitted by a multiple curvilinear regression in which the independent variables playing a significant role were the corrected number of PFC in its linear term and the age in its linear and quadratic terms. From comparison of the standard coefficients of this regression, the observed variations of avidity could be attributed in part (82%) to the response and in part (18%) to the age. For any value of response, avidity increased 15-fold from day 10 to reach a maximum at day 110 and then declined 5-fold at the age of 720 days. Heterogeneity of avidity also changed parabolically with age as high avidity classes were present in adulthood and absent at 10 and 720 days.

Regulation of anti-hapten antibody secretion by carrier-specific suppressor T cells

Carrier-primed T lymphocytes can suppress high avidity IgG anti-hapten antibody secretion within 90 min. in vitro if the suppressor and target cells are primed with the same carrier determinants. Suppression seems to be directed to the antibody secreting cell since the effect is rapid and does not depend on macrophages or T cells in the target cell population. Suppression can be blocked by inclusion of soluble carrier in the cell mixture or by treatment of the target cells with anti-carrier antibody or pronase. Moreover, suppression can be augmented by PFC exposure to the soluble hapten-carrier conjugate. Finally, carrier specificity may be altered by preincubation of the target population with a hapten-heterologous carrier before addition of suppressor cells specific for the heterologous carrier. Thus, it is likely that high avidity suppression depends upon immunogen bound to the surfaces of antibody secreting cells which serves as a target for suppressor cells or molecules.

A study of the increased serum level of IgG1 in 'lethargic' mice combined with a depressed thymus-dependent lymphoid system

In a series of recent studies on 'lethargic' mice, a neurological mutation of the mouse, significant abnormalities were discovered in the thymus and its dependent regions in the lymph nodes and spleen. The present study was made as an approach toward finding the possible causes for these abnormalities. Serum IgG1 levels were stldied in 'lethargic' mutants at the age when severe deficiency of the thymus-dependent lymphoid system is known to occur in the animal. Using the radial immunodiffusion method, it was found that serum IgG1 levels are always significantly higher in 'lethargic' mice than in their normal littermates. Possible causes of the higher IgG1 in the serum of 'lethargic' mice are discussed. The authors note the similarities of other mouse mutations to that of the 'lethargic' mouse and propose the possibility that a common mechanism may account for immunologic deficiencies in several types of mutant mice.

Effect of carrier priming on antibody avidity in the in vivo and in vitro immune response

The effect of carrier priming on antibody avidity was investigated under several experimental conditions. Basically, mice were carrier primed with HRBC (horse red blood cells) prior to immunization with TNP (2,4,6-trinitrophenyl) conjugated to HRBC. Immunization was performed either in vivo or in spleen cell culture, and avidity of anti-TNP antibodies was estimated from inhibition of direct PFC (plaque-forming cells) by free TNP-BSA (-bovine serum albumin).

The data indicate the appropriate conditions under which carrier priming can enhance antibody avidity. The carrier effect is maximized by priming the animals with 10⁴-10⁵ HRBC 3-7 days before immunization with a low dose of TNP-HRBC. Hyper-immunization by repeated injections of a high dose of the conjugate does not modify the carrier effect on avidity but it delays the fall of avidity in both carrier primed and unprimed animals. These results are interpreted in terms of T- and B-cell co-operation within the framework of the maturation theory of antibody affinity.

Carrier priming was also found to increase the number of direct PFC of the IgM and, mostly, of the non-IgM classes, a finding in agreement with the notion that T cells can help IgM production and the shift to IgG.

Characterization of an inhibitory allogeneic effect on humoral responsiveness in vitro

Evidence is presented that the induction of a humoral response is inhibitable by a thymus-derived cell (TI) that acts on the antigen-sensitive precursors of both the thymus-derived cooperating and the bone marrow-derived antibody-secreting cell-that is, the tC and B cell respectively. The inhibition of induction of the tC and B cell by the TI cell is shown to be reversed by increasing the effective level of cooperation. This competitive interaction between the inhibitory (TI) and cooperating (TC) systems is postulated to be part of the mechanism for regulating the class of the response, cell-mediated or humoral. The following properties of the inhibitory system were demonstrated: [1] The tI cell--the antigen-sensitive precursor of the TI cell--is both paralyzable and inducible. [2] The TI cell appears during the induction of a cell-mediated response and, if not identical to the effector cytotoxic ('killer') TK cell, the TI cell is induced in parallel with it. [3] The effector function of the TI cell, like that of the TK cell, is H-2-restricted.

Modulation of mouse anti-trinitrophenyl plaque-forming cell affinity by adjuvants or lectins

The efffects of several kinds of adjuvants or lectins, such as Corynebacterium parvum, dextran, poly AU, poly IC, dibutyryl cAMP, concanavalin A (Con A), phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and pokeweed mitogen (PWM) on anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) direct plaque-forming cells (PFC) in the spleen of mice and the affinity of antibodies produced by these PFC were examined. The numbers of anti-TNP PFC in the spleens of mice which had been injected with C. parvum 7 days in advance were greater than those in controls after immunization with TNP-coupled heterologous erythrocytes, while the affinity of antibodies released by these PFC. Copolymers of nucleotides, poly AU and poly IC, were capable of enhancing splenic anti-TNP PFC responses, but showed almost no altering of PFC affinity. Dibutyryl cAMP did not have any effect on this system. Con A had potencies to both augment the number of anti-TNP PFC and heighten the PFC affinity, while PHA seemed to lack these potencies. Injection of PWM in the presence of antigen increased the number of anti-TNP PFC and heightened slightly the PFC affinity. These results indicate that the heightening of the affinity at the cellular level is regulated in ways different from the augmenting effects on the number of anti-TNP PFC by adjuvants or lectins. These results are discussed in the light of the mode of action of the substances used.

Persisting T cells in rats tolerant of human serum albumin. The significance of tolerant and nonimmune T cells which preferentially restrict high affinity antibody synthesis

The adoptive response of primed rat thoracic duct lymphocytes ('TDL) following specific antigen challenge (soluble human serum albumin, s-HSA) was restricted when cells were transferred into syngeneic, adult (AS2 X AS)F1 hybrid recipients in comparison with irradiated hosts. This adoptive memory response was also inhibited in irradiated recipients by transferring nonimmune TDL along with 'TDL. Recirculating B cells (B-TDL) did not inhibit the 'TDL response, indicating that the adoptive secondary response was regulated by T cells. Antibody synthesis was preferentially restricted in the high affinity memory cell precursor population, demonstrating a role for T cells in regulating the maturation of antibody affinity. The adoptive memory response was liberated from this T regulatory effect in adult recipients when hosts were challenged with the alum-precipitated adjuvant form (HSA-adj) rather than the soluble form of HSA. Since the adoptive memory response was sensitive to the presence or absence of T cells, this experimental model was used to determine whether or not T cells were eliminated from HSA-tolerant rats. Antibody synthesis by 'TDL was reduced approximately 10-fold compared with controls when transferred into tolerant recipients and challenged with either s-HSA or HSA-adj; a similar reduction was not observed by substituting bovine serum albumin (BSA) 'TDL and challenging with s-BSA. The tolerance-induced inhibition of HSA 'TDL was destroyed by irradiation and TDL from HSA-tolerant donors were more effective than normal nonimmune TDL in reducing the adoptive HSA 'TDL response. HSA-tolerant TDL did not inhibit the BSA 'TDL response significantly. The results indicate that T cells are not eliminated by tolerance induction in this model and after interaction with tolerogen may exert an active (or competitive) role in restricting antibody synthesis by high affinity B memory cell precursors. However, the fact that tolerant T cells are not able to prevent a primary response suggests that unresponsiveness to HSA in the T compartment represents a functional deficiency and not an active suppression at this level. Nevertheless, the presence of these tolerant cells probably accounts for the failure of antibody affinity to mature in partially tolerant rats.

Effect of bacterial lipopolysaccharides on anti-trinitrophenyl antibody-producing cells. Nonspecific modification of the affinity at the cellular level

The effect of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) on anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) direct plaque-forming cells (PFC) in the spleen of mice and the affinity of antibodies produced by these PFC were examined. Simultaneous injection of bacterial LPS and TNP-coupled sheep red blood cells(SRBC) induced an obvious increase in anti-TNP PFC numbers and heightened the antibody affinity at cellular levels. The higher the doses of LPS, the greater the effects. Concomitant injection of LPS in TNP-coupled homologous mouse red blood cells (MRBC) also elicited good anti-TNP PFC response and slightly heightened the affinity. Priming with LPS and SRBC together 7 days prior to immunization did not enhance the anti-TNP PFC response and it was difficult to alter the affinity. Preinjection with small amounts of TNP-MRBC or -rabbit red blood cells and LPS simultaneously did not induce any significant increase in anti-TNP PFC secondary response after reimmunization with TNP-SRBC, but obviously heightened the antibody affinity. Injection of LPS simultaneously with the secondary immunization was effective for both the anti-TNP PFC response and the alteration of antibody affinity. These results suggest that LPS affects the control mechanisms of anti-TNP antibody affinity via the non-thymus-derived helper cell function, and the adjuvant action and alteration of antibody affinity induced by LPS are regulated by different mechanisms.

Properties of antigen-specific suppressive T-cell factor in the regulation of antibody response of the mouse. I. In vivo activity and immunochemical characterization

An antigen-specific suppressive T-cell factor was extracted from physically disrupted thymocytes and spleen cells of mice that had been immunized with soluble protein antigens. The factor, when inoculated into syngeneic normal mice, could induce a significant suppression of IgG antibody response against a hapten coupled to the carrier protein by which the donor of the suppressor factor was immunized. The suppressor factor was found only effective in suppressing the antibody response of syngeneic or H-2 histocompatible recipients. The suppressive T-cell factor was removed by absorption with immunoadsorbent composed of the relevant antigen, but not with any of those of anti-immunoglobulin antibodies. The factor was successfully removed by alloantibodies with specificity for the K end (H-2K, I-A and I-B) of the H-2 complex of the donor strain, but not by those for the D end (I-C, SsSlp, and H-2D). The activity was removed by absorption with a heterologous antithymocyte serum. The mol wt of the suppression T-cell factor was between 35,000 and 60,000 as determined by Sephadex G-200 gel filtration. The suppressive T-cell factor was found to be a heat-liable protein.

Genetic control of immune responses in vitro. V. Stimulation of suppressor T cells in nonresponder mice by the terpolymer L-glutamic acid 60-L-alanine 30-L-tyrosine 10 (GAT)

In recent studies we have found that GAT not only fails to elicit a GAT-specific response in nonresponder mice but also specifically decreases the ability of nonresponder mice to develop a GAT-specific PFC response to a subsequent challenge with GAT bound to the immunogenic carrier, MBSA. Studies presented in this paper demonstrate that B cells from nonresponder, DBA/1 mice rendered unresponsive by GAT in vivo can respond in vitro to GAT-MBSA if exogenous, carrier-primed T cells are added to the cultures. The unresponsiveness was shown to be the result of impaired carrier-specific helper T-cell function in the spleen cells of GAT-primed mice. Spleen cells from GAT-primed mice specifically suppressed the GAT-specific PFC response of spleen cells from normal DBA/1 mice incubated with GAT-MBSA. This suppression was prevented by pretreatment of GAT-primed spleen cells with anti-theta serum plus C or X irradiation. Identification of the suppressor cells as T cells was confirmed by the demonstration that suppressor cells were confined to the fraction of the column-purified lymphocytes which contained theta-positive cells and a few non-Ig-bearing cells. The significance of these data to our understanding of Ir-gene regulation of the immune response is discussed.