Studies of the HLA system and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus

Genetic epidemiology of type 1 diabetes

Family and twin studies indicate that a substantial fraction of susceptibility to type 1 diabetes is attributable to genetic factors. These and other epidemiologic studies also implicate environmental factors as important triggers. Although the specific environmental factors that contribute to immune-mediated diabetes remain unknown, several of the relevant genetic factors have been identified using two main approaches: genome-wide linkage analysis and candidate gene association studies. This article reviews the epidemiology of type 1 diabetes, the relative merits of linkage and association studies, and the results achieved so far using these two approaches. Prospects for the future of type 1 diabetes genetics research are considered.

Cutaneous manifestations of diabetes mellitus

Diabetes mellitus (DM) is a heterogeneous group of disorders characterized by a high serum glucose level and by disturbances of carbohydrate and lipid metabolism. It is estimated that 11 million persons in the United States have DM, 90% of whom have non-insulin-dependent DM. At least 30% of persons with diabetes have some type of cutaneous involvement during the course of their chronic disease. This review classifies the cutaneous findings in DM into four categories: (1) skin diseases with strong to weak association with DM; (2) cutaneous infections; (3) cutaneous manifestations of diabetic complications; and (4) skin reactions to diabetic treatment. Each of these categories is reviewed as well as the pathophysiology of the normal and diabetic basement membrane for a better understanding of the cutaneous manifestations of DM.

Distribution of HLA class II alleles among Scandinavian patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE): an increased risk of SLE among non[DRB1*03,DQA1*0501,DQB1*0201] class II homozygotes?

HLA-DRB1, -DRB3, -DQA1 and -DQB1 alleles were determined by DNA typing in 51 Scandinavian patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and 129 controls. DRB1*03,DRB3*0101,DQA1*0501,DQB1*0201 were significantly increased in the patient group, with relative risks (RR) of 2.80, 3.07, 3.55 and 2.12, respectively. These alleles are in strong linkage disequilibrium, and their possible relative contributions in predisposition to SLE are difficult to distinguish. The strongest association was found for DQA1*0501, which is in linkage disequilibrium with DRB1*03 as well as DRB1*11,12 (DR5). An increased frequency of DRB1*11,12 was observed (RR = 1.89, ns). No association with DRB1*15,16 (DR2) was found. The patients had a higher frequency of HLA class II homozygosity than the controls (RR = 5.05, p = 0.0005). When compared to the low-risk group (nonDRB1*03 class II heterozygotes), the cases homozygous for DRB1*03,DQA1*0501,DQB1*0201, known to be in linkage disequilibrium with the complement allele C4A*Q0, had the highest relative risk of developing SLE (RR = 16.39, p = 0.0002). However non[DRB1*03,DQA1*0501,DQB1*0201] class II homozygotes had a higher relative risk (RR = 4.68, p = 0.0147) than DRB1*03,DQA1*0501,DQB1*0201 heterozygotes, known to carry the C4A*Q0 allele (RR = 2.72, p = 0.0088). This may suggest that HLA class II molecules are directly involved in susceptibility to SLE.

T cell defined HLA epitopes and T cell receptor polymorphism in insulin dependent diabetes mellitus

T cell defined epitopes on class II HLA molecules (epitopes distinguishable by T cells but not by antibodies) seem to be important determinants of IDDM susceptibility/resistance. Although HLA-DR4 is associated with IDDM in many populations, DR4-positive HLA haplotypes vary greatly (relative risk from greater than 10 to less than 1). This variation seems to depend on both the DQ allele and T cell defined subtypes of the DR4 allele. These IDDM associated alleles at the two loci (DQB1 and DRB1) are not correlated with each other in the healthy population, so they clearly are independent risk factors. HLA-DR2 has universally been associated with lack of IDDM, and seems to be protective. However, not all DR2 haplotypes protect, and the protection or lack of protection correlates with T cell defined subtypes of DR2. In this case, however, the DR2 subtypes do correlate with DQ alleles, so it is unclear which locus (loci) is (are) actually affecting the disease process. It may be significant that, for both DR2 and DR4, only the more protective subtypes have arginine at amino acid position 71. Other portions of the DR beta chain are clearly important, however. Although TCR alpha and beta seemed to be promising candidates for additional IDDM susceptibility genes, in fact the various TCR alpha and beta haplotypes are equal, or nearly equal, with regard to IDDM susceptibility. The importance of HLA alleles in IDDM susceptibility, and the lack of importance of TCR alpha and beta alleles, may be due to the different means by which the HLA and TCR molecules achieve antigen binding diversity: HLA molecules by multiple loci and allelic diversity, and TCR molecules by the tremendous diversity that can be generated from a single TCR allele during T cell maturation.

HLA gene and phenotype data of 60 insulin-dependent diabetic patients from north-eastern Italy. A negative association with DR5 rather than DR2?

The purpose of our study was to evaluate what kind of relationships exist between HLA antigens and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), in 20 families and in 40 single patients coming from and living in North Eastern Italy. The subjects studied show a strong association with HLA-DR3 and/or -DR4; at least one of these antigens is present in 88% of the diabetic subjects; this confirms that these antigens play a role in the pathogenesis of IDDM. We also noticed a negative association between IDDM and DR5 rather than DR2 and DR7. This result supports the hypothesis of a specific protective effect of DR5, at least as regards the population studied. Possibly, the gene(s) hypothetically involved in the protection against IDDM is (are) in linkage disequilibrium with DR2 and/or DR7 in some Caucasian populations and with DR5 in others. Another important result is the frequent HLA identity (75% of cases) among diabetic siblings of the same families. This result indicates that HLA identity is the main condition responsible for the susceptibility to the disease in the healthy siblings with HLA antigens identical to the diabetic siblings.

Insulin dependent diabetes mellitus epidemiology: HLA genotype study in 12 north eastern Italian families with two siblings affected by type I diabetes

The purpose of our study was to evaluate the relationship between the histocompatibility antigens and type I diabetes mellitus in families living in the north-eastern part of Italy. In each family two siblings were affected by diabetes. HLA-antigens were determined with the lymphocytotoxicity test, utilizing antisera of the series A-B-C-DR. The phenotypic frequencies were compared with those observed in controls. We showed that diabetes has a strong association with HLA DR 3 and/or DR 4 antigens. In particular we registered high frequency of compound heterozygous DR 3 - DR 4 subjects, and this fact supports the hypothesis of the existence of two different genes for diabetes associated with these HLA antigens. Moreover we observed a particular haplotype segregation with a very high percentage of HLA identity between patients belonging to the same family, confirming the association between HLA and genetic susceptibility to insulin dependent diabetes. These results confirm data in the literature and, completed by other data from other patients' families living in our area, will be useful in providing reliable genetic counselling.

A diabetes-susceptible HLA haplotype is best defined by a combination of HLA-DR and -DQ alleles

HLA-DR4 is associated with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) in many populations. Many recent studies suggest that the DR4 effect is really due to DQ3.2, an allele of the nearby DQB1 locus. We used T cell clones, MAb, and allele-specific oligonucleotides to test IDDM and control subjects for DR4 subtypes (Dw4, Dw10, Dw13, and Dw14) and for DR4-associated DQB1 alleles (DQ3.1 and DQ3.2). We find that (a) IDDM is approximately equally associated with alleles of the DRB1 locus (Dw4 and Dw10, combined relative risk, RR = 6.4) and the DQB1 locus (DQ3.2, RR = 5.9); and (b) there is significant interaction, in a statistical sense, between these DR and DQ alleles in IDDM. The only IDDM-associated DR4 haplotypes were those carrying the IDDM-associated alleles at both loci (RR = 12.1); haplotypes with Dw4 or 10 but not DQ3.2, or vice versa, had a RR less than 1. Alternative explanations include: (a) that susceptibility requires specific allelic products of both DR and DQ loci; (b) that the combination of certain DR and DQ alleles marks haplotypes with the true susceptibility allele at a third locus; or (c) that Dw4 and 10 mark haplotypes with an allele at another locus that interacts with DQ3.2. As discussed, this third locus is unlikely to be DQA1 (DQ alpha). The data thus are not easily reconciled with an exclusive effect of HLA-DQ. This information increases our ability to predict IDDM by genetic typing: in the population studied, heterozygotes DR3/[DQ3.2, Dw4] or DR3/[DQ3.2, Dw10] had a relative risk of 38.0 and an absolute risk of 1 in 15.

Inherited diseases in North American Mennonites: focus on Old Colony (Chortitza) Mennonites

The patterns of migration and the genetic disorders occurring among North American Mennonites are reviewed, and inherited conditions recently recognized in a religious and genetic isolate, the Old Colony (Chortitza) Mennonites, are described. Old Colony Mennonites are of Dutch/German origin and descend from approximately 400 founding families who settled in the Old Colony, Chortitza (the Ukraine, USSR) in the late 1700s, and then migrated to Canada and Central and South America in the past century. We investigated over 6 generations of a Canadian Old Colony kindred in which there was extensive intermarriage, and in whom 28 individuals developed diabetes mellitus. Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) occurred in 14 affected individuals in 10 closely related sibships; the 11 living IDDM patients were all concordant for the immunogenetic marker HLA-DR4. Fourteen close relatives had other disorders of carbohydrate metabolism, including gestational diabetes and non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Other close relatives had autoimmune diseases, including rheumatoid arthritis, hyper- and hypothyroidism, multiple sclerosis, and red cell aplasia. Other inherited diseases, including Alport syndrome, congenital defects, and inborn errors of metabolism were also found in the kindred. In the almost exclusively (99%) Old Colony Mennonite public health district in which the kindred was ascertained, there were multiple cases of Tourette syndrome, of malformations (including congenital heart defects and cleft lip +/- palate), and familial clusters of inborn errors of metabolism. We report this Old Colony (Chortitza) Mennonite isolate because 1) there are large familial aggregations of tissue-specific autoimmune diseases, malformations, inborn errors of metabolism, and of some other conditions whose genetic basis is still unknown; 2) there are multiple cases of rare genetic conditions, 3) we have established a computerized genealogic data base on over 1,000 kindred members as well as a cryopreserved lymphocyte/DNA bank on over 100 closely related individuals with various genetic conditions; and 4) this religious isolate, which extends across North, Central, and South America, offers an excellent opportunity for studying the epidemiology and molecular genetics of both common and rare inherited diseases.

Immunological aspects of diabetes mellitus: prospects for pharmacological modification

It is now well known that insulin-dependent diabetes is a chronic progressive autoimmune disease. The prolonged prediabetic phase of progressive beta-cell dysfunction is associated with immunological abnormalities. A prediabetic period is suggested by the appearance of islet cell antibodies, anti-insulin antibodies, and anti-insulin receptor antibodies. The existence of activated T lymphocytes and abnormal T cell subsets are also other markers. There is still no concensus about the use of the immunosuppression superimposed upon conventional insulin therapy in early diagnosed IDDM and the follow-up of the relatives of IDDM patients who share the genetic predisposition and serological markers for the risk of future onset of IDDM. Treatment in the prodromal period cannot be justified because a link between the disease and early markers such as ICA has not been established with certainty (Diabetes Research Program NIH, 1983). Many immunopharmacological manipulations were reported to be effective in animal models. However, most of them are not readily applied to human subjects. Moreover, IDDM patients are now believed to be heterogeneous, with a complex genetic background. HLA-DR, and more recently DQ, are closely related to the genetic predisposition to IDDM but those genes are not themselves diabetogenic. The contribution of autoimmunity does not appear to be uniform, and in some cases, the contribution of virus is considered more important. There is a lack of a marker for the future onset of IDDM. ICA and ICSA were found after mumps infection, but the existence of those autoantibodies and even the co-existence of HLA-DR3 do not always indicate the future trend to insulin dependency. More precise markers will be disclosed through the biochemical analysis of the target antigens on pancreatic beta-cell for islet antibodies and effector T cells. Much safer and more effective immunopharmacological treatment will be developed through animal experimentation using rat and mouse models. The recent development and interest in this field will further facilitate the attainment of the goal for the complete prevention of IDDM.

Increased insulin concentrations in nondiabetic offspring of diabetic parents

Insulin resistance is thought by many to be the primary defect that results in non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM). An implication of this theory is that prediabetic persons have higher serum insulin levels than normal subjects. We assessed serum insulin concentrations in a cohort of 1497 nondiabetic Mexican Americans, a population at high risk for NIDDM, according to whether their parents or siblings had diabetes. It was assumed that prediabetic persons would be more likely to have strong family histories of diabetes. We found a stepwise increase in fasting insulin levels in nondiabetics with neither, one, or both parents with diabetes (69.8, 77.8, and 94.6 pmol per liter, respectively; P = 0.002). Similar results were observed for insulin sum (the total of insulin concentrations in the fasting state and at 30, 60, and 120 minutes after a 75-g oral glucose load). The differences in insulin sums according to family history remained statistically significant in analyses of covariance, which controlled for variations in body-mass index, body-fat distribution, and level of blood glucose. Subjects without diabetes who had a diabetic sibling had higher fasting concentrations of insulin than subjects without a diabetic sibling (83.2 vs. 69.6 pmol per liter), but the difference was not statistically significant. We conclude that prediabetic persons, who would be expected to be more numerous in kindreds with progressively stronger family histories of diabetes, have hyperinsulinemia. This supports the insulin-resistance hypothesis.

Predicting future treatment of diabetes mellitus from characteristics available at presentation

This study was designed to identify the clinical features of a newly diagnosed diabetic patient that are most useful in deciding treatment. A secondary aim was to formulate a statistical model for predicting subsequent treatment. The following features were considered in 289 patients: age, sex, severity and duration of symptoms, degree and duration of weight loss, glycosuria, ketonuria, blood glucose concentration, body mass index (BMI), and family history of diabetes. Three treatment groups, 6 months after diagnosis, were defined: diet alone, diet with oral hypoglycaemic agent(s), and insulin-treated. Univariate analysis showed that symptom severity, glycosuria, ketonuria, glucose concentration, weight loss, and BMI were significantly different between the three groups. Age and rate of weight loss were significantly different between the insulin-treated and non-insulin-treated groups. Multivariate analysis gave a model to calculate the probability of requiring each of the three treatments given certain characteristics. A second cohort of 174 patients was used to assess the accuracy of the model. The model predicted the actual treatment at 6 months correctly in 72%.

T-cell-defined DR4 subtypes as markers for type 1 diabetes

In most populations studied, HLA-DR4, a DRB1 (formerly DR beta I) allele, is increased in frequency among patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). Using T-cells, one can distinguish five subtypes of DR4 (Dw4, Dw10, Dw13, Dw14, and Dw15). Two of these (Dw4 and Dw10) are IDDM-associated in the populations studied here. Therefore, Dw4 and Dw10 could be causative or merely markers for a linked diabetes allele. If they are causative, one might expect them to share some unique structural element or at least to associate consistently with IDDM in different populations. Published sequence data show no structural element unique to Dw4 and Dw10; moreover, the associations of these DR4-Dw subtypes with diabetes vary considerably in different populations. Thus the DRB1 locus probably cannot account for the DR4 association in IDDM. The strong linkage disequilibrium between IDDM and Dw4 and Dw10 suggests that the diabetes susceptibility locus should be in the vicinity of the DR region or the DQ region of the HLA complex. Alternative hypotheses are discussed, relating DR- and DQ-region alleles to IDDM. We further postulate that the evolutionary event that produced the Dw10 allele occurred on a Dw4 haplotype that happened to carry a diabetes susceptibility allele at another locus.

Contrasting features of insulin dependent diabetes mellitus associated with neuroectodermal defects and classical insulin dependent diabetes mellitus

The Wolfram, or DIDMOAD, syndrome is a rare congenital disease that is associated with diabetes insipidus, insulin dependent diabetes mellitus of an early onset, bilateral optic atrophy and deafness. Urological disorders are usually present as well. We have studied nine patients belonging to five different families. All of the family members were HLA typed (including DR), and islet cell as well as antinuclear antibody determinations were carried out. Although individuals with insulin dependent diabetes mellitus are very prone to have either HLA-DR3 or -DR4 antigens, none of our patients had DR3 antigens and only one was DR4 positive. On the other hand, three of our patients were typed as HLA-DR2 positive. This antigen is uncommon in classical insulin dependent diabetes. In one of the families, the affected siblings did not share the same HLA haplotype. Islet cell and antinuclear antibodies were not found in any of the cases and six of the patients had a small, but significant, insulin secretory reserve. On the basis of some of the clinical features it was also possible to further distinguish between the DIDMOAD syndrome and the classical insulin dependent diabetes mellitus. The differences encountered between classical and DIDMOAD insulin dependent diabetes mellitus--the presence/absence of HLA linkage, HLA-DR2, -DR3 and -DR4 associations, islet cell or antinuclear antibodies, the tendency to ketosis and diabetic retinopathy--indicate that their etiopathogenies are triggered by distinct mechanisms.

Wolfram's syndrome and HLA

A Sicilian family with three siblings affected by Wolfram's syndrome (Ws) is reported. HLA typing was performed in eight individuals from this family through three generations. Two of the three patients were HLA DR2 positive. The results suggest that the gene for Ws is not linked to the HLA region on chromosome 6, but located on some other chromosome, and that the allele HLA DR2 might predispose to the mutation responsible for Ws.

The endocrinologic associations of the autoimmune rheumatic diseases

Having seen five patients with both SLE and thyroid disease (case reports available on request) in a short period of time, we have undertaken a survey of the association between the ARD and endocrine disorders. On the basis of a literature review and our own reported study, it is apparent that an association between these major groups of disorders is well established with some individual diseases, though much more dubious in others (Table 3). The possibility of coexistent endocrine disease in a patient with a multisystem ARD should be carefully considered throughout the course of the patient's follow-up.

HLA-DR4 in insulin-dependent diabetic parents and their diabetic offspring: a clue to dominant inheritance

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) susceptibility determinants are known to be associated with both HLA-DR3 and -DR4. We monitored the inheritance of HLA-DR alleles in 37 families in which IDDM affected one parent and at least one offspring in order to try to learn more about the modes of inheritance of IDDM determinants. Ninety-seven insulin-dependent diabetics whose parents did not have diabetes and 158 nondiabetics were used as control groups for estimates of DR allele frequencies in the overall diabetic and general populations. The proportion of diabetic parents who transmitted DR4 to diabetic offspring (78%) was significantly higher (P less than 0.001) than the gene frequency of DR4 in the overall diabetic population (43%). The proportion of nondiabetic parents who transmitted DR4 to diabetic offspring (22%) was not significantly different from the gene frequency of DR4 in the nondiabetic population (16%), but it was significantly lower (P less than 0.05) than the gene frequency in the overall IDDM population. These proportions suggest that inheritance of the DR4-associated IDDM susceptibility determinant is not recessive, because in recessive inheritance expression of a trait depends on each parent contributing a susceptibility determinant. The proportions of diabetic and nondiabetic parents who transmitted the DR allele associated with the susceptibility determinant would then equal one another. The transmission of predominantly DR4 from affected parents to affected offspring suggests that susceptibility to IDDM is inherited primarily via a single dose of a potent determinant associated with DR4, as in dominant inheritance. When DR3 was transmitted at all it was usually by the nondiabetic parent. Only 8% of diabetic parents transmitted DR3 but 35% of nondiabetic parents transmitted DR3. The proportion of nondiabetic parents who transmitted DR3 was similar to the gene frequency of DR3 in the overall diabetic population (29%), but it was significantly higher than the gene frequency of DR3 in the nondiabetic population (15%; P less than 0.005). The percentage of diabetic offspring with the genotype DR3DR4 (35%) was identical to the percentage of individuals in the overall IDDM population with this genotype (35%). Numerous population data indicate that the DR3DR4 genotype carries a higher relative risk for IDDM than any other genotype, which suggests synergism between the DR3- and DR4-associated determinants. The family data reported here support this synergism but suggest that the DR4-associated determinant can give substantial susceptibility independent of the DR3-associated determinant and that the DR3-associated determinant is often expressed as enhancing susceptibility in the presence of the dominant DR4- associated determinant.

Postprandial 2-hr C-peptide concentration as a guide for insulin treatment in patient with NIDDM

To determine the usefulness of postpradial-2hr serum C-peptide as a guide for insulin treatment in NIDDM, the 67 NIDDM patients admitted in Kyung Hee University Hospital from Nov. 1981 to May 1984 were classified according to postprandial 2-hr insulin, C-peptide levels and 24-hr urine C-peptide levels. The patients were divided into 3 groups according to the level of insulin or C-peptide in normal persons reported previously. In 22 patients with postprandial 2-hr values of more than 5.8 ng/ml for C-peptide, 12 patients (55%) were diet controllable and only 5 patients (22%) required insulin treatment. On the other hand, in the classification according to postprandial 2-hr insulin or 24-hr urine C-peptide levels, higher response groups should be controlled by diet alone, but 9 of 18 patients (50%) for insulin, 8 of 14 patients (57%) for 24-hr urine C-peptide required insulin treatment. The classification according to postprandial 2hr C-peptide levels was a more sensitive guide for insulin treatment than that with postprandial 2hr insulin level or 24hr urine C-peptide level.

Glucose tolerance in siblings of type 1 diabetic patients: relationship to HLA status

In this report, we present an analysis of glucose and insulin responses during oral glucose tolerance tests in 369 siblings of Type 1 diabetic patients. All have been HLA typed at the A, B and C loci. Though most had normal glucose tolerance by National Diabetes Data Group criteria (92% of the males and 95% of the females), siblings who shared both HLA haplotypes with the diabetic patient in the family had higher mean 3-hour glucose areas than those who shared one or neither HLA haplotype (p less than 0.01). This difference was more marked in males and older siblings. Insulin concentrations did not differ significantly between the two groups except that, for those aged less than 16 years, the group sharing both haplotypes had lower fasting insulin concentrations (p = 0.05); for 16-29 year olds, the corresponding group had marginally higher 3-hour insulin areas than the remainder of siblings (p = 0.17). Little association with specific haplotypes (A1B8 or A2B15) was seen. Multivariate analyses, adjusting for age and obesity, eliminated the 3-h glucose difference in females by HLA sharing status (p = 0.37) although in males it remained significant (p less than 0.001). Failure to account for age, sex and obesity may explain some of the conflicts in the reported literature. The glucose tolerance differences seen by HLA haplotype sharing status did not correlate with the presence of anti-islet cell antibodies. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the HLA identical siblings, particularly males, have different (i.e. worse) glucose tolerance than their haploidentical and non-HLA identical siblings.

A minor subset of HLA-DR3 haplotypes is preferentially increased in type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes

We have been using human T-lymphocyte clones specifically sensitized to detect leucocyte antigens of Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetic patients in the hope of detecting novel HLA antigens associated with Type 1 diabetes. We previously described two such clones which define a new class II HLA antigen, Boston-1 (BO1). BO1 is found mainly on cells of persons with particular HLA-DR antigens and, of potential significance for diabetes, BO1 identifies a distinctive subset of DR3 haplotypes. We report here that BO1+ DR3 haplotypes are overrepresented in Type 1 diabetes. That is, significantly more of the DR3-positive subjects are BO1-positive in the patient group (31%) than in the control group (8%), suggesting that a diabetes-susceptibility gene may be more common on the BO1+ than on the BO1- DR3 haplotypes. Alternative interpretations are also discussed.

Analysis of negative and multiple HLA antigen disease associations

The nature and extent of negative and multiple HLA antigen disease associations are investigated theoretically under two models. The first model assumes that an HLA antigen is involved directly in predisposing individuals to disease. The second model assumes that the association of a particular HLA antigen(s) with a disease is the result of linkage disequilibrium between the allele determining the antigen and alleles at a nearby locus which confers susceptibility to disease. We determined whether observed decreases in antigen frequencies among a patient group are simply the inevitable result of the fact that if one or more alleles at a locus is increased in frequency, then others must be decreased. Under the antigen predisposing model exact predictions concerning allele and antigen class frequencies at the predisposing locus, and the non-predisposing loci, are given. The predictions are examined using HLA-DR data for multiple sclerosis.

HLA-A, B, C and DR antigen associations in insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) in South African Negro (black) and Cape coloured people

HLA-A, B, C and DR antigen frequencies were determined in South African Negro (Black) (50) and Cape Coloured (57) patients with insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) and in appropriate controls. The Black patients failed to show associations commonly reported for American Black patients with IDDM but did show a weakly significant increase in the DRw9 frequency. However, this antigen was rare even in the patient group and HLA associated genes do not appear to play a major role in the pathogenesis of IDDM in these people. The Cape Coloureds have a high proportion of Caucasoid genes. Coloured IDDM patients had the expected low DR2 and high DR4 frequencies. Unexpectedly the Cape Coloureds failed to show significant associations of IDDM with B8 or DR3.

Will a three-allele model of inheritance explain the HLA data for type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes?

The HLA data from nine published studies on Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes were examined to see whether a three-allele model for the inheritance of Type 1 diabetes at the HLA-associated locus could be rejected. None of the data rejected the three-allele model. The data were also examined to see whether they would reject a recessive model. Out of the nine data sets, five rejected a recessive and four did not. The p value for all studies together rejected a recessive. Two of the data sets allowed us to test the hypothesis that multiplex and simplex families would exhibit different modes of inheritance. Multiplex data from both data sets rejected recessive inheritance while the multiplex data from only one data set also rejected three-allele inheritance. The results of assuming a recessive model and analyzing the data from simplex families led to different results from the two data sets. In addition, data from a non-European population were examined and found to reject both recessive and three-allele inheritance for Type 1 diabetes at the HLA-associated locus.

The genetics of type I and type II diabetes: analysis by recombinant DNA methodology

Susceptibility to IDDM is linked to the HLA-D locus on the short arm of chromosome 6, a region believed to be involved in the process of communication between cells which determines immune responses. Presumably an HLA molecule encoded by this region, unable to present a particular antigenic pathogen to the immune system, is inherited. The HLA-DR locus is quite complex, however. The gene which codes for this defective molecule may be identified by a combination of use of monoclonal antibodies and cloned gene probes which specifically hybridize to various portions of this region. Investigators are searching for HLA-DR4 containing chromosomes in IDDM which show similar patterns of restriction enzyme polymorphism. Hopefully, complete structural analysis of these related sequences will provide information about the mechanisms which confer susceptibility to develop IDDM. A strong genetic component is involved in NIDDM evidenced by a high concordance in monozygotic twins. Nevertheless, there is much evidence of genetic heterogeneity. At the present time no clear cut genetic marker has been defined. The human insulin gene has been cloned and by Southern blot hybridization analysis of peripheral leukocyte DNA, the insulin gene locus is being evaluated as a possible contributor to the genetic defect. Population studies at the present time have not identified any particular polymorphic insulin allele associated with NIDDM. Population studies are complicated by heterogeneity of NIDDM, racial and ethnic differences, and heterogeneity of insulin alleles. Linkage analysis in family studies will provide an alternative approach to population studies to determine what role if any the insulin gene plays in the genetic component of this disease. Because NIDDM is heterogeneous and perhaps polygenic in nature, these linkage analyses in families with NIDDM can be extended to other genes when they are cloned such as that coding for the insulin receptor. The familial aggregation of diabetes has long been noted (see ref. 1 for review). In relatives of diabetics, the prevalence ranges from 10-30%, while it is variously estimated to be between 0.1-3% in the general population. But familial aggregation of a trait may be caused either by genetic or environmental factors. One approach to dissecting the contribution of these factors is the study of concordance in twins. Pyke and associates observed that overall identical twins always show a higher concordance rate than dizygotic twins, irrespective of their age of diagnosis. Furthermore, they noted that identical twins of younger onset are often discordant for diabetes while identical twins of older onset are usually concordant.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Immunological aspects of type 1 and 2 diabetes mellitus

IDDM occurs predominantly among individuals being class II antigen HLA-DR 3 and/or 4 positive, while NIDDM is not associated with HLA-D. Although the HLA-DR 3 or 4 specificities are prerequisites for IDDM to develop, their high frequencies (about 60%) in the background population preclude tissue typing as a predictive test, underlined by the observation that less than 50% of monozygotic twins are concordant for IDDM. The presence of a number of immune abnormalities argues that the causes of IDDM may be sought in an altered immune reaction against antigens present in the pancreatic B cells and/or in the environment. The majority of IDDM patients of short duration show both cellular and humoral autoimmunity against the pancreatic B cells. Similar phenomena may be observed in patients initially diagnosed as NIDDM and treated with oral hypoglycemic agents. It has been speculated that these patients have a retarded form of IDDM. It is possible that the combination of specific Class II antigen molecule(s) and an invading antigen (virus, bacterium, chemical etc.) presented to the immune system triggers the formation of effector cells such as B lymphocytes and cytotoxic T lymphocytes which also cross-react with the pancreatic B cells. Multiple exposures to this or related antigens throughout several years may eventually lead a sufficient loss of pancreatic B cells to cause insulin dependence.

Anti-tubulin antibodies in recent onset type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus: comparison with islet cell antibodies

Antibodies to tubulin, the fundamental protein of microtubules, were studied by radioimmunoassay in patients with Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes of varying duration and in healthy control subjects. Elevated levels of anti-tubulin antibodies were found in 46% of 28 patients with Type 1 diabetes of recent onset (less than or equal to 6 months) and in only 6.2% of 64 patients with long-standing Type 1 diabetes (duration 6-43 years). None of 34 DR3-positive normal subjects and none of 20 Type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetic patients were positive for anti-tubulin antibodies. Anti-tubulin antibody levels were elevated in two out of 26 first-degree relatives of Type 1 diabetic patients. The specificity of the detection of anti-tubulin antibodies was demonstrated by dilution of the sera, competitive binding experiments between labelled and unlabelled tubulin, immunoblotting. Antibodies to tubulin were elevated in 60% of patients with islet cell surface antibodies and there was a significant association between anti-tubulin antibodies and islet-cell surface antibodies. These antibodies, however, recognize different specificities, since adsorption of islet cell surface antibody by rat islets did not alter the anti-tubulin antibody activity. Elevated anti-actin antibody responses were found in two out of 17 and one out of 26 patients with recent onset and long-standing Type 1 diabetes, respectively. In conclusion, anti-tubulin antibodies are detected in a high proportion of patients with diabetes of recent onset, are associated with islet cell surface antibodies and like islet cell surface antibodies decrease or disappear during the course of the disease.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Immunoregulatory T-lymphocyte subset deficiency in newly diagnosed type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus

Humoral and cell-mediated disorders in Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes suggest that an imbalance of immunoregulatory T-cell subsets exists. In 23 newly diagnosed (onset less than 3 months) and 21 long-standing Type 1 diabetic patients, T lymphocyte subsets were analyzed using monoclonal antibodies (OKT3, OKT4, OKT8, OKM1). The newly diagnosed patients showed a reduction with a significant difference from healthy controls in total T cells (OKT3+: 58.1 +/- 8.5% versus 70.7 +/- 8.0%), helper/inducer cells (OKT4+: 33.8 +/- 7.0% versus 47.1 +/- 8.3%), suppressor/cytotoxic cells (OKT8+: 18.5 +/- 7.3% versus 32 +/- 6.8%) and monocytes (OKM1+: 11.5 +/- 3.8% versus 19.9 +/- 5.2%) (p less than 0.001). The long-standing diabetic patients also revealed a low number of immunoregulatory T cells compared with control subjects, although to a lesser extent (p less than 0.01-0.05). The helper/suppressor ratio (OKT4+/OKT8+) was higher in newly diagnosed patients than in control subjects (2.2 +/- 1.3 versus 1.5 +/- 0.3; p less than 0.02). When compared with 95% tolerance limits in the control subjects, the reduction of OKT8+ cells in the newly diagnosed diabetic patients appeared more marked: the mean (18.5%) coincided with the lower limit of normal subjects (18.3%). Ten of the newly diagnosed Type 1 diabetic patients had a value below the normal lower limit. Out data point to the occurrence of different immunoregulatory abnormalities in newly diagnosed Type 1 diabetic patients, especially in OKT8+ and OKT4+ cells. The imbalance in T lymphocyte subsets is further proof of the role of cellular autoimmunity in the pathogenesis of the early phases of Type 1 diabetes.

Immunoglobulin (Gm) markers and alpha 1-antitrypsin (PI) types in rheumatoid arthritis and early onset chronic active hepatitis

No Gm allotype, haplotype or phenotype was increased or decreased in frequency in two autoimmune diseases, rheumatoid arthritis (RA) or chronic active hepatitis (CAH) in comparison with control frequencies. The frequencies of the Gm haplotypes among 206 controls were 0.70, 0.19 and 0.11 for fb, ag and axg , respectively. Neither Gm heterozygosity nor homozygosity was associated with either disease. There was no interaction between alpha 1-antitrypsin (PI) and Gm type in the two diseases.

A two-susceptibility-allele model for genetic diseases and associated marker loci: differences and similarities to a one-s-allele model

A model for genetic diseases and associated markers is defined where two distinct susceptibility alleles are possible, each associated with a different marker allele. Marker genotype distributions in a disease population are then expressed in terms of haplotype frequencies and penetrance parameters. It is shown that, if the heterozygote with two different disease alleles has a higher penetrance than the two disease homogzygotes, the observed to 'Hardy-Weinberg-expected' ratio of associated marker genotypes (the alpha/beta ratio of Falk, Mendell & Rubinstein, 1983) will always be greater than or equal to one. When all disease penetrances are equal, the model becomes indistinguishable from a recessive one-s-allele model with alpha/beta = 1. Application of these observations to several data sets for insulin dependent diabetes mellitus suggests the possibility that different marker genotype distributions in different samples may be due to different penetrances of the disease genotypes in the samples. If a particular environment causes the heterozygote disease genotype (with two different disease alleles) to have the highest penetrance, the marker genotype distribution would be compatible with the 2-s-allele model. In other environments where the three disease genotypes have essentially equal penetrances, the marker distribution would be compatible with the 1-s-allele model.

Severe hypertension in the Spanish population. Association with specific HLA antigens

There is now increasing evidence for immunological changes in essential hypertension. Immunological response is determined in part by genes linked to the HLA system. It has been reported a positive association between HLA B15 and the risk for cerebral events in essential hypertensive (EH) patients. We studied the distribution of HLA antigens in 128 EH (age range, 13-85 years) and 1000 normotensive controls. EH were classified in accordance with the World Health Organization (WHO) criteria: in WHO Stages I and II, there were 100 patients; in WHO Stage III, there were 28 patients. HLA-A and B antigens of peripheral blood lymphocytes were studied according to the microlymphocytotoxicity test. The results were compared by chi-square analysis, and the p value was multiplied by the number of antigens studied at each locus, to avoid overestimation of an association. Frequency of HLA-BW 22 was higher in EH compared with controls (5.4% vs 1.2%, p less than 0.01). Frequency of HLA-B12 in EH with WHO Stage III hypertension (64.2%) was significantly increased compared either with EH in WHO Stage I or II (29%, p less than 0.01) or the control group (26.9% p less than 0.001). The incidence of HLA-B15 antigen in the whole hypertensive group was 3.1%, lower than in normotensive controls (6.4%, p less than 0.8). None of the patients with WHO Stage III hypertension had the HLA-B15 antigen. In conclusion, the results seemed to indicated that the Spanish population had an association between HLA-B12 and severe hypertension.

Evidence for an association between rheumatoid arthritis and autoimmune endocrine disease

Evidence is presented for the first time of a significantly increased prevalence of type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes in the close relatives of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Thirty-nine (13%) of 295 patients with classical or definite rheumatoid arthritis had a first or second degree relative with type 1 diabetes and 38 (13%) had a close relative with autoimmune thyroid disease. These findings could be compatible with a possible common genetically determined mechanism of susceptibility to both diseases.

The genetic susceptibility to type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes: analysis of the HLA-DR association

HLA-DR and MT1, MT2, MT3 genotypes have been investigated in 123 Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetic subjects and their families. Ninety-eight percent of probands possessed either DR3 (relative risk = 5.0), or DR4 (relative risk = 6.8) or both antigens (relative risk = 14.3), emphasizing the strong association of the disease with these two antigens. Almost 51% of the probands were DR3, DR4 heterozygotes. The DR antigen combinations of the parents leading to DR3, DR4 heterozygous and to DR3 and DR4 homozygous offspring were analysed. There was a marked increase in DR3, DR4 heterozygosity, but no increase in homozygosity for these antigens compared with the expected frequencies. These results are compatible with the existence of two susceptibility genes operating at a locus or at loci closely linked to that of HLA-DR. There was a striking reduction of DR7 (relative risk = 0.1) and only five probands possessed DR2 (relative risk = 0.1). In each case, the other inherited allele was DR3 or DR4. Linkage disequilibrium between B7 and DR2 was much lower in the haplotypes of the probands than in the 'non-diabetic' parental haplotype. In contrast, the association of BW62 with DR4 was more pronounced in the haplotypes of the probands. There was no increase in recombination frequency in these families and no strong effect of HLA-DR on age of onset could be demonstrated. There was a significant shift towards DR identity compared with identity for the whole HLA haplotype (A, B, C and DR) in both healthy and diabetic siblings (p less than 0.025).

The search for heterogeneity in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus: evidence for familial and nonfamilial forms

Using five different published sets of data, we looked at the distribution of HLA-DR genotypes among diabetic probands. It was possible to reject dominant inheritance at the HLA-associated locus, but some of the data were compatible with recessive inheritance while some were not. An attempt to reconcile the conflicting data by proposing a three-allele model apparently failed. It proved possible to resolve some of the conflicting data by proposing that simplex families represent primarily a recessive form of insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) while multiplex families represent primarily two other subforms: one showing three-allele inheritance and one not. We also propose that the HLA locus involved in IDDM mediates the effect of an environmental agent on a second disease locus.

Investigation of the mode of inheritance of the HLA associated diseases by the method of antigen genotype frequencies among diseased individuals

Statistical features of the method of antigen genotype frequencies among the diseased, for single and multiple disease associations at a locus, will be presented. A methodology to determine when a true intermediate mode of inheritance can be distinguished from strict recessive or additive inheritance will be developed. The effect of sporadics and ascertainment bias on the observed antigen genotype frequencies will be investigated. Data on ankylosing spondylitis, multiple sclerosis and dermatitis herpetiformis are very close to expectations for an additive (or dominant) mode of inheritance for the HLA-linked disease-predisposing gene, and data on hemochromatosis, insulin dependent diabetes mellitus and celiac disease are close to recessive expectations. If an intermediate model does apply in any of these cases, it must be an intermediate model that is fairly close to a strict recessive or dominant model; as appropriate. DR data for insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) strongly indicate that there are two separate "disease" alleles, which exhibit negative complementation, predisposing individuals to IDDM, where the mode of inheritance of the "disease" alleles considered separately is close to recessive. In general, this method cannot rule out the existence of sporadics or a second disease-predisposing gene, when the penetrance values over the two disease-predisposing genes are strictly additive, for diseases showing agreement with additive (or dominant) modes of inheritance.

HLA-DR typing in identical twins with insulin-dependent diabetes: difference between concordant and discordant pairs

A total of 106 pairs of identical twins, of whom 56 were concordant and 50 discordant for insulin-dependent diabetes, were typed for HLA-DR. In both the concordant and discordant groups there was a high prevalence of the antigens DR3 and DR4, a low prevalence of DR5 and DR7, and a virtual absence of DR2. The heterozygous phenotype DR3,DR4 was more prevalent in concordant than discordant pairs. This was therefore the first demonstration of a genetic difference between concordant and discordant identical twin pairs. These findings suggest that possession of both DR3 and DR4 antigens confers a greater genetic predisposition to insulin-dependent diabetes than does the possession of either antigen alone.

HLA haplotype study of 53 juvenile insulin-dependent diabetic (I.D.D.) families

R4 heterozygotes was observed. By contrast, the observed frequency of patients homozygous for DR3 or DR4 was not increased, but even slightly decreased. The data support a model of inheritance comprising at least two closely linked specifically "diabetic" loci (most of the time marked by B18, BfF1, DR3 and B15, BfS, DR4) and a non-specifically "diabetic" haplotype favouring auto-immunisation (most of the time marked by B8, BfS, DR3). This model is discussed in the light of the presented data and of those of the literature.

HLA and susceptibility to type I diabetes. Hypothesis

Positive associations between the antigens D(R)3 and D(R)4 and negative associations of D(R)2 have been reported with insulin dependent or type I diabetes mellitus. It has been suggested that susceptibility factor(s) associated with the D(R)3 and D(R)4 haplotypes and a resistance factor associated with the D(R)2 haplotype may be involved in the pathogenesis of the disease. We propose a hypothesis herein which attempts to unify these findings based on our present understanding suggesting (a) the existence of multiple antigenic determinants associated with any one D(R) haplotype and (b) the sharing of "single" D region encoded determinants between what we now refer to as different D(R) haplotypes. The hypothesis, in its simplest form, focuses on a single D region determinant which can be found associated at different frequencies with the various D haplotypes as potentially explaining the findings.

Type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetes--an epidemiological overview

Despite the use of a wide range of different methodologies and diagnostic criteria, epidemiological studies have shown that Type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetes has a global distribution and its prevalence varies from country to country, in different ethnic groups in the same country, and between the same ethnic group undergoing internal or external migration. Rural-urban and migration studies indicate that change towards a 'Westernized' lifestyle is associated with a dramatic increase in the prevalence rates for Type 2 diabetes. Between populations, comparisons are confounded by a wide range of different ascertainment rates, survey methodologies, and diagnostic criteria for diabetes. However, low prevalence rates for Type 2 diabetes are seen in Eskimos and populations of the Far East, while the highest are seen in American Indians, urbanized Pacific Island populations, and migrant Asian Indians. Available evidence suggests that these latter groups have a genetic susceptibility to Type 2 diabetes ('diabetes genotype') and that the disease is unmasked by environmental factors. There appears to be a spectrum of interaction between genetic and environmental factors--in certain populations the genetic role may be more important than environmental, or vice versa. Epidemiological studies, apart from their value in population screenings and case-finding, have contributed to the new classification and diagnostic criteria for diabetes and our understanding of risk factors and host characteristics in the aetiology of Type 2 diabetes.

Genetic heterogeneity of diabetes and HLA

Histocompatibility (HLA) antigens and genotypes B, D and DR were studied in large sample of Caucasian insulin dependent diabetic (IDD) probands. The associations between IDD and B8, B15, Dw3, Dw4, and DR3, and DR4 were measured by relative risks (RR) and delta values. Both the homozygotes (B8/8: RR 10, B 15/15: RR 7, DR3/3: RR32, DR4/4: RR34) and the heterozygotes (B8/15: RR 11, DR3/4: RR22) for the high-risk antigens showed highly significant elevation of the relative risks, yet there were no statistically significant differences between the homo- and the heterozygotes. The delta measurements supported the RR results. RR and delta were found significantly decreased for B7, Dw2, and DR2. There were no relationships observed between age at diagnosis or family history and HLA. Although we were unable to demonstrate a statistically significant difference between the RR for the high-risk antigens heterozygote vs. the high-risk antigen homozygotes, our study like many others shows that the RR is higher for the heterozygotes. Thus our data are compatible with genetic heterogeneity of IDD.

BF types and the mode of inheritance of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM)

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) has been found to be highly associated with a rare allele of the complement protein, properdin factor B (BF). Assuming that there is a susceptibility gene for IDDM tightly linked to the genetic locus for BF and the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), the distribution of BF types in more than 1100 North American IDDM patients strongly argues for the rejection of dominant, epistatic, and overdominant modes of inheritance. Other evidence suggesting complex modes of inheritance for IDDM is reviewed and it is concluded that our observations and published data are consistent with the idea of susceptibility to IDDM being inherited as a simple autosomal recessive trait. C4 and C2 types, also linked to BF and the MHC, were investigated too. C4 Fs0 was found to be increased in association with BF F1, while C4 f0S and C2 b were each found to occur twice as frequently as in a control population and will be of value in defining haplotypes associated with susceptibility to IDDM.

HLA antigens in type I (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus in North India

Fifty-four North Indian patients with Type I (Insulin-Dependent) diabetes mellitus who were aged 30 yr or under at onset were HLA-typed. The frequencies of HLA-BW21, BW35, and A28 were significantly increased and that of HLA-B7 was significantly reduced. On correction for the number of antigens tested, only the difference observed with HLA-BW21 for positive association and B7 for negative association remained statistically significant. HLA-B8, B15 and B18 did not demonstrate any significant association with IDDM in this series of patients. The results of the study further emphasize the well recognized race specificity in HLA antigen distribution in normal population as well as disease states. This association of HLA-BW21 with IDDM is the first report from North India.