The double edged sword of the immune response: mutational analysis of a murine anti-pneumococcal, anti-DNA antibody

SLE: a cognitive step forward-a synthesis of rethinking theories, causality, and ignored DNA structures

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is classified by instinctual classification criteria. A valid proclamation is that these formally accepted SLE classification criteria legitimate the syndrome as being difficult to explain and therefore enigmatic. SLE involves scientific problems linked to etiological factors and criteria. Our insufficient understanding of the clinical condition uniformly denoted SLE depends on the still open question of whether SLE is, according to classification criteria, a well-defined one disease entity or represents a variety of overlapping indistinct syndromes. Without rational hypotheses, these problems harm clear definition(s) of the syndrome. Why SLE is not anchored in logic, consequent, downstream interdependent and interactive inflammatory networks may rely on ignored predictive causality principles. Authoritative classification criteria do not reflect consequent causality criteria and do not unify characterization principles such as diagnostic criteria. We need now to reconcile legendary scientific achievements to concretize the delimitation of what SLE really is. Not all classified SLE syndromes are "genuine SLE"; many are theoretically "SLE-like non-SLE" syndromes. In this study, progressive theories imply imperative challenges to reconsider the fundamental impact of "the causality principle". This may offer us logic classification and diagnostic criteria aimed at identifying concise SLE syndromes as research objects. Can a systems science approach solve this problem?

The greatest contribution to medical science is the transformation from studying symptoms to studying their causes-the unrelenting legacy of Robert Koch and Louis Pasteur-and a causality perspective to approach a definition of SLE

The basic initiative related to this study is derived from the fact that systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a unique and fertile system science subject. We are, however, still far from understanding its nature. It may be fair to indicate that we are spending more time and resources on studying the complexity of classified SLE than studying the validity of classification criteria. This study represents a theoretical analysis of current instinctual SLE classification criteria based on "the causality principle." The discussion has its basis on the radical scientific traditions introduced by Robert Koch and Louis Pasteur. They announced significant changes in our thinking of disease etiology through the implementation of the modern version of "the causality principle." They influenced all aspects of today's medical concepts and research: the transformation of medical science from studies of symptoms to study their causes, relevant for monosymptomatic diseases as for syndromes. Their studies focused on bacteria as causes of infectious diseases and on how the immune system adapts to control and prevent contagious spreading. This is the most significant paradigm shift in the modern history of medicine and resulted in radical changes in our view of the immune system. They described acquired post-infection immunity and active immunization by antigen-specific vaccines. The paradigm "transformation" has a great theoretical impact also on current studies of autoimmune diseases like SLE: symptoms and their cause(s). In this study, the evolution of SLE classification and diagnostic criteria is discussed from "the causality principle" perspective, and if contemporary SLE classification criteria are as useful as believed today for SLE research. This skepticism is based on the fact that classification criteria are not selected based on cogent causal strategies. The SLE classification criteria do not harmonize with Koch's and Pasteur's causality principle paradigms and not with Witebsky's Koch-derived postulates for autoimmune and infectious diseases. It is not established whether the classification criteria can separate SLE as a "one disease entity" from "SLE-like non-SLE disorders"-the latter in terms of SLE imitations. This is discussed here in terms of weight, rank, and impact of the classification criteria: Do they all originate from "one basic causal etiology"? Probably not.

Revisiting B cell tolerance and autoantibodies in seropositive and seronegative autoimmune rheumatic disease (AIRD)

Autoimmune rheumatic diseases (AIRD) are categorized seropositive or seronegative, dependent upon the presence or absence of specific autoreactive antibodies, including rheumatoid factor and anti-citrullinated protein antibodies. Autoantibody-based diagnostics have proved helpful in patient care, not only for diagnosis but also for monitoring of disease activity and prediction of therapy responsiveness. Recent work demonstrates that AIRD patients develop autoantibodies beyond those contained in the original categorization. In this study we discuss key mechanisms that underlie autoantibody development in AIRD: defects in early B cell development, genetic variants involved in regulating B cell and T cell tolerance, environmental triggers and antigen modification. We describe how autoantibodies can directly contribute to AIRD pathogenesis through innate and adaptive immune mechanisms, eventually culminating in systemic inflammation and localized tissue damage. We conclude by discussing recent insights that suggest distinct AIRD have incorrectly been denominated seronegative.

Autoimmunity and SLE: Factual and Semantic Evidence-Based Critical Analyses of Definitions, Etiology, and Pathogenesis

One cannot discuss anti-dsDNA antibodies and lupus nephritis without discussing the nature of Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). SLE is insistently described as a prototype autoimmune syndrome, with anti-dsDNA antibodies as a central biomarker and a pathogenic factor. The two entities, "SLE" and "The Anti-dsDNA Antibody," have been linked in previous and contemporary studies although serious criticism to this mutual linkage have been raised: Anti-dsDNA antibodies were first described in bacterial infections and not in SLE; later in SLE, viral and parasitic infections and in malignancies. An increasing number of studies on classification criteria for SLE have been published in the aftermath of the canonical 1982 American College of Rheumatology SLE classification sets of criteria. Considering these studies, it is surprising to observe a nearby complete absence of fundamental critical/theoretical discussions aimed to explain how and why the classification criteria are linked in context of etiology, pathogenicity, or biology. This study is an attempt to prioritize critical comments on the contemporary definition and classification of SLE and of anti-dsDNA antibodies in context of lupus nephritis. Epidemiology, etiology, pathogenesis, and measures of therapy efficacy are implemented as problems in the present discussion. In order to understand whether or not disparate clinical SLE phenotypes are useful to determine its basic biological processes accounting for the syndrome is problematic. A central problem is discussed on whether the clinical role of anti-dsDNA antibodies from principal reasons can be accepted as a biomarker for SLE without clarifying what we define as an anti-dsDNA antibody, and in which biologic contexts the antibodies appear. In sum, this study is an attempt to bring to the forum critical comments on the contemporary definition and classification of SLE, lupus nephritis and anti-dsDNA antibodies. Four concise hypotheses are suggested for future science at the end of this analytical study.

Neurological disorders-associated anti-glycosphingolipid IgG-antibodies display differentially restricted IgG subclass distribution

Antibodies against several self-glycans on glycosphingolipids are frequently detected in different neurological disorders. Their pathogenic role is profusely documented, but the keys for their origin remain elusive. Additionally, antibodies recognizing non-self glycans appear in normal human serum during immune response to bacteria. Using HPTLC-immunostaining we aimed to characterize IgM and IgG subclass antibody responses against glycosphingolipids carrying self glycans (GM1/GM2/GM3/GD1a/GD1b/GD3/GT1b/GQ1b) and non-self glycans (Forssman/GA1/“A” blood group/Nt7) in sera from 27 randomly selected neurological disorder patients presenting IgG reactivity towards any of these antigens. Presence of IgG2 (p = 0.0001) and IgG1 (p = 0.0078) was more frequent for IgG antibodies against non-self glycans, along with less restricted antibody response (two or more simultaneous IgG subclasses). Contrariwise, IgG subclass distribution against self glycans showed clear dominance for IgG3 presence (p = 0.0017) and more restricted IgG-subclass distributions (i.e. a single IgG subclass, p = 0.0133). Interestingly, anti-self glycan IgG antibodies with simultaneous IgM presence had higher proportion of IgG2 (p = 0.0295). IgG subclass frequencies were skewed towards IgG1 (p = 0.0266) for “anti-self glycan A” subgroup (GM2/GM1/GD1b) and to IgG3 (p = 0.0007) for “anti-self glycan B” subgroup (GM3/GD1a/GD3/GT1b/GQ1b). Variations in players and/or antigenic presentation pathways supporting isotype (M-G) and IgG-subclass pattern differences in the humoral immune response against glycosphingolipids carrying non-self versus self-glycans are discussed.

The dsDNA, Anti-dsDNA Antibody, and Lupus Nephritis: What We Agree on, What Must Be Done, and What the Best Strategy Forward Could Be

This study aims to understand what lupus nephritis is, its origin, clinical context, and its pathogenesis. Truly, we encounter many conceptual and immanent tribulations in our attempts to search for the pathogenesis of this disease—and how to explain its assumed link to SLE. Central in the present landscape stay a short history of the early studies that substantiated the structures of isolated or chromatin-assembled mammalian dsDNA, and its assumed, highly controversial role in induction of anti-dsDNA antibodies. Arguments discussed here may provoke the view that anti-dsDNA antibodies are not what we think they are, as they may be antibodies operational in quite different biological contexts, although they bind dsDNA by chance. This may not mean that these antibodies are not pathogenic but they do not inform how they are so. This theoretical study centers the content around the origin and impact of extra-cellular DNA, and if dsDNA has an effect on the adaptive immune system. The pathogenic potential of chromatin-anti-dsDNA antibody interactions is limited to incite lupus nephritis and dermatitis which may be linked in a common pathogenic process. These are major criteria in SLE classification systems but are not shared with other defined manifestations in SLE, which may mean that they are their own disease entities, and not integrated in SLE. Today, the models thought to explain lupus nephritis are divergent and inconsistent. We miss a comprehensive perspective to try the different models against each other. To do this, we need to take all elements of the syndrome SLE into account. This can only be achieved by concentrating on the interactions between autoimmunity, immunopathology, deviant cell death and necrotic chromatin in context of elements of system science. System science provides a framework where data generated by experts can be compared, and tested against each other. This approach open for consensus on central elements making up “lupus nephritis” to separate what we agree on and how to understand the basis for conflicting models. This has not been done yet in a systematic context.

Autoantibodies in systemic autoimmune diseases: specificity and pathogenicity

In this Review we focus on the initiation of autoantibody production and autoantibody pathogenicity, with a special emphasis on the targeted antigens. Release of intracellular antigens due to excessive cell death or to ineffective clearance of apoptotic debris, modification of self-antigens during inflammatory responses, and molecular mimicry contribute to the initiation of autoantibody production. We hypothesize that those autoreactive B cells that survive and produce pathogenic autoantibodies have specificity for self-antigens that are TLR ligands. Such B cells experience both B cell receptor (BCR) activation and TLR engagement, leading to an escape from tolerance. Moreover, the autoantibodies they produce form immune complexes that can activate myeloid cells and thereby establish the proinflammatory milieu that further negates tolerance mechanisms of both B and T cells.

C4 Deficiency is a predisposing factor for Streptococcus pneumoniae-induced autoantibody production

Reductions in C4 levels may predispose individuals to infection with encapsulated bacteria as well as autoimmunity. In this study, we examined the role C4 has in protection against Streptococcus pneumoniae-induced autoimmunity. Mild respiratory infection with serotype 19F pneumococci selectively induced systemic anti-dsDNA IgA production in naive C4(-/-) mice, but not in C3(-/-) or wild-type mice. Systemic challenge with virulent serotype 3 pneumococci also induced anti-dsDNA IgA production in immune C4(-/-) mice. Remarkably, pneumococcal polysaccharide (PPS) vaccination alone induced C4(-/-) mice to produce increased anti-dsDNA IgA levels that were maintained in some mice for months. These effects were most pronounced in female C4(-/-) mice. Importantly, immunization-induced increases in anti-dsDNA IgA levels were strongly associated with increased IgA deposition in kidneys. Cross-reactivity between pneumococcal Ags and dsDNA played a partial role in the induction of anti-dsDNA IgA, but a major role for PPS-associated TLR2 agonists was also revealed. Administration of the TLR2/4 antagonist, OxPAPC, at the time of PPS immunization completely blocked the production of anti-dsDNA IgA in C4(-/-) mice without suppressing PPS-specific Ab production. The TLR2 agonist, Pam3CSK4, similarly induced anti-dsDNA IgA production in C4(-/-) mice, which OxPAPC also prevented. LPS, a TLR4 agonist, had no effect. Pam3CSK4, but not LPS, also induced dsDNA-specific IgA production by C4(-/-) splenic IgA(+) B cells in vitro, indicating that TLR2 agonists can stimulate autoantibody production via B cell-intrinsic mechanisms. Collectively, our results show an important role for C4 in suppressing autoantibody production elicited by cross-reactive Ags and TLR2 agonists associated with S. pneumoniae.

Effects of adjuvants for human use in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)-prone (New Zealand black/New Zealand white) F1 mice

The safety of four different adjuvants was assessed in lupus-prone New Zealand black/New Zealand white (BW)F1 mice. Four groups of mice were injected intraperitoneally with incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA), complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA), squalene (SQU) or aluminium hydroxide (ALU). An additional group received plain phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) (UNT group). Mice were primed at week 9 and boosted every other week up to week 15. Proteinuria became detectable at weeks 17 (IFA group), 24 (CFA group), 28 (SQU and ALU groups) and 32 (UNT group). Different mean values were obtained among the groups from weeks 17 to 21 [week 17: one-way analysis of variance (anova) P = 0·016; weeks 18 and 19: P = 0·048; weeks 20 and 21: P = 0·013] being higher in the IFA group than the others [Tukey's honestly significant difference (HSD) post-test P < 0·05]. No differences in anti-DNA antibody levels were observed among groups. Anti-RNP/Sm antibody developed at week 19 in only one CFA-treated mouse. Mean mouse weight at week 18 was lower in the ALU group than the IFA (Tukey's HSD post-test P = 0·04), CFA (P = 0·01) and SQU (P < 0·0001) groups, while the mean weight in the SQU group was higher than in the IFA (P = 0·009), CFA (P = 0·013) and UNT (P = 0·005) groups. The ALU group weight decreased by almost half between weeks 29 and 31, indicating some toxic effect of ALU in the late post-immunization period. Thus, SQU was the least toxic adjuvant as it did not (i) accelerate proteinuria onset compared to IFA; (ii) induce toxicity compared to ALU or (iii) elicit anti-RNP/Sm autoantibody, as occurred in the CFA group.

The link between antibodies to OxLDL and natural protection against pneumococci depends on D(H) gene conservation

Germline D_H sequences are required for the generation of natural antibodies reactive to bacterial phosphorylcholine but not for those reactive to self-antigen.

Selection and physiological production of protective natural antibodies (NAbs) have been associated with exposure to endogenous antigens. The extent to which this association depends on germline NAb sequence is uncertain. Here we show that alterations in germline D_H sequence can sever the association between the production of self-reactive NAbs and NAbs that afford protection against a pathogen. In unmanipulated hosts, the availability of the evolutionarily conserved DFL16.1 gene segment sequence profoundly affected the serum levels of NAbs against bacterial phosphorylcholine but not oxidized low-density lipoprotein. Mice with partially altered DFL16.1 sequence could use N nucleotides to recreate the amino acid sequence associated with the classical protective T15 idiotype–positive NAbs, whereas those without DFL16.1 could not. DFL16.1 gene–deficient mice proved more susceptible to challenge with live Streptococcus pneumoniae. Our findings indicate that although production of self-reactive NAbs can be independent of germline D_H sequence, their capacity to provide protection against pathogens cannot. The potential relevance of these findings for the rational design of vaccines is discussed.

Role of Structure-Based Changes due to Somatic Mutation in Highly Homologous DNA-Binding and DNA-Hydrolyzing Autoantibodies Exemplified by A23P Substitution in the VH Domain

Anti-DNA autoantibodies are responsible for tissue injury in lupus. A subset of DNA-specific antibodies capable of DNA cleavage can be even more harmful after entering the living cells by destroying nuclear DNA. Origins of anti-DNA autoantibodies are not fully understood, and the mechanism of induction of DNA-cleaving activity remains speculative. The autoantibody BV04-01 derived from lupus-prone mouse is the only DNA-hydrolyzing immunoglobulin with known 3D structure. Identification and analysis of antibodies homologous to BV04-01 may help to understand molecular bases and origins of DNA-cleaving activity of autoantibodies. BLAST search identified murine anti-DNA autoantibody MRL-4 with sequences of variable region genes highly homologous to those of autoantibody BV04-01. Despite significant homology to BV04-01, not only MRL-4 had no DNA-cleaving activity, but also reversion of its unusual P23 mutation to the germline alanine resulted in a dramatic loss of affinity to DNA. Contrary to this effect, transfer of the P23 mutation to the BV04-01 has resulted in a significant drop in DNA binding and almost complete loss of catalytic activity. In the present paper we analyzed the properties of two homologous autoantibodies and mutants thereof and discussed the implications of unusual somatic mutations for the development of autoantibodies with DNA-binding and DNA-hydrolyzing activity.

The constant region contributes to the antigenic specificity and renal pathogenicity of murine anti-DNA antibodies

Affinity for DNA and cross-reactivity with renal antigens are associated with enhanced renal pathogenicity of lupus autoantibodies. In addition, certain IgG subclasses are enriched in nephritic kidneys, suggesting that isotype may determine the outcome of antibody binding to renal antigens. To investigate if the isotype of DNA antibodies affects renal pathogenicity by influencing antigen binding, we derived IgM, IgG1, IgG2b and IgG2a forms of the PL9-11 antibody (IgG3 anti-DNA) by in vitro class switching or PCR cloning. The affinity and specificity of PL9-11 antibodies for nuclear and renal antigens were analyzed using ELISA, Western blotting, surface plasmon resonance (SPR), binding to mesangial cells, and glomerular proteome arrays. Renal deposition and pathogenicity were assayed in mice injected with PL9-11 hybridomas. We found that PL9-11 and its isotype-switched variants had differential binding to DNA and chromatin (IgG3>IgG2a>IgG1>IgG2b>IgM) by direct and competition ELISA, and SPR. In contrast, in binding to laminin and collagen IV the IgG2a isotype actually had the highest affinity. Differences in affinity of PL9-11 antibodies for renal antigens were mirrored in analysis of specificity for glomeruli, and were associated with significant differences in renal pathogenicity in vivo and survival. Our novel findings indicate that the constant region plays an important role in the nephritogenicity of antibodies to DNA by affecting immunoglobulin affinity and specificity. Increased binding to multiple glomerular and/or nuclear antigens may contribute to the renal pathogenicity of anti-DNA antibodies of the IgG2a and IgG3 isotype. Finally, class switch recombination may be another mechanism by which B cell autoreactivity is generated.

IL-6 contributes to an immune tolerance checkpoint in post germinal center B cells

The generation of a B cell repertoire involves producing and subsequently purging autoreactive B cells. Receptor editing, clonal deletion and anergy are key mechanisms of central B cell tolerance. Somatic mutation of antigen-activated B cells within the germinal center produces a second wave of autoreactivity; but the regulatory mechanisms that operate at this phase of B cell activation are poorly understood. We recently identified a post germinal center tolerance checkpoint, where receptor editing is re-induced to extinguish autoreactivity that is generated by somatic hypermutation. Re-induction of the recombinase genes RAG1 and RAG2 in antigen-activated B cells requires antigen to engage the B cell receptor and IL-7 to signal through the IL-7 receptor. We demonstrate that this process requires IL-6 to upregulate IL-7 receptor expression on post germinal center B cells. Diminishing IL-6 by blocking antibody or haplo-insufficiency leads to reduced expression of the IL-7 receptor and RAG and increased titers of anti-DNA antibodies following immunization with a peptide mimetope of DNA. The dependence on IL-6 to initiate receptor editing is B cell intrinsic. Interestingly, estradiol decreases IL-6 expression thereby increasing the anti-DNA response. Our data reveal a novel regulatory cascade to control post germinal center B cell autoreactivity.

Autoimmunogenicity of the helix-loop-helix DNA-binding domain

Nonimmunogenic character of native DNA, and its high immunogenicity when presented in complex with the DNA-binding proteins indicate that the latter might contain molecular triggers of anti-DNA response. To find if this is the case, we have evaluated the autoimmunogenic potential of the main DNA-binding domain of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase that belongs to the canonical helix-loop-helix type. BALB/c mice were immunized with a peptide representing the domain, alone or in complex with the fragmented human DNA in the presence of an adjuvant. Mice were assessed for specific antibodies, autoantibodies against a panel of self-antigens; glomerular immunoglobulin deposition; and for the signs of autoimmune disease, such as proteinuria, and changes in the blood components. Immunization with the adjuvanted peptide-DNA complex induced autoantibodies against double-stranded DNA, histones, heterochromatin, and kidney proteins; glomerular IgG and IgA deposition; proteinuria; thrombocytopenia, and anemia. Altogether, this identifies the helix-loop-helix DNA-binding domain as one of the molecular triggers of autoimmunity to DNA and DNA-associated proteins. The experiments cast new light on the role of the DNA-binding retroviral proteins in the induction of autoimmunity, and on the origins of autoimmune complications in the microbial infections in general. It also implies that choosing the DNA-binding proteins as vaccine candidates should be done with precaution.

Abrogation of lupus nephritis in activation-induced deaminase-deficient MRL/lpr mice

We generated MRL/lpr mice deficient in activation-induced deaminase (AID). Because AID is required for Ig hypermutation and class switch recombination, these mice lack hypermutated IgG Abs. Unlike their AID wild-type littermates, AID-deficient MRL/lpr mice not only lacked autoreactive IgG Abs but also experienced a dramatic increase in the levels of autoreactive IgM. This phenotype in AID-deficient mice translated into a significant reduction in glomerulonephritis, minimal mononuclear cell infiltration in the kidney, and a dramatic increase in survival to levels comparable to those previously reported for MRL/lpr mice completely lacking B cells and well below those of mice lacking secreted Abs. Therefore, this study wherein littermates with either high levels of autoreactive IgM or autoreactive IgG were directly examined proves that autoreactive IgM Abs alone are not sufficient to promote kidney disease in MRL/lpr mice. In addition, the substantial decrease in mortality combined with a dramatic increase in autoreactive IgM Abs in AID-deficient MRL/lpr mice suggest that autoreactive IgM Abs might not only fail to promote nephritis but may also provide a protective role in MRL/lpr mice. This novel mouse model containing high levels of autoreactive, unmutated IgM Abs will help delineate the contribution of autoreactive IgM to autoimmunity.

Infections and SLE

Viral and bacterial infections may serve as an environmental trigger for the development or exacerbation of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in the genetically predetermined individual. In addition, SLE patients are more prone to develop common (pneumonia, urinary tract infection, cellulitis, sepsis), chronic (tuberculosis), and opportunistic infections possibly due to inherit genetic and immunologic defects (complement deficiencies, mannose-binding lectin [MBL] polymorphisms, elevated Fcgamma III and GM-CSF levels, osteopontion polymorphism), but also due to the broad spectrum immunosuppressive agents that are part of therapy for severe manifestations of the disease. Hence, SLE patients are considered a high-risk population, where identification and treatment of chronic infections such as tuberculosis, hepatitis B or human immunodeficiency virus, are important prior to the institution of immunosuppression so as to prevent reactivation or exacerbation of the infection. Infections in SLE patients remain a source of morbidity and mortality. A caveat often encountered is to distinguish between a lupus flare and an acute infection; in such cases parameters including elevated CRP (and adhesion molecules) may aid in the diagnosis of infection. Recent research has provided convincing evidence that EBV infection may play a major role not only in molecular mimicry but also in aberrations of B cells and apoptosis leading to a state of perpetual heightened immune response in SLE.

Cross-reactivity of human lupus anti-DNA antibodies with alpha-actinin and nephritogenic potential

OBJECTIVE

Cross-reactivity with kidney antigens is believed to be a critical determinant in the renal pathogenicity of anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibodies. Murine nephritogenic anti-dsDNA antibodies have been shown to cross-react with alpha-actinin, and anti-alpha-actinin antibodies have been found to be deposited in the kidneys of lupus mice with active nephritis. Furthermore, in humans with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), it has been found that a greater proportion of polyclonal IgG anti-dsDNA antibodies from patients with renal involvement bind to alpha-actinin than do those from patients without renal disease. We undertook this study to substantiate a direct link between cross-reactive anti-dsDNA/anti-alpha-actinin antibodies and the pathogenesis of lupus nephritis in humans.

METHODS

A panel of 10 anti-dsDNA and/or anti-alpha-actinin antibodies was generated by Epstein-Barr virus transformation of lymphocytes from patients with SLE and was extensively characterized. Antibody binding was studied by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and Western blotting. Antibody potential for pathogenicity was assessed by measuring binding to isolated glomeruli and mesangial cells and by evaluation of histologic features of the kidney following injection in vivo.

RESULTS

All anti-dsDNA antibodies isolated also bound alpha-actinin. Cross-reactive antibodies bound to mesangial cells and to isolated glomeruli ex vivo. Binding to glomeruli was not inhibited by DNase treatment, but could be abrogated by alpha-actinin. Furthermore, histopathologic abnormalities seen in mice injected intraperitoneally with a cross-reactive cell line included fusion of podocyte foot processes and subepithelial and subendothelial deposition.

CONCLUSION

These studies provide strong support for the hypothesis that alpha-actinin is a major cross-reactive target for anti-dsDNA antibodies in SLE patients. Cross-reactive anti-dsDNA/anti-alpha-actinin antibodies from SLE patients are pathogenic and may contribute to the kidney lesions in lupus nephritis.

Clinical significance of anti-dsDNA antibody isotypes: IgG/IgM ratio of anti-dsDNA antibodies as a prognostic marker for lupus nephritis

The objective of this paper is to investigate the association between patterns of anti-dsDNA antibody isotypes and specific clinical manifestations (categorized in renal, musculoskeletal, cutaneous, hematological, pulmonary, neurological and cardiac). Sera of 202 systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients, 33 patients suffering from other autoimmune diseases and 115 healthy blood donors were analysed for anti-dsDNA antibodies by IgG-, IgA- and IgM-specific ELISA, Farr-assay and CLIF. A subset of 24 SLE patients was investigated in a longitudinal study over a period of one to six years. Disease activity of 105 SLE patients was measured according to the ECLAM score. In the cohort of SLE patients 63% were positive for the IgG class, 40% for the IgA and 57% for the IgM class specific anti-dsDNA ELISA. Sensitivity (79%) and specificity (99%) for the diagnosis of SLE appeared to be highest for the ELISA measuring all isotypes of anti-dsDNA antibodies. The concentrations of anti-dsDNA isotypes showed a strong correlation with disease activity. Analysing the relationship between IgG, IgA and IgM anti-dsDNA antibody isotypes and clinical manifestation, we found a significant association of the IgM isotype with cutaneous involvement and of the IgG isotype with lupus nephritis. The IgG/IgM ratio of anti-dsDNA antibodies represented a significant parameter to distinguish patients with lupus nephritis from those without renal involvement. In the longitudinal study, a continuous ratio under 0.8 was associated with absence of renal involvement throughout the investigated period. In conclusion, the evaluation of anti-dsDNA isotypes provides a diagnostic tool to define subsets within SLE patients with different clinical manifestations. In particular, the IgG/IgM ratio of anti-dsDNA antibodies could be used as a prognostic marker for lupus nephritis during the course of the disease.

Antigenic triggers and molecular targets for anti-double-stranded DNA antibodies

While anti-double-stranded (ds)DNA antibodies are a characteristic serologic hallmark for SLE, the triggering antigen is unknown. Using phage display libraries, we identified DWEYSVWLSN as a peptide mimic of DNA for a pathogenic anti-dsDNA antibody. Peptide immunization of non-autoimmune mice induced anti-dsDNA as well as other lupus-associated antibodies. Molecular analysis of the induced anti-dsDNA antibodies revealed several similarities with anti-dsDNA antibodies that appear spontaneously in lupus mice. Furthermore, lupus-prone mice immunized with this peptide DNA mimic had higher autoantibody titers as well as more severe nephritis. Anti-DNA antibodies may contribute to lupus nephritis via cross-reactivity with renal antigen. Using western blotting of lysates of mesangial cells from a lupus mouse, we found that a pathogenic anti-DNA antibody binds to alpha-actinin. High titers of anti-alpha-actinin antibodies were present in the sera and kidney eluates of lupus mice with active disease. Binding to alpha-actinin was diminished in mesangial cells derived from BALB/c mice, suggesting that target antigen expression may play a role in determining autoantibody binding to the kidney. We conclude that a pathogenic, lupus-like autoantibody response can be induced by a peptide antigen, and that alpha-actinin is a cross-reactive renal target for the pathogenic anti-dsDNA autoantibody response in lupus mice.

Alpha-actinin is a cross-reactive renal target for pathogenic anti-DNA antibodies

Anti-DNA Abs commonly found in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus are thought to play an important pathogenic role in lupus nephritis. Anti-DNA Abs may contribute to renal disease by cross-reactivity with renal Ags, the identity of which remain elusive. To identify a target Ag for pathogenic anti-DNA Abs, we performed Western blotting and immunoprecipitations of mesangial cell lysates from the lupus-prone MRL-lpr/lpr mouse and a nonautoimmune BALB/c mouse with the pathogenic anti-DNA Ab R4A. We found that R4A (but not a nonpathogenic Ab mutant of R4A) binds to and immunoprecipitates a 100-kDa protein expressed on the cell surface and in lysates of MRL-lpr/lpr mesangial cells. DNase treatment of the lysate and of the R4A Ab did not effect binding, indicating that the binding of R4A to the 100-kDa protein was direct and not mediated by an antigenic bridge containing DNA. Binding was greatly diminished in BALB/c lysates, suggesting that Ag expression or availability at the level of the target organ may be a factor in determining susceptibility to lupus nephritis. Following identification of this 100-kDa protein as nonmuscle alpha-actinin, binding of R4A to alpha-actinin was confirmed by Western blot, ELISA, inhibition studies, and immunofluorescence. High titers of anti-alpha-actinin Abs were present in sera and kidney eluates of lupus mice with active nephritis. These results indicate that the nephritogenicity of some anti-DNA Abs may be mediated via cross-reactivity with alpha-actinin. Furthermore, variations in target Ag display between individuals may underlie differential susceptibility to anti-DNA Ab-induced renal disease.

Cutting edge: expansion and activation of a population of autoreactive marginal zone B cells in a model of estrogen-induced lupus

We have demonstrated previously that 17 beta-estradiol (E2) treatment of BALB/c mice transgenic for the heavy chain of a pathogenic anti-DNA Ab induces a lupus-like phenotype with expansion of anti-DNA B cells, elevation of anti-DNA Ab titers, and glomerular immunoglobulin deposition. To understand this loss of B cell tolerance, the effects of E2 on B cell development and activation were examined. A sustained increase in E2 resulted in an altered distribution of B cell subsets, with a diminished transitional population and an increase in marginal zone B cells. Depletion of CD4+ T cells did not abrogate these effects. Furthermore, the B cells that spontaneously secreted anti-DNA Abs displayed a marginal zone phenotype. Thus, a sustained increase in E2 alters B cell development, leading to the survival, expansion, and activation of a population of autoreactive marginal zone B cells implicating this B cell subset in autoimmunity.

Crossreactivity of human anti-dsDNA antibodies to phosphorylcholine: clues to their origin

The presence of anti-double stranded DNA (dsDNA) antibodies is a serological diagnostic feature of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), an autoimmune rheumatic disorder. Studies by several investigators have suggested that a response to a microbial antigen can lead to the induction of SLE-like autoimmunity, in both humans and mice, since anti-dsDNA antibodies have been shown to crossreact with foreign antigens. In particular, anti-DNA antibodies have been shown to crossreact with phosphorylcholine (PC), a dominant epitope on pneumococcal cell wall polysaccharide. We have investigated the binding characteristics of human polyclonal anti-DNA antibodies from the sera of SLE patients. In this study we show that the DNA binding of polyclonal serum derived antibodies can be partially inhibited by phosphorylcholine (PC). The binding of affinity-purified anti-DNA antibodies from the sera of patients with SLE was also found to be inhibited by PC. We further demonstrated that the serum IgG1 (T dependent) anti-DNA response was more likely to crossreact with PC than the IgG2 (T independent) response to DNA. The studies suggest there may be a T dependent and T independent response to DNA with the T dependent response displaying more crossreactivity with microbial antigen.

Enhanced mutational activity and disturbed selection of mutations in V(H) gene rearrangements in a patient with systemic lupus erythematosus

To determine the impact of somatic hypermutation and selective influences on the V(H) gene repertoire in SLE, the mutational frequency and pattern of mutations in nonproductively and productively rearranged V(H) genes obtained from genomic DNA of individual CD19+ B cells were analyzed in a patient with SLE. The mutational frequencies of nonproductive (6.54 x 10(-2)) as well as of productive (4.38 x 10(-2)) V(H) rearrangements were significantly higher in the SLE patient than in normal controls (3.8 x 10(-2), p<0.001 and 3.3 x 10(-2); p<0.001, respectively). Analysis of nonproductive rearrangements documented only minor abnormalities of the targeting of the mutator in the SLE patient. The majority of "mutational hot spots", although different than in normals, appeared in the CDRs and an increased frequency of mutations in RGYW/WRCY sequences was observed. Moreover, no biases in base pair changes were found in the nonproductive repertoire. In contrast, there was a selection against A and T mutations and towards G mutations within the productive repertoire. Importantly, there were no significant differences in the R/S ratios of mutations within the FRs between the nonproductive and productive repertoire consistent with abnormalities in elimination of B cells expressing V(H) genes with these mutations. The result of this abnormality was a significantly higher R/S ratio of the V(H)genes in the productive repertoire of the SLE patient compared to normals (p<0.05). These data indicate that the mutational machinery was markedly enhanced in this SLE patient but exhibited nearly normal targeting, whereas selective influences were abnormal. These findings suggest that both enhanced mutational activity and disturbances in selection may have played a role in the emergence of autoreactivity in this SLE patient.

T cell studies in a peptide-induced model of systemic lupus erythematosus

We have previously reported that immunization with a peptide mimetope of dsDNA on a branched polylysine backbone (DWEYSVWLSN-MAP) induces a systemic lupus erythematosus-like syndrome in the nonautoimmune BALB/c mouse strain. To understand the mechanism underlying this breakdown in self tolerance, we examined the role of T cells in the response. Our results show that the anti-foreign and anti-self response induced by immunization is T cell dependent and is mediated by I-E(d)-restricted CD4(+) T cells of the Th1 subset. In addition, generation of the critical T cell epitope requires processing by APCs and depends on the presence of both DWEYSVWLSN and the MAP backbone. The breakdown in self tolerance does not occur through cross-reactivity between the T cell epitope of DWEYSVWLSN-MAP and epitopes derived from nuclear Ags. In this induced-model of SLE, therefore, autoreactivity results from the activation of T cells specific for foreign Ag and of cross-reactive anti-foreign, anti-self B cells. Despite the fact that tissue injury is mediated by Ab, the critical initiating T cell response is Th1.

Towards a quantitative model of immunogenicity: counting pathways in sequence space

One of the fundamental aims of structural biology is the identification of high-affinity ligands for arbitrary receptors. The maturation of the antibody repertoire elegantly and robustly solves this problem through an evolutionary mechanism comprising repeated cycles of mutation and preferential replication. To understand better the limitations and biases of this process, we developed an interpretation of antibody maturation within the framework of sequence space and fitness landscapes. Several well-described phenomena can be directly derived from this framework, and new predictions can be made. Ultimately, this reconceptualization of the clonal selection process suggests a quantitative, testable model of immunogenicity.

Structure-function analysis of a lupus anti-DNA autoantibody: central role of the heavy chain complementarity-determining region 3 Arg in binding of double- and single-stranded DNA

To determine the contribution of the somatic point mutations and that of the complementarity-determining region (CDR)3 Arg to DNA binding, we engineered the germline V(H) and V(kappa) gene revertant and site-mutagenized the CDR3 Arg residues of the mutated and "antigen-selected" mAb 412.67. This anti-DNA autoantibody was derived from B-1 cells of a lupus patient and bore two H-CDR3 Arg, Arg105 and Arg107, encoded by N segment additions, and one kappa-CDR3 Arg, Arg97, resulting from a point mutation (Kasaian et al. 1994. J. Immunol. 152: 3137-3151; Kasaian et al. 1995. Ann. N.Y Acad. Sci. 764: 410-423). The germ-line revertant bound double-stranded (ds) DNA and single-stranded (ss) DNA as effectively as its wild-type counterpart (relative avidity: 6.4x10(-7) and 9.9x10(-9) vs. 6.7x10(-7) and 9.1 x10(-9) g/microl), raising the possibility that an antigen other than DNA was responsible for the selection of the mAb 412.67 V(H) and V(kappa) point mutations. H-CDR3 Arg105 and Arg107 were both required for dsDNA binding, but either Arg105 or Arg107 was sufficient for ssDNA binding. The central role of Arg105 and Arg107 in DNA binding reflected their solvent-exposed orientation at the apex of the H-CDR3 main loop. Consistent with its inward orientation afar from the antigen-binding surface, the kappa-CDR3 Arg97 played no role in either dsDNA or ssDNA binding.

Light chain determines the binding property of human anti-dsDNA IgG autoantibodies

We have previously prepared human anti-double-stranded (ds) DNA IgG Fab clones using phage-display technology. Nucleotide sequence analysis of genes of immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy and light chain variable regions in these Fab clones suggested that the DNA-binding activity of the clones depended on light chain usage. To confirm the role of the light chain in antibody binding to DNA, we constructed in the present study's new recombined Fab clones by heavy and light chain shuffling between the original anti-dsDNA Fab clones. Clones constructed by pairing Fdgamma fragments with the light chain from a high DNA-binding clone showed high DNA-binding activities, whereas other constructed clones using light chains from low DNA-binding clones showed low DNA-binding activities. Our results indicate that light chains in anti-dsDNA antibodies can determine the DNA-binding activity of the antibodies. Ig chain shuffling of phage-display antibodies may be useful for investigating the molecular mechanisms for antigen-antibody binding of human autoantibodies.

Can immunization precipitate connective tissue disease? Report of five cases of systemic lupus erythematosus and review of the literature

OBJECTIVES

To report a series of five patients who developed systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) after immunization and review the literature on vaccine-associated connective tissue diseases and the theoretical mechanisms that could explain such an association.

METHODS

Uncontrolled retrospective analysis of cases identified sporadically over 7 years at three centers.

RESULTS

In our series of 5 patients, symptoms of SLE developed within 2 to 3 weeks after secondary immunization. All patients met American College of Rheumatology (ACR) criteria for the diagnosis of SLE. In most patients, symptoms have been persistent.

CONCLUSION

Although a coincidental association between vaccination and the onset of SLE cannot be excluded, the temporal relationship with the development of symptoms makes it immunologically plausible that vaccination triggered systemic autoimmunity in these rare cases. We propose that epidemiological studies be performed to examine this potential association in more detail to quantitate the risk and identify possible genetic risk factors.

The Role of Environmental Antigens in the Spontaneous Development of Autoimmunity in MRL-lpr Mice

It has been proposed that the “normal” stimulation of the immune system that occurs from interactions with environmental stimuli, whether infectious or dietary, is necessary for the initiation and/or continuation of autoimmunity. We tested this hypothesis by deriving a group of MRL-lpr mice into a germfree (GF) environment. At 5 mo of age, no differences between GF and conventional MRL-lpr mice were noted in lymphoproliferation, flow cytometric analysis of lymph node cells (LN), or histologic analysis of the kidneys. Autoantibody levels were comparably elevated in both groups. A second experiment tested the role of residual environmental stimuli by contrasting GF mice fed either a low m.w., ultrafiltered Ag-free (GF-AF) diet or an autoclaved natural ingredient diet (GF-NI). At 4 mo of age, both groups showed extensive lymphoproliferation and aberrant T cell formation, although the GF-AF mice had ∼50% smaller LNs compared with sex-matched GF-NI controls. Autoantibody formation was present in both groups. Histologic analysis of the kidneys revealed that GF-AF mice had much lower levels of nephritis, while immunofluorescence analysis demonstrated no difference in Ig deposits but did reveal a paucity of C3 deposition in the kidneys of GF-AF mice.

These data do not support a role for infectious agents in the induction of lymphoproliferation and B cell autoimmunity in MRL-lpr mice. Furthermore, they suggest that autoantibodies do not originate from B cells that were initially committed to exogenous Ags. They do suggest a possible contributory role for dietary exposure in the extent of lymphoproliferation and development of nephritis in this strain.

Immunopathogenesis of SLE

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune rheumatic disease characterized by the deposition of autoantibodies and immune complexes, leading to tissue damage. The immunopathogenesis of SLE is like a jigsaw puzzle, some pieces of which are missing or have not fallen into place. In predisposed individuals, the initial stimulus is likely to be one or more of the environmental agents interacting with susceptibility genes. Once the critical threshold is breached there is a failure of the immune system to downregulate the ensuing abnormal immune response, involving polyclonal B cell activation and hyperactive T cell help. Key questions include, what are the processes behind the availability of autoantigens and the breakdown of tolerance that give rise to the pathogenic autoantibodies? Current areas of research also involve the roles played by cytokines, adhesion molecules, co-stimulatory molecules and apoptosis.

Hidden anti-phospholipid antibodies in normal human sera circulate as immune complexes whose antigen can be removed by heat, acid, hypermolar buffers or phospholipase treatments

Heat treatment of normal human serum reveals otherwise masked anti-cardiolipin antibodies (aCL). We studied the mechanism of masking and the nature of the inhibitor of these aCL IgG. Other forms of treatment, besides heating for 30 min at 56 degrees C, can also unmask hidden aCL IgG. These include acid pH, hypermolar buffers and phospholipase digestion. When unmasked, these aCL recognize other anionic and zwitterionic phospholipids, but do not react with DNA, cell antigens or IgG. Using thin layer chromatography we demonstrate that the heat-labile inhibitor(s) of these aCL are phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylglycerol and phosphatidylcholine. These antibodies are not beta2-glycoprotein-I dependent and actually compete with this protein for phospholipid binding. The hidden antibodies are comprised of two populations of IgG autoantibodies: one reactive with cardiolipin, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylinositol, phosphatidylglycerol, phosphatidylethanolamine and sphingomyelin, and the other reactive almost exclusively with phosphatidylcholine and phosphorylcholine on enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay plates or when exposed by bromelain on the erythrocyte surface. Our data suggest that hidden aCL are natural oligoreactive IgG anti-phospholipid autoantibodies that circulate masked by their antigen.

Immunization with a peptide surrogate for double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) induces autoantibody production and renal immunoglobulin deposition

Anti-double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) antibodies are the serologic abnormality characteristically associated with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and may play an important role in disease pathogenesis. Although the anti-dsDNA antibodies present in SLE are indicative of an antigen-driven response, the antigen has not been conclusively identified. By screening a phage peptide display library, we demonstrated previously that the decapeptide DWEYSVWLSN is specifically bound by the pathogenic murine IgG2b anti-dsDNA antibody R4A. To investigate the possibility that a protein antigen might trigger lupus-like autoimmunity, we immunized BALB/c mice with DWEYSVWLSN in adjuvant. Mice developed significant titers of IgG anti-dsDNA antibodies 2-3 wk after the initial immunization. Immunized mice also developed antibodies against some other lupus autoantigens, and immunoglobulin deposition was present in renal glomeruli at 49 d. Although an immune response to peptide and dsDNA was evident in BALB/c mice, there was little response in other inbred strains. This study demonstrates that lupus-like anti-dsDNA reactivity can be generated in nonautoimmune mice by immunization with a peptide antigen. Peptide-induced autoimmunity may prove useful in understanding the spreading of antigenic specificities targeted in SLE. However, most importantly, the demonstration that a peptide antigen can initiate a SLE-like immune response opens a new chapter on the potential antigenic stimuli that might trigger SLE.

Analysis of the targeting of the hypermutational machinery and the impact of subsequent selection on the distribution of nucleotide changes in human VHDJH rearrangements

B cells are unique in that they generate and tolerate a high rate of mutations in their antigen receptor genes and employ these mutations as a basis of avidity maturation. The precise role of the mutational machinery versus subsequent selection in determining the frequency and distribution of mutations has not been fully analyzed. To address these issues, the influence of the intrinsic mutational machinery and subsequent selection on the frequency and distribution of mutations in the expressed human immunoglobulin repertoire was analyzed. Analysis of non-productively rearranged VH genes from individual human B cells provided an opportunity to examine the immediate impact of somatic hypermutation without superimposed selective influences. Comparison with the frequency and distribution of mutations in the productively rearranged human VH genes permitted an estimate of the influences of subsequent selection.

Delineation of Selective Influences Shaping the Mutated Expressed Human Ig Heavy Chain Repertoire

After Ag exposure, somatic hypermutation and subsequent selection play significant roles in shaping the peripheral B cell repertoire. However, the disparate impact of each process has not been completely delineated. To address this, the mutational patterns of a large panel of productive VHDJH rearrangements of individual human B cells were analyzed and compared with those of a previously reported panel of nonproductive VHDJH rearrangements. The productive VH rearrangements exhibited a significantly lower mutational frequency and a significantly smaller number of replacement mutations than the nonproductively rearranged genes, suggesting that structural constraints of the Ig molecule and selective influences both impacted the repertoire, militating against replacement mutations. Positive selection favored a mean of four to six replacements in complementarity-determining region 1 (CDR1) and CDR2, and less than two replacements in the framework regions (FRs). In contrast, the negative impact of replacement mutations generated an increased number of silent mutations within both the CDRs and FRs of the productive repertoire accompanied by a net increase in the ratio of replacement to silent mutations in the CDRs compared with that in the FRs. Moreover, there was a negative influence on the distribution of amino acid changes resulting from mutations of highly mutable codons, such as AGY, TAY, GTA, and GCT, preferentially leading to conservative changes in the expressed Ig repertoire. The results are consistent with the conclusion that the expressed repertoire is limited, compared with the potential generated by the mutational machinery, by the dual requirements of avoiding autoreactivity and satisfying structural constraints of an intact Ig molecule.