Cleavage of collagen RNA transcripts by hammerhead ribozymes in vitro is mutation-specific and shows competitive binding effects

Emerging Landscape of Osteogenesis Imperfecta Pathogenesis and Therapeutic Approaches

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is an uncommon genetic disorder characterized by shortness of stature, hearing loss, poor bone mass, recurrent fractures, and skeletal abnormalities. Pathogenic variations have been found in over 20 distinct genes that are involved in the pathophysiology of OI, contributing to the disorder's clinical and genetic variability. Although medications, surgical procedures, and other interventions can partially alleviate certain symptoms, there is still no known cure for OI. In this Review, we provide a comprehensive overview of genetic pathogenesis, existing treatment modalities, and new developments in biotechnologies such as gene editing, stem cell reprogramming, functional differentiation, and transplantation for potential future OI therapy.

Osteoblasts mineralization and collagen matrix are conserved upon specific Col1a2 silencing

Classical osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is an inherited rare brittle bone disease caused by dominant mutations in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes, encoding for the α chains of collagen type I. The definitive cure for the disease will require a gene therapy approach, aimed to correct or suppress the mutant allele. Interestingly, individuals lacking α2(I) chain and synthetizing collagen α1(I)₃ homotrimers do not show bone phenotype, making appealing a bone specific COL1A2 silencing approach for OI therapy. To this aim, three different Col1a2-silencing RNAs (siRNAs), −3554, −3825 and −4125, selected at the 3′-end of the murine Col1a2 transcript were tested in vitro and in vivo. In murine embryonic fibroblasts Col1a2-siRNA-3554 was able to efficiently and specifically target the Col1a2 mRNA and to strongly reduce α2(I) chain expression. Its efficiency and specificity were also demonstrated in primary murine osteoblasts, whose mineralization was preserved. The efficiency of Col1a2-siRNA-3554 was proved also in vivo. Biphasic calcium phosphate implants loaded with murine mesenchymal stem cells were intramuscularly transplanted in nude mice and injected with Col1a2-siRNA-3554 three times a week for three weeks. Collagen α2 silencing was demonstrated both at mRNA and protein level and Masson's Trichrome staining confirmed the presence of newly formed collagen matrix. Our data pave the way for further investigation of Col1a2 silencing and siRNA delivery to the bone tissue as a possible strategy for OI therapy.

•

Identification of a specific and efficient Col1a2 siRNA

•

Silencing of Col1a2 allows osteoblasts mineralization.

•

Col1a2 silencing is not impairing matrix deposition in vivo.

Effects of Pathogenic Variations in the Human Rhodopsin Gene (hRHO) on the Predicted Accessibility for a Lead Candidate Ribozyme

Purpose

The mutation-independent strategy for hammerhead ribozyme (hhRz) or RNA interference (RNAi)-based gene therapeutics to treat autosomal dominant diseases is predicated on the hypothesis that a single therapeutic would equivalently suppress all/most of the diverse mutant mRNAs in patients with the disease phenotype. However, the hypothesis has not been formally tested. We address this through a comprehensive bioinformatics study of how mutations affect target mRNA structure accessibility for a single lead hhRz therapeutic (725GUC↓), designed against human rod rhodopsin mRNA (hRHO), for patients with hRHO mutations that cause autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa.

Methods

A total of 199 in silico coding region mutations (missense, nonsense, insert, deletion, indel) were made in hRHO mRNA based on Human Gene Mutation Database and Database of Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms. Each mRNA was folded with MFold, SFold, and OligoWalk algorithms and subjected to a bioinformatics model called multiparameter prediction of RNA accessibility. Predicted accessibility of each mutant over both a broad local region and the explicit lead ribozyme annealing site were compared quantitatively to wild-type hRHO mRNA.

Results

Accessibility of the 725GUC↓ site is sensitive to some mutations. For single nucleotide missense mutations, proximity of the mutation to the hhRz annealing site increases the impact on predicted accessibility, but some distant mutations also influence accessibility.

Conclusions

A mutation-independent strategy appears viable in this specific context but certain mutations could significantly influence ribozyme or RNAi efficacy through impact on accessibility at the target annealing site/region. This possibility must be considered in applications of this gene therapy strategy.

Allele-specific Col1a1 silencing reduces mutant collagen in fibroblasts from Brtl mouse, a model for classical osteogenesis imperfecta

Gene silencing approaches have the potential to become a powerful curative tool for a variety of monogenic diseases caused by gain-of-function mutations. Classical osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), a dominantly inherited bone dysplasia, is characterized in its more severe forms by synthesis of structurally abnormal type I collagen, which exerts a negative effect on extracellular matrix. Specific suppression of the mutant (Mut) allele would convert severe OI forms to the mild type caused by a quantitative defect in normal collagen. Here, we describe the in vitro and ex vivo investigation of a small interfering RNA (siRNA) approach to allele-specific gene silencing using Mut Col1a1 from the Brtl mouse, a well-characterized model for classical human OI. A human embryonic kidney cell line, which expresses the firefly luciferase gene, combined with either wild-type or Mut Brtl Col1a1 exon 23 sequences, was used for the first screening. The siRNAs selected based on their specificity and the corresponding short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) subcloned in a lentiviral vector were evaluated ex vivo in Brtl fibroblasts for their effect on collagen transcripts and protein. A preferential reduction of the Mut allele of up to 52% was associated with about 40% decrease of the Mut protein, with no alteration of cell proliferation. Interestingly, a downregulation of HSP47, a specific collagen chaperone known to be upregulated in some OI cases, was detected. Our data support further testing of shRNAs and their delivery by lentivirus as a strategy to specifically suppress the Mut allele in mesenchymal stem cells of OI patients for autologous transplantation.

Recessive osteogenesis imperfecta: clinical, radiological, and molecular findings

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) or "brittle bone disease" is currently best described as a group of hereditary connective tissue disorders related to primary defects in type I procollagen, and to alterations in type I procollagen biosynthesis, both associated with osteoporosis and increased susceptibility to bone fractures. Initially, the autosomal dominant forms of OI, caused by mutations in either COL1A1 or COL1A2, were described. However, for decades, the molecular defect of a small percentage of patients clinically diagnosed with OI has remained elusive. It has been in the last 6 years that the genetic causes of several forms of OI with autosomal recessive inheritance have been characterized. These comprise defects of collagen chaperones, and proteins involved in type I procollagen assembly, processing and maturation, as well as proteins involved in the formation and homeostasis of bone tissue. This article reviews the recently characterized forms of recessive OI, focusing in particular on their clinical and molecular findings, and on their radiological characterisation. Clinical management and treatment of OI in general will be discussed, too.

Osteogenesis Imperfecta: A Review with Clinical Examples

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is characterized by susceptibility to bone fractures, with a severity ranging from subtle increase in fracture frequency to prenatal fractures. The first scientific description of OI dates from 1788. Since then, important milestones in OI research and treatment have, among others, been the classification of OI into 4 types (the 'Sillence classification'), the discovery of defects in collagen type I biosynthesis as a cause of most cases of OI and the use of bisphosphonate therapy. Furthermore, in the past 5 years, it has become clear that OI comprises a group of heterogeneous disorders, with an estimated 90% of cases due to a causative variant in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes and with the remaining 10% due to causative recessive variants in the 8 genes known so far, or in other currently unknown genes. This review aims to highlight the current knowledge around the history, epidemiology, pathogenesis, clinical/radiological features, management, and future prospects of OI. The text will be illustrated with clinical descriptions, including radiographs and, where possible, photographs of patients with OI.

Variables and strategies in development of therapeutic post-transcriptional gene silencing agents

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) agents such as ribozymes, RNAi and antisense have substantial potential for gene therapy of human retinal degenerations. These technologies are used to knockdown a specific target RNA and its cognate protein. The disease target mRNA may be a mutant mRNA causing an autosomal dominant retinal degeneration or a normal mRNA that is overexpressed in certain diseases. All PTGS technologies depend upon the initial critical annealing event of the PTGS ligand to the target RNA. This event requires that the PTGS agent is in a conformational state able to support hybridization and that the target have a large and accessible single-stranded platform to allow rapid annealing, although such platforms are rare. We address the biocomplexity that currently limits PTGS therapeutic development with particular emphasis on biophysical variables that influence cellular performance. We address the different strategies that can be used for development of PTGS agents intended for therapeutic translation. These issues apply generally to the development of PTGS agents for retinal, ocular, or systemic diseases. This review should assist the interested reader to rapidly appreciate critical variables in PTGS development and facilitate initial design and testing of such agents against new targets of clinical interest.

Current and emerging treatments for the management of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is the most common bone genetic disorder and it is characterized by bone brittleness and various degrees of growth disorder. Clinical severity varies widely; nowadays eight types are distinguished and two new forms have been recently described although not yet classified. The approach to such a variable and heterogeneous disease should be global and therefore multidisciplinary. For simplicity, the objectives of treatment can be reduced to three typical situations: the lethal perinatal form (type II), in which the problem is survival at birth; the severe and moderate forms (types III-IX), in which the objective is 'autonomy'; and the mild form (type I), in which the aim is to reach 'normal life'. Three types of treatment are available: non-surgical management (physical therapy, rehabilitation, bracing and splinting), surgical management (intramedullary rod positioning, spinal and basilar impression surgery) and medical-pharmacological management (drugs to increase the strength of bone and decrease the number of fractures as bisphosphonates or growth hormone, depending on the type of OI). Suggestions and guidelines for a therapeutic approach are indicated and updated with the most recent findings in OI diagnosis and treatment.

Effective suppression of Dengue fever virus in mosquito cell cultures using retroviral transduction of hammerhead ribozymes targeting the viral genome

Outbreaks of Dengue impose a heavy economic burden on developing countries in terms of vector control and human morbidity. Effective vaccines against all four serotypes of Dengue are in development, but population replacement with transgenic vectors unable to transmit the virus might ultimately prove to be an effective approach to disease suppression, or even eradication. A key element of the refractory transgenic vector approach is the development of transgenes that effectively prohibit viral transmission. In this report we test the effectiveness of several hammerhead ribozymes for suppressing DENV in lentivirus-transduced mosquito cells in an attempt to mimic the transgenic use of these effector molecules in mosquitoes. A lentivirus vector that expresses these ribozymes as a fusion RNA molecule using an Ae. aegypti tRNA^val promoter and terminating with a 60A tail insures optimal expression, localization, and activity of the hammerhead ribozyme against the DENV genome. Among the 14 hammerhead ribozymes we designed to attack the DENV-2 NGC genome, several appear to be relatively effective in reducing virus production from transduced cells by as much as 2 logs. Among the sequences targeted are 10 that are conserved among all DENV serotype 2 strains. Our results confirm that hammerhead ribozymes can be effective in suppressing DENV in a transgenic approach, and provide an alternative or supplementary approach to proposed siRNA strategies for DENV suppression in transgenic mosquitoes.

Hammerhead ribozyme-mediated silencing of the mutant fibrillin-1 of tight skin mouse: insight into the functional role of mutant fibrillin-1

The tight skin (Tsk/+) mouse is a model for fibrotic disorders. The genetic defect in the Tsk/+ is an in-frame duplication between exons 17 and 40 of the fibrillin-1 gene which gives rise to a large transcript and protein. Mice homozygous for the mutation die in utero, whereas heterozygotes survive and spontaneously develop connective tissue disease. In this study, we generated hammerhead ribozymes directed against the mutant fibrillin-1 transcript. A partially mispairing ribozyme was the most effective vehicle to cleave the mutant transcript without undesired cleavage of wild type transcripts, as shown by cell-free RNA cleavage and cleavage in cell lines harboring the ribozyme, by RT-PCR, Northern and Western Blotting. Global gene expression profiling using oligonucleotide microarrays showed the expected reduction in fibrillin-1 mRNA, and down-regulation of several gene cohorts in ribozyme harboring TskR1 cells compared to Tsk/+ cells. Two of the functional clusters included genes regulating extracellular matrix such as connective tissue growth factor, serpine-1 (plasminogen activator inhibitor-1) and TIMP-1 and TIMP-3, and those involved in cytoskeletal organization and myofibroblast formation including calponins and transgelin. Ribozyme-mediated inhibition was confirmed by Western Blot and functional analysis using cell-reporter systems and remodeling of three dimensional collagen gels. Our results underline the therapeutic potential of hammerhead ribozymes in dominant negative defects and suggest that changes in microfibril architecture brought about by fibrillin-1 mutation lead to a complex disease phenotype.

Emerging therapeutic approaches for osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is an incurable genetic brittle-bone disease. Although drug therapy, surgery and physiotherapy represent current treatments for OI, the search is ongoing for effective and innovative new therapies targeting the underlying causes of the disease. In this regard, recent advances in the fields of gene and stem-cell therapies have been considerable. In spite of the many challenges that remain, potential new therapies for OI, which have been tested in cell culture systems, animal models and patients, offer hope for the future development of successful therapies. Recent progress in the field is reviewed here.

Preparation of anti-mouse caspase-12 mRNA hammerhead ribozyme and identification of its activity in vitro

AIM: To prepare and identify specific anti-mouse caspase-12 hammerhead ribozymes in vitro, in order to select a more effective ribozyme against mouse caspase-12 as a potential tool to rescue cells from endoplasmic reticulum stress induced apoptosis.

METHODS: Two hammerhead ribozymes directed separately against 138 and 218 site of nucleotide of mouse caspase-12 mRNA were designed by computer software, and their DNA sequences were synthesized. The synthesized ribozymes were cloned into an eukaryotic expression vector-neo^rpBSKU6 and embedded in U6 SnRNA context for further study. Mouse caspase-12 gene segment was cloned into PGEM-T vector under the control of T7 RNA polymerase promoter (containing gene sequence from positions nt 41 to nt 894) as target. In vitro transcription both the ribozymes and target utilize T7 promoter. The target was labeled with [α-³²P]UTP, while ribozymes were not labeled. After gel purification the RNAs were dissolved in RNase free water. Ribozyme and target were incubated for 90 min at 37°C in reaction buffer (40 mmol/L Tris-HCL, pH 7.5, 10 mmol/L Mg²⁺). Molar ratio of ribozyme vs target was 30:1. Samples were analyzed on 6% PAGE (containing 8 mol/L urea).

RESULTS: Both caspase-12 and ribozyme gene sequences were successfully cloned into expression vector confirmed by sequencing. Ribozymes and caspase-12 mRNA were obtained by in vitro transcription. Cleavage experiment showed that in a physiological similar condition (37°C, pH 7.5), Rz138 and Rz218 both cleaved targets at predicted sites, for Rz138 the cleavage efficiency was about 100%, for Rz218 the value was 36.66%.

CONCLUSION: Rz138 prepared in vitro can site specific cleave mouse caspase-12 mRNA with an excellent efficiency. It shows a potential to suppress the expression of caspase-12 in vivo, thus provided a new way to protect cells from ER stress induced apoptosis.

Endogenously Expressed Multimeric Self-Cleaving Hammerhead Ribozymes Ablate Mutant Collagen in Cellulo

Hammerhead ribozymes are small catalytic RNA molecules that can be targeted to any RNA molecule containing a putative cleavage site. We developed a vector (pCOLZ) that uses the COL1A1 promoter to drive expression of a self-cleaving multimeric ribozyme (M8Rz547) and its monomeric counterpart (Rz547). The ribozymes were stably coexpressed in MC3T3-E1 osteoblasts expressing a truncated COL1A1 target transcript. The multimeric ribozyme exhibited self-cleavage to derivative fragments, including monomers. Increased expression of ribozymes was found in cells expressing the multimeric ribozyme. A modest reduction of truncated target transcript and protein was seen in cells expressing the ribozyme monomer, while nearly complete ablation of target transcript and protein occurred in cells expressing the ribozyme multimer. A reversion to a more normal collagen phenotype, measured as an increase in fibril diameter and restored fibrillar architecture, and a decreased rate of collagen turnover were seen in cells expressing the ribozyme multimer.

Gene therapy approaches for osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a heterogeneous group of genetic disorders that affect connective tissue integrity. The hallmark of OI is bone fragility, although other manifestations, which include osteoporosis, dentigenesis imperfecta, blue sclera, easy bruising, joint laxity and scoliosis, are also common among OI patients. The severity of OI ranges from prenatal death to mild osteopenia without limb deformity. Most forms of OI result from mutations in the genes that encode either the proalpha1or proalpha2 polypeptide chains that comprise type I collagen molecules, the major structural protein of bone. Treatment depends mainly on the severity of the disease with the primary goal to minimize fractures and maximize function. Current treatments include surgical intervention with intramedullarly stabilization and the use of prostheses. Pharmacological agents have also been attempted with limited success with the exception of recent use of bisphosphonates, which have been to shown to have some effect. Since OI is a genetic disease, these agents are not expected to alter the course of the collagen mutations. Cell and gene therapies as potential treatments for OI are therefore currently being actively investigated. The design of gene therapies for OI is however complicated by the genetic heterogeneity of the disease and by the factor that most of the OI mutations are dominant negative where the mutant allele product interferes with the function of the normal allele. The present review will discuss the molecular changes seen in OI, the current treatment options and the gene therapy approaches being investigated as potential future treatments for OI.

Ribozyme- and siRNA-Mediated Suppression of RGS-Containing RhoGEF Proteins

Given recent efforts to determine the sequence information on thousands of genes in the human genome, the current challenge is to identify the functions of these genes, including those encoding the regulator of G-protein signaling protein gene superfamily, and to establish their roles in particular signaling pathways in a native system. Increasingly, reverse genetic approaches are being used to address these questions. This article compares two powerful approaches [ribozyme and "short interfering" RNA (siRNA) techniques] under identical conditions for the first report on the suppression of endogenous RGS domain-containing RhoGEFs. The siRNA technique was found to be much more potent than ribozyme targeting at the same mRNA site of RGS-RhoGEFs. Also, the three siRNAs targeting LARG, PDZ-RhoGEF, and p115-RhoGEF are able to discriminate the closely related sequences within this RGS-RhoGEF gene family.

Receptor-selective effects of endogenous RGS3 and RGS5 to regulate mitogen-activated protein kinase activation in rat vascular smooth muscle cells

Regulators of G protein signaling (RGS) proteins compose a highly diverse protein family best known for inhibition of G protein signaling by enhancing GTP hydrolysis by Galpha subunits. Little is known about the function of endogenous RGS proteins. In this study, we used synthetic ribozymes targeted to RGS2, RGS3, RGS5, and RGS7 to assess their function. After demonstrating the specificity of in vitro cleavage by the RGS ribozymes, rat aorta smooth muscle cells were used for transient transfection with the RGS-specific ribozymes. RGS3 and RGS5 ribozymes differentially enhanced carbachol- and angiotensin II-induced MAP kinase activity, respectively, whereas RGS2 and RGS7 ribozymes had no effect. This enhancement was pertussis toxin-insensitive. Thus RGS3 is a negative modulator of muscarinic m3 receptor signaling, and RGS5 is a negative modulator of angiotensin AT1a receptor signaling through G(q/11). Also, RGS5 ribozyme enhanced angiotensin-stimulated inositol phosphate release. These results indicate the feasibility of using the ribozyme technology to determine the functional role of endogenous RGS proteins in signaling pathways and to define novel receptor-selective roles of endogenous RGS3 and RGS5 in modulating MAP kinase responses to either carbachol or angiotensin.

Analysis of inhibitory action of modified U1 snRNAs on target gene expression: discrimination of two RNA targets differing by a 1 bp mismatch

The modified U1 snRNA gene can suppress expression of a target transgene. In the present study, its potential utility to inhibit a dominant negative/gain of function mutation is explored. Using a green fluorescent protein (GFP) target gene, inhibition was achieved in all cells transduced with U1antiGFP directed at multiple sites within GFP. Using a chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) target gene, inhibition was not increased by increasing the hybridization domain from 10 to 16 bp or when a site in an upstream exon or intron was targeted. To determine if a U1 anti-target design could discriminate between two transcripts that differ by a 1-2 bp mismatch, GFPtpz and GFPsaph were chosen as targets because they share sequence homology except for three regions where a 1, 2 or 3 bp mismatch exists. The results demonstrated that U1antiGFP correctly reduced its cognate GFP expression by >90% and therefore U1 anti-target constructs are able to discriminate a 1 or 2 bp mismatch in their target mRNA. Thus, these U1 anti-target constructs may be effective in a strategy of somatic gene therapy for a dominant negative/gain of function mutation due to the discreteness of its discrimination. It may complement other anti-target strategies to reduce the cellular load of a mutant transcript.

Synthetic hammerhead ribozymes as tools in gene expression

The assessment of genetic controls for sequential developmental processes such as tooth formation and biomineralization is often difficult in transgenic "knockout" models, where phenotypes reflect only the permanent eradication of a gene, and reveal little about the dynamic range of expression for the gene(s) involved. One promising strategy to overcome this problem is through the use of ribozymes, a class of metalloenzymes made entirely of ribonucleic acid (RNA), that are capable of cleaving other RNA molecules in a catalytic fashion. Their activity can be targeted against specific mRNAs by selection of unique sequences flanking a conserved catalytic motif. In synthetic ribozymes, specificity, stability, and cell permeability can be dramatically improved by the incorporation of chemically modified ribonucleotides. This review focuses on the design and application of hammerhead ribozymes, the best-known and most widely used class of RNA-based enzymes. So far, except for a few conserved structures at the catalytic core, no one particular model or superior ribozyme design has been identified. It may well be that each cell, tissue, and organism has different requirements for the uptake, activity, and stability of hammerhead ribozymes. However, designed ribozymes can be highly effective agents for timed and localized elimination of gene products. As the 3D structures of active hammerhead molecules are revealed, more effective ribozymes will be developed. Today, developments in ribozyme-mediated sequence-specific blocking of gene expression hold great promise for active RNA enzymes as tools in biomolecular research and for eliminating unwanted gene expression in human diseases.

Selection and characterization of active hammerhead ribozymes targeted against cyclin E and E2F1 full-length mRNA

Proliferation of vascular smooth muscle cells is generally accepted as a key event in the development of restenosis following percutaneous transluminal angioplasty. To prevent human restenosis, we have designed a molecular strategy based on hammerhead ribozymes targeted against the mRNA of cyclin E and E2F1, two proteins relevant in cell cycle progression whose regulation is interconnected by a positive feedback loop. Following the identification of accessible ribozyme target sites by RNase H mapping, several hammerhead ribozymes were generated that cleave with comparable efficiency two different splice forms of cyclin E mRNA and the full-length and a truncated form of E2F1 RNA, respectively. The most active ribozymes were tested in vitro under single-turnover conditions yielding k(react)/K(m) ratios between 36 and 73 x 10(4) M(-1) min(-1), which places them in the top range ribozymes targeted against long and structured substrates. In addition, we show that the most active ribozyme selected in vitro reduces specifically and significantly (p < 0.0028) proliferation of cultured human vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMC).

Transfer of proalpha2(I) cDNA into cells of a murine model of human Osteogenesis Imperfecta restores synthesis of type I collagen comprised of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) heterotrimers in vitro and in vivo

The oim mouse is a model of human Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) that has deficient synthesis of proalpha2(I) chains. Cells isolated from oim mice synthesize alpha1(I) collagen homotrimers that accumulate in tissues. To explore the feasibility of gene therapy for OI, a murine proalpha2(I) cDNA was inserted into an adenovirus vector and transferred into bone marrow stromal cells isolated from oim mice femurs. The murine cDNA under the control of the cytomegalovirus early promoter was expressed by the transduced cells. Analysis of the collagens synthesized by the transduced cells demonstrated that the cells synthesized stable type I collagen comprised of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) heterotrimers in the correct ratio of 2:1. The collagen was efficiently secreted and also the cells retained the osteogenic potential as indicated by the expression of alkaline phosphatase activity when the transduced cells were treated with recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein 2. Injection of the virus carrying the murine proalpha2(I) cDNA into oim skin demonstrated synthesis of type I collagen comprised of alpha1 and alpha2 chains at the injection site. These preliminary data demonstrate that collagen genes can be transferred into bone marrow stromal cells as well as fibroblasts in vivo and that the genes are efficiently expressed. These data encourage further studies in gene replacement for some forms of OI and use of bone marrow stromal cells as vehicles to deliver therapeutic genes to bone.

Osteogenesis imperfecta: practical treatment guidelines

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), an inherited connective tissue disorder of remarkable clinical variability, is caused by a quantitative or qualitative defect in collagen synthesis and is characterised by bone fragility. The number of fractures and deformities, and the age at which they begin greatly influence the prognosis and the achievement of walking and autonomy. A multidisciplinary team approach is essential for diagnosis, for communication with patient and parents, and to tailor treatment needs to the severity of the disease and the age of the patient. Three types of treatment are available: nonsurgical management (physical therapy, rehabilitation, bracing and splinting), surgery (intramedullary rod positioning, spinal and basilar impression surgery), and drugs to increase the strength of bone and decrease the number of fractures. An aggressive rehabilitative approach is indicated to optimise functional ability and walking capacity; appropriately timed surgery to insert intramedullary rods provides improved function of extremities. Despite a high rate of complications, intramedullary telescopic roding has proven to be the most successful method for preventing and correcting fractures and deformities of long bones, improving walking capability and leading to successful rehabilitation of even severely affected patients. Surgery may be required in patients with progressive spinal deformity and in those with symptomatic basilar impression. Hearing function, dentinogenesis imperfecta, cardiac and respiratory function, and neurological changes must be monitored. The causal defect of the disease cannot be corrected with medical treatment and, currently, only symptomatic therapy is available. In recent years growth hormone (GH) and bisphosphonate agents have been used in OI therapy. GH is beneficial in patients with moderate forms of OI, showing a positive effect on bone turnover, bone mineral density and height velocity rate. Bisphosphonates have proved beneficial in children with severe OI, increasing bone mineral density and reducing the fracture rate and pain with no adverse effects reported. These data require confirmation in double-blind controlled studies; however, bisphosphonates have markedly improved morbidity in patients with OI. Future developments in genetic therapy may be directed towards either replacing cells carrying the mutant gene with normal cells or silencing the mutant allele using antisense suppression therapy, thus transforming a biochemically severe form of OI into a mild form.

Hammerhead ribozymes selectively suppress mutant type I collagen mRNA in osteogenesis imperfecta fibroblasts

Ribozymes are a promising agent for the gene therapy of dominant negative genetic disorders by allele-specific mRNA suppression. To test allele-specific mRNA suppression in cells, we used fibroblasts from a patient with osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). These cells contain a mutation in one alpha1(I) collagen allele which both causes the skeletal disorder and generates a novel ribozyme cleavage site. In a preliminary in vitro assay, ribozymes cleaved mutant RNA substrate whereas normal substrate was left intact. For the studies in cell culture we generated cell lines stably expressing active (AR) and inactive (IR) ribozymes targeted to mutant alpha1(I) collagen mRNA. Quantitative competitive RT-PCR analyses of type I collagen mRNA, normalized to beta-actin expression levels, revealed that the level of mutant alpha1(I) collagen mRNA was significantly decreased by approximately 50% in cells expressing AR. Normal alpha1(I) collagen mRNA showed no significant reduction when AR or IR was expressed from the pHbetaAPr-1-neo vector and a small (10-20%) but significant reduction when either ribozyme was expressed from the pCI.neo vector. In clonal lines derived from cells expressing AR the level of ribozyme expression correlated with the extent of reduction in the mutant:normal alpha1(I) mRNA ratio, ranging from 0.33 to 0.96. Stable expression of active ribozyme did not affect cell viability, as assessed by growth rates. Ribozyme cleavage of mutant mRNA results in a reduction in mutant type I collagen protein, as demonstrated by SDS-urea-PAGE. This is the first report of ribozymes causing specific suppression of an endogenous mutant mRNA in cells derived from a patient with a dominant negative genetic disorder.

Osteogenesis imperfecta: prospects for molecular therapeutics

Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) is a dominant negative disorder of connective tissue. OI patients present with bone fragility and skeletal deformity within a broad phenotypic range. Defects in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes, coding, respectively, for the alpha1 and alpha2 chains of type I collagen, are the causative mutations. Over 150 mutations have been characterized. Both quantitative defects, such as null COL1A1 alleles, and qualitative defects, such as glycine substitutions, exon skipping, deletions, and insertions, have been described in type I collagen. Quantitative and structural mutations are associated with the milder and more severe forms of OI, respectively. A more detailed relationship between genotype and phenotype is still incompletely understood; several models have been proposed and are being tested. Transgenic and knock-out murine models for OI have previously been created. We have recently generated a knock-in murine model (the Brittle mouse) carrying a typical glycine substitution in type I collagen. This mouse will permit a better understanding of OI pathophysiology and phenotypic variability. It will also be used for gene therapeutic approaches to OI, especially mutation suppression by hammerhead ribozymes. The present review will provide an update of OI clinical and molecular data and outline gene therapeutic approaches being tested on OI murine models for this disorder.

Bone marrow stromal cells: characterization and clinical application

The bone marrow stroma consists of a heterogeneous population of cells that provide the structural and physiological support for hematopoietic cells. Additionally, the bone marrow stroma contains cells with a stem-cell-like character that allows them to differentiate into bone, cartilage, adipocytes, and hematopoietic supporting tissues. Several experimental approaches have been used to characterize the development and functional nature of these cells in vivo and their differentiating potential in vitro. In vivo, presumptive osteogenic precursors have been identified by morphologic and immunohistochemical methods. In culture, the stromal cells can be separated from hematopoietic cells by their differential adhesion to tissue culture plastic and their prolonged proliferative potential. In cultures generated from single-cell suspensions of marrow, bone marrow stromal cells grow in colonies, each derived from a single precursor cell termed the colony-forming unit-fibroblast. Culture methods have been developed to expand marrow stromal cells derived from human, mouse, and other species. Under appropriate conditions, these cells are capable of forming new bone after in vivo transplantation. Various methods of cultivation and transplantation conditions have been studied and found to have substantial influence on the transplantation outcome. The finding that bone marrow stromal cells can be manipulated in vitro and subsequently form bone in vivo provides a powerful new model system for studying the basic biology of bone and for generating models for therapeutic strategies aimed at regenerating skeletal elements.

Use of the Cre/lox recombination system to develop a non-lethal knock-in murine model for osteogenesis imperfecta with an alpha1(I) G349C substitution. Variability in phenotype in BrtlIV mice

We utilized the Cre/lox recombination system to develop the first knock-in murine model for osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The moderately severe OI phenotype was obtained from an alpha1(I) Gly(349) --> Cys substitution in type I collagen, reproducing the mutation in a type IV OI child. We introduced four single nucleotide (nt) changes into murine col1a1 exon 23: the disease causing G-->T transversion (nt 1546), an adjacent G-->T change (nt 1551) to generate a GUC ribozyme cleavage site, and two transversions (nt 1567 C-->A and nt 1569 C-->G) to cause a Leu --> Met substitution. We also introduced a 3.2-kilobase pair transcription/translation stop cassette in intron 22, flanked by directly repeating lox recombination sites. After homologous recombination in ES cells, two male chimeras were obtained. Chimeras were mated with transgenic females expressing Cre recombinase to remove the stop cassette from a portion of the progeny's cells. To generate mice with full expression of the Gly(349) --> Cys mutation, these offspring were then mated with wild-type females. Skeletal staining and bone histology of the F2 revealed a classical OI phenotype with deformity, fragility, osteoporosis and disorganized trabecular structure. We designate these mice BrtlIV (Brittle IV). BrtlIV mice have phenotypic variability ranging from perinatal lethality to long term survival with reproductive success. The phenotypic variability is not associated with differences in expression levels of the mutant allele in total RNA derived from tissue extracts. Expression of the mutant protein is also equivalent in different phenotypes. Thus, these mice are an excellent model for delineation of the modifying factors postulated to affect human OI phenotypes. In addition, we generated knock-in mice carrying an "intronic" inclusion by mating chimeras with wild-type females. Alternative splicing involving the stop cassette results in retention of non-collagenous sequences. These mice reproduce the lethal phenotype of similar human mutations and are designated BrtlII.

A mutation-independent therapeutic strategem for osteogenesis imperfecta

Given the genetically heterogeneous nature of many dominantly inherited disorders, it will be imperative to design mutation-independent therapeutic strategies to circumvent such heterogeneity. Intragenic polymorphism represents a genomic resource that may be harnessed in the development of allele-specific mutation-independent therapeutics. A hammerhead ribozyme, Rzpol1a1, selectively cleaves a common single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) of the human COL1A1 transcript (heterozygosity frequency of 2 pq = 0.4032, from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium). One SNP variant contains a hammerhead ribozyme cleavage site, and the other does not. Kinetic evaluation shows Rzpol1a1 to be both specific and extremely efficient in vitro. Thus, a single efficient ribozyme has been characterized that should be valuable in the development of a gene therapy suitable for up to 1 in 5 dominant-negative osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) patients, where over 150 different mutations have been identified to date. Given the increasing characterization of intragenic SNP, it is predicted that such a mutation-independent strategy, based on selective silencing of mutant alleles at SNP, may become increasingly important in future genomics-driven drug development for many heterogeneous dominant disorders and complex traits.

Hammerhead ribozymes targeted to the FBN1 mRNA can discriminate a single base mismatch between ribozyme and target

Hammerhead ribozymes are catalytic RNA molecules that can act in trans, with ribozyme and substrate being two different oligoribonucleotides with regions of complementarity. Mutations in the gene for fibrillin-1 (FBN1) cause Marfan syndrome. The majority of mutations are single-base changes, many of which exert their effect via a dominant-negative mechanism. Previously we have shown that an antisense hammerhead ribozyme, targeted to the FBN1 mRNA can reduce deposition of fibrillin to the extracellular matrix of cultured fibroblasts, suggesting it may be possible to utilize ribozymes to down regulate the production of mutant protein and thus restore normal fibrillin function. This might be achieved by the mutation creating a ribozyme cleavage site that is not present in the normal allele, however this is likely to limit the number of mutations that could be targeted. Alternatively, it might be possible to target the mutant allele via the ribozyme binding arms. To determine the potential of ribozymes to preferentially target mutant FBN1 alleles via the latter approach, the effect of mismatches in helix I of a hammerhead ribozyme, on the cleavage of fibrillin (FBN1) mRNA was investigated. A single base mismatch significantly reduced ribozyme cleavage efficiency both in vitro and in vivo. The discrimination between fully-matched and mismatched ribozyme varied with the length of helix I, with the discrimination being more pronounced in ribozymes with a shorter helix. These data suggest that it should be possible to design hammerhead ribozymes that can discriminate between closely related (mutant and normal) target RNAs varying in as little as a single nucleotide, even if the mutation does not create a ribozyme cleavage site.