Monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies detect a new type of post-translational modification of axonemal tubulin

Tubulin post-translational modifications in protists - Tiny models for solving big questions

Protists are an exceptionally diverse group of mostly single-celled eukaryotes. The organization of the microtubular cytoskeleton in protists from various evolutionary lineages has different levels of sophistication, from a network of microtubules (MTs) supporting intracellular trafficking as in Dictyostelium, to complex structures such as basal bodies and cilia/flagella enabling cell motility, and lineage-specific adaptations such as the ventral disc in Giardia. MTs building these diverse structures have specific properties partly due to the presence of tubulin post-translational modifications (PTMs). Among them there are highly evolutionarily conserved PTMs: acetylation, detyrosination, (poly)glutamylation and (poly)glycylation. In some protists also less common tubulin PTMs were identified, including phosphorylation, methylation, Δ2-, Δ5- of α-tubulin, polyubiquitination, sumoylation, or S-palmitoylation. Not surprisingly, several single-celled organisms become models to study tubulin PTMs, including their effect on MT properties and discovery of the modifying enzymes. Here, we briefly summarize the current knowledge on tubulin PTMs in unicellular eukaryotes and highlight key findings in protists as model organisms.

Posttranslational modifications of the cytoskeleton

The cytoskeleton plays important roles in many essential processes at the cellular and organismal levels, including cell migration and motility, cell division, and the establishment and maintenance of cell and tissue architecture. In order to facilitate these varied functions, the main cytoskeletal components-microtubules, actin filaments, and intermediate filaments-must form highly diverse intracellular arrays in different subcellular areas and cell types. The question of how this diversity is conferred has been the focus of research for decades. One key mechanism is the addition of posttranslational modifications (PTMs) to the major cytoskeletal proteins. This posttranslational addition of various chemical groups dramatically increases the complexity of the cytoskeletal proteome and helps facilitate major global and local cytoskeletal functions. Cytoskeletal proteins undergo many PTMs, most of which are not well understood. Recent technological advances in proteomics and cell biology have allowed for the in-depth study of individual PTMs and their functions in the cytoskeleton. Here, we provide an overview of the major PTMs that occur on the main structural components of the three cytoskeletal systems-tubulin, actin, and intermediate filament proteins-and highlight the cellular function of these modifications.

C-Terminal Tail Polyglycylation and Polyglutamylation Alter Microtubule Mechanical Properties

Microtubules are biopolymers that perform diverse cellular functions. Microtubule behavior regulation occurs in part through post-translational modification of both the α- and β-subunits of tubulin. One class of modifications is the heterogeneous addition of glycine and/or glutamate residues to the disordered C-terminal tails (CTTs) of tubulin. Because of their prevalence in stable, high-stress cellular structures such as cilia, we sought to determine if these modifications alter microtubules' intrinsic stiffness. Here, we describe the purification and characterization of differentially modified pools of tubulin from Tetrahymena thermophila. We found that post-translational modifications do affect microtubule stiffness but do not affect the number of protofilaments incorporated into microtubules. We measured the spin dynamics of nuclei in the CTT backbone by NMR spectroscopy to explore the mechanism of this change. Our results show that the α-tubulin CTT does not protrude out from the microtubule surface, as is commonly depicted in models, but instead interacts with the dimer's surface. This suggests that the interactions of the α-tubulin CTT with the tubulin body contributes to the stiffness of the assembled microtubule, thus providing insight into the mechanism by which polyglycylation and polyglutamylation can alter microtubule mechanical properties.

Single-Peptide TR-FRET Detection Platform for Cysteine-Specific Post-Translational Modifications

Post-translational modifications (PTMs) are one of the most important regulatory mechanisms in cells, and they play key roles in cell signaling both in health and disease. PTM catalyzing enzymes have become significant drug targets, and therefore, tremendous interest has been focused on the development of broad-scale assays to monitor several different PTMs with a single detection platform. Most of the current methodologies suffer from low throughput or rely on antibody recognition, increasing the assay costs, and decreasing the multifunctionality of the assay. Thus, we have developed a sensitive time-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) detection method for PTMs of cysteine residues using a single-peptide approach performed in a 384-well format. In the developed assay, the enzyme-specific biotinylated substrate peptide is post-translationally modified at the cysteine residue, preventing the subsequent thiol coupling with a reactive AlexaFluor 680 acceptor dye. In the absence of enzymatic activity, increase in the TR-FRET signal between the biotin-bound Eu(III)-labeled streptavidin donor and the cysteine-coupled AlexaFluor 680 acceptor dye is observed. We demonstrate the detection concept with cysteine modifying S-nitrosylation and ADP-ribosylation reactions using a chemical nitric oxide donor S-nitrosoglutathione and enzymatic ADP-ribosyltransferase PtxS1-subunit of pertussis toxin, respectively. As a proof of concept, three peptide substrates derived from the small GTPase K-Ras and the inhibitory α-subunit of the heterotrimeric G-protein Gαi showed expected functionality in both chemical and enzymatic assays. Measurements yielded signal-to-background ratios of 28.7, 33.0, and 8.7 between the modified and the nonmodified substrates for the three peptides in the S-nitrosylation assay, 5.8 in the NAD⁺ hydrolysis assay, and 6.8 in the enzymatic ADP-ribosyltransferase inhibitor dose–response assay. The developed antibody-free assay for cysteine-modifying enzymes provides a detection platform with low nanomolar peptide substrate consumption, and the assay is potentially applicable to investigate various cysteine-modifying enzymes in a high throughput compatible format.

Insights of the tubulin code in gametes and embryos: from basic research to potential clinical applications in humans†

Microtubules are intracellular filaments that define in space and in time a large number of essential cellular functions such as cell division, morphology and motility, intracellular transport and flagella and cilia assembly. They are therefore essential for spermatozoon and oocyte maturation and function, and for embryo development. The dynamic and functional properties of the microtubules are in large part defined by various classes of interacting proteins including MAPs (microtubule associated proteins), microtubule-dependent motors, and severing and modifying enzymes. Multiple mechanisms regulate these interactions. One of them is defined by the high diversity of the microtubules themselves generated by the combination of different tubulin isotypes and by several tubulin post-translational modifications (PTMs). This generates a so-called tubulin code that finely regulates the specific set of proteins that associates with a given microtubule thereby defining the properties and functions of the network. Here we provide an in depth review of the current knowledge on the tubulin isotypes and PTMs in spermatozoa, oocytes, and preimplantation embryos in various model systems and in the human species. We focus on functional implications of the tubulin code for cytoskeletal function, particularly in the field of human reproduction and development, with special emphasis on gamete quality and infertility. Finally, we discuss some of the knowledge gaps and propose future research directions.

Tubulin glycylation controls primary cilia length

In motile cilia and flagella, tubulin glycylation is involved in axoneme stabilization. Using a newly developed antibody, Gadadhar et al. now show that glycylation also accumulates in primary cilia, where it controls ciliary length. This suggests an important role for this PTM in primary cilia homeostasis.

As essential components of the eukaryotic cytoskeleton, microtubules fulfill a variety of functions that can be temporally and spatially controlled by tubulin posttranslational modifications. Tubulin glycylation has so far been mostly found on motile cilia and flagella, where it is involved in the stabilization of the axoneme. In contrast, barely anything is known about the role of glycylation in primary cilia because of limitations in detecting this modification in these organelles. We thus developed novel glycylation-specific antibodies with which we detected glycylation in many primary cilia. Glycylation accumulates in primary cilia in a length-dependent manner, and depletion or overexpression of glycylating enzymes modulates the length of primary cilia in cultured cells. This strongly suggests that glycylation is essential for the homeostasis of primary cilia, which has important implications for human disorders related to primary cilia dysfunctions, such as ciliopathies and certain types of cancer.

The Altered Hepatic Tubulin Code in Alcoholic Liver Disease

The molecular mechanisms that lead to the progression of alcoholic liver disease have been actively examined for decades. Because the hepatic microtubule cytoskeleton supports innumerable cellular processes, it has been the focus of many such mechanistic studies. It has long been appreciated that α-tubulin is a major target for modification by highly reactive ethanol metabolites and reactive oxygen species. It is also now apparent that alcohol exposure induces post-translational modifications that are part of the natural repertoire, mainly acetylation. In this review, the modifications of the "tubulin code" are described as well as those adducts by ethanol metabolites. The potential cellular consequences of microtubule modification are described with a focus on alcohol-induced defects in protein trafficking and enhanced steatosis. Possible mechanisms that can explain hepatic dysfunction are described and how this relates to the onset of liver injury is discussed. Finally, we propose that agents that alter the cellular acetylation state may represent a novel therapeutic strategy for treating liver disease.

Writing and Reading the Tubulin Code

Microtubules give rise to intracellular structures with diverse morphologies and dynamics that are crucial for cell division, motility, and differentiation. They are decorated with abundant and chemically diverse posttranslational modifications that modulate their stability and interactions with cellular regulators. These modifications are important for the biogenesis and maintenance of complex microtubule arrays such as those found in spindles, cilia, neuronal processes, and platelets. Here we discuss the nature and subcellular distribution of these posttranslational marks whose patterns have been proposed to constitute a tubulin code that is interpreted by cellular effectors. We review the enzymes responsible for writing the tubulin code, explore their functional consequences, and identify outstanding challenges in deciphering the tubulin code.

Ependymal cell differentiation, from monociliated to multiciliated cells

Primary and motile cilia differ in their structure, composition, and function. In the brain, primary cilia are immotile signalling organelles present on neural stem cells and neurons. Multiple motile cilia are found on the surface of ependymal cells in all brain ventricles, where they contribute to the flow of cerebrospinal fluid. During development, monociliated ependymal progenitor cells differentiate into multiciliated ependymal cells, thus providing a simple system for studying the transition between these two stages. In this chapter, we provide protocols for immunofluorescence staining of developing ependymal cells in vivo, on whole mounts of lateral ventricle walls, and in vitro, on cultured ependymal cells. We also provide a list of markers we currently use to stain both types of cilia, including proteins at the ciliary membrane and tubulin posttranslational modifications of the axoneme.

Ciliary heterogeneity within a single cell: the Paramecium model

Paramecium is a single cell able to divide in its morphologically differentiated stage that has many cilia anchored at its cell surface. Many thousands of cilia are thus assembled in a short period of time during division to duplicate the cell pattern while the cell continues swimming. Most, but not all, of these sensory cilia are motile and involved in two main functions: prey capture and cell locomotion. These cilia display heterogeneity, both in their length and their biochemical properties. Thanks to these properties, as well as to the availability of many postgenomic tools and the possibility to follow the regrowth of cilia after deciliation, Paramecium offers a nice opportunity to study the assembly of the cilia, as well as the genesis of their diversity within a single cell. In this paper, after a brief survey of Paramecium morphology and cilia properties, we describe the tools and the protocols currently used for immunofluorescence, transmission electron microscopy, and ultrastructural immunocytochemistry to analyze cilia, with special recommendations to overcome the problem raised by cilium diversity.

The tubulin code: molecular components, readout mechanisms, and functions

Microtubules are cytoskeletal filaments that are dynamically assembled from α/β-tubulin heterodimers. The primary sequence and structure of the tubulin proteins and, consequently, the properties and architecture of microtubules are highly conserved in eukaryotes. Despite this conservation, tubulin is subject to heterogeneity that is generated in two ways: by the expression of different tubulin isotypes and by posttranslational modifications (PTMs). Identifying the mechanisms that generate and control tubulin heterogeneity and how this heterogeneity affects microtubule function are long-standing goals in the field. Recent work on tubulin PTMs has shed light on how these modifications could contribute to a “tubulin code” that coordinates the complex functions of microtubules in cells.

Intrinsically disordered tubulin tails: complex tuners of microtubule functions?

Microtubules are essential cellular polymers assembled from tubulin heterodimers. The tubulin dimer consists of a compact folded globular core and intrinsically disordered C-terminal tails. The tubulin tails form a lawn of densely grafted, negatively charged, flexible peptides on the exterior of the microtubule, potentially akin to brush polymers in the field of synthetic materials. These tails are hotspots for conserved, chemically complex posttranslational modifications that have the potential to act in a combinatorial fashion to regulate microtubule polymer dynamics and interactions with microtubule effectors, giving rise to a "tubulin code". In this review, I summarize our current knowledge of the enzymes that generate the astonishing tubulin chemical diversity observed in cells and describe recent advances in deciphering the roles of tubulin C-terminal tails and their posttranslational modifications in regulating the activity of molecular motors and microtubule associated proteins. Lastly, I outline the promises, challenges and potential pitfalls of deciphering the tubulin code.

Investigating tubulin posttranslational modifications with specific antibodies

Microtubules play highly diverse and essential roles in every eukaryotic cell. While built from conserved dimers of α- and β-tubulin, microtubules can be diversified by posttranslational modifications in order to fulfill specific functions in cells. The tubulin posttranslational modifications: acetylation, detyrosination, polyglutamylation, and polyglycylation play important roles in microtubule functions; however, only little functional and mechanistic insight has been gained so far. The modification state of microtubules can be visualized with specific antibodies. A drawback is that detailed information about the specificities and limitations of these antibodies are not easily accessible in the literature. We provide here a comprehensive description of the currently available set of antibodies specific to tubulin modifications. Focusing on glutamylation antibodies, we discuss specific protocols that allow using these antibodies to gain semi-quantitative information on the levels and distribution of tubulin modifications in immunocytochemistry and immunoblot.

The chemical complexity of cellular microtubules: tubulin post-translational modification enzymes and their roles in tuning microtubule functions

Cellular microtubules are marked by abundant and evolutionarily conserved post-translational modifications that have the potential to tune their functions. This review focuses on the astonishing chemical complexity introduced in the tubulin heterodimer at the post-translational level and summarizes the recent advances in identifying the enzymes responsible for these modifications and deciphering the consequences of tubulin's chemical diversity on the function of molecular motors and microtubule associated proteins.

Ciliary and flagellar structure and function--their regulations by posttranslational modifications of axonemal tubulin

Eukaryotic cilia and flagella are evolutionarily conserved microtubule-based organelles protruding from the cell surface. They perform dynein-driven beating which contributes to cell locomotion or flow generation. They also play important roles in sensing as cellular antennae, which allows cells to respond to various external stimuli. The main components of cilia and flagella, α- and β-tubulins, are known to undergo various posttranslational modifications (PTMs), including phosphorylation, palmitoylation, tyrosination/detyrosination, Δ2 modification, acetylation, glutamylation, and glycylation. Recent identification of tubulin-modifying enzymes, especially tubulin tyrosine ligase-like proteins which perform tubulin glutamylation and glycylation, has demonstrated the importance of tubulin modifications for the assembly and functions of cilia and flagella. In this chapter, we review recent work on PTMs of ciliary and flagellar tubulins in conjunction with discussing the basic knowledge.

Maintaining cell polarity through vegetative cell pattern dedifferentiation: cytoskeleton and morphogenesis in the hypotrich ciliate Sterkiella histriomuscorum

The morphological differentiation of ciliates is achieved through the development of a submembraneous cytoskeleton in which the cilia are anchored. In most hypotrich ciliates, this cytoskeleton is mainly constructed of microtubules. In these species, cells pass through vegetative cell pattern dedifferentiated stages during their biological cycle. In order to investigate the behaviour of the cytoskeleton during these stages, we analysed the reorganization of the cytoskeleton during the sexual cycle of Sterkiella histriomuscorum by microscopy. Sterkiella exconjugants transiently dedifferentiate to form zygocysts devoid of ciliature and infraciliature. Immunofluorescence images obtained with antibodies directed against pericentrosomal material and tubulin showed that the cells resorb their ciliature and basal bodies, but retain their submembraneous microtubular cytoskeleton during the whole process and that the body plan is maintained through vegetative cell pattern dedifferentiation: the cell polarity remains printed on the cell surface by the microtubular cytoskeleton which in turn could mark the sites of basal body assembly during zygocyst morphogenesis. The results are discussed in terms of mechanisms of cell patterning.

Evolutionary divergence of enzymatic mechanisms for posttranslational polyglycylation

Polyglycylation is a posttranslational modification that generates glycine side chains on proteins. Here we identify a family of evolutionarily conserved glycine ligases that modify tubulin using different enzymatic mechanisms. In mammals, two distinct enzyme types catalyze the initiation and elongation steps of polyglycylation, whereas Drosophila glycylases are bifunctional. We further show that the human elongating glycylase has lost enzymatic activity due to two amino acid changes, suggesting that the functions of protein glycylation could be sufficiently fulfilled by monoglycylation. Depletion of a glycylase in Drosophila using RNA interference results in adult flies with strongly decreased total glycylation levels and male sterility associated with defects in sperm individualization and axonemal maintenance. A more severe RNAi depletion is lethal at early developmental stages, indicating that protein glycylation is essential. Together with the observation that multiple proteins are glycylated, our functional data point towards a general role of glycylation in protein functions.

Mammalian cilia function is independent of the polymeric state of tubulin glycylation

Polyglycylation is a polymeric post-translational modification of tubulin that is ubiquitous and widely present in cilia and flagella. It consists of the addition of highly variable numbers of glycyl residues as side chains onto the gamma carboxyl group of specific glutamyl residues at the C-termini of alpha- and beta-tubulin. The function of polyglycylation is poorly understood, however, studies in Tetrahymena have shown that the mutation of polyglycylation sites in beta-tubulin resulted in axonemal abnormality or lethality. This suggests that polyglycylation is functionally essential in protists. We hypothesize that polyglycylation is also essential in mammalian cilia and that the extent of polyglycylation has functional significance. In this study, we examined polyglycylation states in ciliated tissues and in mouse tracheal epithelial cell cultures. We utilized two antibodies, TAP 952 and AXO 49, which recognize glutamyl sites possessing monomeric glycylation sites and glutamyl sites possessing polymeric glycylation sites, respectively. Monomeric glycylation sites were observed in cilia of all the ciliated tissues examined but were invariably excluded from the distal tips. In contrast, polymeric glycylation sites were rare, but when observed, they were localized at the bases of cilia. During ciliogenesis, in epithelial cell cultures, monomeric glycylation sites were observed, but the extent of polymeric glycylation sites were variable and were only observed during the early stages of the cultures. Our observations suggest that while monomeric glycylation sites are universal and likely essential in mammalian cilia, polymeric glycylation sites are not required for ciliary beating. Rather, our observations suggest that the number of added glycyl residues increases progressively from the tips of cilia toward their bases.

Ciliary tubulin and its post-translational modifications

Tubulin, the most abundant axonemal protein, is extensively modified by several highly conserved post-translational mechanisms including acetylation, detyrosination, glutamylation, and glycylation. We discuss the pathways that contribute to the assembly and maintenance of axonemal microtubules, with emphasis on the potential functions of post-translational modifications that affect tubulin. The recent identification of a number of tubulin modifying enzymes and mutational studies of modification sites on tubulin have allowed for significant functional insights. Polymeric modifications of tubulin (glutamylation and glycylation) have emerged as important determinants of the 9 + 2 axoneme assembly and motility.

Katanin regulates dynamics of microtubules and biogenesis of motile cilia

The in vivo significance of microtubule severing and the mechanisms governing its spatial regulation are not well understood. In Tetrahymena, a cell type with elaborate microtubule arrays, we engineered null mutations in subunits of the microtubule-severing complex, katanin. We show that katanin activity is essential. The net effect of katanin on the polymer mass depends on the microtubule type and location. Although katanin reduces the polymer mass and destabilizes the internal network of microtubules, its activity increases the mass of ciliary microtubules. We also show that katanin reduces the levels of several types of post-translational modifications on tubulin of internal and cortical microtubules. Furthermore, katanin deficiencies phenocopy a mutation of β-tubulin that prevents deposition of polymodifications (glutamylation and glycylation) on microtubules. We propose that katanin preferentially severs older, post-translationally modified segments of microtubules.

Back on track – On the role of the microtubule for kinesin motility and cellular function

The evolution of cytoskeletal filaments (actin- and intermediate-filaments, and the microtubules) and their associated motor- and non-motor-proteins has enabled the eukaryotic cell to achieve complex organizational and structural tasks. This ability to control cellular transport processes and structures allowed for the development of such complex cellular organelles like cilia or flagella in single-cell organisms and made possible the development and differentiation of multi-cellular organisms with highly specialized, polarized cells. Also, the faithful segregation of large amounts of genetic information during cell division relies crucially on the reorganization and control of the cytoskeleton, making the cytoskeleton a key prerequisite for the development of highly complex genomes. Therefore, it is not surprising that the eukaryotic cell continuously invests considerable resources in the establishment, maintenance, modification and rearrangement of the cytoskeletal filaments and the regulation of its interaction with accessory proteins. Here we review the literature on the interaction between microtubules and motor-proteins of the kinesin-family. Our particular interest is the role of the microtubule in the regulation of kinesin motility and cellular function. After an introduction of the kinesin-microtubule interaction we focus on two interrelated aspects: (1) the active allosteric participation of the microtubule during the interaction with kinesins in general and (2) the possible regulatory role of post-translational modifications of the microtubule in the kinesin-microtubule interaction.

Monoclonal Antibodies to Esophageal Cancer–Related Gene2 Protein

Esophageal cancer related gene2 (ECRG2) acts as a bi-functional gene associated with regulation of cell growth and death, and plays an important role in carcinogenesis of esophageal cancer. RT-PCR and Northern blot data showed that ECRG2 was expressed in normal esophagus, liver, colon, and lung tissues, but lost or greatly down-regulated in the adjacent and cancerous tissues, especially in esophageal cancer. However, studies of protein have been hampered by the lack of a sensitive and specific antibody. Here, we generated anti-ECRG2 monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) by using c-terminal of ECRG2 peptide as immunogen. Antibodies 8C9c53, 5E3c9, and 3C5c76, are suitable for detecting the ECRG2 on ELISA and Western blot assays, and 1E4c2 and 4B6c41 are suitable for immunofluorescence microscopy. The study also provides novel data about ECRG2 protein expression in the cytoplasm and the possibility of post-translation modification in mammalian cells. Based on these findings, it may be expected that anti-ECRG2 monoclonal antibodies will be valuable tools for research and diagnosis.

Polyglycylation domain of beta-tubulin maintains axonemal architecture and affects cytokinesis in Tetrahymena

Polyglycylation occurs through the post-translational addition of a polyglycine peptide to the gamma-carboxyl group of glutamic acids near the C terminus of alpha- and beta-tubulin, and has been found only in cells with axonemes, from protists to humans. In Tetrahymena thermophila, multiple sites of polyglycylation on alpha-tubulin are dispensable. By contrast, mutating similar sites on beta-tubulin has site-specific effects, affecting cell motility and cytokinesis, or resulting in cell death. Here, we address the lethality of a polyglycylation deficiency in T. thermophila using heterokaryons. Cells with a lethal mutation in the polyglycylation domain of beta-tubulin assembled axonemes that lack the central pair, B-subfibres and the transitional zone of outer microtubules (MTs). Furthermore, an arrest in cytokinesis occurred, and was associated with incomplete severing of cortical MTs positioned near the cleavage furrow. Thus, tubulin polyglycylation is required for the maintenance of some stable microtubular organelles that are all known to be polyglycylated in vivo, but its effects on MTs appear to be organelle-specific.

Tubulin polyglycylation in Platyhelminthes: diversity among stable microtubule networks and very late occurrence during spermiogenesis

The distribution of glycylated tubulin has been analyzed in different populations of stable microtubules in a digenean flatworm, Echinostoma caproni (Platyhelminthes). Two cellular types, spermatozoa and ciliated excretory cells, have been analyzed by means of immunofluorescence, immunogold, and immunoblotting techniques using two monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), AXO 49, and TAP 952, specifically directed against differently glycylated isoforms of tubulin. The presence of glycylated tubulin in the two cell types was shown. However, the differential reactivities of TAP 952 and AXO 49 mAbs with the two axoneme types suggest a difference in their glycylation level. In addition, within a single cell, the spermatozoon, cortical microtubules underlying the flagellar membrane, and axonemal microtubules were shown to comprise different tubulin isoforms, the latter ones only being labelled with one of the antiglycylated tubulin mAbs, TAP 952. Similarly, the antiacetylated (6-11B-1) and polyglutamylated (GT335) tubulin mAbs decorated the two types of axonemal microtubules, but not the cortical ones. From these data, a subcellular sorting of posttranslationally modified tubulin isoforms within spermatozoa, on the one hand, and a cellular sorting of glycylated isoforms inside the whole organism, on the other hand, is demonstrated in the flatworm E. caproni. Last, a sequential occurrence of tubulin posttranslational modifications was observed in the course of spermiogenesis. Acetylation appears first, followed shortly by glutamylation; glycylation takes place at the extreme end of spermiogenesis and, specifically, in a proximo-distal process. Thus in agreement with, and extending other studies [Bré et al., 1996], glycylation appears to close the sequence of posttranslational events occurring in axonemal microtubules during spermiogenesis.

Glutamylation of centriole and cytoplasmic tubulin in proliferating non-neuronal cells

We have examined the distribution of glutamylated tubulin in non-neuronal cell lines. A major part of centriole tubulin is highly modified on both the alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits, whereas a minor part of the cytoplasmic tubulin is slightly modified, on the beta-tubulin only. Furthermore, we observed that tubulin glutamylation varies during the cell cycle: an increase occurs during mitosis on both centriole and spindle microtubules. In the spindle, this increase appears more obvious on the pole-to-pole and kinetochore microtubules than on the astral microtubules. The cellular pattern and the temporal variation of this post-translational modification contrast with other previously described tubulin modifications. The functional significance of this distribution is discussed.

Polyglycylation of tubulin is essential and affects cell motility and division in Tetrahymena thermophila

We analyzed the role of tubulin polyglycylation in Tetrahymena thermophila using in vivo mutagenesis and immunochemical analysis with modification-specific antibodies. Three and five polyglycylation sites were identified at glutamic acids near the COOH termini of alpha- and beta-tubulin, respectively. Mutants lacking all polyglycylation sites on alpha-tubulin have normal phenotype, whereas similar sites on beta-tubulin are essential. A viable mutant with three mutated sites in beta-tubulin showed reduced tubulin glycylation, slow growth and motility, and defects in cytokinesis. Cells in which all five polyglycylation sites on beta-tubulin were mutated were viable if they were cotransformed with an alpha-tubulin gene whose COOH terminus was replaced by the wild-type COOH terminus of beta-tubulin. In this double mutant, beta-tubulin lacked detectable polyglycylation, while the alpha-beta tubulin chimera was hyperglycylated compared with alpha-tubulin in wild-type cells. Thus, the essential function of polyglycylation of the COOH terminus of beta-tubulin can be transferred to alpha-tubulin, indicating it is the total amount of polyglycylation on both alpha- and beta-tubulin that is essential for survival.

Molecular mechanisms of microtubular organelle assembly in Tetrahymena

Thanks to recent technological advances, the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila has emerged as an attractive model organism for studies on the assembly of microtubular organelles in a single cell. Tetrahymena assembles 17 types of distinct microtubules, which are localized in cilia, cell cortex, nuclei, and the endoplasm. These diverse microtubules have distinct morphologies, stabilities, and associations with specific Microtubule-Associated Proteins. For example, kinesin-111, a microtubular motor protein, is required for assembly of cilia and is preferentially targeted to microtubules of actively assembled, immature cilia. It is unlikely that the unique properties of individual microtubules are derived from the utilization of diverse tubulin genes, because Tetrahymena expresses only a single isotype of alpha- and two isotypes of 1-tubulin. However, Tetrahymena tubulins are modified secondarily by a host of posttranslational mechanisms. Each microtubule organelle type displays a unique set of secondary tubulin modifications. The results of systematic in vivo mutational analyses of modification sites indicate a divergence in significance among post-translational mechanisms affecting either alpha- or beta-tubulin. Both acetylation and polyglycylation of alpha-tubulin are not essential and their complete elimination does not change the cell's phenotype in an appreciable way. However, the multiple polyglycylation sites on 1-tubulin are essential for survival, and their partial elimination dramatically affects cell motility, growth and morphology. Thus, both high-precision targeting of molecular motors to individual organelles as well as organelle-specific tubulin modifications contribute to the creation of diverse microtubules in a single cytoplasm of Tetrahymena.

Polyglutamylation and polyglycylation of alpha- and beta-tubulins during in vitro ciliated cell differentiation of human respiratory epithelial cells

Tubulins are the major proteins within centriolar and axonemal structures. In all cell types studied so far, numerous alpha- and beta-tubulin isoforms are generated both by expression of a multigenic family and various post-translational modifications. We have developed a primary culture of human nasal epithelial cells where the ciliated cell differentiation process has been observed and quantified. We have used this system to study several properties concerning polyglutamylation and polyglycylation of tubulin. GT335, a monoclonal antibody directed against glutamylated tubulins, stained the centriole/basal bodies and the axonemes of ciliated cells, and the centrioles of non-ciliated cells. By contrast, axonemal but not centriolar tubulins were polyglycylated. Several polyglutamylated and polyglycylated tubulin isotypes were detected by two-dimensional electrophoresis, using GT335 and a specific monoclonal antibody (TAP952) directed against short polyglycyl chains. Immunoelectron microscopy experiments revealed that polyglycylation only affected axonemal tubulin. Using the same technical approach, polyglutamylation was shown to be an early event in the centriole assembly process, as gold particles were detected in fibrogranular material corresponding to the first cytoplasmic structures involved in centriologenesis. In a functional assay, GT335 and TAP952 had a dose-dependent inhibitory effect on ciliary beat frequency. TAP952 had only a weak effect while GT335 treatment led to a total arrest of beating. These results strongly suggest that in human ciliated epithelial cells, tubulin polyglycylation has only a structural role in cilia axonemes, while polyglutamylation may have a function both in centriole assembly and in cilia activity.

Evidence for a mouse brain-specific variant of alpha-tubulin

While studying the neural precursor cell intermediate filament protein known as nestin in the developing mouse brain, we observed a strong cross-reaction of our nestin antibody with a 50 kDa protein that appeared on embryonic day 10 and continued to accumulate until postnatal day 1. Here we report evidence that this protein is a brain-specific variant form of alpha-tubulin and discuss its implications.

Microtubule polyglutamylation in Drosophila melanogaster brain and testis

The presence of glutamylated tubulin, a widespread posttranslational modification of alpha- and beta-tubulin, has been investigated in Drosophila melanogaster using the specific monoclonal antibody GT335. We show here that this modification is strongly detected in brain and testis whereas other tissues analyzed did not appear to contain any glutamylated isoforms. Neuronal microtubules are glutamylated on alpha-tubulin only whereas sperm flagella showed a strong modification of both alpha- and beta-tubulin. These results argue for an essential role for glutamylation in differentiation processes that require microtubule stabilization.

Structural characterization by tandem mass spectrometry of the posttranslational polyglycylation of tubulin

Polyglycylation is a posttranslational modification specific to tubulin. This modification was originally identified in highly stable microtubules from Paramecium cilia. As many as 34 posttranslationally added glycine residues have been located in the C-terminal domains of Paramecium alpha- and beta-tubulin. In this study, post source decay matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (PSD MALDI MS) and electrospray ionization on a hybrid quadrupole orthogonal time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer (ESI Q-TOF MS/MS) were both used to demonstrate that a single molecule of beta-tubulin, from either dynamic cytoplasmic microtubules or stable axonemal microtubules, can be glycylated on each of the last four C-terminal glutamate residues Glu437, Glu438, Glu439, and Glu441 in the sequence 427DATAEEEGEFEEEGEQ442. In both dynamic and stable microtubules the most abundant beta-tubulin isoform contains six posttranslationally added glycine residues: two glycine residues on both Glu437 and Glu438 and one glycine residue on both Glu439 and Glu441. The number and relative abundance of glycylated isoforms of beta-tubulin in both cytoplasmic and axonemal microtubules were compared by MALDI MS.1 The abundance of the major glycylated isoforms in axonemal tubulin decreases regularly with glycylation levels from 6 to 19 whereas it drops abruptly in cytoplasmic tubulin with glycylation levels from 6 to 9. However, the polyglycine chains are similarly distributed on the four C-terminal glutamate residues of cytoplasmic and axonemal tubulin. The polyglycylation results in bulky C-terminal domains with negatively charged surfaces, all surrounding the microtubular structure.

Tubulin polyglycylation: differential posttranslational modification of dynamic cytoplasmic and stable axonemal microtubules in paramecium

Polyglycylation, a posttranslational modification of tubulin, was discovered in the highly stable axonemal microtubules of Paramecium cilia where it involves the lateral linkage of up to 34 glycine units per tubulin subunit. The observation of this type of posttranslational modification mainly in axonemes raises the question as to its relationship with axonemal organization and with microtubule stability. This led us to investigate the glycylation status of cytoplasmic microtubules that correspond to the dynamic microtubules in Paramecium. Two anti-glycylated tubulin monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), TAP 952 and AXO 49, are shown here to exhibit different affinities toward mono- and polyglycylated synthetic tubulin peptides. Using immunoblotting and mass spectrometry, we show that cytoplasmic tubulin is glycylated. In contrast to the highly glycylated axonemal tubulin, which is recognized by the two mAbs, cytoplasmic tubulin reacts exclusively with TAP 952, and the alpha- and beta- tubulin subunits are modified by only 1-5 and 2-9 glycine units, respectively. Our analyses suggest that most of the cytoplasmic tubulin contains side chain lengths of 1 or 2 glycine units distributed on several glycylation sites. The subcellular partition of distinct polyglycylated tubulin isoforms between cytoplasmic and axonemal compartments implies the existence of regulatory mechanisms for glycylation. By following axonemal tubulin immunoreactivity with anti-glycylated tubulin mAbs upon incubation with a Paramecium cellular extract, the presence of a deglycylation enzyme is revealed in the cytoplasm of this organism. These observations establish that polyglycylation is reversible and indicate that, in vivo, an equilibrium between glycylating and deglycylating enzymes might be responsible for the length of the oligoglycine side chains of tubulin.

The microtubular system and posttranslationally modified tubulin during spermatogenesis in a parasitic nematode with amoeboid and aflagellate spermatozoa

Using transmission electron microscopy and immunologic approaches with various antibodies against general tubulin and posttranslationally modified tubulin, we investigated microtubule organization during spermatogenesis in Heligmosomoides polygyrus, a species in which a conspicuous but transient microtubular system exists in several forms: a cytoplasmic network in the spermatocyte, the meiotic spindle, a perinuclear network and a longitudinal bundle of microtubules in the spermatid. This pattern differs from most nematodes including Caenorhabditis elegans, in which spermatids have not microtubules. In the spermatozoon of H. polygyrus, immunocytochemistry does not detect tubulin, but electron microscopy reveals two centrioles with a unique structure of 10 singlets. In male germ cells, microtubules are probably involved in cell shaping and positioning of organelles but not in cell motility. In all transient tubulin structures described in spermatocytes and spermatids of H. polygyrus, detyrosination, tyrosination, and polyglutamylation were detected, but acetylation and polyglycylation were not. The presence/absence of these posttranslational modifications is apparently not stage dependent. This is the first study of posttranslationally modified tubulin in nematode spermatogenesis.

The axonemal microtubules of the Chlamydomonas flagellum differ in tubulin isoform content

Little is known of the molecular basis for the diversity of microtubule structure and function found within the eukaryotic flagellum. Antibodies that discriminate between tyrosinated alpha tubulin and post-translationally detyrosinated alpha tubulin were used to localize these complementary tubulin isoforms in flagella of the single-celled green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Immunofluorescence analysis of intact axonemes detected both isoforms along most of the lengths of flagella; however, each had a short distal zone rich in tyrosinated tubulin. Localizations on splayed axonemes revealed that the microtubules of the central-pair apparatus were rich in tyrosinated tubulin, while outer doublets contained a mixture of both isoforms. Immunoelectron analysis of individual outer doublets revealed that while tyrosinated tubulin was present in both A and B tubules, detyrosinated tubulin was largely confined to the wall of the B hemi-tubules. The absence of detyrosinated tubulin from the A tubules of the outer doublets and the microtubules of the central pair, both of which extend past the B hemi-tubules of the outer doublets in the flagellar tip, explained the appearance of a tyrosinated tubulin-rich distal zone on intact axonemes. Localizations performed on cells regenerating flagella revealed that flagellar assembly used tyrosinated tubulin; detyrosination of the B tubule occurred during later stages of regeneration, well after microtubule polymerization. The developmental timing of detyrosination, which occurs over a period during which the regrowing flagella begin to beat more effectively, suggests that post-translational modification of the B tubule surface may enhance dynein/B tubule interactions that power flagellar beating.

Multiple forms of tubulin: different gene products and covalent modifications

Tubulin, the subunit protein of microtubules, is an alpha/beta heterodimer. In many organisms, both alpha and beta exist in numerous isotypic forms encoded by different genes. In addition, both alpha and beta undergo a variety of posttranslational covalent modifications, including acetylation, phosphorylation, detyrosylation, polyglutamylation, and polyglycylation. In this review the distribution and possible functional significance of the various forms of tubulin are discussed. In analyzing the differences among tubulin isotypes encoded by different genes, some appear to have no functional significance, some increase the overall adaptability of the organism to environmental challenges, and some appear to perform specific functions including formation of particular organelles and interactions with specific proteins. Purified isotypes also display different properties in vitro. Although the significance of all the covalent modification of tubulin is not fully understood, some of them may influence the stability of modified microtubules in vivo as well as interactions with certain proteins and may help to determine the functional role of microtubules in the cell. The review also discusses isotypes of gamma-tubulin and puts various forms of tubulin in an evolutionary context.

Posttranslational modifications of alpha- and beta-tubulin in Giardia lamblia, an ancient eukaryote

Tubulin of Giardia lamblia, a representative of the oldest eukaryotes, was screened for posttranslational modifications. Mass spectrometry of the carboxy-terminal peptides documents a large number of variants. Both alpha- and beta-tubulin show polyglycylation with up to 20 and 15 extra glycyl residues respectively. Minor variants show a low level of glutamylation without or with glycylation. The glutamylation-specific antibody GT335 detects alpha- and beta-tubulin in immunoblots. The terminal tyrosine is fully retained in alpha-tubulin, which is completely acetylated at Lys-40. Thus except for the detyrosination/tyrosination cycle all posttranslational modifications known for higher eukaryotes are already present in Giardia.

A specific alpha-tubulin is associated with the initiation of parthenogenesis in 'Salmon' wheat lines

The 'Salmon system' consists of isogenic but alloplasmic wheat lines with either sexual or autonomous embryo development. Using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis these lines have been screened for proteins potentially involved in the initiation of parthenogenesis. A temporally altered expression of the polypeptide 'P 115.1' in the sexual and parthenogenetic 'Salmon' lines seems to be related with the autonomous embryo formation. Around anthesis when most of the egg cells begin the parthenogenetic development, the polypeptide 'P 115.1' was present in ovaries of the parthenogenetic lines but not in ovaries of the sexual line. Moreover, this polypeptide is only expressed in the ovaries of amphidiploid parthenogenetic plants containing differentiated embryo sacs. It is absent from ovaries of the analogous polyhaploid plants, which lack any embryo sac structure within their ovules. Furthermore, the polypeptide was neither detectable in meristematic tissue of root tips nor in leaves. N-terminal amino acid sequencing identified 'P 115.1' as an alpha-tubulin. Thus, 'P 115.1' apparently represents an embryo sac-specific isoform of alpha-tubulin involved in the initiation of embryo development.

Tubulin tyrosine ligase: protein and mRNA expression in developing rat skeletal muscle

Alpha tubulin can be post-translationally tyrosinated at the carboxy-terminus by a specific enzyme: tubulin tyrosine ligase. The expression of tubulin tyrosine ligase mRNA and protein during the development of rat skeletal muscle was examined in the present study. A portion of the coding region of the rat ligase cDNA was isolated and sequenced. The nucleotide and amino acid sequences showed about 90% homology with previously reported porcine and bovine ligase sequences. In newborn rats, ligase mRNA and protein were highly expressed in skeletal muscle. During early postnatal development, however, both ligase mRNA and protein dropped down dramatically. Quantitative measurements revealed that ligase protein at postnatal day 20 represented only 10% or less of the level at postnatal day 1. Ligase mRNA expression was also examined during the myogenesis in vitro. A strong ligase mRNA signal was detected in both undifferentiated myoblasts and cross-striated, contractile myotubes. The present results suggest that, during muscle differentiation, ligase function may be regulated by the amount of available mRNA. The discrepancy in the ligase expression between the in vivo and in vitro myogenesis suggests that factors controlling the levels of mRNA in vivo are lost in vitro.

Tubulin post-translational modifications--enzymes and their mechanisms of action

This review describes the enzymes responsible for the post-translational modifications of tubulin, including detyrosination/tyrosination, acetylation/deacetylation, phosphorylation, polyglutamylation, polyglycylation and the generation of non-tyrosinatable alpha-tubulin. Tubulin tyrosine-ligase, which reattaches tyrosine to detyrosinated tubulin, has been extensively characterized and its gene sequenced. Enzymes such as tubulin-specific carboxypeptidase and alpha-tubulin acetyltransferase, required, respectively, for detyrosination and acetylation of tubulin, have yet to be purified to homogeneity and examined in defined systems. This has produced some conflicting results, especially for the carboxypeptidase. The phosphorylation of tubulin by several different types of kinases has been studied in detail but drawing conclusions is difficult because many of these enzymes modify proteins other than their actual substrates, an especially pertinent consideration for in vitro experiments. Tubulin phosphorylation in cultured neuronal cells has proven to be the best model for evaluation of kinase effects on tubulin/microtubule function. There is little information on the enzymes required for polyglutamylation, polyglycylation, and production of non-tyrosinatable tubulin, but the available data permit interesting speculation of a mechanistic nature. Clearly, to achieve a full appreciation of tubulin post-translational changes the responsible enzymes must be characterized. Knowing when the enzymes are active in cells, if soluble or polymerized tubulin is the preferred substrate and the amino acid residues modified by each enzyme are all important. Moreover, acquisition of purified enzymes will lead to cloning and sequencing of their genes. With this information, one can manipulate cell genomes in order to either modify key enzymes or change their relative amounts, and perhaps reveal the physiological significance of tubulin post-translational modifications.

Axonemal tubulin polyglycylation probed with two monoclonal antibodies: widespread evolutionary distribution, appearance during spermatozoan maturation and possible function in motility

Two monoclonal antibodies, AXO 49 and TAP 952, probed with carboxy-terminal peptides from Paramecium axonemal tubulin and with polyglycylated synthetic peptides, are found to recognize differently tubulin polyglycylation, the most recently identified posttranslational modification discovered in Paramecium axonemal tubulin. With these antibodies, we show that tubulin polyglycylation is widely distributed in organisms ranging from ciliated protozoa to mammals; it arose early in the course of evolution, but seems to be absent in primitive protozoa such as the Euglenozoa. Tubulin polyglycylation is the last posttranslational modification which takes place in the course of Drosophila spermatogenesis and its occurrence corresponds to the end of spermatozoan maturation. An involvement of polyglycylated tubulin in axoneme motility is suggested since AXO 49 and TAP 952 specifically inhibit the reactivated motility of sea urchin spermatozoa.