Attribution and expression of incentive salience are differentially signaled by ultrasonic vocalizations in rats

Distinct acute stressors exert an antagonistic effect on complex grooming during novelty habituation in rats

Grooming is a common readout in multiple rat models of neuropsychiatric diseases. It is usually associated with distress and negative emotionality, but also with emotional de-arousal after stress. These seemingly conflicting interpretations may result from specific grooming sequences appearing at different arousal levels and during distinct phases of the stress response. To further explore this hypothesis, we analyzed how distinct stressors affect grooming syntaxis and kinetics. To that end, we explored the independent and interacting effects of foot shocks, corticosterone (CORT), and novelty on exploratory activity, grooming, and ultrasonic vocalizations (USVs) in an open-field test (OF). Wistar rats were intraperitoneally injected either with vehicle or CORT, placed in a chamber where half of them were foot-shocked and then assessed in the OF. The next day, animals were re-exposed to the shock chamber and then tested in the OF without receiving any treatment. On day 1, foot shocks and -to a less extent CORT- increased freezing and inhibited rearing in the chamber, but only foot shocks increased distress USVs. In the OF, both treatments suppressed complex grooming, with foot-shocks also inhibiting exploration and CORT marginally reducing rearing. On day 2, foot-shocked rats showed conditioned fear when re-exposed to the chamber. When tested in the OF, foot-shocked and CORT-treated animals still showed low levels of complex grooming, with the former group also showing increased distress USVs. In this study, all different stressors inhibited complex grooming, suggesting an inverse association between these grooming subtypes and negative emotionality.

Appetitive 50 kHz calls in a pavlovian conditioned approach task in Cacna1c haploinsufficient rats

We have previously shown that rats emit high-frequency 50 kHz ultrasonic vocalizations (USV) during sign- and goal-tracking in a common Pavlovian conditioned approach task. Such 50 kHz calls are probably related to positive affect and are associated with meso-limbic dopamine function. In humans, the CACNA1C gene, encoding for the α_1C subunit of the L-type voltage-gated calcium channel Ca_V1.2, is implicated in several mental disorders, including mood disorders associated with altered dopamine signaling. In the present study, we investigated sign- and goal-tracking behavior and the emission of 50 kHz USV in Cacna1c haploinsufficent rats in a task where food pellet delivery is signaled by an appearance of an otherwise inoperable lever. Over the course of this Pavlovian training, these rats not only increased their approach to the reward site, but also their rates of pressing the inoperable lever. During subsequent extinction tests, where reward delivery was omitted, extinction patterns differed between reward site (i.e. magazine entries) and lever, since magazine entries quickly declined whereas behavior towards the lever transiently increased. Based on established criteria to define sign- or goal-tracking individuals, no CACNA1C rat met a sign-tracking criterion, since around 42% of rats tested where goal-trackers and the other 58% fell into an intermediate range. Regarding USV, we found that the CACNA1C rats emitted 50 kHz calls with a clear subject-dependent pattern; also, most of them were of a flat subtype and occurred mainly during initial habituation phases without cues or rewards. Compared, to previously published wildtype controls, Cacna1c haploinsufficent rats displayed reduced numbers of appetitive 50 kHz calls. Moreover, similar to wildtype littermate controls, 50 kHz call emission in Cacna1c haploinsufficent rats was intra-individually stable over training days and was negatively associated with goal-tracking. Together, these findings provide evidence in support of 50 kHz calls as trait marker. The finding that Cacna1c haploinsufficent rats show reductions of 50 kHz calls accompanied with more goal-tracking, is consistent with the assumption of altered dopamine signaling in these rats, a finding which supports their applicability in models of mental disorders.

Muscarinic regulation of self-grooming behavior and ultrasonic vocalizations in the context of open-field habituation in rats

Laboratory rats repeatedly exposed to an open field (OF) apparatus display increasingly high levels of grooming -especially that characterized by long and complex sequences- which has been taken as an additional index of novelty habituation. We hypothesized that disrupting such a learning process by administering an amnesic drug as the antimuscarinic scopolamine (SCP) could delay the appearance of more complex grooming subtypes. Thus, rats were pretreated either with SCP (15 mg/kg or 30 mg/kg) or vehicle (VEH) upon four one-day apart OF (OF1-4). On a fifth assessment, all rats received VEH to analyze the likely carry-over effect of SCP. Finally, we measured 50-kHz and 22-kHz ultrasonic vocalizations (USVs) as reliable markers of positive and negative emotionality, respectively. We found that SCP increased locomotion during OF1 and reduced rearing on OF1-OF4, causing no disruption in habituation over tests. SCP prevented the increase of total grooming time by inhibiting complex grooming subtypes and promoting short cephalic sequences. Despite the SCP-induced alterations on grooming agreed with our hypotheses, those changes may have resulted from a motor impairment that could have also affected rearing behavior. Additionally, SCP suppressed 50-kHz USVs while marginally increased 22-kHz calls. Once SCP was withdrawn, rearing, grooming, and some 50-kHz USVs subtypes returned to VEH levels, suggesting that novelty habituation occurred despite the SCP administration. Altogether, that mixed profile of SCP-induced behavioral changes may derive from the complex interplay between the contrasting action of SCP on different brain regions and the doses here used.

Rat 50 kHz Trill Calls Are Tied to the Expectation of Social Interaction

Rats emit a variety of calls in the 40–80 kHz range (50 kHz calls). While these calls are generally associated with positive affect, it is unclear whether certain calls might be used selectively in certain contexts. To examine this, we looked at ultrasonic calls in 30–40 day old male rats during the expectation of either play or food, both of which are reinforcing. Behavior and vocalizations were recorded while rats were in a test chamber awaiting the arrival of a play partner or food over seven days of testing. Control groups were included for the non-specific effects of food deprivation and social isolation. Play reward led to an increase in 50 kHz vocalizations, generally, with specific increases in trill and “trill with jump” calls not seen in other groups. Expectation of food reward did not lead to a significant increase in vocalizations of any type, perhaps due to the young age of our study group. Further, rats that were food deprived for the food expectation study showed markedly lower calls overall and had a different profile of call types compared to rats that were socially isolated. Taken together, the results suggest that trill-associated calls may be used selectively when rats are socially isolated and/or expecting a social encounter.

Distinct Profiles of 50 kHz Vocalizations Differentiate Between Social Versus Non-social Reward Approach and Consumption

Social animals tend to possess an elaborate vocal communication repertoire, and rats are no exception. Rats utilize ultrasonic vocalizations (USVs) to communicate information about a wide range of socially relevant cues, as well as information regarding the valence of the behavior and/or surrounding environment. Both quantitative and qualitative acoustic properties of these USVs are thought to communicate context-specific information to conspecifics. Rat USVs have been broadly categorized into 22 and 50 kHz call categories, which can be further classified into subtypes based on their sonographic features. Recent research indicates that the 50 kHz calls and their various subtype profiles may be related to the processing of social and non-social rewards. However, only a handful of studies have investigated USV elicitation in the context of both social and non-social rewards. Here, we employ a novel behavioral paradigm, the social-sucrose preference test, that allowed us to measure rats’ vocal responses to both non-social (i.e., 2, 5, and 10% sucrose) and social reward (interact with a Juvenile rat), presented concurrently. We analyzed adult male Long-Evans rats’ vocal responses toward social and non-social rewards, with a specific focus on 50 kHz calls and their 14 subtypes. We demonstrate that rats’ preference and their vocal responses toward a social reward were both influenced by the concentration of the non-social reward in the maze. In other words, rats showed a trade-off between time spent with non-social or social stimuli along with increasing concentrations of sucrose, and also, we found a clear difference in the emission of flat and frequency-modulated calls in the social and non-social reward zones. Furthermore, we report that the proportion of individual subtypes of 50 kHz calls, as well as the total USV counts, showed variation across different types of rewards as well. Our findings provide a thorough overview of rat vocal responses toward non-social and social rewards and are a clear depiction of the variability in the rat vocalization repertoire, establishing the role of call subtypes as key players driving context-specific vocal responses of rats.

Biological Functions of Rat Ultrasonic Vocalizations, Arousal Mechanisms, and Call Initiation

This review summarizes all reported and suspected functions of ultrasonic vocalizations in infant and adult rats. The review leads to the conclusion that all types of ultrasonic vocalizations subserving all functions are vocal expressions of emotional arousal initiated by the activity of the reticular core of the brainstem. The emotional arousal is dichotomic in nature and is initiated by two opposite-in-function ascending reticular systems that are separate from the cognitive reticular activating system. The mesolimbic cholinergic system initiates the aversive state of anxiety with concomitant emission of 22 kHz calls, while the mesolimbic dopaminergic system initiates the appetitive state of hedonia with concomitant emission of 50 kHz vocalizations. These two mutually exclusive arousal systems prepare the animal for two different behavioral outcomes. The transition from broadband infant isolation calls to the well-structured adult types of vocalizations is explained, and the social importance of adult rat vocal communication is emphasized. The association of 22 kHz and 50 kHz vocalizations with aversive and appetitive states, respectively, was utilized in numerous quantitatively measured preclinical models of physiological, psychological, neurological, neuropsychiatric, and neurodevelopmental investigations. The present review should help in understanding and the interpretation of these models in biomedical research.

The cage test as an easy way to screen and evaluate spontaneous activity in preclinical neuroscience studies

Within behavioral neuroscience, subjects used to be randomly assigned to the experimental groups based on the premise that interindividual variability will be homogeneously distributed. However, the equivalence offered by randomization diminishes in small samples, which is the case for most experiments in the field. In rodents, it is well-recognized that individual differences in psychomotor reactivity, risk-assessment behaviors, and emotional responsiveness modulate the effects of different pharmacological and non-pharmacological treatments. For that reason, knowing such differences before the experiment provides highly valuable information for balancing the groups so that the interindividual variability is equally distributed within the groups without excluding subjects as far as possible. Because unconditioned anxiety tests such as the open-field (OF) and the elevated plus-maze are commonly used within experimental procedures, we developed a strategy to explore the rat's behavioral phenotype by assessing it in a very innocuous testing context: a housing cage.•We offer a very straightforward protocol for assessing spontaneous, novelty-induced reactivity in rodents.•We describe its implementation, analysis, and use, as well as some suggestions about key behavioral readouts for the group allocation procedure.•The current protocol provides an alternative strategy to assess a reasonably wide range of behavioral outcomes, most of which are of great interest in modeling different neuropsychiatric disorders.

Ultrasonic vocalizations and individual differences in rats performing a Pavlovian conditioned approach task

Rats emit distinct types of ultrasonic vocalizations (USV), including high-frequency 50-kHz USV, which occur in appetitive situations. Such 50-kHz USV are thought to reflect positive affective states, for example in case of reward anticipation, and are linked to dopamine signaling. The present study was conducted to investigate whether rats emit 50-kHz USV during a Pavlovian conditioned approach task and whether trait-like differences in 50-kHz USV emission are associated with sign- versus goal-tracking. We hypothesize that individuals engaging more with a cue predicting a food reward will also elicit more 50-kHz USV. In order to test this, we investigated 34 female rats and gauged USV while they underwent a Pavlovian conditioned approach training and extinction paradigm. For one, we found a high subject-dependent variability in the emission of 50-kHz calls. These were not largely affected by state differences, since these 50-kHz USV were observed throughout the task. During task progress and in most subjects, there was a rather complete shift toward goal-tracking, but subjects engaging more with the cue predicting a reward also emitted higher numbers of appetitive 50-kHz calls. This supports the hypothesis that sign-tracking is positively associated with the emission of 50-kHz USV. The high subject-dependent variability in the emission of 50-kHz calls warrants special attention in future appetitive studies.

Acute stress differentially affects grooming subtypes and ultrasonic vocalisations in the open-field and home-cage test in rats

Grooming behaviour in rodents has been associated with emotional distress, especially in unfamiliar and aversive contexts. However, the biological function of grooming in such situations is still unclear. We hypothesised that particular grooming subtypes are differentially associated with the stress response. Here, we investigated the effects of an acute stress exposure on grooming and ultrasonic vocalisations (USVs) assessed on different testing contexts varying in the level of familiarity. To this aim, footshocked and non-footshocked rats were tested for 20 min on one of the following conditions: an unfamiliar open-field test, a familiar open-field test, and an individual home cage filled with bedding. We found that footshock stress slightly decreased complex grooming sequences while increased cephalic grooming. Stress induced a negative affective state inferred from an increase and decrease of 22-kHz and 50-kHz calls, respectively. The latter USVs correlated positively with the complex grooming subtypes. Altogether, a detailed analysis of grooming seems necessary for elucidating its diverse biological functions. Nevertheless, footshock stress and testing conditions produced weaker-than-expected effects, possibly because the time elapsed between footshocks and behavioural testing was too short for eliciting a full stress response, and because the simple footshock-chamber experience may have impeded detecting stronger effects of familiarity.

Neurobehavioral Effects of Restricted and Unpredictable Environmental Enrichment in Rats

To study how motivational factors modulate experience-dependent neurobehavioral plasticity, we modify a protocol of environmental enrichment (EE) in rats. We assumed that the benefits derived from EE might vary according to the level of incentive salience attributed to it. To enhance the rewarding properties of EE, access to the EE cage varied randomly from 2 to 48 h for 30 days (REE). The REE group was enriched only 50% of the time and was compared to standard housing and continuous EE (CEE) groups. As behavioral readout, we analyzed the spontaneous activity and the ultrasonic vocalizations (USVs) within the EE cage weekly, and in the open field test at the end of the experiment. In the cage, REE increased the utilization of materials, physical activity, and the rate of appetitive USVs. In the OF, the CEE-induced enhancements in novelty habituation and social signaling were equaled by the REE. At the neural level, we measured the expression of genes related to neural plasticity and epigenetic regulations in different brain regions. In the dorsal striatum and hippocampus, REE upregulated the expression of the brain-derived neurotrophic factor, its tropomyosin kinase B receptor, and the DNA methyltransferase 3A. Altogether, our results suggest that the higher activity within the cage and the augmented incentive motivation provoked by the REE boosted its neurobehavioral effects equaling or surpassing those observed in the CEE condition. As constant exposures to treatments or stimulating environments are virtually impossible for humans, restricted EE protocols would have greater translational value than traditional ones.

Odour conditioning of positive affective states: Rats can learn to associate an odour with being tickled

Most associative learning tests in rodents use negative stimuli, such as electric shocks. We investigated if young rats can learn to associate the presence of an odour with the experience of being tickled (i.e. using an experimenter’s hand to mimic rough-and-tumble play), shown to elicit 50 kHz ultrasonic vocalisations (USVs), which are indicative of positive affect. Male, pair-housed Wistar rats (N = 24) were all exposed to two neutral odours (A and B) presented in a perforated container on alternate days in a test arena. Following 60s of exposure, the rats were either tickled on days when odour A (n = 8) or odour B (n = 8) was present, or never tickled (n = 8). When tickled, rats produced significantly more 50 kHz USVs compared to the days when not being tickled, and compared to control rats. The level of anticipatory 50 kHz USVs in the 60s prior to tickling did not differ significantly between the tickled and control rats. As a retrieval test following the odour conditioning, rats were exposed successively in the same arena to three odours: an unknown neutral odour, extract of fox faeces, and either odours A or B. Compared to controls, 50 kHz USVs of tickled rats increased when exposed to the odour they had previously experienced when tickled, indicating that these rats had learned to associate the odour with the positive experience of being tickled. In a test with free access for 5 min to both arms of a T-maze, each containing one of the odours, rats tickled with odour A spent more time in the arm with this odour. This work is the first to test in a fully balanced design whether rats can learn to associate an odour with tickling, and indicates that positive odour conditioning has potential to be used as an alternative to negative conditioning tests.

Diazepam blocks 50 kHz ultrasonic vocalizations and stereotypies but not the increase in locomotor activity induced in rats by amphetamine

RATIONALE

We have recently shown that the benzodiazepine diazepam inhibits dopamine release in the NAc and blocks the increased release of dopamine induced by DL-amphetamine. Rewarding stimuli and many drugs of abuse can induce dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens as well as 50-kHz ultrasonic vocalizations (USVs) in rats.

OBJECTIVES

In the present study, we tested the hypothesis that diazepam can also block the increase in locomotor activity and USVs elicited by amphetamine.

METHODS

Fifty-kilohertz USVs, stereotypy, and locomotor behavior were scored in adult male Wistar rats treated with i.p. injections of saline, 3 mg/kg DL-amphetamine, 2 mg/kg diazepam, 0.2 mg/kg haloperidol, or a combination of these drugs.

RESULTS

In agreement with previous studies, amphetamine caused significant increases in the number of USV calls, stereotypies, and locomotor activity. The D2 dopamine receptor antagonist haloperidol blocked the effects of amphetamine on USVs, stereotypy, and locomotor activity. Diazepam blocked the effect of amphetamine on USV and stereotypy, but not on horizontal locomotion.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that diazepam blocks the rewarding effect of amphetamine. This finding is promising for basic research regarding treatments of substance use disorders and evaluation of the impact of benzodiazepines on motivation.

Rat 50-kHz ultrasonic vocalizations as a tool in studying neurochemical mechanisms that regulate positive emotional states

BACKGROUND

Adolescent and adult rats emit 50-kHz ultrasonic vocalizations (USVs) to communicate the appetitive arousal and the presence of positive emotional states to conspecifics.

NEW METHOD

Based on its communicative function, emission of 50-kHz USVs is increasingly being evaluated in preclinical studies of affective behavior, motivation and social behavior.

RESULTS

Emission of 50-kHz USVs is initiated by the activation of dopamine receptors in the shell subregion of the nucleus accumbens. However, several lines of evidence show that non-dopaminergic receptors may influence the numbers of 50-kHz USVs that are emitted, as well as the acoustic parameters of calls.

COMPARISON WITH EXISTING METHODS

Emission of 50-kHz USVs is a non-invasive method that may be used to study reward and motivation without the need for extensive training and complex animal manipulations. Moreover, emission of 50-kHz USVs can be used alone or combined with other well-standardized behavioral paradigms (e.g., conditioned place preference, self-administration).

CONCLUSIONS

This review summarizes the current evidence concerning molecular mechanisms that regulate the emission of 50-kHz USVs. Moreover, the review discusses the usefulness of 50-kHz USVs as an experimental tool to investigate how different neurotransmitter systems regulate the manifestations of positive emotional states, and also use of this tool in preclinical modeling of psychiatric diseases.

Individual differences in food cue responsivity are associated with acute and repeated cocaine-induced vocalizations, but not cue-induced vocalizations

RATIONALE

Individuals prone to attribute incentive salience to food-associated stimuli ("cues") are also more sensitive to cues during drug seeking and drug taking. This may be due in part to a difference in sensitivity to the affective or other stimulus properties of the drug. In rats, these properties are associated with 50-kHz ultrasonic vocalizations (USVs), in that they are elicited during putative positive affective and motivational states, including in response to drugs of abuse.

OBJECTIVES

We sought to determine whether individual differences in the tendency to attribute incentive salience to a food cue (as measured by approach) were associated with differences in cocaine-induced USVs. We also tested whether the food cue would elicit USVs and if this response was related to approach to the food cue.

METHODS

In experiment 1, rats underwent Pavlovian conditioned approach (PavCA) training where they learned to associate a cue (an illuminated lever) with the delivery of a food pellet into a food cup. Subjects were categorized based on their approach to the cue ("sign-trackers") or to the food cup ("goal-trackers"). Rats subsequently underwent nine testing days in which they were given saline or cocaine (10 mg/kg i.p) and placed into a locomotor chamber. In experiment 2, rats were first tested in the locomotor chambers for one saline-treated day followed by one cocaine-treated day and then trained in PavCA. USVs were recorded from a subset of individuals during the last day of PavCA to determine if the food cue would elicit USVs.

RESULTS

Sign-trackers produced 5-24 times more cocaine-induced 50 kHz USVs compared to goal-trackers for all days of experiment 1, and this response sensitized with repeated cocaine, only in sign-trackers. Similarly in experiment 2, individuals that produced the most cocaine-induced USVs on a single exposure also showed the greatest tendency to sign-track during PavCA. Lastly, while sign-trackers produced more USVs during PavCA generally, the cue itself did not elicit additional USVs in sign- or goal-trackers.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate a robust and consistent relationship between approach to a food cue and cocaine-induced USV production. Thus, these USVs may index the neurobiological differences underlying the behavioral distinctions of sign- and goal-trackers.