Metabolism of low density lipoproteins by pigeon skin fibroblasts and aortic smooth muscle cells. Comparison of cells from atherosclerosis-susceptible and atherosclerosis-resistant pigeons

The pigeon (Columba livia) model of spontaneous atherosclerosis

Multiple animal models have been employed to study human atherosclerosis, the principal cause of mortality in the United States. Each model has individual advantages related to specific pathologies. Initiation, the earliest disease phase, is best modeled by the White Carneau (WC-As) pigeon. Atherosclerosis develops spontaneously in the WC-As without either external manipulation or known risk factors. Furthermore, susceptibility is caused by a single gene defect inherited in an autosomal recessive manner. The Show Racer (SR-Ar) pigeon is resistant to atherosclerosis. Breed differences in the biochemistry and metabolism of celiac foci cells have been described. For example, WC-As have lower oxidative metabolism but higher amounts of chondroitin-6-sulfate and nonesterified fatty acids compared with SR-Ar. Gene expression in aortic smooth muscle cells was compared between breeds using representational difference analysis and microarray analysis. Energy metabolism and cellular phenotype were the chief gene expression differences. Glycolysis and synthetic cell types were related to the WC-As but oxidative metabolism and contractile cell types were related to the SR-Ar. Rosiglitazone, a PPARγ agonist, blocked RNA binding motif (RBMS1) expression in WC-As cells. The drug may act through the c-myc oncogene as RBMS1 is a c-myc target. Proteomic tests of aortic smooth muscle cells supported greater glycosylation in the WC-As and a transforming growth factor β effect in SR-Ar. Unoxidized fatty acids build up in WC-As cells because of their metabolic deficiency, ultimately preventing the contractile phenotype in these cells. The single gene responsible for the disease is likely regulatory in nature.

Differentially expressed genes in aortic smooth muscle cells from atherosclerosis-susceptible and atherosclerosis-resistant pigeons

Susceptibility to spontaneous atherosclerosis in the White Carneau (WC-As) pigeon shows autosomal recessive inheritance. Aortic smooth muscle cells (SMC) cultured from susceptible WC-As and resistant Show Racer (SR-Ar) pigeons exhibit developmental and degenerative features corresponding to the respective SMC at atherosclerosis-prone sites in vivo. We used representational difference analysis to identify differentially expressed genes between WC-As and SR-Ar aortic SMC. Total RNA was extracted from cultured primary SMC of each breed, converted to double-stranded cDNA, followed by direct comparison in reciprocal representational difference analysis experiments. Difference products were cloned, sequenced, and identified by BLAST against the chicken genome. Six putative biochemical pathways were distinctly different between breeds with genes involved in energy metabolism and contractility exhibiting the most striking disparity. Genes associated with glycolysis and a synthetic SMC phenotype were expressed in WC-As cells. In contrast, SR-Ar cells expressed genes indicative of oxidative phosphorylation and a contractile SMC phenotype. In WC-As cells, the alternatives of insufficient ATP production limiting contractile function or the lack of functional contractile elements downregulating ATP synthesis cannot be distinguished due to the compressed in vitro versus in vivo developmental time frame. However, the genetic potential for effectively coupling energy production to muscle contraction present in the resistant SR-Ar was lacking in the susceptible WC-As.

Identification of a variant collagen alpha 3 (VI) in early-stage avian arteriosclerotic plaques

A 170 kD protein, prominent in soluble extracts of rooster arteriosclerotic plaques, has been partially characterized. The protein was eluted from a size exclusion column in a broad molecular weight fraction > 100 kD. Concanavalin A and a murine polyclonal antibody raised against the isolated 170 kD protein reacted with the protein on Western blots. The 170 kD protein had an isoelectric point of approximately 5.4 and was digested by collagenase treatment. Amino acid analysis of a 70 kD fragment of the protein closely resembled that for chick collagen alpha 3 (VI). A 13 amino acid sequence within this 70 kD fragment had 69% identity and 85% homology to chicken collagen alpha 3 (VI). Soluble protein extracts from cultured plaque smooth muscle cells (SMC), and from healthy artery SMC, contained low levels of the protein. These cellular extracts also reacted with the polyclonal antibody described above. Although the protein lacks absolute amino acid sequence identity with collagen alpha 3 (VI) it shares with it many biochemical features, suggesting that the 170 kD protein is a variant species of chick collagen alpha 3 (VI).

Benzo(a)pyrene enhances atherosclerosis in White Carneau and Show Racer pigeons

Benzo(a)pyrene (BaP), a major environmental pollutant and component of cigarette smoke, is both carcinogenic and atherogenic in experimental models. We investigated the effect of long-term administration of BaP on atherogenesis in both atherosclerosis-susceptible White Carneau (WC) and atherosclerosis-resistant Show Racer (SR) pigeons. The number and size of arterial lesions in the brachiocephalic arteries in WC and SR females but not males were significantly enhanced after long-term dosing with BaP. Metabolic activation appears to be required for BaP atherogenicity, since benzo(e)pyrene (BeP), a noncarcinogenic analogue of BaP, did not enhance lesion development. Studies with 3H-BaP revealed no significant differences between male and female or between WC and SR pigeons in the arterial distribution of BaP and/or its metabolites. There were no consistent differences in blood pressure or plasma cholesterol levels between breeds or sexes. However, chronic administration of BaP did result in complete infertility in female birds, concomitant with grossly visible changes in ovarian appearance. These results clearly show that long-term dosing with BaP alters ovarian structure and function in treated birds, at the same time aggravating the development of arterial lesions. Thus, BaP-induced atherogenicity in female pigeons may be a consequence of an alteration in estrogen production or of antiestrogenic properties of BaP at the level of the arterial wall and may serve as a highly useful animal model to examine the well-known rapid development of atherosclerosis in postmenopausal women.

Long-term treatment of neonatal aortic smooth muscle cells with beta VLDL induces cholesterol accumulation

A model for smooth muscle derived foam cells was developed by treating smooth muscle cells isolated from the aortae of neonatal rabbits with beta VLDL for up to 1 month. Hyperlipidemic beta VLDL isolated from cholesterol fed rabbits induced proliferation of the cells that were maintained in lipid deficient serum. In addition, the lipoprotein fraction stimulated [14C]oleic acid incorporation into [14C]cholesteryl ester, even in cultures that had been chronically exposed to the lipoprotein. The accumulation of cholesterol was evaluated and small amounts of cholesteryl ester were demonstrated in cultures treated for 3 days with beta VLDL. However, continued exposure to the lipoprotein resulted in larger elevations in total cholesterol, approximately 65% of which was in the esterified form in cultures treated with 100 micrograms beta VLDL/ml for 24 days. When cholesterol levels were examined as a function of time, it was determined that both total cholesterol and cholesteryl ester levels increased. Approximately 2-3 weeks after lipoprotein was introduced to the culture, maximum levels were attained. Triglyceride levels were also measured and found to increase more than two-fold in cultures that had been incubated in the presence of beta VLDL for 24 days, when compared to cultures incubated in its absence. Examination of the cultures by electron microscopy revealed intracytoplasmic lipid droplets in beta VLDL treated cells. These results suggest that beta VLDL treatment of neonatal aortic smooth muscle cells provides an ideal model in which to study the lipid laden smooth muscle cells that characterize the atherosclerotic plaque.

In vivo clearance of low-density lipoproteins and beta-very-low-density lipoproteins in normal and hypercholesterolemic White Carneau pigeons

Low-density lipoproteins (hLDL) and beta-migrating-very-low-density lipoproteins (beta-VLDL) were isolated from the plasma of cholesterol-fed White Carneau (WC) pigeons and low-density lipoproteins (nLDL) were isolated from the plasma of grain-fed WC pigeons. The lipoproteins were radiolabeled with 125I or 131I and injected into normocholesterolemic or hypercholesterolemic WC pigeons to determine their rate of clearance from the plasma. The fractional catabolic rate (FCR) of nLDL and hLDL in normocholesterolemic pigeons averaged 0.202 and 0.206 pools/h.respectively. beta-VLDL was cleared at a significantly slower rate of 0.155 pools/h. The FCR of the same lipoproteins injected into hypercholesterolemic pigeons was reduced by 17% for nLDL, 50% for hLDL and 57% for beta-VLDL, indicating that the effect of hypercholesterolemia on clearance in vivo was different for the three lipoproteins. The FCR of reductively methylated pigeon LDL (MeLDL), which gives a measure of receptor-independent clearance of LDL, was shown previously to be 0.037 pools/h. These studies suggest therefore that LDL and beta-VLDL are cleared from the plasma of normocholesterolemic and hypercholesterolemic pigeons at a rate substantially greater than that predicted for non-specific processes. Despite the reduction in the clearance rate of hLDL and beta-VLDL due to cholesterol feeding, the absolute amount of cholesterol that was cleared from the plasma by these lipoproteins was increased from approx. 200 mg/kg body weight per day in the normocholesterolemic pigeons to greater than 1000 mg/kg body weight per day in the hypercholesterolemic pigeons. This is due principally to the enrichment in cholesterol relative to protein of the lipoproteins isolated from cholesterol-fed pigeons and the failure of hypercholesterolemia to completely inhibit receptor-dependent clearance of LDL and beta-VLDL. The lower rate of clearance of beta-VLDL relative to LDL is in marked contrast to mammalian beta-VLDL, which is cleared much faster than LDL, but is consistent with the lack of apo E on pigeon lipoproteins. Apo E is the apoprotein that is thought to be responsible for the rapid clearance of beta-VLDL in normocholesterolemic mammals. The low rate of beta-VLDL clearance in pigeons also suggests that pigeons lack an apolipoprotein that function like mammalian apo E.

beta-VLDL and acetylated-LDL binding to pigeon monocyte macrophages

Blood-derived monocytes are an important source of foam cells in atherosclerotic lesions of White Carneau pigeons. Based upon studies with cultured blood monocytes (monocyte macrophages) and peritoneal macrophages from a variety of mammalian species, it has been proposed that these cells become loaded with cholesteryl esters through the uptake of lipoproteins including beta-migrating very low density lipoproteins (beta-VLDL) and low density lipoproteins that have been chemically modified in a manner analogous to experimental acetylation (Ac-LDL). The purpose of this study was to determine whether similar mechanisms functioned in pigeon monocyte macrophages. Radioiodinated pigeon beta-VLDL and Ac-LDL were incubated with White Carneau pigeon monocyte macrophages that had been maintained in culture for 7 days. Scatchard analysis of the specific binding data revealed the presence of specific and saturable receptors for both beta-VLDL and Ac-LDL. beta-VLDL receptors had both low and high affinity binding components, whereas Ac-LDL receptors displayed a single class of high affinity binding sites. beta-VLDL binding remained relatively constant from 3 to 10 days in culture while Ac-LDL binding increased with time in culture. Competition studies demonstrated a high degree of binding specificity for 125I-Ac-LDL, but less for 125I-beta-VLDL. Binding of 125I-beta-VLDL was not competed for by Ac-LDL, but was by beta-VLDL and by low density lipoproteins from both normal and hypercholesterolemic pigeons. Following binding of beta-VLDL and Ac-LDL, the lipoproteins were rapidly internalized and degraded. Although the majority of degradation was secondary to internalization by the monocyte macrophages, approx. 5% of the degradation resulted from enzymatic activity in the culture medium, presumably due to secretion of proteolytic enzymes by the cells. As measured by esterification of [14C]oleate to cholesterol, it was shown that the cholesterol liberated from the degradation of both beta-VLDL and Ac-LDL stimulated cholesteryl ester synthesis in pigeon monocyte macrophages. These studies confirm the existence of specific beta-VLDL and Ac-LDL receptors on the surface of pigeon monocyte macrophages which facilitate both internalization of the lipoproteins and subsequent stimulation of cholesteryl ester synthesis. This is the first demonstration of beta-VLDL and Ac-LDL receptors on monocyte macrophages from an avian species, and the findings support the potential role for the receptor-mediated uptake of a variety of abnormal lipoproteins in the formation of monocyte-derived foam cells in the arterial wall of White Carneau pigeons during the development of atherosclerosis.

Cholesteryl ester accumulation in smooth muscle cells after uptake of necrotic products from atherosclerotic lesions

Cholesterol-ladened plasma membrane vesicles were used to load smooth muscle cells (SMC) with cholesterol. Plasma membrane vesicles (PMV) were isolated from rabbit atherosclerotic lesions, and characterized as to size, cholesterol content, and marker enzyme (plasma membrane, lysosome, endoplasmic reticulum) composition. PMV were regarded as a necrotic product since they are produced upon injury to cells. Degradation of PMV was proportional to the PMV protein concentration in the culture medium, suggesting bulk intake of PMV. Cholesterol accumulation of SMC varied with the cholesterol content of the vesicle. Incubation for 3 days with PMV having 0.39 and 0.62 mg cholesterol/mg protein induced the accumulation of 8 and 29 micrograms of esterified cholesterol/mg cell protein, respectively. Incorporation of oleate into cholesteryl ester during a 24-hr period under these conditions, however, was the same. The contribution of cholesterol ester synthesis to the esterified cholesterol content of SMC was 40 and 11% of the total when exposed to PMV having, respectively, low and high contents of cholesterol. This study suggests that cholesterol-bearing PMV in lesions can be utilized to load lesion-SMC. These observations suggest that lipid-bearing elements other than low density lipoprotein may be responsible for cholesterol-loaded SMC in lesions.