1984: all idiotypes are equal, but some are more equal than others

A cascade reaction network mimicking the basic functional steps of adaptive immune response

Biological systems use complex ‘information-processing cores’ composed of molecular networks to coordinate their external environment and internal states. An example of this is the acquired, or adaptive, immune system (AIS), which is composed of both humoral and cell-mediated components. Here we report the step-by-step construction of a prototype mimic of the AIS that we call an adaptive immune response simulator (AIRS). DNA and enzymes are used as simple artificial analogues of the components of the AIS to create a system that responds to specific molecular stimuli in vitro. We show that this network of reactions can function in a manner that is superficially similar to the most basic responses of the vertebrate AIS, including reaction sequences that mimic both humoral and cellular responses. As such, AIRS provides guidelines for the design and engineering of artificial reaction networks and molecular devices.

A cascade reaction network has been created that can function in a manner that is superficially similar to the most basic steps of the vertebrate adaptive immune response. This reaction network uses DNA and enzymes as simple artificial analogues of the components of the acquired immune system.

Moloney leukemia virus-induced cell surface antigen mimicry by monoclonal antibodies

We have investigated antigen-independent modulation of immune responses by monoclonal antibodies directed against both viral and nonviral antigens. BALB/c mice were immunized with monoclonal IgM (i.e. Ab1) specific for either Moloney murine leukemia virus-induced cell surface antigen (MCSA) or the hapten 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP). Injection with either Ab1 activated a functional idiotypic (Id) network as evidenced by production of both anti-Id (Ab2) antibodies and anti-anti-Id (Ab3) antibodies. A subset of induced Ab3 (designated Ab1'), exhibited specificity for antigen (virus or DNP). In mice immunized with anti-Id antibodies (Ab2), production of Ab3 and Ab1' was also observed. In the MCSA system, antibody-induced Ab1' responses were effective in protecting mice from tumor development upon subsequent challenge with live virus. Furthermore, antigen-independent modulation of immunity to both viral and nonviral antigens was found to be thymus-dependent. Similar findings in other viral systems suggest that antibody-induced activation of Id networks may prove a viable alternative vaccine strategy that can elicit antigen-specific responses, and in some cases protection, in the apparent absence of exposure to antigen.

The developmental patterns of B cell precursors distinguishing between environmental and nonenvironmental forms of phosphocholine

We have analyzed the developmental patterns of two groups of B cell precursors in nonimmunized BALB/c mice with respect to their relative proportions, absolute frequencies, V gene usage, fine specificity, and avidity for antigen. One group of B cells (group I) secretes antibodies specific for PC and PC-containing bacteria, whereas the other group (group II) produces antibodies recognizing only nonenvironmental PC-protein conjugates. A marked shift in the proportions of group I and group II occurs during ontogeny: while the group I B cells dominate (greater than 85%) the adult antibody repertoire, the group II B cells have equal representation in neonatal mice from Days 1 to 7, and remain as a significant portion until 2 weeks of age. Examination of the absolute frequencies of group I and group II B cells revealed that the frequency of group II B cells remained relatively stable throughout ontogeny, whereas group I B cells expanded rapidly after 7 days of age to predominate in the adult. Genetic analysis indicated that early group I antibodies were encoded by VH and VL genes different from adult group I antibodies which are mostly encoded by a single VH (S107) and VL (V kappa 22) gene combination (the T15 idiotype). On the other hand, early group II antibodies used VH genes comparable to their adult counterparts. The majority of early group I antibodies have lower avidity for PC than adult T15+ antibodies, whereas the avidity of neonatal group II antibodies varies considerably and is comparable with that of the adult group II antibodies. Our results suggest that the ontogeny of phosphocholine-specific B cells may be regulated according to their fine specificity rather than to their avidity or V gene usage.

An evolutionarily-conserved role for murine Ly-1 B cells in protection against bacterial infections

The murine Ly-1 B cell lineage, although comprising only a minority of peripheral IgM+ B cells, secretes a major proportion of the IgM antibodies occurring naturally in serum. Ly-1 B cells also seed a large number of IgA+ plasma cells to the gut walls, thereby contributing significantly to production of natural IgA antibodies in response to chronic stimulation by the normal gut flora. Apart from these naturally-produced antibodies, Ly-1 B cells also produce specific antibodies following deliberate immunisation with the bacterial cell wall antigens, phosphorylcholine and dextran. The inability of the X-linked immunodeficient CBA/N mice to produce antibody responses to these two antigens is overcome by reconstitution with normal Ly-1 B cells from the parental CBA strain. Ly-1 B cells therefore appear to play a dominant role in natural immunity and protection against bacterial infections. The compartmentalisation of development and function within murine B cells is suggestive of an evolutionary structuring of the murine immune system, with Ly-1 B cells representing a conserved, primitive B cell lineage and retaining key, associated functions.

A simple model for the immune network

In this note I present a simple model for the idiotypic network among antibodies and study its relevance for the maintenance of immunological memory; in particular, the memory capacity of such a model is studied. Some of the similarities with the spin glass model and with neural networks are discussed.

Idiotypic networks incorporating T-B cell co-operation. The conditions for percolation

Previous work was concerned with symmetric immune networks of idiotypic interactions amongst B cell clones. The behaviour of these networks was contrary to expectations. This was caused by an extensive percolation of idiotypic signals. Idiotypic activation was thus expected to affect almost all (greater than 10(7] B cell clones. We here analyse whether the incorporation of helper T cells (Th) into these B cell models could cause a reduction in the percolation. Empirical work on idiotypic interactions between Th and B cells however, would suggest that two different idiotypic Th models should be developed: (1) a Th which recognises native B cell idiotypes, i.e. a non-MHC-restricted "ThId" model, and (2) a "classical" MHC-restricted helper T cell model. In the ThId model, the Th-B cell interaction is symmetric. A 2-D model of a Th and a B cell clone that interact idiotypically with each other accounts for various equilibria (i.e. one virgin and two immune states). Introduction of antigen does indeed lead to a state switch from the virgin to the immune state; such a system is thus able to "remember" its exposure to antigen. Idiotypic signals do however, percolate in ThId models via these "B-Th-B-Th" pathways: proliferating Th and B cell clones that interact idiotypically, will always activate each other reciprocally. In the MHC-restricted Th model, Th-B interactions are asymmetric. Because the B cell idiotypes are processed and subsequently presented by MHC molecules, the Th receptor and the native B cell receptor are not expected to be complementary. Thus the Th and the B cells are unable to activate each other reciprocally, and a 2-D Th-B cell model cannot account for idiotypic memory. In contrast to the ThId model, idiotypic activation cannot percolate via "B-Th-B-Th" interactions. Due to the assymmetry idiotypic activation stops at the first Th level. A Th clone cannot activate a subsequent B cell clone: if the B cells recognise the Th cells, they see idiotype but get no help; if the Th cells see the B cells, the B cells are helped but see no idiotype. The percolation along "B-B-B" pathways in these two models is next analysed. Two B cells clones, each helped by one Th clone, are connected by a symmetric idiotypic interaction. It turns out that in both models the second (i.e. anti-idiotypic) B cells (B2) never proliferate.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Binding specificity of antiidiotypic autoantibodies to anti-DNA antibodies in humans

Human antiidiotypic antibodies to anti-DNA antibodies can be separated into at least two categories based on their binding to anti-DNA, antiidiotypic antibodies, and antigens. One type was found mainly in inactive stage of SLE. The antiidiotypic antibodies appear to be directed towards idiotype (Id) determinants in the antigen-binding sites of anti-DNA antibodies. Antibody from patient T.K. acted like a mirror image of anti-single-stranded DNA antibodies, O-81, as determined by a competitive inhibition RIA. Antibodies from patient S.U. also seemed to be Ab 2 beta and Ab 2 gamma to anti-double-stranded(ds) DNA antibodies, NE-1. Most of normal subjects, on the other hand, had antibodies that bound to the human monoclonal anti-ds DNA antibodies, NE-1, NE-13, 7F4, and O-81. The Id-anti-Id interaction was not inhibited by the addition of DNA. Thus, normal subjects had Ab2 alpha activity that recognizes Id determinants in the framework region common among anti-DNA antibodies, whereas antiidiotypic antibodies in most SLE sera appear to show Ab 2 beta and Ab 2 gamma activity. The results provide evidence that the Id network system regulates immunological tolerance to DNA in humans.

Evolution of antibody variable region structure during the immune response

The results reviewed above reveal that during the anti-Ars immune response of strain A mice a somatic process that results in the evolution of V region structure occurs. This process involves both the selection of V regions encoded by particular gene segment combinations as well as the selection of structural variants of these V regions produced by somatic mutation as the immune response progresses. As a result, both quantitative and qualitative changes in the V region population initially elicited by immunization take place. The structural and functional character of the immune V region repertoire appears to be largely determined by this process of "somatic evolution" occurring in the primary response.

Parallel sets of autoantibodies in MRL-lpr/lpr mice. An anti-DNA, anti-SmRNP, anti-gp70 network

The public idiotype Id-H130 occurs in MRL-lpr/lpr serum both on a high proportion of anti-DNA autoantibodies as well as on antibodies that do not bind to DNA. To define members of the latter population, we prepared hybridomas and selected Id-H130+ mAbs that did not bind to DNA. One such antibody, mAb 28/12, was found to be an anti-SmRNP antibody. To determine whether mAb 28/12 had rheumatoid factor activity, we tested its ability to bind, in a solid-phase assay, to 16 mouse IgM mAbs. mAb 28/12 bound to only four of the panel, two anti-DNA antibodies (mAbs 512 and 319) and two anti-gp70 antibodies (mAbs 514 and 1417). In a liquid-phase competition assay with a panel of 32 monoclonal IgM and IgG antibodies, including allotype-matched Igs, mAb 28/12 reacted only with mAbs 512, 319, 514, and 1417. The binding of mAb 28/12 to mAbs 512 and 319 was displaced by DNA, but not by RNA, indicating that the idiotype it defines (Id-28/12) is in the antigen-binding region of the two anti-DNA antibodies. In the two anti-gp70 antibodies (mAbs 514 and 1417), Id-28/12 seems to occur in the framework region. To determine if all four Id-28/12+ antibodies shared a common antigen-binding property, they were tested for their ability to react with DNA and gp70. The two anti-gp70 antibodies did not bind to DNA. However, the two anti-DNA antibodies were found to immunoprecipitate viral proteins from retrovirus-infected cells. mAb 512 reacted with gp70, both in cell membrane lysates and in purified form; mAb 319 reacted with gp85, which contains both gp70 and the retroviral protein p15. Antibodies with properties similar to those of mAb 28/12 were found in MRL-lpr/lpr serum. It was possible, by affinity chromatography on an anti-gp70 antibody column, to isolate from serum those anti-(anti-gp70) antibodies with anti-SmRNP activity. These results show that parallel sets of autoantibodies, which share a common idiotype, but which bind to different autoantigens, occur in MRL-lpr/lpr mice. Some populations of anti-DNA, anti-SmRNP, and anti-gp70 antibodies appear to constitute a network of autoantibodies in that strain. We speculate that part of the anti-SmRNP population of autoantibodies can arise by mutation of germline-encoded anti-DNA antibodies.

Influence of a minor recurrent idiotype on the regulation of immune response: route dependence

Sp6, a BALB/c hybridoma, produces anti-TNP IgM antibodies (AB), which carry a minor recurrent idiotype (ID). Despite the fact that only about 20% of BALB/c anti-TNP AB carry the Sp6 ID, injection of Sp6-coated spleen cells (Sp6-SC) significantly influenced the anti-TNP B cell response. Repeated intratrail (i.t.) or intravenous (i.v.) injections of Sp6-SC resulted only in a minor increase of the anti-TNP background response. When mice consecutively were challenged with TNP-horse red blood cells (HRBC), i.t. injections of Sp6-SC resulted in a 2-3-fold increase in the number of anti-TNP plaque-forming cells (PFC), while i.v. injection of Sp6-SC displayed no effect on a primary anti-TNP response. But, after i.v. as well as i.t. application of Sp6-SC, it was not possible to obtain hapten-specific suppression by i.v. injection of TNP-haptenized lymphocytes. In vitro characterization of the underlying mechanism revealed that the helper effect, which only was observed after i.t. injection, was due to a Lyt-1+ population, not adhering to Sp6-coated plates, while counterregulation of hapten-specific suppression was found in a Lyt-2+ population, adhering to Sp6-coated plates. Hence, depending on the route of priming, injection of AB with a recurrent ID can augment the response towards the nominal antigen either directly via activation of helper cells or indirectly via activation of counterregulatory cells.

Suppression of in vitro human antithyroglobulin antibody secretion by private and cross-reactive anti-idiotypic antibodies

This is a report on suppression of in vitro human antithyroglobulin antibody secretion in Epstein-Barr (EB) virus-transformed B lymphocytes by private and cross-reactive anti-idiotypic antibodies. Two polyclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies, private anti-Yo-Id and cross-reactive anti-Uc-Id antibodies, were raised in rabbits. Human IgG, lambda antithyroglobulin antibody-producing cell line (Yo3) and human IgG-producing cell line (Yo5), which did not contain the antithyroglobulin activity were established by EB virus transformation of peripheral lymphocytes of patient Yo with chronic thyroiditis. Binding of anti-Yo-Id and anti-Uc-Id antibodies to IgG F(ab')2 antithyroglobulin derived from patient Yo was significantly inhibited by human thyroglobulin and affinity-purified IgG antithyroglobulin of Yo3 cell line. Both private anti-Yo-Id and cross-reactive anti-Uc-Id antibodies suppressed the antithyroglobulin antibody secretion in Yo3 cell line. But these anti-idiotypic antibodies did not suppress the IgG secretion in Yo5 cell line. These results suggested that interactions between idiotype and anti-idiotype may play a role in the immune system of human chronic thyroiditis.

In vitro production of an anti-DNA idiotype by lymphocytes of normal subjects and patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

We investigated whether normal B cells can synthesize antibodies with an idiotypic marker that occurs with high frequency in anti-DNA antibodies of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). This idiotype, Id16/6, has been found in the serum of patients with active SLE and in monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies derived from unrelated patients with the disease. We found that cultured lymphocytes of all normal subjects tested produced Id16/6 when stimulated by pokeweed mitogen (PWM). By contrast, lymphocytes from SLE patients produced Id16/6 even without mitogenic stimulation, whether or not they were obtained from patients in remission or relapse. Relapsed patients' lymphocytes spontaneously produced the highest levels of Id16/6 which was found in IgG and IgA, in addition to IgM. The majority of Id16/6 produced by PWM-stimulated lymphocytes from either normal subjects or patients in remission did not bind to nucleic acid. In relapse, however, the nucleic acid-binding proportion of Id16/6 rose substantially, indicating that the spontaneously activated B cells in active SLE differ from the subset of B cells that produce Id16/6 upon PWM stimulation. The findings suggest that the lupus Id16/6 family is conserved in normal individuals and it consists of two populations of antibodies with different antigenic specificities. The major set is not directed against nucleic acid antigens; its antigenic specificity is unknown and it dominates the Id16/6 family that appears after PWM stimulation. The other, minor set binds to nucleic acids and becomes prominent in clinically active lupus. These two sets of idiotypically related antibodies may be connected by an immunoregulatory network.

A rapid and efficient immunization protocol for production of monoclonal antibodies reactive with autoantigens

A simple, time-saving and efficient immunization method suitable for the production of mouse monoclonal antibody secreting hybridomas is described. Draining lymph nodes isolated 9 days after a primary immunization were used as the source of antibody producing cells. No systemic spread of antibody producing cells or specific antibodies could be detected. The present protocol was employed to generate a panel of collagen type II reactive monoclonal antibodies. Most of the monoclonals so generated were found to be of the IgG class.

Establishment of idiotypic helper T-cell repertoires early in life

Immunoglobulin variable-region (V) genes, it is now recognized, do not encode specific receptors for T lymphocytes. Classical observations on T-cell expression of immunoglobulin idiotypes had remained unexplained until recent experiments showed that immunoglobulin idiotypes expressed by T lymphocytes in normal mice are absent in cells of the same specificity isolated from donors whose B-cell system has been suppressed by administration of anti-mu antibodies from birth. This observation provided evidence for the 'learning' of T-cell idiotypes from the B-cell/antibody system and, therefore, for the importance of idiotypic network interactions in the selection of available lymphocyte repertoires before antigenic challenge. Previously described influences of B cells and/or antibodies on the T-helper (Th) cell compartment would appear to operate at the level of clonal repertoires by complementarities with defined immunoglobulin idiotypes. Other authors, however, had previously shown the striking stability of T-cell idiotype expression in chimaeric animals reconstituted with T and B cells originating from donors showing differential idiotype expression. We have now investigated this apparent discrepancy and present here results demonstrating that immunoglobulin-dependent selection of T-cell (idiotypic) repertoires only operates for the first 3 weeks of life.

Helper T cells reacting to idiotype on IgG but not IgM

Immunization with an IgG1 but not an IgM monoclonal anti-NP (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl) antibody induced idiotype-recognizing T helper cells, although these two antibodies carry the same variable regions. The T cells appear to react to an idiotype on the IgG1 but not the IgM antibody. They selectively enhance the expression of that idiotype in the IgG1 fraction of an in vitro anti-NP response.

Immunochemical similarities between monoclonal antibacterial Waldenstrom's macroglobulins and monoclonal anti-DNA lupus autoantibodies

Six monoclonal IgM from patients with Waldenstrom's macroglobulinemia that react with Klebsiella polysaccharides were tested for their ability to bind to nucleic acid antigens. One of the macroglobulins bound to the polynucleotide poly(G), and one bound to poly(G), poly(I), and single-stranded DNA. The reaction with the polynucleotides was specifically inhibited by the Klebsiella polysaccharide K30. A monoclonal lupus anti-DNA antibody (16/6) was found to react weakly with the Klebsiella polysaccharides K30 and K21. Five of the Waldenstrom macroglobulins shared an idiotypic determinant with the 16/6 anti-DNA antibody. The reaction between the macroglobulins and the antiidiotype serum was specifically inhibited by Klebsiella polysaccharides, an indication that the idiotypic marker was in the antigen-binding site of the macroglobulins. These results indicate the existence of widely dispersed conserved variable region genes that encode idiotypically related immunoglobulins with the capacity to bind to both bacterial polysaccharides and nucleic acids. Such genes can be expressed by patients with either Waldenstrom's macroglobulinemia or systemic lupus erythematosus.

Origins of anti-DNA autoantibodies

Images