Biocontrol of the Potato Blackleg and Soft Rot Diseases Caused by Dickeya dianthicola

Unveiling the frontiers of potato disease research through bibliometric analysis

Research on potato diseases had been widely reported, but a systematic review of potato diseases was lacking. Here, bibliometrics was used to systematically analyze the progress of potato disease. The publications related to "potato" and "disease" were searched in the Web of Science (WOS) from 2014 to 2023. The results showed that a total of 2095 publications on potato diseases were retrieved, with the annual publication output increasing year by year at a growth rate of 8.52%. The main countries where publications were issued were the United States, China, and India. There was relatively close cooperation observed between China, the United States, and the United Kingdom in terms of international collaboration, while international cooperation by India was less extensive. Based on citation analysis and trending topics, potential future research directions include nanoparticles, which provides highly effective carriers for biologically active substances due to their small dimensions, extensive surface area, and numerous binding sites; machine learning, which facilitates rapid identification of relevant targets in extensive datasets, thereby accelerating the process of disease diagnosis and fungicide innovation; and synthetic communities composed of various functional microorganisms, which demonstrate more stable effects in disease prevention and control.

Multilocus sequence and phenotypic analysis of Pectobacterium and Dickeya type strains for identification of soft rot Pectobacteriaceae from symptomatic potato stems and tubers in Pennsylvania

Outbreaks of potato blackleg and soft rot caused by Pectobacterium species and more recently Dickeya species across the U.S. mid-Atlantic region have caused yield loss due to poor emergence as well as losses from stem and tuber rot. To develop management strategies for soft rot diseases, we must first identify which members of the soft rot Pectobacteriaceae are present in regional potato plantings. However, the rapidly expanding number of soft rot Pectobacteriaceae species and the lack of readily available comparative data for type strains of Pectobacterium and Dickeya hinder quick identification. This manuscript provides a comparative analysis of soft rot Pectobacteriaceae and a comprehensive comparison of type strains from this group using rep-PCR, MLSA and 16S sequence analysis, as well as phenotypic and physiological analyses using Biolog GEN III plates. These data were used to identify isolates cultured from symptomatic potato stems collected between 2016 and 2018. The isolates were characterized for phenotypic traits and by sequence analysis to identify the bacteria from potatoes with blackleg and soft rot symptoms in Pennsylvania potato fields. In this survey, P. actinidiae, P. brasiliense, P. polonicum, P. polaris, P. punjabense, P. parmentieri, and P. versatile were identified from Pennsylvania for the first time. Importantly, the presence of P. actinidiae in Pennsylvania represents the first report of this organism in the U.S. As expected, P. carotorvorum and D. dianthicola were also isolated. In addition to a resource for future work studying the Dickeya and Pectobacterium associated with potato blackleg and soft rot, we provide recommendations for future surveys to monitor for quarantine or emerging soft rot Pectobacteriace regionally.

Simply Versatile: The Use of Peribacillus simplex in Sustainable Agriculture

Peribacillus simplex is a Gram-positive, spore-forming bacterium derived from a vast range of different origins. Notably, it is part of the plant-growth-promoting rhizobacterial community of many crops. Although members of the Bacillaceae family have been widely used in agriculture, P. simplex has, so far, remained in the shadow of its more famous relatives, e.g., Bacillus subtilis or Bacillus thuringiensis. Recent studies have, however, started to uncover the bacterium's highly promising and versatile properties, in particular in agricultural and environmental applications. Hence, here, we review the plant-growth-promoting features of P. simplex, as well as its biocontrol activity against a variety of detrimental plant pests in different crops. We further highlight the bacterium's potential as a bioremediation agent for environmental contaminants, such as metals, pesticide residues, or (crude) oil. Finally, we examine the recent developments in the European regulatory landscape to facilitate the use of microorganisms in plant protection products. Undoubtedly, further studies on P. simplex will reveal additional benefits for agricultural and environmentally friendly applications.

Pseudomonas PA14H7: Identification and Quantification of the 7-Hydroxytropolone Iron Complex as an Active Metabolite against Dickeya, the Causal Agent of Blackleg on the Potato Plant

Soft rot Pectobacteriaceae (SRP), such as Pectobacterium and Dickeya, are phytopathogenic agents responsible for blackleg disease on several crops, such as potatoes, affecting the yield and depressing the seed production quality. However, neither conventional nor biocontrol products are available on the market to control this disease. In this study Pseudomonas PA14H7, a bacteria isolated from potato rhizosphere, was selected as a potential antagonist agent against Dickeya solani. In order to understand the mechanism involved in this antagonism, we managed to identify the main active molecule(s) produced by PA14H7. Cell-free supernatant (CFS) of PA14H7 cultures were extracted and analyzed using LC-MS, GC-MS, and NMR. We further correlated the biological activity against Dickeya solani of extracted CFS-PA14H7 to the presence of 7-hydroxytropolone (7-HT) complexed with iron. In a second time, we have synthesized this molecule and determined accurately using LC-UV, LC-MS, and GC-MS that, after 48 h incubation, PA14H7 released, in its CFS, around 9 mg/L of 7-HT. The biological activities of CFS-PA14H7 vs. synthetic 7-HT, at this concentration, were evaluated to have a similar bacteriostatic effect on the growth of Dickeya solani. Even if 7-HT is produced by other Pseudomonas species and is mostly known for its antibacterial and antifungal activities, this is the first description of its involvement as an effective molecule against pectinolytic bacteria. Our work opens the way for the comprehension of the mode of action of PA14H7 as a biocontrol agent against potato blackleg.

Biocontrol of Soft Rot Dickeya and Pectobacterium Pathogens by Broad-Spectrum Antagonistic Bacteria within Paenibacillus polymyxa Complex

Polymyxin-producing bacteria within the Paenibacillus polymyxa complex have broad-spectrum activities against fungi and bacteria. Their antibacterial activities against soft rot Dickeya and Pectobacterium phytopathogens containing multiple polymyxin-resistant genes were not clear. Here, we selected nine strains within the P. polymyxa complex having broad-spectrum antagonistic activities against phytopathogenic fungi and a polymyxin-resistant D. dadantii strain causing stem and root rot disease of sweet potato and did antagonistic assays on nutrient agar and sweet potato tuber slices. These strains within the P. polymyxa complex showed clear antagonistic activities against D. dadantii in vitro and in vivo. The most effective antagonistic strain P. polymyxa ShX301 showed broad-spectrum antagonistic activities against all the test Dickeya and Pectobacterium strains, completely eliminated D. dadantii from sweet potato seed tubers, and promoted the growth of sweet potato seedlings. Cell-free culture filtrate of P. polymyxa ShX301 inhibited D. dadantii growth, swimming motility, and biofilm formation and disrupted D. dadantii plasma membranes, releasing nucleic acids and proteins. Multiple lipopeptides produced by P. polymyxa ShX301 may play a major role in the bactericidal and bacteriostatic actions. This study clarifies that the antimicrobial spectrum of polymyxin-producing bacteria within the P. polymyxa complex includes the polymyxin-resistant Dickeya and Pectobacterium phytopathogens and strengthens the fact that bacteria within the P. polymyxa complex have high probability of being effective biocontrol agents and plant growth promoters.

Fengycin produced by Bacillus subtilis XF-1 plays a major role in the biocontrol of Chinese cabbage clubroot via direct effect and defense stimulation

Bacillus subtilis XF-1 is a well-investigated biocontrol agent against the biotrophic Plasmodiophora brassicae Woron., the causal agent of clubroot disease of cruciferous crops. The present study demonstrates that XF-1 could efficiently control clubroot disease via leaf spraying and provides an understanding of the biocontrol mechanisms. High-performance thin-layer chromatography (HTPLC) analysis indicated the presence of fengycin-type cyclopeptides in the supernatant. A ppsB deletion mutant of XF-1 resulted in no fengycin production, significantly reduced the lysis rate of testing spores in vitro and the primary infection rate of root hair in vivo, and decreased the protection value against clubroot disease under the greenhouse conditions. Confocal laser scanning microscopy proved that fengycin was not required for leaf internalization and root colonization. Moreover, the expression level of the ppsB gene in XF-1 was regulated by its cell density in root during interaction with P. brassicae. In addition, the ΔppsB mutant of XF-1 could not efficiently control disease because it led to a lower activation level of the jasmonic acid and salicylic acid signaling pathways in roots, which are necessary for the plant defense reaction upon pathogen invasion. Altogether, the present study provides a new understanding of specific cues in the interaction between B. subtilis and P. brassicae as well as insights into the application of B. subtilis in agriculture.

Efficacy of Soft-Rot Disease Biocontrol Agents in the Inhibition of Production Field Pathogen Isolates

The Dickeya and Pectobacterium bacterial species cause blackleg and soft-rot diseases on potato plants and tubers. Prophylactic actions are essential to conserve a high quality of seed potato tubers. Biocontrol approaches are emerging, but we need to know how efficient biocontrol agents are when facing the natural diversity of pathogens. In this work, we sampled 16 production fields, which were excluded from the seed tuber certification scheme, as well as seven experimental parcels, which were planted with seed tubers from those production fields. We collected and characterized 669 Dickeya and Pectobacterium isolates, all characterized using nucleotide sequence of the gapA gene. This deep sampling effort highlighted eleven Dickeya and Pectobacterium species, including four dominant species namely D. solani, D. dianthicola, P. atrosepticum and P. parmentieri. Variations in the relative abundance of pathogens revealed different diversity patterns at a field or parcel level. The Dickeya-enriched patterns were maintained in parcels planted with rejected seed tubers, suggesting a vertical transmission of the pathogen consortium. Then, we retained 41 isolates representing the observed species diversity of pathogens and we tested each of them against six biocontrol agents. From this work, we confirmed the importance of prophylactic actions to discard contaminated seed tubers. We also identified a couple of biocontrol agents of the Pseudomonas genus that were efficient against a wide range of pathogen species.

Development of a Bacteriophage Cocktail against Pectobacterium carotovorum Subsp. carotovorum and Its Effects on Pectobacterium Virulence

Pectobacterium carotovorum subsp. carotovorum is a necrotrophic plant pathogen that secretes plant cell wall-degrading enzymes (PCWDEs) that cause soft rot disease in various crops. Bacteriophages have been under consideration as harmless antibacterial agents to replace antibiotics and copper-based pesticides. However, the emergence of bacteriophage resistance is one of the main concerns that should be resolved for practical phage applications. In this study, we developed a phage cocktail with three lytic phages that recognize colanic acid (phage POP12) or flagella (phages POP15 and POP17) as phage receptors to minimize phage resistance. The phage cocktail effectively suppressed the emergence of phage-resistant P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum compared with single phages in in vitro challenge assays. The application of the phage cocktail to napa cabbage (Brassica rapa subsp. pekinensis) resulted in significant growth retardation of P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum (P < 0.05) and prevented the symptoms of soft rot disease. Furthermore, phage cocktail treatments of young napa cabbage leaves in a greenhouse environment indicated effective prevention of soft rot disease compared to that in the nonphage negative control. We isolated 15 phage-resistant mutants after a phage cocktail treatment to assess the virulence-associated phenotypes compared to those of wild-type (WT) strain Pcc27. All mutants showed reduced production of four different PCWDEs, leading to lower levels of tissue softening. Ten of the 15 phage-resistant mutants additionally exhibited decreased swimming motility. Taken together, these results show that the phage cocktail developed here, which targets two different types of phage receptors, provides an effective strategy for controlling P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum in agricultural products, with a potential ability to attenuate P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum virulence. IMPORTANCE Pectobacterium carotovorum subsp. carotovorum is a phytopathogen that causes soft rot disease in various crops by producing plant cell wall-degrading enzymes (PCWDEs). Although antibiotics and copper-based pesticides have been extensively applied to inhibit P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum, the emergence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria and demand for harmless antimicrobial products have emphasized the necessity of finding alternative therapeutic strategies. To address this problem, we developed a phage cocktail consisting of three P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum-specific phages that recognize colanic acids and flagella of P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum. The phage cocktail treatments significantly decreased P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum populations, as well as soft rot symptoms in napa cabbage. Simultaneously, they resulted in virulence attenuation in phage-resistant P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum, which was represented by decreased PCWDE production and decreased flagellum-mediated swimming motility. These results suggested that preparations of phage cocktails targeting multiple receptors would be an effective approach to biocontrol of P. carotovorum subsp. carotovorum in crops.

Comparative Genomics Insights into a Novel Biocontrol Agent Paenibacillus peoriae Strain ZF390 against Bacterial Soft Rot

Simple Summary

Bacterial soft rot, attributed to Pectobacterium brasiliense infection, has caused destructive impacts and colossal economic losses to China’s agricultural industry. Chemical control, which was ubiquitously used, cannot manage this disease as expected, so biocontrol has been followed with interest to date. In this study, we found a Paenibacillus peoriae strain ZF390 that had a potent control efficiency over cucumber plants against Pectobacterium brasiliense, and the comparative genomic analysis revealed biocontrol mechanisms might be involved in the strain ZF390.

Abstract

Bacterial soft rot, caused by Pectobacterium brasiliense, can infect several economically important horticultural crops. However, the management strategies available to control this disease are limited. Plant-growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) have been considered to be promising biocontrol agents. With the aim of obtaining a strain suitable for agricultural applications, 161 strains were isolated from the rhizosphere soil of healthy cucumber plants and screened through plate bioassays and greenhouse tests. Paenibacillus peoriae ZF390 exhibited an eminent control effect against soft rot disease and a broad antagonistic activity spectrum in vitro. Moreover, ZF390 showed good activities of cellulase, protease, and phosphatase and a tolerance of heavy metal. Whole-genome sequencing was performed and annotated to explore the underlying biocontrol mechanisms. Strain ZF390 consists of one 6,193,667 bp circular chromosome and three plasmids. Comparative genome analysis revealed that ZF390 involves ten gene clusters responsible for secondary metabolite antibiotic synthesis, matching its excellent biocontrol activity. Plenty of genes related to plant growth promotion, biofilm formation, and induced systemic resistance were mined to reveal the biocontrol mechanisms that might consist in strain ZF390. Overall, these findings suggest that strain ZF390 could be a potential biocontrol agent in bacterial-soft-rot management, as well as a source of antimicrobial mechanisms for further exploitation.

Rhizosphere Microbiomes of Potato Cultivated under Bacillus subtilis Treatment Influence the Quality of Potato Tubers

Plants serve as a niche for the growth and proliferation of a diversity of microorganisms. Soil microorganisms, which closely interact with plants, are increasingly being recognized as factors important to plant health. In this study, we explored the use of high-throughput DNA sequencing of the fungal ITS and bacterial 16S for characterization of the fungal and bacterial microbiomes following biocontrol treatment (DT) with Bacillus subtilis strain Bv17 relative to treatments without biocontrol (DC) during the potato growth cycle at three time points. A total of 5631 operational taxonomic units (OTUs) were identified from the 16S data, and 2236 OTUs were identified from the ITS data. The number of bacterial and fungal OTU in DT was higher than in DC and gradually increased during potato growth. In addition, indices such as Ace, Chao, Shannon, and Simpson were higher in DT than in DC, indicating greater richness and community diversity in soil following the biocontrol treatment. Additionally, the potato tuber yields improved without a measurable change in the bacterial communities following the B. subtilis strain Bv17 treatment. These results suggest that soil microbial communities in the rhizosphere are differentially affected by the biocontrol treatment while improving potato yield, providing a strong basis for biocontrol utilization in crop production.

Laboratory Assays Used to Rank Potato Cultivar Tolerance to Blackleg Showed That Tuber Vacuum Infiltration Results Correlate With Field Observations

Seed potato certification data collected in Colorado from 2012 to 2016 was used to rank potato cultivar tolerance to blackleg. Five cultivars with different tolerance levels to blackleg ('Chipeta' ≈ 'Alegria' ≈ 'Lamoka' < 'Classic Russet' < 'Yukon Gem') were tested to determine whether we could validate field data with laboratory assays. A strain isolated from Colorado, Pectobacterium atrosepticum CW1-4, and the P. atrosepticum type strain, 33260, were used to inoculate plants through vacuum infiltration of tubers or stem inoculation. Disease was assessed with time-lapse video and by measuring lesion length and disease incidence. After vacuum infiltration of tubers with P. atrosepticum CW1-4 and 33260, cultivars varied in tolerance to soft rot ('Lamoka' < 'Classic Russet' < 'Alegria' ≈ 'Yukon Gem' < 'Chipeta'). Blackleg tolerance of the five cultivars also varied after vacuum infiltration ('Lamoka' < 'Alegria' ≈ 'Chipeta' < 'Classic Russet' ≈ 'Yukon Gem'). All cultivars were susceptible after stem inoculation with either strain. In this assay, 'Chipeta' had the longest lesions, and 'Lamoka' had the smallest lesions. Time-lapse video was used to assess 'Classic Russet' and 'Yukon Gem.' 'Yukon Gem' developed disease symptoms faster than 'Classic Russet,' but the difference was not significant. These results indicate that relative susceptibility of the five cultivars to P. atrosepticum depends on the assay used and that laboratory and greenhouse results differed from field observations.

Biosensors Used for Epifluorescence and Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopies to Study Dickeya and Pectobacterium Virulence and Biocontrol

Promoter-probe vectors carrying fluorescent protein-reporter genes are powerful tools used to study microbial ecology, epidemiology, and etiology. In addition, they provide direct visual evidence of molecular interactions related to cell physiology and metabolism. Knowledge and advances carried out thanks to the construction of soft-rot Pectobacteriaceae biosensors, often inoculated in potato Solanum tuberosum, are discussed in this review. Under epifluorescence and confocal laser scanning microscopies, Dickeya and Pectobacterium-tagged strains managed to monitor in situ bacterial viability, microcolony and biofilm formation, and colonization of infected plant organs, as well as disease symptoms, such as cell-wall lysis and their suppression by biocontrol antagonists. The use of dual-colored reporters encoding the first fluorophore expressed from a constitutive promoter as a cell tag, while a second was used as a regulator-based reporter system, was also used to simultaneously visualize bacterial spread and activity. This revealed the chronology of events leading to tuber maceration and quorum-sensing communication, in addition to the disruption of the latter by biocontrol agents. The promising potential of these fluorescent biosensors should make it possible to apprehend other activities, such as subcellular localization of key proteins involved in bacterial virulence in planta, in the near future.

Pectobacterium brasiliense: Genomics, Host Range and Disease Management

Pectobacterium brasiliense (Pbr) is considered as one of the most virulent species among the Pectobacteriaceae. This species has a broad host range within horticulture crops and is well distributed elsewhere. It has been found to be pathogenic not only in the field causing blackleg and soft rot of potato, but it is also transmitted via storage causing soft rot of other vegetables. Genomic analysis and other cost-effective molecular detection methods such as a quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) are essential to investigate the ecology and pathogenesis of the Pbr. The lack of fast, field deployable point-of-care testing (POCT) methods, specific control strategies and current limited genomic knowledge make management of this species difficult. Thus far, no comprehensive review exists about Pbr, however there is an intense need to research the biology, detection, pathogenicity and management of Pbr, not only because of its fast distribution across Europe and other countries but also due to its increased survival to various climatic conditions. This review outlines the information available in peer-reviewed literature regarding host range, detection methods, genomics, geographical distribution, nomenclature and taxonomical evolution along with some of the possible management and control strategies. In summary, the conclusions and a further directions highlight the management of this species.

Pattern and causes of the establishment of the invasive bacterial potato pathogen Dickeya solani and of the maintenance of the resident pathogen D. dianthicola

Invasive pathogens can be a threat when they affect human health, food production or ecosystem services, by displacing resident species, and we need to understand the cause of their establishment. We studied the patterns and causes of the establishment of the pathogen Dickeya solani that recently invaded potato agrosystems in Europe by assessing its invasion dynamics and its competitive ability against the closely related resident D. dianthicola species. Epidemiological records over one decade in France revealed the establishment of D. solani and the maintenance of the resident D. dianthicola in potato fields exhibiting blackleg symptoms. Using experimentations, we showed that D. dianthicola caused a higher symptom incidence on aerial parts of potato plants than D. solani, while D. solani was more aggressive on tubers (i.e. with more severe symptoms). In co-infection assays, D. dianthicola outcompeted D. solani in aerial parts, while the two species co-existed in tubers. A comparison of 76 D. solani genomes (56 of which have been sequenced here) revealed balanced frequencies of two previously uncharacterized alleles, VfmB_Pro and VfmB_Ser , at the vfmB virulence gene. Experimental inoculations showed that the VfmB_Ser population was more aggressive on tubers, while the VfmB_Pro population outcompeted the VfmB_Ser population in stem lesions, suggesting an important role of the vfmB virulence gene in the ecology of the pathogens. This study thus brings novel insights allowing a better understanding of the pattern and causes of the D.solani invasion into potato production agrosystems, and the reasons why the endemic D. dianthicola nevertheless persisted.

Screening, Identification and Efficacy Evaluation of Antagonistic Bacteria for Biocontrol of Soft Rot Disease Caused by Dickeya zeae

Dickeya zeae is the causal agent of bacterial soft rot disease, with a wide range of hosts all over the world. At present, chemical agents, especially agricultural antibiotics, are commonly used in the prevention and control of bacterial soft rot, causing the emergence of resistant pathogens and therefore increasing the difficulty of disease prevention and control. This study aims to provide a safer and more effective biocontrol method for soft rot disease caused by D. zeae. The spot-on-lawn assay was used to screen antagonistic bacteria, and three strains including SC3, SC11 and 3-10 revealed strong antagonistic effects and were identified as Pseudomonas fluorescens, P. parafulva and Bacillus velezensis, respectively, using multi-locus sequence analysis (MLSA) based on the sequences of 16S rRNA and other housekeeping genes. In vitro antimicrobial activity showed that two Pseudomonas strains SC3 and SC11 were only antagonistic to some pathogenic bacteria, while strain 3-10 had broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity on both pathogenic bacteria and fungi. Evaluation of control efficacy in greenhouse trials showed that they all restrained the occurrence and development of soft rot disease caused by D. zeae MS2 or EC1. Among them, strain SC3 had the most impressive biocontrol efficacy on alleviating the soft rot symptoms on both monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous hosts, and strain 3-10 additionally reduced the occurrence of banana wilt disease caused by Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubensis. This is the first report of P. fluorescens, P. parafulva and B. velezensis as potential bio-reagents on controlling soft rot disease caused by D. zeae.

Biocontrol of tobacco black shank disease (Phytophthora nicotianae) by Bacillus velezensis Ba168

Tobacco black shank (TBS) caused by Phytophthora nicotianae is destructive to almost all tobacco cultivars and is widespread in many tobacco-growing countries. Through lab study and field test, we isolated plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) strain Ba168 which is a promising biocontrol strain of TBS. Ba168 was isolated from 168 soil samples and identified as Bacillus velezensis by its genetic and phenotypic characteristics. A susceptibility test indicated that the P. nicotianae antagonistic materials of Ba168 in extracellular metabolites were composed of effective and stable proteins/peptides. P. nicotianae's growth was suppressed by the ammonium sulfate precipitation of Ba168 culture filtrates (ASPBa) at a minimum inhibitory concentration of 5 μg/mL. Extracellular conductivity, pH, and the wet/dry weights of P. nicotianae's mycelia, along with scanning electron microscope analysis, suggested that Ba168-derived proteins/peptides could effectively inhibit P. nicotianae by causing irreversible damage to its cell walls and membranes. Protein identification of ASPBa supported these results and identified many key proteins responsible for various biocontrol-related pathways. Field assays of TBS control efficacy of many PGPRs and agrochemicals showed that all PGPR preparations reduced the disease index of tobacco, but Ba168 was the most effective. These results demonstrated the importance of Bacillus-derived proteins/peptides in the inhibition of P. nicotianae through irreversible damage to its cell wall and membrane; and the effectiveness of PGPR strain B. velezensis Ba168 for biocontrol of the soil-borne disease caused by P. nicotianae.

The Great Five-an artificial bacterial consortium with antagonistic activity towards Pectobacterium spp. and Dickeya spp.: formulation, shelf life, and the ability to prevent soft rot of potato in storage

Abstract

“The Great Five” (GF) is an artificial bacterial consortium developed to protect potato tubers from soft rot caused by Pectobacterium spp. and Dickeya spp. To investigate the commercialization potential of the GF, we developed liquid and powder formulations of the consortium and of each of the comprising strains (Serratia plymuthica strain A294, Enterobacter amnigenus strain A167, Rahnella aquatilis strain H145, Serratia rubidaea strain H440, and S. rubidaea strain H469). To form powders, the cells were lyophilized using a newly developed lyoprotectant: Reagent PS. The shelf life of the formulations stored at 8 and 22 °C was monitored for a period of 12 months. The longest shelf life was obtained for formulations stored at 8 °C; however, the viability of all formulations was negatively affected at 22 °C. For the consortium, a 2.5 log₁₀ cfu (colony forming units) drop in cell number was recorded for the liquid formulation after 6 months, while in case of powders, the drop remained below 1 log₁₀ cfu following 12 months. The ability of the powder formulations to preserve biocontrol activity of the consortium was tested on potato tubers treated with the formulations and a mixture of the soft rot pathogens. The inoculated tubers were stored for 6 months at 8 °C to mimic commercial storage conditions. Soft rot severity and incidence on potato tubers treated with formulations were significantly reduced (62–75% and 48–61%, respectively) in comparison to positive control with pathogens alone. The potential use of the newly developed formulations of “The Great Five” for the biocontrol of soft rot is discussed.

Key Points

• An innovative reagent to protect bacterial cells during lyophilization was developed.

• Powder formulations of “The Great Five” prolonged its shelf life.

• The powder-formulated “The Great Five” was active against soft rot bacteria on potato tubers.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s00253-020-10550-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A Rare Thioquinolobactin Siderophore Present in a Bioactive Pseudomonas sp. DTU12.1

Many of the soil-dwelling Pseudomonas species are known to produce secondary metabolite compounds, which can have antagonistic activity against other microorganisms, including important plant pathogens. It is thus of importance to isolate new strains of Pseudomonas and discover novel or rare gene clusters encoding bioactive products. In an effort to accomplish this, we have isolated a bioactive Pseudomonas strain DTU12.1 from leaf-covered soil in Denmark. Following genome sequencing with Illumina and Oxford Nanopore technologies, we generated a complete genome sequence with the length of 5,943,629 base pairs. The DTU12.1 strain contained a complete gene cluster for a rare thioquinolobactin siderophore, which was previously described as possessing bioactivity against oomycetes and several fungal species. We placed the DTU12.1 strain within Pseudomonas gessardii subgroup of fluorescent pseudomonads, where it formed a distinct clade with other Pseudomonas strains, most of which also contained a complete thioquinolobactin gene cluster. Only two other Pseudomonas strains were found to contain the gene cluster, though they were present in a different phylogenetic clade and were missing a transcriptional regulator of the whole cluster. We show that having the complete genome sequence and establishing phylogenetic relationships with other strains can enable us to start evaluating the distribution and evolutionary origins of secondary metabolite clusters.

Comparative genomics reveals signature regions used to develop a robust and sensitive multiplex TaqMan real-time qPCR assay to detect the genus Dickeya and Dickeya dianthicola

AIMS

Dickeya species are high consequence plant pathogenic bacteria; associated with potato disease outbreaks and subsequent economic losses worldwide. Early, accurate and reliable detection of Dickeya spp. is needed to prevent establishment and further dissemination of this pathogen. Therefore, a multiplex TaqMan qPCR was developed for sensitive detection of Dickeya spp. and specifically, Dickeya dianthicola.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A signature genomic region for the genus Dickeya (mglA/mglC) and unique genomic region for D. dianthicola (alcohol dehydrogenase) were identified using a whole genome-based comparative genomics approach. The developed multiplex TaqMan qPCR was validated using extensive inclusivity and exclusivity panels, and naturally/artificially infected samples to confirm broad range detection capability and specificity. Both sensitivity and spiked assays showed a detection limit of 10 fg DNA.

CONCLUSION

The developed multiplex assay is sensitive and reliable to detect Dickeya spp. and D. dianthicola with no false positives or false negatives. It was able to detect mixed infection from naturally and artificially infected plant materials.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

The developed assay will serve as a practical tool for screening of propagative material, monitoring the presence and distribution, and quantification of target pathogens in a breeding programme. The assay also has applications in routine diagnostics, biosecurity and microbial forensics.

Genetic Potential of the Biocontrol Agent Pseudomonas brassicacearum (Formerly P. trivialis) 3Re2-7 Unraveled by Genome Sequencing and Mining, Comparative Genomics and Transcriptomics

The genus Pseudomonas comprises many known plant-associated microbes with plant growth promotion and disease suppression properties. Genome-based studies allow the prediction of the underlying mechanisms using genome mining tools and the analysis of the genes unique for a strain by implementing comparative genomics. Here, we provide the genome sequence of the strain Pseudomonas brassicacearum 3Re2-7, formerly known as P. trivialis and P. reactans, elucidate its revised taxonomic classification, experimentally verify the gene predictions by transcriptome sequencing, describe its genetic biocontrol potential and contextualize it to other known Pseudomonas biocontrol agents. The P. brassicacearum 3Re2-7 genome comprises a circular chromosome with a size of 6,738,544 bp and a GC-content of 60.83%. 6267 genes were annotated, of which 6113 were shown to be transcribed in rich medium and/or in the presence of Rhizoctonia solani. Genome mining identified genes related to biocontrol traits such as secondary metabolite and siderophore biosynthesis, plant growth promotion, inorganic phosphate solubilization, biosynthesis of lipo- and exopolysaccharides, exoproteases, volatiles and detoxification. Core genome analysis revealed, that the 3Re2-7 genome exhibits a high collinearity with the representative genome for the species, P. brassicacearum subsp. brassicacearum NFM421. Comparative genomics allowed the identification of 105 specific genes and revealed gene clusters that might encode specialized biocontrol mechanisms of strain 3Re2-7. Moreover, we captured the transcriptome of P. brassicacearum 3Re2-7, confirming the transcription of the predicted biocontrol-related genes. The gene clusters coding for 2,4-diacetylphloroglucinol (phlABCDEFGH) and hydrogen cyanide (hcnABC) were shown to be highly transcribed. Further genes predicted to encode putative alginate production enzymes, a pyrroloquinoline quinone precursor peptide PqqA and a matrixin family metalloprotease were also found to be highly transcribed. With this study, we provide a basis to further characterize the mechanisms for biocontrol in Pseudomonas species, towards a sustainable and safe application of P. brassicacearum biocontrol agents.

Biocontrol of Soft Rot of Chinese Cabbage Using an Endophytic Bacterial Strain

Soft rot caused by Pectobacterium carotovorum subsp. carotovorum (Pcc) is a major constraint in the production of Chinese cabbage. The objective of this study was to demonstrate that the causative agent Pcc may be successfully managed by Bacillus amyloliquefaciens KC-1, both in vitro and in vivo. Chinese cabbage seedlings were cultivated in organic substrate termed bio-organic substrate using a floating-seedling system with B. amyloliquefaciens KC-1. This approach was applied in a greenhouse to evaluate the management of soft rot. The results showed that the extent of soft rot, as well as the transmission of Pcc to the stem progeny and its survival in the rhizosphere, was reduced following inoculation with B. amyloliquefaciens KC-1. In contrast, the population diversity of B. amyloliquefaciens KC-1 persisted in the Chinese cabbage stems after germination. These findings revealed that B. amyloliquefaciens KC-1 was able to survive and suppress the growth of Pcc in Chinese cabbage and its rhizosphere, protecting the host from the pathogen. The use of B. amyloliquefaciens KC-1 throughout the growth period of plants may be an effective strategy for the prevention of soft rot in Chinese cabbage.

Temporal resistance of potato tubers: Antibacterial assays and metabolite profiling of wound-healing tissue extracts from contrasting cultivars

Solanum tuberosum, commonly known as the potato, is a worldwide food staple. During harvest, storage, and distribution the crop is at risk of mechanical damage. Wounding of the tuber skin can also become a point of entry for bacterial and fungal pathogens, resulting in substantial agricultural losses. Building on the proposal that potato tubers produce metabolites to defend against microbial infection during early stages of wound healing before protective suberized periderm tissues have developed, we assessed extracts of wound tissues from four potato cultivars with differing skin morphologies (Norkotah Russet, Atlantic, Chipeta, and Yukon Gold). These assays were conducted at 0, 1, 2, 3 and 7 days post wounding against the plant pathogen Erwinia carotovora and a non-pathogenic Escherichia coli strain that served as a control. For each of the potato cultivars, only polar wound tissue extracts demonstrated antibacterial activity. The polar extracts from earlier wound-healing time points (days 0, 1 and 2) displayed notably higher antibacterial activity against both strains than the later wound-healing stages (days 3 and 7). These results support a burst of antibacterial activity at early time points. Parallel metabolite profiling of the extracts revealed differences in chemical composition at different wound-healing time points and allowed for identification of potential marker compounds according to healing stage for each of the cultivars. It was possible to monitor the transformations in the metabolite profiles that could account for the phenomenon of temporal resistance by looking at the relative quantities of various metabolite classes as a function of time.

Biological control of the soft rot bacterium Pectobacterium carotovorum by Bacillus amyloliquefaciens strain Ar10 producing glycolipid-like compounds

Four hundred and fifty bacteria were evaluated for antagonistic activity against bacterial soft rot of potato caused by Pectobacterium carotovorum sp strain II16. A strain Ar10 exhibiting potent antagonist activity has been identified as Bacillus amyloliquefaciens on the basis of biochemical and molecular characterization. Cell free supernatant showed a broad spectrum of antibacterial activity against human and phytopathogenic bacteria in the range of 10-60 AU/mL. Incubation of P. carotovorum cells with increasing concentrations of the antibacterial compound showed a killing rate of 94.8 and 96% at MIC and 2xMIC respectively. In addition, the antibacterial agent did not exert haemolytic activity at the active concentration and has been preliminary characterized by TLC and GC-MS as a glycolipid compound. Treatment of potato tubers with strain Ar10 for 72 h significantly reduced the severity of disease symptoms (100 and 85.05% reduction of necrosis deep / area and weight loss respectively). The same levels in disease symptoms severity was also recorded following treatment of potato tubers with cell free supernatant for 1 h. Data suggest that protection against potato soft rot disease may be related to glycolipid production by strain Ar10. The present study affords new alternatives for anti-Pectobacterium carotovorum bioactive compounds against the soft rot disease of potato.

A Complex Mechanism Involving LysR and TetR/AcrR That Regulates Iron Scavenger Biosynthesis in Pseudomonas donghuensis HYS

7-Hydroxytropolone (7-HT) is a symmetrical seven-membered heteroatomic ring with a carboxyl group and two hydroxyl groups and was recently reported to be an iron scavenger of Pseudomonas donghuensis HYS. Cluster 1 includes 12 genes related to the synthesis of 7-HT; among these genes, those for two regulators, Orf1 and Orf12, were predicted to regulate 7-HT biosynthesis and to be LysR-type transcriptional regulators (LTTRs) and TetR/AcrR family transcriptional regulators, respectively. Data from real-time quantitative PCR and β-galactosidase and classical siderophore assays indicated that the transcription levels of orf1 and orf12, as well as those of crucial genes orf6 to orf9, were repressed under high-iron conditions. The deletion of orf1 and orf12 led to an absence of 7-HT and a decrease in orf6-orf9 expression. Orf1 and Orf12 were essential for the production of 7-HT through orf6-orf9 These two regulators are regulated by the Gac/Rsm system; Orf1 facilitates the expression of Orf12, and Orf12 concomitantly stimulates the expression of orf6-orf9 to synthesize 7-HT. The overexpression of Orf12 decreased 7-HT yields, possibly through decreased orf6-orf9 expression. This work thus outlines a complex mechanism regulating the biosynthesis of the iron scavenger 7-HT in P. donghuensis HYS. The synergy between Orf1 and Orf12 ensures that 7-HT acts as an iron chelator despite being toxic to bacteria and provides new ideas for the novel regulation of dual-functional secondary metabolism and research on 7-HT and its derivates in other bacteria.IMPORTANCE A complex regulation mechanism including two regulators, LysR and TetR/AcrR, in the biosynthesis of the novel iron scavenger 7-hydroxytropolone (7-HT) was verified in Pseudomonas donghuensis HYS. The coaction of LysR Orf1 and TetR/AcrR Orf12 may balance the toxicity and iron chelation of 7-HT in P. donghuensis HYS to overcome iron deficiency, as well as improve the bacterial competitiveness under iron-scarce conditions because of the toxicity of 7-HT toward other bacteria, making the accurate regulation of 7-HT biosynthesis indispensable. This regulation mechanism may be ubiquitous in the Pseudomonas putida group but may better explain the group's strong adaptability.

When Genome-Based Approach Meets the "Old but Good": Revealing Genes Involved in the Antibacterial Activity of Pseudomonas sp. P482 against Soft Rot Pathogens

Dickeya solani and Pectobacterium carotovorum subsp. brasiliense are recently established species of bacterial plant pathogens causing black leg and soft rot of many vegetables and ornamental plants. Pseudomonas sp. strain P482 inhibits the growth of these pathogens, a desired trait considering the limited measures to combat these diseases. In this study, we determined the genetic background of the antibacterial activity of P482, and established the phylogenetic position of this strain. Pseudomonas sp. P482 was classified as Pseudomonas donghuensis. Genome mining revealed that the P482 genome does not contain genes determining the synthesis of known antimicrobials. However, the ClusterFinder algorithm, designed to detect atypical or novel classes of secondary metabolite gene clusters, predicted 18 such clusters in the genome. Screening of a Tn5 mutant library yielded an antimicrobial negative transposon mutant. The transposon insertion was located in a gene encoding an HpcH/HpaI aldolase/citrate lyase family protein. This gene is located in a hypothetical cluster predicted by the ClusterFinder, together with the downstream homologs of four nfs genes, that confer production of a non-fluorescent siderophore by P. donghuensis HYS^T. Site-directed inactivation of the HpcH/HpaI aldolase gene, the adjacent short chain dehydrogenase gene, as well as a homolog of an essential nfs cluster gene, all abolished the antimicrobial activity of the P482, suggesting their involvement in a common biosynthesis pathway. However, none of the mutants showed a decreased siderophore yield, neither was the antimicrobial activity of the wild type P482 compromised by high iron bioavailability. A genomic region comprising the nfs cluster and three upstream genes is involved in the antibacterial activity of P. donghuensis P482 against D. solani and P. carotovorum subsp. brasiliense. The genes studied are unique to the two known P. donghuensis strains. This study illustrates that mining of microbial genomes is a powerful approach for predictingthe presence of novel secondary-metabolite encoding genes especially when coupled with transposon mutagenesis.