Matching for private or public HLA epitopes reduces acute rejection episodes and improves two-year renal allograft function

Pathophysiology of Rejection in Kidney Transplantation

Kidney transplantation has been the optimal treatment for end-stage kidney disease for almost 70 years, with increasing frequency over this period. Despite the prevalence of the procedure, allograft rejection continues to impact transplant recipients, with consequences ranging from hospitalization to allograft failure. Rates of rejection have declined over time, which has been largely attributed to developments in immunosuppressive therapy, understanding of the immune system, and monitoring. Developments in these therapies, as well as an improved understanding of rejection risk and the epidemiology of rejection, are dependent on a foundational understanding of the pathophysiology of rejection. This review explains the interconnected mechanisms behind antibody-mediated and T-cell-mediated rejection and highlights how these processes contribute to outcomes and can inform future progress.

Effect of donor-to-recipient HLA matching in low-immunological risk kidney transplant recipients without induction therapy on acute rejection, graft survival, infections, and surgical complications at 3 years: The road towards new recommendations

BACKGROUND

Donor-to-recipient human leukocyte antigen mismatching is considered one of the strongest determinants for graft and patient survival in kidney transplant recipients (KTR).

OBJECTIVE

This retrospective study discusses the impact of HLA matching as low immunological risk KTR without induction therapy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Records of 80 adult kidney transplant patients were reviewed with three years of the follow-up. All patients had panel reactive antibodies (PRA) < 20%, absence of donor-specific antibodies (DSA) and did not receive the induction therapy. These patients were divided into two groups according to their HLA matching between donor and recipient: 55 patients with ≥ 3 HLA matches (Group I; low immunogenicity) were compared to 25 patients with <3 HLA matches (Group II; high immunogenicity). The primary endpoints included the rate and severity of acute rejection (AR) episodes, graft function (creatinine level), and survival at 1, 3, 6, 12, and 36 months. Secondary endpoints include the rate and type of infections at one-year, surgical complications at one-year, and patient survival at 1, 6, 12, and 36 months after kidney transplantation. Baseline demographic characteristics were comparable between the two groups except for recipient age, donor gender, and pre-transplant dialysis time.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference observed between two groups at one-year in infection rate, the length of hospital stay, AR severity, the rate of cytomegalovirus infection, and the occurrence of delayed graft function. However, the rate of AR, the graft function upon discharge, and the rate and type of surgical complications at one-year were significantly higher in Group II (high immunogenicity). The patient and graft survival at three years, the death-censored graft survival, and the serum creatinine levels at 1, 3, 6, 12, and 36 months were similar between two groups. Two deaths occurred in each group (NS).

CONCLUSION

In our center, the donor-to-recipient HLA mismatch is not considered an immunological risk factor in low-risk kidney transplant recipients (PRA < 20% and absence of DSA).

Evidence for the alloimmune basis and prognostic significance of Borderline T cell-mediated rejection

Prognostic biomarkers of T cell-mediated rejection (TCMR) have not been adequately studied in the modern era. We evaluated 803 renal transplant recipients and correlated HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch alloimmune risk categories (low, intermediate, high) with the severity, frequency, and persistence of TCMR. Allograft survival was reduced in recipients with Banff Borderline (hazard ratio [HR] 2.4, P = .003) and Banff ≥ IA TCMR (HR 4.3, P < .0001) including a subset who never developed de novo donor-specific antibodies (P = .002). HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch alloimmune risk categories were multivariate correlates of Banff Borderline and Banff ≥ IA TCMR and correlated with the severity and frequency of rejection episodes. Recipient age, HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch category, and cyclosporin vs tacrolimus immunosuppression were independent correlates of Banff Borderline and Banff ≥ IA TCMR. In the subset treated with tacrolimus (720/803) recipient age, HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch category, and tacrolimus coefficient of variation were independent correlates of TCMR. The correlation of HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch category with TCMR, including Borderline, provides evidence for their alloimmune basis. HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch may represent a precise prognostic biomarker that can be applied to tailor immunosuppression or design clinical trials based on individual patient risk.

Extracorporeal photopheresis in solid organ transplant-associated acute graft-versus-host disease

BACKGROUND

Extracorporeal photopheresis (ECP) culls pathogenic T lymphocytes, be these the clones of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma, or mediators of chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT-GVHD). Whether or not ECP may have an effect in the rarer instances of solid organ transplantation-associated GVHD (SOT-GVHD) is unclear. Mortality rates in SOT-GVHD rival those of transfusion-associated GVHD, with fatalities preceded by pancytopenia and peripheral blood chimerism (PBC) levels exceeding 20%. ECP has been described in two SOT-GVHD cases to date, with one surviving.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Clinicolaboratory features (including HLA relationships) in a case of multivisceral transplantation were reviewed from the time of surgery to the onset and progression of SOT-GVHD. ECP, which was introduced as a less immunosuppressive and more selective intervention, was assessed for its effect on serial PBC (as measured by short-tandem-repeat analysis) and clinical outcome.

RESULTS

Multivisceral SOT-GVHD manifested with erythroderma, neutropenic sepsis, and PBC increasing from 6% on Posttransplant Day (PTD) 38 to 78% by PTD 60 (at a doubling time of 6 days despite corticosteroids). ECP was administered on PTDs 62 and 67 and was associated with the first evidence of PBC decay to 67% on PTD 69. Death nevertheless ensued on the last day of salvage antithymocyte globulin (PTDs 69-73) despite further PBC reduction to 41%.

CONCLUSION

Further study is needed to determine if the sooner or more frequent application of ECP might attenuate the high case fatality rates of SOT-GVHD.

Utility of HLA Antibody Testing in Kidney Transplantation

HLA antigens are polymorphic proteins expressed on donor kidney allograft endothelium and are critical targets for recipient immune recognition. HLA antibodies are risk factors for acute and chronic rejection and allograft loss. Solid-phase immunoassays for HLA antibody detection represent a major advance in sensitivity and specificity over cell-based methods and are widely used in organ allocation and pretransplant risk assessment. Post-transplant, development of de novo donor-specific HLA antibodies and/or increase in donor-specific antibodies from pretransplant levels are associated with adverse outcomes. Although single antigen bead assays have allowed sensitive detection of recipient HLA antibodies and their specificities, a number of interpretive considerations must be appreciated to understand test results in clinical and research contexts. This review, which is especially relevant for clinicians caring for transplant patients, discusses the technical aspects of single antigen bead assays, emphasizes their quantitative limitations, and explores the utility of HLA antibody testing in identifying and managing important pre- and post-transplant clinical outcomes.

Human leukocyte antigen mismatches associated with increased risk of rejection, graft failure, and death independent of initial immunosuppression in renal transplant recipients

Human leukocyte antigen (HLA) mismatches have been shown to adversely affect renal allograft outcomes and remain an important component of the allocation of deceased donor (DD) kidneys. The ongoing importance of HLA mismatches on transplant outcomes in the era of more potent immunosuppression remains debatable. Using Australia and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry, live and DD renal transplant recipients between 1998 and 2009 were examined. The association between the number of HLA mismatches and HLA-loci mismatches and outcomes were examined. Of the 8036 renal transplant recipients, 59% had between 2 and 4 HLA mismatches. Compared with 0 HLA mismatch, increasing HLA mismatches were associated with a higher risk of graft failure and patient death in the adjusted models. HLA mismatches were associated with an incremental risk of rejection although the relative risk was higher for live donor kidney transplants. Increasing HLA-AB and HLA-DR mismatches were associated with a greater risk of acute rejection, graft failure, death-censored graft failure, and/or death. There was no consistent association between initial immunosuppressive regimen and outcomes. Our results corroborate and extend the previous registry analyses demonstrating that HLA mismatches are associated with poorer transplant outcomes independent of immunosuppression and transplant era.

Shipping donor kidneys within Eurotransplant: outcomes after renal transplantation in a single-centre cohort study

BACKGROUND

Shipment of organs during the allocation process aims to improve human leucocyte antigen (HLA) matching but can also have a detrimental effect by prolonging cold ischaemia. The overall effect of organ exchange on post-transplant outcomes in the Eurotransplant (ET) region has not been investigated.

METHODS

This is a retrospective single-centre cohort study to investigate the effect of shipment of renal allografts on cold ischaemia times and the incidence of acute rejection (AR) and graft survival in 661 transplantations of deceased donor kidneys.

RESULTS

Forty-six per cent (N = 301) of the patients received a locally procured and 54% (N = 360) a shipped donor kidney. Locally procured donors tended to be older, more often hypertensive and had less frequently died from trauma. Recipients of shipped kidneys were at higher immunological risk, being younger, more frequently retransplanted and immunized against HLA antigens. Shipped kidneys had a 2.2-h prolongation of cold ischaemia time (18.0 versus 20.2 h; P < 0.0001) but significantly less HLA A, B and DR mismatches (2.20 versus 2.84; P < 0.0001). Recipients of shipped kidneys had an increased incidence of first-year AR [19 versus 13%; odds ratio 1.62 (1.06-2.49); P = 0.026] and death-censored graft loss [hazard ratio 1.6 (1.1-2.4); P = 0.01] that was no longer statistically significant after adjustments for risk factors by multivariable modelling.

CONCLUSIONS

Shipment of kidneys in the ET region is associated with a modest increase in cold ischaemia time and significantly better HLA matching. This allows for successful transplantation of higher risk patients with no significant penalty with regard to AR rates or death-censored graft survival.

Periodontitis case definition affects the association with renal function in kidney transplant recipients

AIM

The aim of this analysis was to investigate the association between periodontal status and renal allograft function in a cohort of renal transplant patients using different periodontitis case definitions.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Fifty-eight kidney transplant patients were included. The subjects were classified into two groups, deterioration or stable/improvement of renal allograft function as expressed by the difference in glomerular filtration rate (GFR) between two time points at least 6 months apart. Chronic periodontitis was defined as: (1) two or more interproximal sites with clinical attachment level (CAL) ≥4 mm or two or more interproximal sites with probing depth (PD) ≥5 mm (DEF1); (2) PD ≥ 5 or CAL ≥ 4 in at least six proximal sites (DEF2); and (3) PD ≥ 5 or CAL ≥ 4 in at least two proximal sites in each quadrant (DEF3).

RESULTS

In a multivariate linear regression model, none of the continuous periodontal variables were significantly associated with deterioration of allograft function. Of the three definitions of chronic periodontitis, only DEF2 emerged as significantly more prevalent in subjects with GFR deterioration and was a statistically significant predictor of GFR deterioration over time.

CONCLUSION

These findings underscore the importance of periodontitis ‘case definition’ in the observed statistical associations between periodontitis and systemic disease.

The impact of immune gene polymorphisms in kidney and liver transplantation

Since the completion of the Human Genome Project, it has become clear that genetic variation exists among individuals that can affect functional gene expression. This finding raises the possibility that differences in genetic phenotypes may account for the interindividual responses seen in the context of the alloimmune response. This review highlights studies examining the relative role of immunologic gene polymorphism in the context of renal and liver transplant outcomes (eg, acute rejection and graft survival). Furthermore, it examines the limitations and pitfalls in the study designs and concludes with the potential of single nucleotide polymorphism analysis in the future care of transplant recipients.

Genetic prediction of renal transplant outcome

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

In the present study, we reviewed recent publications regarding potential genetic predictors of transplant outcome, including acute rejection, metabolism of immunosuppressive medications, long-term transplant outcome, and posttransplant complications.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent studies are based on the candidate gene analysis; specifically, cytokine genes and innate immune response molecules present popular targets for studies of acute rejection and long-term outcome. Pharmacogenomic studies are mostly focused on the genes of drug targets or the corresponding enzymes metabolizing the drug. Posttransplant complications (i.e. infections, diabetes, and malignancies) are associated with a variety of genes of different pathways. Most of the studies are based on just recipient, but not donor, genotype analysis. Positive results are balanced by reports of no association when evaluating the same genetic polymorphisms. Some of the reports might be affected by insufficient study design, including small sample size, lack of adjustment for potential confounders, and multiple comparisons.

SUMMARY

The field remains controversial because of differences in populations, study design, and statistical methods. Studies are based on candidate gene analysis; however, genome-wide association studies are lacking. Future research should be directed at better designed studies, larger sample size, evaluating both recipients and donors, and implementation of genome-wide association studies.

Towards a global human embryonic stem cell bank

An increasingly unbridgeable gap exists between the supply and demand of transplantable organs. Human embryonic stem cell technology could solve the organ shortage problem by restoring diseased or damaged tissue across a range of common conditions. However, such technology faces several largely ignored immunological challenges in delivering cell lines to large populations. We address some of these challenges and argue in favor of encouraging contribution or intentional creation of embryos from which widely immunocompatible stem cell lines could be derived. Further, we argue that current immunological constraints in tissue transplantation demand the creation of a global stem cell bank, which may hold particular promise for minority populations and other sub-groups currently marginalized from organ procurement and allocation systems. Finally, we conclude by offering a number of practical and ethically oriented recommendations for constructing a human embryonic stem cell bank that we hope will help solve the ongoing organ shortage problem.

The impact of human leukocyte antigen matching on transplant complications and immunosuppression dosage

Administrative claims data facilitate ascertainment of outcomes not collected by the transplant registry and provide the opportunity to examine prescribed doses of immunosuppressive medications. Here, we examine the impact of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) matching on traditional outcomes, rejection and survival, and use novel methods to examine immunosuppresion doses and complication rates. The central hypothesis tested in this analysis is that HLA-matched recipients receive lower doses of immunosuppression and have fewer posttransplant complications. We break from tradition by examining HLA matching in both living and deceased donor kidney transplants. As secondary aims, we compare the relative impact of class I and II mismatches and describe outcomes achieved with older donors. Medicare claims linked to the United States Renal Data System database for 23,443 kidney transplants were included in the study. A total of 15,793 transplants were DR mismatched (DRMM), 5,340 manifested no DR mismatches (NODRMM), and 2,310 manifested no ABDR mismatches (NOABDRMM). Patients with NOABDRMM experienced lower adjusted risk of rejection (0.66, 95% confidence interval 0.59-0.74, P < 0.001) and lower hazard of graft loss (0.69, 0.61-0.77, P < 0.001) and death (0.76, 0.63-0.92, P < 0.001) compared with those with DRMM. The hazard of cardiac and diabetic complications was similar between recipients of NOADRMM and DRMM transplants, but the hazard of diarrhea was significantly lower (0.82, 0.73-0.92, P < 0.001) in patients with NOABDRMM. The 6-month dose of mycophenolate mofetil was lower in patients with NOABDRMM. This study validates previous studies that indicated significantly lower risks of rejection, graft loss, and death among patients with 0 HLA-A,B,DR mismatches. Use of administrative claims revealed similar rates of cardiovascular complications. However, HLA-matched deceased donor recipients received lower dosages of mycophenolate mofetil and manifested a lower risk of developing posttransplant diarrhea.

HLA mismatching within or outside of cross-reactive groups (CREGs) is associated with similar outcomes after unrelated hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

The National Marrow Donor Program maintains a registry of volunteer donors for patients in need of a hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Strategies for selecting a partially HLA-mismatched donor vary when a full match cannot be identified. Some transplantation centers limit the selection of mismatched donors to those sharing mismatched antigens within HLA-A and HLA-B cross-reactive groups (CREGs). To assess whether an HLA mismatch within a CREG group ("minor") may result in better outcome than a mismatch outside CREG groups ("major"), we analyzed validated outcomes data from 2709 bone marrow and peripheral blood stem cell transplantations. Three-hundred and ninety-six pairs (15%) were HLA-DRB1 allele matched but had an antigen-level mismatch at HLA-A or HLA-B. Univariate and multivariate analyses of engraftment, graft-versus-host disease, and survival showed that outcome is not significantly different between minor and major mismatches (P = .47, from the log-rank test for Kaplan-Meier survival). However, HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DRB1 allele-matched cases had significantly better outcome than mismatched cases (P < .001). For patients without an HLA match, the selection of a CREG-compatible donor as tested does not improve outcome.

Development of nondonor-specific HLA-DR antibodies in allograft recipients is associated with shared epitopes with mismatched donor DR antigens

Our previous studies showed that not only donor-specific antibodies (DSA) but also nondonor-specific antibodies (NDSA) were detected in the peripheral blood of allograft recipients. The molecular mechanism involved in the development of NDSA is examined here. HLA class II single antigen (SA) beads were used to determine the presence of HLA DR-specific antibodies in renal transplant recipients with failed allografts. Sequence-based antibody-epitope mapping was determined by the comparison of the reaction profiles of different SA recombinant cell lines containing unique epitope pattern. We found that 22 out of 65 recipients with failed grafts developed antibodies against donor HLA DR that is a mismatch with the recipient. Three of them had only DSA while 19 patients had not only DSA but also NDSA. An average of 77.3% of NDSA reacted with targets that share amino acid sequence with mismatched donor DR antigens. Either surface or nonsurface amino acid residues may constitute an antibody epitope. In conclusion, development of NDSA in allograft recipients may be associated with shared amino acids with mismatched donor antigens. SA beads technique not only helps to determine antibody specificities but also provides an ideal approach for the identification of potential HLA antibody epitopes.

Association of HLA class I antigen matching and early graft outcome in living donor kidney transplantation

INTRODUCTION

HLA antigen matching often plays an important role in organ transplantation. As for HLA class I antigen matching, there are differences of opinion regarding its influence on the outcome of renal transplantations. The aim of this study was to evaluate the association of HLA class I antigen matching with early graft outcomes in living donor kidney transplantation.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We evaluated graft outcomes in the first month of transplantation. Major events were slow graft function (serum creatinine > 250 micromol/L at the end of first week), delayed graft function (patients requiring dialysis in first week), and acute rejection episode. Graft outcomes were compared for normal renal function (NRF, serum creatinine < or = 175 micromol/L) impaired renal function (IRF, serum creatinine > 175 micromol/L) or impaired graft function due to an acute rejection episode (IGF).

RESULTS

The 115 subjects had a mean age of 29 +/- 8 years and their donors 38 +/- 11 years (P < .01). Immunosuppression included prednisolone, azathioprine, and cyclosporine. Parents, siblings, and others were kidney donors in 46%, 33%, and 21%, respectively. Comparisons between NRF/IRF (serum creatinine 133 +/- 24 vs 201 +/- 36 micromol/L, P < .01) and NGF/IGF (serum creatinine 146 +/- 44 vs 161 +/- 39 micromol/L, P < .05) showed no difference in number or pattern of HLA matching.

CONCLUSION

HLA class I antigen matching may not produce an added influence on early graft outcome among living donor kidney transplantations.

Influence of Mismatching of HLA Cross-Reactive Groups on Cadaveric Kidney Transplantation

Finding fully HLA-matched recipients for a given donor is not practical due to the allelic diversity of the loci. Cross-reactive group (CREG) matching has been considered a feasible alternative to HLA matching. However, the true efficacy of CREG matching in cadaveric kidney transplantation is controversial. Using conventional HLA and CREG classifications proposed by Rodey and McKenna, we counted the number of mismatches for 319 patients who received cadaver kidney transplants between 1992 and 2003 at Asan Medical Center in Korea. When we compared transplants with four or fewer HLA-A, -B, and -DR antigen mismatches with those with five or more, we observed a significant difference in 5-year survival rate (88.5% versus 78.6%; P = .0189). Transplants with no or one HLA-DR mismatch had a significantly better 5-year survival rate than those with two HLA-DR mismatches (87.9% versus 80.0%; P = .0469). Among transplants with one or two HLA-DR mismatches, transplants with zero or one CREG mismatch showed better 5-year graft survival rate than those with two or more CREG mismatches (89.4% versus 79.8%; P = .0415) only in McKenna's CREG classification. These results suggest that the impact of CREG mismatches on graft survival may depend on CREG classification and on the distribution of HLA-DR mismatches.

The Relative Importance of Cytokine Gene Polymorphisms in the Development of Early and Late Acute Rejection and Six-Month Renal Allograft Pathology

BACKGROUND

Acute rejection episodes and 6-month protocol biopsy acute pathology are highly correlated with long-term outcomes in renal transplant recipients. Recurrent, vascular, and late rejections are particularly deleterious.

METHODS

We determined the relative contribution of human leukocyte antigen matching, cytokine genotypes, delayed graft function (DGF), and baseline immunosuppression to the development of acute rejection and allograft pathology in 118 renal transplant recipients.

RESULTS

Multivariate logistic regression modeling demonstrated that the adjusted odds ratio and 95% confidence interval for recurrent (> or =2) early rejections (0-3 months) increased linearly for high (H) > intermediate (I) > low (L) interferon-gamma (1.8; 1.1-3.2) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)alpha (3.0; 1.3-6.9) genotype, whereas every 1 microg/L increase in the cyclosporine A level was protective (0.991; 0.984-0.999). The odds ratio for recurrent late rejections (4-6 months) increased for H > I > L TNFalpha (5.1; 1.8-14.7) genotype and DGF (7.1; 1.6-30.2), whereas H > I/L transforming growth factor-beta1 genotype decreased the relative risk (0.09: 0.02-0.49). Vascular rejection was only predicted by H > I > L TNFalpha phenotype (3.0; 1.2-7.9). The odds ratio for the 6-month Banff Acute Score (6A > or= 4) increased for H > I > L TNFalpha (2.7; 1.1-6.7) and interleukin-10 (3.4; 1.2-6.2) genotype, and DGF (3.4; 1.1-11.5). Treatment of early subclinical rejection decreased the relative risk (0.20; 0.07-0.62).

CONCLUSIONS

High transforming growth factor-beta1 producer phenotype seems to be protective against acute inflammation, whereas H and I interferon-gamma, TNFalpha, and interleukin-10 producer genotypes correlate with adverse outcomes. Cytokine genotyping identifies individuals who may benefit from more intensive surveillance and treatment posttransplant.

Human leukocyte antigen in the allocation of kidneys from cadaveric donors in the United States

Minorities wait longer for a cadaveric donor kidney transplant than whites. For example, the median waiting time to transplant for candidates listed from 1997 to 1998 was 874 days for whites, 1,493 days for blacks, 1,281 days for Hispanics, 1,491 days for Asians, and 1,466 days for others. The current allocation algorithm has been criticized as contributing to decreased access to transplants for racial minorities. There are two levels in the current algorithm: The first is mandatory national sharing between donors and patients with zero human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A, B, and DR mismatches. The second occurs if there are no candidates and local placement is accomplished based on an algorithm with an HLA component that assigns seven, five, and two points to zero, one, and two HLA-B and DR mismatches, respectively. An analysis of the data shows that a higher percentage of white recipients (21%) received zero antigen mismatched kidneys compared with other races: blacks (7%), Hispanics (14%), and Asians (7%). Whites also received the highest percentage of kidneys with zero B and DR mismatches and one B and DR mismatch compared with the other races. These data indicate that the current algorithm favors whites over minorities, and it is most likely that giving points for HLA-B matching is a strong contributory factor. To address this inequity, the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network and United Network for Organ Sharing Board of Directors approved a recommendation in November 2002 to change the HLA points to award two points for zero DR mismatches and one point for one DR mismatch. Obviously it will take some time to gather sufficient data to allow meaningful analysis of the effect of the policy change.

HLAmatchmaker: a molecularly based algorithm for histocompatibility determination. IV. An alternative strategy to increase the number of compatible donors for highly sensitized patients

BACKGROUND

HLAMatchmaker is a computer algorithm that determines human leukocyte antigen (HLA) compatibility at the level of polymorphic amino acid triplets in antibody-accessible sequence positions. Recent studies have shown that HLA-DR-matched kidney transplant recipients with zero to two triplet mismatches had almost identical graft survival rates as those with zero HLA-A,B,DR antigen mismatches. This report describes how HLAMatchmaker can be used to identify more compatible donors for highly sensitized patients.

METHODS

The HLAMatchmaker program was used to calculate the probability of finding a donor (PFD) with zero, one, or two triplet mismatches for 54 highly sensitized patients waiting for a kidney transplant and having panel reactive antibody (PRA) values greater than 85% and 50 randomly selected nonsensitized patients with PRA values less than 3%.

RESULTS

There was a wide variability for PFD values for the two patient cohorts. If only donors with zero HLA-A,B mismatches were deemed acceptable for recipients, the median PFD of a zero-antigen mismatch was 0.046% for nonsensitized patients and 0.009% for highly sensitized patients (P=0.007). Half of the highly sensitized patients had a PFD below 0.01%, or fewer than 1 in 10,000 donors would have zero antigen mismatches. Application of HLAMatchmaker identified additional HLA antigens with zero-triplet mismatches for 27 patients, resulting in a 1.8-fold increase in PFD. Considering additional antigens with one-triplet or two-triplet mismatches increased the PFD by an additional 3.8-fold and 13.7-fold, respectively. Acceptable antigen mismatches for 37 of the 54 highly sensitized patients were identified by consistently negative reactions in serum screens, and their addition resulted in a 12.7-fold increase of the PFD to a median of 0.141%. Applying these acceptable antigens to the HLAMatchmaker algorithm identified additional antigens with zero or acceptable triplet mismatches and their inclusion increased the PFD by 3.3-fold to 0.347%.

CONCLUSIONS

HLAMatchmaker offers a valuable strategy for identifying more suitably HLA-matched donors and has the potential for alleviating the problem of accumulation of highly sensitized patients on the transplant waiting list.

HLAmatchmaker: a molecularly based algorithm for histocompatibility determination. III. Effect of matching at the HLA-A,B amino acid triplet level on kidney transplant survival

BACKGROUND

HLAMatchmaker is a recently developed computer-based algorithm to determine donor-recipient HLA compatibility at the molecular level. Originally designed for highly alloimmunized patients, this algorithm is based on the concept that immunogenic epitopes are represented by amino acid triplets on exposed parts of protein sequences of HLA-A, -B, and -C chains accessible to alloantibodies. Donor HLA compatibility is determined by intralocus and interlocus comparisons of triplets in polymorphic sequence positions. For most patients, HLAMatchmaker can identify certain mismatched HLA antigens that are zero-triplet mismatches to the patient's HLA phenotype and should, therefore, be considered fully histocompatible. The present study was designed to determine how class I HLA matching at the triplet level affects kidney transplant outcome.

METHODS

We analyzed two multicenter databases of zero-HLA-DR-mismatched kidneys transplanted from 1987 to 1999. One database consisted of 31,879 primary allografts registered by U.S. transplant centers in the United Network for Organ Sharing database and the other consisted of 15,872 transplants in the Eurotransplant program.

RESULTS

HLA-A,B mismatched kidneys that were compatible at the triplet level exhibited almost identical graft survival rates as the zero-HLA-A,B antigen mismatches defined by conventional criteria. This beneficial effect of triplet matching was seen for both nonsensitized and sensitized patients and also for white and nonwhite patients.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that the application of HLAMatchmaker will increase the number of successful transplants, at least in the HLA-DR match combinations.

Definition of permissible and immunogenic HLA antigens based on epitope analysis of the HLA specific antibodies produced in sensitized patients

The goal of this study was to develop an accurate protocol whereby detection of acceptable HLA-A and -B mismatches is based on epitope analysis of HLA class I specific antibodies detected in the serum of highly sensitized patients awaiting a kidney retransplant. A total of 400 serum samples from 44 highly sensitized patients with panel reactive antibodies (PRA) of > or = 60% were collected during a 3-year follow-up period. All patients had been sensitized from a previous graft. In order to define the specificities of the HLA class I specific antibodies, two techniques were used in parallel: the antihuman globulin augmented complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) technique and an enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay (ELISA) technique. Epitope identification was based on class I HLA antigen sequencing, where the unique epitope configuration on one HLA antigen represented the private epitope of the specific HLA antigen, and epitopes shared by more than one HLA antigen represented public determinants. The epitope prediction for the immunogenic HLA epitopes was based on an MHC database. For each highly sensitized patient, antibody specificities against actual and 'at risk' epitopes were defined. Following epitope analysis, all HLA antigens that did not express the actual and/or 'at risk' immunogenic epitopes were considered as acceptable mismatches of epitope analysis. The cytotoxicity of highly sensitized patients was determined using two different panels of selected, separated T lymphocytes. HLA class I specific IgG antibodies against 69 actual and 86 'at risk' epitopes were detected. In all patients, a large number of acceptable mismatches were defined. These included a large number of HLA antigens, corresponding to both HLA-A and -B loci. Our study introduces an accurate protocol for the detection of acceptable mismatches in highly sensitized patients. According to this protocol, the detailed description of immunogenic HLA specific epitope targets, against which HLA class I specific antibodies are directed, is a useful tool for the detection of acceptable mismatches in highly sensitized patients. This may lead to reduced production of HLA class I specific antibodies and, consequently, improved graft survival.

HLAMatchmaker: a molecularly based algorithm for histocompatibility determination. I. Description of the algorithm

This report describes an algorithm for identifying acceptable HLA antigens for highly alloimmunized patients without the need for extensive serum screening. This algorithm is based on the concept that immunogenic epitopes are represented by amino acid triplets on exposed parts of protein sequences of human leukocyte antigen chains (HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-C) accessible to alloantibodies. A computer program (HLAMatchmaker) has been developed to determine class I HLA compatibility at the molecular level. It makes intralocus and interlocus comparisons of polymorphic triplets in sequence positions to determine the spectrum of non-shared triplets on donor HLA antigens. In most cases is it possible to identify certain mismatched HLA antigens that share all their polymorphic triplets with the patient's HLA antigens and could therefore, be considered fully compatible. HLAMatchmaker permits also the identification of additional mismatches that are acceptable as determined from the triplet information on HLA-typed panel cells that do not react with patient's serum.HLAMatchmaker provides an assessment of donor-recipient HLA compatibility at the structural level and this algorithm is different from conventional methods based on the mere counting of numbers of mismatched HLA antigens or CREGs. This donor selection strategy is suitable especially for allosensitized patients in need of a compatible transplant or platelet transfusion.

The impact of late acute rejection after cadaveric kidney transplantation

BACKGROUND

Acute graft rejection (AR) following renal transplantation results in reduced graft survival. However, there is uncertainty regarding the definition, aetiology and long-term graft and patient outcome of AR occurring late in the post-transplant period.

AIM

To determine if rejection episodes can be classified by time from transplantation by their impact on graft survival into early acute rejection (EAR) and late acute rejection (LAR).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

687 consecutive adult renal transplant recipients who received their first cadaveric renal transplant at a single centre. All received cyclosporine (CyA)-based immunosuppression, from 1984 to 1996, with a median follow-up of 6.9 yr. Details were abstracted from clinical records, with emphasis on age, sex, co-morbid conditions, HLA matching, rejection episodes, patient and graft survival.

ANALYSIS

Patients were classified by the presence and time to AR from the date of transplantation. Using those patients who had no AR (NAR) as a baseline, we determined the relative risk of graft failure by time to rejection. The characteristics of patients who had no rejection, EAR and LAR were compared.

RESULTS

Compared with NAR, the risk of graft failure was higher for those patients who suffered a rejection episode. A much higher risk of graft failure was seen when the first rejection episode occurred after 90 d. Thus, a period of 90 d was taken to separate EAR and LAR (relative risk of 3.06 and 5.27 compared with NAR as baseline, p<0.001). Seventy-eight patients (11.4%) had LAR, 271 (39.4%) had EAR and 338 (49.2%) had NAR. The mean age for each of these groups differed (LAR 39.6 yr, EAR 40.8 yr compared with NAR 44 yr, p<0.003). The 5-yr graft survival for those who had LAR was 45% and 10-yr survival was 28%. HLA mismatches were more frequent in those with EAR vs. NAR (zero mismatches in HLA-A: 36 vs. 24%, HLA-B: 35 vs. 23% and HLA-DR: 63 vs. 41%, p<0.003). There was no difference in mismatching frequency between NAR and LAR.

CONCLUSIONS

AR had a deleterious impact on graft survival, particularly if occurring after 90 d. AR episodes should therefore be divided into early and late phases. In view of the very poor graft survival associated with LAR, it is important to gain further insight into the main aetiological factors. Those such as suboptimal CyA blood levels and non-compliance with medication should be further investigated with the aim of developing more effective immunosuppressive regimens in order to reduce the incidence of LAR.

The effect of HLA-C matching on acute renal transplant rejection

BACKGROUND

The acute immunological rejection and long time survival of kidney allografts are correlated with the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) match status between donor and recipient. HLA-A, -B and -DR have all turned out to be relevant HLA loci in several studies. The role of HLA-C has not been studied before now.

METHODS

In 104 consecutive patient/donor pairs from our transplantation unit, we retrospectively analysed whether acute graft rejection is influenced by HLA-C match status between donor and recipient. For typing HLA-C alleles, we used an allele-specific PCR protocol in combination with serology.

RESULTS

By analysing groups of donor/recipient pairs with a homogeneous distribution of HLA-B mismatches in order to exclude an effect of the linkage disequilibrium between HLA-B/C, HLA-C mismatch turned out to be significantly correlated with acute transplant rejection in pairs with one additional mismatch on the B locus (P=0.004). Additional parameters that may hypothetically influence acute rejection episodes (HLA-A or DR mismatch, time of cold and warm ischaemia, previous transplantations, pre-existing HLA antibodies) were also analysed but cannot explain this finding.

CONCLUSION

HLA-C matching of all kidney donors and recipients seems to be an option to reduce the probability of acute rejection episodes. Further studies of greater patient cohorts analysing organ rejection and organ survival are warranted.

In vitro CTL precursor frequencies do not reflect a beneficial effect of cross-reactive group (CREG) matching

Adjustment of histocompatibility-based allocation criteria in kidney transplantation from HLA matching to matching on the basis of cross-reactive groups (CREG), was recently suggested to be a good alternative to transplant with more "well-matched" kidneys, without negatively influencing graft survival. Because graft rejection is often mediated by cytotoxic T cells (CTLs), we investigated whether a beneficial effect of CREG matching is reflected in vitro by lower CTL precursor frequencies (CTLpf). Therefore, CTLpf were determined in a group of healthy individuals and analyzed with respect to the number of HLA and CREG mismatches. A clear correlation was found between the number of HLA mismatches and the CTLpf, that is, the lowest mean frequency in case of 0 HLA-A, B mismatches (66 CTL precursors per 10(6) cells) and the highest in combinations with 4 HLA mismatches (mean = 303 CTLp/10(6) cells). The situation was different in the case of CREG mismatches. Although the highest frequency was found in the group of 4 CREG mismatches, no significant differences were observed between 0, 1, and 2 CREG mismatches. High CTLpf, up to 430/10(6), were even seen in the case of 0 CREG mismatches. Also within a well-defined group of single HLA-A or HLA-B mismatches no difference in CTLpf were observed between the subgroups with 0 vs. 1 CREG mismatches. The present study showed that in vitro the CTLpf correlates better with HLA than with CREG matching. These data are consistent with findings reported by several groups that matching for the CREG does not benefit transplant outcome.

The economic benefit of allocation of kidneys based on cross-reactive group matching

BACKGROUND

Recently the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) began a pilot study to evaluate prospectively the merits of an allocation of cadaveric kidneys based on broader classes of HLA antigens, called cross-reactive groups (CREG). The objectives of the pilot study consider patient outcomes, but not the potential economic impact of a CREG-based allocation. This study predicts the impact of a CREG-based local allocation of cadaveric kidneys on 3-year Medicare payments and graft survival.

METHODS

The UNOS renal transplant registry was merged to Medicare claims data for 1991-1997 by the United States Renal Data System. Average accumulated Medicare payments and graft survival up to 3 years posttransplant for first cadaveric renal transplant recipients were stratified by cross-reactive group mismatch categories. The economic impact was defined as the difference in average 3-year costs per transplant between the current and proposed allocation algorithms. Average 3-year costs were computed as a weighted average of costs, where the weights were the actual and predicted distributions of transplants across cross-reactive group categories.

RESULTS

Results suggest that an organ allocation based on cross-reactive group matching criteria would result in a 3-year cost savings of $1,231 (2%) per transplant, and an average 3-year graft survival improvement of 0.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

Cost savings and graft survival improvements can be expected if CREG criteria were to replace current criteria in the current allocation policy for cadaveric kidneys, although the savings appear to be smaller than may be achievable through expanded HLA matching.

A limited number of HLA epitopes are recognized from HLA class I-specific antibodies detected in the serum of sensitized patients

The goal of this study was to evaluate the epitope specificity of HLA class I-specific antibodies detected in the serum of sensitized patients awaiting retransplantation. The study group consisted of 22 sensitized from previous graft patients, who produced stable IgG HLA class I-specific antibodies. A total of 60 serum samples were screened and analyzed by two techniques in parallel: the antihuman globulin augmented CDC (AHG-CDC) technique and an ELISA technique. All recipients and donors were typed for class I HLA antigens by a standard lymphocytotoxicity technique. The epitope identification was based on class I HLA antigens sequencing, where the multiple immunogenic epitopes are differentially shared among various HLA antigens. The unique epitope configuration on one HLA antigen represents the private epitope of the specific HLA antigen while epitopes shared by more than one HLA antigen represent public determinants. In some HLA antigens (HLA-A1), more than one private epitope has been defined, while in others (HLA-B35, -B51), the private epitopes are not yet known. In a total of 36 antibody reactivity patterns, the majority of the definable IgG HLA class I-specific antibodies corresponded to the A-locus (75%), and only 25% had specificities against the B-locus antigens, although the number of incompatibilities concerning both loci were almost identical (29 for the HLA antigens of the A-locus and 26 for those of B-locus). All patients produced HLA class I-specific antibodies with specificities against the private epitopes of the immunogenic mismatched HLA antigen(s). In 6/21 cases (28.6%), HLA class I alloreactivity spreading to nongraft HLA antigens was detected and 9 public (shared) immunogenic alloepitopes were recognized. In conclusion, appling the epitope analysis of HLA class I-specific antibodies produced by sensitized from previous graft patients, we were able to define the immunogenic alloepitopes. We consider that the immunogenic alloepitopes, during transplantation course, are mainly private epitopes of mismatched HLA antigens and, in certain cases, shared epitopes between the donor alloantigens and other HLA antigens. This knowledge may offer the potential of transplanting sensitized patients through improved donor selection.

Parasitic infection with Trichuris trichiura influences plasma levels of soluble HLA class I

High levels of sHLA-I (soluble HLA--class I) have been correlated with rejection episodes in solid organ transplant recipients and with graft versus host disease in bone marrow recipients. Studies of human infection with parasitic worms of the gut have suggested that certain individuals may be genetically predisposed to intense infection. In this study, the influence of parasitic helminth infection on levels of sHLA-I in plasma was investigated in 155 HLA typed individuals from St. Lucia, exposed to the gut parasite Trichuris trichiura. The results confirmed previous findings showing increased levels of sHLA-I in HLA-A9, and in this case HLA-A23 positive individuals. However, HLA-A9 positive individuals with high worm burden had significantly lower levels of sHLA-I in their plasma compared with HLA-A9 positive subjects with low worm burden. These results suggest that the intensity of T. trichiura infection influences the ability of HLA-A9 positive subjects to maintain high levels of sHLA-I.

Sharing cross-reactive groups of MHC class I improves long-term graft survival

BACKGROUND

Renal transplant loss from chronic rejection remains substantial. To increase our understanding of this syndrome, we identified risk factors predicting late graft loss, with a special emphasis on the impact of human lymphocyte antigen (HLA) matching.

METHODS

We studied all 654 cadaveric kidney transplants performed in our center between 1983 and 1996 that had survived for more than six months. Eighty-two transplants, lost because of chronic rejection, were used as the outcome variable. The influence of HLA mismatches and shares on long-term graft survival was evaluated at the level of private antigens and cross-reactive groups (CREG) of multiple histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I. HLA and other recipient, donors and transplant parameters were studied using univariate and multivariate Cox regression analysis.

RESULTS

The cohort had a mean number of 1.9 HLA mismatches. Because of the homozygosity of HLA antigens, HLA mismatches were not reciprocal to shares. CREG and HLA-A-B mismatches had a relative risk for graft loss of 1.19 (95% CI, 0.97 to 1.45) and 1.05 (0.84 to 1.32) per mismatch. In contrast, the relative risk per shared CREG and broad HLA-A-B antigen was 0.76 (0.63 to 0.92) and 0.79 (0.61 to 1.03). Multivariate analysis revealed that individuals sharing less than four CREGs had a relative risk of 2.13 (1.29 to 3.75) for late graft loss. Other independent predictors were a recipient age of less than 50 years, relative risk 1.95 (1.02 to 3.71); a donor age of more than 50 years, relative risk 1.68 (1.01 to 2.80); acute rejection (vascular vs. no rejection), relative risk 3.52 (1.72 to 7.18); proteinuria (dipstick > 1+ vs. negative), relative risk 2.86 (1.29 to 6.35); and a serum creatinine concentration of more than 150 micromol/liter at six months, relative risk 3.41 (1.96 to 5.94).

CONCLUSION

We identified several coexisting recipient-, donor-, and transplant-related risk factors for graft loss from chronic rejection. In this well-matched group of renal transplants, HLA mismatches and shares had a nonreciprocal relationship. Sharing of HLA antigens, especially CREG of MHC class I, was associated with improved long-term survival.

Transplant surgery injury recruits recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the kidney

BACKGROUND

CD4 T cells, which are stimulated by the "indirect pathway" of antigen-presentation, participate in rejection. These T cells are sensitized by recipient major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-positive leukocytes that migrate into the transplant. Therefore, an important early step in rejection is the immigration of these recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the renal transplant. The regulation of this early step is not understood. We now test the hypothesis that such leukocytes immigrate into the renal transplant in response to ischemic injury occurring during the transplant procedure.

METHODS

We transplanted Brown Norway (BN) kidneys into F1 Lewis/Brown Norway (L/BN) recipients. The F1 recipients are tolerant to the parental BN antigens, and any infiltration of recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes results from injury occurring during transplantation surgery. In addition, ischemia/reperfusion injury was also induced by temporarily occluding the native renal arteries for 30 minutes. Transplanted kidneys and native kidneys, which suffered ischemia/reperfusion injury, were studied by immunohistochemistry on days 3, 7, 14, and 28 after surgery. Staining by the new monoclonal antibody (mAb) OX62 and antibodies to MHC class II identified dendritic cells. In addition, the following monoclonal antibodies identified: gamma/delta T cells, V65; B cells, OX33; cells that may be macrophages, dendritic cells, or dendritic cell precursors, ED1 (+) and OX62 (-); and recipient class II MHC, OX3.

RESULTS

After transplantation, the serum creatinine increased to 4 mg/dl and then decreased, which was consistent with reversible injury during transplantation and the absence of rejection. We found that the injury of transplantation itself resulted in the infiltration of recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the transplanted kidney. This infiltrate peaked at days 7 to 14 after surgery. The inflammation was peritubular and patchy and involved cortex and outer medulla. Double staining for OX62 and OX3 identified some of the infiltrating leukocytes as dendritic cells. Other recipient leukocytes were MHC class II positive, ED1 positive, and OX62 negative. We also found that MHC class II leukocytes, including dendritic cells, infiltrated native kidneys injured by ischemia/reperfusion injury.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that injury to the kidney during transplantation recruits recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the kidney. Some of these leukocytes are dendritic cells.