Importance of amino acid 101 within capsid protein VP1 for modulation of Theiler's virus-induced disease

Viral mouse models used to study multiple sclerosis: past and present

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a common inflammatory demyelinating disease of the central nervous system. Although the etiology of MS is unknown, genetics and environmental factors, such as infections, play a role. Viral infections of mice have been used as model systems to study this demyelinating disease of humans. Three viruses that have long been studied in this capacity are Theiler’s murine encephalomyelitis virus, mouse hepatitis virus, and Semliki Forest virus. This review describes the viruses themselves, the infection process, the disease caused by infection and its accompanying pathology, and the model systems and their usefulness in studying MS.

Virus infection, antiviral immunity, and autoimmunity

As a group of disorders, autoimmunity ranks as the third most prevalent cause of morbidity and mortality in the Western World. However, the etiology of most autoimmune diseases remains unknown. Although genetic linkage studies support a critical underlying role for genetics, the geographic distribution of these disorders as well as the low concordance rates in monozygotic twins suggest that a combination of other factors including environmental ones are involved. Virus infection is a primary factor that has been implicated in the initiation of autoimmune disease. Infection triggers a robust and usually well-coordinated immune response that is critical for viral clearance. However, in some instances, immune regulatory mechanisms may falter, culminating in the breakdown of self-tolerance, resulting in immune-mediated attack directed against both viral and self-antigens. Traditionally, cross-reactive T-cell recognition, known as molecular mimicry, as well as bystander T-cell activation, culminating in epitope spreading, have been the predominant mechanisms elucidated through which infection may culminate in an T-cell-mediated autoimmune response. However, other hypotheses including virus-induced decoy of the immune system also warrant discussion in regard to their potential for triggering autoimmunity. In this review, we discuss the mechanisms by which virus infection and antiviral immunity contribute to the development of autoimmunity.

Identification of a novel neuropathogenic Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus

Theiler's murine encephalitis viruses (TMEV) are divided into two subgroups based on their neurovirulence. Persistent strains resemble Theiler's original viruses (referred to as the TO subgroup), which largely induce a subclinical polioencephalomyelitis during the acute phase of the disease and can persist in the spinal cord of susceptible animals, inducing a chronic demyelinating disease. In contrast, members of the neurovirulent subgroup cause an acute encephalitis characterized by the rapid onset of paralysis and death within days following intracranial inoculation. We report herein the characterization of a novel neurovirulent strain of TMEV, identified using pyrosequencing technology and referred to as NIHE. Complete coverage of the NIHE viral genome was obtained, and it shares <90% nucleotide sequence identity to known TMEV strains irrespective of subgroup, with the greatest sequence variability being observed in genes encoding the leader and capsid proteins. The histopathological analysis of infected brain and spinal cord demonstrate inflammatory lesions and neuronal necrosis during acute infection with no evidence of viral persistence or chronic disease. Intriguingly, genetic analysis indicates the putative expression of the L protein, considered a hallmark of strains within the persistent subgroup. Thus, the identification and characterization of a novel neurovirulent TMEV strain sharing features previously associated with both subgroups will lead to a deeper understanding of the evolution of TMEV strains and new insights into the determinants of neurovirulence.

TGF-beta1 suppresses T cell infiltration and VP2 puff B mutation enhances apoptosis in acute polioencephalitis induced by Theiler's virus

GDVII and DA strains of Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV) differ in VP2 puff B. One week after GDVII virus infection, SJL/J mice had large numbers of TUNEL+ apoptotic cells with a relative lack of T cell infiltration in the brain. DA viruses with mutation in puff B induced higher levels of apoptosis than wild-type DA virus, but levels of inflammation in brains were similar between DA and DA virus mutants. The difference in inflammation among TMEVs could be due to TGF-beta1 expression that was seen only in GDVII virus infection and negatively correlated with CD3+ T cell infiltration.

Direct comparison of demyelinating disease induced by the Daniel's strain and BeAn strain of Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus

We compared CNS disease following intracerebral injection of SJL mice with Daniel's (DA) and BeAn 8386 (BeAn) strains of Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV). In tissue culture, DA was more virulent then BeAn. There was a higher incidence of demyelination in the spinal cords of SJL/J mice infected with DA as compared to BeAn. However, the extent of demyelination was similar between virus strains when comparing those mice that developed demyelination. Even though BeAn infection resulted in lower incidence of demyelination in the spinal cord, these mice showed significant brain disease similar to that observed with DA. There was approximately 100 times more virus specific RNA in the CNS of DA infected mice as compared to BeAn infected mice. This was reflected by more virus antigen positive cells (macrophages/microglia and oligodendrocytes) in the spinal cord white matter of DA infected mice as compared to BeAn. There was no difference in the brain infiltrating immune cells of DA or BeAn infected mice. However, BeAn infected mice showed higher titers of TMEV specific antibody. Functional deficits as measured by Rotarod were more severe in DA infected versus BeAn infected mice. These findings indicate that the diseases induced by DA or BeAn are distinct.

Theiler's virus persistence in the central nervous system of mice is associated with continuous viral replication and a difference in outcome of infection of infiltrating macrophages versus oligodendrocytes

Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV) infection of mice, in which persistent central nervous system (CNS) infection induces Th1 CD4+ T cell responses to both virus and myelin proteins, provides a relevant experimental animal model for MS. During persistence, >10(9) TMEV genome equivalents per spinal cord are detectable by real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Because of the short half-life of TMEV (<1 day), continual viral replication is needed to sustain these very high TMEV copy numbers. An essential role for macrophages in TMEV persistence has been documented and, although limited by host anti-viral immune responses, TMEV nonetheless spreads during persistence to infect other cells, particularly oligodendrocytes, in which the infection is productive and lytic. Virus factors influencing persistence of TMEV are expression of the out-of-frame L* protein and use of sialic acid co-receptors.

Virus persistence in an animal model of multiple sclerosis requires virion attachment to sialic acid coreceptors

Persistent Theiler's virus infection in the central nervous system (CNS) of mice provides a highly relevant animal model for multiple sclerosis. The low-neurovirulence DA strain uses sialic acid as a coreceptor for cell binding before establishing infection. During adaptation of DA virus to growth in sialic acid-deficient cells, three amino acid substitutions (G1100D, T1081I, and T3182A) in the capsid arose, and the virus no longer used sialic acid as a coreceptor. The adapted virus retained acute CNS virulence, but its persistence in the CNS, white matter inflammation, and demyelination were largely abrogated. Infection of murine macrophage but not oligodendrocyte cultures with the adapted virus was also significantly reduced. Substitution of G1100D in an infectious DA virus cDNA clone demonstrated a major role for this mutation in loss of sialic acid binding and CNS persistence. These data indicate a direct role for sialic acid binding in Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus persistence and chronic demyelinating disease.

Evolution of cell recognition by viruses: a source of biological novelty with medical implications

The picture beginning to form from genome analyses of viruses, unicellular organisms, and multicellular organisms is that viruses have shared functional modules with cells. A process of coevolution has probably involved exchanges of genetic information between cells and viruses for long evolutionary periods. From this point of view present-day viruses show flexibility in receptor usage and a capacity to alter through mutation their receptor recognition specificity. It is possible that for the complex DNA viruses, due to a likely limited tolerance to generalized high mutation rates, modifications in receptor specificity will be less frequent than for RNA viruses, albeit with similar biological consequences once they occur. It is found that different receptors, or allelic forms of one receptor, may be used with different efficiency and receptor affinities are probably modified by mutation and selection. Receptor abundance and its affinity for a virus may modulate not only the efficiency of infection, but also the capacity of the virus to diffuse toward other sites of the organism. The chapter concludes that receptors may be shared by different, unrelated viruses and that one virus may use several receptors and may expand its receptor specificity in ways that, at present, are largely unpredictable.

Mutations that affect the tropism of DA and GDVII strains of Theiler's virus in vitro influence sialic acid binding and pathogenicity

Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV) is a natural pathogen of the mouse. The different strains of TMEV are divided into two subgroups according to the pathology they provoke. The neurovirulent strains GDVII and FA induce an acute fatal encephalitis, while persistent strains, like DA and BeAn, cause a chronic demyelinating disease associated with viral persistence in the central nervous system. Different receptor usage was proposed to account for most of the phenotype difference between neurovirulent and persistent strains. Persistent but not neurovirulent strains were shown to bind sialic acid. We characterized DA and GDVII derivatives adapted to grow on CHO-K1 cells. Expression of glycosaminoglycans did not influence infection of CHO-K1 cells by parental and adapted viruses. Mutations resulting from adaptation of DA and GDVII to CHO-K1 cells notably mapped to the well-characterized VP1 CD and VP2 EF loops of the capsid. Adaptation of the DA virus to CHO-K1 cells correlated with decreased sialic acid usage for entry. In contrast, adaptation of the GDVII virus to CHO-K1 cells correlated with the appearance of a weak sialic acid usage for entry. The sialic acid binding capacity of the GDVII variant resulted from a single amino acid mutation (VP1-51, Asn-->Ser) located out of the sialic acid binding region defined for virus DA. Mutations affecting tropism in vitro and sialic acid binding dramatically affected the persistence and neurovirulence of the viruses.

Prolonged gray matter disease without demyelination caused by Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus with a mutation in VP2 puff B

Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV) is divided into two subgroups based on neurovirulence. During the acute phase, DA virus infects cells in the gray matter of the central nervous system (CNS). Throughout the chronic phase, DA virus infects glial cells in the white matter, causing demyelinating disease. Although GDVII virus also infects neurons in the gray matter, infected mice developed a severe polioencephalomyelitis, and no virus is detected in the white matter or other areas in the CNS in rare survivors. Several sequence differences between the two viruses are located in VP2 puff B and VP1 loop II, which are located near each other, close to the proposed receptor binding site. We constructed a DA virus mutant, DApBL2M, which has the VP1 loop II of GDVII virus and a mutation at position 171 in VP2 puff B. While DApBL2M virus replicated less efficiently than DA virus during the acute phase, DApBL2M-induced acute polioencephalitis was comparable to that in DA virus infection. Interestingly, during the chronic phase, DApBL2M caused prolonged gray matter disease in the brain without white matter involvement in the spinal cord. This is opposite what is observed during wild-type DA virus infection. Our study is the first to demonstrate that conformational differences via interaction of VP2 puff B and VP1 loop II between GDVII and DA viruses can play an important role in making the transition of infection from the gray matter in the brain to the spinal cord white matter during TMEV infection.

Peripheral nerve protein, P0, as a potential receptor for Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus

Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV) belongs the family Picornaviridae. TMEV not only replicates in the gastrointestinal tract but also spreads to the central nervous system (CNS) either by a hematogenous or a neural pathway during natural infection. The DA strain of TMEV infects neurons during the acute phase, and glial cells and macrophages during the chronic phase, leading to a demyelinating disease similar to multiple sclerosis. Different virus-host receptor interactions in the peripheral and the neuronal cells could explain the pathways of viral spread from the peripheral to the CNS and neurons to glial cells. However, the receptor for TMEV remains unknown. P0 protein, a 28-31 kD glycoprotein, belongs to the immunoglobulin superfamily and constitutes 50% of the total myelin protein in the peripheral nerve. Other picornaviruses use members of the immunoglobulin superfamily as receptors. Thus we hypothesized P0 protein could act as a receptor for TMEV. In a virus overlay assay, radiolabeled TMEV bound to a 28-30 kD protein from the peripheral nerve of wild-type C57BL/6, but no binding was found in the peripheral nerve from P0-knockout mice. TMEV replicated fourfold higher in P0-transfected BW5147.G.1.4 cells than in mock-transfected cells. The increase in virus replication in the P0-transfected cell line was blocked by preincubation of the cells with anti-P0 antibody. A virus binding study showed that TMEV bound to P0-transfected cells but not to mock-transfected cells. The use of the P0 protein in Schwann cells as a receptor may be one mechanism by which TMEV spreads from the gastrointestinal tract to the CNS.

The CD4-mediated immune response is critical in determining the outcome of infection using Theiler's viruses with VP1 capsid protein point mutations

Daniel's strain of Theiler's virus (DA) induces a chronic demyelinating disease in the central nervous system (CNS) of susceptible SJL mice, which serves as an excellent model of multiple sclerosis. We previously demonstrated that point mutations near a putative virus receptor-binding site [VP1 99 (Gly to Ser) or 100 (Gly to Asp)] totally attenuate the ability of DA to persist and induce demyelination in SJL mice. The current studies demonstrate that class II-restricted CD4(+) T cells play a major role in clearing VP1 mutant DA viruses from the CNS to prevent demyelination. Infection of SJL CD4((-/-)) mice with DA-VP1-99(Ser) or DA-VP1-100(Asp) resulted in virus persistence and prominent demyelination in the spinal cord. In contrast, infection of SJL CD8((-/-)) mice with DA-VP1-99(Ser) or DA-VP1-100 did not result in virus persistence or demyelination. In addition, no virus-specific cytotoxicity was observed in CNS-infiltrating lymphocytes following infection of SJL mice with VP1 mutant viruses. The mutant DA-VP1-99(Ser) and DA-VP1(100) viruses were in fact neurovirulent when compared to the wild-type DA virus, as they induced an overwhelming encephalitis and early lethality (2 to 4 days postinfection) in mice deficient in the IFN-alpha/beta receptor. Therefore, the nondemyelinating phenotype observed with DA-VP1-99(Ser) and DA-VP1-100(Asp) viruses is dependent in part on the CD4-mediated host immune response.

Theiler's viruses with mutations in loop I of VP1 lead to altered tropism and pathogenesis

Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis viruses are picornaviruses that can infect the central nervous system. The DA strain produces an acute polioencephalomyelitis followed by a chronic demyelinating disease in its natural host, the mouse. The ability of DA virus to induce a demyelinating disease renders this virus infection a model for human demyelinating diseases such as multiple sclerosis. Here we describe the generation and characterization of DA virus mutants that contain specific mutations in the viral capsid protein VP1 at sites believed to be important contact regions for the cellular receptor(s). A mutant virus with a threonine-to-aspartate (T81D) substitution in VP1 loop I adjacent to the putative virus receptor binding site exhibited a large-plaque phenotype but had a slower replication cycle in vitro. When this mutant virus was injected into susceptible mice, an altered tropism was seen during the acute stage of the disease and the chronic demyelinating disease was not produced. A virus with a threonine-to-valine substitution (T81V) did not cause any changes in the pattern or extent of disease seen in mice, whereas a virus with a tryptophan substitution at this position (T81W) produced a similar acute disease but was attenuated for the development of the chronic disease. A change in amino acids in a hydrophobic patch located in the wall of the pit, VP1 position 91, to a hydrophilic threonine (V91T) resulted in a profound attenuation of the acute and chronic disease without persistence of virus. This report illustrates the importance of the loop I of VP1 and a site in the wall of the pit in pathogenesis and that amino acid substitutions at these sites result in altered virus-host interactions.

Replacement of loop II of VP1 of the DA strain with loop II of the GDVII strain of Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus alters neurovirulence, viral persistence, and demyelination

Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis viruses, which are murine picornaviruses, can cause central nervous system inflammatory disease. To study the role of loop II in capsid protein VP1, two mutant viruses of strain DA in which DA loop II amino acids were replaced with strain GDVII amino acids were constructed. Infection of mice with the two mutant viruses led to dramatically different patterns of disease.

Adaptation of Theiler's virus to L929 cells: mutations in the putative receptor binding site on the capsid map to neutralization sites and modulate viral persistence

Persistent strains of Theiler's virus, a murine picornavirus, produce a life-long infection of the central nervous system of the mouse and induce a chronic demyelinating disease. Strain DA1, a molecular clone of such a persistent strain, produces a prominent cytopathic effect in BHK-21 cells but is less efficient at infecting L929 cells. We cloned the cDNA of a derivative of virus DA1, adapted to promote a rapid cytopathic effect in L929 cells. Adaptation of the new variant (named KJ6) to L929 cells correlated with an enhanced viral entry rather than with an increased replication rate of the genome. Mutations responsible for L929 cells adaptation occurred in amino acids exposed at the surface of the capsid, in the CD loop of VP1 (100-102) and in the EF loop of VP2 (162-171-173), suggesting that these residues could be involved in receptor recognition. These two clusters of amino acids are precisely known to be part of neutralization epitopes. They also differentiate persistent from neurovirulent strains of Theiler's virus. Adaptation of the virus to L929 cells was accompanied by attenuation of its virulence for the mouse. Taken together, these data suggest a close relationship between receptor binding, virus neutralization, and virus phenotype.

Molecular characterization of a nondemyelinating variant of Daniel's strain of Theiler's virus isolated from a persistently infected glioma cell line

Wild-type Daniel's strain of Theiler's virus (wt-DA) induces a chronic demyelination in susceptible mice which is similar to multiple sclerosis. A variant of wt-DA (designated DA-P12) generated during the 12th passage of persistent infection of a G26-20 glioma cell line failed to persist and induce demyelination in SJL/J mice. To identify the determinants responsible for this change in phenotype, we sequenced the capsid coding sequence (nucleotides [nt] 2991 to 3994) and found three mutations in VP1: residues 99 (Gly to Ser), 100 (Gly to Asp), and 103 (Asn to Lys). To study the role of these mutations in neurovirulence and demyelination, we prepared a recombinant virus, DAP-1C-2A/DA, with replacement of wt-DA nt 2991 to 3994 with the corresponding region of DA-P12, and viruses with individual point mutations at VP1 residues 99(Ser), 100(Asp), and 103(Lys). DAP-1C-2A/DA and viruses with a mutation at VP1 residue 99 or 100 (but not 103) completely attenuated the ability of wt-DA to induce demyelination. Failure to induce demyelination was not due to a general failure in growth, since DA-P12 and other mutant viruses lysed L-2 cells in vitro as effectively as wt-DA. The change in disease phenotype was independent of the specific B- or T-cell immune recognition because a decrease in the neurovirulence of mutant viruses was observed in neonatal mice and immune-deficient RAG1 -/- mice. This difference in neurovirulence is not the complete explanation for the failure of DA-P12 to demyelinate, since virus with a mutation at residue 103(Lys) had decreased neurovirulence but did induce demyelination. Therefore, point mutation at VP1 residue 99 or 100 altered the ability of wt-DA to demyelinate, perhaps related to a disruption in interaction between virus and receptor on certain neural cells.

Role of sialyloligosaccharide binding in Theiler's virus persistence

Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis viruses (TMEVs) belong to the Picornaviridae family and are divided into two groups, typified by strain GDVII virus and members of the TO (Theiler's original) group. The highly virulent GDVII group causes acute encephalitis in mice, while the TO group is less virulent and causes a chronic demyelinating disease which is associated with viral persistence in mice. This persistent central nervous system infection with demyelination resembles multiple sclerosis (MS) in humans and has thus become an important model for studying MS. It has been shown that some of the determinants associated with viral persistence are located on the capsid proteins of the TO group. Structural comparisons of two persistent strains (BeAn and DA) and a highly virulent strain (GDVII) showed that the most significant structural variations between these two groups of viruses are located on the sites that may influence virus binding to cellular receptors. Most animal viruses attach to specific cellular receptors that, in part, determine host range and tissue tropism. In this study, atomic models of TMEV chimeras were built with the known structures of GDVII, BeAn, and DA viruses. Comparisons among the known GDVII, BeAn, and DA structures as well as the predicted models for the TMEV chimeras suggested that a gap on the capsid surface next to the putative receptor binding site, composed of residues from VP1 and VP2, may be important in determining viral persistence by influencing virus attachment to cellular receptors, such as sialyloligosaccharides. Our results showed that sialyllactose, the first three sugar molecules of common oligosaccharides on the surface of mammalian cells, inhibits virus binding to the host cell and infection with the persistent BeAn virus but not the nonpersistent GDVII and chimera 39 viruses.

The immune system preferentially clears Theiler's virus from the gray matter of the central nervous system

Infection of susceptible strains of mice with Daniel's (DA) strains of Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (DAV) results in virus persistence in the central nervous system (CNS) white matter and chronic demyelination similar to that observed in multiple sclerosis. We investigated whether persistence is due to the immune system more efficiently clearing DAV from gray than from white matter of the CNS. Severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) and immunocompetent C.B-17 mice were infected with DAV to determine the kinetics, temporal distribution, and tropism of the virus in CNS. In early disease (6 h to 7 days postinfection), DAV replicated with similar kinetics in the brains and spinal cords of SCID and immunocompetent mice and in gray and white matter. DAV RNA was localized within 48 h in CNS cells of all phenotypes, including neurons, oligodendrocytes, astrocytes, and macrophages/microglia. In late disease (13 to 17 days postinfection), SCID mice became moribund and permitted higher DAV replication in both gray and white matter. In contrast, immunocompetent mice cleared virus from the gray matter but showed replication in the white matter of their brains and spinal cords. Reconstitution of SCID mice with nonimmune splenocytes or anti-DAV antibodies after establishment of infection demonstrated that both cellular and humoral immune responses decreased virus from the gray matter; however, the cellular responses were more effective. SCID mice reconstituted with splenocytes depleted of CD4+ or CD8+ T lymphocytes cleared virus from the gray matter but allowed replication in the white matter. These studies demonstrate that both neurons and glia are infected early following DAV infection but that virus persistence in the white matter is due to preferential clearance of virus from the gray matter by the immune system.

Role of VP2 amino acid 141 in tropism of Theiler's virus within the central nervous system

Following intracranial inoculation, Theiler's virus causes either an acute encephalitis (strain GDVII) or a chronic demyelinating disease (strain DA). The DA strain sequentially infects the grey matter of the brain, the grey matter of the spinal cord, and, finally, the white matter of the spinal cord, where it persists in glial cells and causes demyelinating lesions. Analysis of the phenotype of recombinant viruses has shown that the viral capsid contains determinants for persistence and demyelination. Our previous studies showed that a Lys at position 141 of the VP2 capsid protein (VP2-141) could render a chimeric virus persistent. We also reported that another recombinant virus, virus R5, migrated from the grey matter of the brain to that of the spinal cord inefficiently and was unable to infect the white matter of the spinal cord. In this article, we report that introducing a Lys at position VP2-141 in virus R5 increases its ability to infect the white matter of the spinal cord. Our results indicate that this amino acid is important for the spread of the virus within the central nervous system.

The leader polypeptide of Theiler's virus is essential for neurovirulence but not for virus growth in BHK cells

A leader polypeptide of unknown function is encoded by cardioviruses, such as Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus. Although the deletion of this polypeptide has little effect on the growth of parental GDVII virus in baby hamster kidney (BHK) cells, the mutant virus is completely attenuated and fails to kill mice receiving intracerebral inoculations of high doses of the virus.

The neurovirulent GDVII strain of Theiler's virus can replicate in glial cells

The distribution, spread, neuropathology, tropism, and persistence of the neurovirulent GDVII strain of Theiler's virus in the central nervous system (CNS) was investigated in mice susceptible and resistant to chronic demyelinating infection with TO strains. Following intracerebral inoculation, the virus spread rapidly to specific areas of the CNS. There were, however, specific structures in which infection was consistently undetectable. Virus spread both between adjacent cell bodies and along neuronal pathways. The distribution of the infection was dependent on the site of inoculation. The majority of viral RNA-positive cells were neurons. Many astrocytes were also positive. Infection of both of these cell types was lytic. In contrast, viral RNA-positive oligodendrocytes were rare and were observed only in well-established areas of infection. The majority of oligodendrocytes in these areas were viral RNA negative and were often the major cell type remaining; however, occasional destruction of these cells was observed. No differences in any of the above parameters were observed between CBA and BALB/c mice, susceptible and resistant, respectively, to chronic CNS demyelinating infection with TO strains of Theiler's virus. By using Southern blot hybridization to detect reverse-transcribed PCR-amplified viral RNA sequences, no virus persistence could be detected in the CNS of immunized mice surviving infection with GDVII. In conclusion, the GDVII strain of Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus cannot persist in the CNS, but this is not consequent upon an inability to infect glial cells, including oligodendrocytes.