Specific cytotoxic T cells are found in the nonrejected kidneys of blood-transfused rats

Comparison of Tolerated and Rejected Islet Grafts: A Gene Expression Study

Recently we showed that donor-specific tolerance to MHC-matched islet allografts in diabetic NOD mice could be induced by simultaneous islet and bone marrow transplantation. Mononuclear cell infiltration surrounding the islets was also found in tolerated grafts. In this study, we compared gene expression in the tolerated and rejected islet grafts by using Affymetrix Murine U74A oligonucleotide arrays. To confirm the results of microarray analysis, we performed real-time PCR and RNase protection assay on selected genes. Of over 12,000 genes studied, 57 genes were expressed at consistently higher levels in tolerated islet grafts, and 524 genes in rejected islet grafts. Genes from a variety of functional clusters were found to be different between rejected and tolerated grafts. In the rejected islet grafts, a number of T-cell surface markers and of cytotoxicity-related genes were highly expressed. Also in the rejected grafts, a number of cytokines and chemokines and their receptors were highly expressed. The differential expression of selected genes found by microarray analysis was also confirmed by real-time PCR and RNase protection assay. Our results indicated that gene microarray analysis can help us to detect gene expression differences representative of the biologic mechanisms of tolerance and rejection.

Renal transplant immunology in the last 20 years: A revolution towards graft and patient survival improvement

To deride the hope of progress is the ultimate fatuity, the last word in poverty of spirit and meanness of mind. There is no need to be dismayed by the fact that we cannot yet envisage a definitive solution of our problems, a resting-place beyond which we need not try to go. -P.B. Medawar, 1969 * Thomas E. Starlz, also known as the Father of Clinical Transplantation, once said that organ transplantation was the supreme exception to the rule that most major advances in medicine spring from discoveries in basic science [Starzl T. The mystique of organ transplantation. J Am Coll Surg 2005 Aug;201(2):160-170]. In fact, the first successful identical-twin kidney transplantation performed by Murray's team in December 1954 (Murray J et al. Renal homotransplantations in identical twins. Surg Forum 1955;6:432-436) was the example of an upside down translation medicine: Human clinical transplantation began and researchers tried to understand the underlying immune response and how to control the powerful rejection pathways through experimental models. In the last 20 years, we have witnessed an amazing progress in the knowledge of immunological mechanisms regarding alloimmune response and an outstanding evolution on the identification and characterization of major and minor histocompatibility antigens. This review presents an historical and clinical perspective of those important advances in kidney transplantation immunology in the last 20 years, which contributed to the improvement in patients' quality of life and the survival of end-stage renal patients. In spite of these significant progresses, some areas still need substantial progress, such as the definition of non-invasive biomarkers for acute rejection; the continuous reduction of immunosuppression; the extension of graft survival, and finally the achievement of real graft tolerance extended to HLA mismatch donor: recipient pairs.

Induction of Foxp3-expressing regulatory T-cells by donor blood transfusion is required for tolerance to rat liver allografts

Background

Donor-specific blood transfusion (DST) prior to solid organ transplantation has been shown to induce long-term allograft survival in the absence of immunosuppressive therapy. Although the mechanisms underlying DST-induced allograft tolerance are not well defined, there is evidence to suggest DST induces one or more populations of antigen-specific regulatory cells that suppress allograft rejection. However, neither the identity nor the regulatory properties of these tolerogenic lymphocytes have been reported. Therefore, the objective of this study was to define the kinetics, phenotype and suppressive function of the regulatory cells induced by DST alone or in combination with liver allograft transplantation (LTx).

Methodology/Principal Findings

Tolerance to Dark Agouti (DA; RT1^a) rat liver allografts was induced by injection (iv) of 1 ml of heparinized DA blood to naïve Lewis (LEW; RT1^l) rats once per week for 4 weeks prior to LTx. We found that preoperative DST alone generates CD4⁺ T-cells that when transferred into naïve LEW recipients are capable of suppressing DA liver allograft rejection and promoting long-term survival of the graft and recipient. However, these DST-generated T-cells did not express the regulatory T-cell (Treg) transcription factor Foxp3 nor did they suppress alloantigen (DA)-induced activation of LEW T-cells in vitro suggesting that these lymphocytes are not fully functional regulatory Tregs. We did observe that DST+LTx (but not DST alone) induced the time-dependent formation of CD4⁺Foxp3⁺ Tregs that potently suppressed alloantigen-induced activation of naïve LEW T-cells in vitro and liver allograft rejection in vivo. Finally, we present data demonstrating that virtually all of the Foxp3-expressing Tregs reside within the CD4⁺CD45RC⁻ population whereas in which approximately 50% of these Tregs express CD25.

Conclusions/Significance

We conclude that preoperative DST, in the absence of liver allograft transplantation, induces the formation of CD4⁺ T-cells that are not themselves Tregs but give rise directly or indirectly to fully functional CD4⁺CD45RC⁻Foxp3⁺Tregs when transferred into MHC mismatched recipients prior to LTx. These Tregs possess potent suppressive activity and are capable of suppressing acute liver allograft rejection. Understanding the mechanisms by which preoperative DST induces the generation of tolerogenic Tregs in the presence of alloantigens may lead to the development of novel antigen-specific immunological therapies for the treatment of solid organ rejection.

Role of the liver in determining alloimmune response in vitro following donor-specific spleen cell injection

The aim of our study was to investigate the allogeneic influence inside and outside the liver in vitro following donor-specific cell injection (DSI). DA rats (RT1a) were used as donors and WS rats (RT1k) as recipients. WS were sensitized with DA spleen cells, followed 24h later by total hepatectomy. The liver was transplanted into another WS (sensitized liver-grafted; SL-Grafted). The hepatectomized WS underwent liver transplantation from a naive WS (sensitized liver-removed; SL-Removed). Alloantigens accumulated in the liver in SL-Grafted and in the extrahepatic tissue/organ(s) in SL-Removed. DA hearts were transplanted 10days after antigen administration. To analyze the immune responses, we measured Th1/Th2 cytokine profiles, and perforin mRNA in various organs, allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), and donor-specific immunoglobulin. Th1 cytokine levels in the liver of SL-Grafted and in spleen of SL-Removed were highly and rapidly upregulated but decreased thereafter. IFN-gamma and perforin mRNAs were significantly higher in SL-Grafted and lower in SL-Removed. MLR was significantly higher in SL-Grafted than SL-Removed and controls. There was no significant difference in the donor-specific immunoglobulin level. Our findings suggest that liver and other organs may behave differently to alloantigen, suggesting the importance of an early Th1 reaction in the liver and spleen.

Alloantigen specific T regulatory cells in transplant tolerance

CD4(+)CD25(+)Foxp3(+)T cells are regulatory/suppressor cells (Treg) that include non-antigen(Ag)-specific as well as Ag-specific Tregs. How non-Ag-specific naïve CD4(+)CD25(+)Treg develop into specific Tregs is unknown. We have studied DA rats tolerant to fully allogeneic PVG cardiac grafts that survived with out immunosuppression for over 100 days and identified the cellular basis of alloantigen specific tolerance. Key observations from our studies will be reviewed including how CD4(+)CD25(+)Tregs were first identified and the cytokine dependence of CD4(+)T cells that transfer alloantigen specific transplant tolerance which died in culture unless stimulated with both cytokine rich ConA supernatant and specific donor alloantigen. Both the tolerant CD4(+)CD25(+) and CD4(+)CD25(-) T cell populations are required to transfer tolerance, yet alone the CD4(+)CD25(-) T cell effect rejection. Tolerance transfer occurs with a low ratio of CD4(+)CD25(+)T cells (<1:10), whereas to induce tolerance with naive CD4(+)CD25(+)T cells requires both a ratio of >1:1 and is not alloantigen specific. Recent findings on how naïve CD4(+)CD25(+)T cells developed into two separated pathways of alloantigen specific Tregs, by culturing them with alloAg with either IL-2 or IL-4 and donor alloantigen are described. IL-2 enhances IFN-gammaR and IL-5 mRNA while IL-4 induced a reciprocal profile with de novo IL-5Ralpha and increased IFN-gamma mRNA expression. Both IL-2 and IL-4 alloactivated CD4(+)CD25(+)Tregs within 3-4 days of culture can induce alloantigen specific tolerance at ratios of 1:10. Long term, CD4(+)CD25(+)T cells from tolerant hosts given IL-2 cultured cells have increased IL-5 and IFN-gammaR mRNA; whereas hosts given IL-4 cultured cells had enhanced IL-5Ralpha mRNA expression and IL-5 enhanced their proliferation to donor but not third party alloAg. These findings suggest that Th1 and Th2 responses activate two pathways of alloantigen specific Tregs that can mediate transplant tolerance but are dependent upon cytokines produced by ongoing Th1 and/or Th2 immune responses.

Transfer of Allograft Specific Tolerance Requires CD4+CD25+T Cells but Not Interleukin-4 or Transforming Growth Factor–β and Cannot Induce Tolerance to Linked Antigens

BACKGROUND

The mechanisms by which CD4+T cells, especially CD4+ CD25+T cells, transfer allograft specific tolerance are poorly defined. The role of cytokines and the effect on antigen-presenting cells is not resolved.

METHODS

Anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody (mAb) therapy induced tolerance to PVG heterotopic cardiac transplantation in DA rats. Peripheral CD4+T cells or CD4+ CD25+ and CD4+ CD25-T cell subsets were adoptively transferred to irradiated DA hosts grafted with PVG heart grafts. For specificity studies, tolerant CD4+T cells were transferred to hosts with Lewis or (PVGxLewis)F1 heart grafts. Cytokine mRNA induction and the requirement for interleukin (IL)-4 and transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta in the transfer of tolerance was assessed.

RESULTS

CD4+T cells transferred specific tolerance and suppressed naïve CD4+T cells capacity to effect rejection of PVG but not Lewis grafts. (PVGxLewis)F1 grafts had a major rejection episode but recovered. Later these hosts accepted PVG but not Lewis skin grafts. Adoptive hosts restored with tolerant or naïve cells had similar levels of mRNA expression for all Th1 and Th2 cytokines and effector molecules assayed. Transfer of tolerance by CD4+T cells was not blocked by mAb to IL-4 or TGF-beta. CD4+ CD25-T cells from either naïve or tolerant hosts effected rejection. In contrast neither tolerant nor naïve CD4+ CD25+T cells restored rejection.

CONCLUSIONS

Specific tolerance transfer required CD4+ containing CD4+ CD25+T cells. An inflammatory response with induction of mRNA for Th1 and Th2 cytokines plus cytotoxic effector molecules occurred, but IL-4 and TGF-beta were not essential. Inhibition of antigen presenting cells was not the sole mechanism as there was no linked tolerance.

Functional compartmentalization following induction of long-term graft survival with pregraft donor-specific transfusion

Long-term survival is achieved in rat recipients by pre-graft donor-specific blood transfusion. We characterized the immune compartments in long-term survivors and analyzed them for capacity to transfer tolerance and protect against chronic rejection. Splenocytes and spleen T cells from treated recipients transferred long-term graft survival to 100% of secondary recipients. In contrast, blood transferred graft survival to only 50% of recipients whereas blood T cells had no effect. An unaltered TCR repertoire, an increase in suppressive CD4+CD25+ T cells, a decrease in antidonor T-cell proliferative response and normal perforin-granzyme levels were the hallmarks of the spleen T cells. Blood T cells were characterized by a strongly altered CD8+ repertoire, normal CD4+CD25+ T cell number with unchanged antidonor T-cell proliferative response, an activated T-cell phenotype and an increase in perforin-granzyme levels. However, following the transfer of blood or spleen cells into secondary recipients, all grafts displayed chronic rejection. These findings provide evidence that distinct compartments play critical roles in DST recipients. Regulatory cells do not accumulate in blood, which appears to be a reservoir for cytotoxic T cells. Spleen T cells, which display a regulatory-like profile and transfer graft survival, are not able to prevent chronic rejection.

Possible Involvement of Urokinase-Type Plasminogen Activator Release From Human Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes in the Pathophysiology of Chronic Allograft Nephropathy

BACKGROUND

Little is known of the fibrinolytic host immune mechanisms responsible for induction of chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN), defined as a loss in glomerular filtration rate (GFR) caused by tubular atrophy and interstitial fibrosis, often with fibrous intimal thickening in the small arteries. However, chronic rejection has been reported to be associated with decreased activity of the fibrinolytic system. In our previous study, [Deamino-Cys1, D-Arg8]-vasopressin (dDAVP) induced urokinase-type plasminogen activator (uPA) release from human peripheral T lymphocytes via arginine vasopressin (AVP) V2-receptor-mediated reaction enhanced by an AVP V1-receptor antagonist. Therefore, we examined the level of uPA released from peripheral T lymphocytes by AVP in transplant patients with CAN in comparison with control groups.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In this study, we evaluated in vitro uPA releasing activity of lymphocytes obtained from renal allograft patients with well-functioning grafts (n = 9), CAN (n = 5), or acute rejection episodes (n = 5) compared with lymphocytes from healthy volunteers with normal renal function (n = 12) or patients with renal insufficiency (n = 5).

RESULTS

Lymphocytes prepared from patients with chronic allograft nephropathy showed a significantly lower increase in uPA release induced by the combination of the V1-receptor antagonist and dDAVP compared with those from the other groups.

CONCLUSION

This finding suggested that a decrease in uPA release from human peripheral blood lymphocytes by AVP-related peptides may be potentially involved in the pathophysiology of CAN.

Combination Treatment with Donor-Specific Transfusions and Cyclosporine A Induces Long-Term Survival of Cardiac Allografts in Miniature Swine

BACKGROUND

To evaluate whether pretransplant donor-specific transfusions (DST) can induce tolerance to cardiac allografts in large animals, heterotopic cardiac transplants were performed across a class I MHC barrier in inbred miniature swine.

METHODS

Experimental animals received two DSTs, each containing 1.4x10 viable peripheral blood mononuclear cells, 14 and 7 days prior to transplantation together with a 12-day course of cyclosporine (CyA) (13 mg/kg IV) starting on postoperative day (POD) 0.

RESULTS

Untreated (n=2) and DST-only (n=2) treated control animals rejected between POD 6 and 8. Animals treated with CyA alone (n=3) exhibited graft survival to 53, 52 and 59 days. In contrast, the combination of DST and CyA (n=3) led to stable graft function for >200 days. Long-term survivors maintained peripheral CML response against donor antigen. Following DSTs, the donor-specific proliferative response of CD8+ recipient T cells was significantly increased (P=0.011), and a significant number of CD8+ T cells underwent apoptosis (10.1% on POD 0; 5.2% on POD -14; P=0.04). None of the DST-treated animals developed donor-specific antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

These results are the first to demonstrate the ability of DST to induce operational tolerance to cardiac allografts in large animals, and they suggest that peripheral mechanisms of tolerance mediate this effect.

Early Accumulation of Interferon-?? in Grafts Tolerized by Donor-Specific Blood Transfusion: Friend or Enemy?

BACKGROUND

We previously documented an early (day-2) interferon (IFN)-gamma accumulation in cardiac allografts of rats made tolerant by donor-specific blood transfusion (DSBT) but not in rejecting controls. This contrasted with the IFN-gamma peak seen later (day 5) in rejecting but not in tolerant rats.

METHODS

To further examine the role of early intragraft IFN-gamma in DSBT-induced tolerance, we studied whether IFN-gamma up-regulation correlates with the magnitude of the DSBT effect and how IFN-gamma is influenced by interventions abrogating tolerance.

RESULTS

The protective effect of DSBT depended upon the timing of administration: day-12 DSBT induced indefinite graft survival; day-6 DSBT gave a moderate, and day-0 DSBT, no graft prolongation. IFN-gamma up-regulation correlated with the DSBT effect: it was maximal after day-12 DSBT, intermediate after day-6 DSBT, and absent after day-0 DSBT. Tolerant splenocytes transferred tolerance into naive rats in a donor-specific manner, indicating that alloantigen-specific regulatory cells operate. Thymectomy prevented regulatory cells development, caused further amplification of intragraft IFN-gamma, and led to rejection, although graft survival was still prolonged.

CONCLUSIONS

Day 2 intragraft IFN-gamma correlates with the DSBT protective effect. Thymectomy abrogates DSBT-induced tolerance, prevents regulatory cell development, and paradoxically causes further accumulation of intragraft IFN-gamma. These data indicate that DSBT has a stimulatory and a (thymus-dependent) inhibitory effect on early intragraft IFN-gamma. Intragraft IFN-gamma is beneficial, providing it occurs early and remains moderate. The role of intragraft IFN-gamma in tolerance and rejection depends upon the timing and the degree of production and perhaps the type of IFN-gamma producing cells (regulatory or effector).

Effector mechanisms in transplant rejection

Antigens, provided by the allograft, trigger the activation and proliferation of allospecific T cells. As a consequence of this response, effector elements are generated that mediate graft injury and are responsible for the clinical manifestations of allograft rejection. Donor-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes play a major role in this process. Likewise, CD4+ T cells mediate delayed-type hypersensitivity responses via the production of soluble mediators that function to further activate and guide immune cells to the site of injury. In addition, these mediators may directly alter graft function by modulating vascular tone and permeability or by promoting platelet aggregation. Allospecific CD4+ T cells also promote B-cell maturation and differentiation into antibody-secreting plasma cells via CD40-CD40 ligand interactions. Alloantibodies that are produced by these B cells exert most of their detrimental effects on the graft by activating the complement cascade. Alternatively, antibodies can bind Fc receptors on natural killer cells or macrophages and cause target cell lysis via antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity. In this review, we discuss these major effector pathways, focusing on their role in the pathogenesis of allograft rejection.

Pretransplant blood transfusion without additional immunotherapy generates CD25+CD4+ regulatory T cells: a potential explanation for the blood-transfusion effect

BACKGROUND

Preoperative blood transfusion has had a significant historic impact on graft outcome in clinical kidney transplantation, and the effect has been widely replicated in many experimental transplant models. Although the mechanisms underlying the blood-transfusion effect are poorly understood, one possibility is that preexposure to alloantigen results in the induction of regulatory cells with the capacity to control the effector arm of the immune response.

METHODS

Recent studies in autoimmune models have shown that T cells with regulatory function can be isolated from unmanipulated animals on the basis of CD25 expression, and we have recently shown that pretreatment of recipient mice with donor alloantigen combined with anti-CD4 antibody therapy generates CD25+CD4+ T cells that can prevent graft rejection. We therefore used this sensitive adoptive transfer mouse model to ask whether blood transfusion in the absence of any other treatment can also lead to the generation of alloreactive CD25+CD4+ regulatory T cells.

RESULTS

Although a single donor-specific transfusion (DST) fails to induce dominant regulation, we demonstrate that pretreatment with multiple DSTs generates CD25+CD4+ T cells that are as effective as those that result from blood transfusion under anti-CD4 antibody cover. More importantly, our results show that these cells also develop following multiple transfusions of unrelated (random) blood.

CONCLUSION

These results provide a basis for understanding the blood-transfusion effect in transplantation and, by providing a link between naturally occurring regulatory cells and those induced by alloantigen, may shed new light on the fundamental basis of the effect itself.

Development of infectious tolerance after donor-specific transfusion and rat heart transplantation

Regulatory cells developed after donor-specific transfusion (DST)-induced acceptance of a LEW heart transplanted into a DA rat. Both DST and the cardiac transplant were necessary to generate the regulatory cells. This donor-specific tolerance can then be transferred into a new DA recipient by adoptive transfer of lymphocytes from the DST-treated long term survivor (LTS) in a dose-dependent manner. The effectiveness of tolerance did not diminish over five generations of adoptive transfer, thus supporting its infectious nature. Although both spleen and lymph node cells were equally effective, graft-infiltrating lymphocytes were more potent. A high level of indirect CTL activity and MLC proliferation were observed in lymphocytes from LTS. In vivo tracking of adoptively transferred CFSE-labeled splenocytes from LTS showed equivalent FACS proliferation and a higher percentage of graft-infiltrating lymphocytes 7 days after heart transplantation, compared with adoptively transferred naive splenocytes. Adoptive transfer of CD8(+)-depleted LTS splenocytes resulted in 100% subsequent LEW allograft acceptance; whereas CD4(+) depletion decreased acceptance to 40%, and depletion of both CD4 and CD8 resulted in 0% acceptance. When positively selected CD4(+) or CD8(+) cells were adoptively transferred, 100% or 62.5% of LEW cardiac allografts survived, respectively. In conclusion, DST alone promotes a donor-specific infectious tolerance of a heart graft that can be adoptively transferred to subsequent naive allograft recipients despite the undiminished in vitro immunological response to donor Ag. Although both CD4(+) and CD8(+) populations are responsible for the regulatory mechanism in DST-induced tolerance, the CD4(+) population appears to dominate.

Immunobiology and long-term graft function in a transplant heterotopic renal rat model

BACKGROUND

The Th1-Th2 paradigm proposes clonal expansion of Th2 lymphocytes as the basis of allograft tolerance. The Th2 cells have been found to be present in recipients with long-term allograft survival. However, the presence of Th2 cells and tolerance is not a uniform finding. Previously we have shown that pre-engraftment single dose rapamycin and a 7-d course of cyclosporin induce transplantation tolerance to 120 d. In the present study, we investigated the immunobiology of grafts in a long-term follow-up (>350 d).

METHODS

Kidney allografts (n = 7), isografts (n = 5) and single nephrectomy (n = 3) groups were followed for 350 +/- 87 d. Heterotopic kidney transplant was performed by the same surgeon in the allograft group (ACI-Lewis) and the isograft group (Lewis-Lewis). The left kidney was removed in the single nephrectomy group. The allograft group was treated with pre-engraftment single dose rapamycin and a 7-d course of cyclosporin. A kidney biopsy was performed at midpoint time for histological study and tissue was frozen for measuring intragraft cytokine expression (IL-4, IL-10) in all animals. Prior to biopsy, serum blood urea nitrogen (BUN) and creatinine (Cr) levels were studied. Serum BUN, Cr levels, plus 24-h urinary protein (PRO) were measured prior to sacrifice. Randomly, four allograft rats received skin grafts (ACI, Lewis and Buffalo skin donors) after kidney biopsy. Skin grafts were studied for a mean of 6 weeks for signs of acceptance or rejection. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Tukey's test was used; p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

The mean follow up was 352 +/- 87 d. BUN and Cr levels at biopsy time (mean 214 d) were not statistically different between the three groups (p = 0.19 and p = 0.66). At sacrifice (mean 352 d), BUN, Cr and PRO were statistically different between allograft and isograft groups (p = 0.013), and between allograft and single nephrectomy groups (p = 0.027). Functional and histological signs of graft loss occurred in three of seven (42.8%) of the allografts at 352 d. Using BANFF criteria, three allografts at biopsy time and seven allografts (100%) and four isografts (80%) at sacrifice time developed chronic histologic changes. Intragraft overexpression of IL-4 and IL-10 was seen at biopsy and sacrifice time in six of seven allografts and one of five isografts. All donor specific skin grafts (ACI-Lewis) on allografts were accepted and third party (Buffalo) donor skin grafts were rejected in all animals (>95% skin necrosis).

CONCLUSIONS

This highly stringent, functional, renal transplant model yields 100% normal renal function as compared with isografts at 120 d follow-up. With the follow-up extended to 350 d, 43% of the allografts loose function and develop a chronic allograft histology despite a demonstrated intragraft Th2 cytokine dominance and donor specific skin graft acceptance.

Donor-lymphocyte infusion induces transplantation tolerance by activating systemic and graft-infiltrating double-negative regulatory T cells

Donor-lymphocyte infusion (DLI) before transplantation can lead to specific tolerance to allografts in mice, nonhuman primates, and humans. We and others have demonstrated a role for regulatory T cells in DLI-induced, donor-specific transplantation tolerance, but it is not known how regulatory T cells are activated and where they execute their function. In this study, we observed, in both transgenic and normal mice, that DLI before transplantation is required for activation of alphabeta-T-cell-receptor-positive, CD3(+)CD4(-)CD8(-) double-negative (DN) regulatory T cells in the periphery of recipient mice. More interestingly, DLI induced DN regulatory T cells to migrate preferentially to donor-specific allogeneic skin grafts and to form a majority of graft-infiltrating T cells in accepted skin allografts. Furthermore, both recipient-derived peripheral and graft-infiltrating DN T cells were able to suppress and kill antidonor CD8(+) T cells in an antigen-specific manner. These data indicate that DLI may induce donor-specific transplantation tolerance by activating recipient DN regulatory T cells in the periphery and by promoting migration of regulatory T cells to donor-specific allogeneic skin grafts. Our results also show that DN regulatory T cells can eliminate antidonor T cells both systemically and locally, a finding suggesting that graft-infiltrating T cells can be beneficial to graft survival.

Transfer of "infectious" cardiac allograft tolerance induced by donor-specific transfusion

BACKGROUND

"Infectious tolerance" has been defined as the tolerance induced in a new recipient by the adoptive transfer of cells from a recipient accepting an allograft after anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 monoclonal antibody treatment. A clear understanding of the mechanisms responsible for graft acceptance after donor-specific blood transfusion (DST) has remained elusive. We examined the development and "infectious" nature of immunologic changes resulting in indefinite survival of LEW to DA rat cardiac allografts after DST alone without the need for antibody.

METHODS

One hundred x 10(6) LEW splenocytes (SC) as DST were injected intravenously into DA recipients 7 days before LEW cardiac transplantation. Subsequently, 100 x 10(6) SC harvested from a DA recipient 30, 60, or 100 days after graft acceptance were adoptively transferred into lightly gamma-irradiated (450 rad) naïve DA recipients 24 hours before a second LEW cardiac allograft. Subsequent graft function was determined.

RESULTS

Adoptive transfer of SC from the DST-treated DA rats 30 days after LEW heart transplant acceptance into naïve gamma-irradiated DA rats failed to transfer tolerance to LEW cardiac allografts. However, SC from DA rats bearing LEW hearts for more than 60 days induced indefinite tolerance to all LEW hearts. This infectious tolerance could be adoptively transferred again to a second DA recipient.

CONCLUSIONS

DST-generated regulatory cells can downregulate naïve lymphocytes to promote allograft acceptance. This tolerance can be expanded and serially transferred to a subsequent naïve cardiac recipient.

Linked unresponsiveness: early cytokine gene expression profiles in cardiac allografts following pretreatment of recipients with bone marrow cells expressing donor MHC alloantigen

Linked unresponsiveness operates to induce specific unresponsiveness to fully mismatched vascularized allografts in recipients pretreated with anti-CD4 antibody and syngeneic bone marrow cells expressing a single donor MHC class I alloantigen. The aim of the study was to evaluate early post transplant cytokine expression in allografts where linked unresponsiveness was required for long term graft survival. CBA (H2(k)) mice were pretreated with CBK (H2(k)+K(b)) bone marrow cells under the cover of anti-CD4 antibody 28 days before transplantation of a CBK or a C57BL/10 (H2(b)) cardiac allograft. In both cases graft survival was prolonged (MST=100 days). Intragraft expression for interferon (IFN)-gamma, interleukin (IL)-2, IL-4, IL-10, IL-12(p40), IL-18, iNOS, transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta(1) and C-beta was determined on day 1.5, 3, 7 and 14 after transplantation. Whereas rejecting allografts displayed a sharp peak in IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-4 and IL-10 expression, non-rejecting allografts were characterized by an initial TGF-beta(1) and IFN-gamma production. An increasing IL-4 expression towards day 14 was a unique feature of linked unresponsiveness. All non-rejecting allografts were characterized by an increasing IL-12(p40) production towards day 14. In summary, the early cytokine expression pattern in allografts after bone marrow induced operational tolerance is influenced by the quantity of donor alloantigens expressed on the graft as well as on the bone marrow inoculum.

Different qualitative and quantitative regulation of V beta TCR transcripts during early acute allograft rejection and tolerance induction

Recently, using a global method of T cell repertoire analysis, we showed that purified naive T cells confronted in vitro with allogeneic APCs in a direct pathway-restricted MLR up-regulate their Vbeta mRNAs without exhibiting skewing of complementarity-determining region 3 (CDR3) length distribution. In this report, using this approach, we show in vivo that Vbeta transcript regulation and CDR3 length distribution follow the same pattern during acute rejection of MHC-incompatible heart allografts. In contrast, in tolerance induction by priming of recipients with donor cells, the vigorous Vbeta mRNA accumulation with Gaussian CDR3 length distribution is abolished, providing a possible explanation for the down-regulation of activated T cells in tolerant animals. In addition, tolerated grafts harbor T cells with a highly altered repertoire, suggestive of self-restricted presentation with some patterns corresponding to previously identified regulatory cells.

Oral exposure to alloantigen generates intragraft CD8+ regulatory cells

We have previously reported that oral administration of allogeneic rat spleen cells before kidney allotransplantation significantly prolongs graft survival. This prolongation was alloantigen specific and was associated with a decrease in graft-infiltrating cells (GIC) and an increase in transcription of IL-4 mRNA in the GIC. In this study increased splenic mixed lymphocyte responses from animals orally exposed to alloantigen before kidney transplantation suggested that the kidney allograft prolongation was not due to a masking of allorecognition, but to an immunomodulation of the immune response. We have assessed GIC T cell subsets on day 5 post-transplant and found decreased numbers of CD4(+) T cells in fed animals compared with controls, but there was no change in CD8(+) T cell numbers. The CD8(+) GIC from fed animals transcribed substantial levels of perforin, granzyme, and Fas ligand mRNA, indicating the presence of active CTL. Direct CTL assays showed that the GIC from fed recipients exhibited higher allo-CTL activity than GIC from control unfed recipients. In addition, the CD8(+) GIC exhibited high levels of IL-4 mRNA, suggesting Tc2-type regulatory cells. Prolonged graft survival in the face of active CTL and Tc2 cells suggests the presence of a CD8(+) regulatory cell population in the allograft. To confirm this, cell transfer experiments were performed. Prolongation of graft survival was transferred from rats orally exposed to alloantigen to naive animals by transfer of CD8(+) GIC. This is the first report that oral exposure to alloantigen prolongs kidney allograft survival by the generation of intragraft CD8(+) regulatory cells.

Inhibition of the allograft response by donor specific blood transfusion: association with reduced local TH1 cytokines and nitric oxide but enhanced prostaglandin E2 production

BACKGROUND

Donor-specific blood transfusion (DST) may improve allograft survival in human and animal models, but the mechanisms for this graft protective effect are incompletely understood. The sponge matrix allograft model was used to determine if DST induces regulatory factors within the allograft.

METHODS

C57BL/6 (H-2b) recipients received donor-specific (DBA/2J, H-2d) or syngeneic (C57BL/6) blood 7 days before sponge matrix allograft (DBA/2J) implantation. Fourteen days postgrafting, the sponge infiltrating cells (SIC) were examined for cytotoxic T cell (CTL) and natural killer (NK) activity, and sponge exudate fluid (SEF) was assessed for nitric oxide (.N=O) and prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) content. Interleukin- (IL) 2, IL-4, IL-10, and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) production by SIC was also determined. Recipient splenocytes were simultaneously assessed for anti-donor cytotoxic and proliferative responses and .N=O production.

RESULTS

SIC from mice receiving syngeneic transfusions (ST) acquired both CTL and NK activity postgrafting, with maximal activity by day 14. DST suppressed both CTL and NK activity throughout the postgrafting period. Limiting dilution analysis (LDA) of SIC to determine precursor and native CTL frequency showed significantly lower responder cell frequency after DST compared with ST. SEF .N=O levels and SIC production of IL-2 and IFN-gamma in grafted DST mice were significantly lower than in grafted mice receiving ST. No significant amounts of IL-4 and very low levels of IL-10 were produced by SIC from grafted mice after either ST or DST. Conversely, PGE2 content of sponge fluid and serum from DST mice was higher than in mice receiving ST. Antigen stimulated splenocyte proliferation and CTL development assessed by LDA were also inhibited by DST.

CONCLUSIONS

Reduction in local TH1 cytokines, absence of detectable TH2 cytokines, with enhanced PGE2 and depressed .N=O were observed in the local graft environment after DST. These data support the hypothesis that DST induces donor-specific intragraft suppressor factors, accompanied by reduced local and systemic immune activation.

Differential role for competitive reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction and intracellular cytokine staining as diagnostic tools for the assessment of intragraft cytokine profiles in rejecting and nonrejecting heart allografts

The early and reliable diagnosis of allograft rejection is a difficult task and the assessment of cytokine expression in the grafts can be a helpful parameter. We have compared competitive reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) with intracellular cytokine staining by flow cytometry as tools to measure cytokine expression in rejecting and nonrejecting murine cardiac allografts. Both techniques gave comparable results for cytokine expression in rejecting allografts and syngeneic controls. Grafts from mice pretreated with anti-CD4 antibody and donor-specific blood transfusion showed a marked reduction in cytokine expression, as assessed by competitive RT-PCR, even though a cellular infiltrate was present in the graft. In contrast, the cytokine production measured by intracellular cytokine staining of the isolated graft-infiltrating cells was high and exceeded even that of the rejecting allografts. We conclude that intracellular cytokine staining of graft-infiltrating leukocytes by flow cytometry does not necessarily reflect accurately the cytokine milieu in the graft. This technique might therefore have a limited clinical application in contrast to competitive RT-PCR for the differentiation between graft acceptance and graft rejection.

Allograft tolerance induced by cyclophosphamide without prior inoculation of donor cells--immune suppression and redirection

OBJECTIVES

To determine the possibility and cellular mechanism of inducing allograft tolerance by multiple injection of a lower dose of cyclophosphamide without prior infusion of donor cells.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Heterotopic heart grafts were performed in MHC mismatched strain combinations (C57/B6 vs. BALB/c). Cyclophosphamide (40 mg/kg) was given intravenously on days 0, 2, 4 and 7 without prior infusion of donor cells. Long-term (> 100 days) allograft survival with normal histology was achieved. The long-term survivors accepted the donor skin grafts, but rejected the third-party skin grafts. Cyclophosphamide treatment initially led to profound lymphocytopenia, inhibition of spontaneous blastogenesis and low levels of lymphocyte proliferation response to both donor and third-party antigens. Ultimately, donor-specific tolerance occurred demonstrated by normal levels of peripheral lymphocytes, spontaneous blastogenesis and lymphocyte proliferation response to third-party antigens, and low levels of lymphocyte proliferation response to donor antigen. A switch of cytokines from IFNgamma dominant to IL-4 dominant, a low level of IgM and a high level of IgG1 were found in tolerant mice.

CONCLUSIONS

Allograft tolerance can be induced by a short course of cyclophosphamide without prior donor cell inoculation. Tolerance induced is characterized initially by non-specific immunosuppression, which progresses to donor-specific hyporesponsiveness associated with the development of a Th2 dominant cytokine response.

Antigen presentation by parenchymal cells: a route to peripheral tolerance?

T-cell activation and the development of efficient immune responses requires the delivery, by the antigen-presenting cell, of two distinct signals. The first results from the engagement of the TCR:CD3:CD4 complex, and the second from the interaction of CD28 with the B7 family of co-stimulatory molecules. In this context, the physiological significance and the functional consequences of antigen presentation by B7-deficient parenchymal cells, which express MHC class II molecules as a result of inflammation, remains a matter of debate. In this paper we have attempted to critically review the often conflicting reports on the functional effects of antigen presentation by epithelial and endothelial cells to T cells, both in vitro and in vivo. Our own findings are summarised in a model which is consistent with the suggestion of an important role for antigen presentation by parenchymal cells in the induction and the maintenance of peripheral tolerance.

Lung allograft dysfunction correlates with gamma-interferon gene expression in bronchoalveolar lavage

BACKGROUND

Preceding episodes of acute cellular rejection (ACR) may predispose lung allografts to the subsequent development of irreversible dysfunction or bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS). Other histologic patterns such as bronchiolitis obliterans with organizing pneumonia (BOOP), organizing pneumonia, lymphocytic bronchiolitis and diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) may also adversely affect allograft function. We have previously reported the predominant expression of Th1 cytokines (IL-2 and interferon gamma) in rejecting and Th2 (IL-10) in a tolerant model of rat lung transplantation. Here we correlate the "Th1/Th2 paradigm" in clinical lung transplantation with histologic findings and assess the effect on serial spirometric function.

METHODS

We examined the mRNA expression of IL-2, interferon gamma, IL-10 and ICAM-1 in 53 bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) specimens from 23 lung transplant (LT) recipients utilizing qualitative "nested" reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). We also measured IgG1 and IgG2 levels in 44 BAL specimens by ELISA. The mRNA expression for cytokines, ICAM-1 and the IgG2/IgG1 ratios were correlated with the presence or absence of ACR and alternate "histologic patterns". Serial spirometry were analyzed for the 2-3 month interval before bronchoscopic (FOB) assessment to derive "baseline" forced expiratory volume-one second (FEV1) values. The change in FEV1 coincident with (deltaFEV1 pre) and for the 2-3 month interval subsequent to (deltaFEV1 post) FOB were expressed relative to "baseline" spirometric indexes.

RESULTS

Detection of mRNA for interferon gamma and ICAM-1 correlated significantly with ACR, whereas IL-2 and IL-10 expression did not correlate. IL-10 was virtually "ubiquitous" in most BAL samples irrespective of the presence or absence of ACR. The highest correlation was observed with interferon gamma for acute cellular rejection whereupon the sensitivity was 77.7%, specificity 87.7%, positive predictive value 73.6% and negative predictive value 88.2%, although for ICAM-1 these values were 75%, 65.7%, 50.0% and 85.0%, respectively. Nevertheless, 4 of 5 episodes of respiratory tract infection (bacterial, CMV, Aspergillus spp.) were similarly associated with cytokine mRNA. The ratios of IgG2 to IgG1, a reflection of Th1/Th2 influence, were not statistically different when analyzed for the presence or absence of ACR (0.91+/-0.53 vs. 1.02+/-0.70, respectively; p = NS). By analysis of FEV1 trends, expression of interferon gamma was associated with a greater and persistent decrement (deltaFEV1 pre: -0.265+/-0.78 liters, and post: -0.236+/-0.1161; mean +/- SE) than ACR in the absence of interferon gamma expression (+0.158 +/- +0.065 and +0.236+/-0.007 liters, respectively) (Student-Newman-Keuls, p<.05).

CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest that interferon gamma mRNA expression and ICAM-1 may be valuable in both the diagnosis and prognosis for lung allograft ACR. IL-10, a Th2 cytokine, was locally expressed both in the presence and absence of ACR. Expression of mRNA for interferon y in BAL and, to a lesser extent ICAM-1, were associated with increased lung allograft dysfunction. Whether BAL cytokine "immunosurveillance" would complement or possibly supplant a specific "histologic pattern" and thereby direct different therapies after lung transplantation, may be potentially rewarding areas of further investigation.

Intra- and extrahepatic leukocytes and cytokine mRNA expression during liver regeneration after partial hepatectomy in rats

We investigated intra- and extrahepatic leukocytes during liver regeneration after a 70% partial hepatectomy in the rats using flow cytometry and RT-PCR for cytokine mRNA expression. Our study indicated that LFA-1 CD3+ cell, NK3.2.3++ T cells, and CD5+ B cells, which are activated in autoimmune diseases and malignancy in humans and mice, were activated in the early phase of liver regeneration in the liver and the blood after partial hepatectomy in the rats. On measuring cytokine mRNA expression by RT-PCR, only IFN-gamma mRNA was detected in the normal rat liver. IFN-gamma mRNA expression clearly decreased in the liver on day 1 after partial hepatectomy and increased thereafter. IL-2 and IL-4 mRNA were not detected in the liver regardless of hepatectomy. Every cytokine was detected in normal spleen and increased in the early phase after partial hepatectomy. These were also detected in normal thymus; however, IL-2 and IFN-gamma mRNA expressions decreased and IL-4 mRNA expression increased slightly in the early phase after partial hepatectomy. Thus, the immune system dramatically changed both in the liver and elsewhere in the early phase of liver regeneration after partial hepatectomy.

Intra- and extrahepatic leukocytes and cytokine mRNA expression during liver regeneration after partial hepatectomy in rats

We investigated intra- and extrahepatic leukocytes during liver regeneration after a 70% partial hepatectomy in the rats using flow cytometry and RT-PCR for cytokine mRNA expression. Our study indicated that LFA-1 CD3+ cell, NK3.2.3++ T cells, and CD5+ B cells, which are activated in autoimmune diseases and malignancy in humans and mice, were activated in the early phase of liver regeneration in the liver and the blood after partial hepatectomy in the rats. On measuring cytokine mRNA expression by RT-PCR, only IFN-gamma mRNA was detected in the normal rat liver. IFN-gamma mRNA expression clearly decreased in the liver on day 1 after partial hepatectomy and increased thereafter. IL-2 and IL-4 mRNA were not detected in the liver regardless of hepatectomy. Every cytokine was detected in normal spleen and increased in the early phase after partial hepatectomy. These were also detected in normal thymus; however, IL-2 and IFN-gamma mRNA expressions decreased and IL-4 mRNA expression increased slightly in the early phase after partial hepatectomy. Thus, the immune system dramatically changed both in the liver and elsewhere in the early phase of liver regeneration after partial hepatectomy.

Differential Th1 and Th2 cell regulation of murine cardiac allograft acceptance by blocking cell adhesion of ICAM-1/LFA-1 and VCAM-1/VLA-4

Administration of anti-intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM)-1 monoclonal antibody (mAb) plus anti-lymphocyte function associated antigen (LFA)-1 mAb induces tolerance in murine cardiac transplantation, while anti-vascular cell adhesion molecule (VCAM)-1 mAb plus anti-very late antigen (VLA)-4 mAb administration prolongs graft survival, but leads to tolerance only in some cases. BALB/c mice hearts were transplanted into C3H/He recipients. Each combination of anti-VCAM-1 plus anti-VLA-4 mAbs (100 microg each/day, i.p.) or anti-ICAM-1 plus anti-LFA-1 mAbs (50 microg each/day, i.p.) was administered for 5 days. For control study, third group mice received daily with FK506 administration (1 mg/kg/day). The cardiac allografts and recipients' spleens were harvested on day 7; the expression of cytokines were detected using immunohistochemistry, reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and in situ RT-PCR. Th2 cytokines (IL-4 and IL-10) were markedly enhanced and Th1 cytokines (IFN-gamma and IL-2) were suppressed in recipients treated with anti-ICAM-1 mAb plus anti-LFA-1 mAb, while poor Th2 cytokine expression allowed persistent Th1 cytokine expression in recipient mice with anti-VCAM-1 mAb plus anti-VLA-4 mAb treatment. Both Th1 and Th2 cytokine expression was suppressed in FK506-treated mice. It is concluded that immunological tolerance and prolonged graft survival induced by blocking cell adhesion is regulated by different cytokine expression.

Tolerance to Antigen-Presenting Cell-Depleted Islet Allografts Is CD4 T Cell Dependent

Pretreatment of pancreatic islets in 95% oxygen culture depletes graft-associated APCs and leads to indefinite allograft acceptance in immunocompetent recipients. As such, the APC-depleted allograft represents a model of peripheral alloantigen presentation in the absence of donor-derived costimulation. Over time, a state of donor-specific tolerance develops in which recipients are resistant to donor APC-induced graft rejection. Thus, persistence of the graft is sufficient to induce tolerance independent of other immune interventions. Donor-specific tolerance could be adoptively transferred to immune-deficient SCID recipient mice transplanted with fresh immunogenic islet allografts, indicating that the original recipient was not simply “ignorant” of donor antigens. Interestingly, despite the fact that the original islet allograft presented only MHC class I alloantigens, CD8+ T cells obtained from tolerant animals readily collaborated with naive CD4+ T cells to reject donor-type islet grafts. Conversely, tolerant CD4+ T cells failed to collaborate effectively with naive CD8+ T cells for the rejection of donor-type grafts. In conclusion, the MHC class I+, II− islet allograft paradoxically leads to a change in the donor-reactive CD4 T cell subset and not in the CD8 subset. We hypothesize that the tolerant state is not due to direct class I alloantigen presentation to CD8 T cells but, rather, occurs via the indirect pathway of donor Ag presentation to CD4 T cells in the context of host MHC class II molecules.

Induction of specific tolerance to allografts in rats by therapy with non-mitogenic, non-depleting anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody: association with TH2 cytokines not anergy

BACKGROUND

Anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies (mAb) are potent immunosuppressives in transplantation but most do not induce tolerance. They induce anergy in Th1 cells but, if they bind to Fc receptors on antigen presenting cells, they activate T cells to release cytokines.

METHODS

This study examined the mechanisms of transplant tolerance induction to PVG fully allogeneic grafts in dark agouti rats by G4.18, a mouse immunoglobulinG3 anti-rat CD3 mAb that does not bind rat Fc receptors. Evidence of T cell activation was assayed by flow cytometry, reverse transcription (RT)-polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for cytokine mRNA, and responsiveness in mixed lymphocyte culture.

RESULTS

G4.18 treatment modulated T cell receptor/CD3 and CD2 and depleted T cells by <20% but did not induce activation surface markers. mRNA for interleukin (IL)-2, interferon (IFN)-gamma, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha, and IL-4 in the lymph node, spleen, and thymus was not increased, and IFN-gamma mRNA was reduced. G4.18-treated and naive rat cells had similar proliferation and expression of IL-2, IFN-gamma, and IL-4 in vitro. G4.18-treated allograft recipients had no induction of mRNA for IL-2, IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, TNF-beta, IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, perforin, and granzyme A & B in the spleen or grafts, with levels similar to those in isografts. The IL-4 and IL-5 mRNA levels in the spleen but not the graft of G4.18-treated recipients were higher than in rejecting and naive animals. Cells from G4.18-treated graft recipients proliferated more rapidly to the donor than to the third party and had increased IL-4 expression.

CONCLUSIONS

G4.18 induced transplant tolerance by a combination of modulation and blocking of the TCR/CD3, associated with increased Th2 cytokines, without depletion, induction of anergy, or nonspecific activation of T cells.

Intragraft cytokine expression in tolerant rat renal allografts with rapamycin and cyclosporin immunosuppression

The Th-1/Th-2 paradigm proposes clonal expansion of Th-2 lymphocytes as the basis of tolerance towards allografts. Intragraft cytokine expression was evaluated in a highly stringent model of renal transplantation. ACI and Lewis rats were used as donors and recipients, respectively, for heterotopic renal transplantation. Group A (n = 8) received a single dose of rapamycin and cyclosporin 12 h prior to engraftment, followed by 7 d of cyclosporin post-operatively. Isografts (Group B, n = 5) and control allografts (Group C, n = 4) received no immunosuppression. Sacrifice was performed after 120 d. Intragraft expression of IL-10, IL-4, and IFN-gamma was determined using qualitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). All groups had functionally normal grafts at sacrifice, with 50% histological tolerance among Group A animals. No isografts showed evidence of cellular infiltrate, and all control allografts showed severe rejection. IL-10 was only detected in the tolerant animals (p < 0.001). Similarly, IL-4 was detected predominantly in the tolerant allografts (p < 0.05). IFN-gamma was only isolated in rejected allografts, whether treated or untreated (p < 0.001). We conclude that the expansion of Th-2 cells is associated with tolerance, while the expansion of Th-1 cell is associated with acute cellular rejection.

Induction of immunologic tolerance for transplantation

In the second half of the 20th century, the transplantation of replacement organs and tissues to cure disease has become a clinical reality. Success has been achieved as a direct result of progress in understanding the cellular and molecular biology of the immune system. This understanding has led to the development of immunosuppressive pharmaceuticals that are part of nearly every transplantation procedure. All such drugs are toxic to some degree, however, and their chronic use, mandatory in transplantation, predisposes the patient to the development of infection and cancer. In addition, many of them may have deleterious long-term effects on the function of grafts. New immunosuppressive agents are constantly under development, but organ transplantation remains a therapy that requires patients to choose between the risks of their primary illness and its treatment on the one hand, and the risks of life-long systemic immunosuppression on the other. Alternatives to immunosuppression include modulation of donor grafts to reduce immunogenicity, removal of passenger leukocytes, transplantation into immunologically privileged sites like the testis or thymus, encapsulation of tissue, and the induction of a state of immunologic tolerance. It is the last of these alternatives that has, perhaps, the most promise and most generic applicability as a future therapy. Recent reports documenting long-term graft survival in the absence of immunosuppression suggest that tolerance-based therapies may soon become a clinical reality. Of particular interest to our laboratory are transplantation strategies that focus on the induction of donor-specific T-cell unresponsiveness. The basic biology, protocols, experimental outcomes, and clinical implications of tolerance-based transplantation are the focus of this review.

Recombinant IFN-gamma abrogates allograft tolerance induced by donor-specific blood transfusion by restoring alloantibody production

Donor-specific tolerance to heart allograft was induced in adult Lewis rats by pregraft donor-specific blood transfusion (DST). We previously showed that this tolerant state is characterized by a dramatic inhibition of T cell and macrophage activation. In addition, tolerant animals could not mount an efficient anti-donor humoral response whereas transfer of sera from rejecting animals triggered rejection in tolerant animals. This tolerance can be abrogated by daily post-graft administration of recombinant IFN-gamma (rIFN-gamma). To elucidate the mechanisms of action of rIFN-gamma, T cell, macrophage and B cell functions were assessed in allograft recipients. IFN-gamma did not restore the expression of Th1-related cytokine mRNA or the activated macrophage product inducible nitric oxide synthase in allografts. Importantly, rIFN-gamma treatment promptly restored the anti-donor humoral response in DST-treated recipients. We conclude that rIFN-gamma treatment in DST-treated allograft recipients cannot reverse the unresponsive state of Th1 cells and macrophages infiltrating the graft, but can provide B cell help for IgG alloantibody production which is lacking in these animals.

Critical Requirement for Graft Passenger Leukocytes in Allograft Tolerance Induced by Donor Blood Transfusion

Tolerance to a vascularized allograft can be induced in adult animals by pregraft donor-specific blood transfusion (DST). Mechanisms underlying this effect appear to depend on unresponsiveness of alloreactive T-helper cells. In this study, we examined the roles of DST and cellular components of the allograft that are important in inducing T-cell unresponsiveness in a rat model. DST alone did not tolerize alloreactive recipient T-helper cells, but the combination of DST and heart allograft induced profound inhibition of the antidonor proliferative response in spleen but not in lymph node cells. When heart allografts were depleted of passenger leukocytes by pretreating the donor with cyclophosphamide or by parking the graft for 2 months in a tolerant recipient, tolerance induction in DST-treated recipients was abrogated. Tolerance could then be restored in a majority of DST-treated recipients of passenger leukocytes depleted grafts by injecting them at the time of grafting with donor, but not third-party, dendritic cells. This indicates that graft passenger leukocytes, most likely dendritic cells, are required for DST-induced allograft tolerance.

Critical Requirement for Graft Passenger Leukocytes in Allograft Tolerance Induced by Donor Blood Transfusion

Tolerance to a vascularized allograft can be induced in adult animals by pregraft donor-specific blood transfusion (DST). Mechanisms underlying this effect appear to depend on unresponsiveness of alloreactive T-helper cells. In this study, we examined the roles of DST and cellular components of the allograft that are important in inducing T-cell unresponsiveness in a rat model. DST alone did not tolerize alloreactive recipient T-helper cells, but the combination of DST and heart allograft induced profound inhibition of the antidonor proliferative response in spleen but not in lymph node cells. When heart allografts were depleted of passenger leukocytes by pretreating the donor with cyclophosphamide or by parking the graft for 2 months in a tolerant recipient, tolerance induction in DST-treated recipients was abrogated. Tolerance could then be restored in a majority of DST-treated recipients of passenger leukocytes depleted grafts by injecting them at the time of grafting with donor, but not third-party, dendritic cells. This indicates that graft passenger leukocytes, most likely dendritic cells, are required for DST-induced allograft tolerance.

Redefining peripheral tolerance in the BALB/c to CBA mouse cardiac allograft model: vascular and cytokine analysis after transient CD4 T cell depletion

BACKGROUND

To evaluate cardiac allografts from recipients that had achieved peripheral tolerance after transient CD4+ T cell depletion, we analyzed cellular infiltrate, cytokine expression, and vascular thickening. Long-surviving cardiac allografts from tolerant recipients were compared with acutely rejecting allografts and isografts.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In CBA mice treated with anti-CD4 (GK1.5, 0.5 mg intraperitoneally on days 1-28), BALB/c cardiac allografts survived >100 days. These recipients were tested for tolerance at >70 days, by challenge with donor and third-party (C57BL/6) skin grafts. BALB/c skin grafts survived >30 days, although C57BL/6 skin was rejected in <12 days, reflecting alloantigen-specific peripheral tolerance. When vascular thickening in graft arteries was assessed and computerized measurements performed, heart allografts from tolerant recipients showed significantly increased percentage of luminal occlusion compared with isografts (47% compared with 1.2%). Semiquantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction was used to assess normalized intragraft mRNA transcripts for cytokines and T cell markers, with immunoperoxidase staining of frozen sections to confirmed the presence of protein. Compared with rejecting grafts, well-preserved hearts from tolerant mice had lower levels of macrophage and T cell infiltration and decreased transcription of interferon-gamma, interleukin (IL)-2, IL-10, and inducible nitric oxide synthase. IL-4 expression was similar in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The degree of tolerance achieved allowed specific acceptance of donor skin grafts, preserved primary graft function, and reduced inflammatory activation. Tolerance did not, however, completely prevent macrophage and T cell infiltration of the graft or the development of vascular lesions typical of chronic rejection.

A critical role for transforming growth factor-beta in donor transfusion-induced allograft tolerance

Donor-specific (DST) or nonspecific blood transfusions administered before transplantation can enhance survival of vascularized allografts both in humans and animals but the immunological mechanisms of this effect remain unclear. We have analyzed the expression and the role of endogenous TGF-beta1 in a model of heart allograft tolerance, induced by pregraft DST in adult rats. We reported previously that this tolerance occurs despite a strong infiltration of leukocytes into the graft that are unable to produce both Th1- and Th2-related cytokines in vivo. Allografts from DST-treated rats express high levels of TGF-beta1 mRNA and active protein. This phenomenon is correlated with the rapid infiltration of leukocytes producing high amounts of TGF-beta1. TGF-beta1-producing cells are virtually absent among early infiltrating cells in rejected grafts but are found at a later time point. The induction of allograft tolerance in vivo is abrogated by administration of neutralizing anti-TGF-beta mAb. Moreover, overexpression of active TGF- beta1 in heart allografts using a recombinant adenovirus leads to prolonged graft survival in unmodified recipients. Taken together, our results identify TGF-beta as a critical cytokine involved in the suppression of allograft rejection induced by DST and suggest that TGF-beta-producing regulatory cells are also involved in allograft tolerance.

Importance of T cells to accelerated rejection and acceptance of renal allografts in sensitized rat recipients

BACKGROUND

Sensitized recipients often experience fulminant allograft loss by yet ill-defined cellular and/or humoral immune mechanisms. In this study, we analyzed the contribution of cellular elements, in particular T cells, to the accelerated rejection of renal allografts in sensitized rats.

METHODS AND RESULTS

LEW rats sensitized with BN skin grafts died of uremia in 3.3+/-0.9 days after transplantation of a BN kidney, similarly to bilaterally nephrectomized animals. Adoptive transfer of 10(6) graft-infiltrating mononuclear cells as well as their CD25+ subset into otherwise normal LEW recipients accelerated rejection of BN test cardiac allografts (5.4+/-0.5 days to 6.6+/-0.4 days vs. 7.8+/-0.8 days in controls, P<0.0007), while the CD25- population was ineffective (8.0+/-0.6 days, NS). Furthermore, alpha/beta-T-cell receptor (TCR)-targeted therapy with R73 monoclonal antibody abrogated accelerated rejection, and produced long-term survival in sensitized animals treated before kidney engraftment (day -7 to day -1). Long-term survival was associated with an up-regulation of intragraft interleukin-4 and interleukin-10 expression in conjunction with depressed Th-1-type cytokines. In addition, alpha/beta-TCR-targeted therapy even in low subtherapeutic dose decreased IgM alloantibody levels, and prevented the switch from IgM to IgG alloantibody response.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first report that documents the striking efficacy of alpha/beta-TCR-targeted therapy in sensitized rat renal transplant recipients. The results provide evidence for a critical role of T cells for both accelerated rejection and long-term graft survival. Up-regulation of Th2-type cytokine profile may, at least in part, contribute to the acquisition of immune unresponsiveness after alpha/beta-TCR-targeted therapy in this well-defined rat renal transplant model.

Comparative studies of specific acquired systemic tolerance induced by intrathymic inoculation of a single synthetic Wistar-Furth (RT1U) allo-MHC class I (RT1.AU) peptide or WAG (RT1U)-derived class I peptide

BACKGROUND

Because T cell receptor-MHC class I/self-peptide interactions regulate T-cell development, the presence of MHC allopeptides in the thymus may influence T-cell tolerance to alloantigens. This hypothesis is supported by our most recent finding that intrathymic (IT) inoculation of nonimmunogenic synthetic peptides derived from "WAG" RT1.A induces tolerance to cardiac allografts in the Wistar-Furth (WF)-to-ACI model. To evaluate whether in vivo immunogenicity of MHC peptides is relevant to tolerance induction and to examine the effect of peptide specificity, we compared the effects on graft survival of well-defined, strain-specific immunogenic WF MHC class I peptides (RT1.AU) with closely related but non-strain-specific class I peptides derived from WAG (RT1U).

METHODS

In vivo immunization of seven MHC class I peptides synthesized from RT1.AU sequences showed that two (u-5 and u-7) were immunogenic, whereas five others were not immunogenic in ACI recipients. We then examined the effects on cardiac allograft survival in the WF-to-ACI model of the two immunogenic RT1.AU peptides (u-5 and u-7) and three immunogenic WAG-derived peptides (peptides 1, 2, and 5).

RESULTS

A combination of equal amounts (150 microg or 300 microg) of u-5 or u-7 each with 0.5 ml of antilymphocyte serum (ALS) on day -7 led to 60% and 100% permanent graft survival (>150 days), respectively. IT injection of the individual peptides on day -7 showed that only 300 microg of u-5 significantly prolonged graft survival to a median survival time of 17.3 days from 10.5 days in naive recipients. IT injection of 150, 300, and 600 microg of u-5 combined with 0.5 ml of ALS on day -7 led to permanent graft survival (> 150 days) in four of six, nine of nine, and six of six ACI recipients, respectively, compared with a median survival time of 15.4 days in ALS alone-treated controls. In contrast, similar treatments with peptide u-7 with or without 0.5 ml of ALS did not prolong graft survival, thus demonstrating that peptide u-5 alone mediates the observed effects on graft prolongation. A total of 300 microg of u-5 injected IT combined with ALS led to acute rejection of third-party (Lewis) grafts. Intravenous injection of 300 microg of u-5 with ALS also did not prolong WF graft survival in ACI recipients. The long-term unresponsive ACI recipients accepted permanently donor-type (WF) but not third-party (Lewis) second-set cardiac and islet allografts. Similarly, we showed that although IT injection of 600 and 1200 microg of a mixture of immunogenic WAG-derived peptides 1, 2, and 5 combined with 0.5 ml of ALS on day -7 led to permanent WF graft survival in ACI, only IT injection of 300 microg of peptide 2 combined with ALS led to permanent graft survival (>150 days) in four of five animals. To define the underlying mechanisms of tolerance, we examined in vitro the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity, and cytokine profile of unresponsive recipients. Although the results showed nonspecific T-cell suppression in the MLR at 25 days after transplantation, which correlated with the persistence of ALS immunosuppression, long-term unresponsive animals showed normal MLR to donor and third-party antigens. In contrast, the donor-specific reactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes remained suppressed in short-term and long-term unresponsive rats.

CONCLUSION

Of interest is our finding that IT injection of a short segment of WAG-derived MHC class I peptide induces active acquired tolerance similar to results obtained with the use of pure WF-derived peptide u-5 in the WF-to-ACI rat combination. It is noteworthy that we could not confirm the T helper (Th)1/Th2 paradigm in this model by initial cytokine analysis. Whether induction of tolerance by IT injection of allo-MHC peptides will have clinical usefulness must await results of similar studies in large animals. However, of major interest is the finding that a short segment of RT1.AU represents the tolerogenic

Fas ligand, tumor necrosis factor-alpha expression, and apoptosis during allograft rejection and tolerance

BACKGROUND

Cytotoxic T cells can induce target cell lysis and apoptosis by different pathways. The interactions of CD95 antigen (Fas) with its ligand (CD95L) and of tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha with its receptor (TNF-R1) lead to apoptotic cell death. Recently, conflicting studies have been published concerning the expression and the role of CD95L in allograft rejection and tolerance.

METHODS

In this study, the intragraft expression of CD95/CD95L and TNF-alpha and the frequency and distribution of apoptotic cells were compared in a model of heterotopic cardiac allograft in the rat in which recipients were either not treated (acute rejection) or pretreated with donor-specific blood transfusion (tolerant).

RESULTS

In the acutely rejected allografts, a peak in the expression of CD95L and TNF-alpha and in the number of apoptotic cells was observed during the first week after transplantation; apoptotic cells were confined to graft-infiltrating cells. In the tolerated allografts, however, levels of graft-infiltrating cell apoptosis and CD95L and TNF-alpha expression during the same period of time were dramatically lower. The expression of Fas was constitutive and was not modulated during acute rejection or tolerance.

CONCLUSION

This down-regulation of CD95L and TNF-alpha in allografts rendered tolerant by donor-specific transfusion suggests a role for apoptosis-inducing pathways in acute allograft rejection.

Donor-specific hyporeactivity after liver transplantation: prominent decreases in donor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor frequencies independent of changes in helper T lymphocyte precursor frequencies or suppressor cell activity

BACKGROUND

The development of immunological donor-specific hyporeactivity may account for the low incidence of chronic rejection after clinical liver transplantation. We investigated whether hyporeactivity commonly develops after liver transplantation by analyzing precursor frequencies of donor-reactive cytotoxic (CTLp) and helper (HTLp) T lymphocytes and mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) reactivity in liver allograft recipients. We further studied whether CTLp hyporeactivity correlated with changes in donor-specific HTLp frequencies or suppressor cell activity.

METHODS

CTLp and HTLp frequencies and MLC reactivity against donor and third-party spleen cells were determined in pre- and posttransplantation peripheral blood samples from 18 recipients with good graft function 2 years after transplantation. By mixing posttransplantation samples (with "putative" suppressor cell activity) with pretransplantation samples (in which normal CTL activity with no suppressor cell activity is expected), the presence of suppressor cell activity in peripheral blood was analyzed.

RESULTS

Two years after transplantation, all but one (94%) of the recipients had developed CTLp hyporeactivity as evidenced by reduced donor-specific CTLp frequencies. The development of hyporeactivity was not specific for any particular underlying disease. The occurrence of HTL hyporeactivity, however, was less frequent: 38% and 20% of recipients were HTLp and MLC hyporeactive, respectively. Decreases in CTLp frequencies did not correlate with decreased donor-specific HTL function or suppressor cell activity in peripheral blood samples.

CONCLUSIONS

Donor-specific CTLp hyporeactivity can develop in the majority of liver allograft recipients, irrespective of underlying disease. Donor-specific HTL hyporeactivity, however, occurs infrequently. A reduction in donor-specific CTLp frequencies was found to be independent of changes in donor-specific HTLp or suppressor cell activity, suggesting that other mechanisms (e.g., clonal deletion) are operative in the reduction of donor-specific CTLp after liver transplantation.

The immunologic role of IFN-gamma in ACI to Lewis kidney transplantation

BACKGROUND

One of the proposed mechanisms of tolerance induction is the Th-1/Th-2 paradigm. The Th-1 cell is proinflammatory, secreting IFN-gamma and IL-2. Conversely, the Th-2 cell is anti-inflammatory, secreting IL-4 and IL-10. In our earlier studies a shift toward Th-2 dominance was required for tolerance induction in this model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

ACI and Lewis rats were used as donors and recipients, respectively. Twelve hours prior to engraftment, rapamycin 1.5 mg/kg po and cyclosporin 10 mg/kg sc were given, followed by 5 mg/kg sc postop (days 1-7). Lewis rats were used as isografts. Functional allograft tolerance was induced consistently in 100% of the recipients with 50% of the allografts exhibiting normal histology beyond 120 days. Qualitative RT-PCR was performed on the grafts to determine IFN-gamma expression with beta-actin housekeeping gene as control.

RESULTS

IFN-gamma was expressed in all untreated allografts (5/5) and all treated, yet rejecting, allografts (4/4). None of the isografts (0/5) or histologically tolerant allografts (0/4) expressed IFN-gamma. This distribution was statistically significant (P < 0.001, Fischer's exact test).

CONCLUSION

Our findings support a shift from Th-2 to Th-1 predominance as the corollary mechanism responsible for preventing histologic tolerance.