Loss of Tolerance to Exogenous and Endogenous Factor VIII in a Mild Hemophilia A Patient With an Arg593 to Cys Mutation

Prevalence and Incidence of Non-neutralizing Antibodies in Congenital Hemophilia A- A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Objectives: In hemophilia A the presence of non-neutralizing antibodies (NNAs) against Factor VIII (FVIII) may predict the development of neutralizing antibodies (inhibitors) and accelerate the clearance of administrated FVIII concentrates. This systematic review aimed to assess: (1) the prevalence and incidence of NNAs in patients with congenital hemophilia without inhibitors and (2) the association between NNAs and patient and treatment characteristics.

Methods: We conducted a search in MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science and the Cochrane database. We included cross-sectional and longitudinal studies reporting on NNAs in patients with hemophilia A and B, who were inhibitor-negative at the start of the observation period. Data were extracted on: hemophilia type and severity, patient and treatment characteristics, NNA prevalence and incidence, NNA assays and inhibitor development. Two independent reviewers performed study selection, data extraction and risk of bias assessment, using adapted criteria of the Joanna Briggs Institute. Studies were classified as high-quality when ≥5/9 criteria were met. NNA assays were classified as high-quality when both quality criteria were met: (1) use of positive controls and (2) competition with FVIII to establish FVIII-specificity. We reported NNA prevalence and incidence for each study. The pooled NNA prevalence was assessed for well-designed studies in previously treated patients, employing high-quality NNA assays.

Results: We included data from 2,723 inhibitor-negative patients with hemophilia A, derived from 28 studies. Most studies were cross-sectional (19/28) and none reported on NNAs in hemophilia B. Study design was of high quality in 16/28 studies and the NNA assay quality was high in 9/28 studies. Various NNA assays were used, predominantly ELISA (18/28) with different cut-off values. We found a large variety in NNA prevalence (Range, 0–100%). The pooled NNA prevalence in high-quality studies was 25% (95% CI, 16–38%). The incidence of new NNA development was reported in one study (0.01 NNA per person-exposure day).

Conclusion: This systematic review identified studies that were heterogeneous in study design, patient population and NNA assay type, with NNA prevalence ranging from 0 to 100% in inhibitor-negative patients with hemophilia A. The pooled NNA prevalence was 25% in high-quality studies including only previously treated patients and performing high-quality NNA assays.

The past and future of haemophilia: diagnosis, treatments, and its complications

Haemophilia A and B are hereditary haemorrhagic disorders characterised by deficiency or dysfunction of coagulation protein factors VIII and IX, respectively. Recurrent joint and muscle bleeds lead to severe and progressive musculoskeletal damage. Existing treatment relies on replacement therapy with clotting factors, either at the time of bleeding (ie, on demand) or as part of a prophylactic schedule. The major complication of such therapy is the development of neutralising antibodies (ie, inhibitors), which is most frequent in haemophilia A. Treatment might improve considerably with the availability of new modified drugs, which might overcome existing prophylaxis limitations by reducing dosing frequency and thereby rendering therapy less distressing for the patient. Subcutaneous administration of some new therapies would also simplify prophylaxis in children with poor venous access. Gene therapy has the potential for a definitive cure, and important results have been obtained in haemophilia B. Despite improvements in haemophilia care, the availability of clotting factor concentrates for all affected individuals worldwide remains the biggest challenge.

Factor VIII gene variants and inhibitor risk in African American hemophilia A patients

African American hemophilia A (HA) patients experience a higher incidence of neutralizing anti-factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies ("inhibitors") vis-à-vis white patients. Nonsynonymous single-nucleotide polymorphisms (ns-SNPs) in the F8 gene encoding FVIII-H484, FVIII-E1241, and FVIII-V2238 are more prevalent in African Americans. This study tested the hypothesis that immune responses to these sites provoke inhibitors. Blood samples were obtained from 174 African American and 198 white HA subjects and their F8 gene sequences determined. Major histocompatibility complex class II binding and T-cell recognition of polymorphic sequences were evaluated using quantitative binding assays and HLA-DRB1 tetramers. Peptides corresponding to 4 common ns-SNPs showed limited binding to 11 HLA-DRB1 proteins. CD4 T cells from 22 subjects treated with FVIII products having sequences at residues FVIII-484, 1241, and 2238 differing from those of putative proteins encoded by their F8 genes did not show high-avidity tetramer binding, whereas positive-control staining of tetanus-specific CD4 T cells was routinely successful. African Americans with an intron-22 inversion mutation showed a 2-3 times-higher inhibitor incidence than whites with the same mutation (odds ratio = 2.3 [1.1-5.0, P = .04]), but this did not correlate with any of the ns-SNPs. We conclude that immune responses to "sequence-mismatched" FVIII products are unlikely to contribute appreciably to the inhibitor incidence in African Americans.

The intron-22-inverted F8 locus permits factor VIII synthesis: explanation for low inhibitor risk and a role for pharmacogenomics

Intron-22-inversion patients express the entire Factor VIII (FVIII)-amino-acid sequence intracellularly as 2 non-secreted polypeptides and have a positive "intracellular (I)-FVIII-CRM" status. Mutations conferring a positive I-FVIII-CRM status are associated with low inhibitor risk and are pharmacogenetically relevant because inhibitor risk may be affected by the nature of the therapeutic FVIII-protein (tFVIII), the affinity of any tFVIII-derived foreign peptide (tFVIII-fp) for any HLA class-II isomer (HLA-II) comprising individual major histocompatibility complex (MHC) repertoires, and the stability of any tFVIII-fp/HLA-II complex. We hypothesize that mutations conferring a completely or substantially negative I-FVIII-CRM status are pharmacogenetically irrelevant because inhibitor risk is high with any tFVIII and individual MHC repertoire.

Inhibitor development and management in three non-severe haemophilia A patients with T295A variant

Missense mutations are the most common F8 gene defects among the patients with non-severe haemophilia A. This type of mutation is typically associated with low (5%) inhibitor risk. In the present retrospective study we analysed the clinical data of 16 haemophiliacs with the T295A missense mutation treated at Bonn Haemophilia Centre. In total, three patients developed inhibitors: two patients experienced low-titer and one high-titer inhibitors. Both patients with low titer inhibitors underwent successful ITI. The third patient, at the age of 81, developed initially low-titer inhibitors (3 BU/ml) after rFVIII therapy because of knee surgery. He experienced spontaneous multiple large skin haematomas and haemarthrosis. Immunosuppressive therapy was not applicable because of the infectious origin of discitis (Th3-Th4). Immunoadsorption was performed, but the inhibitor titer increased up to 42 BU/ml nine weeks after termination. A successful treatment of discitis with antibiotics finally allowed a weekly therapy (four times) with rituximab (375 mg/m(2)). This resulted in a decrease of inhibitor titre to 0.7 BU/ml eight weeks after the fourth rituximab application. Patient had endogenous FVIII levels of 3-5%. Twelve months after rituximab therapy (after B cells recovery) he relapsed with low-titer inhibitors and therefore was treated with single rituximab dose (375 mg/m(2)) again. This resulted in his depletion of B cells, measurable endogenous FVIII levels and non measurable inhibitors. This study demonstrated T295A variant to be associated with significantly increased (3/16 patients, 17%) inhibitor development.

T-cell responses in two unrelated hemophilia A inhibitor subjects include an epitope at the factor VIII R593C missense site

BACKGROUND

Development of neutralizing anti-factor (F)VIII antibodies ('inhibitors') is a serious clinical problem in hemophilia A. Increased inhibitor risk has been associated with certain FVIII missense substitutions, including R593C in the A2 domain.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the present study was to identify T-cell epitopes in FVIII and characterize T-cell responses in two unrelated hemophilia A subjects sharing F8-R593C and HLA-DRB1*1101 genotypes. We hypothesized that the hemophilic substitution site coincides with an important T-cell epitope.

PATIENTS/METHODS

The binding affinities of peptides for recombinant HLA-DR proteins were measured and compared with epitope prediction results. CD4+ T cells were stimulated using peptides and stained with fluorescent, peptide-loaded tetramers.

RESULTS

The inhibitor subjects, but not HLA-matched controls, had high-avidity HLA-DRB1*1101-restricted T-cell responses against FVIII(589-608), which contains the hemophilic missense site. Antigen-specific T cells secreted Th1 and Th2 cytokines and proliferated in response to FVIII and FVIII(592-603). FVIII(589-608) bound with physiologically relevant (micromolar) IC(50) values to recombinant DR0101, DR1101 and DR1501 proteins.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemophilia A patients with R593C missense substitutions and these HLA haplotypes had an increased incidence of inhibitors in our cohorts, supporting a paradigm in which presentation of FVIII epitopes containing the wild-type R593 influences inhibitor risk in this hemophilia A sub-population.

HLA-DR-restricted T-cell responses to factor VIII epitopes in a mild haemophilia A family with missense substitution A2201P

An HLA-DRA-DRB1*0101-restricted T-cell epitope in the factor VIII (FVIII) C2 domain occurred in a mild haemophilia A patient with missense substitution FVIII-A2201P. His T cells responded to synthetic peptides FVIII(2186-2205) and FVIII(2194-2213) (J Thromb Haemost 2007; 5: 2399). T cells from family members with genotype FVIII-A2201P were analysed to determine if FVIII-specific T cells occur in individuals with a haemophilic mutation but no clinically significant inhibitor response. Fluorescent MHC class II tetramers corresponding to subjects'HLA-DRB1 types were loaded with 20-mer peptides and utilized to label antigen-specific CD4+ T cells. T-cell responses to peptides spanning the FVIII-C2 sequence were evaluated. T cells recognizing specific peptides were cloned, and antigen specificity was verified by proliferation assays. Plasma and/or purified IgG samples were tested for FVIII inhibitory activity. CD4+ T cells and T-cell clones from two brothers who shared the DRB1*0101 allele responded to FVIII(2194-2213). A haemophilic cousin's HLA-DRA-DRB1*1104-restricted response to FVIII(2202-2221) was detected only when CD4+CD25+ cells were depleted. A great uncle and two obligate carriers had no detectable FVIII-C2-specific T cells. Concentrated IgG from the brother without a clinical inhibitor response showed a low-titre FVIII inhibitor. FVIII-specific T cells and inhibitory IgG were found in a previously infused, haemophilic subject who had a sub-clinical FVIII inhibitor. CD4+CD25+ depleted T cells from a non-infused haemophilic cousin recognized an overlapping FVIII epitope, indicating a latent HLA-DRA-DRB1*1104-restricted T-cell response to FVIII. Specific T-cell responses to FVIII can occur without clinically significant inhibitors.

Mild haemophilia: a disease with many faces and many unexpected pitfalls

SUMMARY

Despite major advances in diagnosis and treatment, the management of patients with mild haemophilia (MH) remains a major challenge. Mild haemophilia is defined by factor levels between 0.05 and 0.40 IU mL(-1). The bleeding associated with mild haemophilia is most frequently episodic, occurring during surgery or following trauma. Spontaneous bleeding is rare. Diagnosis is sometimes delayed because of insensitivity of screening clotting assays or discrepancies in factor VIII activity as measured by different assays. The treatment of choice in mild haemophilia A is desmopressin, which typically induces a 2-6-fold increase of factor VIII over baseline. However, desmopressin has its limitations in this setting such as the occurrence of tachyphylaxis and failure to respond in an undetermined proportion of patients. Factors underlying poor biological response or magnitude of response to desmopressin are incompletely understood. Inhibitor development in mild haemophilia is particularly distressing. This complication arises at an older age in this patient group because of infrequent need for factor VIII replacement. Inhibitors in mild haemophilia patients often cross-react with endogenous factor VIII resulting in severe spontaneous bleeding frequently in a postoperative setting. Intensive perioperative use of factor VIII and some specific mutations induce a particularly high risk for inhibitor development, but risk factors are incompletely understood. For reasons of the older age of the patients, treatment of bleeding with bypassing agents may cause major thrombotic complications. Data on therapeutic options for inhibitor eradication in patients with mild haemophilia are particularly scarce. With increased life-expectancy for all haemophilia patients, the group of elderly patients with mild haemophilia requiring major surgery will further increase. Prevention of inhibitors, particularly in this patient group, should be a major topic of interest in both clinic and research.

Mild hemophilia A

Mild hemophilia A (HA), defined by clinical features and factor VIII coagulant activity (FVIII:C) between 0.05 and 0.40 IU mL(-1), is characteristically distinct from severe HA. Indeed, although the molecular characterization of mild HA has permitted the identification of specific underlying mutations, its clinical phenotype is strikingly different from that of patients with a severe FVIII defect, where spontaneous hemorrhages or recurrent joint bleeding are usual manifestations. With aging, mild HA patients may develop complications (i.e. cancers and cardiovascular disorders), the management of which may prove challenging due to the concomitant bleeding tendency. Furthermore, the development of inhibitors provides an additional major complication in these patients, because it increases the severity of the bleeding phenotype and complicates their management. Standard management of mild HA includes the use of desmopressin and antifibrinolytic agents for minor bleeding episodes or surgical procedures, whilst major bleeding or surgery requires replacement therapy with FVIII concentrates. As regards treatment of patients with inhibitors, bypassing agents (i.e. activated prothrombin complex concentrates and recombinant activated FVII) have proven effective in the treatment of bleeding episodes, but as there are insufficient data to determine the optimal approach to immune tolerance induction in this group of patients, their optimal management remains controversial. Rituximab is a newer, promising therapeutic option for inhibitor eradication in such patients. Many aspects concerning mild HA remain to be clarified, including the molecular basis, the natural history and the optimal diagnostic and therapeutic strategies. Only large prospective studies will shed light on this condition.

Intensive peri-operative use of factor VIII and the Arg593-->Cys mutation are risk factors for inhibitor development in mild/moderate hemophilia A

BACKGROUND

A severe and challenging complication in the treatment of hemophilia A is the development of inhibiting antibodies (inhibitors) directed towards factor VIII (FVIII). Inhibitors aggravate bleeding complications, disabilities and costs. The etiology of inhibitor development is incompletely understood.

OBJECTIVES

In a large cohort study in patients with mild/moderate hemophilia A we evaluated the role of genotype and intensive FVIII exposure in inhibitor development.

PATIENTS/METHODS

Longitudinal clinical data from 138 mild/moderate hemophilia A patients were retrospectively collected from 1 January 1980 to 1 January 2008 and analyzed by multivariate analysis using Poisson regression.

RESULTS

Genotyping demonstrated the Arg593Cys missense mutation in 52 (38%) patients; the remaining 86 patients had 26 other missense mutations. Sixty-three (46%) patients received intensive FVIII concentrate administration, 41 of them for surgery. Ten patients (7%) developed inhibitors, eight of them carrying the Arg593Cys mutation. Compared with the other patients, those with the Arg593Cys mutation had a 10-fold increased risk of developing inhibitors (RR 10; 95% CI, 0.9-119).The other two inhibitor patients had the newly detected mutations Pro1761Gln and Glu2228Asp. In both these patients and in five patients with genotype Arg593Cys, inhibitors developed after intensive peri-operative use of FVIII concentrate (RR 186; 95% CI, 25-1403). In five of the 10 inhibitor patients FVIII was administered by continuous infusion during surgery (RR 13; 95% CI, 1.9-86).

CONCLUSION

The Arg593Cys genotype and intensive peri-operative use of FVIII, especially when administered by continuous infusion, are associated with an increased risk for inhibitor development in mild/moderate hemophilia A.

T-cell responses over time in a mild hemophilia A inhibitor subject: epitope identification and transient immunogenicity of the corresponding self-peptide

BACKGROUND

Antibodies that neutralize factor (F) VIII activity, clinically referred to as 'inhibitors', complicate the treatment of hemophilia A patients; current tolerance and bypass strategies are extremely costly and sometimes ineffective. The development of inhibitors requires T-cell help.

OBJECTIVES

We characterized T-cell responses of a subject with mild hemophilia A with missense genotype A2201P for one year following his initial inhibitor response, with the goals of defining the primary epitope(s) and its (their) MHC Class II restriction. We investigated the possible involvement of regulatory T cells in modulating immune responses.

PATIENTS/METHODS

The subject developed high-titer FVIII-neutralizing antibodies (250 BU mL(-1)) that declined over time to 8 BU ml(-1). His clotting activity was initially impaired (3%) but returned to baseline (8-10%) within four weeks. MHC Class II tetramers were used to analyze his CD4 T cells, which were stimulated with peptides spanning the C2 domain. Responses of total and CD25-depleted CD4 cells to sequences containing A2201 (native), P2201 (hemophilic), and other predicted T-cell epitopes were evaluated.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

An HLA-DRA-DRB1*0101 restricted T-cell epitope containing the wild-type A2201 sequence was identified. Interestingly, peptides containing A2201 were recognized by CD4 T cells at all time points, whereas a P2201 peptide was recognized only near the initial peak response. The responsiveness of CD25-depleted CD4 cells to an A2201 peptide was enhanced 11 and 19 weeks following inhibitor detection, suggesting the possible involvement of CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells in modulating immune responses. Patient-derived T-cell clones proliferated in response to C2 protein and to peptides containing A2201 but not P2201.

Immunogenicity of biopharmaceuticals

The availability of biopharmaceuticals has been increasing over the past decade and as their patents expire, the emergence of biosimilar agents approaches. The primary issue of concern for the safety of these agents is the potential for immunogenicity. Both product- and host-related factors have documented impact on the immune response, but many factors are still unknown. Although in many cases the presence of antibodies may have little clinical consequence, the upsurge of pure red cell aplasia cases further increased concerns about potential clinical consequences of extensive use of biopharmaceuticals and biosimilars. Available laboratory measurement methods are insufficient to predict biological and clinical properties of biopharmaceuticals, or even to compare their bioequivalence. Comparison of results from different studies is complicated by the variability of assay measurements, presentation of data and lack of standardization.

Characteristics of inhibitors in mild/moderate haemophilia A

Patients with mild or moderate haemophilia A usually have a mild bleeding disorder requiring only occasional treatment with factor VIII (FVIII) concentrates. The frequency of inhibitor development in such patients has been the subject of several recent surveys, which significantly modified our appreciation of this complication. Studies of the anti-FVIII antibodies provided an explanation for the different bleeding phenotypes observed in mild/moderate haemophilia A patients with inhibitors. Antibodies distinguishing between the patient's mutant FVIII and the normal wild-type FVIII were characterized, in addition to antibodies inhibiting completely or only partially FVIII activity. T lymphocytes recognizing FVIII and likely involved in the development of the immune response to FVIII were successfully identified. The FVIII peptides recognized by those FVIII-specific cells bind to many major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules, which may provide an explanation for the lack of strong association between MHC haplotypes and inhibitor development. Although these studies have advanced our understanding of the conditions leading to inhibitor development, further work is required to determine whether the mode of FVIII administration significantly influences inhibitor development. Further studies of the genetic factors are also required to fully understand the mechanisms leading to inhibitor development in patients with mild/moderate haemophilia A.

Tyr2105Cys mutation in exon 22 of FVIII gene is a risk factor for the development of inhibitors in patients with mild/moderate haemophilia A

We report the case of a patient with mild haemophilia A, due to a Tyr2105Cys mutation in exon 22 of the C1 domain, who developed a high-titre factor VIII inhibitor (maximum titre 1600 BU) with recurrent severe haemorrhages and fatal intracranial bleeding. Based on published data, it appears that although this mutation occurs rarely in patients with mild or moderate haemophilia A, it is frequently associated with the development of high-titre inhibitors.

Impact of Choice of Treatment for Bleeding Episodes on Inhibitor Outcome in Patients With Mild/Moderate Hemophilia A and Inhibitors

Patients with mild/moderate hemophilia A (MHA) may develop inhibitors to factor VIII (FVIII). In this condition, FVIII clotting activity (FVIII:C) baseline levels may remain stable for some patients, but may be reduced to less than 0.01 U/mL for others. Several risk factors for the development of inhibitors in MHA have been proposed. Genetic factors, such as mutations in the FVIII gene, may play a central role; however, other influences, such as intensive treatment with FVIII products, may also be important. Optimal treatment regimens have yet to be determined, not only for the eradication of inhibitors, but also for the management or surgical prophylaxis of hemorrhages associated with this condition. Several treatment options for the control of bleeding in patients with MHA and inhibitors (MHAI) are currently available, and the choice of therapeutic strategy should be given careful consideration; some treatments may produce an anamnestic response, thus delaying the return to FVIII:C baseline levels and adversely affecting the duration of the severe bleeding phenotype. To increase our knowledge of MHAI, a retrospective collection of data is currently being performed among hemophilia centers in France and Belgium. Based on five examples of patients with MHAI collated from preliminary study data, we illustrate the impact on inhibitor outcome of the therapeutic choices used to treat bleeding episodes in these patients.

Identification and removal of a promiscuous CD4+ T cell epitope from the C1 domain of factor VIII

BACKGROUND

The development of inhibitors in hemophiliacs is a severe complication of factor VIII (FVIII) replacement therapy and is a process driven by FVIII specific T helper cells.

OBJECTIVES

To finely map T cell epitopes within the whole FVIII protein in order to investigate the possibility of engineering FVIII variants with reduced propensity for inhibitor development.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

T cell lines were generated from five patients with severe hemophilia who had developed inhibitors, and were screened for T cell proliferation against pools of overlapping peptides spanning the entire B domain deleted (BDD) FVIII sequence. Positive peptide pools were decoded by screening individual peptides against the T cell lines. Positive peptides, and mutants thereof, were tested for their ability to bind major histocompatibility complex (MHC) Class II and stimulate T cell proliferation in a panel of healthy donors. The activities of the corresponding mutant proteins were assessed via chromogenic assay.

RESULTS

One peptide, spanning FVIII amino acids 2098-2112, elicited a vigorous response from one hemophiliac donor, induced strong T cell responses in the panel of healthy donors and bound to a number of HLA-DR alleles. Mutations were made in this peptide that removed its ability to stimulate T cells of healthy donors and to bind to MHC Class II while retaining full activity when incorporated into a mutant BDD-FVIII protein.

CONCLUSIONS

Fine T cell epitope mapping of the entire FVIII protein is feasible, although challenging, and this knowledge may be used to create FVIII variants which potentially have reduced immunogenicity.

HLA class II genotype and factor VIII inhibitors in mild haemophilia A patients with an Arg593 to Cys mutation

We evaluated inhibitor formation in a group of patients with mild haemophilia A caused by an Arg593 to Cys mutation. A remarkably high cumulative inhibitor incidence of 14% over 22 years was observed. Three of 49 patients developed transient, low-titre inhibitors, which remained below 2.0 BU mL(-1). Four patients with an Arg593 to Cys mutation developed high-titre inhibitors (>5.0 BU mL(-1)). Three of these patients have been described previously. In this study, we characterized inhibitory antibodies in a fourth patient with high-titre inhibitors. Epitope mapping studies revealed that antibodies were predominantly directed to the A2 domain of factor VIII. We addressed the role of human leucocyte antigen (HLA) class II alleles in inhibitor development in patients with an Arg593 to Cys mutation by HLA genotyping. In the group of inhibitor patients raised frequencies of HLA-DRB1*01 and HLA-DQB1*05 were observed that did not reached statistical significance. Our data suggest that inhibitor development in mild haemophilia A patients with an Arg593 to Cys mutation is not linked to HLA class II profile.

Inhibitors in congenital coagulation disorders

The development of inhibitory 'allo' antibodies to a deficient coagulation factor is arguably now the most severe and important complication of clotting factor concentrate exposure in haemophilia and other congenital coagulation disorders. Furthermore, development of an inhibitor to the factor VIII or factor IX transgene product remains a significant concern in gene therapy protocols for haemophilia. Although the development of an inhibitor does not usually change the rate, initial severity or pattern of bleeding, it does compromise the ability to manage haemorrhage in affected individuals, resulting in a greater rate of complications, cost and disability. The purpose of this review is to summarize current understanding of the epidemiology, immunobiology, laboratory evaluation and management of inhibitors arising in patients with congenital coagulation disorders. An attempt has been made to focus on recent advances in the immunology of inhibitors, and to speculate on their potential clinical application.

Effective and safe use of recombinant factor VIIa (NovoSevenR) in elderly mild haemophilia A patients with high-titre antibodies against factor VIII

Three patients with mild haemophilia A who developed high-titre antibodies against factor VIII at high age are reported. These patients had only a limited number of exposure days of FVIII concentrates in the past. The patients had to undergo surgery or presented with recurrent bleeding episodes. Treatment with recombinant FVIIa (rFVIIa) was effective and safe. Despite the high age and the presence of coronary heart disease in one of the patients, no adverse events or thrombotic complications occurred. These cases illustrate that the physician should always be alert on the development of inhibitors, also in elderly patients with mild haemophilia, in whom FVIII inhibitors had never been detectable before and that treatment with rFVIIa was effective and well-tolerated.

Intensive exposure to factor VIII is a risk factor for inhibitor development in mild hemophilia A

BACKGROUND

Inhibitors are rare in boys with mild hemophilia A (MHA; factor (F)VIII:C > 5%) but may arise following intense FVIII exposure, e.g. continuous infusion (CI).

OBJECTIVES

To determine the impact of intense FVIII exposure in inhibitor formation in MHA at our institution and to compare this with previous reports.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We reviewed FVIII exposure and inhibitor development in boys (ages 0-18 years) with MHA followed at our institution from 1996 to 2001 and conducted a Medline search (1966-2002) on the experience of inhibitor development following intensive/CI exposure to FVIII.

RESULTS

We identified 54 boys with MHA. Twenty-nine (54%) had been exposed to FVIII. Seven had received FVIII by CI. Four developed inhibitors; three high titer (at ages 10 years, 16 years and 17 years) and one low titer (at 1 month old). All four had received a CI of recombinant (r) FVIII of at least 6 days within 6 weeks of developing inhibitors. Baseline FVIII levels fell to < 1% in all cases and the three with high-titer inhibitors developed severe bleeding. Immune tolerance therapy (ITT) was attempted in two boys and was successful in one. Our literature search identified 35 cases (only four children) with MHA developing inhibitors following intense FVIII exposure often in the context of surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of inhibitors in our MHA population was 7.4%. If expressed according to exposure the incidence was significantly higher: 14% (4/29) for any exposure to FVIII and 57% (4/7) for exposure by CI. A prospective study to address whether CI is associated with an increased incidence of inhibitor development in MHA is warranted.

Analysis of factor VIII inhibitors in a haemophilia A patient with an Arg593-->Cys mutation using phage display

We characterized anti-factor VIII antibodies in a mild haemophilia A patient with an Arg593-->Cys mutation in the A2 domain, using V gene phage-display technology. All isolated single-chain variable-domain antibody fragments were directed against residues Arg484-Ile508, a binding site for factor VIII inhibitors in the A2 domain. After a further period of replacement therapy, a transient rise in inhibitor titre was observed. These antibodies were directed against the A2 domain. Activation of a pre-existing pool of B cells, which express antibodies against residues Arg484-Ile508, could explain the rapid anamnestic response.

Factor VIII inhibitor in a patient with mild haemophilia A and an Asn618-->Ser mutation responsive to immune tolerance induction and cyclophosphamide

We describe a patient with mild haemophilia A (original value of factor VIII activity 0.30 U/ml) who developed an inhibitor (36.1 Bethesda U/ml) which cross-reacted with his endogenous factor VIII. This caused a decline in basal factor VIII level (< 0.01 U/ml) and severe haemorrhagic events. Treatment to induce immune tolerance was started with factor VIII/von Willebrand factor (VWF) concentrates, but inhibitor levels increased progressively and the patient suffered serious bleeding. Cyclophosphamide was administered and, after 8 months treatment, factor VIII levels increased to 0.20 U/ml and the inhibitor could no longer be detected. Screening of his factor VIII gene revealed a missense mutation in exon 13 that predicts substitution of Asn618-->Ser in the A2 domain of factor VIII. Immunoprecipitation analysis showed that the antibodies present in the patient's plasma reacted with metabolically labelled A2 domain and, to a lesser extent, with factor VIII light chain. Inhibitory antibodies were completely neutralized by recombinant A2 domain, whereas no neutralization was observed after the addition of factor VIII light chain (A3-C1-C2) and C2 domain. More detailed analysis showed that the majority of inhibitory antibodies were directed against residues Arg484-Ile508, a previously identified binding site for factor VIII inhibitors. Our findings suggest that immune tolerance therapy and cyclophosphamide were successful in eradicating inhibitory antibodies against a common epitope on factor VIII.

Successful treatment of high titer inhibitors in mild hemophilia A with avoidance of factor VIII and immunosuppressive therapy

We describe two patients with mild hemophilia A (MHA) who developed high titer inhibitor (HTI) following intensive recombinant factor VIII (rFVIII) concentrate replacement for surgery and trauma. Intranasal desmopressin was instituted shortly following immunosuppressive therapy (IST) and activated prothrombin complex concentrate (APCC) in one case, and following APCC alone in the second case. Avoidance of factor VIII (FVIII) coupled with intranasal desmopressin prophylaxis three times a week resulted in undetectable inhibitor levels. Both patients have had no further bleeding episodes and have been maintained on desmopressin prophylaxis prior to activity for the past 2 to 3 years. Recombinant factor VIIa (rFVIIa) was used successfully prior to a second surgery in one patient without complication.

In hemophilia A and autoantibody inhibitor patients: the factor VIII A2 domain and light chain are most immunogenic

Factor VIII (fVIII) is a protein cofactor essential for blood coagulation, and it binds in the factor Xase complex to factors IXa, X, and phospholipid. In about 30% of severe hemophilia A patients, treatment with fVIII leads to production of anti-fVIII antibodies. Anti-fVIII autoantibodies also rarely appear in normal individuals. Those antibodies that inactivate fVIII (inhibitors) prevent optimal fVIII therapy. Inhibitor epitopes were previously localized to the fVIII A2, A3, and C2 domains and to an acidic amino acid region between A1 and A2. Such anti-fVIII antibodies interfere with fVIII binding to components of the factor Xase complex and prevent blood coagulation. When total anti-fVIII titers were determined for each fVIII domain in 43 inhibitor plasmas by immunoprecipitation (IP) and inhibitor neutralization assays, the anti-light chain (LCh) antibody titer was highest, anti-A2 was intermediate, and anti-A1 and anti-B were low. The relative immunogenicity of the fVIII domains in hemophilic and autoantibody inhibitor patients was similar.

Circulating factor VIII immune complexes in patients with type 2 acquired hemophilia A and protection from activated protein C-mediated proteolysis

Factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitor antibodies are classified into 2 groups according to the kinetic pattern of FVIII inactivation. Type 2 antibodies are more commonly observed in patients with acquired hemophilia A and do not completely inhibit FVIII activity; in most cases, substantial levels of circulating FVIII are detected. Three type 2 autoantibodies from patients who had normal levels of FVIII antigen despite having low levels of FVIII activity were studied. The antibodies reacted exclusively with the light chain of FVIII but not with the C2 domain, and their epitopes were therefore ascribed to the regions in the A3-C1 domains. Heavy and light chains of FVIII were detected in plasma-derived immune complexes extracted by using protein G Sepharose. Direct binding assays using anhydro-activated protein C (anhydro-APC), a catalytically inactive derivative of activated protein C (APC) in which the active-site serine is converted to dehydroalanine, were used to examine the relation between immune complexes and APC. The intact FVIII, 80-kd light chain, and 72-kd light chain bound in a dose-dependent manner to anhydro-APC, with K(d) values of 580, 540, and 310 nM, respectively, whereas no appreciable binding was detected for the heavy chain. The 3 autoantibodies blocked FVIII binding to anhydro-APC by approximately 80% and consequently inhibited APC-induced FVIII proteolytic inactivation. These antibodies also bound to a synthetic peptide, His2009-Val2018, which contains the APC binding site. The findings suggest that binding of type 2 autoantibodies, recognizing residues His2009 to Val2018, protects FVIII from APC-mediated proteolysis and might contribute to the presence of FVIII immune complexes in the circulation.

Low factor VIII recovery in haemophilia A patients without inhibitor titre is not due to the presence of anti-factor VIII antibodies undetectable by the Bethesda assay

Measurements of factor VIII (FVIII) recovery in previously untreated patients with haemophilia A were done as part of the clinical trial of safety and efficacy of the recombinant FVIII, Recombinate. In 22 of 72 assessable patients, positive inhibitor titres > or = 0.6 Bethesda units mL-1 were detected by the Bethesda assay in one or more plasma samples, and the remaining 50 patients were negative at all timepoints. Of the latter group, 16 individuals without inhibitors unexpectedly had both normal (111) and low (52) recoveries during the study. We investigated the possibility that other antibodies not detectable in the Bethesda assay were responsible for the low recovery, by using a highly sensitive immunopreciptation (IP) assay for detection of all antiFVIII antibodies. Eight of the 16 patients with low and normal recoveries did indeed have antibodies detected by the IP assay, and the remaining eight were negative. Four antibody-positive individuals had insignificantly low titres, and the other four had modest to high titres. In the latter group, antibodies were found with similar frequencies and titre in plasmas from patients with low or normal recovery. Low recovery in haemophilia A patients without inhibitor titres must therefore be attributed to factors other than antiFVIII.

Detection of all anti-factor VIII antibodies in haemophilia A patients by the Bethesda assay and a more sensitive immunoprecipitation assay

Plasmas from 40 haemophilia A patients enrolled in a study by the paediatric group of the German Society on Thrombosis and Hemostasis were tested by the Bethesda assay for inhibitor antibodies and by a more sensitive immunoprecipitation assay (IP) for all antifactor VIII antibodies. Of the 26 severe, 11 moderate and three mild haemophiliacs, 18, two, and none, respectively, had positive Bethesda titres after several factor VIII infusions. In 275 plasmas with Bethesda titres of 0, 0.6--1.0, > 1--5, and > 5--655, the IP responses were 0-238, 0--61, 0--786, and 43--6141, respectively, and a reliable positive IP titre was > 4.2. The overlapping ranges of IP titres indicated large differences in the ratio of inhibitory to noninhibitory antibodies in individual plasmas. In five of seven patients with Bethesda titres of 0.6--1, the IP titres were < 4.2, suggesting a lack of precision of Bethesda titres < or = 1. Detection of the primary immune response was found in only three patients by IP assay before a positive Bethesda assay. This precludes early, reliable testing of which patients will be immunologically responsive. In four patients undergoing immune tolerance therapy, antifactor VIII antibodies were still detectable by the IP assay in the absence of a Bethesda titre, which indicates that antibodies were completely eradicated in none of the patients. Our results show that the use of both the Bethesda and IP assays can provide more accurate detection of antifactor VIII antibodies in all patients.

Factor VIII C2 domain contains the thrombin-binding site responsible for thrombin-catalyzed cleavage at Arg1689

Thrombin-catalyzed factor VIII activation is an essential positive feedback mechanism regulating intrinsic blood coagulation. A factor VIII human antibody, A-FF, with C2 epitope, exclusively inhibited factor VIII activation and cleavage at Arg(1689) by thrombin. The results suggested that A-FF prevented the interaction of thrombin with factor VIII and that the C2 domain was involved in the interaction with thrombin. We performed direct binding assays using anhydro-thrombin, a catalytically inactive derivative of thrombin in which the active-site serine is converted to dehydroalanine. Intact factor VIII, 80-kDa light chain, 72-kDa light chain, and heavy chain fragments bound dose-dependently to anhydro-thrombin, and the K(d) values were 48, 150, 106, and 180 nm, respectively. The C2 and A2 domains also dose-dependently bound to anhydro-thrombin, and the K(d) values were 440 and 488 nm, respectively. The A1 domain did not bind to anhydro-thrombin. A-FF completely inhibited C2 domain binding to anhydro-thrombin (IC(50), 18 nm), whereas it did not inhibit A2 domain binding. Furthermore, C2-specific affinity purified F(ab)'(2) of A-FF, and the recombinant C2 domain inhibited thrombin cleavage at Arg(1689). Our results indicate that the C2 domain contains the thrombin-binding site responsible for the cleavage at Arg(1689).

Hemophilic factor VIII C1- and C2-domain missense mutations and their modeling to the 1.5-angstrom human C2-domain crystal structure

Factor VIII C domains contain key binding sites for von Willebrand factor (vWF) and phospholipid membranes. Hemophilic patients were screened for factor VIII C-domain mutations to provide a well-characterized series. Mutated residues were localized to the high-resolution C2 structure and to a homology model of C1. Of 30 families found with mutations in the C domains, there were 14 missense changes, and 9 of these were novel. Of the missense mutations, 10 were associated with reduced vWF binding and 8 were at residues with surface-exposed side chains. Six of the 10 mutants had nearly equivalent factor VIII clotting activity and antigen level, suggesting that reduced vWF binding could cause hemophilia by reducing factor VIII stability in circulation. When the present series was combined with previously described mutations from an online international database, 11 C1 and C2 mutations in patients with mild or moderately severe hemophilia A were associated with antibody-inhibitor development in at least one affected individual. Of these substitutions, 6 occurred at surface-exposed residues. As further details of the C1 structure and its interface with C2 become available, and as binding studies are performed on the plasma of more patients with hemophilic C-domain mutations, prediction of surface binding sites should improve, allowing confirmation by site-specific mutagenesis of surface-exposed residues.

Hemophilic factor VIII C1- and C2-domain missense mutations and their modeling to the 1.5-angstrom human C2-domain crystal structure

Factor VIII C domains contain key binding sites for von Willebrand factor (vWF) and phospholipid membranes. Hemophilic patients were screened for factor VIII C-domain mutations to provide a well-characterized series. Mutated residues were localized to the high-resolution C2 structure and to a homology model of C1. Of 30 families found with mutations in the C domains, there were 14 missense changes, and 9 of these were novel. Of the missense mutations, 10 were associated with reduced vWF binding and 8 were at residues with surface-exposed side chains. Six of the 10 mutants had nearly equivalent factor VIII clotting activity and antigen level, suggesting that reduced vWF binding could cause hemophilia by reducing factor VIII stability in circulation. When the present series was combined with previously described mutations from an online international database, 11 C1 and C2 mutations in patients with mild or moderately severe hemophilia A were associated with antibody-inhibitor development in at least one affected individual. Of these substitutions, 6 occurred at surface-exposed residues. As further details of the C1 structure and its interface with C2 become available, and as binding studies are performed on the plasma of more patients with hemophilic C-domain mutations, prediction of surface binding sites should improve, allowing confirmation by site-specific mutagenesis of surface-exposed residues.

Intracellular accumulation of factor VIII induced by missense mutations Arg593-->Cys and Asn618-->Ser explains cross-reacting material-reduced haemophilia A

Patients with cross-reacting material (CRM)-reduced haemophilia A exhibit reduced levels of factor VIII antigen. In this study, we determined the molecular basis of the genetic defect in the factor VIII gene induced by either the Arg593-->Cys or the Asn618-->Ser missense mutation, identified in two CRM-reduced haemophilia A patients. We introduced either the Arg593-->Cys or the Asn618-->Ser mutation into a B-domain-deleted factor VIII cDNA and expressed the modified cDNAs in C127 cells. Reduced levels of factor VIII activity and factor VIII antigen in conditioned medium of transfected cells indicated that the secretion of both factor VIII variants was impaired. The ratio of factor VIII antigen present in cell extract to that in conditioned medium was 1.9 and 2.4 times higher for rFVIII-R593C and rFVIII-N618S, respectively, than for rFVIII. Metabolic labelling and immunoprecipitation of transfected cells revealed that rFVIII-R593C and rFVIII-N618S persisted somewhat longer inside the cell than factor rFVIII. Intracellular accumulation and subsequent degradation of factor VIII-R593C and factor VIII-N618S may explain the reduced levels of both factor VIII activity and antigen in plasma of mild haemophilia A patients with corresponding genetic defects.

A human antibody directed to the factor VIII C1 domain inhibits factor VIII cofactor activity and binding to von Willebrand factor

The occurrence of factor VIII (fVIII) inhibitory antibodies is a rare complication of fVIII substitution therapy in mild/moderate hemophilia A patients. fVIII mutations in certain regions such as the C1 domain are, however, more frequently associated with inhibitor, for reasons which remain unclear. To determine whether inhibitors could map to the mutation site, we analyzed at the clonal level the immune response of such a patient with an inhibitor to wild-type but not self-fVIII and an Arg2150His substitution in the C1 domain. Immortalization of the patient B lymphocytes provided a cell line producing an anti-fVIII IgG4κ antibody, LE2E9, that inhibited fVIII cofactor activity, following type 2 kinetics and prevented fVIII binding to von Willebrand factor. Epitope mapping with recombinant fVIII fragments indicated that LE2E9 recognized the fVIII C1 domain, but not the Arg2150His-substituted C1 domain. Accordingly, LE2E9 did not inhibit Arg2150His fVIII activity. These observations identify C1 as a novel target for fVIII inhibitors and demonstrate that Arg2150His substitution alters a B-cell epitope in the C1 domain, which may contribute to the higher inhibitor incidence in patients carrying such substitution. (Blood. 2000; 95:156-163)

A human antibody directed to the factor VIII C1 domain inhibits factor VIII cofactor activity and binding to von Willebrand factor

The occurrence of factor VIII (fVIII) inhibitory antibodies is a rare complication of fVIII substitution therapy in mild/moderate hemophilia A patients. fVIII mutations in certain regions such as the C1 domain are, however, more frequently associated with inhibitor, for reasons which remain unclear. To determine whether inhibitors could map to the mutation site, we analyzed at the clonal level the immune response of such a patient with an inhibitor to wild-type but not self-fVIII and an Arg2150His substitution in the C1 domain. Immortalization of the patient B lymphocytes provided a cell line producing an anti-fVIII IgG4κ antibody, LE2E9, that inhibited fVIII cofactor activity, following type 2 kinetics and prevented fVIII binding to von Willebrand factor. Epitope mapping with recombinant fVIII fragments indicated that LE2E9 recognized the fVIII C1 domain, but not the Arg2150His-substituted C1 domain. Accordingly, LE2E9 did not inhibit Arg2150His fVIII activity. These observations identify C1 as a novel target for fVIII inhibitors and demonstrate that Arg2150His substitution alters a B-cell epitope in the C1 domain, which may contribute to the higher inhibitor incidence in patients carrying such substitution. (Blood. 2000; 95:156-163)

Role of factor VIII C2 domain in factor VIII binding to factor Xa

Factor VIII (FVIII) is activated by proteolytic cleavages with thrombin and factor Xa (FXa) in the intrinsic blood coagulation pathway. The anti-C2 monoclonal antibody ESH8, which recognizes residues 2248-2285 and does not inhibit FVIII binding to von Willebrand factor or phospholipid, inhibited FVIII activation by FXa in a clotting assay. Furthermore, analysis by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed that ESH8 inhibited FXa cleavage in the presence or absence of phospholipid. The light chain (LCh) fragments (both 80 and 72 kDa) and the recombinant C2 domain dose-dependently bound to immobilized anhydro-FXa, a catalytically inactive derivative of FXa in which dehydroalanine replaces the active-site serine. The affinity (K(d)) values for the 80- and 72-kDa LCh fragments and the C2 domain were 55, 51, and 560 nM, respectively. The heavy chain of FVIII did not bind to anhydro-FXa. Similarly, competitive assays using overlapping synthetic peptides corresponding to ESH8 epitopes (residues 2248-2285) demonstrated that a peptide designated EP-2 (residues 2253-2270; TSMYVKEFLISSSQDGHQ) inhibited the binding of the C2 domain or the 72-kDa LCh to anhydro-FXa by more than 95 and 84%, respectively. Our results provide the first evidence for a direct role of the C2 domain in the association between FVIII and FXa.

Antifactor VIII Antibody Inhibiting Allogeneic but not Autologous Factor VIII in Patients With Mild Hemophilia A

Two unrelated patients with the same Arg2150His mutation in the factor VIII (FVIII) C1 domain, a residual FVIII activity of 0.09 IU/mL, and inhibitor titres of 300 and 6 Bethesda Units, respectively, were studied. Further analysis of patient LE, with the highest inhibitor titer, showed that (1) plasma or polyclonal IgG antibodies prepared from LE plasma inhibited the activity of allogeneic (wild-type) but not of self FVIII; (2) the presence of von Willebrand factor (vWF) increased by over 10-fold the inhibitory activity on wild-type FVIII; (3) the kinetics of FVIII inhibition followed a type II pattern, but in contrast to previously described type II inhibitors, LE IgG was potentiated by the presence of vWF instead of being in competition with it; (4) polyclonal LE IgG recognized the FVIII light chain in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and the recombinant A3-C1 domains in an immunoprecipitation assay, indicating that at least part of LE antibodies reacted with the FVIII domain encompassing the mutation site; and (5) LE IgG inhibited FVIII activity by decreasing the rate of FVIIIa release from vWF, but LE IgG recognized an epitope distinct from ESH8, a murine monoclonal antibody exhibiting the same property. We conclude that the present inhibitors are unique in that they clearly distinguish wild-type from self, mutated FVIII. The inhibition of wild-type FVIII by LE antibody is enhanced by vWF and is associated with an antibody-dependent reduced rate of FVIIIa release from vWF.

Antifactor VIII Antibody Inhibiting Allogeneic but not Autologous Factor VIII in Patients With Mild Hemophilia A

Two unrelated patients with the same Arg2150His mutation in the factor VIII (FVIII) C1 domain, a residual FVIII activity of 0.09 IU/mL, and inhibitor titres of 300 and 6 Bethesda Units, respectively, were studied. Further analysis of patient LE, with the highest inhibitor titer, showed that (1) plasma or polyclonal IgG antibodies prepared from LE plasma inhibited the activity of allogeneic (wild-type) but not of self FVIII; (2) the presence of von Willebrand factor (vWF) increased by over 10-fold the inhibitory activity on wild-type FVIII; (3) the kinetics of FVIII inhibition followed a type II pattern, but in contrast to previously described type II inhibitors, LE IgG was potentiated by the presence of vWF instead of being in competition with it; (4) polyclonal LE IgG recognized the FVIII light chain in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and the recombinant A3-C1 domains in an immunoprecipitation assay, indicating that at least part of LE antibodies reacted with the FVIII domain encompassing the mutation site; and (5) LE IgG inhibited FVIII activity by decreasing the rate of FVIIIa release from vWF, but LE IgG recognized an epitope distinct from ESH8, a murine monoclonal antibody exhibiting the same property. We conclude that the present inhibitors are unique in that they clearly distinguish wild-type from self, mutated FVIII. The inhibition of wild-type FVIII by LE antibody is enhanced by vWF and is associated with an antibody-dependent reduced rate of FVIIIa release from vWF.

A domain mutations in 65 haemophilia A families and molecular modelling of dysfunctional factor VIII proteins

A variety of mutations are found in haemophilia A families. Those with circulating, dysfunctional protein can provide insights into structural determinants of factor VIII function. A molecular model based upon the crystal structure of the homologous A domains in caeruloplasmin enables predictions of molecular consequences of mutations. To identify haemophilic mutations in coding regions for three A domains of factor VIII and predict amino acid substitutions important for coagulant cofactor function, amplified DNA fragments from 188 unrelated haemophilia A families were screened for heteroduplex formation. Exons 1-19 were examined. 65 families were positive for 58 distinct mutations (39 novel) on DNA sequencing. 12 were non-missense mutations. 38 missense mutations were found in patients that circulate or potentially circulate dysfunctional factor VIII protein and are in an A domain molecular model. Of these 38, 12 have identical residues among all known species of factors V, VIII and caeruloplasmin. These 38 mutations have been localized onto a factor VIII A domain molecular model. Of these, 19 are in coiled, 15 in beta-pleated sheet, and two each in turns and alpha-helical structures. 15 substituted residues are on the surface, nine are partially on the surface and 14 are buried within the model structure. Mutant side-chain substitutions were inserted to predict changes in surface groups or, for buried residues, potential surface areas whose structure is probably disrupted by the substitution.

Some Human Inhibitor Antibodies Interfere With Factor VIII Binding to Factor IX

Factor VIII (fVIII) functions as a cofactor of factor IXa in the intrinsic pathway of blood coagulation. Its absence or abnormality causes the bleeding disorder hemophilia A. About 23% of hemophiliacs who receive therapeutic fVIII infusions develop antibodies that inhibit its activity. We previously showed by inhibitor neutralization assays that the fVIII A2 and C2 domain polypeptides contain common inhibitor epitopes. Often hemophilic inhibitor plasmas were partially neutralized by C2 and more completely neutralized by fVIII light chain (A3-C1-C2), suggesting the presence of an additional major inhibitor epitope(s) within the A3-C1 domains. In immunoprecipitation assays, 17 of 18 inhibitor IgGs bound to recombinant 35S-A3-C1. Amino acids 1811-1818 of the A3 domain comprise a binding site for factors IX and IXa. Three inhibitor IgGs prevented binding of factor IXa to fVIII light chain, and the binding of each IgG to light chain was competed by A3 peptide 1804-1819. The generation of factor Xa by the fVIIIa/fIXa complex in a chromogenic assay was prevented by these inhibitors. Therefore, we propose that another important mechanism of fVIII inactivation by human inhibitors is the prevention of fVIIIa/fIXa association.

Factor VIII inhibitors in mild and moderate-severity haemophilia A

Inhibitors are an uncommon complication of mild haemophilia, occurring in 3-13% of patients and usually arising during adulthood. The risk of inhibitor development in this group appears to be associated with relatively few high-risk factor VIII genotypes clustered in the A2 and C2 domains, especially the Arg593-Cys and the Trp2229-Cys mutations. Kindreds with these mutations have an inhibitor incidence of up to 40%. These mutations may induce a stable conformational change in the factor VIII molecule rendering it antigenically distinct from wild-type factor VIII. Inhibitors in mild haemophilia usually cross-react with endogenous factor VIII reducing the basal VIIIC to < 0.01 IU/ml, and causing spontaneous bleeding. This bleeding is sometimes severe and life-threatening, two-thirds of patients developing a pattern of soft tissue, gastrointestinal (GI) and urinogenital bleeding reminiscent of acquired haemophilia. Bleeding has been treated with human and porcine factor VIII, bypass therapy and DDAVP. Recombinant factor VIIa and DDAVP have the advantage that they do not induce an anamnestic rise in inhibitor titre. About 60% of these inhibitors disappear in the remainder over a median of 9 months. Few of these inhibitors recur, suggesting that most such patients have become tolerant. The inhibitors persist long-term and remain troublesome in about 40% of patients. The limited data available on immune tolerance induction in this group indicate a generally poor response to this approach. Two of nine achieved tolerance, with a partial response in a further four. Inhibitors are an uncommon but life-threatening complication of haemophilia. This complication should be considered when selecting the treatment modality for patients with a family history of inhibitors, and DDAVP used whenever possible.