The neuropathology of glycine encephalopathy: a report of five cases with immunohistochemical and ultrastructural observations

Deep postnatal phenotyping of a new mouse model of nonketotic hyperglycinemia

Nonketotic hyperglycinemia due to deficient glycine cleavage enzyme activity causes a severe neonatal epileptic encephalopathy. Current therapies based on mitigating glycine excess have only limited impact. An animal model with postnatal phenotyping is needed to explore new therapeutic approaches. We developed a Gldc p.Ala394Val mutant model and bred it to congenic status in two colonies on C57Bl/6J (B6) and J129X1/SvJ (J129) backgrounds. Mutant mice had reduced P-protein and enzyme activity indicating a hypomorphic mutant. Glycine levels were increased in blood and brain regions, exacerbated by dietary glycine, with higher levels in female than male J129 mice. Birth defects were more prevalent in mutant B6 than J129 mice, and hydrocephalus was more frequent in B6 (40%) compared to J129 (none). The hydrocephalus rate was increased by postnatal glycine challenge in B6 mice, more so when delivered from the first neonatal week than from the fourth. Mutant mice had reduced weight gain following weaning until the eighth postnatal week, which was exacerbated by glycine loading. The electrographic spike rate was increased in mutant mice following glycine loading, but no seizures were observed. The alpha/delta band intensity ratio was decreased in the left cortex in female J129 mice, which were less active in an open field test and explored less in a Y-maze, suggesting an encephalopathic effect. Mutant mice showed no evidence of memory dysfunction. This partial recapitulation of human symptoms and biochemistry will facilitate the evaluation of new therapeutic approaches with an early postnatal time window likely most effective.

Deep postnatal phenotyping of a new mouse model of nonketotic hyperglycinemia

Nonketotic hyperglycinemia due to deficient glycine cleavage enzyme activity causes a severe neonatal epileptic encephalopathy. Current therapies based on mitigating glycine excess have only limited impact. An animal model with postnatal phenotyping is needed to explore new therapeutic approaches. We developed a Gldc p.Ala394Val mutant model and bred it to congenic status in 2 colonies on C57Bl/6J (B6) and J129X1/SvJ (J129) backgrounds. Mutant mice had reduced P-protein and enzyme activity indicating a hypomorphic mutant. Glycine levels were increased in blood and brain regions, exacerbated by dietary glycine, with higher levels in female than male J129 mice. Birth defects were more prevalent in mutant B6 than J129 mice, and hydrocephalus was more frequent in B6 (40%) compared to J129 (none). The hydrocephalus rate was increased by postnatal glycine challenge in B6 mice, more so when delivered from the first neonatal week than from the fourth. Mutant mice had reduced weight gain following weaning until the eighth postnatal week, which was exacerbated by glycine loading. The electrographic spike rate was increased in mutant mice following glycine loading, but no seizures were observed. The alpha/delta band intensity ratio was decreased in the left cortex in female J129 mice, which were less active in an open field test and explored less in a Y-maze, suggesting an encephalopathic effect. Mutant mice showed no evidence of memory dysfunction. This partial recapitulation of human symptoms and biochemistry will facilitate the evaluation of new therapeutic approaches with an early postnatal time window likely most effective.

Take home message

A mouse model of nonketotic hyperglycinemia is described that shows postnatal abnormalities in glycine levels, neural tube defects, body weight, electroencephalographic recordings, and in activity in young mice making it amenable for the evaluation of novel treatment interventions.

Author contributions

Study concept and design: JVH, MHM, NB, KNMAnimal study data: MAS, HJ, NB, MHM, JC, CBBiochemical and genetic studies: MAS, RAVH, MWFStatistical analysis: NB, JVHFirst draft writing: JVH, NB, MHMCritical rewriting: MAS, NB, MHM, TAB, JC, MWF, KNM, JVHFinal responsibility, guarantor, and communicating author: JVH.

Competing interest statement

The University of Colorado (JVH, MS, KNM, HJ) has the intention to file Intellectual property protection for certain biochemical treatments of NKH. Otherwise, the authors have stated that they had no interests that might be perceived as posing a conflict or bias to this subject matter.

Funding support

Financial support is acknowledged form the NKH Crusaders, Brodyn's Friends, Nora Jane Almany Foundation, the Dickens Family Foundation, the Lucas John Foundation, Les Petits Bourdons, Joseph's Fund, the Barnett Family, Maud & Vic Foundation, Lucy's BEElievers fund, Hope for NKH, Madi's Mission NKH fund, and from Dr. and Ms. Shaw, and the University of Colorado Foundation NKH research fund. The study was supported by a grant (CNS-X-19-103) from the University of Colorado School of Medicine and the Colorado Clinical Translational Science Institute, which is supported by NIH/NCATS Colorado CTSA Grant Number UL1 TR002535. Contents are the authors' sole responsibility and do not necessarily represent official NIH views. All funding sources had no role in the design or execution of the study, the interpretation of data, or the writing of the study.

Ethics approval on Laboratory Animal Studies

Mouse studies were carried out with approval from the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of the University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus (IACUC# 00413).

Data sharing statement

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Brain imaging in classic nonketotic hyperglycinemia: Quantitative analysis and relation to phenotype

Patients with severe nonketotic hyperglycinemia (NKH) have absent psychomotor development and intractable epilepsy, whereas attenuated patients have variable psychomotor development and absent or treatable epilepsy; differences in brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) between phenotypes have not been reported. In a retrospective cross-sectional study, we reviewed 38 MRI studies from 24 molecularly proven NKH patients, and 2 transient NKH patients. Quantitative analyses included corpus callosum size, apparent diffusion coefficient, automated brain volumetric analysis, and glycine/creatine ratio by spectroscopy. All patients age <3 months had restricted diffusion in the posterior limb of the internal capsule, anterior brainstem, posterior tegmental tracts, and cerebellum, not present in transient NKH. In older infants, the pattern evolved and included generalized diffusion restriction in the supratentorial white matter, which quantitatively peaked between 3 and 12 months. No patient had absent corpus callosum or gyral malformation. The corpus callosum was relatively short in severe compared to attenuated phenotypes, and thin in severe cases only. The corpus callosum growth rate differed by severity; age-matched Z-scores of thickness worsened in severe cases only. Cerebral volume was decreased in the hippocampus, globus pallidus, cerebral cortex, thalamus, and cerebellum. Severe patients had greatest glycine/creatine ratios. In this study, no brain malformations were identified. The growth failure of the corpus callosum is worse in severe NKH, whereas the diffusion restriction pattern, reflecting microspongiosis, does not discriminate by phenotypic severity. NKH is therefore a disorder of brain growth best recognized in the corpus callosum, whereas spongiosis is not prognostic.

Megalencephalic leukoencephalopathy with cysts: the Glialcam-null mouse model

Objective

Megalencephalic leukoencephalopathy with cysts (MLC) is a genetic infantile‐onset disease characterized by macrocephaly and white matter edema due to loss of MLC1 function. Recessive mutations in either MLC1 or GLIALCAM cause the disease. MLC1 is involved in astrocytic volume regulation; GlialCAM ensures the correct membrane localization of MLC1. Their exact role in brain ion‐water homeostasis is only partly defined. We characterized Glialcam‐null mice for further studies.

Methods

We investigated the consequences of loss of GlialCAM in Glialcam‐null mice and compared GlialCAM developmental expression in mice and men.

Results

Glialcam‐null mice had early‐onset megalencephaly and increased brain water content. From 3 weeks, astrocytes were abnormal with swollen processes abutting blood vessels. Concomitantly, progressive white matter vacuolization developed due to intramyelinic edema. Glialcam‐null astrocytes showed abolished expression of MLC1, reduced expression of the chloride channel ClC‐2 and increased expression and redistribution of the water channel aquaporin4. Expression of other MLC1‐interacting proteins and the volume regulated anion channel LRRC8A was unchanged. In mice, GlialCAM expression increased until 3 weeks and then stabilized. In humans, GlialCAM expression was highest in the first 3 years to then decrease and stabilize from approximately 5 years.

Interpretation

Glialcam‐null mice replicate the early stages of the human disease with early‐onset intramyelinic edema. The earliest change is astrocytic swelling, further substantiating that a defect in astrocytic volume regulation is the primary cellular defect in MLC. GlialCAM expression affects expression of MLC1, ClC‐2 and aquaporin4, indicating that abnormal interplay between these proteins is a disease mechanism in megalencephalic leukoencephalopathy with cysts.

Characteristic MRI findings in neonatal nonketotic hyperglycinemia due to sequence changes in GLDC gene encoding the enzyme glycine decarboxylase

Neonatal metabolic encephalopathy may be related to electrolyte imbalances, endocrine dysfunction, or inborn errors of metabolism. The metabolic encephalopathies are always a diagnostic challenge to the neonatologist and pediatricians. This is more so because the signs and symptoms of are nonspecific and are often similar to those with other neonatal emergencies. Clinical suspicion of neonatal encephalopathy should be considered in any infant exhibiting an abnormal level of consciousness, seizures, tone and reflex abnormalities, apnea, aspiration, and feeding difficulties. A definitive diagnosis is frequently not possible during the neonatal care unit or emergency department. But the proper initial management based on the probable diagnosis can be life-saving or reduce neurologic sequelae. In the case of inborn errors of metabolism, imaging may play a vital role either in limiting the differential diagnosis or yet times pointing towards the specific diagnosis or error of metabolism. We report DWI-ADC changes on MRI in the acute stages of neonatal nonketotic hyperglycinemia (NKH) due to sequence changes in GLDC gene.

Progressive vacuolating glycine leukoencephalopathy with pulmonary hypertension

To report two unrelated patients with a new phenotype of nonketotic hyperglycinemia associated with idiopathic pulmonary hypertension. Clinical findings included rapidly progressive neurological deterioration with onset in the first year of life characterized by developmental regression without seizures or electroencephalogram abnormalities during follow-up. Both patients died before the age of 18 months. Glycine cleavage system deficiency was confirmed by enzymatic studies in frozen liver. Molecular analysis in the related genes showed no pathogenic mutation. Radiological and pathological findings were consistent with progressive vacuolating encephalopathy. Our patients with biochemical and enzymatic parameters consistent with atypical nonketotic hyperglycinemia. The clinical and radiological evolution, as progressive vacuolating leukoencephalopathy and the association with pulmonary hypertension constitute a previously unrecognized variant.

Cobalamin (vitamin B12) in subacute combined degeneration and beyond: traditional interpretations and novel theories

Subacute combined degeneration (SCD) is a neuropathy due to cobalamin (Cbl) (vitamin B(12)) deficiency acquired in adult age. Hitherto, the theories advanced to explain the pathogenesis of SCD have postulated a causal relationship between SCD lesions and the impairment of either or both of two Cbl-dependent reactions. We have identified a new experimental model, the totally gastrectomized rat, to reproduce the key morphological features of the disease [spongy vacuolation, intramyelinic and interstitial edema of the white matter of the central nervous system (CNS), and astrogliosis], and found new mechanisms responsible for the pathogenesis of SCD: the neuropathological lesions in TGX rats are not only due to mere vitamin withdrawal but also to the overproduction of the myelinolytic tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha and the reduced synthesis of the two neurotrophic agents, epidermal growth factor (EGF) and interleukin-6. This deregulation of the balance between TNF-alpha and EGF synthesis induced by Cbl deficiency has been verified in the sera of patients with pernicious anemia (but not in those with iron-deficient anemia), and in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of SCD patients. These new functions are not linked to the coenzyme functions of the vitamin, but it is still unknown whether they involve genetic or epigenetic mechanisms. Low Cbl levels have also been repeatedly observed in the sera and/or CSF of patients with Alzheimer's disease or multiple sclerosis, but whether Cbl deficit plays a role in the pathogenesis of these diseases is still unclear.

Increased cerebrospinal fluid glycine: a biochemical marker for a leukoencephalopathy with vanishing white matter

Recently, a new disease entity has been defined: the disease of vanishing white matter. This leukoencephalopathy has an autosomal-recessive mode of inheritance. No cause or biochemical marker is known. We studied cerebrospinal fluid amino acids in five patients with the disease and found a consistent, moderate elevation of cerebrospinal fluid glycine in all. The ratio of cerebrospinal fluid to plasma glycine was elevated in four patients, in two patients reaching the level considered diagnostic for nonketotic hyperglycinemia. The activity of the glycine cleavage system was found to be normal in lymphoblasts in two patients. The elevation of cerebrospinal fluid glycine in the disease of vanishing white matter is either caused by a primary disturbance of glycine metabolism or is secondary to excitotoxic brain damage.

Epizootic vacuolar myelinopathy of the central nervous system of bald eagles (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) and American coots (Fulica americana)

Unprecedented mortality occurred in bald eagles (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) at DeGray Lake, Arkansas, during the winters of 1994-1995 and 1996-1997. The first eagles were found dead during November, soon after arrival from fall migration, and deaths continued into January during both episodes. In total, 29 eagles died at or near DeGray Lake in the winter of 1994-1995 and 26 died in the winter of 1996-1997; no eagle mortality was noted during the same months of the intervening winter or in the earlier history of the lake. During the mortality events, sick eagles were observed overflying perches or colliding with rock walls. Signs of incoordination and limb paresis were also observed in American coots (Fulica americana) during the episodes of eagle mortality, but mortality in coots was minimal. No consistent abnormalities were seen on gross necropsy of either species. No microscopic findings in organs other than the central nervous system (CNS) could explain the cause of death. By light microscopy, all 26 eagles examined and 62/77 (81%) coots had striking, diffuse, spongy degeneration of the white matter of the CNS. Vacuolation occurred in all myelinated CNS tissue, including the cerebellar folia and medulla oblongata, but was most prominent in the optic tectum. In the spinal cord, vacuoles were concentrated near the gray matter, and occasional swollen axons were seen. Vacuoles were uniformly present in optic nerves but were not evident in the retina or peripheral or autonomic nerves. Cellular inflammatory response to the lesion was distinctly lacking. Vacuoles were 8-50 microns in diameter and occurred individually, in clusters, or in rows. In sections stained by luxol fast blue/periodic acid-Schiff stain, the vacuoles were delimited and transected by myelin strands. Transmission electron microscopy revealed intramyelinic vacuoles formed in the myelin sheaths by splitting of one or more myelin lamellae at the intraperiodic line. This lesion is characteristic of toxicity from hexachlorophene, triethyltin, bromethalin, isonicotinic acid hydrazide, and certain exotic plant toxins; however, despite exhaustive testing, no etiology was determined for the DeGray Lake mortality events. This is the first report of vacuolar myelinopathy associated with spontaneous mortality in wild birds.

Spongy encephalopathy in ketotic hyperglycinemia

Three cases of ketotic hyperglycinemia are described. Spongy encephalopathy was present in white as well as gray matter. The cell type that predominantly exhibited swelling was the astrocyte. Glycine binding is required for activation of the NMDA receptor. By constant excitation a surplus of glycine could disturb the ion balance. This might provide the pathogenetic principle of seizures and cytotoxic edema in hyperglycinemia.

Neonatal glycine encephalopathy: biochemical and neuropathologic findings

A patient with neonatal glycine encephalopathy who had severe neurologic retardation, spasticity, and seizures died at 17 years of age. Glycine concentration was markedly elevated in brain tissue, especially in the cerebellum. Neuropathologic study revealed spongy myelinopathy throughout the central nervous system and calcium oxalate crystals in the cerebellum, which are probably derived from degradation of glycine. Myelinopathy appeared to be static compared to neonatal patients. The neurologic manifestations of neonatal glycine encephalopathy are probably due to neurotransmitter abnormalities, not to myelin damage.

Neuropathology of Rett syndrome

Rett syndrome is an increasingly recognized progressive disorder in females, commencing in infancy and characterized by autistic behavior, gait ataxia, stereotyped movements, seizures and generalized growth and mental retardation, possibly associated with disorders of central biogenic amine synthesis. The gene locus and pathogenesis of Rett syndrome are unknown. Autopsy studies in nine girls dying between 4 and 17 years, and sural nerve and muscle biopsies from two girls aged 3 and 17 years showed: (1) diffuse cortical atrophy/micrencephaly, with a decrease in brain weight by 12% to 34% of age-matched controls, apparently related to the duration of the disorder; (2) mild diffuse cortical atrophy with increased amounts of neuronal lipofuscin and occasional mild gliosis, but without signs of a storage disorder; (3) underpigmentation of the zona compacta nigrae, which showed fewer well-pigmented neurons for age and fewer melanin granules per neuron, while total numbers of nigral neurons and the substructure of neuromelanin were normal for age. No pathological changes were seen in other transmitter-specific brain stem nuclei; (4) immunoreactivity for tyrosine hydroxylase was slightly reduced in nigral and hypothalamic neurons, and the pituitary gland showed decreased immunoreaction for prolactin and growth hormone; (5) ultrastructurally, in frontal cortex and caudate nucleus, isolated abnormal neurites and reactive or degenerative axonal swellings were seen; the latter are possibly related to the nigral changes, suggesting some dysfunction of the dopaminergic nigrostriatal system, which is supported by neurochemical data; (6) preliminary biochemical studies revealed increased beta-endorphines in thalamus and cerebellum; (7) peripheral nerves demonstrated increase in small fibers without demyelination and increased numbers of neurofilaments in axons, suggesting distal axonopathy, while skeletal muscle showed alterations in the sarcoplasmic reticulum with circular profiles in the Z-filaments. These nonspecific changes may be interpreted as early signs of denervation. The variety of lesions in the central, neuroendocrine and peripheral neuromuscular systems in Rett syndrome are discussed with regard to their clinical and biochemical significance.

Neuropathology of Rett syndrome

Autopsy studies in 8 girls with the Rett syndrome dying between 4 and 15 years showed: Diffuse cerebral atrophy/micrencephaly, with a decrease in brain weight by 13.8 to 33.8% of age-matched controls, apparently related to the duration of the disorder; Mild, but inconsistent diffuse cortical atrophy without developmental disorders apart from occasional microdysgenesis (three cases), but increased amounts of neuronal lipofuscin, and occasional mild astrocytic gliosis; Mild, but inconsistent spongy changes in cerebral and cerebellar white matter, optic nerve (two cases), and myelinated fascicles of the brainstem tegmentum, without signs of dys- or demyelination, and apparently different from the spongy myelinopathy common to aminoacidopathies; Most conspicuous was an underpigmentation of the substantia nigra which contained many fewer well-pigmented neurons for age (53-73%), and fewer pigmented granules per neuron, while the total number of nigral neurons and the triphasic substructure of neuromelanin were normal for age. No pathologic changes were seen in locus coeruleus, nucleus basalis of Meynert, and nucleus dorsalis raphe; Electron microscopy of autopsy material from an 11-year-old girl showed increased amounts of neuronal lipofuscin without signs of a storage disorder. Reactive and degenerating axons in the caudate nucleus were possibly related to the nigral changes, suggesting some dysfunction of the dopaminergic nigro-striatal system, while the synaptic organization of the neostriatum appeared unaffected. Peripheral nerve from a patient dying in advanced stage showed increased numbers of unmyelinated (regenerated?) axons, with almost no demyelination and few remyelinated axons, suggesting axonal degeneration rather than hypomyelination, but exogenous factors (malnutrition) cannot be excluded. The pathogenetic mechanisms of the morphologic brain lesions and their relations to clinical and neurochemical findings in Rett syndrome are unknown and deserve further intensive investigations.

Ultrastructural findings in maple syrup urine disease in Poll Hereford calves

Ultrastructural findings in the nervous systems of two Poll Hereford calves affected with maple syrup urine disease or branched chain ketoacid decarboxylase deficiency are described. The calves were affected within 2 days of birth with a severe generalised central nervous system (CNS) disorder characterised by dullness and weakness, progressing to recumbency and opisthotonus. The urine had an odour of burnt sugar. Analysis of plasma and cerebrospinal fluid demonstrated significantly elevated levels of the branched chain amino acids leucine, isoleucine and valine. Status spongiosus affecting mainly the white matter was recorded at microscopic examination of the CNS, with ultrastructural examination confirming the presence of intramyelinic vacuole formation, suggesting myelin oedema.

Myelin basic protein and myelin-associated glycoprotein in chronic, relapsing experimental allergic encephalomyelitis

One-micron plastic sections of spinal cords from SJL/J mice with chronic relapsing experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) were reacted immunocytochemically with antiserum to myelin basic protein and myelin-associated glycoprotein. The distribution of myelin basic protein and myelin-associated glycoprotein in myelin sheaths was compared in acute and chronic areas of demyelination. No difference in the size of the lesion was seen with the two antisera. Myelin-associated glycoprotein was seen periaxonally in both normal myelin sheaths and sheaths which showed extensive splitting and ballooning as seen with toluidine blue stain and myelin basic protein antiserum. At least at the level of the light microscope, myelin basic protein antiserum gave intense staining of myelin while antiserum to myelin-associated glycoprotein showed little or no affinity to stain the myelin sheath itself, in contrast to other recent electron microscope observations. A few myelin basic protein or myelin-associated glycoprotein-containing oligodendrocytes were seen in lesion areas and remyelination by oligodendrocytes was rare. These observations are in agreement with findings from other models of EAE and multiple sclerosis where a primary loss of myelin has been implicated.