Should Canada and the United States universally vaccinate infants against hepatitis B? A cost-effectiveness analysis

Cost Effectiveness of Implementing a Universal Birth Hepatitis B Vaccination Program in Ontario

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The World Health Organization recommends a universal hepatitis B vaccination within the first 24 h of birth. However, hepatitis B vaccines are given during adolescence in many jurisdictions including in Ontario, Canada. The objective of this study was to assess the cost effectiveness of shifting the hepatitis B vaccination timing from adolescence to birth.

METHODS

A state-transition model of 18 health states representing the natural history of acute and chronic hepatitis B was developed to conduct a cost-utility analysis. Most input parameters were obtained from the Canadian literature or publicly available provincial data. The model followed a lifetime model time horizon with health outcomes and costs being discounted at 1.5% annually. Deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed to test the robustness of the model. Analyses were conducted from a public-payer perspective with all costs adjusted to 2021 Canadian dollars.

RESULTS

Hepatitis B vaccination in newborns dominated the current strategy of adolescent vaccination. The probabilistic analysis showed that the newborn strategy was cost effective in 100% of the iterations at a willingness-to-pay threshold of $50,000/quality-adjusted life-year and cost saving in 79.39% of the iterations. A microsimulation projected that a newborn vaccination may lead to reductions in cases by 16.1% in acute hepatitis B, 43.2% in chronic hepatitis B, 48.2% in hepatocellular carcinoma, and 51.9% in hepatitis B liver-related death.

CONCLUSIONS

Our analysis suggests that changing the age of the hepatitis B vaccination recommendation from adolescent to newborn is cost effective and mostly a cost-saving strategy. Newborn vaccination may lead to cost and health benefits while aligning with best available evidence and guidance from the World Health Organization.

Countdown on hepatitis B elimination by 2030: the global burden of liver disease related to hepatitis B and association with socioeconomic status

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection causes both acute and chronic liver disease, performing the key driver toward the global elimination of viral hepatitis by 2030. We used data from Global Burden of Disease (GBD) study to quantify the burden of liver disease due to hepatitis B at the global, regional and national levels.

METHODS

Annual incident cases and age-standardized incidence rates (ASIRs) of liver disease due to hepatitis B between 1990 and 2019 were collected from GBD study 2019. Percentage changes of incident cases and estimated annual percentage changes (EAPCs) of ASIRs were calculated to quantify their temporal trends. Correlations between EAPC and socio-demographic index (SDI) and universal health coverage index (UHCI) were evaluated by Pearson correlation analyses.

RESULTS

Globally, the incident cases of liver disease due to hepatitis B decreased by 4.51% from 84.45 million in 1990 to 80.65 million in 2019 and ASIR decreased by an average of 1.52% (95%CI - 1.66%, - 1.37%) per year in this period. For the spectrum of liver disease due to hepatitis B, ASIR of cirrhosis and other chronic liver diseases increased by an average of 0.13% (95%CI 0.04%, 0.22%) per year in low SDI region and 0.24% (95%CI 0.04%, 0.34%) per year in low-middle SDI region, and ASIR of liver cancer increased by an average of 0.91% (95%CI 0.37%, 1.46%) per year in high SDI region in 1990-2019. Positive correlations of EAPC in ASIR of liver cancer with SDI and UHCI were observed in nations with SDI ≥ 0.7 or UHCI ≥ 70.

CONCLUSION

HBV infection remains a global health problem, causing low and low-middle SDI regions with an increasing trend of cirrhosis and other chronic liver diseases, and high SDI region with an increasing trend of liver cancer. Efforts to eliminate hepatitis B by 2030 needs to focus on not only developing regions but also developed regions.

Ending risk-group HBV vaccination for MSM after the introduction of universal infant HBV vaccination: A mathematical modelling study

BACKGROUND

Risk-group HBV vaccination for men who have sex with men (MSM) was introduced in the Netherlands in 2002, followed by universal infant vaccination in 2011, that will enable termination of risk-group vaccination over time. The introduction of pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for HIV prevention might result in increased HBV testing and vaccination against HBV. The aim of this study was to investigate the impact of the transition from risk-group to universal HBV vaccination, accounting for improvements in HBV testing and treatment, as well as the introduction of PrEP.

METHODS

We developed a mathematical model for HBV transmission among MSM. Universal vaccination was modelled by assigning some MSM (5-15% in 2028 increasing to 80-90% in 2033 and thereafter) to be vaccinated when they become sexually active. We investigated different scenarios assuming 0.5% extra vaccination rate and 0.5% extra testing rate due to PrEP consultations; and 5% of HIV-negative MSM on PrEP, that will reduce the probability of HBV acquisition by 88%.

RESULTS

Universal vaccination resulted in a reduction of 24% (interquartile range; 22-25%) of the total number of HBV infections among MSM estimated to occur from 2020 to 2070. With universal vaccination, terminating risk-group vaccination in 2030 or 2040 resulted in 30% or 10% more HBV infections over 2020-2070, respectively, compared to continuation of risk-group vaccination until 2070. With PrEP and continued risk-group vaccination, the total number of HBV infections over 2020-2070 was reduced by 13%.

CONCLUSIONS

Universal HBV vaccination can lead to a major reduction in HBV incidence among MSM in the future. The reduction becomes smaller when ending risk-group HBV vaccination, but larger by PrEP use for HIV prevention. Efforts to keep high levels of HBV vaccination, testing, and treatment have to be continued in the coming decades in order to eliminate HBV as a health threat for MSM.

Economic evaluations of vaccines in Canada: a scoping review

BACKGROUND

This study aims to summarise and describe the evolution of published economic evaluations of vaccines in Canada, thereby outlining the current state of this expanding and meaningful research.

METHODS

Using Arksey and O'Malley's scoping review framework we assembled relevant research from both academic and grey literature. Following abstract and full-text review we identified 60 articles to be included in the final analysis.

RESULTS

We found that since 1988 there has been a steady increase in the number of economic evaluations on vaccines in Canada. Many of these studies focus on the more recently licensed vaccines, such as influenza (16.7%), human papillomavirus (15.0%) and pneumococcal disease (15.0%). Since 2010 economic evaluations of vaccines have shown increased adherence to economic evaluation guidelines (OR = 4.6, CI 1.33, 18.7), suggesting there has been improvement in the consistency and transparency of these studies. However, there remains room for improvement, for instance, we found evidence that studies who stated a conflict of interest are more likely to assert the vaccine of interest was cost-effective (OR = 7.4; CI 1.04, 17.8). Furthermore, most reports use static models that do not consider herd immunity, and only a few evaluate vaccines post-implementation (ex-post) and traveller's vaccinations.

CONCLUSION

Researchers should examine identified research gaps and continue to improve standardization and transparency when reporting to ensure economic evaluations of vaccines best meet the needs of policy-makers, other researchers and the public.

A Cost-Benefit Analysis of Gown Use in Controlling Vancomycin-ResistantEnterococcusTransmission Is It Worth the Price?

Objective:

To determine the net benefit and costs associated with gown use in preventing transmission of van-comycin-resistantEnterococcus(VRE).

Design:

A cost-benefit analysis measuring the net benefit of gowns was performed. Benefits, defined as averted costs from reduced VRE colonization and infection, were estimated using a matched cohort study. Data sources included a step-down cost allocation system, hospital informatics, and microbiology databases.

Setting:

The medical intensive care unit (MICU) at Barnes-Jewish Hospital, St. Louis, Missouri.

Patients:

Patients admitted to the MICU for more than 24 hours from July 1, 1997, to December 31, 1999.

Interventions:

Alternating periods when all healthcare workers and visitors were required to wear gowns and gloves versus gloves alone on entry to the rooms of patients colonized or infected with VRE.

Results:

On base-case analysis, 58 VRE cases were averted with gown use during 18 months. The annual net benefit of the gown policy was $419,346 and the cost per case averted of VRE was $1,897. The analysis was most sensitive to the level of VRE transmission.

Conclusions:

Infection control policies (eg, gown use) initially increase the cost of health services delivery. However, such policies can be cost saving by averting nosocomial infections and the associated costs of treatment. The cost savings to the hospital plus the benefits to patients and their families of avoiding nosocomial infections make effective infection control policies a good investment.

Cost-effectiveness of augmenting universal hepatitis B vaccination with immunoglobin treatment

OBJECTIVE

To compare the cost-effectiveness of hepatitis B virus (HBV) control strategies combining universal vaccination with hepatitis B immunoglobulin (HBIG) treatment for neonates of carrier mothers.

METHODS

Drawing on Taiwan's experience, we developed a decision-analytic model to estimate the clinical and economic outcomes for 4 strategies: (1) strategy V-universal vaccination; (2) strategy S-V plus screening for hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) and HBIG treatment for HBsAg-positive mothers' neonates; (3) strategy E-V plus screening for hepatitis B e-antigen (HBeAg), HBIG for HBeAg-positive mothers' neonates; (4) strategy S&E-V plus screening for HBsAg then HBeAg, HBIG for all HBeAg-positive, and some HBeAg-negative/HBsAg-positive mothers' neonates.

RESULTS

Strategy S averted the most infections, followed by S&E, E, and V. In most cases, the more effective strategies were also more costly. The willingness-to-pay (WTP) above which strategy S was cost-effective rose as carrier rate declined and was <$4000 per infection averted for carrier rates >5%. The WTP below which strategy V was optimal also increased as carrier rate declined, from $1400 at 30% carrier rate to $3100 at 5% carrier rate. Strategies involving E were optimal for an intermediate range of WTP that narrowed as carrier rate declined.

CONCLUSIONS

HBIG treatment for neonates of HBsAg carrier mothers is likely to be a cost-effective addition to universal vaccination, particularly in settings with adequate health care infrastructure. Targeting HBIG to neonates of higher risk HBeAg-positive mothers may be preferred where WTP is moderate. However, in very resource-limited settings, universal vaccination alone is optimal.

Hepatitis B vaccine effectiveness in the face of global HBV genotype diversity

Recombinant hepatitis B vaccines are of the A2 genotype; one of ten known genotypes whose distribution varies globally. Reports of rare HBV infections in blood donors with an imbalance of non-A2 genotype HBV in vaccinated subjects have raised questions about the cross-protection afforded by HBV-A2 vaccines. Infections in HBV vaccinees were asymptomatic and transient, indicating that vaccination prevented clinical disease. Preclinical data demonstrate cross-reactivity and cross-protection by A2 vaccines against non-A2 HBV genotypes. Substantial improvements in HBV control have been demonstrated in countries with diverse genotype distribution that have introduced universal childhood HBV vaccination programs. Available data show that current HBV-A2 vaccines are highly effective in preventing infections and clinical disease caused by all known HBV genotypes.

Economic evaluation of infant and adolescent hepatitis B vaccination in the UK

A Markov model of hepatitis B virus (HBV) disease progression in the UK estimated that 81% of predicted HBV-associated morbidity and mortality could be prevented by universal infant vaccination at a cost of approximately £ 260,000 per QALY gained. Universal adolescent vaccination would be less effective (45% prevented) and less cost-effective (£ 493,000 per QALY gained). Higher HBV incidence rates in males and intermediate/high risk ethnic populations meant it was approximately 3 times more cost-effective to vaccinate these groups. At current vaccine costs a selective infant vaccination programme, based on vaccinating intermediate/high risk ethnic populations would not be considered cost effective. The threshold cost per vaccinated child at which the programme would be considered cost-effective was investigated. Universal infant vaccination would be cost-effective if the average cost of vaccinating each child against HBV, including vaccine and administration costs of all doses, was less than £ 4.09. Given the low cost of vaccination required to make a universal programme cost-effective the most feasible policy in the UK would be to use a suitably priced combined vaccine that included the other antigens in the current infant vaccination schedule.

Immunity to hepatitis B vaccine in Tanzanian under-5 children

BACKGROUND

Hepatitis B vaccine was introduced in Tanzania in 2002 and is administered as DPT-hepatitis B at 4, 8 and 12 weeks of life.

AIM

To determine immunity to hepatitis B virus in children under 5 years attending reproductive and child health (RCH) clinics.

METHODS

A cross-sectional, health facility-based study was conducted between July and December 2007 at Temeke, Amana and Mwananyamala municipal hospitals in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Children under 5 years who had received DPT-HB vaccine as evidenced by RCH card number 1 were included. Blood samples were collected to determine hepatitis B surface antigen (HB(s)Ag) and antibodies to hepatitis B surface antigen (anti-HB(s)) and hepatitis B core antigen (Anti-HB(c)). An anti-HB(s) level of > or =10 mIU/ml is regarded as protective. Nutritional and HIV status were also determined.

RESULTS

A total of 296 children under 5 years vaccinated with DPT-HB were recruited, 153 (51.7%) of whom were male. Altogether, 205 (69.3%) children had anti-HB(s) levels > or =10 mIU/ml. The number of DPT-HB vaccine doses, time interval since last DPT-HB dose and HIV status were significant predictors of anti-HB(s) levels. Five children (1.7%) were positive for HB(s)Ag, suggesting possible vertical transmission. No child had anti-HB(c) antibodies.

CONCLUSION

More than two-thirds of children under 5 years had protective anti-HB(s) levels. A change in the hepatitis B immunisation schedule to include a dose immediately after birth should improve immunity.

The impact of chronic hepatitis B on quality of life: a multinational study of utilities from infected and uninfected persons

OBJECTIVES

Chronic hepatitis B (CHB) is a condition that results in substantial morbidity and mortality worldwide because of progressive liver damage. Investigators undertaking economic evaluations of new therapeutic agents require estimates of health-related quality of life (HRQOL). Recently, evidence has begun to accumulate that differences in cultural backgrounds have a quantifiable impact on perceptions of health. The objective was to elicit utilities for six health states that occur after infection with the hepatitis B virus from infected and uninfected respondents living in jurisdictions with low and with high CHB endemicity.

METHODS

Standard gamble utilities were elicited from hepatitis patients and uninfected respondents using an interviewer-administered survey in the United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Spain, Hong Kong, and mainland China. Generalized linear models were used to the effect on utilities of current health, age and sex, jurisdiction and, for infected respondents, current disease state.

RESULTS

The sample included 534 CHB-infected patients and 600 uninfected respondents. CHB and compensated cirrhosis had a moderate impact on HRQOL with utilities ranging from 0.68 to 0.80. Decompensated cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma had a stronger impact with utilities ranging from 0.35 to 0.41. Significant variation was observed between countries, with both types of respondents in mainland China and Hong Kong reporting systematically lower utilities.

CONCLUSIONS

Health states related to CHB infection have substantial reductions in HRQOL and the utilities reported in this study provide valuable information for comparing new treatment options. The observed intercountry differences suggest that economic evaluations may benefit from country-specific utility estimates. The extent that systematic intercountry differences in utilities hold true for other infectious and chronic diseases remains an open question and has considerable implications for the proper conduct and interpretation of economic evaluations.

Medical decision analysis in infectious diseases

Medical decision analysis (MDA) has played an important role in assisting infectious disease physicians make decisions associated with varying levels of complexity. Clinicians are often uncomfortable with some aspects of MDA, particularly when utilities are used as outcome measures. However, as the present paper outlines, MDA may use other outcome variables, including costs and disease complications. In this context, this explicit, reproducible analytic framework is an important tool in the area of infectious diseases, and is frequently applied to many situations, including cost effectiveness analyses, studies involving assessment of risks versus benefits of preventive and treatment strategies, and other situations. The objective of this paper is to assist infectious diseases clinicians to understand better the role of MDA in clinical practice. In this regard, the principles of MDA are reviewed and a common clinical example is used for illustrative purposes.

Uptake and behavioural and attitudinal determinants of immunization in an expanded routine infant hepatitis B vaccination program in British Columbia

INTRODUCTION

British Columbia (BC) implemented a universal infant hepatitis B (HB) immunization program in 2001. The study objective was to evaluate HB immunization coverage among the first six-month cohort of eligible infants in the province outside of the Vancouver-Richmond health region and to assess parent/guardian behavioural and attitudinal determinants of HB immunization.

METHODS

A cross-sectional survey of HB immunization was conducted using a random sample of eligible infants born between 1 January-30 June 2001. HB immunization coverage data were obtained from the provincial Public Health Information System, and through a telephone survey of 487 of eligible infants' parents/guardians that was conducted between October 2002-January 2003. At this time, parents/guardians were also asked about behaviours and attitudes towards immunization, based on the Immunization Health Belief Model Scale.

RESULTS

HB immunization coverage with at least one dose of HB vaccine was 89% and uptake of 3 doses of HB vaccine was 78%. HB immunization was significantly associated (p<0.001) with a recommendation for HB immunization from a health care professional. The main reason for non-HB immunization was parental concern about side effects.

DISCUSSION

Seventy-eight percent of infants completed the 3-dose HB vaccination schedule. Parental behaviour regarding HB immunization of their children was strongly influenced by a supportive recommendation from either a nurse or doctor.

Potential cost-effectiveness of a preventive hepatitis C vaccine in high risk and average risk populations in Canada

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) vaccine development remains at an early stage. We explored the economic and health consequences of potential HCV vaccines by comparing universal vaccination with a hepatitis C vaccine to no vaccination in two groups: (1) injecting drug users (IDU); (2) all 12 year olds, using a Markov cohort simulation. Among IDUs, vaccination would avert 248 cases of HCV infection and 89 HCV-related deaths per 1000 individuals, and reduce costs. In average risk cohorts, vaccination did not reduce costs but was reasonably cost effective. These results provide encouragement to vaccine developers that a vaccine that is moderately effective and reasonably priced should not face economic barriers to implementation and will be attractive to third party payers.

The cost effectiveness of hepatitis immunization for US college students

Hepatitis B immunization is recommended for all American children, and hepatitis A immunization is recommended for children who live in areas with elevated disease rates. Because hepatitis A and B occur most commonly in young adults, the authors examined the cost effectiveness of college-based vaccination. They developed epidemiologic models to consider infection risks and disease progression and then compared the cost of vaccination with economic, longevity, and quality of life benefits. Immunization of 100,000 students would prevent 1,403 acute cases of hepatitis A, 929 cases of hepatitis B, and 144 cases of chronic hepatitis B. Hepatitis B vaccination would cost the health system $7,600 per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained but would reduce societal costs by 6%. Hepatitis A/B vaccination would cost the health system dollar 8,500 per QALY but would reduce societal costs by 12%. Until childhood and adolescent vaccination can produce immune cohorts of young adults, college-based hepatitis immunization can reduce disease transmission in a cost-effective manner.

Effectiveness and cost comparison of two strategies for hepatitis B vaccination of schoolchildren

CONTEXT

In 1994, immunization against hepatitis B was implemented in schools in Quebec, targeting grade 4 students. In 1996-1997 and 1997-1998, one Local Community Service Centre (CLSC) replaced the school-based program in its district with vaccination offered in community clinics after school hours. The aim of the current study was to compare the effectiveness and costs of school-based and clinic-based programs.

METHODS

Vaccination coverage data were collected in the CLSC with the clinic-based program (CBP), and in three matched CLSCs with a school-based program (SBP), from 1994 to 2000. Surveys were conducted to estimate costs to parents, to schools and to CLSCs in 1997-1998.

RESULTS

With the implementation of the CBP, the vaccination coverage fell to 73%, compared with over 90% in the SBPs. Coverage increased to 90% when the CBP was abandoned. Costs to the CLSC were not much lower in the CBP. Societal costs were $63 per student vaccinated in the CBP, and < or = $40 in the SBPs.

CONCLUSION

Results demonstrate the advantage of a SBP over a CBP for the immunization of schoolchildren.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of predischarge monitoring for apnea of prematurity

OBJECTIVE

It is standard practice to defer discharge of premature infants until they have achieved a set number of days without experiencing apnea. The duration of this period, however, is highly variable across institutions, and there is scant literature on its effectiveness or value-for-money. Our objective was to establish the economic impact of varying durations of predischarge observation for apnea of prematurity.

METHODS

Using computer simulation, we compared the alternatives of hospital monitoring for 1 to 10 days, after apparent cessation of apnea, with no monitoring and with the next longest period of monitoring. The daily probability of apnea requiring stimulation after a given number of apnea-free days was obtained from chart review of 216 infants, beginning on the day they attained both full feeds and temperature stability in an open crib. Baseline rates of survival or impairment, utilities for calculation of quality-adjusted life years (QALYs), outcomes for respiratory arrest at home, and long-run costs for neurodevelopmental impairment were derived from the literature. Hospital expenditures were obtained from itemized billing records for infants on each of the final 10 days of hospitalization and converted to costs using Medicare cost-to-charge ratios. Costs are reported in 2000 US dollars.

RESULTS

For infants born at 24 to 26 weeks' gestation, each additional day of monitoring cost from $41000 per QALY saved for the first day to >$130000 per additional QALY gained for the tenth day. Cost-effectiveness was poorer for infants who were born at gestational ages >30 weeks. Results were sensitive to the proportion of charted apneas requiring stimulation that would actually progress, without intervention, to respiratory arrest.

CONCLUSIONS

In this model, the cost-effectiveness of predischarge monitoring for apnea of prematurity declined significantly as the duration of monitoring was increased. Consideration should be given to alternative uses for resources in formulating neonatal discharge guidelines.

Measuring hepatitis B uptake in a new universal infant program

BACKGROUND

Vancouver-Richmond Health Board has the highest reported rate of hepatitis B in Canada, including an annual average of 25 cases in children under 12 years of age, based on reports from 1994-1997 inclusive. The current provincial adolescent grade-six hepatitis B immunization program does not protect against childhood infection. The regional health board implemented universal infant hepatitis B immunization in September 1998.

METHOD

Immunization coverage data were obtained on a random sample of 191 infants born in March 1999 one year after initiation of the program.

RESULTS

By eight months of age, 97.9% of children had received some vaccinations. 73.8% of infants had received three doses of hepatitis B vaccine and 12.6% had received two doses. In comparison, 89% had received three doses and 7.9% two doses of DPTP-Hib vaccine. 13.1% of infants had not received any hepatitis B vaccine. For a majority (67%) of these children, their physician's lack of awareness or lack of acceptance of the program constituted the reason for no hepatitis B vaccine uptake. Only one parent cited adverse publicity as the reason for refusing vaccination.

INTERPRETATION

This survey reveals a successful first year of the program without harm to the pre-existing childhood vaccination programs. Hepatitis B vaccine uptake can be improved by increased awareness among physicians and parents.

An economic evaluation of universal infant vaccination against hepatitis B virus using a combination vaccine (Hib-HepB): a decision analytic approach to cost effectiveness

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the health impact and cost effectiveness of two infant vaccination strategies for protection against hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection in the Australian population. Vaccinating only high-risk infants, assuming 65% compliance, was compared with universal vaccination of infants using a combination Hib-HepB vaccine, with 87.4% compliance.

METHOD

A Markov model simulated the natural history of HBV infection and disease in an Australian birth cohort. The cohort was divided into those at high risk of infection (infants born into high-risk families) and low-risk infants. Clinical and epidemiological data used were obtained from published reports and a survey of clinical experts. The model included the health costs associated with acute and chronic HBV infection, and the sequelae of chronic HBV infection.

RESULTS

The model predicted that universal hepatitis B vaccination of an Australian birth cohort (260,000 births) would result in a 77% reduction in cases of HBV infection. The incremental cost per life year gained was $11,862, which is low compared with many other health care interventions. With no discounting of costs or consequences, universal vaccination with the combination vaccine was predicted to save lives and reduce costs.

CONCLUSION

There is no socially accepted threshold value for cost per life year gained to guide decisions about funding Australian health care interventions. Nevertheless, based on these results, universal hepatitis B vaccination of Australian infants using a combination Hib-HepB vaccine would almost certainly be regarded as a worthwhile investment of public funds.

Cost-effectiveness and implications of newborn screening for prolongation of QT interval for the prevention of sudden infant death syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To determine the cost-effectiveness of universal and high-risk neonatal electrocardiographic (ECG) screening for QT prolongation as a predictor of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) risk in a theoretical group of neonates.

STUDY DESIGN

Incremental cost-effectiveness analysis with decision analytic modeling. A hypothetical cohort of healthy, term infants was modeled, comparing options of no screening, high-risk neonate screening, and universal screening. The high-risk strategy is speculative, because no currently accepted methodology is known for identifying infants at high risk for SIDS. Given the uncertain mechanisms of association between prolonged corrected QT interval (QTc) and SIDS, analyses were repeated under different assumptions. Sensitivity analyses were also performed on all input variables for both costs and effectiveness.

RESULTS

Under the assumption that neonatal electrocardiographic screening detects long QT syndrome responsive to conventional therapy, the cost-effectiveness of high-risk screening was $3403 per life year gained, whereas universal screening cost $18,465 per additional life year gained. However, if the effectiveness of SIDS therapy falls below 10%, the cost-effectiveness deteriorates to $28,376 per life year saved for the high-risk strategy and $118,900 for universal screening. The analyses were robust to a broad array of sensitivity analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

The acceptability of the cost-effectiveness of neonatal electrocardiographic screening is heavily dependent on the pathophysiologic mechanism of SIDS and on the efficacy of monitoring and antiarrhythmic treatment. The nature of this association must be elucidated before routine neonatal electrocardiographic screening is warranted.

Twelve-year follow-up of a prospective randomized trial of hepatitis B recombinant DNA yeast vaccine versus plasma-derived vaccine without booster doses in children

A total of 318 children were prospectively randomized in group 1 with two 5-microg doses of recombinant vaccine given at 0 and 1 month; in group 2 with three 5-microg doses of recombinant vaccine given at 0, 1, and 6 months; or in group 3 with three doses of plasma-derived vaccine given at 0, 1, and 6 months. Eleven subjects with a hepatitis B surface antigen antibody (anti-HBs) titer of less than 10 mIU/mL at 12 months were given an extra dose of vaccine and were excluded from analysis. No booster doses were given to any other subjects. All children were followed up yearly for the level of anti-HBs titers and for the detection of hepatitis B infection. At the 12th year of follow-up, there were significantly fewer subjects with anti-HBs of 10 mIU/mL or above in group 1 (60.4%) when compared with group 2 (81.4%; P =.0287) and group 3 (79.0%; P =. 0381). The geometric mean titers (GMTs) of subjects of group 1 were significantly lower than those of group 2 and group 3 throughout the 12 years of follow-up. A total of 65 subjects had one or more episodes of anamnestic response. No subject became positive for hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg); 2 became positive for hepatitis B core antigen antibody (anti-HBc). In conclusion, the long-term protective immunity was better with three doses of hepatitis B vaccine (either the recombinant or plasma-derived) than with two doses. However, protection from hepatitis B infection could be equally achieved by either two doses or three doses of the vaccine. Booster doses were not necessary, probably because of effective anamnestic response.

An economic analysis of different strategies of immunization against hepatitis A virus in developed countries

Acute hepatitis A is a major public health problem in developed countries, and because a large proportion of patients with acute hepatitis A do not have any identifiable risk factors, current practice of targeting the high-risk groups for vaccination against hepatitis A virus (HAV) is unlikely to have a significant impact on the overall incidence of acute hepatitis A. No economic analysis of strategies of mass immunization against HAV is available. Three different strategies of immunization against HAV using commercially available inactivated vaccine were compared in a Markov model analysis of a cohort of 2-year-old healthy children in a developed country. In strategy I, universal vaccination was pursued. In strategy II, children were initially screened for antibody and, if susceptible, they were vaccinated. In strategy III, no vaccination was offered. Cost per person and quality adjusted life-years (QALY) gained in each strategy were the outcome measures compared. The baseline analysis showed that strategy II is more cost-effective than strategy I, with marginal cost-effectiveness ratios of $7,267. 67 and $12,833.34, respectively, compared with a strategy of no intervention. Sensitivity analysis showed that if the cost of the two-dose vaccine could be reduced to less than $57, the strategy of universal vaccination would be the preferred immunization strategy. Different strategies of mass immunization against HAV in the developed countries are cost-effective by current standards of health care interventions and should be considered for incorporation into current childhood immunization programs.

[Economic evaluation of various hepatitis B vaccination Strategies in Switzerland]

The aim of this study was to assess and compare the costs and epidemiological impact of different vaccination strategies against hepatitis B in Switzerland. A birth cohort of 85,000 individuals was followed over its lifetime using a decision tree analysis. Published data were used to simulate the risk of hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection in the cohort, the consecutive clinical outcomes and the associated costs. Five vaccination scenarios were assessed and compared to the baseline, defined as the high-risk group strategy without prenatal screening. These were: 1. systematic prenatal screening and vaccination of newborns at risk; 2. universal vaccination of infants; 3. universal vaccination of schoolchildren; 4. universal vaccination of infants and schoolchildren; 5. universal vaccination of infants, schoolchildren and adolescents. Results are presented using a 3% annual discounting rate. Systematic prenatal screening reduced the number of chronic infections by 11% and prevented 6 deaths per year. The cost per year of life saved was estimated to be 23,350 CHF. The four universal vaccination scenarios had a much larger impact on the number of chronic infections and deaths prevented (reduction of 68-78%). Costs per year of life saved for universal vaccination ranged from 8820 CHF (infant strategy) to 12,380 CHF (schoolchildren strategy). However, the vaccination of schoolchildren would be as cost-effective as the vaccination of infants using alternative assumptions (a lower compliance for infants compared to schoolchildren or the need for a booster later in the life for infants). The benefit-cost ratio ranged from 1.2 (systematic prenatal screening and vaccination of newborns at risk) to 2.9 (vaccination of infants). Universal vaccination against hepatitis B is more cost-effective than the current selective vaccination strategy of newborns.

Costs and cost-effectiveness of a universal, school-based hepatitis B vaccination program

OBJECTIVES

This study evaluated the costs and cost-effectiveness of a school-based grade 6 universal vaccination program against hepatitis B.

METHODS

We performed a descriptive cost study and cost-effectiveness analysis of British Columbia's vaccination program for 1994 and 1995. Since 1992, public health nurses have administered hepatitis B vaccine to grade 6 students in schools. We measured costs of vaccine, vaccine administration, and net program costs and used a validated Markov model to calculate the cost-effectiveness of the program.

RESULTS

Vaccinating each student cost $44, $24 of which was the cost of vaccine administration. The net cost was $9 per person; considering productivity costs, net savings were $75 per person. Marginal cost per life year gained was $2100. Universal adolescent vaccination is also economically attractive in the United States but less attractive in regions with incidence rates below 3 cases per 100,000 per year.

CONCLUSIONS

Hepatitis B vaccine can be delivered in North American schools at a reasonable cost. Adolescent vaccination is economically attractive in North American regions of high and average incidence rates. Our analysis supports vaccination in adolescents who remain at risk for hepatitis B virus infection.

Evaluating the cost-effectiveness of clinical and public health measures

Cost-effectiveness analysis, an analytic tool that expresses as a ratio the cost of obtaining an additional unit of health outcome, can help decision makers achieve more health protection for the same or less cost. We characterize the state of the cost-effectiveness analysis literature by reviewing how this technique is applied to various clinical and public health interventions. We describe the results of cost-effectiveness analyses for over 40 interventions to reduce cancer, heart disease, trauma, and infectious disease. The cost-effectiveness ratios for these interventions vary enormously, from interventions that save money to those that cost more than $1 million per year of life gained. The methods used to derive the cost-effectiveness ratios also vary considerably, and we summarize this variation within each health area. Greater uniformity of analytical practice will be necessary if cost-effectiveness analysis is to become a more influential tool in debates about resource allocation.

A compelling rationale for using preoperative visits to complete adult immunizations

Immunization is a safe and cost-effective method to protect adult patients against many diseases, including hepatitis B, pneumococcal infections, and influenza. Despite this fact, only 10% to 40% of adults in the United States who would benefit have been immunized. Approximately 62% to 92% of patients who develop a disease preventable by vaccination have visited an outpatient clinic at least once in the 3 years preceding their illness. Efforts to educate providers about immunization guidelines have not increased immunization rates. In this report, we propose using the preanesthesia clinic as an alternative site to screen, identify, and immunize adults at risk. We also discuss three vaccines that could be offered to patients and analyze the efficacy of the vaccines.

Hepatitis B immunization in a low-incidence province of Canada: comparing alternative strategies

This study provides a comparative cost-effectiveness analysis of three universal immunization programs for hepatitis B virus (HBV). Using three theoretical cohorts of infants, 10-year-olds, and 12-year-olds, a universal immunization program was compared with a prenatal screening/newborn immunization program involving testing of prepartum women and immunization of newborns of HBsAg-positive mothers. A Markov long-term outcome model used Manitoba data to estimate costs and health outcomes across the lifespan. The model was based on an HBV incidence rate of 19/100,000 and a discount rate of 5% and incorporated the most recent treatment advances (interferon therapy). Cost-effectiveness was calculated as the ratio of dollars spent per year of life saved, with costs determined from the perspective of a third-party payer. The universal infant-immunization program, although not cost-saving, was associated with a low, economically attractive cost-effectiveness ratio of $15,900 (Canadian) per year of life saved, a figure substantially lower than the ratios of $97,600 and $184,800 (Canadian) associated with the universal programs for 10- and 12-year-olds, respectively. Cost-effectiveness ratios were found to be sensitive to changes in immunization costs, HBV incidence rates, and the rate at which protective antibody levels are lost over time: If these variables move in the directions suggested by current trends, the authors anticipate an increasing economic appeal of universal programs well into the future. A universal program of HBV immunization for infants appears to be economically practical in regions where HBV infection rates are low and stable.

Hepatitis B component does not interfere with the immune response to diphtheria, tetanus and whole-cell Bordetella pertussis components of a quadrivalent (DTPw-HB) vaccine: a controlled trial in healthy infants

The aim of this single-blind, parallel trial was to assess whether the hepatitis B (HB) component of a DTPw-HB vaccine interferes with the immune response to the other three components when administered at 3, 5 and 7 months of age. One hundred and six infants were randomized to receive three doses of DTPw or DTPw-HB vaccines. Seroprotection (or seroresponse) rates and geometric mean titers (GMT) of antibodies were assessed 3-6 weeks after the third dose. Anti-diphtheria, anti-tetanus and anti-Bordetella pertussis antibodies were measured by ELISA and anti-HBs by radioimmunoassay. Local and general signs and symptoms were recorded for a 4-day follow-up period after each vaccination. After the full vaccination course all subjects in both groups had seroprotective titers (> or = 0.1 IU ml-1) against diphtheria and tetanus and seroresponded (titers > or = 15 EL.U ml-1) to B. pertussis, and there was no significant difference between groups in relation to GMT. All subjects vaccinated with DTPw-HB had seroprotective levels (> or = 10 mIU ml-1) of anti-HBs antibodies after the third dose (GMT of 2318 mIU ml-1). Overall there were no significant differences between groups in relation to the incidence of local and general symptoms. These results show that the HB component did not interfere with the immune response to the other three components of the vaccine.

Primer on medical decision analysis: Part 4--Analyzing the model and interpreting the results

This paper is the fourth of a five-part series that describes the principles of construction and evaluation of valid decision models. In this review, the authors describe the key principles of detecting and eliminating structural and programming errors in decision trees (debugging). In addition, they offer guidelines to facilitate the interpretation of analytic results of decision models.

Cost comparison of recombinant human erythropoietin and blood transfusion in cancer chemotherapy-induced anemia

OBJECTIVE

To compare the cost of recombinant human erythropoietin (rHuEPO) with that of blood transfusion in the treatment of chemotherapy-induced anemia from a healthcare system perspective.

DESIGN

A decision analytic model. Baseline estimates were obtained from a review of clinical trials data and economic evaluation studies.

SUBJECTS

Secondary data analyses of patients with advanced malignancies, excluding hematologic malignancies and metastasized solid tumors.

INTERVENTIONS

Patients received either leukocyte-depleted packed red blood cells (PRBCs) or rHuEPO 150 units/kg s.c. three times per week for 6 months (24 wk). After 6 weeks, if rHuEPO recipients did not display a response, they received rHuEPO 300 units/kg s.c. three times weekly for the duration of therapy. If rHuEPO recipients still exhibited no response, they were given blood transfusions.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

For a treatment period of 24 weeks, approximately 64% of rHuEPO recipients responded at an average expected cost of $12971 per patient. One hundred percent of transfusion recipients responded at a cost of $481; this resulted in a cost savings of $8490. Variation of response rates for rHuEPO or PRBCs did not appreciably lower costs. Lower rHuEPO dosages and higher numbers of transfused units of PRBCs yielded approximately equivalent costs; however, these strategies may not be clinically prudent.

CONCLUSIONS

From a healthcare system cost and outcome perspective, blood transfusion is the preferred strategy for chemotherapy-induced anemia. However, rHuEPO may be considered an effective blood-sparing alternative for patients with non-stem cell disorders. Future cost-effectiveness analyses are needed to assess more completely both the clinical and quality-of-life benefits rHuEPO may contribute to individual patients' lives and to society overall.

Costing methods in the Canadian literature on the economic evaluation of health care. A survey and assessment

We reviewed the Canadian literature on cost-effectiveness from 1980-95 with regard to costing methodologies. We abstracted each study using a list of data elements that describe costing methodology, and evaluated costing methodologies in the light of biases in costing methods, site, and case-mix selection.

Comprehensive control (or elimination) of hepatitis B virus transmission in the United States

In the United States, the reported rate of hepatitis B has declined by over 50% since 1987, probably as a result of vaccination programmes, behavioural changes, refinements in blood screening procedures, and the availability of virus inactivated blood components. The majority of new hepatitis B infections occur in 20-39 year olds, and perinatal transmission is uncommon except in certain at risk groups. Initial efforts to control hepatitis B in the US were targeted at high risk groups, including health care personnel. Then, in 1988, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommended screening of all pregnant females for hepatitis B surface antigen and full immunisation of infants born to those testing positive. A recommendation for universal immunisation of infants was endorsed in 1991. Compliance has been slow but progressive. The CDC also has recommended 'catch up' immunisation of adolescents and high risk children and adults. Demonstration projects suggest that these can be successful, given the provision of free or low cost vaccine and appropriate support. Hepatitis B vaccination has been shown to be cost effective and should be integrated into the routine childhood immunisation schedule. Responses to hepatitis B vaccine have largely been shown to be durable, although at least one booster dose after five to 10 years seems prudent, especially if a low dose, yeast derived vaccine has been used.

The tension between cost containment and the underutilization of effective health services

One of the common ingredients in all attempts to slow escalating health care costs is to control the utilization of services that provide little or uncertain benefit. To reform existing delivery systems, the organization, provision, and financing of health care need to be evaluated critically. Successful reform requires that more rational methods be used to determine which services to provide. The preferences of physicians, patients, and payers of care do not appear optimal from a societal perspective in choosing health care services. While reducing the use of interventions of little or unknown benefit should save money, a policy to restrict the use of medical services may lead to an unwanted result: the underutilization of interventions of proven clinical benefit. Through the determination of the value--by rigorous assessment of both costs and benefits of available alternatives--in a context sensitive to the unique cultural, political, and economic characteristics of individual nations, the health of the population should be improved and growth of health expenditures constrained. This is the first step in health care reform.

Is vaccination against hepatitis B efficient? A review of world literature

We report on the result of a study aimed at assessing the variability of assumptions upon which economic models for the introduction of vaccination against Hepatitis B are based, the conclusions reached and define a minimum set of methodological standards upon which future economic studies on vaccines should be based. We identified 116 published and unpublished works by Medline literature searches, consulting private databases and corresponding with all authors and researchers active in economic evaluation of vaccines. All works were assessed but we included in our review only those which were original economic analyses (90 studies). Principal epidemiological and economic variables were extracted and compared where possible. Rough manipulations were carried out to make the data comparable. We found profound variability on the main parameters of the efficiency equation (disease incidence, costing methods, use of marginal theory, discounting and study time-span, sensitivity analysis and reporting methods). We also found inconsistencies in definition and study design in 38% of a subset of studies. Although we found scarce decision-making impact, we believe that due to uncertain or unclear methodology, few studies reach valid conclusions. In future decisions may be based on biased evidence and scarce resources committed to untested programmes. There is an urgent need to standardise study methods and define a common set of procedures.