Killing of an encapsulated strain of Escherichia coli by human serum

Polymerization of C9 enhances bacterial cell envelope damage and killing by membrane attack complex pores

Complement proteins can form membrane attack complex (MAC) pores that directly kill Gram-negative bacteria. MAC pores assemble by stepwise binding of C5b, C6, C7, C8 and finally C9, which can polymerize into a transmembrane ring of up to 18 C9 monomers. It is still unclear if the assembly of a polymeric-C9 ring is necessary to sufficiently damage the bacterial cell envelope to kill bacteria. In this paper, polymerization of C9 was prevented without affecting binding of C9 to C5b-8, by locking the first transmembrane helix domain of C9. Using this system, we show that polymerization of C9 strongly enhanced damage to both the bacterial outer and inner membrane, resulting in more rapid killing of several Escherichia coli and Klebsiella strains in serum. By comparing binding of wildtype and ‘locked’ C9 by flow cytometry, we also show that polymerization of C9 is impaired when the amount of available C9 per C5b-8 is limited. This suggests that an excess of C9 is required to efficiently form polymeric-C9. Finally, we show that polymerization of C9 was impaired on complement-resistant E. coli strains that survive killing by MAC pores. This suggests that these bacteria can specifically block polymerization of C9. All tested complement-resistant E. coli expressed LPS O-antigen (O-Ag), compared to only one out of four complement-sensitive E. coli. By restoring O-Ag expression in an O-Ag negative strain, we show that the O-Ag impairs polymerization of C9 and results in complement-resistance. Altogether, these insights are important to understand how MAC pores kill bacteria and how bacterial pathogens can resist MAC-dependent killing.

In this paper, we focus on how complement proteins, an essential part of the immune system, kill Gram-negative bacteria via so-called membrane attack complex (MAC) pores. The MAC is a large pore that consists of five different proteins. The final component, C9, assembles a ring of up to 18 C9 molecules that damages the bacterial cell envelope. Here, we aimed to better understand if this polymeric-C9 ring is necessary to kill bacteria and if bacteria can interfere in its assembly. We uncover that polymerization of C9 increased the damage to the entire bacterial cell envelope, which resulted in more rapid killing of several Gram-negative species. We also show that some clinical Escherichia coli strains can block polymerization of C9 and survive MAC-dependent killing by modifying sugars in the bacterial cell envelope, namely the O-antigen of lipopolysaccharide. These insights help us to better understand how the immune system kills bacteria and how pathogenic bacteria can survive killing.

Proteomic characterization of the interactions between fish serum proteins and waterborne bacteria reveals the suppression of anti-oxidative defense as a serum-mediated antimicrobial mechanism

Fish blood is one of the crucial tissues of innate immune system, but the full repertoire of fish serum components involved in antibacterial defense is not fully identified. In this study, we demonstrated that turbot serum, but not the heat-inactivated control, significantly reduced the number of Edwardsiella tarda (E. tarda). By conjugating serum proteins with fluorescent dyes, we showed that E. tarda were coated with multiple fish proteins. In order to identify these proteins, we used E. tarda to capture turbot serum proteins and subjected the samples to shotgun proteomic analysis. A total of 76 fish proteins were identified in high confidence, including known antimicrobial proteins such as immunoglobins and complement components. 34 proteins with no previously known immunological functions were also identified. The expression of one of these proteins, IQ motif containing H (IQCH), was exclusively in fish brain and gonads and was induced during bacterial infection. This approach also allowed the study of the corresponding proteomic changes in E. tarda exposed to turbot serum, which is a general decrease of bacterial protein expression except for an upregulation of membrane components after serum treatment. Interestingly, while most other known stresses stimulate bacterial antioxidant enzymes, fish serum induced a rapid suppression of antioxidant proteins and led to an accumulation of reactive oxygen species. Heat treatment of fish serum eliminated this effect, suggesting that heat labile factors in the fish serum overrode bacterial antioxidant defenses. Taken together, this work offers a comprehensive view of the interactions between fish serum proteins and bacteria, and reveals previously unknown factors and mechanisms in fish innate immunity.

Bacteria under stress by complement and coagulation

The complement and coagulation systems are two related protein cascades in plasma that serve important roles in host defense and hemostasis, respectively. Complement activation on bacteria supports cellular immune responses and leads to direct killing of bacteria via assembly of the Membrane Attack Complex (MAC). Recent studies have indicated that the coagulation system also contributes to mammalian innate defense since coagulation factors can entrap bacteria inside clots and generate small antibacterial peptides. In this review, we will provide detailed insights into the molecular interplay between these protein cascades and bacteria. We take a closer look at how these pathways are activated on bacterial surfaces and discuss the mechanisms by which they directly cause stress to bacterial cells. The poorly understood mechanism for bacterial killing by the MAC will be reevaluated in light of recent structural insights. Finally, we highlight the strategies used by pathogenic bacteria to modulate these protein networks. Overall, these insights will contribute to a better understanding of the host defense roles of complement and coagulation against bacteria.

A murine model to study the antibacterial effect of copper on infectivity of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium

This study investigated the effect of copper as an antibacterial agent on the infectivity of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. Mice were infected orally with a standardized dose of unstressed Salmonella Typhimurium and copper-stressed cells of Salmonella Typhimurium. Bacterial counts in ileum, blood, liver and spleen were observed up to 168 h under normal aerobic conditions. Serum sensitivity, phagocytosis, malondialdehyde levels and histopathology were studied for both set of animals. A decreased bacterial count in the organs with mild symptoms of infection and a complete recovery by 48 h was observed in mice infected with copper-stressed bacteria. Histopathological examination of ileum tissue demonstrated regeneration of damaged tissue post-infection with copper-stressed bacteria and no malondialdehyde levels were detected after 24 h in ileum, spleen and liver. Exposure to copper sensitized Salmonella Typhimurium to the lytic action of serum and intracellular killing by peritoneal macrophages. It can be concluded that copper stress confers a decrease in the infectivity of healthy Salmonella Typhimurium in normal mice. This study highlights the significance of use of copper as an antibacterial agent against Salmonella Typhimurium in reducing the risk of incidence of Salmonella infections from contaminated water.

Increased Pho regulon activation correlates with decreased virulence of an avian pathogenic Escherichia coli O78 strain

Avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) strains are associated with respiratory infections, septicemia, cellulitis, peritonitis, and other conditions, since colibacillosis manifests in many ways. The Pho regulon is jointly controlled by the two-component regulatory system PhoBR and by the phosphate-specific transport (Pst) system. To determine the specific roles of the PhoBR regulon and the Pst system in the pathogenesis of the APEC O78 strain χ7122, different phoBR and pst mutant strains were tested in vivo in chickens and in vitro for virulence traits. Mutations resulting in constitutive activation of the Pho regulon rendered strains more sensitive than the wild type to hydrogen peroxide and to the bactericidal effects of rabbit serum. In addition, production of type 1 fimbriae was also impaired in these strains. Using a chicken competitive infection model, all PhoB constitutive mutants were outcompeted by the wild-type parent, including strains containing a functional Pst system. Cumulative inactivation of the Pst system and the PhoB regulator resulted in a restoration of virulence. In addition, loss of the PhoB regulator alone did not affect virulence in the chicken infection model. Interestingly, the level of attenuation of the mutant strains correlated directly with the level of activation of the Pho regulon. Overall, results indicate that activation of the Pho regulon rather than phosphate transport by the Pst system plays a major role in the attenuation of the APEC O78 strain χ7122.

Inactivation of the pst system reduces the virulence of an avian pathogenic Escherichia coli O78 strain

Escherichia coli O78 strains are frequently associated with extraintestinal diseases, such as airsacculitis and septicemia, in poultry, livestock, and humans. To understand the influence of the pst operon in the virulence of E. coli, we introduced mutations into the pst genes of the avian pathogenic E. coli (APEC) O78:K80 strain chi7122 by allelic exchange. The mutation of pst genes led to the constitutive expression of the Pho regulon. Furthermore, the virulence of APEC strain chi7122 in a chicken infection model was attenuated by inactivation of the Pst system. The pst mutant caused significantly fewer extraintestinal lesions in infected chickens, and bacterial numbers isolated from different tissues after infection were significantly lower for the mutant than for the wild-type strain. Moreover, resistance to the bactericidal effects of rabbit serum and acid shock was impaired in the pst mutant, in contrast to the wild-type strain. In addition, the MIC of polymyxin was twofold lower for the mutant than for the wild-type strain. Although the pst mutant demonstrated an increased susceptibility to rabbit serum, this strain was not killed by chicken serum, suggesting the presence of differences in host innate immune defenses and complement-mediated killing. In APEC O78 strain chi7122, a functional Pst system is required for full virulence and resistance to acid shock and polymyxin. Our results suggest that the mutation of pst genes induces a deregulation of phosphate sensing and changes in the cell surface composition that lead to decreased virulence, indicating the importance of the Pst system for the virulence of pathogenic E. coli strains from different hosts.

TraJ-dependent Escherichia coli K1 interactions with professional phagocytes are important for early systemic dissemination of infection in the neonatal rat

Escherichia coli is a major cause of neonatal bacterial sepsis and meningitis. We recently identified a gene, traJ, which contributes to the ability of E. coli K1 to penetrate the blood-brain barrier in the neonatal rat. Because very little is known regarding the most critical step in disease progression, translocation to the gut and dissemination to the lymphoid tissues after a natural route of infection, we assessed the ability of a traJ mutant to cause systemic disease in the neonatal rat. Our studies determined that the traJ mutant is significantly less virulent than the wild type in the neonatal rat due to a decreased ability to disseminate from the mesenteric lymph nodes to the deeper tissues of the liver and spleen and to the blood during the early stages of systemic disease. Histopathologic studies determined that although significantly less or no mutant bacteria were recovered from the spleen and livers of infected neonatal rats, the inflammatory response was considerably greater than that in wild-type-colonized tissues. In vitro studies revealed that macrophages internalize the traJ mutant less frequently than they do the wild type and by a morphologically distinct process. Furthermore, we determined that tissue macrophages and dendritic cells within the liver and spleen are the major cellular targets of E. coli K1 and that TraJ significantly contributes to the predominantly intracellular nature of E. coli K1 within these professional phagocytes exclusively during the early stages of systemic disease. These data indicate that, contrary to earlier indications, E. coli K1 resides within professional phagocytes, and this is essential for the efficient progression of systemic disease.

Extended virulence genotype of pathogenic Escherichia coli isolates carrying the afa-8 operon: evidence of similarities between isolates from humans and animals with extraintestinal infections

The afimbrial AfaE-VIII adhesin is common among Escherichia coli isolates from calves with intestinal and/or extraintestinal infections and from humans with sepsis or pyelonephritis. The virulence genotypes of 77 Escherichia coli afa-8 isolates from farm animals and humans were compared to determine whether any trait of commonality exists between isolates of the different host species. Over half of the extraintestinal afa-8 isolates were associated with pap and f17Ac adhesin genes and contained virulence genes (pap, hly, and cnf1) which are characteristic of human extraintestinal pathogenic E. coli (ExPEC). PapG, which occurs as three known variants (variants I to III), is encoded by the corresponding three alleles of papG. Among the pap-positive strains, new papG variants (papGrs) that differed from the isolates with genes for the three adhesin classes predominated over isolates with papG allele III, which in turn were more prevalent than those with allele II. The data showed the substantial prevalence of the enteroaggregative E. coli heat-stable enterotoxin gene (east1) among afa-8 isolates. Most of the afa-8 isolates harbored the high-pathogenicity island (HPI) present in pathogenic Yersinia; however, two-thirds of the HPI-positive strains shared a truncated HPI integrase gene. The presence of ExPEC-associated virulence factors (VFs) in extraintestinal isolates that carry genes typical of enteric strains and that express O antigens associated with intestinal E. coli is consistent with transfer of VFs and O-antigen determinants between ExPEC and enteric strains. The similarities between animal and human ExPEC strains support the hypothesis of overlapping populations, with members of certain clones or clonal groups including animal and human strains. The presence of multiple-antibiotic-resistant bovine afa-8 strains among such clones may represent a potential public health risk.

Virulence factors in Escherichia coli isolated from the blood of bacteremic neonatal calves

Twenty-five Escherichia coli isolates from the blood of critically ill bacteremic calves sampled in two separate studies on a calf-rearing farm housing over 15,000 calves, in the San Joaquin Valley, California were studied. Isolates were characterized for O serogroups and for pathotypes as determined by the presence of specific virulence factors including heat-labile enterotoxin (LT), heat-stable enterotoxins a and b (STa, STb), verotoxins 1 and 2 (VT1, VT2), cytotoxic necrotizing factor (CNF), aerobactin, intimin Eae and P, F17 and CS31A fimbrial adhesins, and resistance to bactericidal effects of serum. These isolates constituted a heterogeneous group. However, isolates were mostly aerobactin positive and often resistant to the bactericidal effects of serum. Isolates of pathotypes O78 (n=6), O119:CS31a (n=3), and P positive but O non-typeable (n=3) were associated with a high mortality rate. The remaining isolates belonged to diverse pathotypes, often possessing the adhesins P, F17, CS31A and Eae but belonging to O serogroups other than O78 and O119, and were less frequently associated with mortality. Although no virulence factor common to all isolates was identified, the capacity to use iron by the presence of aerobactin which is important to the capture of iron was a predominant factor. Moreover, certain pathotypes appear to be associated with primary colisepticemia whereas other pathotypes may cause a bacteremia without necessarily leading to septicemia.

Molecular aspects of complement-mediated bacterial killing. Periplasmic conversion of C9 from a protoxin to a toxin

As part of the membrane attack complex complement protein C9 is responsible for direct killing of bacteria. Here we show that in the periplasmic space of an Escherichia coli cell C9 is converted from a protoxin to a toxin by periplasmic conditions missing in spheroplasts. This conversion is independent of the pathway by which C9 enters the periplasm. Both, C9 shocked into the periplasm and plasmid-expressed C9 targeted to the periplasm via a signal sequence are toxic. Toxicity requires disulfide-linked C9 because export into the periplasm of cells defective in disulfide bond synthesis (dsbA and dsbB mutants) is not toxic unless N-acetylcysteine is added externally to promote cystines. A N-terminal fragment, C9[1-144], is not toxic nor is cytoplasmically expressed C9, even in trxB mutants that are able to form disulfide bonds in the cytoplasm. Importantly, expression of full-length C9 in complement-resistant cells has no effect on their viability. Expression and translocation into the periplasm may provide a novel model to identify molecular mechanisms of other bactericidal disulfide-linked proteins and to investigate the nature of bacterial complement resistance.

Horse complement protein C9: primary structure and cytotoxic activity

Lack of hemolytic activity of horse serum is an inherent property of horse C9. To understand the molecular reasons for this deficiency we have cloned C9 cDNA from a horse liver cDNA library and have sequenced the cDNA yielding the complete coding sequence for horse C9. Purification of C9 from horse plasma and microsequencing established the N-terminus of the mature protein and verified that the correct horse C9 cDNA clone had been isolated. The deduced amino acid sequence corresponds to a mature protein of 526 amino acids that is 77% identical to human C9. It has the same domain structure as human C9 and contains 22 cysteines and four invariant tryptophans. The few differences include the N-terminus, which is an unblocked glycine in horse C9 but pyroglutamine in human C9, and three potential N-glycosylation sites compared to two in human C9. The N-terminal difference is unimportant since microsequencing of bovine C9, which is strongly hemolytic, established that it also has an unblocked glycine identical to horse C9. There are no obvious structural differences apparent that could resolve the differences in hemolytic potency between the two molecules. Aside from a few conservative replacements, both C9 sequences are identical between positions 250 and 360. This region includes the membrane interaction domain in C9 and the postulated transmembrane segment that is thought to constitute the wall of a putative transmembrane pore and, therefore, should be required for cytotoxicity. In agreement with this prediction we have observed that, in contrast to the marked decrease in hemolytic activity, horse C9 is very efficient in killing a variety of Gram-negative bacteria. These results demonstrate that horse C9 is a structurally competent molecule with efficient cytotoxic activity. Its inability to lyse erythrocytes may be related to the action of control proteins on target cell membranes.

Identification of a mutation in the pst-phoU operon that reduces pathogenicity of an Escherichia coli strain causing septicemia in pigs

We used transposon (TnphoA) mutagenesis to study the role of virulence factors of pathogenic Escherichia coli strains associated with septicemia in calves and piglets. We have produced an avirulent and serum-sensitive mutant of wild-type pathogenic strain 5131 O115:K"V165":F165 and have localized and identified the TnphoA insertion in the pstC gene of the pst-phoU operon. This operon encodes the PstSCAB transporter and PhoU protein that negatively regulate the phosphate (Pho) regulon. This mutation is pleiotropic and could have an effect on pathogenicity and on the production of the surface polysaccharides of strain 5131. The mutant demonstrated restored repressibility of alkaline phosphatase and regained the capacity to resist serum and to survive systemically for at least 5 days in experimentally inoculated pigs when complemented with plasmid pAN92, bearing the pst-phoU operon.

C9-mediated killing of bacterial cells by transferred C5b-8 complexes: transferred C5b-9 complexes are nonbactericidal

The formation of the C5b-9 complex on the outer membrane of complement-sensitive cells of Escherichia coli results in inhibition of inner membrane function and the death of the cell. Cells bearing a precursor of the C5b-9 site, the C5b-8 complex, suffer no loss in viability. Antibiotic-sensitive, complement-sensitive donor cells bearing precursor C5b-8 complexes were incubated with equal numbers of antibiotic-resistant, complement-sensitive acceptor cells that had not been exposed to a complement source. This cell mixture was incubated with 5 mM EDTA for 5 min and then with calcium chloride (20 mM) for various times. The excess calcium ion concentration was effectively reduced with additional EDTA, and the cell mixture was washed and resuspended in buffer. The viability of the acceptor cells was assayed by plating on antibiotic-containing media. C9 was added to the mixture, and the mixture was incubated for 10 min at 37 degrees C and then plated as described above. It was found that the acceptor cells were killed by the addition of purified C9 only after incubation with donor cells bearing C5b-8 sites during the transfer procedure. This indicates that precursor C5b-8 sites that support C9-mediated killing could be transferred between cells. No loss in viability was detected for acceptor cells subjected to the procedure described above in the presence of donor cells bearing complete C5b-9 complexes, formed prior to mixing with acceptor cells for the transfer procedure.

Study on the bactericidal activity and synergistic effect of neutropenic rat serum with gentamicin

It is well known that normal rat serum (NRS) shows an antibacterial activity because of the presence of endogenous substances that are able to express a defence against pathogenic microorganisms. Moreover, in former studies, we observed that NRS presents a synergistic activity with some antibiotics (thus able to lower minimum inhibitory concentration values). The aim of this research was to study the antibacterial activity and synergistic effect of neutropenic rat sera (NPRS) with gentamicin. The animals were made neutropenic by the i.p. injection of cyclophosphamide (100 mg/kg on day 0 and 75 mg on day 4). At all tested concentrations (from 0.25% to 5%) NPRS showed lower antibacterial activity than NRS with differences which were always statistically significant. The synergistic activity of NPRS with gentamicin was still present and quite similar to that of NRS, in spite of many altered blood parameters showing evident immunodepression. Some possible interpretations of these results are discussed.

Domain structure, functional activity, and polymerization of trout complement protein C9

The 3' region of trout C9 has been resequenced and found to differ from the previously published sequence (Stanley and Herz, EMBO J. 6:1951; 1987). In contrast to other sequenced C9 molecules, but in common with the other terminal complement components, trout C9 was found to contain an additional carboxy terminal thrombospondin domain. This domain does not restrict polymerization, as has been previously suggested (Stanley and Luzio, Nature 334:475; 1988), since alternative pathway activation of trout complement by rabbit erythrocytes lead to the formation of circular membrane attack complement lesions on the erythrocyte membrane. Although the trout C9 molecule is larger than human C9, the diameters of circular trout membrane attack complexes were approximately 30% smaller than their human counterparts. No lysis of erythrocytes bearing human C5b-7 or C5b-8 complexes was detected following incubation with trout serum containing EDTA, which suggests that trout C8 and C9 are unable to bind to human C7 and C8, respectively. Finally, trout and human serum were equally effective at killing the human serum-sensitive strain Salmonella minnesota Re595.

Characterization of a polysaccharide capsular antigen of septicemic Escherichia coli O115:K "V165" :F165 and evaluation of its role in pathogenicity

Escherichia coli strains of serogroup O115:K(-):F165 have been associated with septicemia in calves and piglets. These strains express a capsular antigen referred to as K"V165" which inhibits agglutination of the O antigen by anti-O115 serum. We used hybrid transposon TnphoA mutants M48, 18b, and 2, and a spontaneous O-agglutinable mutant, 5131a, to evaluate the role of K"V165" in the pathogenicity of E. coli O115. Mutant M48 was as resistant to 90% rabbit serum and as virulent in day-old chickens as the parent strain 5131, mutants 18b and 5131a were less resistant to serum and less virulent in chickens, and mutant 2 was serum sensitive and avirulent. Analysis of outer membrane protein and lipopolysaccharide profiles failed to show any difference between the transposon mutants and the parent strain. In contrast, the spontaneous O-agglutinable mutant showed additional bands in the 16-kDa region of the polysaccharide ladder-like pattern. Mutants 2 and 5131a produced significantly less K"V165" capsular antigen than the parent strain, as demonstrated by a competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with adsorbed anti-K"V165" serum. In addition, electron microscopic analysis revealed that mutants 2 and 5131a had lost the capsular layer observed in the parent strain after fixation with glutaraldehyde-lysine. This capsule contained carbohydrate compounds and resembled an O-antigen capsule since it prevented O-antigen agglutination before the bacteria were heated at 100 degrees C and induced bacterial serum resistance. The capsule-defective mutants colonized the intestinal epithelium of experimentally infected gnotobiotic pigs but failed to induce clinical signs of septicemia. We concluded that E. coli strains of serogroup O115 expressed a polysaccharide capsular antigen which induced serum resistance and consequently contributed to the pathogenicity of the bacteria.

pap-and pil-related DNA sequences and other virulence determinants associated with Escherichia coli isolated from septicemic chickens and turkeys

Escherichia coli isolates from septicemic or healthy chickens and turkeys from Quebec were serotyped, examined genotypically by using DNA probes specific for the pil and pap fimbrial systems and the aerobactin siderophore system, and examined phenotypically for lethality in day-old chicks, hemagglutination, serum resistance, and aerobactin production. Serogroups O78 and O1 were most common in septicemic chickens and turkeys. pap+ isolates from chickens were associated with septicemia, and pap+ isolates from turkeys were associated with lethality in day-old chicks. Four of nine pap+ isolates from septicemic turkeys expressed P adhesin, whereas all pap+ isolates from septicemic chickens were negative for P adhesin. The pil+ genotype was associated with septicemia in chickens and with serum resistance in isolates from turkeys. Mannose-sensitive hemagglutination of guinea pig erythrocytes was associated with septicemia in chickens and turkeys, although this phenotype was not associated with pil+ isolates from turkeys. Serum resistance was associated with isolates from septicemic turkeys and with lethality in isolates from chickens. The aerobactin system was associated with isolates from septicemic chickens and turkeys. Overall, results indicated that (i) genotypic examination may reveal virulence-associated traits which differ from the typically expected phenotype and/or are not readily expressed in vitro, and (ii) certain phenotypic and genotypic traits associated with E. coli causing extraintestinal disease in humans and animals are also associated with E. coli causing avian septicemia.

Resistance of Escherichia coli to osmotically introduced complement component C9

Investigation into the action of osmotically introduced C9 in Escherichia coli (in the absence of any other complement components) revealed that C9 could inhibit inner membrane respiration and cause a decrease in the viability of cells that were normally complement sensitive. This effect is analogous to the loss of inner membrane function and viability due to the assembly of the C5b-9 complex on these cells. Complement-resistant cells showed no such inhibition of respiration or loss of viability when subjected to the osmotic introduction of C9. The reason for this failure of C9 to affect complement-resistant cells was explored to determine whether this resistance to C9 was due to an inability of proteins in general to be osmotically introduced into the complement-resistant cells. The protein toxins melittin and colicin E1 were showed to be able to kill these complement-resistant cells (as well as complement-sensitive cells) when osmotically introduced into the periplasm. Therefore, cellular resistance to osmotically introduced C9 is not due to an inability of proteins to be introduced into the cells and may be related to a mechanism of cellular resistance to the C5b-9 complex.

Transfer of preformed terminal C5b-9 complement complexes into the outer membrane of viable gram-negative bacteria: effect on viability and integrity

An efficient fusion system between Gram-negative bacteria and liposomes incorporating detergent-extracted C5b-9 complexes has been developed that allows delivery of preformed terminal complexes to the cell envelope (Tomlinson et al., 1989b). Fusion of Salmonella minnesota Re595 and Escherichia coli 17 with C5b-9-incorporated liposomes resulted in the transfer of 1900 C5b-9 complexes to each target bacterial cell. No loss in viability of bacteria was observed following fusion, even though the deposotion of 900 complexes onto the envelope following exposure to lysozyme-free serum effected a greater than 99% loss of viability. Increased sensitivity to antibiotics normally excluded from the cell by an integral outer membrane (OM), as well as the ability of the chromogenic substrate PADAC to gain access to periplasmically located beta-lactamase, indicated that transferred C5b-9 complexes functioned as water-filled channels through the OM. A similar conclusion was drawn from measurements demonstrating the uptake by cells of the lipophilic cation tetraphenylphosphonium (bromide), a result further indicating that the membrane potential across the cytoplasmic membrane was maintained following C5b-9 transfer to the OM. Examination of S. minnesota Re595 by electron microscopy revealed no obvious difference between cells exposed to lethal concentrations of lysozyme-free serum and cells following fusion with C5b-9-incorporated liposomes. These data suggest either that there are critical sites in the OM to which liposome-delivered C5b-9 complexes are unable to gain access or that bacterial cell death is related to events occurring during polymerization of C9 on the cell surface.

Membrane damage to Escherichia coli and bactericidal kinetics by the alternative complement pathway of channel catfish

1. Increased permeability of cytoplasmic membranes in Escherichia coli was a consequence of alternative complement pathway (ACP) activity of serum of channel catfish, Ictalurus punctatus. Evidence was provided by beta-galactosidase activity extracellularly when E. coli was incubated with catfish serum. 2. Lesions were detected on outer membranes of E. coli following exposure to catfish serum. 3. Catfish ACP induced a temporal sequence of pre-killing and killing phases. 4. Loss of cell viability, killing rate and cytoplasmic enzyme release increased with increasing serum concentrations. 5. By incubating E. coli with sera treated to remove complement, both release of cytoplasmic enzyme and bactericidal activity were eliminated. 6. Lethal activity associated with channel catfish ACP against Gram-negative bacteria was functionally comparable to that seen in mammalian and reptilian systems.

Transfer of phospholipid and protein into the envelope of gram-negative bacteria by liposome fusion

A liposome-bacterial fusion system was developed in order to introduce preformed terminal complement complexes, C5b-9, into the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. Liposomes were prepared from a total phospholipid extract of Salmonella minnesota Re595. Fusion between liposomes and Salmonella sp. or Escherichia coli 17 was dependent on time, temperature, pH, and Ca2+ and PO4- concentration. Only Salmonella sp. with attenuated LPS core regions were able to fuse efficiently with liposomes. It was demonstrated that fusion of liposomes with S. minnesota Re595 or E. coli 17 under optimum conditions resulted in (i) quantitative transfer of the self-quenching fluorescent membrane probe octadecyl rhodamine B chloride from the liposomal bilayer to the bacterial envelope, (ii) transfer of radiolabeled liposomal phospholipid to the bacterial outer membrane and its subsequent translocation to the cytoplasmic membrane, demonstrated by isolation of the bacterial membranes following fusion, and (iii) delivery of liposome-entrapped horseradish peroxidase (HRP) to the periplasmic space, confirmed by a chemiluminescent assay. Following fusion of liposomes incorporating C5b-9 complexes with S. minnesota Re595 or E. coli 17, immunological analysis of the isolated membranes revealed C5b-9 complexes located exclusively in the outer membrane.

Killing of gram-negative bacteria by complement. Fractionation of cell membranes after complement C5b-9 deposition on to the surface of Salmonella minnesota Re595

The effect of C5b-9 deposition on the envelope of target Gram-negative bacteria was studied. In order to understand the changes occurring after complement deposition on the bacterial surface, the preparation of Gram-negative bacterial membranes by different methods involving the osmotic lysis of spheroplasts was investigated. Subsequent fractionation of the outer membrane (OM) and cytoplasmic membrane (CM) by sucrose-density-gradient centrifugation showed differences in the membrane profiles obtained. The results indicate that optimum separation of OM and CM components requires effective digestion of DNA in the total membrane preparation before density-gradient fractionation. Salmonella minnesota Re595 carrying the intermediate complement complex C5b-7 (BC1-7) or C5b-8 (BC1-8) were efficiently killed upon incubation with purified C8 + C9 or C9 respectively. Human-alpha-thrombin-cleaved C9 (C9n), which is unable to form tubular poly(C9), was shown to be more effective at killing than native C9. By using an optimized system for the separation of OM and CM, it was found that, subsequent to lethal complement attack, the CM could not be recovered when C9 was used as the terminal complement component, but was recovered with reduced yield when C9n replaced C9. The results show that inability to recover the CM on sucrose density gradients after complement attack may not be a consequence of an essential membrane damage event required for complement-mediated killing of Gram-negative bacteria.

Interaction of human defensins with Escherichia coli. Mechanism of bactericidal activity

Defensins are small, cysteine-rich antimicrobial peptides that are abundant in human, rabbit, and guinea pig neutrophils (PMN). Three defensins (human neutrophil peptide defensin [HNP]-1, HNP-2, and HNP-3) constitute between 30 and 50% of the total protein in azurophil granules of human PMN. We examined the mechanism of HNP-mediated bactericidal activity against Escherichia coli ML-35 (i-, y-, z+) and its pBR322-transformed derivative, E. coli ML-35p. Under conditions that supported bactericidal activity, HNP-1 sequentially permeabilized the outer membrane (OM) and inner membrane (IM) of E. coli. Coincident with these events, bacterial synthesis of DNA, RNA, and protein ceased and the colony count fell. Although these events were closely coupled under standard assay conditions, OM permeabilization was partially dissociated from IM permeabilization when experiments were performed with E. coli that had been plasmolyzed by mannitol. Under such conditions, the rate and extent of bacterial death more closely paralled loss of IM integrity than OM permeabilization. Electron microscopy of E. coli that had been killed by defensins revealed the presence of striking electron-dense deposits in the periplasmic space and affixed to the OM. Overall, these studies show that HNP-mediated bactericidal activity against E. coli ML-35 is associated with sequential permeabilization of the OM and IM, and that inner membrane permeabilization appears to be the lethal event.

Effect of osmotic protection on nucleated cell killing by C5b-9: cell death is not affected by the prevention of cell swelling

Formation of C5b-9 channels in the plasma membrane can lead to erythrocyte lysis or nucleated cell death. Lysis of erythrocytes by complement occurs as a result of colloid osmotic swelling and rupture of the plasma membrane, due to the unregulated flux of ions and water through C5b-9 channels. This colloid osmotic mechanism of lysis is largely based on the evidence that the extent of hemolysis is reduced, when macromolecules are placed in the medium to balance the osmotic gradient created by intracellular macromolecules, which are too large to diffuse through complement channels. The role of colloid osmotic deregulation, as a cause of nucleated cell killing by C5b-9, however, has been recently questioned [Kim S., Carney D. F. and Shin M. L. J. Immun. 138, 1530 (1987)]. In the present study, we investigated the effect of osmotic protection, with an 81,000 mol. wt dextran or bovine serum albumin, on Ehrlich cell killing by complement channels. The results indicated that prevention of cell swelling by dextran did not reduce the extent or rate of nucleated cell killing by either small (C5b-9l), or large (C5b-9m), complement channels when assessed by vital dye stain. The release of cytoplasmic lactate dehydrogenase as an alternative measure of cell death, however, was retarded and/or reduced, in the presence of dextran or albumin, at concns that prevented cell swelling. These results indicate that C5b-9 can kill nucleated cells effectively, in the absence of colloidal osmotic cell swelling, and that release of cytoplasmic macromolecules may not be a reliable indicator of cell death, when osmotic protectants are employed.

Killing of Brucella abortus by bovine serum

Studies of the serum bactericidal system in bovine brucellosis were undertaken to investigate the role of the humoral immune response in protection of cattle against the facultative intracellular parasite Brucella abortus. Fresh sera from normal control cattle, infected cattle, and cattle immunized with B. abortus cell envelopes were collected before treatment and during the course of immunization or infection. Normal fresh bovine serum or fresh agammaglobulinemic serum from colostrum-deprived calves was effective in killing smooth virulent B. abortus 2308, but rough strains RB51 (a rough mutant of strain 2308) and 45/20 were much more sensitive to serum. The difference in susceptibility to serum was shown to be correlated with differences in lipopolysaccharide chemotype, with the more resistant strain 2308 having O polysaccharide and the more susceptible strains 45/20 and RB51 lacking O side chains. By treatment of fresh serum with MgCl2 and EGTA [ethylene glycol-bis(beta-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid] killing was shown to occur via the classical pathway of complement activation. When antibody to B. abortus was present, killing of strain RB51 increased but killing of smooth strain 2308 decreased. The earliest antibody response in serum from infected animals did not interfere with killing. When affinity-purified bovine immunoglobulins specific for B. abortus smooth lipopolysaccharide were added to fresh normal bovine serum, immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) and IgG2 isotypes blocked killing but IgM and IgA isotypes did not. Thus, it appears that serum from previously unexposed animals or animals early during infection can kill smooth B. abortus, an appropriate defense mechanism before the organism becomes intracellular. At later stages of infection, blocking antibodies predominate.

Determination of serum bactericidal activity against Escherichia coli by an automated photometric method

The resistance of gram-negative bacteria to complement-mediated serum activity is supposedly an important virulence factor. However, the lack of standardization in the methods used to determine serum activity and the many definitions applied make the comparisons between studies very difficult. We developed a rapid photometric method that we compared with a classical killing one. Escherichia coli in the exponential phase of growth in brain heart infusion broth (final inoculum, 10(7) CFU/ml) at 35 degrees C was added to 50% human serum in Veronal buffer. Viable counts and automatic recording of the variations in the optical densities were obtained for 40 E. coli strains isolated from the stools of healthy adults. With the viable count method, 17 (42.5%) were susceptible (at least a 1 log CFU/ml decrease), 17 (42.5%) were resistant (a 0.6 log CFU/ml increase), 4 (10%) were intermediate (poorly growing inoculum or a decrease of less than 1 log CFU/ml), and 2 could not be classified (nonreproducible results). Agreement between both methods was observed for 87.5% of the stool strains. Eight reference strains of known susceptibilities were classified identically by both methods, leading to a final concordance rate of 89.6%. A total of 129 blood isolates were tested by the photometric method: 64 (49.6%) were resistant, 50 (38.8%) were susceptible 5 (3.9%) showed early regrowth, and 10 (7.7%) were not perfectly reproducible. Of these 129 blood isolates, 5 were also tested by the killing method: 37 (49%) were resistant, 32 (43%) were susceptible, and 6 (8%) were intermediate. The concordance rate between both assays was 89% for the blood isolates; when the minor discordances were ruled out, it was 97%. This automated method could be a useful screening tool for detecting resistance to serum in clinical trials and for studying the in vitro variations of this property.

Bacterial killing by complement. C9-mediated killing in the absence of C5b-8

The ability of serum complement to kill Gram-negative bacteria requires assembly of the membrane attack complex (MAC) on the cell surface. The molecular events that lead to cell killing after MAC assembly are unknown. We have investigated the effect of C9 on bacterial survival in the presence and absence of its receptor, the C5b-8 complex, on the outer membrane. A fluorescence assay of the membrane potential across the inner bacterial membrane revealed that addition of C9 to cells bearing the performed C5b-8 complex caused a rapid and complete dissipation of the membrane potential. No fluorescence change was observed in serum-resistant strains of Escherichia coli. Addition of trypsin, after C9 was bound to C5b-8, did not rescue the cells from the lethal effects of C9. Furthermore, assays of cell killing kinetics and C9 binding indicate that formation of tubular poly(C9) is not required for killing. When C9 was introduced into the periplasmic space in the absence of its receptor by means of an osmotic shock procedure, cell killing occurred. Other proteins, such as C8 or serum albumin, were not toxic, and C9 was ineffective against two resistant strains. The results presented here and previously [Dankert & Esser (1986) Biochemistry 25, 1094-1100], when considered together, indicate that the 'lethal unit' in complement killing of some Gram-negative bacteria is a C9-derived product that acts by dissipation of cellular energy.

Inhibitory effect of capsular antigen of Vibrio vulnificus on bactericidal activity of human serum

Opaque (Op) and translucent (Tr) colonial variants were isolated from Vibrio vulnificus strains. Op-type variants were more resistant than the isogenic Tr-type variants, but the survival rate of the Op-type variants varied with the strains. Antisera were prepared by immunizing rabbit with whole cells of Op and Tr variants of some strains, in which the difference of the sensitivity between Op and Tr cells was remarkable. Then agglutination tests with their living and heat-killed cells were carried out. The results suggested the presence of capsular antigen in Op cells and its absence in Tr cells, with the exception of the existence of a slight amount of capsular material in Tr variants of strain L-180. The thin capsular layer of Tr cells of strain L-180 was also demonstrated electron microscopically, but the layer was thinner than that of the isogenic Op cells. Results of determination of sugar content in the extracted capsular fraction also showed that Op to Tr transformation was due to loss of capsular antigen of the cells. These results confirmed the morphological studies previously reported which suggested the prevention of host defense system by the capsular material of the vibrio.

Lipopolysaccharide size and distribution determine serum resistance in Salmonella montevideo

The survival of Salmonella montevideo during serum treatment depends on the presence of an O antigen (O-Ag) associated with the lipopolysaccharide molecule. In this organism, the O antigen is a polysaccharide composed of 0 to more than 55 subunits, each containing 4 mannose residues together with glucose and n-acetylglucosamine. We used a mutant strain of S. montevideo that requires exogenous mannose for the synthesis of O-Ag. Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) was prepared from these cells grown under three different conditions where the availability of exogenous mannose was regulated such that the average number of O-Ag units per LPS molecule, the percentage of LPS molecules bearing long O-Ag side chains, and the percentage of lipid A cores bearing O-Ag were all varied. These changes in LPS profiles were monitored on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels, and cells with different LPS profiles were tested for their ability to survive treatment with pooled normal human serum. Survival in serum was associated with LPS that contained an average of 4 to 5 O-Ag units per LPS molecule, and 20 to 23% of the LPS molecules had more than 14 O-Ag units per LPS molecule. Serum survival was less clearly associated with the percentage of lipid A cores covered with O-Ag. We propose, based on these data and on previous work, that the O-Ag polysaccharide provides the cell protection from serum killing by sterically hindering access of the C5b-9 complex to the outer membrane and that a critical density of long O-Ag polysaccharide is necessary to provide protection.

Does complement kill E. coli by producing transmural pores?

Three lines of evidence are presented to indicate that C5b-9 kills serum-sensitive E. coli K 12 cells by generating functional pores across the outer and inner bacterial membrane. First, viable cells carrying C5b-8 complexes are impermeable to o-nitrophenyl-beta-D-galactoside (ONPG), but lose viability and become permeable to this marker upon post-treatment with purified C9 in the absence of lysozyme. Cells killed with colicin E1 or gentamicin are also impermeable to ONPG but take up the marker if they are post-treated with lysozyme-free serum. Second, killing by C5b-9 is highly effective, deposition of only a small number of complexes being lethal. This has been demonstrated in experiments where viable cells carrying 2000-4000 C5b-7 complexes per CFU were permitted to multiply in broth culture, and the daughter generations subsequently treated with purified C8 and C9. Fifty percent killing was observed in the fifth to sixth generation, corresponding to a dilution of C5b-7 complexes to 50-100 molecules/CFU. In the presence of 2 mM EDTA, further dilution of C5b-7 down to 8-30 complexes/CFU still caused 50% killing of daughter cells. Third, treatment of C5b-7 cells with purified CC8 and C9 results in the release of intracellular K+, which commences immediately after addition of C8/C9. This was shown in experiments where C5b-7 cells were packed to high density in saline, post-treated with C8 + C9, and K+ directly measured in the cell supernatants. Based on these results, we propose that C5b-9 pores deposited in the outer bacterial membrane periodically fuse with the inner membrane, the transmural pores thus generated permitting rapid K+ efflux, with cell death ensuing through the collapse of membrane potential.

Stable insertion of C5b-9 complement complexes into the outer membrane of serum treated, susceptible Escherichia coli cells as a prerequisite for killing

Escherichia coli 17, a K12 derivative, was rapidly killed by human serum following a short lag period of 10 min. Stable binding of terminal C5b-9 complement complexes was investigated in time course experiments. Serum treated E. coli cells were lysed osmotically and the resulting outer and cytoplasmic membrane vesicles separated by sucrose gradient centrifugation. Exposure of E. coli 17 to serum rapidly reduced the degree of recoverability of cytoplasmic membrane vesicles. Electron microscopy revealed no interaction of C5b-9 complexes with CM vesicles. In contrast there was a clear time-dependent deposition of terminal complement complexes onto OM-vesicles. Very few complexes were detected during the prekilling phase of the reaction; initiation of the active killing phase was accompanied by a large increase in complement lesions. In contrast, no C5b-9 complexes could be visualised on outer or cytoplasmic membrane vesicles of a smooth, serum-resistant E. coli strain. We conclude that complement-mediated killing is a consequence of stable binding of C5b-9 complexes to the outer membrane of susceptible strains.

Serum-resistant mutants of Escherichia coli O111 contain increased lipopolysaccharide, lack an O antigen-containing capsule, and cover more of their lipid A core with O antigen

Escherichia coli strains of group O111 were characterized with respect to sensitivity to complement killing, amount of lipopolysaccharide and O antigen-containing capsule, and distribution of O antigen. All wild-type E. coli O111 strains were resistant to complement killing in the absence of specific antibody. Presensitization of strains with antibody to whole cells (OK antibody), followed by incubation in 50% pooled normal human serum as a source of complement, subdivided wild-type strains into three types: completely resistant, partially resistant, and sensitive. Completely and partially resistant mutants were isolated by cycles of serum killing, starting with one sensitive strain. Completely resistant mutants had no O antigen-containing capsule, but had 50% more lipopolysaccharide than did the parent, and this lipopolysaccharide had 30% fewer lipid A core molecules devoid of O antigen. Partially resistant mutants still had O antigen-containing capsule, but contained 40% more lipopolysaccharide than did the parent; the extent of coverage of lipid A core with O antigen remained unchanged. No correlations were found between outer membrane protein composition and the degree of serum resistance. Since the terminal membrane attack complex (C5b-9) must stably insert into a hydrophobic membrane site to effect killing, we conclude that both increased lipid A core and increased coverage of lipid A core with O antigen preclude access of C5b-9 to lethal sites on the cell surface.

Interaction of human complement proteins with serum-sensitive and serum-resistant strains of Escherichia coli

Exposure of serum-susceptible Escherichia coli strains to lethal concns of lysozyme-free human serum resulted in stable binding of complement components to the outer membrane (OM), but not to the cytoplasmic membrane (CM). The short prekilling phase of the reaction was accompanied by binding of C3b; loss of viability was immediately preceeded by stable deposition onto the OM of the component proteins of the membrane attack complex. During the early stages of the active killing phase, bound monomeric C9 could be resolved into two distinct bands on SDS-polyacrylamide gels. Serum exposure lead to a progressive loss of CM recoverability, which appeared to result from partial degradation of CM phospholipids. In contrast, exposure of a resistant E, coli strain to human serum resulted in little change in the membrane profile and very little stable deposition of terminal complement components onto the OM.

Membrane changes induced by exposure of Escherichia coli to human serum

The effect of bactericidal concentrations of lysozyme-free human serum on parameters of membrane integrity has been studied in serum-susceptible and serum-resistant Escherichia coli strains. Serum treatment released all of the alkaline phosphatase from the periplasmic space of two rapidly serum-susceptible strains but did so at different rates. In contrast, no periplasmic enzyme was released from two serum-resistant strains or from one moderately susceptible smooth strain. Lysozyme-free serum and heat-inactivated serum released comparable amounts of 86Rb+ from preloaded cells at comparable rates, regardless of serum susceptibility. Serum decreased the rate of phospholipid biosynthesis in both serum-susceptible and serum-resistant strains. In susceptible but not in resistant strains, intracellular ATP pools were depleted after serum exposure. Outer membranes and cytoplasmic membranes were prepared from serum-treated E. coli, and assays for C3 and C5b-9(m) were performed. With rapidly susceptible strains, C3 deposition on the outer membrane without attachment of C5b-9(m) occurred during the short prekilling phase. Subsequent bacterial killing was accompanied by deposition of C5b-9(m), which was recovered with C3 exclusively in outer membrane fractions with increased density and by eventual total loss of recoverable cytoplasmic membranes. Minimal deposition of complement components, without accompanying cytoplasmic membrane loss, occurred with serum-resistant strains. Loss of recoverable cytoplasmic membrane was not due to the action of either serum or bacterial phospholipase A. The results raise the possibilities that C5b-9(m) primarily damages the outer membrane and that the bacteria themselves actively participate in the ensuing, as yet unclarified, metabolic reactions that finally lead to their death.

Bactericidal and bacteriolytic activity of serum against gram-negative bacteria

Images