Unraveling the Genetics of Congenital Hypothyroidism: Challenges and Opportunities

Revealing the genetic complexity of hypothyroidism: integrating complementary association methods

Hypothyroidism is a common endocrine disorder whose prevalence increases with age. The disease manifests itself when the thyroid gland fails to produce sufficient thyroid hormones. The disorder includes cases of congenital hypothyroidism (CH), but most cases exhibit hormonal feedback dysregulation and destruction of the thyroid gland by autoantibodies. In this study, we sought to identify causal genes for hypothyroidism in large populations. The study used the UK-Biobank (UKB) database, reporting on 13,687 cases of European ancestry. We used GWAS compilation from Open Targets (OT) and tuned protocols focusing on genes and coding regions, along with complementary association methods of PWAS (proteome-based) and TWAS (transcriptome-based). Comparing summary statistics from numerous GWAS revealed a limited number of variants associated with thyroid development. The proteome-wide association study method identified 77 statistically significant genes, half of which are located within the Chr6-MHC locus and are enriched with autoimmunity-related genes. While coding GWAS and PWAS highlighted the centrality of immune-related genes, OT and transcriptome-wide association study mostly identified genes involved in thyroid developmental programs. We used independent populations from Finland (FinnGen) and the Taiwan cohort to validate the PWAS results. The higher prevalence in females relative to males is substantiated as the polygenic risk score prediction of hypothyroidism relied mostly from the female group genetics. Comparing results from OT, TWAS, and PWAS revealed the complementary facets of hypothyroidism's etiology. This study underscores the significance of synthesizing gene-phenotype association methods for this common, intricate disease. We propose that the integration of established association methods enhances interpretability and clinical utility.

Prevalence of Transient Hypothyroidism in Children Diagnosed with Congenital Hypothyroidism between 2000 and 2016

Newborn screening (NBS) for congenital hypothyroidism (CH) was introduced in Switzerland in 1977, which allowed for the preclinical, biochemical diagnosis. The aim of this study was to evaluate the prevalence of transient CH (tCH) in the canton of Zurich. In this analytical cohort study, all newborns born in the canton of Zurich, between the 1st of January 2000 and the 30st of June 2016, with a TSH value above 15 mU/L (whole blood) were included. There were 115 cases out of 247,918 babies born during the study period. However, 23 cases had to be excluded due to missing data. The definite diagnosis was made after a thyroxine withdrawal at 2 years of age. The total prevalence of confirmed CH and the female to male ratio (f/m) were 1:2695 and 2.17:1; for permanent CH (pCH), 1:3443 and 2.8:1; and for tCH, 1:12,396 and 1:1, respectively. The TSH value was significantly higher in pCH compared to tCH, at 130.3 (62.9-171.9) and 36.4 (26.5-53.3) (median and interquartile range), respectively (p < 0.001). The prevalences found for congenital hypothyroidism and its transient form are comparable to previous studies. TSH concentration at birth was predictive for the further course of the disease. Low birth weight correlated with a tCH, whereas low gestational age did not. The dominance of the female sex in congenital hypothyroidism is supported by a gender ratio of 2.17:1.

Clinical and genetic investigation in patients with permanent congenital hypothyroidism

BACKGROUND

Permanent congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is usually a more severe type of CH. However, the molecular etiology and clinical features of permanent CH remain unclear.

METHODS

We recruited 42 patients who were diagnosed with CH and followed-up after diagnosis. Demographic information and data at diagnosis and treatment were recorded. Genetic analyses were performed using whole exome sequencing. Based on the presence or absence of variants and differences in clinical features, we grouped the study participants and analyzed their characteristics.

RESULTS

A total of 29 patients (69.0 %) were identified as having variants potentially related to their disease. Among the 24 patients with normal-sized thyroid gland-in-situ (GIS) or goiter, 23 (95.8 %, P < 0.001) had variants. This is compared to 18 patients with thyroid dysgenesis (TD), of which six (33.3 %) had genetic variants. We detected 55 variants in six genes, the most frequently mutated gene being DUOX2 (70.9 %). Biallelic DUOX2 variants were detected in 14 of 24 (58.3 %) GIS or goiter patients. Compared to the cases with variants, the L-T4 dose at 2 and 3 years of age and current dose were higher in the unmutated cases. At 2 years of age, patients with TD required higher doses of L-T4 supplementation. Patients with DUOX2 variants showed lower doses of L-T4 being required at 2 and 3 years of age and current. Furthermore, patients with GIS or goiter with DUOX2 variants showed lower doses of L-T4.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with CH, whether TD or GIS or goiter, are at risk of developing a permanent condition. Compared with patients with TD, the detection of variants was higher in patients with GIS or goiter. The most frequently mutated gene was DUOX2, with a biallelic type. Patients with TD required higher doses of L-T4 supplementation with age, whereas those patients with the DUOX2 variant required relatively lower doses.

Neuropsychological Alterations in Patients with Congenital Hypothyroidism Treated with Levothyroxine: Linked Factors and Thyroid Hormone Hyposensitivity

Eighty-five percent of the studies of patients with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) treated with Levothyroxine (L-T₄) report neuropsychological sequelae throughout life. In neonates and infants, there is a deficit in sensorimotor skills (impaired balance). In preschool and elementary school children and adolescents, there are alterations in intellectual quotient (low scores), language (delayed phonological acquisition), memory (visual, verbal, visuospatial, visuoconstructive, autobiographical, and semantic), sensorimotor skills (impaired fine and gross motor control), and visuoconstructive–visuospatial domain (low scores in spatial location, block design, and object assembly). These neuropsychological domains are also affected in young adults, except for language (adequate verbal fluency) and visuoconstructive–visuospatial domain (no data). The onset and severity of neuropsychological sequelae in patients with treated CH depend on several factors: extrinsic, related to L-T₄ treatment and social aspects, and intrinsic, such as severity and etiology of CH, as well as structural and physiological changes in the brain. In this review, we hypothesized that thyroid hormone hyposensitivity (THH) could also contribute to neuropsychological alterations by reducing the effectiveness of L-T₄ treatment in the brain. Thus, further research could approach the THH hypothesis at basic and clinical levels to implement new endocrinological and neuropsychological therapies for CH patients.

Whole-Exome Sequencing in Congenital Hypothyroidism Due to Thyroid Dysgenesis

Context: Congenital hypothyroidism due to thyroid dysgenesis (CHTD) is a predominantly sporadic and nonsyndromic (NS) condition of unknown etiology. NS-CHTD shows a 40-fold increase in relative risk among first-degree relatives (1 in 100 compared with a birth prevalence of 1 in 4000 in the general population), but a discordance rate between monozygotic (MZ) twins of 92%. This suggests a two-hit mechanism, combining a genetic predisposition (incomplete penetrance of inherited variants) with postzygotic events (accounting for MZ twin discordance). Objective: To evaluate whether whole-exome sequencing (WES) allows to identify new predisposing genes in NS-CHTD. Methods: We performed a case-control study by comparing the whole exome of 36 nonconsanguineous cases of NS-CHTD (33 with lingual thyroid ectopy and 3 with athyreosis, based on technetium pertechnetate scintigraphy at diagnosis) with that of 301 unaffected controls to assess for enrichment in rare protein-altering variants. We performed an unbiased approach using a gene-based burden with a false discovery rate correction. Moreover, we identified all rare pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants, based on in silico prediction tools, in 27 genes previously associated with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) (thyroid dysgenesis [TD] and dyshormonogenesis). Results: After correction for multiple testing, no enrichment in rare protein-altering variants was observed in NS-CHTD. Pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants (21 variants in 12 CH genes) were identified in 42% of cases. Eight percent of cases had variants in more than one gene (oligogenic group); these were not more severely affected than monogenic cases. Moreover, cases with protein-altering variants in dyshormonogenesis-related genes were not more severely affected than those without. Conclusions: No new predisposing genes were identified following an unbiased analysis of WES data in a well-characterized NS-CHTD cohort. Nonetheless, the discovery rate of rare pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants was 42%. Eight percent of the cases harbored multiple variants in genes associated with TD or dyshormonogenesis, but these variants did not explain the variability of hypothyroidism observed in dysgenesis. WES did not identify a genetic cause in NS-CHTD cases, confirming the complex etiology of this disease. Additional studies in larger cohorts and/or novel discovery approaches are required.

Impact of the Mutational Landscape of the Sodium/Iodide Symporter in Congenital Hypothyroidism

Background: Iodide transport defect is an uncommon cause of dyshormonogenic congenital hypothyroidism due to homozygous or compound heterozygous pathogenic variants in the SLC5A5 gene, which encodes the sodium/iodide symporter (NIS), causing deficient iodide accumulation in thyroid follicular cells, thus impairing thyroid hormonogenesis. Methods:SLC5A5 gene variants were compiled from public databases and research articles exploring the molecular bases of congenital hypothyroidism. Using a dataset of 198 missense NIS variants classified as either benign or pathogenic, we developed and validated a machine learning-based NIS-specific variant classifier to predict the impact of missense NIS variants. Results: We generated a manually curated dataset containing 7793 unique SLC5A5 variants. As most databases compiled exome sequencing data, variant mapping revealed an increased density of variants in SLC5A5 coding exons. Based on allele frequency (AF) analysis, we established an AF threshold of 1:10,000 above which a variant should be considered benign. Most pathogenic NIS variants were located in the protein-coding region, as most patients were genetically diagnosed by using a candidate gene strategy limited to this region. Significantly, we evidenced that 94.5% of missense NIS variants were classified as of uncertain significance. Therefore, we developed an NIS-specific variant classifier to improve the prediction of pathogenicity of missense variants. Our classifier predicted the clinical outcome of missense variants with high accuracy (90%), outperforming state-of-the-art pathogenicity predictors, such as REVEL, PolyPhen-2, and SIFT. Based on the excellent performance of our classifier, we predicted the mutational landscape of NIS. The analysis of the mutational landscape revealed that most missense variants located in transmembrane segments are frequently pathogenic. Moreover, we predicted that ∼28% of all single-nucleotide variants that could cause missense NIS variants are pathogenic, thus putatively leading to congenital hypothyroidism if present in homozygous or compound heterozygous state. Conclusions: We reported the first NIS-specific variant classifier aiming at improving the interpretation of missense NIS variants in clinical practice. Deciphering the mutational landscape for every protein involved in thyroid hormonogenesis is a relevant task for a deep understanding of the molecular mechanisms causing dyshormonogenic congenital hypothyroidism.

Screening and Functional Analysis of TPO Gene Mutations in a Cohort of Chinese Patients With Congenital Hypothyroidism

BACKGROUNDS

As a crucial enzyme in thyroid hormone synthesis, the genetic defective thyroid peroxidase (TPO) was one of the main genetic factors leading to congenital hypothyroidism (CH).

METHODS

Mutations in the TPO gene were screened and identified in 219 patients with CH from northwest China by using high-throughput sequencing and bioinformatics analysis. The biological function of detected variants was studied by in vitro experiments and homology modeling.

RESULTS

Nineteen rare variants, including seven novel ones, were detected in 17 of 219 patients (7.8%). Most cases were detected with one single heterozygous variant, and only two patients were detected with multiple variants, i.e., compounds for (1) IVS7-1G>A, p.Ala443Val, and p.Arg769Trp and (2) p.Asn592Ser and p.Asn798Lys. The biological function of the four missense mutations (i.e., p.Ala443Val, p.Arg769Trp, p.Asn592Ser, and p.Asn798Lys) they carried were further studied. Experimental data showed that these four mutations did not affect the protein expression level of the TPO gene but remarkably reduced the peroxidase activity toward guaiacol oxidation, retaining 8-32% of activity of the wild-type protein. The comparison of the predicted 3-D structures of wild-type and mutant TPO proteins showed that these four amino acid substitutions changed the non-covalent interactions of studied residues that might alter the structure and function of the TPO protein.

CONCLUSION

This study was the first to analyze the TPO mutation spectrum of patients with CH in northwest China. Our data indicated that the TPO mutation was not a common reason to cause CH in China. The functional data may help to clarify the structure-function relationship of the TPO protein and provide further evidence for the elucidation of the genetic etiology of CH.

Genetic and Phenotypic Characteristics of Congenital Hypothyroidism in a Chinese Cohort

BACKGROUND

The molecular etiology and the genotype-phenotype correlation of congenital hypothyroidism (CH) remain unclear.

METHODS

We performed genetic analysis in 42 newborns with CH using whole-exome sequencing. Patients were divided into a single-gene group and a multi-gene group according to the number of affected genes, or divided into a monoallelic group, a biallelic group, and an oligogenic group according to the pattern of the detected variants. The clinical characteristics were compared between groups.

RESULTS

Thyroid dysgenesis (TD) was observed in 10 patients and goiter in 5 patients, whereas 27 patients had normal-sized gland-in-situ (GIS). We identified 58 variants in five genes in 29 patients. The genes with the most frequent variants were DUOX2 (70.7%), followed by TSHR (12.1%), DUOXA2 (10.3%), and TPO (5.2%). Variants in the genes causing dyshormonogenesis (DH) were more common than those in the genes causing TD (87.9% versus 12.1%). Among the patients with detected variants, 26 (89.7%) were harboring a single gene variant (single-gene group), which include 22 patients harboring biallelic variants (biallelic group) and four patients harboring monoallelic variants (monoallelic group). Three (10.3%) patients harbored variants in two or three genes (multi-gene group or oligogenic group). Compared with the single-gene group, the levothyroxine (L-T4) dose at 1 year of age was higher in the multi-gene group (p = 0.018). A controllable reduction in the L-T4 dose was observed in 25% of patients in the monoallelic group and 59.1% of patients in the biallelic group; however, no patients with such reduction in the L-T4 dose were observed in the oligogenic group.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with normal-sized GIS accounted for the majority of our cohort. Genetic defects in the genes causing DH were more common than those in the genes causing TD, with biallelic variants in DUOX2 being dominant. DH might be the leading pathophysiology of CH in Chinese individuals.