Anammox-based technologies: A review of recent advances, mechanism, and bottlenecks

The removal of nitrogen via the ANAMMOX process is a promising green wastewater treatment technology, with numerous benefits. The incessant studies on the ANAMMOX process over the years due to its long start-up and high operational cost has positively influenced its technological advancement, even though at a rather slow pace. At the moment, relatively new ANAMMOX technologies are being developed with the goal of treating low carbon wastewater at low temperatures, tackling nitrite and nitrate accumulation and methane utilization from digestates while also recovering resources (phosphorus) in a sustainable manner. This review compares and contrasts the handful of ANAMMOX -based processes developed thus far with plausible solutions for addressing their respective bottlenecks hindering full-scale implementation. Ultimately, future prospects for advancing understanding of mechanisms and engineering application of ANAMMOX process are posited. As a whole, technological advances in process design and patents have greatly contributed to better understanding of the ANAMMOX process, which has greatly aided in the optimization and industrialization of the ANAMMOX process. This review is intended to provide researchers with an overview of the present state of research and technological development of the ANAMMOX process, thus serving as a guide for realizing energy autarkic future practical applications.

Carbon fixation via volatile fatty acids recovery from sewage sludge through electrochemical-pretreatment-based anaerobic digestion

Capturing the carbon in volatile fatty acids (VFA) produced from the anaerobic digestion (AD) of sewage sludge has the potential to not only provide economic benefits but also reduce greenhouse gas production. This study demonstrates a chemical-free method to collect VFA from an AD instead of methane that involves electrochemical pretreatment (EPT) of sludge. Experimental results show that applying 15 V EPT for 45 min enhances acidogenesis and selectively inhibits methanogenesis, leading to a substantial VFA accumulation (2563.1 ± 307.9 mg COD/L) and achieving 2.5 times more carbon fixation than via methane production. Interfacial thermodynamic analysis shows that EPT induces a decrease in both the repulsive electrostatic energy (from 152.9 kT to 12.2 kT) and the energy barrier (from 57.0 kT to 2.6 kT) in the sludge, leading to increased sludge aggregation and entrapment of microorganisms. Molecular docking sheds lights on how the methanogens interacts with the organic matter released from EPT (e.g., alanine-tRNA ligase), showing that these interactions potentially interfere with the proteins that are associated with the activities of the methanogens and the electron transfer pathways, thereby impeding methanogenesis. Integrating EPT into AD therefore facilitates the recovery of valuable VFA and the capture of carbon from freshwater sludge, providing notable economic and environmental benefits in sewage sludge treatment.

Microbial response and recovery strategy of the anammox process under ciprofloxacin stress from pure strain and consortia perspectives

Ciprofloxacin (CIP) poses a high risk of resistance development in water environments. Therefore, comprehensive effects and recovery strategies of CIP in anaerobic ammonia oxidation (anammox) process were systematically elucidated from consortia and pure strains perspectives. The anammox consortia was not significantly affected by the stress of 10 mg L-1 CIP, while the higher concentration (20 mg L-1) of CIP caused a dramatic reduction in the nitrogen removal performance of anammox system. Simultaneously, the abundances of dominant functional bacteria and corresponding genes also significantly decreased. Such inhibition could not be mitigated by the recovery strategy of adding hydrazine and hydroxylamine. Reducing nitrogen load rate from 5.1 to 1.4 kg N m-3 d-1 promoted the restoration of three reactors. In addition, the robustness and recovery of anammox systems was evaluated using starvation and shock strategies. Simultaneously, antibiotic resistance genes and key metabolic pathways of anammox consortia were upregulated, such as carbohydrate and energy metabolisms. In addition, 11 pure stains were isolated from the anammox system and identified through phylogenetic analysis, 40 % of which showed multidrug resistance, especially Pseudomonas. These findings provide deep insights into the responding mechanism of anammox consortia to CIP stress and promote the application of anammox process for treating wastewater containing antibiotics.

Effects of ammonia nitrogen and organic carbon availability on microbial community structure and ecological interactions in a full-scale partial nitritation and anammox (PN/A) system

Nutrient availability significantly impacts microbial biosynthesis, cell growth, and cell cycle progression. In this study, a full-scale plug-flow partial nitritation/anammox (PN/A) system was used to investigate variations in the microbial community structure in both immobilized carriers and flocs, as well as a gradual decrease in nutrient availability from upstream to downstream. We found that reduced ammonia nitrogen (from 150.4 to 30.6 mg/L) and organic carbon (from 415.7 to 342.8 mg/L) availability significantly lowered microbial diversity and altered microbial communities in biofilms other than flocs from upstream to downstream. The abundance of all anammox bacteria increased by 1.97 times, from 3.25 × 1010 to 6.40 × 1010 copies per gram of wet sludge, in the biofilm core microbiome. Furthermore, from upstream to downstream, taxa with lower ribosomal RNA operon copy numbers were consistently enriched in both biofilm and floc communities, indicating that slow-growing microorganisms are more likely to be enriched in low-nutrient environments. Rare taxa with a relative abundance of less than 0.1% exhibited unique metabolic functions, including amino acid, carbohydrate, cofactor, and vitamin metabolisms, which was inferred by PICRUST2 and persisted across the nutrient gradient in both the biofilm and floc communities. Despite their low abundance, they may play important roles in mediating the stability and function of the PN/A system. Overall, the results demonstrate the impact of a naturally formed ammonia nitrogen and organic carbon gradient in a full-scale plug-flow PN/A installation on nutrient availability and its effects on microbial diversity, community composition, and microbial interactions, which expands our fundamental understanding of this energy-efficient and promising biotechnology for treating high-strength ammonium wastewater.

Linking morphological features to anammox communities in a partial nitritation and anammox (PN/A) biofilm reactor

Partial nitritation/anammox (PN/A) has been recognized as a cost-efficient process for wastewater nitrogen removal. The addition of carriers could help achieve biomass retention and enhance the treatment efficiency by forming the dense biofilm. However, accurately determining the abundance of anammox bacteria (AnAOB) to evaluate the biofilm development still remains challenging in practice without access to specialized facilities and experimental skills. In this study, we explored the feasibility of utilizing the morphological features of anammox biofilm as an indication of the biofilm development progression, and its correlation with microbial communities was also revealed. The time-series biofilms from an integrated fixed-film activated sludge (IFAS) system with stable PN/A performance were sampled representing the different biofilm development stages. The biofilm morphological features including color and texture were respectively quantified by red (R) coordinate and Local binary pattern (LBP) descriptor via image processing. Hierarchy clustering analysis proved that the extracted morphological descriptors could well distinguish the different stages (colonization, succession, and maturation) of biofilm development. The microbial community dynamics of time-series anammox biofilms were investigated using the amplicon sequence variant (ASV) analysis. Candidatus Brocadia, as the typical AnAOB, dominated in the whole communities of 16.3%-20.0%, moreover, the biofilm development was found to be driven by distinct Brocadia species. Linear regression evidenced that the Brocadia abundance could be directly correlated to the value of R and LBP, and the total variation of microbial communities could be significantly explained by the morphological features via redundancy analysis. This study demonstrates a new way to monitor the biofilm development by extracting the visible features of anammox aggregates, which can help facilitate the automated control of anammox-based bioprocess.

Synergistic interactions between anammox and dissimilatory nitrate reducing bacteria sustains reactor performance across variable nitrogen loading ratios

Anaerobic ammonium oxidizing (anammox) bacteria are utilized for high efficiency nitrogen removal from nitrogen-laden sidestreams in wastewater treatment plants. The anammox bacteria form a variety of competitive and mutualistic interactions with heterotrophic bacteria that often employ denitrification or dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) for energy generation. These interactions can be heavily influenced by the influent ratio of ammonium to nitrite, NH4+:NO2-, where deviations from the widely acknowledged stoichiometric ratio (1:1.32) have been demonstrated to have deleterious effects on anammox efficiency. Thus, it is important to understand how variable NH4+:NO2- ratios impact the microbial ecology of anammox reactors. We observed the response of the microbial community in a lab scale anammox membrane bioreactor (MBR) to changes in the influent NH4+:NO2- ratio using both 16S rRNA gene and shotgun metagenomic sequencing. Ammonium removal efficiency decreased from 99.77 ± 0.04% when the ratio was 1:1.32 (prior to day 89) to 90.85 ± 0.29% when the ratio was decreased to 1:1.1 (day 89-202) and 90.14 ± 0.09% when the ratio was changed to 1:1.13 (day 169-200). Over this same timespan, the overall nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) remained relatively unchanged (85.26 ± 0.01% from day 0-89, compared to 85.49 ± 0.01% from day 89-169, and 83.04 ± 0.01% from day 169-200). When the ratio was slightly increased to 1:1.17-1:1.2 (day 202-253), the ammonium removal efficiency increased to 97.28 ± 0.45% and the NRE increased to 88.21 ± 0.01%. Analysis of 16 S rRNA gene sequences demonstrated increased relative abundance of taxa belonging to Bacteroidetes, Chloroflexi, and Ignavibacteriae over the course of the experiment. The relative abundance of Planctomycetes, the phylum to which anammox bacteria belong, decreased from 77.19% at the beginning of the experiment to 12.24% by the end of the experiment. Analysis of metagenome assembled genomes (MAGs) indicated increased abundance of bacteria with nrfAH genes used for DNRA after the introduction of lower influent NH4+:NO2- ratios. The high relative abundance of DNRA bacteria coinciding with sustained bioreactor performance indicates a mutualistic relationship between the anammox and DNRA bacteria. Understanding these interactions could support more robust bioreactor operation at variable nitrogen loading ratios.

Microbial ecological responses of partial nitritation/anammox granular sludge to real water matrices and its potential application

Granular sludges are commonly microbial aggregates used to apply partial nitritation/anammox (PN/A) processes during efficient biological nitrogen removal from ammonium-rich wastewater. Considering keystone taxa of anammox bacteria (AnAOB) in granules and their sensitivity to unfavorable environments, it is essential to investigate microbial responses of autotrophic PN/A granules to real water matrices containing organic and inorganic pollutants. In this study, tap water, surface water, and biotreated wastewater effluents were fed into a series of continuous PN/A granular reactors, respectively, and the differentiation in functional activity, sludge morphology, microbial community structure, and nitrogen metabolic pathways was analyzed by integrating kinetic batch testing, size characterization, and metagenomic sequencing. The results showed that feeding of biotreated wastewater effluents causes significant decreases in nitrogen removal activity and washout of AnAOB (dominated by Candidatus Kuenenia) from autotrophic PN/A granules due to the accumulation of heavy metals and formation of cavities. Microbial co-occurrence networks and nitrogen cycle-related genes provided evidence for the high dependence of symbiotic heterotrophs (such as Proteobacteria, Chloroflexi, and Bacteroidetes) on anammox metabolism. The enhancement of Nitrosomonas nitritation in the granules would be considered as an important contributor to greenhouse gas (N₂O) emissions from real water matrices. In a novel view on the application of microbial responses, we suggest a bioassay of PN/A granules by size characterization of red-color cores in ecological risk assessment of water environments.

The optimum particle size of anaerobic ammonia oxidation granular sludge under different substrate concentrations

The nitrogen removal performance of anaerobic ammonia oxidation granular sludge (AnGS) varies widely among particle sizes. In this paper, the nitrogen removal performance, extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) secretion level and microbial community of AnGS with different particle sizes were investigated to select the optimal particle size for different substrate concentrations. The results showed that the optimal particle size migrated from 0.6-1.6 mm to 1.6-2.5 mm and then to 2.5-3.2 mm as the substrate concentration increased. When the influent concentration of NH₄⁺-N was 110 mg/L, granular sludge with particle size of 1.6-2.5 mm showed excellent nitrogen removal performance with the highest EPS secretion, while the highest EPS secretion gradually migrated to smaller particles as the substrate concentration decreased. The nitrogen removal performance of AnGS with different particle sizes depends on different proportions of anaerobic ammonium-oxidizing (anammox) bacteria (Candidates_Jettenia, Candidates_Kuenenia, Candidatus_Brocadia), heterotrophic nitrification aerobic denitrifying bacteria (Acinetobacter) and denitrifying bacteria (Denitratisoma). The optimum particle size range for AnGS has been clarified for different influent nitrogen concentrations, which can provide some new understanding for the application of anammox reactors.

Characterization of Enrichment Cultures of Anammox, Nitrifying and Denitrifying Bacteria Obtained from a Cold, Heavily Nitrogen-Polluted Aquifer

Anammox bacteria related to Candidatus Scalindua were recently discovered in a cold (7.5 °C) aquifer near sludge repositories containing solid wastes of uranium and processed polymetallic concentrate. Groundwater has a very high level of nitrate and ammonia pollution (up to 10 and 0.5 g/L, respectively) and a very low content of organic carbon (2.5 mg/L). To assess the potential for bioremediation of polluted groundwater in situ, enrichment cultures of anammox, nitrifying, and denitrifying bacteria were obtained and analyzed. Fed-batch enrichment of anammox bacteria was not successful. Stable removal of ammonium and nitrite (up to 100%) was achieved in a continuous-flow reactor packed with a nonwoven fabric at 15 °C, and enrichment in anammox bacteria was confirmed by FISH and qPCR assays. The relatively low total N removal efficiency (up to 55%) was due to nonstoichiometric nitrate buildup. This phenomenon can be explained by a shift in the metabolism of anammox bacteria towards the production of more nitrates and less N₂ at low temperatures compared to the canonical stoichiometry. In addition, the too high an estimate of specific anammox activity suggests that N cycle microbial groups other than anammox bacteria may have contributed significantly to N removal. Stable nitrite production was observed in the denitrifying enrichment culture, while no "conventional" nitrifiers were found in the corresponding enrichment cultures. Xanthomonadaceae was a common taxon for all microbial communities, indicating its exclusive role in this ecosystem. This study opens up new knowledge about the metabolic capabilities of N cycle bacteria and potential approaches for sustainable bioremediation of heavily N-polluted cold ecosystems.

Characteristics of biotrickling filter system for hydrogen sulfide removal with seasonal temperature variations: A strategy for low temperature conditions

The impact of temperature on the biological removal of hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) from air is critical to its effective application in cold regions or seasons. This study investigated the effect of seasonal temperature variations (7-30 °C) on the H₂S removal performance of a biotrickling filter system, with an effective H₂S elimination capacity of 98.1 g/m³/h (removal efficiency = 83.1 %) achieved at temperatures of 10-12 °C. Biofilm growth was found to be accelerated by increased secretion of extracellular polymeric substances, enhanced biofilm adhesion capacity and relatively high levels of elemental sulfur accumulation, which help to retain heat within the filter bed under cold conditions. High-throughput sequencing showed that the psychrotolerant sulfur-oxidizing bacterium (SOB) Metallibacterium was gradually enriched (54.8 %) at temperatures below 15 °C. The major pathways of sulfur metabolism under low temperature conditions were determined based on the detection of enzymes related to sulfur metabolism. Finally, a strategy to enrich Metallibacterium was proposed to promote the application of biodesulfurization under low temperature conditions.

Adding organics to enrich mixotrophic sulfur-oxidizing bacteria under extremely acidic conditions-A novel strategy to enhance hydrogen sulfide removal

Biotreatment of high load hydrogen sulfide (H2S) can lead to rapid acidification of a bioreactor, which greatly challenges the application of bio-desulfurization technology. In this study, the bio-desulfurization performance was improved by enriching acidophilic mixotrophic sulfur-oxidizing bacteria (SOB) by adding organics under extremely acidic conditions (pH < 1.0). A biotrickling filter (BTF) for the removal of H2S was established and operated under pH < 1.0 for 420 days. In the autotrophic period, the maximum H2S elimination capacity (ECmax-H2S) was 135.8 g/m3/h with biofilm mass remaining within 11.1 g/L-BTF. The autotrophic SOB bacterium Acidithiobacillus was dominant (62.1 %). When glucose was added to the BTF system, ECmax-H2S increased by 272 % to 464.3 g/m3/h as biofilm mass increased to 22.3 g/L-BTF. The acidophilic mixotrophic SOB bacteria Mycobacterium (78.4 %) and Alicyclobacillus (20.7 %) were enriched while Acidithiobacillus was gradually eliminated (<0.1 %). Furthermore, the major sulfur metabolism pathways were identified to explore the desulfurization mechanism under extremely acidic conditions. To maintain optimal desulfurization performance and avoid biofilm overgrowth in the BTF system, biofilm mass should be maintained within 20-22 g/L-BTF. This can be achieved by adding 1.0 g/L-BTF glucose every 20 days under a load rate of H2S in 50-90 g/m3/h and a trickling liquid velocity of 1.8 m/h. Extremely acidic conditions eliminated non-aciduric microorganisms so that the addition of organics can increase the abundance of acidophilic mixotrophic SOB (>99 %), thus offering a novel strategy for enhancing H2S removal.

The mechanism of C-N-S interconnection degradation in organic-rich sediments by Ca(NO3)2 - CaO2 synergistic remediation

The rebound of black-odorous occurred in organic-rich sediments has become a critical issue due to its great harm to the ecological environment. Elements such as S, C, and N play a crucial role in the biogeochemical cycle of black-odorous rivers. As electronic acceptors, Ca(NO₃)₂ and CaO₂ can effectively remove acidified volatile sulfide (AVS) and organic matter to control the black-odorous rebound. However, the remediation mechanisms in organic-rich sediments by Ca(NO₃)₂ and CaO₂ are unclear. The present study explored the mechanism of C-N-S interconnection degradation in organic-rich urban river sediments by adding different ratios and sequences of Ca(NO₃)₂ and CaO₂. The results showed that Ca(NO₃)₂ remediation followed by CaO₂ and the accepted electron ratio 1:1 of Ca(NO₃)₂ to CaO₂ is an effective method for controlling the rebound of black-odorous and reducing the accumulation NO₂^--N. Mainly attributed to that, CaO₂ enhanced the degradation of organic matter by stimulating enzymatic activities in the sediments, which is also the main reason for controlling the rebound of black-odorous. Since CaO₂ releases O₂ and •OH, which inhibit nosZgenes, NO₂^--N accumulates when remedied simultaneously with Ca(NO₃)₂ and CaO₂. Co-occurrence network analysis illustrated that sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification bacteria, heterotrophic denitrifying bacteria, and sulfate-reducing bacteria interact strongly inside one module, clarifying a solid interaction of C-N-S substances among these bacteria. Our results reveal the C-N-S interconnection degradation mechanism and provide a new perspective on applying biochemical remediation in organic-rich urban river sediments.

Key enzymes involved in anammox-based processes for wastewater treatment: An applied overview

The anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) process has attracted significant attention as an economic, robustness, and sustainable method for the treatment of nitrogen (N)-rich wastewater. Anammox bacteria (AnAOB) coexist with other microorganisms, and particularly with ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and/or heterotrophic bacteria (HB), in symbiosis in favor of the substrate requirement (ammonium and nitrite) of the AnAOB being supplied by these other organisms. The dynamics of these microbial communities have a significant effect on the N-removal performance, but the corresponding metabolic pathways are still not fully understood. These processes involve many common metabolites that may act as key factors to control the symbiotic interactions between these organisms, to maximize N-removal efficiency from wastewater. Therefore, this work overviews the current state of knowledge about the metabolism of these microorganisms including key enzymes and intermediate metabolites and summarizes already reported experiences based on the employment of certain metabolites for the improvement of N-removal using anammox-based processes. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Approaches knowledge about the biochemistry and metabolic pathways involved in anammox-based processes. Some molecular tools can be used to determine enzymatic activity, serving as an optimization in nitrogen removal processes. Enzymatic evaluation allied to the physical-chemical and biomolecular analysis of the nitrogen removal processes expands the application in different effluents.

Metagenomic Insights Into Competition Between Denitrification and Dissimilatory Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia Within One-Stage and Two-Stage Partial-Nitritation Anammox Bioreactor Configurations

Anaerobic ammonia oxidizing bacteria (Anammox) are implemented in high-efficiency wastewater treatment systems operated in two general configurations; one-stage systems combine aerobic ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and Anammox within a single aerated reactor, whereas two-stage configurations separate these processes into discrete tanks. Within both configurations heterotrophic populations that perform denitrification or dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonia (DNRA) compete for carbon and nitrate or nitrite and can impact reactor performance because DNRA retains nitrogen in the system. Therefore, it is important to understand how selective pressures imposed by one-stage and two-stage reactor configurations impact the microbial community structure and associated nitrogen transforming functions. We performed 16S rRNA gene and metagenomic sequencing on different biomass fractions (granules, flocs, and suspended biomass) sampled from two facilities treating sludge dewatering centrate: a one-stage treatment facility (Chambers Creek, Tacoma, WA) and a two-stage system (Rotterdam, Netherlands). Similar microbial populations were identified across the different samples, but relative abundances differed between reactor configurations and biomass sources. Analysis of metagenome assembled genomes (MAGs) indicated different lifestyles for abundant heterotrophic populations. Acidobacteria, Bacteroidetes, and Chloroflexi MAGs had varying capacity for DNRA and denitrification. Acidobacteria MAGs possessed high numbers of glycosyl hydrolases and glycosyl transferases indicating a role in biomass degradation. Ignavibacteria and Phycosphaerae MAGs contributed to the greater relative abundance of DNRA associated nrf genes in the two-stage granules and contained genomic features suggesting a preference for an anoxic or microoxic niche. In the one-stage granules a MAG assigned to Burkholderiales accounted for much of the abundant denitrification genes and had genomic features, including the potential for autotrophic denitrification using reduced sulfur, that indicate an ability to adapt its physiology to varying redox conditions. Overall, the competition for carbon substrates between denitrifying and DNRA performing heterotrophs may be impacted by configuration specific selective pressures. In one-stage systems oxygen availability in the bulk liquid and the oxygen gradient within granules would provide a greater niche space for heterotrophic populations capable of utilizing both oxygen and nitrate or nitrite as terminal electron acceptors, compared to two-stage systems where a homogeneous anoxic environment would favor heterotrophic populations primarily adapted to anaerobic metabolism.

Multidisciplinary characterization of nitrogen-removal granular sludge: A review of advances and technologies

Nitrogen-removal granular sludge (NRGS) is a promising technology in wastewater treatment, with advantages of efficient nitrogen removal, less footprint, lower sludge production and energy consumption, and is a way for wastewater treatment plants to achieve carbon-neutrality. Aerobic granular sludge (AGS) and anammox granular sludge (AnGS) are two typical NRGS technologies that have attracted extensive attention. Mounting evidence has shown strong associations between NRGS properties and the status of NRGS systems; however, a holistic view is still missing. The aim of this article is to provide an overview of NRGS with an emphasis on characterization. Specifically, the integrated nitrogen transformation pathways inside NRGS and the performance of NRGS treating various wastewaters are discussed. NRGS properties are categorized as physical-, chemical-, biological- and systematical ones, presenting current advances and corresponding characterization technologies. Finally, the future prospects for furthering the mechanistic understanding and engineering application of NRGS are proposed. Overall, the technological advancements in characterization have greatly contributed to understanding NRGS properties, which are potential factors for optimizing the performance and evaluating the working status of NRGS. This review will provide guidance in characterizing NRGS properties and boost the introduction of novel characterization technologies.

Carrier surface modification for enhanced attachment and growth of anammox biofilm

This study investigates and compares the ammonia removal kinetics, attachment, biofilm development and anammox bacteria enrichment on various surface modified carriers throughout the 163 days of start-up of an MBBR system: virgin, dextran-functionalized carriers, silica-functionalized and pre-seeded denitrifying carriers. Silica-functionalized carriers along with pre-seeded denitrifying carriers induced significant higher kinetics, faster biofilm growth and greater anammox bacteria enrichment during the 64 days of operation compared to non-modified virgin and dextran-functionalized carriers. The elevated anammox bacteria counts along with the elevated kinetics of all carriers measured at day 106 indicated that the completed biofilm growth and biofilm maturation are achieved prior to or at day 106 of start-up. The NH₄⁺-N removal rate for virgin, dextran-functionalized, silica-functionalized and pre-seeded denitrifying carriers were achieved 0.684 ± 0.019, 0.608 ± 0.016, 0.634 ± 0.017 and 0.665 ± 0.018 g NH₄⁺-N/m²/d, respectively, at day 106. The results demonstrate that the silica-functionalized and pre-seeded denitrifying carriers offer advantages during the early stage of start-up while the dextran-functionalized carriers did not reduce the start-up period for anammox biofilm.

How anammox process resists the multi-antibiotic stress: Resistance gene accumulation and microbial community evolution

The effects of multiple antibiotics on the anaerobic ammonia oxidation (anammox) process were investigated. The resistance of the anammox system to high-concentration antibiotics was also demonstrated through gradual acclimation experiments. Inhibition of the anammox process (R₁) occurred when the concentrations of erythromycin (ERY), sulfamethoxazole (SMX) and tetracycline (TC) were 0.1, 5.0 and 0.1 mg L^-1, respectively. The nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) of R₁ was reduced from 97.2% to 60.7% within 12 days and then recovered to 88.9 ± 9.5% when the nitrogen loading declined from 4.52 ± 0.69 to 2.11 ± 0.58 kg N m^-3 d^-1. Even when the concentrations of ERY, SMX and TC were as high as 1.0, 15.0 and 1.0 mg L^-1, respectively, R₁ maintained stable operation. The increases in the abundance of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and in extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) content showed that the anammox process alleviated stress from multiple antibiotics mainly by producing ARGs and secreting EPS. The molecular docking simulation results illustrated the potential binding sites between ammonium transporter and different antibiotics. The upregulation of functional gene expression and the stable abundance of Candidatus Kuenenia in R₁ compared with that in the control suggested that the R₁ reactor generally maintained more stable long-term operation. This work provides a new understanding of the application of the anammox process to treat wastewater containing multiple antibiotics.

Specific Denitrifying and Dissimilatory Nitrate Reduction to Ammonium Bacteria Assisted the Recovery of Anammox Community From Nitrite Inhibition

The anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) by autotrophic anaerobic ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AnAOB) is a biological process used to remove reactive nitrogen from wastewater. It has been repeatedly reported that elevated nitrite concentrations can severely inhibit the growth of AnAOB, which renders the anammox process challenging for industrial-scale applications. Both denitrifying (DN) and dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) bacteria can potentially consume excess nitrite in an anammox system to prevent its inhibitory effect on AnAOB. However, metabolic interactions among DN, DNRA, and AnAOB bacteria under elevated nitrite conditions remain to be elucidated at metabolic resolutions. In this study, a laboratory-scale anammox bioreactor was used to conduct an investigation of the microbial shift and functional interactions of AnAOB, DN, and DNRA bacteria during a long-term nitrite inhibition to eventual self-recovery episode. The relative abundance of AnAOB first decreased due to high nitrite concentration, which lowered the system’s nitrogen removal efficiency, but then recovered automatically without any external interference. Based on the relative abundance variations of genomes in the inhibition, adaptation, and recovery periods, we found that DN and DNRA bacteria could be divided into three niche groups: type I (types Ia and Ib) that includes mainly DN bacteria and type II and type III that include primarily DNRA bacteria. Type Ia and type II bacteria outcompeted other bacteria in the inhibition and adaptation periods, respectively. They were recognized as potential nitrite scavengers at high nitrite concentrations, contributing to stabilizing the nitrite concentration and the eventual recovery of the anammox system. These findings shed light on the potential engineering solutions to maintain a robust and efficient industrial-scale anammox process.

Mainstream double-anammox driven by nitritation and denitratation using a one-stage step-feed bioreactor with real municipal wastewater

A novel double-anammox process for advanced mainstream nitrogen removal was established using step-feed sequencing batch reactor (SBR) system with integration of suspend sludge and biofilms. Following optimization of influent distribution ratio, the effluent total inorganic nitrogen (TIN) was < 10.2 mg N/L, with influent TIN of 43.4 mg N/L, and anammox contributed 71.4% to TIN removal. Biological processes and batch tests revealed that gradient C/N reduction promoted denitratation/anammox in anoxic stage, and simultaneous nitritation and anammox were achieved in oxic stage. Specially, anammox maintained on biofilms with abundance over 10⁹ copies/ (g dry sludge). High-throughput sequencing revealed that Thauera and Nitrosomonas were enriched in flocs. Furthermore, metagenomic sequencing confirmed that Thauera owns narG and napA (NO₃^-→NO₂^-) and Nitrosomonas owns amoA (NH₄⁺→NO₂^-), support stable NO₂^- supply for double-anammox. This mainstream anammox-dominant process could potentially be used for stable nitrogen removal in municipal wastewater treatment plants.

Variations of N concentrations and microbial community in the start-up of anammox using anaerobic heterotrophic sludge: Influence of a long reaction-phase time and comparison of the efficiencies of attached-versus suspended-growth cultures

Anaerobic sludge was capable of producing anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) cultures. However, the low activity of anammox bacteria in the seed sludge often led to a long time for stable anammox to initiate. The objective of this study was to investigate the influence of an extended reaction-phase time in the sequencing batch reactor (SBR) on the rapid startup of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) using anaerobic heterotrophic bacteria as the seed sludge. After the startup, suspended and attached bacteria in anammox were separately analyzed for comparison. The variations of nitrogen concentrations and shifts of the microbial community structures were studied. The results showed that anammox occurred after a long reaction-phase time in the SBR with the efficient removals of NH₄⁺ (96.4%) and NO₂^- (99.8%). The effective NO₂^- treatment before anammox startup was attributable to inevitable denitrification or dissimilatory nitrate reduction (e.g., Denitratisoma). The occurrence of anammox was supported by the anammox stoichiometry, bacteria diversity variation, and principal component analysis. The overall nitrogen removal rate (NRR) and nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) was 0.07 kg/m³-d and 92.8%, respectively. The relative molar quantities of NH₄⁺ and NO₂^- removed as well as N₂ and NO₃^- formed were 1(1):1.29(1.32):1.45(1.02):0.15(0.26), as the numbers in the parentheses represent the theoretical values. Denitratisoma and Desulfatiglans dominated in the seed sludge, whereas Candidatus_Jettenia abundances were significantly higher in anammox attached- (26.0%) and suspended-growth cultures (14.5%). Fifty-three genera were simultaneously identified in all samples, suggesting their importance in the startup of anammox from anaerobic sludge. Candidatus_Jettenia was observed to be more associated with the growth of anammox biofilm (the abundances were 26.0% and 14.5% in attached- and suspended-growth cultures, respectively) and supported the fine nitrogen removal performance in the attached-growth cultures.

Metabolic flexibility of aerobic methanotrophs under anoxic conditions in Arctic lake sediments

Methane (CH₄) emissions from Arctic lakes are a large and growing source of greenhouse gas to the atmosphere with critical implications for global climate. Because Arctic lakes are ice covered for much of the year, understanding the metabolic flexibility of methanotrophs under anoxic conditions would aid in characterizing the mechanisms responsible for limiting CH₄ emissions from high-latitude regions. Using sediments from an active CH₄ seep in Lake Qalluuraq, Alaska, we conducted DNA-based stable isotope probing (SIP) in anoxic mesocosms and found that aerobic Gammaproteobacterial methanotrophs dominated in assimilating CH₄. Aerobic methanotrophs were also detected down to 70 cm deep in sediments at the seep site, where anoxic conditions persist. Metagenomic analyses of the heavy DNA from ¹³CH₄-SIP incubations showed that these aerobic methanotrophs had the capacity to generate intermediates such as methanol, formaldehyde, and formate from CH₄ oxidation and to oxidize formaldehyde in the tetrahydromethanopterin (H₄MPT)-dependent pathway under anoxic conditions. The high levels of Fe present in sediments, combined with Fe and CH₄ profiles in the persistent CH₄ seep site, suggested that oxidation of CH₄, or, more specifically, its intermediates such as methanol and formaldehyde might be coupled to iron reduction. Aerobic methanotrophs also possessed genes associated with nitrogen and hydrogen metabolism, which might provide potentially alternative energy conservation options under anoxic conditions. These results expand the known metabolic spectrum of aerobic methanotrophs under anoxic conditions and necessitate the re-assessment of the mechanisms underlying CH₄ oxidation in the Arctic, especially under lakes that experience extended O₂ limitations during ice cover.

Inhibition of anammox activity by municipal and industrial wastewater pollutants: A review

The use of the anammox process for nitrogen removal has gained popularity across the world due to its low energy consumption and waste generation. Anammox reactors have been used to treat ammonium-rich effluents such as chemical, pharmaceutical, semiconductor, livestock, and coke oven wastewater. Recently, full-scale installations have been implemented for municipal wastewater treatment. The efficiency of biological processes is susceptible to inhibitory effects of pollutants present in wastewater. Considering the increasing number of emerging contaminants detected in wastewater, the impacts of the different types of pollutants on anammox bacteria must be understood. This review presents a compilation of the studies assessing the inhibitory effects of different wastewater pollutants towards anammox activity. The pollutants were classified as antibiotics, aromatics, azoles, surfactants, microplastics, organic solvents, humic substances, biodegradable organic matter, or metals and metallic nanoparticles. The interactions between the pollutants and anammox bacteria have been described, as well as the interactions between different pollutants leading to synergistic effects. We also reviewed the effects of pollutants on distinct species of anammox bacteria, and the main toxicity mechanisms leading to irreversible loss of anammox activity have been identified. Finally, we provided an analysis of strategies to overcome the inhibitory effects of wastewater pollutants on the nitrogen removal performance. We believe this review will contribute with essential information to assist the operation and design of anammox reactors treating different types of wastewaters.

Insights into complete nitrate removal in one-stage nitritation-anammox by coupling heterotrophic denitrification

Nitritation-anammox has been considered to be the most promising process for nitrogen (N) removal from wastewater. However, the anammox reaction still produces an amount of nitrate, which cannot be removed further. This study hypothesizes that heterotrophic denitrification can be an appealing option to remove the residual nitrate in the one-stage nitritation-anammox process. Through monitoring N-removal performance and microbial community succession of a laboratory microaerobic reactor, the effect of four different levels of oxygen supply on nitrate removal was investigated. The reactor was continuously fed with real manure-free piggery wastewater containing ~240 mg NH₄⁺-N/L and chemical oxygen demand (COD)/total nitrogen (TN) ratio of less than 1 for 180 days. With a high influent loading rate of 0.7 kg N/(m³·d), efficient total nitrogen removal (>80 %) was achieved during stable operation of dissolved oxygen (DO) concentrations between 0.3 and 0.6 mg O₂/L, indicating N-removal via the nitritation-anammox pathway in the low-carbon wastewater treatment. At the same time, the effluent nitrate reduced with decreased oxygen supply and completely depleted at DO of 0.3 ± 0.1 mg O₂/L. In addition to oxygen, preventing ammonia nitrogen from falling to very low levels (<10 mg/L) could be also useful for the complete nitrate removal and stable nitritation-anammox. 16S rRNA gene-based analyses confirmed a complex microbial community including nitrifiers, denitrifiers and anammox bacteria in the biomass of the reactor. Collectively, this study provides new insights into high-level N-removal of a nitritation-anammox process by complete nitrate depletion.

Metagenomic prediction analysis of microbial aggregation in anammox-dominated community

Aggregation of anammox bacteria is essential to maintain high biomass concentrations and prevent the loss of biomass in anammox processes. PICRUSt (Phylogenetic Investigation of Communities by Reconstruction of Unobserved States) was used in this study to predict the metagenomic potentials and characterize the microbial community structure and functional features in anammox aggregates (e.g., sludge flocs, biofilms, and granules). The results showed that Candidatus Brocadia was the most dominant anammox genera in all aggregates (38.0% in flocs, 69.4% in biofilm, and 52.0% in granules) and the functional gene involved in the anammox process was detected in the highest amount in biofilms, followed by granules and flocs. Furthermore, the anammox microbial aggregation pathway was explored that anammox bacteria have strong motility and high capability for early attachment. Anammox bacteria could produce large amounts of EPS (extracellular polymeric substances) regulated by quinolone and transport to extracellular environment through type II secretion system. The strong ability of c-di-GMP (bis-(3'-5')-cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate) synthesis enabled a stable architectural structure of aggregation. This study elucidated the aggregation mechanism of anammox microorganisms at the genetic level to enhance the stability of anammox processes. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Candidatus Brocadia was the most dominant anammox genera in aggregates. Anammox bacteria have strong motility and high attachment capability. Anammox bacteria possess strong EPS synthesis regulated by quinolone. c-di-GMP synthesis enables a stable structure of aggregation.

Activities and metabolic versatility of distinct anammox bacteria in a full-scale wastewater treatment system

Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) is a key N₂-producing process in the global nitrogen cycle. Major progress in understanding the core mechanism of anammox bacteria has been made, but our knowledge of the survival strategies of anammox bacteria in complex ecosystems, such as full-scale wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs), remains limited. Here, by combining metagenomics with in situ metatranscriptomics, complex anammox-driven nitrogen cycles in an anoxic tank and a granular activated carbon (GAC) biofilm module of a full-scale WWTP treating landfill leachate were constructed. Four distinct anammox metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs), representing a new genus named Ca. Loosdrechtii, a new species in Ca. Kuenenia, a new species in Ca. Brocadia, and a new strain in "Ca. Kuenenia stuttgartiensis", were simultaneously retrieved from the GAC biofilm. Metabolic reconstruction revealed that all anammox organisms highly expressed the core metabolic enzymes and showed a high metabolic versatility. Pathways for dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) coupled to volatile fatty acids (VFAs) oxidation likely assist anammox bacteria to survive unfavorable conditions and facilitate switches between lifestyles in oxygen fluctuating environments. The new Ca. Kuenenia species dominated the anammox community of the GAC biofilm, specifically may be enhanced by the uniquely encoded flexible ammonium and iron acquisition strategies. The new Ca. Brocadia species likely has an extensive niche distribution that is simultaneously established in the anoxic tank and the GAC biofilm, the two distinct niches. The highly diverse and impressive metabolic versatility of anammox bacteria revealed in this study advance our understanding of the survival and application of anammox bacteria in the full-scale wastewater treatment system.

Metatranscriptomic analysis reveals active microbes and genes responded to short-term Cr(VI) stress

Heavy metals have been severely polluting the environment. However, the response mechanism of microbial communities to short-term heavy metals stress remains unclear. In this study, metagenomics (MG) and metatranscriptomics (MT) was performed to observe the microbial response to short-term Cr(VI) stress. MG data showed that 99.1% of species were similar in the control and Cr(VI) treated groups. However, MT data demonstrated that 83% of the microbes were active in which 58.7% increased, while the relative abundance of 41.3% decreased after short-term Cr(VI) incubation. The MT results also revealed 9% of microbes were dormant in samples. Genes associated with oxidative stress, Cr(VI) transport, resistance, and reduction, as well as genes with unknown functions were 2-10 times upregulated after Cr(VI) treatment. To further confirm the function of unknown genes, two genes (314 and 494) were selected to detect the Cr(VI) resistance and reduction ability. The results showed that these genes significantly increased the Cr(VI) remediation ability of Escherichia coli. MT results also revealed an increase in the expression of some rare genera (at least two times) after Cr(VI) treatment, indicating these rare species played a crucial role in microbial response to short-term Cr(VI) stress. In summary, MT is an efficient way to understand the role of active and dormant microbes in specific environmental conditions.

Advanced nitrogen removal from anaerobically pre-treated potato wastewater via partial nitritation-anammox in a continuous fed SBR

Partial nitritation-anammox was carried out successfully in a continuous fed Sequencing Batch Reactor (cf-SBR), composed of 3 compartments operated in continuous mode. The reactor was operated with floccular biomass (flocs) and biofilm to remove nitrogen from the anaerobic effluent from the potato industry at different nitrogen loading rates (0.16 g TN L^-1 d^-1 - 0.8 g TN L^-1 d^-1). At the maximum nitrogen loading rate (NLR) evaluated the nitrogen removal and ammonia oxidation achieved were 62% and 74% respectively. During the evaluation of the NLR, it was observed an improvement of the characteristics of the sludge, improving the Sludge Volumetric Index (SVI) from 228 to 63 mL g^-1 MLSS. Moreover, molecular analysis (qPCR) confirmed the presence of anammox bacteria on the flocs and in the biofilm from the cf-SBR. The results showed the capability of the reactor to carry out the partial nitritation-anammox in the same reactor at pilot scale. The cf-SBR was presented as a suitable and feasible technology for advanced nitrogen removal under partial nitritation and anammox conditions.

Deciphering the mechanism of medium size anammox granular sludge driving better nitrogen removal performance

In this study, an integrated investigation to the microbial activities, extracellular polymeric substance (EPS), microbial community and function of anammox granular sludge (AnGS) was performed.Results showed that AnGS at 0.5-1.0 mm had the highest average specific anammox activity (SAA) of 345.9 mg NH₄⁺-N·gVSS^-1·d^-1, but AnGS at 1.0-1.5 mm with higher SAA might lead to better nitrogen removal efficiency. The content of slime EPS and SAA achieved positively correlation with R² of 98.11%, while protein/polysaccharide ratio of slime EPS and sludge volume index achieved negatively correlation with R² of 99.13%. Cadidatus Broccadia and Denitratisoma were positive correlations and most abundant in AnGS 0.5-1.0 mm of 20% and AnGS 1.0-1.5 mm of 37%, respectively. AnGS at 0.5-1.0 mm exhibited higher energy metabolism which mostly contributed to produce protein. The study provides new insights into the mechanisms of AnGS about 1 mm playing more important role in nitrogen removal performance.

Research progress on enhancing the performance of autotrophic nitrogen removal systems using microbial immobilization technology

The autotrophic nitrogen removal process has great potential to be applied to the biological removal of nitrogen from wastewater, but its application is hindered by its unstable operation under adverse environmental conditions, such as those presented by low temperatures, high organic matter concentrations, or the presence of toxic substances. Granules and microbial entrapment technology can effectively retain and enrich microbial assemblages in reactors to improve operating efficiency and reactor stability. The carriers can also protect the reactor's internal microorganisms from interference from the external environment. This article critically reviews the existing literature on autotrophic nitrogen removal systems using immobilization technology. We focus our discussion on the natural aggregation process (granulation) and entrapment technology. The selection of carrier materials and entrapment methods are identified and described in detail and the mechanisms through which entrapment technology protects microorganisms are analyzed. This review will provide a better understanding of the mechanisms through which immobilization operates and the prospects for immobilization technology to be applied in autotrophic nitrogen removal systems.

Responses of microbial structures, functions and metabolic pathways for nitrogen removal to different hydraulic retention times in anaerobic side-stream reactor coupled membrane bioreactors

Synchronous sludge reduction and nitrogen removal have attracted increasing attention, while the underlying mechanisms of diverse nitrogen metabolism within the complicated processes remain unclear. Four anoxic/oxic membrane bioreactors, three of which were upgraded by anaerobic side-stream reactors (ASSR) and carriers (APSSR-MBRs), were operated to determine effects of hydraulic retention time of ASSRs. APSSR-MBRs achieved more significant nitrogen removal and higher nitrate uptake rate because of more denitrifying bacteria and the supernumerary release of secondary substrates. Ammonia uptake rate showed the diverse Nitrospira preceded over anaerobic decay and sulfide inhibition in the ASSR, and made the reactor exhibit higher nitrification capacity. Metagenomic analysis indicated that APSSR-MBRs showed higher abundances of genes related to nitrogen consumption processes, and higher abundances on the carriers, confirming their pivotal roles in nitrogen metabolism. This study provided novel perspectives to build a bridge between process model and nitrogen metabolism in the sludge reduction system..

Impacts of ammonia loading and biofilm age on the prevalence of nitrogen-cycling microorganisms in a full-scale submerged attached-growth reactor

This study reports the impacts of seasonal ammonia load changes and biofilm age on the quantity of biomass and on the prevalence of ammonia- and nitrite-metabolizing organisms within a submerged attached-growth reactor (SAGR™) following lagoon treatment. Ammonia (NH₃ ) loadings (0.12-3.17 kg/d) in the primary SAGR were measured over 223 days from May to December in 2017. Adjustment of the wastewater flow path on September 1 successfully increased NH₃ loading to the primary SAGR, which subsequently caused reactor biomass to increase. The NH₃ removal rate in October (0.5 kg/d) was greater than rates in June and July (0.3 and 0.2 kg/d) despite a water temperature decrease from >24 to 15.6°C. This elevated removal rate in October, and the sustained removal rate in December (0.4 kg/d, 5.3°C) were associated with a measured increase in microbial biomass. The relative abundance of the anammox organism C. Brocadia was 5 times greater in the mature biofilm after 686 days of growth, and the genus Pseudomonas increased sevenfold. The presence of Pseudomonas, which contains denitrifying species, and anammox suggests a high potential for removal of total nitrogen in SAGRs. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Pseudomonas prevalence and the presence of anammox suggest a high potential for total nitrogen removal in mature SAGR biofilms. The abundance of the anammox microorganism C. Brocadia was greater after 686 days of biofilm growth compared with 33 days. Simple operational changes can increase biomass in the SAGR to maintain, or even increase, NH₃ transformation rates during cold weather.

Achieving single-stage partial nitritation and anammox (PN/A) using a submerged dynamic membrane sequencing batch reactor (DM-SBR)

Single-stage partial nitration and anammox (PN/A) process was achieved in a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) using a submerged dynamic membrane (DM) in this study. The reactor was stably operated for 200 days, and the nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) was sustained at 70.3 ± 7.2% at a nitrogen loading rate (NLR) ranging from 0.1 to 0.3 kgNm^-3  day^-1 with a hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 24 hr. When the NLR was 0.2 kgN m^-3 day^-1 , the NRE achieved was high as 80% with a low concentration of dissolved oxygen (DO) of 0.13 mg/L. In addition, the specific activity of anammox bacteria and ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) reached was 2.72 and 16.80 gN gVSS^-1 day^-1 , respectively. The DM intercepted the biomass due to the lamellar, intact, dense biofilm self-generated on the surface of the supporting material, which had an effluent turbidity of 10 NTU. The enriched anammox functional bacteria were Candidatus Jettenia (11.06%) and the AOB-like functional bacteria consisted primarily of Nitrosomonas, with a relative abundance of 2.76%, which ensured the PN/A process proceeding. This study provides a novel reactor configuration of the single-stage PN/A process in the view of practical applications. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Single-stage partial nitration and anammox (PN/A) process was achieved using a submerged dynamic membrane (DM) in this study. The reactor was stably operated for 200 days, and the nitrogen removal efficiency was sustained at 70.3 ± 7.2%. The feasibility of the PN/A system with DM is evaluated. The main objective is to provide a control strategy of the DM-SBRs for practical applications.

A review of quorum sensing improving partial nitritation-anammox process: Functions, mechanisms and prospects

Partial nitritation-anammox (PNA) is a promising and energy-efficient process for the sustainable nitrogen removal. However, its wide applications are still limited by the long start-up period and instability of long-term operation. Quorum sensing (QS), as a way of cell-to-cell communication generally regulating various microbial behaviors, has been increasingly investigated in PNA process, because QS may substantially manipulate the metabolism of microorganisms and overcome the limitations of PNA process. This critical review provides a comprehensive analysis of QS in PNA systems, and identifies the challenges and opportunities for the optimization of PNA process based on QS. The analysis is grouped based on the configurations of PNA process, including partial nitritation, anammox and single-stage PNA systems. QS is confirmed to regulate various properties of PNA systems, including microbial activity, microbial growth rate, microbial aggregation, microbial interactions and the robustness under adverse conditions. Major challenges in the mechanisms of QS, such as QS circuits, target genes and the response to environmental inputs, are identified. Potential applications of QS, such as short-term addition of certain acyl-homoserine lactones (AHLs) or substances containing AHLs, transient unfavorable conditions to stimulate the secretion of AHLs, are also proposed. This review focuses on the theoretical and practical cognation for QS in PNA systems, and serves as a stepping stone for further QS-based strategies to enhance nitrogen removal through PNA process.

Highly enriched anammox within anoxic biofilms by reducing suspended sludge biomass in a real-sewage A2/O process

This study proposes a novel strategy of stably enriching anammox in mainstream, based on the competitive difference to NO₂^- between anoxic biofilms and suspended sludge. A modified anaerobic-anoxic-oxic (A²/O) process run for 500 days with actual municipal wastewater. Microbial analysis revealed that anoxic-carrier biofilms had a significantly higher abundance of anammox (qPCR: 0.74% - 4.34%) than suspended sludge (P< 0.001). Batch tests showed that anammox within anoxic-carrier biofilms contributed to significant nitrogen removal, coupled with partial-denitrification (NO₃^- → NO₂^-). The anammox genus, Ca. Brocadia, was highly enriched when suspended sludge was accidentally lost. Further batch tests found that reducing suspended biomass helped anammox enrichment in anoxic-carrier biofilms, because the suspended sludge had strong NO₂^- competition (NO₂^- → N₂) with anammox (increased nirK). Metagenomic sequencing revealed that Ca. Brocadia dominates in the anoxic-carrier biofilms, and is the most important narG contributor to NO₃^- → NO₂^-, which could have promoted the competition of NO₂^- with heterotrophic bacteria. For this A²/O process, the low effluent total nitrogen (8.9 mg ± 1.0 mg N/L) was attributed to partial-denitrification coupling with anammox, demonstrating that this process is applicable to the general influent N-concentration range (30 mg - 50 mg NH₄⁺-N/L) of municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Based on the special competitive preference of anammox for NO₂^-, this study provides a promising and practical alternative for enriching anammox bacteria in municipal WWTPs.

Metagenomic Insight Into Patterns and Mechanism of Nitrogen Cycle During Biocrust Succession

The successional ecology of nitrogen cycling in biocrusts and the linkages to ecosystem processes remains unclear. To explore this, four successional stages of natural biocrust with five batches of repeated sampling and three developmental stages of simulated biocrust were studied using relative and absolute quantified multi-omics methods. A consistent pattern across all biocrust was found where ammonium assimilation, mineralization, dissimilatory nitrite to ammonium (DNiRA), and assimilatory nitrate to ammonium were abundant, while denitrification medium, N-fixation, and ammonia oxidation were low. Mathematic analysis showed that the nitrogen cycle in natural biocrust was driven by dissolved organic N and NO₃^–. pH and SO₄^2– were the strongest variables affecting denitrification, while C:(N:P) was the strongest variable affecting N-fixation, DNiRA, nitrite oxidation, and dissimilatory nitrate to nitrite. Furthermore, N-fixation and DNiRA were closely related to elemental stoichiometry and redox balance, while assimilatory nitrite to ammonium (ANiRA) and mineralization were related to hydrological cycles. Together with the absolute quantification and network models, our results suggest that responsive ANiRA and mineralization decreased during biocrust succession; whereas central respiratory DNiRA, the final step of denitrification, and the complexity and interaction of the whole nitrogen cycle network increased. Therefore, our study stresses the changing environmental functions in the biocrust N-cycle, which are succession-dependent.

Selective enrichment and metagenomic analysis of three novel comammox Nitrospira in a urine-fed membrane bioreactor

The discovery of complete ammonia-oxidizing (comammox) Nitrospira has added an important new process to the microbial nitrogen cycle. While comammox Nitrospira have been detected in various ecosystems, only few studies have achieved their enrichment over other canonical nitrifiers. Here, we obtained a selective enrichment of comammox Nitrospira in a urine-fed membrane bioreactor in less than 200 days. By using 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing and quantitative PCR of the functional marker gene amoA, we observed a dominance (up to 30% relative abundance) of comammox Nitrospira over ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and archaea. Furthermore, the complete genomes of three new clade A comammox Nitrospira were recovered by metagenomics. These three strains were divergent from previously reported comammox species according to comparative genome and amoA-based analyses. In addition to the key genes for ammonia and nitrite oxidation, the three recovered genomes contained a complete urea utilization pathway. Our findings suggest that the urea present in the urine media played a significant role in the selective enrichment of these novel comammox Nitrospira, and support the diversity and versatility of their metabolism.

Short- and long-term effects of copper on anammox under gradually increased copper concentrations

This study aims to determine both short- and long-term response of enriched anammox culture to Cu. Assessment of short-term inhibition is based both on total applied Cu concentration and potential bioavailable fractions like intracellular, surface-bound, soluble and free Cu ion. The half maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) values for total applied, soluble, intracellular and cell-associated concentrations were determined as 4.57 mg/L, 1.97 mg/L, 0.71 mg/L, 1.11 mg/L, respectively. Correlation between the surface-bound fraction of Cu and inhibition response was weak, suggesting that Cu sorbed to biomass was not directly responsible for the effects on anammox activity. There was a disparity between the results of short- and long-term experiments in terms of inhibition threshold concentration (i.e. short-term IC50 = 4.57 mg/L vs long-term IC50 = 6.74 mg/L). Candidatus Kuenenia (59.8%) and Candidatus Brocadia (40.2%) were the two main anammox genera within the initial biomass sample. One of the most interesting finding of the study is the demonstration that a complete wash-out of C. Brocadia genus at an applied Cu concentration of 6.5 mg/L. This strongly indicates that C. Brocadia were not able to tolerate high copper concentrations and all nitrogen conversion was carried out by C. Kuenenia during the Cu exposure period.

Optimizing anammox capacity for weak wastewater in an AnSBBR using aerobic activated sludge as inoculation

Process optimization is essential for improving the efficiency of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) process in a practical application. In this study, an anaerobic sequence biofilm batch reactor (AnSBBR) inoculated with aerobic activated sludge was chosen as an efficient mainstream anammox reactor for treating low-nitrogen wastewater. To optimize the AnSBBR-anammox process, eight different operation stages lasting for a total of 215 days were conducted by regulating key process parameters. Principal components analysis revealed significant effects of the substrate ratio (SR) and volumetric exchange ratio (VER) on anammox performance, while other parameters (cycle time, hydraulic retention time and nitrogen loading rate) played minor roles. The highest removal efficiencies for ammonia and total nitrogen, respectively, reached 99.8% and 95.3% under optimal conditions. High-throughput sequencing found the anammox species Candidatus Brocadia and Candidatus Kuenenia made up as much as 8.5% and 3.5%, respectively, of the microbial community. Redundancy analysis indicated that these taxa were also greatly influenced by operating parameters, particularly SR and VER. This research helps to decode the correlations among nitrogen removal capacity, process parameters and the microbial community to enhance anammox in an AnSBBR system.

Critical Analysis of Biomass Retention Strategies in Mainstream and Sidestream ANAMMOX-Mediated Nitrogen Removal Systems

ANAMMOX (anaerobic ammonium oxidation) represents an energy-efficient process for biological nitrogen removal, particularly from wastewater streams with low chemical oxygen demand (COD) to nitrogen (C/N) ratios. Its widespread application, however, is still hampered by a lack of access to biomass-enriched with ANAMMOX bacteria (AMX), slow growth rates of AMX, and their sensitivity to inhibition. Although the coupling of ANAMMOX processes with partial nitrification is already widespread, especially for sidestream treatment, maintaining a functional population density of AMX remains a challenge in these systems. Therefore, strategies that maximize retention of AMX-rich biomass are essential to promote process stability. This paper reviews existing methods of biomass retention in ANAMMOX-mediated systems, focusing on (i) granulation; (ii) biofilm formation on carrier materials; (iii) gel entrapment; and (iv) membrane technology in mainstream and sidestream systems. In addition, the microbial ecology of different ANAMMOX-mediated systems is reviewed.

Temperature modulates stress response in mainstream anammox reactors

Autotrophic nitrogen removal by anaerobic ammonium oxidizing (anammox) bacteria is an energy-efficient nitrogen removal process in wastewater treatment. However, full-scale deployment under mainstream conditions remains challenging for practitioners due to the high stress susceptibility of anammox bacteria towards fluctuations in dissolved oxygen (DO) and temperature. Here, we investigated the response of microbial biofilms with verified anammox activity to DO shocks under 20 °C and 14 °C. While pulse disturbances of 0.3 mg L-1 DO prompted only moderate declines in the NH4+ removal rates, 1.0 mg L-1 DO led to complete but reversible inhibition of the NH4+ removal activity in all reactors. Genome-centric metagenomics and metatranscriptomics were used to investigate the stress response on various biological levels. We show that temperature regime and strength of DO perturbations induced divergent responses from the process level down to the transcriptional profile of individual taxa. Community-wide gene expression differed significantly depending on the temperature regime in all reactors, and we found a noticeable impact of DO disturbances on genes involved in transcription, translation, replication and posttranslational modification at 20 °C but not 14 °C. Genome-centric analysis revealed that different anammox species and other key biofilm taxa differed in their transcriptional responses to distinct temperature regimes and DO disturbances.

Anammox process dosed with biochars for enhanced nitrogen removal: Role of surface functional groups

Biochar is an inexpensive redox-active carbon material that has been demonstrated to enhance microbial nitrogen-transforming processes. However, how redox-active biochar affects anammox remains unclear. Here, the effects of three functionally distinct biochars produced from corn stover biomass at varied pyrolysis temperatures (CS300, CS500, CS800) were evaluated as additives on the anammox performance in three reactors (R300, R550, R800) over the long term, during which nitrogen loading rate was either increased drastically (pulse strategy) or gradually (gradual strategy). Nitrogen removal was achieved at 86.5% (R300), 77.1% (Control), 59.3% (R550) and 57.7% (R800) under pulse strategy, and at 95.4% (R300), 92.3% (R550), 86.2% (Control) and 82.0% (R800) under gradual strategy, respectively. Compared with Control, addition of CS300 increased abundance of Candidatus Kuenenia with superior anammox activity. CS300 enriched with reduced functional groups (phenolic/hydroquinone) could donate electrons to support bioenergetics of anammox metabolism, whereas electron-accepting CS800 functioned inversely. Overall, this study highlights the importance of surface functional groups and redox property of biochar such that determines whether its addition impose stimulatory or suppressive effect on anammox process.

Anammox attachment and biofilm development on surface-modified carriers with planktonic- and biofilm-based inoculation

This study investigates the kinetics, attachment, biofilm development and anammox bacteria enrichment of a novel detached anammox biofilm inoculation method on non-modified virgin MBBR carriers and pre-seeded denitrifying carriers. The study compares these results to the more common use of attached anammox carriers for anammox MBBR inoculation. The anammox bacteria specific attachment-growth rates for virgin carriers inoculated with detached anammox biofilm mass were 38.1% greater for the first 25 days, leading to approximately 30% less time required to achieve complete biofilm coverage than those measured in attached biofilm carrier inoculated systems during the attachment and early biofilm growth stages. The biofilm thickness increase rate was also 52.3% higher for virgin carriers with detached biofilm inoculum. Further, inoculation using pre-seeded denitrifying carriers compared to virgin carriers demonstrated a 13.8% preferential increase in anammox bacteria specific attachment-growth rate and a corresponding 47.2% higher NH₄⁺-N removal rate at the time of biofilm maturation.

Larger Anammox Granules not only Harbor Higher Species Diversity but also Support More Functional Diversity

Granule-based partial nitritation and anammox (PN/A) represents one of the most energy-efficient biotechniques for ammonium removal from wastewater. The PN/A granules appear in a continuum of sizes, yet little is known about the extent to which microbial communities and microbial metabolisms are partitioned between size-fractionated granules. Here, we divided granules harvested from a pilot-scale PN/A reactor into five discrete size fractions (<0.2, 0.2-0.5, 0.5-0.8, 0.8-1.0, and >1.0 mm). The composition and functional attribute of five pools of the size-fractionated granules were characterized by 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene amplicon and metagenomic and metatranscriptomic sequencing to provide a comprehensive insight into the key microbial group in a PN/A system. Larger granules were shown to not only harbor higher microbial diversity but also support more diverse functions than smaller granules. De novo coassembly and binning of metagenomic reads yielded 22 draft genomes of dominant microorganisms, which allowed us to infer an ecological model of the microbial ecosystem in anammox-based granules. This genome-based ecological model indicates that nitrifying organisms in smaller granules feed nitrite to anammox bacteria in larger granules. The results improve our understanding of the PN/A system, especially for the metabolic interactions between small and large granules.

Review of characteristics of anammox bacteria and strategies for anammox start-up for sustainable wastewater resource management

Wastewater management has experienced different stages, including pollutant removal, resource recovery, and water nexus. Within these stages, anaerobic ammonia oxidation-based biotechnology can be incorporated for nitrogen removal, which can help achieve sustainable wastewater management, such as reclamation and ecologization of wastewater. Here, the physiology, metabolism, reaction kinetics and microbial interactions of anammox bacteria are discussed, and strategies to start-up the anammox system are presented. Anammox bacteria are slow growers with a high doubling time and a low reaction rate. Although most anammox bacteria grow autotrophically, some types can grow mixotrophically. The reaction stoichiometric coefficients can be affected by loading rates and other biological reactions. Microbial interactions also contribute to enhanced biological nitrogen removal and promote activities of anammox bacteria. The start-up of the anammox process is the key aspect for its practical application, which can be realized through seed selection, system stimulation, and biomass concentration enhancement.

Fast start-up of PN/A process in a single-stage packed bed and mechanism of nitrogen removal

The single-stage partial nitritation-anammox (PN/A) process is severely limited by a long start-up time and unstable removal efficiency. In this study, PN/A was developed in 67 days in a novel packed bed equipped with porous bio-carriers by gradually increasing the influent nitrogen loading rate (0.15-0.73 kg-N m^-3·d^-1) and controlling the dissolved oxygen (< 1.2 mg L^-1). An average ammonium nitrogen removal efficiency (ARE) and total nitrogen removal efficiency (TNR) of 87.01 and 72.41%, respectively, were obtained. This represents a reliable alternative method of achieving rapid PN/A start-up. The results of 16S rRNA sequencing showed that Proteobacteria and Planctomycetes, with which ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and anammox bacteria were affiliated, accounted for 38.8%, representing the dominant phylum in the system after acclimation. The abundance of Nitrosomonas and Candidatus Brocadia increased by 16 and 1.79%, respectively. The results of metagenomics and metatranscriptomics revealed that the nitrite oxidation process was blocked by the transcriptional suppression of nitrite oxidoreductase and the entire nitrogen metabolism process was dominated by the partial nitritation and anammox process. Moreover, a high abundance of heterotrophic bacteria with potential for nitrogen removal was detected. In the nitrogen cycle, a widespread nitrite-accumulated denitrification helps to form a nitrite loop, which promotes the efficiency of total nitrogen removal. This is crucial for further improving the nitrogen removal mechanism in the PN/A system.

Successful establishment of partial denitrification by introducing hydrolytic acidification of slowly biodegradable organic matter

Partial denitrification (PD, nitrate → nitrite) was successfully established in this study by introducing hydrolytic acidification (HA) of slowly biodegradable organic matter (SBOM). A high selectivity for the nitrate over nitrite as electron acceptors was obtained during a 178-day long-term operation, with the nitrate to nitrite transformation ratio climbing to 81.3% at an influent SBOM of 286 mg/L and low-strength nitrate of 40 mg/L. Acetate (33.9%) and dissolved saccharide (19.3%), as the major SBOM HA products, indeed facilitated high-efficiency nitrite production by serving as favorable electron donors. This was well explained by the metagenomic analysis that the dominant Dechloromonas and Thauera denitrifying genera, which hold 3.9 times higher abundance of nitrate reductase than nitrite reductase, also played a key role in carbon glycolysis and acidification. This study provides new insight into PD development in multiple types of wastewater for the versatile carbon/nitrogen metabolism of functional bacteria.

Targeted metagenomics reveals extensive diversity of the denitrifying community in partial nitritation anammox and activated sludge systems

The substantial presence of denitrifiers has already been reported in partial nitritation anammox (PNA) systems using the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene, but little is known about the phylogenetic diversity based on denitrification pathway functional genes. Therefore, we performed a metagenomic analysis to determine the distribution of denitrification genes and the associated phylogeny in PNA systems and whether a niche separation between PNA and conventional activated sludge (AS) systems exists. The results revealed a distinct abundance pattern of denitrification pathway genes and their association to the microbial species between PNA and AS systems. In contrast, the taxonomic analysis, based on the 16S rRNA gene, did not detect notable variability in denitrifying community composition across samples. In general, narG and nosZa2 genes were dominant in all samples. While the potential for different stages of denitrification was redundant, variation in species composition and lack of the complete denitrification gene pool in each species appears to confer niche separation between PNA and AS systems. This study suggests that targeted metagenomics can help to determine the denitrifying microbial composition at a fine-scale resolution while overcoming current biases in quantitative polymerase chain reaction approaches due to a lack of appropriate primers.

Comparative Genome-Centric Analysis of Freshwater and Marine ANAMMOX Cultures Suggests Functional Redundancy in Nitrogen Removal Processes

There is a lack of understanding of the interaction between anammox bacteria and the flanking microbial communities in both freshwater (non-saline) and marine (saline) ecosystems. Here, we present a comparative genome-based exploration of two different anammox bioreactors, through the analysis of 23 metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs), 12 from freshwater anammox reactor (FWR), and 11 from marine anammox reactor (MWR). To understand the contribution of individual members to community functions, we applied the index of replication (iRep) to determine bacteria that are actively replicating. Using genomic content and iRep information, we provided a potential ecological role for the dominant members of the community based on the reactor operating conditions. In the non-saline system, anammox (Candidatus Brocadia sinica) and auxotrophic neighboring bacteria belonging to the phyla Ignavibacteriae and Chloroflexi might interact to reduce nitrate to nitrite for direct use by anammox bacteria. Whereas, in the saline reactor, anammox bacterium (Ca. Scalindua erythraensis) and flanking community belonging to phyla Planctomycetes (different than anammox bacteria)—which persistently growing in the system—may catabolize detritus and extracellular material and recycle nitrate to nitrite for direct use by anammox bacteria. Despite different microbial communities, there was functional redundancy in both ecosystems. These results signify the potential application of marine anammox bacteria for treating saline N-rich wastewaters.

Soil anammox and denitrification processes connected with N cycling genes co-supporting or contrasting under different water conditions

The anaerobic ammonium oxidizing bacteria (anammox) are the hidden culprit behind the excessive nitrogen loss under a favorable environment, since their detection and abundance get disturbed by several unknown factors. This study intends to find the gap between actual anammox working capacity under different water conditions and fertilizers in the laboratory. The ¹⁵N-isotopic tracer technique was used to measure anammox and denitrification rate, and anammox community structure was analyzed through high-throughput sequencing with cytochrome cd-1 nitrite reductase functional gene (an_nirS gene, initially found in Candidatus Scalindua). The experiment consisted of four treatments, i.e., (I) CK_ Control, (II) UR_Urea, (III) PM_Pig Manure, and (IV) SRF_ Slow release fertilizer, under two water conditions, i.e., (a) Continuous flooding_ CF, (b) Alternate wetting and drying_ AWD. Results showed that anammox under CF decreased over time by -40.24%, and denitrification increased up to 39.25%. However, anammox activity under AWD increased up to 10.62% with the availability of NO₂^-, and surprisingly accompanied by the reduction in denitrification loss (-31.97%), being the most critical factor. We found that soil nifH and AOB genes were strongly favorable for anammox activity, while we observed the presence of anammox and AOB genes co-existing at the same time in paddy soil. The high-throughput sequencing with an_nirS functional gene showed a much higher diversity of anammox genera ever reported, mostly uncultured and unidentified. We concluded that water management is more prominent than fertilizer for anammox, and the most critical factor is the duration of AWD cycle, because of short term air supply could boost anammox activity and gene abundance, and could reduce denitrifier activity as well as nirK gene abundance.