Galactose breath testing distinguishes variant and severe galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase genotypes

Whole-body galactose oxidation as a robust functional assay to assess the efficacy of gene-based therapies in a mouse model of Galactosemia

Despite the implementation of lifesaving newborn screening programs and a galactose-restricted diet, many patients with classic galactosemia develop long-term debilitating neurological deficits and primary ovarian insufficiency. Previously, we showed that the administration of human GALT mRNA predominantly expressed in the GalT gene-trapped mouse liver augmented the expression of hepatic GALT activity, which decreased not only galactose-1 phosphate (gal-1P) in the liver but also peripheral tissues. Since each peripheral tissue requires distinct methods to examine the biomarker and/or GALT effect, this highlights the necessity for alternative strategies to evaluate the overall impact of therapies. In this study, we established that whole-body galactose oxidation (WBGO) as a robust, noninvasive, and specific method to assess the in vivo pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic parameters of two experimental gene-based therapies that aimed to restore GALT activity in a mouse model of galactosemia. Although our results illustrated the long-lasting efficacy of AAVrh10-mediated GALT gene transfer, we found that GALT mRNA therapy that targets the liver predominantly is sufficient to sustain WBGO. The latter could have important implications in the design of novel targeted therapy to ensure optimal efficacy and safety.

Clinical and biochemical phenotypes, genotypes, and long-term outcomes of individuals with galactosemia type I from a single metabolic genetics center in Alberta

Background

Galactosemia type I is an autosomal recessive disorder of galactose metabolism due to galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase deficiency, encoded by GALT. To investigate the phenotypes, genotypes and long-term outcomes of galactosemia, we performed a retrospective cohort study in our center.

Methods

All individuals with galactosemia type I were included. We divided individuals into two groups to compare the outcomes of those treated symptomatically (SymX) and asymptomatically (AsymX). We reviewed electronic patient charts for clinical features, biochemical investigations, molecular genetic investigations, treatments, and outcomes.

Results

There were 25 individuals including classic (n = 17), clinical variant (n = 4), and biochemical variant (Duarte) galactosemia (n = 4). Twelve individuals were diagnosed symptomatically (SymX), and 9 individuals were diagnosed asymptomatically (AsymX). We did not include individuals with biochemical variant (Duarte) galactosemia into any of these groups. At the time of the diagnosis, conjugated hyperbilirubinemia was present in 83.3% of SymX group, whereas only 22% of AsymX group. SymX group had hepatomegaly (25%), failure to thrive (33.3%), cataract (16.7%) and sepsis (25%), whereas none of the individuals in the AsymX group had these clinical features. Fourteen variants in GALT were identified including pathogenic/likely pathogenic (n = 12), and likely benign/benign (n = 2) variants. The vast majority of individuals with classic and clinical variant galactosemia were treated with a galactose-lactose-free diet for life (n = 20/21). Intellectual disability was present in 54.5% of the SymX group, and in 37.5% of the AsymX group as a long-term outcome. Tremors were present 50% of the SymX group, and in 22% of the AsymX group as a long-term outcome. Although, intellectual disability and tremors seem to be less common in the AsymX group, there was no statistically significant difference between both groups. Primary ovarian insufficiency was present 50% of the SymX group, whereas in 20% of the AsymX group in post-pubertal females. We report a novel hypomorphic GALT variant (p.Ala303Ser) in one individual with clinical variant galactosemia. We also report an individual with clinical variant galactosemia with normal urine galactitol levels on a normal diet.

Conclusion

It seems that newborn screening and early administration of a galactose-lactose-free diet decreases the long-term galactosemia-associated complications but does not prevent them completely. It may be that not all individuals with clinical variant galactosemia may need a galactose-lactose-free diet. It is timely to find new therapeutic strategies that can reduce the frequency of late-onset complications in galactosemia.

Pathophysiology of long-term complications in classic galactosemia: What we do and do not know

Despite many decades of research involving both human subjects and model systems, the underlying pathophysiology of long-term complications in classic galactosemia (CG) remains poorly understood. In this review, intended for those already familiar with galactosemia, we focus on the big questions relating to outcomes, mechanism, and markers, drawing on relevant literature where available, attempting to navigate inconsistencies where they appear, and acknowledging gaps in knowledge where they persist.

[13C]-galactose breath test in a patient with galactokinase deficiency and spastic diparesis

Galactokinase deficiency is an inborn error of carbohydrate metabolism due to a block in the formation of galactose-1-phosphate from galactose. Although the association of galactokinase deficiency with formation of cataracts is well established, the extent of the clinical phenotype is still under investigation. We describe a 6-year-old female who was diagnosed with galactokinase deficiency due to cataract formation when she was 10 months of age and initially started on galactose-restricted diet at that time for 5 months. She developed gait abnormality at 4 years of age. Breath tests via measurement of 13C isotope in exhaled carbon dioxide following 13C-labeled galactose administration at carbon-1 and carbon-2 positions revealed oxidation rates within the normal range. The results in this patient strikingly contrast with the results of another patient with GALK1 deficiency that underwent breath testing with [1-14C]-galactose and [2-14C]-galactose. Extension of in vivo breath tests to other galactokinase patients is needed to better understand the pathophysiology of this disease.

The 1-13 C galactose breath test in GALT deficient patients distinguishes NBS detected variant patients but does not predict outcome in classical phenotypes

Classical galactosemia (CG) patients frequently develop long-term complications despite early dietary treatment. The highly variable clinical outcome is poorly understood and a lack of prognostic biomarkers hampers individual prognostication and treatment. The aim of this study was to investigate the association between residual galactose oxidation capacity and clinical and biochemical outcomes in CG patients with varying geno- and phenotypes. The noninvasive 1-¹³ C galactose breath test was used to assess whole body galactose oxidation capacity. Participants received a 7 mg/kg oral dose of 1-¹³ C labelled galactose. The galactose oxidation capacity was determined by calculating the cumulative percentage dose of the administered galactose (CUMPCD) recovered as ¹³ CO₂ in exhaled air. Forty-one CG patients (5-47 years) and four adult controls were included. The median galactose oxidation capacity after 120 minutes (CUMPCDT120) of 34 classical patients (0.29; 0.08-7.51) was significantly lower when compared to two homozygous p.Ser135Leu patients (9.44; 8.66-10.22), one heterozygous p.Ser135Leu patient 18.59, four NBS detected variant patients (13.79; 12.73-14.87) and four controls (9.29; 8.94-10.02). There was a clear correlation between Gal-1-P levels and CUMPCDT120 (P < .0005). In the classical patients, the differences in CUMPCDT120 were small and did not distinguish between patients with poor and normal clinical outcomes. The galactose breath test distinguished classical patients from homo- and heterozygous p.Ser135Leu and NBS detected variant patients, but was not able to predict clinical outcomes in classical patients. Future studies are warranted to enable individualised prognostication and treatment, especially in NBS variants with galactose oxidation capacities in the control range.

Clinical and molecular characteristics and time of diagnosis of patients with classical galactosemia in an unscreened population in Turkey

Classical galactosemia is an autosomal recessive inborn error of metabolism caused by biallelic pathogenic variants in the GALT gene. With the benefit of early diagnosis by newborn screening, the acute presentation of galactosemia can be prevented. In this study, we describe the clinical phenotypes, time of diagnosis and GALT genotypes of 76 galactosemia patients from Turkey, where the disease is not yet included in the newborn screening program. The median age at first symptom was 10 days (range 5-20), while the median age at diagnosis was 30 days (range 17-53). Nearly half of the patients (36 patients, 47.4%) were diagnosed later than age 1 month. Fifty-eight individuals were found to have 18 different pathogenic variants in their 116 mutant alleles. In our sample, Q188R variant has the highest frequency with 53%, the other half of the allele frequency of the patients showed 17 different genotypes. Despite presenting with typical clinical manifestations, classical galactosemia patients are diagnosed late in Turkey. Due to the geographical location of our country, different pathogenic GALT variants may be seen in Turkish patients. In the present study, a clear genotype-phenotype correlation could not be established in patients.

The ability of an LC-MS/MS-based erythrocyte GALT enzyme assay to predict the phenotype in subjects with GALT deficiency

BACKGROUND

GALT deficiency is a rare genetic disorder of carbohydrate metabolism. Due to the decreased activity or absence of the enzyme galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT), cells from affected individuals are unable to metabolize galactose normally. Lactose consumption in the newborn period could potentially lead to a lethal disease process with multi-organ involvement. In contrast to the newborn-stage disease, however, a galactose-restricted diet does not prevent long-term complications such as central nervous system (CNS) dysfunction with speech defects, learning disability and neurological disease in addition to hypergonadotropic hypogonadism or primary ovarian insufficiency (POI) in females. As the literature suggests an association between GALT enzyme activity and the long-term complications, it is of importance to have a highly sensitive assay to quantify the GALT enzyme activity. To that end, we had developed a sensitive and accurate LC-MS/MS method to measure GALT enzyme activity. Its ability to predict outcome is the subject of this report.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The GALT enzyme activity in erythrocytes from 160 individuals, in which 135 with classic, clinical variant or biochemical variant galactosemia, was quantified by LC-MS/MS. Individuals with GALT deficiency were evaluated for the long-term complications of speech defects, dysarthria, ataxia, dystonia, tremor, POI, as well as intellectual functioning (full scale IQ). The LC-MS/MS results were compared to a variety of assays: radioactive, [¹⁴C]-galactose-1-phosphate, paper chromatography with scintillation counting, enzyme-coupled assays with spectrophotometric or fluorometric readout or high-pressure liquid chromatography with UV detection of UDP-galactose.

RESULTS

The LC-MS/MS method measured GALT activity as low as 0.2%, whereas other methods showed no detectable activity. Largely due to GALT activities that were over 1%, the LC-MS/MS measurements were not significantly different than values obtained in other laboratories using other methodologies. Severe long-term complications were less frequently noted in subjects with >1% activity. Patients with a p.Q188R/p.Q188R genotype have no residual enzyme activity in erythrocytes.

CONCLUSION

Our LC-MS/MS assay may be necessary to accurately quantify residual GALT activities below 5%. The data suggest that patients with >1% residual activity are less likely to develop diet-independent long-term complications. However, much larger sample sizes are needed to properly assess the clinical phenotype in patients with residual enzyme activities between 0.1 and 5%.

Arginine does not rescue p.Q188R mutation deleterious effect in classic galactosemia

Background

Classic galactosemia is a rare genetic metabolic disease with an unmet treatment need. Current standard of care fails to prevent chronically-debilitating brain and gonadal complications.

Many mutations in the GALT gene responsible for classic galactosemia have been described to give rise to variants with conformational abnormalities. This pathogenic mechanism is highly amenable to a therapeutic strategy based on chemical/pharmacological chaperones. Arginine, a chemical chaperone, has shown beneficial effect in other inherited metabolic disorders, as well as in a prokaryotic model of classic galactosemia.

The p.Q188R mutation presents a high prevalence in the Caucasian population, making it a very clinically relevant mutation. This mutation gives rise to a protein with lower conformational stability and lower catalytic activity. The aim of this study is to assess the potential therapeutic role of arginine for this mutation.

Methods

Arginine aspartate administration to four patients with the p.Q188R/p.Q188R mutation, in vitro studies with three fibroblast cell lines derived from classic galactosemia patients as well as recombinant protein experiments were used to evaluate the effect of arginine in galactose metabolism. This study has been registered at https://clinicaltrials.gov (NCT03580122) on 09 July 2018. Retrospectively registered.

Results

Following a month of arginine administration, patients did not show a significant improvement of whole-body galactose oxidative capacity (p = 0.22), erythrocyte GALT activity (p = 0.87), urinary galactose (p = 0.52) and urinary galactitol levels (p = 0.41). Patients’ fibroblasts exposed to arginine did not show changes in GALT activity. Thermal shift analysis of recombinant p.Q188R GALT protein in the presence of arginine did not exhibit a positive effect.

Conclusions

This short pilot study in four patients homozygous for the p.Q188R/p.Q188R mutation reveals that arginine has no potential therapeutic role for galactosemia patients homozygous for the p.Q188R mutation.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s13023-018-0954-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Galactose oxidation using (13)C in healthy and galactosemic children

Galactosemia is an inborn error of galactose metabolism that occurs mainly as the outcome of galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) deficiency. The ability to assess galactose oxidation following administration of a galactose-labeled isotope (1-(13)C-galactose) allows the determination of galactose metabolism in a practical manner. We aimed to assess the level of galactose oxidation in both healthy and galactosemic Brazilian children. Twenty-one healthy children and seven children with galactosemia ranging from 1 to 7 years of age were studied. A breath test was used to quantitate (13)CO2 enrichment in exhaled air before and at 30, 60, and 120 min after the oral administration of 7 mg/kg of an aqueous solution of 1-(13)C-galactose to all children. The molar ratios of (13)CO2 and (12)CO2 were quantified by the mass/charge ratio (m/z) of stable isotopes in each air sample by gas-isotope-ratio mass spectrometry. In sick children, the cumulative percentage of (13)C from labeled galactose (CUMPCD) in the exhaled air ranged from 0.03% at 30 min to 1.67% at 120 min. In contrast, healthy subjects showed a much broader range in CUMPCD, with values from 0.4% at 30 min to 5.58% at 120 min. The study found a significant difference in galactose oxidation between children with and without galactosemia, demonstrating that the breath test is useful in discriminating children with GALT deficiencies.

Galactosemia: when is it a newborn screening emergency?

Classic galactosemia is an autosomal recessive disorder of carbohydrate metabolism, due to a severe deficiency of the enzyme, galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT), that catalyzes the conversion of galactose-1-phosphate and uridine diphosphate glucose (UDPglucose) to uridine diphosphate galactose (UDPgalactose) and glucose-1-phosphate. Upon consumption of lactose in the neonatal period, the affected infants develop a potentially lethal disease process with multiorgan involvement. Since the advent of newborn screening (NBS) for galactosemia, we rarely encounter such overwhelmingly ill newborns. After ascertainment that the positive NBS indicates the possibility of galactosemia due to GALT deficiency, the critical question for the physician is whether the infant has the classic or a variant form of GALT deficiency, as classic galactosemia is a medical emergency. However, there are over 230 GALT gene mutations that have been detected around the world. Yet, most positive NBS tests are due to the Duarte biochemical variant condition or a simple false positive. In order to make the correct decision as well as provide informative counseling to parents of infants with a positive NBS, I utilize a relatively simple classification scheme for GALT deficiency. There are three basic forms of GALT deficiency: 1) classic galactosemia; 2) clinical variant galactosemia; and 3) biochemical variant galactosemia. The classic genotype is typified by Q188R/Q188R, the clinical variant by S135L/S135L and the biochemical variant by N314D/Q188R. In classic galactosemia, the erythrocyte GALT enzyme activity is absent or markedly reduced, the blood galactose and erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate levels are markedly elevated, and the patient is at risk to develop potentially lethal E. coli sepsis, as well as the long-term diet-independent complications of galactosemia. Patients with the clinical variant form require treatment but do not die from E. coli sepsis in the neonatal period. If the clinician suspects galactosemia, even if based on clinical findings alone, then the infant should be immediately placed on a lactose-restricted diet. The purpose of this review is to help the clinician make the correct therapeutic decision after an NBS test has returned positive for galactosemia.

Structural and molecular biology of type I galactosemia: disease-associated mutations

Type I galactosemia results from reduced galactose 1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT) activity. Signs of disease include damage to the eyes, brain, liver, and ovaries. However, the exact nature and severity of the pathology depends on the mutation(s) in the patient's genes and his/her environment. Considerable enzymological and structural knowledge has been accumulated and this provides a basis to explain, at a biochemical level, impairment in the enzyme in the more than 230 disease-associated variants, which have been described. The most common variant, Q188R, occurs close to the active site and the dimer interface. The substitution probably disrupts both UDP-sugar binding and homodimer stability. Other alterations, for example K285N, occur close to the surface of the enzyme and most likely affect the folding and stability of the enzyme. There are a number of unanswered questions in the field, which require resolution. These include the possibility that the main enzymes of galactose metabolism form a supramolecular complex and the need for a high resolution crystal structure of human GALT.

Negative screening tests in classical galactosaemia caused by S135L homozygosity

Classical galactosaemia is relatively common in Ireland due to a high carrier rate of the Q188R GALT mutation. It is screened for using a bacterial inhibition assay (BIA) for free galactose. A Beutler assay on day one of life is performed only in high risk cases (infants of the Traveller community and relatives of known cases). A 16-month-old Irish-born boy of Nigerian origin was referred for investigation of developmental delay, and failure to thrive. He had oral aversion to solids and his diet consisted of cow's milk and milk-based cereal mixes. He was found to have microcephaly, weight <2nd percentile, hepatomegaly and bilateral cataracts. Coagulation screen was normal and transaminases were slightly elevated. His original newborn screen was reviewed and confirmed to have been negative; urinary reducing substances on three separate occasions were negative. Beutler assay demonstrated "absent" red cell galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) activity. GALT enzyme activity was <0.5 gsubs/h per gHb confirming classical galactosaemia. Gal-1-P was elevated at 1.88 micromol/gHb. Mutation analysis of the GALT gene revealed S135L homozygosity. S135L/S135L galactosaemia is associated with absent red cell GALT activity but with approximately 10% activity in other tissues such as the liver and intestines, probably explaining the negative screening tests and the somewhat milder phenotype associated with this genotype. The patient was commenced on galactose-restricted diet; on follow-up at 2 years of age, growth had normalized but there was global developmental delay. In conclusion, galactosaemia must be considered in children who present with poor growth, hepatomegaly, developmental delay and cataracts and GALT enzyme analysis should be a first line test in such cases. Non-enzymatic screening methods such as urinary reducing substances and BIA for free galactose are not reliable in S135L homozygous galactosaemia.

Screening newborns for galactosemia using total body galactose oxidation to CO2 in expired air

Classic galactosemia is caused by impaired galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT EC 2.7.712). If discovered and treated within the first days of life, the acute problems of hepatocellular damage, sepsis, and death are prevented. However, chronic problems such as ataxia, tremor, dyspraxic speech, and ovarian failure may occur. To determine whether screening newborns before discharge from the nursery for GALT deficiency is feasible and whether acute and chronic signs could be prevented by earlier intervention, we developed a simplified "breath test." We quantitated total body oxidation of C-D-galactose to CO2 in expired air by normal newborns between 2 h and 2 mo of age and compared their results to older children with GALT deficiency. We found no differences in total body galactose oxidation (TBGO) among normal newborns up to 48 h of age, but a 2-fold rise in TBGO developed during their first 2 wk of life. Older children with galactosemia had significantly less oxidative capacity than normal newborns. We conclude that newborn breath testing for total body galactose oxidation is feasible before discharge from nursery. It has potential utility for both preventing acute neonatal toxicity and determining the mechanisms producing long-term complications such as ovarian failure, dyspraxia, ataxia, and tremors.

Untreated classical galactosemia patient with mild phenotype

Despite life-long galactose restriction, long-term complications generally occur in classical galactosemia. We report an adult male with classical galactosemia (Q188R homozygosity, severely reduced erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase activity) who has a surprisingly mild phenotype despite genotype and enzyme activity associated with severe phenotype. Moreover he has a normal galactose intake from the age of 3 years. This case is probably an example of the important role of yet unknown susceptibility and or modifier genes.

Prevention of a molecular misdiagnosis in galactosemia

PURPOSE

The polymerase chain reaction is generally used for mutational analysis of the galactose-1-phosphate uridyl transferase (GALT) gene in the diagnosis of galactosemia. This method is problematic when used in families of Ashkenazi Jewish descent.

METHODS

We amplified the GALT gene from leukocyte DNA followed by allele specific oligonucleotide hybridization, DNA sequencing and Southern Blot analysis to determine the mutant alleles causing galactosemia in a representative Jewish family.

RESULTS

The proband's diagnosis of galactosemia was confirmed by high levels of erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate, absence of erythrocyte GALT activity and impaired total body oxidation of galactose to expired CO2. Initial molecular analysis of GALT alleles in the family showed homozygosity for a K285N missense mutation in the proband, homozygosity for N314D in the mother and heterozygosity for N314D and K285N in the father. These results contradicted Mendelian logic. Southern blot hybridization with GALT cDNA proved the presence of a complex 5 kb GALT deletion in the proband and her mother's DNA enabling a corrected genotype.

CONCLUSIONS

Since a deletion of the GALT gene is a common mutation causing galactosemia among Ashkenazim Jewish families, this deletion should be suspected and tested for by genomic hybridization or by using primers specific for the 5 kb deletion.

UDP-galactose pyrophosphorylase in mice with galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase deficiency

UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase (E.C. 2.7.7.9), encoded by ugp, provides UDP-glucose which is critical to the synthesis of glycogen, and also catalyzes the reaction between UTP and galactose-1-phosphate, yielding UDP-galactose. This activity of UDP-gal pyrophosphorylase (UDP-galPP) suggests a role in an alternate pathway for galactose metabolism in patients with deficiency of galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT). We examined the effects of GALT deficiency and dietary galactose on UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase (UDP-gluPP) and UDP-galactose pyrophosphorylase activity and ugp expression in liver of mice with homozygous deletion of the critical regions of galt. Activity with glucose-1-phosphate as substrate was significantly higher than that with galactose-1-phosphate. In liver from mice with GALT deficiency (G/G), UDP-galPP activity appeared to be lower than that measured in liver from control (N/N) animals. This difference disappeared when the N/N tissue homogenate was dialyzed to remove residual UDP-glucose, confirming that careful elimination of residual GALT activity is necessary, since GALT has 1000-fold greater activity toward galactose-1-phosphate than that of UDP-galPP in liver homogenates. Prior exposure to conventional mouse chow, high galactose chow, and high glucose chow did not alter UDP-glu PP or UDP-galPP activity. Steady state UGP mRNA levels were determined in tissues from normal and G/G animals. UGP expression was highest in liver, and did not differ by genotype or exposure to high galactose chow. UDP-galPP activity may account for unexplained ability to oxidize galactose in animals with no GALT activity, but is insufficient to alter accumulation of galactose metabolites.

Mediators of galactose sensitivity in UDP-galactose 4'-epimerase-impaired mammalian cells

UDP-galactose 4'-epimerase (GALE) catalyzes the final step in the Leloir pathway of galactose metabolism, interconverting UDP-galactose and UDP-glucose. Unlike its Escherichia coli counterpart, mammalian GALE also interconverts UDP-N-acetylgalactosamine and UDP-N-acetylglucosamine. Considering the key roles played by all four of these UDP-sugars in glycosylation, human GALE therefore not only contributes to the Leloir pathway, but also functions as a gatekeeper overseeing the ratios of important substrate pools required for the synthesis of glycosylated macromolecules. Defects in human GALE result in the disorder epimerase-deficiency galactosemia. To explore the relationship among GALE activity, substrate specificity, metabolic balance, and galactose sensitivity in mammalian cells, we employed a previously described GALE-null line of Chinese hamster ovary cells, ldlD. Using a transfection protocol, we generated ldlD derivative cell lines that expressed different levels of wild-type human GALE or E. coli GALE and compared the phenotypes and metabolic profiles of these lines cultured in the presence versus absence of galactose. We found that GALE-null cells accumulated abnormally high levels of Gal-1-P and UDP-Gal and abnormally low levels of UDP-Glc and UDP-GlcNAc in the presence of galactose and that human GALE expression corrected each of these defects. Comparing the human GALE- and E. coli GALE-expressing cells, we found that although GALE activity toward both substrates was required to restore metabolic balance, UDP-GalNAc activity was not required for cell proliferation in the presence of otherwise cytostatic concentrations of galactose. Finally, we found that uridine supplementation, which essentially corrected UDP-Glc and, to a lesser extent UDP-GlcNAc depletion, enabled ldlD cells to proliferate in the presence of galactose despite the continued accumulation of Gal-1-P and UDP-Gal. These data offer important insights into the mechanism of galactose sensitivity in epimerase-impaired cells and suggest a potential novel therapy for patients with epimerase-deficiency galactosemia.

Extended [13C]galactose oxidation studies in patients with galactosemia

Since patients with galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) deficiency have considerable endogenous galactose formation and only limited urinary excretion of galactose metabolites, there must be mechanisms for disposal of the sugar. Otherwise, a steady-state could not be maintained and there would be continuous body accumulation of galactose and alternate pathway products. Previous studies quantitating the amount of galactose handled by oxidation to CO2 focused on short collection periods of expired air after administering isotopically labeled galactose mainly designed for discerning differences in the capacity to oxidize the sugar in relation to genotype. Assuming that there may be more extensive oxidation than that observed in short-term studies in order to dispose the daily galactose burden, we have examined the amount of [1-13C]galactose oxidized to 13CO2 over a 24-h period after either a single bolus or continuous IV administration by 11 patients with classic galactosemia including patients homozygous for the Q188R gene mutation. As much as 58% of the administered galactose was oxidized to 13CO2 in 24 h. The pathways involved remain to be determined but a significant amount may be metabolized by non-GALT pathways since a patient homozygous for gene deletion had an oxidative capability. We conclude that classic patients have the ability to slowly oxidize galactose to CO2 in 24 h in amounts comparable to that which a normal handles in approximately one-fifth the time. This capacity enables the galactosemic to maintain a balance of galactose disposal with the galactose burden imposed by endogenous formation and dietary intake.

Insights into the pathogenesis of galactosemia

In humans, the absence of galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) leads to significant neonatal morbidity and mortality which are dependent on galactose ingestion, as well as long-term complications of primary ovarian failure and cognitive dysfunction, which are diet independent. The creation of a knockout mouse model for GALT deficiency was aimed at providing an organism in which metabolic challenges and gene manipulation could address the enigmatic pathophysiologic questions raised by humans with galactosemia. Instead, the mouse represents a biochemical phenotype without evidence of clinical morbidity. The similarities and differences between mice and humans with galactosemia are explored from metabolite, enzyme, and process points of view. The mouse both produces and oxidizes galactose in a manner similar to humans. It differs in brain accumulation of galactitol. Future directions for exploration of this enigmatic condition are discussed.

Verbal dyspraxia and galactosemia

Classical galactosemia is an autosomal recessive disorder resulting from deficient galactose-1-phosphateuridyl transferase (GALT) activity. Verbal dyspraxia is an unusual outcome in galactosemia. Here we validated a simplified breath test of total body galactose oxidation against genotype and evaluated five potential biochemical risk indicators for verbal dyspraxia in galactosemia: cumulative percentage dose (CUMPCD) of (13)CO(2) in breath, mean erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate, highest erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate, mean urinary galactitol, and erythrocyte GALT activity. Thirteen controls and 42 patients with galactosemia took a (13)C-galactose bolus, and the (CUMPCD) of (13)CO(2) in expired air was determined. Patients with <5% CUMPCD had mutant alleles that severely impaired human GALT enzyme catalysis. Patients with > or =5% CUMPCD had milder mutant human GALT alleles. Twenty-four patients consented to formal speech evaluation; 15 (63%) had verbal dyspraxia. Dyspraxic patients had significantly lower CUMPCD values (2.84 +/- 5.76% versus 11.51 +/- 7.67%; p < 0.008) and significantly higher mean erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate (3.38 +/- 0.922 mg/dL versus 1.92 +/- 1.28 mg/dL; p = 0.019) and mean urinary galactitol concentrations (192.4 +/- 75.8 mmol/mol creatinine versus 122.0 +/- 56.4; p = 0.048) than patients with normal speech. CUMPCD values <5%, mean erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate levels >2.7 mg/dL, and mean urinary galactitol levels >135 mmol/mol creatinine were associated with dyspraxic outcome with odds ratios of 21, 13, and 5, respectively. We conclude that total body oxidation of galactose to CO(2) in expired air reflects genotype and that this breath test is a sensitive predictor of verbal dyspraxia in patients with galactosemia.

Metabolism of 13C galactose by lymphoblasts from patients with galactosemia determined by NMR spectroscopy

In order to assess the pathways by which galactose is metabolized by galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) deficient cells, lymphoblasts from 10 galactosemic patients with defined genotypes (six Q188R homozygotes, two S153L homozygotes, and two with homozygous deletions) were incubated with 1mM 1- or 2-13C galactose for 2.5 and 5 h. The 13C-labeled metabolites were identified and quantified using nuclear magnetic resonance and the results were compared to that obtained with cells from eight normal individuals. Cells from galactosemic patients formed two to three times the galactose-1-phosphate (Gal-1P) in normal cells, no difference being observed between the various genotypes. Galactitol formation was not significantly different from normal cells. No labeled galactonate was detected. Cells with the Q188R and S135L mutations formed both labeled uridine diphosphogalactose (UDPgal) and uridine diphosphoglucose (UDPglu), but to a lesser extent than normals, whereas cells with the GALT deletion did not. The pattern of 13C enrichment of the ribose carbons of adenosine monophosphate upon incubation of the normal cells with 1-13C galactose paralleled that found for incubations with 1-13C glucose, which is consistent with galactose disposition through the Leloir pathway to glucose and its subsequent metabolism to ribose. Cells with the GALT deletion formed no detectable labeled ribose, whereas cells from a patient homozygous for Q188R mutation formed labeled ribose in a pattern similar to normal albeit with lower enrichment. The results suggest that there is residual GALT activity and function of the Leloir pathway in the presence of the Q188R as well as S135L mutation.

The clinical and molecular spectrum of galactosemia in patients from the Cape Town region of South Africa

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to document the clinical, laboratory and genetic features of galactosemia in patients from the Cape Town metropolitan region.

METHODS

Diagnoses were based on thin layer chromatography for galactosuria/galactosemia and assays of erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) and galactokinase activities. Patients were screened for the common S135L and Q188R transferase gene mutations, using PCR-based assays. Screening for the S135L mutation in black newborns was used to estimate the carrier rate for galactosemia in black South Africans.

RESULTS

A positive diagnosis of galactosemia was made in 17 patients between the years 1980 to 2001. All had very low or absent galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) activity, and normal galactokinase levels. The mean age at diagnosis was 5.1 months (range 4 days to 6.5 months). A review of 9 patients showed that hepatomegaly (9/9), and splenomegaly, failure to thrive, developmental delay, bilateral cataracts (6/9) were the most frequent features at diagnosis. Six had conjugated hyperbilirubinemia. Four experienced invasive E. coli infection before diagnosis. Ten patients were submitted to DNA analysis. All 4 black patients and 2 of mixed extraction were homozygous for the S135L allele, while all 3 white patients were homozygous for the Q188R allele. The remaining patient of mixed extraction was heterozygous for the Q188R allele. The estimated carrier frequency of the S135L mutation in 725 healthy black newborns was 1/60.

CONCLUSIONS

In the absence of newborn screening the delay in diagnosis is most often unacceptably long. Also, carrier frequency data predict a galactosemia incidence of approximately 1/14 400 for black newborns in the Cape Metropole, which is much higher than the current detection rate. It is thus likely that many patients go undetected.

Structure-function analyses of a common mutation in blacks with transferase-deficiency galactosemia

We previously identified a missense mutation at amino acid 135 of human galactose 1-phosphate uridyltransferase (hGALT) in which a leucine (TTG) was substituted for a serine (TCG), S135L. This mutation was common in black patients with galactosemia and homozygotes (S135L/S135L) had no GALT activity or protein in their erythrocytes or lymphoblasts. However, there was residual GALT activity and protein in their leukocytes, and they had near normal total body [13C]galactose oxidation to 13CO2 in breath. To evaluate the biochemical mechanism(s) producing these effects, we overexpressed hGALT proteins with site-directed mutations in this nonconserved amino acid in a GALT-minus Escherichia coli. Enzyme activities detected in bacterial lysates overexpressing either S135 (wild type), A135, C135, H135, L135, S132-H135, T135, or Y135 were 100, 4.7, 3.0, 4.0, 2.7, 0.7, 35.4, and 1.4%, respectively. Only the threonine substitution (S135T) had significant enzyme activity in these lysates. There was also decreased abundance of all mutant proteins in the lysates exposed to bacterial proteolysis during preparation and analysis. This added the variable of bio-instability to analysis of enzyme activities in lysates. To further characterize the catalytic role of serine at amino acid 135 and to differentiate bio-instability from impaired catalysis by the leucine substitution, we purified wild-type and L135-hGALT proteins to homogeneity and analyzed identical amounts of enzyme protein. We found that the apparent Vmax of the purified L135-hGALT protein was significantly reduced from 80 +/- 5.9 to 5.8 +/- 1.8 micromol glucose 1-phosphate released/min/mg hGALT protein with no increase in KM for galactose 1-phosphate for the second displacement. The first displacement reaction, although three orders of magnitude slower, was similar between the wild type and L135-hGALT. We conclude that a hydroxyl group on amino acid 135 is required for the catalysis of uridyl transfer from UDP-glucose to UDP-galactose in the presence of galactose 1-phosphate, and plays a role in the bio-stability of hGALT.

Oxidation of galactose by galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase-deficient lymphoblasts

The ability of EB virus-transformed lymphoblasts with undetectable galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) from 15 galactosaemic patients to oxidize [1-(14)C]galactose to 14CO2 was compared to that of cells from 7 normal subjects. The oxidation of galactose but not of glucose was markedly diminished by cells from Q188R homozygous galactosaemic patients but was not absent. After 2.5 h these cells liberated 14CO2 at nearly 3% and at 5 h up to 9% of normal. Cells from patients homozygous for the S135L mutation produced much larger amounts of 14CO2 (15-17% of normal) and were distinguishable from the Q188R homozygous cells. A cell line with a homozygous deletion of the GALT gene oxidized galactose at 7% of the normal rate, suggesting that pathways(s) other than GALT exist in these cells as well as Q188R homozygous cells for oxidation of galactose to CO2. Concentration dependence studies are consistent with the presence of a pathway that is unsaturable or has a very high Km The ability of 10(7) lymphoblasts with the S135L genotype to oxidize more than 7% of the sugar to 14CO2 in 5 h suggests the presence of residual GALT despite the inability to detect the activity by enzymatic analysis.

Galactose metabolism in mice with galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase deficiency: sucklings and 7-week-old animals fed a high-galactose diet

Mice deficient in galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) demonstrate abnormal galactose metabolism but no obvious clinical phenotype. To further dissect the pathways of galactose metabolism in these animals, galactose oxidation and metabolite levels were studied in 16-day-old sucklings and the effect of a 4 week prior exposure to a 40% glucose or 40% galactose diet was determined in 7-week-old mice. Suckling GALT-deficient (G/G) mice slowly oxidized [1-14C]galactose to 14CO2, 4.0% of the dose when fed and 7.9% when fasted compared to normal animals 38.3 and 36.4% in 4 h, respectively. Plasma of G/G sucklings contained 11.1 mM galactose and erythrocyte galactose 1-phosphate levels were 28.2 and 31.9 mg/dl packed cells. Galactose, galactitol, galactonate, and galactose 1-phosphate were found in G/G suckling mouse tissues. The tissue galactose concentrations were 10% or less of that in plasma, suggesting that there was limited cellular entry of galactose. In 7-week-old fasted mice with 4 weeks prior exposure to glucose or galactose-containing diet, 4-h oxidation was 12.9 and 15.0% of the administered radiolabeled galactose, respectively. Normal animals oxidized 33.9 and 37.9% of the dose when fed the same diets, respectively. The ability of G/G mice to oxidize galactose in the absence of GALT activity suggests the presence of alternate metabolic pathways for galactose disposition. G/G mice fed the galactose-free 40% glucose diet had erythrocyte galactose 1-phosphate levels ranging from 6.4 to 17.7 mg/dl packed cells and detectable galactose and galactose metabolites in tissues, suggesting that these animals endogenously produced galactose. The plasma of 40% galactose-fed G/G mice contained 9.1 mM galactose with red blood cell galactose 1-phosphate averaging 43.6 mg/dl. Tissues of these animals also contained high levels of galactose and galactose 1-phosphate. Liver contained over 4 micromol/g galactonate but little galactitol. Despite the elevated galactose and galactose 1-phosphate, the animals tolerated the high-galactose diet and were indistinguishable from normal animals, exhibiting no manifestations of galactose toxicity seen in human GALT-deficient galactosemia. The data suggest that high galactose 1-phosphate levels do not cause galactose toxicity and that high galactitol in combination with galactose 1-phosphate may be a prerequisite. Absence of GALT appears necessary but insufficient to produce human galactosemic phenotype.

Evidence for alternate galactose oxidation in a patient with deletion of the galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase gene

The persistent, dietary-independent elevation of galactose metabolites in patients with galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) deficiency is probably secondary to de novo synthesis of galactose. Relatively constant steady-state levels of galactose metabolites in patients also suggest that non-GALT metabolic pathways must function to dispose of the galactose synthesized each day. The discovery of a patient with a rare deletion of the GALT gene provided a unique opportunity to examine the availability of any alternate galactose oxidative capacity both in vivo and in vitro. Utilizing genomic DNA from the patient, Southern blot data demonstrated that 10 of the 11 GALT exons were homozygously deleted. By measurement of 13CO2 in expired air for up to 24 h after an oral bolus of [1-13C]galactose, it was demonstrated that 17% of the galactose was metabolized, a value comparable to the 3-h elimination rate in a control subject. Furthermore, lymphoblasts prepared from the patient could also convert [1-14C]galactose to 14CO2. This unique study provides the first unambiguous evidence that another pathway exists in man that can be responsible for galactose disposal. Further knowledge of this alternate galactose oxidative route and its regulation may aid in formulating new strategies for the treatment of galactosemia.

Risk factors for premature ovarian failure in females with galactosemia

The risk for premature ovarian failure (POF) in females with galactosemia can be predicted by analyzing 3 areas of risk pathology: the patient's molecular genotype for galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT), alternate pathways for galactose metabolism, and the patient's environment at diagnosis and during treatment.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective cross-sectional information was collected on 53 females with classic galactosemia, and their ovarian function was analyzed by determination of serum follicle-stimulating hormone and luteinizing hormone levels and by clinical observation. The associations were analyzed between POF and the mutations in GALT, the highest erythrocyte galactose-1-phosphate (Gal-1-P) level at diagnosis, the age at which dietary treatment was initiated, mean erythrocyte Gal-1-P level during treatment, and whole-body carbon 13-labeled galactose oxidation to (13)CO(2).

RESULTS

The most prevalent mutation, Q188R, had a significant effect of genotype category (Q188R/Q188R, Q188R/Other, Other/Other) on POF (P =.04, Fisher exact test and an odds ratio of 8.3). Mean erythrocyte Gal-1-P level during treatment was a significant risk factor for POF (P =.04). Also, all patients studied with less than 5% total body oxidation of galactose to (13)CO(2) had POF, whereas those with more than 5% did not have POF (P =.008, Fisher exact test).

CONCLUSION

The development of POF in females with galactosemia is more likely if the patient's genotype is Q188R/Q188R, if the mean erythrocyte Gal-1-P is >3.5 mg/dL during therapy, and if the recovery of (13)CO(2) from whole-body (13)C-galactose oxidation is reduced below 5% of administered (13)C-galactose.