Outer hair cell electromotility is low-pass filtered relative to the molecular conformational changes that produce nonlinear capacitance

Multiple Modes of Motion for the Effectiveness of Outer Hair Cells at High Frequencies

Outer hair cells (OHCs) are essential for the sensitivity and frequency specificity of the mammalian ear. To perform this function, OHCs need to amplify the motion of the basilar membrane (BM), which is much stiffer than themselves. If OHCs and the BM are components of a single oscillator, this impedance mismatch seriously limits the effectiveness of OHCs. However, the elaborated structure of the organ of Corti can support multiple modes of motion. Here, systems of two coupled oscillators are examined as the simplest models of the system with multiple modes of motion. It is found that some of these model systems have conditions, under which an OHC can function as an effective amplifier, overcoming the impedance mismatch. The present examination suggests that the presence of multiple modes of motion is a key to the exquisite performance of the mammalian ear.

Rate Dependent Cochlear Outer Hair Cell Force Generation: Models and Parameter Estimation

The outer hair cells (OHCs) of the mammalian cochlea are the mediators of an active, nonlinear electromechanical process necessary for sensitive, frequency specific hearing. The membrane protein prestin conveys to the OHC a piezoelectric-like behavior hypothesized to actuate a high frequency, cycle-by-cycle conversion of electrical to mechanical energy to boost cochlear responses to low-level sound. This hypothesis has been debated for decades, and we address two key remaining issues: the influence of the rate dependence of conformal changes in prestin and the OHC transmembrane impedance. We develop a theoretical electromechanical model of the OHC that explicitly includes rate dependence of conformal transitions, viscoelasticity, and piezoelectricity. Using this theory, we show the influence of rate dependence and viscoelasticity on electromechanical force generation. Further, we stress the importance of using the correct mechanical boundary conditions when estimating the transmembrane capacitance. Finally, a set of experiments is described to uniquely estimate the constitutive properties of the OHC from whole-cell measurements.

Role of mitochondrial dysfunction and oxidative stress in sensorineural hearing loss

Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) can either be genetically inherited or acquired as a result of aging, noise exposure, or ototoxic drugs. Although the precise pathophysiological mechanisms underlying SNHL remain unclear, an overwhelming body of evidence implicates mitochondrial dysfunction and oxidative stress playing a central etiological role. With its high metabolic demands, the cochlea, particularly the sensory hair cells, stria vascularis, and spiral ganglion neurons, is vulnerable to the damaging effects of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS). Mitochondrial dysfunction and consequent oxidative stress in cochlear cells can be caused by inherited mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations (hereditary hearing loss and aminoglycoside-induced ototoxicity), accumulation of acquired mtDNA mutations with age (age-related hearing loss), mitochondrial overdrive and calcium dysregulation (noise-induced hearing loss and cisplatin-induced ototoxicity), or accumulation of ototoxic drugs within hair cell mitochondria (drug-induced hearing loss). In this review, we provide an overview of our current knowledge on the role of mitochondrial dysfunction and oxidative stress in the development of SNHL caused by genetic mutations, aging, exposure to excessive noise, and ototoxic drugs. We also explore the advancements in antioxidant therapies for the different forms of acquired SNHL that are being evaluated in preclinical and clinical studies.

Megahertz Sampling of Prestin (SLC26a5) Voltage-Sensor Charge Movements in Outer Hair Cell Membranes Reveals Ultrasonic Activity that May Support Electromotility and Cochlear Amplification

Charged moieties in the outer hair cell (OHC) membrane motor protein, prestin, are driven by transmembrane voltage to power OHC electromotility (eM) and cochlear amplification (CA), an enhancement of mammalian hearing. Consequently, the speed of prestin's conformational switching constrains its dynamic influence on micromechanics of the cell and the organ of Corti. Corresponding voltage-sensor charge movements in prestin, classically assessed as a voltage-dependent, nonlinear membrane capacitance (NLC), have been used to gauge its frequency response, but have been validly measured only out to 30 kHz. Thus, controversy exists concerning the effectiveness of eM in supporting CA at ultrasonic frequencies where some mammals can hear. Using megahertz sampling of guinea pig (either sex) prestin charge movements, we extend interrogations of NLC into the ultrasonic range (up to 120 kHz) and find an order of magnitude larger response at 80 kHz than previously predicted, indicating that an influence of eM at ultrasonic frequencies is likely, in line with recent in vivo results (Levic et al., 2022). Given wider bandwidth interrogations, we also validate kinetic model predictions of prestin by directly observing its characteristic cut-off frequency under voltage-clamp as the intersection frequency (Fis), near 19 kHz, of the real and imaginary components of complex NLC (cNLC). The frequency response of prestin displacement current noise determined from either the Nyquist relation or stationary measures aligns with this cut-off. We conclude that voltage stimulation accurately assesses the spectral limits of prestin activity, and that voltage-dependent conformational switching is physiologically significant in the ultrasonic range.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT The motor protein prestin powers outer hair cell (OHC) electromotility (eM) and cochlear amplification (CA), an enhancement of high-frequency mammalian hearing. The ability of prestin to work at very high frequencies depends on its membrane voltage-driven conformation switching. Using megahertz sampling, we extend measures of prestin charge movement into the ultrasonic range and find response magnitude at 80 kHz an order of magnitude larger than previously estimated, despite confirmation of previous low pass characteristic frequency cut-offs. The frequency response of prestin noise garnered by the admittance-based Nyquist relation or stationary noise measures confirms this characteristic cut-off frequency. Our data indicate that voltage perturbation provides accurate assessment of prestin performance indicating that it can support cochlear amplification into a higher frequency range than previously thought.

The Remarkable Outer Hair Cell: Proceedings of a Symposium in Honour of W. E. Brownell

In 1985, Bill Brownell and colleagues published the remarkable observation that cochlear outer hair cells (OHCs) express voltage-driven mechanical motion: electromotility. They proposed OHC electromotility as the mechanism for the elusive "cochlear amplifier" required to explain the sensitivity of mammalian hearing. The finding and hypothesis stimulated an explosion of experiments that have transformed our understanding of cochlear mechanics and physiology, the evolution of hair cell structure and function, and audiology. Here, we bring together examples of current research that illustrate the continuing impact of the discovery of OHC electromotility.

The Long Outer-Hair-Cell RC Time Constant: A Feature, Not a Bug, of the Mammalian Cochlea

The cochlea of the mammalian inner ear includes an active, hydromechanical amplifier thought to arise via the piezoelectric action of the outer hair cells (OHCs). A classic problem of cochlear biophysics is that the RC (resistance-capacitance) time constant of the hair-cell membrane appears inconveniently long, producing an effective cut-off frequency much lower than that of most audible sounds. The long RC time constant implies that the OHC receptor potential-and hence its electromotile response-decreases by roughly two orders of magnitude over the frequency range of mammalian hearing, casting doubt on the hypothesized role of cycle-by-cycle OHC-based amplification in mammalian hearing. Here, we review published data and basic physics to show that the "RC problem" has been magnified by viewing it through the wrong lens. Our analysis finds no appreciable mismatch between the expected magnitude of high-frequency electromotility and the sound-evoked displacements of the organ of Corti. Rather than precluding significant OHC-based boosts to auditory sensitivity, the long RC time constant appears beneficial for hearing, reducing the effects of internal noise and distortion while increasing the fidelity of cochlear amplification.

Coupling between outer hair cell electromotility and prestin sensor charge depends on voltage operating point

The OHC drives cochlear amplification, and prestin activity is the basis. The frequency response of nonlinear capacitance (NLC), which is a ratiometric measure of prestin's voltage-sensor charge movement (dQp/dVm), depends on the location of AC voltage excitation along prestin's operating voltage range, being slowest at the voltage (Vh) where NLC peaks. Here we directly investigate the coupling between prestin charge movement (Qp) and electromotility (eM) at frequencies up to 6.25 kHz, and find tight correspondence between the two at operating voltages displaced from Vh. Near Vh, however, eM shows a slower frequency response than Qp. We reason that coupling is more susceptible to molecular/cellular loads at Vh, where prestin compliance is expected to be maximal. Recent cryo-EM studies have begun to shed light on structural features of prestin that impact its performance against loads. This article is part of the Special Issue Outer hair cell Edited by Joseph Santos-Sacchi and Kumar Navaratnam.

Unloading outer hair cell bundles in vivo does not yield evidence of spontaneous oscillations in the mouse cochlea

Along with outer hair cell (OHC) somatic electromotility as the actuator of cochlear amplification, active hair bundle motility may be a complementary mechanism in the mammalian auditory system. Here, we searched the mouse cochlea for the presence of spontaneous bundle oscillations that have been observed in non-mammalian ears. In those systems, removal of the overlying membrane is necessary for spontaneous bundle oscillations to manifest. Thus, we used a genetic mouse model with a C1509G (cysteine-to-glycine) point mutation in the Tecta gene where the tectorial (TM) is lifted away from the OHC bundles, allowing us to explore whether unloaded bundles spontaneously oscillate. We used VOCTV in vivo to detect OHC length changes due to electromotility as a proxy for the spontaneous opening and closing of the mechanoelectrical transduction (MET) channels associated with bundle oscillation. In wild type mice with the TM attached to OHC bundles, we did find peaks in vibratory magnitude spectra. Such peaks were not observed in the mutants where the TM is detached from the OHC bundles. Statistical analysis of the time signals indicates that these peaks do not signify active oscillations. Rather, they are filtered responses of the sensitive wild type cochlea to weak background noise. We therefore conclude that, to the limits of our system (∼30 pm), there is no spontaneous mechanical activity that manifests as oscillations in OHC electromotility within the mouse cochlea, arguing that unloaded OHC bundles do not oscillate in vivo. This article is part of the Special Issue Outer hair cell Edited by Joseph Santos-Sacchi and Kumar Navaratnam.

On the frequency response of prestin charge movement in membrane patches

Outer hair cell (OHC) nonlinear membrane capacitance (NLC) derives from voltage-dependent sensor charge movements within the membrane protein prestin (SLC26a5) that drive OHC electromotility. The ability of the protein to influence hearing depends on its reaction to membrane receptor potentials across auditory frequency. Estimates of prestin's frequency response have been evaluated by several groups out to tens of kHz in voltage-clamped macro-patches of OHC membrane. The response is a power function of frequency which is down 40 dB at 77 kHz. Despite these observations, concerns remain that the macro-patch approach is flawed due to mechanical constraints of pipette solution column load or patch size itself. In the absence of these influences, prestin's frequency response is posited by some to be ultrasonic in nature. Here we evaluate the influence of these putative confounding factors on prestin's frequency response. We show that neither pipette column height, nor negative or positive pipette pressure substantially influence total sensor charge frequency response. Additionally, patch surface area has negligible influence. We conclude that the speed of voltage-driven conformational changes in prestin within the plasma membrane are accurately assessed with the macro-patch technique, permitting investigations of membrane characteristics that can substantially alter prestin's performance bandwidth. We illustrate significant alterations in bandwidth by perturbation of membrane fluidity and chloride anion concentration. Finally, we speculate that OHC membrane characteristics may differ along the tonotopic axis of the cochlea to tune NLC frequency cut-offs.

Progress in understanding the structural mechanism underlying prestin's electromotile activity

Prestin (SLC26A5), a member of the SLC26 transporter family, is the molecular actuator that drives OHC electromotility (eM). A wealth of biophysical data indicates that eM is mediated by an area motor mechanism, in which prestin molecules act as elementary actuators by changing their area in the membrane in response to changes in membrane potential. The area changes of a large and densely packed population of prestin molecules sum up, resulting in macroscopic cellular movement. At the single protein level, this model implies major voltage-driven conformational rearrangements. However, the nature of these structural dynamics remained unknown. A main obstacle in elucidating the eM mechanism has been the lack of structural information about SLC26 transporters. The recent emergence of several high-resolution cryo-EM structures of prestin as well as other SLC26 transporter family members now provides a reliable picture of prestin's molecular architecture. Thus, SLC26 transporters including prestin generally are dimers, and each protomer is folded according to a 7+7 transmembrane domain inverted repeat (7TMIR) architecture. Here, we review these structural findings and discuss insights into a potential molecular mechanism. Most important, distinct conformations were observed when purifying and imaging prestin bound to either its physiological ligand, chloride, or to competitively inhibitory anions, sulfate or salicylate. Despite differences in detail, these structural snapshots indicate that the conformational landscape of prestin includes rearrangements between the two major domains of prestin's transmembrane region (TMD), core and scaffold ('gate') domains. Notably, distinct conformations differ in the area the TMD occupies in the membrane and in their impact on the immediate lipid environment. Both effects can contribute to generate membrane deformation and thus may underly electromotility. Further functional studies will be necessary to determine whether these or similar structural rearrangements are driven by membrane potential to mediate piezoelectric activity. This article is part of the Special Issue Outer hair cell Edited by Joseph Santos-Sacchi and Kumar Navaratnam.

Cochlear outer hair cell electromotility enhances organ of Corti motion on a cycle-by-cycle basis at high frequencies in vivo

Mammalian hearing depends on an amplification process involving prestin, a voltage-sensitive motor protein that enables cochlear outer hair cells (OHCs) to change length and generate force. However, it has been questioned whether this prestin-based somatic electromotility can operate fast enough in vivo to amplify cochlear vibrations at the high frequencies that mammals hear. In this study, we measured sound-evoked vibrations from within the living mouse cochlea and found that the top and bottom of the OHCs move in opposite directions at frequencies exceeding 20 kHz, consistent with fast somatic length changes. These motions are physiologically vulnerable, depend on prestin, and dominate the cochlea's vibratory response to high-frequency sound. This dominance was observed despite mechanisms that clearly low-pass filter the in vivo electromotile response. Low-pass filtering therefore does not critically limit the OHC's ability to move the organ of Corti on a cycle-by-cycle basis. Our data argue that electromotility serves as the primary high-frequency amplifying mechanism within the mammalian cochlea.

State dependent effects on the frequency response of prestin's real and imaginary components of nonlinear capacitance

The outer hair cell (OHC) membrane harbors a voltage-dependent protein, prestin (SLC26a5), in high density, whose charge movement is evidenced as a nonlinear capacitance (NLC). NLC is bell-shaped, with its peak occurring at a voltage, V_h, where sensor charge is equally distributed across the plasma membrane. Thus, V_h provides information on the conformational state of prestin. V_h is sensitive to membrane tension, shifting to positive voltage as tension increases and is the basis for considering prestin piezoelectric (PZE). NLC can be deconstructed into real and imaginary components that report on charge movements in phase or 90 degrees out of phase with AC voltage. Here we show in membrane macro-patches of the OHC that there is a partial trade-off in the magnitude of real and imaginary components as interrogation frequency increases, as predicted by a recent PZE model (Rabbitt in Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 17:21880–21888, 2020). However, we find similar behavior in a simple 2-state voltage-dependent kinetic model of prestin that lacks piezoelectric coupling. At a particular frequency, F_is, the complex component magnitudes intersect. Using this metric, F_is, which depends on the frequency response of each complex component, we find that initial V_h influences F_is; thus, by categorizing patches into groups of different V_h, (above and below − 30 mV) we find that F_is is lower for the negative V_h group. We also find that the effect of membrane tension on complex NLC is dependent, but differentially so, on initial V_h. Whereas the negative group exhibits shifts to higher frequencies for increasing tension, the opposite occurs for the positive group. Despite complex component trade-offs, the low-pass roll-off in absolute magnitude of NLC, which varies little with our perturbations and is indicative of diminishing total charge movement, poses a challenge for a role of voltage-driven prestin in cochlear amplification at very high frequencies.

The cochlear outer hair cell speed paradox

Cochlear outer hair cells (OHCs) are among the fastest known biological motors and are essential for high-frequency hearing in mammals. It is commonly hypothesized that OHCs amplify vibrations in the cochlea through cycle-by-cycle changes in length, but recent data suggest OHCs are low-pass filtered and unable to follow high-frequency signals. The fact that OHCs are required for high-frequency hearing but appear to be throttled by slow electromotility is the "OHC speed paradox." The present report resolves this paradox and reveals origins of ultrafast OHC function and power output in the context of the cochlear load. Results demonstrate that the speed of electromotility reflects how fast the cell can extend against the load, and does not reflect the intrinsic speed of the motor element itself or the nearly instantaneous speed at which the coulomb force is transmitted. OHC power output at auditory frequencies is revealed by emergence of an imaginary nonlinear capacitance reflecting the phase of electrical charge displacement required for the motor to overcome the viscous cochlear load.

Complex nonlinear capacitance in outer hair cell macro-patches: effects of membrane tension

Outer hair cell (OHC) nonlinear capacitance (NLC) represents voltage sensor charge movements of prestin (SLC26a5), the protein responsible for OHC electromotility. Previous measures of NLC frequency response have employed methods which did not assess the influence of dielectric loss (sensor charge movements out of phase with voltage) that may occur, and such loss conceivably may influence prestin's frequency dependent activity. Here we evaluate prestin's complex capacitance out to 30 kHz and find that prestin's frequency response determined using this approach coincides with all previous estimates. We also show that membrane tension has no effect on prestin's frequency response, despite substantial shifts in its voltage operating range, indicating that prestin transition rate alterations do not account for the shifts. The magnitude roll-off of prestin activity across frequency surpasses the reductions of NLC caused by salicylate treatments that are known to abolish cochlear amplification. Such roll-off likely limits the effectiveness of prestin in contributing to cochlear amplification at the very high acoustic frequencies processed by some mammals.

Cooperativity of Kv7.4 channels confers ultrafast electromechanical sensitivity and emergent properties in cochlear outer hair cells

The mammalian cochlea relies on active electromotility of outer hair cells (OHCs) to resolve sound frequencies. OHCs use ionic channels and somatic electromotility to achieve the process. It is unclear, though, how the kinetics of voltage-gated ionic channels operate to overcome extrinsic viscous drag on OHCs at high frequency. Here, we report ultrafast electromechanical gating of clustered K_v7.4 in OHCs. Increases in kinetics and sensitivity resulting from cooperativity among clustered-K_v7.4 were revealed, using optogenetics strategies. Upon clustering, the half-activation voltage shifted negative, and the speed of activation increased relative to solitary channels. Clustering also rendered K_v7.4 channels mechanically sensitive, confirmed in consolidated K_v7.4 channels at the base of OHCs. K_v7.4 clusters provide OHCs with ultrafast electromechanical channel gating, varying in magnitude and speed along the cochlea axis. Ultrafast K_v7.4 gating provides OHCs with a feedback mechanism that enables the cochlea to overcome viscous drag and resolve sounds at auditory frequencies.

Maturation of Voltage-induced Shifts in SLC26a5 (Prestin) Operating Point during Trafficking and Membrane Insertion

Prestin (SLC26a5) is an integral membrane motor protein in outer hair cells (OHC) that underlies cochlear amplification. As a voltage-dependent protein, it relies on intrinsic sensor charge to respond to transmembrane voltage (receptor potentials), thereby effecting conformational changes. The protein's electromechanical actively is experimentally monitored as a bell-shaped nonlinear capacitance (NLC), whose magnitude peaks at a characteristic voltage, V_h. This voltage denotes the midpoint of prestin's charge-voltage (Q-V) Boltzmann distribution and region of maximum gain of OHC electromotility. It is an important factor in hearing capabilities for mammals. A variety of biophysical forces can influence the distribution of charge, gauged by shifts in V_h, including prior holding voltage or membrane potential. Here we report that the effectiveness of prior voltage augments during the delivery of prestin to the membranes in an inducible HEK cell line. The augmentation coincides with an increase in prestin density, maturing at a characteristic membrane areal density of 870 functional prestin units per square micrometer, and is likely indicative of prestin-prestin cooperative interactions.

Two-tone distortion in reticular lamina vibration of the living cochlea

It has been demonstrated that isolated auditory sensory cells, outer hair cells, can generate distortion products at low frequencies. It remains unknown, however, whether or not motile outer hair cells are able to generate two-tone distortion at high frequencies in living cochleae under the mechanical loads caused by surounding tissues and fluids. By measuring sub-nanometer vibration directly from the apical ends of outer hair cells using a custom-built heterodyne low-coherence interferometer, here we show outer hair cell-generated two-tone distortion in reticular lamina motion in the living cochlea. Reticular-lamina distortion is significantly greater and occurs at a broader frequency range than that of the basilar membrane. Contrary to expectations, our results indicate that motile outer hair cells are capable of generating two-tone distortion in vivo not only at the locations tuned to primary tones but also at a broad region basal to these locations.

Ren et al. used an in house heterodyne low-coherence interferometer to measure sub-nanometer vibrations, a proxy for distortion products, in living cochleae of gerbils. They were able to locate the generation source of the outer hair cell in the reticular lamina versus the basilar membrane in vivo.

Diverse Mechanisms of Sound Frequency Discrimination in the Vertebrate Cochlea

Discrimination of different sound frequencies is pivotal to recognizing and localizing friend and foe. Here, I review the various hair cell-tuning mechanisms used among vertebrates. Electrical resonance, filtering of the receptor potential by voltage-dependent ion channels, is ubiquitous in all non-mammals, but has an upper limit of ~1 kHz. The frequency range is extended by mechanical resonance of the hair bundles in frogs and lizards, but may need active hair-bundle motion to achieve sharp tuning up to 5 kHz. Tuning in mammals uses somatic motility of outer hair cells, underpinned by the membrane protein prestin, to expand the frequency range. The bird cochlea may also use prestin at high frequencies, but hair cells <1 kHz show electrical resonance.

Voltage Does Not Drive Prestin (SLC26a5) Electro-Mechanical Activity at High Frequencies Where Cochlear Amplification Is Best

Cochlear amplification denotes a boost to auditory sensitivity and selectivity that is dependent on outer hair cells from Corti's organ. Voltage-driven electromotility of the cell is believed to feed energy back into the cochlear partition via a cycle-by-cycle mechanism at very high acoustic frequencies. Here we show using wide-band macro-patch voltage-clamp to drive prestin, the molecular motor underlying electromotility, that its voltage-sensor charge movement is unusually low pass in nature, being incapable of following high-frequency voltage changes. Our data are incompatible with a cycle-by-cycle mechanism responsible for high-frequency tuning in mammals.

•

Outer hair cells (OHC) boost auditory sensation for very high acoustic frequencies

•

We studied the frequency response of OHC's electromechanical nonlinear capacitance

•

The response is incommensurate with cycle-by-cycle feedback at very high frequencies

•

OHCs likely use another mechanism to drive cochlear amplification at high frequencies