Comparative analysis of humoral immune responses to HIV type 1 envelope glycoproteins in mice immunized with a DNA vaccine, recombinant Semliki Forest virus RNA, or recombinant Semliki Forest virus particles

Advances in saRNA Vaccine Research against Emerging/Re-Emerging Viruses

Although conventional vaccine approaches have proven to be successful in preventing infectious diseases in past decades, for vaccine development against emerging/re-emerging viruses, one of the main challenges is rapid response in terms of design and manufacture. mRNA vaccines can be designed and produced within days, representing a powerful approach for developing vaccines. Furthermore, mRNA vaccines can be scaled up and may not have the risk of integration. mRNA vaccines are roughly divided into non-replicating mRNA vaccines and self-amplifying RNA (saRNA) vaccines. In this review, we provide an overview of saRNA vaccines, and discuss future directions and challenges in advancing this promising vaccine platform to combat emerging/re-emerging viruses.

Vaccine development for zoonotic viral diseases caused by positive‑sense single‑stranded RNA viruses belonging to the Coronaviridae and Togaviridae families (Review)

Outbreaks of zoonotic viral diseases pose a severe threat to public health and economies worldwide, with this currently being more prominent than it previously was human history. These emergency zoonotic diseases that originated and transmitted from vertebrates to humans have been estimated to account for approximately one billion cases of illness and have caused millions of deaths worldwide annually. The recent emergence of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (coronavirus disease 2019) is an excellent example of the unpredictable public health threat causing a pandemic. The present review summarizes the literature data regarding the main vaccine developments in human clinical phase I, II and III trials against the zoonotic positive-sense single-stranded RNA viruses belonging to the Coronavirus and Alphavirus genera, including severe acute respiratory syndrome, Middle east respiratory syndrome, Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus, Semliki Forest virus, Ross River virus, Chikungunya virus and O'nyong-nyong virus. That there are neither vaccines nor effective antiviral drugs available against most of these viruses is undeniable. Therefore, new explosive outbreaks of these zoonotic viruses may surely be expected. The present comprehensive review provides an update on the status of vaccine development in different clinical trials against these viruses, as well as an overview of the present results of these trials.

Applications of self-replicating RNA

Self-replicating RNA viral vectors have been engineered for both prophylactic and therapeutic applications. Mainly the areas of infectious diseases and cancer have been targeted. Both positive and negative strand RNA viruses have been utilized including alphaviruses, flaviviruses, measles viruses and rhabdoviruses. The high-level of RNA amplification has provided efficient expression of viral surface proteins and tumor antigens. Immunization studies in animal models have elicit robust neutralizing antibody responses. In the context of infectious diseases, immunization with self-replicating RNA viral vectors has provided protection against challenges with lethal doses of pathogens in animal models. Similarly, immunization with vectors expressing tumor antigens has resulted in tumor regression and eradication and protection against tumor challenges in animal models. The transient nature and non-integration of viral RNA into the host genome are ideal features for vaccine development. Moreover, self-replicating RNA viral vectors show great flexibility as they can be applied as recombinant viral particles, RNA replicons or DNA replicon plasmids. Several clinical trials have been conducted especially in the area of cancer immunotherapy.

The Delivery of mRNA Vaccines for Therapeutics

mRNA vaccines have been revolutionary in combating the COVID-19 pandemic in the past two years. They have also become a versatile tool for the prevention of infectious diseases and treatment of cancers. For effective vaccination, mRNA formulation, delivery method and composition of the mRNA carrier play an important role. mRNA vaccines can be delivered using lipid nanoparticles, polymers, peptides or naked mRNA. The vaccine efficacy is influenced by the appropriate delivery materials, formulation methods and selection of a proper administration route. In addition, co-delivery of several mRNAs could also be beneficial and enhance immunity against various variants of an infectious pathogen or several pathogens altogether. Here, we review the recent progress in the delivery methods, modes of delivery and patentable mRNA vaccine technologies.

Self-Replicating RNA Viruses for Vaccine Development against Infectious Diseases and Cancer

Alphaviruses, flaviviruses, measles viruses and rhabdoviruses are enveloped single-stranded RNA viruses, which have been engineered for recombinant protein expression and vaccine development. Due to the presence of RNA-dependent RNA polymerase activity, subgenomic RNA can replicate close to 106 copies per cell for translation in the cytoplasm providing extreme transgene expression levels, which is why they are named self-replicating RNA viruses. Expression of surface proteins of pathogens causing infectious disease and tumor antigens provide the basis for vaccine development against infectious diseases and cancer. Self-replicating RNA viral vectors can be administered as replicon RNA at significantly lower doses than conventional mRNA, recombinant particles, or DNA plasmids. Self-replicating RNA viral vectors have been applied for vaccine development against influenza virus, HIV, hepatitis B virus, human papilloma virus, Ebola virus, etc., showing robust immune response and protection in animal models. Recently, paramyxovirus and rhabdovirus vector-based SARS-CoV-2 vaccines as well as RNA vaccines based on self-amplifying alphaviruses have been evaluated in clinical settings. Vaccines against various cancers such as brain, breast, lung, ovarian, prostate cancer and melanoma have also been developed. Clinical trials have shown good safety and target-specific immune responses. Ervebo, the VSV-based vaccine against Ebola virus disease has been approved for human use.

Immunogenicity of stabilized HIV-1 Env trimers delivered by self-amplifying mRNA

Self-amplifying mRNA (saRNA) represents a promising platform for nucleic acid delivery of vaccine immunogens. Unlike plasmid DNA, saRNA does not require entry into the nucleus of target cells for expression, having the capacity to drive higher protein expression compared to mRNA as it replicates within the cytoplasm. In this study, we examined the potential of stabilized native-like HIV-1 Envelope glycoprotein (Env) trimers to elicit immune responses when delivered by saRNA polyplexes (PLXs), assembled with linear polyethylenimine. We showed that Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus (VEEV) saRNA induces a stronger humoral immune response to the encoded transgene compared to Semliki Forest virus saRNA. Moreover, we characterized the immunogenicity of the soluble and membrane-bound ConSOSL.UFO Env design in mice and showed a faster humoral kinetic and an immunoglobulin G (IgG)2a skew using a membrane-bound design. The immune response generated by PLX VEEV saRNA encoding the membrane-bound Env was then evaluated in larger animal models including macaques, in which low doses induced high IgG responses. Our data demonstrated that the VEEV saRNA PLX nanoparticle formulation represents a suitable platform for the delivery of stabilized HIV-1 Env and has the potential to be used in a variety of vaccine regimens.

Application of Viral Vectors for Vaccine Development with a Special Emphasis on COVID-19

Viral vectors can generate high levels of recombinant protein expression providing the basis for modern vaccine development. A large number of different viral vector expression systems have been utilized for targeting viral surface proteins and tumor-associated antigens. Immunization studies in preclinical animal models have evaluated the elicited humoral and cellular responses and the possible protection against challenges with lethal doses of infectious pathogens or tumor cells. Several vaccine candidates for both infectious diseases and various cancers have been subjected to a number of clinical trials. Human immunization trials have confirmed safe application of viral vectors, generation of neutralizing antibodies and protection against challenges with lethal doses. A special emphasis is placed on COVID-19 vaccines based on viral vectors. Likewise, the flexibility and advantages of applying viral particles, RNA replicons and DNA replicon vectors of self-replicating RNA viruses for vaccine development are presented.

Development and Applications of Viral Vectored Vaccines to Combat Zoonotic and Emerging Public Health Threats

Vaccination is arguably the most cost-effective preventative measure against infectious diseases. While vaccines have been successfully developed against certain viruses (e.g., yellow fever virus, polio virus, and human papilloma virus HPV), those against a number of other important public health threats, such as HIV-1, hepatitis C, and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), have so far had very limited success. The global pandemic of COVID-19, caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus, highlights the urgency of vaccine development against this and other constant threats of zoonotic infection. While some traditional methods of producing vaccines have proven to be successful, new concepts have emerged in recent years to produce more cost-effective and less time-consuming vaccines that rely on viral vectors to deliver the desired immunogens. This review discusses the advantages and disadvantages of different viral vaccine vectors and their general strategies and applications in both human and veterinary medicines. A careful review of these issues is necessary as they can provide important insights into how some of these viral vaccine vectors can induce robust and long-lasting immune responses in order to provide protective efficacy against a variety of infectious disease threats to humans and animals, including those with zoonotic potential to cause global pandemics.

Self-Amplifying RNA Viruses as RNA Vaccines

Single-stranded RNA viruses such as alphaviruses, flaviviruses, measles viruses and rhabdoviruses are characterized by their capacity of highly efficient self-amplification of RNA in host cells, which make them attractive vehicles for vaccine development. Particularly, alphaviruses and flaviviruses can be administered as recombinant particles, layered DNA/RNA plasmid vectors carrying the RNA replicon and even RNA replicon molecules. Self-amplifying RNA viral vectors have been used for high level expression of viral and tumor antigens, which in immunization studies have elicited strong cellular and humoral immune responses in animal models. Vaccination has provided protection against challenges with lethal doses of viral pathogens and tumor cells. Moreover, clinical trials have demonstrated safe application of RNA viral vectors and even promising results in rhabdovirus-based phase III trials on an Ebola virus vaccine. Preclinical and clinical applications of self-amplifying RNA viral vectors have proven efficient for vaccine development and due to the presence of RNA replicons, amplification of RNA in host cells will generate superior immune responses with significantly reduced amounts of RNA delivered. The need for novel and efficient vaccines has become even more evident due to the global COVID-19 pandemic, which has further highlighted the urgency in challenging emerging diseases.

RNA Viruses as Tools in Gene Therapy and Vaccine Development

RNA viruses have been subjected to substantial engineering efforts to support gene therapy applications and vaccine development. Typically, retroviruses, lentiviruses, alphaviruses, flaviviruses rhabdoviruses, measles viruses, Newcastle disease viruses, and picornaviruses have been employed as expression vectors for treatment of various diseases including different types of cancers, hemophilia, and infectious diseases. Moreover, vaccination with viral vectors has evaluated immunogenicity against infectious agents and protection against challenges with pathogenic organisms. Several preclinical studies in animal models have confirmed both immune responses and protection against lethal challenges. Similarly, administration of RNA viral vectors in animals implanted with tumor xenografts resulted in tumor regression and prolonged survival, and in some cases complete tumor clearance. Based on preclinical results, clinical trials have been conducted to establish the safety of RNA virus delivery. Moreover, stem cell-based lentiviral therapy provided life-long production of factor VIII potentially generating a cure for hemophilia A. Several clinical trials on cancer patients have generated anti-tumor activity, prolonged survival, and even progression-free survival.

Self-Replicating RNA Viruses for RNA Therapeutics

Self-replicating single-stranded RNA viruses such as alphaviruses, flaviviruses, measles viruses, and rhabdoviruses provide efficient delivery and high-level expression of therapeutic genes due to their high capacity of RNA replication. This has contributed to novel approaches for therapeutic applications including vaccine development and gene therapy-based immunotherapy. Numerous studies in animal tumor models have demonstrated that self-replicating RNA viral vectors can generate antibody responses against infectious agents and tumor cells. Moreover, protection against challenges with pathogenic Ebola virus was obtained in primates immunized with alphaviruses and flaviviruses. Similarly, vaccinated animals have been demonstrated to withstand challenges with lethal doses of tumor cells. Furthermore, clinical trials have been conducted for several indications with self-amplifying RNA viruses. In this context, alphaviruses have been subjected to phase I clinical trials for a cytomegalovirus vaccine generating neutralizing antibodies in healthy volunteers, and for antigen delivery to dendritic cells providing clinically relevant antibody responses in cancer patients, respectively. Likewise, rhabdovirus particles have been subjected to phase I/II clinical trials showing good safety and immunogenicity against Ebola virus. Rhabdoviruses have generated promising results in phase III trials against Ebola virus. The purpose of this review is to summarize the achievements of using self-replicating RNA viruses for RNA therapy based on preclinical animal studies and clinical trials in humans.

Immunogenicity of virus-like Semliki Forest virus replicon particles expressing Indian HIV-1C gag, env and polRT genes

Development of a vaccine targeting human immunodeficiency virus-1 subtype C (HIV-1C) is an important public health priority in regions with a high prevalence of the clade C virus. The present study demonstrates the immunogenicity of recombinant Semliki Forest virus (SFV)-based virus-like replicon particles (VRPs) expressing Indian HIV-1C env/gag/polRT genes. Immunization of mice with recombinant VRPs in a homologous prime-boost protocol, either individually or in combination, elicited significant antigen-specific IFN-γ T cell responses as detected by the ELISPOT assay. Additionally, Gag-specific TNF-α secreting CD8⁺ and CD4⁺ T cells and Env-specific IL-2 secreting T cells were also elicited by mice immunized with Gag and Env constructs, respectively, as estimated by intracellular cytokine staining assay. Moreover, an HIV Pol-specific TNF-α response was elicited in mice immunized with a combination of the three VRP constructs. Furthermore, HIV-1C Gag and Env-specific binding antibodies were elicited as verified by gp120 ELISA and p24 Gag ELISA, respectively. The immunogenicity of VRPs was found to be higher as compared to that of RNA replicons and VRPs may therefore be promising preventive and therapeutic candidate vaccines for the control and management of HIV/AIDS.

Alphavirus-Based Vaccines

Alphavirus-based vectors have been engineered from Semliki Forest virus, Sindbis virus, and Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus and applied for vaccine development. Immunization in preclinical animal models has been conducted with naked RNA replicons, recombinant viral particles and layered DNA-RNA vectors. Most commonly, the targets for the immunization have been viral surface proteins and tumor antigens, which have elicited strong immune responses and even provided protection against challenges with lethal doses of virus and tumor cells, respectively. As alphaviruses also cause epidemics, vaccines have been developed against Chikungunya virus. Despite the success in several animal smodels only a few clinical trials have been conducted in humans, so far.

Replicon RNA Viral Vectors as Vaccines

Single-stranded RNA viruses of both positive and negative polarity have been used as vectors for vaccine development. In this context, alphaviruses, flaviviruses, measles virus and rhabdoviruses have been engineered for expression of surface protein genes and antigens. Administration of replicon RNA vectors has resulted in strong immune responses and generation of neutralizing antibodies in various animal models. Immunization of mice, chicken, pigs and primates with virus-like particles, naked RNA or layered DNA/RNA plasmids has provided protection against challenges with lethal doses of infectious agents and administered tumor cells. Both prophylactic and therapeutic efficacy has been achieved in cancer immunotherapy. Moreover, recombinant particles and replicon RNAs have been encapsulated by liposomes to improve delivery and targeting. Replicon RNA vectors have also been subjected to clinical trials. Overall, immunization with self-replicating RNA viruses provides high transient expression levels of antigens resulting in generation of neutralizing antibody responses and protection against lethal challenges under safe conditions.

Self-replicating RNA viral vectors in vaccine development and gene therapy

RNA viruses are characterized by their efficient capacity to replicate at high levels in mammalian cells leading to high expression of foreign genes and making them attractive candidates for vectors engineered for vaccine development and gene therapy. Particularly, alphaviruses, flaviviruses, rhabdoviruses and measles viruses have been applied for immunization against infectious agents and tumors. Application of replicon RNA, DNA/RNA-layered vectors and replication-deficient viral particles have provided strong immune responses and protection against challenges with lethal doses of viral pathogens or tumor cells. Moreover, tumor regression has been obtained when RNA replicons have been administered in the form of RNA, DNA and viral particles, including replication-proficient oncolytic particles.

Alphavirus-Based Vaccines

Alphavirus vectors based on Semliki Forest virus, Sindbis virus, and Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus have been widely applied for vaccine development. Naked RNA replicons, recombinant viral particles, and layered DNA vectors have been subjected to immunization in preclinical animal models with antigens for viral targets and tumor antigens. Moreover, a limited number of clinical trials have been conducted in humans. Vaccination with alphavirus vectors has demonstrated efficient immune responses and has showed protection against challenges with lethal doses of virus and tumor cells, respectively. Moreover, vaccines have been developed against alphaviruses causing epidemics such as Chikungunya virus.

Immunogenicity of Semliki Forest virus based self-amplifying RNA expressing Indian HIV-1C genes in mice

Development of recombinant vaccines is considered as a promising approach to prevent transmission and eradication of HIV/AIDS. Candidate vaccines tested so far have shown poor to modest efficacy. Self-amplifying RNAs of positive strand alphaviruses are reported to be promising vectors for development of recombinant vaccines. This study describes the construction, in vitro expression and in vivo immunogenicity of recombinant RNA vaccines developed by individually cloning gag, env and polRT genes of primary HIV-1C Indian isolates using Semliki Forest virus (SFV) vector. HIV-1C specific T cell responses were detected in mice immunized with rSFV2gen/gag RNA by IFN-γ ELISPOT assay. Furthermore, using flow cytometry based intracellular cytokine staining (ICCS) assay HIV-1C specific IL-2 responses were detected in immunized mice that were mediated by both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells. Mice immunized with rSFV2gen/env RNA elicited HIV-1C Env-specific antibodies as detected by gp120 ELISA. The Env, Gag and Pol (RT) RNA constructs in combination elicited better HIV-1C Env-specific humoral responses compared to mice immunized with Env RNA alone. In conclusion, rSFV2gen RNA constructs encoding HIV-1C antigens elicited clear cell mediated and humoral immune responses in mice, thus demonstrating the potential of self-amplifying rSFV2gen RNA as a promising candidate for anti-HIV vaccine development.

RNA-based viral vectors

The advent of reverse genetic approaches to manipulate the genomes of both positive (+) and negative (-) sense RNA viruses allowed researchers to harness these genomes for basic research. Manipulation of positive sense RNA virus genomes occurred first largely because infectious RNA could be transcribed directly from cDNA versions of the RNA genomes. Manipulation of negative strand RNA virus genomes rapidly followed as more sophisticated approaches to provide RNA-dependent RNA polymerase complexes coupled with negative-strand RNA templates were developed. These advances have driven an explosion of RNA virus vaccine vector development. That is, development of approaches to exploit the basic replication and expression strategies of RNA viruses to produce vaccine antigens that have been engineered into their genomes. This study has led to significant preclinical testing of many RNA virus vectors against a wide range of pathogens as well as cancer targets. Multiple RNA virus vectors have advanced through preclinical testing to human clinical evaluation. This review will focus on RNA virus vectors designed to express heterologous genes that are packaged into viral particles and have progressed to clinical testing.

Self-replicating alphavirus RNA vaccines

Recombinant nucleic acids are considered as promising next-generation vaccines. These vaccines express the native antigen upon delivery into tissue, thus mimicking live attenuated vaccines without having the risk of reversion to pathogenicity. They also stimulate the innate immune system, thus potentiating responses. Nucleic acid vaccines are easy to produce at reasonable cost and are stable. During the past years, focus has been on the use of plasmid DNA for vaccination. Now mRNA and replicon vaccines have come into focus as promising technology platforms for vaccine development. This review discusses self-replicating RNA vaccines developed from alphavirus expression vectors. These replicon vaccines can be delivered as RNA, DNA or as recombinant virus particles. All three platforms have been pre-clinically evaluated as vaccines against a number of infectious diseases and cancer. Results have been very encouraging and propelled the first human clinical trials, the results of which have been promising.

RNA-based drugs and vaccines

RNA-based approaches have provided novel alternatives for modern drug discovery. The application of RNA as therapeutic agents has, until recently, been hampered by issues related to poor delivery and stability, but chemical modifications and new delivery approaches have increased progress. Moreover, the discovery of the importance of RNA in gene regulation and gene silencing has revealed new drug targets, especially related to treatment of cancer and other diseases. Recent engineering of small molecules designed from RNA sequences to target miRNAs opens up new possibilities in drug development. Furthermore, RNA-based vaccines have been engineered applying RNA virus vectors and non-viral delivery for vaccine development.

Alphavirus-based vaccines

Alphavirus vectors have demonstrated high levels of transient heterologous gene expression both in vitro and in vivo and, therefore, possess attractive features for vaccine development. The most commonly used delivery vectors are based on three single-stranded encapsulated alphaviruses, namely Semliki Forest virus, Sindbis virus and Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus. Alphavirus vectors have been applied as replication-deficient recombinant viral particles and, more recently, as replication-proficient particles. Moreover, in vitro transcribed RNA, as well as layered DNA vectors have been applied for immunization. A large number of highly immunogenic viral structural proteins expressed from alphavirus vectors have elicited strong neutralizing antibody responses in multispecies animal models. Furthermore, immunization studies have demonstrated robust protection against challenges with lethal doses of virus in rodents and primates. Similarly, vaccination with alphavirus vectors expressing tumor antigens resulted in prophylactic protection against challenges with tumor-inducing cancerous cells. As certain alphaviruses, such as Chikungunya virus, have been associated with epidemics in animals and humans, attention has also been paid to the development of vaccines against alphaviruses themselves. Recent progress in alphavirus vector development and vaccine technology has allowed conducting clinical trials in humans.

Utility of the Sindbis replicon system as an Env-targeted HIV vaccine

Sindbis replicon-based vaccine vectors are designed to combine the immunostimulatory properties of replicating viruses with the superior safety profile of non-replicating systems. In this study we performed a detailed assessment of Sindbis (SIN) replicon vectors expressing HIV-1 envelope protein (Env) for the induction of cell-mediated and humoral immune responses in a small animal model. SIN-derived virus-like particles (VLP) elicited Env-specific antibody responses that were detectable after boosting with recombinant Env protein. This priming effect could be mediated by replicon activity alone but may be enhanced by Env attached to the surface of VLP, offering a potential advantage for this mode of replicon delivery for Env based vaccination strategies. In contrast, the Env-specific CTL responses that were elicited by SIN-VLP were entirely dependent on replicon activity. SIN-VLP priming induced more durable humoral responses than immunization with protein only. This is important from a vaccine perspective, given the intrinsic tendency of Env to induce short-lived antibody responses in the context of vaccination or infection. These results indicate that further efforts to enhance the magnitude and durability of the HIV-1 Env-specific immune responses generated by Sindbis vectors, either alone or as part of prime-boost regimens, are justified.

Vaccination with recombinant Semliki Forest virus particles expressing translation initiation factor 3 of Brucella abortus induces protective immunity in BALB/c mice

Recombinant replicons of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) can be used to induce high-level, transient expression of heterologous proteins in vivo. We constructed infectious but replication-deficient SFV particles carrying recombinant RNA encoding the Brucella abortus translation initiation factor 3 (IF3). The recombinant SFV particles (SFV-IF3 particles) were then evaluated for their ability to induce immune responses and to protect BALB/c mice against a challenge with B. abortus 2308 following vaccination. Animals inoculated with SFV-IF3 developed IF3-specific IgM antibodies at day 14 post-immunization. In vitro stimulation of splenocytes from vaccinated mice with either recombinant IF3 (rIF3) or crude Brucella protein extracts resulted in a T-cell proliferative response and induction of interferon gamma secretion, but not interleukin-4. In addition, mice immunized with SFV-IF3 exhibited a significant level of resistance against challenge with the virulent B. abortus strain 2308 (P<0.01). These findings indicate that an SFV-based vector carrying RNA encoding Brucella IF3 has potential for use as a vaccine to induce protection against B. abortus infections.

Assembly of trans-encapsidated recombinant viral vectors engineered from Tobacco mosaic virus and Semliki Forest virus and their evaluation as immunogens

RNA virus vectors are attractive vaccine delivery agents capable of directing high-level gene expression without integration into host cell DNA. However, delivery of non-encapsidated RNA viral vectors into animal cells is relatively inefficient. By introducing the tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) origin of assembly into the RNA genome of Semliki Forest virus (SFV), we generated an SFV expression vector that could be efficiently packaged (trans-encapsidated) in vitro by purified TMV coat protein (CP). Using cellular assays, pseudovirus disassembly, RNA replication and reporter gene expression were demonstrated. We also evaluated the immune response to trans-encapsidated recombinant SFV carrying a model antigen gene (beta-galactosidase) in C57/B6 mice. Relative to RNA alone, vector encapsidation significantly improved the humoral and cellular immune responses. Furthermore, reassembly with recombinant TMV CPs permitted the display of peptide epitopes on the capsid surface as either genetic fusions or through chemical conjugation, to complement the immunoreactivity of the encapsidated RNA genetic payload. The SFV vector/TMV CP system described provides an alternative nucleic acid delivery mechanism that is safe, easy to manufacture in vitro and that also facilitates the generation of unique nucleic acid/protein antigen compositions.

Intranasal delivery of vaccines against HIV

HIV poses a serious health threat in the world. Mucosal transmission of HIV through the genitourinary tract may be the most important route of transmission. Intranasal immunisations induce vaginal and systemic immune responses. Various protein-, DNA- and RNA-based immunopotentiating adjuvants/delivery systems and live bacterial and viral vectors are available for intranasal immunisations, and these systems may differ in their ability to induce a specific type of immune response (e.g., a cytotoxic T cell versus an antibody response). As the protection against HIV may require both cytotoxic T cell and antibodies, a combination of adjuvants/delivery systems for combinations of mucosal and parenteral immunisations may be required in order to develop a protective anti-HIV vaccine.

Current Efforts on Generation of Optimal Immune Responses against HIV through Mucosal Immunisations

Currently, over 40 million HIV-infected individuals are found around the globe, with an additional 15,000 daily infections. There is a general consensus that the most effective way to prevent new infections is to introduce a prophylactic vaccine. It is also generally agreed that both cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and neutralising antibodies are important to mediate protection. The neutralising antibodies must be broadly reactive to neutralise multiple primary isolates. There is also increasing agreement that CTLs and neutralising antibodies should be present at mucosal sites of HIV entry, the draining lymph nodes and systemically. The route of immunisation is important when determining the site where protection is desired, i.e. the female genitourinary tract versus the male or female rectum versus systemic tissues, as are the type of HIV-related antigens, immunopotentiating adjuvants and delivery systems. Finally, multiple vaccine delivery systems may be required to be administered through both mucosal and parenteral routes to induce optimal immune responses and protection against HIV infection through rectal, vaginal or systemic routes of transmission. This review discusses current efforts on the generation of optimal immune responses against HIV in the genitourinary and intestinal tracts using mucosal immunisations alone or combinations of mucosal and parenteral immunisations.

Induction of cytotoxic T lymphocyte activity by immunization with recombinant Semliki Forest virus: indications for cross-priming

For the rational design of vaccines capable of inducing CD8+ T cell responses knowledge of the identity of the antigen-presenting cell (APC) and the mechanism of antigen presentation is very important. Here, we address these issues for alphavirus-based immunization, in particular immunization with recombinant Semliki Forest virus (rSFV). Studies with dendritic cells (DCs) from various origins revealed that rSFV has a very limited capacity to transfect this cell type in vitro. To further investigate in vivo whether rSFV transfects professional antigen-presenting cells directly or whether the antigens reach APCs via a mechanism of cross-priming we compared the immunological effects of three different SFV-constructs encoding the influenza nucleoprotein (NP). These constructs differ in the amount of NP produced per cell or in the stability of the NP, respectively. Induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) appeared to benefit from a large amount of stable antigen. In contrast, rapid antigen degradation, and thus availability of antigenic peptides in the transfected cell, was found to be disadvantageous. Based on these in vitro and in vivo results, we hypothesize that antigen presentation after SFV-based immunization proceeds via a mechanism in which APCs are not transfected directly but acquire antigen from other transfected cells and present it to CTLs in a process of cross-priming.

Cellular immune responses to helper-free HSV-1 amplicon particles encoding HIV-1 gp120 are enhanced by DNA priming

A single inoculation of herpes simplex virus type-1 (HSV-1) amplicon vectors encoding human immunodeficiency virus type-1 gp120 (HSV:gp120) results in robust, specific immune responses to gp120. To explore further the utility of this novel vaccine delivery system, we examined the kinetics of the cellular immune response by tetramer staining, following a single intramuscular administration of HSV:gp120 particles, and found that it peaks at 9-28 days post-immunization, before declining to a stable memory response. We also examined the utility of prime-boost regimens using packaged amplicon particles and naked amplicon plasmid DNA (DNA:gp120). These experiments showed that two sequential immunizations with HSV:gp120 resulted in a 5-10-fold increase in gp120-specific cellular immune responses and that plasmid DNA priming, followed by amplicon particle boosting, imparted the strongest acute and memory T cell responses, as determined by tetramer analysis. Collectively, these results demonstrate the utility of HSV amplicon vectors in prime-boost regimens for HIV vaccine development.

Alphavirus vectors for vaccine production and gene therapy

Alphavirus vectors demonstrate high expression of heterologous proteins in a broad range of host cells. Replication-deficient as well as replication-competent variants exist. Systemic delivery of many viral antigens has elicited strong antibody responses in immunized mice and primates, and protection against challenges with lethal viruses was obtained. Similarly, prophylactic vaccination was established against tumor challenges. Attention has been paid to the engineering of improved targeting to immunologically active cells, such as dendritic cells. In the area of gene therapy, intratumoral injections of alphavirus vectors have resulted in potentially promising tumor rejection. Moreover, encapsulation of alphavirus particles into liposomes demonstrated efficient tumor targeting in mice with severe combined immunodeficiency, which permitted the initiation of clinical trials for patients with advanced kidney carcinoma and melanoma.

A review of vaccines for HIV prevention

HIV/AIDS has become the most devastating pandemic in recorded history. It has killed 40 million people in the last 20 years and the World Health Organisation estimated that at least 14,000 new infections occurred daily in 2001. There will be up to 100 million new infections in the next 10 years (for current updates, visit http://www.unaids.org/epidemic_update/). Most HIV infections occur in the developing world, and the adverse social and economic impact of the HIV/AIDS pandemic, particularly in the developing world, is unprecedented. Highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) has had significant effects on HIV/AIDS in the developed world. The drugs have acted to prolong survival, reduce the viral load, and to alleviate suffering. However, the incidence of side effects and resistance is high and the drugs are unaffordable and unavailable in the developing world. HAART regimens are difficult to comply with. Public health efforts to modify the behaviour, attitude and culture that accelerate the spread of HIV/AIDS have had only modest success. There is urgent need for a prophylactic and/or therapeutic HIV vaccine. This is a review of the obstacles and current trends in HIV vaccine development.

RNA based vaccines

The recognition that CD8(+) T-cell mediated Th1 immune responses were necessary to produce immunity to intracellular and transformed self pathogens led to intense interest in the delivery of nucleic acids, DNA, or RNA encoding candidate antigens, as vaccines. Antigen presenting cells (APC) encounter most protein and vaccine immunogens as extracellular proteins and, thus, present them on major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules leading to the activation of CD4(+) T cells. Protein antigens encoded by nucleic acids delivered to dendritic cell (DC) are produced inside the cell and, thus, can stimulate MHC class I mediated activation of CD8(+) T-cell immune responses. Unfortunately, DCs are not readily transfected with DNA (Akbari et al., 1999) resulting in the requirement for high concentrations of DNA and repeated immunizations to achieved immune responses. RNA, on the other hand, is readily taken up and expressed by DC, making it an alternative vaccine candidate. In this article, we will discuss immune responses developed, interactions between APC and RNA that activate and dictate DC activation, and preliminary studies using RNA in vivo and in vitro to develop protective immunity.

Alphavirus vectors and vaccination

Alphaviruses are positive-stranded RNA viruses that have a broad host range and therefore are capable of replicating in many vertebrate and invertebrate cells. The single-stranded alphavirus genome is divided into two ORFs. The first ORF encodes the nonstructural proteins that are translated upon entry of the virus into the cytoplasm and are responsible for transcription and replication of viral RNA. The second ORF is under the control of a subgenomic promoter and normally encodes the structural proteins, which are responsible for encapsidation of viral RNA and final assembly into enveloped particles. Expression vectors have been engineered from at least three alphaviruses in which the structural protein gene region has been replaced by heterologous genes and have been shown to express high levels of the heterologous protein in cultured cells. These RNA vectors, known as replicons, are capable of replicating on their own but are not packaged into virus-like particles unless the structural proteins are provided in trans. Thus, replicons are single cycle vectors incapable of spreading from infected to noninfected cells. Because of these features, alphavirus replicon vectors are being developed as a platform vaccine technology for numerous viral, bacterial, protozoan and tumour antigens where they have been shown to be efficient inducers of both humoral and T cell responses. In addition, as the alphavirus structural proteins are not expressed in vaccine recipients, antivector immune responses are generally minimal, allowing for multiple effective immunisations of the same individual.

Hepatitis C virus non-structural protein 3-specific cellular immune responses following single or combined immunization with DNA or recombinant Semliki Forest virus particles

The capacity of recombinant Semliki Forest virus particles (rSFV) expressing the hepatitis C virus non-structural protein 3 (NS3) to induce, in comparison or in combination with an NS3-expressing plasmid, specific cellular and humoral immune responses in murine models was evaluated. In vitro studies indicated that both types of vaccine expressed the expected size protein, albeit with different efficacies. The use of mice transgenic for the human HLA-A2.1 molecule indicated that the rSFV-expressed NS3 protein induces, as shown previously for an NS3 DNA vaccine, NS3-specific cytotoxic lymphocytes (CTLs) targeted at one dominant HLA-A2 epitope described in infected patients. All DNA/rSFV vaccine combinations evaluated induced specific CTLs, which were detectable for up to 31 weeks after the first injection. Overall, less than 1 log difference was observed in terms of the vigour of the bulk CTL response induced and the CTL precursor frequency between all vaccines (ranging from 1:2.6x10(5) to 1:1x10(6)). Anti-NS3 antibodies could only be detected following a combined vaccine regimen in non-transgenic BALB/c mice. In conclusion, rSFV particles expressing NS3 are capable of inducing NS3-specific cellular immune responses targeted at a major HLA-A2 epitope. Such responses were comparable to those obtained with a DNA-based NS3 vaccine, whether in the context of single or combined regimens.

The transmembrane protein of HIV-1 primary isolates modulates cell surface expression of their envelope glycoproteins

We have recently shown that the level of cell surface expression of envelope glycoproteins derived from various human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) primary isolates (PI) was lower than those of envelope glycoproteins derived from T-cell laboratory-adapted (TCLA) HIV-1 (D. Brand et al., 2000, Virology 271, 350-362). We investigated this phenomenon by comparing the cell surface expression of chimeric envelope glycoproteins constructed by swapping the gp120 surface and gp41 transmembrane glycoproteins of the TCLA HIV-1MN and the PI HIV-1(133), HIV-1G365, or HIV-1EFRA. We found that each chimeric envelope construct had a cell surface-specific pattern of expression similar to that of the parental envelope glycoproteins corresponding to the gp41. Thus, the difference in cell surface expression observed between TCLA viruses and various PI is probably due to a signal located in gp41. Identification of this signal may be important for the design of PI envelope-derived immunogens and may increase our understanding of the mechanisms by which HIV-1 escapes from the immune system.

A recombinant Semliki Forest virus particle vaccine encoding the prME and NS1 proteins of louping ill virus is effective in a sheep challenge model

This study has examined the efficacy following intramuscular administration of a recombinant Semliki Forest virus (rSFV) vaccine, encoding the prME and NS1 proteins of louping ill virus (LIV), in sheep. Administration of rSFV-LIV vaccine resulted in transient detection at the injection site and draining lymph node only and no dissemination to distal sites. In addition, the recombinant vaccine offered complete protection against subcutaneous challenge with LIV, and partial protection following intranasal administration of LIV. Protected animals had no pathological changes normally associated with LIV infection, and had developed high antibody titres. In contrast, the two animals not protected exhibited classical clinical signs and neuropathological lesions of LIV infection. These findings indicate that rSFV-based vaccines have the potential to be developed as effective prototype vaccines for LIV.

Comparative immunization study using RNA and DNA constructs encoding a part of the Plasmodium falciparum antigen Pf332

Development of nucleic acid-based vaccines against parasitic diseases shows great promise, although certain concerns about safety aspects of conventional DNA vaccines have been raised. This study presents a comparison of antibody responses induced in mice by DNA and RNA-based immunization with vectors encoding a part of the P. falciparum antigen Pf332. Two types of plasmids were used, one conventional DNA plasmid containing a cytomegalovirus promoter and one suicidal DNA plasmid encoding the Semliki Forest virus (SFV) replicase. RNA, encoding the SFV replicase and the relevant antigen, was delivered either as naked RNA or packaged in SFV suicide particles. In general, the antibody responses induced by the DNA plasmids were low and peaking after three injections, the conventional plasmid giving the highest responses. Also the RNA delivered in SFV particles consistently induced antibody responses, although comparatively low. Analyses of the ratio of immunoglobulin (Ig)G1/IgG2a subclasses in the responses indicated that all plasmids resulted in a bias for a Th2-type of response, while the SFV-particles elicited a Th1 type of response. Importantly, all these immunogens induced an immunological memory, which could be efficiently activated by a booster injection with the corresponding protein, with unchanged patterns of IgG subclasses.

Recombinant Semliki Forest virus vector exhibits potential for avian virus vaccine development

The Semliki Forest virus (SFV) expression system was evaluated as a basis for avian vaccine development. Initial studies indicated that 1-day-old specific pathogen-free (SPF) chicks were susceptible to infection with an infectious strain of SFV, producing SFV-specific antibodies but no clinical disease. One-day-old SPF chicks immunised intramuscularly with recombinant replication-defective SFV (rSFV) particles expressing the Escherichia coli (E. coli) lacZ reporter gene developed high titres of beta-gal- specific antibodies at 4 weeks p.i. after two inoculations. In contrast, significantly lower antibody levels were elicited in chicks immunised with a recombinant SFV-based DNA construct or a conventional CMV promoter-based DNA plasmid. rSFV particles encoding the protective VP2 protein or the VP2/VP4/VP3 polyprotein of infectious bursal disease virus (IBDV) were produced and the expressed antigens were characterised in cell culture. Proteins of the correct size were generated and found to react against a range of IBDV-specific monoclonal antibodies. Immunisation of 1-day-old SPF chicks with rSFV particles encoding the IBDV proteins resulted in specific antibodies being elicited in all birds, neutralising antibodies being induced in some but not all birds.

Immunogenicity of recombinant envelope glycoproteins derived from T-cell line-adapted isolates or primary HIV isolates: a comparative study using multivalent vaccine approaches

We investigated immunogenic properties of native envelope glycoproteins derived from HIV-1 (subtype B). Our main objective was to assess whether the design of multivalent vaccines affects generation of neutralizing antibodies against primary viruses. Recombinant Semliki Forest virus (SFV) particles producing various HIV-1 envelope glycoproteins were used as vaccine vectors. The following multivalent vaccination approaches were compared: 1) immunization with a mixture of recombinant SFV expressing envelope glycoproteins derived from three HIV-1 primary isolates and two T-cell laboratory-adapted (TCLA) viruses; 2) immunization with a mixture of recombinant SFV expressing only the envelope glycoproteins derived from three HIV-1 primary isolates; 3) sequential immunizations with the recombinant SFV expressing the envelope glycoproteins derived from three HIV-1 primary isolates and two TCLA viruses, respectively. Two monovalent vaccine approaches using SFV expressing envelope glycoproteins derived from a single primary isolate or TCLA virus were also included in the study. The multivalent vaccination strategies based on SFV vaccine vectors did not induce more neutralizing antibodies than the previously tested TCLA envelope immunogens, which gave disappointing results against primary isolates.

Semliki Forest virus-based vaccines: persistence, distribution and pathological analysis in two animal systems

This study has examined the persistence, distribution and pathological changes following intramuscular administration of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) vaccine vectors in mice and chickens. Administration of recombinant SFV RNA particles showed persistence at the injection site of mice up to 7 days, transient detection in secondary lymphoid organs and no dissemination to distal sites. In contrast, administration of a layered SFV DNA/RNA vector and a conventional standard naked DNA vector resulted in long-term persistence at the injection site, plasmid DNA being detected at 8 months post-inoculation in mice. Plasmid DNA was found distributed throughout the body, and tissues distal from the site of injection were positive up to 3 months. A similar pattern was observed in chickens. Mild pathological changes were observed at the injection site only, and plasmid DNA or recombinant RNA was not detected in mouse foetuses. These findings indicate that SFV-based vectors have the potential to be developed as safe vaccines.

Identification of the glycoprotein 41(TM) cytoplasmic tail domains of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 that interact with Pr55Gag particles

We investigated the protein/protein interactions that occur during human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) budding. We evaluated the binding to Pr55Gag particles of peptides mapping to the cytoplasmic tail of gp41TM and of host-cell proteins, in a cell-free, in vitro assay. Host-cell proteins and irrelevant viral envelope peptides did not bind. Peptides corresponding to a large central domain of the gp41TM cytoplasmic tail (93 residues) bound to Pr55Gag particles. This demonstrates that a Gag/Env interaction is responsible for the specific incorporation of the Env glycoprotein into nascent HIV-1 virions, and defines more accurately the gp41TM domain involved in this interaction.

Antigenic properties of recombinant envelope glycoproteins derived from T-cell-line-adapted isolates or primary human immunodeficiency virus isolates and their relationship to immunogenicity

The native envelope glycoproteins of primary HIV-1 virions have weaker antigenicity than do T-cell laboratory-adapted (TCLA) viruses. These antigenic properties require further evaluation if recombinant envelope glycoproteins are produced as part of a vaccine strategy. In this study, we compared the antigenicity of recombinant envelope glycoproteins derived from three primary isolates (PI) (HIV-1(BX08), HIV-1(CHA), and HIV-1(133)) and two TCLA viruses (HIV-1(HXB2) and HIV-1(MN)) produced using the Semliki Forest virus (SFV) system. This analysis was performed by radioimmunoprecipitation assays and flow cytometry. The results suggest that the SFV produces envelope glycoproteins with features in common with the envelopes found in naturally occurring virions. In particular, the PI envelopes had weak heterogeneous antigenic properties. However, the cytometric analysis also showed that there was less envelope glycoprotein on the cell surface for the PI envelopes than for those of TCLA viruses, suggesting differences in their intracellular trafficking. The immunogenic properties of the various envelope glycoproteins were evaluated in mice using recombinant SFV particles as vaccine vectors. The PI envelopes were less immunogenic than the TCLA envelopes, probably due to both their low antigenicity and cell surface expression level. Thus, it may be difficult to design an effective vaccine based on native recombinant PI envelopes.

Generation of monoclonal antibodies to native human immunodeficiency virus type 1 envelope glycoprotein by immunization of mice with naked RNA

The Semliki Forest virus (SFV) vector system is a new approach for in vivo expression of heterologous proteins and can also be used to generate specific immune responses in animal models. HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein produced using the SFV expression system is correctly folded, cleaved, transported to the cell surface and exhibits functional activity. We evaluated a recombinant Semliki Forest virus naked RNA-based immunization protocol for generation of monoclonal antibodies against the HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein. In vitro-transcribed RNA encoding for the SFV replicase complex and Env protein of HIV-1 (HXB2 strain) was injected intramuscularly to mice. This approach elicited an Env-specific antibody response in four mice out of five and a monoclonal antibody, 12H2, directed against gp41 was produced. Our results show that recombinant SFV RNA immunization can potentially be used as a quick and direct method to produce monoclonal antibodies, with the particular advantage that vectored RNA, rather than purified antigen, delivers a complex oligomer produced correctly.